All profiles

Person

Leor Sapir

Senior fellow, Manhattan Institute

13documented ties13 names on file
2organizations with a role on file
@LeorSapir person

Revised 2026-11-05.

"Read (page summary)" means the page was opened with a fetch tool that returned a summary, not the full text.

Framing note: Sapir's writing, testimony and posting against gender-affirming care, whether on "pediatric gender medicine," "evidence," insurance coding, suicide risk or surgery, is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. His credentials and his stated wish to "depoliticize" the issue do not change that. Nothing below treats it as a position, a concern or a debate. Where he leans on the Cass Review and the 2025 HHS report (which he helped write), that is also anti-trans rhetoric, and the published critiques of both are set against it in section 4.

1. Public identity and role

  • X bio (archive snapshot 2026-11-04): "Senior Fellow @ManhattanInst | Ph.D. @BostonCollege & Post-Doc @Harvard | Gender medicine | Causes and consequences of institutional dysfunction | opinions own". 46,800 followers, verified.
  • Manhattan Institute (MI) bio: "Leor Sapir is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute. He holds a Ph.D. in Political Science from Boston College and completed a postdoctoral fellowship at the Program on Constitutional Government at Harvard University" (MI page, 1; City Journal contributor page, page summary; current title confirmed). The bio says he is a regular City Journal contributor with pieces in the Wall Street Journal, Tablet and The Hill, co-authored amicus briefs "for lawsuits on parental rights in education", is lead author of a letter in the Archives of Sexual Behavior on "rapid onset gender dysphoria", and has "testified before legislative health committees in Utah and Texas" with work "cited by federal judges in the case of [the plaintiff] v Miss USA LLC" (Ninth Circuit No. 21-35228; the plaintiff's name is not reproduced). These are his employer's self-description. Its biography gives no hearing dates or bill numbers. Section 3 gives the dates and bills documented in legislative records.
  • Joined MI: an MI announcement dated 2022-03-22 says "The Manhattan Institute is pleased to welcome Dr. Leor Sapir as an adjunct fellow" (MI release "Leor Sapir joins the Manhattan Institute", 2, dated 2022-03-22, initial title adjunct fellow). Transgender Map says he "began working at the Manhattan Institute in 2022" (carried for the year only; its framing words are the tracker's).
  • HHS report: MI says he is "the coauthor of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services report Treatment for Pediatric Gender Dysphoria: Review of Evidence and Best Practice". The report was published 2025-05-01 with anonymous authors; HHS named nine authors on 2025-11-19, Sapir among them, with the Manhattan Institute as his affiliation (Wikipedia, 3, page summary; STAT, 2025-11-19, 4, read-part, paywalled: "HHS... re-released its controversial report on gender dysphoria in children, and this time it named the previously anonymous authors"; the readable part does not name Sapir; opa.hhs.gov is on the blocked list). Transgender Map calls him "lead author"; that is the tracker's wording, MI says "coauthor", and Wikipedia lists nine authors with no lead. Mother Jones (2026-04-14 update) calls him "the ringleader", says he explained on the City Journal podcast that he got "the call to spearhead the creation" of the report and recruit its authors, and quotes him saying he "was not the final decision maker on the HHS report's content or wording." So: he led the assembly of the author team by his own account; his claim of final authority was disclaimed by him.
  • Earlier: a Tikvah Fellow and Harvard postdoctoral fellow (Tikvah Fund page, page summary; it gives no years for either, so none are stated). A 2020 Boston College dissertation argued that the federal ban on sex discrimination in schools should not be read to ban anti-trans discrimination (Mother Jones; see section 4).
  • Employment record: MI's own tax filing lists him as Senior Fellow (see section 7).

2. Posting record (project archive, all posts coded)

  • Followers 46,800 (tier 10k-100k). Keyword posts (weighted) 34.6; views on keyword posts 695,003; influence rank 95 under equal weighting (not in the top set under every weighting).
  • Coded posts: 241, every post, reply and quote by the account that matched the search terms (archive as of 2026-11-16). Severity: C0 40; C1 167; C2 14; C3 3; C4 15; C5 2. Share at C2 or above: 14.1% (34 of 241).
  • Shield framing (the post justifies itself by protecting children or women): 51 of 241 coded posts (21.2%).
  • Targeting events: 17. Adult-care posts verified: 0. Aurora-case posts: 0.
  • Top narratives (coded posts carrying each): MEDICAL_HARM 79; INSTITUTIONAL_CAPTURE 68; DENIAL 55; CONTAGION 29; IDEOLOGY_CULT 28.
  • What the coded posts show: Most of this account's coded posts are anti-trans rhetoric: 201 of 241 are C1 or above. The heaviest lines are the claim that gender medicine harms children (79 posts), the claim that medical and professional bodies have been captured by activists (68) and denial of trans people's identity (55), with the claim that being trans spreads socially (29) and that trans identity is a cult or ideology (28) behind them. 51 of the 201 carry a protective claim; 150 make no appeal to protecting anyone, 39 of those deny trans people's identity and 12 are dehumanizing or single out a person (C3 to C5). Most of the output is from 2025 and 2026, and the C4 and C5 posts mostly single out public figures (10).
  • The archive holds 427 posts attributed to the account (replies, quotes and reposts included).
  • C3 posts (dehumanizing or degrading):
    • @LeorSapir Quote

      LEGO marketing trans to kids. I wonder if they have little figurines with scars across their chests and little hypodermic needles to hold in those u-shaped hands.

      Quotes a post by T00685; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.

      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded appearance child indoctrination medical harm

      quote post, shield flagged

      What it says About LEGO marketing trans-themed figures to children, it says "I wonder if they have little figurines with scars across their chests and little hypodermic needles to hold in those u-shaped hands." The joke treats trans people's bodies as a punchline and treats surgery on minors as the norm.

