Sting’s nonbinary daughter has been cast in a male role in the new ‘Sense and Sensibility’. The moment Eliot Sumner appears on screen as Mr Palmer, the illusion is shattered. Pandering to trans has ruined an otherwise decent film, says Janet Murray https://buff.ly/SYEXnHz

Spiked
Online magazine founded in 2000
1. Public identity, ownership and leadership
- Self-description: "The magazine that wants to change the world as well as report on it. For humanism, democracy and freedom." (X bio, archive). Its About page: founded in 2000; "making the case for freedom of speech, democracy and human endeavour, and against authoritarianism, identity politics and misanthropic greenism"; "The vast majority of our revenue comes directly from our readers". It names Mick Hume, Brendan O'Neill and Tom Slater as its three editors.
- Lineage: Wikipedia says Spiked was created by Mick Hume, a former leader of the Revolutionary Communist Party, and grew from Living Marxism, which closed in 2000 after losing a libel case brought by ITN. Wikipedia lists Tom Slater as editor since September 2021, replacing Brendan O'Neill (editor from 2007), who became "chief political writer" and hosts The Brendan O'Neill Show. The About page lists Fraser Myers as deputy editor and a managing editor who is not named here.
- Legal owner (Companies House): SPIKED LIMITED, company number 03935644, earliest officer appointments dated 28 February 2000 (the officers page does not show the incorporation date; Companies House basic company data gives incorporation 2000-02-28, see below). Current directors: Luke Gittos (appointed 10 November 2017), Patrick Hayes (13 October 2025), a director (6 September 2018) and a director (20 February 2026). Persons with significant control (each holding more than 25% and not more than 50% of shares and votes): Patrick Hayes, Luke Gittos and one other person who is not named here. Ceased: one person (11 December 2025), Jennie Bristow and Frank Furedi (both ceased 5 February 2021; the PSC record names him "Ferenc Furedi", the officer record "Frank Furedi"). Earlier directors include Frank Furedi (officer record; to 26 May 2017), Helene Guldberg (secretary and director to 10 November 2017) and Mick Hume, the founder (to 12 December 2005). Basic data: private limited, SIC 58190, incorporated 2000-02-28, accounts category total exemption full, last accounts 2026-03-31 (Companies House basic company data, 03935644, 2). The filing history (fetched 2026-11-08) shows accounts filed 2022-11-04 (FY2022), 2023-11-23, 2024-05-31, 2025-04-29 and 2026-09-10 (FY2026). The PSC snapshot (Companies House persons with significant control, 03935644, 3) lists Luke Gittos, one other person and Patrick Hayes (from 2025-12-11), each with ownership and voting of 25-50% (Gittos and the other notified 2021-02-05); one further individual at 25-50% (notified 2021-02-05, ceased 2025-12-11); and Jennie Bristow and Ferenc Furedi, 25-50%, notified 2016-04-06 and ceased 2021-02-05.
- US arm: "Spiked US Inc." is named by Wikipedia as a recipient of Charles Koch Foundation money (section 7). The IRS records do list Spiked US Inc, EIN 47-3207516 (details in sections 6 and 7). No record reviewed here links this EIN to Spiked Limited (03935644); the press and Wikipedia describe it as Spiked's US arm.
- X account: 210.8k followers (project archive).
2. Posting record (project archive, all posts coded)
- Followers 210,800 (tier 100k-1M). Keyword posts (weighted) 25.9; views on keyword posts 446,621; influence rank 114 under equal weighting (not in the top set under every weighting).
- Coded posts: 74, every post, reply and quote by the account that matched the search terms (archive as of 2026-11-16). Severity: C0 1; C1 47; C2 2; C3 12; C4 12; C5 0. Share at C2 or above: 35.1% (26 of 74).
- Shield framing (the post justifies itself by protecting children or women): 24 of 74 coded posts (32.4%).
- Targeting events: 12. Adult-care posts verified: 0. Aurora-case posts: 0.
- Top narratives (coded posts carrying each): IDEOLOGY_CULT 30; INSTITUTIONAL_CAPTURE 22; POLITICAL_ENEMY 21; DENIAL 21; SPEECH_PERSECUTION 16.
