The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
There is a difference between prescribing puberty blockers to children with central precocious (abnormally early) puberty and prescribing them to kids with no physical pathology during normally timed puberty.
The diagnoses and risk/benefit profiles are different.
Doctors can continue prescribing puberty blockers to children with central precocious puberty regardless of whether those children are transgender-identified.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
From a new paper by Dr. Michael Biggs of Oxford University in Medico-Legal Journal, based on a talk he gave:
"[E]ven though only a small number of children have undergone early puberty suppression, they dominate media portrayals and they help to construct the image of the transgender child. It’s very telling that all the media friendly trans kids have had early puberty suppression: Jazz Jennings in America and Jackie Green in the UK; there was also a trans boy called Leo who was featured on BBC Children’s television; and Valentijn de Hingh, a very famous transgender woman in the Netherlands. So actually they have an outsized role in constructing this idea of a transgender child.
"Moreover, the availability of puberty blockers becomes a kind of self-fulfilling prophecy because it makes social transition feasible. Before puberty blockers, it was not really possible to socially transition in school because, obviously, your emerging sex characteristics would become visible to everyone. But the availability of puberty blockers makes social transition in school possible; consequently, social transition becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy because it locks in the transgender identity.
"I think the final broader cultural ramification of puberty suppression is that you begin to conceive puberty not as a crucial life stage that we all have to go through in order to become adults – but as literally a disease or almost like a disease. As de Vries, the most published Dutch gender clinician, says, ‘Disallowing puberty suppression, resulting in irreversible development of secondary sex characteristics, may be considered unethical’. This is why she said we can never have a randomised control trial because it’s actually unethical not to stop puberty. So the broader social and cultural implications of puberty suppression are very wide."
Trans activists have pressured Washington State University to (temporarily) suspend a CME by the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine, echoing a similar (and successful) bullying campaign against @[private account] and @[private account].
@benryanwriter reports ⤵️
Jo, regarding your first point, yes, I did consider that. GnRHa can be said to "modify" sex traits in the sense that they prevent them from developing (a kind of teleological argument, if you will). It's less clear to me that we can say the same about orchiectomy plus penectomy. Mastectomy is maybe in the middle. Regardless, I think it's helpful to have a term that captures the purpose of these procedures, which, incidentally, is what "gender-affirming care" tries to do so.
Regarding your second point, that's a tricky one. You're right that some trans-identified adults (seems to be of the older generation?) do not deny the reality of their sex, though in the younger generations, and among gender doctors, I've seen plenty of evidence of such denial. The catch, of course, is when we move from the biological category to the social category. If you define woman as an adult human female, and understand female as one of the two sexes, then a trans-identified male who wishes to be treated as a woman ipso facto wishes to be treated as female. And that seems indistinguishable from asking others to rejecting (or deny) one's sex. I guess the question is: is your second claim compatible with the definition of woman as an adult human female?
UPDATE ON LANGUAGE
A while ago, I began using the term "sex-trait modification" (STM) as an alternative to the sanitized and euphemistic "gender-affirming care" (GAC). The latter is a marketing term and ill-suited for evidence-based, ethical medicine.
In response, some people have argued that even STM, though obviously better than GAC, is not great, not least because it inaccurately describes some procedures. A male who undergoes orchiectomy and penectomy doesn't have his genitals "modified." He has them removed entirely. A child whose puberty is suppressed with GnRHa doesn't have his sex traits modified but rather prevented from developing in the first place.
A proposed alternative to STM is "sex-rejecting procedures" (SRP). While also not perfect, I do think this term better captures what happens in the context of medical interventions. Specifically, it better captures the purpose of these interventions, which is to distance oneself from the embodied, immutable reality of being male or female (i.e., sex).
My goal in the past few years has been to find and use language that can facilitate substantive discussion among people--in particular medical and mental health professionals--who are open-minded and who want to act in the best interests of patients, including those who identify as transgender. I continue to believe that neutral, descriptive language that is neither hyperbolic nor sanitizing is critical for achieving that goal.
