The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Excellent @GBNews report by @[private account] on the recent puberty blockers trial protest in Westminster.
It features counter protestors from 'Trans Kids Deserve Better' (the group that disrupted the 2024 @AllianceLGB conference by releasing crickets into the venue). Along with their disturbing 'Arm trans kids' banner - and my footage of them being asked to take it down by police.
You'll see Connie asking the masked counter protestors whether they felt the way they were presenting themselves would convince onlookers they were on the right side of the debate ... she was sworn at and accused of harassment.
Both myself and @[private account] also asked counter protestors for comment (also captured on video) ... but they didn't seem keen to engage with us either.
Watch here đ
https://youtu.be/9qOGIKRXFAI?si=fDGymntvM75UjoyY
Some trans activists - and, disappointingly, a handful of gender-critical people - are claiming I sent myself the âToilet Monitorâ pin badge, either to monetise it or as some kind of PR stunt. That is quite some accusation.
Anyone with basic maths skills can see monetisation clearly isnât the aim. The âPR stuntâ claim, however, is more revealing - particularly at a time when the police are dealing with serious threats made against womenâs rights campaigners. I have, of course, preserved the evidence should I ever need to involve the police.
While itâs disappointing to hear this from gender-critical people - and without a shred of evidence - there is a striking irony here.
Women are routinely told they must accept the word of a man who says he is a woman, and allow him into single-sex spaces - along with his assurance that he poses no risk, as if declaring an identity magically removes male violence or entitlement.
Yet some of those very same people refuse to accept the word of a woman who says she received a pin badge through the post.
A contradiction that speaks for itself.
âźď¸ Quote of the day âźď¸
âSo you are saying that trans man and women may be fearful of going out in case they run into a middle aged woman wearing a âtoilet monitorâ badge?â đ¤
So you are saying that trans man and women may be fearful of going out in case they run into middle aged woman wearing a âtoilet monitorâ badge? đ¤
Yesterday, a report in the Daily Mail detailed serious threats and intimidation directed at organisations defending womenâs rights - including @SexMattersOrg and the @SpeechUnion.
Sadly, itâs not surprising. We have repeatedly seen trans activists attend protests wearing black masks and carrying placards calling for women to be hanged, set on fire, urinated on defecated on - or even raped.
In October, a group calling itself âBash Back âsmashed windows at the venue hosting the @[private account] conference, then stood outside in black masks, attempting to intimidate women as they entered.
Over Christmas, a chilling online threat was made against a friend. Senior politicians - including @wesstreeting - have also been explicitly targeted.
Last week, I received an anonymous item through the post - because I publicly defend womenâs sex-based rights. And apparently *I* should be prosecuted for talking about it publicly.
Itâs heartening that the police now appear to be taking this seriously - but it has taken far too long.
And yet some people - including women - still defend this ideology. đ¤Ż
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentideology cultspeech persecutionviolence terror
A conversation I often have with my mum - who spent 40 years in NHS nursing - is this: men who enter womenâs spaces can no longer be embarrassed into leaving by women.
Not because women suddenly became comfortable with it - but because power shifted.
Leaders in business, politics, healthcare, education, sport and leisure have been captured by gender ideology. Which means if a woman objects, they will side with the man - even if, privately, they agree with her.
Because disagreeing openly could cost them their job. Or, at the very least, their social standing.
And women canât rely on other women to back them up either.
I can guarantee that if there were a man in the womenâs changing room at my gym, at least one woman would accuse me of bullying a âpoor, tortured soulâ. Sheâd tell me he was only trying to live his life, remind me that trans people are among the most marginalised in society - and frame my objection as cruelty.
Meanwhile, women who agreed with me would likely stay silent. Not because they donât care, but because theyâre afraid - afraid of being labelled a bigot - or worse.
And thatâs how we end up with extraordinary stories like this: a woman banned from her council gym for challenging a man in the womenâs changing room - a man who then accused *her* of attacking him.