- What the coded posts show: 73 of the 74 coded posts are anti-trans, mostly headline posts promoting articles by its writers. The main lines are the claim that trans identity is an ideology or cult (30 posts), capture of institutions by it (22), trans people and their allies as a political enemy (21), denial of trans identity (21) and persecution of those who speak out (16). 24 carry a protective claim, so 49 make no appeal to protecting anyone; of those, 13 deny trans people's identity and 14 are dehumanizing or single out a person. Of the posts at C4 or C5, 10 single out public figures and 2 private individuals. Output rises sharply in 2026, with 37 posts at C1.
- Examples from the full coded record (the highest-reach posts by severity level and main line of attack):
@spikedonline Post C4 targeting hand-coded appearance denialWhat it says Promotes an article saying that when a nonbinary actor appears on screen "the illusion is shattered" and that "Pandering to trans has ruined an otherwise decent film"; it singles out a public figure and denies their identity.
@spikedonline Post Bridget Phillipson is working with trans activists to subvert the Supreme Court gender ruling. Her objections to single-sex spaces are beyond idiotic. She is betraying women and girls, says Jo Bartosch https://buff.ly/0enf9SR
C4 targeting hand-coded institutional capture women spacesWhat it says Promotes an article accusing a government minister of working with trans activists to "subvert the Supreme Court gender ruling" and calling her objections to single-sex spaces "beyond idiotic", framed as protecting women and girls.
@spikedonline Post Stewart Lee epitomises the 'regime comedian' – someone who aligns snugly with dominant orthodoxies. He poses as an anti-authoritarian, while ignoring the cancellation of dissenters from trans dogma. He is a moral and artistic coward, writes Graham Linehan https://buff.ly/CQzwj7z
C4 targeting hand-coded ideology cult speech persecutionWhat it says Promotes an article calling a comedian a "moral and artistic coward" for "ignoring the cancellation of dissenters from trans dogma", singling out a public figure.
@spikedonline Post A planned ‘trans uprising’ at the Labour Women’s Conference only attracted a handful of sad transvestites. Good. Gender ideology may be finally losing its grip, says Jo Bartosch https://buff.ly/BvPxlBl
C3 dehumanizing hand-coded appearance denial ideology cult political enemyWhat it says Promotes an article celebrating that a planned "trans uprising" drew only "a handful of sad transvestites", using a slur, and hoping gender ideology is "finally losing its grip".
@spikedonline Post If a boy thinks he’s a girl, then he clearly has mental-health issues. Why have we let trans activists convince us otherwise? This isn’t compassion – it’s negligence. It is harming vulnerable kids, says Stella O’Malley https://buff.ly/XVLS6sS
C3 dehumanizing hand-coded child indoctrination institutional capture mental illnessWhat it says Promotes an article asserting that "If a boy thinks he's a girl, then he clearly has mental-health issues", treating trans identity as a mental illness.
@spikedonline Post Labour’s ‘conversion therapy’ bill is an Orwellian nightmare. Parents can be jailed for questioning a child’s ’trans identity’. ‘Deadnaming’ will also be criminalised. It is sinister, says Andrew Tettenborn https://buff.ly/S2oB6Q6
C2 false claims hand-coded child indoctrination denial speech persecutionWhat it says Promotes an article calling a bill against conversion practices "an Orwellian nightmare" and saying parents can be jailed for questioning a child's identity.
Correction Conversion-practices legislation targets coercive or abusive attempts to change identity, not parents asking questions; major US medical associations support affirming care.
3. Documented moments (dated)
- 2021-09-03: O'Neill, "The transgender delusion": "[a trans author] is a man who believes he is a woman... I think he is deluded" and compares a trans woman to "a man who chops off his ear" becoming Van Gogh; it adds "I say this not to be insulting" (the piece misgenders the author on purpose).
- 2022-06-25: O'Neill, "Is trans surgery just state-sanctioned mutilation?" argues that gender-affirming surgery "is mutilation" and that "maybe it's the word we need right now"; an editorial CLARIFICATION appended says an earlier version wrongly stated that Katherine Deves compared trans surgery to the Holocaust. Calling gender-affirming surgery "mutilation" is dehumanizing anti-trans rhetoric (section 4); the evidence brief records that reported regret after surgery is low, a pooled 1% across 27 studies of 7,928 surgical patients (meta-analysis, PRS Global Open, 2021, 4).
