The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
It's a cult.
Most people haven't realized yet that most cults are online now and pose as "movements." It's not weirdos in robes or in a commune somewhere; it's all online.
We have to learn how to protect our kids from online cults like trans and groyper.
Quotes a post by T05753; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
All I can say about @roddreher is "better late than never," but I fear he's going to be the equivalent of a radfem fighting trans, which isn't a compliment in the slightest.
Quotes a post by T08898; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
So ridiculously uninformed (and anti-Trump, anti-MAGA, and anti-conservative) that it's just funny to see this stuff now that I know directly how dumb it is. Just raw dumb. As dumb as trans.
Quotes a post by T03326; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The friend-enemy distinction is the logic of Leftism. Marcuse called it "Liberating Tolerance." Marx called it "oppressor vs oppressed." Mao called it "the people and the enemies of the people." The trans activists call it "trans activists vs transphobic bigots."
These Woke Right turds aren't in anyone's radar, and they're all whining about it like trans militants and drag queens claiming anyone pointing out their misseeds "puts their lives in danger."
Iron Law of Woke Histrionics.
Quotes a post by T06688; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Never Again is now.
This is why back at the start of the year, I was already saying parents who luckily avoided watching their kids go trans will now be doomed in many cases to watch them get recruited as Nazis.
Never Again is now.
Quotes a post by T08853; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The funny (infuriating?) irony is that they'll make this demand directly alongside the utterly contradictory demand that we recognize that women aren't the only people who can give birth because some "transmen" (trans-identifying women) can.
It's not actually contradictory in Queer Leftism, though, because the ultimate point is for nothing to be stable and for the people who accept Queer Theory to be the ultimate arbiters of reality. If a "transman" decides to have a child, that affirms the instability of sex. If another, or even the same, "transman" decides to have an abortion, it's "gender-affirming care" to maintain the illusion of "transmasculinity."
You think this is contradictory, but it's only contradictory from outside their perspective (so, in reality). From inside their wack Queer perspective, it is the Queer Theorist getting to decide what reality is for him/herself such that other people have to go along with it. It's not just an act of defying reality in radical self-definition. It's turning themselves into gurus who get to determine when black is black and when white is black instead, fostering a state of total dependency on the cult for the basic interpretation of reality.
It doesn't compute because like all "trans" language, the language itself is confusing, intrinsically. "Transmasculine" refers to a kind of disordered WOMAN. If she got pregnant and gave birth, it would affirm WOMANHOOD. Therefore, it's "gender-affirming care" to prevent that.
I've been hearing these kinds of stories from concerned conservative moms and dads for about a year, which I mentioned to Jordan Peterson some months ago. A lot of parents were lucky not to see their kids go trans or nonbinary or BLM only to watch them sucked into Nazism later.
Quotes a post by T01711; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Once again, we don't need Woke Right nonsense. It isn't solving any problems or helping anything. We're solving the trans and other problems without their lunatic radicalism just fine, as you can see.
Quoting @nypost: Trans UPenn swimmer Lia Thomas to have titles stripped as university bends the knee to Trump admin https://trib.al/Q2PB0UX
I didn't defend The Dispatch, though they're welcome to hire whoever they want.
I pointed out that William Wolfe, who is a bitch, is a dishonest actor engaging in cancel culture (against Jake Meador, not the trans-identifying person).
That they're Woke is painfully obvious.
I guess the new Woke Right lie about me is that I am pro-trans and oppose "right-wing anti-trans" activism because I called out the fact that William Wolfe is using a trans-identified person as a fulcrum for a struggle session against a guy who is exposing him. They're so boring.
I barely remember this paper, to be honest, lol. It got very little engagement, frankly, both from us and from the editors. I don't know if it even had a point except to argue some kind of feminist nonsense using masculinity through autoethnography. Its purpose was to discredit autoethnography, which deserves to be discredited completely.
The description we wrote for this paper at the time was that it was one of our "pure hoaxes," which were most of our first six papers we wrote, all of which failed completely. This brings up an important point about the project: there were two modes, and our success and failure rates in each tell us something important.
By "pure hoax," what @peterboghossian and I meant is very specific. (@[private account] didn't really help with these except too late and without much effort because they were lost causes for a bigger reason.) A "pure hoax" had no engagement at all with the existing literature. We wrote whatever we wanted and did all of our citations merely through keyword searches without reading or understanding the source material whatsoever.
As it turns out, we learned that the journal editors, never mind the peer reviewers (except in exactly one case), do not fall for pure hoaxes. "The Conceptual Penis as a Social Construct" was a pure hoax too, which is why it only ended up in a predatory journal we never would have sent it to on our own (hence that related academic publishing scandal we uncovered by mistake). This means something very important about the process: believe it or not it's working exactly like it's supposed to work.
Peer review didn't fail in the Grievance Studies Affair. It worked exactly correctly. It filtered out every "pure hoax" we did. What it could not filter out was terrible work that engaged the already terrible literature. That's something far different and far worse. No one would take any academic work seriously, and shouldn't, if the process wasn't effectively filtering out garbage. As it turns out, it does filter out garbage; what it cannot filter out is corruption. (@BretWeinstein will recognize why this is a true emergency, btw.)
We had several "pure hoax" papers that inadvertently worked rather like a control group, which allows us to tease out the much more important conclusion we actually arrived at: "Peer review is only as good as the peers involved, and any corruption they possess will be passed on successfully into the canon of official 'knowledge.'"
Because all of our papers worked backwards from their conclusions and because this is the mechanism of activity in peer review, Bret's now very famous specialized term of "idea laundering" is exactly correct, and we face the crisis that there is literally no way for us to know whatsoever outside of replicable and replicated hard science what is and isn't true as a result of it.
