All profiles

Person

Janet Murray

Director of SEEN in Journalism

2documented ties2 names on file
2organizations with a role on file
@jan_murray person

Posts are author-attributed (her own text) and cited as "X post <id>, <date>".

Identification check: the account is verified with display name "Janet Murray" and its own bio reads "Independent journalism | Women's rights & institutional capture | Investigations: [link] | Director @JournalismSEEN" (X bio as recorded in the project archive, 2026-10-31). SEEN in Journalism announced Janet Murray as its new Director on 2026-07-16 (SEEN Substack, "A new chapter for Seen in Journalism", 1). In her own post of 2026-09-05 she writes "Having covered trans activism within Girlguiding for the Telegraph" (2026-09-05). Her name, role and byline are public; the account is hers on her own bio and statements.

Framing note: she presents herself as an independent investigative journalist. Her output on trans people is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric: it denies trans women's womanhood, treats them as a safeguarding threat, and mocks them. Journalism credentials and an "investigation" label do not make it good-faith (Tracking Trans Hate assessment of the coded posts in section 2; method in the report).

1. Public identity and role

  • Journalist. Director of SEEN in Journalism since 2026-07-16, taking over from founder Cath Leng (SEEN Substack post of 2026-07-16, 1; Leng founded it, led it for "more than two years" and said she would stay involved). Her recent articles appeared in The Telegraph, The Mail on Sunday, UnHerd and Spiked, and she earlier spent years as an education reporter and editor, mainly at The Guardian (same post).
  • Her own post says she covered trans activism in Girlguiding for the Telegraph (2026-09-05).
  • X account: 44,100 followers (tier 10k-100k), created 2009-01-13.

2. Posting record (project archive, all posts coded)

  • Followers 44,100 (tier 10k-100k). Keyword posts (weighted) 58.0; views on keyword posts 1,543,306; influence rank 45 under equal weighting (not in the top set under every weighting).
  • Coded posts: 186, every post, reply and quote by the account that matched the search terms (archive as of 2026-11-16). Severity: C0 19; C1 109; C2 2; C3 12; C4 38; C5 6. Share at C2 or above: 31.2% (58 of 186).
  • Shield framing (the post justifies itself by protecting children or women): 93 of 186 coded posts (50.0%).
  • Targeting events: 44. Adult-care posts verified: 0. Aurora-case posts: 0.
  • Top narratives (coded posts carrying each): DENIAL 94; WOMEN_SPACES 64; SPEECH_PERSECUTION 36; INSTITUTIONAL_CAPTURE 29; ACTIVIST_HARASSMENT 23.
  • What the coded posts show: Of 186 coded posts, 167 are anti-trans, all from 2025 and 2026. The main lines are denial of trans people's identity (94 posts), claims about women's spaces (64), claims that critics are silenced (36) and attacks on institutions (29). 93 of the 167 carry a protective claim, chiefly denial of identity (62) and women's spaces (56); 74 make no appeal to protecting anyone, of which 32 deny trans people's identity and 17 are dehumanizing or single out a person. The posts coded C4 or C5 single out private individuals (28), public figures (12), minors (3) and institutions (1). Output is heaviest in 2026.
  • The archive holds 186 posts she wrote with keyword matches (2025-05-19 to 2026-11-10) and 201 reposts by her of others.
  • C4: her own post of 2026-07-05, 50,080 views: a post about a volunteer, unnamed and unverified (a private person, not identified here). Her related posts: one of 2026-07-04, 215,576 views, and her reply of 2026-07-05, 206,163 views.
  • Own high-view posts: 2026-03-04, 330,089 views ("I didn't really get the problem with gender ideology at first"; the "gender ideology" framing denies trans people's identity); 2026-08-03, 279,514 views (a gay man on how gender identity "can undermine the rights of gay, lesbian, bisexual and straight people"); 2026-01-29, 230,303 views, on a friend in the medical profession who said "But trans women are not men"; 2026-08-10, 228,967 views, quoting a BBC presenter's question about trans women using facilities; 2026-08-02, 148,693 views, an unverified secondhand story about an intimate examination ("The patient was clearly male - and appeared to be sexually aroused"; used as a safeguarding warning, see section 4, item 3); a post of 2026-08-08, 143,275 views, mocking a trans woman interviewed on local radio ("feel sorry for him"; the interviewee is a private person and is not named or otherwise identified here); 2026-01-30, 141,611 views, on Hampstead Heath swimming; 2025-12-17, 125,696 views, on a puberty-blockers protest and a sign "Arm trans kids"; 2026-01-05, 120,397 views, on a data breach by the group "Bash Back"; 2026-06-25, 96,962 views: "A man who wants to put a baby's mouth around his nipple should prompt safeguarding questions." Safeguarding framing used as a shield (section 4, item 3).
  • Reposts by her are not her words (201 in the archive). Examples with large reach on the original: a post by LibsOfTikTok that a Netflix show is "pushing pro-transgender on CHILDREN" (2025-10-01, original dated 2025-09-29, 34M views on the original), and posts on Graham Linehan. They carry no claim about what she said.
  • Examples from the full coded record (the highest-reach posts by severity level and main line of attack):
    • @jan_murray Post

