Evidence

Accurate context

The facts that answer the false and distorted claims found in the posts, each with its source and how that source was read.

Accurate context

This page answers false or distorted claims that circulate in anti-trans posts collected on X. For each claim it says what is claimed, what the evidence shows, and, where there are any, examples from the collected posts. Each entry names the narrative as bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric, and every fact and figure is given exactly as its source gives it. "Coded posts" are collected posts that the research team's coding scale rated C2, a false claim stated as fact; the counts below are for the first 133 such posts, from the first three coded samples.

Key to the labels: [source read in full] the page or paper text was opened and read; [abstract or summary read] only an abstract, a summary or part of the source was read, which includes claims taken from the project's evidence brief, "The Evidence Case for Access to Gender-Affirming Care", whose author states that most of its sources were read as abstracts, publisher summaries and news coverage; [reported by a secondary source] the claim comes from a source that reports on the original, such as Wikipedia or a news article about a study; [could not be opened] the source could not be opened, so the claim is not independently confirmed.

No private suspect, victim or minor is named: crime suspects, shooters and people targeted by false claims appear only as "the suspect", "the shooter" or "the partner". Suicide appears only as survey statistics; support resources are on the Progress and resilience page.

Corrections, one entry per false or distorted claim

1. "Trans people are violent", "trans terror", "trans mass shooters"

What is claimed. 77 of the coded posts made this claim, the largest group. Examples as they appear: "Trans identifying people have the highest per capita rate of mass shootings than any other demographic"; "Trans terror is real"; "We have a transgender violence epidemic in America"; series posts that list one incident after another ("MORE TRANS VIOLENCE", "TRANS TERROR", "trans death cult"); "the vast majority of trans women are straight men" combined with prison counts; "testosterone makes trans men violent".

What the evidence shows.

  • Base rate. The Gun Violence Archive (GVA) counted "5,748 mass shootings between Jan. 1, 2013, and Sept. 15, 2025", of which five had a confirmed transgender shooter, "as high as eight" if unverified cases are included, "less than 0.1%". GVA's definition is "a minimum of four victims shot, either injured or killed". The Violence Project (Hamline University) found 201 mass shooters from 1966 to 2024 under its own definition ("four or more people shot and killed, excluding the shooter, in a public location"). One was transgender, and 196 (97.5%) were cisgender men. FactCheck.org called the claim that "the majority" or "all" mass shooters are transgender "false". The two definitions differ, so the counts are not combined. FactCheck.org, "Few Mass Shooters Have Been Transgender", 17 Sep 2025. [source read in full]
  • Some attackers were trans. The Covenant School (Nashville, 2023) shooter was described by the police chief on the day as someone who "identifies as trans" (Wikipedia). [reported by a secondary source] The correction is that this is a handful of cases in thousands, and that being trans is not a documented motive in any of them.
  • Victimization runs the other way. Transgender people experienced 86.2 violent victimizations per 1,000 persons, against 21.7 per 1,000 for cisgender people (National Crime Victimization Survey, 2017-2018, pooled). Flores, Meyer, Langton and Herman, American Journal of Public Health 2021;111(4):726-729. The abstract and the main text give the same rates, and the main text describes 86.2 as the rate of violence. The abstract does not adjust for age or income. [source read in full]
  • Prison and offence counts. Counts of trans prisoners describe the offence mix of a small incarcerated group (for example UK Ministry of Justice figures posted by a public account, 1 Jul 2025). They are not offending rates for trans people in general, and no rate comparison to cisgender people is possible from them. This is reasoning about what such a figure can show; the Ministry of Justice tables themselves were not opened. [could not be opened]
  • "Hormones make people violent." None of the posts cites a study, and no source supporting it was found. It is an unsupported assertion.

Examples from the data.

  • Philadelphia (Kingsessing), July 2023: tracked accounts and public figures called the shooter a trans "BLM activist". FactCheck.org (17 Sep 2025) lists it as not a trans shooter, per local law enforcement. [source read in full]
  • Annunciation Church, Minneapolis, 27 Aug 2025: federal officials called it domestic terrorism and an anti-Catholic hate crime. Wikipedia reports that DHS Secretary Noem and FBI Director Patel emphasized the shooter's gender identity, and that Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon blamed gender-affirming care; the page states: "There is no evidence that [the shooter] had begun receiving gender affirming care or hormone replacement therapy." [reported by a secondary source] Posts that say "gender ideology failed" or "trans terrorist" turn one case into a group trait.
  • Charlie Kirk, 10 Sep 2025: see entry 2.
  • Tumbler Ridge, BC, 10 Feb 2026: Wikipedia reports that RCMP Deputy Commissioner McDonald later said the shooter was a "trans woman", that police said they did not know the motive and had no information the shooter was bullied, and that photos of an unrelated Ontario trans woman were circulated as the shooter (AFP, Snopes and Vancouver Sun fact-checks, and CBC reporting on false claims about trans people after the shooting, are cited there). [reported by a secondary source] The post in the data links "transitioning" and "heavy doses of SSRIs" to the massacre. No source read ties either to the attack; the motive was "under investigation".
  • San Diego mosque attack, 18 May 2026: a viral "trans couple" claim was rated False by PolitiFact (20 May 2026). [source read in full] Snopes (20 May 2026) published a news article headed "Posts claim San Diego mosque shooters were 'trans couple.' There's no proof"; no "False" rating label was seen, and only the headline and summary were read. Reporting there describes the shooters' writings as anti-Muslim, antisemitic and white-nationalist. [abstract or summary read]
  • The Zizians (Jan 2025 Vermont shooting that killed a US Border Patrol agent): Wikipedia calls them "an informal group of rationalists" in its lead and, in its Beliefs section, "a small offshoot of the rationalist community"; it says the group is "mostly transgender or non-binary", attributing that to USA Today (February 2025), with no exact count, and describes six allegedly linked deaths (three in 2022, three in 2025). [reported by a secondary source] "Trantifa" and "trans death cult" are labels placed on a small group. One group's alleged crimes are not data about trans people. A book title in the data ("Inside a Trans Death Cult") sells that frame.
  • The 2022 plot against a Supreme Court justice: the defendant told police she was upset about the leaked Dobbs draft and about the Uvalde shooting (CBS News, via Wikipedia). She came out as a trans woman in September 2025. [reported by a secondary source] A post that writes "THEY'RE TRANSGENDER" in a sentencing headline leaves the stated motive out.
  • Covenant School "pro-transgender activists" and "FBI suppression" posts: see entry 2.