Idea laundering occurs when "prejudice and opinion" can be laundered into "knowledge" in the same way that criminal money can be laundered into "clean" money through passing it through channels recognized to be legitimate. Activism, corruption, prejudice, and opinion can all be magically laundered into "knowledge" by passing it through a filter that removes garbage but not bias. As "gender-affirming care" shows, even with SCOTUS justices citing WPATH in Skrmetti in their dissent, this is extremely consequential, and that's just in one domain.
Though it isn't relevant to this paper specifically since we wrote several "pure hoaxes," including "The Conceptual Penis as a Social Construct" (and "Pre-Epistemic Trans"), I think this is actually one of the most important conclusions from the Grievance Studies Affair, and it is far too-often lost on everyone what it actually reveals.
Here's the link again: https://newdiscourses.com/rebraiding-masculinity/
"Queering Plato" is probably our second most spectacular failure of a paper, but it was designed to test the penetration of Queer Theory into mainstream philosophy by saying all readings of Plato should be "queered" and turned into bids for sexual emancipation.
While it was something of an abortion from the beginning, it was based off a project @peterboghossian and I toyed with even before the Grievance Studies Affair really began. Unbeknownst to most people, we actually had written a second early trial balloon paper, which ended up getting no response at all from a Queer Theory journal at Duke University Press, which publishes some astonishingly stupid stuff to this day.
That paper, which has partially been argued elsewhere since, was nicknamed "pre-epistemic trans" and argued that technically everyone is trans although people claiming not to be just don't know it yet. So, everyone is really trans, and only the openly trans-identifying people know they're trans. (Unless Peter has it, the text of that hoax has been lost to time.)
With this stupid presuppositionalist argument, we didn't realize at the time that we were tapping into a real belief of Queer Theory, which stems from the fact that it's ultimately Queer Gnosticism. In Queer Theory, the belief is actually that everyone is originally "queer," but society "straightens us out," which has to be interrupted, including by destroying childhood innocence (a "straightening" tool).
In our little also-aborted hoax to this point, we argued that the only way you can possibly know whether you're trans or not is to transition. Everyone else just hasn't realized it yet and cannot realize it because it could technically change at any time by overcoming one's own socialization in a flash of insight. It's too bad this paper may be lost to time because it's short and stupid and funny.
"Queering Plato," rather than doing what it did, which was a lot of hard work for Peter to get the engagement with the Classics right, we really should have just used Plato's Cave Metaphor to rearticulate the "pre-epistemic trans" argument. It might have actually worked, maybe even in a significant journal like Hypatia. Who knows?
Here's that link again: https://newdiscourses.com/queering-plato/
What became the Grievance Studies Affair began with a trial-balloon paper that @peterboghossian and I wrote in late 2016, hilariously titled "The Conceptual Penis as a Social Construct." It's one of the funniest things I've ever written, rivaled only by a couple of the later Grievance Studies Papers (YMMV).
It is not housed on the Grievance Studies Affair @NewDiscourses portal, but perhaps it should be, because it wasn't part of the Grievance Studies Affair properly. It might be its second most-famous contribution, however.
In the paper, Peter and I took inspiration from a real paper that had been published in the highest-ranking gender studies journal, Gender & Society, characterizing menstrual blood as a social construct. We argued that penises are not best thought of as male reproductive organs, in part because "pre-operative trans women" also have them (which was effectively repeated in the Supreme Court argumentation this week in the Skrmetti case). Instead, they should be thought of as social constructs that create toxic masculinity and rape culture and cause all the problems in the world, especially climate change.
This paper was ultimately accepted by means of a related but passed-over academic publishing scandal in a (likely) predatory journal called Cogent Social Sciences after a clear sham peer review process after being rejected and transferred from a masculinities journal called NORMA.
Because of the low quality of the journal and the one-off nature of the stunt, it was left ambiguous if Peter and I had proved any point about gender studies and related fields ("Grievance Studies" fields) at all. We were admonished to write more papers, target serious journals, and be more accurate in our claims, and we accepted this challenge happily.
"The Conceptual Penis as a Social Construct" was published in Cogent Social Sciences on May 19, 2017, and by June 7 Peter and I had resolved to start the Grievance Studies Affair to do the job right.
https://www.skeptic.com/content/files/2025/03/23311886.2017.1330439.pdf
The dissents in the recent Skrmetti decision upholding Tennessee's right to prohibit certain medical interventions on trans-identifying minors are alarming. Consider this thread well.
Quotes a post by A0873; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There are no trans children. There are only victims of gender ideology and a related social, professional, and medical complex that shouldn't exist.
Quoting @CoryBooker: Today the Supreme Court chose to abandon trans children in America. Upholding the Tennessee ban on medical care for trans kids is heartless. This is a sad day, but know I will never stop fighting to protect trans children everywhere.
@[private account]
Quoting @againstgrmrs: Right on schedule, Trantifa Extremists on @[private account] are calling for the cold-blooded murdering of Supreme Court Justices who ruled states can indeed protect the lives of children by denying proven-harmful medications & surgeries to minors.
When the cult doesn’t get their way with your kids, violence is their first go-to.
C2 false claimshand-codedideology cultpolitical enemyviolence terror
One aspect of the trans issue and fight we don't talk nearly enough about is the forced incursion of men into sororities in college, which can carry with it all the issues you can imagine.
CC @[private account] @MegEBrock
@JenniferSey @Riley_Gaines_ @chloecole
https://www.dailysignal.com/2025/06/11/turns-out-sororities-are-for-women-after-all/
Woke Right Lie of the Day
"Marxism is not Woke; Woke is not Marxist."
