Joshua Dunlap
1documented tie1 name on file
1organization with a role on file
Who he is
Judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. The Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts' monthly confirmation list records his Senate confirmation on 2025-11-04 (U.S. Courts, "Judicial Confirmations for November 2025", update as of 11/30/2025, 1; its table lists "Dunlap,Joshua D." with nomination date 07/15/2025, confirmation date 11/04/2025 and court "01 - CCA"); Wikipedia's list of federal judges appointed by Donald Trump gives his nomination as 2025-07-15, the vote as 52 to 46 and his service as starting 2025-11-07 (2). He is a public figure as a sitting federal appellate judge.
Link to Alliance Defending Freedom
- Blackstone Fellowship, 2006: in his written answers to the Senate Judiciary Committee (questions dated 2025-08-06), in reply to Senator Whitehouse's question whether he worked for the Alliance Defense Fund (now Alliance Defending Freedom) in 2006, he wrote: "I participated in the Blackstone Fellowship, a program offered by the organization then known as the Alliance Defend Fund [sic], in 2006." To a further question on services to ADF he answered that he "may have been asked to provide services to ADF" and does not recollect providing any (Senate Judiciary Committee, questions-for-the-record responses, 3, primary). A senator's question states that he interned at ADF during law school; his answers do not address it, so it is not entered as a tie.
Ruling in a case about trans people since confirmation
- 2026-05-19: sitting with Judges Gelpí and Montecalvo, he joined an order of the First Circuit in No. 26-1568 (In re: Motion to Quash Administrative Subpoena to Rhode Island Hospital; the Child Advocate for Rhode Island, appellee, against the United States, appellant). The order concerns a Department of Justice subpoena issued in July 2025 to Rhode Island Hospital for records, with identifying and health information, of children who had received gender-affirming care there. The district court in Rhode Island had quashed the subpoena on 2026-05-13, finding it lacked a congressionally authorized purpose, was issued for an improper purpose and violated the Fourteenth Amendment privacy rights of the child patients; the Northern District of Texas had separately ordered the hospital to comply and, on 2026-05-18, to hand the records to that court for safekeeping pending appeals. The panel denied the Child Advocate's motion for an injunction pending appeal because she had not shown irreparable harm, noting the Texas court's assurance that the records would be held in camera and given to DOJ only if the courts of appeals ruled against the hospital (First Circuit, order of 2026-05-19, 4, primary).
- In a separate concurrence he wrote that there were serious questions about the Child Advocate's standing and that her request was effectively a collateral attack on the Texas court's order. He called one of her arguments "little more than sophistry", and wrote that the district court had not analysed two of the government's theories of liability and that, assuming those theories were valid, its improper-purpose reasoning "would fall away", so that there were "serious questions about the merits of the district court's decision" (same order, concurrence and footnote 5, primary). Reports of the order: Rhode Island Current via News From The States (2026-05-20, 5) and Just the News (2026-05-21, 6).
- The order is an interim ruling on one motion; the appeals in the First and Fifth Circuits were pending when the order was entered; the later steps in both appeals are set out below.
- Later steps in the Rhode Island Hospital subpoena matter: the Clearinghouse docket summary (7) shows the Department of Justice's notice of appeal on 2026-05-14 (the First Circuit assigned No. 26-1568 that day), the Child Advocate's motion for an injunction pending appeal on 2026-05-19, and the denial as docket entry 53, which that page lists on 2026-05-20. The order was entered on 2026-05-19: its face reads "Entered: May 19, 2026" (4), and the page's document table dates it May 19 and lists it as 177 F.4th 21, while the page's summary text cites 2026 WL 1407553. The summary dates the Child Advocate's motion, not the order, to May 19. The panel named in the entry is Judges Gelpí, Montecalvo and Dunlap, and it notes that Judge Dunlap concurred separately. The same page shows a motion by the Department of Justice on 2026-05-22 to expedite briefing and argument (from the case summary, not a docket entry) and no merits decision; its last docket entry is dated 2026-08-18.
- Argument: Bloomberg Law (the page's credit; address news.bgov.com), in an article of 2026-10-07 headed "DOJ's Transgender Care Subpoena Appeal Confronts Doubtful Judges", reports that the First Circuit heard on that Wednesday the government's appeals from the rulings that quashed subpoenas to Rhode Island Hospital and to Boston Children's Hospital (8; the text available names no judges and reports no decision). According to First Things First, a site that tracks the First Circuit, the panel that heard No. 26-1568 on 2026-10-07 was Judges Gelpí, Thompson and Montecalvo (9; the site says its calendar data are "as of November 3, 2026"; its decision column for the case reads "pending"); the court's own pages do not name the panel: its list of oral-argument recordings for October 2026 (10) lists No. 26-1568 and No. 25-2092 as argued 2026-10-07 and names no judges, its calendar pages show no panel for that sitting, and its opinions list (11; the most recent entry on the list when read was dated 2026-11-13) holds no opinion in either number. On First Things First's account, which is secondary to the court's own calendar, Judge Dunlap sat on the May motions panel (the Clearinghouse docket page, 7, shows the May 2026 order on the motion for an injunction pending appeal entered by Judges Gelpí, Montecalvo and Dunlap, with Judge Dunlap concurring, and no decision after the 2026-10-07 argument) and not on the October argument panel; no merits decision is on either page.
