The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Yes, of course. The source of truth (scientific method? Lived experience? Etc) and how we can know it (to loosely quote Susan Stryker, a founder of the transgender studies discipline, trans issues at bottom are epistemological).
Although I’d have worded it a bit differently, Wesley’s post is 100% correct.
My guiding premise over these past years has been that the trans issue never was just—or even primarily—about people who identify as transgender.
It’s a symbolic, high-visibility proxy debate over issues and fault lines at the heart of contemporary liberal democracies: the nature and limits of parental authority; the role of schools in the moral and cultural education of youth; the norms and expectations that guide the professional class; the meaning of expertise and the basis for its demand for deference; freedom of speech and the limits of social and governmental control; the mutually correcting role of science and common sense; and so much more.
Failure to understand these deeper issues is what leads to misunderstanding of why people of all political and ideological persuasions oppose “gender identity.” Reduction of that skepticism to “hate” or “prejudice”—which may exist in some quarters!—guarantees a continuation of culture war.
Framing these debates as a debate over the fate of transgender people is therefore misleading, and not a bit self-serving. Of course they are implicated, and their rights ought to factor in to public debates just like everyone else’s. But the assumption that the debate is all about how a society accommodates a discrete minority is, at best, superficial.
Quoting @wesyang: Trans women in women's sports is a top tier issue for humanity because it's a proxy for the following questions:
-- Are we liberal society? (Or are we a progressive authoritarian society?)
-- Are we a pluralistic society? (Or are we social justice theocracy?)
-- Are we a democratic society? (Or are we governed by the unrepresentative consensus of a tiny, delusional elite?)
-- Are we a reason-based society? (Or are we a cargo cult that worships idols?)
-- Are we a reality-based society? (Or do we treat falsehoods as truths when told by people in power that it is virtuous to do so?)
-- Can we put a stop to obvious insanity? (Or are we in the thrall of ridiculous dogmas that no one can dispute because a powerful lobby calls it virtuous to clap along to absurdities and cruelties that destroy fairness?)
It’s been proposed as one way to get around medical restrictions, as an alternative to discrimination based on trans status, gender identity, or sex.
The ADA (1990) explicitly excluded transsexuality and GID, and this new HHS rule pertains to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act (1973).
A well-funded transgender advocacy network has been facilitating evasion of age minimum laws on medical transition.
One org dished out $1.2 million in a single year in travel grants.
Admissions of (de-facto) billing fraud, possible violations of state licensing requirements.
Quoting @buttonslives: NEW UNDERCOVER INVESTIGATION: I spent several months investigating a nationwide network of advocacy organizations and medical providers helping families continue medically transitioning their children in defiance of state laws.
My investigation centers on Campaign for Southern Equality (CSE), an LGBT advocacy nonprofit that connects families with cooperating medical providers across the country. CSE has distributed over $1 million in travel grants to more than 1,200 families, plus another $1 million to partner organizations, including funding for medical appointments.
With CSE's knowledge, providers in its referral network told me the ways that they circumvent state restrictions on gender-transition treatments for minors.
Some discussed using alternative diagnosis codes, such as “endocrine disorder,” to facilitate prescriptions or insurance coverage. Others described mailing medications directly to families' homes or sending prescriptions to pharmacies in states where these interventions are banned.
Providers also discussed conducting virtual appointments with patients in those states. Others required patients to cross state lines for telehealth but did not appear to have a reliable method for verifying their physical location.
My primary undercover scenario involved an 11-year-old girl in Tennessee who had only recently begun identifying as nonbinary, with no long history of gender-related distress. The providers I shared this scenario with seemed eager to treat her. Many indicated that puberty blockers could be prescribed after an initial evaluation lasting just one to several hours.
My investigation uncovered practices that may violate state and federal laws and pose medical risks to children living hundreds or thousands of miles from their treating physicians.
Read my full @[private account] investigation: https://www.city-journal.org/article/pediatric-gender-transition-treatments-bans
ICYMI: Our new data analysis finds evidence of at least 15,437 minors in Washington who had a transgender-related clinical diagnosis on their health insurance claims between 2017 and 2023.
Quoting @LeorSapir: NEW: At least 15,437 Washington minors had a transgender-related diagnosis on their insurance claims from 2017 to 2023.
In 2022, that included 1 in 58 teen girls.
A new @ManhattanInst analysis of insurance-claims data 🧵
We do, actually, have an analysis of transgender-related clinical diagnoses in the state of Oregon by ZIP area. We just haven't published it (yet).
Portland is in the lead.
See next post for preview.
Quotes a post by T19469; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Thanks for sharing, but I do want to be clear that our findings were not about medical intervention per se. They were about diagnoses that open the door to such interventions. It's reasonable to assume that claims listing a transgender-related diagnosis involve treatment for the condition, but it's not guaranteed for all cases.
Read the full analysis, including data and methods, in my latest for @[private account]: https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-youth-children-teens-washington
NEW: At least 15,437 Washington minors had a transgender-related diagnosis on their insurance claims from 2017 to 2023.
In 2022, that included 1 in 58 teen girls.
