The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Something that always strikes me when I see videos like this - and when I’ve gone along to events like this myself and tried to speak to trans activists …
There is SO much in the press about the overdiagnosis of autism and ADHD. It’s almost become a joke.
Meanwhile, pretty much every parent I speak to with a trans-identifying child tells me their child has a diagnosis of autism, ADHD or both. Or that they suspect this, but haven’t been able to access an assessment.
In some cases, their child was referred for ‘gender-affirming care’ before they’d even been screened for autism.
And anyone who knows anything about autism will know that characteristics such as ‘black and white’ thinking can make some autistic young people particularly vulnerable to being drawn into activism. By people who may not have their best interests at heart. Especially when it offers a sense of identity and belonging.
While outrageous amounts of money have been spent educating people about trans identities and promoting so-called ‘gender-affirming care’, parents are still struggling to get their children assessed for autism and ADHD - let alone access proper support.
And while we hear plenty about the supposed overdiagnosis of autism and ADHD, I hear far less discussion about why diagnoses are rising, whether we’re recognising young people who were previously overlooked, and what support they actually need.
Quotes a post by A2012; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No but 🙄🙄🙄 - but good to see the old chestnut about trans people driving buses.
I know they don't have many readers, but they would probably still be wise to acquaint themselves with defamation law ...
Will any so-called ‘trans rights’ groups condemn the death threat sent to the @[private account] I wonder?
According to the Daily Mail, an email threatened to “murder whoever doesn’t support trans rights”. It contained a photograph of a large kitchen knife, insisted it wasn’t a joke and warned that the sender knew where they worked.
These women took their employer to a tribunal after being required to share their changing room with a man. They stood up for their privacy and dignity at work - and won.
Yet three of them needed security guards to escort them to their cars after a day spent caring for patients. Seven stayed away from work while waiting for police to act.
A man has since been arrested and released on conditional bail while enquiries continue. But the nurses say police only took action after the Daily Mail intervened.
This is not the first time women have faced threats for defending their sex-based rights.
Condemning a death threat against women should be straightforward, whatever your views on their case.
Will any trans rights groups say so publicly?
Let’s see, shall we.
🚨 NEW: “If I was a trans boy, could I have a baby?”
A nine-year-old boy asked his mother that question. His school employed a male teacher who identified as non-binary and ran a lunchtime LGBT club. “We all call him the man in the dress,” one pupil told her.
For my Telegraph investigation, I spoke to parents about what happens when a male teacher asks pupils to call him ‘Miss’, or a non-binary teacher uses ‘Mx’, and what happened when parents raised concerns.
One mother said pupils worried they’d get into trouble for saying ‘Sir’. Other parents struggled to find out what was being discussed in lunchtime LGBT clubs.
Every family I interviewed asked to remain anonymous. They feared repercussions for their children.
I’ll be following up in [Un]Captured with some of the stories that didn’t make it into the piece.
Link below (gift link) 👇
‘Progress takes time’: Stonewall CEO on turning down the heat on the trans debate https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/progress-takes-time-stonewall-ceo-on-turning-down-the-heat-on-the-trans-debate?CMP=share_btn_url
May be flattering myself here… but the Girlguiding trans activists have published a selection of Halloween costumes.
One of them is a ‘sad journalist’. ☹️
I think that might be me. 🤣
They’re not terribly keen on me reporting on their campaign to get boys back into Girlguiding.
Can’t really see myself wearing that shirt, though …
"Eventually, I stopped trying to explain and accepted that trans activism had secured one victory.
Whatever the outcome of the legal dispute, I felt I had become the problem for challenging what had happened to us."
This was painful to write - but also strangely healing.
Thanks @jo_bartosch for publishing this in the @TERF_Times
Link to read below 👇
It sounded pretty … until you reminded yourself what the words were (different variations of trans girls are girls)
Quoting @jan_murray: I went along to the Girlguiding protest this afternoon against the “boy ban” which comes into force tomorrow following last year’s Supreme Court ruling.
Having covered trans activism within Girlguiding for the Telegraph, it was slightly surreal seeing some of the activists in person.
It was also possibly the first protest involving trans activists I’ve attended where nobody told me to f**k off.
The event was very well organised: no abusive placards*, no swearing and everyone impeccably polite.
There was face painting and colouring, bubbles and glitter.
And then the singing.
I mean, how many protests have you been to where women start singing what sounded like campfire songs in harmony?
Only most seemed to include some variation of the refrain: “trans girls are girls”.
I introduced myself as a journalist and asked whether anyone might be willing to speak to me.
Initially, I thought someone might.
Then I suspect word got around that I was THAT journalist.
Things became a tiny bit more hostile - mostly people standing in front of my camera and waving flags.
This was particularly noticeable when Petra Wenham spoke about how painful it was no longer to be able to belong to the Women’s Institute.
Wenham is the male trans activist who famously appeared on the cover of the WI’s membership magazine.
I stayed around afterwards hoping one of the Girlguiding activists might speak to me.
Apparently not.
Another freelance journalist seemed rather more welcome and was busy interviewing people.
There is much more to say about what I saw and heard today, and I’ll do that in a longer piece.
But I left with an overwhelming sense of sadness.
More to follow.
*Well maybe apart from this one?!
While volunteering as a run leader, I walked into the ladies to find a little boy sitting on the loo with the door open.
I immediately reported it. Safeguarding procedures kicked in. His mum was found, asked to remove her son from the ladies and reminded of the rules.
Quite right too.
But some of the same people involved believe that trans women are women - and that boys can be girls if they say they are.
So what if that little boy had simply said: “I’m a girl”?
Would the safeguarding concern suddenly disappear?
That is the absurdity we are living with.
I went along to the Girlguiding protest this afternoon against the “boy ban” which comes into force tomorrow following last year’s Supreme Court ruling.
Having covered trans activism within Girlguiding for the Telegraph, it was slightly surreal seeing some of the activists in person.
It was also possibly the first protest involving trans activists I’ve attended where nobody told me to f**k off.
The event was very well organised: no abusive placards*, no swearing and everyone impeccably polite.
There was face painting and colouring, bubbles and glitter.
And then the singing.
I mean, how many protests have you been to where women start singing what sounded like campfire songs in harmony?
Only most seemed to include some variation of the refrain: “trans girls are girls”.
I introduced myself as a journalist and asked whether anyone might be willing to speak to me.
Initially, I thought someone might.
Then I suspect word got around that I was THAT journalist.
Things became a tiny bit more hostile - mostly people standing in front of my camera and waving flags.
This was particularly noticeable when Petra Wenham spoke about how painful it was no longer to be able to belong to the Women’s Institute.
Wenham is the male trans activist who famously appeared on the cover of the WI’s membership magazine.
I stayed around afterwards hoping one of the Girlguiding activists might speak to me.
Apparently not.
Another freelance journalist seemed rather more welcome and was busy interviewing people.
There is much more to say about what I saw and heard today, and I’ll do that in a longer piece.
But I left with an overwhelming sense of sadness.
More to follow.
*Well maybe apart from this one?!
After around 25 years, I’ve resigned my NUJ membership.
I kept paying my monthly subs even when I was running my marketing business full-time because I still wrote the occasional piece - and because I wanted the reassurance of having union support if anything ever arose from something I’d written in the past.
But, like many trade unions, the NUJ increasingly seems to have little to say in support of women as a sex class.
Its response to the revised EHRC Code of Practice was dreadful. Given that the Code follows a landmark ruling clarifying the meaning of “sex” and “woman” in equality law, I would have expected the rights and concerns of women to be front and centre.
Instead, the statement seemed far more focused on reassuring trans and non-binary members. Women felt like an afterthought.
I was also deeply uncomfortable with its statement following Jason Arday’s death, which seemed to stray from defending journalists into policing which ideas and sources are considered acceptable.
A journalists’ union should surely be defending journalists’ freedom to question, investigate and report on contested ideas - not telling them which ideas are acceptable.
I wasn't saying the term 'trans women' was the right one. I was saying it's the one my mum understands! My point was more that these are the kinds of conversations that need to be happening in newsrooms - rather than using activist language (from either side).
More footage from ‘family friendly’ Manchester Pride.
Men in budgie smugglers high-fiving young children - alongside the trans mascot inflatable sharks.
A wholesome family day out, apparently.
Quotes a post by A2162; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yeah I do sometimes use trans identifying on my FB page.
Anyway this agreeable disagreement is far too respectful.
I now feel compelled to tell you are a Nazi, bigot, homophobic, transphobic, biphobic and only care about this topic ‘cos you’re dog ugly and no one wants to f**k you 🤣 (actually I think only women get the latter).
For the record though I think ‘trans identifying’ creates dissonance - and is also activist language. As journalists I think we should be reaching for the phrases that allow audiences to understand - not what people say we ‘should’ be using. That’s ideological too.
What do you think is a better phrase? ‘Man who identifies as a woman’ is my preferred - but my experience in ‘real life’ is that people generally do get ‘trans women’. But my point wasn’t really - this is the phrase I think is best. More that these feel like the kind of conversations newsrooms should be having … and yet they are not.
“If men can run in the women’s category, it’s a mixed-sex category.”
Former Olympian @[private account] spells out the problem with parkrun’s current policy in this interview with @[private account] on @GBNEWS
Nobody is calling for trans people to be banned from parkrun. They are simply asking for one of its four categories to be reserved for women and girls, she says.
