The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Where to begin with this one-sided BBC Wales article on the draft Conversion Practices Bill?
Readers deserve to know what the draft actually says and why many people and groups oppose it.
• Smith and Humanists UK make the case for a ban. Nobody gets to explain why they oppose this draft bill.
• The article doesn’t tell readers that the draft also covers transgender identities.
• It also skips a basic rule-of-law question: can parents and therapists tell in advance when a frank conversation might be treated as a criminal offence?
• Gay Men’s Network, Sex Matters and LGB Alliance had already given evidence to the same parliamentary committee. Where are their arguments about the potential effects on parents and exploratory therapy?
• The article repeats a figure from Smith’s testimony suggesting 75% of survivors want a ban, without identifying the survey or telling readers what respondents were asked.
BBC News interviewed a critic when the draft was published in June. Why couldn’t this piece give readers even a brief account of the objections, or link to that earlier reporting?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cre3xq7ed33do
“LGBTQ+ people are being targeted. Our rights, our identities and our existence are being debated and attacked.”
These are the words of a senior legal counsel at Sky, who co-chairs its LGBTQ+ staff group.
According to The Sunday Times, an internal video also attacked “extraordinarily well-funded bigots” campaigning to exclude trans people from sport and shared spaces.
Presumably that includes women campaigning for single-sex spaces and fair sporting categories?
Gender-critical beliefs are protected under the Equality Act. So what message does this send to Sky employees who hold those beliefs?
And what does it tell us about the culture inside one of Britain's biggest news broadcasters?
Read below 👇
This has to be one of the most extraordinary examples of what happens when gender ideology gets into the newsroom.
The Daily Mail is reporting that transgender actor Hunter Schafer has undergone “gender-affirming bottom surgery”.
Yet the journalist repeatedly describes Schafer as “she”, calls him an “actress” and claims he “transitioned to female” as a teenager.
But if Schafer had already become female, what exactly was the surgery affirming?
And why is a journalist reporting on surgery involving male genitalia seemingly unable to acknowledge that the patient is male?
This isn’t about being unkind to anyone. It’s about the language journalists use to describe biological reality.
Because when journalists start treating the idea that human beings can change sex as established fact, rather than distinguishing sex from gender identity, they’re no longer simply reporting what happened.
They’re adopting a contested belief as the framework for their reporting.
Link below 👇
Excellent discussion between @HadleyFreeman and Helen Webberley today about the NHS ban on men in women’s single-sex spaces.
Plenty of strong challenges from Jeremy Vine, who didn’t let Webberley get away with answering different questions from the ones he asked.
And a strong challenge from Freeman when Webberley compared requiring trans-identifying people to use NHS spaces corresponding to their biological sex with the treatment of black Americans depicted in Mississippi Burning - a film about racist violence in the 1960s.
There was also an interesting slip from Webberley, who said it was outrageous to suggest that all MEN might harm women - and appeared to include “trans women” in that group.
So perhaps she does know that men are not women, after all…
Quotes a post by A2915; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Good to see this story on the front page of the Times today - as it should be.
Of course the 'trans women' in the headline should be really be MEN. That would be accurate language.
But 'Hospitals to place men on male wards' sounds ridiculous doesn't it?
Almost as ridiculous as men who 'identify' as women being placed on female wards in the first place.
This is a very misleading statement.
Trans people are not being excluded from healthcare. They are being excluded from certain single-sex spaces for which they do not meet the eligibility criteria.
In the same way that under-18s are excluded from age-restricted premises.
Having eligibility criteria does not automatically amount to discrimination or indignity.
Why should respecting the privacy, dignity and boundaries of women and girls be considered an indignity to anyone else?
And why do their feelings matter less?
Quotes a post by T09338; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The BBC has announced a two-part documentary about J.K. Rowling. And already, its choice of language raises questions.
The BBC’s press release says the series will explore Rowling’s “dramatic rise, cultural influence and contested legacy”, describing how the Harry Potter author became “one of Britain’s most polarising public figures”.
According to the programme makers, her “unflinching personal beliefs have sparked a fraught and divisive dialogue that continues to this day”.
But whose framing is this?
Rowling has become one of the UK’s most prominent defenders of women’s sex-based rights, using her considerable influence and wealth to challenge policies she believes undermine those rights.
Yet the BBC’s announcement appears to frame her beliefs as the source of division, rather than asking why defending those rights has become so contentious.
Women’s rights do get a brief mention - but only in the context of how her supporters see her, contrasted with critics who describe her as an opponent of “trans equality”.
Words matter in journalism. So do the editorial assumptions behind them.
Of course, we haven’t seen the documentary yet. So we’ll reserve judgment until the show is aired.
But when a broadcaster describes a woman’s defence of sex-based rights in terms of her “contested legacy” and “divisive” beliefs, it’s reasonable to ask what assumptions are already shaping the story.
We’ll be watching with interest.
So @bindelj was also at the journalism workshop on reporting trans issues.
Here’s her take 👇
Quoting @bindelj: I also attended. It was a perfect storm of REALLY boring and REALLY TransStalinist.
https://x.com/jan_murray/status/2107904279751323822?s=20
All mainstream outlets should be covering this story - and speaking to parents of trans-identifying children about what the Conversion Practices Bill could mean in practice.
Sadly, we fear too many will look the other way.
Quoting @jan_murray: NEW 🚨 This is what critics of Labour’s so-called Conversion Practices Bill have been warning about.
Parents are already being referred to social services - and even the police - for refusing to affirm a child experiencing gender distress.
Saying no to a child who wants you to buy them chest binders, agree to puberty blockers or call them by a different name is what many would regard as good parenting.
Children’s brains are still developing. What they say they want at 14 may be very different a decade later - by which time some changes to their body may be irreversible.
Now imagine giving the state even more power to intervene.
Parents must be free to question life-changing decisions about their children without fear of being treated as abusers.
My latest for the Mail on Sunday.
Link below 👇
Three Metro articles from the past week.
All are part of Metro’s ‘Queer Hope & Joy’ series, which it says is running alongside LGBT Foundation’s ‘Hope Starts Here’ campaign.
1. A lesbian Muslim writer describing herself as a “Queer Palestinian” and writing about sexuality, gender identity and belonging
2. A lesbian journalist who claims a “Queer Utopia” residential “saved” her after redundancy and depression
3. A female writer who identifies as a trans man describing the “euphoria” of going topless after double mastectomy. And feeling like ‘one of the boys’
Is this journalism? Or is Metro participating in an advocacy campaign that promotes contested ideas about gender identity?
Sex Matters lost its High Court case against the CPS. But that isn’t quite the whole story.
The challenge has resulted in the CPS changing its guidance so that prosecutors can explicitly refer to a trans suspect by pronouns matching their birth sex where appropriate.
The court also criticised parts of the previous guidance.
So “claim dismissed” may be legally accurate. But reporting only the defeat risks missing the rather important fact that the challenge nevertheless forced changes.
New 📣
@jan_murray
Girl Guiding continues to promote trans-activism.
‘Teenage girls in Dorset have been introduced to non-binary identities during a Girlguiding meeting, The Telegraph has learnt.
Leaders were advised to divide Guides into “team boy” and “team girl” to discuss stereotypes before talking about the concept of non-binary identification during a session titled “Binary Breakdown” this week.’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/09/26/girl-guides-divided-team-boy-girl-non-binary-identities/
Thorough analysis in a terrific piece by @[private account] @[private account]
on the relationship between women and unions, who are supposed to represent all workers.
‘It is a statement released on the day of the Women’s Conference, by a movement whose largest affiliates are made up overwhelmingly of low-paid women. The word “women” does not appear in it once’
Headlines:
The Women’s Rights Law the Unions Want Changed
Section 28 Comparison is the Wrong Ghost to Summon
What Happened to the Darlington Nurses?
Who Represented Women When the Unions Did Not?
Sandie Peggie’s Case Against the RCN
Women’s Rights and the Limits of Union Solidarity
‘Eleven unions found one voice this morning to say that trans rights are workers’ rights. They are.
There is one more sentence the movement needs to say just as clearly, and today, on the day of the Women’s Conference, not one of them could bring themselves to say it.’
👏👏👏
https://heartlandstribune.com/labour-womens-conference/
@GBNEWS covers the story that transactivists and unions are claiming ‘trans people are banned’ from Labour Women’s Conference in Liverpool.
Yet:
‘Biological females who identify as trans will not be banned’.
Quoting @GBNEWS: 'Everybody knows the difference between men and women. We don't need laws, we don't need policies, we don't need pieces of paper.'
Debbie Hayton calls trans protests outside the Labour Women's Conference 'tiring and tedious'.
📺 Freeview 236, Sky 512, Virgin 604
Here for info for @[private account] is the sex of the shooter reported back in February; from a journalistic outlet that covers stories about trans-identified people. Again, overwhelmingly, males. It’s the BBC having a look around this site to see what other stories they might be missing or reporting with factual errors.
Quoting @reduxx: BREAKING
The identity of the Tumbler Ridge shooter can now be confirmed as Jesse “Jess” Strang.
Strang is a biological male who started to “identify” as a "girl" around 2023.
Strang was raised in a family that valued hunting, and began learning how to shoot rifles when he was just a child. Many guns were kept in the family's residence.
Facebook posts from his mother indicate he may have struggled with behavioral issues, including violent tendencies, from a very young age.
Strang fatally shot 10 people prior to taking his own life.
[h/t @preta_6, @Slatzism, @junonewscom]
C2 false claimshand-codedcoverupmedia pronoun complaintshooter attributionviolence terror
Meanwhile in Liverpool, unions are again in focus, as several have refused to attend the Labour Women’s Conference after men have been barred from attending.
Unfortunately this is reported without using the words ‘man’ or ‘men’:
‘Labour barred trans women from being delegates at the conference in the wake of last year's Supreme Court ruling on biological sex’
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16161657/Protesters-Labour-womens-conference-trans-delegates.html
@Telegraph does a good job covering Day 3 of Sandie Peggie v RCN.
Their report includes revealing details that emerged during cross-examination of the union witness.
‘On Friday Ms Cunningham told Mr Provan that this derived from “some of the wilder shores” of gender identity ideology.
She challenged him over a section stating that children “should be accorded the same respect for their self-defined or true gender as trans adults are, regardless of their genital sex”.
Combined with the definition of gender identity in the glossary, she said it created “a rather alarming implication that RCN members ought, in order to be inclusive, to affirm and treat with respect the eunuch identity of a child patient”.’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/cebf674d6f319930
BBC does a better job than Sky in its coverage of yesterday’s hearing Day 3 Sandie Peggie v RCN.
Their report includes a quote from barrister Naomi Cunningham where she cross-examines the RCN witness, arguing that the union had adopted transgender ideology
‘Cunningham said the union could be seen "celebrating" this belief through photographs at Pride events and its sale of merchandise depicting the 'progress Pride' flag – an updated version of the traditional rainbow flag which incorporates transgender colours.
Asked to explain why the RCN did not also offer merchandise in support of Christian, atheist or vegan beliefs, Provan said: "No, I don't work in the area where we design our merchandise."’
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3vgy822rkzjo?app-referrer=deep-link
Disappointing coverage from Sky News of Sandie Peggie v RCN Union.
‘Trans row’ doesn’t explain that the trans identified man in question was married to a woman, presumably heterosexual, and was in a changing room used by women nurses.
Also yesterday’s tribunal was considerably more interesting than portrayed here. It was the first we’d heard from a Union representative during the proceedings.
The cross-examination was striking in the way it explored a broader culture within the NHS, including merchandise and training sessions.
None of that makes it into this report unfortunately.
Quoting @SkyNews: Trans row nurse's beliefs had 'no bearing' on union decision to refuse support, tribunal told
Read the full story🔗
https://trib.al/zfP1Pwu
Metro claims to have the inside scoop on protests at the upcoming Labour Party conference - but somehow manages to obscure one rather important fact.
Trans women have NOT been banned from Labour's party conference.
Men have.
Labour has restricted attendance at its Women's Conference to biological women, following the Supreme Court ruling.
Metro repeatedly describes this as a “trans ban”, despite Labour confirming that the fringe events and exhibitions are open to everyone with the appropriate conference pass. 
This is both inaccurate and misleading reporting from Metro. And once again its writers are behaving like activists - not journalists.
Link below 👇
@[private account] reports from USA
‘Ninth Circuit overturns order requiring Oregon to house transgender women in women's prisons’
There was a disagreement about language:
‘…for example, most uses of transgender used quotation marks, and Tung referred to transgender women as “male inmates who claim to be female,” rather than the more common phrase “identify as female.”
The Department of Justice spokesperson in Oregon, Jenny Hansson, noted the wordage.
‘While praising the judges for agreeing with the government’s “core legal arguments,” she hastened to add, in an email:
“While we agree with the outcome of the case, we strongly disagree with the court’s harmful language. It does not reflect our brief or our values.”’
Values which appear to concern the description of a plaintiff who “sexually assaulted a woman by lodging a footlong plastic object into that woman’s vagina.”
https://www.courthousenews.com/ninth-circuit-overturns-order-requiring-oregon-to-house-transgender-women-in-womens-prisons
An Australian news outlet reports on a landmark ‘dead-name’ ruling.
Commentators point out that even when checking prior legal names for safeguarding reasons, the priority is the feelings of the trans-identified person, rather than a commitment to facts and accuracy.
Quotes a post by A1607; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@Telegraph reporting:
‘Women in the Liberal Democrats and Green Party claim they have “been bullied out of their political home” by trans activists.
The Liberal Voice for Women and Green Women’s Declaration, have jointly written to Bridget Phillipson, the Minister for Women and Equalities, saying they have “experienced a sustained pattern of abuse, harassment, dehumanisation, intimidation and physical aggression” from “fellow members”.’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/09/18/trans-activists-bullying-lib-dems-and-greens/
Oxford law expert challenges Sandie Peggie tribunal restrictions.
‘Dr Michael Foran, 32, an associate professor of law, has written to the head of Scotland’s tribunal service to challenge restrictions which have been imposed on who can watch the case next week.
A number of feminists, legal commentators and journalists are hoping to observe the latest iteration of Peggie’s legal fight, which was prompted by her suspension from NHS Fife after she refused to share a changing room with transgender medic, Dr Beth Upton, who was born a man.’
The case received much attention in December 2025 and the background is available @[private account]
Substack
https://tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/appeal-peggie-vs-fife-health-board
Here’s The Times’ article regarding next week’s hearing:
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/oxford-law-expert-challenges-sandie-peggie-tribunal-restrictions-mfrfml7p7
@nypost reporting latest study on medical interventions and suicide risk for trans-identified children.
‘Protecting children from transgender treatments does not increase suicide rates — and our data proves it.
Kids who assert they’re “born in the wrong body” typically suffer from serious mental-health issues, including depression and anxiety, that are themselves linked to suicide risk.
Quotes a post by T04491; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Public sector remains captured by inclusion, writes @[private account]
‘..vulnerable female patients are put in wards with trans women, with no concern for their safety or privacy.’
An excellent piece that would have even more clarity had @thetimes added an explanatory/editorial note that ‘trans women’ are in fact men.
https://www.thetimes.com/article/49bf75de-ce60-441a-ae27-4651e8f95bbc?shareToken=e2fe934d29c73e43ac552f8b9b46fc10
Former Labour councillor hounded out of debate by abusive trans activists.
‘Emina Ibrahim attended Haringey council’s cabinet meeting on Tuesday night to present a petition to the Green Party-controlled borough calling for guarantees that single-sex spaces for victims of domestic violence would be protected.
She was met outside by a group of trans rights activists, who shouted abuse as Ms Ibrahim and two others involved with the petition entered the building. The delegation later had to be escorted out of the back of the building for their own safety.’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/09/16/former-labour-councillor-hounded-out-debate-abusive-trans/
‘Nadia Whittome, Labour MP, said she was in talks with “trans-led organisations” on how to campaign for overhauling the Equality Act 2010
‘Julia Georgiou, who is also a trans woman, told the event: “The EHRC are already moving on to the workplace regs. We know this is going to come here, and the only way to get out of that is to simply change the law.’
No word as to which women’s organisations had been consulted.
Quotes a post by T17426; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Burnham must rewrite Equality Act to support trans rights, union activists say.
‘Ms Whittome told an event on the fringes of the Trades Union Congress (TUC) in Brighton on Monday that the EHRC guidance was “as bad as it is possible to be”.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/5f26357d516a7d61
Massachusetts has had a ‘conversion therapy ban’ in place since 2019.
This story below is one of the outcomes.
As usual with trans activism, language is manipulated and a ‘conversion therapy ban’ is not necessarily the positive and clear legal instrument it seems.
Quoting @FoxNews: A Massachusetts family says the state took custody of their teenage daughter after they refused to affirm her as a boy, citing their Catholic faith.
The parents allege a school counselor socially transitioned their daughter without their knowledge, then reported them to the Department of Children and Families.
Now the state has guardianship, and a restraining order prevents the teen's parents and older brother from contacting her.
A judge has temporarily blocked the state from administering high-dose testosterone as the family fights the case. The next court hearing is set for Oct. 29. | @[private account] @[private account]
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedchild indoctrinationinstitutional capturestate takes children
📌 Our Fortnightly Round-up (31 Aug–13 Sep) 📌
This edition’s theme: When Journalism Becomes Captured. Includes:
- Graham Linehan, Jon Ronson and journalistic neutrality
- Daily Record calling a male offender a “pre-op transgender woman”
- Metro framing friendship as “queer community”
- An imperfect apology from BBC Three Counties
- A “crisis of representation” of drag queens at the BBC
- IPSO complaints over reporting on women’s rights
Featuring @[private account] @SexMattersOrg @[private account] @Glinner
Link below 👇
P.S. Subscribe to our Substack and get our round-up delivered straight to your inbox.
This isn’t the first time the NSPCC has faced scrutiny.
@jo_bartosch wrote about trans activism and men’s behaviour at the charity back in 2019.
https://uncommongroundmedia.com/nspcc-employee-films-himself-masturbating-at-work/
Here’s the link to the documentary, which is in Spanish:
‘Colombia: Factory of Trans Children” is an investigative documentary that exposes the advancement of the trans agenda among minors in Colombia and the cultural, medical, and social consequences this could have for future generations.’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8aYCYN3VzQ8
‘The child protection charity has removed a policy that adults supervising pupils while they change should be the same sex as the children from its latest safeguarding briefing.
Campaigners and MPs last night called on the NSPCC to reinstate the policy, and accused the charity of making the change under pressure from transgender activists.’
Quoting @DailyMail: Fury as NSPCC say male teachers can supervise girls in changing rooms https://trib.al/ilToTDN
‘A trans woman is a man. Being accurate is not unkind.’
Our SEEN in journalism director on @gbnews this evening.
Quoting @jan_murray: ‘How do you define transphobia Matthew?’
Short clip from my appearance on @[private account]’s Free Speech Nation on @gbnews tonight - where a male guest appeared to suggest it was ‘unkind’ to call a man a man.
A familiar tactic used by trans activists to discourage journalists from scrutinising trans ideology is to complain to their industry regulators.
Case in point: this is the second complaint about SEEN in Journalism director @jan_murray's reporting in as many weeks.
One concerns an article highlighting the experiences of gender-critical women working in the NHS - including their fear of asking for single-sex changing facilities - or simply stating that people cannot change sex.
The other concerns males competing in women’s categories at parkrun.
Both are legitimate matters of public interest.
Anyone is entitled to use the regulatory complaints process. But publicly announcing a complaint before it has even been considered- without identifying any alleged inaccuracy or breach - risks turning that process into a means of applying pressure to journalists.
A complaint is not a finding.
And journalists must remain free to investigate contested issues - without fear or favour.
Quoting @jan_murray: Trans advocacy organisation TransLucent has issued a ‘statement’ saying it has submitted a complaint to IPSO about my latest Telegraph article.
The article is about the culture of fear experienced by gender-critical women working in the NHS. Including fear of speaking up about men using their changing rooms or stating they don't believe people can change sex. I’ll link to it below.
For context, TransLucent has also complained to IPSO about another recent article of mine.
Not entirely sure what purpose this statement serves-other than, perhaps, to advertise one of the tactics used to discourage women from speaking out 🤷♀️
This is a man.
Yet the Daily Record tells readers that “a woman has been brought to justice” after making false rape and sexual assault allegations against several men.
Khloe Simmonds is male. But the report describes Simmonds as a “pre-op transgender woman” and then carefully navigates around that basic fact with “they/them” and female pronouns.
That is not a trivial language choice.
Simmonds was jailed for seven-and-a-half years after admitting eight counts of perverting the course of justice. At one point, the false allegations reportedly accounted for 2.5% of all rape and serious sexual assault allegations in Harrow.
When reporting crime, sex matters.
Journalists can explain that someone identifies as transgender. They can report the language used in court.
But they should not tell readers that a male offender is a woman.
Link below 👇
What if the BBC and other mainstream broadcasters had challenged trans ideology instead of affirming it?
This exchange between Vanessa Feltz and @AndrewGold_ok offers a glimpse of the conversations audiences should have heard years ago.
What does “be kind” mean for women losing single-sex spaces? For employees compelled to affirm beliefs they do not share? For children being medicalised? Can someone literally change sex? And what happens when one person’s identity conflicts with another person’s rights?
Instead of examining those questions, much of the media adopted the language and assumptions of trans activism - while presenting those who challenged them as cruel, hateful or obsessed with other people’s lives.
Had journalists subjected these claims to proper scrutiny from the beginning, would so many institutions have adopted damaging policies? Would people have lost jobs and livelihoods? Would children have been placed on medical pathways that many now regret?
Journalism is supposed to test contested claims - not affirm them.
Do watch the full Vanessa Feltz interview on Andrew Gold’s Heretics YouTube channel (link below) 👇
The BBC has devoted a 30-minute podcast and a 2,000-word article to why Pride events are struggling.
It considers costs, corporate “nervousness”, Reform councils, “culture wars” and hostility towards trans people.
Yet it omits some key parts of the story.
Such as legitimate concerns about sexualised content at daytime events marketed as “family friendly”: fetish and puppy-play outfits, sex-toy stalls and even reports of sex acts being performed in public.
Nor does it mention the multiple safeguarding scandals involving people linked to Pride organisations.
Like Stephen Ireland - co-founder of Pride in Surrey - who was jailed for 24 years for r*ping a 12-year-old boy and other child-sex offences.
The BBC discusses growing corporate “nervousness” but doesn’t seriously examine why companies may no longer consider association with Pride commercially wise.
Major brands including PlayStation, Durex and Costa Coffee were absent from sponsorship lists in 2025 after backing Pride events the previous year.
Some police, fire and ambulance services have withdrawn from official participation in Pride following legal advice about political impartiality.
Did any of this influence their withdrawal?
The BBC doesn't even ask.
Neither does it address how overtly political Pride has become.
Or explain that Pride is no longer simply about equal rights for lesbians, gay men and bisexual people - the “LGB” many members of the public may assume they are supporting.
It is now attached to the “TQIA+”: gender-identity politics, contested claims about biological sex and demands affecting women’s single-sex rights.
The BBC does touch on the resulting tensions and acknowledges that some lesbians, gay men and bisexual people no longer feel represented by Pride.
But it barely explores why.
Its only substantial dissenting voice is a Reform politician.
One unnamed gender-critical lesbian is briefly paraphrased but is not heard in the podcast. No gender-critical woman is named, interviewed or given any meaningful opportunity to explain her concerns.
Trans contributors, by contrast, are named, heard directly and given space to describe feeling frightened, unsafe and pushed “back into the dark”.
The effect is unmistakable: one side is humanised; the other is largely represented by a politician from a right-wing party.
That is not an impartial examination of why attitudes towards Pride are changing. It is editorial framing that invites sympathy for one perspective while withholding it from the other.
Links below👇
"Its article count may be perfectly accurate - but let us be clear: its interpretation of that data is advocacy, not an impartial finding."
There are striking similarities here with Amnesty's, now withdrawn, 'Like A Snowball report' - which counted numbers of 'negative' articles about trans people.
Research - that by Amnesty's own admission - was not reliable. Yet is still being quoted by trans activists.
Their definition of 'negative' coverage? Seemingly any article that didn't affirm trans ideology.
Very concerning.
Quotes a post by T03918; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Interesting editorial choice from @[private account].
This weekend, it chose to interview a University of Cambridge professor with Tourette’s - someone who had already been the subject of a lengthy feature on the BBC website.
Meanwhile, there were plenty of potentially newsworthy guests/stories that could have been featured:
@ForWomenScot - who recently won a legal guarantee that rules allowing trans inmates into women’s prisons cannot be revived
@[private account] - after two former male NBA players declared themselves eligible for the WNBA draft - the top US women’s professional basketball league - by saying they identify as women. Or what about the rise of ‘Sophie Mania’, after WNBA player Sophie Cunningham spoke out against men in women’s sport.
@[private account] - the female police officer recently sacked after speaking out against guidance that could require female officers to strip-search biological men identifying as women. Just months earlier, Fletcher led an investigation that put prolific paedophile Ross Jackson behind bars for 23 years
@WomensRightsNet - whose Red Flag campaign has highlighted councils replacing separate male and female changing rooms with mixed-sex “changing villages” - often citing Sport England guidance. WRN says this raises privacy, dignity and safety concerns for women and girls. Sport England has now put that guidance under review.
@SexMattersOrg which this week challenged Amnesty International UK’s claim that its now-withdrawn report branding gender-critical groups part of an “anti-rights movement” was simply an isolated error - and called for an independent review into Amnesty’s wider approach to sex and gender.
We could go on.
But you get the picture.
This is not to say BBC Woman’s Hour should cover only these kinds of stories.
The question is whether, over time, its editorial choices provide due impartiality on contested issues affecting women - including sex and gender.
And the timing is interesting. With Cambridge University already at the centre of a major story about scrutiny, journalism and what gets challenged, Woman’s Hour’s choice to devote airtime to a sympathetic profile of another Cambridge professor is certainly notable.
The Guardian defines a “transgender woman” as:
“A person assigned male at birth who transitions to align with their gender identity.”
“Assigned male at birth” is ideological, activist language. Sex is observed and recorded, not assigned.
And why make this so complicated?
In a story about eligibility for women’s basketball, the relevant fact is very simple:
A transgender woman is male.
A man.
Story below 👇
With some notable exceptions, many mainstream media outlets still seem afraid of covering trans or women's rights issues.
Which means they either avoid it altogether, tiptoe around the difficult questions - or, if they’re the BBC, stick a drag queen in every segment to demonstrate how diverse they are.
So when it comes to reporting on sex and gender, we increasingly need independent journalists like @jo_bartosch to tell us what others won’t.
She recently launched @TERF_Times - which, in her own words, is “here for harpies, hags and harridans”.
Expect honest, accurate reporting on the issues that matter - without the endless drag queens.
Do follow @TERF_Times and support Jo's important independent journalism.
Quoting @TERF_Times: 'But are there enough UK TERFy stories to write about?' I present the past few days... and we didn't capture them all! Read and support us at https://www.terftimes.com/
This @[private account] article is about a Blackpool councillor who alleges that participants in a recent pro-trans walk were intimidated by protesters who were “spreading hatred”.
He also claims that one protester at the August 5 event shouted that the Trans community should be “slaughtered”.
Clearly, this is concerning. But the article is problematic because these claims are presented as established fact, without making clear whether the reporter has seen verifiable evidence to support them.
If the reporter has seen evidence, the article should make that clear. If not, it should use words such as “alleged” or “claimed” rather than presenting one participant’s account as established fact.
There is further confusion when the councillor, described as an openly gay man, says: “We just want to use the toilet and they want us to die.”
Who does “we” mean - and was that clarified?
Serious allegations require precise, independently verified reporting. Without that, this reads more like activism than journalism.
Link below 👇
BBC Radio Ulster devoted considerable airtime to the cancellation of WRN Northern Ireland’s panel at Féile an Phobail.
But giving women airtime is not the same as providing balanced coverage.
Gender-critical campaigners were repeatedly accused of being “far-right”, “toxic”, opposed to trans people having rights and supportive of “genital inspections”.