    • @LeorSapir Reply

      Replying to @LeorSapir

      Declaring themselves trans or non-binary is the best, and sometimes the only, way for white teenage girls to say: "I'm not a racist. I'm not an oppressor." (A number of them opt-out of oppressor status by seeking mental illness diagnoses, which also makes them "oppressed").

      C1 anti-trans rhetoric contagion denial

      reply

      What it says Says declaring oneself trans or non-binary is "the best, and sometimes the only, way for white teenage girls" to show they are not racist, and that some seek "mental illness diagnoses". This is a social-contagion and mental-illness claim. Wide evidence and the major medical associations do not support it (see section 4 on the brief).

  • C1 post: 2026-07-18 (1,423 views, shield flagged): promotes his City Journal piece on Oregon Medicaid and puberty blockers.
  • Examples from the full coded record (the highest-reach posts by severity level and main line of attack):
    • @LeorSapir Quote

      The president of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health admits to making over a million dollars in the past year on gender surgeries, and says that only advocates of these procedures should develop guidelines for them. Read more here.

      Quoting @LeorSapir: 🚨NEW DOCUMENTS in the Alabama lawsuit over sex "change" age restrictions. Some very interesting facts now coming to light. 🧵
      C4 targeting hand-coded conspiracy denial institutional capture medical harm

      28,436 views

      What it says Quote post saying the head of a medical association "admits to making over a million dollars" on gender surgeries and that only advocates should write guidelines, singling out a public figure to cast gender medicine as profiteering.

    • @LeorSapir Post

      In a thread lamenting the Biden administration renouncing gender surgeries for kids, trans activist Erin Reed (@ErinInTheMorn) claims that Rachel Levine (@[private account]) pressured @[private account] to eliminate age minimums for gender surgeries in order to ensure a “more conservative” approach. That’s an interesting spin. The problem is that it’s false, at least according to… Levine and WPATH. Levine’s own chief of staff told WPATH that Levine was worried specifying age minimums would invite bans. Levine reportedly wondered if the specific ages could be taken out of SOC8 and then “perhaps an adjunct document could be… created or distributed in a way that’s less visible…” Levine was “very concerned that having ages… will affect access to [surgeries] for trans youth…” WPATH later explained that eliminating ages was intended to “ensure greater access” to surgeries for kids. It’s clear from the unsealed emails that taking out the ages was meant to protect gender surgeries for kids, not make them less likely.

      C4 targeting hand-coded institutional capture medical harm

      21,011 views

      What it says Opening post of a thread that takes aim at a trans journalist and a federal health official over claims about age minimums for "gender surgeries" for kids, presenting a policy dispute as pressure from activists.

    • @LeorSapir Reply

      Replying to T29253

      Dr. Haller, Can you please explain what you mean by "children... who are undeniably transgender to their core"? And how can a clinician know that a child "is undeniably transgender"? The dominant view in your field seems to be that clinicians and parents can know a child is "undeniably transgender" when the child says so. Is that your view? I don't deny that there are kids who are extremely gender nonconforming, or who are confused/mistaken about their sex. But I'm guessing you mean something else by "transgender to their core"? Genuinely curious where you stand on this.

      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded denial mental illness

      69 views

      What it says Reply to a doctor that repeats "undeniably transgender" in quotation marks to deny that a child or a clinician can know a child's gender identity.

    • @LeorSapir Reply

      Replying to @LeorSapir

      From there the girls get invested in the trans/non-binary identity, and some go on to hormones and surgeries. So in the name of "anti-racism" we are now pushing teenage girls into self-mutilation. Like a ritualistic purge, with young girls offered up as the sacrifice.

      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded child indoctrination contagion medical harm religious demonization

      0 views

      What it says Reply that calls medical transition for teenage girls "self-mutilation", compares it to a "ritualistic purge" with girls "offered up as the sacrifice", and ties it to anti-racism teaching.

    • @LeorSapir Reply

      Replying to @LeorSapir

      After seeing changes in her transgender case load, Solheim decided to look more closely at the research. She "was floored" to find that it was "not just poor; it was fraudulent. I couldn’t understand how my medical association, let alone others in my field, could endorse it."

      C2 false claims hand-coded conspiracy institutional capture medical harm

      122,811 views

      What it says Reply that quotes a clinician calling the research on gender-affirming care "not just poor; it was fraudulent", presented as proof that medical bodies endorse it wrongly.

      Correction AAP, Endocrine Society, AMA and other major US medical associations support gender-affirming care; low certainty ratings reflect no feasible RCTs, common in pediatrics, not fraud.

    • @LeorSapir Post

      In Oregon, 1 in 65 girls received a transgender-related clinical diagnosis between 2016 and 2023. 1 in 240 girls received hormones. Kids in Oregon were almost 20 times more likely than kids in Mississippi to have a "gender dysphoria" diagnosis. How did this happen?

      C1 anti-trans rhetoric hand-coded contagion institutional capture medical harm

      555,770 views

      What it says Post that gives the share of girls in one state with a transgender-related diagnosis and asks "How did this happen?", presenting being trans as a social contagion.

