All profiles

Person

Robby Starbuck

Conservative activist and podcaster

8documented ties7 names on file
3organizations with a role on file
@robbystarbuck person

Framing note: the rhetoric documented below is anti-trans rhetoric advanced in bad faith, including the parts presented as anti-"woke" corporate accountability, child protection or women's-safety arguments (Tracking Trans Hate assessment of the coded posts in section 2; method in the report). Facts, dates and amounts are exact as sources give them.

1. Public identity and role

  • Conservative activist, podcaster and filmmaker; former music-video director (Wikipedia). Wikipedia does not mention a 2015 endorsement; a Media Matters piece reports that he says he endorsed Trump in 2015, so treat it as his own claim.
  • Politics: declared for the Republican nomination in Tennessee's 5th district in 2021; the Tennessee Republican Party removed him from the 2022 primary ballot, the Tennessee Supreme Court upheld the removal, and he ran as a write-in without winning the nomination (Wikipedia).
  • Anti-trans media: directed the film "The War on Children" (Feb 2024), which news outlets described as anti-trans (Wikipedia, which says it opposes gender-affirming care and that critics called it anti-trans).
  • Corporate pressure campaigns on DEI and LGBTQ+ policies from June 2024 (section 3).
  • Visiting fellow at the Heritage Foundation, announced 2025-04-02, leading its "capital markets initiative" (Daily Wire).
  • Adviser to Meta on "ideological and political bias" in its AI since August 2025 under a lawsuit settlement (section 6; Wikipedia; ABC17/Yahoo, 2025-08-14, say settlement made him an advisor on "ideological and political bias", no financial terms disclosed).
  • Hosts "The Robby Starbuck Show" (podcast).
  • Book: Wikipedia lists a forthcoming book, "Your Truth; The Truth: Why Wokeness Demands Everything—and Forgives Nothing" (Wikipedia; the entry is marked as needing a citation). Young America's Foundation's speaker page describes him as a filmmaker and says he "started his public stand by endorsing Trump in the 2015 Republican primary", and lists as accomplishments (the page's claims, not verified) helping to pass Tennessee restrictions on gender-transition surgeries and hormones for minors and on drag shows with children present (1).

2. Posting record (project archive, all posts coded)

  • Followers 860,800 (tier 100k-1M). Keyword posts (weighted) 169.0; views on keyword posts 30,056,422; influence rank 65 under equal weighting (not in the top set under every weighting).
  • Coded posts: 273, every post, reply and quote by the account that matched the search terms (archive as of 2026-11-16). Severity: C0 8; C1 95; C2 35; C3 36; C4 53; C5 46. Share at C2 or above: 62.3% (170 of 273).
  • Shield framing (the post justifies itself by protecting children or women): 86 of 273 coded posts (31.5%).
  • Targeting events: 99. Adult-care posts verified: 2. Aurora-case posts: 0.
  • Top narratives (coded posts carrying each): POLITICAL_ENEMY 100; DENIAL 78; INSTITUTIONAL_CAPTURE 46; CHILD_INDOCTRINATION 40; IDEOLOGY_CULT 39.
  • What the coded posts show: Of 273 coded posts, 265 are anti-trans (C1 or above). 86 of those carry a protective claim, mainly about children (35 under child indoctrination), casting trans people as a political enemy (27) and medical harm (29); the other 179 make no appeal to protecting anyone, and in those 51 deny trans people's identity and 77 are dehumanizing or single out a person. Across all coded posts the leading lines of attack are casting trans people and their allies as a political enemy (100), denial of identity (78), the claim that institutions are captured by activists (46), child indoctrination (40), ideology or cult claims (39), medical harm (39) and shooter attribution (38). The coded posts run from 2020 to 2026, and the C4 and C5 posts single out institutions (32), public figures (29), private individuals (28) and minors (10).
  • Examples:
    • @robbystarbuck Quote

      Keep in mind that Democrats want you to let the trans Philidelphia mass shooter into the bathroom with your wife and daughters.

      Quotes a post by T00715; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.

      C2 false claims political enemy shooter attribution women spaces

      24,009 views, C2

      What it says "Keep in mind that Democrats want you to let the trans Philidelphia mass shooter into the bathroom with your wife and daughters," quoting another account's post about the suspect.

      Correction No official source had identified the shooter as trans; bathroom-access laws are not linked to violence by trans people. Fox News (6 July 2023) reported a member of the Philadelphia district attorney's LGBTQ advisory committee saying "The suspect has not identified themselves as trans. They have only identified themselves as male." A Logically Facts fact-check rated the claim false. Whether he deleted or corrected the post is not shown in the sources.

    • 2025-05-28 (quote, 63,607 views) and 2025-05-28 (reply, 9,761 views), both 2025-05-28, answering a Democratic congressman: "Your party did the following: Put TAMPONS in boys bathrooms at schools; Wanted to use our tax dollars to fund sex changes for illegal immigrants IN PRISON; Passed laws to strip parental rights if they don't want to trans their confused child. Yes Ro, Democrats are woke." The second bullet concerns incarcerated adults (see section 4). The third bullet's "confused child" language is dismissive of trans youth.
  • Examples from the full coded record (the highest-reach posts by severity level and main line of attack):
    • @robbystarbuck Quote

      Wow. AFTER the anti-Christian "performance" at his event, @[private account] thanked the trans singer that performed this hateful, evil song. If he attempts to apologize, just know his first instinct was to thank the singer after he sang it.

