The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
More cracks of sunlight in the world of U.S. pediatric gender medicine?
Amy Tishelman, formerly of Boston Children's gender clinic (GeMS), in an interview with the Boston Globe:
* social influence and maladaptive coping mechanisms can result in trans ID.
* "readiness assessment" is not, in practice, about assessing whether a kid should get Rx. She thinks it should be.
* GeMS hasn't kept track of its initial cohort of patients to see how they're doing.
* "I feel really concerned about the current state of the research."
The discrepancy between what Tishelman admits with regard to the research, lack of tracking, and sources of trans ID, and her supreme confidence that, yes, of course, some kids benefit from Rx, is quite staggering.
Cognitive dissonance seems likely here.
Link below.
My point is not that feminism or self-described feminists alone caused gender ideology. Men, especially male sexologists and trans-identified male philanthropists, played a vital role as well. But I do think feminism played a major role, at least in the U.S. /end
2/ One of the architects of this legal shift was Ilona Turner, who worked at the National Center for Lesbian Rights from 2008-2011 and was legal director at the Transgender Law Center from 2011-2018. These were the pivotal years for "sex means gender means gender identity," and Turner played a key role in inspiring the jurisprudential shift.
Great comment from Kara.
I agree that "'trans' is simply a lie," but I don't think it *has* to be a lie. It depends on what that term means.
Its current meaning--a person who has a "gender identity" that is different from their "assigned sex"--is harmful pseudoscience. "Gender identity" has no definition that doesn't rely on circular logic or sex stereotypes. And sex isn't "assigned at birth." It's determined at conception and recognized at or before birth with near-perfect accuracy. A "trans woman," accordingly, is a man who, for whatever reason, wishes to be treated as a woman, and may take steps--clothing, chemical or surgical alteration--to "pass" as one.
If "trans" simply meant an effort by a man or women to simulate the appearance of and be treated socially as a member of the opposite sex, then "trans" would not be a lie. It would accurately describe what some people feel they need to do. We could then have a reasonable debate about how to accommodate such people without compromising the rights of women and girls and the safety and wellbeing of children.
Unfortunately, the hallmark of the contemporary trans movement is to reject the second definition of "trans" in favor of the first. And that is what makes this movement extreme and illiberal. That the movement uses a liberal "rights" discourse to advance its aims is irrelevant. At most, it shows that our understanding of what rights are, where they come from, and why they are worthy of shaping social institutions has been thoroughly distorted.
A social movement cannot plausibly claim to advance justice--social or otherwise--if its core propositions are fundamentally untrue. "Rights talk" presupposes a prior commitment to truth. Not "my truth" or "lived experience" or "different ways of knowing" truth, but rational, empirically demonstrable Truth.
Well-meaning liberals can pretend--in the spirit of philosophical pragmatists like Richard Rorty--that society doesn't need to agree on basic truths to be liberal, and that we can socially affirm false beliefs in order to be "kind" and "inclusive." But the experience of the past years has clearly shown that this doesn't work.
Quoting @KDansky: The @nytimes published this article titled, "Transgender Activists Question the Movement’s Confrontational Approach. Facing diminishing public support, some activists say all-or-nothing tactics are not working" today.
I submitted the following comment, which the moderators approved:
'Of course they need to question their "confrontational" approach. They bully and insult everyone who stands up for the material reality of sex. Just yesterday, I received a death threat containing misogynist slurs via email by one such "transgender activist."
More to the point of this article, it's time for the New York Times to simply say out loud what the vast majority of people know: "trans" is simply a lie. One hundred percent of human beings are either female or male, and no one changes sex. It's fine if some people claim to have some kind of "identity," but none of that changes material reality.
Please stop framing all opposition to "trans" as "right" or "Republican." I am a lifelong Democrat and a feminist. I hear from Democrats every day who are furious at what the party's leaders have done to define sex out of existence. They're sick of it. It's why I wrote "The Reckoning: How the Democrats and the Left Betrayed Women and Girls."
Everyone can simply say right out loud that a woman is an adult human female and a man is an adult human male. It's just true.
Please see Women's Declaration International USA for more information about the feminist fight to protect the sex-based rights of women and girls. It's a nonpartisan organization, but the vast majority of its supporters hail from the political left. I served as president from 2021 until July of this year and remain a loyal volunteer. It's time to start telling the truth. "Trans" is just a money-grubbing scam.'
#terfswereright
#ListentoTERFs
#HoldTheLine
@[private account] @[private account]
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/26/us/politics/transgender-activists-rights.html
"'Here we are calling Republicans weird, and we’re the party that makes people put pronouns in their email signature,' said Representative Seth Moulton of Massachusetts..."
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/26/us/politics/transgender-activists-rights.html
The president of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health admits to making over a million dollars in the past year on gender surgeries, and says that only advocates of these procedures should develop guidelines for them.
Read more here.