3. Documented moments

  • 2020: Boston College PhD dissertation on Title IX (Mother Jones).
  • 2022-03-22: joins the Manhattan Institute as adjunct fellow (MI release, 2).
  • 2022-11-02: The case is the Ninth Circuit's against Miss United States of America, LLC (No. 21-35228, D.C. No. 3:19-cv-02048-MO, opinion filed 2022-11-02; text read at 5). Footnote 2 of Judge VanDyke's concurring opinion ("VANDYKE, Circuit Judge, concurring") lists, among sources, "Leor Sapir, A Cause, Not a Cure, City Journal (May 10, 2022)", with the parenthetical that a new study on gender-affirming therapy "provides further evidence that 'gender-affirming' therapy creates or prolongs the very problem it purports to solve", beside Abigail Shrier's "Irreversible Damage" and a Wall Street Journal piece by Paul McHugh. The citation is one judge's, in a concurrence, in a case about a pageant's right to exclude a trans woman (an adult); it is not a finding of the court, and the claim it quotes is contradicted by the evidence for care (see the evidence brief). The dissent is by Judge Graber. Another footnote of the same concurrence cites a Women's Liberation Front brief in the case.
  • 2023-03-14: the Ninth Circuit's order in No. 21-35228 (the Miss United States of America pageant case), denying rehearing en banc, is two pages, filed "Before: Susan P. Graber, Carlos T. Bea, and Lawrence VanDyke, Circuit Judges". It says a judge sua sponte requested a vote on whether to rehear the case en banc, that the matter "failed to receive a majority of the votes of the non-recused active judges in favor of en banc consideration", that Judges Forrest and H.A. Thomas did not participate, and that "Rehearing en banc is DENIED." No opinion, concurrence or dissent is attached and the order cites no author, so it does not cite Sapir again; his only citation in the case is footnote 2 of Judge VanDyke's concurrence of 2022-11-02 (order read, 6, accessed 2026-11-12).
  • 2023-03-27: At the Texas House Public Health Committee’s March 27, 2023 hearing, the official witness list places Leor Sapir under “For” on HB 1686 and gives his representation as “Self.” The minutes record testimony or registration and refer to the list. The record leaves his spoken remarks unverified. (7, 8)
  • 2023-08-19: article "Transgender Care Needs Better Science, More Transparency" (a Dallas Morning News piece reposted by MI), which calls WPATH's claim of "the most rigorous protocol in the world" "simply false" (see section 4).
  • 2023-10-26: HuffPost reports the Edelman Family Foundation gave MI $400,000 for a "gender identity initiative" (HuffPost, page summary; the article does not mention Sapir and gives no date for the gift). The Edelman Family Foundation's tax-year 2022 return (IRS Form 990 e-file, object id 202341359349103194) reports $400,000 with purpose as filed "TO PROVIDE SUPPORT FOR THE GENDER IDENTITY INITATIVE AT THE MANHATTAN INSTITUTE" (spelling as filed). The filing does not name Sapir and the record does not tie the grant to him.
  • 2024-08-12: his newsletter "A Consensus No Longer" says the American Society of Plastic Surgeons became "the first major medical organization to challenge the consensus" on care for minors. Erin in the Morning (an advocacy outlet) reports that ASPS then issued a statement that it "has not issued a clinical practice guideline" on the subject and "opposes any attempts at legal encroachment into the practice of medicine." Note: the evidence brief reports that ASPS recommended in February 2026 delaying all gender-related surgery until at least age 19, so the ASPS position moved after this exchange.
  • 2026-02-03: Fox News (Kristine Parks, 9): the American Society of Plastic Surgeons announced a position statement recommending that surgeons delay chest, genital and facial gender surgeries until at least age 19, citing "insufficient evidence demonstrating a favorable risk-benefit ratio" and "low certainty" evidence on mental health outcomes, and said it is not a clinical practice guideline; the article links the statement at 10. The Society's own page of 14 August 2024, "ASPS statement regarding gender surgery for adolescents" (11), says there is "considerable uncertainty as to the long-term efficacy" of the surgery for adolescents, that "the existing evidence base is viewed as low quality/low certainty" and that "ASPS has not endorsed any organization's practice recommendations for the treatment of adolescents with gender dysphoria"; it names no bill. The Fox page does not mention Sapir. Low certainty ratings are a dispute about study design in a field where randomized trials are widely considered unethical.
  • City Journal piece (published the day after the Skrmetti oral argument per its text, "yesterday"; City Journal page dated 2024-12-05; the argument was 2024-12-04) "ACLU Attorney Confesses: Transgender-Suicide Claim is a Myth". See section 4 on suicide risk.
  • 2024-25 term: the Manhattan Institute and Sapir filed an amicus brief supporting respondents in United States v. Skrmetti, arguing that neither scientific evidence nor global health authorities support the safety and efficacy of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones for youthful gender dysphoria (brief at 12; dated 2024-10-15, see section 4). This is his own brief, separate from the ten briefs listed below; the case list in his bio remains undated. It is anti-trans rhetoric in the form of a court filing; the brief's evidence claims are answered by the evidence brief and the critiques in section 4.
  • Amicus briefs (ten): The briefs themselves (hosted by the Manhattan Institute at media4.manhattan-institute.org) each name "Manhattan Institute and Dr. Leor Sapir" as amici on the cover; the last two add Defending Education. Dates are the briefs' date lines and, for the Supreme Court, the docket entries (supremecourt.gov dockets, accessed 2026-11-12). Cases are given by court and public body sued.