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. It takes rare individual cases and a group of 0.1% or fewer of mass shooters and presents them as the character of a whole population, while the same population experiences victimization at about four times the cisgender rate in the National Crime Victimization Survey abstract's figures (86.2 / 21.7 = 3.97, computed here, not the paper's own ratio).


2. "The shooter was a trans Democrat" and "The FBI tried to hide..."

What is claimed. These posts practice motive displacement: a documented motive is replaced with a trait of the suspect, and the same posts then turn to taxpayers, hormones or a supposed cover-up. Examples:

  • Aurora, Illinois, 15 Oct 2026: a NY Post headline (4.19M views, 75% of all views in the case study) read "Trans neo-Nazi teen accused of Hindu temple mass shooting plot will get hormone treatments in jail: judge". The headline is quoted as archived by the project, and the view figures are the project's own archive figures; the NY Post page could not be opened, so neither is independently confirmed. [could not be opened] Tracked-account posts then wrote "he was a Transgender Democrat... Democrat leaders have their latest propaganda hoax: 'He was a White supremacist'" (quoting a Hindu American's statement about "a white supremacist"), "'White supremacist' he was literally on hormone replacement therapy", and "the 'Neo-Nazi' transgender".
  • Kirk case, 14 Sep 2025: "FBI tried to hide trans identity of Charlie Kirk suspect's lover".
  • Covenant School, 2023: "Pro-Transgender Activists Seek to Hide School Shooter's Manifesto" (Breitbart, 29 Mar 2023) and "FBI reportedly suppressing" (Post Millennial, 21 Apr 2023). The headlines are as recorded by the project; the articles were not opened, so they are not independently confirmed. [could not be opened]

What the evidence shows.