A new @ManhattanInst analysis of insurance-claims data 🧵
An important data point here is that trans issues don’t rank high for most moderate/Dem voters, at least not as discrete policy questions. They are likely more proxy tests for cultural in-touch-ness and overall candidate credibility. If Dems who disavow aspects of trans activism and get elected later renege, they may be able to avoid angering moderate/Dem voters if they take strong anti-GOP positions on other, more voter-salient issues. Think Abigail Spanberger.
Turek is a Democrat, in case that wasn’t clear.
A big question will be whether Dems who have disavowed key aspects of trans activism and gone on to win elections will follow through with their apparent convictions when it comes time to vote on bills or participate in hearings.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Iowa Senate candidate Josh Turek’s campaign ad coming out against major tenets of transgender activism has ignited a fire of fury on Bluesky, with leading activists such as Erin Reed demanding followers not vote for him and ask for their money back.
"Twenty-first century trans activism is the very inverse of [twentieth century civil rights] movements. It is elitist to its core. Spawned in philosophy and gender studies departments, it has taken over cultural, political and state-run institutions, which have then attempted to impose it, top down, on regular people who never voted for it and, as all available polls show, do not believe in it."
Quoting @jk_rowling: I wrote a new piece about women’s rights and whether or not I want trans people dead. (Spoiler: I don’t)👇
https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/an-update-to-my-essay-of-june-2020/
If I had to guess: AI generated, organized and paid for by Paxton supporter. I can’t see how the trans org could possibly be so politically stupid. But who knows.
Except that I *didn't* take the brochures to be legit. My first public comment on them was to say that they are likely a false flag, made credible by the resemblance of their contents to what trans groups regularly say.
So, I guess your cartoon is irrelevant 🤷♂️
I use my platform to say exactly what I think to be true. Which is that these brochures were likely not sent by the trans org, but they're thought to be so because their contents are exactly what such orgs regularly say.
No more, no less.
Quoting @AriDrennen: You absolutely do not need to use your platform to endorse false flags!
Amidst allegations that the trans advocacy brochure sent to Texas households is a false flag designed to boost Paxton’s campaign, one trans advocate writes:
“There’s nothing in it that’s actually bad, but it absolutely is designed to fearmonger…”
This is my position too, although I would have used “trans-identified” instead of “trans.”
I think 98% people on either side of this debate want to see these kids live happy and healthy lives.
Quotes a post by T00816; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The deflection strategy seems to be gaining ground among Democrats and progressives.
The strategy: When asked about trans policies, which are unpopular even among normie liberal voters, say that it’s a non-issue and pivot to gas prices.
Will it work?
Quoting @conservmillen: I debated feminism with a women’s rights activist who refused to say what a woman is. Can you guess her response?
Shoutout @mattwalshblog for the question to end all questions
"As of 2025, 9% of females and 5% of males on U.S. college campuses have a sex-incongruent identity."
Note that, consistent with trans movement politics and gender medicine, trans here includes non-binary.
"Non-binary identities outstrip cross-sex identities 3:1."
Quoting @segm_ebm: 🚨 Claims that youth trans identities have "plummeted" are greatly exaggerated. SEGM's new analysis shows that trans identification on U.S. college campuses reached an all-time high in 2025—a 3,600% increase since 2000. The trend is female-dominated.
Read the Spotlight ⬇️ /1
Do we let "parents decide" whether their kids should be able to buy and consume cigarettes or alcohol?
Do we let "parents decide" whether their kids should be lobotomized, if the kid wants it and a doctor is willing to do it?
Is medicine a consumer good that merely requires a willing vendor and eager customer (or caregiver)?
Curious why trans advocacy strategists think this is a viable long-term solution for Democrats. To me it reads as a band-aid solution, a way to defer the inevitable reckoning to a later date.
Critics of pediatric gender medicine once had to contend with all purported medical authorities saying in unison, "the science is settled."
No longer. Journalists, researchers, doctors, lawyers, parent advocates, detransitioners, politicians, and others successfully challenged that consensus, showing it lacked any foundation. Now gender clinicians argue acknowledge low-quality evidence but say that shouldn't be a barrier.
Is it really harder for reformers to get past this latest "parents decide" talking point?
To be clear, I think the proposed strategy could very well work for midterms and even 2028. But as a long term strategy? I have serious doubts.
Quoting @AriDrennen: 4/ What works instead: "sports associations should absolutely make rules around transgender athletes' participation, but those rules don't need to be the same in college and kindergarten." On health care, parents decide, not politicians.
Oh, sorry if that wasn’t clear. Gender clinicians don’t advocate for brain scans because they see it as “gatekeeping” and their guiding principle is “trans kids know who they are and should have total control over medical interventions.”
Aaron, I want to respond to your objection, but first I want to make sure I understand it. Are you saying the following?
“Let’s assume the transgender brain theory is true and not confounded by homosexuality or neuroplasticity. One reason kids wouldn’t be getting brain scans before getting hormones or surgeries is that a brain scan has insufficient diagnostic specificity and/or sensitivity. Population-level trends cannot be translated into a sufficiently accurate diagnostic tool.”