- As of 2026-11-16, the First Circuit's opinions list (11; the most recent entry on the list when read was dated 2026-11-13) holds no opinion in No. 26-1568 or No. 25-2092. The court's page for the October 2026 argument recordings gives each argument as an audio file (No. 26-1568: 12; No. 25-2092: 13) and names no judges.
- The Fifth Circuit appeal: the Clearinghouse page for the Texas proceeding (14) records the Fifth Circuit appeal number 26-10431 on a district docket entry of 2026-05-20, with records on appeal filed on 2026-05-28, 2026-06-01 and 2026-08-14, and its case summary says the Fifth Circuit denied the hospital's stay motion on 2026-05-12 (the same summary dates the hospital's appeal to 2026-05-06 and its Fifth Circuit stay motion to 2026-05-09, and the district docket lists the notice of appeal as entry 6 of 2026-05-06, so the date does not precede the appeal; the 2026-05-20 entry only records the appeal number), while the same page also says that as of June 11 stay briefing in the appellate court remained ongoing (its docket lists no order of 2026-05-12); it shows no argument date and no decision. A second notice of appeal to the Fifth Circuit is listed for 2026-07-14 without a docket number.
- The Fifth Circuit appeal, argued on 2026-11-04: Bloomberg Law (Celine Castronuovo, 2026-11-04, "Hospital Faces Skeptical Fifth Circuit in Trans Records Dispute") reports that judges on a Fifth Circuit panel "expressed doubt Wednesday that Rhode Island Hospital was denied due process" when a district court ordered enforcement of the subpoena, and that Judges Kyle Duncan and Kurt Engelhardt questioned the hospital's move to quash the subpoena in Rhode Island federal court rather than in the Northern District of Texas, where the enforcement order was issued (15). As of 2026-11-13 no decision of the Fifth Circuit is reported. Courthouse News Service (Christina van Waasbergen, 2026-11-04, 16) reports the same argument before a panel of Fifth Circuit Judges Kyle Duncan, Kurt Engelhardt and Irma Ramirez and reports no decision. The Clearinghouse page for the Texas proceeding (14; as of 2026-11-14) lists no Fifth Circuit decision; its latest entries are in the Northern District of Texas: an order of 2026-10-09 that the hospital file a status report (ECF 37) and the hospital's status report of 2026-10-19 on what the page calls the rolling production (ECF 38); it gives no argument date or panel.
- First Circuit No. 25-1442, opinion of 2026-08-26: The First Circuit's opinion of 2026-08-26 in No. 25-1442, an appeal by spectators whom school officials told to remove wristbands they wore at a girls' soccer game in protest against a trans girl's participation, was issued by a panel of Judges Rikelman, Lynch and Howard; Judge Lynch wrote the opinion and Judge Rikelman concurred in the judgment (First Circuit, opinion in No. 25-1442, 17). Judge Dunlap was not on that panel. The wristband protest aimed at a trans girl is anti-trans rhetoric; the spectators and the athlete are private people and are not named here.
- First Circuit No. 25-1638, opinion of 2026-09-01 (18): the panel was Chief Judge Barron and Judges Lynch and Montecalvo; the opinion, by Judge Montecalvo, concerns Puerto Rico's birth-certificate policy that lets binary trans people but not nonbinary people change the gender marker, vacates the district court's order and remands (equal protection, rational basis). Judge Dunlap was not on it.
- Other First Circuit cases that discuss transgender people or gender identity, 2025-11-07 to 2026-09-03: First Circuit No. 25-1356, opinion of 2025-12-22 (a city's refusal to let private citizens fly flags on a city flagpole; the opinion recounts that the city removed a Save Women's Sports flag in 2020, that the mayor then said in a public statement of 2020-10-14 that the flag "contain[ed] a discriminatory message toward the transgender community", and that in 2024 the city denied a request to fly a "Detransitioner Awareness" flag; the plaintiffs are private people, so the case is cited by docket number), panel Judges Gelpí, Lynch and Howard. The flag names quoted here, "Save Women's Sports" and "Detransitioner Awareness", are the wording of the opinion's account, not the profile's; anti-trans rhetoric is never made in good faith, whatever the framing. Crosspoint Church v. Makin, No. 24-1590, opinion of 2026-07-02 (a church school's challenge to provisions of Maine's Human Rights Act, among them its sexual orientation and gender identity nondiscrimination rule; 19), panel Judges Montecalvo and Kayatta (a third judge, Judge Selya, heard argument and died before the opinion; the opinion says the two remaining judges issued it under 28 U.S.C. section 46(d)). First Circuit No. 24-1739, opinion of 2026-07-02 (the companion appeal against the same Maine provisions; minor children are among the parties, so the case is cited by court and docket number), same panel. Judge Dunlap was not on any of these panels. With the three cases already on the page (Nos. 25-1579, 25-1442 and 25-1638) and the interim order in No. 26-1568, the only case about trans people in which he is documented is the order of 2026-05-19.