      Quoting @robbystarbuck: Bernie Sanders just had the transgender singer of Against Me sing a song that says: "Does your God have a big fat d*ck? Cause it feels like he’s fucking me" and "Does he shoot wads of honey and c*m twice on Easter Sunday? This is who the Democrats are now. Pure evil. Other lyrics are somehow even more grotesque and anti-Christian. These people are insane. @[private account] is a lunatic and anti-Christian. Yes, this was at Bernie’s rally. This singer goes by the name Laura Jane Grace. Here’s more of the lyrics: "What’s his favourite position? Missionary? Magic bullet? We all give him no lover Just a hand and a mother Can he c*m a shotgun blast And shoot salvation up your a*s? Does he chew c*nt like bubblegum And give bl*wj*bs like a vacuum? Does his D go deep So deep it puts an a*s to sleep? Who’s the 6 to his 9 And what are his other kinks? If he grows all the trees Does he taste every peach? Is your god f*cking you and f*cking me? I know creation must get lonely After all he’s one and only And his son was so well hung I think the big man deserves one" This is what Democrats stand for now. Source: @[private account]
      C5 harassment political enemy religious demonization

      930,339 views

      What it says Quote post that casts a trans singer's performance at a political event as "this hateful, evil song" and accuses a senator of thanking the singer; coded C4 as religious demonization and singling out a public figure.

    • @robbystarbuck Post

      This post singles out a person who is not known to be a public figure (netflix). Its text and link are withheld.

      C5 harassment institutional capture political enemy
      482 replies 3,770 reposts 173 quotes 11,019 likes 522,251 views

      522,251 views

      What it says Lists speakers at a company training as "far left speakers", including a trans activist, to argue the company has been captured; coded C4 as singling out a public figure, with political-enemy and institutional-capture framing.

    • @robbystarbuck Post

      Jesse Watters exposes some crazy stuff in the new Congressional spending bill: There’s BIG money for a gay senior living home, college tuition for young people IN EGYPT, teaching elementary school kids about being trans, zoo tickets and even $ for kids to get chest binders. If House Republicans vote for this, every single one that does deserves to lose their seat. STOP NEGOTIATING WITH LUNATICS. Shut the country down if you need to. Introduce a clean bill without all the waste and play offense. America is tired of paying for the sexual kinks of the deviant lunatics who hold us hostage. When I saw that the GOP Whip in the house TOLD members that leadership recommended a yes vote I just wanted to know when we became the surrender caucus because that’s what they’ve become. Be leaders, not hostages. Stop surrendering to lunatics. Stop it. These people want to hurt you and the people who vote for you. Act like it. They want to bind the chests of kids and brainwash them into trans ideology. Act like it. Respond accordingly. Stop being weak. Enough is enough. It’s maddening. What use are you if you surrender to the craziest people in our country? @[private account] — as a Christian Dad how can you tell members to vote for this crap that Democrats demand? Play hardball and save this country! Act like you were born for a time such as this. Am I the only one angry about this? I don’t think so but let the speaker know what you think in the comments….

      C5 harassment child indoctrination fetish fraud gov spending mental illness political enemy

      372,739 views

      What it says Relays a broadcaster's list of items in a spending bill, including "teaching elementary school kids about being trans" and "$ for kids to get chest binders", as outrageous; coded C3 as a government-spending and child-indoctrination claim.

    • @robbystarbuck Post

      In the new Joker comic he gets pregnant and gives birth. Yep, the Joker is trans now. At least the character is the joker because a pregnant woman thinking they’re a pregnant man is the definition of a joker. Who else is sick of this lunacy?

      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded appearance denial mental illness

      82,153 views

      What it says Calls a comic-book storyline "the definition of a joker" and says "a pregnant woman thinking they're a pregnant man" is lunacy; coded C3 as denial of identity and mockery.

    • @robbystarbuck Post

      Sorry but BOTH SIDES don’t need to lower the temperature. One side does. In less than 2 weeks there have been 5 domestic terrorism attacks by leftists. If you count the trans Minneapolis school shooter it’s actually 6 attacks. Call this what it is: Left wing domestic terrorism!

      C2 false claims hand-coded political enemy shooter attribution violence terror

      853,678 views

      What it says Argues that "BOTH SIDES don't need to lower the temperature" and counts "the trans Minneapolis school shooter" as a sixth leftist attack; coded C2 as shooter attribution.

      Correction Being trans is not a motive; no data show trans people commit disproportionate political violence; "leftist terror epidemic" with trans shooter is a false series framing.

    • @robbystarbuck Post

      Catholic kids were murdered by a trans terrorist and Minneapolis Democrat mayor is worried about "hate" being "directed at our trans community" over the shooting. Apparently Democrats just can’t wait to lower their public approval rating. Truly evil.

      C2 false claims hand-coded political enemy shooter attribution victim dismissal violence terror

      230,390 views

      What it says Calls a shooting at a church school the work of "a trans terrorist" and says a mayor's worry about hate is "Truly evil"; coded C2 as shooter attribution.

      Correction Being trans is not a motive for violence; "trans terrorist" frames one attack as typical of trans people, which is false.

