All profiles

Organization

The Challenge Foundation

EIN 58-1817816
At least $30Kreceived on fileIRS Form 990 filings · 1 funder
At least $13.1Mgiven on fileIRS Form 990 filings · 5 recipients
8documented ties8 names on file

A private foundation (Form 990-PF filer) filed as "THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION". Other filers carry the same or a similar name under other EINs (the master file lists Challenge Foundation bodies at Derby KS, Englewood CO and elsewhere); this page covers EIN 58-1817816, whose returns carry the grants to the profiled organizations below. The IRS exempt-organization master file lists it as Challenge Foundation, Tigard OR (exempt since 1989-12; NTEE T22 (Philanthropy, grantmaking foundations)), with assets of $396,205 and income of $2,500,025 in the master file's amount fields (latest period 2025-12; the Form 990-PF for the same period gives total revenue of $1,949,663, so the two figures differ) (IRS exempt-organization master file, EIN 58-1817816). Its returns for TY2014, TY2015 and TY2017 were filed in care of an accounting firm in Atlanta GA and the others from Tigard OR, as recorded. As filed, it gave the Heritage Foundation, Young America's Foundation, the Manhattan Institute and the State Policy Network every year or nearly every year; its two largest named recipients by amount are TEAMCFA and TEAMCFA FOUNDATION, and its TY2014 return lists a single row of $8,346,150 to "SEE ATTACHED SCHEDULE" (Plano TX), which names no recipient. No filing states that any grant paid for work on trans issues, and the sources cited here document no anti-trans work by the foundation. The other filers named Challenge Foundation (Englewood CO, EIN 84-1480014; Chicago IL, EIN 36-4277119) have no grant row to a profiled organization (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 84-1480014 and EIN 36-4277119; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 1 and 2).

Source: IRS Form 990-series e-files, EIN 58-1817816 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3). Each grant is counted once, and a return that repeats another return of the same period was counted once. Returns in the records: 12 returns: 12 Form 990PF, periods ending 2014-12, 2015-12, 2016-12, 2017-12, 2018-12, 2019-12, 2020-12, 2021-12, 2022-12, 2023-12, 2024-12, 2025-12. Form 990-PF grant rows carry no recipient EIN: a match is by the recipient's full name and place; a misspelling or truncation is quoted as filed. Quotation marks give the filer's own wording.