Instead of being given the opportunity to explain why single sex spaces are important for women, gender critical guests were required to defend themselves against slurs and factual inaccuracies. And to justify the use of accurate language to describe biological sex.
Meanwhile, a trans-identifying young man was interviewed sympathetically - without being asked reasonable questions, such as, why he believed he was a woman or what that meant.
The result was coverage in which women advocating for sex-based rights were treated as the problem, while the substance of their concerns was barely explored.
Important analysis from @SexMattersOrg that highlights how broadcasters can platform both sides - and still frame the debate in a profoundly one-sided way.
Link below👇
There is no reason to refer to a male child rapist as a ‘she’. Shameful. We are not even going to call it ‘journalism’.
https://www.wiltshire999s.co.uk/swindon-trans-offending-jailed-years/
Jeremy Vine challenged some dubious claims during today’s Channel 5 discussion on JK Rowling’s legal fund. That’s welcome.
But much of the conversation on women’s rights was driven by Owen Jones - with comparatively little input from the other guest, Alys Denby.
Among the claims presented as settled fact were:
- JK Rowling had “changed the law”, rather than the Supreme Court interpreting existing legislation in a case brought by For Women Scotland
- The ruling had left trans people “in limbo”.
- Trans rights and women’s rights “rise together or fall together”
- Countries expanding abortion rights also advance women’s rights
Jones also argued that the exclusion of men who identify as women from
single sex spaces depends on whether it’s a “proportionate means” of achieving a legitimate aim.
But the obvious follow-up question wasn’t asked:
‘OK, Owen. Can you give me a scenario where providing women with their own toilets, showers and changing room - spaces that men cannot access - to protect their privacy, dignity and safety would not be a legitimate aim?’
Commentators are entitled to make arguments. Journalists should test them - particularly when they’re presented as established fact.
"Journalists should not be afraid to ask trans-identifying contributors the same challenging questions they would ask any other guest."
📌 Our Weekly Round-up (3–9 August) 📌
This week's theme: Why Are Journalists Still Afraid of Trans People. Includes:
- LBC: where were the women?
- BBC Three Counties: three men, no female guest
- Jeremy Vine (Channel 5): when legal clarity gives way to confusion
A wider look at how the new EHRC Code on single-sex spaces was reported.
Link to read below 👇
***
P.S. Subscribe to our Substack and get our weekly round-up delivered straight to your inbox every week.
PART 2 ➡️ Last week, BBC Three Counties devoted an hour-long segment to the new EHRC Code on single-sex spaces. It featured three men talking for around 30 minutes - but no female guest to explain why women's single-sex spaces matter.
We've since learned that a suitable organisation was approached for an interview, but was then told it was not needed.
Last week's post (link below) looked at the omission of female voices. But the framing of the discussion is notable too - starting with the title: 'is it right to tell transgender people which toilet to use?'
The presenter Jonathan Vernon-Smith followed up with:
"My question to you today is: is that right, or does that seem unnecessarily unkind and mean?”
But the new EHRC Code isn't an optional act of kindness. It sets out how organisations are expected to comply with equality law following the Supreme Court's ruling that "sex" in the Equality Act means biological sex
Vernon-Smith introduced his first guest, barrister Robin Moira White, apologising in advance in case he used language that might be considered 'offensive'. Later, he repeated a similar message to a caller.
But it's not "offensive" to state the truth. Saying that a man is a man is factually correct.
White also made a number of significant claims that went largely unchallenged. Including:
- Excluding a trans-identifying male from female toilets would "probably" amount to discrimination
- Members of the public could become "toilet police"
- There are "around 40 times" as many 'butch lesbians' as trans people
- The changes could cost "several billion" pounds
- The Supreme Court ruling is likely to be reversed within two or three years
Robin Moira White has a distinctly male voice, yet female pronouns were used throughout the interview. Later, listeners were introduced to "Michelle" from Watford as a woman, only to hear another distinctly male voice.
That creates the kind of dissonance that leaves listeners questioning whether they heard correctly.
Good journalism should help audiences understand what they're hearing, not leave them wondering whether they've misunderstood it.
It’s isn't about helping audiences arrive at a preferred conclusion.
It's about helping them understand the facts clearly enough to reach their own.
“I know of one parent who had to explain to her five-year-old daughter why she couldn’t be with her friends next term because she’s trans.”
The five-year-old ‘daughter’ is actually a male child. A son.
That’s confusing for readers - particularly in an article which repeatedly talks about the importance of girls-only spaces.
It’s also ideological language presented, without qualification, as fact.
Reporting sex accurately matters - including in articles written in the first person.
Quoting @jan_murray: A Girlguiding volunteer of almost 10 years has given an interview to The i about why she is resigning over the organisation’s return to being single-sex.
It’s actually quite a sad read. Amy Best-Rokins says Girlguiding was hugely important to her growing up and clearly remains an important part of her life.
But there’s a striking contradiction at the heart of her argument.
She repeatedly explains why girls need girls-only spaces - saying girls need somewhere they can “be themselves and have their voices heard”, and describing how they become quieter when boys are around.
Yet she is leaving because boys and men who identify as girls and women can no longer be members or leaders.
Some of her comments also raise questions about boundaries. She talks about Guides confiding in her about being “queer” and suggests the new policy sends the message that there is a “wrong” way to be a girl.
Parents need to be able to trust that volunteers in a girls’ organisation will not give their children confusing messages about sex - including the idea that boys can become girls simply by saying they are.
Not mentioned in the article is that Amy is an active member of GATE, which campaigns against Girlguiding’s decision to exclude males who identify as female.
On balance, I think it’s better that volunteers who cannot accept Girlguiding being genuinely single-sex choose to leave.
But how sad that young women are walking away from an organisation that has meant so much to them because they have been convinced that human beings can change sex.
Link below (behind Paywall)👇
James O'Brien is currently discussing the new EHRC Code of Practice on @LBC.
We'll reserve judgement until we've heard the full programme. However, he has already referred, multiple times, to women shouting at politicians: "Can women have a penis?"
He has also referred to himself as a 'Cis man' and suggested that while it may not be possible for women to have a penis biologically, it may be possible "socially". And linked gender critical views with Donald Trump.
Meanwhile, LBC has published an opinion article by Melissa Dee, CEO of a dedicated refuge for transgender and non-binary survivors of domestic abuse.
The piece raises legitimate questions about ensuring vulnerable trans people have access to appropriate services and support.
However, it also asserts that some transgender people could effectively be excluded from both male and female facilities as a result of the updated EHRC Code of Practice. That is not what the Code says.
Opinion journalism is entitled to take a position. It should not, however, present contested interpretations as established fact.
If an opinion piece blurs that distinction, it is the editor's job to challenge it before publication.
Quoting @LBC: 'For trans people, the right to exist freely is being stripped away'
✍️ Melissa Dee for LBC Opinion
https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/trans-people-nonbinary-echr-code-opinion-5HjdfdT_2/
Good to see @[private account] covering the new EHRC statutory code on single-sex spaces - which comes into effect today - and giving its chair, Mary-Ann Stephenson, a decent amount of time to explain the legal position.
But the introduction still slips into ideological framing, presenting the issue as ‘angry debate’ - women’s rights versus “trans rights”.
Lambeth council deputy leader Natalie Kane’s contribution was pre-recorded, meaning her claims went unchallenged - particularly the suggestion that the guidance could discourage LGBTQIA people from accessing “life-saving” services, which seems unrelated to rules on single-sex toilets and changing rooms.
She should also have been asked about the women whose privacy, dignity and safety these services exist to protect.
"Tristan identifies as a trans woman. Her preferred pronouns are she/her."
These are the words of @[private account] presenter @[private account] during today's interview with Fiona McAnena from @SexMattersOrg. About a male guest.
They were discussing his recent interview with Tristan Morrow - a young man who left the Orange Order and now identifies as a trans woman.
SEEN in Journalism criticised that interview for:
- Inaccuracy: using female pronouns for a man
- Failing to challenge contested ideological claims
- Not mentioning women once - despite covering disputes over women's sex-based spaces
We've now had the chance to listen back to today's interview with @[private account] (McAnena). While it was encouraging to hear a gender-critical woman given similar airtime, the two interviews could hardly have been more different.
Morrow was largely allowed to tell his personal story uninterrupted and with relatively little challenge.
McAnena faced repeated interruptions and hostile questioning, much of it relating to the recent controversy over the cancellation of a Women's Rights Network event at the Belfast arts festival Féile an Phobail.
Among the questions Buckler put to her - some more than once - were:
- Do you accept that people born male should be allowed to live as women?
- Do you object to referring to Tristan Morrow as "she"?
- How does using female pronouns for trans women impact your rights?
- Do you believe trans people have a right to exist?
- Do you accept there are adults who feel they are in the wrong body?
- Would you welcome a trans person to your event ?
McAnena did an admirable job of steering the conversation back to women's rights. Buckler repeatedly returned it to transgender identity.
Buckler also made several references to SEEN in Journalism's criticism of his interview with Morrow, but appeared to misunderstand the substance of our argument.
We did not say he should have included a female voice to "push back" on Morrow. We said he never mentioned women or women's rights once during a 21-minute interview about a dispute rooted in women's sex-based spaces.
That is a different point entirely.
We also raised concerns about inaccurate language - using female pronouns to describe a male guest.
Rather than engaging with those concerns, Buckler appeared to double down - at one point, appearing to rebuke McAnena for referring to Morrow as "he".
But our criticism wasn't about politeness.
It was about accuracy.
A principle the BBC should hold in the highest regard.
At one point, Buckler said he wasn't speaking from either side.
Yet across these two interviews, listeners learnt far more about identifying as trans than they did about why women defend sex-based rights.
Good journalism should help audiences understand competing perspectives, not steer them towards one.
Excellent use of clear language in reporting by Euan McColm @[private account] No confusing use of ‘transgender’ or ‘transwomen’ to create a misleading headline. The reader knows exactly what is happening from the start.
‘State-funded 'chestfeeding' by trans-identifying males is unforgivable abuse of infants’
Quotes a post by A0944; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Impressive clarity here in this interview from @[private account] recorded in advance of today’s panel discussion @[private account]
Good to hear this perspective on @[private account] .
The presenter, Chris, asked more questions about the impact on trans people than the impact on women.
The notion that women talking about reality is too upsetting to hear haunts many of these conversations.
@[private account] gave a clear example of male violence that happened in New Zealand when women met to talk publicly about their rights. Women’s words should not be met with violence from men, trans - identified or otherwise.
Clear about the law and how it needs to be upheld, however people feel about themselves.
A worthwhile listen.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pRkkTNf61rA
We urge @thetimes to reconsider its use of the word ‘transgender’ (see quote first few lines below), because it’s not specific enough.
‘Transgender’ doesn’t tell the reader whether the doctor is male or female.
In this case the doctor is a male. Hence Sandie Peggie’s refusal to share a changing room with a man.
The story - and the case - only make sense if the reader is aware the doctor is a man.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: Sandie Peggie, a nurse who refused to share a women’s changing room with a transgender doctor will have her appeal against the findings of an employment tribunal heard @thetimes
‘A statement released on behalf of Peggie’s lawyers said a judge had concluded there were reasonable grounds for bringing 13 points of appeal. It is expected a full appeal hearing will be heard in the first half of next year’
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/sandie-peggie-appeal-nhs-fife-tribunal-kdwhnxn0r
Sandie Peggie, a nurse who refused to share a women’s changing room with a transgender doctor will have her appeal against the findings of an employment tribunal heard @thetimes
‘A statement released on behalf of Peggie’s lawyers said a judge had concluded there were reasonable grounds for bringing 13 points of appeal. It is expected a full appeal hearing will be heard in the first half of next year’
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/sandie-peggie-appeal-nhs-fife-tribunal-kdwhnxn0r
@bindelj writes about the sacking of DC Rachel Fletcher, who was chair of Northumbria Police SEEN.
‘Fletcher also complained about a presentation on “The power of pronouns”, delivered by a trans man and another member of the DEI team. Attendees were warned that refusal to use preferred pronouns would cause harm. Again, these were sent by email. And each time, Fletcher says she received an acknowledgement promising to review her complaints and come back to her. “But they never did, they just reported me to Professional Standards.”’
https://unherd.com/2026/08/does-the-force-fear-feminists/
Confusing pronoun choices as the Daily Record uses ‘she’ in the headline for trans activist Sophie Molly - formerly Euan Weddell - and ‘he’ in the copy.
Molly claims he plans to use as many female toilets as possible on August 5 when the EHRC guidance deadline passes - ‘because I can’.
The reporting of this story is considerably fairer than the headline suggests.
Describing Sophie Cunningham as basketball’s new “anti-trans Maga poster girl” doesn’t exactly feel like a neutral description of her stated position.
But readers do hear Cunningham’s own words, her critics’ arguments and the views of her supporters.
The result is a much more balanced piece than the headline would lead readers to expect.
Link below 👇
Amnesty International UK has apologised for its A Growing Threat report - which labelled dozens of organisations, including women’s rights groups, as part of an “anti-rights” movement.
SEEN in Journalism was one of 51 organisations categorised as “gender critical” in the report and was among the many groups listed that submitted a formal complaint.
Amnesty has also removed its "Like a Snowball report" - published in May - which portrayed gender-critical campaigning as an organised attack on trans rights.
That report also offered questionable advice to journalists, urging them to publish more “positive” stories about trans people and avoid questions such as: “Can women have a penis?”
This is also good news.
Journalism should not be instructed to produce “positive” coverage. It should be accurate, impartial and willing to ask difficult questions.
And journalists committed to accurate reporting on sex and gender should never have been characterised as “anti-rights” for doing so.
Journalism is not about telling people what they want to hear. It is about reporting facts accurately, even when they are uncomfortable.
Richards is excluded because the conference is restricted by sex. It has nothing to do being trans. Asking journalists to make that distinction is not “hatred”. It is asking them to report accurately
This is blatantly inaccurate @MetroUK.
Steph Richards is excluded from the formal proceedings of Labour’s women’s conference because he is a man - not because he is trans.
While we’re discussing inaccuracies:
“Biological sex assigned at birth” is both inaccurate and ideologically loaded. Sex is observed and recorded, not assigned.
Richards having a GRC and undergoing surgery is irrelevant to eligibility because neither changes his sex under the Equality Act.
It is regrettable that Labour previously misled Richards about his eligibility for women’s opportunities. But last year’s Supreme Court judgment clarified the meaning of “woman” and “female” in law.
Isn’t it time Metro caught up - and stopped misleading its readers?
Four powerful unions boycotting Labour Women’s Conference is a strong story.
But @metrouk seemed muddled about the top line.
Accurately reported, four unions are pulling out because males are excluded from a women's conference.
Trans women are, by definition, male.
The ideological framing goes beyond the inaccurate “trans ban” headline (trans women may still attend fringe events).
Metro also states that the Supreme Court defined women as “people assigned female at birth”. It did not. The Court held that “woman” and “sex” in the Equality Act mean biological sex.
“Assigned female at birth” is ideologically contested language- not the wording or finding of the Court.
All four boycotting unions are quoted in the article - alongside two trans-advocacy groups.
Balance does not mean giving every viewpoint equal weight. But quoting six voices from one side, while failing to seek comment from the likes of Sex Matters, Labour Women’s Declaration or anyone able to explain the case for a women-only forum, is quite something.
Link below 👇
“Thuggish, sectarian, right-wing accounts.”
“You couldn’t get a sheet of paper between them and the far right.”
“They don’t want your kind of toxic gender ideology at their festival.”
“They were the same people cheering on attacks on migrants.”
“I’d be embarrassed if my political allies were Elon Musk and Donald Trump.”
These were among the descriptions used by Belfast Telegraph crime correspondent Allison Morris during a BBC Radio Ulster interview with @SexMattersOrg Director of Advocacy Helen Joyce earlier today.
They were debating the cancellation of a Women’s Rights Network event at Féile an Phobail.
Morris was defending her recent Belfast Telegraph column in which she accused women campaigning for sex-based rights of “obsessing” over a tiny trans minority and described them as an “online sectarian mob”.
She repeatedly linked gender-critical campaigners to Donald Trump, Elon Musk, anti-migrant activists and the far right - associations apparently drawn from scrolling people’s social-media feeds.
She accused Joyce of bringing a “nasty attitude” to the interview and asserted - incorrectly - that JK Rowling was funding legal action against Féile. The presenter read out a statement from WRN that refuted this.
When Joyce alleged that false claims had been made in both the column and the interview and said Morris should have checked her facts, Morris snapped: “We don’t interview people for opinion articles.”
Presumably Morris was unaware of Joyce’s own background as a journalist.
Opinion journalism allows robust criticism. But it does not remove the responsibility to check facts, represent opposing arguments fairly, acknowledge where claims are contested and distinguish scrutiny from personal attack.
Developments on the Amnesty front @thetimes
‘Amnesty boss offers to meet Sex Matters after trans rights row’
https://www.thetimes.com/article/ff158cd4-4d64-48cf-ba46-6cc741e184d1?shareToken=55c874c27136041ca8397777db85c272
@bindelj has spoken out about trans ideology for more than 20 years. She attended Pride at the weekend and reports for @Telegraph with brutal honesty about what she witnessed:
‘What I hadn’t anticipated was how upsetting I would find it. The sight of hundreds of young women showing off their double mastectomy scars left me tearful.
The first thing I had witnessed on arrival were two women, both with facial hair, passing cream to each other, wincing as they massaged the scars where their breasts had been.’
‘There’s nothing to celebrate about the extremism of trans Pride’ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/2026/07/27/nothing-to-celebrate-about-the-extremism-of-trans-pride/
Who ensures the police follow the law?
New from @[private account]
‘A police force is breaking the law by placing men who claim to be transgender in custody cells intended for women. Staffordshire Police is openly defying last year’s Supreme Court judgment, in other words, and is quite proud of the fact. Detainees are allowed “to self-identify their gender” and “may be placed in accommodation consistent with their gender identity”.’
https://unherd.com/newsroom/why-is-staffordshire-police-still-putting-men-in-womens-cells/
In @thetimes Lord Walney says the militant trans group Bash Back ‘deserves more serious attention’ after it published a guide on how to arm themselves and carry out repeated illegal attacks on MPs.
It told activists to form “independent local cells”, “identify a target” — including MPs, organisations and political party conferences — and “ensure your target can be hit repeatedly until they desist” from their “transphobic” activities
@[private account]
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/proscribe-militant-trans-group-bash-back-ex-political-violence-tsar-l9t757tjn
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Coverage of @[private account] and
Féile an Phobail
in the Belfast Telegraph.
The thrust seems to be that because women are already being abused by men on a regular basis, caring about women’s rights as impacted by trans identified men is not important.
The supposed parallel with Trump and Musk is outdated and could have been written in 2021. Most commentators now know that women who campaign for single sex spaces come from across the political spectrum.
https://archive.ph/2026.07.27-065721/https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/womens-rights-are-at-risk-just-not-from-a-tiny-trans-minority/a/159151011.html
📌Our weekly Substack round-up is here 📌
This week's theme? Media bias comes in many guises.
Including:
- London Trans+ Pride: what was left out of the coverage?
- Féile an Phobail: why follow-up journalism matters
- NHS Scotland: has anything really changed?
- Amnesty's 'anti-rights' report: did the scrutiny continue?
- Reduxx and the value of staying with a story
Read the latest edition here 👇
_______
P.S. Subscribe to our Substack and get our weekly round-up delivered straight to your inbox.
Alongside positive coverage of London Trans+ Pride - which left out the more unsavoury parts - both the Metro and Standard published an interview with Caroline Litman, whose child Alice died by suicide in 2022.
Litman believes long waits for gender-related healthcare contributed to her child's death.
The death of her child was a tragedy and her perspective absolutely deserves to be heard.
But journalism also has a responsibility to distinguish between personal testimony and wider evidence.
Both articles prominently report Litman's warning that "more children are going to die" unless the Prime Minister reverses what she calls Labour's "anti-trans policies". They also report claims that gender-affirming care is "life-saving care, especially in under-18s".
But these are not settled claims. In fact, they sit at the heart of one of the most fiercely debated areas of medicine and public policy. Yet readers are given little indication of that.
Where are the equivalent interviews with detransitioners who believe medical transition harmed them? Or with parents from groups such as Bayswater Support Group, who say they struggled to access exploratory care and felt affirmation was presented as the only acceptable path?
The loss of a young person's life is heartbreaking. But journalists still have a responsibility to report the facts accurately, distinguish between evidence and opinion and provide appropriate balance.
That doesn't mean giving equal weight to every viewpoint. It means acknowledging that there are other legitimate experiences and perspectives which are directly relevant to the story.
Balance doesn't mean denying a grieving mother's voice.
It means ensuring that other grieving families, detransitioners and parents with different experiences are heard too. Otherwise, journalism begins to look less like impartial reporting and more like advocacy.
It’s not just the BBC ignoring the more unsavoury side of yesterday’s London Trans+ Pride.
Across much of the mainstream media, the event was presented primarily as a colourful, peaceful demonstration against the loss of rights.
Images and reporting that might have complicated that narrative - including extremist placards, masked protesters and calls for violence against “TERFs”- were largely absent.
Journalism is always about editorial choices. And sometimes the most revealing choice is what gets left out.
The BBC’s coverage of yesterday’s London Trans+ Pride presents a colourful, celebratory event.
And leaves out its uglier side.
Like the placard that appeared to suggest that “TERFs” should be gassed. Or another that declared “OFF WITH THEIR HEADS” above pictures of JK Rowling and Queen Camilla.
The report mentions speeches by trans activists. But doesn't mention the one given by Sarah Jane Baker, who served 30 years in prison following convictions for kidnapping, torture and attempted murder.
Baker spoke about removing his own testicles after apparently being refused gender-affirming care.
Nor did the BBC mention the young woman wearing a placard with a QR code seeking donations for “gender surgery”. Or the young woman celebrating an upcoming elective mastectomy with the words: “It's my last summer with tits'.
Did BBC reporters see none of this, either while covering the event in person or on social media?
Every attendee quoted by the BBC is supportive, describing the event as “joyous”, “cathartic” or “amazing”. Claims about “malevolent” attitudes and the media failing to platform trans voices are reported without challenge.
No report can include everything.
But editorial choices matter.
When the BBC shows only the joyful, inclusive face of an explicitly political protest - while omitting violent rhetoric, a highly controversial speaker and any opposing perspective - it does not give audiences a rounded picture.
It sanitises the event.
Link in comments 👇
A leading industry publication reports that the Good Law Project (GLP) has complained to the Charity Commission and Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy, alleging that @SexMattersOrg is “breaking charity law” and spreading “hate”.
The @[private account] article appears to initially have been published without a right of reply from Sex Matters. It was later updated with comments taken from the charity’s blog.
Even after the update, it largely adopts the GLP’s framing. The organisation is described positively as one that “uses the law to protect the interests of the public”, while charged descriptions such as “anti-trans”, “hateful” and “dehumanising” are repeated in relation to Sex Matters.
Numerous contentious claims and quotations receive little context or scrutiny.
Take Girlguiding. Sex Matters Director of Advocacy @HJoyceGender's description of its former membership policy as a “human rights abuse against vulnerable children” is presented as painting trans people - including children. - as an “inherent threat”.
Yet the article does not explain that the membership policy previous allowed boys to join - as long as they 'identified' as girls - which raised legitimate safeguarding concerns.
Nor does it explain the significance of last year's Supreme Court ruling or Girlguiding’s legal obligations as a single-sex organisation.
Which means readers cannot fairly assess either Joyce’s criticism or the GLP’s interpretation of it.
A journalist’s job is not to take a side - it is to report the facts fairly.
Yet the central allegation is never properly tested: do these 46 incidents genuinely amount to hateful conduct - or is “hate” being used to delegitimise lawful advocacy on women's sex-based rights?
Link below 👇
Following our previous post about Chris Buckler's BBC interview with Tristan Morrow - who spoke about leaving the Orange Order and identifying as a trans woman - we listened to another segment from the same edition of The Stephen Nolan Show.
The discussion was about Féile an Phobail's decision to cancel a Women's Rights Network panel event on women's sex-based rights.
Overall, it was a much more balanced discussion.
Buckler challenged both guests, questioned claims from both sides and pushed back at various points.
But several moments stood out.
One was a claim by People Before Profit's Fiona Ferguson that organisations like the Women's Rights Network wanted "people's genitals to be checked before they're allowed to go into toilets."
Buckler then asked @[private account]'s Nora Calder:
"Do you want people's genitals checked before they go to the toilet?"
When a guest makes a highly contentious factual claim, shouldn't the first question be whether there's evidence to support it? Otherwise, an unsubstantiated allegation risks becoming the premise of the discussion - rather than something to be tested.
Ferguson also invoked contested suicide statistics relating to transgender people, which also went unchallenged.
But there are broader editorial questions too.
Tristan Morrow - a young man who identifies as a woman - was given 21 minutes of airtime, during which his perspective was explored with relatively little challenge.
Where is the equivalent long-form interview with a woman explaining why single-sex spaces matter to her? Or with someone who says they have suffered discrimination because of their lawful gender-critical beliefs?
The BBC also chose to publish Morrow's interview separately on BBC Sounds as a standalone programme, giving further prominence to one side's personal testimony.
And prior to introducing this segment Buckler reflected on the response to the interview with Tristan Morrow saying he'd received "lovely messages" from listeners.
There is, of course, nothing wrong with telling his story. And due impartiality doesn't require every viewpoint to receive equal airtime.
But it does require careful editorial judgement about which voices are amplified, how contested claims are handled, and whose experiences audiences are invited to understand.
Taken together, this coverage raises legitimate questions about whether that standard was met.
🎧 We've shared a short clip here. You can listen to the full discussion from on The Stephen Nolan Show (22 July). Tristan Morrow's interview is also available separately on BBC Sounds as a standalone programme.
What a remarkable interview,” says the BBC’s Chris Buckler, at the end of his conversation with a young man who left the Orange Order to ‘become a trans woman.’
He’s not wrong. But perhaps not for the reasons he thinks.
Not only does he use female pronouns for his guest, without qualification, he also makes a number of contested statements himself. Including:
“There are lots of ways to live a trans life.”
What does that actually mean?
He doesn’t explain.
Neither does he meaningfully interrogate a number of his guest’s claims - including that trans rights in Northern Ireland are in a “bad spot” or could be repealed “like in the US.”
The Rainbow Project is also mentioned, multiple times. But listeners are given no context that it is an advocacy organisation supporting LGBTQIA+ people, including asylum seekers and refugees.
Most strikingly, although Buckler acknowledges there is “fierce debate” on these issues, women are never mentioned.
Not one single mention of women’s rights.
In a 21 minute ‘coming out’ interview - with someone who claims it’s ‘scary’ being trans in the current political climate.
Instead, Buckler closes by saying he doesn’t want to end on a negative note and asks his guest: “What is the most positive thing about coming out as trans?”
So yes, it was a remarkable interview.
Just not for the reasons he suggested.
Link to listen below 👇
CLARIFICATION
******************
Separately, we'd like to apologise to
@[private account] who we initially thought was the presenter (as the interview was on his regular show). We name checked him, incorrectly, in our original post.
We did publish a clarification as soon as we realised we'd got it wrong. But felt it was best to republish the post with the correct attribution, which we have done here.
This article in The Athletic is a good example of how ideological framing can influence journalism.
The caption says Sophie Cunningham “came out against” transgender athletes competing in women’s sport. But that isn’t quite what she said. Her position was that males who identify as transgender should not compete in female sporting categories. Those are not the same thing.
The article also says Cunningham “doubled down” on her comments. That isn’t a neutral description. It implies obstinacy or wrongdoing rather than simply standing by a previously expressed view.
It also uses the term “cisgender athletes” as though it were an uncontested, neutral description - despite ongoing disagreement about that terminology.
Readers are given little context as to why many sports governing bodies have introduced sex-based eligibility rules. Instead, the issue is framed primarily as a political controversy.
Link below 👇
Should journalists describe Pride as a celebration or a protest?