3. Documented moments (dated)

  • 2021-2022: congressional run; removed from the 2022 primary ballot by the state party, upheld by the Tennessee Supreme Court (Wikipedia; exact date not given).
  • 2023-06: accused an actor of "child abuse" over a family photo; a photo agency sent a legal warning over his use of the copyrighted image (Wikipedia).
  • 2023-07-05: Philadelphia shooting post (above).
  • 2024-02: "The War on Children" streamed on X; its trailer passed 30 million views after Elon Musk promoted it (PinkNews, 11 Feb 2024). Participants' complaints: a Nashville drag performer said she was told the film would examine how drag and gender-affirming care bans affect LGBTQ+ mental health, and that her interview was edited to make her seem unwilling to condemn the sexual exposure of children; another performer withdrew, saying the team "absolutely misled me about the premise and tone." Rolling Stone reported that production emails described the film as "tentatively titled 'It Takes A Village'". Starbuck told Rolling Stone that a lack of transparency did not contribute to participants' hesitation.
  • 2024-06: began campaigning against companies over DEI, LGBTQ+ support and climate policies. Tractor Supply rolled back initiatives that month (Wikipedia, confirms the June 2024 start and Tractor Supply first); then John Deere (July), Harley-Davidson, Brown-Forman, Lowe's and Ford (August), Molson Coors and Caterpillar (September), Toyota (October), Boeing and Walmart (November), Nissan (December), McDonald's and Target (January 2025) (Wikipedia). CNN reviewed the changes on 2024-12-17 and called most of them "performative tweaks"; Ford kept several policies and Walmart kept supplier-diversity efforts (Wikipedia citing CNN).
  • 2024-08-28: CNN profile: said gay pride parades and LGBTQ events "promote sex to children" (a claim CNN's report did not support); said he backed Tennessee bills banning gender-affirming care for minors and criminalizing drag where minors could see it (CNN via KTVZ).
  • 2025-03: boosted a claim about "transgender mice" government spending (as reported by The Guardian, Oct 2025, 2).
  • 2025-04-02: named Heritage Foundation visiting fellow (Daily Wire).
  • 2025-04: sued Meta in Delaware (over $5 million sought), alleging that its AI falsely linked him to January 6; settled in August 2025 with an advisory role; terms undisclosed. On 2025-08-11 Meta hired him as an adviser on "ideological and political bias" after the settlement (The Verge, 2025-08-11, cited by Wikipedia; Wikipedia: April 2025 suit, August 2025 advisory role; ABC17: originally sought $5 million, no financial terms disclosed).
  • 2025-05-28: the "sex changes for illegal immigrants IN PRISON" posts (above).
  • 2025-10-22: sued Google over AI outputs (section 8).
  • 2022-03-02 to 2022-12-25: his campaign committee, Robby Starbuck For Congress LLC (FEC committee C00781484, candidate H2TN05339, treasurer listed as Robby Starbuck), paid Dhillon Law Group, Inc. $164,997 in three operating expenditures described as legal fees or services: $10,000 (2022-03-02), $125,000 (2022-05-18) and $29,997 (2022-12-25) (FEC operating expenditures, committee C00781484, 3).
  • 2026-10-14: Uncloseted Media reported that Starbuck is enrolled in Facebook's content monetization program; the Washington Blade, reporting it, names him ("Brown and Starbuck are both enrolled in the content monetization program") and describes him as an anti-DEI campaigner who "has promoted conspiracy theories claiming that pesticides turn children gay" (that characterization is the outlet's; Washington Blade, 2026-10-14, 4). The article gives no payment amount.
  • 2025-10-12: the Guardian's report that he spent the weeks after his Meta appointment "spreading disinformation about shootings, transgender people, vaccines, crime, and protests" is reproduced in its opening paragraphs on Joe.My.God (2025-10-12). The reproduced text says he "has also spread overheated claims and falsehoods about transgender and LGBTQ people", "baselessly claimed that individual shooters in the US were motivated by leftist ideology" and "baselessly asserted that city officials in Portland were working with anti-fascists", and gives no example of the trans-related claims. The Guardian's headline, as the blog's embedded post gives it, is "Meta AI adviser spreads disinformation about shootings, vaccines and trans people". (Joe.My.God, 5; the Guardian, 2)
  • 2025-10-13: PinkNews, summarizing the Guardian report (it links 2), reports that Heidi Beirich, co-founder of the Global Project Against Hate and Extremism, told the Guardian "He peddles lies and pushes extremism, and it is hard to believe any of this will help make their platforms safer or better.", and quotes Eric Bloem of the Human Rights Campaign Foundation saying Robby Starbuck pushes "a dangerous anti-LGBTQ agenda, spreading disinformation and denying the very existence of transgender people." The PinkNews piece gives no trans-related examples from the Guardian. (PinkNews, 6)

4. Evidence that the child and sports framing is pretextual

His public line is protecting children, parents and "merit." His record reaches adults.