My mum retired more than a decade ago, finishing her career at matron level. She had no truck with men trying to access womenâs spaces - and when a man who said he was a woman turned up at a sports club she belongs to, she firmly directed him to a third space to change.
What I donât think she fully grasps, having been out of the workplace for a while, is just how hard it now is to get backing - from institutions, businesses and even from other women.
And how if it wasnât for the unrelenting courage of journalists like @[private account] - weâd never even get to hear stories like this.
Video highlights from Wednesdayâs puberty blocker trial protest organised by @roseveniceallan.
Iâd normally have shared this sooner, but a few individual clips and photos felt more urgent to put out first.
I spent longer than intended âover the roadâ with the counter-protesters (hence I had to snaffle a couple of clips from X). I did, however, ask every single counter-protester if they'd be willing to speak to me. All declined.
I do hope Wes Streeting watches this video (itâs 90 seconds long) - and takes a proper look at the âArm Trans Kidsâ poster. Which features guns and explosives poking out of a childâs Wendy house and toy car.
Because itâs hard not to feel that it says more about what's driving this activism - and the kind of children who may be affected by the puberty blockers trial - than any words ever could.
Thanks to @HJoyceGender @[private account] @[private account] @RosieDuffield1 @[private account] @SexMattersOrg @RupertLowe10 @Jebadoo2 @AllianceLGB
Yesterday I wrote to my email list about having to restart my career at 51 - after getting 'cancelled' for objecting to the term âpregnant peopleâ. Summary:
Hi Janet
Sorry you got breast cancer. I didn't know you were a teacher before. Why do you hate trans people?
Love
A 'Queer' Woman
I replied publicly on Facebook and LinkedIn - as I felt it was a better use of my time - rather than a protracted private exchange. But really đ
Someone has commented that the âArm Trans Kidsâ banner is wrong - but shows how desperate young people with gender dysphoria are.
I know people who are desperate for a new hip or a hysterectomy - because theyâre living in excruciating pain.
Parents who are desperate for access to lifesaving cancer treatment for a child.
Are they holding up banners calling for vulnerable children to be armed with guns?
With guns poking out of Wendy Houses and childrenâs toy cars?
Surrounded by explosives?
No.
No they are not.
Quoting @jan_murray: I was at the puberty blockers protest today (video footage to follow). One clip, in particular, shows police officers asking counter-protesters to remove a sign.
The sign read: âArm trans kids.â Literally - give them guns. Look closely and youâll see the firearms - including one protruding from the side of a childâs toy car.
Another one Iâll be showing to my ânormalâ friends who think people are getting their knickers in a twist about gender ideology. And that people should just be more âkindâ.
I approached one of the counter-protesters - the only person whose face was not covered - and asked if he would be willing to be interviewed on camera. He declined. Would any other protestors speak to me? Unlikely, he said - as it was âtheir lives.â
I moved along the line of counter-protesters, asking if anyone would speak to me about why they were there - or why they oppose the puberty blocker ban. Each person lowered their head and remained silent.
The sign was later removed - at the request of the police.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Belatedly ... it was genuinely lovely to meet some of the people who have inspired and supported me since my rather unceremonious âcancellationâ in April (for saying I donât like the phrase âpregnant peopleâ) at yesterdayâs puberty blockers trial protest.
I regret not getting to speak to more of you - but as
@[private account] (who I did manage to speak to) kindly reminded me, itâs only a few weeks since I finished radiotherapy - so I didnât linger too long afterwards.
That said, Iâm very glad I managed to capture some decent video footage - including the police asking the TRAs to take down that dreadful âarm trans kidsâ flag. You can take the journalist out of the newsroom and all that.
Iâm planning to edit it into a short video and hope to get to that later today đ¤
'Have you ever talked to a trans person?'
A question women who publicly defend their sex-based rights and language are often asked by activists (whilst also calling them bigots, transphobes, Nazis etc).