A London Trans+ Pride organiser claims a planned BBC interview was dropped after a disagreement over exactly that question.
The organiser told Attitude magazine
the BBC referred to the event as a “celebration”. The organisers pushed back, insisting: “No, it’s a protest.”
If true, why was the BBC trying to sanitise an event that, to many, is a protest?
The BBC says it has no record of the alleged incident and cannot comment on the specific claim.
On Sunday morning, BBC Scotland broadcast a ten-minute discussion about “queer identities”- with virtually no meaningful challenge to the terminology or claims being made.
Presenter Tony Kearney was interviewing Alice Oseman, author of the Heartstopper graphic novels, which centre on a romance between two teenage boys and have been adapted into a popular Netflix series.
Kearney praised Heartstopper for bringing terminology such as “aromantic” and “asexual” into mainstream media and “normalising” identities that might otherwise be marginalised.
But he didn’t clarify what those terms - or, indeed, the phrase “queer identities” - actually mean. Nor did he acknowledge that some of these labels, and the ideas underpinning them, are contested.
When Oseman referred to legal rulings being “fought against”, the trans community being under intense scrutiny and public discourse causing trans people “so much harm”, Kearney didn’t ask which rulings, what scrutiny or which discourse she meant.
These claims were allowed to pass as settled facts.
In a ten-minute interview, there was just one passing reference to “pushback” before the discussion moved swiftly to countries where homosexuality is illegal - an important issue, but a different one from contested ideas about gender identity.
This was broadcast on BBC Radio Scotland’s Sunday Morning, described as:
“Two hours of music and conversation with a faith and ethical perspective. Taking the week’s events to ask what they say about our values and beliefs.”
Just to be clear: the issue isn’t that the BBC discussed Heartstopper.
It’s that contested ideas were presented without context or challenge - and without a single genuinely probing question.
We've clipped the most notable sections together here.
The full interview is available on BBC Sounds - approx
03:48 - 14:23, (19 July 2026)
‘Born a man, but identifies as a trans woman’ says the report and uses factually accurate pronouns throughout. Agree with WRN Norfolk though that the pink hatted pic is an odd choice of photograph for a highly dangerous man.
Quotes a post by T09064; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Two pieces in @WSJopinion and @[private account] by Leor Sapir. Why the rapid increase, where 1 in 65 girls in one state received a ‘trans’ diagnosis?
Quoting @LeorSapir: In Oregon, 1 in 65 girls received a transgender-related clinical diagnosis between 2016 and 2023.
1 in 240 girls received hormones.
Kids in Oregon were almost 20 times more likely than kids in Mississippi to have a "gender dysphoria" diagnosis.
How did this happen?
This @[private account] article associates the ‘gender binary’ with MAGA. Even though it’s clear they mean ‘sex’ in the article, which is in fact a biological binary that exists outside of any politics.
It’s also seen as a ‘contradiction’ that military aged men are given testosterone, whilst ‘The Trump administration has denounced puberty blockers and hormone therapy for transgender minors as “chemical mutilation”.’
Experimentation on consenting adult males with hormones would be seen by most people as a very different thing to giving hormones on minors. Sadly the opportunity to spell out any facts about hormone use is overlooked. Politics comes before factual information in this piece unfortunately. https://www.ft.com/content/c5045a09-29c1-4a9b-8f5b-f8dead22b09c?syn-25a6b1a6=1
@Telegraph
‘Anti-trans views classed as misinformation in government report.’
Document in the next link below 👇https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/5058d05218cc876f
Why is the National Council for the Training of Journalists (NCTJ) - the UK's principal journalism training and accreditation body - quoting Attitude magazine in a post about honesty in journalism?
This is a publication that has repeatedly claimed the EHRC's guidance "excludes" trans people from single-sex spaces.
That is not what the guidance says.
The guidance explains that trans people may lawfully be excluded from single-sex spaces that do not correspond to their biological sex in certain circumstances. That is not the same as saying trans people are excluded from single-sex spaces altogether.
Precision matters. Especially in guidance on honesty and accuracy for journalists.
Quotes a post by T17954; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘Green Party councillors attended a transgender rights rally where some protesters repeatedly stabbed darts into an effigy of Andy Burnham’
https://www.thetimes.com/article/90b8043b-0dd7-45d0-a873-dacad5c0f227?shareToken=c71c59dc61ee4807a4ae9c61b67a07bf
We have also written to @[private account] about our inclusion in their recent report ⬇️
Re: Amnesty International UK publication “A Growing Threat – The Anti Rights Movement in the UK”
Dear Ms Moscogiuri, Ms Horton and Mr Ruthven,
Seen in Journalism is a network of journalists and content makers committed to restoring accuracy and impartiality in reporting on sex and gender.
We are writing regarding your publication A Growing Threat – The Anti Rights Movement in the UK, released on 8 July 2026 and removed shortly afterwards.
Your report wrongly labelled several UK organisations, including Seen In Journalism, as “anti rights”, and linked gender critical groups to misogyny, homophobia, and anti-abortion activism.
These claims are inaccurate, misleading and seriously harmful.
Seen in Journalism has never opposed the rights of women, LGB people, or even those who identify as transgender. Nor have we ever campaigned on abortion. Presenting us as part of an “anti rights” movement misinforms the public and damages our reputation.
The report also described organisations supporting parents, detransitioners and young people as engaging in “conversion practices”.
This is a serious allegation presented without evidence.
Given Amnesty International’s influence, these mischaracterisations carry weight.
We demand that Amnesty issue a clear public apology and correction addressing the false statements made about Seen in Journalism and other groups.
We would appreciate confirmation that this matter is being formally reviewed.
‘Labour’s Manchester mayor hopeful clashes with Burnham over trans views’
That’s if you believe Burnham has actually changed his mind
@Telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/07/04/labour-manchester-mayor-bev-craig-andy-burnham-clash-trans/
Once again the BBC frames opposition to the Conversion Practices draft bill as entirely religious in nature. Although this is a religion-based programme, it doesn’t explain at any point that there are concerns that affirmation is seen by many as a conversion practice, nor does it explain that there are also grave safeguarding concerns from medics and psychotherapists. Badly misleading, and the pres was unable to challenge the pro-trans guest on the detail of how the loose and subjective terms ‘abuse’, ‘economic and emotional pressure’ and ‘serious harm’ can be interpreted and exploited.
There’s no balance over time and platforms: these concerns are vastly underreported in the BBC website compared to the lived complaints of transactivists, and the fears of gay conversion by transitioning aren’t there at all.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m002ymvv
‘Supreme Court bans trans athletes from sports handing Trump culture war victory’
No it doesn’t, and no it’s not a culture war
‘Supreme Court rules on single sex sports in a victory for women’s rights’
Quoting @DailyMail: Supreme Court BANS transgender athletes from sports handing Trump culture war victory https://trib.al/Zx5DX1f
‘This does not mean that the Tribunal has reached or is expressing any view on the transgender or gender identity debate’
Yes it does. The Tribunal has reached and is expressing a view that a trans person’s requests are of more value than the person or persons who do not wish to comply with them. It has reached and is expressing the view that compliance with preferred pronouns is *only* a matter of respect and that respect is *only* due to the trans person.
‘What the curious case of Darren Rigby says about BBC trans coverage’
https://www.thetimes.com/article/1d940dfa-bb62-4af5-90fe-49756bb0b269?shareToken=85eae18ec1ccd2d37c8d28df99eb13ad
‘Army chiefs ‘failing female soldiers’ over trans guidance’
@Telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/06/27/female-soldiers-failed-by-mod-over-trans-guidance-claim/
He remains an LGBT reporter/producer but his focus when he does do these stories is strictly LGB. Think gay veterans etc. The ‘trans’ story is covered by others. But giving him this means they don’t ‘get’ the story, and there’s no way he’s going to point out to them that the while point of the bill is a vehicle for self-ID.
‘This new trans ‘conversion’ law is a punishment for parents’
@telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/2026/06/26/leader-2-this-new-trans-conversion-law-is-a-punishment/
‘Under SEEN principles you would lose language, pronouns, gender identity. Without those, trans people would no longer exist’.
Of course the people would exist. But this is exactly why compliant language is defended to such an extreme in the media, and why all the SEENs are vital. Language compliance is a furiously defended, foundational need for gender identity activists. If you can’t change the law, change the meaning of the word in the law. Or the policy. Or the story. So while the BBC kicked out Mermaids, kicked out Stonewall, kicked out the LGBTQ job, and instructed writers to use ‘biological male’, it is still too afraid to kick self-ID out of its writing rules. The same goes for almost every other outlet. Some actually use it as a quid pro quo for keeping IPSO quiet while they cover a wider range of stories.
There’s no law to force the use of inaccurate pronouns, and no regulatory rule. It’s the expression of, as well as the result of, enormous power.
Quotes a post by A2920; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘Dig beneath the surface of this data and there’s less of a problem here than meets the eye..11% of 195 cases were incidents that took place abroad, and only 52% were from people classified as British citizens..a further 38% were classified as historic’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/06/25/banning-trans-conversion-therapy-will-cause-far-more-harm/
‘The Office for Equality and Opportunity said talking children out of irreversible trans treatments would not fall foul of the law as the offence would have to be for the intention of changing someone’s identity, be abusive as well as causing long-term harm’
@Telegraph
‘However, critics say the definition of abuse is drawn too wide and covers “controlling or coercive words or behaviour”, “use of economic pressure” and “use of psychological or emotional pressure” – all of which could be used against parents, teachers and health professionals’
Quotes from Maya @MForstater and @AllianceLGB with @stonewalluk and Hilary Cass in support.
Most coverage is missing the lived experience of parents and the Bayswater Support response
Quoting @SexMattersOrg: “Opponents of the bill have long warned the new law could criminalise doctors, teachers and parents for having conversations with children about whether they really wish to change gender.”
@MForstater in @Telegraph on the draft conversion-practices bill
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/06/25/five-year-sentences-for-conversion-therapy-under-new-law/
Unfortunately this is a bill that mandates conversion therapy for gay people via transgender affirmation. For example, parents who suggest their daughter does not need clinical intervention because she’s simply a lesbian, not a man, face criminal charges and a prison sentence.
It’s a homophobic plan. Conversion therapy for LGB could have been passed years ago - long before Boris Johnson promised it - but it’s always been held up by gender identity campaigners who said it had to be ‘inclusive’.
Typically objections are framed as ‘religious’, because focussing on the parents who could be jailed for telling their children the truth - that they can’t change sex - would be extremely uncomfortable and stark for many campaigners. But it’s the case.
Terrible, minimal, barely there update, framed around ‘trans’ over single sex.
‘Payout for Darlington nurses after trans changing room tribunal’
Ps Drop ‘unisex’ and ‘gender neutral’ completely and just use ‘single’ and ‘mixed sex’, so much clearer. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c39yr3078z7o
This👇 x a thousand
You don’t have to affirm a person’s ‘trans identity’ to be biased. You just have to affirm that gender identity exists. That’s bias enough.
Quoting @genspect: “How could that ever be a scientific study? We’re starting with the completely false premise that gender identities exist.”
- @_CryMiaRiver on the PATHWAYS puberty blocker trial
Yes: and it should be extracted from trusted media educational materials too. This👇is BBC Bitesize for 14-16 year olds. It doesn’t have to affirm a child’s ‘trans identity’ to be harmful: it simply has to affirm that ‘gender identity’ is real and innate, and the damage is done.
‘Seeing our mainstream media in Australian referring to a man strongly suspected of murdering his grandson as the little boy's 'Grandmother' is one of the most disgraceful examples of the complete capitulation of our press to the idiocy of 'trans'.’
Quotes a post by A2782; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Even after the apology and corrections, they can’t bear to give it a ‘trans’ tag and put it on the right page
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: You have to remember that if it weren’t for you (and us, and every complainant) holding the BBC to account, its original version would be the historical record. Don’t stop.
‘This article was originally published without including key details about this case, due to miscommunication between BBC reporters in court and the writers’
‘We have updated the article to explain that these threats were directed at three all-girls' schools, related to the "misgendering" of trans girls and that Darren Rigby identified in one threat as a trans woman’
‘We have also included further details from these communications which referred to TERFs, targeting female pupils and staff and included threats to use bladed weapons, a crossbow, a revolver, and poison.’
‘Separately, we have also added reaction from senior leaders at all three schools, in which they explain the fear, disruption and upset caused by these threats to pupils, parents and staff.’
‘We have also included comments from Recorder Eric Lamb during sentencing that despite Rigby's guilty plea at the earliest opportunity, this was a "planned and sophisticated plot" which included measures to make him harder to trace, and the Recorder's references to defence submissions which included Rigby's heavy use of cannabis and alcohol, immaturity, previous convictions and refusals to provide medical information for two psychiatric reports
‘We apologise for the failures in our reporting’
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0e20ll9gz2o
You have to remember that if it weren’t for you (and us, and every complainant) holding the BBC to account, its original version would be the historical record. Don’t stop.
‘This article was originally published without including key details about this case, due to miscommunication between BBC reporters in court and the writers’
‘We have updated the article to explain that these threats were directed at three all-girls' schools, related to the "misgendering" of trans girls and that Darren Rigby identified in one threat as a trans woman’
‘We have also included further details from these communications which referred to TERFs, targeting female pupils and staff and included threats to use bladed weapons, a crossbow, a revolver, and poison.’
‘Separately, we have also added reaction from senior leaders at all three schools, in which they explain the fear, disruption and upset caused by these threats to pupils, parents and staff.’
‘We have also included comments from Recorder Eric Lamb during sentencing that despite Rigby's guilty plea at the earliest opportunity, this was a "planned and sophisticated plot" which included measures to make him harder to trace, and the Recorder's references to defence submissions which included Rigby's heavy use of cannabis and alcohol, immaturity, previous convictions and refusals to provide medical information for two psychiatric reports
‘We apologise for the failures in our reporting’
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0e20ll9gz2o
‘Controversial NHS transgender teens puberty blocker trial given green light despite court challenge’
‘Children who think they’re trans’ - way better than ‘trans children’ which the @DailyMail is still persistently using - why?
@thesun
@[private account] https://www.thesun.co.uk/health/39473321/nhs-transgender-teenager-puberty-blocker-pathways-trial-approved/
V quickly @DailyMail - they’re not ‘transgender children’. They’re children who are said to be ‘trans’.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: ‘Children as young as 11 to be given puberty blockers in controversial trial as furious campaigners urge courts to completely shut down 'unethical experiment'’
@DailyMail https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15914283/children-young-11-given-puberty-blockers.html
As the puberty blocker trial gets the go-ahead, it’s vital to keep a focus on where trans identification begins. This report from
@[private account]
@[private account]
@[private account]
reveals how children are coached into a belief in gender identity via captured literature.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: Update on the PATHWAYS clinical trial
http://Gov.uk
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/update-on-the-pathways-clinical-trial
This is on the BBC front page - click to keep it there
‘Scottish guidance for trans prisoners is unlawful’
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cz7502eq5lro
‘The other major point of debate will be trans conversion therapy and all of the opposing views on gender identity’
Quoting @PaulBrandITV: The reason I point to religious groups is because there has been a huge to and fro about whether the ban will apply to religious settings. Freedoms collide here - freedom to be who you are versus freedom to believe what you want etc.
The other major point of debate will be trans conversion therapy and all of the opposing views on gender identity, as I’ve already alluded to in my first tweet.
This isn’t great for @STVNews
It doesn’t explain one time that this is about men/males in women’s jails - a huge contrast to @[private account] coverage
https://news.stv.tv/politics/scottish-government-loses-legal-challenge-over-trans-prisoners-in-female-jails
‘In all the circumstances, the prisons guidance is unlawful’
@BBCNews - a decent go of it and care taken
Two notes: it was once (and various trans media guides demand this) verboten and at the least highly controversial to say ‘opposite sex’, believe it or not. Good to see it used freely here. Secondly ‘sex at birth’ should be abandoned everywhere. If you need a qualifier for people with a GRC, it should be the phrase ‘certificated sex’. Sex as a standalone word with its natural meaning should be normalised. However the BBC isn’t the only mainstream outlet that clings to this phrasing, and this write up is really pretty fair.
‘Judge rules Scottish guidance for housing trans prisoners is unlawful’
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cz7502eq5lro
‘BREAKING
Scotland's trans prison policy is unlawful finds Court of Session’
Nice to see so many outlets jumping on this as the banging story it is
https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/26210300.scotlands-trans-prison-policy-unlawful-finds-court-session/
‘Housing trans inmates in women’s jails ‘unlawful’, judge rules’
The Standard also means male but can’t bear to say do - PA has a lot to answer for
https://www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/scottish-scottish-prison-service-court-of-session-scottish-government-supreme-court-b1286808.html
‘Housing trans inmates in women’s jails ‘unlawful’, judge rules’
@irish_news means ‘male trans inmates’
https://www.irishnews.com/news/uk/housing-trans-inmates-in-womens-jails-unlawful-judge-rules-6AZH3DK66FJX3DBMVZCL2NP7FU/
‘SNP ministers lose court battle over trans prisoners in female jails’

@TheScotsman
https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/snp-ministers-lose-court-battle-over-trans-prisoners-in-female-jails-8750281
An informative case study. Gender identity activists (MP Samantha Niblet is an example, Amnesty another, there are plenty) complain about the number of stories about trans-identified people in the last five years. Leaving aside the fact that for the most part they are stories about women or child safeguarding, the period from which this case study late 20-teens) was taken was a time of maximum positive exposure for trans campaigners. There were no complaints from activists then about too much coverage - but some journalists, medics and feminists complained about the stories that *weren’t* being told. Those complaints are still relevant.
From our point of view, yes this is a tragedy but it’s also a really hard-hitting feature or lived experience. A good story, in other words, and to be fair quite an easy story - it’s begging to be told. It’s also informative for others and for parents. There are thousands similar. They weren’t told then, and they still aren’t being told. To comply with activists, journalists and editors have had to suppress their natural instinct for a scandal, for over a decade. When this type of ‘personal journey’ is routinely broadcast or published, in mainstream media specifically, then we might (might) say the media tide has turned. But there’s still too much fear.
Quotes a post by T13768; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘The Misuse of Suicide Statistics by Transgender Activists’
By Peter Sim @[private account]
https://open.substack.com/pub/justdad7180/p/the-misuse-of-suicide-statistics?r=3lemhw&utm_medium=ios
International human rights expert and Scottish Human Rights Commission member Dr Claire Methven O'Brien @[private account] on the SNP plan to ban so-called ‘conversion therapy’
‘Parents could be guilty of a crime just for querying the feeling of a daughter or son that they were ‘born in the wrong body’. A gently-framed question to your trans-identifying child – ‘Why do you think that, pet?’ for example – would be outlawed as dangerous hate speech.’
‘You might be considered guilty of conversion practices - in SNP-speak - just for failing to affirm someone else’s belief that they have changed or can change their sex’
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15908455/In-past-idea-just-talking-child-land-you-JAIL-unthinkable-threat-REAL.html
The Media Democracy Festival. As recommended by ‘trans women are women’ Jeremy Corbyn and Clive Lewis. Featuring Peter Jukes of Byline Times. Not an event where the compliant narrative will be challenged.
Never be complacent that the tide is turning on counterfactual sex and gender coverage. Heels are being dug in.
https://mediademocracyfestival.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Programme-MDF26-A4-V3.png
‘A year on from controversy over a lack of gender critical writers in its programme, the festival will be hosting a ‘good faith discussion’ which will feature a panel of legal experts looking at the impact of last year’s Supreme Court ruling on the definition of a woman’
Good faith? Let’s see more on that 👇
‘Global conflicts, the rise of the far right, online conspiracies, immigration and AI will be among the major issues tackled at the Edinburgh International Book Festival under the banner of ‘Changing your mind’.
The EBF itself has been incapable of such change: multiple headliners are openly and radically activist in favour of sex self-ID - Nicola Sturgeon, Q Manivannan, former Finnish Prime Minister Sanna Marin and Juno Dawson are four - along with activist-lite guests like Lorraine Kelly.
Here’s the unbalanced panel on the Supreme Court ruling - Karen Monaghan is there but with Brenda Hale and Keio Yoshida
https://www.edbookfest.co.uk/events/when-rights-collide
Here is Brenda Hale on the Supreme Court ruling and ‘questioning what was meant by ‘biological sex’’
https://www.theguardian.com/law/2025/may/22/court-ruling-legal-definition-of-a-woman-misinterpreted-lady-hale
Here is Keio talking about ‘Queer joy and trans rights’
https://ramonamag.com/2025/06/keio-yoshida-talks-trans-rights-legal-wins-and-queer-joy-worldwide/
Good faith would involve a fourth and relevant member of the panel who’s a gender critical activist, to balance Keio, who no one has ever heard of anyway.
Good faith would include Susan Smith, Marion Calder or Trina Budge of @ForWomenScot, for their relationship to the legal case.
Good faith would include @[private account] for her relationship with the EHRC.
Good faith might even include a panel member from @SexMattersOrg or a journalist like @[private account] or @[private account]
The current panel is not balanced, and consequently the ‘good faith’ claim is an attempt at gaslighting, which the Herald should have integrated further.
https://archive.ph/2026.06.16-152715/https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/26196411.book-festival-lines-nicola-sturgeon-liz-lloyd-q-manivannan/
‘Through the Looking Glass’, a report by SEEN in Publishing, Transgender Trend and Biology in Medicine, will be formally presented in a House of Lords committee room at the invitation of Baroness Jenkins at 4:30pm today.
‘Journalists across Ireland realised that if the Irish Times were toeing the line, it’d be a brave fool who went against it.
Then Joe Duffy allowed himself to be silenced by @[private account] and that was the death knell to free thought about trans issues in Irish mainstream media.
‘Rather than having the integrity to admit they’ve been silenced, Irish journalists try to keep their self-respect by pretending they have more important things to write about’
Quoting @stellaomalley3: The chilling effect is most clear when you look at what happened to Ken Zucker.
In 2015 Dr Ken Zucker got sacked from his position since 1981 as clinical lead of the gender services in Canada. When Zucker was taken down, he was known to be the most respected world expert on gender issues in kids. Consequently, clinicians across the world immediately silenced themselves.
The thinking was that if trans activists could take down Zucker then they could take down anyone. I’ve heard GIDS clinicians from the Tavistock describe how the news of Zucker being sacked caused shockwaves at GIDS.
Zucker later won $586000 in compensation from the clinic but the damage was done.
The same chilling effect happened when the @IrishTimes pandered to trans activists in the student union in 2021. Journalists across Ireland released that if the Irish Times were toeing the line, then it’d be a brave fool who went against this.
(From then on I became blacklisted from the Irish mainstream media but luckily my work was valued elsewhere).
Then the following summer, June 2022, Joe Duffy allowed himself to be silenced by @[private account] and that was the death knell to free thought about trans issues in the Irish mainstream media.
Again the thought process was that if Joe Duffy could be silenced - and he could - then anyone could be. Just like Ken Zucker with gender therapy, the impact sent shockwaves through Irish journalism.
Sadly, rather than having the integrity to admit they’ve been silenced, the Irish journalists now try to keep their self-respect by pretending that they just have other more important things to write about.
It’s insult upon injury but this is where we are
‘Taskmaster faces fury from trans mob as Richard Ayoade lands role after Graham Linehan support’
Exceptional intolerance from gender identity activists https://www.gbnews.com/celebrity/taskmaster-richard-ayoade-graham-linehan-trans-backlash
Thorough, detailed fact check of recent claims regarding a recent ‘detransition’ study out of Canada. Well worth bookmarking from @[private account]
Brief snapshots but pls read the whole thing:
‘We urge those with a scientific bent to look closely into the authors and understand the conflict of interest’
‘Its design (selection bias, short follow-up, subjective charting, no controls, narrow outcomes) severely limits causal claims about innate/immutable identity or the necessity/safety of early medicalization’
‘It does not refute historical desistance data, population-level non-persistence findings, or concerns about social influence and exploratory care’
‘This study will, of course, be cited endlessly by trans activists, dubious NGOs funded by opaque means, and "gender-affirming" providers who make bank off the nebulous concept of "gender identity", ignoring the poor quality and evident biases present even with a cursory glance’
Quotes a post by A0606; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There’s a real problem here which is partly ‘our’ fault. Journalists simply haven’t challenged enough this activist idea that rejecting the Code can change the law. They haven’t sufficiently factchecked transactivist MPs, and have even contributed to this Code-led belief by stressing (constantly) the importance of waiting for the Code. Some have even ‘waited for the Code’ themselves in building their own policies.
Of course the National doesn’t explain in this piece either
‘The guidance bans transgender women from using female toilets, changing facilities and sports teams, and transgender men from the male facilities’
It’s wishful thinking on a spectacular scale.
‘More than 15k people write to MPs calling for EHRC trans guidance to be scrapped’
https://www.thenational.scot/news/26191284.15k-people-write-mps-calling-ehrc-trans-guidance-stop/
‘An artist who would go on to become a defining figure of..LGBT+ culture’
Not T+ at all. Did not speak about ‘trans’. He knew what a man was. This is the BBC profile by TQ reporter Josh Parry.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cpq393dz535o
Here’s the other, better profile.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgjxdr27z4o
‘SNP accused of 'working hand in glove' with trans radicals to scrap single-sex spaces and 'undermine women's rights'’
Fantastic to see this coverage, long overdue - a true scandal
@DailyMail https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15895823/SNP-trans-radicals-single-sex-spaces.html
The most problematic elements of this report - apart from the selective nature of the story choice - are the rewriting of ‘trans’ into LGB history, the deployment of mainly T sympathetic voices and the incorrect description of the flag as Pride, not Progress. The Progress flag is indubitably a trans flag and there’s huge controversy around its appropriation of the rainbow, which this report fails to reflect.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c621455wy2yo
‘Lib Dem trans rights stance condemned by leader’s own brother’
‘It does not matter if the trans woman is the most wholesome person in the world - that misses the point.
‘Opposition to single sex spaces demonstrates a sad lack of insight, understanding or compassion for girls and women’
Killer last line ..’some trans-activists will stay with the Lib Dems in the hope of a coalition with the Greens..Where did I put my passport?’
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15891443/Lib-Dem-trans-rights-stance-condemned-leader-Ed-Daveys-brother.html
‘District Judge Amanda Brailsford asked officials how they could expect to enforce the law when many trans people now carry ID that corresponds with their correct gender’
Not just UK MPs who believe sex is undetectable. Here’s a US judge equally mystified.
Quoting @PinkNews: Idaho officials tell judge they can use DNA testing to enforce trans bathroom laws
https://www.thepinknews.com/2026/06/11/idaho-dna-bathroom-law/?utm_content=1781195212&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter
There is no limit to the media demands of gender identity activists.
From the BBC, on the More or Less pod ‘Transgender women in sport’:
‘A listener complained that ‘The construction ‘transgender women vs. women’ carries a specific logical implication: that transgender women are not women’ and argued this meant the report failed to meet the BBC’s editorial standards for impartiality’.
Not upheld. But for the terrible reason that ‘the podcast did not offer a view on whether or not transgender women are women’.
The podcast didn’t need to ‘offer a view’. It needed to explain the *fact* that they aren’t, for the benefit of the audience.
This is what the BBC is balancing against your complaints that describing men as women is inaccurate.
It’s a false comparison because the facts land squarely on one side of the question, and the complaints response and editorial policy should reflect that.
But because the BBC still gets nonsensical complaints like this👇 it thinks it’s being fair overall.
Here’s the podcast
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0n6gnpr
https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/index.php/ecu/transgender-women-in-sport-does-comparable-mean-equal-more-or-less-podcast
‘NUJ statement on revised EHRC Equality Act Code of Practice’
https://www.nuj.org.uk/resource/nuj-statement-on-revised-ehrc-equality-act-code-of-practice.html
‘The NUJ stresses that the media, like has a responsibility to treat transgender people with fairness, integrity and respect. The NUJ encourages members and the wider media to follow the union’s code of conduct and LGBT+ reporting guidelines.