  • Aurora: what officials and the court record say (suspect, 19, not named).
    • Prosecutors say the suspect planned a mass shooting for about two years and targeted a Hindu temple in Aurora for two months. On Sunday 11 Oct his AR-style rifle jammed as he tried to shoot a man from a car. Co-workers called 911 and police found him in the parking lot of a Palatine apartment complex. A search found a rifle, magazines, 300 rounds of ammunition, a gas can and Nazi materials. WBEZ, 15 Oct 2026, 1 [source read in full] Chicago Sun-Times, 15 Oct 2026. [source read in full] The accounts of the arrest differ: ABC6 says he was arrested outside his home, and Fox 32 says only that he was arrested Sunday. The sources are not reconciled here.
    • WBEZ, quoting court records (the records were not opened), reports an eight-page manifesto (Fox 32, 2, also describes an eight-page document with a manifesto title) in which he describes himself as "a sociopathic white supremacist Neo Nazi filled with hatred, fantasizing about mass murder nearly every day". Prosecutors say it calls nonwhite people "subhumans" and describes a "plot to kill as many of them as possible", and that he "regularly made disparaging comments … about people of other races, particularly people from India". Associate Judge Andreana Turano noted in a detention order that he was a self-described white supremacist. Charges: making a terrorist threat and illegal gun possession (Fox 32: terrorist threat and unlawful possession of a rifle with a barrel shorter than 16 inches). [source read in full] ABC6 reports a Class X classification, and the arrest the same afternoon; no hate-crime charge had been reported as of 30 Oct. [source read in full] On 30 Oct a judge kept him jailed as a continuing threat to public safety, and the defense filed a speedy-trial motion; federal charges were still under review (Fox 32, 30 Oct 2026; the article's address contains the suspect's name and is not printed). [source read in full]
    • U.S. Rep. Raja Krishnamoorthi said he would ask the FBI to investigate and prosecute it as a hate crime (WBEZ). [source read in full] WBEZ says he was inside the temple with family members, including his parents, celebrating Navaratri when the attempted shooting happened; Fox 32 says he said his family was at the temple that Sunday and that police did not comment further on his statement; he told the Sun-Times he never saw the suspect. [source read in full]
  • The hormone order. Fox 32 (15 Oct 2026 and 30 Oct 2026) reports that a judge put a "jailhouse healthcare order" in place, "saying he receives hormone injections for gender transition and is being treated for ADHD, depression and anxiety"; Outlook India also reports it. [source read in full] Neither Fox 32 article gives the order's date or its legal reason, WBEZ does not mention the order, and the NY Post page could not be opened, so no reason is stated here. Continuing a detainee's existing medical care is the context in which the hook appears, not a policy choice made for the suspect.
  • Gender identity. No official, prosecutor or court filing found states the suspect's gender identity. The only item is the hormone order. Posts disagree with each other on the suspect's sex assigned at birth, and a claim that he was a "registered Democrat" was not verified in any source read.
  • The framing. Of 41 tracked-account posts, 35 (85%), carrying 97% of the views, put trans identity first or left the ideology out, and none treated the ideology as the story (the project's analysis of the case). Being trans is not a motive. The documented motive is neo-Nazi and white-supremacist hatred directed at Indians and Hindus. A headline that puts "trans" first and the ideology second invites readers to link the crime to being trans; that is motive displacement.
  • The Kirk case.
    • The suspect surrendered on 11 Sep after his parents recognized him; Utah Gov. Cox said on 14 Sep that the suspect held "leftist ideology". Prosecutor Gray said the suspect's mother described him as becoming "more pro-gay and trans rights-oriented", and that texts to the roommate said "I had enough of his hatred. Some hate can't be negotiated out." ABC News reported that the charging documents did not indicate whether those stances were a motivating factor (Wikipedia). [reported by a secondary source]
    • The roommate and romantic partner was "not considered a suspect", was described as "aghast" and "shocked", and was "very cooperative" with investigators (Wikipedia). [reported by a secondary source]
    • Utah Gov. Cox said on 14 Sep 2025 that the roommate was a romantic partner who is transgender, and that the partner had been "incredibly cooperative" (AP, via PBS NewsHour). The same report says authorities had not said whether it is relevant to the motive. [source read in full] Because an official stated it publicly, no source supports "the FBI tried to hide" it. A partner's gender identity is not a motive.
    • The Wall Street Journal's "transgender ideology" engravings report was from an ATF bulletin; the New York Times reported it was unverified and the Journal added an editor's note, not a retraction (Wikipedia). [reported by a secondary source]
  • The Covenant School records dispute. Those who acted to withhold the writings were the Metro Nashville Police (open investigation), the FBI (it told Metro Council member Courtney Johnston the documents describe a "blueprint of total destruction" that could inspire other shooters), and the Covenant School together with a group of parents said to represent 75% of the school's families, who were granted leave to intervene. Breitbart's "pro-transgender activists" rested on public statements by advocacy groups arguing against publication; it identified no litigant or official as such. On 4 Feb 2026 the Tennessee Court of Appeals ruled that the trial court must proceed with making the documents available for inspection (Wikipedia). The Metro Nashville Police closed its investigation in April 2025, citing a desire for notoriety. [reported by a secondary source]

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. A documented extremist motive is demoted, mocked as a "hoax", or replaced with a trait of the suspect, and the same post then turns to taxpayers, hormones or a supposed cover-up. A headline from a large outlet is held to the same standard. The posts addressed to a Hindu American who described the attempted attack are an additional harm: they call the victims' community liars about the motive their own court record documents.


3. "Transgender Day of Visibility replaces Easter" and "5% of under-19s are trans"

What is claimed. 26 of the coded posts fell in this group of distorted statistics and other fabricated figures. Two claims that could be checked against a source are answered here: "Transgender Day of Visibility replaces Easter" and "Biden declared Easter a trans holiday" (about 6 posts), and "5% of under-19s are trans".

What the evidence shows.

  • Easter. Transgender activist Rachel Crandall Crocker created the day in 2009 and it is held on 31 March every year. It fell on Easter Sunday in 2024. Reuters, per Wikipedia, found Biden did not set the day to coincide with Easter. Biden's 2021 proclamation was the first presidential proclamation for it. Wikipedia, "Transgender Day of Visibility"; the Reuters fact-check itself was not opened. [reported by a secondary source]
  • The "5%" figure. Pew (survey 16-22 May 2022, 10,188 adults) found 1.6% of US adults trans or nonbinary and 5.1% of adults younger than 30. Pew Research Center, 7 Jun 2022. [source read in full] The Williams Institute (Aug 2025; BRFSS 2021-2023, YRBS 2021 and 2023) estimates 1.0% of those aged 13 and older, 0.8% of adults and 3.3% of youth aged 13-17. [source read in full] The "5%" is the under-30 adult figure.

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. These are manufactured grievances: a 15th-anniversary observance becomes an attack on Christianity, and an under-30 figure is stretched to children. The posts fall mostly under the project's "political enemy" and "ideology cult" narratives.


4. "Gender-affirming care is experimental" and "there is no evidence" (and the Cass Review and HHS report)

What is claimed. 14 of the coded posts stated that care is "experimental" or has "no evidence base" as fact. The same claim reaches the posts through appeals to the Cass Review, the 2025 HHS report and European reviews, and through "elevated suicidality is a lie", "care is manufactured for profit" and "most trans youth are really autistic and being sterilized".