    • First Circuit No. 23-1069, case brought by the parents of two minor students (D. Mass. 3:22-cv-30041-MGM), supporting plaintiffs-appellants and reversal, dated March 21, 2023 (the Institute's page is dated 2023-03-20).
    • Eleventh Circuit No. 23-10385-HH, case against the School Board of Leon County, Florida (N.D. Fla. 4:21-CV-00415-MW-MJF), dated May 22, 2023.
    • Ninth Circuit No. 23-16031, school-policy case (E.D. Cal. 2:23-cv-00032-JAM-DMC), supporting plaintiff-appellant and reversal, dated October 31, 2023.
    • Supreme Court No. 23-1280 (Parents Protecting Our Children, UA v. Eau Claire Area School District, Wisconsin; petition to review a Seventh Circuit judgment): amicus brief docketed Jul 08 2024; petition filed 2024-06-05; "Petition DENIED" on Dec 09 2024, with Justice Kavanaugh noting he would grant and Justice Alito, joined by Justice Thomas, dissenting (docket).
    • Third Circuit No. 24-3278, case against Delaware Valley Regional High School Board of Education (D.N.J. 3:24-cv-00107), dated July 7, 2025.
    • Supreme Court No. 25-77 (petition to review the First Circuit's judgment in No. 23-1069): amicus brief docketed Aug 21 2025; petition filed 2025-07-18; "Petition DENIED" on Apr 20 2026 (docket).
    • Supreme Court No. 25-840, International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc. v. Ferguson, on Washington's 2023 law on runaway minors: petition filed 2026-01-07; his amicus brief docketed Feb 17 2026 (petition stage); "Petition GRANTED" on Jun 29 2026; a second brief of the Manhattan Institute and Dr. Sapir docketed Sep 15 2026 (merits stage, supporting petitioners); "SET FOR ARGUMENT on Monday, December 7, 2026" (docket entry of Sep 04 2026); the Solicitor General's motion for divided argument was granted Nov 09 2026.
    • Ninth Circuit No. 26-475, school-policy case (E.D. Cal. 2:23-cv-00032-DJC-DMC), with Defending Education, supporting plaintiff-appellant and reversal, dated March 9, 2026.
    • Ninth Circuit Nos. 25-8056 and 26-2337, case against the California Attorney General (S.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-0768-BAS-VET), with Defending Education, supporting plaintiffs-appellees and affirmance, dated September 1, 2026. The Supreme Court docket of application No. 25A810 in this case (13) shows an application to vacate the Ninth Circuit's stay in No. 25-8056 filed 2026-01-08, a response filed 2026-01-21 and a reply filed 2026-01-22; by order of 2026-03-02, per curiam with separate writings, the application was "granted as to the parents but is otherwise denied."
      • The Manhattan Institute's publication page for the brief, dated 2026-09-01, lists Leor Sapir among its authors, the court as the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, the amici as the Manhattan Institute, Defending Education and Leor Sapir, and the side as the plaintiffs; it states no case number. It links the brief as a PDF on the Manhattan Institute's site. The case is cited by court and docket numbers (Nos. 25-8056 and 26-2337) and by the institute's publication date of 2026-09-01.
      • The State's emergency motion of 2026-03-06 (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 25-8056, DktEntry 24.1, a party's filing) says the Supreme Court issued a per curiam opinion on 2026-03-02 "granting in part and denying in part" the plaintiffs' application to vacate the stay "that this Court entered on January 5", and that the Ninth Circuit "issued an order vacating the stay as to the parents' claims and confirming that '[t]he stay remains in effect as to the remaining claims'" (C.A. Dkt. 19 at 3, as quoted by the motion). The motion asks the court to modify the stay order as to two terms of the injunction.
      • Thomas More Society, report dated 2026-09-03 (its address is not reproduced because it carries a party's name): the answering brief was filed "at the end of August", twelve amicus briefs supporting affirmance were filed "this week", and "Briefing in the Ninth Circuit is ongoing"; it names the Manhattan Institute, Defending Education and Leor Sapir among the amici and states no oral argument date. It is the party's own account.
      • District order of 2025-12-22 in the same case, the class action over California schools' policies on students' names, pronouns and gender presentation (U.S. District Court, S.D. Cal., No. 3:23-cv-00768, Document 308, filed 2025-12-22, titled "Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion for a Class-Wide Permanent Injunction", four pages, signed 2025-12-22). The introduction says the court heard oral argument on 2025-11-17 on the plaintiffs' "Motion for Summary Judgment and for a Class-Wide Permanent Injunction" and "GRANTS the Motion". The order enjoins the Attorney General, the State Superintendent and the eleven State Board of Education members it names, with their officers, agents, employees and attorneys, from implementing or enforcing the California Constitution's privacy provision, other California law (including Education Code sections 200 and 220 and Government Code section 11135) or regulations and guidance (including the state's 2016 legal advisory on transgender students and the PRISM training) in ways that would permit or require school employees to mislead a parent about a child's gender presentation, to use a name or pronoun a parent has objected to, or to require staff, over their own objection, to conceal a social transition from parents, or that would interfere with staff telling parents. It requires a prominent statement in state training materials and sets no bond. Source: U.S. District Court, S.D. Cal., No. 3:23-cv-00768, Document 308, 2025-12-22. Names of students, parents and teachers in the captions are not reproduced here, and neither are file addresses that carry them. The circuit-court briefs carry no court stamp in the Institute's copies, so their dates are the date lines above, not docket stamps. Eight of the ten oppose a school's support of a trans student's social transition or back parental notification; the other two are both in No. 25-840, on Washington's law on runaway minors. All ten are anti-trans rhetoric in the form of court filings. The dockets show the Institute's Supreme Court briefs supported two petitions that were denied and one that was granted.