      I can't stop thinking about the fact that Laura Kuenssberg - a BBC journalist with decades of experience - did not challenge a male who claimed to take the contraceptive pill to 'prevent pregnancy'. She was speaking to Victoria McCloud - previously the UK's only transgender judge - who is challenging the recent Supreme Court ruling on the definition of the word woman in equalities law. Not only did she fail to challenge this claim in the moment, she didn't return to the topic later. There were more than 30 minutes remaining of the Newcast programme - plenty of time for a producer/editor to flag it up. As one of the most well known political journalists in the UK, we've seen Kuenssberg ask tough questions - many many times. So why couldn't she challenge a male who appeared to believe he could get pregnant? 🤔

      C4 targeting hand-coded denial institutional capture media pronoun complaint

      68,384 views

      What it says Post saying a broadcaster "did not challenge a male who claimed to take the contraceptive pill to 'prevent pregnancy'", misgendering a trans judge who is challenging a court ruling and attacking a journalist as part of an institutional-capture claim; coded C4.

    • @jan_murray Quote

      This MP says I “hate trans people.” Why? Because I believe - correctly - that human beings cannot change sex. If you agree with me, she believes you hate trans people too. I don’t know about you, but I have strong feelings about elected representatives making sweeping accusations like this about people they disagree with. @[private account] is entitled to her personal views. What I object to is an elected MP using her platform to make false and inflammatory claims about members of the public who hold a lawful belief, while showing such open disdain for the people she was elected to represent. After all, many of her constituents are likely to share my views. Public office requires a degree of fairness, professionalism and respect - especially towards those who disagree with you. If an MP cannot engage respectfully with the public - without resorting to caricature and smears - I don’t believe they deserve to hold public office.

      Quotes a post by T04890; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.

      C4 targeting hand-coded denial speech persecution

      1,310 views

      What it says Quote post answering an MP's criticism by asserting that "human beings cannot change sex" and that anyone who agrees would be accused of hating trans people; it denies trans identity and casts criticism as persecution; coded C4.

    • @jan_murray Quote

      ‘Out of respect for the trans community … and the respect for pronouns … I am using what are deemed to be the ‘correct’ pronouns in this case.’ What a dope. And I don’t see ‘showing respect for the trans community’ in any journalists’ code of conduct. Whereas reporting events factually and truthfully - and without bias - is. And what the heck is ‘respect for pronouns’?

      Quoting @JournalismSEEN:
      C4 targeting hand-coded denial media pronoun complaint

      383 views

      What it says Quote post that mocks a journalist who used a trans person's correct pronouns, calling the journalist "What a dope", and says respect for the trans community is not part of journalism; coded C4.

    • @jan_murray Post

      One of the most disturbing responses I keep seeing to concerns about cross-dressing men around children - is: “I’d rather leave my child with a trans-identifying man than a priest.” The grim irony is that priests are also men in frocks - and society learnt the hardest possible way that membership of a trusted or supposedly virtuous group does not exempt anyone from safeguarding. Adults who seek access to children will exploit whatever position offers it. That is precisely why safeguarding procedures now apply in churches, schools, Scouts, Girlguiding and elsewhere. They exist because trust, status and good intentions are not enough. Yet some people appear to believe that a man putting on a dress and declaring himself a woman somehow makes him inherently safe - or that questioning his access to women and children is itself hateful. It does not. He remains male, and the overwhelming majority of sexual and violent offending is committed by males. Identity does not erase sex, and compassion does not require us to abandon ordinary safeguarding principles. None of this means every man - or every trans-identifying man - is dangerous. Safeguarding has never worked by declaring entire groups guilty. It works by recognising patterns of risk, maintaining appropriate boundaries and applying the same rules consistently. These may be uncomfortable truths. That is precisely why they must not be ignored.