What the evidence shows. The first part of this list (adults, adolescents, professional bodies) is the case for care as set out in the project's evidence brief.

  • Adults. A Johns Hopkins systematic review (2021; 20 studies, 15 of them trials or prospective cohorts) found hormone therapy associated with higher quality of life and lower depression and anxiety. [abstract or summary read] In JAMA Surgery (2021; 3,559 US Transgender Survey respondents with surgery, 16,401 who wanted it), surgery was associated with lower past-month distress (aOR 0.58) and past-year suicidal ideation (aOR 0.56). [abstract or summary read] A 2025 JAMA Network Open cohort (3,592 patients) found a 15% lower risk of moderate to severe depression over four years among those prescribed hormones. [abstract or summary read]
  • Adolescents. NEJM 2023;388(3):240-250: 315 youth aged 12 to 20, followed two years on hormones; depression and anxiety fell and life satisfaction rose. The paper has an erratum (NEJM 389:1540, Oct 2023), whose contents were not read. [abstract or summary read] Seattle Children's (JAMA Netw Open 2022): aOR 0.40 for depression and 0.27 for suicidality. [abstract or summary read] PLOS ONE 2022 (21,598 adults who had wanted hormones): starting in early adolescence was associated with lower odds of past-year suicidal ideation than never receiving them (aOR 0.4). [abstract or summary read] A 2026 rapid review (2021 to August 2025) found generally mild adverse events and stable or improved mental health. [abstract or summary read]
  • Persistence and regret. See entry 7.
  • Cornell's literature review. The evidence brief says Cornell found 56 studies of transition and well-being, 52 (93%) showing improvement and none showing harm. Cornell's review page reports 55 primary studies, 51 (93%) showing improvement, 4 mixed or null, and no study finding that transition causes overall harm, for articles from 1991 through June 2017. [source read in full] The Cornell news release says "Of 56 peer-reviewed studies, 52 (93 percent)", so Cornell's two pages differ; the figures here are the review page's own count (55 and 51). The review page says it is "difficult to conduct prospective studies or randomized control trials of treatments for gender dysphoria".
  • Professional bodies.
    • Endocrine Society, position statement of 16 Dec 2020: treatment is "effective, relatively safe (when appropriately monitored)", "established as the standard of care", and "medically necessary" (the last phrase comes from the page's Considerations section, describing the Society's guideline). [source read in full]
    • AMA board chair, March 2026 letter: "The AMA supports gender-affirming care as medically necessary per our policy", and "There has been no change in AMA policy with respect to access to and provision of gender-affirming care"; the board does not endorse the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) statement of February 2026. Erin in the Morning, 27 Mar 2026; the article dates the letter only as "a March newsletter". [source read in full]
    • The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) reaffirmed its 2018 policy in 2023 and kept it after February 2026, as reported by the evidence brief; the AAP page could not be opened, so this is not independently confirmed. [could not be opened]
    • The evidence brief reports that the ASPS issued a statement in February 2026 on the timing of gender-related surgery. No readable source for that statement was found, so its content is not stated here as fact.

Anti-trans rhetoric dressed as review: Cass, HHS and European reviews.

  • Cass Review (England, April 2024). Posts cite it as proof that care is "experimental". A peer-reviewed appraisal (Noone et al., BMC Medical Research Methodology 2025; 25:128) used the ROBIS tool and found "a high risk of bias in each of the systematic reviews" commissioned for Cass, citing "unexplained protocol deviations, ambiguous eligibility criteria, inadequate study identification" and failure to carry limitations into conclusions. It also reports flaws in the primary research that "suggest a double standard in the quality of evidence produced for the Cass report", and concludes the recommendations "warrant critical scrutiny". [abstract or summary read] The BMA council voted to commission an independent evaluation, citing a preprint of this critique and the Yale paper. [abstract or summary read] The Yale Integrity Project white paper (2024) is not peer reviewed and has itself been rebutted in a peer-reviewed journal. [abstract or summary read] No claim is made here that the Cass team decided its conclusions in advance. The Cass final report itself was not read for this page.
  • HHS report (2025). Two versions exist: 1 May 2025 (authors not named) and 19 Nov 2025 (re-released with minor changes and named authors) (Wikipedia). [reported by a secondary source] Executive Order 14187 of 28 Jan 2025, "Protecting Children From Chemical and Surgical Mutilation", already refers to "The blatant harm done to children by chemical and surgical mutilation" (Sec. 3(a)) and says "medical professionals are maiming and sterilizing a growing number of impressionable children" (Sec. 1). The order defines "child" in Sec. 2(a) as "an individual or individuals under 19 years of age". Federal Register. [source read in full] The AAP said the report "misrepresent[ed] the current medical consensus" (AAP News, 1 May 2025) and the Endocrine Society said "Medical studies show that access to this care improves the well-being of transgender and nonbinary people" (response dated 29 May 2025 on Wikipedia), both via Wikipedia. [reported by a secondary source] A peer-reviewed appraisal in the Journal of Adolescent Health charged it with violating scientific norms and selectively misusing research; this is reported only by the evidence brief. [abstract or summary read] The nine named authors of the November 2025 version include co-founders or affiliates of advocacy and policy groups, listed on the Wikipedia page; no characterization of anyone is made beyond that listing. [reported by a secondary source]
  • "Low certainty." Evidence reviews in England, Sweden, Finland and the US rated the certainty of the evidence for youth as low. This is a dispute about study design, in a field where randomized trials are widely considered unethical and low certainty ratings are common across pediatric medicine. [abstract or summary read] The 2021 Johns Hopkins review itself noted high risk of bias, small samples and confounding and could draw no conclusions about suicide deaths. [abstract or summary read] "Experimental" posts do not engage with study design. They state that no evidence exists, which is false, and they are not good-faith summaries of a rated evidence base.