So I decided to ask some of the counter-protestors at today's puberty blocker trial protest why they feel the trial should go ahead.
Here's what they had to say ...
Well done to @[private account] for getting the police to remove this appalling âArm trans kidsâ banner at todayâs puberty-blocker trial protest.
I managed to capture the moment on video.
The message is disturbing at any time - but calling for vulnerable young people to be given guns, just three days after 15 Jews were shot dead on Bondi Beach, is beyond grotesque. No words.
I was at the puberty blockers protest today (video footage to follow). One clip, in particular, shows police officers asking counter-protesters to remove a sign.
The sign read: âArm trans kids.â Literally - give them guns. Look closely and youâll see the firearms - including one protruding from the side of a childâs toy car.
Another one Iâll be showing to my ânormalâ friends who think people are getting their knickers in a twist about gender ideology. And that people should just be more âkindâ.
I approached one of the counter-protesters - the only person whose face was not covered - and asked if he would be willing to be interviewed on camera. He declined. Would any other protestors speak to me? Unlikely, he said - as it was âtheir lives.â
I moved along the line of counter-protesters, asking if anyone would speak to me about why they were there - or why they oppose the puberty blocker ban. Each person lowered their head and remained silent.
The sign was later removed - at the request of the police.
C1 anti-trans rhetoricactivist harassmentviolence terror
Iâm seeing a lot of posts from men wringing their hands about the Sandie Peggie case.
Claiming the law is âcomplexâ. Repeating the highly publicised errors in the original tribunal ruling. And omitting the fact that an amended ruling has already been published - with an appeal now imminent.
The law is actually very simple: men stay out of womenâs spaces. And identifying as a woman does not make you one - even with a Gender Recognition Certificate.
And hereâs the thing. I canât think of a single man in my life who would agree that a woman should be forced to get changed in front of a man.
So if youâre one of those men who is thinks itâs âcomplicatedâ Iâd like you to imagine this.
Youâre standing outside an enclosed space. A changing room. A room with a locked door.
Inside is a man wearing womenâs clothes and makeup.
Now imagine your mother, your wife, your daughter, your sister - women you love - being required to go in one by one. Alone. And being told they must undress in front of that man. Against their will.
I donât want to hear statistics about the likelihood of an attack. Or that transgender people are oppressed. None of that is relevant here.
Because I just want you to think about how the women you love would *feel* if they were forced to change in front of a man.
Uncomfortable. Violated. Embarrassed. Afraid.
And if that doesnât trouble you - if you still insist this is all âcomplexâ - then I seriously worry for the women in your life.
Because they clearly cannot rely on you to protect them.
âThe people who have a problem with how we speak of men who claim to be women never - NEVER - have any criticisms for the men who tried to destroy our lives.â
Every word. đđđ
Trans activists are deplorable - but at least theyâre upfront. They donât try to hide their hatred of women. But thereâs a special place in hell for those who looked the other way while women were being abused and threatened. And gently shoved women under the bus while they thought no one was looking. Along with anyone supporting them.
Quoting @salltweets: I should probably tell this story more than I do:
@Glinner was the first âbig nameâ to support me when I was dragged into this ridiculous yet deeply consequential âfightâ. I was completely cancelled for committing the crime of not only knowing what a woman is but creating something exclusively for women. Graham reposted my words, giving me a bigger audience than Iâd ever had at a time when women like myself were expected to be silent & accept the destruction of our lives by the men who claim to be us. Not only that, he invested in my start up, putting his money where his mouth is by helping a woman run a woman only space when she desperately needed the help. He did it when his own life, career & livelihood were imploding, making his support even more admirable.