This is a pretty hilarious Woke Right lie that I've already partially addressed (linked in next post threaded below), but I want to get under the hood of it a little more because it's important (and funny).
First of all, yes it is. Marxism is an opportunistic parasitic ideology* that has only one agenda: to seize the means of production of man and society by any means necessary. It literally defines both truth and ethics in terms of this agenda.
Marxism is an operating system; a worldview; a way of viewing the world and behaving in it (theory and praxis). It is not a set of conclusions, a specific analysis, a set of analytic tools, a set of tactics, or really even just an ideology (see * above). It's a totalizing worldview based intrinsically on the conflict of contending classes as a means of reaching ultimate social, economic, cultural, and political synthesis and "return of man to himself as a social, i.e., human, being" bringing with him the benefits of "all the previous stages of development."
Woke is a manifestation of that parasitic worldview trying to make the leap to infect a new "species" of society, namely free, liberal societies running with individual liberties and free enterprise. Marxism was only successful before Woke at installing itself by force or by subverting feudal systems, not "capitalistic" liberal ones.
Think of it like a real virus like bird flu. Bird flu infects birds. It does not infect humans under normal conditions. It is evolved to attack weaknesses in bird biology and to exploit receptors on bird cells, but these don't readily cross over to other species. Sometimes, there's a trans-species leap from birds to people, and we end up with avian flu or bird flus that can infect humans, and they're usually pretty nasty. In fact, all flus originate from this species-jumping phenomenon, which designates them specifically as a kind of plague (a disease for non-human animals that evolves to infect humans). Plagues are usually really nasty and bad and can be far deadlier than typical human-borne diseases (like common colds).
Marxism is a plague ideology in this specific sense overall, but we're focusing on Woke. Though Marx didn't realize it as he outlined it, thinking he was talking about specific classes in capitalism (workers versus "bourgeois" management), his ideological virus was really only suited to infect feudal societies at scale, which Lenin ultimately discovered and/or proved. It couldn't infect capitalist, liberal, or free societies, to the great consternation of the Marxists.
(Incidentally, a side-effect of partial forced infection by Marxism in such societies was a rampant and psychotically deranged nationalism called Fascism, which was like a deformed hybrid of corporatist capitalism that adopted lots of Marxist RNA, in a sense.)
Marxism had to make a variety of evolutionary leaps to find receptors in free, liberal, capitalistic societies in order to infect it. Cultural Marxists like Antonio Gramsci indicated that infiltrating the cultural institutions and rotting them from within would soften a society up to going Marxist. The Neo-Marxists identified a need to abandon the working class specifically to focus on other more "vital" centers of revolutionary energy, like Marcuse's sexual and racial minorities. It's a lot to explain how Paulo Freire's liberationist ideas influenced things, but they set the stage for any "marginalized" knowing system to be the basis for a mutated Marxist critique, resulting in favoring "other ways of knowing." Postmodernism amplified that.
These developments are like an unsecured ideological biolab in Wuhan with no reasonable safety protections and eventually a lot of Deep State money that shouldn't have been dumped into them. The result was what we called "Woke" (or "Woke Left"). The receptor sites were specifically identity-cultural points that the post-segregation, post-colonial, post-1960s (not post-WWII) generations were particularly soft and susceptible to under a badly twisted and perverted notion of "tolerance" mixed with heavy amounts of deliberately amplified and exploited generational guilt.
"Woke," which is the Intersectional variant of all of this, which is ultimately best characterized as American Maoism, was the result of an evolutionary process by Marxism, for Marxism, to find a way to get its class-conflict-oriented worldview central in the American sociocultural mind. For those playing at home, Mao was a Marxist. Maoism is a set of tactics he developed for mutating the original Marxist virus to be particularly effective on the Chinese people he was trying to force-infect with it.
So yes, Woke is Marxism, and Marxism is Woke. I'm not going over it again. The lie is busted completely.
It raises the important question, though, of why the Woke Right would defend Marxism from accusations of being "Woke" in the first place (in exactly the same way the Marxist and strictly neo-Marxist Left does, by the way).
The reason is because the Woke Right is not interested in stopping Woke. It is interested in stopping the Left, but it is even more interested in destroying classical liberalism. It's happy to use the Left as the cover for its project of destroying classical liberalism, but that's its real project. Why do you think they call themselves the "post-liberal Right"?
Both Woke Right and Woke Left agree that classical liberalism and individual rights (what Marx and Hitler both called "egotism") have to be done away with completely. They disagree over who gets to do it and how society will be organized. The Woke Left is tyrannical in the name of ending oppression. The Woke Right is tyrannical in the name of installing oppression. This is because the "Left" is radically anti-hierarchy while the "Right" is radically pro-hierarchy.
So the real reason the Woke Right tells this lie is to hide what it's really doing. The Woke Right is attacking classical liberalism in the name of "stopping the Left."
(Incidentally, the Woke Left is doing the same thing. It is attacking classical liberalism in the name of "stopping the Right.")
An essential and central argument from the Woke Right that is part of what makes it Woke is that classical liberalism itself necessarily becomes Communism. If they were to admit that Marxism is a parasitic aberration and attack on classical liberalism that finally found a way to exploit its receptor sites (mostly located in views on tolerance), they would have to abandon their central premise and raison d'etre, which is to destroy classical liberalism (a.k.a., America) in the name of posting up against the Left rather than actually fighting the Left.
(Btw, this is also why they want America defined as a "people in a place" (blood and soil): they have to dislocate what America really represents, which is an experiment in genuine classical liberalism, in order to attack it in the name of "saving" it.)