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. A claim stated as fact that care is "experimental" or has no evidence is rated C2, a false claim stated as fact. Appeals to Cass, HHS or European reviews are treated the same way, whatever the credentials of the person making them.


5. "Minors routinely get surgery", "schools arrange transition", "child mutilation"

What is claimed. 11 of the coded posts made this claim, and all 11 used a child-protection framing as a shield. Examples: "Surgery on trans children", "mutilation", "sterilized", "schools transition kids", "$X per surgery", a Trans Day of Visibility message described as an order to transition children.

What the evidence shows.

  • Prevalence of surgery in minors. In a claims-data research letter (Dai et al., JAMA Network Open 2024;7(6):e2418814), of 85 gender-affirming procedures identified among minors, 82 (96.4%) were chest-related. Rates were 2.1 per 100,000 people aged 15-17, 0.1 per 100,000 aged 13-14 and 0 at 12 and younger (the paper gives rates per 100,000 total people in each age group, not per insured people with a TGD-related diagnosis). The paper gives the year studied as 2019, the data source as Inovalon Insights insured-claims data, and the limit "limited to insurance-covered use and not self-paid use". The authors conclude concerns about high rates "may be unwarranted". The figures support "rare" (about 2 per 100,000 people aged 15-17 in the year studied) and show nearly all were chest procedures. They do not support "never". [source read in full]
  • Bans. As of 9 Nov 2026, 26 states plus one territory ban medication and surgery for transgender youth (the page notes that court orders block the bans in Montana and Kansas); Arizona bans surgery only; 48% of trans youth aged 13-17 live in states banning both and 2% in surgery-only states. Movement Advancement Project (an advocacy organization). [source read in full]
  • Schools. Wikipedia, citing two sources, one labeled KFF, reports "no evidence that any school in the United States had provided gender-affirming surgery to a student" as of September 2024. The KFF page itself was not opened. [reported by a secondary source]
  • Public opinion, for context. Pew (survey 10-17 Feb 2025, 5,097 US adults): 56% favor banning health care professionals from providing gender-transition care for minors (up 10 points; 2022: 46%, computed from the reported change). The page says "for minors", not "under 18". Republicans favor the ban at 79% (72% in 2022) and Democrats at 35% (26% in 2022). [source read in full]
  • Under 18 and under 26. The "protect children" frame covers wider ages in the orders and bills the same people write.
    • Executive Order 14187 (28 Jan 2025) defines "child" as under 19. [source read in full]
    • Texas HB 4754 (88th Legislature, introduced version, the "Texas Millstone Act"): author Tinderholt; caption "relating to health benefit plan coverage for and prohibitions on gender transitioning procedures"; Sec. 161.704 applies to individuals "younger than 26 years of age"; Sec. 161.707: "An offense under this section is a state jail felony"; Sec. 161.708: the licensing agency "shall revoke the license, certification, or authorization"; public-money (161.705) and Medicaid (161.706) bars. It was filed 10 Mar 2023, referred to Public Health 22 Mar 2023, and left "In committee", with no coauthors and no later action. The bill does not label the under-26s "children" in the text read; the age appears as a threshold in the provider ban. It applies to everyone under 26. [source read in full]
    • Oklahoma SB 129 (2023), Sen. David Bullard. Metro Weekly, 18 Jan 2023: Bullard's bill covers treatments for anyone "under the age of 26", with a felony for prescribing or referring, prosecution up to 40 years after prescribing, unprofessional-conduct consequences, and Bullard's quote "The brain is not fully developed until 25." The article gives no bill number; the match to SB 129 is by author (Bullard is the author on the Oklahoma legislature page, and the Rules committee's title on 8 Feb 2023 was "Health care; creating the Millstone Act of 2023; prohibiting provision of or referral for gender transition procedures"). The vote page records Rules 16-2 on 8 Feb 2023 (Do Pass as Amended, Committee Substitute) and Appropriations 14-6 on 1 Mar 2023, when a committee substitute and a motion to strike the title (both by Sen. Thompson) were adopted; the title became "Health care; prohibiting certain uses of public funds, public facilities, and public employees." The age threshold of the introduced bill is therefore from Metro Weekly, not from the bill text. A separate House bill by Rep. Jim Olsen (number not given in the source) covers "any patient under the age of 21" with a $100,000 fine and up to a decade in prison (Metro Weekly); "HB 101" is not supported by Metro Weekly. [source read in full]
    • South Carolina H. 4624 (2023-24), sponsors led by Reps. Hiott, G. M. Smith and McCravy (44 House sponsors). The bill title speaks of "a person under eighteen years of age" and Sec. 44-42-320(A) bars providers from procedures "to a person under eighteen years of age", but the Medicaid section 44-42-350 says the program may not cover prohibited practices "to an individual under twenty-six (26) years of age". The committee report of 5 Mar 2024 recommends striking the under-26 language from 44-42-350; the text dated 6 Mar 2024 still contains it. The under-26 language is in the original text only, not in any enacted law confirmed here. [source read in full]
    • Kansas: under 21, not 26. SB 12 (2023) would have made it a felony to provide gender-affirming care "to teens and adults under the age of 21" (class 4 felony for hormone therapy or puberty blockers, surgery bar, license loss), cosponsored by Sens. Mike Thompson and Mark Steffen, nicknamed "Kansas Child Mutilation Prevention Act". HPPR, 14 Jan 2023. [source read in full] The Kansas legislature page could not be opened, so the bill text was not read and no Kansas bill status is stated. [could not be opened] No source supports "under 26" for Kansas; the supported figure is under 21.
    • In sum: under 26 in Texas, Oklahoma (as introduced) and South Carolina (Medicaid section of the introduced bill); under 21 in Kansas and in a House bill in Oklahoma.
    • Texas HB 3399 (2025), covering care at every age. 89th Legislature, author Money, coauthors Harris, Holt, Little, Lozano, Metcalf, Tinderholt and Virdell. Filed 26 Feb 2025; read first time and referred to Public Health 21 Mar 2025; "In committee". The introduced text has the caption "relating to the provision of procedures and treatments for gender transitioning, gender reassignment, or gender dysphoria" and the use of public money; it replaces "child" with "person" throughout Sections 161.702-161.705 and strikes the definition of "child" as someone under 18. It bars physicians and providers from surgeries "that sterilize", mastectomy, and prescribing puberty blockers and supraphysiologic hormone doses "for the purpose of transitioning a person's" biological sex, with no explicit age limit. Sec. 161.703(b)-(c): a continuing-treatment exception for a course begun before 1 Jun 2025 (changed from 2023), for a person who attended 12 or more counseling sessions over at least six months, with the person required to "wean off the prescription drug over a period of time and in a manner that is safe and medically appropriate". The text read contains no penalty provisions; Medicaid and public-money bars are included. The page shows no vote or action after committee referral. "All ages" is a reading of "person" for "child"; the bill itself says "person". [source read in full]