Money received

  • Revenue, expenses and assets as filed (IRS Form 990-series e-file, EIN 58-1817816): period ending 2014-12-31: revenue $11,332,468, expenses $9,514,383, assets $17,111,109, Form 990PF, object id 201523209349102812; period ending 2015-12-31: revenue $3,743,152, expenses $5,984,216, assets $5,029,356, Form 990PF, object id 201613209349102691; period ending 2016-12-31: revenue $4,677,291, expenses $6,977,516, assets $10,904,008, Form 990PF, object id 201800319349100025; period ending 2017-12-31: revenue $1,028,779, expenses $1,586,921, assets $10,777,890, Form 990PF, object id 201823199349103222; period ending 2018-12-31: revenue $809,597, expenses $2,909,491, assets $8,773,412, Form 990PF, object id 201923199349105232; period ending 2019-12-31: revenue $260,882, expenses $1,576,021, assets $6,868,105, Form 990PF, object id 202043219349105804; period ending 2020-12-31: revenue -$798,991, expenses $2,342,741, assets $3,261,461, Form 990PF, object id 202143199349107664; period ending 2021-12-31: revenue $1,336,371, expenses $2,027,039, assets $2,411,110, Form 990PF, object id 202243079349100504; period ending 2022-12-31: revenue $2,610,985, expenses $1,953,702, assets $1,187,768, Form 990PF, object id 202343179349101964; period ending 2023-12-31: revenue $1,597,224, expenses $1,917,613, assets $844,107, Form 990PF, object id 202442899349100314; period ending 2024-12-31: revenue $1,396,994, expenses $1,922,809, assets $326,494, Form 990PF, object id 202511339349102156; period ending 2025-12-31: revenue $1,949,663, expenses $1,890,446, assets $396,205, Form 990PF, object id 202611339349103856.
  • The returns for 2014 to 2025 name the contributors on Schedule B (given by role here, except John Bryan, who is named under People on file; see below).
  • Schedule B of the foundation's Forms 990-PF lists the contributors as follows: 2015 one named individual, $724,388 (object id 201613209349102691); 2016 one named contributor, $2,945,753 (201800319349100025); 2017 one, $600,456 (201823199349103222); 2018 two individuals filing jointly, $582,808 (201923199349105232); 2019 the same two, $589,677 (202043219349105804); 2020 $26,222 (202143199349107664); 2021 $1,002,193 (202243079349100504). In each of these years the single Schedule B entry (for 2018 and 2019, one entry filed jointly by two individuals) equals the whole contributions figure ProPublica lists for the year. The returns for 2022 ($2,263,581, object id 202343179349101964) and 2023 ($1,526,940, object id 202442899349100314) each name one contributor on Schedule B (the same name in both years, and the same surname as the contributors of 2015 to 2021), and the amounts again equal the year's contributions. The returns for 2014 (object id 201523209349102812), 2024 (202511339349102156) and 2025 (202611339349103856) name more than one individual contributor on Schedule B: 2014 two, $4,589,687 and $5,200,285 (the second a noncash gift described as an investment in partnerships); 2024 two, $220,818 and $33,847 (the second noncash); 2025 three, $518,862, $31,500 and $130,807 (all noncash). In each of those years the rows together equal the contributions the return reports. The contributors are given by role here, except John Bryan (see People on file). (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, EIN 58-1817816, Schedule B; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3)
  • Related organization on the returns of EIN 81-1808142: Challenge Foundation Group Inc (Challenge Foundation Properties Inc until the 2021 return), Forest City NC, EIN 81-1808142. The Form 990 for the period ending 2022-06-30 (object id 202341179349301519; 4) and the Form 990 for the period ending 2023-06-30 (object id 202401369349315315; 5, IRS public e-file release) answer "false" to the related-organization question, attach no Schedule R (schedules present: A, D, J and O, and I on the first), and contain neither the name "The Challenge Foundation" nor EIN 58-1817816. The first return's Schedule I lists nine school recipients as the filer wrote them: Brevard Academy, Davidson Charter Academy, Ethos Academy, Excelsior Classical, Hirsch Academy, Pioneer Preparatory, Thomas Jefferson, Unity Classical and Veritas Community; the second has no Schedule I. Both returns are listed for the EIN in the IRS indexes (6 and 7). With the five returns of Challenge Foundation Group Inc described below (2019-06-30, 2020-06-30, 2021-06-30, 2024-06-30, 2025-06-30), none names The Challenge Foundation (EIN 58-1817816).
  • One related-organization record points at this EIN: in the IRS Form 990-series e-file returns (28 link rows for this EIN), the return of Brevard Academy Inc (EIN 56-2049981; object id 202111329349305161; period ending 2020-06-30) lists Challenge Foundation Properties (EIN 81-1808142, Forest City NC) as a related tax-exempt organization, relationship "SUPPORT 501C3", "direct controlling: N/A". This links the school's return to Challenge Foundation Group Inc and still not to The Challenge Foundation (EIN 58-1817816).