The Woke Left argues, in parallel, that classical liberalism necessarily becomes Fascism. They both say this is the case because of classical liberalism's focus on individualism, which enables the other extreme by negating the group mentality and group-based "rights" that their side believes is an essential and necessary ingredient in society ignored or suppressed by "evil" classical liberalism.
Both are obviously wrong, but what you have when you have two polar opposing views that both fight the same target in the name of fighting each other is a polarized dialectic. Both its Left and Right pole are trying to undermine and destroy classical liberalism, but both claim their real function is to free us from the evil excesses of the other side. The point of the polarized dialectic is to generate both a fake fight and lots of energy to accomplish the shared goal between the poles, which in this case is the destruction of individual liberties. Obviously, being diametrically opposed, they'll fight (forever) over which side gets to hold power and for which vision, but there's no way off the ride once individual liberties are destroyed.
Particularly galling is that he's claiming they stopped Pride Month garbage when countless real activists who are true unsung heroes did all the hard legwork (not just bitching on shows) to make that happen and that the big hammer drop against it was the murder of six innocent people by a trans lunatic at the Covington School in Nashville just before "Pride" 2023, which changed the whole tenor and trajectory of it. The radical right did very little here and deserves only a little credit. They also used it to radicalize and therefore deserve massive negative credit as well. Total score: Deep in the negative. But they're too narcissistic and opportunist to do anything but climb up on the platform and take the trophy like a transman in women's running, aren't they?
Quotes a post by T08578; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnesspolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
To let you know @roddreher, I have been saying this about our sons, with the comparison to trans with our daughters, since at least January, arguably since last October (iirc). This is part of why they hate you.
That's a Big Montana, like the state where Chris brought me out a few years ago (June 2021, for those keeping notes) for a discussion on how to fight against Woke and argued vigorously with the group that we shouldn't go after trans or gender ideology. So... yeah. Arby's!
Three cult dynamics of Woke, Left and Right, a long post/🧵:
In his book analyzing the cult of Maoism, Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism, Robert Jay Lifton identified two cult dynamics in what we might call "Woke" political cults: the "cult of confession" and "cult of enthusiasm." To these, I'm adding a third, the "cult of transgression," which is also generally present. In this thread, I want to briefly explain these three and how both Woke Right and Woke Left do them.
Cult of Confession
Lifton's analysis is really valuable on the "confession" dynamic, by which people are made increasingly vulnerable and punished and love-bombed into cult adherence through a process of confession to crimes defined on cult terms. The process is that people are accused or struggled for having committed some crime against the cult's framework and led into a process of struggle, criticism, and self-criticism through cycles of confession and abuse.
The cult of confession creates a dynamic in which people confess to "crimes" in the accusations (criticism), experience moral contrition and abuse (struggle), and eventually begin to spontaneously confess to further crimes (self-criticism) to achieve moral standing in the cult. It's all about generating and exploiting guilt and shame to drive people into deep social and emotional adherence to the cult.
Part of the dynamic Lifton points out is the tendency to project the guilt and shame onto others through an accusation dynamic that comes along with the cult of confession. In a "misery loves company" kind of way, or in the "cycle of abuse," criticism and struggle are extended outward to others for moral absolution of the guilty, shame-filled self, spreading the cult and its dynamic.
On the Woke Left: The cult of confession is abundantly obvious on the Woke Left, where people are accused of complicity in "systemic" hate and harms like "racism," "misogyny," and "transphobia" on terms defined by Woke Left identity politics. It requires basically no explanation now as we've all seen it and as this is more or less what DEI meetings/trainings are. Robin DiAngelo's entire "whiteness training" shtick is this in the name of "antiracism," and we're all familiar now.
On the Woke Right: The cult of confession on the Woke Right involves confessing to having failed to see through the conspiracy theories and psyops and to having been "cucked" by both Woke Left social repression and the "liberal" social norms often falsely associated with that repression, be that "political correctness" or just actually restraining one's speech to be dignified and polite (which isn't quite the same). It involves feeling as though one might have been "controlled opposition" and owning up to that, often with outwardly changed behavior.
Both of these manifestations lead into the cult of transgression in that the criticism, struggle, self-criticism, thus also guilt and shame, programs of the cult lead to transgressing existing (good) social norms and boundaries.
Cult of Transgression
The cult of transgression dynamic is characterized by transgression of the established social norms of society in the name of going against a perceived moral enemy on "the other side" that the mainstream society is complicit in producing and sustaining. It is a dynamic where transgressing normal boundaries leads to a sense of camaraderie and elevated outsider status, i.e., people who "get it" and know when and why they can break "the rules."
Lifton, who wrote before the Cultural Revolution, doesn't document a cult of transgression in the early People's Republic of China (PRC), but it was present in the Red Guard in particular during the Cultural Revolution. The Red Guard was a youth movement strongly encouraged by Mao to break social taboos, sometimes violently and destructively. "To rebel is justified" (a plainly Luciferian concept) was the call Mao made to transgress.
The Red Guard were sent out to "Smash the Four Olds," meaning anything reminiscent of "Old" China, so that socialism could be unleashed to advance. This involved destroying temples, schools, artwork, homes, books, and people, anything that held to the "old ways." It was purely a cult of transgression led by youth, and it also transgressed the most sacred value of China: familial piety. Youth were encouraged to turn on their parents, grandparents, teachers, and even police, not to mention party officials Mao wanted ruined. All of this was deeply transgressive.