ââŚthough I havenât seen much of the showâs creator, Graham Linehan, and am baffled as to why he got involved in the culture wars. I feel sorry for him â heâs entitled to his opinions, but the way he presented them made it confrontational.â
The people who have a problem with how we speak of men who claim to be women never - NEVER - have any criticisms for the men who tried to destroy our lives. There isnât so much as a tone shift when they are referring to the men who routinely send us threats. Either they donât know itâs happening, so are willfully publicly commenting on an issue they know nothing about, or they are aware of it & think that life destruction/de*th threats are an appropriate response to knowing what a woman is.
A man claiming to be a woman is the confrontation & if more people had responded to it like Graham did, we wouldnât *still* be dealing with this absolute madness.
Thank you, @Glinner đЎ
When I was choosing quotes from inspiring women for my 2026 Courageous Planner, I caught myself doing something I hate: wondering whether any of the quotes Iâd picked might be considered âproblematic.â
And I stopped myself right there.
Because after everything Iâve experienced this year - being piled on and âcancelledâ simply for saying I donât like the phrase âpregnant peopleâ - the last thing Iâm going to do is start cancelling other women.
When they came for me, it wasnât about that one comment. Or disagreement with my gender-critical views. It was as if anything Iâd previously said or done they *did* like was instantly erased.
I was suddenly just a hateful, bigoted monster.
So when someone commented yesterday, âMargaret Atwood doesnât support women,â in response this quote (included in the planner) I had to smile.
Because while Atwood now has - to steal Baroness Falkner's phrase - some âunusual and surprisingâ views ⌠this quote is stonking.
And is still as relevant today as it was in 1982.
As someone who knows what it feels like to be erased for so-called 'wrongthink', I refuse to do the same to other women - including those whoâve inspired me in the past. Disagree with someoneâs views if you want. But cancelling their entire body of work? No thanks.
If we start using the same authoritarian silencing tactics on each other that weâve faced from trans activists, I believe we lose our power.
Maybe you disagree - and thatâs fine.
But surely we can disagree like adults.
And if you'd like to invest in my âTERF Plannerâ ⌠best do it before Margaret Atwood finds out sheâs featured and has the entire print run seized and pulped (I'm kidding ... obviously).
đ Link to purchase your 2026 COURAGEOUS PLANNER is in the comments. Use code WOMEN10 at checkout to save 10%.
****
P.S. Even if you donât want or need a planner, sharing this post helps get it in front of someone who does. If you appreciate my work, please consider sharing.
I felt the guy who was asking her what an adult human female was trying to get a âgotchaâ her by trying to make her say women need protecting from trans people. She didnât let that happen. At the same time, I think the public need reminding that saying yes to trans women means saying yes to any man. I think many struggle with this simple safeguarding issue.
About time too. đđđ
Although ITV still apparently not got the message about accurate, fact-based language.
Meanwhile NFWI chief executive Melissa Green said many members would find the decision to exclude men âextremely painfulâ.
She added: âHowever, this change is only in respect to our membership policy and does not change our firm belief that transgender women are women.â đ
âEveryone knows what a trans woman is,â proclaimed human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell in a recent GB News broadcast.
Except they donât - and thatâs exactly why accurate, sex-based language matters. Itâs not semantics. Itâs about womenâs safety.
In this interview, we talk language, the BBC - and what happens when women are cancelled for saying whatâs true. Here's a quick preview.
đ Full interview with @[private account] đ¤ đ drops tonight Wednesday 12 November @[private account] pm (GMT). Link in first comment (we'll be live in the chat) đ
Why does every conversation about protecting WOMEN get made about trans people? So back to WOMEN ⌠of all the settings where we really donât want predatory men entering spaces they shouldnât be in its hospitals. Because there are many vulnerable people in hospitals. Jimmy Savile used his âcelebrityâ status to gain access to women - and children in hospital settings - under the ruse of charity fundraising. WOMEN - female staff - raised the alarm about someone who was later proved to be a s*xual predator đ¨ and were not listened to.
In this case, 26 female members of staff raised valid concerns about ONE male entering a hospital space he shouldnât be in - and his behaviour whilst in that space. In doing so they highlighted a potential safeguarding risk - not only for themselves - but also for others - including many vulnerable people i.e. patients.