  • 2025-02-18: the First Circuit's opinion in No. 23-1069, the parents' suit over the school protocol of using a student's requested name and pronouns without notifying parents unless the student consents, lists the Manhattan Institute and Dr. Leor Sapir among the amici curiae, with the Manhattan Institute as counsel on brief; the listing does not say which side each amicus supports. The parents argued that the school's use of a student's requested name and pronouns without telling them violated their due process parental rights. The First Circuit affirmed the dismissal of the complaint, holding that the parents had not plausibly alleged that the protocol restricted a fundamental parental right and that the protocol survives rational basis review: "We therefore affirm the district court's grant of the motion to dismiss." The words are the First Circuit's. The Supreme Court granted an extension of time to petition on 2025-03-05; the petition (No. 25-77) was filed on 2025-07-18 and certiorari was denied on 2026-04-20, leaving the First Circuit's affirmance of the dismissal in place. (Opinion, U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, No. 23-1069, 2025-02-18, p. 2; the opinion appended to the parents' Application to Extend Time to File Petition for Writ of Certiorari, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24A848 (later No. 25-77), 14, 2025-02-28, pp. 8, 52)
  • 2025-01: attended an American Enterprise Institute "parental rights" event; 2025-02: appeared with a conservative trans media figure at Middlebury College at an event of the Alexander Hamilton Forum titled "What is the Right Approach on Public Policy and Transgender Medicine?" (Transgender Map, citing the Middlebury Campus). Attending is not appearing, so the AEI event is not a tie.
  • 2025-02 (day not confirmed): City Journal, "The Corruption of the New England Journal of Medicine" (see section 4). Transgender Map reports a Daily Mail story on the editor on 2025-02-27.
  • 2025-05-01 / 2025-11-19: HHS report released, authors named (Wikipedia, page summary). The AAP responded on 2025-05-01 that it "misrepresent[s] the current medical consensus"; the American Psychiatric Association said its methodology "lacks sufficient transparency"; the AMA and AAP issued a joint statement rejecting the updated report on 2025-11-19 (Wikipedia, page summary).
  • 2025-07-09: panelist on "The Politicization of Science", listed as "Fellow at The Manhattan Institute", at the Federal Trade Commission workshop "The Dangers of 'Gender-Affirming Care' for Minors"; the panel also included the Alabama Solicitor General, a DOJ deputy assistant attorney general and another whistleblower (FTC event page, 15; the page also lists the DOJ official as Deputy Assistant Attorney General, Consumer Protection Branch). A Heritage Foundation senior research fellow and the American Principles Project's policy director spoke on panel 6 (same page).
  • 2025-12-18: HHS Secretary Kennedy issued a declaration and proposed two rules: no federal Medicaid or CHIP payment for puberty blockers, hormones or surgery for minors, and a condition of hospital participation in Medicare and Medicaid (Mother Jones). Mother Jones says the HHS report is the foundation for the pending rules. In March 2026 a federal judge in Oregon ruled Kennedy overstepped by declaring unilaterally that the care fails professional standards (Mother Jones). At least nine hospital systems had stopped providing blockers and hormones by April 2026 (Mother Jones citing a Stat analysis).
  • 2026-04-14: Mother Jones, "Trump Is About to Drop a 'Nuclear Weapon' on Trans Youth Health Care," names Sapir as the report's ringleader; he gave responses after publication.
  • 2026-07-18: promotes his City Journal piece on Oregon Medicaid coverage (2026-07-18).
  • 2022-08-19: his essay "Trans Extremism and the Weak American State" was first published at Genspect.org on 19 August 2022, according to a note in the essay; Genspect's Substack republished it on 2024-04-25 with a byline listing him as a Manhattan Institute senior fellow (Genspect Substack, 16).
  • 2024-06-19: he testified to the Utah Legislature's Health and Human Services Interim Committee on transgender health care for minors, in the context of S.B. 16, the bill banning medical treatment for transgender minors. Better Utah, an advocacy group's blog (2024-07-03, 17; the post calls the meeting the "July Interim meeting", while the committee minutes above give 2024-06-19), says he spoke as a Manhattan Institute representative, not a physician, was the only speaker who directly addressed research outcomes, and said a clinician would be biased by prior involvement in the field.
  • 2023-01-18: Senate Health and Human Services Standing Committee, S.B. 16 (minutes heading "Sex Characteristic Surgical Procedures"): assisted the bill's sponsor; Utah Legislature minutes: "Dr. Leon Sapir, PhD, Manhattan Institute" (18); the Salt Lake Tribune of 2023-01-18 names him as "Leor Sapir, from the Manhattan Institute" and reports the exchange with Sen. Jen Plumb in which he said he has a Ph.D. in political science and that the Institute is "a public policy think tank" (19). 2024-06-19: Health and Human Services Interim Committee, agenda item "Transgender Treatment for Minors": the minutes list "Leor Sapir, Fellow, Manhattan Institute" presenting on recent studies and the Cass Review (20; committee archive 21). The date is the legislature's own; the bill under discussion in 2023 is S.B. 16 and the 2024 item covers S.B. 16 (2023) implementation. The Cass Review appeal is anti-trans rhetoric.