  1. Opposes care for incarcerated adults: "Wanted to use our tax dollars to fund sex changes for illegal immigrants IN PRISON" (2025-05-28 and 2025-05-28; 63,607 and 9,761 views). The reference is to Kamala Harris's ACLU questionnaire, in which she wrote that she supports policies ensuring "federal prisoners and detainees are able to obtain medically necessary care" (Law Dork). Prisoners and detainees are adults.
  2. Campaigns target adults' workplaces and symbols, not children: the corporate campaigns were against employee-resource groups, Pride sponsorships, Human Rights Campaign ties and DEI policies (Wikipedia, CNN). The stated reason, "promote sex to children," is a claim that CNN's report did not support (CNN). It is a smear of LGBTQ+ adults and events, not a child-protection argument.
  3. Bans on care reaching beyond a single age group: CNN says he backed Tennessee's minors bans.
  4. Attribution of violence to trans people before facts: the Philadelphia post (2023-07-05) tied bathroom access to a shooter whom no official source had identified as trans (Fox News; Logically Facts). Treating trans people collectively as a danger in bathrooms is the "women's spaces" shield (WOMEN_SPACES, SHOOTER_ATTRIBUTION).
  5. Dehumanizing language alongside "protect the children": "confused child" (2025-05-28) and, per a Politwoops excerpt, a pledge to keep calling "groomers" what they are "even if it means that I end up banned off social media" (as quoted by Politwoops). Calling trans people or their allies "groomers" is a dehumanizing smear.
  6. Deceptive production of the film: participants say they were told a different topic (PinkNews; Rolling Stone). A film "protecting children" built by misleading adults who were interviewed is not a child-protection act.
  7. Post-Meta pattern: The Guardian reports false claims about trans people in the weeks after his appointment to advise Meta on "bias" (2).
  8. Most of his anti-trans posts carry no protective claim:, for example 2024-09-08, which mocks trans troops as 'confused men playing dress up', and 2025-09-12, which lists being transgender among traits of 'psychopaths' (Tracking Trans Hate assessment of the coded posts in section 2; method in the report).
  • Adult-care and adult-directed posts, his own posts: (a) a post of 2025-02-12 (159,045 views; not linked, because it singles out private individuals): "Worcester City Council voted to become a transgender sanctuary city after this parade of lunatics screamed at them. Democrats still don't understand why they lost. Total lunatics. Make mental institutions GREAT AGAIN!" The post is aimed at people who spoke at a council meeting about a measure for trans residents; a call for mental institutions aimed at them is hate speech. (b) 2025-12-20 (21,460 views): "As [another account] proposed, a new change the Trump admin should roll out: Any health insurer that covers puberty blockers, hormones or trans surgeries can't access any government funds or programs." The text names no age limit; an insurer-level penalty reaches coverage for adults, and the proposal is anti-trans. (c) 2020 posts defending the ban on trans military service, which concerns adults: 2020-01-29, 2020-02-22 and 2020-07-27; and 2020-06-14 defending the Trump administration's reversal of a rule on sex discrimination in health insurance ("It is NOT what it was made out to be"). (d) 2026-02-20 (241,528 views) lists "trans surgeries" among what taxes pay for. (e) For accuracy, posts that carve out adults: 2022-12-27 (55 views): "Adults have the right to do whatever they want in that regard but kids can't consent to life altering cosmetic surgeries"; 2026-02-16 (1,358 views): "You do you, you're an adult and if you don't push it on kids or enter girls spaces making them uncomfortable, I really don't care what you do." The same account in the same period posted (a) and (b), so the adult carve-out is not a consistent position and the child framing works as a shield.
  • The 2025-12-20 insurer post compared with a bill and with HHS actions: no bill or agency action read matches the post's proposal, in (b) above, that an insurer covering puberty blockers, hormones or surgery would lose access to all government funds and programs. The closest bill read is H.R. 2202, the "End Taxpayer Funding of Gender Experimentation Act of 2025", introduced 2025-03-18 by Rep. LaMalfa: its section 302 says no federal funds "shall be expended for health benefits coverage that includes coverage of gender transition procedures", and title II would disallow ACA premium credits and cost-sharing reductions for plans that include such coverage; its definition of "gender transition procedure" sets no age limit, so it reaches adults. Unlike the post, the bill states that it does not restrict a non-federal provider from offering such coverage paid entirely with non-federal funds (sections 304 and 305) (GPO text as introduced, 7). It is an anti-trans bill aimed at coverage of care for trans people of all ages. The bill-status record (8) gives 23 cosponsors, policy area Health, referral to the Committee on Energy and Commerce and in addition to the Committees on the Judiciary and Ways and Means, and latest action 2025-03-18 ("Referred to the Committee on Energy and Commerce, and in addition to the Committees on the Judiciary, and Ways and Means"); as of 2026-11-08 the bill had not moved past referral to committee. The Senate companion, S. 977 (introduced 2025-03-12), shows "Read twice and referred" and no later action in the same record.
  • Two days before the post, HHS announced on 2025-12-18 a proposed Medicare and Medicaid hospital condition of participation barring hospitals from providing this care to patients under 18, a proposed ban on federal Medicaid funding for it under 18 and CHIP funding under 19, FDA warning letters to sellers of breast binders, a proposed Section 504 revision excluding "gender dysphoria" not resulting from physical impairments from the definition of "disability", and a declaration by the Secretary (HHS press release, 9). These anti-trans actions concern hospitals, state Medicaid programs and minors, not insurers generally. The post does not cite any of them. The agency action read that concerns insurers is the Office of Personnel Management's FEHB Program Carrier Letter 2025-01b of 2025-08-15, an anti-trans action: for Plan Year 2026 it removes hormonal and surgical gender-affirming care from coverage under the federal employee and postal service health benefits programs, an exclusion that "applies regardless of age", keeps counseling covered, and requires carriers to set an exceptions process for enrollees mid-treatment (10). It governs what the federal employees' plans cover; it does not cut an insurer off from other government funds or programs, and it came four months before the post. The Medicaid and CHIP funding ban was finalized on 2026-08-13 (91 FR 52406, effective 2026-10-13; 11); it bars federal Medicaid funding for the care for under-18s and CHIP funding for under-19s, allows up to six months of continued federal funding of hormone medication for enrollees already receiving it, and contains no provision that cuts insurers off from other government funds or programs.

5. Platform enforcement history

  • Self-reported: he says Twitter shadowbanned him in 2022 within a week of announcing his candidacy (his campaign profile); that TikTok banned and later unbanned him (Daily Signal interview); and that Amazon Prime Video removed "The War on Children" in 2024, which he suspected was because of its content about "transitioning kids" (PinkNews 28 Aug 2024). All of this is his own account.