  • Contributions received, as ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer lists them: tax year 2011 $8,221,428; 2012 $7,540,874; 2013 $8,230,086; 2014 $9,789,972; 2015 $724,388; 2016 $2,945,753; 2017 $600,456; 2018 $582,808; 2019 $589,677; 2020 $26,222; 2021 $1,002,193; 2022 $2,263,581; 2023 $1,526,940; 2024 $254,665; 2025 $681,169. The contributions of tax years 2014 to 2025 total $20,987,824. ProPublica's listing shows no donor names. The "Total revenue" figures above (for example 2020, -$798,991) include investment results; the contributions line is separate. (source: 3).
  • Not a tie (name match), outside every total: the Adolph Coors Foundation (EIN 51-0172279; see its page) filed 2 rows, $30,000, to "Challenge Foundation The" and "THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION", Englewood CO: year ended 2019-11-30 $15,000 ("program-specific") and year ended 2023-11-30 $15,000 ("GENERAL OPERATING GRANT"). Form 990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN, and Englewood CO is not a place shown on this body's returns (they are filed from Atlanta GA and Tigard OR); it is the place of The Challenge Foundation Inc (EIN 84-1480014), a separate body of the same name. The rows are therefore a name match and are not counted for this body. (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 51-0172279, object ids 202000639349100310, 202411039349100611; Colorado Gives page)
  • Three rows from The Prosperity Denver Fund (EIN 84-2091903) carry this body's EIN 58-1817816 but are filed to "THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION", Englewood CO, with the purpose "TO REIMBURSE FOR SCHOLARSHIPS": $14,270 (period ending 2021-09-30, object 202220749349300917), $19,112 (2022-09-30, object 202300669349301625) and $13,068 (2023-09-30, object 202430749349300943); $46,450 in all. They are stated apart and are in no total on this page. Englewood CO is not a place shown on this body's returns (Atlanta GA and Tigard OR), the purpose is a scholarship purpose, and the same fund's row for the period ending 2025-09-30 to the same name, place and purpose ($172,566, object 202642029349300339) carries the Englewood body's own EIN 84-1480014 (The Challenge Foundation Inc, see the item below); a typed-EIN error for the Englewood body is therefore the likelier reading of the three rows. If the rows were counted for this body on the strength of the typed EIN, the figure would be $46,450 in 3 rows. [IRS Form 990 e-files, giver EIN 84-2091903, Schedule I rows; which body received the three rows is not established.]
  • The Prosperity Denver Fund's Schedule I: The fund's Schedule I (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 84-2091903, objects 202220749349300917, 202300669349301625, 202430749349300943, 202541609349301109, 202642029349300339) has every grant row (167 grant rows in the five periods: 21, 19, 24, 44 and 59) with the purpose "TO REIMBURSE FOR SCHOLARSHIPS", to Colorado and other scholarship, apprenticeship and youth bodies (for example Denver Scholarship Foundation $4,411,649 in the period ending 2021-09-30 and $9,580,914 in the period ending 2025-09-30). The fund is a Denver body (IRS master file: Denver CO, NTEE B82, formed 2020-05; Colorado Secretary of State charity record from 2019-02-25). The three rows with this foundation's EIN are filed with the place Englewood CO, the same place and purpose as the row of the period ending 2025-09-30 that carries EIN 84-1480014, and other rows of the fund carry two different EINs for one body (for example "Evans Scholars Foundation" with EIN 36-2865965 in three periods, 2021 to 2023, and EIN 36-2518129 in the last two, 2024 and 2025). The Tigard foundation's own returns list scholarship-purpose grants to other recipients (for example Cascade Policy Institute, "CHILDREN'S SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM", $50,000 a year, TY2022 to TY2025) and no Colorado recipient. The Englewood body's own program of scholarships makes a typed-EIN reading possible, and that is the likelier reading; no filing states it.
  • The Prosperity Denver Fund's own story page "Prosperity Partner: The Challenge Foundation Opening Doors from Middle School to High School" (8; dated "Sep 30" on the page) says the fund "is proud to partner with The Challenge Foundation" and quotes the partner's staff: "The Challenge Foundation supports scholars on their educational journey from 6th grade through college". That is the program of the Englewood CO body (EIN 84-1480014; its returns and the Colorado Gives page describe support from the 6th grade through college), not of this foundation, whose returns show grants to organizations and no scholarship program in Colorado. The fund's own partner page thus describes its partner "The Challenge Foundation" by the Englewood body's program, which supports reading the three rows filed with this foundation's EIN ($46,450, 2021 to 2023, place Englewood CO, purpose "TO REIMBURSE FOR SCHOLARSHIPS") as rows to the Englewood body with a mistyped EIN; no filing states it. They stay out of every total on this page.