4. Evidence that the child framing is pretextual

  1. The HHS report was built to serve a political action, in his words. On the City Journal podcast he said the administration "wanted to be able to cite it in their regulatory action" and that it is "obviously going to be central justification in the administration's various actions on this issue", and that he had "about eight weeks, nine weeks" (Mother Jones quoting the podcast). He picked eight co-authors who "all already held positions against gender-affirming treatments for minors"; Mother Jones reports he chose people with no direct experience providing hormone treatments to trans children. He told Mother Jones that having such experience "would amount to a conflict of interest."
  2. The target reaches adults. His 2020 dissertation argued the federal sex-discrimination ban in education should not cover anti-trans discrimination, a rule that reaches students of every age, including adult students (Mother Jones). The Trump order that preceded the report, which Mother Jones says told HHS to shut down the treatments, called the care "blatant harm" before the review began (Mother Jones; evidence brief, citing Wikipedia). Mother Jones does not say that order commissioned the report.
  3. He attacks the evidence base for adults too. The 2023 article attacks WPATH's standards of care, whose commissioned review, he writes, "included research subjects of any age, not just minors" and rated the evidence "low" (the quote shows he attacks the SOC-8 evidence review that covered all ages, not that he opposes adult care). The Johns Hopkins review the brief cites found hormone therapy associated with higher quality of life and lower depression and anxiety across ages (evidence brief). The low certainty rating of the evidence is a dispute about study design, in a field where, as the evidence brief puts it, defenders respond that randomized trials are widely considered unethical in this area and that low certainty ratings are common across pediatric medicine; it does not show the care is unreviewed, and it does not make his attack sincere. (evidence brief)
  4. Reliance on Cass and HHS is anti-trans rhetoric. His own essays cite Cass's "circularity" finding to call medical-association support for care a "consensus" with no basis (City Journal, "A Consensus No Longer," read). Set against it, the brief reports a peer-reviewed appraisal (BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2025) that rated all seven systematic reviews commissioned for Cass at high risk of bias; a Yale Integrity Project white paper (not peer reviewed); critics' point that the order preceding the HHS report, which told HHS to shut down the treatments, had already called the care "blatant harm"; a Journal of Adolescent Health appraisal charging misuse of evidence; and the AAP president's statement that the report failed to reflect pediatric care. Peer reviewers of the November 2025 re-release included one who said it is "clearly not a neutral report" (Wikipedia, page summary). The brief also states there is no established evidence that Cass decided its conclusions in advance, and the Yale authors noted that Cass does not recommend a ban on care.
  5. Suicide-risk denial. His City Journal piece calls the claim that suicide rates among gender-dysphoric young people are high "the trans suicide myth" and says activists "exploit public ignorance" about the difference between suicidality and deaths; it defines suicidality to include "using gestures of self-harm as a cry for help or as a form of emotional manipulation". Correction on file: elevated suicidality in trans youth is documented, and the Seattle Children's cohort (JAMA Network Open, 2022) found youth on blockers or hormones had lower odds of suicidality (aOR 0.27) (evidence brief). His suicide-risk denial is anti-trans rhetoric, contradicted by the evidence on file.
  6. Claims of widespread surgery on minors. His MI analysis claims "5,288 to 6,294" double mastectomies for girls under 18 in an all-payer insurance claims database (2017 to 2023), and 1,873 "nonbinary" mastectomies, and he suggests under-counting (City Journal article; the figures are his, from claims data with diagnosis-code assumptions). Mother Jones reports that among minors coded as trans in one insurance study, about 5 percent took blockers and 11 percent hormones, with surgery rarer, and says 27 states now ban the care for minors, surgery included. Presenting surgery on minors as widespread is malice or gross indifference to the facts.
  7. Dehumanizing and mocking language beside the child shield. The LEGO post (2022-06-08) and the "mental illness diagnoses" claim (2022-05-27) both reach beyond medicine.
  8. Personal targeting. In "The Corruption of the New England Journal of Medicine" he argues an NEJM editor's coverage shows "editorial bias", pointing to the editor's "family situation" (City Journal's words). The family member is a private individual and is not described here. Transgender Map says the Daily Mail later ran a story on the editor.
  9. Defense of "exploratory" therapy. His Genspect-hosted essay "Trans Extremism and the Weak American State" writes "conversion therapy" in scare quotes and glosses it as "exploratory talk therapy" for "cross-gender identified kids", calls a California bill a path to a "child-driven, no-safeguarding-allowed conveyor belt into lifelong medicalization", and describes Republican efforts to ban pediatric medical transition and limit the female sports category as things lawmakers "have tried". Mother Jones says the HHS report defended exploratory psychotherapy, "an approach embraced by modern-day conversion therapists" (Mother Jones's wording).
  10. Most of his anti-trans posts make no protective claim: 150 of 201 appeal to protecting no one, 39 of those deny trans people's identity and 12 are dehumanizing or single out a person (2026-04-27 targets a trans lawyer; 2026-05-12 quotes a journal line on "excluding transgender women from menstrual cycle-related experiences" as a denial of trans women's womanhood).
  11. The amicus brief of the Manhattan Institute and Dr. Leor Sapir in No. 23-477 reaches adults. It quotes the amicus brief of the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine and so asserts that "the field of pediatric gender medicine was launched because 'gender transition in adults failed to yield the intended positive outcomes.'" (p. 24; the inner words are the Society's, as quoted by the amici). The sentence is a claim about adult transition made in a brief that defends a law limited to minors. Case status: the Supreme Court affirmed the Sixth Circuit's judgment 6-3 on 2025-06-18 (605 U.S. 495), the result this brief asked for. (Brief of the Manhattan Institute and Dr. Leor Sapir as Amici Curiae Supporting Respondents, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-477, 2024-10-15, p. 24)

If this material is distressing: in the United States, call or text 988 (the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, 22). The Trevor Project supports LGBTQ young people at 1-866-488-7386, by text (START to 678-678) or at 23. Trans Lifeline runs a peer support hotline staffed by trans people at (877) 565-8860 in the US and (877) 330-6366 in Canada, on weekdays (hours at 24).

5. Platform enforcement history

None found. The account is active (archive status active, last seen 2026-11-04). No report of suspension, reinstatement or demonetization was found.

6. Ties

Role

  • Manhattan Institute for Policy Research: adjunct fellow from 2022-03-22; senior fellow now (MI release; MI person page; MI Form 990 for tax year 2025 (IRS e-file object id 202621889349301732, EIN 13-2912529, 25) lists Leor Sapir, Senior Fellow, 40.00 average hours, reportable compensation from the organization $205,213 and other compensation $36,290 (public record)).
  • City Journal (MI's publication): "regular contributor" (MI person page 1; pay not disclosed).

Formal joint work

  • U.S. Department of Health and Human Services: his Manhattan Institute bio says he is coauthor of the 2025 report (MI person page). Mother Jones (2026-04-14) says he was asked to lead the report and recruit its authors ("got the call") and quotes him: "I didn't want this to be perceived as some hit job by a bunch of MAGA-aligned conservatives"; it gives "May 2025" for publication and "November 2025" for the author names, without exact days. Erin in the Morning (2025-11-20) lists him as second author and likewise gives only "May"; the 2025-05-01 and 2025-11-19 day-level dates remain unconfirmed by these pages.
  • Amicus briefs on parental rights in education, and testimony before health committees in Utah and Texas (MI bio; self-description, undated, bills and cases not named). Separately, the Skrmetti amicus brief supporting respondents, filed with MI (section 3). Section 3 dates and numbers the ten amicus filings. The recorded joint work is the briefs.
  • Utah Legislature, Health and Human Services Interim Committee: testimony on minors' transgender health care, 2024-06-19 (Utah Legislature minutes, 20; Better Utah blog, 2024-07-03, 17). Section 3 records the Texas House witness-list entry for HB 1686. The separate witness list for 2023 Senate Bill 14 has no "Sapir" entry (Texas Legislature witness list, 26); this covers only that list, not other bills or the House side.
  • A case against Miss USA LLC (a plaintiff v. Miss USA LLC; court and docket not given by the source): his bio says his work was cited by federal judges in this case; the court, date and passage are Ninth Circuit No. 21-35228 (opinion filed 2022-11-02), footnote 2 of Judge VanDyke's concurrence, which cites his City Journal piece of 2022-05-10 (section 3) (MI person page, 1).
  • Genspect: his essay "Trans Extremism and the Weak American State" is published on Genspect's Substack. Genspect has its own profile page.
  • Defending Education: Defending Education is the same legal entity as Parents Defending Education: IRS EIN 86-1596460 (Arlington VA). IRS Form 990 e-files list the name "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION" for 2021-12-31, 2022-12-31 and 2023-12-31 (revenue $3,178,345, $4,301,156 and $5,098,994) and "DEFENDING EDUCATION" for 2024-12-31 and 2025-12-31 (revenue $5,331,408 and $6,635,388); the IRS exempt-organization master file lists "DEFENDING EDUCATION"; the Colorado charity register lists "DEFENDING EDUCATION" as an alternate name of the registrant "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION" (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 86-1596460 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 27); Colorado Secretary of State charities register, entity 20213007633). The organization's own description in the Ninth Circuit brief: "Defending Education (DE) is a national, nonprofit, grassroots association... DE uses advocacy, disclosure, and litigation to combat the increasing politicization and indoctrination of America's youth". The two names are one organization, with a profile already under its earlier name. Because Defending Education joined as a co-amicus on the cover of two briefs with him, the relationship is formal joint work rather than a mention.