6. Ties

Role:

  • Heritage Foundation, visiting fellow leading the "capital markets initiative", announced 2025-04-02 (Daily Wire; the Heritage release of 2 Apr 2025 confirms it). Pay not disclosed in the article. A visiting fellowship is not a filed office, so no registry tie row is added. The Heritage Foundation's Form 990 returns (EIN 23-7327730; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12) run through tax year 2024 (filed 2025, object 202523199349302027); the fellowship was announced 2025-04-02, so no return on file can show it. Heritage's Part VII rows across TY2010-TY2024 (127 distinct names) include no Starbuck. The Heritage Foundation, a (c)(3), has no lobbying filings; its affiliate Heritage Action files LD-2 reports.
  • Meta Platforms, adviser on "ideological and political bias" in AI under the August 2025 settlement, with Joel Kaplan co-signing a joint statement (Yahoo/ABC17). Meta declined to say whether he is paid. A Yahoo News article says that under the settlement he will advise Meta on "bias" in its AI, that Meta declined to say whether he is paid, and gives no announcement date (a linked CNBC interview is dated 2025-08-08); a CNN article dated 2025-08-14 carries the joint statement.

Formal joint work:

  • Dhillon Law Group: its page "Starbuck v. Meta" (13) says Dhillon Law Group, on his behalf, filed a defamation suit against Meta Platforms in Delaware Superior Court on 2025-04-28. Counsel of record in the Google suit: the complaint's signature block, read at the Reason-hosted copy (14, accessed 2026-11-10), is dated 2025-10-22, lists three lawyers of Dhillon Law Group Inc. (San Francisco) as "Of Counsel", and a lawyer of Shaw Keller LLP (Wilmington) as attorney for the plaintiff; the Delaware Superior Court's opinion of 2026-07-24 (C.A. No. N25C-10-211 MAA, Judge Meghan A. Adams) lists Shaw Keller LLP, Baughman Law and Dhillon Law Group Inc. for the plaintiff and Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, P.C. for Google (leagle.com, 15, accessed 2026-11-10). So Dhillon Law Group's formal joint work with him on the Google suit is confirmed.

Funding and formal joint work:

  • Dhillon Law Group, Inc.: received $164,997 in legal fees from his 2022 campaign committee (FEC committee C00781484; see section 3). The committee paid it for legal work in 2022, before the Meta suit of 2025; the filings do not state what the work was. (FEC operating expenditures, committee C00781484, 16)

An appearance or listing:

  • Young America's Foundation lists him in its speaker section (1); the page names no event, date or fee and no formal role.

Narrative alignment only (not a tie):

  • Elon Musk promoted the film's trailer (PinkNews): promotion, not a documented relationship.
  • Heritage's own campaign against "woke" corporations is the same theme.
  • Unpaid director rows: A person filed as "ROBBY STARBUCK" appears on two Tennessee bodies' returns. Citizens for Limited Government and Constitutional Integrity Inc (EIN 85-2140761, Franklin TN, 501(c)(4), doing business as Tennessee Stands, website tennesseestands.org, formed 2020) lists him as Director, 1 hour a week, compensation $0, on its Form 990 for TY2020 (object 202110749349301506) and TY2021 (object 202232799349301803). The affiliated Tennessee Stands Foundation Inc (EIN 85-3460880, 501(c)(3)) lists "Robby Starbuck", Director, $0, on its TY2021 Form 990 (object 202242799349301624). He is not listed on the TY2022, TY2023 or TY2024 returns of either body (objects 202333199349305268, 202303199349305020, 202443199349313419, 202403199349312795, 202533169349304033, 202513169349304456). The president (Gary Humble, also "Founder and Chairman of the Board" on 17) and the other directors are named on the same returns. [IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 85-2140761 and EIN 85-3460880, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 18 and 19 Context only: he was a TN-5 candidate in 2021, and the Star News Network (2021-11-11) reports that he spoke at the kickoff of the Stand for Tennessee PAC, whose chairman is Gary Humble (the article does not name Tennessee Stands). Neither body's returns describe any work concerning trans people: the mission text is "educate citizens regarding a constitutional form of government", and the site lists parental rights, medical freedom and a rejection of "modern progressivism, Marxism, and the globalist agenda" without addressing gender. No tie row and no page for either body. Status: a candidate page by U.S. Campaigns on The Thinking Conservative, dated 2023-06-06, written in campaign wording and linking to his campaign website, says: "Robby is on the board for Tennessee Stands (a group fighting to ensure the rights of Tennesseans are not trampled on by the government)" (20). With this statement of the role, the director rows filed as "ROBBY STARBUCK" on the Form 990s of Citizens for Limited Government and Constitutional Integrity Inc (EIN 85-2140761, doing business as Tennessee Stands) for TY2020 and TY2021 are his board service and no longer only a name match. The statement names "Tennessee Stands", not Tennessee Stands Foundation Inc (EIN 85-3460880), so the Foundation's TY2021 director row is not attributed to him. The organization's own team page (17, accessed 2026-11-14) lists its board as its founder and chairman, Gary Humble, and four other directors, and does not name Robby Starbuck; the statement above that he is not listed on the TY2022, TY2023 or TY2024 returns is consistent with that list. Its about page names the Tennessee Stands Foundation, Inc. as a 501(c)(3); the page also carries the name Citizens for Limited Government and Constitutional Integrity, Inc. in its copyright line with no tax-status label, so that body's 501(c)(4) status is taken from the IRS record, not from the page.
  • Appearance or listing: Star News Network, 2021-11-11 (21): "First-time candidate Robby Starbuck is running as a Republican to represent Tennessee's 5th Congressional District"; he spoke at the Stand for Tennessee PAC fundraising kickoff (chairman: Gary Humble) and the week before, with his wife, at a Williamson Families PAC event. Not trans-related in the text.