We didn't agree there is overlap. That's an assumption you're making. It's theoretically possible--and, taking Twenge and the YRBS/WI data together, likely--that the share of youth among trans-identified people went up while the overall rate of trans ID among youth went down.
You're comparing apples to oranges. "What share of youth identify as trans" and "what share of people who identify as trans are youth" are two separate questions.
For those wondering if the reported drop in trans ID among youth matches what we found last year in our analysis of a national insurance database.
Short answer: yes, but.
Quoting @LeorSapir: Good question. Recognizing that trans ID is not the same as gender dysphoria Dx, and neither is the same as medical procedures, we did find a decline in both GD Dx and mastectomy from 2022 to 2023. Our data for 2023 were not complete (we had data until October, if memory serves), so it wasn't possible to state definitively that there were declines. However, at least with regard to GD Dx, we adjusted for the missing data, and the estimate still came in at lower than 2022.
What's "this data" though? Williams Institute? YRBS? The WI page you highlighted is more about the age skew within the trans-ID population, not the overall rates of trans ID among youth. Sorry, just trying to understand what you're comparing here.
Good question. Recognizing that trans ID is not the same as gender dysphoria Dx, and neither is the same as medical procedures, we did find a decline in both GD Dx and mastectomy from 2022 to 2023. Our data for 2023 were not complete (we had data until October, if memory serves), so it wasn't possible to state definitively that there were declines. However, at least with regard to GD Dx, we adjusted for the missing data, and the estimate still came in at lower than 2022.
Update on the debate over whether trans ID has fallen among youth
Quoting @benryanwriter: NEWS: Trans and nonbinary identities are indeed in free-fall in college age Americans.
Prof. Jean Twenge @[private account] found new survey data that supports @epkaufm's much disputed claim from last week.
Twenge also found data indicating that trans identity increased exponentially by birth year until those born after about 2002. These identities have plummeted in those born more recently—who are now 20 to 23 years old.
The problem with Kaufman's data is it didn't distinguish between trans and nonbinary identities. The data that Twenge found does.
The decline in such identities in younger Americans raises important questions about the future of the field of pediatric gender medicine and the question of whether these identities are at least partially driven by social influences, as opposed to immutable, inborn traits.
Clark presents useful summaries of survey data on differences in attitude between men and women.
I admit that the gap on questions of free speech/pursuit of truth is larger than I previously thought.
(On trans issues, other surveys have shown, it’s about 10 points.)
Quotes a post by T32180; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A few days ago, @epkaufm published a report claiming to show that transgender identification was on the decline (see graph). The specific finding was that non-binary identification was on the decline.
Critics on either side of the gender debate argued that the finding was invalid because (a) non-binary is not transgender, or at least not a reliable proxy for it, and/or (b) Kaufmann did not weight the surveys (i.e., adjust for problems of representation in the data). Had he done so, they say, the data would have showed that non-binary is actually on the rise.
Kaufmann has now published a response to these criticisms (see next post).
What Ben is pointing out here is that the survey published today on trans ID has a limitation.
Yes, inasmuch as nonbinary is considered part of trans, that subcategory of trans is shown to be on the decline.
However, for surveys that only ask if respondents identify as man/woman/nonbinary etc., it's not possible to know if someone who ticks, e.g., "man," is a female who identifies as a man. So, it's possible that the *total* rate of trans ID has not, in fact, gone down, even if NB-trans has.
(Caveat: the CDC YRBS recently incorporated a two-step question that is supposed to pick up on this nuance. I haven't gone over the data, so I don't know if that info was included).
In short, an interesting finding for sure, but interpret with caution. I admit that I, too, missed this at first.
Quoting @benryanwriter: If someone in college identifies as trans and are asked, "Do you identify as male, female or nonbinary," then they're probably going to say they are male or female, not nonbinary. Therefore presuming that shifts in nonbinary identification in college-age youth responding to such a survey should not necessarily be interpreted as shifts in trans identification.