Money given

  • Size of the grant-paid rows as filed: 157 rows, $33,430,408. By return (period end; rows; total; object id): 2014-12-31, 1 row, $8,346,150, 201523209349102812; 2015-12-31, 6 rows, $3,735,000, 201613209349102691; 2016-12-31, 11 rows, $5,700,500, 201800319349100025; 2017-12-31, 11 rows, $1,346,000, 201823199349103222; 2018-12-31, 21 rows, $2,728,920, 201923199349105232; 2019-12-31, 18 rows, $1,398,000, 202043219349105804; 2020-12-31, 17 rows, $1,398,338, 202143199349107664; 2021-12-31, 16 rows, $1,847,500, 202243079349100504; 2022-12-31, 16 rows, $1,765,000, 202343179349101964; 2023-12-31, 14 rows, $1,745,000, 202442899349100314; 2024-12-31, 13 rows, $1,735,000, 202511339349102156; 2025-12-31, 13 rows, $1,685,000, 202611339349103856 (IRS Form 990-series e-file grant rows, giver EIN 58-1817816).
  • Largest recipients as filed (no description added beyond the filer's wording): SEE ATTACHED SCHEDULE, PLANO TX, $8,346,150 (1 row); TEAMCFA, CHARLOTTE NC, $4,725,000 (1 row); TEAMCFA FOUNDATION, TEMPE AZ, $3,550,000 (1 row); YOUNG AMERICAN'S FOUNDATION, RESTON VA, $2,200,000 (7 rows, this one spelling only; all spellings together are $2,695,170 in 10 rows, see below); GOLDWATER INSTITUTE, PHOENIX AZ, $1,825,000 (10 rows); MOVING PICTURE INSTITUTE, NEW YORK NY, $1,350,000 (8 rows); CORE KNOWLEDGE FOUNDATION, CHARLOTTESVILLE VA, $1,125,000 (3 rows); HERITAGE FOUNDATION, WASHINGTON DC, $950,000 (9 rows); STATE POLICY NETWORK, ARLINGTON VA, $950,000 (8 rows); PARENTS FOR EDUCATIONAL FREEDOM IN NC (PEFNC), RALEIGH NC, $865,000 (9 rows).
  • The TY2014 return (object id 201523209349102812) lists one grant row of $8,346,150 to "SEE ATTACHED SCHEDULE", Plano TX; the attachment that would name the recipient is not part of the IRS e-file data, so the row is attributed to no recipient and is out of every recipient total.
  • The same TY2014 return (Form 990-PF, period 2014-01-01 to 2014-12-31, object id 201523209349102812) files its single grant row, $8,346,150, to "SEE ATTACHED SCHEDULE" with the purpose "SEE ATTACHED". Its statement of expenditure responsibility names one grant: Team CFA Foundation, Tempe AZ, dated 2014-12-31, $3,660,000, purpose as filed "to provide ongoing operational support for the organization resulting in the continued ....", with the answer "NO" to any diversion by the grantee. The e-file names no other recipient of the year's grants. The Plano TX line on the grant row is also the address line the return gives for its list of officers and highest-paid employees, so it is not shown to be a recipient's address. (IRS Form 990-PF, EIN 58-1817816, object id 201523209349102812, 9)