7. Income and funding

  • Subscriptions: $5-a-month X subscriptions (he declined to give a number), plus merchandise: t-shirts, books and supplements (CNN, Aug 28, 2024). He says he takes no outside funding and is self-funded, with two employees who research targets (CNN; his own claim).
  • Podcast and film: monetization not disclosed.
  • Meta: Meta declined to discuss financial terms of the settlement or whether he is paid for the advisory role; he sought over $5 million in the suit (Yahoo/ABC17).
  • Heritage: pay not disclosed (Daily Wire).
  • Campaign finance: his 2022 write-in committee ("Robby Starbuck For Congress LLC") appears in FEC data (3).
  • Meta content monetization: enrolled, per Uncloseted Media (as reported by the Washington Blade, 2026-10-14, 4, and by LGBTQ Nation below); no amount is given. The data come from the Meta Monetization Archive compiled by What To Fix, with a most recent update on 15 September (as the article describes it).
  • Meta monetization, further reading: LGBTQ Nation's copy of the Uncloseted Media / The 19th report (22) names him: "Brown and Starbuck are both enrolled in the content monetization program", with no payment amount for any of the 29 accounts; the Washington Blade copy cited above names him too. The What To Fix Meta Monetization Archive's "About the data" page (23) lists filters and fields (publisher name, handle, subscribers, ID, date_added, end_date, language, country) and says the data come from Meta's partner-publisher disclosures; it lists no payment amounts, so no amount for his account can come from it. The report's general figures (a creator quoted by The Hollywood Reporter as earning $20,000 to $30,000 a month; a bonus advertised as up to $5,000) are not his.
  • Heritage: The Heritage Foundation's Form 990 returns (EIN 23-7327730; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12) run through TY2024 (latest object 202523199349302027, period ending 2024-12-31), so a TY2025 return that could show a fellowship is not among them. No public source reviewed here states his pay.
  • 2022 campaign finance (FEC committee C00781484, 3): operating expenditures of $467,435.39 and individual contributions of $253,329 in its rows (memo entries excluded; not a certified total); its rows include 11 rows totalling $102,810 filed in his name, 2021-06-04 to 2023-06-29: 10 rows ($102,310) coded as loans received from him and one row ($500, 2022-08-15) coded 20C, which the FEC code list defines as a loan repayment made to him (see section 7, next item).
  • Committee rows after 2022: Rows of his House committee (FEC C00781484) dated 2023-01-01 or later: 2023-01-31 bank fees $232.83; 2023-06-29 a $5,310 row coded 16C (loan from the candidate; image 202307059582435097); and on 2023-06-29 four contribution refunds (code 22Y) to individual contributors totalling $5,210 ($2,900, $1,000, $1,000, $310). So the last loan was recorded the same day as refunds of $5,210 to contributors, which reads as the committee closing out (inference from date and amounts; no memo text reviewed here). No row after 2023-06-29. The contributors are private individuals and are not named. [FEC rows, 24
  • Committee debts: FEC committee page (3, accessed 2026-11-12): status "Administratively terminated House"; 2025-2026 cycle receipts $0 and disbursements $0; "Debts/loans owed by the committee: $115,787.79"; "owed to the committee: $0". $115,787.79 is more than the net loans from him ($101,810 in the filed transaction rows, which are in whole dollars: $102,310 in 16C rows less one $500 repayment row coded 20C; Schedule C of the latest report gives $101,810.82, below), so it may include vendor debts; whether his loans were repaid or forgiven is not shown in the sources reviewed here.
  • Who is owed the $115,787.79: his own loans and five vendors (six debts, HSP Direct twice). The latest report of Robby Starbuck For Congress LLC (FEC committee C00781484), the October Quarterly for 2026-07-01 to 2026-09-30, received 2026-10-15, shows debts owed by the committee of $115,787.79, $0 owed to it, $0 cash on hand and no receipts or disbursements in the period; the same debt figure stands on each of the five latest reports, from the July Quarterly 2025 on (FEC data for committee C00781484, 3).
  • Schedule C of that report lists ten loans from the candidate, "STARBUCK, ROBBY", incurred 2021-06-04 to 2023-06-29, original amounts $5,000, $3,000, $5,000, $5,000, $5,000, $31,000, $10,000, $21,000, $12,000 and $5,310.82 ($102,310.82 in all); one loan (2022-07-11, $5,000) shows $500 repaid, every other loan $0 repaid, for an outstanding balance of $101,810.82. Due dates as filed run from 12/31/31 to 06/01/2039 (Schedule C of the same report).
  • Schedule D of that report lists six vendor debts, $13,976.97 in all, each outstanding at the same amount since the report for the third quarter of 2022: HSP Direct, postage $6,516.65 and creative fee $3,000.00; Fulfillment Solutions, printing $2,620.83; Nova List, list management $1,040.32; Sunrise Data Services, list management $434.68; DonorBureau LLC, prospecting $364.49. These debts were first incurred in the first quarter of 2022, some at larger amounts that were partly paid in 2022 (Schedule D of the same report). $101,810.82 in loans plus $13,976.97 in vendor debts equals the $115,787.79 shown. On the filings reviewed here, his loans to the committee have not been repaid apart from $500, and they have not been reported as forgiven.
  • Dhillon Law Group payments as filed on the 2022 committee's Schedule B: $10,000 (2022-03-02, purpose "LEGAL SERVICES"), $125,000 (2022-05-18, "LEGAL FEES") and $29,997 (2022-12-25, "LEGAL FEES"), a total of $164,997 (FEC operating expenditures, committee C00781484, 3). The 11 rows filed in his name (2021-06-04 to 2023-06-29, $102,810) carry FEC transaction-type codes 16C (10 rows, $102,310) and 20C (one row, $500) in the filed data; the filed data lists the 20C row as coming from him, but the FEC's code list describes 16C as "Loan received from the candidate" and 20C as "Loan repayment made to candidate" (25, accessed 2026-11-10), so ten rows are loans from him to the committee ($102,310) and one row is a repayment to him ($500), which would make the net loan $101,810 if both are as coded; none is a contribution (same source). The committee's FEC record in the 2026 cycle lists it as a House principal campaign committee, candidate H2TN05339, party REP (FEC committee page, 3). The year-end report for 2022 (coverage 2022-10-01 to 2022-12-31) files the $29,997.00 payment of 2022-12-25 with the election designation 'P2022', the 2022 primary, and carries no memo or text record that says what the payment was for (FEC filing 1683416, 26).
  • Dhillon Law Group in the 2022 federal ballot suit: the opinion of the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee in Newsom (also known as Robby Starbuck) v. Golden, No. 3:22-cv-00318, filed 2022-05-12 (Chief Judge Waverly D. Crenshaw, Jr.), lists Dhillon Law Group, Inc. (Alexandria, VA) among the counsel for the plaintiff; the plaintiff is Robert Starbuck Newsom, "aka Robby Starbuck", a candidate for Tennessee's Fifth Congressional District, and the defendants are the Tennessee Republican Party, its chairman and two state election officials (27). The Tennessee Star (Aaron Gulbransen, 2022-05-24, 28) reports that a Dhillon Law Group attorney confirmed the firm was no longer representing him, and that he filed a new suit on 2022-05-20 in Davidson County Chancery Court with a different firm. The committee's three payments to the firm (dates and amounts above) carry only the purposes "LEGAL SERVICES" and "LEGAL FEES" and do not say which matter each payment covered, so no payment is tied here to a particular case; what is documented is that the firm acted as his counsel in a federal suit over his removal from the 2022 primary ballot in May 2022.
  • Docket dates of the 2022 federal ballot suit: the CourtListener docket of Newsom v. Golden, No. 3:22-cv-00318 (M.D. Tenn.) (archive copy of 2022-06-10, 29) gives the date filed as 2022-05-02 (complaint, Document 1, with a motion for a temporary restraining order and a motion for a preliminary injunction on 2022-05-03), the court's memorandum opinion as Document 37 of 2022-05-12, and an "Order Dismissing Case" as Document 41 of 2022-05-18, the date the docket gives as the date terminated.