Unless the questionnaire itself specifies that NB is not trans, I would think that it's a plausible interpretation, given framing by gender authorities, that at least some NBs, and likely most, understand NB as part of trans.
Yes, we've seen this evidence for a while now. NB appears to be (or at least was) the fasted growing category within "transgender," as that term has been defined by medical, mental health, educational, legal, cultural, and other authorities. It's totally fine to reject that definition (e.g., in favor of a "true transsexual" type of definition, as Brianna often uses), but one should be clear that that is what one is doing.
I'm not so sure what you're not so sure about. Are you saying that we shouldn't accept the prevailing definition of trans, which includes nonbinary? Kaufmann's finding is valid if we accept that definition, invalid if we don't.
I'm not saying such a move would be illegitimate. Just genuinely curious what you have in mind here.
Not only is there nothing to distinguish nonbinary from binary trans identification within the widely accepted definition. There's also nothing to distinguish lifelong agony related to one's sex and/or desire to undergo medical interventions from run-of-the-mill gender nonconformity.
On this point, see @SwipeWright's essay in WSJ Opinion, "Every Tomboy is Tagged 'Transgender'"
https://www.wsj.com/articles/every-tomboy-is-tagged-transgender-transsexual-gender-dysphoria-children-hormones-clinic-terminology-expectations-11663872092?msockid=3394aed285fc6632282aba2384bf67b1
Ben Ryan reflects on what we know and (more importantly) don't know about the links between transgender identity, transgender activism, and violence.
Quoting @unherd: There have been no academic studies that have analysed the available data to produce an estimate of the per-capita rates of mass shootings among trans people versus other demographics.
Read @benryanwriter on why we need research, not demonisation 👇
https://buff.ly/KS7hnhn
This is a bad idea, and likely unconstitutional.
If the goal is to ban gun ownership for people with mental illness (associated with risk of violence), do it consistently, without regard to trans.
Quoting @MaryMargOlohan: BREAKING: The Justice Department is deliberating banning guns for transgenders as part of a range of options blocking mentally unstable individuals from committing acts of violence, @realDailyWire has learned.
Story to come.
This is a must-read. It’s why I find the trans issue so fascinating. It’s NOT just about the health issues of a small number of people. It’s fundamentally about the health of Western institutions and expertise, and the vulnerability of both to political and ideological forces.
Quoting @benryanwriter: In a follow-up newsletter to my coverage of what @JesseSingal called the "disaster at McMaster," I:
▶️Go into greater depth about the ethical debates between Dr. Guyatt and others behind the effort to develop evidence-based treatment guidelines for pediatric gender medicine.
▶️Publish detailed statements from Dr. Guyatt that he made at the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine (SEGM) conference in New York in October 2023, which I attended. These remarks will help clarify his point of view on how evidence-based-medicine principles should guide pediatric gender medicine clinical decision-making. The quotes will also indicate at least one way that Dr. Guyatt contradicted himself in his Aug. 14 statement.
▶️Call into question Dr. Guyatt’s recent astonishing claim to Singal that he didn’t know until a few months ago that since 2021, SEGM was funding his team’s work on the gender-medicine review papers. In their August statement, Dr. Guyatt and his colleagues disavowed SEGM in oblique terms, suggesting that the nonprofit is not truly grounded in science, but failing to explain their reasoning.
▶️Publish internal emails that I obtained of the McMaster team deliberating over how to respond to mounting activist pressure for them to distance themselves from the “misuse” of their work by those seeking to cause “harm”.
See the 🧵⬇️⬇️
According to the widely accepted definition of transgender (someone whose innate sense of gender is different from what’s expected of their sex), yes, all but the most manly men and girly girls, and perhaps even they, are indeed transgender.
Quotes a post by T28557; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
New editorial by gender docs in JAMA Pediatrics argues that the cisgender/transgender binary doesn’t capture cisgender boys who feel a bit like girls and cisgender girls who feel a bit like boys.
These, apparently, need to be studied and made more visible to the medical field.
Edwards-Leeper agrees that the term “trans kid” is "not neutral," and that it "puts [kids] on a more likely path toward medicalization."
She used to use this term but says she doesn’t do so anymore.
1/ Concepts including "assigned sex," "gender identity" and "trans kids" are foundational to the field as it exists today. Clarity about these concepts is critical to having a plausible clinical rationale.
I once saw a woman testify in a state legislative hearing on gender medicine about how the law would impact her three transgender children.
At what point do people pause to wonder, hmm, what might be going on here?
These are the opening paragraphs from today’s New York Times article.
Calling kids “transgender minors” is not editorial neutrality. Nor is it a matter of “style.” It is taking sides in a debate, and NYT has to stop pretending otherwise.
Also, “two transgender daughters”?
@[private account] @SarahEMcBride @ezraklein Yes. They conflate the percentage of adults who identify as transgender with the importance this issue should have for the average American. The problem, of course, is that even families who don't have an adult or kid who IDs as trans are affected by gender identity policies.
A few weeks ago, Rep. @SarahEMcBride appeared on @ezraklein's podcast and made the case that Democrats moved too fast on transgender issues and failed to persuade the public. This article makes a similar case.
In both instances, there is some concession that the party has adopted a "maximalist" position dictated to it by advocacy groups, but the assumption otherwise is that a slightly more moderate version of the program would be acceptable to the majority of Americans. This would mean some males in female sports, some kids getting medically transitioned, and some social and potentially even legal pressures to speak and act in ways that signal a replacement of sex with "gender identity."
I don't think this assumption is well-supported.
First, it does not make much sense to assume that the American public, including Democratic voters, know less today about these issues than they did, say, five years ago. The opposite is almost certainly the case. Thus, the more the public has been exposed to the substantive debate over these policies, the more it has drifted to the side of skepticism.
Second, as I've written in the past, trans issues seem to have gone in the opposite direction of gay/lesbian issues in terms of the "contact hypothesis." The more people who identify as trans become visible, the more they are personally known to other Americans, the less popular gender identity policies in sports and medicine seem to become.
In my view, there is a reason groups like SPLC, ACLU, and GLAD deploy shaming tactics against liberal institutions such as the New York Times when they report on the substance of, say, youth gender medicine. Activists seem to appreciate that letting the public consider the arguments on substance does not work in their favor. They'd prefer that these policy issues remain siloed within professional issue networks with little or no public exposure.
I can't blame them.
Put simply, this isn't a case of issue network elites pushing for policies without enough time to make the argument to the public. Rather, the argument has been made, and it has found to be unpersuasive on its merits.
If anything, I'd say that the one thing keeping the public--and especially Democratic voters--from becoming even more skeptical at an even faster pace is Republicans speaking about these issues with a tone that appears (or is) lacking in compassion.
Dr. Haller,
Can you please explain what you mean by "children... who are undeniably transgender to their core"?
And how can a clinician know that a child "is undeniably transgender"?
The dominant view in your field seems to be that clinicians and parents can know a child is "undeniably transgender" when the child says so. Is that your view?
I don't deny that there are kids who are extremely gender nonconforming, or who are confused/mistaken about their sex. But I'm guessing you mean something else by "transgender to their core"?
Genuinely curious where you stand on this.
Whether Brianna is right here depends entirely on what is meant by the loaded phrases "trans people exist" and "protection in society."
1. If it means that some people have a "gender identity" that is different from their "sex assigned at birth," and that their "gender identity" is real and socially relevant more than their "assigned sex" (in short, gender ideology), then agreeing that "trans people exist" means assenting to unscientific and--as we have come painfully to learn--harmful propositions, and ones that Sullivan himself rejects.
Recent years have offered up many examples of leading public figures and institutions posing exactly this all-or-nothing choice: "If you don't agree with the new understanding of sex and gender, which underwrites transgender identity, then you deny the very existence of trans people."
If you accept gender ideology as true, then "protection in society" means eliminating sex-based spaces and activities, changing how we talk, and authorizing medical interventions for children to align their bodies with their "gender identity."
2. If, however, "trans people exist" means that some people wish, for whatever reason, to be perceived and treated as members of the opposite sex, then it's false to say that "95 percent of the people in this space" deny that "trans people exist." Rather, at issue is how a tolerant society should understand and respond to their distress/desires.
***
There is a reason why almost all Americans who currently reject the propositions of gender ideology said nothing about this matter before 2014 or so. That was when "trans people exist" began to change its meaning from (2) to (1), and when, consequently, "protections" came to mean "using law and social institutions to force people to go along with gender ideology."
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Andrew Sullivan on how the gay rights movement radicalized and lost its way: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/26/opinion/gay-lesbian-trans-rights.html?unlocked_article_code=1.R08.STnM.XL_KMkPAvm49&smid=url-share
One interesting aspect of the Skrmetti decision is that the transgender movement's redefinition of core terms (sex, gender, gender identity, and transgender) in recent years has made it all but inevitable that the Court will refuse to recognize transgender as a group eligible for special constitutional protection.
The current, widely accepted definition of transgender is someone whose "gender identity" is different from their "assigned sex," with "gender identity" being defined as a person's "inner sense" of gender, and gender being defined (if at all) in terms of stereotypes.
Thus, the definition of transgender endorsed by such authorities as the American Psychological Association is not meaningfully different from the definition of gender nonconformity--including garden-variety nonconformity. (See, e.g., @SwipeWright's essay on this matter in WSJ Opinion.)
Since by this new definition of transgender practically anybody could legitimately identify that way, it's hard to see how transgender can be seen as a "discrete and immutable characteristic" coterminous with a defined social minority group.
.@helenlewis in @TheAtlantic: “Trump’s actions on trans policies reflect a pattern across the administration of chaotic executive orders, inflammatory language, and counterproductive decisions. European reviews have found that American child gender-medicine practices far outstrip the available evidence for their safety and efficacy. But the Trump administration isn’t helping convince the champions of puberty blockers to reconsider. When the Department of Health and Human Services commissioned a balanced, well-evidenced report suggesting caution in child gender medicine, the administration preempted its release by calling the practice ‘chemical and surgical mutilation.’ The White House’s emotive language duly gave liberals—along with the medical associations who were criticized by the report—permission to ignore the findings.”
To be fair, I think there would have been plenty of ignoring had the Trump administration (or any Republican admin) not used inflammatory language or initiated policies before the report came out. After all, many liberals and medical associations have ignored or demonized researchers making careful and respectful arguments in peer reviewed journals. That’s what led to this issue being politicized in the first place.
Still, I think Helen makes a good point.
Creating a transgender category in sports, which @Simone_Biles recommends as an alternative to males competing in female sports, has been heavily criticized by trans advocacy groups as “separate but equal” and a violation of dignity and civil rights.
People in glass houses…
Quoting @Simone_Biles: @Riley_Gaines_ You’re truly sick, all of this campaigning because you lost a race. Straight up sore loser. You should be uplifting the trans community and perhaps finding a way to make sports inclusive OR creating a new avenue where trans feel safe in sports. Maybe a transgender category IN ALL sports!!
But instead… You bully them…
One things for sure is no one in sports is safe with you around!!!!!
Regarding sports, Cowan writes that "transgender girls and women should not be allowed to compete in women’s sports at the level of high school or above in ways that compromise safety or fairness. But these should not be decisions for politicians; instead, rules governing those activities should be made by sports associations and local school districts."
The problem here is that these very associations were the ones pushing for gender identity-based participation. Lia Thomas did not violate NCAA or World Aquatics rules when winning the NCAA Division I championship in 2022. It was only because of growing outcry and political pressure that the rules were later changed. The high school boys now winning medals in girls' competitions across the country are playing by the rules, not violating them. And that's precisely the problem.
And as long as Cowan is talking about politicians interfering with sports, why not mention how Democratic lawmakers passed gender identity codes that effectively compelled sports associations to adopt gender identity policies? Why not mention Catherine Lhamon, architect of the Obama-era Title IX crusades in favor of gender identity sports?
As with medicine and schools, social institutions fell capture to activists and showed absolutely no signs of being willing to moderate, making it necessary, due to lack of alternatives, for Republicans to step in. Like Cowan, I wish social institutions could regulate themselves. Alas, they cannot.
Jonathan Cowan, president of the liberal think tank @[private account], writes in @[private account] on how trans issues are liability for Democrats, and how they can moderate.
We should welcome perspectives such as these, but I think Cowan still gets it wrong.
Thread 🧵
20/ The ideological intrusion into medicine and the creation of a false consensus on youth gender medicine starts with medical journals like NEJM.
Read my latest: https://www.city-journal.org/article/new-england-journal-of-medicine-transgender-activists
18/ A few months later, on “Transgender Day of Remembrance,” NEJM co-hosted a symposium with Harvard Medical School’s DEI office, titled “Sex, Gender, and Sexuality in the Journal.”
4/ In 2023, NEJM published “Psychosocial Functioning in Transgender Youth after 2 Years of Hormones” (Chen et al.)
NEJM claims that its peer-review process involves “detailed checking for accuracy” to “prevent[] overstatements.”
Did that happen here?
TRAs, 2010-2020: we need to embed a new gender theory across all social institutions, including schools, clinics, academic research programs, public interest orgs, state and federal bureaucracies, media style guides, prisons, homeless shelters, and international orgs like WHO. We need to redefine what it means to be humans, and dispense with millennia of understanding of human sex differences. And we need to make sure that kids agree with this, even if their parents do not. Anyone who objects will be labeled a transphobe and a violator of civil rights law.
Republicans: um, no.
TRAs: why are Republicans making everything about trans people?
Quoting @TheAdvocateMag: Sarah McBride is 'mystified' that Republicans are making trans people a 'priority' https://www.advocate.com/politics/sarah-mcbride-republicans-lgbtq-priorities?utm_campaign=trueanthem&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook
Complicated, not something I can reproduce here. It’s mostly clinic samples, and questionably representative. Trans ID is another question, but even that’s not entirely reliable.
Brianna is correct that the central rationale for transitioning kids--ability to pass as adults--does not really apply to girls given the powerful effects of testosterone on the body.
The reason boys are said to "need" early transition is the same reason girls do not; testosterone is the elephant in the room.
It's not true, however, that the skyrocketing rates of trans ID and referrals to gender clinics have been only among adolescent girls. In the U.K., for instance, referrals of adolescent boys went from 24 in 2009 to 426 by 2016--a nearly 18-fold rise. In Norway, referrals for adolescent boys went from close to zero in the early 2000s to around 70 by 2019. (Source: Cass Review.)
Even if we accept that some of these boys will experience severe distress associated with their male bodies for the remainder of their lives, and that no less invasive treatment will help them, there is no way to know who these boys are. Gender clinicians who believe they are "conservative" and "cautious" because they insist on thorough mental health evaluations are either arrogant or deceiving themselves. There is no evidence for such claims, and they fly in the face of common sense and accumulated wisdom about child development.
The Dutch implicitly acknowledged the low predictive value of a "gender identity disorder" diagnosis. They argued, after all, that puberty blockers are reversible and will "buy time" to figure out whether transition is the right path. By their own admission, they couldn't be certain the adolescents who received these drugs were future transsexuals.
In her report to the NHS, Hilary Cass wrote that "A formal diagnosis of gender dysphoria is frequently cited as a prerequisite for accessing hormone treatment. However, it is not reliably predictive of whether that young person will have longstanding gender incongruence in the future, or whether medical intervention will be the best option for them" (p. 193).
So, while I'm sympathetic to Brianna's point that it's wrong to treat boys and girls as being interchangeable for the purpose of early interventions, I strongly disagree that we should save the girls by sacrificing the boys. That is unacceptable.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.