They were ignored.
In fact they werenât just ignored, they were told *they* were the problem.
In a hospital setting.
What part of this - which just basic safeguarding awareness - is so hard to understand?
I feel like itâs worse to say âI agree trans women should stay out of womenâs spaces. Except âŚâ Thatâs how women get hoodwinked into feeling sorry for men who actually have no regard for womenâs boundaries at all. Good men stay out - no ifs or buts.
Read the article here: https://www.auntminnieeurope.com/clinical-news/womens-imaging/article/15769702/transgender-breast-care-emerges-as-priority-for-radiology
When I was diagnosed with breast cancer, earlier this year, one of the most irritating things was how quickly people felt the need to âremindâ me that men can get breast cancer too.
Of course they can - no oneâs denying that. But around 99% of people diagnosed with breast cancer are women.
So yes, health professionals should absolutely be aware that men and trans-identifying people can develop breast cancer - and make sure patients are aware of the risks.
But thatâs not the same as claiming - as in this professional journal article - that âtransgender breast care should be a priority for radiology.â
Why should women be sidelined from a disease that overwhelmingly affects them?
Women who identify as men and have had mastectomies still understand their biology.
Itâs insulting to pretend otherwise.
And if they donât, itâs the job of healthcare professionals to explain that - compassionately, and based on evidence. Not to rebuild policy around the exceptions.
Health policy should be guided by proportion and biological reality - not ideology.
And that means keeping women - who represent 99% of breast cancer patients - front and centre.
Thanks @JournalismSEEN for highlighting this (link to read article in comments).
I think Iâve found the cure for the insufferably woke. You know the types who are offended by everything - and throw words like "ally" and "unsafe" into every conversation.
The answer? Make them live as a ginger for a week. đĽ
My hairâs faded to dark brown now - but as a natural ginger, I feel qualified to speak with some authority on the subject.
And weâre basically the only group left who arenât allowed to be offended by anything. Including people who openly - and unapologetically:
- Laugh at our appearance (and say theyâre glad they donât look like us)
- Say theyâre relieved their kids arenât ginger/are praying their future ones wonât be
- Speculate - loudly - about whatâs âbetween our legsâ (a complaint usually reserved for the trans community)
But as a ginger, youâre literally not allowed to be offended by ANY of it. If you donât laugh along, youâre told youâve âno sense of humour.â
In my experience, even the most painfully woke have no problem with a bit of 'ginger-bashing'.
In fact, they seem to positively enjoy it.
While itâs tiring hearing the same old tropes over and over, we do learn not to take it personally. And to accept that some people really are just massive d**kheads.
So maybe thatâs the answer.
Round up the woke and make them live as gingers.
Or at least shadow one for a week or two.
âCos we could certainly teach them a thing or two about tolerance - and not taking themselves too seriously. đ§Ą
Dear MP ⌠Iâm writing to complain about trans people being banned from bathrooms. I mean - technically - theyâre not actually banned at all. But thatâs a mere technicality. In truth, weâre pissed off that men can no longer get away with entering womenâs spaces - and claiming they have the right to do so - so weâve gotta say *something* right?
Iâm not really a religious person.
But religion is very much part of my culture. Raised in an Irish Catholic family. Married into another Irish Catholic family. Compulsory Sunday Mass, endless RE lessonsâŚ
And though I spent much of my childhood praying God wouldnât call me to be a nun, I do have a fondness for some of the slightly bonkers traditions - the 'Sacred Heart' picture by the door, the Mary statues, the relatives who come back from Lourdes with empty pill bottles full of holy water.
While there are many things I struggle with about the Catholic faith (and its history), I'm grateful for the moral grounding it gave me - that inner sense of right and wrong I can always come back to.
Which is why Iâm uneasy about the 'anything goes' direction some Christian faiths seem to be taking right now - particularly around the transgender movement (case in the point: the Canterbury Cathedral artist).