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. "Mutilation", "castration" and "child abuse" are dehumanizing slogans (rated C3 on the project's scale). Promoting the idea that surgery on minors is widespread is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric.


6. "Social contagion" and "rapid-onset gender dysphoria"

What is claimed. Trans identity is described as a fad spread among peers or online: "ROGD", "over 10% of youth", "caused by pharma/atrazine/autism/parenting".

What the evidence shows.

  • The study that introduced it. Littman 2018, PLOS ONE, used 256 parent-completed surveys ("274 completed, 18 excluded"), recruited on three websites (4thwavenow, Transgender Trend and Youth Trans Critical Professionals), with snowball sampling from a fourth site. [abstract or summary read] The republished version (correction of 19 Mar 2019, PLOS ONE 14(3):e0214157) changed the title, abstract, introduction, discussion and conclusion and states: "Rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) is not a formal mental health diagnosis at this time"; the study's "output was hypothesis-generating rather than hypothesis-testing"; "claims about causal associations cannot be made"; it "did not collect data from the adolescents and young adults (AYAs) or clinicians and therefore does not validate the phenomenon". The correction itself describes the recruitment sites as cautious or negative about medical and surgical transition, so the sample is not representative. [source read in full]
  • Later evidence. A sample of 173 trans youth under 16 from 10 Canadian gender clinics, 2017-2019 (Bauer et al., J Pediatr, online Nov 2021) found, per Wikipedia, no evidence that "rapid onset" was linked to mental-health problems, lack of parental support or high support from online or trans friends; the paper itself was not read. In July 2021 a coalition (cosigned by the American Psychological Association, the American Psychiatric Association and dozens of other groups) called for ROGD's elimination from clinical use, saying "there are no sound empirical studies of ROGD". WPATH's 2018 commentary said it is not recognized by any professional association or listed in the DSM or ICD. The AAP and Endocrine Society are not named on that page. [reported by a secondary source]
  • Size. The numbers in entry 11 do not support a surge as a mass phenomenon. A Williams Institute youth estimate of 3.3% (aged 13-17) is a share of that age group, not evidence of a trend.
  • Share of the collected posts. The contagion narrative appears in 3.7% of posts in a random sample of 1,000 posts from the collected data.

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. It recasts trans identity as an infection to be contained, which makes the people themselves the problem.


7. "Regret and detransition are common"

What is claimed. "Everyone regrets it", "detransitioners are the real victims", "regret is the secret".

What the evidence shows.