Is that your objection?
Let’s leave aside DSDs and metaphysical nature of the statement “female brain in male body.”
Let’s also assume for the sake of argument that this is in fact the reason gender clinicians don’t advocate for brain scans. I suspect we both know it’s not, but let’s assume so.
Oh, sure. I’m sure $ cost is why they don’t do brain scans on 14 year old girls who identify as boys and want testosterone.
I mean, it’s not like trans advocacy groups in collaboration with Democrats are able to get insurers to cover expensive treatments or anything.
Quotes a post by A0364; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Clinical proponents of the transgender brain theory never say that young patients should undergo brain scans as part of diagnosis.
The theory seems intended purely for lay consumption and reassurance of parents (& maybe clinicians).
New peer reviewed article on the science👇
Quoting @SwipeWright: 🚨NEW: Our critique of a major "brain sex" study is now published.
@[private account], @[private account], and I evaluate a central premise of gender activism and medicine: that trans-identifying people have brains that are shifted away from their sex and toward their "gender identity."
The "brain sex" concept is so central because it purports to provide an empirical scientific basis for the notion that a child can be "born in the wrong body" and would therefore benefit from body-altering medical procedures to align their body with their mind/brain.
The problem is that this concept is pure pseudoscience and propped up by deeply flawed methods and badly misinterpreted data.
One of the most prominent studies is Kurth et al. (2022), published in the Journal of Clinical Medicine, which claimed that the brains of transgender women are shifted away from their sex and toward their "gender identity." The paper became one of the journal’s most accessed articles and has been cited in major media outlets, scientific papers, legal arguments, and policy discussions involving pediatric gender medicine and sports.
We point out that the paper's headline conclusion rests on a series of serious methodological problems.
Each group contained only 24 participants. The authors used poorly justified parametric methods, one-tailed post hoc tests, made no correction for multiple comparisons, and omitted important robustness checks. Once accounted for, the main finding is no longer statistically significant.
An even more glaring failure of the study was that it failed to account for sexual orientation, despite its known association with neuroanatomical variation and despite the authors having the relevant participant data needed to examine it!
We each repeatedly requested the anonymized participant-level data from the paper's lead author so we could independently evaluate the findings.
We received no response.
The evidence simply does not justify the sweeping "brain sex" conclusion for which this study has become famous.
Our full critique in @[private account] is open access. Read it at the link below, and please cite it and share it whenever you encounter the false claim that trans people have brains that more closely resemble the sex they identify than their own sex.
🔗https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-026-09747-2
There was a clear shift in focus among those groups after Obergefell (2015), with advocacy activities centering primarily on gender (promoting new ideas and associated policies and social practices related to sex/gender).
Makenzie Scott gave $163m to LGBT groups between 2020-2022, and it’s a fair assumption that the large majority of that went to gender advocacy. She also gave $45m to Trevor this year, and gender stuff (framed as suicide prevention) is also a primary focus of Trevor.
But aside from the world of NGOs and private philanthropy, there have also been substantial government grants and programs, amounting to hundreds of millions of $, promoting gender in one way or another. For example, government records show that NIH allocated about $500m in grants toward trans-related research (virtually all of it supportive in one way or another) during the Biden years. If you tally up these and other state and federal grants in education, culture, etc., that’s *a lot* of money.
Organizations pushing back against these initiatives have a combined budget of probably $40-50 million per year (earmarked for this purpose). Even if I’m off by $20-30 million, that’s still far less than the money that has supported trans advocacy.
Curious to know if others have different estimates. This is a very rough estimate.
It would be really interesting to see an analysis by an independent researcher of the money behind the transgender debate. I suspect that if you tally up all private and public funding, transgender advocacy has outspent its opposition by orders of magnitude.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A central argument levied by transgender activists, Parker Molloy among them, is that overwhelming public opposition to the principal tenets of this movement is inorganic and is largely or completely the product of cynical persuasion campaigns waged by conservatives.
I used to think so (though as a man how could I know?) but some women believe otherwise. I don’t know how well things worked in the past. What I do know is that the trans activism of the last decade+ has made the previous situation impossible to recover, even if it was reasonable. Expectations have fundamentally changed, and policies need to be rethought.
It's possible that WPATH just gave up the game.
If its recommendations are merely one "opinion" in a legitimate debate defined by "uncertainty," and if doctors should judge independently whether to follow them, why should insurers follow them? Why should judges defer to them as the accepted standard of care? Why should other medical groups endorse or at least not oppose them?
It's possible the FTC just got its win, regardless of how this case turns out.
Why would WPATH do this? Why would they throw trans-identified patients under the bus (as they see it)? Perhaps to save their own skin?
Quoting @segm_ebm: 🚨 WPATH has conceded in court that its "Standards of Care" is merely an opinion. WPATH says it represents one side of an unsettled scientific debate marked by uncertainty — and physicains & orgs that rely on WPATH as the standard of care must bear "independent responsibility."/1
After seeing changes in her transgender case load, Solheim decided to look more closely at the research. She "was floored" to find that it was "not just poor; it was fraudulent. I couldn’t understand how my medical association, let alone others in my field, could endorse it."