An appearance or listing

  • Federal Trade Commission workshop panel, 2025-07-09 (FTC page, 15: Wednesday, July 9, 2025, Panel 2 "The Politicization of Science", "Leor Sapir, Ph.D., Fellow at The Manhattan Institute").
  • Middlebury College / Alexander Hamilton Forum, 2025-02 (Middlebury Campus, 28).
  • Podcasts named by MI: Andrew Sullivan's Weekly Dish, Wesley Yang's Year Zero, Gender: A Wider Lens. Another named: City Journal podcast, where he described the HHS report (Mother Jones).

Funding (org-level; not a tie to him)

  • Edelman Family Foundation to the Manhattan Institute: $400,000 on the TY2022 return (object id 202341359349103194), purpose as filed "TO PROVIDE SUPPORT FOR THE GENDER IDENTITY INITATIVE AT THE MANHATTAN INSTITUTE"; across 2021-2022 the funder's returns show $725,000 in 4 rows under purposes including that initiative and general support on domestic policy and urban affairs (IRS Form 990 e-file; recipient matched by name and state; Sapir not named in the filing). HuffPost (2023-10-26, page summary) reported the $400,000 without a date. Transgender Map ties his 2022 start to it; HuffPost does not.

Narrative alignment only (not a tie)

  • Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine: Mother Jones reports several HHS authors have SEGM ties, including a SEGM co-founder among the nine; Sapir's own tie is not documented. An advocacy outlet calls SEGM his "buddies" (Assigned Media, not a source for a tie).
  • AEI "parental rights" event (attended, 2025-01).
  • Heritage Foundation, Alliance Defending Freedom: no tie documented.

7. Income and funding

  • Salary: Manhattan Institute (EIN 13-2912529) return for the year ending 2025-12-31 lists Leor Sapir, Senior Fellow, reportable compensation $205,213 plus other compensation $36,290, total $241,503 (IRS Form 990 e-file, object id 202621889349301732; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 25). He is not listed on MI returns for FY2021 through the period ending 2024-12; Part VII names only officers, trustees and highest-paid employees over $100,000, so that shows only that he was not in that group. Other MI Senior Fellows on the same return are listed at $247,956 to $381,438. Earlier returns: the Institute's returns on file for the periods ending 2018-09-30, 2019-09-30, 2020-09-30, 2021-09-30, 2022-09-30, 2023-09-30, 2024-09-30, 2024-12-31 and 2025-12-31 (object ids 201921589349300332, 202011419349300516, 202112049349300321, 202241869349301604, 202301749349300805, 202421789349300307, 202541679349301564, 202522119349300517, 202621889349301732) each list five highest-paid employees over the reporting threshold; the fifth-listed amount was $249,784, $240,725, $267,189, $259,912, $248,052, $286,312, $240,342, $287,885 and $241,503 respectively. (Returns for periods ending 2013 to 2017 are also on file, five listed each; he is not on them.) He appears only on the last (total $241,503). No contractor or grant row in his name appears on any of them. This shows he was not among the five highest-paid listed before the period ending 2025-12-31; it does not show whether the Institute paid him (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 13-2912529; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 25).
  • Manhattan Institute funders, organization level, per funders' returns (IRS Form 990 e-file returns; a grant shows money moved for the filed purpose, not that it paid for anti-trans work; not added across funders): Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation $2,600,000 (9 rows, 2020-2024; e.g. "To support the Tocqueville Project"); Sarah Scaife Foundation $2,880,000 (5 rows, 2020-2024; $570,000 in each of 2020 to 2023 and $600,000 in 2024); Mercer Family Foundation $2,134,225 (7 rows, 2011-2017: $2,034,225 in 6 rows for 2012-2017 and $100,000 for 2011); DonorsTrust $758,250 (18 rows, 2020-2024); Bradley Impact Fund $382,740 (12 rows: $155,500 in 5 rows for 2013-2017 and $227,240 in 7 rows for 2018-2024; the row of $30,050 for 2021 is on both of the fund's returns for that year and is counted once). Rows without a recipient EIN (the Bradley Foundation, Scaife and Mercer rows) are matched by the recipient's full name or plain abbreviation ("MANHATTAN INST FOR POLICY RESEARCH" on the Mercer rows) and place, New York NY (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). None names Sapir. (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 52-2166327 (object ids 202133199349305758, 202243199349308799, 202323049349300742, 202423189349304787, 202513179349312256) and EIN 45-4678325 (object ids 201401349349303240, 201541419349300129, 201611379349306231, 201711099349300536, 201821219349300737, 201941449349300114, 202022979349301842, 202203489349301650, 202323199349323507, 202403199349311950, 202523189349302832 and 202233199349326743), recipient EIN 13-2912529; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 29 and 30)
  • Manhattan Institute funder lines compared with the funders' returns: DonorsTrust 18 rows, $758,250 (2020 to 2024) and Bradley Impact Fund 12 rows, $382,740 agree; the Edelman Family Foundation gave the Manhattan Institute 4 rows, $725,000 (2021 to 2022), which agrees with that foundation's returns; the Mercer Family Foundation total ($2,134,225 in 7 rows, 2011 to 2017) agrees. The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation and Sarah Scaife Foundation figures above are those of the funders' returns. (IRS Form 990-PF and Form 990 e-file grant rows.)
  • Institutional funding: MI reported revenue of $25,896,967 and expenses of $27,124,105 for 2025 (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 13-2912529, tax period 2025-01-01 to 2025-12-31, object id 202621889349301732, submitted 2026-07-07; 25 (public record)). Edelman Family Foundation gift of $400,000 for a "gender identity initiative" (HuffPost, 2023-10-26; gift not tied to him by name).
  • His essays also appear on Genspect's Substack and City Journal's Substack and in his newsletter; no books or paid subscriptions found. City Journal and the Wall Street Journal pay for articles at undisclosed rates.