And here are those guidelines, which refer journalists to Trans Media Watch
https://www.nuj.org.uk/static/b121e12d-034d-4a3d-997b68eb49bc3e17/NUJ-guidelines-on-LGBT-reporting.pdf
This is the TMW media guide
https://transmediawatch.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Media-Style-Guide.pdf
The NUJ is completely captured.
‘Police chiefs face legal challenge over trans guidance that lets biological men request strip-search by female officers’
Much clearer headline than the Telegraph on the @WomensRightsNet @SexMattersOrg judicial review
@DailyMail https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15889749/Police-chiefs-legal-challenge-trans-strip-search-female-officers.html
‘While a vote would not be required to enact the code and make it statutory, either House could pass a motion to reject it within the 40 days’
‘An EDM can be lodged to highlight an objection but does not automatically lead to a debate or a vote’ https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15888391/Keir-Starmer-facing-transgender-rights-rebellion-100-MPs-demand-guidance-protecting-women-spaces-scrapped.html
‘Trans suspects can demand strip search by female officer’
They mean male trans-identifying
Gift🎁 article
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/9eb5be1e7fe3e1f0
‘The claim that neuroscience has established a biological basis for trans identity in children circulates in clinical guidance, advocacy literature, and mainstream journalism with a confidence the underlying research does not support.
‘When examined carefully, the findings..fail to establish what is claimed on their behalf’
Quotes a post by A2299; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘The obvious response is to marvel at the intellectual poverty which assumes identifying as trans confers a permanent state of vulnerability and the right to never have one’s opinion challenged..yet our MPs have spent the past week making the same points’
@jo_bartosch in @unherd
These tactics and arguments are out of 2017 / 2018 and it’s worrying that they’re coming back. Terrific piece from Jo.
https://unherd.com/newsroom/trans-activists-are-realising-that-gender-law-was-never-on-their-side/
‘’Please join me in walking out and refusing to platform this bigot’..Audience members could be heard urging the protesters to leave’
‘Oxford professor cancels lectures after abuse from pro-trans protesters’ @[private account]
@telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/9184b1e907696f9c
‘The justices are poised to decide major cases concerning US culture wars issues such as guns and trans athletes.. intensifying efforts to restrict the rights of trans people..cracking down on the rights of trans people..ban transgender athletes from sports teams for women and girls..gender-affirming medical care for transgender minors..’ and more.
You can’t trust @Reuters
Get past the captured language and there’s a handy list of upcoming US cases.
Quoting @Reuters: President Trump's policies on tariffs, immigration and firing regulatory officials have drawn attention during the Supreme Court's current term. Now the justices are poised to decide major cases concerning ‘culture-war’ issues https://reut.rs/4uPV82B
‘Gender policing’ is jargon for knowing that a person is male or female. It should only ever be used by activists. Impartial journalists should never use this phrase.
Another day, another podcast, more men opining about ‘mercilessly targeting trans people’.
Quotes a post by T11997; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Note: leaving aside the absurd notion that one could ‘misgender a baby’, this is the principle of self-ID in action, and the reason so many outlets struggle. It’s none, or all. If a baby, then also a rapist.
If it’s ’some’ then journalists at the sharp end have to make day to day desk decisions on whether someone is ‘true trans’ and ‘deserves’ pronouns, story by story.
The maximally defensible solution is simply to say: always be accurate, and at the very least never lie.
Quotes a post by A3572; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘Norfolk MP Clive Lewis faces criticism after calling on the government to protect organisations coming under pressure to change their trans policies. He’s accused of ignoring that the law on the issue is now crystal clear’
@EDP24 is consistently solid
https://www.edp24.co.uk/news/26166760.norfolk-mp-clive-lewis-rebuked-single-sex-spaces-letter/
‘Why are trade unions undermining women’s workplace rights? Unions spend more time defending ‘trans brothers and sisters’ than the interests of female members’
By @jan_murray in @spikedonline
https://www.spiked-online.com/2026/06/04/why-are-trade-unions-undermining-womens-workplace-rights/
‘Trans people keep access to Hampstead ponds’
‘Trans people can continue to use Hamstead (sic) Heath's ponds after the City of London Corporation voted to keep the existing policy in place’
The BBC online team is incorrigible. Trans people never lost access, and were never threatened with being unable to use the ponds. That would be illegal. Whereas implementing the Supreme Court ruling is obviously not illegal.
Ludicrously misleading headline @BBCNews - designed to build an exclusion and victimhood narrative out of single-sex policy.
How hard is it to get it right?
‘Hampstead ponds to defy Equality Act on trans access’
‘‘Hampstead ponds to defy Supreme Court on trans access’
‘Hampstead ponds votes against single sex access’
‘Trans males keep access to women’s pond at Hampstead’
‘Trans people keep access to opposite sex Hampstead ponds’
No idea why the BBC wants to hide this from the transgender page, but it does. Some late in the day awareness that it’s a very bad look, perhaps.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqjpjvvyp91o
The BBC covers the finding that a school’s mixed sex toilet set up, where girls and boys share handwashing facilities, constituted an act of indirect discrimination against primary school girls.
But @[private account] decided not to tag it Schools, Primary Schools, Court of Session, Lothian, Equality Act, Transgender People, Toilets, Equality Act, Scottish Government, Court of Session, Sexism or Young People, all of which serve to hide it from those pages.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgzgldvv47o
Gift 🎁 link
‘House of Commons staff have been advised to contact trans activist groups and mental health workers for support if they are upset by official guidance protecting women’s right to single-sex spaces’
‘An email sent to all Commons staff called the new advice a “challenging and sensitive issue” and provided links to “external sources of support”, including a group which opposes the new guidance’
By @[private account] in @Telegraph
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/9e29da3269b2f11f
Quick comment on media claims of ‘segregation’ of trans people.
They shouldn’t be allowed to pass by an interviewer without the fact check that ‘segregation’ is not opposed by most gender identity activists. They still wish male and female facilities to be segregated, but want exceptions for their own presence in the ‘opposite segregated’ facility.
It’s all outlets, and a lot of it springs from the police. But it’s such a huge case, and such a horrifying level of misogyny, coupled with the Southport link and the trans activist link, that BBC Merseyside should 💯 have reported it fully.
All outlets leave out the ‘trans’ connection. The deliberate burying of the targeting of women is what’s so unnerving from the BBC.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: You can see in the police link that it’s not mentioned. This is the sentencing for a court case some time ago, when the evidence emerged. Copy across most outlets regurgitates the police focus on drink and cannabis as the cause/motive/mitigation. It’s not only the BBC, but the BBC has a greater responsibility.
There are other quotes which we’re still trying to find live links for and until we do we won’t post them as verified.
What should have happened is that alarm bells should set off during the trial, and the police asked about it after the sentencing hearing happened or the upsum was released. Journalists should have made this unavoidable for the police. This is active burying and hiding.
The reluctance of the police to be matter of fact about reporting these things is so important - it means all outlets can hide behind the police upsum in the face of complaints. They’re so sensitive on behalf of the ‘trans community’ - they don’t want any criminal or misogynistic trait publicly attached to it.
There’s something very, very deeply disturbing at the effort by the police and the collusion of the BBC and most outlets actively to minimise Rigby’s extreme and violent misogyny. ‘Girls’ schools’ could be in the headline. Those quotes from the threatening emails are highly newsworthy. His rage at ‘trans oppression’ is central to the story. The information contributes to pattern recognition and potential safety awareness for girls and women.
This is rewriting history to a frightening degree. It’s not enough that the police have omitted all reference to women and girls as victims in the sentencing update. No one is to be allowed to remember the ‘trans link’ and put it together with these crimes of female hatred.
Here’s the police update.
https://www.merseyside.police.uk/news/merseyside/news/2026/june-2026/runcorn-man-sentenced-to-28-months-for-sending-hoax-emails-to-schools/
Here’s one half decent piece.
https://www.runcornandwidnesworld.co.uk/news/26156676.man-behind-hoax-threats-schools-thought-hide-behind-keyboard/
‘Darren Rigby, who sent hoax death threats to schools is jailed’
All girls’ schools were specifically targeted. Rigby ‘threatened to carry out deadly attacks supposedly in response to the treatment of ‘transwomen’’. None of this features in the coverage across outlets, despite the evidence emerging in email evidence and in court, neither does it feature in the Merseyside Police report.
‘I’m going to kill every girl and woman staff member I come across’
‘I'm going to shoot and stab all your girls’
It’s a crime of extreme misogyny in the cause of ‘fighting trans oppression’ but any mention of ‘trans’ has been erased by the police, PA and all news outlets. In addition the BBC report hides the fact that it was a crime against women and girls.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0e20ll9gz2o
https://southport.thelead.uk/p/hoax-attacker-threatened-violent
‘Four major newspapers published 17,000 articles about trans people in the last five years. How about mind your own business?’
This is extreme hypocrisy. There was no objection when trans-affirmative items, features and films were being pumped out without relief to a previously uninterested public. Indeed all that content had the encouragement of, and many were instigated by, organisations specifically set up to ensure that the self-identifying narrative swamped every media outlet.
No presenter should ever allow this claim to get past them. Trans activists wanted media coverage, lots of it - they just don’t like it now it’s moved toward journalism instead of unadulterated PR. https://x.com/TheGreenParty/status/2062142371777720590/video/1
British Medical Association statement on the EHRC Code of Practice
‘We are deeply concerned about the potentially devastating repercussions of this proposal on trans patients’ access to healthcare, the ability of trans healthcare staff to conduct their everyday duties, and the NHS’s ability to protect the rights and dignity of their trans patients and staff’
@TheBMA
https://www.bma.org.uk/news-and-opinion/statement-ehrc-code-of-practice-for-services-public-functions-and-associations
We’ve reposted a few clips from this programme but just to say it was calmly, deftly and fairly handled by the presenter. None of the customary fearful ‘some people might say that’s offensive’ dissimulation, even though the gender identity guest was (accidentally) outnumbered (and outgunned on debate points landed).
Trans sympathisers might look for a reason to complain about that, but it simply goes some way to redress the ‘balance over time and platforms’ issue at the BBC. Trans-sympathetic guests have routinely had significantly more airtime on the BBC, across platforms and Online, so no potential complaint on that ground should be upheld. It is not the presenter or producer’s fault that coherent arguments came from one side of the debate only.
Further note on the claim of a current media ‘obsession’. No gender identity sympathiser has ever complained about media ‘obsession’ during the decade that coverage - across all media as well as the BBC - was uniformly trans positive, and moreover completely out of proportion to the numbers involved, as confirmed by guest Samantha Niblett. That could be the only thing that could have been picked up on by the pres with a mild fact check.
You might also want to see the contributions to the conversation of Labour MP Niblett, which haven’t been on our TL so far. We recommend watching this measured convo - it’s the last item starting about 32 minutes in.
@[private account]
@GoodwinMJ
https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m002x6qz/politics-live-02062026
@[private account]
@[private account]
@BBCPolitics
Scotland’s Presiding Officer Kenny Gibson said two weeks ago he wouldn’t tolerate MSPs ‘misgendering’ their trans-identifying colleagues. Now, in response to concerns, he’s linked to the guidance which women’s rights campaigners said at the time appears directly to contradict him.
It really matters for journalists because everything said in the Chamber is privileged and must be faithfully quoted.
When MSPs are accurate about sex in the Chamber, it’s one of the few ways that accuracy in language can be achieved by news outlets without fearing complaints or regulatory interference. Or to look at it another way, it’s one of the ways they can be obliged to use accurate language.
The reverse is true: inaccurate language can be forced on news outlets because it’s contempt to broadcast a report that’s unfaithful to proceedings.
Here’s one of the reports on his original comments - this from @[private account]
https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/not-good-start-kenny-new-37165001
‘Kenny Gibson said that he would not tolerate politicians refusing to use the chosen pronouns of the newly elected Green MSPs Iris Duane and Q Manivannan’
Here’s the guidance he links to:
https://www.parliament.scot/-/media/files/code-of-conduct/po-chamber-conduct-booklet.pdf
and there’s a screenshot too 👇
‘There is no list of banned words’
‘Whether or not a term is appropriate is..not a matter for the Presiding Officer to rule on’
‘The Presiding Officers chair in the interests of freedom of expression’
The question remains whether Gibson will use ‘members must not use demeaning, discriminatory or harassing language..based on protected characteristics’ to try to force MSPs to comply.
Any decision to do so would be met with robust challenge and would accordingly produce a significant Streisand effect.
We hope for the sake of accuracy in the media that this plan to forbid ‘misgendering’ is not attempted. There is no law against ‘misgendering’ in the UK, and MSPs should not be the only people in the country subject to legal penalty simply for using natural and accurate terms.
Relevant background comments for sex and gender
‘A big challenge is how we extend inclusivity to our trans colleagues? Diversity is never done’
https://diva-magazine.com/2024/01/17/dawn-airey/
@[private account]
Quotes a post by T30793; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes - it will be interesting to see whether gender activist MSPs also refuse to give consent out of ‘solidarity with the trans community’. A campaign along these lines can be expected.
Has to be some kind of media turning point when an outlet not only publishes the phrase ‘trans men pregnant brain fart’ but is so proud that it posts it on X too.
On the Australian Sex Discrimination Commissioner’s struggling relationship with biological reality.
Quoting @DailyMail: It was the 'trans men pregnant' brainfart heard across the country. But there's another side to Sex Discrimination Commissioner Anna Coddy's embarrasing waffle: PVO https://trib.al/ms7QGpR
Here’s a share token 🎁 for the @Telegraph article yesterday on Childline and ‘trans’ kids
‘Surge in counselling for children questioning their gender’
This is full of the language of gender identity PR. Story deserves more than this.
/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/c2c29b7401f392a0
From @ITVNews on James Murray - this is straight and fair. Really nice to see this.
‘Health Secretary James Murray: I would no longer say trans women are women’ https://www.itv.com/news/london/2026-06-01/health-secretary-i-would-no-longer-say-trans-women-are-women
‘Holyrood to restore MSP gender search after trans survey’
Confusing and rather ridiculous language - they mean sex, which is the only salient bit, and the only thing the argument was about, and the only thing left out of the headline.
They just had to find a way not to say ‘MSP sex search’, which it’s fair to try to avoid. So instead you say ‘Holyrood to restore public data on MSPs’ sex after row’ - or similar. It takes ten seconds, unless you’re particularly attached to the words ‘trans’ and ‘gender’, which is the case here.
With this framing, the BBC goes along with the diversity narrative that it was just an administrative pause for a survey, even though the survey deadline isn’t until this Friday, so it’s not ‘after trans survey’ at all. It’s because of the work of women’s rights campaigners.
‘Some MSPs had raised concerns about women being "erased" from the website after the search filter was removed last month’ - no need for the inverted commas BBC - it was erased, and will no longer be erased.
This is written through the lens of putting a gloss on an embarrassing backtrack to a poor decision by gender identity activists.
(Also no need for an apostrophe in MSPs plural)
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c332x6j51y6o
Totally fascinating clip. The 👀 that @[private account] gives Derbyshire, as she actively works to get him to describe ‘trans rights’ as a ‘middle class hobby horse’ - which would be quite a gotcha - followed by her disconcerted silence when he just says ‘men’ instead.
She knew exactly what he was thinking of, and he knew exactly what she was doing. But the work on renormalising natural language has paid off. A couple of years ago he would have had to say ‘trans’ in some form, or ‘gender’, to describe events. Now he can just say ‘men’ and the power of that language trickery drains away completely.
Fantastic from @[private account]
‘The new EHRC ruling isn’t just about trans people’s access to toilets - it’s about protecting other vital single-sex spaces’ https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/jun/01/ehrc-ruling-trans-peoples-access-to-toilets-protecting-single-sex-spaces?CMP=share_btn_url
Health Secretary: I changed my mind – trans women are not women https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/06/01/james-murray-i-changed-my-mind-trans-women-not-women/
Wikipedia founder: Both sides of the trans debate have been toxic’
This is the man cited by the new BBC Director General as an expert on trust.
With reference to ‘the transgender issue’ (in an all staff Q and A when he arrived in the job a couple of weeks ago) Matt Brittin said he’d got to know Jimmy Wales really well, and that it was a benefit having pages being edited by ‘people from the extremes’. In fact he said: ‘These are some of the best pages on Wiki’. He cited the book referenced in the article: The Seven Rules of Trust.
To say it’s a flawed approach to journalism is an understatement. Truth is not determined by consensus, nor by which extremists on the day have the time and the right access to fight hour by hour for the upper hand online.
‘Wales highlights the polarising and often depressing nature of online interactions by mentioning the culture wars over gender identity as an example [note: it’s not a culture war @thetimes]
‘He said: 'The trans issue has been very toxic in the UK on all sides. It’s not a place where reasonable people want to have thoughtful conversations. It’s just a lot of screaming, unfortunately, which means not much progress is made on that.’'
That’s profoundly shallow, as well as insulting to women, LGB people and child safeguarding experts. The one-sided and power-filled nature of the screaming is *exactly* what made Wales make this 'both sides' comment. The screaming (and threats) spring from the male desire to access any and every female space, and Wales is too afraid (or too misogynist, but let's not presume) to say so.
Or perhaps his ignorance results from an over-reliance on his own supposedly authoritative resource, Wikipedia.
Matt Brittin said he believes the BBC can learn lessons from Wiki on 'some of these big hot topics' where 'every word has been fought over'.
But Wiki does have its own policy - it doesn’t allow accuracy to win in this fight. Just like the BBC, it caves to self-ID and cites ‘dignity’ as a reason for pronoun compliance.
Jimmy Wales, Matt Brittin, the BBC, everyone who contributes to Wiki, all of us know there are two immutable human sexes. Some choose to lie. That is not a culture war, or a healthy and contentious debate. It’s top-down dishonesty dressed up as respect. While one side is methodically dismantling this mountain of untruth, the other side, the side that wants the legal status of sex and LGB erased, is screaming at them.
It would be very due for Matt Brittin to understand that a Wiki rumble is not an appropriate framework for editorial decision-making, on this subject least of all. Because everyone - everyone - recognises the lie.
A few screenshots will follow.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/wikipedia-founder-jimmy-wales-toxic-trans-debate-lm639057w
‘Police force that insists [male] trans officers use women's toilets is threatened with legal action’
‘Gwent Police is accused of breaching new equality guidance [the law] by saying 'trans members of staff are entitled to use the facilities of the gender in which they present’
@WomensRightsNet lawyer has written to the force saying: 'If we do not receive a satisfactory response within 14 days, our client reserves the right to issue court proceedings without further notice.'
‘The WRN requested gender policies under the Freedom of Information Act from all forces..a spokeswoman said: ‘Our request for a meeting was dismissed out of hand. This cavalier disregard for the law is both astonishing and deeply concerning’
@DailyMail
@[private account]
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15862635/Police-force-trans-officers-use-womens-toilets.html
‘Civil war has broken out in the LibDems after Sir Ed Davey pledged to oppose official guidance protecting female-only spaces’
Extensive quotes from @[private account] from @[private account] in @Telegraph
@[private account]
‘Lib Dems at loggerheads’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/31/lib-dems-split-over-trans-guidance/
‘LGBTQ press conference at track meet involving trans athlete descends into chaos, police summoned’
From Fox News
There’s a link also@[private account] here to a story about a women’s sport campaigner being assaulted (alleged) by a TQ activist https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/lgbtq-press-conference-track-meet-involving-trans-athlete-descends-chaos-police-summoned
‘Judge who spared teen rapists jail gave suspended sentence to transgender paedophile who then flouted court orders’
@TheSun https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/39265071/judge-spared-teen-rapists-jail-transgender-paedophile/
Here’s the @Independent Pride list. Disproportionate representation of drag/trans identified men. Extreme over-representation of highly vocal trans allies.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/independent-pride-list-2026-lgbt-changemakers-alan-carr-b2981863.html
Whole thread is 👌
This is the framing activists want - women’s rights versus trans rights, ie ‘women versus trans’. Once you adopt that lens 1. you can’t be impartial and 2. you completely forget and abandon LGB. Anyway the thread says it better.
Quoting @Jebadoo2: 4/ I wouldn't mind so much, but this is literally the only perspective that gets pushed by the BBC, at no point is it conceded that sex in law is a vital protection for half the population and the gay/lesbian minority. It's all about the (normally heterosexual) male transvestite
What an interesting choice by the @heraldscotland
Either it showed the column to MacWhirter for a preview and pre-edit, or it unilaterally decided to protect this trans campaigner from the consequences (and direct corrections) of her own words. Interesting either way.
Quoting @ForWomenScot: Interesting - all reference to MacWhirter has been removed and replaced with "the columnist". Is she not happy to stand by what she wrote about us? We are named in her piece.
https://www.heraldscotland.com/politics/viewpoint/26144399.womens-rights-come-poor-second-demands-trans-men/?ref=twtrec
We’re a single issue account, focussed on restoring accuracy and impartiality to sex and gender.
Our focus on both means we can confirm categorically that there is no middle ground to be reached or reasonable discussion to be had on whether being male or female is determined by the brain. It is not. We are not ‘here for that’. It’s just a fact. There is no ‘true trans’: there are men and women.
There could be a middle ground, and certainly there could be a discussion, on whether or not and to what extent society, via policy and law, should pretend that it *is* determined by the brain, and pretend that some people are the opposite sex.
For that to take place, everyone would first have to acknowledge that it’s a pretence.
Since campaigners as here👇 are incapable of acknowledging this, it means the discussion cannot be had, and therefore no middle ground - *specifically on the benefits and disbenefit of pretending* - can be reached.
Tl:dr no reasonable discussion or middle ground or on changing sex, because there isn’t one. No reasonable discussion or middle ground on pretending, because gender identity activists like Kirstie won’t admit it’s a pretence, and thus won’t allow the conversation to take place at all.
Quoting @KirstieMAllsopp: One basic Twitter rule I should not forget, is if someone has a single issue account, ie they tweet on one issue 90% of the time, then there is no reasonable discussion or middle ground, they are here for one thing only.
Very raw post. If these ‘lived experiences’ were to make it to broadcast media, online ‘transing’ would make it into the Online Harms conversation.
Esther Ghey is a regular ‘online harms’ media contributor. Is it insensitive to ask her or her fellow campaigners important questions about online persuasion and encouragement into a trans identity?
If you think so - that’s how the media conversation, and therefore the political conversation, is limited by her campaign presence. Her profound and visible grief means interviewers won’t ‘go there’. They’ll wait until she does, if she ever does.
It’s no use gasping in horror at even raising the issue. That only goes to prove the point harder.
Children are encouraged by social media into trans identities. This can lead to irreversible physical and psychosocial damage. That is an online harm and the root of a major medical scandal. Why should it not be part of an online harms conversation about the law?
Quotes a post by A3318; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘Lloyds Bank bans trans women from using female lavatories’
‘Britain’s biggest bank has told trans women not to use female lavatories after the equalities watchdog said single-sex spaces should be defined by biology’
Louis Goss again 👍 https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/05/29/lloyds-bank-bans-trans-women-using-female-lavatories/
Your focus is wrong. Your framing is ‘a row’. You balance ‘trans rights’ and ‘women’s rights’ as if they are equal principles.
No - the question is whether sex and sexual orientation have legal status in law, or not.
This issue requires harder thinking based on what you know (we know you know) to be a fact: that sex and sexual orientation exist in reality. There is a campaign to remove legal protections from these realities. That is what you call on your post ‘trans rights’.
The BBC likes to treat the idea that one can change sex, and the knowledge that one can’t, as if they were both opinions of equal weight. It does this because it is afraid of gender identity activists.
You know there is no middle ground. You are secure enough, and well informed enough, to say so, and to conduct interviews built on that. It’s your duty as a journalist to do so.
It’s not to be minimised as a ‘row’. It’s a top down campaign to remove legal protection from sex and sexual orientation, and an active grassroots defence to prevent that happening. Trans-identified people have all the rights that everyone else has. They, plus allies, are engaged in a campaign fully to remove the legal status of two main cohorts: women and LGB people.
Maybe on a teatime drive programme it could be argued that these things need to be simplified. Not on Political Thinking.
Note: You shouldn’t adopt activist language as if it’s your own. ‘Be who they are’ ? - you can ask better questions than that.
Mary-Anne Stephenson isn’t on one side of the debate - she’s a neutral expert. You don’t need to ‘balance’ her via questioning style.
There’s a different and more coherent way of being a Devil’s Advocate than using the language of activists themselves: ‘dignity’ - ‘want to be who they are’ etc as Nick Robinson does here. If a pres is going to use activist language it should be more clearly signposted: the BBC Academy teaches that you shouldn’t adopt activist language as if it were the BBC’s own.
Of course the BBC does that all the time: it’s a breach of a fundamental principle that’s written into its style guide.
We have no doubt that DG Matt Brittin has been reassured that the problem of bias has been dealt with by recent guidance to always make ‘sex’ clear where it helps audience understanding. That means a certain complacency has crept in. But while self-ID is still in the style guide, bias is still the order of the day.
There’s still a belief in ‘true trans’ because the internal conversation didn’t dig deep enough. It never reached the nefarious reasons why men are so obsessed with access to female spaces and the erasure of sex as a legal status. It only scratched the surface.
We’ve written to Mr Brittin to explain this and to warn against this type of complacency, while trans affirmation is still written through its news and creative divisions. https://x.com/BBCr4today/status/2060300868898185232/video/1
The @[private account] prog gives Giles Fraser the opportunity to deplore boundaries in terms of our ‘moral anxieties’ in relation to ‘the trans issue’ because ‘God is a hybrid’ and in Christianity ‘hybridity is the very cornerstone of life’.
Not subtle.
‘Germany's Trans Laws are a Threat to Women, Free Speech, and Common Sense’ https://europeanconservative.com/articles/commentary/germanys-trans-laws-are-a-threat-to-women-free-speech-and-common-sense/
‘Pro-trans church ‘brazenly defies law’ on women’s lavatories’ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/05/28/pro-trans-church-brazenly-defies-law-on-womens-lavatories/
‘Vast sums of taxpayer cash are still being funnelled into NGOs promoting medical misinformation to children’
@spikedonline
Excellent detail on the money trail, with a focus on Mermaids and Gendered Intelligence
Reports of demise exaggerated etc https://www.spiked-online.com/2026/05/28/how-the-blob-keeps-trans-activism-on-life-support/
‘Trans ideology is easy to slide into..It does not upend old-fashioned sexism so much as repackage it. It asks for no uncomfortable introspection about the stereotypes we collude in. On the contrary, it rewards their enthusiastic performance’
@jo_bartosch
https://fairerdisputations.org/the-upside-of-feminization/
Fascinating and in depth article by @[private account] for Labour Heartlands on the framing of the ‘trans debate’ around toilets rather than women’s fundamental rights.
It’s an accurate observation of a highly successful PR campaign. Across the media, presenters last week repeatedly asked women if they feel guilty about men who can’t use their toilets, businesses who can’t afford to build more toilets, and disabled people whose toilets are suggested as alternatives.
But most importantly they’ve not bern asking about anything except toilets. Specifically they’ve failed to ask men/trans campaigners why they don’t understand that if they are included in the legal meaning of ‘woman’, women themselves have no rights at all on the basis of sex.
It follows a pattern of successful ‘identity’ media campaigns, with which news outlets collude because 1. their proponents are very top down and powerful and 2. they advance men’s rights. Previous examples include lived experience journalism, no debate, the narrative of victimhood and the infinite necessity of a trans male contributor.
This excellent article also looks at the impact:- ‘The cost has been real and it has fallen on working class women in particular’.
https://labourheartlands.com/trans-rights-the-conjuring-trick-at-the-toilet-door/
On progressive politics and ‘trans rights’ in @Telegraph
‘This is a movement built on dangerous lies that must be defended to the point of intellectual oblivion’
@[private account]
The claim by Australia’s Sex Discrimination commissioner that men (‘transwomen’) could face pregnancy discrimination ‘is a perfect example of how progressive dogma operates’.