  • Dutch cohort. 720 people who started blockers then hormones as adolescents; 704 (98%) were still using hormones at follow-up, 16 (2%) were not. The press release adds: "it remains unknown whether they stopped using hormones because they regretted transitioning". Follow-up varied by patient (to December 2018). Lancet Child & Adolescent Health, published 20 Oct 2022, via EurekAlert. [source read in full]
  • Surgical regret. Pooled regret of 1% (27 studies, 7,928 surgical patients; Bustos et al., PRS Global Open 2021). [abstract or summary read] Cornell reports pooled regret rates of 0.3% to 3.8% and says regrets are "extremely rare", most likely after lack of social support or poor outcomes with older surgical techniques. [abstract or summary read]
  • Detransition is not the same as regret. Of 27,715 transgender and gender-diverse adults in the 2015 US Transgender Survey, 17,151 (61.9%) had ever pursued gender affirmation; 2,242 (13.1%) of those 17,151 reported detransitioning at some point (13.1% is of the 17,151, not of all 27,715), and 82.5% of those cited at least one external factor such as family pressure or stigma. Turban, Loo, Almazan and Keuroghlian, LGBT Health 2021;8(4):273-280. [abstract or summary read]
  • People who stop hormones, are lost to follow-up, or stop temporarily are not the same as people who regret. Such counts do not measure regret.

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. Presenting regret or detransition as common is false. It treats a rare outcome as the norm.


8. "Trans women are taking over women's sport" and "hundreds of trophies"

What is claimed. 3 of the coded posts made this claim. Examples: "NCAA: nearly 900 medals taken from women", "men in women's sports".

What the evidence shows.

  • NCAA President Charlie Baker told Congress that fewer than 10 of the NCAA's more than 500,000 athletes were transgender (The Bulwark's paraphrase, not a quotation). [source read in full] The Advocate reports it as "only 10 trans athletes, out of 510,000" and dates it 2024 (testimony of Dec 2024). [source read in full] The two retellings differ ("fewer than 10" and "only 10"); the testimony itself was not opened.
  • An NCAA spokesperson, speaking to Pablo Torre Finds Out, said the number of transgender student-athletes competing in women's sports is "effectively zero" (no spokesperson is named). [source read in full] The Advocate (28 Oct 2026) attributes the phrase to a Torre post of 27 Oct 2026: "The NCAA tells us effectively ZERO trans student-athletes are now competing in women's sports", and adds that after the poll was commissioned the NCAA told Torre "no trans athletes are currently competing in any NCAA competitions nationwide". These are relayed statements, not a published NCAA release. The Advocate also says the NCAA "in February 2025 imposed new restrictions barring trans girls and women" (the sentence is truncated at 125 characters in the extract). [source read in full]
  • The "900 medals" figure: no source was found, and it cannot be checked against NCAA numbers, which show a handful of athletes.
  • The false picture is measured. The Bulwark and Pablo Torre Finds Out, with YouGov fielding, surveyed 1,417 American adults from YouGov's opt-in panel on 10-14 October 2026, weighted to be representative, margin of error plus or minus 3.6 points. 31% chose the "none or less than 1 percent" option, which is the right answer (the true number is below 1%), 15% chose 1-5% and 14% believed 6-25% of NCAA athletes are trans. The page does not give the exact question wording and refers to a toplines PDF that was not opened. [source read in full] The Advocate (28 Oct 2026) corroborates: "About 15 percent of Americans believe between 1 percent and 5 percent of athletes in the NCAA are transgender", "Another 14 percent... 6 percent and 25 percent"; the 31% are those who say fewer than 1%. The Advocate does not mention YouGov or the sample size; only The Bulwark does. [source read in full] The 31% option includes "none", so it is not the sum of the other two (15% + 14% = 29%).
  • Public opinion, for context. Pew (survey 10-17 Feb 2025): 66% favor requiring trans athletes to compete on teams matching sex assigned at birth, up 8 points (2022: 58%, computed). [source read in full] Pew, 11 Aug 2026: in a survey of 17-30 Nov 2025 (n = 10,357), 73% were not too or not at all comfortable with trans athletes on teams not matching birth sex, 13% extremely or very comfortable, 14% somewhat; restrictions 66% (Feb 2025); Republicans 85% (2022) to 88% (2025), Democrats 37% to 45%. Pew gave 2022 comparisons only for those figures. [source read in full]

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. A false picture of how many people are involved is the base of the grievance. Pushing it, to a public where 14% believe 6-25%, is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric.


9. "41%" used as a taunt

What is claimed. "41% attempt suicide" is used as an insult or as proof that trans people are unstable, and as "if affirmation prevents suicide, why is the figure so high".

What the evidence shows.

  • The 41% figure is a lifetime suicide-attempt figure from the 2008-09 National Transgender Discrimination Survey (NTDS), reported by Haas, Rodgers and Herman (Williams Institute and AFSP, January 2014). Only a metadata abstract confirming "41%... from an NTDS sample" was seen. It is a convenience-sample survey, not deaths. [abstract or summary read]
  • A newer survey measures the past year: 38.9% reported serious suicide thoughts and 5.3% an attempt in the year before the 2022 US Trans Survey (more than 92,000 respondents). Herman, Kopparam and Scheim, Williams Institute, June 2026, 3 [source read in full] A lifetime figure and a past-year figure measure different things and cannot be compared.
  • Disputes over suicide risk are used in the collected posts to argue against care ("emotional blackmail").

