Evidence

Progress and resilience

Verified evidence of progress: court rulings, laws, public support and community strength, each with its source.

Progress and resilience

This page collects verified evidence of support for trans people: public opinion on protections, court decisions in both directions, accountability for harassment and false claims, what research shows reduces prejudice, and what supports community resilience. It also lists crisis and support lines. Where a fact comes from Wikipedia, that is stated; it is a secondary source, and the underlying judgment should be checked before it is quoted.

Key to the labels: [source read in full] the page or paper text was opened and read; [abstract or summary read] only an abstract, a summary or part of the source was read; [reported by a secondary source] the claim comes from a source that reports on the original, such as Wikipedia; [could not be opened] the source could not be opened, so the claim is not independently confirmed.

The court losses and the movement in opinion polling listed here are the result of the child-protection, sports and "mutilation" messaging campaigns, which are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. Polling shows timing, not proof of cause. Nothing below shows that these framings are sincere.

1. Opinion data: support for protections

  • 72% of Americans support nondiscrimination protections for LGBTQ people (2025); support was 71% in 2015, peaked at 80% in 2022, then declined to 72%. Support ranges by state from 53% (Arkansas) to 85% (Massachusetts). PRRI, "Mapping Support for LGBTQ Rights Across the 50 States: Insights from PRRI's 2025 American Values Atlas", 2026-03-19; 22,111 adults, online, 2025-02-28 to 2025-12-08. The 2015 and 2022 figures are as reported in PRRI's 2026 report. [source read in full]
  • 71% agree that "transgender people deserve the same rights and protections as other Americans"; 24% disagree. Same PRRI report. The wording is as reported in a summary of the report, so the exact item text may differ. [source read in full]
  • 56% favor protecting trans people from discrimination in jobs, housing and public spaces, which is down 8 points from 2022. A majority still supports protections, but support fell. Pew Research Center, "Americans have grown more supportive of restrictions for trans people in recent years", 2025-02-26; survey 2025-02-10 to 2025-02-17, 5,097 adults. [source read in full]
  • 22% favor and 53% oppose requiring health insurers to cover gender transition care (down 5 points since 2022). Coverage is not backed by a majority. Same Pew report. [source read in full]
  • Gallup: 34% say trans athletes should play on teams matching their gender identity; 69% say birth sex. Support for sports restrictions is high, and Gallup's moral-acceptability item (40% acceptable, 54% wrong) fell 6 points from 2021. Gallup, "Two-Thirds in U.S. Prefer Birth Sex on IDs, in Athletics", 2025-06-10; phone survey 2025-05-01 to 05-18, 1,003 adults, plus or minus 4. [source read in full]
  • Gallup 2026: 38% say changing one's gender is morally acceptable, 57% wrong (2021: 46% and 51%); 65% favor same-sex marriage, down from a peak of 71%. This shows the same downward trend. Gallup, "U.S. Support for LGBTQ+ Issues Remains Down From Peak", 2026-06-03; phone survey 2026-05-01 to 05-17, 1,001 adults, plus or minus 4. [source read in full]

Reading these together: majorities back general nondiscrimination protections (PRRI 72%, Pew 56%; the two surveys ask different questions), while support for protections has fallen since 2022 and support for restrictions on sports and youth care has risen (Pew 2025: 66% sports, 56% banning youth care, up 8 and 10 points). Pew gives partisan splits: 79% of Republicans and Republican leaners favor banning care for minors (72% in 2022), 35% of Democrats and leaners (26% in 2022). These data are consistent with a messaging effect, but they do not by themselves show one.

2. Courts, in both directions

For trans people or protections

  • Bostock v. Clayton County, 590 U.S. 644 (decided 2020-06-15, 6-3, Gorsuch, J.). Syllabus: "An employer who fires an individual merely for being gay or transgender violates Title VII." Source: Cornell LII. [source read in full] Skrmetti (below) says: "We have not yet considered whether Bostock's reasoning reaches beyond the Title VII context".
  • Tickle v Giggle for Girls (Australia). Per Wikipedia (the judgments were not opened): Federal Court, 2024-08-23, found indirect discrimination under the Sex Discrimination Act and awarded A$10,000; Full Federal Court, 2026-05-15 ([2026] FCAFC 64) dismissed the app owner's appeal, held there were two acts of direct discrimination, held the special-measures exemption did not permit gender-identity discrimination, and raised damages to A$20,000; the High Court refused special leave to appeal on 2026-09-10 ([2026] HCADisp 209). [reported by a secondary source]
  • Florida SB 254 (adults' consent and prescriber rules). Per Wikipedia (the opinion was not opened): a federal judge (Hinkle) permanently blocked the law on 2024-06-11; the 11th Circuit stayed that ruling in August 2024. The merits status is not verified. [reported by a secondary source]
  • Libs of TikTok defamation suit (Maryland). Not a case about a trans plaintiff; listed under accountability below.