Recipients that have a profile in this project

A profile is no finding about the grant; each recipient's own page carries what is documented about its work. Purposes are the foundation's wording as filed, not a finding.

  • The Heritage Foundation (23-7327730): $950,000 in 9 rows (matched by full name and place); by year of the period end: 2017 $25,000; 2018 $100,000; 2019 $100,000; 2020 $100,000; 2021 $125,000; 2022 $125,000; 2023 $125,000; 2024 $125,000; 2025 $125,000; filed as "HERITAGE FOUNDATION", WASHINGTON DC; purposes as filed: "SUPPORT FOR THE NATIONAL ESA PLAN"; "MILITARY ESA LEGISLATION & FREE SPEECH EFFORTS"; "ED CHOICE REFORMS"; "PROJECTS WITH THE CENTER FOR EDUCATION POLICY". (IRS Form 990-series e-file, giver EIN 58-1817816, object ids 201823199349103222, 201923199349105232, 202043219349105804, 202143199349107664, 202243079349100504, 202343179349101964, 202442899349100314, 202511339349102156, 202611339349103856)
  • Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (13-2912529): $225,000 in 3 rows (matched by full name and place); by year of the period end: 2018 $50,000; 2019 $50,000; 2021 $125,000; filed as "MANHATTAN INSTITUTE FOR POLICY RESEARCH", NEW YORK NY; purposes as filed: "PROJECTS RELATING TO THE PROMOTION OF CAPITALISM, ENTREPRENEURIALISM & VOCATIONAL EDUCATION"; "PARENT TOOLKIT PROJECT". (IRS Form 990-series e-file, giver EIN 58-1817816, object ids 201923199349105232, 202043219349105804, 202243079349100504)
  • State Policy Network (57-0952531): $950,000 in 8 rows (matched by full name and place); by year of the period end: 2018 $100,000; 2019 $50,000; 2020 $50,000; 2021 $150,000; 2022 $150,000; 2023 $150,000; 2024 $150,000; 2025 $150,000; filed as "STATE POLICY NETWORK", ARLINGTON VA; purposes as filed: "EFFORTS OF WORKPLACE FREEDOM COALITION"; "LEGISLATIVE EFFORTS RE OPT-OUT CAMPAIGN"; "EDPRIZE"; "ESA'S & LEADERS PROJECT"; and 2 more. (IRS Form 990-series e-file, giver EIN 58-1817816, object ids 201923199349105232, 202043219349105804, 202143199349107664, 202243079349100504, 202343179349101964, 202442899349100314, 202511339349102156, 202611339349103856)
  • Young America's Foundation (23-7042029): $2,695,170 in 10 rows (matched by full name and place; nine rows are filed with the misspelling "YOUNG AMERICAN'S FOUNDATION" (7 rows) or "YOUNG AMERICA'S FOUNDATION" (2 rows) with Reston VA, and one row (TY2017, $161,000) is filed with the place "RENTON VA", one letter from Reston VA with the state right); by year of the period end: 2016 $80,500; 2017 $161,000; 2018 $253,670; 2019 $250,000; 2020 $250,000; 2021 $350,000; 2022 $300,000; 2023 $350,000; 2024 $350,000; 2025 $350,000; filed as "YOUNG AMERICA'S FOUNDATION", RESTON VA; "YOUNG AMERICA'S FOUNDATION", RENTON VA; "YOUNG AMERICAN'S FOUNDATION", RESTON VA; purposes as filed: "HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT SCHOLARSHIPS FOR SUMMER CONFERENCE"; "HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT SCHOLARSHIPS FOR CONFERENCES, SPONSORSHIP OF SPEAKERS"; "ONGOING AND EXPANDED SUPPORT FOR HS CONFERENCES"; "NATIONAL CONSERVATIVE STUDENT CONFERENCE"; "NATIONAL STUDENT CONFERENCE". (IRS Form 990-series e-file, giver EIN 58-1817816, object ids 201800319349100025, 201823199349103222, 201923199349105232, 202043219349105804, 202143199349107664, 202243079349100504, 202343179349101964, 202442899349100314, 202511339349102156, 202611339349103856)
  • Five Form 990 returns of Challenge Foundation Group Inc (EIN 81-1808142; filed as Challenge Foundation Properties Inc for the periods ending 2019-06-30, 2020-06-30 and 2021-06-30, and as Challenge Foundation Group Inc for 2024-06-30 and 2025-06-30; all from Forest City NC): on each, the answer to the related-entity question is "No" (no Schedule R is attached), and none names The Challenge Foundation (EIN 58-1817816) anywhere (IRS Form 990 e-file, object ids 202141379349302524 and 202141379349302764, members 2021Redo_allCycles/202141379349302524_public.xml and 2021Redo_allCycles/202141379349302764_public.xml of 10; 202231369349308303, member 2022Redo_cycle01_41/202231369349308303_public.xml of 11; 202511359349302296, member of 12; 202611359349310256, member of 13).
  • The program text of Challenge Foundation Group Inc on its 2024 and 2025 returns reads "Finance the construction of buildings for startup charter schools in NC then lease the buildings to the schools until they are able to secure financing to purchase the buildings from CF Properties". Its Schedule I for 2024 lists nine grants of $25,000 "Gen Support" to schools in North Carolina, Arizona and Georgia; for 2025 it lists $132,997 "Tutoring" to "Team NC" with EIN 26-2778821 (TeamCFA Foundation's EIN) and seven other grants (same returns).
  • People: the 2024 and 2025 returns of Challenge Foundation Group Inc list eight officers and directors, named only on the filings and given here by role.
  • The University of North Carolina System's page for C. Philip Byers, a member of its Board of Governors (term 2023-2027), says he retired in 2006 as sheriff of Rutherford County. It says he was named president of Challenge Foundation Properties, "a sister organization to TeamCFA", in 2014, that he served as "southeast regional director for the Challenge Foundation", and that he served as "executive director for Education Freedom Alliance" (14, accessed 2026-11-16). Challenge Foundation Group Inc's returns for the years ended 2022-06-30 and 2023-06-30 (objects 202341179349301519 and 202401369349315315) list "Philip Byers" as President/Executive Director. EIN 81-1808142 was filed as Challenge Foundation Properties Inc until the 2021 return, and the Group's program text on the 2022 return speaks of schools buying their buildings "from CF Properties". So the Group is the body the UNC page names, and its president is the public figure the page describes. The returns of TeamNC Foundation (2022, object 202311299349103841) and Together Each Achieves More NC (2025, object 202641359349101679), both EIN 26-2778821, list a board member of the same name. The UNC page does not mention a TeamCFA board seat, so that listing stays a name match. The page gives no place or EIN for "the Challenge Foundation". (IRS Form 990 and 990-PF e-files, EINs 81-1808142 and 26-2778821, 15 and 16)
  • The other side of the 2025 grant: the Form 990-PF of Together Each Achieves More NC (EIN 26-2778821, the later name of TeamCFA Foundation) for 2024-07-01 to 2025-06-30 lists on Schedule B a single contributor, Challenge Foundation Group Inc, Forest City NC, $132,997, the same figure as its contributions line and its total revenue for the year ($132,997) (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, object id 202641359349101679, member 202641359349101679_public.xml of 17).
  • So the returns of Challenge Foundation Group Inc show money from that body (not from The Challenge Foundation) to TeamCFA Foundation and no listed relationship between it and either TeamCFA Foundation or The Challenge Foundation; no filing examined for this profile links Challenge Foundation Group Inc to The Challenge Foundation.