In 2024, Rep. Seth Moulton told the New York Times, “I have two little girls, I don’t want them getting run over on a playing field by a male or formerly male athlete, but as a Democrat I’m supposed to be afraid to say that.”
Moulton is now apologizing, and the federal Transgender Bill of Rights he is backing will ensure that, in his own words, male athletes can run over his little girls.
In Oregon, 1 in 65 girls received a transgender-related clinical diagnosis between 2016 and 2023.
1 in 240 girls received hormones.
Kids in Oregon were almost 20 times more likely than kids in Mississippi to have a "gender dysphoria" diagnosis.
How did this happen?
For the new (national and Oregon) data on diagnoses and the Oregon Medicaid story in City Journal: https://www.city-journal.org/article/oregon-transgender-puberty-blocker-hormones
The combined diagnosis rate (0.98%) was only slightly lower than the % of Oregon teens who identified as transgender on state surveys in those years (1.18%), suggesting that social identification was a short step to diagnosis.
1 in 4 diagnosed kids got medicalized in Oregon.
The Research Connections study found that 1.51% of insured Oregon girls--or 1 in 65--and 0.46% of boys (combined 0.98%) received a "transgender-related diagnosis" during those years.
1 in 65 girls.
"Antidiscrimination" is an abstraction. The issue, as always, is what specific policies or practices are meant by this term (blacks not being allowed to vote, women being formally barred from entry into medical schools, etc.).
Here's a thought experiment. If, like Edsall, you agree that sex is real and binary and one cannot change one's sex, and if you agree that in some contexts social institutions should be allowed or even required to treat men and women differently, in what sense are trans-identified people "discriminated" against in America today? Are there cafes who won't serve patrons if they appear transgender? Employers who say that, as a matter of principle, they won't hire trans applicants? Perhaps, though I haven't heard of such cases.
One can argue, as some liberal critics of the trans movement (e.g., Andrew Sullivan) do, that the Bostock ruling formally ended "discrimination" against trans-identified people. But the details of that case are important. It was a consolidation of two lawsuits, one involving a trans-identified plaintiff. That case involved a male employee of a funeral home that lawfully maintained a sex-differentiated dress policy. The plaintiff, Aimee Stephens, wanted to dress like a woman. Gorsuch's opinion said that prohibiting that was discrimination, because "but for" Stephens' sex, a dress would have been permitted.
One could, however, arrive at the same legal result by different reasoning. One could argue--as trans-identified plaintiffs historically DID argue--that Stephens was a man who was required to "conform" to male-typical attire. In essence, one could apply the Price Waterhouse v Hopkins precedent. Whatever you think of that precedent and its application to the Stephens case, it's at least doubtful that Bostock "formally ended discrimination against trans people.:"
It's unclear to me what remains of "discrimination" when you take away those policies and practices that legitimately treat men and women differently. That even critics of the trans movement consistently fall into this trap tells me either that they are thinking of this at a high (and unhelpful) level of abstraction, or that they're trying to buy permission from fellow liberals to criticize the trans movement's excesses. Or both.
FWIW, I don't think there's any contradiction between saying that academic feminism helped lay the intellectual foundations for sex-denialism and saying that the trans rights movement made use of those foundations (among other things) to advance the interests of men at the expense of women.
Excellent new conversation on Beyond Gender with @_CryMiaRiver and philosophers @[private account] and Moti Gorin on the not-at-all controversial question of “whether transgender children exist.”
NEWS: The Federal Trade Commission has just announced its lawsuit (with four states) against the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. 👇
Read my full analysis of these and other issues with the NHB study in @[private account]
https://www.city-journal.org/article/nature-human-behavior-transgender-suicide-study
In their reply to the methodological critics, the authors of the NHB study make an interesting admission: negative public discourse surrounding passage of "anti-trans laws" may be responsible for observed increase in suicide attempts.
But they fail to see the implication.
But as the new methodological analysis shows, the headline-grabbing finding relied on a tiny dataset from a single state (Idaho), where “anti-trans laws” had been blocked by the courts for over a year by the time the supposed elevation in suicide attempts appeared in the data.
In 2024, amidst a wave of state legislation on transgender issues, a leading academic journal published a study claiming to find that that legislation increased suicide attempts by up to 72%.
Another Major Transgender Suicide Study Crumbles
A widely cited study published in the prestigious @[private account] claimed that “anti-transgender laws” encouraged teen suicide attempts.
A new methodological review dismantles that finding.
New from me in @[private account]
Despite appearing to promise in his mayoral campaign that he would invest $65m in "gender-affirming care" for adults and minors, @[private account]'s office told trans activist Erin Reed yesterday that the money (at least for now) will go toward medical interventions for adults 19+.
Quoting @Osint613: Mayor Mamdani announced $15 million for gender-affirming care services at a Pride event at New York City Hall.
Important new article
Based on 37 publicly available detransition testimonies, the authors describe pathways into and mechanisms of maintenance of trans identity, as well as catalysts for detransition and post-transition concerns.