- 2023-08-28: Marc Glendening, "The trans threat to freedom" (5), argues that a Labour pledge to ban "trans conversion therapy" would mean that, in the article's words, "anyone who refuses to affirm the desire of trans people to transition" "could be subject to prosecution". This frames a ban on conversion practices as persecution of ordinary clinicians and parents.
- 2024-04-11: Andrew Doyle, "The Cass Review shames the gay-rights establishment" (title from his Spiked author page, which lists it dated 11 April 2024). The title invokes the Cass Review, which Spiked uses as authority; the published methodological critiques of the Review are in section 4 of the page (Spiked author page, 6, accessed 2026-11-11).
- 2024-04-16: Joanna Williams, "After Cass, let's kick trans ideology out of the classroom". Uses the Cass Review as its authority; see section 4.
- 2024-06-25: Andrew Doyle, "It's time for gay people to turn our backs on Pride" and 2022-07-30, "How Stonewall turned against gay rights" (titles from the same author page).
- 2025-01-30: Andrew Doyle, "Is the horror of child transitioning finally coming to an end?", praises Trump's order "Protecting Children From Chemical and Surgical Mutilation" and says "when it comes to the mutilation of children, tribalist political loyalties are surely not the priority". The order's title and Doyle's "mutilation of children" are dehumanizing anti-trans rhetoric (section 4); the evidence brief records an NIH-funded cohort of 315 trans and nonbinary youth in which depression and anxiety fell over two years after starting hormones (New England Journal of Medicine, 2023, 7).
- 2025-04-17: O'Neill, "The hilarious meltdown of men who think they're women", the day after the UK Supreme Court ruling on the Equality Act: "the caterwauling of fellas in dresses... It's delicious... I am so here for it"; it mocks trans people, among them two named trans public figures, and uses crude sexual language about trans women's bodies (terms redacted here).
- 2025-04 (podcast page; the page is undated and April 2025 is inferred from its "Tuesday 15 April" reference): The Brendan O'Neill Show with the director of campaigns at Sex Matters on "why no sport is safe from gender ideology" and "why Trump's executive order on women's sports isn't working".
- 2026-04-07: O'Neill, "The dangers of 'gender-affirming care' are now undeniable", on a Finnish register study in Acta Paediatrica; see section 4.
- 2026-08-31: the "womanface" article (section 2; 2026-08-31).
4. Evidence that the child and sports framing is a pretext
- Attacks on trans adults with no child in view: "The transgender delusion" (2021), the 17 April 2025 article gloating over a ruling that removes trans women from women's changing rooms and bathrooms, and the 2026-08-31 piece mocking trans comics' bodies ("estrogen-bloated moobs").
- Dehumanizing language alongside the child frame: "mutilation" is used in a headline (2022) and a quoted order (2025); "trans lunacy" and "trans insanity" appear in Spiked's own posts (archive, 2024-07-06 and 2026-07-06).
- Opposing transition at any age: the 2021 and 2022 pieces argue that a trans woman is "a man who believes he is a woman" and that surgery is "mutilation" without an age limit. The 2022 text speaks of "a young woman" and "your daughter"; the 2021 text is about an adult author.
- O'Neill approved Executive Order 14201 ("Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports") as a feminist act (The Spectator, 6 February 2025, 8) and the UK Supreme Court's reading of "woman" (The Spectator, 16 April 2025, 9), and called trans women's womanhood "the most lunatic luxury belief of all" (The Spectator, 30 September 2025, 10; Wikipedia, 11, dump of 2026-10-01). These reach all women's sport and all trans women, not only children.
- Appeals to reviews are rhetoric, not neutral evidence: the 2024 Cass piece and the 2026 Finnish-study piece use the reviews as proof that care is harmful. The evidence brief records published critiques of the Cass Review: a peer-reviewed appraisal in BMC Medical Research Methodology (2025) rated all seven commissioned systematic reviews at high risk of bias; the BMA's council voted to commission an independent evaluation. On the evidence itself, the brief's words are that low certainty ratings for youth evidence reflect a dispute about study design, in a field where randomized trials are widely considered unethical and low certainty ratings are common across pediatric medicine. That describes the evidence only. It does not make Spiked's use of the reviews sincere; it is bad-faith rhetoric. Spiked's headline says the Finnish study shows treatment "deepen[s] troubled kids' distress"; an observational cohort cannot by itself show that (the headline's claim is Spiked's).