The "Woke" neo-Marxist movements in the West adopted this, not insignificantly following the instruction of characters like the "liberationists" Herbert Marcuse and Paulo Freire, both of whom encouraged it and derived it from Mao. Marcuse called his project the "Great Refusal," in fact. Books based on Freire's methods and Marcuse's influence include bell hooks's Teaching to Transgress. Transgression, particularly in the youth, is a key element of being "Woke." "Liberation" refers to breaking free of the existing society in party by transgressing against its norms and boundaries.
On the Woke Left: The cult of transgression appears in a few ways. The most obvious of these is the pure transgression of the Queer movement, including the increasingly lewd and grotesque performances associated with it. Adding genders and sexualities, pronouns, ugly dress, exotic hair colors, etc., and bringing these to children also qualifies. So does expanding the definition of "racism" until it encompasses everything and everyone (for cult of confession purposes), as does violating the expectation that no racism from dominant races (whites, Asians, Jews) also extends an expectation of no racism to dominant races (whites, Asians, Jews).
The cult of confession is therefore empowered by the cult of transgression. As the list of things that qualifies as both permissible and taboo expands (each a transgression), so does the demand for confession and the capacity to accuse others.
Consider the transgression against the boundary of calling things racist. At first, only hostile racial animus counts, but then the boundary of this definition is transgressed by calling more benign expressions "racist." This expands further by calling virtually everything "racist." The cult of transgression traps people through the cult of confession dynamic eventually because you cannot back out without having to confess to it being "racist" to do so, even if the transgression has already gone too far. The same is true of leaning into "reverse" racism. To try to stop is to be accused of "upholding racism." The result is a purity (death) spiral.
On the Woke Right: The cult of transgression on the Woke Right is reactionary, mainly, and therefore embodies the idea of "same energy, opposite direction." Being increasingly edgy ("based") against first Leftist expectations and then good civilizational norms ("liberalism") is part of this ritual. This usually takes the form of saying increasingly racist things, for example, in an attempt to be defiant and funny, though hostile intent not only can cloak itself here but may eventually develop. Like with the Woke Left situation, there's simply no way back without invoking the cult of confession dynamic that traps you. If you try to stop or back out, you're part of the problem the transgressions are allegedly meant to resolve, and you'll be cast out.
Woke Right transgressions can be crude (racism, sexism, misogyny, antisemitism, etc.) or more sophisticated, say targeting the ideals of Western liberalism itself and transgressing against the Constitution and its limitations. Of course, the Woke Left also does this more sophisticated type. The cult of transgression gives way to the cult of enthusiasm Lifton also describes.
Cult of Enthusiasm
Lifton describes a cult of enthusiasm in the totalist circumstance, where participants as a result of the above dynamics gain an almost maniacal enthusiasm for working toward the goals of the cult. In the PRC, these goals were set by Mao and the CCP, but they generalize easily.
The main goal Mao pushed was "building socialism," and he worked up his people into a frenzy to attempt to do it, often with the Communists under him rabidly competing to be the most Communist and to deliver for the PRC the most. This was particularly evident during the Socialist High Tide and Great Leap Forward disasters Mao executed in the middle then late 1950s.
In both cases, the cult of enthusiasm led people to competitively set higher and higher impossible production targets and other quotas, which ended up starving maybe close to 100 million people total and ruining the Chinese economy twice. Everyone wanted to prove they were the most enthusiastic socialists who would get it done, even if most individuals hated what was happening. The cult environment, driven mad by the cult of confession and totalist conditions, demanded it, and people became lunatic zealots in pursuit of the goals.
On the Woke Left: The Woke Left's cult of enthusiasm obviously spilled over in 2020 into the streets, but it includes ridiculous ideas like "Critical Joy," "Critical Hope," and "Trans Joy." The feverish "Joy" branding of the Harris-Waltz Campaign is an example. The idea of achieving liberation, including by browbeating everyone and everything ("Smash the Four Olds"), spills over into a kind of brutal mania. Blogging endlessly about features of self, particularly sexuality, characterizes part of the project. Since this project is mostly critical in orientation, unlike Mao's, it is mostly destructive. The difference for Mao was that he had already taken power and therefore could work on "building socialism," whereas the Woke Left never fully achieved operational power of that sort.
We also see this cult of enthusiasm (or saw it) during Covid-19, what with all the fun dance numbers our unbelievably overburdened health professionals were producing, for example. It also included the rampant enthusiasm many of our neighbors expressed in trying to force people to wear masks, socially distance, and take experimental gene therapy shots, combined with a lot of cult of confession (and accusation) and cult of transgression (you have to violate your bodily autonomy and livelihood for the greater good) activity.
On the Woke Right: The term for the cult of enthusiasm on the Woke Right used by the Woke Right, which they partly derived from misinterpreting President Donald Trump, is "winning." They are enthusiastic about "going on offense" because they "know what time it is" and are "tired of losing," so everything begins to revolve maniacally (worse than mindlessly) around winning at all costs and by any means. Like the Maoists with "building socialism" and the Woke Left with "reimagining society" and chasing "liberation," it is a cult of mania that mostly results in destruction and ends-justify-means idiotic behaviors.
Here, as in the other places, the cult of enthusiasm offers a significant suite of rewards for the sufficiently enthusiastic. The cocktail parties, galas, and entry and welcome into the elite layers of the movement ("inclusion and belonging," btw) all depend on being sufficiently confessed, transgressive, and enthusiastic in the goals of the political cult. Everyone in the cult at least intuits, if not knows, they will be cast out of the elite circles, or have no hope ever of being invited to them ("irrelevant") if they don't participate in the rituals of these three cult dynamics. That loss of status or potential for status is often psychosocially catastrophic and helps maintain both the cult and the entire dynamic (these three cult dynamics) that drive it.