- Outcome of the Maine school cases of 2026-07-02: in Crosspoint Church v. Makin, No. 24-1590, Judge Kayatta's opinion for the two remaining judges of the panel (Judges Montecalvo and Kayatta) affirms in part and reverses in part the district court's order denying the church's motion for a permanent injunction. It affirms the order insofar as it found no case or controversy on the Employment Rule and rejected the church's arguments against the Religious Nondiscrimination Rule and the Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Nondiscrimination Rule. It reverses the order as to the Religious Expression Rule and remands for "the timely entry of a permanent injunction against the Religious Expression Rule as applied to Crosspoint". On the Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Nondiscrimination Rule the opinion holds that the rule regulates conduct and not speech, so it is not subject to strict scrutiny, and that it survives rational basis review for the reasons given in the companion opinion; it describes the church as seeking "to refuse admission to (and expel) any student who is gay or transgender". In the companion appeal, First Circuit No. 24-1739 (cited by court and docket number because minor children are among the parties), the same panel affirms in part and reverses in part the denial of a preliminary injunction on the same lines: it affirms as to the Employment Rule (no case or controversy) and the Religious Nondiscrimination Rule and the Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Nondiscrimination Rule, and reverses as to the Religious Expression Rule, remanding for a preliminary injunction against that rule as applied to the plaintiff. The Crosspoint opinion says it "follows on the heels of" the companion opinion. (First Circuit opinion in No. 24-1590, 20, conclusion at Part IV and Part III; First Circuit opinion in No. 24-1739, conclusion at Part IV.)
Ties
- Role: Blackstone Fellowship participant, 2006, Alliance Defending Freedom (his own written answer).
- Narrative alignment only (not a tie): none recorded.
What the sources don't show
- Whether he has sat on First Circuit cases about trans people other than No. 26-1568: the opinions and judgment reviewed above (Nos. 25-1356, 25-1442, 25-1579, 25-1638, 24-1590 and 24-1739) were issued by panels that did not include him; that review covers the cases named there, not every order of the court.
- The outcome of the merits appeals in the First and Fifth Circuits.
- Other First Circuit work: the First Circuit's judgment of 2026-06-05 in the passport-policy appeal (No. 25-1579; plaintiffs, appellees, against the President, the Department of State and the United States), which dismissed the appeal as moot, was issued by Judges Montecalvo, Rikelman and Aframe, so Judge Dunlap was not on that panel (judgment as hosted by the ACLU, 21).
Open questions
- How did the First Circuit rule on the merits of No. 26-1568, and who sat on the panel that heard it on 2026-10-07? The court's opinions list (its most recent entry when read was dated 2026-11-13) holds no opinion in it; the court's page gives the argument as an audio recording and names no judges; the panel Judges Gelpí, Thompson and Montecalvo comes from First Things First, a site that tracks the First Circuit.
- Did he sit on later First Circuit orders in other cases about trans people? None is documented here: he was not on the panel of any of the six other opinions and judgments reviewed on this page, among them the 2026-06-05 passport judgment, No. 25-1579.
- Outcomes of the merits appeals: First Circuit No. 26-1568 and the Fifth Circuit appeal No. 26-10431 (the order's footnote 1 gives that number; the Clearinghouse page lists records on appeal through 2026-08-14 and a reported stay denial of 2026-05-12 alongside a statement that stay briefing was ongoing as of June 11, with no argument date or decision).
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- https://www.uscourts.gov/judges-judgeships/judicial-vacancies/archive-judicial-vacancies/2025/11/confirmations
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_federal_judges_appointed_by_Donald_Trump
- https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/download/20250730_qfr-responses_dunlappdf?download=1
- https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/sites/ca1/files/opnfiles/26-1568O-01A.pdf
- https://www.newsfromthestates.com/article/boston-appeals-court-rejects-ri-child-advocates-emergency-relief-petition
- https://justthenews.com/government/first-circuit-rejects-emergency-bid-shield-pediatric-gender-care-records-doj
- https://clearinghouse.net/case/48138/
- https://news.bgov.com/us-law-week/dojs-transgender-care-subpoena-appeal-confronts-doubtful-judges
- https://firstthingsfirstblog.com/sittings/?sitting=2026-10-07-boston
- https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/doar/results/2026-10
- https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/opinions
- https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/sites/ca1/files/oralargs/26-1568_20261007.mp3
- https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/sites/ca1/files/oralargs/25-2092_20261007.mp3
- https://clearinghouse.net/case/48133/
- https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/hospital-faces-skeptical-fifth-circuit-in-trans-records-dispute
- https://courthousenews.com/rhode-island-hospital-asks-fifth-circuit-to-axe-doj-subpoena-for-trans-patient-records/
- https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/sites/ca1/files/opnfiles/25-1442P-01A.pdf
- https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/sites/ca1/files/opnfiles/25-1638P-01A.pdf
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10886352/crosspoint-church-v-makin/
- https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/sites/ca1/files/opnfiles/24-1590P-01A.pdf
- https://assets.aclu.org/live/uploads/2025/02/2026-06-05-Order-dismissing-appeal-as-moot.pdf