People on file

  • Officers and directors on the returns of The Challenge Foundation (EIN 58-1817816, not Challenge Foundation Group Inc), by role only (names on a return alone are not given; for the TY2015 trustee, see the entry on who is behind the foundation). Return year 2014 to 2025; the last year lists: 2 trustee, 1 executive director (IRS Form 990-series e-files). ProPublica's listing of the same returns shows an executive director and two other people for each year from 2018 on.
  • Founder, grant purposes and staff: Reporting presents John Bryan as the person whose family trust the foundation is (see the entry on who is behind the foundation); no source cited here says who formed it in 1989. The foundation's own grant rows state their purposes. The TY2015 row of $3,550,000 to "TEAMCFA FOUNDATION", Tempe AZ, reads "SUSTAINING SUPPORT FOR THE TEAMCFA FOUNDATION TO CONTINUE DEVELOPING THE TEAMCFA NATIONAL NETWORK OF CHALLENGE FOUNDATION ACADEMIES." and the TY2016 row of $4,725,000 to "TEAMCFA", Charlotte NC, reads "OPERATIONS OF CHARTER SCHOOL NETWORK" (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, EIN 58-1817816, objects 201613209349102691 and 201800319349100025). Officers by role, from the same ProPublica listing: an executive director (paid $215,000 in 2014 and 2015 and a former executive director from 2017), further paid staff in 2014 and 2015, and unpaid trustees; from 2018 on, three people (executive director, two others) on every return. The other officers are known only from the returns and are not named here; John Bryan is named in the entry on who is behind the foundation.
  • Who is behind the foundation: NC Policy Watch, a progressive outlet now published as NC Newsline (Sarah Ovaska-Few, "Charter's conservative backers raise questions", 2011-04-20, 18, accessed 2026-11-17), describes "John Bryan, a retired Oregon business executive and significant funder of the conservative school choice movement". It writes of "Bryan's $37 million family trust, the Challenge Foundation" and of "Bryan's Team CFA (the charter school arm of the Challenge Foundation)", and says a marketing director of the foundation said in an email "that the trust has been helping fund charter schools since 1989". Willamette Week (Nigel Jaquiss, 2012-12-19, 19) writes that "TeamCFA is the creation of John Bryan." The foundation's TY2015 return lists John Bryan as a trustee and as the only Schedule B contributor, $724,388, the year's contributions figure (object 201613209349102691). The TY2021 Schedule B lists one contributor, filed jointly in his name and that of a second trustee (object 202243079349100504). The two reports present John Bryan as the person whose family trust the Challenge Foundation is and whose network TeamCFA is; the foundation's own TY2015 row to TeamCFA Foundation names "the TeamCFA national network of Challenge Foundation Academies". Neither report calls him its founder, gives an EIN or says who signed the foundation's papers in 1989. (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, EIN 58-1817816, 20)

Ties

  • Funding, money given: the profiled organizations listed above, at the amounts and tax years stated (matched by full name and place).

What the records don't show

  • Who funds the organization: the returns for 2014 to 2025 name their Schedule B contributors, who are given by role here, except John Bryan (see Money received and People on file). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, EIN 58-1817816; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3)
  • What any grant paid for beyond the purpose wording on the row. (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, EIN 58-1817816; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3)
  • The foundation's own statement: the Form 990-PF for 2023 (EIN 58-1817816; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3) gives the address WWW.CHALLENGEFOUNDATION.ORG on its face and says applicants should review the grantmaking guidelines on the website ("REVIEW THE GRANTMAKING GUIDELINES ON THE FOUNDATION'S WEBSITE"). It lists two unpaid trustees (1 hour a week) and an executive director (40 hours a week, pay $132,000). Its Schedule B lists one individual contributor, $1,526,940, which equals the contributions figure for the year; the contributor shares a name with one of the two trustees. The return names no founder. The people stay by role.
  • The foundation's own website, in an archive copy captured 2023-06-10 (original address 21; archive address 22), says: "Established in 1989, we are a private charitable trust", that "the Board of Trustees and Advisory Committee have determined that the Foundation will support model charter schools" and that it also supports "school choice and education reform projects that promote the charter school movement"; "Grant proposals are received only at the Foundation's request." The page names no founder, no trustee and no donor.