8. Legal matters (he is the plaintiff in each)

  • Starbuck v. Meta (Delaware Superior Court, filed April 2025; over $5 million sought): settled in August 2025 with Meta hiring him as an advisor on "ideological and political bias" in its AI; financial terms not disclosed (Wikipedia). Filing date: Dhillon Law Group's page (13) says 2025-04-28; The Hill gives April 29, 2025. The two dates differ by a day and are both given as reported.
  • Starbuck v. Google LLC: Superior Court of the State of Delaware, No. N25C-10-211 MAA (CourtListener docket 73666763, 30; reading "MAA" as Judge Meghan A. Adams's initials is our inference). Filed 2025-10-22 per Reuters (via Al Jazeera) and Bloomberg Law. The complaint, hosted by Reason (14), is captioned "Robert Starbuck v. Google LLC" with a jury trial demanded. Relief sought: at least $15 million and an injunction (Fox News, Bloomberg Law). He alleges that Google's AI products produced a false biography of him (including false claims of sexual assault, convictions and a shooting) and invented sources; the complaint quotes the chatbot's own statement that it reached 2,843,917 unique users, a figure the complaint attributes to the chatbot, not an independently measured count. Bloomberg Law reports that the complaint cites "at least 22 statements that are defamation per se". These are his allegations. Google moved to dismiss in November 2025 (Reuters; the 2025-11-17 date is as secondary sources give it), challenging publication, actual malice and damages (letsdatascience.com). On 2026-07-24 Judge Meghan Adams denied the motion to dismiss "in its entirety" (letsdatascience.com, 2026-07-25; magica.com; Fox News). It is a pleading-stage ruling under Delaware's notice-pleading standard, not a finding that the outputs were false or that Google is liable; the case moves to discovery. The case was open as of the 2026-07-24 opinion, read in full in the next entry. The suit concerns AI statements about his own conduct, not trans people.
  • Starbuck v. Google, what the 2026-07-24 opinion holds: Superior Court of Delaware, C.A. No. N25C-10-211 MAA, opinion of Judge Meghan A. Adams, submitted April 6, 2026, decided July 24, 2026, "Google LLC's Motion to Dismiss: DENIED" (Delaware courts opinion PDF, 31). The opinion says: "This Opinion DENIES Google's motion in its entirety" and that the Court "intends to convey no agreement with the truth of the matters asserted in the Complaint" (page 1). Holdings, in the opinion's headings and findings: the complaint "sufficiently alleges facts supporting the element of publication"; on actual malice, "The parties agree (for purposes of this motion) that Starbuck is a public figure" and "The Court finds the allegations in the Complaint are sufficient to survive a motion to dismiss"; on damages, his allegations of emotional distress are "sufficiently well-pled to proceed to discovery and flesh out the allegations", the complaint "survives under both jurisdictions' laws" (Delaware and Tennessee), "so a choice of law analysis between the two is unnecessary". It is a decision at the pleading stage on the complaint's allegations, not a finding that the outputs were false or that Google is liable. The suit concerns AI statements about his own conduct, not trans people.
  • Also: a June 2023 legal warning from a photo agency over a copyrighted photo (Wikipedia); no suit reported.