Mixed

  • For Women Scotland v The Scottish Ministers [2025] UKSC 16 (2025-04-16). Per Wikipedia: unanimous; "man", "woman" and "sex" in the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex, not certificated sex. The same account says the Court noted trans people keep protection from discrimination, harassment and unequal pay based on gender reassignment, and records critics who dispute that the ruling leaves trans people unharmed, including because it could allow exclusion from single-sex spaces. This is a loss on the meaning of "sex" with a residual protection, not a win. The Supreme Court's own pages did not give the holding text. [reported by a secondary source]

Against

  • United States v. Skrmetti, No. 23-477 (2025-06-18, 6-3, Roberts, C.J.). Held that Tennessee's ban on puberty blockers and hormones for minors with gender dysphoria is not subject to heightened scrutiny and satisfies rational-basis review. The Court did not decide whether transgender status is a suspect or quasi-suspect class (Cornell LII). [source read in full] Sotomayor dissented, joined by Jackson and in part by Kagan. Rational-basis review asks only whether a conceivable rational basis exists; the ruling is not a finding that the care is ineffective, and the published evidence for care is in the project's evidence brief.
  • Little v. Hecox (No. 24-38) and West Virginia v. B.P.J. (No. 24-43), decided 2026-06-30, opinion by Kavanaugh, J. Held that Title IX allows schools to provide separate teams defined by biological sex, and that the Idaho and West Virginia laws did not violate equal protection; the laws were upheld (Cornell LII syllabus and Wikipedia). The 6-3 split is on equal protection: Kavanaugh wrote for six justices, and Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson concurred in part and dissented in part. The Court held that Hecox's case is not moot (footnote 4), reversed the Ninth Circuit's judgment and remanded. [source read in full]
  • Military and passports. The Court stayed lower-court injunctions on 2025-05-06 (military service policy, United States v. Shilling, 6-3) and 2025-11-06 (passport sex markers, Trump v. Orr, 6-3), with Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson dissenting in both; litigation continues (SCOTUSblog). [source read in full]

3. Accountability for harassment and false claims

  • Defamation suit over the false naming of a pilot after the Potomac collision. Per Wikipedia (citing The Guardian, Washington Post, NYT, NBC News and Law360): a Virginia National Guard pilot who was falsely named online as the pilot of the helicopter sued the owner of the account in April 2025 (U.S. District Court, District of Colorado), alleging "a destructive and irresponsible defamation campaign". In September 2025 a federal judge declined to dismiss the complaint. The case is pending as far as the article reports. No later ruling was found. The plaintiff and defendant are not named here. [reported by a secondary source]
  • Libs of TikTok (Maryland). Baltimore Banner (2026-10-22; a Baltimore County Circuit judge and Libs of TikTok's operator are described without names): on Wednesday 2026-10-21 the judge denied the operator's motion to dismiss a defamation suit filed in 2025 by a teacher. The Banner lists other defendants, two Moms for Liberty chapter chairs; five state delegates had been dismissed from the suit earlier. The judge found she had "adequate notice" of the suit and had chosen to get involved in a Maryland dispute, so the ruling concerns the motion to dismiss only; it is not a finding of liability. Some counts against one chapter chair (tortious interference and civil conspiracy) were dismissed, with defamation and false light counts remaining. The suit arose from a dispute over a parents'-rights event, not a trans plaintiff; it is relevant as an example of legal consequences for online targeting. [source read in full]
  • Both cases are open and are not findings that the allegations are true.