Because when males are allowed to register as female, women lose placings and records - and the message is clear: men’s feelings matter more than women’s achievements.
That's why people get it - they know it means 'not real' - which is helpful for understanding. Whereas using trans identifying male/female can be a bit like trying to put a duvet cover on a duvet .... people are like, wait what, do you mean ..... ?
Whenever I publish an important piece like today’s Mail story on men competing in women’s parkrun categories, one thing is almost guaranteed: some of the first criticism will be about the language rather than the substance of the story.
So I thought it might be helpful to explain how things actually work in the mainstream media - and the pressures sex-realist/ gender-critical journalists are navigating behind the scenes.
First, let’s not forget that most mainstream publications still wouldn’t even touch a story asking a question as basic as: why are men still being allowed to compete in women’s sporting categories and steal their achievements.
There are still only a handful of mainstream outlets prepared to publish these kinds of stories: the Daily Mail, Telegraph, GB News, Talk and, sometimes, The Times.
And even there, gender-critical journalists and editors can be up against it.
I regularly see people saying journalists should simply refuse to use terms such as “trans woman”, insist on “man” and “woman”, or walk away from publications that won’t use exactly the terminology they want.
But I’m afraid journalism doesn’t work like that.
Let's not forget that parts of the media have been 'captured' - as they have in most industries. Which means there are trans activists in newsrooms too. Even in outlets that will cover these kinds of stories.
And, as in other sectors, it only takes one activist - or one person with a trans identifying relative - to make everyone start treading on eggshells.
Even media regulators like IPSO and Ofcom face these kind of pressures.
So when you see a story like mine today, please don’t underestimate what may have gone on behind the scenes just to get it published.
Sometimes somebody has had to stick their neck out simply to get “she/her” removed when referring to a man - because that may still be what a publication’s style guide says.
Recently, I discovered to my horror that an important piece I had written was due to appear using “she/her” throughout for someone who was clearly male. At the last minute it was changed to “they/them”.
Still not my preference.
But better.
As an independent journalist, I also don’t have the luxury of simply walking away every time an editor makes a language choice I dislike. Sometimes you have to ask: does the benefit of getting an important story in front of hundreds of thousands of people outweigh wording that isn’t exactly what I would have chosen?
But there is another side to this.
Journalists also need to be careful not to replace activist language from one side of a contested debate with activist language from the other.
For example, terms such as “trans-identifying male” or “trans-identifying female” may be favoured by some gender-critical campaigners, but to many ordinary audiences they are unfamiliar and confusing.
And our job as journalists is not to write in the language of a movement. It is to be accurate, clear and understood.
To put this into context, if I talk to my mum about trans identifying males/females, she'll typically assume I mean the opposite.
If I say “trans woman”, she at least understands who I mean - and that I’m not talking about an *actual* woman.
So by all means challenge broadcasters and publications over inaccurate or misleading language.
Members of @JournalismSEEN do this every day - sometimes at risk to their own jobs/financial security.
But do also bear in mind the reality of getting these stories into the mainstream at all - and that the journalists doing so may already be pushing much harder behind the scenes than the public ever see.
The BBC has published a gender-critical play.
No … this is not a joke.
And it’s actually pretty good.
The play explores the relationship between a mother and her 17-year-old daughter, who leaves the family home after adopting a “non-binary” identity.
It’s a painful listen at times - not least because the script is spookily accurate and could have been lifted straight from the trans-activist playbook.
The frustrating thing is that those who most need to hear it probably won’t listen.
Because trans activism has created a culture in which some people claim they cannot even read, watch or hear anything that challenges their worldview.
Which is precisely why content like this matters.
Link to listen below 👇
Woman gets ‘peaked’ in real time (although will likely never admit it).
This is an uncomfortable watch. You can see Vanessa Feltz knows she is way out of her depth and doesn’t have a single valid argument to support trans ideology.
Quoting @AndrewGold_ok: That escalated fast! I didn't intend to have this debate with mainstream TV host Vanessa Feltz. Who do you think is right?
Watch the full thing in 1st reply.
Did the penny drop over the trans issue for Vanessa Feltz in this interview?
I think it did - but feel sure she’ll never
admit it.
Feltz argued vociferously that the trans identifying men she’d interviewed in the 90s were poor, tortured souls. And therefore we should all be more kind yada yada.
She barely let @AndrewGold_ok speak when he tried to explain that, back then, these men weren’t trying to convince us they were *actually* women.
Feltz is an incredibly bright woman.
Which may be why she suddenly clammed up and claimed she didn’t know much about the issue.
Quoting @AndrewGold_ok: She's been a legendary TV host for decades. We just argued about everything. Vanessa Feltz called me nasty.
But was I being nasty? And does this perfectly encapsulate the difference between the mainstream and independents?
One of the most disturbing responses I keep seeing to concerns about cross-dressing men around children - is:
“I’d rather leave my child with a trans-identifying man than a priest.”
The grim irony is that priests are also men in frocks - and society learnt the hardest possible way that membership of a trusted or supposedly virtuous group does not exempt anyone from safeguarding.
Adults who seek access to children will exploit whatever position offers it. That is precisely why safeguarding procedures now apply in churches, schools, Scouts, Girlguiding and elsewhere. They exist because trust, status and good intentions are not enough.
Yet some people appear to believe that a man putting on a dress and declaring himself a woman somehow makes him inherently safe - or that questioning his access to women and children is itself hateful.
It does not. He remains male, and the overwhelming majority of sexual and violent offending is committed by males. Identity does not erase sex, and compassion does not require us to abandon ordinary safeguarding principles.
None of this means every man - or every trans-identifying man - is dangerous. Safeguarding has never worked by declaring entire groups guilty. It works by recognising patterns of risk, maintaining appropriate boundaries and applying the same rules consistently.
These may be uncomfortable truths. That is precisely why they must not be ignored.
This choir is looking for new members - and provides a great example of how gender ideology ties organisations in knots.
Electric Belles describes itself as a choir for “women and non-binary people” - which could include both sexes.
But an Instagram post says it welcomes singers in the soprano and alto ranges. That’s an important qualification - because those are female vocal ranges.
In other words, males are excluded.
If that's the case, why not say so?
Sex matters - even in singing.
Because men and women's voices are different
A mixed-sex choir may need to accommodate everything from high sopranos to low basses, which can significantly influence its repertoire.
A single sex choir is a different proposition entirely.
Case in point: as someone who runs a mostly female choir, I know the frustration of finding a song we want to sing only to discover the backing tracks are available solely in “men’s keys”.
So can a 'non-binary' man join Electric Belles only if he can sing soprano or alto? Could a woman with a lower voice be turned away? What about trans-identifying singers whose voices may not correspond with their sex?
In its attempt to sound inclusive, this choir has made a simple membership policy needlessly confusing.
Gender ideology strikes again.
Looks like it's Non-Binary Fortnight at Metro.
(Aug 9) A Black non-binary dad on the joys of being Black, Brown, trans or queer in the countryside.
(Aug 15) A non-binary mother who complains that being a mother gives people “permission” to see her as a woman.
(Aug 16) A non-binary nanny - and the four-year-old who’s her “biggest LGBT ally”.
“I began to see that I thrive in the plurality of gender… letting my masculine and feminine energies co-exist together,” says the non-binary nanny.
Who refers to children as “niblings”.
Righto.
Any idea when TERF Fortnight starts?
Girls On The Go describes itself as a “girl-only health and wellness community” whose mission is to make Britain “a less lonely place for women”.
But it seems to be in a bit of a muddle about what “girl-only” actually means.
In a recent Instagram post, GOTG Liverpool announced it's“not open to all girls” - followed by a 17-point list of women who are not welcome.
Top of the list are women who believe protecting women’s spaces means excluding “trans women” - i.e. men.
Also unwelcome are women who do not hold the prescribed views on:
- Preferred pronouns: good
- “Misgendering”: bad
- Reform: bad
- English flags: bad
- “Queer” identities: good
- Abortion: good
- Biological reality: bad
- Immigration and refugees: good
- “Body positivity”: good
- “White feminism”: bad
Members must also share the group’s assessment of events in Palestine, Iran, Congo, Ukraine and Sudan - and be willing to speak publicly about political issues.
These are all subjects on which women may hold differing and nuanced views. But there appears to be little room for nuance in the GOTG community.
This is not simply about ensuring members behave respectfully. It is an ideological purity test.
Males who identify as women are welcome in this supposedly “girl-only” community.
Women who hold lawful beliefs about sex - or vote for the wrong political party - are not.
Oh the irony.
An organisation claiming to combat loneliness among women is explicitly excluding women who fail to subscribe to its political worldview.
Perhaps it should stop calling itself “girl-only”.
Because it appears to actually be “ideology-only”.
Any civil servants feeling disgruntled about losing their 13 weeks’ paid “gender reassignment leave” might want to give 'Pip & Nut' a try.
This leading nut-butter company is offering:
- Paid leave for “gender-affirming” appointments, surgery and recovery
- Flexible working to accommodate appointments
- Time off for employees supporting trans or non-binary partners and family members
- Free therapy for the family members of trans and non-binary people - provided through NutshellMHS
- Compulsory pronoun and “gender-neutral language” education for the entire workforce - so your colleagues will all be suitably terrified of 'misgendering' you
Pip & Nut has also declared that it does not support the EHRC’s guidance on single-sex spaces.
It’s an extraordinary package - although, frankly, I’d expect nothing less from a leading nut-butter retailer.