‘The untruths, contradictions and hypocrisies of progressivism are a drug. Its advocates are so captured, cult-like, by an addiction to identity politics that it would take a professional intervention to save them’
‘Progressive politics is a cult built on lies’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/05/27/progressive-politics-is-a-dangerous-cult-built-on-lies/
Charlie Craggs was given an opportunity no gender critical feminist has ever been offered - a BBC documentary on trans teens (which had to be temporarily pulled from broadcast and re-edited after internal representations). He is not marginalised.
Quoting @MetroUK: 'When I first watched the video – I wasn’t even angry or upset – I was actually jealous. Imagine this being your biggest problem in life,' writes Charlie Craggs✍️
Truly unhelpful contribution to the debate, painting a fantasy version of victimhood.
‘Trans people like me face segregation’
He’s just a man who can’t use the girls’ loo. Archive because we’d like to encourage more constructive comment than this. https://archive.ph/2026.05.27-105014/https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/may/27/trans-people-segregation-parliament-supreme-court-ehrc
‘Transgender taxpayers have been given lifetime access to an HMRC hotline reserved for MPs and members of the Royal family.
‘HMRC insisted the policy was necessary because the records of transgender people required “greater protection” to ensure confidentiality under equality laws’
@Telegraph
It’s those who have a GRC. The GRA says that no one is allowed to share GRC status info if it’s acquired in a professional capacity. However it doesn’t say it can’t be shared for professional purposes - for example between tax advisers.
‘People who legally change their gender with a Gender Recognition Certificate, an official document confirming their transition, have their records restricted by the tax service – meaning only a select few officials can access them.
‘They are then told to contact the hotline PD1 ‘questions about your tax or National Insurance’ as outlined in guidance published on HMRC’s website.
..’Transgender people who claim benefits or are in receipt of the state pension also have their queries handled by a specialist team at the Department for Work and Pensions.’
‘HMRC gives trans people access to VIP hotline’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/consumer-affairs/hmrc-gives-trans-people-access-to-vip-hotline/
‘Labour’s trans guidance ‘poses danger to women..Campaigners say code of practice - warning staff not to question people’s genders - ‘risks harassment’’
This should have been an issue put to Mary-Anne Stephenson on R4 Today, and to everyone promoting or welcoming this Code since it was published.
The hallmark of the gender identity movement is that it’s so top down that in every instance, individual women have to fight it against powerful institutions which support it. Here again we see businesses misled into thinking it’s inappropriate to ask people about their sex, leaving it to individual women here and there - they may be traumatised, frightened, looking after children, or just naturally nervous, but the authorities are too afraid to help them. These women will have to raise the alarm all alone and face being accused of harassment at the end of it.
We know that men will breach the law. They’ve promised to. So the question that pres needs to ask is:- why have you left it to individual women to police it - again?
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/25/campaigners-claim-labour-trans-guidance-risks-harassment/
‘Universities STILL won't ban men from women's spaces’
Loving this clarity - men not trans women
‘Campaign group Women Won’t Wheesht says its investigation found just one out of Scotland’s 16 unis has a clear biological sex-based policy’
@DailyMail https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15847335/Universities-wont-ban-men-womens-spaces-despite-Supreme-Court-ruling.html
‘How could this have happened? How could a vulnerable woman have been placed in a secure psychiatric ward brimming with troubled, unstable men? The answer, of course, lies in the NHS’s embrace of trans ideology..safety be damned’
@spikedonline https://www.spiked-online.com/2026/05/20/how-the-nhss-gender-lunacy-led-to-a-horrific-sex-attack/
‘The inevitable protests and high-profile flouting of the law in the next few weeks will not only upset actual women using those services but will guarantee plenty more attention for the trans issue’
Smashing comment piece
‘Labour could be a world beacon for women’s rights’
‘Our Government could embolden those who buckle under trans demands, but it remains an outlier’
By @[private account] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/05/25/labour-could-be-a-world-beacon-for-womens-rights/
‘Legal world torn apart by trans rows despite Supreme Court ruling’
This is very good in @Telegraph
Interviews with several lawyers including Sarah Phillimore and Naomi Cunningham
Will hunt for gift link https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/05/23/legal-world-torn-apart-trans-rows-supreme-court-ruling/
No, they weren’t banned. Trans females.l can still participate. Men were banned.
Quoting @Telegraph: Oxford students have staged a revolt after transgender rowers were banned from participating in women’s competitions.
The informal ballot saw 49 votes against new regulations with just one in support and five abstentions 👇
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/rowing/2026/05/22/oxford-students-protest-ban-transgender-rowers-womens-races/?WT.mc_id=tmgoff_tw_post_ban-transgender-rowers-womens-races/
Another classic example of replacing male with trans. It changes the whole story.
If trans rowers were not allowed to enter, it would be illegal @GBNEWS
Stop giving the impression they’re banned. They’re not.
Quoting @GBNEWS: Oxford University students call for transgender rowers to enter women's boat race
https://www.gbnews.com/sport/oxford-university-transgender-rowers
‘Norfolk Police forced to tear up trans policy after EHRC report’
@edp24
Excellent clarity of language in here https://www.edp24.co.uk/news/26130491.norfolk-police-forced-tear-trans-policy-ehrc-report/
📣 New from @[private account]
‘BBC director-general under pressure to free corporation from trans ‘capture’’
He’s been urged to ‘weed out transactivists’..’Senior managers who allowed the BBC to become a mouthpiece for trans radicals are still in place’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/05/23/bbc-director-general-under-pressure-free-corporation-trans/
We’ve yet to see or hear a pres ask a ‘trans’ guest why they feel entitled to ignore the law
The reason journos like Vine and Rajan think it’s ‘impossible to police’ is because they don’t want to say no to these men, they know it’s risky for women to say no, and they know the men won’t take no for an answer. Then they mask it all as compassion.
Quoting @MetroUK: Trans people have been using gendered spaces for decades – we’re not going to stop now https://trib.al/AhfDdOJ
‘We need to hear their voices’
But have we, this morning? We’ve heard a lot from trans-identified men and their allies. Not so much from women who will have to challenge these men themselves. Here’s an example: Jeremy Vine just invited two trans allies to interrupt a woman who was gang-raped in a toilet after pointing out to her that she was in a single sex facility. Clipping up.
Quotes a post by T14531; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Replies closed (thanks @[private account]) which is an unusual sign of discomfort. The really angry people this morning are ‘the trans community’ - they’re angry with the EHRC, and could pile in. On the other hand Amol’s treatment on Today was to ignore the rights of women and gay people completely.
All criticism will be brushed off by Today and the Complaints Unit as ‘both sides hate us so we must have got it right’. It’s a somewhat juvenile approach, but the alternative would be to deploy some critical thinking around impartiality, and that’s not normally the go-to response.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Just want to make a point clear after 20 hours of coverage: not only are ‘trans women’ men, it is accurate and impartial for news outlets to explain this. It’s not just permitted: it’s their professional duty.
Here’s @amolrajan interviewing Mary Anne Stephenson of the @EHRC
There is one perspective only: the trans perspective, and mainly, the trans XY perspective. Former Head of News Fran Unsworth said in a recent interview: ‘It’s the sea we swim in’. So it is here. The weight of bias becomes most obvious when you imagine the sorts of questions that could be asked by an impartial team.
‘Women have waited for this a long time - how can we be sure that now they really will have single sex spaces for their safety and privacy?’
‘Some women say you’ve loosened the duty on service providers by using the phrase ‘case by case’. How do you respond?’
‘Isn’t this draft even more confusing than the first draft when it comes to ‘proportionality’?
‘What about this advice that it’s not appropriate to challenge men in women’s toilets - surely that’s important for enforcement?’
‘Why do you think so many trans-identified people say they’re determined to breach the law - do you think this guidance will help them to respect it?’
‘Some campaigners blame the Minister for the confusion because she decided to consult in a way that was never done before trans people were admitted to opposite sex spaces. Are you disappointed it’s taken so long to lay this guidance before parliament?’
‘Service providers have already had a year to be working on provision - surely they have no more excuses for failing to implement the law?’
This 👆line of questioning is so breathtakingly unlikely ever to happen that the audience becomes dulled to the bias. But don’t ever accept a lower standard, just because those lower standards have prevailed for ten and more years. It’s a very important slot and interview, and the Today programme fluffed it. This is a public service organisation that you pay for, and this was a very poor effort.
Don’t let it go with ‘that’s par for the course’ because everyone is inured to BBC bias on this. It’s poor, and what’s worse is, the @[private account] team won’t see it at all. They believe Mary-Anne Stephenson is the appropriate balance for a ‘pro-trans’ narrative.
That means they see her as being on one side of the debate, the ‘anti-trans’ side, rather than the neutral regulator she is. It’s a tell. This is a great shame. Clip of Stephenson to follow.
This absolute untruth from @guardian is contradicted by its own fact check.
It’s no good thinking ‘people will know what we mean’. Reporting such a deliberately obfuscated legal issue means you *must* be clear.
The usual intent of this type of framing is to make guidance and policy look cruel and transphobic.
The likelihood of this being accidental is low as the Guardian doubles down in the first paragraph:
‘Single-sex toilets and changing rooms in England, Wales and Scotland must exclude transgender men and women, according to a new code of practice from the equalities watchdog’
In fact the code specifically highlights that trans people mustn’t be excluded from anywhere except facilities intended solely for the opposite sex.
Naturally there’s no lens through which the Guardian could write the headline:
‘Women’s toilets must be women only, EHRC code confirms’
It’s disappointing that this is the ‘news’ take rather than a column or opinion, where unsubstantiated hyperbole is always expected.
‘Critics fear it will consolidate a chilling effect as trans people avoid public places altogether’
There’s no interest in reporting the suffering of women at all. None.
Here’s the link.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/may/21/single-sex-toilets-exclude-transgender-people-england-wales-scotland-code-of-practice
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: What is the updated EHRC code of practice about and how does it apply? | Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) | The Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/may/21/what-is-the-updated-ehrc-code-of-practice-about-and-how-does-it-apply-equalities-watchdog
Great fact-checking here from @MichelleDewbs
There’s a contrast with the BBC, which presented these same facts as if they were a Sex Matters campaign argument.
GB News is unduly accused of lack of balance on ‘trans’. Look at who it has on.
Helen Belcher was put up for guest bids today by the gender activist PR group Neon. The BBC should have ignored it - his campaigning was one of the main drivers in the BBC itself adopting self-identification of gender in 2013. He had a material impact on the BBC misleading so many people - not just trans-identified people, but the entire BBC audience.
Yes these tough questions need to be asked - including about Belcher’s role in ensuring that a lie was and is perpetrated nationally by almost every media organisation to the profound disbenefit of children and women.
Quotes a post by A2915; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
BBC World Tonight spoke to @HJoyceGender, and nearly made it to the end of a very fair interview without asking about unhappy trans people.
Up to that point, it was the BBC’s best hit with @SexMattersOrg since @MForstater was on the News Channel on April 16 2026
This is great from @[private account] in @DailyMail - a really important part of the story. No point having the law, or the Code, if you can’t enforce either.
‘Transgender people should NOT be asked what sex they are in toilets, long-awaited guidance says’
Comment from @MForstater
‘It's absurd to say that it is ‘unlikely to be either practical or appropriate’ to ask an individual what sex they are in relation to facilities such as toilets: if a man walks into a women's space it will be not just appropriate to challenge him, but essential’
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15838029/Transgender-people-NOT-asked-sex-toilets-long-awaited-guidance-Britains-equalities-watchdog-states.html
‘This means, for instance, that a trans woman - a biological male who identifies as a woman - should not use female toilets or changing rooms, according to the code of practice’
@BBCNews
@[private account]
@[private account]
V fair, v clear
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0e2rj3zj02o
‘If a service provider admits trans people to a service intended for the opposite sex, it can no longer rely on the exceptions..A service provided to women and trans women could be unlawful sex discrimination or lead to unlawful harassment against women who use the service’
‘The combined effect of the exceptions relating to sex and gender reassignment..may impose significant limitations on the ability of some trans people to participate in some gender-affected activities. If the exceptions are properly applied, this will not be unlawful’
‘Any sex-based rules or arrangements relating to participation in a gender-affected activity should be applied on the basis of biological sex.
‘Therefore, trans people should not be included in single-sex or separate-sex competitions for the sex with which they identify’
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: On sport
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/equality-act-2010-draft-code-of-practice-for-services-public-functions-and-associations-2026/equality-act-2010-draft-code-of-practice-for-services-public-functions-and-associations-2026
This is what All About Trans was subsumed into - Heard. Nathalie McDermott is at the heart of it all. Heard is so proud of its Newsnight interaction, it’s on the front page.
https://heard.org.uk/
Wonder if Evan Davies enjoys that particular lean in to popular criticism
On the Amnesty ‘snowball’ report
Briefly: this is the advice it has for journalists now, topped off with ‘seek advice from trans-led organisations’.
Most of these were exactly the dominant tactics from 2012 to 2021/22. The media’s collusion and compliance with these tactics harmed women and children.
This part of the report must have been produced in a bubble. For a period, most news orgs went a little bit mad and decided to tell lies all the time about one specific issue, and take editorial decisions based on whether they advanced the gender identity cause.
We are only just climbing out of this disaster. No one will take Amnesty’s advice.
https://media.amnesty.org.uk/documents/Like_a_snowball_final_.pdf
‘The national broadcaster has played a central role in one of the worst medical and media scandals of our age’
On the BBC and its transactivism by @jo_bartosch in @spikedonline https://www.spiked-online.com/2026/05/21/how-the-bbc-became-pravda-for-trans-actvists/
‘I stood up against trans extremism at the Cambridge Union. The result surprised me’
@[private account]
@Telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/05/21/i-stood-up-against-trans-extremism-at-cambridge-union/
This doesn’t have a trans tag or appear on the trans page, presumably because it makes gender activists look bad
Nor does it have a women’s rights tag
It’s a little veil over what’s happened - and considering the BBC has in the past been so obsessed with diversity, 50:50 and measuring ‘gender data’ - that’s probably deliberate
‘LGBTQ+ groups call on Health Secretary to reverse restrictions on trans healthcare’
The ‘Emerging Audiences’ editor at @DailyMirror should know that ‘trans’ is a declining, not emerging, customer. The actual Gen Z/A emerging audience is reality-focussed. https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/health/lgbtq-groups-call-new-health-37177313
‘Trans banned from Oxford University women's rowing team’
Inaccurate headline @[private account]
And stop saying ‘people’ out of fear of saying ‘men’
https://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/26124198.trans-banned-oxford-university-womens-rowing-team/
‘The trans war on reality’
‘Trans activists loudly trumpet a false mythology of victimhood; in fact, trans people are more likely to kill than be killed’
@jo_bartosch in @[private account] https://thecritic.co.uk/issues/may-2026/the-trans-war-on-reality/
C2 false claimshand-codedvictim dismissalviolence terror
Useful Burnham/Bannatyne/spending scandal round up of the revelations over the last couple of days
‘Burnham loses support of Dragons’ Den star over trans views’ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/20/burnham-loses-support-dragons-den-bannatyne-trans-views/
At this stage the @Telegraph (and all news outlets) should really be pushing back very very hard on the activist language. The ban is on men, however they identify. This is about single sex spaces, not ‘trans rights’.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: 📣 GIFT LINK
‘Trans women must be barred from female toilets, changing facilities and sports teams, new official guidance is to state’
@Telegraph
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/20/phillipson-to-ban-trans-women-from-female-toilets/
It’s not clear enough here that Downview is putatively a women’s jail
‘Population of Britain's only dedicated wing for trans women prisoners increases despite Supreme Court ruling on biological sex’
@DailyMail https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15831137/Population-Britains-dedicated-wing-trans-women-prisoners-increases-despite-Supreme-Court-ruling-biological-sex.html?ns_mchannel=rss&ns_campaign=1490&ito=social-twitter_mailonline#
‘Concerns at trans MSP's ‘conversion’ plan that could criminalise parents’
He’s lodged a ‘motion demanding a legal ban on so-called conversion practices ‘across all settings’’
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15835321/Concerns-trans-MSPs-conversion-plan-criminalise-parents.html
📣 GIFT LINK
‘Trans women must be barred from female toilets, changing facilities and sports teams, new official guidance is to state’
@Telegraph
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/05/20/phillipson-to-ban-trans-women-from-female-toilets/
‘If Ms Unsworth experienced this level of activist bullying on the trans issue, could this be the only subject on which progressive group-think impacted the BBC’s journalistic standards?’
🎯 - if it lies about this, what else does it lie about?
🎁 gift
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/c45343c4084ac521
These aren’t facts. This is what happens when powerful misogynists drive AI models.
Matt Brittin, formerly of Google, now the BBC DG, needs to let go of any idea that there is a form of tech that can produce tracking data to ‘satnav’ the facts around sex and gender, and therefore bake in impartiality. It’s not possible. These are just a couple of search engines’ AI responses, both of them ludicrous.
Brittin is going to have to sit at his desk and use critical thinking to decide on the evidence, not seek an AI collective opinion that he can deploy to BBC editorial policy.
Everybody who ‘both sides’ this debate wants to delegate it to someone else. To the courts, to the EHRC, to tech, to activist groups, to trans ‘experts’, to politicians. It’s all just a way of evading responsibility. We hope Matt is ready to take it, but it’s still not clear that he will.
Gift version of the @Telegraph on Andy Burnham
‘Andy Burnham urged to reveal whether he still backs trans self-ID’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/81573e096bbc88db
‘Andy Burnham under pressure to confirm stance on self ID after leaked video’
@[private account]
https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/2207497/andy-burnham-transgender-self-ID-2207497
If you’re interested in the ‘trans age’ claim, the BBC and Victoria Derbyshire took it sufficiently seriously to platform two guests on it - jane fae and Emile Rateband. Fae said it was ‘tasteless’ to claim to be ‘trans age’.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-46186651
‘UK Ranked Second-Worst Place in Western Europe for LGBTI+ Rights’
Paywall free
It’s based on TQ+ not LGB.
‘Rainbow Map of Europe from the European branch of the International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association’
https://archive.ph/2026.05.18-111617/https://novaramedia.com/2026/05/18/uk-ranked-second-worst-place-in-western-europe-for-lgbti-rights/
Yes. Look at the guy in the piece selected by the BBC to comment on the BBC’s future under Brittin, on the Today programme and highlighted online, Ash Atalla.
Here’s what he says about sex and gender - a clear message that ‘trans is niche’, ie he won’t engage with it. This is the approved view. Of course, for 15 years trans has been designated of primary importance for pro-trans content, and niche for realist content. What it really signals is fear and misogyny. Men matter, women don’t.
The official approval of the ‘trans is niche’ message says: we won’t tackle, we won’t intervene, we’ll leave the way clear for identity activists to produce and broadcast whatever affirmative guff they want.
Hard to know what it will take to help the BBC understand. There’s still immense internal complacency, more than you can imagine. To generalise: they think themselves entirely superior to non-BBC employees, and believe that there’s jealousy involved in the criticism.
This isn’t every single BBC employee obviously, but it’s routinely the type that gets promoted, offered projects, leadership roles, postings, attachments, committee chair positions etc. There’s so much complacency. If you could have a phrase to sum up the BBC’s corporate attitude to criticism, it would be: ‘Well they would say that, wouldn’t they’.
It fetishizes young audiences, and having trained them up on identity content, now says it has to produce yet more identity content to keep them happy. But these are middle-aged men offering up other middle-aged men in dresses as entertainment, and their middle-aged gender beliefs as impartial news.
They can’t see what we see. Matt Brittin was so recently a trans cheerleader than he will struggle mightily to understand the scale of the problem.
Helen is also a fabulous journalist
‘Helen Joyce says fighting the trans battle is a cause she will never give up on’
NB: it’s a battle for women’s and children’s rights, but headlines will headline
@DailyMail
@hjoycegender https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15822003/She-branded-bigot-recorded-having-committed-hate-crime-tried-shut-Helen-Joyce-says-fighting-trans-battle-cause-never-on.html
The Times and the Telegraph both call @Glinner’s posts ‘anti-trans’ today.
The problem with ‘anti-trans’ is it’s built on a claim that it’s ‘anti’ a kind of person. Rather, it’s anti an idea, a harmful, unsubstantiated belief in wrong sex brain.
🎁share
https://www.thetimes.com/article/1e39f379-c676-4728-8676-bdf92dedb61c?shareToken=04523bf0ad640d54e427ab0f94df30cd
A problems is that some of the heads of BBC commissioning strategy are extremely, extremely, highly affirmative. Mr Yelland risks future dollar if he admits that ‘trans women’ are men. Not to say his beliefs are dependent on that, but it’s just a fact. These are the people who gave Jordan Gray excessive airtime after he exposed his penis on live TV. That’s how pro-trans diversity leaks in to programming that has a newsy bent and is supposed to be trustworthy and authoritative.
Union chief says she 'wouldn't' be comfortable representing Sandie Peggie in trans row - Daily Record https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/politics/union-chief-says-wouldnt-comfortable-36420631
‘My worst fear for the future is that facts no longer matter..I’d be horrified if we reached that point’
Fiona ‘trans people would vehemently disagree with you’ Bruce
https://youtu.be/LGR_pNAdGqM?si=UWVdY8-h0W8qMPJ6
‘While she did not encounter trans women (biological males) in the facilities’
That’s the way - but make it the HL
‘NHS faces discrimination claims from female staff after tribunal finds trans policies wrongly allowed males to use single-sex toilets’ https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15825049/NHS-faces-thousands-discrimination-claims-female-staff-tribunal-finds-wrongly-allowed-transgender-women-use-single-sex-toilets.html
‘I transitioned into a man - then changed my mind. Now the trans 'cult' that groomed me into changing sex has hounded me out of TWO cities’
@[private account]
@nickwallis
https://www.dailymail.com/lifestyle/article-15817599/Philippa-Roberts-detransition-man-woman.html
‘BBC News boss: I was driven out by trans activism’
Gift🎁article written up from the exclusive by @[private account] in @unherd https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/5af5e3dbfc978969
‘Unsworth said the ‘world went mad’ around progressive politics during her time at the BBC, and that the BBC ‘went a bit mad with it’.
‘Pointing to coverage of trans issues, she said there’d been ‘a kind of national bullying..in every institution in society’, adding that dissenting views were often unwelcome within the BBC’.
‘Unsworth suggested that only one acceptable viewpoint was permitted within the organisation and that journalists felt pressure to conform to prevailing narratives’
Unsworth headed News and Current Affairs from 2018 to 2022.
Some of our members met her to complain about and discuss coverage. She listened like a journalist, and asked the questions you’d expect of a journalist. Very few did: only two names are instantly memorable as showing any interest.
@[private account] has done a magnificent job here.
There’s a paywall but it’s £3 for three months. It’s definitely worth it. This is comprehensive detail.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: Do not miss this. Hearing from Fran Unsworth is a scoop.
‘It raises much wider questions about whether women who state basic biological realities, or advocate for female-only spaces and sport, are increasingly being treated as unacceptable by organisations that claim to value equality and inclusion’
Great job from @[private account]
Click and share
Nitpick alert -
‘[Trans ideology] is the view that gender is defined by self-id rather than biological sex’
Better to say ‘being male or female’ not ‘gender’, which has so many meanings that it’s meaningless.
It could be confusing. ‘Gender’ IS defined by self-ID. Being male or female isn’t.
Quoting @jan_murray: Read article for free here (gift link) 👉 https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/934c19f39e32913b
The main examples are these.
‘The Scottish government had asserted that transgender people with a gender recognition certificate (GRC) were entitled to the same sex-based protections as biological women’
- please stop hiding the fact that they’re men, BBC. It looks deliberate. You mean ‘transgender males’.
‘The court sided with campaign group For Women Scotland which argued that sex-based protections for women should only apply to those that are born female’
- there are no women who are not born female. The phrase you’re looking for @[private account] is ‘should only apply to females’. Given that you’ve chosen a longer and more convoluted wording, this also looks like an intentional claim that women exist who are not female, which is inaccurate.
‘..anyone trying to convince the courts that Northern Ireland can take a different path on trans rights…the trans rights case is fought..’
- this is a women’s rights case. This is a ‘tell’ of a trans-framed lens that needs adjusting.
There are lots of positives about this piece and it looks balanced in terms of expertise. The gaps mean that lots of readers (women in Northern Ireland who want to know if they’ll be obliged to change in front of men, for example) will be given the impression that their sex-based rights under the law are more dubious than is actually the case.
‘Trans women are women’, new Health Secretary said’
Gift 🎁 article from @Telegraph following up on work from Nutmeg, @juliahb1 and others https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/ef8a76d2275f8a9c
It an inversion of due diligence. No pro trans stories get this. It’s oversight upon oversight - they’re so worried that they send it right to the top for approval, and that takes time.
Just treat it like a normal story. Be journalists.
Today’s only rightful headline
‘Women’s rights and spaces must always allow men, Australian court rules’
‘Groundbreaking ruling that trans woman was discriminated against’ - which is everywhere - is not it. It is a direct lie and turns point blank away from the real story.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: This HL should read
‘Australia: Women’s rights and spaces must always include males, court rules’
That’s the story, not this compliant trash
‘Giggle app discriminated against trans woman Roxanne Tickle, appeal judge rules when doubling damages’
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/may/15/giggle-for-girls-app-discriminated-against-trans-woman-roxanne-tickle-appeal-case-ntwnfb
For those who don’t want to give clicks to language that erases women’s rights - archive version of the Mail
‘Transgender woman wins groundbreaking 'what is a woman' case after she was kicked off a female-only app in Australia’ https://archive.ph/2026.05.15-062613/https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15820049/Transgender-woman-wins-groundbreaking-woman-case-kicked-female-app-Australia.html
This is bizarre - @[private account] actually includes sexual violence and mental health helpline numbers in its coverage of Sall’s case. It’s not a bad write up but it’s doubtful those numbers are there for devastated women.
https://www.9news.com.au/national/giggle-v-tickle-transgender-ban-from-womenonly-app-remains-unlawful/bc897f1c-ab43-4847-b7fd-7f8af8b19737
This is so terrible and anti-women we can’t contribute to the clicks, so here’s another archive. It’s @[private account]
‘Groundbreaking’
It’s the biggest blow to women’s rights in a century but go ahead and genuflect. Honestly chronic.
https://archive.ph/2026.05.15-061157/https://www.news.com.au/national/courts-law/femaleonly-app-founder-loses-landmark-transgender-discrimination-appeal/news-story/96c4b1e2fa1196dc45f611a945599333
This is actually the image used by the Sydney Morning Herald today. It’s very fitting that everyone knows it as SMH 🤦♂️
Here’s the archive without a paywall
https://archive.ph/2026.05.15-044004/https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/damages-doubled-after-trans-woman-s-landmark-discrimination-win-20260514-p5zx14.html
Aaand that landmark word comes from @Reuters, infamously compliant and silent on the removal of women’s rights
Which means it will be replicated everywhere
https://uk.news.yahoo.com/australian-court-upholds-ruling-transgender-070625553.html
This HL should read
‘Australia: Women’s rights and spaces must always include males, court rules’
That’s the story, not this compliant trash
‘Giggle app discriminated against trans woman Roxanne Tickle, appeal judge rules when doubling damages’
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/may/15/giggle-for-girls-app-discriminated-against-trans-woman-roxanne-tickle-appeal-case-ntwnfb
Any outlet that uses the word ‘landmark’ is praising the decision. This is the Guardian, so not surprising. It’s almost gloating.
‘Giggle for Girls app discriminated against trans woman Roxanne Tickle, appeal judge rules when doubling damages’
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/may/15/giggle-for-girls-app-discriminated-against-trans-woman-roxanne-tickle-appeal-case-ntwnfb
‘Male athlete wins three women’s events’
‘Trans’ is why they want in - it’s not why women want them out. You adopt the lens transactivists want you to adopt when you frame it like this @GBNEWS
Quoting @GBNEWS: Transgender athlete wins three events as protest erupts at US track meet
https://www.gbnews.com/sport/transgender-athlete-wins-three-events-protest-erupts-us-track-meet
The failure of Fiona Bruce to moderate this conversation appropriately - with a fact check - is testament to the power (not discrimination) and fawning (not hate) that the trans community is offered.