These three cult dynamics appear in virtually all cults in various ways, but particularly in ones that are large-scale political cults taking the form of mass movements. They are sociological and psychological poison, so it helps for us to be aware of them and on guard for them, including our own participation in them.
Have you noticed these dynamics anywhere, Left, Right, or elsewhere?
Conservative parents all over the country who, by the grace of God, didn't lose their daughters to trans because of Woke Left now face seeing their sons lured towards Nazism by the Woke Right, and the justifications are just as bad and based in resentment as in 1920-30s Germany.
I like pointing out that the Christian Nationalist wings are "Politically Christian" in exactly the same way the CRT people saw people as "Politically Black." That's exactly what you're hitting with "trans-Christian," and it's why we're not attacking Christians or Christianity.
On high-commitment, or totalizing, ideological cults like Woke, or, one could say, Maoist cults. A super long post/🧵!
Perhaps the best documenter and analyst of the cult of Maoism, from which Woke derives (including Woke Right, as we'll see), was Robert Jay Lifton, who was in Hong Kong in the early 1950s interviewing and documenting refugees and exiles from the newly formed People's Republic of China. Lifton wrote books about this including the thorough case-study driven Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism: A Study of "Brainwashing" in China (1961).
In this book, inter alia, Lifton gives a few vivid descriptions of the cult phenomenon of the "thought reform" environment in China (also translated: "ideological remolding") that characterizes two aspects of it as what he calls a "cult of confession" and a "cult of enthusiasm." These may be comprehensive of the Maoist Communist milieu, but to them I would add a third, a "cult of transgression," for modern Woke cult environments and behavior, only there in nascent form in Mao's People's Republic.
The "cult of confession" is a key feature of the totalizing cult because creates incredible vulnerability in each individual. The way it works is by getting people to confess to their own wrongdoing, increasingly as defined against the ideological expectations of the cult. The idea is that people would confess to their sins against the cult doctrine and each other in order to bond, avoid punishment, signal adherence and understanding of the doctrine, etc.
Every confession has a number of psychosocial effects. First, it induces massive vulnerability in the confessor. The whole group is hearing things the confessor will be judged for, perhaps harshly. Second, it therefore opens a gate to a carrot-or-stick reaction of punishment or leniency that enables trauma bonding of the confessor to the group and its leadership cadres. Third, it provides catharsis for the confessor and even some of the people witnessing that confession, allowing them to vent the pressures of cult belonging into deeper cult commitment. Fourth, it inspires more people to confess for themselves and, in fact, competitive confession where people try to give bigger and bigger confessions as it goes from one person to the next, amplifying the all the other psychosocial effects.
You can easily imagine the last of those characteristics if you've ever sat in a class where everyone is supposed to give some kind of introduction of themselves with an update on their emotional growth (yoga classes often do this, for example). The first few people say a little, and by the end it's a sob-fest with long, detailed stories of high emotional content and valence and tons of flowing empathy. Now imagine that but confessing evils you have committed, including against imaginary crimes.
The Woke Left made strong use of this "cult of confession" dynamic. DEI meetings were, in essence, exactly this program rammed into a professional workplace setting. Accusations of mysterious "structural" racism or transphobia or whatever were leveled, and everyone has to look for ways they've contributed or been complicit and confess it all in front of the group. There is also much confessing of "I used to be like this but then I learned how much harm it causes to people of color for white people to go hiking" or some such. "It encodes whiteness into the recreation, hiking culture, and the outdoors, which is exclusionary." You get the idea.
Lifton characterizes the "cult of enthusiasm" as partially derivative to the cult of confession and partly free-standing. In short, the cult of enthusiasm refers to a strong current of enthusiasm for supporting the cult program, beliefs, and its leadership. It's also usually highly emotional in nature and meant not to create and manipulate guilt and shame so much as to whip up frenzy, mania, and enthusiasm in the participants.
Part of that can be done directly, particularly in the PRC context in the form of party and party leadership (esp. Mao) worship or various icons that were held up as ideal comrades. Some of it is derivative to the cult of confession, however, where after confessing, an enthusiasm to "do better" emerges with people frantically and manically participating in the cult's behaviors and rituals, including denunciations of class enemies or those who haven't confessed sufficiently or at all.
Psychologically, the cult of enthusiasm dynamic energizes members of the cult, helps them bond in a shared sense of activity and worldview, reinforces the cult's beliefs, inspires loyalty and commitment, and reinforces the sense of the high social cost of dissent while also discouraging it through general social pressure and enthusiasm for the common cult direction. The highly emotionally charged atmosphere of this cult dynamic is instrumental to binding and orienting people with the cult's doctrines.
The Woke Left did this as well, as indicated by my deliberate wry usage of the phrase "do better" in the previous paragraph. The denunciation rituals are obvious and, in fact, more or less characterize Woke Left behavior in most people's minds. There was also the general enthusiasm for "liberation" and a "socially just world," though, as we hear in ridiculous terms like "trans joy." Every Pride parade was a "cult of enthusiasm" exercise, as were many of their other rallies, protests, demonstrations, and so on. (This has led me in the past to say that protest is Woke church.)
Lifton doesn't talk specifically about a third cult dynamic that is overwhelmingly obvious in the Woke but that was also present in the Maoist thought-reform context, though he does discuss the phenomenon. It's what I'm calling the cult of transgression phenomenon.
The purpose of Woke theory is often to transgress norms and boundaries, especially in Queer Theory, which is explicitly formulated to do this and only this. bell hooks (name intentionally not capitalized) even published a famous book called Teaching to Transgress that highlights the centrality of this behavior in a semi-formal academic way, even though, again, every Pride demonstration made it obviously clear in a more tangible and blatant way.