"Does this now mean that a trans woman who was born a man but now lives her life as a woman, dresses like a woman, lives her life as a woman has a woman's name, refers to herself as she and her. Does this mean she would have to use the male facilities?'
A question from a BBC presenter about the new EHRC guidance on single sex spaces.
I recommend reading it a few times to fully appreciate how absurd it is.
Not least because wearing women's clothes and using a woman's name does not make you a woman.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: PART 2 ➡️ Last week, BBC Three Counties devoted an hour-long segment to the new EHRC Code on single-sex spaces. It featured three men talking for around 30 minutes - but no female guest to explain why women's single-sex spaces matter.
We've since learned that a suitable organisation was approached for an interview, but was then told it was not needed.
Last week's post (link below) looked at the omission of female voices. But the framing of the discussion is notable too - starting with the title: 'is it right to tell transgender people which toilet to use?'
The presenter Jonathan Vernon-Smith followed up with:
"My question to you today is: is that right, or does that seem unnecessarily unkind and mean?”
But the new EHRC Code isn't an optional act of kindness. It sets out how organisations are expected to comply with equality law following the Supreme Court's ruling that "sex" in the Equality Act means biological sex
Vernon-Smith introduced his first guest, barrister Robin Moira White, apologising in advance in case he used language that might be considered 'offensive'. Later, he repeated a similar message to a caller.
But it's not "offensive" to state the truth. Saying that a man is a man is factually correct.
White also made a number of significant claims that went largely unchallenged. Including:
- Excluding a trans-identifying male from female toilets would "probably" amount to discrimination
- Members of the public could become "toilet police"
- There are "around 40 times" as many 'butch lesbians' as trans people
- The changes could cost "several billion" pounds
- The Supreme Court ruling is likely to be reversed within two or three years
Robin Moira White has a distinctly male voice, yet female pronouns were used throughout the interview. Later, listeners were introduced to "Michelle" from Watford as a woman, only to hear another distinctly male voice.
That creates the kind of dissonance that leaves listeners questioning whether they heard correctly.
Good journalism should help audiences understand what they're hearing, not leave them wondering whether they've misunderstood it.
It’s isn't about helping audiences arrive at a preferred conclusion.
It's about helping them understand the facts clearly enough to reach their own.
Fulham FC have unveiled their third kit.
Its pastel blue, pink and white colour scheme has prompted fans to speculate that it was designed to resemble the trans flag.
One Instagram user wrote:
"trans flag kit 🤭🤣🏳️⚧️"
The club hasn't said that's the inspiration.
But fans may be onto something. Fulham owner Tony Khan is also founder and CEO of All Elite Wrestling (AEW) - the first major US wrestling promotion to sign an openly transgender wrestler during his tenure.
Some fans, however. seem distinctly unimpressed.
Instagram comments include:
"Thank God the away kit is decent."
"Awful, thank God we won't use it that much."
"Did the club tell adidas, 'it can be sky blue pink for all we care…'"
That 17k figure comes from the more withdrawn Amnesty ‘Like A Snowball’ report - which, in the organisation’s words, did not meet their own standards of professionalism. One of the problems of course was the definition they were using for anti-trans which appears to have included stating, correctly, that a man is a man. I do have sympathy for trans people on this. Many organisations have published false information on this topic - suicide statistics being another prominent example. As these kinds of falsehoods are being exposed, I should imagine it does feel uncomfortable for some people who identify as trans. They may feel it reflects badly on them - even though they personally had no part in it. But that is no justification for continuing to promote falsehoods.
A governor at this NHS Trust has spent the last 18 months trying to get them to update their transgender and single sex policies.
Trying to get them to understand that they placed women and children at risk - in a Trust that deals with some of the most vulnerable patients in society.
I've seen all the evidence.
Letters, emails, meetings, transcripts, FOIs.
At one meeting, he talked them through the Darlington Nurses and Sandie Peggie cases - sending them video/clips, newspaper cuttings and so on.
Last year, they reassured him they were looking at the policies. But a recent FOI revealed no action had been taken.
Last month, he publicly opposed the reappointment of the Trust's chair - over the mishandling of this matter.
They still didn't take action.
My latest for @Telegraph
Quoting @jan_murray: 🚨 BREAKING >> Staff at an NHS trust received an email on Wednesday telling them there would be “no immediate changes” to its policies following new statutory EHRC guidance on single-sex spaces.
Those policies allow men who identify as women to be placed on women’s hospital wards - and to use toilets, showers and changing rooms intended for female staff.
A public governor has been challenging the policies for more than 18 months, including raising his concerns with the EHRC and even publicly objecting to the reappointment of the Trust’s chair.
Yet nothing has changed.
Truly one of the most extraordinary stories I’ve worked on this year. My latest @Telegraph
Link below 👇
Why are trans-identifying media guests often treated with kid gloves?
It seems even the toughest of interviewers will accept ‘lived experience’ - with very little scrutiny.
Women, meanwhile, are expected to defend their position - often against what feels like hostile attack.
My latest from @spikedonline ⬇️
Why are men who want to enter women’s toilets given such sympathetic coverage in the media?
My latest for @[private account] looks at how even the fiercest interviewers seem to lose their nerve when covering trans issues.
To the point that they won’t even challenge ridiculous claims. Such as the suggestion the new EHRC guidance on single-sex spaces will mean trans people have to piss their pants in the street.
Link below 👇
This Tunbridge Wells bookshop has opened its loo to trans people - to support them during this “difficult time”.
I used to live in TW and can think of several public facilities nearby, so I’m not entirely sure why this would be necessary.
That aside, why restrict this act of kindness to trans people?
I do hope the offer also extends to pregnant women, people with IBD, disabled people and anyone else who may get caught short while out shopping.
This MP says I “hate trans people.”
Why? Because I believe - correctly - that human beings cannot change sex.
If you agree with me, she believes you hate trans people too.
I don’t know about you, but I have strong feelings about elected representatives making sweeping accusations like this about people they disagree with.
@[private account] is entitled to her personal views.
What I object to is an elected MP using her platform to make false and inflammatory claims about members of the public who hold a lawful belief, while showing such open disdain for the people she was elected to represent.
After all, many of her constituents are likely to share my views.
Public office requires a degree of fairness, professionalism and respect - especially towards those who disagree with you.
If an MP cannot engage respectfully with the public - without resorting to caricature and smears - I don’t believe they deserve to hold public office.
Quotes a post by T04890; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Janet, can you explain to me why single-sex spaces are so important to women?" @mrmarkdolan asked me in an interview this afternoon.
Such a simple question. Yet one I rarely hear journalists ask women.
Far more often we're asked why we object to using she/her pronouns for males, whether we understand how upsetting exclusion can be, or told that the real issue is male violence against women - not trans people using our toilets/changing rooms.
I'm sure it won't surprise anyone that Dolan broadly agrees with me. But that's irrelevant.
On the day the new EHRC guidance on single-sex spaces came into force, every journalist should have been asking women this question - and genuinely wanting to understand the answer. Regardless of any personal views they may hold.
If you're trying to help audiences understand what has become a highly contested issue, you have to ask women why single-sex spaces matter to them in the first place - and let audiences hear the answer so they can reach their own conclusions.
Full interview available over on @TalkTV
“Trans-identifying” is not prohibited language, and Ofcom’s due-impartiality rules do not require every guest expressing a view to be accompanied by someone with the opposing view. Nor do they require equal airtime.
You are, of course, free to complain - but announcing your complaint before apparently hearing the interview rather suggests your objection is to my participation, rather than anything actually broadcast.
Currently listening to James O'Brien's LBC segment on the EHRC Code.
A trans-identifying person has just talked about wetting themselves outside a toilet.
Not only did this go unchallenged - it elicited sympathetic "hmmms" from O'Brien.
When is a journalist going to ask the obvious follow-up question?
Why would you urinate on yourself when you could use a gender-neutral toilet - or, if one isn't available, the facilities for your biological sex?
Why are they so afraid of asking an obvious - and reasonable - question?
Discovering your partner is same sex attracted can be distressing and have life changing implications.
Discovering your male partner believes they were born in the wrong body and wants you to affirm them as the opposite sex - including, potentially, continuing your relationship as a 'lesbian' - even though you are same sex attracted is really not really comparable.
Especially if you have children, who may now be expected to affirm their father's identity as female.
And participate in his delusion that he is a woman.
I'm taking a guess here, but I imagine you also tell women they shouldn't object to 'Cis' - it's just a word after all. Yet women whose partners subject them to what many would regard as coercive abuse, must not call themselves 'trans widows.'
Listen to this gay man explain why gender identity ideology can undermine the rights of gay, lesbian, bisexual and straight people.
He argues that nobody should be pressured to include people in their dating pool if they don't align with their sexual orientation.
Nor should anyone be labelled homophobic, biphobic, transphobic - or anything else - simply for stating their sexual boundaries.
He also explains how the steady expansion of gender identity categories can gradually erode social and safeguarding boundaries, shifting what people feel able to question or challenge.
It wasn't so long ago that saying "trans women are women" or "women can have penises" would have been regarded as extraordinary.
Today, those ideas are repeated by governments, public bodies and influential institutions.
That's why language matters. It doesn't just describe reality. Over time, it shapes what society comes to accept.
Which can, ultimately, be dangerous.
I watched this episode of the BBC's 'Red Flag' series last night.
It's a horrific story about a young woman drawn into an abusive relationship with someone she believed was a man. Her partner later claimed to have transitioned from male to female, before admitting it was all a lie: they had always been female and had never transitioned.