Because compassion and support for those struggling with gender identity are vital - but affirming someoneâs confusion, simply to appear kind, isnât truly kind at all. In fact, it feels deeply un-Christian to me.
Itâs a bit like parenting: being a good parent isnât about agreeing with everything your child says or does. Sometimes it means offering tough love, while staying present and supportive - which is actually far harder.
And, as Iâve said many times before, being good isnât the same as being 'nice'.
Trans women are men - which is why the âfight and flightâ still kicks in. Because wearing a dress does not make a man a woman. And when he looks into your eyes mockingly. Because heâs in your space and intimidating women makes him feel powerful and dominant. And he knows he could overpower you - even though heâs wearing a dress - yes he is being violent.
Trans activists have smashed one of the large front windows of the Brighton Centre - the venue where 2500 feminists are meeting this weekend to discuss (amongst other things) their sex-based rights, male violence and misogyny.
They've also painted this slogan on the window đđđ
'Feminism is the refusal to define a woman.'
In other words ... being a feminist now means saying women donât exist as a distinct biological sex. And that men are the authority on everything. Including feminism. đ
There are angry radicalised men outside the building- using violence to bully, harass and terrorise females. Who have gathered together to speak about women's' issues.
And if none of this seems problematic to you, I seriously do wonder.
Particularly if you're a woman.
âOut of respect for the trans community ⌠and the respect for pronouns ⌠I am using what are deemed to be the âcorrectâ pronouns in this case.â
What a dope. And I donât see âshowing respect for the trans communityâ in any journalistsâ code of conduct.
Whereas reporting events factually and truthfully - and without bias - is.
And what the heck is ârespect for pronounsâ?
It took me far too long to cop on
that womenâs rights, spaces and language were being erased by the trans movement - which favours âinclusionâ for everyone but women.
But once I saw it I couldnât unsee it. So I spoke up. And of course my life imploded dramatically - as it typically does for women who
speak up.
I shared my story in this recent podcast interview with @[private account]
Quotes a post by T08045; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Someone I went to school with recently said she felt I was âunkindâ to defend womenâs rights and spaces (because this makes trans people feel excluded).
During the course of this conversation this woman (who is a lesbian) talked about being a âtomboyâ and how she hated the way her mum tried to force her to wear dresses when was a child.
I wanted to say to her: âWell if
you were a teenager now, your
mum forcing you to wear dresses
may have been the least of your problems!â I didnât - because it was an unusually respectful discussion (but maybe I should have done).
Seeing this extract from @[private account] âs teenage diary reminded me of that conversation.
Because I remember a few girls like her from school. Who didnât seem to embrace being a young woman.
Some of them are lesbians.
Some of them arenât - theyâre just less stereotypically âfeminineâ than others. All of which is pretty unremarkable. Because we all know that make up and âgirlyâ clothes do not make you a girl/woman.
I did most of my adolescent years in
80s - a time when parents werenât obsessed with âparentingâ. Hence they barely seemed to notice if a boy preferred the girls clothes in the dressing up box or a girl preferred playing with soldiers to Sindy dolls.
As long as you were âoccupiedâ and not âgetting under their feetâ.
Iâm sure they did notice. But they didnât try to âfixâ everything.
âItâs just a phase,â is something I remember hearing peopleâs mums say to one another a lot.
And thereâs actually something quite healthy about giving your kids the freedom to have âphasesâ - without jumping in and trying to put a label on it.
Quotes a post by A2585; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I can't stop thinking about the fact that Laura Kuenssberg - a BBC journalist with decades of experience - did not challenge a male who claimed to take the contraceptive pill to 'prevent pregnancy'.
She was speaking to Victoria McCloud - previously the UK's only transgender judge - who is challenging the recent Supreme Court ruling on the definition of the word woman in equalities law.