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. Mocking suicide or telling people it is their destiny is rated C4 or C5 on the project's scale (C5 when it baits); using a statistic about suffering as an insult is hate speech aimed at a vulnerable group. The statistic describes the effect of stigma, rejection and violence, not a trait of being trans.


10. Bathrooms, changing rooms and prisons ("trans women endanger women")

What is claimed. "Men in women's bathrooms", "predators", "it's about safety", and trans prisoner counts used to argue against women's prisons.

What the evidence shows.

  • Who is at risk in restrooms. In the 2015 US Transgender Survey (27,715 respondents), 1% reported being sexually assaulted in a public restroom for being transgender, 12% reported verbal harassment there, 1% non-sexual physical assault and 9% denial of restroom access (as reported by Wikipedia, "Bathroom bill"; the survey itself was not opened). [reported by a secondary source]
  • Studies of crime. Wikipedia reports a 2018 Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law paper finding "no current evidence" that gender-corresponding restroom access increases sexual offenses, and reports (Vox, Media Matters) no increases in states and districts with trans protections. [reported by a secondary source] The studies cannot show an event never happens; they show no measurable increase and a rare event.
  • North Carolina (HB2). Elon University polled 799 registered voters on 12-16 Sep 2016 (margin of error plus or minus 3.86 points; 644 said they are likely to vote). Question: "Do you support or oppose HB2?" Results among likely voters: "Support: 39.5 percent", "Oppose: 49.5 percent", "Neither/No opinion: 7.1 percent", "Don't know: 3.5 percent". So "40%" is a rounding of 39.5% among likely voters, in September 2016, after HB2 was in force. Elon University Poll news release of 19 Sep 2016, "N.C. voters oppose HB2, razor-thin margins in governor, U.S. Senate races". [source read in full] An earlier Elon release (19 Apr 2016, survey 10-15 Apr, 692 residents, 621 registered voters, margin of error 3.93) asked a different question, whether the state should prohibit cities from passing such ordinances: 49% "should prohibit", 39% "cities should be allowed", 11% don't know. The two polls ask different questions and should not be mixed. [source read in full]
  • Trump in 2016. ABC11 Raleigh-Durham, "Donald Trump comes out against North Carolina's HB2", 21 Apr 2016. Quotes in the article: "leave it the way it is", "There have been very few complaints the way it is", "There has been so little trouble", and "North Carolina did something that was very strong and they're paying a big price". He also said a transgender person such as Caitlyn Jenner would be allowed to use the restroom of her choice at Trump Tower. ABC11 does not name the outlet, but WUNC (21 Apr 2016) says Trump was asked about HB2 on "Thursday's NBC Today Show". [source read in full] He reversed: at a Raleigh rally on Tuesday 5 Jul 2016 he told the News and Observer "I'm going with the state" (Advocate, 7 Jul 2016). [source read in full]
  • Opinion has moved the other way since. Pew (10-17 Feb 2025, n = 5,097): 49% favor requiring bathrooms to match birth sex, 26% oppose, up 8 points from 2022. This shows timing, not cause. Pew, 26 Feb 2025, "Americans have grown more supportive of restrictions for trans people in recent years". The same survey: 56% support "policies aimed at protecting trans people from discrimination in jobs, housing and public spaces", down 8 points (the 2022 level, 64%, is computed here and is not stated on the page); 47% favor banning elementary-school teaching on gender identity, up 6; 22% favor insurance coverage for gender-transition care and 53% oppose, down 5. [source read in full]
  • Prisons. Counts of a small prison group do not give offending rates (see entry 1). The UK and US prison tables were not opened.

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. It puts trans women in the position of a threat at the moment when the data show them as the targets of restroom harassment and exclusion. Trump said "leave it the way it is" in April 2016 and then said he was "with the state" in July 2016, which shows how quickly a stated position moves when the frame works.


11. "Everyone is trans now" and an inflated size

What is claimed. "Everyone is trans now", "5% of teenagers", "1 in 10 kids".

What the evidence shows.

  • Pew (16-22 May 2022, 10,188 adults): 1.6% of US adults transgender or nonbinary; 5.1% of adults younger than 30; 44% know a trans person (42% in 2021, 37% in 2017). [source read in full]
  • Williams Institute (Aug 2025; BRFSS 2021-2023, YRBS 2021 and 2023): 1.0% of those aged 13 and older, about 2.8 million people (about 2.1 million adults, about 724,000 youth); 0.8% of adults and 3.3% of youth aged 13-17. [source read in full]

Why this is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. "Everyone" turns a 1-3% group into a majority threat. It is part of the same sustained effort as the sports numbers: a public with a wildly inaccurate picture is easier to move.

Sources

  1. https://www.wbez.org/crime/2026/10/15/gun-jammed-when-neo-nazi-attempted-mass-shooting-at-hindu-temple-in-aurora-prosecutors-say
  2. https://www.fox32chicago.com/news/palatine-aurora-hindu-temple-shooting-plot-police-update
  3. https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/suicidality-transgender-adults/