5. Platform enforcement history
The account is active (archive: last seen 2026-11-04).
6. Ties
- Role: Companies House officers and controllers of Spiked Ltd (section 1): Luke Gittos, Patrick Hayes and two further directors; Gittos, Hayes and one other person with significant control (Companies House).
- Role: Mick Hume, Tom Slater (editors), Brendan O'Neill (chief political writer), Fraser Myers (deputy editor), and a managing editor who is not named here (About page; Wikipedia).
- Funding: Charles Koch Foundation to Spiked US Inc, purpose "General Operating Support", recipient status PC, from the funder's Form 990 Schedule I (IRS Form 990 e-file returns of the Charles Koch Foundation, Schedule I): tax period 2016, USD 130,000 paid plus USD 20,000 "approved for future payment" (return object id 201713199349103301); tax period 2017, USD 20,000 paid (object id 201823199349104557), equal to the 2016 pledge, so the two are not added; tax period 2018, USD 130,000 paid (object id 201903199349102110). Paid rows total USD 280,000 over the three tax periods. The DeSmog/Guardian reporting says the programme gave USD 300,000 over three years and USD 150,000 in 2016, and Spiked's own 2018 piece says USD 170,000 in 2016; the filed rows do not reconcile with those figures, so the filed rows are reported and the others attributed. The foundation is a grantmaking foundation, not a donor-advised fund. The grants are recorded for Spiked US Inc only and are not shown as received by Spiked Limited. The campus-events purpose is as reported by DeSmog UK and the Guardian (via Wikipedia); the filed purpose is general operating support. O'Neill's response (per Wikipedia) called the criticism "McCarthyism" and said the programme supports groups from across the spectrum.
- Role: Spiked US Inc officers as filed (all USD 0 pay): Ceri Dingle, President (2020 return; Vice President on the 2019 return; Powerbase, an advocacy wiki, accessed 2026-11-09, lists a Ceri Dingle as a director of WORLDwrite and a Spiked Ltd shareholder per a 2010 annual return; no source reviewed here ties her to Spiked US Inc beyond the filing), plus a Treasurer and a Secretary on the 2020 return, and a principal officer on the 2016 Form 990-N, who aren't named here (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 47-3207516 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12), object ids 202002799349200310 (2019) and 202101559349200215 (2020); IRS Form 990-N and SOI extracts).
- Tracked contributors (link to their profiles): TwisterFilm (Malcolm Clark): a regular contributor per the Spiked author page, which lists 15 articles dated 30 March 2025 to 20 October 2026 and has four pages of pagination, so the full archive is longer than those 15 (accessed 2026-11-08). No payment is documented. roseveniceallan (Venice Allan, Let Women Speak organiser as described in her profile): two Spiked articles, 7 June 2024 ("Hampstead Ladies' Pond is no place for men") and 22 May 2026 (an article on assisted dying) (author page, accessed 2026-11-08), appearance or listing. Others: WomenReadWomen (interview extract on Spiked 2024-11-12, appearance or listing), salltweets (O'Neill Show guest 2024-05-16, appearance or listing), SwipeWright (podcast guest, appearance or listing), Janet Murray (director of JournalismSEEN, Spiked writer).
- Formal joint work: Spiked's own "supporter" events and the O'Neill Show live podcasts (About page) are its own programming, not external ties.
- Narrative alignment only (not a tie): a Free Speech Union quotation on the About page.
7. Income and funding
- Reader revenue: "The vast majority of our revenue comes directly from our readers" and "Only 0.1% of regular readers currently support us" (About page, article footers, undated). Supporter membership: no price on the page. Donation offer: "Donate £25 or more to get a year's membership of spiked supporters for half the usual price" (podcast page, 2025). Live ticketed events: a spiked summit at £80, or £50 for supporters (page reviewed here, undated). Books: O'Neill's "After the Pogrom" (2024) was published by Spiked (Wikipedia).
- Koch Foundation funding 2016-2018: USD 280,000 paid across tax periods 2016, 2017 and 2018 per the funder's Schedule I (section 6).