Despite the paper's limitations, which the authors acknowledge (non-representative sample, subjective self-assessment, etc.), it should serve as a touchstone for future research on etiology, persistence, and detransition.
Open access 👇
I don't think it's pedantic. If a girl is "affirmed" as being "really a boy," and gets Rx on that basis, she is being actively misled by medical authorities. If she's told there is evidence that it'll resolve/mitigate her depression/anxiety, she's being actively misled. Sure, non-trans people alter sex characteristics all the time (e.g., boob job). But these procedures are not framed as "medically necessary." They're typically not covered by insurance. And they're not being offered as a "standard of care" to vulnerable teens.
Senator Ed Markey (@[private account]) of Massachusetts likewise made no mention of WPATH at the HELP hearing.
Markey has cited WPATH in a proposed federal Transgender Bill of Rights, which he co-sponsored with @[private account] in March 2023 and again in February 2026.
At no point did the Senate Democrats or their expert witness, @[private account] of the National Center for LGBTQ (formerly Lesbian) Rights (@[private account]), refer to or cite the authority of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH (@[private account]).
Dear Rep. Nadler (@[private account]),
Do you regard the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (@[private account]) as an authority on trans medicine in general and trans youth medicine in particular?
Quotes a post by T07121; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Cass Review has many strengths, and Cass herself deserves much praise for her important work, but this is undoubtedly one of the report’s weaknesses.
I do wonder whether Cass would have come to this conclusion had her report included a section on medical ethics and delved into the conceptual basis of trans medicine (e.g., whether there is a tolerably clear definition of “gender identity”).
Quoting @genspect: Mia Hughes, director of Genspect Canada, on the baffling conclusion of the UK’s Cass Report calling for a puberty blocker clinical trial:
“You spent four years examining this scandal, and your conclusion is we need to put more kids on this treatment to decide whether it's good or bad.
That's mad to me.
The outcome should be: my goodness, it was a mistake from Patient Zero, and it's still a mistake now. We never should have done it.
Let's get rid of the entire treatment protocol and actually help these kids.”
Technically, I think it's directed at "transgender men, non-binary, and agender people." In other words, women.
(Screenshot is from a Mass NOW educational pamphlet)
A key explanation for why Democrats support unpopular (70/30, 80/20) positions on trans issues.
This is not to deny that some Dems are "true believers." But electoral incentives are, in my view, more important.
Quoting @LeorSapir: Most won't, for a simple reason. They need to win elections, starting with primaries, and "the groups" are FAR more influential in that process than unengaged voters. By the time the latter get involved, the choice is between Trump/Trumpism and Democrats who have signed on to trans ideas/policies, which, frankly, are not top priority for most unengaged voters. Every general election comes down to "sure, we're crazy on some issues, but Trump is worse." And Dems believe--not without some justification--that that strategy is effective enough to remain competitive.
Most won't, for a simple reason. They need to win elections, starting with primaries, and "the groups" are FAR more influential in that process than unengaged voters. By the time the latter get involved, the choice is between Trump/Trumpism and Democrats who have signed on to trans ideas/policies, which, frankly, are not top priority for most unengaged voters. Every general election comes down to "sure, we're crazy on some issues, but Trump is worse." And Dems believe--not without some justification--that that strategy is effective enough to remain competitive.
Something liberal pundits and even some trans rights advocates have been saying for quite some time now:
One of the reasons trans activism has suffered serious setbacks is because it has convinced itself that only right-wing religious extremists oppose its ideas and policies.
The inability to grasp the deep unpopularity of those ideas and policies among moderates and liberals makes course correction very difficult, if not impossible, and all but guarantees continued extremism and loss of popular support.
Add to that the Democratic Party's vulnerability to "the groups" (e.g., Seth Moutlon), which spells an absence of a key corrective mechanism, and you get a movement that is driving itself into the ground.
Quoting @JenniferSey: I backed these measures and chaired one.
I’m not Evangelical. Not that there’s anything wrong with it. I’m just not.
When will reality intrude on these people’s existence??
Dr. Helen Webberly said at the Cambridge Union transgender debate that anyone in attendance who raises their hand to vote for the proposition--that is, anyone who disagrees with her--will have "blood dripping down their hands."
Quoting @PiersUncensored: "People have been scared into silence... It's extremely dangerous to be doing - I do not trust her!"
Maeve Halligan accuses Dr Helen Webberley of "profiting" off of children that are trans.
📺https://youtu.be/_rTrtvtXuBI
@piersmorgan | @[private account]
You’re right that BBC has been abysmal on Jews/Israel. I think both the trans-queer coverage and the Israel coverage are symptoms of the same underlying cause/ideology.
“As one long-serving [BBC] presenter put it to me: ‘It’s the only area of our professional life where we’re told you have to say things that aren’t true.’”
An internal report by “BBC pride” complains of “balanced debates on LGBT issues,” which are “at odds with the BBC’s corporate stance on LGBT inclusion.”
Felt need at BBC to appeal/pander to young staffers and audiences. Corporate cuts reduced senior staff tilting the balance toward younger, more ideological staff.
“Stonewall, channeled through the BBC’s diversity team, was able to pursue its agenda across the organization unchallenged.”