Not only did she fail to challenge this claim in the moment, she didn't return to the topic later. There were more than 30 minutes remaining of the Newcast programme - plenty of time for a producer/editor
to flag it up.
As one of the most well known political journalists in the UK, we've seen Kuenssberg ask tough questions - many many times.
So why couldn't she challenge a male who appeared to believe he could get pregnant? đ¤
So disappointing to see gymnast @Simone_Biles attacking Riley Gaines for defending womenâs sport.
As @salltweets points out - a transgender category was created in swimming and no one entered. Which is typical across sports where this has been attempted.
That aside, Simone Biles appears to think @Riley_Gaines_ should be responsible for finding a solution for males who want to compete in womenâs categories.
But that isnât her responsibility.
Nor is it the responsibility of any female athlete who has been cheated out of their rightful placing, scholarship or prize money by a male participant.
Or any female athlete who has been forced to share a changing room with someone with a p*nis.
Instead of criticising women like Gaines, who put their livelihoods on the line to defend womenâs sport, perhaps Biles - and women who share her views - could redirect their energy into âfinding a wayâ to get trans people participating in sports.
In their rightful categories.
Quoting @Simone_Biles: @Riley_Gaines_ Youâre truly sick, all of this campaigning because you lost a race. Straight up sore loser. You should be uplifting the trans community and perhaps finding a way to make sports inclusive OR creating a new avenue where trans feel safe in sports. Maybe a transgender category IN ALL sports!!
But instead⌠You bully themâŚ
One things for sure is no one in sports is safe with you around!!!!!
I've now re-listened to the @[private account] interview with @[private account] CEO about the Supreme Court ruling. Here are the numbers* >>
- Women/Woman - 8 mentions
- Men - 2 mentions
- Trans - 14 mentions
So people who are NOT women were mentioned twice as many times - in a segment on women's sex-based rights.
The first question from @[private account] was: âWhat are Amnesty members telling you about the impact of this?â
Not: âWhat does the ruling mean for womenâs human rights?â
Sacha Deshmukh then spoke for a full five minutes on fear, harassment and discrimination. Of trans people. He didn't mention women once.
Next he suggested @HJoyceGender's reading of the ruling - that 'trans women are men' - was not just inaccurate, but also âdangerous.â
Seven minutes into a 15-minute segment, Rani finally asked a question about women's rights.
Deshmukh's answer focused on the persecution of trans people - pointing out they make up 1% of the population. Whilst seemingly unaware of the 51% he was ignoring (and the irony).
He brushed off a question on the @[private account] - saying 80% of violence towards women is carried out by partners/ex-partners/friends.
It appeared he couldnât think of single argument for giving biological women privacy over other groups.
The implication being that women should be happy to breastfeed, manage menstruation, undergo intimate medical care, undress - or anything else they'd really rather do in private - in any setting. Because to do otherwise would contribute to the 'persecution'.
His arguments were presented as a defence of human rights. For everyone except women.
On Woman's Hour.
*Estimate from transcript
Quoting @jan_murray: Just listened to this and found it quite uncomfortable listening.
Because it felt like @[private account] was challenging @KateBMwriting to justify the existence of lesbians. By pushing her to say men couldnât be lesbians - then saying some people might find that view offensive.
So I re-listened to the recent Robin Moira White interview (trans identifying man + barrister) to compare. But there were no questions that offered a similar level of âchallengeâ. Like:
- What do you mean when you use the word woman?
- What would you say to people who say trans women are men - and that you canât actually change sex?
- Some would argue that your beliefs are offensive to women - in fact many have - what would you say to that?
There was no challenge to Robin around identity versus biology at all. Yet Kate was subjected to the most idiotic questioning e.g. why she might want to exclude men from her dating pool as a lesbian.
In fact @[private account] even went on to clarify that Robinâs pronouns were she/her (after Kate had used âheâ and explained her reasoning).
And this is âWomanâs Hourâ. Just extraordinary.