- DeSmog (2018-12-04) says Spiked US Inc declared total funding of $137,000 on its 2016 tax return, and that the Charles Koch Foundation's 2016 gifts of $130,000 and $20,000 ($150,000) were more than that. It also says the foundation gave Spiked US Inc $20,000 in 2017, "over half of the $37k in total declared" for that year. (DeSmog, 13) Comparison with the filings: Spiked US Inc's 2016 filing in the IRS e-postcard records is a Form 990-N (gross receipts normally $50,000 or less), which carries no revenue figure; ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer lists a further 2016 document, labelled Form 990-EZ and filed in April 2018 with the 2017 return, whose figures are not shown in the listing, so the $137,000 can be neither matched nor excluded; its 2017 Form 990-EZ shows revenue of $32,293 (IRS SOI extract, EIN 47-3207516; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12), not $37,000. The press figures and the filed figures do not agree; the filed ones are the ones counted here.
- DeSmog also reports that Spiked's managing editor said the foundation had given as much as $300,000 over three years; Spiked's own 2018 article says the 2016 grant was $170,000 (the two accounts differ: $150,000 in DeSmog, $170,000 in Spiked) for a campus-debate programme it calls the "Unsafe Space Tour" (14; the programme name is Spiked's wording).
- Spiked US Inc own filings (USD; IRS SOI extract, EIN 47-3207516; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12): revenue 32,293 / expenses 135,278 (2017); revenue 173,475 / expenses 166,402 (2018); 5,496 / 20,665 (2019); 111 / 24,542 (2020, total assets 0); mission "Promotion of Freedom of speech, thought and expression". Not combined with Spiked Limited's pound figures.
- Spiked Limited files no Form 990 (UK company). Its accounts are in the total-exemption category (balance sheet only), so no turnover is filed.
- Spiked US Inc (EIN 47-3207516), filings as ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer lists them (accessed 2026-11-11): 2016, a document labelled Form 990-EZ with no revenue or expense figures in the data table (the table calls it a postcard filing by gross receipts); 2017 Form 990-EZ, revenue USD 32,293, expenses USD 135,278; 2018, revenue 173,475, expenses 166,402; 2019, revenue 5,496, expenses 20,665; 2020, revenue 111, expenses 24,542. The file names in the listing show that the 2016 and 2017 documents were both filed in April 2018 and the 2018 document in April 2019; the 2016 document is a 990-EZ by its file name, while the IRS e-postcard bulk file lists a Form 990-N for 2016. The listing gives the exemption as issued in January 2016, the organization's city as Hoboken, NJ and its fiscal year end as December. The figures match the IRS records already on the page. The 2016 document's own figures are not shown in the listing, so the difference between DeSmog's "$137,000 declared" for 2016 and the filed rows (and between its "$37k" for 2017 and the filed USD 32,293) is not explained: the 2016 figure could only come from the April 2018 document (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12).
8. Legal matters
- Predecessor: Living Marxism (LM) closed in 2000 after losing an ITN libel case (Wikipedia). The defendant was LM's publisher, not Spiked.
Sources and open questions
Open: why the filed Koch rows (USD 280,000 paid) differ from the USD 300,000 in the press, and whether another Koch entity made further grants; what the April 2018 document labelled Form 990-EZ for 2016 shows (revenue, contributions, officers), which would settle DeSmog's USD 137,000 for 2016 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer display page for the 2016 document, or the IRS document itself); Spiked Ltd balance-sheet figures (now on the Spiked Limited page, for the year to 31 March 2026); whether Spiked pays Clark or Allan.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- image page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiked_(magazine)
- https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/03935644
- https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/03935644/persons-with-significant-control
- https://eld.bl.uk/catalog/100143933984_0x000001
- https://www.spiked-online.com/2023/08/28/the-trans-threat-to-freedom/
- https://www.spiked-online.com/author/andrew-doyle/
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10081536
- https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/donald-trump-is-liberating-america-from-the-transgender-madness/
- https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-did-we-need-the-supreme-court-to-tell-us-what-a-woman-is/
- https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/there-is-no-way-back-for-emma-watson-after-jk-rowlings-brutal-demolition/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brendan_O'Neill_(author)
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/473207516
- https://www.desmog.com/2018/12/04/spiked-lm-dark-money-koch-brothers/.
- https://www.spiked-online.com/2018/12/03/the-new-mccarthyism-is-ruining-public-life/