Fiona Bruce is terminally incapable of fact checking sex. ‘Let’s hear from the audience ’ - that’s what’s ridiculous. Obviously panellists will bicker. Her job is to reality check, which she’s happy to do on any other issue but frightened of on sex and gender. The editor of Question Time used to run the Radio news desk which as most people know was quite sensible on ‘trans’. He could easily say to Bruce: you are free to fact check this, I’ve got your back. He may have already tried it (we’ve asked, with no response) but this is the residual power of transactivism - her public image and the money that goes with it is too precious. It’s come up too many times for the pair of them not to know the facts and to have made a conscious decision to leave the facts unclear. It’s pretty shameful. She’s paid over £400K and she won’t say ‘the facts are, no one changes sex, ever’. She will certainly imagine she’s very brave, facing the QT audience every week, but this is a foundational test of integrity that she fails.
@[private account]
@[private account]
The BBC is on a gigantic cost cutting exercise again. Her impact on public trust in BBC product must be huge. Save money and improve the BBC’s trust ratings by the magic of replacement. There are several presenters who’d do a better job.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The whole thumbnail is wrong, deliberately so, because the unbiased version is shorter
‘Father Ted co-creator Graham Linehan, who was found guilty of damaging the mobile phone of a transgender activist during a dispute outside a conference, has had his conviction overturned’
‘Father Ted co-creator Graham Linehan has been cleared on appeal of damaging the mobile phone of a transgender activist during a dispute outside a conference’
@rtenews do better
It’s not a reporter’s job to affirm. Your job is to report what’s true. Journalism 101. Transgender affirmation involves, to put it bluntly but truthfully, a lie. It is inaccurate. Of all the professions, the journalist’s mission is based on truth-telling. There’s no other part or purpose of journalism which is not negated by abandoning accuracy. This happened: who, what, when and where - we don’t want your opinions when you report. Save it for a column, and even then - don’t lie.
Maybe you think people are marginalised, maybe you want to be nice, maybe you don’t understand. But if you report on this, it’s your job to understand, and it’s not your job to lie for people you pity.
It sounds harsh, but which bit isn’t true? You’re a reporter, not a propagandist or a PR machine, or their mate or their Mum. You wanted this job, so just do it. Without lying.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: Ludicrously unnecessary mendacious language
It really matters if you portray the claimed (non) victim as a woman. It’s a smear that sticks even after acquittal, and it certainly shouldn’t be in a headline. Accuracy please. It’s not illegal.
That’s a good point. Affirmation here means transgender affirmation. Agree it’s not a valid journalistic pursuit. It’s a betrayal of your entire purpose as a reporter.
‘Prominent anti-transgender activist..his anti-transgender activism’
BBC Radio News on @Glinner
Grim from the BBC - @[private account], as ents correspondent, swims in a world of affirmation. No one on the desk would have been confident enough to correct him (because he’s a corr, and because the affirmation culture of the BBC means they won’t want to speak up) and he probably would have argued if they tried to.
Mzimba could have said ‘women and LGB rights campaigner’, he could have said gender critical campaigner, or sex based rights campaigner. Instead he saw it through a trans framing, and a trans lens, and he expressed a defamatory opinion.
It’s a restriction on revealing GRC status but not on stating someone is trans or what their bio sex is.
There could be an issue with gender pay gap data and GDPR but on toilets and changing rooms, the GRA doesn’t stop any employer telling a person they can’t use the facilities of the opposite sex.
‘Related topics: television’
Hiding a significant victory against a trans activist from the trans page, BBC Online? Whyever would you do that?
‘Graham Linehan's conviction for damaging trans activist's phone overturned’ https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/czx2vk4zx3xo
Do read this. The victim narrative is perpetuated by outlets like the BBC which hide stories about trans (mainly male) criminals from its ‘transgender people’ page and tag, but include stories where the trans-identified person is abused or in some way vulnerable.
For example: the Minneapolis shooter Robin Westman. But there are many, many more.
Quotes a post by A1185; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This report not unexpectedly omits significant salient factors
1 For example the number of co-morbidities suffered by children who are said to be trans-identified, including depression, abuse and family or sexual trauma
‘A growing body of research indicates that transgender youth experience substantial mental health disparities, such as higher rates of depression and anxiety’
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11250281/
2 The sustained reluctance of GPs to refer children for psychosocial support that may be perceived as ‘transphobic’ or ‘conversion therapy’ and instead put them on a gender clinic waiting list. This could be reinforced by any ‘conversion therapy’ ban
3 Evidence of raised rates of suicidality after hormonal intervention
https://www.genderclinicnews.com/p/alarming-but-false
https://statsforgender.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/There-is-little-evidence-that-medical-transition-decreases-suicidality.pdf
The statistics are terrible but Pink News blames them on the lack of access to medical treatment, which is unevidenced.
@[private account]
@[private account]
@[private account]
@[private account]
@genspect
@stellaomalley3
Quoting @PinkNews: Trans people in UK dying by suicide at higher rates than any other demographic ➡️ https://bit.ly/4w0lOyJ
📷 Getty
It needs to be out of the media. While established outlets still run with self-ID, harm is being done and there is a toehold back into public favour. Legacy press and broadcasting are still riddled with people who think trans-identified men are vulnerable women.
‘Bearded trans woman jailed for "grotesque" dirty nappies obsession’
No outlet needs to use mendacious language. They want to. From local outlets to the @[private account] they fall in line. https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/2199437/bearded-transgender-woman-jailed-grotesque
‘WI branches to close over transgender ban’
There is no trans ban @[private account] https://www.bristol247.com/news-and-features/news/wi-branches-close-over-transgender-ban/
When men like this win awards it’s not in spite of their misogyny, it’s because of.
Liew believes trans-identified men are women and he’s not shy about it. He is approved view. He is a warning and an example to reality based journalists, even when ‘sex and gender’ isn’t a factor.
He might claim to be controversial, and brave, but he chose the orthodoxy that secures his position.
Quotes a post by T23376; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘Keep Hampstead ponds trans inclusive, City of London recommends’
Scheming use of trans-inclusive
Why not say ‘mixed sex’, BBC? Because it’s too accurate. ‘Trans-inclusive’ falsely implies that ‘trans people’ could excluded from the Ponds under the law. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c30r0ezd434o
‘The plaintiff has never been camera-shy in the media spotlight’
Certainly never shy - it’s been his career. Here’s a still from a sample My Genderation (he’s a Director) offering about a girl who wants to be a boy - ‘Puberty blockers save lives’ - almost all its material is focussed on affirming kids and young people, along with the idea that old trans men were once trans kids (including a fawning chat by his female partner Fox with, of all people, Mridul Wadhwa). BBC3 has now scrubbed its My Genderation pages as has Channel 4, but his influence, not just in Iceland, has been huge. ‘Owl’ Fisher advised the youth-oriented campaign group All About Trans, which was set up specifically to persuade journalists and media content producers that what they could see with their own eyes wasn’t true. Very successfully so. Example here👇- he was a BBC ‘100 Women’ during the BBC’s extended trough in trans compliance, and was even sympathetically interviewed at an internal BBC panel event by Identity Corr Megha Mohan, who in 2018/19 it was essential to convert to ‘trans women are women, and who now only produces affirmative content. He was naturally very impressed by ITV’s trans child promo offering, Butterfly - saying it showed a realistic glimpse into an authentic struggle as would be expected from the co-author of the Trans Teen Survival Guide. A great deal of My Genderation’s work has centred around a victim narrative. These principles of ‘trans from birth, always a victim’ remain ingrained, particularly by feature content, in UK media. It’s harmful for the media to tell parents that their kids can change sex, and even more harmful to lie to the kids themselves, and his role in that is important.
Quotes a post by A1526; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans substitute teacher, 19, allegedly plotted chilling 'murder spree' at a Virginia school https://nypost.com/2026/04/24/us-news/trans-substitute-teacher-19-allegedly-plotted-chilling-murder-spree-at-a-virginia-school/
Delay to guidance on women’s spaces ‘weakens rule of law’, says UN https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/women-girls-delay-trans-guidance-637kjrtpg
Reports in Turkish media of a trans identified shooter in Turkey's worst ever school shooting:
'The school killer’s horrifying secrets have come to light: he believed himself to be a ‘woman’ and posed in a skirt'
https://www.haberhergun.com/haber/okul-katilinin-dehset-verici-sirlari-ortaya-cikti-kendini-kadin-sandi-etekle-poz-verdi_67189/
Starting 10'17" in, @[private account] on @[private account] 'If women and men and trans people could see the guidance, they would be incredibly reassured... trans people are protected, women now have more clarity, they don't need to go to court, they don't need to lose their jobs and be called bigots all the time for holding the views they hold in terms of defending their privacy, dignity and safety...we wished the guidance could have been out there immediately' https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/live/bbc_radio_fourfm
Europa Press report from Spain on a male prisoner, identified as the "Celador de Olot" (a murderer convicted of killing elderly people), who 'transitioned legally to female' and was subsequently transferred to a women's prison wing.
' The "Alianza contra el Borrado de las Mujeres" (Alliance Against the Erasure of Women) condemned the move, calling for the immediate repeal of the "Ley Trans" (Trans Law) and arguing that safety is being sacrificed.
Feminist groups claim this is not an isolated incident and that the legislation poses risks to the security of female inmates.' Link below 👇
Guardian reports on latest to and fro between government and EHRC, quoting Maya Forstater: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/apr/14/ehrc-supreme-court-ruling-gender-transgender
The statement does include: 'This government has always supported the protection of single-sex spaces based on biological sex. The Supreme Court’s ruling last year brought clarity for women and service providers such as hospitals and refuges, and made clear that protections for trans people remain in the Equality Act.' So perhaps there's no need for organisations to wait for guidance on single-sex spaces. They could simply follow the law.
The BBC's coverage of the Jennifer Melle story omits that the transgender patient involved was a convicted paedophile being transferred from a high security men's prison https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cx2vlxdnnpqo#:~:text=A%20nurse%20from%20south%20London,for%20using%20the%20wrong%20pronouns.
More coverage of the continuing delay to the publishing of EHRC guidance on single-sex spaces in an interview with @[private account] in The Telegraph, where she also talks about living with threats from trans activists. “You have a Government led by a lawyer, yet he’s unable to uphold the law in its most visible form, which is statutory guidance produced by a regulator – an independent regulator – of that law.” https://archive.ph/aaxd0
'Every day it's getting harder and harder for trans people to just exist...We just want to be'
These men who blame courts and sporting organisations for single sex policies - do they have any idea how many 'normies', or non-activists, view their cause as completely *over*? To whom do they think they are appealing?
This is not just a rebellion from Gen A and Z - it's a more rounded acceptance that for most people, this has come and gone as a fad, while the scale of the scandal and the harm is still unknown and unreported.
The @dailymail could have had a 'sad face' story from harmed females at any point, but the truth is that emotional appeals from men have always got more attention and clicks than emotinal appeals from women.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/darts/article-15719521/Trans-darts-star-retired-emotional-video-new-rule-change-just-weeks-Olympics-introduced-transgender-ban.html
The Telegraph joined in the affirmation as it almost always does - the price paid for the amount of coverage it gives this issue
'Prompting the transgender player Noa-Lynn van Leuven to say that she has been retired from the sport'
It's just unnecessary
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/darts/2026/04/09/darts-bans-transgender-players-born-male-from-womens-events/
'No sign of the Cambridge pro-trans mob when activism is really needed'
by @[private account]
'Supporting female heroes freed from Afghan oppression by a university scheme is beyond those students obsessed by culture wars'
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/04/10/no-sign-of-the-cambridge-trans-mob-when-activism-is-needed/
'People'
'Youth patients under 18'
'Transgender and queer youth'
'Young people
Why are you so, so afraid of the word 'children' @guardian?
'Explainer' - no, it's an exercise in hyperbole that even recycles the suicide myth
Nothing more irritating than a heap of affirmative bias pretending to be a factcheck
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/apr/02/supreme-court-conversion-therapy-ruling-impact-meaning
'Women’s Institute tearing itself apart over trans policy'
Unlike the Guardian piece a couple of weeks ago, this focusses on the chaotic impact of so-called 'inclusion' on women trying to get on with just doing things without men around.
'Members are rebelling against the organisation’s new trans-inclusion policy amid fears it will restrict gender-critical views'
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/04/04/womens-institute-tearing-itself-apart-over-trans-policy-uk/
'Boots is allowing the sale of trans drugs to under-18s despite the NHS warning about their effects on children'.
'Britain’s biggest high-street chemist is among a handful of pharmacy chains filling out private prescriptions for oestrogen and testosterone for 16 and 17-year-olds'.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/04/04/boots-selling-trans-drugs-harm-to-children-fears-nhs/
'Working back from that with talking, family therapy, therapy on Flo's side as well, talking with family and realising you're not alone'
The key admission, which @DailyMail doesn't pick up on. She found the wrong people. Affirmation talk therapy, affirmation family therapy, outsiders intervening to affirm so that an entire family is trained to believe that a girl is a boy. Her first instinct was right - it's ludicrous, but it was gtrained out of her.
'Tamzin Outhwaite opens up about her eldest child being transgender'
https://mol.im/a/15705879
Thanks for covering but once again - being trans is not why she wouldn’t play against him. It’s because he is a man.
Being trans is the reason *he* wanted to play. It’s *his* framing.
None of this is inaccurate. But trans doesn’t mean male, and vice versa.
Quoting @Telegraph: 🔴In 2023, pool player Lynne Pinches refused to play against transgender opponent Harriet Haynes in the Champion of Champions final
Read more about the ruling ⬇️
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/snooker/2026/04/03/snooker-bans-transgender-players-from-womens-game/?WT.mc_id=tmgoff_fb_photo_transgender-players-from-womens-game/
We're very late with our review of the week! but here it is
'Matt Brittin, the Guides, the Olympics, more trans crime, and the cruelty of the CPS'
https://seeninjournalism.substack.com/p/matt-brittin-the-guides-the-olympics
C2 false claimshand-codedcrime caseviolence terror
Breaches BBC rules that say it should always be made clear what sex a ‘trans’ person is ‘if it side audience understanding’
It does here
‘Darlington Council votes against single-sex spaces in its buildings’ https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c1eqn6xyv0qo
Finally the @thetimes
Full overview of coverage in the weekend media overview on our Substack
https://www.thetimes.com/sport/olympics/article/transgender-women-banned-female-olympics-02khp7p37
Sneaky from the @Independent
Decent-ish write up but at the top, instead of an image of any of the male athletes or of Kirsty Coventry, there’s a video titled ‘Republicans demand a ban trans athletes at the Olympics’, thus framing the entire announcement as slavish to what its readers will consider to be the far right and Donald Trump
https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/olympics/transgender-ban-ioc-female-category-gender-eligibility-b2946193.html
‘Olympics BAN transgender athletes from ALL women's sports’
Also not true
However: ‘The IOC's new rules do not filter down to grassroots or recreational sports programmes, meaning young girls could still face transgender athletes in their respective disciplines’ - there’s an awareness that the scandal abides
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/othersports/article-15681297/Olympics-BAN-transgender-DSD-athletes-womens-sports-using-sex-tests-block-likes-gender-row-boxer-Imane-Khelif-male-weightlifter-Laurel-Hubbard.html
‘Transgender women athletes banned from Olympics by new IOC policy on female eligibility’
Also not true: they can compete in the male category.
https://www.cnn.com/2026/03/26/sport/olympics-transgender-women-athletes-banned
Poor to very poor from @SkyNews
The number of times men are described as women is self destructive - do they not want readers and viewers to understand the story?
Rob Harris, sorry to say, seems caught up in TQ+ talking points
https://www.skysports.com/olympics/news/15234/13524679/transgender-women-athletes-banned-from-female-olympic-events
‘A draft law to stop the gender medicalisation of minors is up against organised resistance and captured media’
By @Bernard_Lane on Portugal
🙏 Bernard for focussing too on media responsibility
It’s *so* important. Media coverage preceded a gigantic lift in child referrals in the UK, media coverage has ruined children’s and family lives accordingly. It’s a universal legacy media convention that trans issues are considered by editors to be tremendously important when it’s an affirmative story, and beyond niche when it’s a safeguarding story. It’s absolute recklessness from editors and commissioners.
‘Carla Lockhart MP calls for Government guidance after victory of Jennifer Melle and Darlington nurses in NHS transgender battles’
@[private account] https://www.newsletter.co.uk/news/politics/carla-lockhart-mp-calls-for-government-guidance-after-victory-of-jennifer-melle-and-darlington-nurses-in-nhs-transgender-battles-6301706
ITV News should join the dots between trans-only refuge - no protests and harassment
Women-only refuge - protests and harassment
It’s basic stuff
‘First trans refuge in North West offers domestic abuse survivors place to 'finally breathe'’ https://www.itv.com/news/granada/2026-03-25/i-feel-empowered-inside-north-wests-first-trans-refuge-for-abuse-survivors
‘India rolls back trans rights with draconian amendment’
More on India from the activist standpoint. Like Portugal, India seems to be turning on a sixpence. https://www.thecanary.co/trending/2026/03/25/india-trans-rights/
Did you know that ‘lived experience’ is another piece of stolen language? First used mainly in feminist campaigning - now co-opted by gender identity activism to mean something wholly different
‘Trans women footballers share lived experiences’
Archive https://archive.ph/2026.03.26-070655/https://sportsmedialgbt.com/transgender-women-footballers-report-research-lived-experiences-lgbtq
The @itvnews version - ‘trans inclusive guidance’
https://www.itv.com/news/channel/2026-03-25/jersey-politicians-vote-to-keep-trans-inclusive-school-guidance
‘Bid to change trans guidance for Jersey schools rejected’
This is safeguarding guidance drawn up by @[private account]
Fair report
Boilerplate responses from gender activists:
‘Plans were politically motivated’
‘Culture wars’
‘Weaponisation’ https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvge7rlmm83o
Affirmation for a murderer - led by court officials
‘Trans woman who stabbed her murderer boyfriend to death after meeting him in men's jail faces life in prison’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15678893/Trans-woman-prison-stabbing-boyfriend.html
We have two posts on Matt Brittin today. Here’s the second
‘His history of transgender affirmation is no secret, as neither employer, nor new employee, thought it the least bit interesting or relevant to the job. In one sense it’s helpful. He has no plausible deniability if the BBC starts she-her-ing rapists again. He’ll get the blame’
https://open.substack.com/pub/seeninjournalism/p/thoughts-on-bbc-leadership?r=3lemhw&utm_medium=ios
A long BBC clip but very well worth a listen. This is @[private account] talking to @[private account] and Alexa Moore of the Rainbow Project about the legal status of trans-identified people in Northern Ireland. He challenges both but absolutely destroys, ever so politely, Alexa Moore’s claims. It’s not lost on us that these are three men discussing women’s rights, but for sure two of them do know what’s real and what isn’t.
‘Beyond shock. Beyond surprise. Beyond grief..the trans girls and young women directly affected, who are now sundered from friends and social ties, I feel a deep and lasting sorrow’
Jane Fae (male)
https://archive.ph/2026.03.25-125031/https://metro.co.uk/2026/03/25/girl-guides-womens-institute-trans-people-told-dont-belong-2-27660381/
This is a great listen, and also a true insight into a commonplace presenter framing, to which Ella’s (appropriate) response was:- we need accuracy and facts, not appeals to girls to be nice.
Kait Borsay is a super presenter but if you want to hear a ‘middle ground, be kind, true trans’ narrative it’s here in action. It was picked apart awfully well but this is the pernicious framing that drives so much legacy media coverage. Shouting at them just generates tone-policing. It has to be dissected every single time. Recommended listen.
Quotes a post by T14847; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It *could* have been devil’s advocacy but it didn’t sound like it. ‘I’ve met trans kids’ is rather a clue. Dollars to doughnuts there are friends in the mix who’ve transed their own children.
‘We were wrong.. I think we should completely stop doing anything that might harm children’ - says the former head of what was and is a huge transgender activist driving force in the US.
Tremendous piece from @[private account]
Glaad still supports life-altering irreversible medical treatments for children who’ve been led to believe they are ‘in the wrong body’, so this intervention is timely.
Read the piece here.
https://open.substack.com/pub/benappel/p/former-glaad-president-we-were-wrong?r=3lemhw&utm_medium=ios
As broken by @bindelj on her Substack
‘Transgender stalker who treatened to 'batter' surgeon will serve sentence in women's jail’ @[private account] https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/2186210/transgender-stalker-who-treatened-batter
Great to acknowledge that sex and gender is the top of the story, very due
‘..while reaffirming her support for the trans community..’
The subconscious ‘tell’ in the third par. Affirmative framing is a hard habit to break. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cgmevmvmy49o
Grim@[private account] by @guardian but it does give a line to @SexMattersorg
‘Girlguiding gives trans girls and women until September to leave UK organisation’ https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/mar/24/girlguiding-trans-girls-women-leave
Aside from a complaint, we’ve asked for the phrases ‘trans boys’ and ‘trans girls’ to be added to ‘trans children’ in the Style Guide as terms to be ‘generally avoided’.
Ok this isn’t true.
Children who are said by teachers or parents to be ‘trans’ can stay in the Guides quite happily so long as they’re girls.
Loose media talk like this fuels accusations of so-called ‘transphobia’ @thetimes
Say male, say boys.
Quoting @thetimes: Girlguiding tells trans members they must leave by September https://www.thetimes.com/uk/society/article/girlguiding-trans-ban-gv8w208m8?utm_term=Autofeed&utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Twitter#Echobox=1774357376
Imagine it being breaking headline news that boys can’t be in the Guides. We live in that world.
Here’s @jan_murray’s piece from two days ago on the internal war which saw gender activists lose another battle today
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/03/22/girl-guides-at-war-over-trans-ban/
No one should be pretending they’re girls of any kind, it’s harmful to everyone, not least the boys themselves. It’s worse than ‘trans women’ because these are children.
The style guide says ‘Generally avoid the term "trans child/children" or "transgender child/children", unless attributed’ - so by logic they should avoid ‘trans boys’ and ‘trans girls’.
We’ll be focussing on that and using the style guide in our complaint.
The anger over ‘trans girls’ is due - we objected to Sky doing it this morning. It’s highly activist and dangerous.
Here’s the guidance (in the screenshot - not in the public domain) and here’s the ‘preferred pronouns’ style guide which needs to change.
Since the BBC adopted the ‘bio male’ rule, other outlets have started doing it, as if by osmosis. It’s important and it’s why activists hate it.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsstyleguide/g
We see a lot of criticism of this but it’s not as bad as it would have been only six months ago. The issues are obvious but it does make clear these are boys, even though like every other outlet it uses the activist terms ‘trans girls and women’.
The new guidance, that says every piece has to make clear what sex the subjects are, is being complied with. That’s not in the public domain, like the official style guide, but has been sent to all staff as a direct instruction from the head of news content.
The BBC has corrected *some* pieces which don’t do this but not all. The specialist reporters who cover this (not Michael here) always make it clear, but local reporters are bad at it and they’re defended (wrongly) by the complaints unit.
They still use the outdated ‘preferred pronouns’ style guide. We’ve been trying to change this since forever, but one insider said it would be like putting a bomb under the newsroom.
Partly it’s fear but partly it’s a residual sense that preferred pronouns are simply a matter of politeness.
The BBC just has to cling on to this ‘bio male’ guidance by its fingernails until it can move even further forward. We would have been sure with Tim Davie and Deborah Turness, but the question is whether Matt Brittin will cave to internal campaigning to resume unconditional affirmation.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cx2rn250ddjo
Matt Brittin hasn’t officially been named yet but he will be. He’s got transgender activism - and pronouns - in his history.
There are a number of middle-aged men at the BBC who’ve been key in promoting and supporting gender ideology and affirmation. Tim Davie wasn’t one of them, and it was a disaster for this issue that he left.
Most of those men are still in role, and in Matt Britton we could get another. It still seems unlikely that the BBC will resume its extreme obsession with self-identification, but it’s full of gender guerillas, and they’ll redouble their efforts.
Anyone who can make representations to him, make them early doors. He has to understand there is no going back.
Quoting @Telegraph: 🖋️ "A healthy BBC needs the support of a big cross-section of the British population; it cannot rely just on the progressive Left."
Why was Matt Brittin chosen for the role? Read more from Robin Aitken ⤵️
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/03/23/brittin-bbc-dg-left-wing/?WT.mc_id=tmgoff_tw_post
‘Trans row: School in landmark High Court fight over boys using girls’ changing rooms’
School is in Brighton and legal case is also brought against Brighton and Hove council https://www.gbnews.com/news/trans-school-court-changing-rooms
‘Trump invents new word in rant on transgender and SAVE Act, and rejects any shutdown deal with Democrats without voter ID’
The word is ‘mutilisation’
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/trump-government-shutdown-democrats-tsa-b2943629.html
So many versions of this story over the last few days so here’s a link. Trans campaigners complain about someone pretending to be trans. Is the irony lost on them? Yes it entirely is
‘The Last Of Us’ criticised for "tone deaf" casting of trans role’ https://www.nme.com/news/gaming-news/the-last-of-us-backlash-casting-trans-character-lev-season-three-3936145
‘EXCLUSIVE: Jennifer Melle says she has blown away by the support shown by the public after she was cancelled in a trans patient misgendering row’
@[private account]
https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/2185397/NHS-transgender-woke-biological-sex-women
Gift 🎁 link
‘Macmillan Cancer Support will prioritise access to its welfare advice for gay, transgender and ethnic minority cancer patients’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/51c2e8ddf229fc20
Today from 4.30 pm MPs will debate puberty blockers at Westminster Hall. Watch on this link.
https://www.youtube.com/live/HHa3B2PiX60?si=zRG2p6BeJ9KTme3-
The transcript will be published here.
https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2026-03-23
This debate is a result of the public petition created by @JamesEsses to
‘Cancel the clinical trial into puberty blockers and safeguard vulnerable children’
which more than 146,000 people signed. The petition is here.
https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/751839
The debate will be opened by MP Jamie Stone, an admitted trans activist, as Chair of the Petitions committee.
A government minister will attend and respond.
Here’s the http://gov.uk page
https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/326/petitions-committee/news/212716/mps-will-debate-a-petition-relating-to-the-clinical-trial-into-puberty-blockers/
From Saturday
‘Democrats voted 49 to 41 against the Protection for Women and Girls in Sports Act on Saturday, blocking one of President Donald Trump’s top priorities. It’s fourth time Democrats have defeated the proposed bill’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15669197/Senate-blocks-bill-transgender-womens-sports.html
There’s a Medium article by a trans-identified female about the importance of language. Here be a sample. Apart from being wrong on everything else, she’s spot on about this. She just can’t see it for what it is - replacing activism with accuracy.
Handbrake turn in India where self-ID has until now swept all before it
‘Transgender Act Amendment: Why do activists strongly oppose the changes?’
‘At the heart of the opposition is the proposed shift towards requiring “medical proof” of gender identity’ https://www.indiatoday.in/india/law-news/story/transgender-act-amendment-bill-sexual-gender-identities-medical-proof-opposition-protest-parliament-2885701-2026-03-23
‘Judges given training by Scottish Trans and Gendered Intelligence..legal experts were told by pro-trans groups how to refer to the community during proceedings’
And news consumers were then gaslit by outlets: ‘We follow the language used in court’
🎁🎁
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/45b4b06485bbc73a
There will be a fresh inquest into the death of a 20-year-old trans-identified female, Aiden Longmuir. This is a Good Law Project case. Among other concerns, the family want her recorded as male on her death certificate. All details are here: this is a *not* a GLP link.
https://www.leighday.co.uk/news/press-releases/2026-news/fresh-inquest-ordered-into-death-of-trans-man-following-legal-challenge/
Also in Scotland, an intervention from the Scottish Human Rights Commission on men in women's jails. Urgent talks are sought. Reported by the Herald.
https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/25949150.human-rights-watchdog-concerns-trans-prison-policy/?ref=twtrec
Next: Sex Matters wins its Court of Appeal bid to continue a legal challenge over rules allowing men to use the women's pond at Hampstead Heath. Not, as the BBC puts it, allowing 'trans people to use the single-sex facilities'. The decision by the High Court in February last month to block it has been overturned.