8. Legal matters

None directly against him found. He is named as a co-author of the HHS report that the AAP and others have rejected; litigation over the HHS declaration and rules is ongoing (an Oregon federal judge ruled against Kennedy's declaration in March 2026 per Mother Jones), but he is not a party in anything found.

Open questions

  • Whether MI paid him before 2025: he is below the Part VII reporting threshold on earlier returns; the TY2025 line ($241,503) is confirmed. The returns for the periods ending 2018-09-30 through 2025-12-31 (nine returns, listed in section 7) each list five highest-paid employees, and he is on none before the period ending 2025-12-31; no independent-contractor or grant row in his name appears on any of them. The filings therefore show only that he was not among the five highest-paid listed; they do not show whether he was paid (IRS Form 990 e-file returns, EIN 13-2912529; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 25).
  • What Sapir said at the March 27, 2023 hearing on Texas HB 1686 and which other Texas hearings his Manhattan Institute biography refers to. The official witness list for HB 1686 records his position and lists him as representing himself (section 3).
  • The outcome of Supreme Court No. 25-840 (argument set for 2026-12-07; his second brief docketed 2026-09-15): pending; docket at supremecourt.gov.
  • Whether the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine, Heritage Foundation or Alliance Defending Freedom has a formal tie to him: none documented.
  • The original ASPS statement of August 2024: answered. The Society's own page, dated 14 August 2024 (11), carries the three phrases the Catholic News Agency report of 2024-08-16 (carried by the National Catholic Register, 31) quotes: "considerable uncertainty as to the long-term efficacy", "the existing evidence base is viewed as low quality/low certainty" and "ASPS has not endorsed any organization's practice recommendations for the treatment of adolescents with gender dysphoria". The page names no bill; it also says members should be able to provide care "without fear of government-sanctioned penalties and criminalization". The report links to Sapir's own post sharing the statement and attributes no statement on legislation to the Society. Low certainty ratings are common across pediatric medicine, where randomized trials are widely considered unethical; they are a dispute about study design and do not show the rhetoric is sincere. Later: Fox News (2026-02-03) reports the Society's position statement of that date recommends delaying chest, genital and facial gender surgeries to at least age 19.
  • The claims-data estimates in his Manhattan Institute analysis of mastectomies for minors: a Substack post by Ben Ryan dated 2024-08-23 (the City Journal piece it cites is dated 2024-08-12) repeats the "5,288 to 6,294" range as a "non-peer-reviewed analysis" in City Journal and quotes Sapir's own caveats that "2023 data are incomplete" and that the figures are an undercount because procedures had to be insured and patients needed a prior gender dysphoria diagnosis; it does not examine the method (32).

Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.

Sources

  1. https://manhattan.institute/person/leor-sapir
  2. https://manhattan.institute/article/leor-sapir-joins-the-manhattan-institute
  3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_administration_HHS_gender_dysphoria_report
  4. https://www.statnews.com/2025/11/19/hhs-gender-affirming-care-report-authors-named/
  5. https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2022/11/02/21-35228.pdf
  6. https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2023/03/14/21-35228.pdf
  7. https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/88R/witlistmtg/html/C4102023032708001.HTM
  8. https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/88R/minutes/html/C4102023032708001.HTM
  9. https://www.foxnews.com/media/major-medical-organization-urges-delaying-youth-gender-surgeries
  10. https://www.plasticsurgery.org/documents/health-policy/positions/2026-gender-surgery-children-adolescents.pdf
  11. https://www.plasticsurgery.org/reconstructive-procedures/asps-statement-regarding-gender-surgery-for-adolescents
  12. https://media4.manhattan-institute.org/wp-content/uploads/Skrmetti-merits.pdf
  13. https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25a810.html
  14. https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/24A848.html
  15. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/events/2025/07/dangers-gender-affirming-care-minors
  16. https://genspect.substack.com/p/trans-extremism-and-the-weak-american
  17. https://betterutah.org/include-medical-providers-in-discussions-of-transgender-healthcare-for-minors
  18. https://le.utah.gov/interim/2023/html/00000381.htm
  19. https://sltrib.com/news/politics/2023/01/18/why-gop-lawmakers-want-stop
  20. https://le.utah.gov/interim/2024/html/00002769.htm
  21. https://le.utah.gov/av/committeeArchive.jsp?mtgID=19415
  22. https://988lifeline.org
  23. https://www.thetrevorproject.org/get-help/
  24. https://translifeline.org/hotline/
  25. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/132912529
  26. https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/88R/witlistbill/html/SB00014S.htm
  27. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/861596460
  28. https://www.middleburycampus.com/article/2025/02/college-sponsored-transgender-healthcare-talk-receives-backlash-inspires-alternative-talk
  29. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/522166327
  30. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/454678325
  31. https://www.ncregister.com/cna/american-society-of-plastic-surgeons-says-it-has-not-endorsed-transgender-surgery-for-teens
  32. https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim