Gage Skidmore from Surprise, AZ, United States of America, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (James_Lindsay_(52586746259)_(cropped).jpg) [image page1; CC BY-SA 2.02]
James Lindsay
Co-manager of New Discourses LLC
18documented ties15 names on file
1organization with a role on file
@ConceptualJamesperson
1. Public identity and role
Describes himself in his X bio (archive, 2026-10-27/11-04) as "Chief Anti-totalitarianism Officer @NewDiscourses". 568,500 followers, verified; account created 2012-09-16 (archive). Amplified 113 times by 48 tracked accounts (influence table, as of 2026-11-16).
Credentials: a Ph.D. in mathematics (Wikipedia: Ph.D. in mathematics in 2010 from the University of Tennessee, Knoxville; the Transgender Map page says the same).
Founder and president of New Discourses; Genspect USA described him as "author, speaker, founder, and president of New Discourses" (Genspect USA's own words, in its announcement of him as a speaker for ROGD Awareness Day 2024 on "The Queering of American Schools"; the announcement does not show that he attended).
Co-author of "How to Have Impossible Conversations" (2019, with Peter Boghossian), "Cynical Theories" (2020, with Helen Pluckrose; Pitchstone; a bestseller on Wall Street Journal, USA Today and Publishers Weekly lists), "Race Marxism" (2022), "Counter Wokecraft" (2021) and "The Queering of the American Child" (2024, with Logan Lancing) (Wikipedia, 1: titles and years match; it lists Counter Wokecraft as co-written with Charles Pincourt and The Queering of the American Child with Logan Lancing). In 2017-2018 he and Boghossian submitted hoax papers to journals (the "grievance studies affair"; Wikipedia).
Wikipedia says he has been credited as one of several public figures who helped popularize "groomer" as a slur against LGBTQ educators, which it supports with NBC News, Daily Beast and Yahoo News reporting (Wikipedia; the article names these sources). Transgender Map (an advocacy tracker) calls him an "anti-transgender activist". Both are third-party characterisations (Wikipedia; Transgender Map).
New Discourses LLC (Florida Division of Corporations, entity L19000234287, 3; formed 2019-09-17; Active): one record of the filing lists James S Lindsay (Manager) and Michael W O'Fallon, the second co-manager and also the registered agent (publicly, the founder of Sovereign Nations per the New Discourses event page for "Saving American Liberty, Session 2", 2026-11-09; Wikipedia's James A. Lindsay article, calls him president of Sovereign Nations, says Lindsay's video series is hosted by Sovereign Nations and says New Discourses is "owned by" him; the filing does not confirm ownership); a third person with the title "Auth" is also listed, without a name given here. The Florida Division of Corporations data as of 2026-11-08 list James S. Lindsay and Michael W. O'Fallon as Managers and O'Fallon as registered agent (section 6).
2. Posting record (project archive, all posts coded)
Followers 568,500 (tier 100k-1M). Keyword posts (weighted) 54.2; views on keyword posts 974,680; influence rank 110 under equal weighting (not in the top set under every weighting).
Coded posts: 203, every post, reply and quote by the account that matched the search terms (archive as of 2026-11-16). Severity: C0 21; C1 128; C2 15; C3 24; C4 14; C5 1. Share at C2 or above: 26.6% (54 of 203).
Shield framing (the post justifies itself by protecting children or women): 28 of 203 coded posts (13.8%).
What the coded posts show: Most of this account's coded posts are anti-trans rhetoric: 182 of 203 are C1 or above, and the record runs from 2019 to 2026 with its heaviest posts in 2025 and 2026. The dominant line, in 60 posts, casts trans people and their allies as a political enemy, followed by the claim that trans identity is a cult or ideology (50), denial of trans people's identity (45), the claim that trans people are violent (20) and the claim that gender medicine causes harm (18). Only 28 of the 182 carry a protective claim; 154 make no appeal to protecting anyone, 36 of those deny trans people's identity and 31 are dehumanizing or single out a person (C3 to C5). The C4 and C5 posts single out private individuals (7, never named here) and public figures (8).
257 archived posts, 2019-08 to 2026-10 (snapshot of 2026-11-04); 202 collected from his own timeline, the rest through other tracked accounts.
Coded: 2026-03-11 (C1, CONTAGION, DENIAL): "When you figure out the formula to inspire them or trans-identifying young people out of their radicalism, let us know." 2021-10-02 (C1, sports shield): "HONK", linking a Post Millennial story on a trans athlete's award. Both posts are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric, as the framing note at the top of this profile describes.
Highest-reach posts about trans people (archive; several are reposts by tracked accounts of his original posts; each is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric, as the framing note at the top of this profile describes):
An X post of 2023-04-06 (3,155,793 views): "Colorado police intervene and stop another trans school shooter before it happens." (A district attorney's spokesman said the defendant "was in the process of transitioning to female" (Fox 29 and sister stations, 2023-04-07); no attack took place and nobody was shot, so the "shooter" label is unsupported, and "another" presents one case as a pattern (section 3); FactCheck.org, 17 Sep 2025, reports that mass shooters are rarely trans: under 0.1% of mass shootings recorded by the Gun Violence Archive.)
A quote post of 2023-10-24 (the archive row is a repost by another account; 425,651 views): "Trans girls don't exist. They deserve to be treated for their severe mental illnesses in minimally invasive and aggressive ways. They deserve to be protected from groomers and Queer Theory."
@realDailyWireRepost
Reposted from @ConceptualJames, originally posted 2025-01-10 14:21 UTC. The words are the original author's.
The story of what has been happening to our kids under trans and gender ideology is horrifying. Turning Point USA has made an amazing, must-watch, must-share documentary about it called Identity Crisis I'm proud to be part of. Free on X this weekend!
https://x.com/realDailyWire/status/1877716776274075718/video/1
394,524 views
What it says "The story of what has been happening to our kids under trans and gender ideology is horrifying. Turning Point USA has made an amazing, must-watch, must-share documentary about it called Identity Crisis I'm proud to be part of."
A quote post of 2023-09-10 (360,647 views): "The trans cult is unbelievably destructive. Unbelievably."
@ConceptualJamesPost
Conservative parents all over the country who, by the grace of God, didn't lose their daughters to trans because of Woke Left now face seeing their sons lured towards Nazism by the Woke Right, and the justifications are just as bad and based in resentment as in 1920-30s Germany.
What it says "didn't lose their daughters to trans because of Woke Left now face seeing their sons lured towards Nazism by the Woke Right".
Examples from the full coded record (the highest-reach posts by severity level and main line of attack):
@ConceptualJamesQuote
Doesn't he have the same Nazi tattoo as that recent trans murderer in Rhode Island?
Quotes a post by T05760; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C4 targetinghand-codedcrime caseviolence terror
3,682 views
What it says Quote post asking whether a public figure has "the same Nazi tattoo as that recent trans murderer", tying trans people to Nazism and murder.
What it says Post that answers a story about a trans athlete's award with "LOL HONK", mocking a public figure.
@ConceptualJamesQuote
Trans violence is violence.
And as many have predicted and explained over the years, the suite of factors that constitute and underlie trans ideology, including its selection bias to disordered individuals and the irreversible damage it causes, plus the sheer unreality, do this.
Quoting @nypost: 'Shocking' study shows link between transgender ideology and left-wing violence https://trib.al/PaeT57j
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedideology cultmedical harmmental illnessviolence terror
44,721 views
What it says Says "Trans violence is violence" and blames trans ideology, with its "selection bias to disordered individuals" and "irreversible damage", for it, presenting trans people as disordered and dangerous.
@ConceptualJamesQuote
Trans violence is violence.
Quoting @lukerosiak:
C2 false claimshand-codedviolence terror
30,185 views
What it says Quote post whose only text is "Trans violence is violence.", casting trans people as violent.
Correction Trans people are far more often victims than perpetrators of violence; no epidemic exists.
@ConceptualJamesQuote
Never Again is now.
This is why back at the start of the year, I was already saying parents who luckily avoided watching their kids go trans will now be doomed in many cases to watch them get recruited as Nazis.
Never Again is now.
Quotes a post by T08853; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedcontagion
152,774 views
What it says Says parents who avoided watching their kids "go trans" are now "doomed" to see them "recruited as Nazis", linking trans identity to extremism.
@ConceptualJamesPost
In some ways, "America First" has become for Gen Z a kind of political trans ideology. Trans ideology believes gender can be separate from sex and can therefore be modified according to feeling, and "America First" believes the US can be separate from the world and thrive.
This is the result of a clever trick that has hijacked the idea of prioritizing America over globalist or "global cooperation" agendas that characterized presidencies from Clinton's to Obama's. Prioritizing American interests rather than other interests when those are at the expense of America is the right way, but this doesn't mean we can actually divorce the world (as the "isolationists" insist).
The trick capitalizes on a mentality of domestic prioritization in order to sell a program of anti-strategic withdrawal from the world stage that only benefits our enemies around the world (think the geopolitical equivalent of Biden's catastrophic Afghanistan withdrawal). America is part of the world and has to participate in it to protect and prioritize its interests.
This is where the parallel to trans comes in most strongly. Trans ideology depends on believing the individual identity can be severed from the underlying physical reality of sex, which is kind of an anti-strategic withdrawal from the realities of embodiment to focus on one's own individual interests regardless of reality.
The fact is, America cannot withdraw from the world. It is part of the world, and the world is happening out there and to us. China, Russia, Iran, and the enemies of America will not pause in their designs so America can "focus on domestic issues." We absolutely MUST walk and chew gum at the same time: we absolutely MUST engage in both domestic and international issues at once, in exactly the same way as we abosolutely MUST attend to matters of personal identity and our embodied biological realities at the same time.
We can prioritize what we engage in differently, but we cannot actually withdraw and only focus on domestic policy. That is a lie. We must engage globally as well, especially given that we're subject to the world not just economically and sometimes militarily, but in our own living rooms through relentless foreign propaganda trying to get us to value the wrong things.
The primary target of this manipulation is the United States through its relationship with Israel, which is key to many of the most important things happening in the world today, many of which are in America's direct interests. Trump understand this, but the misled youth don't and are turning on him over it.
The objective is to get people to hear the words "foreign entanglements" and associate it with "bad," rather in the same way a socially transitioning youth is taught to hate the realities of her body in puberty. Some of those "foreign entanglements" are actually strategic alliances that makes the world safer and more prosperous, including for Americans specifically. They are strongly in American interests to engage in. Israel's security in the Middle East is overwhelmingly one of those strategic alliances.
So rather than helping our young people navigate a very complicated global situation in which America is a huge part, we are flooded with propaganda that's roughly the equivalent of telling them we can "stop puberty." It's not a perfect analogy because global affairs have been a hell of a lot more complicated and "pubescent" than they are today, but not really since the end of the Cold War, which predates all of Gen Z by a decade.
Trans ideology effectively tells young people they can retreat from biological reality and choose their own course independent of reality, as if the body isn't really there, and this deracinated, twisted "America First" ideology tells them the same thing but about geopolitical reality. It says we can retreat from the world as it is and choose our own path on the world stage as if it isn't there. That's dead wrong.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedideology cult
138,570 views
What it says Calls "America First" "a kind of political trans ideology" and says it comes from a trick that has hijacked young people, using trans identity as an insult.
3. Documented moments
2022-08: Twitter permanently suspended him. NBC News (2022-12-02) says he "had previously been banned permanently from Twitter for violating its rules on hateful conduct", and cites Center for Countering Digital Hate data that one of the most widely viewed anti-LGBTQ tweets came from him. The Daily Beast headline of 2022-08-09 ("The Banned 'OK Groomer' Guy...") connects the ban to "groomer" posts. He was reinstated after Musk's takeover (Wikipedia says suspended August 2022 and reinstated November 2022; the NBC article of 2022-12-02 does not give a date).
2022-09: a Center for Countering Digital Hate and Human Rights Campaign report found that tweets using "ok, groomer" rose 2,465% from January to July 2022 and ranked him second among the most-viewed hateful tweets (SPLC Extremist Files, "James Lindsay", 4). The same page records that he told Andy Ngo in August 2022 that he "popularized" the phrase.
2022-11-21: Twitter reinstates his account after Elon Musk's takeover (Media Matters reported that he was reinstated on November 21; the Post Millennial headline reads "James Lindsay is back on Twitter after reversal of permanent ban", 5; SPLC, says November 2022). SPLC says the lifetime ban followed his reply calling a transgender Harvard instructor an "ok child sexualization specialist".
2022-12-19: speaks at Turning Point USA's AmericaFest Live (Day 3, per SPLC) about drag performers, referring to "Drag Floyd" (SPLC).
2023-03-15: promotes a conspiracy-style meme about "Operations Drag Floyd and Trans Floyd" (2023-03-15, 105,836 views).
2023-04-06: the Post Millennial story behind his "another trans school shooter" post is dated 2023-04-06. It reports that a 19-year-old was charged after an investigation into threats involving Colorado Springs-area schools; charges were two counts of attempted first-degree murder plus lesser counts; the article does not say that police stated the person's gender identity, and the "trans-identified" wording is the outlet's own; the page shows no correction or update (6). No attack took place; his post says police stopped one "before it happens". The outlet's "trans-identified" wording is its own, but a district attorney's spokesman said the defendant "was in the process of transitioning to female" and "identified as" a feminine name (Fox 29 and sister stations, 2023-04-07). The "shooter" label stays unsupported: nobody was shot; the attempted-murder counts were dismissed under a plea agreement; the defendant pleaded guilty in November 2023 to second-degree assault and was sentenced on 2024-01-30 to six years in prison with 306 days' credit and three years' parole (KRDO, 2024-01-30). The post's "another trans school shooter" presents one case as a pattern. The defendant is a private individual and is not named.
2023-04-06: a second post the same day mocks "Transphobic Red Guard youth demand gun control after a trans person did a school shooting" (2023-04-06).
2023-05-08/09: "Gender identity doesn't exist"; on the federal lawsuit over Tennessee's ban on care for minors: "DOJ is wrong" (2023-05-08, 2023-05-09). Both posts are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric: the first denies trans people's identity (section 4, item 3), and the evidence-brief note under section 4 covers his posts about care for minors.
2023-09-25: "Queer Education Is Evil" episode of New Discourses: "'Queer' is not an identity at all ... Queer is explicitly and intentionally an oppositional political stance" (the Transgender Map list dates the episode). The quoted line is the framing the note at the top of this profile describes: bad-faith rhetoric presented as criticism of "Queer Theory".
2023 (Bigger Picture Conference, Denver): speaker at the Genspect conference (Transgender Map plus Genspect's page showing "James Lindsay's speech at the Genspect Bigger Picture Conference in 2023").
2023-11-15: X put a temporary "restricted" warning on his profile (MRC Free Speech America, a conservative media-watch group, which says "it was also unclear what led to this temporary account restriction" and that he believed it followed a dispute in which he called radical feminists "hags").
2024-03-08: urges lawmakers to "extend the statutes of limitations on all 'transgender' medical care. ... anyone under the age of 25 ... Easier than bans." (2024-03-08, 43,409 views).
2024: publishes "The Queering of the American Child" (Wikipedia). Retail and publisher-promotion listings give the author as Logan Lancing, publisher New Discourses, on sale 2024-02-29, ISBN 9798989741601, and do not list Pitchstone; "Logan Lancing" is a pen name and no one behind it is identified here. Open Library catalog data (accessed 2026-11-08) for ISBN 9798989741601 and 9798989741694 give publisher "New Discourses" and authors "Logan Lancing" and "James Lindsay", published 2024; a catalog record, not the book. "Logan Lancing" remains a pen name with no one identified here.
2025-01-10: takes part in the Turning Point USA documentary "Identity Crisis" (his post).
2025-03-23: states his view on adults (section 4).
2026-06-21: "A lot of parents of conservative young men ... I start by telling them their sons are basically trans now." (2026-06-21, 105,286 views): "trans" as an insult for political opponents.
2026-06-27: speaks at RMV Freedom Fest, Douglas County Fairgrounds, Castle Rock, Colorado, on "Exposing Critical Theory in Plain English"; in the event preview (Rocky Mountain Voice, 2026-06-22, 7), the reporter writes that he named Protect Kids Colorado's executive director Erin Lee as someone he looks to for Colorado detail, and he is quoted as wanting attendees "empowered to get involved", including in an organization like hers. The article describes no formal affiliation. Protect Kids Colorado sponsored the November 2026 ballot measures on school sports (Proposition 134) and on surgery on minors (Proposition 135), which passed (KUNC, 2026-11-06).
2026-07-22: shares a Christian Post piece, "What I Learned After 10 Years of Covering the Trans Madness" (2026-07-22, 175,160 views). Sharing it repeats the "trans madness" wording that section 4, item 5 lists as dehumanizing language.
4. Evidence that the child and sports framing is pretextual
Policy that reaches adults. 2025-03-23: "You can't be transgender because it doesn't exist ... Adults, and only adults, under the purview of their doctors, under satisfactory conditions ... which I think should be extremely stringent in scope and long-running enough in evaluation to exclude all people in the first half of their 20s at the least, might attempt to arrange their bodies ... as if it were a member of the opposite sex". This excludes adults up to at least 25 from care and imposes psychiatric screening on all others; it parallels the age-25/26 bills (Texas HB 4754, 2023, and similar bills) that defined "children" as anyone under 26.
"Easier than bans" on anyone under 25 (2024-03-08): a call for long legal exposure for providers treating adults aged 18 to 24.
Denial of trans identity at every age: "Gender identity doesn't exist" (2023-05-08); "You can't be transgender because it doesn't exist"; "Trans girls don't exist" (a quote post of 2023-10-23 per the post text; the archive row is dated 2023-10-24). Denying trans people's identity is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric (see the evidence-brief note below).
Calling trans people mentally ill: "Trans girls ... severe mental illnesses ... treated ... in minimally invasive and aggressive ways" (2023-10-23 per the post text; the archive row is dated 2023-10-24). Declaring a group's identity a severe mental illness requiring "aggressive" treatment treats trans people as mentally incompetent to decide for themselves.
Dehumanizing language: "the trans cult", "trans madness", "trans lunatics" ("'Epstein class' is another one of those things Marxists say that just means to shut up and give the authority, like how Critical Race Theorists say 'white supremacy' and trans lunatics say 'transphobia.'", 2026-05-24). Wikipedia says he called the Pride flag "the flag of a hostile enemy" (Wikipedia's citation: Centre Daily, 2023-04-22).
Attacks on adults: "The primary person 'misgendering' a trans person is the trans person in question" (2024-03-02) and "no more" participation in respecting identity (2024-05-11).
Violence framing: "Trans violence is violence" (2023-07-06 of 2023-07-05 and a quote post of 2024-06-05; the archive holds both as reposts by tracked accounts, with 120,358 and 133,158 views) and the "trans school shooter" post.
Most of the account's anti-trans posts make no appeal to protecting anyone: 154 of the 182 anti-trans posts carry no protective claim, 36 of those deny trans people's identity and 31 are dehumanizing or single out a person, for example 2026-06-21, which tells parents their sons are "basically trans now", and 2025-07-05, which calls trans men "disordered".
Evidence-brief note: his posts about care for minors and "detransitioners" (2023-05-09, 2024-03-08) are bad-faith rhetoric. Regret is rare: a 27-study meta-analysis (PRS Global Open, 2021; 7,928 surgical patients) pooled regret at 1%; 98% (704 of 720) of a Dutch adolescent cohort were still on hormones (Lancet Child & Adolescent Health, 2022) (evidence brief). Evidence reviews rate the certainty of youth-care evidence as low; that describes the evidence, a dispute about study design in a field where randomized trials are widely considered unethical and low certainty ratings are common across pediatric medicine. It never supports the claim that "gender identity doesn't exist", and his use of it is bad-faith rhetoric.
5. Platform enforcement history
2022-08: permanent Twitter suspension for "hateful conduct" (NBC News via the Wikipedia citation); reinstated after Musk's acquisition (on 2022-11-21: The Post Millennial's article of that date says he "has been reinstated on Twitter on Monday", and Media Matters reported November 21; Wikipedia says November 2022).
According to The Post Millennial, which was favourable to him, Twitter first locked his account in May 2022 over a post about long COVID; suspended him temporarily from 21 July 2022 after he replied "Okay, Groomer" to a Media Matters journalist, on a "hateful conduct" charge; and banned him permanently on 5 August 2022 for what Twitter said was promoting "violence against, threaten, or harass other people on the basis of race, ethnicity, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, religious affiliation, age, disability, or serious disease". The article adds that in August he told Jack Posobiec that the term "groomer" has a "negative pejorative connotation" connected to both pedophilia and cult grooming; using "groomer" for people who support trans youth is a smear that links trans-affirming people to child abuse. (The Post Millennial, "James Lindsay is back on Twitter after reversal of permanent ban", 5; the article is dated 2022-11-21, and the years above follow from that date, since the article gives months and days.)
2023-11-15: temporary "restricted account" warning on X (MRC); reason not stated by X.
Other platforms: Wikipedia lists only the August 2022 permanent suspension by Twitter; the May 2022 lock and the temporary suspension from 21 July 2022 are recorded above (The Post Millennial). No action by Medium, Substack, YouTube, Patreon or Facebook is documented.
6. Ties
Role: New Discourses LLC (FL L19000234287), Manager, with Michael W O'Fallon (publicly the founder of Sovereign Nations, which hosts Lindsay's video series; see the ownership note in section 1) as second co-manager (one record of the Florida filing lists both as managers; the Florida Division of Corporations data as of 2026-11-08 (New Discourses LLC, L19000234287, active, formed 2019-09-17) list James S. Lindsay and Michael W. O'Fallon as Managers and O'Fallon as registered agent, see the next entry).
New Discourses LLC, Florida record: the Florida Division of Corporations data for NEW DISCOURSES LLC (document number L19000234287, Active; state data as of 2026-11-08) list two Managers, filed as "JAMES S LINDSAY" and "Michael W O'Fallon", and a registered agent filed as "O'FALLON W MICHAEL" (Florida Division of Corporations, document number L19000234287, 3). Peter Boghossian is not listed in any role. The data give the current managers and agent only, not those of each annual report since 2020, and do not state who owns the company.
Formal joint work: Turning Point USA, the "Identity Crisis" documentary: his post says he is "proud to be part of" it (2025-01-10); the film was promoted through the Daily Wire's X account (the linked post). Appearance or listing: Turning Point USA's AmericaFest 2022 (photo caption on Wikipedia; no detail).
Formal joint work: Peter Boghossian and Helen Pluckrose (co-authors); Pitchstone Publishing ("Cynical Theories"); Logan Lancing (co-author, 2024) (Wikipedia). The 2024 book's publisher appears to be New Discourses, not Pitchstone. The Pitchstone tie for "Cynical Theories" and "Impossible Conversations" rests on Wikipedia alone.
Role, secondary: LittleSis (crowd-edited) lists him as co-founder and board member of New Discourses. The LittleSis API (8, accessed 2026-11-12) lists Lindsay as "co-founder" with its board flag set (relationship 1696523) and Peter Boghossian (1696519), Helen Pluckrose (1696522), Mike Nayna (1696524) and Jacob Howland (1696534) each as "contributor"; the five relationships cite no source, all carry update times of 2020-07-15 between 19:23 and 19:30 UTC, and none has an amount, description or filing. "Contributor" is a LittleSis category, not a title New Discourses gives: its About page (9) names no founder, staff or contributor. The positions of these four are therefore "listed by LittleSis as a contributor, no source cited".
Appearance or listing: Genspect (2023 Bigger Picture Conference speech; ROGD Awareness Day 2024 announced). Appearance or listing: The Joe Rogan Experience (four appearances as of March 2019; Wikipedia).
Role/ownership (reported): SPLC says New Discourses is owned by Michael O'Fallon, president of Sovereign Nations, which it calls a Christian nationalist organization; in a New Discourses podcast episode "Is Michael O'Fallon a Christian Nationalist?" Lindsay calls him a friend and business associate (episode page, subscriber content). Wikipedia says the site is owned by him; the Florida filing lists both as managers. Ownership is therefore unresolved between sources.
Appearance or listing: AmericaFest Live (Turning Point USA), Day 3, 2022-12-19 (SPLC). Appearance or listing: RMV Freedom Fest, 2026-06-27 (Rocky Mountain Voice).
Funding (as filed): the 2026-06-25 payment from the Protect Kids Colorado Issue Committee to "NEW DISCOURSES LLC" is in section 7; it falls one day before the Freedom Fest begins (2026-06-26) and two days before his talk there on 2026-06-27, but it names no speaker and does not say which event it paid for.
Narrative alignment only (not a tie): Daily Wire (distribution of the film), MRC Free Speech America (reports his restriction as "censorship").
7. Income and funding
Disclosed streams (New Discourses "Support This Work" page, 2026-11-05): "funded primarily by the generous contributions of individuals like you"; one-time card, PayPal, Cash App payments; subscriptions on Locals, Patreon, SubscribeStar, Substack and YouTube Members, from $5 per month on several platforms; merchandise, books and an Amazon affiliate link; mailed checks to a Florida post-office box. The site shows a YouTube channel with 177,000 subscribers.
Funding: payments to the entity "New Discourses" as filed, not to him personally. A Florida LLC named New Discourses LLC exists (L19000234287, formed 2019-09-17, Active; the Florida data as of 2026-11-08 list James S. Lindsay and Michael W. O'Fallon as Managers, see section 6). The filings below name the payee "New Discourses" or "New Discourses LLC"; four give a Florida payee city and one a North Carolina city. No identifier ties these payees to the Florida LLC, and only the first filing names him; Wikipedia cites a Florida annual report for the LLC but also says the site is owned by another person, which conflicts with founder descriptions: unresolved. Listed, not summed:
Education First Alliance PAC, $3,827.70, 2022-06-27, purpose "JAMES LIMDSAY SPEAKING HONORARIA AND TRAVEL" (FEC operating expenditure, doc 4072620221552357597); the one line that names him (misspelled).
Pierce County Republican Party (Washington PDC), $10,000, 2023-10-11, "Fundraising events and related costs Event speaker" (110181776:17851306); no speaker named.
Protect Kids Colorado Issue Committee (Colorado TRACER), $3,073.80, 2026-06-25, "CELEBRATION EVENT: HONORARIUM - $2500 AIRFARE - 573.80" (1684803); no speaker named. Payee cities as filed: Education First Alliance PAC row, Orlando FL; Idaho Republican Party row, Windermere FL; Pierce County Republican Party row, Clearwater FL; Protect Kids Colorado Issue Committee row, Clearwater FL; the VIVEK 2024 row (FEC C00833913, 2023-06-09), Charlotte NC. The Florida record's principal-address city is Orlando; none of the five rows carries the entity number. The Colorado row (TRACER expenditure document 1684803, committee 20245047398): $3,073.80 paid by check, filed 2026-08-02, purpose "Other CELEBRATION EVENT: HONORARIUM - $2500 AIRFARE - 573.80", payee "NEW DISCOURSES LLC", Clearwater FL. Protect Kids Colorado held a volunteer celebration on 2026-05-07 at which CatholicVote received a "Strategic Alliance Partner Award" (Zeale, 2026-05-08; the speakers named are a Protect Kids Colorado board member, CatholicVote's president and Protect Kids Colorado's executive director; Lindsay is not named), seven weeks before the payment. RMV Freedom Fest, Rocky Mountain Voice's "flagship gathering" on 2026-06-26 and 2026-06-27 at the Douglas County Fairgrounds, Castle Rock, titled "Celebrating America's 250th & Colorado's 150th", lists Lindsay on Saturday and Protect Kids Colorado's executive director on its Friday main stage, names no sponsors, and shows Protect Kids Colorado only as her organization (rmvfreedomfest.com; Rocky Mountain Voice, 2026-06-22). The payment's entry names no speaker and no event; the Zeale report on the May event does not name Lindsay, and the Freedom Fest pages name no sponsors.
The Protect Kids Colorado Issue Committee's entry for payment 1684803 (committee 20245047398; $3,073.80 by check dated 2026-06-25, filed 2026-08-02, payee "NEW DISCOURSES LLC", Clearwater FL, purpose "Other CELEBRATION EVENT: HONORARIUM - $2500 AIRFARE - 573.80") stands as filed: the committee's reports in TRACER, through filings of 2026-11-02, hold no amendment of it and no deletion offset for it (other entries carry such offsets, for example "Offset due to deletion of filed item" dated 2026-06-10 and 2026-07-25). No filing names the event or the speaker. The committee's other entries that name events are: catering and beverages for a "celebration event" in April and May 2026 (catering of $7,301.14 dated 2026-05-08, and a security charge for "MAY 7, 2026"); a hotel reimbursement of $567.12 dated 2026-07-28 to an individual for "HOTEL STAY 6/26-6/27, RMV FREEDOM FEST" (document 1694177, filed 2026-09-08); and a "WESTERN SLOPE CELEBRATION EVENT 8/8/2026" at Grand Junction (catering reimbursement $829.00 dated 2026-08-31; hall-rent payments of $300 and $200 dated 2026-09-03). The honorarium falls between the May event and the August event, and one day before the Freedom Fest of 2026-06-26 and 2026-06-27 whose program, as recorded above, lists Lindsay on its Saturday; the filings neither confirm nor exclude either event. (Colorado TRACER campaign finance data, 10, committee 20245047398, expenditure documents 1684803, 1694177, 1694174, 1657752 and 1673183). The four filings that do not name him (the three lines above and the VIVEK 2024 row given in the payee-city line and under Open questions) do not say who spoke or who received the money (FEC, 11; Washington PDC, 12; Colorado TRACER, 10).
Education First Alliance PAC, the payer of the 2022-06-27 line, is a federal PAC registered with the FEC (committee C00806554, Apex, North Carolina; 13); it is not a Florida committee. The FEC rows show it paid "NEW DISCOURSES LLC" $3,827.70 on 2022-06-27 (FEC operating expenditures, 13). The payee name matches the Florida LLC's name; no identifier links the two.
Donor-advised or nonprofit funding: SPLC's page, documents no funding for New Discourses beyond ownership, and the support page shows only individual payments and subscriptions. LittleSis (crowd-edited; 8) lists Helen Pluckrose, Jacob Howland, Mike Nayna and Peter Boghossian as positions at New Discourses besides Lindsay, whom it lists as "co-founder" with its board flag set (relationship 1696523, section 6); uncorroborated.
Books: bestseller-list placement for "Cynical Theories" (Wikipedia); no book sales or royalty amounts are documented, and none are estimated. The site states no tax-deductible or nonprofit status.
8. Legal matters
No legal matters are documented. Wikipedia lists no lawsuits.
Open questions
Which event the 2026-06-25 payment of $3,073.80 to New Discourses LLC ("CELEBRATION EVENT: HONORARIUM - $2500 AIRFARE - 573.80", document 1684803) paid for, and whether it paid for a Lindsay appearance: no filing through 2026-11-02 names it or amends the entry; the committee's other entries put a celebration on 2026-05-07 before it, the Freedom Fest of 2026-06-26 and 2026-06-27 one day after it, and a Western Slope celebration on 2026-08-08 after it.
What New Discourses LLC's Florida annual reports for 2020 to 2025 (L19000234287, formed 2019-09-17, active) each list as managers and registered agent: the current managers and agent are given under Ties, and the annual-report images are on the state's Sunbiz site (3).
Who owns New Discourses: SPLC says Michael O'Fallon; the Florida filing lists Lindsay and O'Fallon as managers; the filing does not state ownership.
Whether Education First Alliance PAC (FEC C00806554) and the other payers' "New Discourses" payees (Idaho Republican Party, Pierce County Republican Party, VIVEK 2024) are the Florida LLC. The VIVEK 2024 row is a payee "New Discourses" ($731.75, "TRAVEL", 2023-06-09, FEC 4101820231805755884, payee city in North Carolina); it names no person and no speaker.
What the LittleSis positions for Pluckrose, Howland, Nayna and Boghossian at New Discourses rest on: the five relationships cite no source and date from 2020-07-15.
Whether any correction or retraction followed his 2023-04-06 post calling the arrested person a "trans school shooter": none appears on the Post Millennial page.
Whether Medium, Substack or YouTube took enforcement actions against his accounts: none is documented.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.