The abuse was physical, financial and coercive. She was isolated from her family, manipulated into staying, and subjected to sex by deception using a prosthetic penis.
The programme's experts identified several classic "red flags": love bombing, moving the relationship too quickly, and restricting contact with family and friends.
But what was striking was the red flags they didn't discuss.
In one scene, the victim talks about feeling torn between wanting to support her partner and recognising that she simply wasn't same-sex attracted.
Yet none of the experts said what seemed to me the obvious thing: it is entirely legitimate to end a relationship because your partner is not the sex you are attracted to.
We've heard similar accounts from so-called "trans widows" - partners of people who later identify as transgender - who describe feeling pressured to remain in relationships that no longer reflect their sexual orientation.
Then there was the inaccurate use of pronouns. The perpetrator was referred to as "he" and "him" throughout, even after it became clear they were female and had never transitioned. The victim, meanwhile, used "they/them".
The BBC's editorial guidance says it uses people's preferred pronouns. But what about accuracy? Continuing to describe someone as "he" after the programme had established they were female only made an already complicated story more difficult to follow.
I came away thinking that one of the biggest red flags wasn't simply the deception itself. It was the pressure the victim felt to override her own sexual orientation to stay in the relationship. Which was barely mentioned at all.
Link below 👇
A female NHS employee shared a disturbing story with me.
A colleague asked a patient who identified as a trans woman whether they would prefer a female member of staff to carry out an intimate examination.
The patient said yes.
So she had to do it.
The patient was clearly male - and appeared to be sexually aroused. Both by having his female identity affirmed and by being intimately examined by a woman.
She was left feeling deeply distressed and questioning why her employer had placed her in that position.
What kind of employer subjects female staff to an experience many would reasonably regard as abusive?
The police are facing similar questions.
Link below 👇
The author of this NION blog post is right; disabled people should not be expected to accommodate people who identify differently from their biological sex in their spaces.
But that's where the agreement ends.
Because any meaningful discussion on this topic has to begin with understanding of the issues at play.
And the writer appears to fundamentally misunderstand why women object to males using female-only spaces.
They cite the Darlington nurses' changing room dispute as an example - claiming the nurses felt uncomfortable sharing a changing room with someone who was 'different'.
That wasn't the issue.
The nurses objected because 'Rose' was male.
To suggest otherwise, fundamentally misrepresents both the problem - and the people involved.
The obvious solution is to redesign toilets and other public facilities so they are all gender-neutral, they argue.
So let's imagine, for a moment, it was proposed that disabled facilities in public venues should be fundamentally redesigned.
As someone who uses those facilities, would they be happy for those changes to be imposed without disabled people ever being asked for their views? I rather suspect not.
And they'd be right to be outraged if this happened. Yet that is exactly what has happened to women.
Who have never been consulted on whether they are willing to give up single-sex spaces in favour of gender-neutral provision.
The article concludes that "this isn't just about toilets", but about disabled and trans people being pushed out of everyday life and treated as an afterthought.
Has it crossed the writer's mind, I wonder, that many women feel exactly the same way? Because women are also a protected group under the Equality Act.
Yet many feel they are the ones being pushed out of spaces created specifically for them - without even being consulted.
Most strikingly of all, the article overlooks the simplest solution: that everyone uses the facilities that correspond with their biological sex. T
his protects women's single-sex spaces, preserves accessible facilities for disabled people, and is entirely consistent with the Supreme Court's interpretation of the Equality Act.
Curiously, that option isn't discussed at all.
Link to read blog post below 👇
The Scouts’ 2026 “Pride” range.
Includes: pronoun badges, “6 Ways to be an LGBTQ+ Ally” badges, Progress Pride neckers and woggles, trans, non-binary and lesbian fleur-de-lis badges, “Pride is Every Day” patches, rainbow flags, “Ask me about my pronouns” pins and a wide range of Pride clothing and accessories.
This isn’t simply about saying everyone is welcome.
It’s the promotion and normalisation of a contested set of beliefs about sex and gender within one of Britain’s largest youth organisations.
Scouts are, of course, free to decide what values they wish to promote. Parents are equally free to decide whether those values align with their own.
But worth remembering that every purchase helps fund the organisation, with the Scout Store stating that “all profits are returned to the Scouts.”
Every politician who’s ‘given it some thought’ and concluded that women cannot have penises and trans women are not women should be asked:
- Why did an apparently well-educated person like you publicly claim to believe something so obviously stupid?
- Will you apologise to the gender-critical women who have been smeared, silenced or cancelled for holding the position you now take?
It took me four months to find a mainstream media outlet willing to publish what I regarded as an obvious public-interest story about safeguarding in a children’s organisation.
The story involved a Girlguiding volunteer who had publicly posted highly sexualised content online.
Why was it so difficult to get published? Because the volunteer was a ‘trans woman’.
As JK Rowling put it:
“If an actual woman had behaved like this while in a position of authority over underage girls it would have been front-page news on every paper.”
In my latest piece for @spikedonline I explore why so much of the mainstream media still appears to be running scared of the trans lobby - and why it’s dangerous.
Link below👇
Bill is trying to pretend people are disturbed by rows of Progress Pride flags in central London because they ‘hate trans people’.
He says I should ‘fuck off’ for pointing out that they look sinister.
Touchy eh?
Quotes a post by T18937; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Abuse is not acceptable and I am genuinely sorry you’ve experienced that.
But we do need to be honest about what constitutes abuse.
Carrying out your work as a journalist is not abuse. Stating, factually, that a trans woman is male is not abuse.
Using slurs, doxxing people and threatening them with violence is abuse.
I've just spent some time trying to compile a list of famous women who have publicly expressed gender-critical views.
Actresses. Musicians. TV personalities. Sportswomen. Authors. Household names.
And honestly, I struggled.
It's much easier to think of men.
Which strikes me as odd, because the vast majority of people believe that it is not possible to change sex.
And most ordinary women I speak to privately are genuinely shocked by cases such as the Darlington nurses - where female nurses were required to share a changing room with a male colleague who identified as a woman, and were then told that they were the problem for objecting.
So why the silence?
I can only conclude that women, much more so than men, are afraid to say what they really think.
They've watched women such as Sharron Davies and Róisín Murphy speak out about biological sex and then talk openly about professional opportunities disappearing, along with income.
They've seen the years of abuse directed at JK Rowling, regardless of her wealth or status.
That's not to say that men who speak publicly about these issues don't receive abuse. They do.
But the abuse directed at women often feels qualitatively different. Women who speak about biological sex and sex-based rights are routinely subjected not just to insults, but to rape threats, death threats and explicitly degrading, sexualised abuse designed to humiliate and dehumanise them.
However the part I find most concerning is this:
Whatever your views on the trans issue itself, how can anyone look at the way women have been treated - simply for expressing an opinion about their own rights, bodies and sports - and not conclude that something has gone badly wrong?
Perhaps many people do think that.
Perhaps they're simply too afraid to say that too.
But I think it was Sall Grover who said that if all the women who've stayed silent spoke up at once, that would be it.
That's all it would take to reveal how small the number of true believers really is.
And yet, still, so many remain silent.
That fear tells us everything.
I once saw a TikTok where the creator was saying that people could support trans/non binary people struggling by cooking their meals/doing their laundry. Apparently being a good 'ally' means you have to wash people's pants.
I love how TRAs accuse you of making anything up they'd rather you didn't say. If I was saying 'trans women are women' (which is provably false) they'd be clapping like seals.
Oof. This @TimesRadio interview with Green Party Mayor of Hackney Zoe Garbett is pure second-hand embarrassment.
When pushed, she says trans women in Hackney should be able to use women's spaces.
But she spends most of the interview trying not to actually say that. Presumably because she knows the legal and political difficulties with doing so.
Instead, she deflects to domestic violence, claims the Supreme Court ruling doesn't protect women, and repeats that "trans women are women" and face high levels of sexual violence.
None of which engage with the substance of the question - or the law.
Disappointing to see a lawyer and Stonewall trustee attempting to undermine the Supreme Court judgement - with historical analogies that conflate sex with race and sexual orientation.
The historical examples Steven Friel cites involve groups being excluded because of prejudice against an innate characteristic. As if this is just another civil rights struggle. That is not what is happening here.
What Friel appears to fundamentally misunderstand is that trans-identifying males are not excluded from female-only spaces because of prejudice or hostility.
They are excluded because they are male.
And because the law recognises that biological sex remains a relevant and protected category.
This is therefore not a question of society "catching up", gaining greater tolerance or becoming more enlightened, as happened with race or gay rights. It is a question of whether biological sex matters in law and in society.
The Supreme Court's answer was that it does. Which makes it surprising to see a lawyer overlook such a fundamental distinction.
Ironically, while arguing that this debate should not be reduced to "bathroom wars", Friel's argument never really moves beyond bathrooms.
For many women, this debate is about far more than toilets. It is about the preservation of single-sex spaces, women's rights and opportunities, fairness in sport, and maintaining clear sex-based boundaries and safeguarding protections.
Read below 👇
The TRUK United documentary We'll Go Down in History - about the UK's first trans football team - begins a wider public release tomorrow.
I'll reserve judgement until I've seen it. But on the face of it, the idea of a trans football team sounds like a sensible approach to fairness in sport: people who identify as a different sex forming their own teams and competitions
What it cannot do, however, is make a man an 'amazing woman'. Or somebody's 'wife.'