On GIDS, critical coverage had to be diluted with positive trans messaging.
Fascinating case study in institutional capture at the @[private account]
@unherd
March 2026 article in @[private account]'s peer-reviewed journal (IJTH):
"Menstruation is typically constructed as a biological hallmark of cisgender womanhood, excluding transgender women from menstrual cycle-related experiences."
Fair criticism of the HHS report:
“Unfortunately, neither the Cass Review nor the HHS report addressed gender dysphoria typology, likely to avoid controversy. Transgender activists and their allies have attempted to suppress discussion of both autogynephilic gender dysphoria and ROGD, preferring the incorrect account that all gender dysphoria is fundamentally similar and begins during childhood.“
Quoting @LeorSapir: New article by @[private account] and @[private account] in Current Opinion in Psychology.
I don't agree with every point, but it's an excellent summary (with useful tables) of where we are, how we got here, and what should replace the current "gender affirming" model.
Highly recommended.
I think we should resist simplistic narratives. If you're looking at sources of support for males in female sports from within the world of athletics, professional female athletes (Megan Rapinoe) and women's groups (Women's Sports Foundation) have been the most outspoken for "trans inclusion." I struggle to think of male athletes who have done the same, but maybe you'll enlighten me. Male athletes seem to remain silent or express support for sex-based sports, although some undoubtedly support gender ID.
I suppose it makes sense that we see more vocal support from women athletes and women's sports groups for males in female sports. Support from these sources is essential to your case in a way that support from male athletes is not.
Waselewski et al. 2023 found that teenage girls and young women athletes were more supportive of inclusion of males in female sports than teenage boys and young men, regardless of whether they had played competitive sports. Unclear if that's still the case in 2026.
My point is we shouldn't treat this issue as "something men are doing to women." It's obviously more complicated than that. Men are taking advantage of women, for sure, but women, for whatever reason, are more likely than men to be okay with that.
https://www.womenssportsfoundation.org/press_release/billie-jean-king-megan-rapinoe-and-candace-parker-join-nearly-200-athletes-supporting-trans-youth-participation-in-sports/
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9909496/#H1-3-ZOI221561
9. Sex. Spend enough time surveying the landscape of U.S. gender medicine and you’ll notice that, with notable exceptions, non-trans heterosexual men are largely absent from the picture. This partly reflects the fact that the “gatekeeping” specialties in gender medicine—psychology, psychiatry, social work, pediatrics—are female-dominated, but it likely also reflects women’s (on average) stronger sense of empathy (in this case, misguided) and (on average) greater desire to avoid emotional harm (saying “no” to a patient). This trait is not inherently bad, and when properly guided, can correct some bad tendencies in medicine such as excessive paternalism.
5. Overcompensation. Some gender doctors, especially vocal ones, explicitly cite adverse childhood experiences growing up gay (lack of acceptance) as a reason to want to prevent “trans kids” from suffering a similar fate. See, e.g., Jack Turban's introduction from his book, Free to Be.
1. Lack of experience. Early-career doctors lack clinical experience, a critical corrective mechanism to the abstractions they absorb in the classroom. Also, being young, they typically don’t have kids themselves and therefore have not experienced the ways of developmentally typical children and teens. If a young clinician lacks these experiences but constantly sees trans-identified patients, it's easy to see how s/he would have a skewed understanding of human sexual development.
David, I get wanting to praise your colleagues, but Gessen has spread misinformation about medical interventions for minors. I don’t know if Pulitzer should be recognizing journalists who spread misinformation where children’s health is concerned.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/06/opinion/supreme-court-trans-teens.html?unlocked_article_code=1.f1A.yI58.90Zz-MET88fk&smid=nytcore-ios-share
Julia, this is a surprisingly uncharitable interpretation of what I wrote. I obviously don't think that letting BG grow his hair out and wear makeup was the problem. Nor am I suggesting that we should compel men to have short hair (though I would enthusiastically endorse a ban on rat-tails). Rather, it's the mediating institutions of culture--academia, yes, but also media, advocacy groups, the education blob, and so on--that build on these at-first fringe cultural trends, extend them, and institutionalize them, while presenting their actions to a half-attentive public as "nothing new here, it's just more Boy George-ism." That is almost exactly what happened, for instance, in the realm of federal law, where lawyers creatively interpreted legal precedents on gender non-conformity to push the envelope on trans issues.
"Inevitable" might be a bit stronger than what I was (clumsily) trying to explain, but to your point, I agree of course that Bowie et al. were doing something very different from the contemporary meaning of trans.
More importantly, you wrote an excellent essay!
I agree that Butler (in her early years at least) rejected the notion of gender identity as it’s understood today. I’ve written about this. (See, eg, her 1988 essay Performative Acts and Gender Constitution.) That’s why, in my post above, I was careful to say that the contemporary meaning of trans is “theoretically incongruent.”
And I wouldn’t call her a feminist either, simply because she herself rejects the term (and its underlying assumption that woman is a natural category).
This is a superb, must-read post. I will disagree with one point, however, which is not central to the thesis of the article but still very relevant.