      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded child predator denial women spaces

      15,547 views

      What it says Post likening "cross-dressing men around children" to abuse by priests, saying priests are "men in frocks"; it uses a child-safety claim to cast trans people as a danger to children; coded C3.

    • @jan_murray Post

      I believe people “peak” about trans ideology in stages - and we have to let them. Because some of what people eventually discover is genuinely frightening and difficult to process. Push too hard too early, and instead of becoming more open to the evidence, many will simply shut down or turn away from it completely. That aside, I spent the best part of a decade in digital marketing. Which is how I know - first hand - that most of us need to hear something more than a dozen times - and often in many different ways - before the message has any chance of landing. And that we can't assume everyone is at the same 'stage' we are. STAGE 0: “Live and let live.” You support gay rights and assume this is mostly about kindness and acceptance. You may feel uncomfortable about men in women’s spaces - but it hasn’t affected you personally, so you don’t think too deeply about it. And because it’s all grouped together under LGBTQIA+, you’ve never really separated sex (LGB) and gender identity (TQIA+). STAGE 1: Something unsettles you. Maybe it’s a nurse being forced to share a changing room with a man who says he's a woman at work. A parent challenging a school because girls are expected to undress in front of a male pupil. Boys being allowed to join a girls’ only organisation. At the same time, you start noticing language changing. NHS leaflets that say “pregnant people” or “cervix havers”. Women’s initiatives that include men. Men in women’s sport. Children being medically transitioned. You still feel sympathetic - especially towards young people struggling with gender identity - but something feels ‘off’. But you still think there must be a sensible solution. Third spaces. Clear boundaries. Some kind of ‘compromise’ maybe? But when you cautiously voice even mild concerns - or see someone else doing so - you realise these views are often treated as unacceptable. STAGE 2: The penny drops. You realise this isn’t simply about being kind to people who are different. People are being expected to publicly deny biological reality - socially, politically and professionally. You notice people in positions of power saying ridiculous things - like ‘women can have penises’ or men can 'grow cervixes.' And that challenging such ridiculous statements costs people jobs, reputations and friendships. You notice some gay people are pushing back hard - and why. Because if sex is no longer real or meaningful, then neither is same-sex attraction. So this doesn’t just affect women’s rights, but gay people too - whose hard-won rights also depend on sex being real. You learn about women like Maya Forstater, Kellie-Jay Keen and Sall Grover - women who have been publicly attacked, vilified and, in Kellie-Jay Keen’s case, physically assaulted, for what feel like entirely reasonable positions about sex and women’s boundaries. You learn what a “TERF” is - and how it’s used as a slur against women who defend their sex-based rights. You see pictures of masked protesters holding up signs calling for women to be hanged and r*ped. Videos of activists calling for them to be urinated and defecated on. Simply for defending their lawful right to single sex changing rooms, toilets and other intimate spaces. You notice journalists, politicians and institutions seemingly afraid to state basic biological facts. Male offenders - who have committed the most serious crimes - being described as women in the press. You start to feel the chill. Not just around women’s rights - but around free speech itself. And start asking yourself: If people can be pressured into denying biological reality - into literally agreeing that the man standing in front of them is actually a woman - what else can they be pressured into staying silent about? STAGE 3: You can’t unsee it You realise that men demanding access to women’s spaces aren’t poor, misunderstood people who simply want acceptance. They are vulnerable. But they need mental health support - not affirmation. You learn that some may have a recognised condition called autogynephilia - where a man is sexually aroused by the idea of himself as a woman. And realise - often with horror - that many public institutions have embedded harmful ideology in the name of compassion and inclusion. Without properly questioning it. Allowing some men to bring their ‘kinks’ to work, education, social and other aspects of public life. In some cases, into settings that include children. You still have compassion. And recognise that many vulnerable children - and their parents - have been swept up in something adults should have questioned much sooner. But know you can’t look the other way. Because you now understand why so many ordinary people stayed silent - not because they agreed, but because they were afraid. At this stage, some people speak publicly. Many speak up earlier. Others support quietly behind the scenes. But very few return to Stage 0 - and nor should they.

      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded denial fetish fraud ideology cult institutional capture lgb wedge

      47,663 views

      What it says Post saying people "peak" about trans ideology in stages and that what they discover is "genuinely frightening", presenting trans identity as an ideology and a threat; coded C3.

    • @jan_murray Post

      A conversation I often have with my mum - who spent 40 years in NHS nursing - is this: men who enter women’s spaces can no longer be embarrassed into leaving by women. Not because women suddenly became comfortable with it - but because power shifted. Leaders in business, politics, healthcare, education, sport and leisure have been captured by gender ideology. Which means if a woman objects, they will side with the man - even if, privately, they agree with her. Because disagreeing openly could cost them their job. Or, at the very least, their social standing. And women can’t rely on other women to back them up either. I can guarantee that if there were a man in the women’s changing room at my gym, at least one woman would accuse me of bullying a “poor, tortured soul”. She’d tell me he was only trying to live his life, remind me that trans people are among the most marginalised in society - and frame my objection as cruelty. Meanwhile, women who agreed with me would likely stay silent. Not because they don’t care, but because they’re afraid - afraid of being labelled a bigot - or worse. And that’s how we end up with extraordinary stories like this: a woman banned from her council gym for challenging a man in the women’s changing room - a man who then accused *her* of attacking him. My mum retired more than a decade ago, finishing her career at matron level. She had no truck with men trying to access women’s spaces - and when a man who said he was a woman turned up at a sports club she belongs to, she firmly directed him to a third space to change. What I don’t think she fully grasps, having been out of the workplace for a while, is just how hard it now is to get backing - from institutions, businesses and even from other women. And how if it wasn’t for the unrelenting courage of journalists like @[private account] - we’d never even get to hear stories like this.

      C1 anti-trans rhetoric hand-coded ideology cult institutional capture speech persecution women spaces

      55,030 views

      What it says Post saying "men who enter women's spaces can no longer be embarrassed into leaving by women", describing trans women as men entering women's spaces under a protective framing; coded C1.

  • Support: if you are struggling or thinking about suicide, help is available. In the US, call or text 988, or chat at 2 (988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline); Trans Lifeline, a peer support line run by trans people, (877) 565-8860 (3); The Trevor Project for LGBTQ+ young people, 1-866-488-7386 or text START to 678-678 (4). In the UK, Samaritans can be called free, day or night, on 116 123 (5).

3. Documented moments

  • 2025-05-19: earliest own keyword post in the archive.
  • 2025-12-17: attends a puberty-blockers protest and posts about a sign (2025-12-17).
  • 2026-01-30: Hampstead Heath post (2026-01-30).
  • 2026-01-29: post that a friend's statement "trans women are not men" is "profoundly wrong" (2026-01-29).
  • 2026-03-04: "I didn't really get the problem" thread (2026-03-04).
  • 2026-07-04/05: posts about a volunteer, unnamed and unverified (a private person, not identified here). No Telegraph item for this story is shown in her posts.
  • 2026-07-16: named Director of SEEN in Journalism (SEEN Substack, 2026-07-16, 1).
  • 2026-08-02/10: NHS and BBC posts (2026-08-02; 2026-08-10).
  • 2026-09-05: attends a Girlguiding protest against the "boy ban" taking effect the next day "following last year's Supreme Court ruling" (2026-09-05). The term "boy ban" calls trans girls boys: it is the denial of identity described in the framing note above (Tracking Trans Hate assessment of the coded posts in section 2; method in the report).

4. Evidence the child and sports framing is pretextual

  1. Denial for adults: "Trans women are not men" is called "profoundly wrong" to say (2026-01-29); "this man" for a trans adult volunteer (2026-07-04); "feel sorry for him" about a trans woman interviewed on local radio (2026-08-08). Each is about an adult and uses misgendering.
  2. Facilities: she quotes a BBC presenter on whether a trans woman "would have to use the male facilities" (2026-08-10) and supports exclusion of adults from spaces; the Girlguiding work is about adult volunteers and leaders.
  3. Safeguarding framing as a shield: "should prompt safeguarding questions" (2026-06-25); an unverified secondhand NHS anecdote (2026-08-02). Neither post cites any data; the account's group also answers a record of only four complaints with "fear of complaining" (2026-01-07, by SEEN in Journalism), a reading that cannot be tested.
  4. Director of a group that asks the BBC to "default to biological sex descriptors and pronouns" and calls complying with self-identification of sex "unkind, disrespectful and harmful to every cohort other than transgender advocates" (SEEN open letter to the BBC, 2025-08-29, 6).
  5. Medical framing: she attended the puberty-blocker protest (2025-12-17). The evidence brief reports 52 of 56 studies in Cornell's review found improvement, none harm; Cass-commissioned reviews were rated high risk of bias in a peer-reviewed appraisal. Certainty ratings for youth care are low because randomized trials are widely considered unethical and low ratings are common across pediatric medicine; that is not evidence of harm, and arguing from it against care is bad-faith rhetoric. She uses the "Arm trans kids" sign, a single counter-protester sign, to characterize a whole movement.
  6. "Trans activist" violence framing: her own post on a data breach by the group "Bash Back" (2026-01-05). Reposts of other accounts on the same theme are amplification, not her words, and are not counted. This single own post is thin evidence that a group's actions are used to indict trans people generally.
  7. Claims the project corrects: the post that ties threats against women's-rights groups to trans activists as a group (2025-12-29) and the post that dismisses statistics on suicide among trans people (2026-08-10) carry project corrections.
  • Support: if you are struggling or thinking about suicide, help is available. In the US, call or text 988, or chat at 2 (988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline); Trans Lifeline, a peer support line run by trans people, (877) 565-8860 (3); The Trevor Project for LGBTQ+ young people, 1-866-488-7386 or text START to 678-678 (4). In the UK, Samaritans can be called free, day or night, on 116 123 (5).

5. Platform enforcement

No platform enforcement action against @jan_murray appears in the public sources reviewed for this profile; no enforcement database was searched.

6. Ties

Role

  • SEEN in Journalism: Director since 2026-07-16 (X bio as recorded in the project archive, 2026-10-31; SEEN Substack, 2026-07-16, 1).
  • The Telegraph: has written for it on Girlguiding (her own post, 2026-09-05); other outlets named in the SEEN Substack post of 2026-07-16: The Mail on Sunday, UnHerd, Spiked (1).

Narrative alignment only (not a tie)

  • SEEN's open letter to the BBC (2025-08-29; not a tie) with For Women Scotland, Women's Rights Network, LGB Alliance, Sex Matters, Transgender Trend, Genspect, Fair Play For Women, Conservatives for Women and others: she was not Director then, and the letter is listed here for the organization she now directs, not as her own act (SEEN open letter to the BBC, 2025-08-29, 6).
  • Reposts of Graham Linehan and others; amplification by JournalismSEEN (34 reposts of her posts in the archive).

7. Income and funding

Not documented. SEEN's appeal for paid subscribers says: "Your support helps us continue publishing, engage with journalists, regulators and other stakeholders and will enable us to expand our work into research, education and training in the coming months" (SEEN Substack, 2026-07-16, 1); no figure and no Director pay is disclosed. Newspaper fees are not public. Nothing is estimated.

8. Legal matters

No legal matters appear in the public sources reviewed for this profile; no court docket search was made.

Summary

  • Journalist and SEEN in Journalism Director whose posts misgender trans adults, run unverified anecdotes as safeguarding warnings, and attack trans-activist groups.
  • Strongest tie: SEEN in Journalism, a role tie (Director from 2026-07-16).
  • Open questions: Telegraph byline list; any records for SEEN.

Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.

Sources

  1. https://seeninjournalism.substack.com/p/a-new-chapter-for-seen-in-journalism
  2. https://988lifeline.org/
  3. https://translifeline.org/hotline/
  4. https://www.thetrevorproject.org/get-help/
  5. https://www.samaritans.org/how-we-can-help/contact-samaritan/
  6. https://seeninjournalism.substack.com/p/our-open-letter-to-the-bbc