The Government has published draft legislation to ban so-called "conversion therapy", including in relation to gender identity.
Ministers say parents have nothing to worry about and that ordinary conversations with children will be protected.
I hope they're right.
But I'm far from convinced.
Because, in many ways, it feels like we're going backwards. Growing up in the 1980s, parents understood that puberty was a confusing time and that young people didn't need to rush into putting labels on themselves.
Yet in 2026, it seems sensible, boundaried parenting is becoming something parents are afraid to practise.
My own child wasn't even out of primary school before I was hearing that classmates were "coming out" as gay or bisexual on Snapchat, or saying they were non-binary or trans.
Children who had barely reached puberty, let alone had any meaningful romantic or sexual experience.
Too often, it seemed the adults around them were affirming these labels rather than being the grown-ups in the relationship and explaining that there was no rush to put a label on whatever they might be feeling.
Now too many people - including politicians - appear to be conflating sexual orientation (being gay or bisexual) with gender identity (being trans).
Which, of course, aren't the same thing.
But by treating them as though they're interchangeable, ordinary parents risk being accused of both homophobia and transphobia simply for encouraging a child to take their time, ask questions and not feel pressured into adopting a label.
That isn't prejudice.
That's sensible, boundaried parenting.
The irony, of course, is that we already have conversion therapy. It's called gender-affirming care.
It's based on the premise that gender-distressed children should change their bodies rather than be helped to become more comfortable in the ones they already have.
And this legislation could mean more children are subjected to what I would regard as conversion therapy, not fewer.
Because ordinary parents who encourage children to take their time and ask questions could instead find themselves facing vexatious complaints alleging "conversion therapy".
The complaints process alone could deter the very conversations that might prevent irreversible decisions later on.
Link below 👇
I can't remember which case this was - perhaps Jasmine Sussex? I'm sure someone will remind me.
But I remember hearing a breastfeeding counsellor describe a grandfather who wanted to attend a breastfeeding support group because he wanted to breastfeed his grandchild so they could "bond".
Wake up, people.
An adult male wanting to place a baby's mouth on his nipple should raise serious safeguarding questions. It is a behaviour that may be associated with paraphilic interests and should not simply be dismissed as a consequence of gender identity.
To be clear, highlighting this is not to say that all trans-identifying males pose a risk to children.
But I do question why more trans-identifying people - and their so-called "allies" - aren't distancing themselves from the claim that men can breastfeed babies, rather than defending or normalising it.
A man who wants to put a baby’s mouth around his nipple should prompt safeguarding questions.
A couple of men producing a few teaspoons of medically induced milk-like fluid is not scientific evidence that men can - or should - breastfeed babies.
If a man is experiencing gender distress to the extent that he wants to breastfeed a baby, it is reasonable to suggest he should be not be able to adopt or obtain a baby by any other means (e.g. surrogacy).
Saying this is not to suggest that all trans-identifying men are unsafe around children.
It is to recognise that men who are interested in breastfeeding babies may have a s*xual fetish - which is a clear safeguarding risk.
Which is precisely why we have to be able to discuss it openly - without accusations of bigotry shutting the conversation down. And question content like this - that seeks to normalise fetish behaviour.
Indeed accusations of bigotry around issues like this should surely make us question the motives of those trying to silence our questions.
Because what’s more important: protecting an adult from offence, or keeping children safe?
Did anyone fact-check this video from @[private account] about the new EHRC Code on single-sex spaces under the Equality Act?
Because there are many sweeping claims that appear to be unsubstantiated.
Take the oft-repeated claim that there have been “17,000 articles about trans people” over the last four years. Even if the figure is accurate, what is it supposed to show?
Were those articles supportive, critical or neutral? How does that compare with coverage of other issues? Without context, the figure means very little.
The same applies to other claims in the video. Assertions are presented as fact, but little evidence is offered.
Has anyone independently verified the statistics, sources and conclusions presented? If so, it would be useful to see the underlying evidence rather than simply hearing the claims repeated.
Given the importance of the topic: the safeguarding of women and children it is not unreasonable to expect a higher standard of evidence - rather than simply repeating statistics that sound alarming.
Apparently it’s not my beliefs that are the problem. It’s the way I express them.
So let me express them for you.
I believe women have the right to single-sex spaces - particularly in intimate settings such as toilets, changing rooms, hospitals and domestic violence shelters.
Not only because the overwhelming majority of violence against women and girls is carried out by biological males, but because women deserve privacy, dignity and comfort.
I believe women have the right to fair sport - from grassroots to elite level.
Not only so they can accurately compare their performance against other female bodies, or avoid losing medals, scholarships and financial opportunities, but so they are not placed at risk of injury - or worse - by competing alongside people who are typically quicker, heavier and stronger.
I believe women deserve their own categories in awards across every field - including the arts, sciences and engineering.
Because someone born male who identifies as a woman can never experience life as a biological female. So to do otherwise is not a level playing field.
I believe humans cannot change sex.
And that being a woman is not a ‘feeling’.
It is not about dresses, make-up or long hair.
And no amount of drugs, surgery or paperwork can change a person’s sex.
I believe the words “woman” and “mother” should not be replaced with so-called “inclusive” language that erases women from motherhood.
Because only female humans who have gone through puberty can conceive, carry a baby and give birth.
And because clear communication in healthcare should take priority over identity-based language.
I believe people who choose to live as the opposite sex are fully aware of their biological sex and medical history. To suggest otherwise is insulting.
There is therefore no need to change medical language to accommodate those choices.
I believe women and girls have the right to say ‘no’ to men in their single-sex spaces - including men who identify as women.
Because women cannot know, on sight, which men present a threat.
They cannot reasonably be expected to “pick and choose” based on how kind, feminine or non-threatening someone appears.
I believe the risk of offending a small number of masculine-presenting women or females who identify as men, does not justify removing women’s single-sex spaces altogether.
And that forcing women and girls to share their single-sex spaces with men - against their will - is a violation of their boundaries.
I do not believe humans can change sex.
Therefore I do not believe trans women are women.
So I do not believe people who identify as trans women should have access to women’s spaces, sports or other female-only categories.
I believe trans people deserve the same rights as everyone else. They already have those rights.
Demanding access to women’s single-sex spaces is asking for additional rights - rights that conflict with women’s boundaries, protections and, here in the UK, the law itself.
I believe a society that cannot accept women’s right to single-sex spaces - and that labels women hateful or bigoted for defending those rights - is an unhealthy one.
I believe the majority of people agree with me. And find my views perfectly reasonable.
But that a small minority within politics, public bodies and major institutions have embedded harmful ideologies that make others afraid to speak honestly.
And the punishment is the process.
There are real consequences for speaking openly: social ostracism, damaged relationships, reputational attacks, loss of income, loss of work and of status.
I do not believe there is anything in this statement that could reasonably be described as hateful, abusive or offensive.
Not that this ultimately matters.
Because my tone is not the problem.
The problem is simply that I am saying things some people do not want to hear.
I am speaking truths some people would rather remain unspoken.
'Trans panic correspondent' 🤣 - I guess that makes me one too. The other point worth making is that some journalists/publications won't touch these kinds of stories. Or if they do, they take the Metro/Observer approach - their recent Girlguiding stories appeared to be activism not reporting. We still ensure the 'other side' is represented - and is given the opportunity to comment - regardless of our personal views on the matter. As journalists are supposed to.
I believe people “peak” about trans ideology in stages - and we have to let them.
Because some of what people eventually discover is genuinely frightening and difficult to process. Push too hard too early, and instead of becoming more open to the evidence, many will simply shut down or turn away from it completely.
That aside, I spent the best part of a decade in digital marketing. Which is how I know - first hand - that most of us need to hear something more than a dozen times - and often in many different ways - before the message has any chance of landing.
And that we can't assume everyone is at the same 'stage' we are.
STAGE 0: “Live and let live.”
You support gay rights and assume this is mostly about kindness and acceptance.
You may feel uncomfortable about men in women’s spaces - but it hasn’t affected you personally, so you don’t think too deeply about it.
And because it’s all grouped together under LGBTQIA+, you’ve never really separated sex (LGB) and gender identity (TQIA+).
STAGE 1: Something unsettles you.
Maybe it’s a nurse being forced to share a changing room with a man who says he's a woman at work. A parent challenging a school because girls are expected to undress in front of a male pupil. Boys being allowed to join a girls’ only organisation.
At the same time, you start noticing language changing.
NHS leaflets that say “pregnant people” or “cervix havers”.
Women’s initiatives that include men.
Men in women’s sport.
Children being medically transitioned.
You still feel sympathetic - especially towards young people struggling with gender identity - but something feels ‘off’.
But you still think there must be a sensible solution.
Third spaces. Clear boundaries. Some kind of ‘compromise’ maybe?
But when you cautiously voice even mild concerns - or see someone else doing so - you realise these views are often treated as unacceptable.
STAGE 2: The penny drops.
You realise this isn’t simply about being kind to people who are different. People are being expected to publicly deny biological reality - socially, politically and professionally.
You notice people in positions of power saying ridiculous things - like ‘women can have penises’ or men can 'grow cervixes.' And that challenging such ridiculous statements costs people jobs, reputations and friendships.
You notice some gay people are pushing back hard - and why.
Because if sex is no longer real or meaningful, then neither is same-sex attraction.
So this doesn’t just affect women’s rights, but gay people too - whose hard-won rights also depend on sex being real.