"The gender benders of the 1980s were doing something genuinely radical. They demonstrated that biological sex and gender presentation could be separated without requiring a claim about inner identity. Boy George did not claim to be a woman. Annie Lennox did not claim to be a man. The affirmative model collapses precisely this distinction, insisting that cross-sex presentation is evidence of cross-sex identity and that discomfort with gender norms is evidence of gender incongruence. The gender benders suggested something different and developmentally more liberating. They suggested that the norms themselves were the problem, not the person failing to fit them."
The distinction being described here, even if possible in theory, seems to me very hard if not impossible to maintain in practice. I don't think it's an accident that Judith Butler, who helped lay the theoretical foundations for the erasure of sex, gained prominence in the context of 1980s gender bending culture. At some point, radical gender bending is bound to invite speculation followed by forthright criticism of the very idea that humans are sexually dimorphic and that sex is defined by the organization of the body toward production of one of two distinct gamete types. (Trans, in the contemporary sense, is the theoretically incongruent marriage of this idea to that of "gender identity," which evolves out of 1960s psychology.)
That's not to suggest that deviation from traditional sex roles is bad or should be condemned. It can, of course, be liberating and, up to a point, good. And it must be tolerated in a society that values free expression. But the notion that a clear, bright line can be drawn and--crucially--enforced between David Bowie-like gender bending and what we've come to know as gender ideology is one I find unconvincing. The attitudes and institutions that permit the one will, with time, almost certainly compel the other.
Quotes a post by A2299; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
SPLC's categorization of SEGM as a "hate group" is routinely cited, not just by transgender activists but by medical groups that support pediatric medical transition and left-wing media outlets. SEGM's Wikipedia page, for instance, reflects SPLC's designation.
Strangio, who graduated from @[private account] in 2004, is known for, among other things:
* Committing to "stopping the circulation" of @AbigailShrier's book Irreversible Damage, in stark violation of @ACLU once-widely recognized principled defense of the First Amendment.
* Saying "I am a constitutional lawyer who fundamentally doesn't believe in the Constitution," and then citing that same Constitution repeatedly in lawsuits dealing with transgender policies.
* Saying "A penis is not a male body part. It's just an unusual body part for a woman."
You might be right that French takes a simplistic/monolithic view of GD/trans-ID. I don’t know his views well enough to say for sure. But the practical conclusion he draws from his (debatable) assumptions is what I’m more focused on here.
JOK is right. The idea that mental health professionals can diagnose a child as “true trans,” or predict how that child will feel about his/her body/sex when grown up, is ridiculous. It’s hubris.
JOK seems to understands this, though from her own perverse perspective.
Quoting @benryanwriter: What top pediatric gender doctor Johanna Olson-Kennedy said behind closed doors at a 2023 conference, a video recording of which I obtained.
To see the video, go to the quote tweet.
On one understanding of trans, yes. But if trans is understood as something one does, rather than something one innately is, that might be a different story.
Yes, he's 100% right about polarization. But I do think there are some questions here about the systemic causes of radicalism and--perhaps more importantly--inability to reverse course. There is also a question about who counts as a trans activist. Does a newspaper editor who kills a story because she has a trans kid count? What about a medical association leader who knows his org has made false claims but won't do anything about it for fear of personal and professional repercussions? And then there is the question of whether prolonged public deliberation, led by assimilations, could have produced a moderate version of trans rights that would have gained the assent of a majority of Americans. I'm not as confident such a thing was possible.
Do you think people on the opposite side of you in this debate believe that kids who identify as trans don't deserve dignity and appropriate care?
Honest question.
Q: So, what does the new Manhattan Institute polling data add to our knowledge of public opinion on these issues?
A: (1) a more granular picture of D voter views, with (2) evidence of some opposition to trans policies even from the party's left wing.
For background, evidence of growing opposition from Dem voters to the party's positions on trans issues isn't new.
Here, for instance, are the results of a February poll by @[private account] on surgeries and hormones for minors.
🚨A new poll by @[private account] of the @ManhattanInst provides more evidence of the gap between Democratic Party policy positions and Democratic voter preferences.
The findings from the questions on transgender issues managed to surprise even me. 🧵
Ben Appel's essay: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/03/gay-boys-lgbtq-trans/686179/?gift=KkbsgAqgmImeUM71Y0bfDLYjEv4OtjbAPG_MGSHk8zI&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share
More importantly, it was based on shoddy science.
For example, the @[private account]’s highly influential 2018 policy statement misrepresented its sources and argued that kids as young as 4 or 5 can have certain knowledge that they are transgender.
Mt. Sinai has long been a major center for transgender procedures.
Quoting @benryanwriter: NEWS: Mt. Sinai, the sprawling hospital system, has joined NYU Langone in shuttering its pediatric gender clinic in the face of threats from the Trump administration of cutting off its Medicaid funding.
NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani @ZohranKMamdani @[private account] pledged in his campaign to spend $65M in city funds on gender-transition treatment to evade pressures from the Trump administration to cut off such access. But since NYU announced it would no longer provide gender-transition drugs or surgeries to minors, the mayor has been mum on the potential for spending public funds on these interventions.