Open questions

  1. The Guardian's trans-related examples (Oct 2025): the opening paragraphs reproduced on joemygod.com say he "has also spread overheated claims and falsehoods about transgender and LGBTQ people" and give no example; reports also say that Meta did not respond and that he called the piece an attempted hit job and said his statements were not made on behalf of Meta.
  2. The judge's name is Meghan A. Adams (spelled so in the opinion listing at leagle.com, accessed 2026-11-10). Dhillon Law Group's role in the Google suit is confirmed (see the entry on Dhillon Law Group above); the opinion text of 2026-07-24 is given in section 8.
  3. Whether the Heritage fellowship is paid; Meta advisory pay is not disclosed. Whether the Meta Monetization Archive lists amounts for his account. Heritage's returns on file run through TY2024 (latest object 202523199349302027), so a TY2025 return that could show a fellowship is not among them; no public source reviewed here states his pay, and the monetization archive's "About the data" page lists no payment amounts.
  4. Tennessee Stands: Form 990s of Citizens for Limited Government and Constitutional Integrity Inc (doing business as Tennessee Stands) list "Robby Starbuck" as Director for 2020-2021; a candidate page of 2023-06-06 says he is on the board for Tennessee Stands, while the organization's own team page does not name him (see section 6).
  5. His position on adult care: posts of 2025-02-12 (aimed at people who spoke at a council meeting), 2025-12-20 (an insurer-level penalty with no age limit), 2020 (the ban on trans military service and a reversal of a health-insurance rule) and 2026-02-20 are adult-directed (section 4), and two posts carve out adults (2022-12-27 and 2026-02-16); the carve-out is not a consistent position, since the same account posted both kinds in the same period.
  6. What the 11 rows totalling $102,810 filed in his name on his 2022 committee were: the FEC transaction-type code list (accessed 2026-11-10, 25) describes 16C as "Loan received from the candidate" and 20C as "Loan repayment made to candidate", so ten rows ($102,310, 2021-06-04 to 2023-06-29) are recorded as loans from him to the committee and one row ($500, 2022-08-15) as a repayment, which would make the net loan $101,810; whether the loans were repaid or forgiven later is not shown in the rows reviewed here. What Dhillon Law Group's 2022 legal work for his committee covered: the firm is listed as his counsel in No. 3:22-cv-00318 (Middle District of Tennessee, filed 2022-05-02; opinion of 2022-05-12) and was no longer representing him when the Tennessee Star reported on 2022-05-24, his suit of 2022-05-20 having been filed with another firm; the committee's filings give only the purposes "LEGAL SERVICES" and "LEGAL FEES" for its payments of 2022-03-02, 2022-05-18 and 2022-12-25.
  7. Who is owed the $115,787.79: answered in section 7 (his own loans, $101,810.82 outstanding, and five vendors (six debts), $13,976.97, on the report for 2026-07-01 to 2026-09-30).

Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.

Sources

  1. https://yaf.org/people/robby-starbuck
  2. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/oct/12/meta-ai-adviser-robby-starbuck
  3. https://www.fec.gov/data/committee/C00781484/
  4. https://www.washingtonblade.com/2026/10/14/ahead-of-the-midterms-meta-has-paid-at-least-29-anti-lgbtq-accounts-for-their-posts/
  5. https://www.joemygod.com/2025/10/metas-new-anti-bias-advisor-is-spreading-maga-lies/
  6. https://www.thepinknews.com/2025/10/13/meta-ai-advisor-robby-starbuck-accused-of-peddling-lies-and-pushing-extremism
  7. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr2202ih/html/BILLS-119hr2202ih.htm
  8. https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/2202
  9. https://www.hhs.gov/press-room/hhs-acts-bar-hospitals-performing-sex-rejecting-procedures-children.html
  10. https://www.opm.gov/healthcare-insurance/carriers/fehb/2025/2025-01b.pdf
  11. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/08/13/2026-16508/medicaid-program-prohibition-on-federal-medicaid-and-childrens-health-insurance-program-funding-for
  12. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/237327730
  13. https://dhillonlaw.com/lawsuits/starbuck-v-meta
  14. https://reason.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/StarbuckvGoogle.pdf
  15. https://www.leagle.com/decision/indeco20260724049
  16. https://www.fec.gov/data/committee/C00781484/.
  17. https://tennesseestands.org/our-team/
  18. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/852140761
  19. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/853460880]
  20. https://www.thethinkingconservative.com/robby-starbuck-u-s-congress-for-tennessee/
  21. https://thestarnewsnetwork.com/2021/11/11/stand-for-tennessee-pac-fundraising-kick-off-features-conservative-political-office-holders-and-candidates/
  22. https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2026/10/ahead-of-the-midterms-meta-paid-at-least-29-anti-lgbtq-accounts-for-their-posts/
  23. https://monetization.wtf/about/meta-monetization-archive/
  24. https://www.fec.gov/data/committee/C00781484/]
  25. https://www.fec.gov/campaign-finance-data/transaction-type-code-descriptions/
  26. https://docquery.fec.gov/dcdev/posted/1683416.fec
  27. https://www.leagle.com/decision/infdco20220516c33
  28. https://thestarnewsnetwork.com/2022/05/24/disqualified-tn-5-candidate-files-in-state-court-against-tennessee-republican-party
  29. https://web.archive.org/web/20220610151546/https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/63282673/newsom-v-golden/
  30. https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/73666763/
  31. https://courts.delaware.gov/opinions/download.aspx?id=398660