You learn about women like Maya Forstater, Kellie-Jay Keen and Sall Grover - women who have been publicly attacked, vilified and, in Kellie-Jay Keen’s case, physically assaulted, for what feel like entirely reasonable positions about sex and women’s boundaries.
You learn what a “TERF” is - and how it’s used as a slur against women who defend their sex-based rights.
You see pictures of masked protesters holding up signs calling for women to be hanged and r*ped. Videos of activists calling for them to be urinated and defecated on. Simply for defending their lawful right to single sex changing rooms, toilets and other intimate spaces.
You notice journalists, politicians and institutions seemingly afraid to state basic biological facts. Male offenders - who have committed the most serious crimes - being described as women in the press.
You start to feel the chill.
Not just around women’s rights - but around free speech itself.
And start asking yourself:
If people can be pressured into denying biological reality - into literally agreeing that the man standing in front of them is actually a woman - what else can they be pressured into staying silent about?
STAGE 3: You can’t unsee it
You realise that men demanding access to women’s spaces aren’t poor, misunderstood people who simply want acceptance.
They are vulnerable.
But they need mental health support - not affirmation.
You learn that some may have a recognised condition called autogynephilia - where a man is sexually aroused by the idea of himself as a woman.
And realise - often with horror - that many public institutions have embedded harmful ideology in the name of compassion and inclusion. Without properly questioning it.
Allowing some men to bring their ‘kinks’ to work, education, social and other aspects of public life. In some cases, into settings that include children.
You still have compassion. And recognise that many vulnerable children - and their parents - have been swept up in something adults should have questioned much sooner. But know you can’t look the other way.
Because you now understand why so many ordinary people stayed silent - not because they agreed, but because they were afraid.
At this stage, some people speak publicly. Many speak up earlier.
Others support quietly behind the scenes.
But very few return to Stage 0 - and nor should they.
This is the video that first raised concerns for me about trans activism inside Girlguiding.
And let to my Sunday Telegraph reporting on the topic.
My investigations revealed that children as young as five were being encouraged to get involved in trans activism - as part of their formal Girlguiding activities - by their Guide leaders.
They were also being given materials designed to train little girls and young women into believing there is nothing wrong with accepting boys/men into their ‘girls only’ spaces. As long as they *say* they’re female.
All of which has huge safeguarding implications.
I’m not saying the Girlguiding leaders involved are conscious of what they’re doing. I personally feel the majority are misguided (no pun intended).
I’m also not saying this is happening in every unit. It isn’t.
But that doesn’t make it ok.
And it certainly doesn’t make it ok for Girlguiding to look the other way - and do nothing about it.
Quoting @jan_murray: If my daughter were in this Guide group, I would remove her immediately.
Because youth organisations shouldn’t be using children to front political campaigns.
This video from Thatcham Rangers, part of Girlguiding, shows girls holding slogans such as “trans girls are girls” and “our story includes trans girls”, while the Guide Promise is read over the top.
The video also includes repeated shots of what appear to be shark and dolphin plush toys - which call to mind the Blåhaj shark plush toy from IKEA, a soft toy that has become a well-known symbol in online trans activism.
The video is presented as part of a badge exercise on protest and activism.
But when it involves coordinated slogans, covered faces and links to activist organisations, it’s reasonable to ask whether this is really a youth activity - or political campaigning.
The caption includes a disclaimer that the views expressed don’t necessarily represent those of Girlguiding or the church involved. But it also thanks activist organisations including Guiders Against Trans Exclusion (GATE) and Newbury Pride.
At the end of last year, Girlguiding announced that boys who identify as girls would no longer be able to join Guiding - a policy change that prompted significant public debate.
To be clear, this isn’t criticism of the girls themselves. The responsibility lies with the adults who organised and encouraged them to take part in a highly contested political campaign.
It was this time last week that I first saw the email from Scope - dropping my choir from the London Marathon.
I was working on a potential Telegraph story at the time - but had to drop everything to focus on trying to resolve the situation.
It’s felt like a full-time job ever since.
The public are behind me. But some people who matter more are upset with me. And sadly, I’m not sure those relationships will ever recover.
Which is, of course, exactly what they want - disharmony, disagreement and for the blame to fall on me, rather than on the actions of Scope.
I don’t blame those people. I know this world. And I remember how scary it was to be thrust into it, with little warning.
Having worked in and around journalism for 25+ years, I also understand the role media visibility can play in achieving legal and other resolutions. But I understand that people who don’t work in that field may not see it that way.
I also understand that trans activists don’t all wear masks and threaten women at protests.
Many work inside organisations, across multiple sectors, embedding authoritarian ideas - such as the belief that saying there are only two sexes is bigotry - while being paid large salaries to do so.
Again, I understand that many people may not see this.
One person said I would have to rename my choir - that it would never recover from this.
I disagree. But that doesn’t mean the perception wasn’t there. Or that the damage wasn’t real.
Someone else said I was an “activist” and that singers would not want to be “tarred with the same brush” as me.
None of that is true. My views are lawful, reasonable and widely held.
But the perception is still there.
Along with the damage.
The irony is that my choir was never about politics. It was about music, community, and supporting others - and that hasn’t changed.
But something that was beautiful has been made ugly. And not by our doing. That’s the real loss in all of this.
Numpties asking whether trans people are excluded from my choir - like it's some kind of 'gotcha' 🙄.
And then demanding I reply to them.
Aggressively of course.
Of course no one is excluded from my choir.
That would be DISCRIMINATION - you know like Scope did to my choir - on account of MY lawfully held views.
Not that we can accept new members at the moment though - given the current crisis.
Not of our own making.
If you have a daughter in Girlguiding who says she’s been designing badges, it might be worth asking a few follow-up questions.
Because activists are circulating a template encouraging girls to design badges for Pride month.
These are not official Girlguiding materials, but the work of the group Guiders Against Trans Exclusion (GATE), which opposes the new rules excluding boys - including those who 'identify' as girls - from Girlguiding.
There are many people I need to thank for their support over the past week or so - and I will, in due course.
But I have to start with @WomensRightsNet - and my local group @[private account].
It was the brilliant @[private account] who encouraged me to join last year, when I first got a taste of trans activism - and the lengths some people will go to to try and destroy your life. Simply for speaking plainly about biological sex - and defending women’s rights to single sex sports and spaces.
In my case, that’s meant attempts to damage my business (and income), my relationships with family and friends - and now, my wonderful choir.
A choir I’ve spent years building - to create fun, friendship and joy for members - and support ordinary people doing extraordinary things, like running marathons for charity.
After 18 months of dealing with this, I’ve developed a clearer understanding of how this world operates - including the tactics used to turn others against you.
I’ve also, to an extent, built a tolerance to the more absurd behaviour that comes with it - including from people who are supposed to be on the same side.
But the members of my choir haven’t.
So I understand how frightening and bewildering this must feel for them.
And I know I have to be strong - for their sake, as much as my own.
Even if that means some may wish I’d stayed quiet and hoped it would all go away.
Thankfully, my @[private account] has my back. For which I am very grateful 🙏
This is what women who defend their lawful sex-based rights, spaces and sports deal with on an almost daily basis.
Apart from the unfounded smears - and suggestions their lawful, reasonable views are ‘extreme’.
I personally feel sure this kind of behaviour does not represent all trans people. I know, first hand, that some of the worst conduct comes from self-professed ‘allies’ - not trans people themselves.
Yet it appears charities and organisations like Scope would rather be complicit in the harassment of women than defend their right to speak freely about what is, after all, biological reality.
I share this because I think it’s important for the public to see.
Quite surreal hearing former Olympic swimmer @sharrond62 on @TalkTV talking about my choir being dropped from tomorrow’s London Marathon - due to my lawful gender critical beliefs.
We were due to be part of the disability charity Scope’s ‘cheer squad’ tomorrow at Mile 3 in Woolwich - for the third year running,
But were dropped - just days away from the event - on account of my apparently problematic views.
As Sharron explains to @mrmarkdolan here, trans activists will stop at nothing to destroy women who defend their sex-based rights.
To the point of attempting to destroy a choir that supports runners raising money for good causes.
And one of the UK’s leading disability charities apparently supports this …
I’m always happy to engage in good-faith discussions - and I appreciate the way you’ve raised it.
So no … it is not my choice of language.
But the piece wouldn’t have been published had I insisted on different terms - something people outside journalism don’t always appreciate.
My view is that it’s better to get the story out there than not at all - as long as there’s a qualifier that signals we’re talking about identity, not biological sex. In most cases, “trans” does that.
In my experience, people do read “trans woman” as an identity, not biology. By contrast, terms like “trans-identifying male/female” are often confusing and misunderstood (in fact people often think they mean the opposite).
I appreciate others take a different view. But if we want the public to engage with these issues, I believe we have to meet people where they are - even if that sometimes involves compromise.
In a media landscape where many outlets won’t cover this at all - or only do so in a highly one-sided way - I personally don’t think we gain anything by prioritising language purity over getting important stories into the public domain.
Particularly stories that help the public understand why this matters - and why they need to care.
🚨BREAKING 🚨
New from me in this week’s Sunday Telegraph 👇
WI members are rebelling over a new membership form that requires them to sign up to beliefs they may not hold - such as “trans women are women” - or risk being pushed out.
Forms are being crossed out.
Lines are being drawn.
Legal threats are on the table.
It's not quite “Jam and Jerusalem” anymore.