Related bodies and other filers

  • TeamCFA Foundation (rows filed to "TEAMCFA FOUNDATION" and "TEAMCFA"): They are tied to a filer by name and place. TeamCFA Foundation, EIN 26-2778821 (IRS exempt-organization master file: 501(c)(3), exempt from 2010-04, NTEE T23; later returns under the names TeamNC Foundation (year ending 2022-06-30) and Together Each Achieves More NC (years ending 2023-06-30 to 2025-06-30), Forest City NC), filed its returns (Form 990-PF, a private operating foundation) from Tempe AZ (the year ending 2015-06-30, and the year 2013) and from Charlotte NC (years ending 2016-06-30 and 2017-06-30) and from Forest City NC afterwards (IRS Form 990-PF e-file and IRS exempt-organization master file, EIN 26-2778821). The foundation's TY2015 row (period ending 2015-12-31) carries Tempe AZ, the filer's place for the year ending 2015-06-30, the year before the row; the TY2016 row carries Charlotte NC, the filer's place for the year ending 2016-06-30 and the next. TeamCFA Foundation's total revenue as filed: $4,405,000 (year ending 2015-06-30), $4,600,420 (2016-06-30), $5,549,090 (2017-06-30), $2,722,309 (2018-06-30), $2,281,880 (2019-06-30). No dollar-for-dollar equality ties the two rows to a revenue line, so the tie rests on the specific name and the purpose wording, with the places consistent with the filer's own. This is a funding tie.
  • The Challenge Foundation Inc (EIN 84-1480014) at Englewood CO is a different body from this one. The Colorado Gives page for "The Challenge Foundation" gives its EIN 84-1480014 and its address in Englewood CO, describes it as a Denver-area education nonprofit founded in 1998 that provides scholarships and support to low-income students from the 6th grade at partner independent schools through college graduation (the page names its founder; he is not otherwise described here); it does not mention Tigard OR. Its returns in the records (periods ending 2011-05-31 to 2025-05-31) are filed from Englewood CO (and Cherry Hills Village CO for the periods ending 2021-05-31 and 2022-05-31), and the IRS master file lists it at Englewood CO (exempt from 1999-04; 501(c)(3)) (23; IRS Form 990 e-files and IRS exempt-organization master file, EIN 84-1480014).
  • The Challenge Foundation Inc, Englewood CO (EIN 84-1480014), Form 990 for the year ended 2023-05-31 (1): mission "THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION WAS FOUNDED TO HELP ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED CHILDREN ATTAIN COLLEGE READINESS AND GRADUATION THROUGH EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES AND HOLISTIC SUPPORT" (as filed, continuing "FROM GRADES SIX THROUGH ..."); programs: a summer program, tutoring and mentoring, and scholarships; Schedule I lists grants to individuals filed "SCHOLARSHIPS - <school>" for seven named independent schools and "COLLEGE SCHOLARSHIPS & SUPPORT". The return answers no to the related-organization questions of Part IV (lines 34 and 35a), attaches no Schedule R, and does not name EIN 58-1817816 or the Tigard foundation. Part VIII reports contributions of $5,006,329, of which $3,296,230 is on the line for related organizations and $1,710,099 all other; no schedule names the related organizations, and the Schedule B amounts are restricted in the public file.
  • The Charlou Foundation (EIN 83-2200839), Form 990 for the period 2022-06-01 to 2023-05-31 (object id 202420859349300727; 24 and 25), states its mission in Part III as being to "SUPPORT AND BENEFIT THE PROGRAMS AND STRATEGIC INITIATIVES OF THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION INC AND THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION ARIZONA INC", gives its website as WWW.THECHALLENGEFOUNDATION.ORG, and reports grants of $3,296,230 (Part III line 4a and Part IX line 1). That is the amount the Englewood body's own return for the year ended 2023-05-31 (object id 202440549349300314, 26) gives on Part VIII line 1d, contributions from related organizations ($3,296,230); that return answers Yes on Part IV line 28c (a 35% controlled entity of persons or organizations described in lines 28a or 28b) and No on line 34 (related to a tax-exempt or taxable entity).
  • Schedule L of the same Englewood return (year ended 2023-05-31, object id 202440549349300314) has one entry in its part on business transactions with interested persons: Challenge Foundation Arizona, relationship "SHARED BOARD OFFICERS, SHARED EXPENSES", amount $11,243, described as an intercompany receivable: at 2023-05-31 the Englewood body "WAS OWED $11,243 BY THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION ARIZONA". The Charlou Foundation, whose grants of $3,296,230 equal the related-organization contributions on Part VIII line 1d of that return, is not an entry on Schedule L; the return's Schedule O has four governance explanations and none mentions a related organization. The Charlou Foundation's own return for the period 2022-06-01 to 2023-05-31 (object id 202420859349300727) lists in Schedule A the two bodies it supports, The Challenge Foundation Inc (EIN 84-1480014) and Challenge Foundation Arizona Inc, and files the grant to the Englewood body (EIN 84-1480014) on Schedule I with the purpose "TRANSFER CHILD CARE INVESTMENTS". (IRS Form 990 e-files of EIN 84-1480014 and EIN 83-2200839; 27 and 28)
  • Other bodies with the Challenge name: Chicago IL, EIN 36-4277119: filed as "Challenge Foundation Incorporated" (later "Water Flow Fund Incorporated", Summit IL), its mission as filed is "to provide vocational educational and job placement assistance" and its revenue is $5,005 to $16,361 in 2019 to 2023; it has no link to this foundation in the records and is a different body. Challenge Foundation Properties Inc, later Challenge Foundation Group Inc (EIN 81-1808142, Forest City NC; mission as filed "To support start-up charter schools through building facilities which are leased to the schools until the school is able ..."; total revenue $34,420,580 for the year ending 2019-06-30, then $749,090 to $2,879,288 in 2020 to 2025) gave TeamCFA Foundation a grant of $2,164,300 ("Program Support", year ending 2019-06-30, object 202141379349302524) and, as Challenge Foundation Group Inc, $132,997 ("Tutoring", year ending 2025-06-30, object 202611359349310256) (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 81-1808142 and EIN 26-2778821). The Form 990 of Challenge Foundation Properties Inc for the year ended 2019-06-30 (EIN 81-1808142, object id 202141379349302524) gives the year of formation 2016 and the state of legal domicile North Carolina, and lists by role a president and executive director, a vice president, a treasurer and two directors (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 81-1808142; 15). No row of this foundation to either body, and no statement that this foundation controls or is controlled by either, is in the records. The Englewood CO body (EIN 84-1480014) is, as described above, a Denver-area scholarship provider; its returns in the records list no row from this foundation and no related organization.
  • The Englewood CO body (EIN 84-1480014): the 13 Forms 990 in the IRS e-file data for periods ending 2011-05-31 to 2025-05-31 contain neither the foundation's EIN nor the surnames of the foundation's two trustees and its executive director, and the return for the year ended 2025-05-31 (object id 202543519349301039; 29) attaches no Schedule R and lists nine board members, none of whom is a trustee or the executive director on the foundation's 2023 return. The Chicago body (EIN 36-4277119, later filing as Water Flow Fund Incorporated): its seven Forms 990-EZ for 2019 to 2025 also contain neither the EIN nor those surnames, and its latest return (object id 202631319349202203; 30) lists three officers, none of whom is on the foundation's return. The returns do not link either body to the foundation.
  • Education Freedom Alliance (EIN 46-2829206; a body whose returns state its goal as improving public education by expanding school choice and enhancing charter school opportunities through advocacy and legislative action at federal, state and local levels) lists "THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION" (EIN 58-1817816) and "TEAMCFA FOUNDATION" (EIN 26-2778821) as related tax-exempt organizations (primary activity "EDUCATION", private foundation; legal domicile Arizona for both on the 2014 and 2015 returns, and Georgia for The Challenge Foundation and Oregon for TeamCFA Foundation on the 2016 and 2017 returns) on Schedule R of its returns for 2014 (object id 201533069349300448), 2015 (201623199349310962), 2016 (201800299349300705) and 2017 (201911429349300341); the return for 2013 (201433189349309523) lists both bodies on its Schedule R as well (legal domicile Georgia for The Challenge Foundation and Arizona for TeamCFA Foundation). The listings mark no controlled-entity relationship and no transfers between the bodies. No grant row of this foundation to Education Freedom Alliance is on the returns reviewed here; the link is the one Education Freedom Alliance's return states. (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 46-2829206, 31)