4. What reduces prejudice and harassment

  • Deep canvassing on transphobia (Miami). Broockman and Kalla, "Durably reducing transphobia: A field experiment on door-to-door canvassing", Science 352(6282):220-224, 2016-04-08. Per the Crossref abstract (the Science page could not be opened): door-to-door canvassing shifted attitudes toward transgender people, and the shift lasted about three months. [abstract or summary read]
  • Replication. Kalla and Broockman, American Political Science Review 114(2):410-425, 2020 (Crossref abstract): three preregistered field experiments, 230 canvassers, 6,869 voters in seven US locations. Arguments alone had no effect; conversations that also exchanged personal narratives reduced exclusionary attitudes for at least four months (d = 0.08). Two experiments on transphobia replicated the effect (d = 0.08 and 0.04). The effects are small in size and based on voter attitudes, not behavior. [abstract or summary read]
  • Empathy-based counter-speech (indirect). Hangartner et al., PNAS 118(50), 2021-12-06 (Crossref abstract): 1,350 English-language Twitter users who had posted xenophobic or racist hate speech were randomized; empathy messages raised deletion of hateful posts by 0.2 SD and reduced new xenophobic hate speech over four weeks by 0.1 SD; humor and warnings of consequences showed no consistent effect. The study concerned racist and xenophobic speech, not anti-trans speech. [abstract or summary read]
  • Visible community norms (indirect). Matias, PNAS 116(20):9785-9789, 2019 (Crossref abstract): across 2,190 online science discussions, announcing rules increased newcomers' rule compliance by more than 8 percentage points and participation by about 70% on average. Not specific to anti-trans harassment. [abstract or summary read]
  • Strength of evidence: canvassing is the only direct trans-specific evidence and is moderate; the other two are indirect.

5. Community resilience (associations, not proof of cause)

  • Gender-identity acceptance and fewer suicide attempts. Price and Green, "Association of Gender Identity Acceptance with Fewer Suicide Attempts Among Transgender and Nonbinary Youth", Transgender Health 8(1):56-63, 2023 (Crossref abstract). 8,218 transgender and nonbinary youth surveyed in 2018. Acceptance from at least one adult was associated with lower odds of a past-year attempt (aOR = 0.67); parental acceptance aOR = 0.57; acceptance by other family aOR = 0.51; at least one peer aOR = 0.66. This is a cross-sectional survey, so it shows association only. [abstract or summary read]
  • Chosen names. Russell, Pollitt, Li and Grossman, "Chosen Name Use Is Linked to Reduced Depressive Symptoms, Suicidal Ideation, and Suicidal Behavior Among Transgender Youth", Journal of Adolescent Health 63(4):503-505, 2018. Title and journal were confirmed from Crossref; the abstract could not be opened, so no figures are given here. [could not be opened]
  • The research on supportive environments is consistent: association, not trial evidence.

6. Support resources

Numbers and hours were checked against each organization's own site on 2026-11-09 (988, The Trevor Project, Trans Lifeline) and 2026-11-08 (Samaritans, Switchboard LGBT+).

  • US: 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. Call or text 988, or chat at chat.988lifeline.org; "available 24/7/365", free and confidential (988lifeline.org). [source read in full] The 988 site now states that the LGBTQ+ youth specialized service ("Press 3 option") "has been restored pursuant to funding and congressional direction". The page gives no date and no access instructions; check 988lifeline.org for current access instructions for that option.
  • US: The Trevor Project (LGBTQ+ young people). Call 1-866-488-7386 (TTY 1-866-803-3699); text START to 678-678; chat via thetrevorproject.org/get-help; 24/7, free and confidential. [source read in full] The page does not state an age range.
  • US and Canada: Trans Lifeline (peer support by trans and nonbinary operators; anonymous). US (877) 565-8860; Canada (877) 330-6366; Spanish: press 2. Hours are Monday to Friday, 10 AM to 6 PM Pacific (1 PM to 9 PM Eastern), for holiday closures see 1; callers may not get through when volume is high; there is no callback service; text and chat are not yet available (translifeline.org/hotline). The line will call emergency services only if the caller asks, though it may report credible threats of violence to others and follows child-abuse reporting law. [source read in full]
  • UK: Samaritans 116 123, 24 hours, free to call (samaritans.org). [source read in full] Shout: text 85258, 24/7, free and confidential (the organization's page gives the number and hours but not the keyword, so no keyword is printed here); call 999 if life is at imminent risk (giveusashout.org). [source read in full] Switchboard LGBT+: 0800 0119 100 (switchboard.lgbt); the site gave no opening hours. [source read in full]

Sources

  1. https://translifeline.org/hotline/