Link below to read for free (gift link)👇
I spoke to someone this morning who said they were delivering some training to a group of Muslim girls.
The booking came via a mosque, which stipulated that the trainer must be female
Perfectly understandable. But had I asked this person whether they believe trans women were women, I feel pretty confident they'd have said yes.
Which raises an obvious tension with a request for female-only trainers for a group of Muslim girls.
One I'm not sure they'd even considered.
If my daughter were in this Guide group, I would remove her immediately.
Because youth organisations shouldn’t be using children to front political campaigns.
This video from Thatcham Rangers, part of Girlguiding, shows girls holding slogans such as “trans girls are girls” and “our story includes trans girls”, while the Guide Promise is read over the top.
The video also includes repeated shots of what appear to be shark and dolphin plush toys - which call to mind the Blåhaj shark plush toy from IKEA, a soft toy that has become a well-known symbol in online trans activism.
The video is presented as part of a badge exercise on protest and activism.
But when it involves coordinated slogans, covered faces and links to activist organisations, it’s reasonable to ask whether this is really a youth activity - or political campaigning.
The caption includes a disclaimer that the views expressed don’t necessarily represent those of Girlguiding or the church involved. But it also thanks activist organisations including Guiders Against Trans Exclusion (GATE) and Newbury Pride.
At the end of last year, Girlguiding announced that boys who identify as girls would no longer be able to join Guiding - a policy change that prompted significant public debate.
To be clear, this isn’t criticism of the girls themselves. The responsibility lies with the adults who organised and encouraged them to take part in a highly contested political campaign.
The actor David Tennant has announced he is supporting ‘Not In Our Name’ - a campaign in support of the trans+ community.
But what exactly is he supporting?
While most campaigns have a clear goal - a law to change, a policy to introduce, a reform to pursue - this one is harder to pin down.
The petition page states:
‘We want the media and politicians to recognise that there is a large number of women who are supportive of the trans+ community. We call on them to report truthfully about the sources of violence against women and to address the systems that perpetuate harm.’
But it’s not clear what “harm” this refers to - or what specific policy change the campaign is actually asking for.
Which is curious, given it’s backed by the Good Law Project - an organisation that typically focuses on legal challenges.
So is the aim simply signalling? The message being: we’re not like those “bigoted” women who defend single-sex spaces.
Tennant has spoken publicly about supporting his non-binary child, so his desire to stand in solidarity is understandable.
But that still leaves the question of what specific change this campaign is actually asking for.
I thought you were going to say he was the one who said he wanted to be the first trans woman to have an abortion. Then I remembered he’d said he was a man 🙄. That’s how effed up it all is - you lose track after a while …
I didn’t really get the problem with gender ideology at first.
I’m liberal-minded about most things. 'Live and let' live has generally been my motto. I believed inclusion mattered. I believed in being kind. In not using language that might upset people unnecessarily.
I knew people who identified as transgender. I knew some adults chose medical treatments or surgery to resemble the opposite sex. That seemed to me a matter of personal autonomy. Adults can do what they wish with their own bodies.
What I hadn’t realised - and I feel slightly embarrassed admitting this - was that I’d misunderstood what was being claimed.
I thought “transgender” meant a form of self-expression. A man who liked wearing women’s clothes. Someone changing their name. Gender non-conformity.
What I hadn’t grasped was that some activists weren’t just asking for tolerance. They were asserting that declaring yourself the opposite sex made you the opposite sex. Not metaphorically. Literally.
And that this wasn’t just cultural. It had legal consequences.
- It meant men who said they were women were demanding access to women’s sports, prisons, domestic violence shelters and hospital wards
- It meant the rewriting of healthcare language - “pregnant people”, “bodies with cervixes” - to avoid saying “women”
- It meant children struggling with identity being affirmed onto medical pathways with lifelong implications
And also redefining same-sex attraction. Lesbians called 'bigoted' for not wanting relationships with men who identify as women. Gay men accused of prejudice for saying they're not attracted to female bodies. None of which made any sense.
But I'd also overlooked how far this had travelled - into HR policies, professional bodies, schools, political parties and public institutions.
And how easily disagreement was framed as cruelty. Speaking up felt risky - because others were being publicly humiliated for doing so.
None of this is abstract.
Because sex is the basis on which safeguarding works. On which data is collected. On which cancer screening programmes run. On which fair sport and single-sex spaces depend. It’s written into law - including the Equality Act - because material differences matter.
If sex becomes a 'feeling' rather than a biological category, those protections become unstable.
And once reality becomes negotiable, everything does.
Once I saw it, I couldn’t unsee it.
But I needed to be sure.
So I read. Books, research papers, policy documents. When I finally spoke publicly, there was backlash from all directions.
Many women thanked me - both quietly and publicly.
But some feminists criticised me for speaking too late.
Others were angry about a past interview I’d done with the parent of a transgender person, accusing me of promoting harm.
It takes courage to change your mind publicly.
It takes courage to speak when you know your reputation, friendships or livelihood may be on the line - when you know raising your voice could strain, or even end, relationships you value.
Once I understood what was at stake, staying silent was no longer an option. I lost my livelihood simply for saying I didn’t like the phrase “pregnant people”. That alone tells you something is deeply wrong. It shouldn’t be this way.
I will never judge any woman for when she finds her voice.
Because every voice adds value - whenever it is raised.
And I know how persuasive this ideology can be. I know how easily it bypassed me. And I know how much courage it takes to admit, publicly, that you got something wrong.
Delighted to hear Cornwall councillor Dulcie Tudor has been cleared following complaints she used discriminatory and offensive language about trans people.
And that my writing will feature in her letter to fellow councillors about why women’s sex-based rights and safeguarding matter.
Tudor faced ten complaints after a social media post in which she referred to trans women as “men pretending to be women” and cited statistics about male violence.
Following external legal advice, the council concluded her comments were lawful and did not breach the code of conduct.
I know first-hand the professional and social cost of defending women’s sex-based rights. It can feel heavy at times.
But seeing Tudor tell @[private account] she’d be sharing my words with councillors - specifically on the erosion of sex-based safeguarding and the reframing of ordinary factual statements as “hate” - makes it feel worthwhile.
The @SpeechUnion which supported Tudor during the investigation, described the complaints process as an attempt to weaponise the code of conduct against an elected representative.
Elected representatives must be free to speak about law, language and safeguarding without facing punitive complaints for expressing mainstream political views.
If words I’ve written are helping shape that conversation inside a council chamber, I’m proud of that.
Link to the post she’s quoting from below for anyone who’d like to read it in full 👇
Several people have said to me recently that they feel like they’re living a double life. And spoken of the gap between what they really think and what they’re prepared to say out loud.
At work, many are either pretending to believe things they don’t or keeping quiet altogether. Not because they’re indifferent, but because they’re afraid that saying the “wrong” thing could cost them clients - or even their job or business.
A number of people told me they attended the Unite the Kingdom event over the summer - but felt it was something they had to keep secret from colleagues or friends.
Some said they wanted to see for themselves whether the people attending really were “far right”, as media coverage, colleagues and friends had suggested. But simply being seen at such an event felt like professional suicide in their industry. One even admitted to disguising their appearance.
These are the kinds of themes showing up consistently in my 'Fear, Cancellation and Work' survey.
And while “Bring your whole self to work” has been
a recurring theme in recent years - with firms hosting initiatives like 'Trans in the City' alongside neurodiversity and menopause programmes - the reality is, not all “selves” are equally welcome at work.
And I keep coming back to this question: if large numbers of people are leading double lives - carefully managing what they say, where they go and who they’re seen with - what does that do to creativity, productivity and innovation?
If this resonates, I’d really value your input.
My anonymous 'Fear, Cancellation and Work' survey closes on Monday 10 February.
The survey takes around 4–5 minutes to complete, responses are anonymous and I’m planning to publish the findings as a report later this month. Over 400 have already taken part - I'd love to get to 500 responses by Monday.
The link to take part is in the first comment 👇
As a woman who was recently treated for breast cancer, words can’t express how angry this makes me feel.
That this information is being distributed by a church chaplain, with the aim of collecting data to be submitted to an NHS Integrated Care Board, makes it even more concerning.
I understand this information is intended for trans people. But women and girls who identify as trans are still female - and over 99% of breast cancer cases affect females. Health information must be clear about that, wherever it appears.
This guidance is publicly available and can be read by anyone. Saying “anyone with breast tissue should attend screening” is vague and medically imprecise.
Breast cancer screening saves lives.
Women and girls need accurate, sex-based advice about risk and screening - not ideology.
Oof 🫣. The UK’s biggest counselling
body was giving out free lipsticks at Manchester’s Trafford centre recently … and it’s not gone down well with LinkedIn users.
The gimmick was part of a new British Association of Counselling and Psychotherapy campaign aimed at encouraging women over 50 to seek counselling.
Even as someone who’s rarely seen without lipstick, I can see why the campaign jarred. Because womanhood isn’t something you wear - it’s something you are.
The BACP has previously been criticised by some therapists and women’s groups for adopting activist language around gender identity. In 2024, it published a blog titled “Are you a trans hostile therapist?” - a move that sparked controversy within the profession.
The reaction online - particularly on LinkedIn - has been critical. One woman commented: “You’re reducing women and their struggles to an aesthetic.” Another wrote: “Sure, a new lipstick will solve everything, thanks.”
'A discussion committee was set up in Western Australia specifically for women who had suffered stillbirth. The trans community is insisting on a seat at the table. It is grotesque and obscene.'
[Response from my post on Facebook y'day on telling a mother she can't say 'pregnant people' ]
One of the most disgusting things I think I've heard.
It wasn’t saying the phrase “pregnant people” that got me cancelled.
It was not apologising for saying it.
Had I apologised for causing offence - or disappeared
to “educate myself” on my so-called internalised transphobia - I suspect I’d have been forgiven. My critics may even have applauded my “bravery”.
But I didn’t apologise.
I defended my position - and my reputation - against the inevitable accusations: bigot, transphobe, Nazi, far right, grifter and so on.
Publicly.
Persistently.
The more persistent the attacks became, the more convinced I became that I was right - because the arguments were always emotional rather than factual.
I was told I was being unkind. Intimidating. That I was trying to “erase” trans people. Inciting violence. Causing teen suicides.
When I asked for evidence for any of these claims, the response shifted.
I was told I was old. Fat. Ugly.
Or called a nonce or a paedophile.
Or accused of wanting to inspect people’s genitals.
And it’s hard to take people seriously who can't distinguish between an emotional outburst and evidence.
It’s even harder to take seriously people who require you to lie in order to gain approval - for example, by saying people can change sex or that someone who is clearly male is a woman.
And who tell you you’re mentally ill if you don’t go along with it. And/or are willing to cut you off if you don't comply.
That isn’t inclusive or progressive.
That’s a cult.
As a self-employed person, in some ways it was easier for me to speak up - I didn’t have a boss to answer to.
The flip side is that when you rely on yourself for income, you’re completely on your own.
There’s no HR.
No tribunals.
You can’t even get suspended on full pay while someone “investigates” you.
But we hear a lot from people like me - the ones who do speak up. What we hear far less about is what people don’t say.
Those who fear being cancelled. Because they see what happens to people like me.
That’s why I’m running the Fear, Cancellation and Work survey.
It’s short (around 4-5 minutes), anonymous and aimed at understanding how fear of reputational fallout is shaping work, business and professional life.
I've had 160+ responses in less than 24 hours and
some of the comments/stories are sobering. I'd love to increase this to 500 over the next few days.
👉Take the survey - link in first comment below ⬇️
I'm planning to turn the results into a report/white paper. So please do share with friends/colleagues.
Not really following - but ‘trans inclusive’ does not mean trans people can use any facility they like (as you appear to have think it does). That’s not what the law says either.
are you referring to the 'consultation' where 86% of people said that wanted 'trans inclusive' facilities - which are already provided, via the three ponds? But 57% stated they did not explicitly agree with self- ID 🤔
I can’t think of anything I’d rather do less than swim in an outdoor pond.
But here’s why I care deeply about what’s happening at Hampstead Heath.
It’s a simple, relatable - and very visual - example of how the public, politicians and the media have been encouraged to feel sympathy for people with questionable motives.
Because there are three public ponds.
A men’s pond.
A women’s pond.
And a mixed pond, open to everyone.
The mixed pond dates back to the 1860s; the men’s to 1894; and the women’s to 1925, after women fought for a space of their own.
So as things stand, it’s hard to imagine a more ‘inclusive’ setup. Yet we’re repeatedly told this arrangement is somehow not inclusive.
And what’s being demanded here is not access to swimming - or “inclusive” arrangements for trans people. Those already exist.
It’s access to the women’s pond - a space where women are partially or fully naked - with the sole criterion for entry being self-identification as female.
Access for men who already have two places to swim, regardless of how they ‘identify’ - and who *know* women don’t want them there.
Just think about that for a moment.
Yes - the headline question asked whether people wanted a “trans-inclusive” pond. Most people will understandably say yes to that.
But that isn’t the actual dispute.
The dispute is about whether there should be a women-only pond - not whether trans people can swim at Hampstead Heath.
The Heath is already trans-inclusive, with three ponds: men’s, women’s and mixed.
The heart of the dispute is whether men can self-identify into the women’s pond. That was Question 3 - and 57% of respondents did not agree with that.
Instead, the City of London chose to lead with a vague headline question that obscures the real point at issue.
You clearly missed the 57% of respondents who did not agree with self ID. As did @[private account] it seems 🤔. As there is a mixed pond, it’s already trans inclusive. No need for men to be in the women’s pond. Interestingly, this wasn’t covered in any of the questions.
This Telegraph headline - and many others I’ve seen - is inaccurate.
The court did *not* rule that trans women can use the ladies’ pond at Hampstead Heath Ladies’ Pond.
It ruled that this particular legal challenge couldn’t be brought in the High Court by a charity. Instead, it would have to be brought in a county court and by an individual woman, not an organisation.
In non-legal terms, it’s a bit like complaining to John Lewis head office about an issue you think affects lots of customers - and being told you can’t complain there at all. You have to go to your local store and only the person directly affected can do it.
So while this is understandably frustrating for Sex Matters, who brought the case, it does not mean men now have a green light to use the women’s pond (even if they say they are women).
All the judgment says is this: this wasn’t the right court or the right route to decide the issue. It is therefore extremely misleading - and irresponsible - to suggest otherwise.
Yesterday a male friend of mine - who works in the medical profession - said to me: “But trans women are not men.”
I try very hard to maintain friendships with people who see the world differently from me. I really do.
But I’m struggling to get past this one. Because it feels profoundly wrong for a trained medical professional to deny biological reality.
This is someone who I’m sure has cared for many vulnerable women and children during their career - including victims of sexual assault and domestic abuse.
Compassionate, non-judgemental
care matters. Of course it does.
But denying material reality is not care.
And if we can’t rely on medical professionals to tell the truth - and to stand up for women and children - who can we trust?
Utterly depressing.
I can’t remember the exact moment that “peaked” me.
But one moment has stayed with me: a Facebook discussion where I mentioned I’d asked my daughter whether a “non-binary” friend was a boy or a girl.
I was piled on by multiple adults - many of them parents of teenagers themselves - for being “offensive” towards someone my under-16 child wanted to spend time alone with.
And I remember thinking: oh my God - they actually believe gender identity matters more than safeguarding a child.
As a parent, it's your responsibility to ensure your
child is safe. That includes having age-appropriate conversations about boundaries, consent, contraception and sex where necessary.
The feelings of another child who is confused about their gender identity are not your responsibility. That responsibility sits with their parents or carers. And those feelings should never take priority over the safety, dignity or boundaries of other children.
Yet there I was, confronted by well-educated adults - people who otherwise seemed perfectly sane - who genuinely believed they should.
It took me a while longer to recognise what was really going on: and that some parents were actively going along with this.
Including allowing their children to dictate what they, as adults, were permitted to think or say. Rather than being the adult in the relationship.
Alastair Campbell is one such example - apparently displaying no embarrassment about publicly asking his daughter Grace what he should think or say about trans issues.
I’ve seen friends do similar.
As if they are afraid to be the parent.
I believe that fear has played a significant role in the boundary failures we now see: boys in girls’ toilets and changing rooms, competing in girls’ sports and schools indulging claims that would once have prompted adult correction - affirming them instead of guiding children back to reality.
I’m not saying it’s easy. One of the hardest parts of parenting is telling your child they’re wrong.
But it is also one of the most loving things you can do - because it teaches them that the world does not bend around their feelings, that other people matter too and that reality, boundaries and responsibility are things they will have to live with long after childhood ends.
So as well as smashing windows in venues where women are meeting, donning black masks and intimidating women in the streets - and making online threats - it appears the trans activist group, Bash Back, may have committed a massive
data breach.
They’ve published the names and donation amounts of hundreds of private individuals who donated to the Free Speech Union.
These are private citizens, targeted because of their lawfully held views.
Whatever the politics, it’s hard to see how exposing people’s personal and financial data could be in the public interest.
Which means there could be serious consequences.
Toil and Toilet Monitoring 🚻🚽
A short thread about how a novelty pin badge apparently turned me into a sex offender - and inspired someone to threaten to shoot me. 🧵
1/ I was anonymously sent a “Toilet Monitor” pin badge by a trans activist.
I turned the joke back on them by making one in suffragette purple and putting it on sale the same day.
They did not take it well. 🎭
The Minister for Women and Equalities, Bridget Phillipson is quoted in the Telegraph as saying trans people must not be used as a “political punchbag”.
Which confirms what many women already knew: despite the job title, her priority is not women.
If it was, she’d acknowledge that it’s women - not trans people - who’ve been the ‘political punchbag’ of the past decade. And that women have been:
- Pressured to deny biological reality - or risk jobs, livelihoods and professional standing
- Forced to share single-sex spaces with men - in changing rooms, prisons, rape-crisis centres, hospital wards and workplaces
- Written out of their own language and replaced with terms like “pregnant people” and “cervix-havers” - then told they’re bigoted for objecting
- Dragged through tribunals, and court cases - just to keep rights that already existed
- Pushed aside while men take women’s places - medals, records, prizes, awards and commercial contracts
- Threatened and abused for speaking up
This is what it looks like to be used as a political punchbag. Being told to stay out of women’s spaces if you’re a man is not - that’s just basic safeguarding practice.
And the final betrayal? Philippson has refused to sign off the updated guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission - meant simply to give clarity on single-sex spaces after the Supreme Court ruling.
After years of women carrying the consequences, our women’s minister has chosen not to act on our behalf. And prioritise men’s feelings over women’s safety, privacy and dignity.
Which tells us exactly who is expected to keep taking the blows.