I understand why the narrative of "folding" has caught on in progressive circles, but I think it's a valid question whether it accurately describes what has happened in some of these institutions.
My hunch is that the decision involved several factors, only one of which is federal/financial pressure. It's plausible, for instance, that for some hospital administrators who already had doubts about "gender-affirming" medical interventions for minors, the Trump administration's actions offered an off-ramp. Now they can say that they were forced to do something that, secretly, they wanted to do anyway.
Or maybe the federal regulations empowered certain elements within the hospital administration that thus far were marginal or silent--for instance, the chief legal officers or risk management teams. Organizational behavior is commonly explained by such dynamics; think, for instance, of how civil rights law created compliance anxieties in large corporations that resulted in the proliferation of human resource departments, which in turn changed corporate culture and priorities.
I have no doubt that some hospital decision-makers are true believers in trans medicine for kids and ended or paused their programs out of fear of federal action. But the whole "they all folded cuz of orange man" narrative strikes me as simplistic and naive.
Quotes a post by T19871; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
New from me in @[private account]:
An opinion poll on trans issues by the left-leaning @[private account] has gone viral.
Its surface findings are consistent with recent polling, but between the lines there lurks, potentially, a more significant finding.
They don’t seem to think so.
“What explains this decline in tolerance? At the moment, we don’t know. But the evidence suggests that we can rule out two common hypotheses. The first is that the anti-gay backlash is a side effect, or spillover, of the backlash against the movement for transgender rights. If that were so, you would expect increases in anti-trans bias to be meaningfully correlated with subsequent increases in anti-gay bias — which the research does not show.”
My prediction for the trans athletics Supreme Court case is a 6-1-2 ruling, with Kagan writing a concurrence.
Kagan is by far the smartest of the three liberal justices. She's smart enough to know that Hartnett's "as-applied" argument means the death of intermediate scrutiny. She's smart enough to know that girls' safety, privacy, and opportunity in sports will be seriously compromised by a ruling that does not uphold state sex-based sports laws. She reads the Washington Post, whose editorial board came out forcefully in favor of sex-based sports. And she knows that public opinion, including among Democratic voters, supports sex-based sports. I don't expect her to join the majority--especially if Roberts assigns Alito or Thomas the majority opinion--but I can't see her signing on to a Sotomayor or Jackson dissent. Like Justice Lewis Powell, who in the Bakke case (1978) tried to split the difference on the constitutionality of racial quotas in admissions by saying that universities can take "diversity" into account, Kagan may try to chart a middle ground between the majority and the dissents. What that'll look like is anyone's guess.
Gorsuch will side with the majority. His Bostock decision was, in my view, a rookie's mistake. He was relatively new to the Court and likely anxious about the only intellectual tribunal that matters to SC justices: elite law school professors. He also probably thought--naively--that he could cabin the Bostock ruling to employment; he went out of his way to say that the ruling doesn't apply to other areas like sports and bathrooms. But he has since discovered that social policy cannot be fragmented through judicial reasoning. I think it was sobering for him to discover that just weeks later, the 4th circuit did (in the GG v. Gloucester case) just what he said courts shouldn't do, and the Biden administration, emboldened by the Gloucester ruling, cited it and Bostock in its gender identity policies.
End of rank punditry.
“Preventing males from competing in female sports isn’t the same as ‘banning transgender athletes from sports.’ Transgender athletes aren’t excluded from athletics; they are simply limited to competing with others of their own sex—like everyone else.”
Quoting @SwipeWright: 🚨In my new essay for the @WSJ, I call out the media’s distortion of the Supreme Court’s women’s sports cases. Despite their efforts to mislead, Americans have never been more clear-eyed on the topic.
This isn’t about “banning trans athletes.” It’s about sex-based categories.
Emma, I think your post assumes that she was trying to satisfy him or the listening public with her answer. I'm not so sure she was. I think she was performing to her colleagues and trans patients.
Interesting that trans activists have aggressively argued that MtF athletes are so few in number that their participation in female sports is a non-issue, but now Sotomayor's argument is that they're numerous enough to threaten satisfaction of the intermediate scrutiny test.
Ahead of oral arguments tomorrow at the Supreme Court, here are the relevant results of the 2025 Ipsos/NYT poll on trans (male) athletes in female sports.
Note the high percentage (26%) of Independent/Something Else who refused to answer. Presumably some, and probably most, would be opposed to M participation in F sports.
Surveys rarely give you information on baseline knowledge. It's more than possible that of the 31% of Dem/leaning who replied, "should be allowed," most think that hormone treatments erase any competitive advantage brought about by male puberty. Additionally, on the baseline knowledge problem, many may not know that sports participation typically also entails entry into female spaces like locker rooms.
Note, also, that this poll is now a year old, and the trend in public opinion over time has been growing skepticism of the trans activist position as represented by the ACLU et al.
Bottom line: I think it's safe to assume that the true percentage of Americans who believe female sports should be reserved to females only is higher than 79%, and of Democrat/leaning who believe the same is higher than 67%. I think this is, or in short order will be, a 90/10 issue.