Here is @SexMattersOrg more accurate update
https://sex-matters.org/posts/updates/hampstead-ponds-judicial-review-going-ahead/
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c7472pz39npo
We’ve just updated our overview of the week which first came out on Friday.
‘Keira Bell, Olivia Bailey, a spate of trans crime, and detrans awareness day’
Plus more, much more of course, it was a non stop week - March 8 to 15.
https://open.substack.com/pub/seeninjournalism/p/keira-bell-olivia-bailey-a-spate?r=3lemhw&utm_medium=ios
A really excellent analysis of the foundational flaw of building policies on the concept of ‘true trans’. It’s by Arty Morty.
The ‘true trans’ position is widely viewed as a compromise between transactivists and realists - including and especially in the media.
That is: they’ve shifted from adopting self-ID, into allowing that some people who say they’re trans might not be. But they retain the idea that some of them *really do* have an opposite sex brain.
That, of course, isn’t true, and where they should have shifted to is that no one has an opposite sex brain. No one is true trans. A man with dysphoria is a man with dysphoria. But they can’t do that, because that lands them on the same side as LGB Alliance, Sex Matters, Posie Parker etc. Doesn’t matter that that’s the truthful side - they’re think they’re not allowed to take any side, even one that’s obviously uniquely accurate.
So they hold fast to this idea that ‘true trans’ is real, that wrong body people truly exist, because otherwise what the hell have they being doing for the last ten years. Notoriously convinced of their own righteousness and cynicism, they can’t possibly admit they were proper fooled and taken in.
When editorial policies are built on that, no one in the mainstream media is deployed to have a good look at why this disorder has grown, what’s the cause, the root, can it be treated rather than affirmed and so on.
But read Arty Morty. This is a snippet but it’s all n the link.
https://substack.com/@[private account]/note/c-227455478?r=3lemhw&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action
‘I’m a GP: here’s why the puberty blockers trial must go ahead’
Fortunately, this is behind a paywall. Archive here.
‘It’s not that the evidence about gender-affirming medicine is weak – rather, attempts to generate better evidence keep getting blocked’ https://archive.ph/2026.03.14-112357/https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/puberty-blockers-trial-trans-gender-cass-review-dysphoria-b2894555.html
‘Scots prison officer sacked for refusing to call trans inmates 'she' loses employment tribunal’
@[private account] picks up the Toshack story from the Telegraph.
‘The judge said David was dismissed solely because he wouldn't follow his employer's policy and this was unrelated to his belief. ThIs is untenable’.
It’s not clear how a company policy forcing an employee to express a belief they don’t share is *not* unlawfully discriminatory. Is it a genuine occupational requirement to describe men as women? Of course not - self-identification is a policy the company has decided to adopt.
Are there non-discriminatory alternatives to forcing employees to comply with self-identification? Of course - instruct others to be more tolerant, particularly the prisoners, and to respect the Equality Act and its protected characteristics.
Free Speech Union says it’s untenable and there’ll be an appeal. We’re pleased to hear it. Self-identification isn’t the law, it’s a belief that’s ungrounded in reality, and an unreasonable demand.
https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-news/scots-prison-officer-sacked-refusing-36868068
‘A taxpayer- funded charity has been criticised over its links to a controversial trans activist group exposed for advising young people how to self-inject gender drugs’
@[private account] https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/charity-slammed-over-links-trans-36868052
Doesn’t seem to look at skeletal or lung differences, or having a body built by T
It debunks recent headlines but not enough
It also grates so hard to hear ‘women women women’ when they’re talking about men
‘More or Less - Trans women in sport’ https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct6w0c
Not experts but this doesn’t address skeletal and lung differences or the advantage of having your body shaped by testosterone
‘More or Less - Trans women in sport: Does ‘comparable’ mean ‘equal’?’
It does debunk recent headlines however @[private account] https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct6w0c
Olivia Bailey's team deleted the post about her meeting with all the trans-identifying men
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: This will look very troublesome to those women fighting for the implementation of the Supreme Court ruling who don’t get this kind of access and government PR, and never have. It’s a poor look.
Helen Belcher, on the left with a fringe, was a co-founder of Trans Media Watch. He’s indirectly and directly partly responsible for the industrial scale UK media capture, from around 2010 onwards, from which we are only just emerging.
That media capture put him where he is today, arguably - excessive affirmation that ‘trans’ people are uniquely vulnerable gets him the government’s ear on ‘trans’ ‘hate’ ‘crime’. Apologies for all the inverted commas but it’s all activist jargon.
Mridul Wadhwa (two away from Belcher) resigned from running a rape crisis centre when a review found he failed to protect women-only spaces and did not ‘prioritise the needs of survivors’. Very shocking that the government is this 👇proud to be working with him.
Meanwhile Olivia Bailey has now told the Commons twice, and additionally an audience at a Stonewall event, that her government plans to ban ‘gender identity’ ‘conversion therapy’. If she can define gender identity she’ll be the only person in the world ever to so. In fact she’d be hard pushed to define ‘trans’.
Retweeted by Bridget Phillipson’s team.
The ratio is its own hate crime.
This should be a PR fail but it's hard to tell if Bailey's team are completely detached from reality, or saw an opportunity for a little light defiant trolling. It's basically a show of trans-identified male power, despite the law.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: This will look very troublesome to those women fighting for the implementation of the Supreme Court ruling who don’t get this kind of access and government PR, and never have. It’s a poor look.
Helen Belcher, on the left with a fringe, was a co-founder of Trans Media Watch. He’s indirectly and directly partly responsible for the industrial scale UK media capture, from around 2010 onwards, from which we are only just emerging.
That media capture put him where he is today, arguably - excessive affirmation that ‘trans’ people are uniquely vulnerable gets him the government’s ear on ‘trans’ ‘hate’ ‘crime’. Apologies for all the inverted commas but it’s all activist jargon.
Mridul Wadhwa (two away from Belcher) resigned from running a rape crisis centre when a review found he failed to protect women-only spaces and did not ‘prioritise the needs of survivors’. Very shocking that the government is this 👇proud to be working with him.
Meanwhile Olivia Bailey has now told the Commons twice, and additionally an audience at a Stonewall event, that her government plans to ban ‘gender identity’ ‘conversion therapy’. If she can define gender identity she’ll be the only person in the world ever to so. In fact she’d be hard pushed to define ‘trans’.
Retweeted by Bridget Phillipson’s team.
'Trans rapist who 'robbed' girls of innocence jailed for nine years'
BBC Scotland are well practised at neutral language but we should be at the point of not bothering with neutrality at all now. He doesn't deserve it, and he doesn't deserve to be hidden from the 'transgender people' page.
The page used to be just called 'transgender' but it was changed about six years ago (when transactivism at the BBC was immensely powerful) to 'transgender people' - because of the push towards 'human story, lived experience, we're not a debate, we are people' schtick. Calling it 'transgender people' also reaffirmed that there is such a thing, when really there are just males and females with various habits and behaviours.
However that nominal change is even more of a reason why these grim cases should be on that page. The story's about a 'transgender' man, and his lived experience of sexually assaulting and raping children, and only getting nine years in prison.
Stories about transgender sexual criminals are routinely hidden under a local tag. This is not just hidden from the trans page, it's hidden from the 'sexual violence' page https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c1038wnxe18, from the violence against women page https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c340r11jgrzt, from the child abuse page https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c46zkd8y97et from the crime page https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/cldy2dmy748t and from the child protection page https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/cz3nm1pr1nyt
and the LGBT page https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/cp7r8vgln2wt
They have to report it, but they'd rather as few people as possible see it
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgky8ndjm4o
The Times is, but it also raises the issue of where he'll be held in prison - male or female
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/serenity-francis-johnston-trans-rapist-j53p7fnbw?utm_term=Autofeed&utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Twitter#Echobox=1773420141
The Sun isn't afraid of pronouns
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/16035070/trans-beast-jailed-rape/?utm_medium=Social&utm_campaign=scottishsuntwitter&u-tm_source=Twitter
Here's coverage about the campaign by gender identity activists *against* this highly significant move in the US state of New Hampshire
https://indepthnh.org/2026/03/12/nh-house-again-passes-bills-impacting-transgender-people/
It means more people will be able to sue for being transed as children. 'Gender' surgeons won't have a 'get out of jail free' pass two years after they've operated on a child.
'Rep. Alice Wade, D-Dover, said the bill does nothing to address any issue and is purely a waste of time. [He] said [he] is an example of the life saving effects that result when she transitioned as a minor. 'I am alive today because of the care I received as a minor'
He knows this will increase surgeons's reluctance - and insurance bills - when it comes to operating on children. Whey are gender activists concerned, when they 'know' detransition and regret is 'so rare'? Perhaps because they're in fact well aware of the harms, and so are the medics involved.
Quotes a post by T19959; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
BBC search tag pages this story is hidden from:
Transgender People
Sexual Violence
Crime
Child Abuse
Child Protection
Women
Women's Rights
LGBT
LGBT+
BBC search tag where it appears
Livington
It's not okay, and it's also not okay to switch off replies. You're publicly funded.
Quoting @BBCScotlandNews: Trans rapist who 'robbed' girls of innocence jailed for nine years https://bbc.in/3Pzovq5
More - three trans-identified men and no Lesbian Labour. Epically bad look.
Quoting @RosieDuffield1: Interesting too that Belcher, an individual LibDem, was granted an audience over Labour groups such as @[private account]. What a strange decision.
‘Historic bid to force trans neo-Nazi who changed gender ‘so he could go to a women's jail’ to REVERSE back to being male’
More on this from @TheSun
How do you reverse back to something you never stopped being in the first place https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/38497296/trans-neo-nazi-forced-reverse-gender-women-jail/
Here’s the Wadhwa background
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c2edeyzz0xmo
There appear to be the same number of women at the table as trans-identified men. For such a tiny minority these men are very over-represented in their access to power.
Helen Belcher is interviewed by the BBC here in 2022.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-wiltshire-64121653
‘The media activist also spoke about how trans people feel excluded from media coverage of trans issues’
You couldn’t make it up
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-wiltshire-64121653
This will look very troublesome to those women fighting for the implementation of the Supreme Court ruling who don’t get this kind of access and government PR, and never have. It’s a poor look.
Helen Belcher, on the left with a fringe, was a co-founder of Trans Media Watch. He’s indirectly and directly partly responsible for the industrial scale UK media capture, from around 2010 onwards, from which we are only just emerging.
That media capture put him where he is today, arguably - excessive affirmation that ‘trans’ people are uniquely vulnerable gets him the government’s ear on ‘trans’ ‘hate’ ‘crime’. Apologies for all the inverted commas but it’s all activist jargon.
Mridul Wadhwa (two away from Belcher) resigned from running a rape crisis centre when a review found he failed to protect women-only spaces and did not ‘prioritise the needs of survivors’. Very shocking that the government is this 👇proud to be working with him.
Meanwhile Olivia Bailey has now told the Commons twice, and additionally an audience at a Stonewall event, that her government plans to ban ‘gender identity’ ‘conversion therapy’. If she can define gender identity she’ll be the only person in the world ever to so. In fact she’d be hard pushed to define ‘trans’.
Retweeted by Bridget Phillipson’s team.
Quotes a post by A2172; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘Stop giving my child trans hormones, mother pleads’
Gift 🎁 link - heartbreaking
‘The mother..has been fighting to protect her child from private providers - which she says are “run by activists and ideologues” – for four years.
@Telegraph
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/a2fba4324f1c32fa
'Trans woman who stalked surgeon who carried out her surgery is jailed'
Detail on which prison estate is at the bottom of the piece. Has been in Wandsworth till now, and wants to go to a women's jail.
Absurdly affirmative. Absurd.
https://mol.im/a/15640605
@DailyMail
And here it is covered by @Telegraph
'It creates a potential loophole by which Hungarian and Bulgarian trans people could move elsewhere in the EU to have their gender legally recognised on their birth certificates back home.'
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/03/12/bulgarias-trans-law-breaks-eu-rules/
‘A [man who says he’s a] trans woman is due to be sentenced for raping a child’
Former Met volunteer
How long will it be before sexual arousal is universally understood to be a factor in some men’s transition
@[private account] - accurate pronouns https://www.bucksfreepress.co.uk/news/25931300.james-bubb-chesham-jailed-rape-crimes/
It’s a shame that @GMB felt that Keira Bell needed to be ‘balanced’ by a satisfied transitioner (who was affirmed throughout). We have heard voices like Keira’s so little, and there has been no shortage of affirmative lived experiences of trans-identified people. Keira WAS the balance to a deluge of affirmation.
Unfortunately the guest was allowed to claim that puberty blockers are ‘completely reversible’. This advice was taken down from the NHS website several years ago. It was challenged by Kate Garraway but it should have been fact-checked in the brief. ‘No - that’s not the case’.
No doubt this hit was an attempt to head off complaints activism at the pass. Paul Brand has a rep of being very activist but he was measured. They both were. Kate asked some insightful questions.
Nothing new from the guest, who rolled out the usual lines: ‘it’s not happening’, ‘trans community is small’ ‘precocious puberty’ ‘the drugs are tremendously hard to get hold of’ ‘you’re monitored incredibly closely’ ‘I knew when I was tiny’ ‘decision comes with full information’ ‘detransition rate is vanishingly small’ and finally - the chutzpah - ‘we are so often not in the room’ (that last came with the encouragement of Paul Brand who just couldn’t stop himself throwing in ‘it’s so toxic, how does that make you feel’.)
To be fair all of them could have been knocked out of the park by the journalists in SiJ (plus most of our non journalist followers) without catching a breath. Kate G really did seek to challenge. But it’s hard to deliver what must seem like very harsh facts when someone whose sanity depends on the facts being untrue is sitting right in front of you. That’s why gender identity activists focus on ‘lived experience’ journalism, in order to disarm.
The visual furniture - ‘puberty blockers saved my life’ was ill-informed. Every single researcher putting a brief together should know that the suicide myth has been debunked by none other than the UK suicide commissioner, Louis Appleby, as well as gender activists in court hearings, and it should never be given prominence without challenge.
Pres were fair. They are very exposed, and they’re not going to say on live TV, what if you want kids, aren’t you worried about your sexual function, how do you know you’re not just saying this because your brain was stalled in a pre-pubertal state, are you being chemically castrated, what about the elevated risk of cancer and stroke, have you thought about the next forty years of pharmacological dependence etc.
But that’s a conversation that should have been had in planning. This is primarily a safeguarding issue, not just a culture war or political ding-ding.
We campaign for balance. What a coincidence that outlets remember what what it is when they’ve had the audacity to platform a detransitioner.
Finally well done to whoever added ‘controversial’ about half a dozen times to ‘puberty blocker trial’ in the script.
Here's the @DailyMail write up of last night's concert
'Sophie Ellis-Bextor and Beth Ditto perform at Trans Mission https://mol.im/a/15637897
For a line by line commentary see @[private account] timeline
Only tangentially gender. But it speaks to the honesty of the man who says ‘trans women are women’
‘Zack Polanski stood by breast enlargment hypnosis claim’ https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cn9enygvezeo
Fascinating insight into how activist journalists don’t think things through.
Dysphoria is a terrible condition rendering its sufferers impossibly vulnerable. But it’s a scandal to try to resolve it🤷♂️
‘Prisons ban gender-affirming care for trans inmates’ https://theweek.com/health/new-federal-policy-transgender-prisoners-conversion-therapy
‘Mike Nesbitt urged to give 'clear answers' on latest NHS trans drugs ban - amid serious health concerns’
@[private account] fantastic this story
Plus - ‘Opposite sex hormones’ - great clarity, and very high up mention of cancer, stroke side effects 👍 https://www.newsletter.co.uk/news/politics/mike-nesbitt-urged-to-give-clear-answers-on-latest-nhs-trans-drugs-ban-amid-serious-health-concerns-5629048
The leader of @TheGreenParty Zack Polanski last night.
His party is currently drawing in many, many disaffected gender identity activists including a big Labour cohort. But the growth in Green membership isn’t a sign that the ‘trans rights’ slogan is gaining in popularity.
Support is simply being focussed in one place, which makes it easier to guesstimate, now that it’s seen as *the* trans rights/LGBTQ+ party. It would be a mistake for editors to assume that rising Green member numbers signal fresh demand for trans affirmative content. Yes it’s all now concentrated in one place, and more extreme at the same time, but that’s no different to reducing a sauce. Some will be transactivists who’ve never been signed up to a party before, and they’re now gathered in place. For example the latest Sex Matters poll showed ever stronger support for single sex spaces, the polar opposite of ‘trans women are women, trans men are men’.
From here, we’d say the Trans Mission concert isn’t a sign of resurgence, it’s just PR to make you think so.
https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/03/01/the-green-party-of-england-and-wales-surpasses-200000-members/
See link for membership: around 200,000 from C68,000since last autumn
Sex Matters poll
https://sex-matters.org/posts/updates/new-poll-shows-most-people-prefer-single-sex-toilets-and-changing-rooms/
Quoting @implausibleblog: Zack Polanski at Trans Mission tonight,
"Are you ready to make hope normal again?"
"For hope to defeat hate?"
"Are you ready to celebrate trans joy?"
"I'm a politicians and I want to say on behalf of all politicians, I'm sorry, we're all let you down"
"So tonight, let's be as clear as we possibly can"
"Trans rights are human rights"
"Trans men are men, trans women are women"
"And non-binary people exist"
"Politicians have tried to blame, tried to distracted"
"Tonight I am here to say, we will not blame, we will not be distracted"
"As a gay man I know when they come for one of us they come for all of us, and we will all stand together"
Here’s the global market forecast for the next decade
‘The sex hormones market is projected to reach approximately $52bn by 2035 at an annual growth rate of about 6.5%..trans rights have propelled demand, expanding the market landscape significantly’
https://coremarketresearch.com/report/sex-hormones
‘There’s money to be made in giving children trans hormones’
Terrific from @[private account] in @Telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/03/10/money-made-giving-children-trans-hormones-nhs-health/
‘Uncertainty over whether NI will follow latest trans drug ban - amid fears over potential links to blood clots, cancer and strokes’
Super from @[private account] @[private account] - yes these health impacts do deserve a headline https://www.newsletter.co.uk/news/politics/uncertainty-over-whether-ni-will-follow-latest-trans-drug-ban-amid-fears-over-potential-links-to-blood-clots-cancer-and-strokes-5627625
Take a look at what @jan_murray has highlighted here. There’s a video. Faceless girls being used to promote the belief (and policies based on the belief) that being a woman or girl is all in your head.
Please, presenters, stop saying trans males are powerless and marginalised.
Quoting @jan_murray: If my daughter were in this Guide group, I would remove her immediately.
Because youth organisations shouldn’t be using children to front political campaigns.
This video from Thatcham Rangers, part of Girlguiding, shows girls holding slogans such as “trans girls are girls” and “our story includes trans girls”, while the Guide Promise is read over the top.
The video also includes repeated shots of what appear to be shark and dolphin plush toys - which call to mind the Blåhaj shark plush toy from IKEA, a soft toy that has become a well-known symbol in online trans activism.
The video is presented as part of a badge exercise on protest and activism.
But when it involves coordinated slogans, covered faces and links to activist organisations, it’s reasonable to ask whether this is really a youth activity - or political campaigning.
The caption includes a disclaimer that the views expressed don’t necessarily represent those of Girlguiding or the church involved. But it also thanks activist organisations including Guiders Against Trans Exclusion (GATE) and Newbury Pride.
At the end of last year, Girlguiding announced that boys who identify as girls would no longer be able to join Guiding - a policy change that prompted significant public debate.
To be clear, this isn’t criticism of the girls themselves. The responsibility lies with the adults who organised and encouraged them to take part in a highly contested political campaign.
Compared to trans people, how many detransitioners can you name? There are C30K on a Reddit forum. And how often are they given a voice on legacy media? It’s vanishingly rare. Well done @GMB for helping to restore the balance.
‘The school safeguarding plans that allow trans activists to abuse both children and parents’ by Prof @[private account] https://www.conservativewoman.co.uk/the-school-safeguarding-plans-that-allow-trans-activists-to-abuse-both-children-and-parents/
‘Using the words ‘gay’ and lesbian’ harms trans people, says Prof’
‘California professor wants to abolish sexual identities like 'gay' and 'lesbian'’
@FoxNews
Quiet part out loud. Beware ‘experts’. https://www.foxnews.com/media/california-professor-calls-abolish-identities-like-gay-lesbian-since-harm-trans-people
‘Anger, Aggression, and Irritability in Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth Following Testosterone Initiation: A 12-Month Longitudinal Analysis’ - PubMed
Self-reported levels of anger in women and girls on testosterone - study https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41739008/
‘Plans to limit trans youth’s access to care’
It’s not informative when every word is a euphemism or meaningless
‘Trump news at a glance’
@Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/mar/09/trump-news-at-a-glance
Trans doctor leaving NHS is a ‘shame’, says Sandie Peggie
@thetimes https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/trans-doctor-leaving-nhs-is-a-shame-says-sandie-peggie-6jq5w93bm
‘Wes Streeting urged to ban trans hormones for under-18s in private clinics’
@Telegraph
Shout if you need a share to be able to read if https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/03/09/streeting-urged-ban-trans-hormones-under-18s-private-clinic/
'Gavin Newsom says he supports trans equality in everything but sports. He claimed there have been multiple instances of cis athletes being “displaced” by trans competitors'
Either this outlet hates X or it assumes no one who reads it is on X
https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2026/03/gavin-newsom-says-he-supports-trans-equality-in-everything-but-sports/
'My rights as a trans person are linked directly to the rights of refugees who are facing horrific prejudice and violence, and to people in Palestine who continue to live through genocide'
More similar within from the Metro in this ad for Trans Mission.
https://archive.ph/ZboPV
The BBC writes up the Hannah Spencer story. From this it's not at all clear what happened. But its use of the wording 'anti-trans activists clashed with women's rights campaigners', means that sadly we can't trust it.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/crrx80g2xjzo
‘Election nightmare for John Swinney as Joanna Cherry vows to lift the lid on trans scandal days before polls open’
@[private account] is truly unstoppable on these stories. It wouldn’t chase all this content and these scoops if they weren’t madly popular. https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-news/election-nightmare-john-swinney-joanna-36838766
‘NHS bans cross-sex hormone drugs for trans under-18s’
Fab from Michael Searles and he gets it right - ‘people who believe they are trans’ - while the sub goes for ‘trans teens’ in the headline. It’s wrong. Everyone should drop the phrase ‘trans kids’. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/03/09/nhs-cross-sex-hormone-drugs-ban-under-18s/
What an extremely misleading take. Firstly - not anti-trans of course. Activist language on stilts. Secondly, even if you don’t know the background or the faces involved, you can clearly see a man trying to ask her questions and Spencer’s defenders trying to stop him.
Quoting @PolitlcsUK: 🚨 WATCH: Green MP Hannah Spencer is forced into a police car after anti-trans protesters fight in front of her in Manchester
The head of the new Fair Work Agency, which will run employment law enforcement, has a history of outspoken trans allyship, @GuidoFawkes reports.
Lisa Pinney was a Stonewall board member for six years, founded a http://gov.uk LGBT Network and accused media columnists of ‘attacking trans people and their fundamental rights’.
https://order-order.com/2026/03/06/revealed-new-employment-rights-bill-enforcers-woke-credentials/
Brilliant exclusive from @nickwallis but the @dailymail
‘The NHS is set to stop giving powerful cross-sex hormones to trans-identifying children under-18, the Mail on Sunday can reveal’
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15625107/NHS-stop-prescribing-puberty-blockers-trans-identifying-children.html
Starmer ‘in wrong place on trans rights’
- paywall free version of story from Friday. Emily Thornberry is the complainant.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/188fb73c39616cca
This is interesting for a presenter to note - but not to object to.
Gareth Barlow on losing the T from LGB - not an impartial observer. He seems cross that a story about gay people doesn’t include trans people.
‘CrossFit Quietly Eases Some Rules on Trans Athletes After Backlash’
TLDR there’s now an Open category in which you can register as your ‘trans’ identity https://www.mambaonline.com/2026/03/07/crossfit-quietly-eases-some-rules-on-trans-athletes-after-backlash/
‘Trans advice book back on Warwickshire library shelves following safeguarding investigation’
‘Two copies of When Kids Say They’re Trans: A Guide For Thoughtful Parents by Stella O’Malley had been removed after a complaint from a trans activist’ https://archive.ph/2026.03.07-073256/https://www.stratford-herald.com/news/trans-advice-book-back-on-library-shelves-after-council-inve-9456386/
‘SNP blasted for handing £3.1m to 'gender extremists' ahead of International Women's Day’
‘Exclusive: The Scottish Government has been slated for handing out millions to Stonewall and Scottish Trans despite their insistence than trans women are men’
https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/snp-blasted-handing-31m-gender-36829765
‘I stood up to the pro-trans fanatics who tried to silence me’
By @_ConnieShaw in @Telegraph
Gift🎁link
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/57c11ce146a5b7c4
‘Trump gets pushback for saying trans surgery for kids can happen with parental consent’
https://thenationaldesk.com/news/americas-news-now/trump-gets-pushback-for-saying-trans-surgery-for-kids-can-happen-with-parental-consent-marjorie-taylor-greene-matt-walsh-mail-in-ballots
‘A USA rugby program has eliminated its women's teams and launched a new one under the 'open' gender division to accommodate trans athletes’
A direct result of moving to Male, Female and Open instead of simply Female and Open?
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/othersports/article-15616919/usa-rugby-women-teams-open-division-trans.html
‘How to vote as a trans person in the local elections’
Breaking News: ‘These people are less likely to have usable photographic ID’😶
This will actually be helpful for anyone who has a different name on their ID to the electoral register https://www.thepinknews.com/2026/03/03/may-2026-local-elections-trans-non-binary-id-voting/
Unfortunately this won’t archive so you’ll have to give it clicks if you want to see it
https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/why-an-olympic-trans-ban-would-solve-nothing_uk_69aa0090e4b066e4081e401d
‘The International Olympic Committee is preparing to dramatically restrict trans athletes from participating in the future Games’
Luckily this isn’t true and there’s no plan for a trans ban. However a man is given a 5’48 VT by @HuffPost to claim otherwise
This is inaccurate
‘designed to guarantee fair competition by excluding trans and DSD competitors’
It’s designed to exclude males. A gene test can’t identify ‘trans’. It reveals male and female. If a female athlete is trans, she’s allowed in the women’s category.
‘Green Party faces gender-critical group lawsuit over trans ‘witch-hunt’
‘Green Women’s Declaration claims discrimination after Zack Polanski’s party banned its stall at last year’s conference’
@thetimes https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/green-party-group-sues-gender-trans-zzsxrzr3z
Same here tho the @Telegraph avoids pronouns. Both papers report on the offences so both are deliberately calling a child sex offender a woman
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/03/03/trans-woman-groped-male-hotel-worker-gender-identity/
‘Shende..had a previous conviction for making, possessing and distributing indecent images of children’
And @DailyMail still calls him a woman. Where is the professional self-respect.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15609129/Transgender-woman-groped-male-hotel-worker-spared-jail-prison.html
Here’s a second piece featuring trans rights activist Patsy Stevenson
It’s very good otherwise but she is emphatically not the voice of women
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c178x2yzkglo
It’s a big fail not to get comment from @WomensRightsNet or @[private account]. They both have a much clearer understanding of police misogyny, but they’re silo’d off into ‘trans’ and ‘non-compliant’. Only approved view charities get the call. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cdr2exyvyxpo
Gift 🎁 article
‘My daughter’s all-girls school accepted a trans pupil – and refused to admit it’
‘After years of being kept in the dark about this biological male, I was gaslit by the head teacher about my safeguarding concerns’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/d5373dd17b58e38c
GB News on @[private account] BBC legal action
‘They argue that linking gender questioning to suicide risk..risks sending a devastating message to distressed teenagers..it could reinforce feelings of hopelessness and raise the risk of copycat behaviour’ https://www.gbnews.com/news/bbc-legal-dangerous-transgender
‘The Students’ Union collaborates with Trans Harm Reduction to ensure safe supplies for people on DIY gender-affirming hormone therapy’
https://universitytimes.ie/2024/12/tcdsu-to-provide-free-injecting-supplies-for-transgender-students/
More on the story that broke at the weekend
@[private account]
‘Fury over trans activists' holding sex hormone injection lessons for young people’
This trans group teams up with student unions to ‘distribute supplies’ https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/fury-over-trans-activists-holding-36796656
This man, Emma Smith, should be recused from reporting on women’s sport and trans access.