The idea of the cult of transgression is essentially the idea of teenage rebellion but turned pathological. Teenagers naturally rebel against their environments, parents, norms, etc., just as a way of testing out boundaries in the effort to stake out an independent adult identity for themselves. They often do this in tightly knit social groups that develop their own slang language, set of in-group jokes, and sets of transgressions that prove their defiance, and they often play off one another to increase the transgressive capacity of their bubble until it strikes various boundaries from which it is supposed to learn important lessons about public versus private behavior, social norms and limitations, etc.
That's normal, but it can also be the basis for a cult of transgression defined by people pushing the boundaries of prevailing norms through cult doctrine and eventually socially and psychologically isolating themselves from those outside the cult. In organic situations like with teenagers, this is likely mostly harmless, but when there is a directed cult ideology in play, it can be a potent cult recruitment and commitment tool that takes the form of what we might call the "ritual of transgression."
The ritual of transgression is best described by saying that everyone in a group within the cult, or the cult itself, competes to transgress the expected norms of behavior and thought a little more but always in a particular direction in line with cult doctrine. You can imagine a group of young Critical Race Theorists sitting around starting with a transgressive statement like "the police are racist" (not worthy of respect) and going down a deep rabbit hole of wanting to defund police, abolish police, abolish prisons, imprison police, kill police, etc., or another one in which "police are racist" turns into discussions of why everything else is racist too, even hiking and probably the mountains people want to hike on.
Radical feminist behavior over the last fifty years (thus Woke activism in many ways) is almost defined by participation in a combination of these three cults with the tip of the spear being the cult of transgression; hence bell hooks's book title. They did this in both theory (blaming men, patriarchy, misogyny, "rape culture," etc., for more and more ridiculous things) and in practice (say, making themselves deliberately hateful and ugly to "reject gender norms" and "being nice" and blaming men for thinking they're ugly and hateful).
The Maoist cult did this too, particularly in the Cultural Revolution under the doctrine of "Smash the Four Olds," which admittedly came long after Lifton's research and publication of Thought Reform. Young people rejected their elders (transgressive) and went on to "smash" anything reminiscent of "old" society (cf. "Boomer mentality"). This is blatant transgression against the existing society, by the way. Streets were renamed, temples desecrated, relics looted, smashed, and burned, and even people were killed or struggled into suicide over their adherence to "old ways of thinking" or "old habits" (cf., again, "Boomer mentality").
In the cult of transgression, the ritual is to transgress to the limits of tolerability with no backtracking and to do so in a social environment where everyone is going a little deeper into the ideology and doctrine of the cult, to which they become increasingly socially bound, partly by it becoming an "in-joke" they can't share elsewhere because it's too transgressive, which is also socially isolating, and partly through a shared sense of rule-breaking. Ultimately, this creates massive social co-dependence on other members of the cult and a self-isolation from outsiders (who will eventually have to be driven away) who might act as moderating forces.
The cult of transgression is much more prominent in Woke circumstances than in Maoist ones because Mao was ultimately the Dear-Leader dictator and the CCP was not to be crossed or violated (or transgressed against), putting sharp limits on how far the transgression could go. Of course, this loosened considerably during the Cultural Revolution because Mao empowered the Red Guard to do exactly this against the sitting Party and to attack them for their hidden capitalist tendencies and lack of revolutionary spirit. Woke, being much more decentralized, is much more strongly characterized by the cult of transgression dynamic than was Maoism, with the brief exception of the Red Guard phenomenon (1966-1968).
A peculiar feature of the cult of transgression is that it's like a system of social valves that increasingly lock a participant into the cult ideology and its increasingly stronger adherents. That is, you cannot go backwards. Once you transgress to a certain degree and the cult accepts that level of transgression or extremism, to back off or moderate at all is actually to violate the terms of the cult of transgression itself, at which point it will turn on you. All participants will eventually participate in the punishment of hypothetical or real moderates or eventually "traitors" and so they know that more than social rejection awaits them if they "cuck out," as the Woke Right would have it.
Put differently, the cult of transgression is a radicalization vehicle with no safe escape hatch and that becomes harder to escape the longer one participates in it and the deeper one gets. Take for example a cult of transgression calling everything racist from a CRT perspective. Suppose you say something isn't racist when someone else transgresses the boundary of saying that it is. According to the rules of the cult, you're now maintaining racism, so you're a racist, so you're a traitor. Punishment will ensue.
Not only can we easily imagine dozens of examples of this behavior on the Woke Left from recent memory and experience, we can also credit it with the whole of the "transgender" phenomenon. Radical feminists wanted to say "gender is a social construct," so they had absolutely no space to stop a movement claiming "sex is a social construct" or any of its derivatives, like that men who claim to be women belong in women's sports punching them in the face and breaking their skulls (which is a huge transgression, when you think of it that way). They just got called "TERFs" and expelled while the transgressive cult marched on without them.
Now, of course, Woke Right circles exhibit all three of these cult dynamics too, most notably the cults of enthusiasm and transgression. In fact, those largely define "Woke Right" functionally. They are wild-eyed enthusiastic in the idea of "winning" instead of "always losing because of 'muh principles,'" and everything they do (under the misapplied brand name "based") is transgressive of the norms of both Woke and through illegitimate conflation polite and normal liberal society. (Yes, this makes Woke Right a "queering" movement in many ways.)
The Woke Right exhibits the cult of confession in confessing to "propaganda" and "psyops" that they either fell for or hadn't fully awakened to until some point in the past, if any of those things apply. More often, since they tend to wish to prove they've always been MAGA elite status epistemologically, it takes the form of confessing they didn't think everything is "fake, gay, and retarded" and that some things might actually be real, or, even less, just that they admit people go along with things until they "wake up." There does not tend to be a competitive confession component to Woke Right, however, but the opposite. People compete to have less to have to confess for.