Quoting @LeorSapir: 🚨NEW DOCUMENTS in the Alabama lawsuit over sex "change" age restrictions.
Some very interesting facts now coming to light. 🧵
1/ This is incredible. In the last 24 hrs, the Biden White House’s lack of message discipline accidentally revealed that its official statements on youth gender medicine are dictated to it by outside transgender activists and pressure groups.
🚨OK this is interesting.
4 days ago the Biden administration told the NYT they oppose gender surgeries for kids.
Today the White House reiterated that position to @[private account] while adding: "we continue to support gender-affirming care for minors like mental health care and respect the role of parents, families, and doctors in these decisions."
This was published at 5:14 pm ET, and made prominent trans activists very upset.
At 10:22 pm ET, The 19th News edited the article, claiming that "it has been updated to clarify the nature of the White House's response." The White House still opposes surgeries, but reportedly now says: “We continue to support gender-affirming care for minors, which represents a continuum of care, and respect the role of parents, families, and doctors in these decisions.”
In other words, between 5:14 and 10:22 the White House reportedly changed "like mental health care" to "a continuum of care." Why?
See screenshots.
This would make for an interesting FOIA.
In a thread lamenting the Biden administration renouncing gender surgeries for kids, trans activist Erin Reed (@ErinInTheMorn) claims that Rachel Levine (@[private account]) pressured @[private account] to eliminate age minimums for gender surgeries in order to ensure a “more conservative” approach.
That’s an interesting spin. The problem is that it’s false, at least according to… Levine and WPATH.
Levine’s own chief of staff told WPATH that Levine was worried specifying age minimums would invite bans. Levine reportedly wondered if the specific ages could be taken out of SOC8 and then “perhaps an adjunct document could be… created or distributed in a way that’s less visible…” Levine was “very concerned that having ages… will affect access to [surgeries] for trans youth…”
WPATH later explained that eliminating ages was intended to “ensure greater access” to surgeries for kids.
It’s clear from the unsealed emails that taking out the ages was meant to protect gender surgeries for kids, not make them less likely.
That's it.
We have hard evidence, black on white, that the World Professional Association for Transgender Health violated core principles of evidence-based medicine when writing its latest "standards of care."
We have hard evidence, black on white, that WPATH is the bedrock of the consensus of U.S. medical groups over "gender-affirming care" for minors.
We have hard evidence, black on white, that the Biden administration both pressured WPATH to produce politically desirable guidelines and then cited those guidelines in numerous policy decisions.
We have hard evidence, black on white, that U.S. healthcare providers have relied on WPATH's "standards of care" when treating minors and vulnerable adults who report feeling distress over their sex.
This is one of the worst medical scandals in modern history, and anyone who denies it should from here on out be treated as a tin-foil-hat-wearing, science-denying nut job.
3/ Two of the plaintiffs in the case, Dr. Richard Ogdon Roberts III and Dr. David L. Paul, are at the heart of a new story, based on whistleblower information, alleging that the two doctors engaged in Medicaid fraud.
See @christopherrufo in @[private account]
https://www.city-journal.org/article/the-murky-business-of-transgender-medicine
2/ SB 14 was initially blocked from going into effect by a Texad district court. That court ruled that the law likely violates the Texas Constitution by infringing on the rights of parents to seek gender Rx for their children, the right of gender clinicians to "occupational freedom," and rights of trans-identified minors to equal protection.
20/ The Cass Review has created a new baseline for public discussion on this issue.
Groups that once would likely have said, “The science is settled, kids know who they are, informed consent is enough, and anyone who disagrees is a bigot,” are now agreeing that, “Yes, the evidence is poor, most trans-identified kids are likely to be harmed by Rx, but let’s allow at least a few boys to transition early as part of an ongoing experiment.”
Not perfect, but definitely progress. /end
12/ The Cass Review strongly rejects the “affirmative” approach that has taken root across the U.S. in medical settings, in which a patient’s self-defined trans identity is itself an indication for Rx.
Last summer, Dr. Eli Coleman, lead author of WPATH's Standards of Care, wrote in @[private account]:
* "When developing the SOC-8, we followed the most rigorous protocol in the world to ensure these standards reflect scientific evidence and meet the needs of transgender patients."
* "Developing the standards of care was a long and painstaking scientific review process."
* "What bothers me the most is that politicians and legislators believe that they can assess the scientific literature and make treatment recommendations."
* "When it comes to gender-affirming care, it’s time we trust the experts."
Newly disclosed internal communications within WPATH show that WPATH privately acknowledged the low quality of research on which it was relying, wrote its SOC with a view to helping Chase Strangio (a lawyer) litigate them in court, and was pressured by HHS's Rachel Levine to remove age minimums.
https://archive.is/b8BVV#selection-1915.0-1915.70
WPATH (@[private account]) SOC8 developer: "Looking at the AAP (@[private account]) in Google they clearly see a group of trans people that I don't recognize, where gender identity always appears at childhood, that is not my experience."