‘Jess Fishlock: Welsh football great 'honoured' to be EuroGames ambassador’
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/c6200gylppzo
‘Anger over trans activists telling young people how to self-medicate’
@[private account] https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/anger-over-trans-activists-telling-36796656
We’ve reposted that earlier - he is very clear on the harms and she asks about hurting trans people who think their very identity is being questioned. It’s poor.
‘The group had urged Ofcom to examine what it described as the corporation’s ‘failure to uphold their duty of impartiality and safeguarding’ as a result of the BBC’s ‘constant drip-feed of one-sided stories...celebrating the trans experience’’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/02/28/parents-court-battle-to-protect-children-bbc-pro-trans-bias/
‘The @[private account] Group, which represents more than 800 parents of primary school children and teenagers who believe they are trans, has told Ofcom it will go to the High Court unless it reverses its decision not to investigate their complaints about BBC coverage’
‘Hundreds of parents are set to go to court over the BBC’s ‘constant drip-feed of one-sided pro-trans programmes’. They’ve warned they will seek a judicial review to force Ofcom to investigate what they claim is the BBC’s pro-trans bias damaging their children’s health’
Here's a link for the Palmer comments, made at a Transgender Equality conference from which he had his entire contribution redacted. Investigation into Palmer's role would be useful @cathynewman @[private account], not just with re: this current issue about public comments, but generally. It's an ideal subject for a Health Editor to drill down into.
https://archive.ph/NVIN2
‘This is the reason Labour refuses to protect women – it's disgraceful’
In @[private account] from @[private account] on the failure to implement the Supreme Court ruling https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/2175632/NHS-biological-sex-gender-trans-women-s-rights-gender-reality
‘Transgender Americans look abroad for safety’
The urge of affirmative journalists publicly to service their beliefs at all costs deserves an investigation all of its own.
This is ‘we are truth-seekers’ CNN.
https://www.cnn.com/2026/02/27/world/video/ruby-mae-johnson-kansas-transgender-id-netherlands-vrtc
In @WSJopinion @WSJ
‘The mantra offered to parents is no longer ‘would you rather have a dead daughter or a living son?’ It is ‘would you rather lose custody of your child, or ‘transition’ her?’
https://www.wsj.com/opinion/states-rip-families-apart-to-serve-transgender-ideology-4875664e
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedideology cultstate takes children
Strange and inaccurate coverage from @Telegraph
‘Hegseth tells Scouts: Ban trans children or lose military support’
There’s no demand to ban trans children, only to register them under sex not ‘gender’. This hyperbolic inaccuracy serves to increase distress and victimhood among families, and offer activists a handle for anger and complaint.
The story is a good one but there’s no point in making it out to be something it isn’t.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/us/news/2026/02/27/hegseth-bans-trans-children-scouts/
‘Trans row: Trauma survivor threatens legal action after magazine pulls work over 'views'’
@GBNEWS https://www.gbnews.com/news/trans-row-trauma-legal-action
On the day of the Cass Review, anecdotal attempts were made by news outlets to put front and foremost ‘happy’ medical transitioners. Counter-intuitively for a report of this nature, instead of interviewing young people harmed by medical protocols, a parade of trans-identified mainly men was rolled out hour by hour to explain how life-saving it had been to undergo hormonal interventions. It was a failure of journalism. It demonstrated however the visceral understanding among affirmative editors that ‘success’ stories were needed to prop up a failing narrative. Nearly two years later the data is being forced out by a very small number of campaigners and journalists who remained focussed on detail rather than narrative. Legacy outlets PR’d ‘successful transition’ and could have, should have, demanded the detail back then.
Quotes a post by T04981; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Side note: Channel 4 News, where Newman presents, showed zero interest in a specialist briefing at the House of Lords on the Pathways research. They neither responded nor attended.
The editor of Channel 4 News, Louisa Compton, was not always this uninterested. From 2015 on onwards she commissioned and edited Victoria Derbyshire’s ‘Transgender Children’ films and content, which were followed by leaps in referrals to gender identity clinics.
Lovely profile of Deta here at 06:23, with a particular focus on her work encouraging girls to take up darts.
Just one issue. Deta didn’t forfeit matches over ‘trans opponents’. It’s because they were men - why so afraid to say so, BBC? Great VT tho
https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m002rvkk/breakfast-27022026
Quotes a post by T17315; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Women’s Institute has come up with a new Diversity and Inclusion policy. All this on trans, and two lines on sex.
https://www.thewi.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0009/719730/NFWI-Equality-Diversity-and-Inclusion-Policy-April-2026.pdf
Probably delusional to attribute this to ‘trans people’
Quoting @TheCanaryUK: 🚨BREAKING: The Green Party has WON the Gorton and Denton by-election!
Contrary to mainstream media wisdom, standing up UNAPOLOGETICALLY for workers, trans people, Palestine and the planet CAN win elections.
So long as editors can cling to the idea that there really are some people with 'wrong body syndrome', it will salve their personal and professional consciences.
If 'true trans' exists, then how could they, mere journalists, possibly have known which 'trans' children and adults people are real or not? How could they have questioned the authority of experts like Emily Simonoff, Hilary Cass and the entire NHS establishment with its decade and a half of 'gender identity' normalisation?
The 'impartial' position for them is: 'true trans' exists but not every one who says they're trans is trans.
This is why they adopt a framing which treats the belief that some people are born in the wrong body as if it were a fact. That's why they think the truth - that no one is ever, has ever been, or ever will be 'born in the wrong body' is an expression of extremism.
And that's what happened on the Laura Kuenssberg show. And that's what needs to be somehow dismantled.
These journalists have neglected the story, and because children have been and are being harmed, it's professionally very awkward, particularly as they think of themselves as tremendously brave 'truth to power' types.
Their exit route is 'true trans'.
/
So much bias comes not with words, pics or choice of guest but simply framing. This is what happened last Sunday,and unfortunately it is quite hard to describe to a journalist, who swims in 'true trans' affirmation, exactly why their entire mindset needs to change.
/
We wrote to the Laura Kuenssberg show editor after the Hilary Cass interview, which was built on the assumption that some children are 'true trans' and need irreversibly medicating. Because of the pause to the puberty blocker trial, we've published it here
https://seeninjournalism.substack.com/p/our-letter-to-the-laura-kuenssberg
Here's our latest weekly overview of media coverage - some stories are still developing so there may be updates over the weekend.
'Puberty blocker trial paused, extreme censorship and a trans man murders his son and ex-wife'
https://seeninjournalism.substack.com/p/puberty-blocker-trial-paused-extreme
'NHS spent £600k in taxpayer cash fighting Darlington nurses in trans row'
‘Appalling’ figure, says one claimant, as trust confirms it won’t appeal tribunal decision'
Gift token for @Telegraph
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/bf213a696953fb5a
'A charity says it will seek to appeal against a High Court ruling throwing out a proposed legal challenge over rules allowing trans people to use single-sex facilities at Hampstead ponds'
'to use opposite sex facilities' - it's that easy to be accurate
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cddn22lv609o
‘Justice Department opens investigations into three Michigan school districts to determine whether they’re teaching lessons that include sexual orientation and gender identity-related content, and whether parents were told they could opt children out’ https://thepostmillennial.com/doj-investigates-michigan-schools-over-trans-indoctrination
‘Is Gender Medicine Diminishing Trust in Doctors?’
@LeorSapir on the latest evidence of collapsed support for ‘gender identity’ based protocols. Very interesting too on how public opinion has been shaped by a basic media failure to inform. It still is a powerful weapon, as it becomes increasingly clear that once people are supplied with the relevant information, they’re against medicalising minors who are claimed to be the opposite sex.
https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-medicine-doctors-hormones-surgeries
It’s exactly why there’s such opposition to accurate and impartial reporting. Journalists who’ve exposed this scandal know that there’s no need to hide the truth or engage in media messaging, like TQ+ affirmative reporters. Activists know that if you tell people the basic truth, it turns out they don’t like what’s going on.
This is what makes media compliance even more excruciating. Editors agreed not to tell their audiences about lifelong pain inflicted on children just because they’d have to deal with a lot of complaints, and their friends with ‘trans’ kids in the family would be upset. They also agreed (most still do agree) not to tell people that ‘trans women’ are men, because of complaints alone. Women just aren’t worth the paperwork.
It’s not in the past. Laura Kuenssberg was told last Sunday on the BBC that medical interventions are ‘brutal’, and she skated past it. Not even a ‘what do you mean?’ After 15 years of trans ‘lived experience’, we’ve yet to see in UK legacy media the personal journey of a castrated gay man who regrets what was done to him, or a woman who can’t have sex ever again because of a paper thin vagina, for example.
So much of the work is still being done by independent (or even citizen) journalists. The extent to which trans identity activism is now a liability, reported by Leor here from The Argument Substack, is untouchable by legacy broadcasters. The BBC’s Washington bureau would recoil in horror at such a pitch.
Deep down all compliant journalists know that such polling shines a light on a media narrative of happy and necessary child transition falling apart. They all dreamed at 18 of exposing scandals, speaking truth to power, going down in history as outstandingly brave reporters. It must make their stomachs fall to find they were on the wrong side of that, they missed the story, and blew their chance.
However, the story is still there - the global market for medical ‘gender affirmation’ is still forecast to grow vastly, for all that US public opinion shows. There’s still time to pick it up, and no need to dress it. Look at the casualness 👇with which the appropriately named Mordor describes celebrity transitions on TikTok motivating Gen Z to get ‘a broader spectrum of procedures’. These aren’t good people. The tide has turned in a corner of public opinion, but the scandal is still wildly out of control.
https://www.mordorintelligence.com/industry-reports/sex-reassignment-surgery-market
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-shropshire-47360102
New from @[private account] in @heraldscotland
'Human rights watchdog urged to challenge prisons trans policy after court admission'
Based on an a plea from @[private account] which has laid out flaws in Scotgov's policy with re: women's rights.
Not sure how new this language convention is from the Herald - but it's not bothering to avoid accurate language for Isla Bryson any more. He-him, as it should be.
The only person who can complain to Ipso about this (and have their complaint progress beyond triage) is Isla Bryson or his representative. Other outlets comply with activist pronouns, or avoid accurate language, not because of fear of the regulator, or the law, but because they choose to.
https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/25833895.pressure-mounts-watchdog-trans-prisoners-policy/?ref=twtrec
📣
‘A trans rapist has been convicted of horrific sex attacks on schoolgirls sparking new fears over SNP prison policy’
‘David [Serenity] Johnston was found guilty of five offences'
'The Scottish Government is saying some trans women are women, but others are not depending on their crimes. But you can’t have it both ways. Either they are or they are not' @[private account] is on the nail in @[private account]
One of the big activist mantras has always been 'who are you to decide who I am?' - yet it's not just Scotgov but journalists who've taken on the role of deciding who deserves to be affirmed and who doesn't. That's exactly what 'no for a rapist, yes for a florist' ends up as.
Is every decision to be referred up to the highest levels (what other story gets this treatment?) - Or is a frontline reporter or sub having to decide whether a man is well-behaved enough to be described as a woman. What if he's a thief? What if he punched a man in a pub? Is there to be a sliding scale?
This is why clear guidance is needed across outlets - either accurate pronouns, or no pronouns and just make clear what sex they are. No inaccurate language, ever.
The Record seems currently to be at 'no for a rapist, yes for a murderer', see its Sophie Eastwood coverage. But it avoids inaccurate language here, just as it's been doing for a couple of years with Isla Bryson. It even called Mridul Wadhwa a 'trans-identifying man', which we think should be standard form. Click and share, it's good coverage. Story’s also in the Mail.
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/trans-rapist-convicted-sex-attacks-36686456
'Trans people are most readily accepted when framed as victims, and most resisted when they present as agents with desire and confidence'
Bit rich to complain when the 'trans community' has been on a (successful) 15 year media mission to present itself as a universal victim.
'Exclusive: In a letter coordinated by the Trans+ Solidarity Alliance and sent to hundreds of MPs, seen by The Independent'
Exclusive in the sense that no one else would have run the story?
'Protect inclusive spaces from gender-critical legal battles, Starmer told after Hampstead ladies pond row'
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/trans-rights-supreme-court-starmer-hampstead-ladies-ponds-b2914769.html
'He will compete in the women's moguls and women's dual moguls this week'
It just feels like we're on for another round of Olympic level gaslighting.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/winterolympics/article-15537773/elis-lundholm-transgender-winter-olympics-sweden.html
'Protecting the female category is one of the key reforms she wants to bring in'
IOC spokesman Mark Adams at a news conference at the Winter Games. It's from @Reuters in @[private account] so there's nonsense like 'assigned at birth' and 'under current rules transgender athletes are eligible to take part' - implying, mendaciously, that a ban is being considered. 'World Rugby bans all transgender athletes from elite-level competitions' - no it doesn't @[private account]. 'Trump has said he would not allow transgender athletes to compete at the LA Games' - no he hasn't. All of this is untrue and 'assigned at birth' is activism, not journalism.
Reporters at the 2024 Games were very challenging about the female category, but now Adams is getting away with a lot.
'The new policy is expected to be announced within the first half of this year'
That gives until June, but journalists had been given to understand it would come earlier than that, just before or after the winter games. What's the delay? Why the delay?
'Don't hold me to it' - why not? Sex testing is very straightforward.
Here's the Reu copy that most outlets will base their coverage on and is picked up almost word for word by Al Jaz.
https://www.reuters.com/sports/sports-leaders-reach-consensus-new-gender-policy-ioc-2026-02-07/
📣
‘Transgenderism is premised on a lie, and in the long run the truth has a stubborn tendency to prevail’
@Newsweek opinion
Thoughtful and evidenced. Sad rather than tub-thumping. https://www.newsweek.com/is-this-the-end-of-transgender-hysteria-11474700
This is a head-scratcher from India, which has become enormously affirmative
Some ‘trans’ pilgrims were denied access to a site where menstruating women are banned
Are they men or women? ‘Trans’ in the Indian press almost always means male but who knows https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/transgender-devotees-allege-harassment-at-pampa/article70495024.ece
‘Trans activist unmasked by judge as being linked to militant trans group Bash Back’
Exclusive from @DailyMail on the hacking and doxxing of Free Speech Union donors
‘Autumn Redpath, 22, was named as a respondent to an injunction’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15452267/Judge-unmasks-trans-zealots-links-shady-group-free-speech-campaigners.html
This doesn’t use man, boy or male at all, except once when unavoidably quoting. It puts ‘biological sex’ and ‘the basis of sex’ in inverted commas, and yet still gives a very strong sense of expecting to lose.
‘US Supreme Court’s next trans rights move’ https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/us-supreme-court-transgender-rights-b2898009.html
Castration as entertainment
Sample: ‘Wildly complex on a formal and semiotic level’
‘New Cinematic Language for Trans Life’
@[private account] https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/a-new-cinematic-language-for-trans-life
Jayney Sutherley says she missed out on several chances for parole because of a ‘hate crime’ charge of ‘misgendering’ and singing ‘Man I feel like a woman’.
That case was found not proven last year. It was covered by @[private account]
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/15785780/jk-rowling-backs-killer-hairdresser-trans-hate-crime/
/
Superb from @LGBCourage and Leanne Owen @[private account]
‘The disparity matters. It raises a more basic question than whether either side is right or wrong: why do allegations framed as anti-trans command immediate institutional attention, while other serious critiques do not?’
/
Here - the entire 90 secs spent by the BBC asking John Swinney about - yes - ‘trans rights’: not women’s rights, or refusing to implement the law, or funding groups that campaign against the law, or women being incarcerated with male criminals. It’s all Scottish women are worth.
We really want the clarity that they’re no kind of woman at all. ‘Trans woman’ is an activist term. It was lobbied for, hard. Continuing to use it is not impartial.
This clarity is currently only consistently available on X. If X is banned in the UK, it will disappear.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: ‘Labour hold up plan to ban transgender women from single sex spaces over costs’
‘The NHS and businesses are still allowing trans women who are biologically male to use single-sex spaces’
By @[private account] in @TheSun
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/37868314/labour-hold-up-ban-transgender-women/
‘Labour hold up plan to ban transgender women from single sex spaces over costs’
‘The NHS and businesses are still allowing trans women who are biologically male to use single-sex spaces’
By @[private account] in @TheSun
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/37868314/labour-hold-up-ban-transgender-women/
‘There are a lot of children who are suffering more distress than they need to, more families that are getting torn apart and more headaches for schools because of the delay’
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/education/article/labour-delay-trans-guidance-schools-health-jfrlpsf08
‘Our audience is well aware of what biological sex is. There is no need to put it in quotation marks as if it’s an alien dialect or an obscure technicality’
@CBSNews
@bariweiss
@nypost
‘CBS staff clashed over trans language’ https://nypost.com/2026/01/06/media/cbs-news-staff-clashed-over-transgender-language-in-internal-email-blow-up/
From the @[private account] piece in @thehill
‘Female prisoner 'hurled in locked cell' at Massachusetts prison after complaining that she had been raped by one of at least three trans sex predators housed there’
@DailyMail https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15445631/female-prisoner-raped-transgender-criminal-mci-framingham-massachusetts.html
SNP ministers are still utterly confused by the concept of binary sex, judging by their latest submission in defence of placing male sex offenders in female prisons. https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/transgender-criminals-scottish-prisons-sexless-nqnm6vq65
Agree. And journalists can and should say that when the question is evaded. With more time, Greer could have been asked to stand up for his beliefs.
The thing is these advocates say so many wrong things in an interview it’s hard to challenge them all in four minutes or less. For example, he could have been challenged very cogently on why he’s not being consistent. The question about Bryson then should be applied to the existing trans/male inmate problem. Greer would have said that EHRC guidance was still needed, and that would then have to be fact-checked. Then there was the ‘it’s not a problem in Ireland’ claim that needed fact-checking.
The Ireland claim was made solely to change the subject.
So much that’s untrue slides by, simply because of the volume of mendacity. A longer interview would have meant more misleading claims having to be challenged.
The best solutions are a really good brief and a really well informed presenter. Nick who is pretty well-informed on it genuinely ran out of time, but even if he’d had 15 minutes he still would have run out of time because he’d have to address ten extra minutes of misleading advocacy.
‘The transgender athlete cases: an explainer’
Like this blog post, though one thing it doesn’t explain is that the athletes are men/boys/male, describing them as girls/women throughout. The trans adj. makes no difference.
It explains Bostock-Clayton County very well. This is so often misrepresented - not least by the BBC. Bostock ruled on the primacy of sex, not gender identity, which it doesn’t mention at all.
Also this Scotus blog (by @[private account]) highlights this background:
‘Idaho also insists that its law does not discriminate against athletes because they are transgender. It notes that “[n]one of the Act’s operative provisions classify based on whether someone identifies as transgender.” Instead, it stresses, the law draws distinctions “based on ‘biological sex’ alone’
We very much want to see an end to claims of ‘a ban on trans athletes’ - or for example Trump’s initial executive order being described as an ‘EO on trans rights’
These things aren’t true: don’t insert the words ‘trans’ and ‘gender identity’ in your copy when it simply isn’t there in legislation, rulings or legal submissions etc.
So, very useful blog. Apart from the affirmative language at the top.
https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/01/the-transgender-athlete-cases-an-explainer/
‘An insulting non-response to a reasonable pertinent question..he may pretend it isn’t a question worth answering, but his pretence can only fool those determined not to pay attention’
‘Swinney buries any hope of an answer on trans prisoners’
@[private account] https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/john-swinney-trans-supreme-court-ruling-snp-fwbb07hz2
‘A pregnant trans guy - this isn't a topic that's talked about’
On the contrary, it’s just about the only reason trans-identified females make outlets, while positive news about trans-identified men is on awards and podium spots
Sexism is as sexism does https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15446669/Transgender-man-pregnant-baby-adoption-Jax-Squire.html
‘Now 'shameful' Swinney challenges gender ruling to protect trans inmates’
By @[private account] in @DailyMail https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15446967/Now-shameful-Swinney-challenges-gender-ruling-protect-trans-inmates.html
The narrative on numbers of trans people changes when it suits activists.
Worried about men in female sports? The narrative says the number is tiny.
Worried about men in female toilets? The narrative says there are so many it’s extremely common and we’ve been sharing toilets with men for years and didn’t notice.
Try percentages
1 per cent of the population being trans is so significant that all policies need to be shaped around their needs
But 1 per cent of the trans population detransitioning is so insignificant they can be ignored
(It’s more than 1 per cent but the numbers aren’t known)
And every time the average news outlet buys these figures unquestioned from activists
Bizarre efforts to avoid implementing the law
@[private account] in @[private account]
‘Ministers claim inmates would be left in an intermediate zone of neither one sex nor the other if there were to be strict ‘segregation’ by biological sex’ https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/transgender-criminals-scottish-prisons-sexless-nqnm6vq65
Dispassionate and full of detail
‘Can employers allow trans employees to use opposite sex changing rooms?’
From the lawyers @[private account] https://www.irwinmitchell.com/news-and-insights/expert-comment/post/102lz5j/can-employers-allow-trans-employees-to-use-opposite-sex-changing-rooms
‘Emergency High Court injunction bans publication of donors’ details after Free Speech Union hacked by trans activists’
@Telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/01/08/free-speech-union-hacked-by-trans-activists/
Colleagues with personal experience of surrogacy have the same inhibiting impact on coverage as colleagues having a personal ‘trans’ relationship.
Are you really going to write or approve an excoriating expose after your entire team just congratulated a fellow correspondent on his adorable acquisition? Doubtful. Not even sure that individual recusal can solve this problem.
Quotes a post by T09030; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The admissions about trans advocate tactics in Scotland were made in 2018 at a Trans Equality conference by Bex Stinson of Stonewall.
Also with prominent speaker or chair roles at the event: Steph Calvert and Megan Key, border control and probation respectively.
/
The cuts were made to adult social care and children's services.
Recommendations now include: a PR campaign for Trans Visibility Day, gyms specifically for trans-identified people, more training for staff, and ‘encouraging gender-inclusive facilities’.
https://blackpool.thelead.uk/p/blackpool-urged-to-step-up-efforts-trans-gender-diverse-people
Blackpool Council cut £8.6m from services a year ago. But there was still money for its public health consultant to build a 76-page report on ‘better understanding the health needs of trans men, trans women, non-binary people and those who define their gender in another way’
/
‘The Italian seaside town that's home to 150 trans women’
It’s still only .8% - supposedly the average figure. https://theface.com/society/torvajanica-italian-town-trans-women-community-father-andrea-conocchia
Out of all the subverted language, using ‘daughter’ for ‘son’ is one which abrades the most. It seems particularly mendacious and needless.
‘Rihanna enlists Elon Musk's trans daughter Vivian, 21, for lingerie brand's Valentine's Day campaign’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-15444277/Rihanna-Elon-Musk-trans-daughter-Vivian-Valentines-Day-campaign.html
‘Minister blames slow watchdog for trans guidance delay’
Pretty good until the end where it doesn’t make it clear that ‘the law is the law’
Phillipson was allowed to make this claim without any real challenge on Politics Live except from other guests. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cr4k61dqnzlo
This is what we mean when we say @[private account] had more cohones that bigger more powerful outlets - it straight up used male pronouns - Daily Mail avoids female but doesn’t go further
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15442761/Bearded-trans-woman-court-accused-plot-firebomb-legal-firm.html
‘Ministers have privately requested that Scotland’s top civil court issues a “declaration of incompatibility” which would severely undermine it, if its other legal arguments fail’
Trans lobbying prioritised prisons ten-odd years ago very deliberately - it’s happening again.
‘SNP ministers are seeking a legal ruling declaring that implementing the Supreme Court’s landmark ruling on sex would unlawfully trample on the human rights of transgender criminals’
Cracking story from @[private account] in @thetimes @[private account]
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/snp-supreme-court-sex-ruling-trans-prisoners-0cphdmqjp
Ever wondered how @newscientist covers the complexity of the trans debate? Brilliant exclusives with leading academics and deep-dive investigations, right? If anyone has the expertise and contacts, it's @newscientist, right? Right? They'd never just.. bury it? Let's find out...
‘The intention was unmistakable: to intimidate and punish private citizens after the Free Speech Union founder, Lord Young, commissioned a security report into the threat posed by Trans Bash Back’
🎁 share
Important read from @jo_bartosch in @Telegraph
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/ee8a4a324ead6fa0
‘On Trans Day of Remembrance the trans flag will be given priority over the saltire..the Progress flag will fly on Feb 1 for LGBT History Month; May 17 for the International Day Against Homophobia, Biphobia and Transphobia; and for Edinburgh and Glasgow Pride events’
@thetimes
‘The US DoJ suffers another setback in efforts to subpoena providers of gender-affirming care for trans youth in order to obtain patient information and details about their treatments’
Good example of linguistic capture, including avoidance of ‘children’ https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/judge-rejects-dojs-subpoena-childrens-hospital-colorado-over-transgender-care-2026-01-06/
‘Quinn apologises after trans edit from Heated Rivalry interview’
This is so interesting
‘There are straight women, there are trans women, there are gay women, like queer women’
Bill for editing out ‘there are trans women’: $25K https://www.attitude.co.uk/culture/film-tv/quinn-apologises-trans-heated-rivalry-connor-storrie-hudson-williams-508066/
‘A famous trans chef has been charged with domestic violence after she allegedly attacked her girlfriend while drunk’
Please @DailyMail we are begging you, the man’s accused of throttling a woman, drop the ridiculous compliance https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15438581/portland-transgender-chef-domestic-violence-attack-girlfriend.html
‘Data from hundreds of public bodies shows only four complaints about trans women in women’s single-sex spaces over three years’
Lack of complaints signals all sorts of things, including fear of complaining. One thing it doesn’t signal is consent. https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2026/01/almost-no-one-is-complaining-about-trans-women-in-womens-spaces-study-finds/
‘Internet feasts on Trump’s impression of transgender weightlifter’
@Independent
‘I want to be very liberal, I want to get that vote, it’s not an easy vote to get’
Clips of Trump in here, it’s not the only time he’s done it https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/trump-transgender-weightlifter-impression-speech-b2895688.html
‘UCL shares new insights on trans and nonbinary sexual health at IUSTI Europe Congress’
Tom Witney, UCL speaker here, has previously highlighted the lack of ‘signs of inclusivity’ such as trans flags in hospitals as a barrier to accessing health care. https://www.ucl.ac.uk/population-health-sciences/news/ucl-shares-new-insights-trans-and-nonbinary-sexual-health-iusti-europe-congress
‘Much less attention is paid to the concrete reality of the existence of trans people and the intimate experience it represents’
We beg to disagree
‘Lived experience’ and ‘personal journey’ have been the primary tools of media affirmation for a decade. https://voxeurop.eu/en/trans-identity-story-empowerment-europe/
/has had ripples - well done Jan Crawford and thanks @guardian for telling us what she did. Change can be slow but starts with conversation.
Loosening activists’ grip on language is foundational, because language like ‘trans kids’ and ‘affirming care’ is foundationally harmful.
/has been measured and serious. (Here’s @_CryMiaRiver writing for Fox last autumn). Fox is really alone among US broadcasters in doing the legwork around neutralising language, which can be painstaking.
So exposing the little exchange at CBS
/
https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/manufactured-tragedy-transgender-kids-how-society-lost-its-grip-reality
/preferred pronouns, trans children etc) and default to affirmative talking points (suicide, hate, marginalised, tiny numbers etc)
Activists worked very hard for a long time to get to a stage where accuracy is considered by news outlets to be at best, beyond the pale, and at
/