The cult of enthusiasm manifests in a frenzy for "winning" literally and explicitly at the expense of their principles. The world is a football game with exactly two teams in a zero-sum battle for political power and hegemonic force, and they're going to win. And winning feels good. They're like an army that has lost its mind after defeating the enemy's vanguard and is now sprinting wildly into a trap, but it binds them together and allows them to criticize all other more moderate or temperate views as "controlled opposition," "cucked," "principled losing," or "losing gracefully."
The word the Woke Right misuses internally for its cult of transgression is "based," which has nothing to do with being based in reality. For them, being "based" does not mean to be based in reality and unafraid to state uncomfortable truths against social pressure while maintaining your values; it means saying edgy things you're not supposed to say in polite society or under Woke hegemony. That is, it means being transgressive, or, in the Woke Left parlance for the exact same thing, being queer, but in a "trad" way.
This feature of the Woke Right cult is likely its most dominant of the three. Woke Right social dynamics tend to involve competitively saying or expressing more "based" (that is, Woke or queer-trad) things, whether that be racist, sexist, anti-gay, Jew-hating or blaming, patriarchal, chauvinistic for their own groups, or extreme (anti-Constitutional) MAGA policy positions or reactions to politics relevant to MAGA policy goals. To go backwards against the social values is to be "controlled opposition," "cucked," "neocon," "warmonger," etc., or simply "Boomer minded" and is verboten.
In the Woke literature, the principle of the cult of transgression is ultimately characterized most blatantly by Herbert Marcuse in "Repressive Tolerance," where he calls the principle "liberating tolerance." He defines it thusly, "Liberating tolerance, then, would mean intolerance against movements from the Right and toleration of movements from the Left. As to the scope of this tolerance and intolerance: ... it would extend to the stage of action as well as of discussion and propaganda, of deed as well as of word."
Another way to term liberating tolerance would be "No Enemies to the Left (NETTL)." The parallel concept in the Maoist cult would be "No Enemies of Mao Zedong Thought," and in the Woke Right cult would be "No Enemies to the Right (NETTR)," which is explicitly and strongly argued for and held to in the Woke Right cult and its various cults of transgression and enthusiasm. These forces are all the same and serve only the function of deepening radicalization, commitment, and cult communal self-isolation.
Have you observed any of these traits in any Woke environments?
Chris's argument was, as we might now recognize, Gramscian tactical, ultimately, not necessarily moral. He insisted that if we took on the controversial transgender issue we would divide our forces against CRT. One thing at a time. Most of us disagreed, but it was just a meeting.
The last time I disagreed (semi)-publicly with Chris Rufo was in June of 2021, face to face. The issue of disagreement was whether the new anti-Woke effort should take on the transgender issue or stick to CRT. Chris wanted CRT only. I didn't. The rest is history.
Great thread explaining why the evidence doesn't remotely support the claims of transgender activists, particularly in law. It's common in lawsuits for transgender activists to make "born that way" arguments (sometimes speaking out of both sides of their mouths), and they're bunk
Quoting @buttonslives: 🧵 Transgender people are not “born that way.”
The studies used to support that claim rely on biological evidence of gender nonconformity—traits linked to same-sex attraction or intersex conditions—and are misrepresented as proof that being trans is a biological condition.
The entirety of the "transgender medicine" narrative is based off bad and misinterpreted studies!
Quoting @buttonslives: Brain scans, twin studies, genetics, prenatal hormone exposure—none of it proves people are born transgender. In my latest article, I explain what these studies are actually identifying and how they’re being misused to push a false biological narrative.
This is a far more complicated point than the "uncensored speech" (a form of liberty) account thinks it is.
You can't be transgender because it doesn't exist, so you aren't at liberty to be something that doesn't exist. Adults, and only adults, under the purview of their doctors, under satisfactory conditions to both, which I think should be extremely stringent in scope and long-running enough in evaluation to exclude all people in the first half of their 20s at the least, might attempt to arrange their bodies (their property, inherently) as if it were a member of the opposite sex, but that doesn't make them the opposite sex or even "transgender." It makes them a man or woman who is endeavoring to live as the other.
But there's a deeper point our liberty-loving (yet denying) confused friend doesn't understand about "transgender." There can be no "transgender" without first accepting gender ideology, which is a social reification of the idea of gender ideology. That is, there can be no "transgender" without compelling the beliefs of the population that "gender identity" is real in the first place, not to mention something that can be chosen and/or changed.
That is, unlike someone (an adult under due advisement of his psychiatrists and physicians under stringent criteria screening for comorbid psychiatric conditions) who is merely trying to manage their distress at wit's end by living as a member of the opposite sex though they are not, and thus shouldering an immense and unpleasant set of personal responsibilities to do so, the "transgender" person intrinsically forces belief in a worldview that is not only narrow but also false.
Since no one has the authority to compel a worldview or the capacity to escape reality, then, the answer turns out to be no.
Quotes a post by T08736; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Quoting @DailyCaller: 🚨BREAKING: Three of four alleged Tesla facility and charger vandals appear to identify as transgender or nonbinary.
The alleged perpetrators of different Tesla properties all identify as transgender, cross dress or go by ‘she/they’ pronouns.
C2 false claimshand-codedcrime casemotive displacementpolitical enemyviolence terror
The word "transition," thus "trans" and "transgender," are incorrect. Transition is the process of going from one thing to another, which never actually happens in a "gender transition." They never get there. There are no "trans" people, speaking terminologically.