Open questions

  • Who established the foundation? Reporting presents John Bryan as the person whose family trust the foundation is (NC Policy Watch, 2011) and the TY2015 return lists a trustee and the sole contributor under his name; neither the reports nor the returns say who formed it in 1989.
  • What the TY2014 attachment ("SEE ATTACHED SCHEDULE", $8,346,150) lists.
  • Which other Challenge Foundation bodies are related to this one: the Englewood CO body (EIN 84-1480014) is a separate scholarship provider; its related-organization contributions of $3,296,230 for the year ended 2023-05-31 equal the grants of $3,296,230 reported by The Charlou Foundation (EIN 83-2200839), which states that it supports that body and Challenge Foundation Arizona Inc. No source cited here states a link between the Englewood body and this foundation, or a link to the filers at Chicago IL (EIN 36-4277119).
  • Which body received the three rows of The Prosperity Denver Fund filed with EIN 58-1817816 ($46,450, 2021 to 2023) to "THE CHALLENGE FOUNDATION", Englewood CO, with the purpose "TO REIMBURSE FOR SCHOLARSHIPS"? The fourth row ($172,566, 2025) carries the Englewood CO body's EIN 84-1480014, and the fund's own partner page describes its partner "The Challenge Foundation" by the Englewood body's program (8), which supports a typed-EIN reading of the three; no filing states which body received them. The fund reimburses eligible nonprofits for postsecondary scholarships offered to Denver students (Denver Scholarship Foundation page of 2020-08-18, 32).
  • Which officer and registered agent the North Carolina Secretary of State lists for Challenge Foundation Group Inc (earlier Challenge Foundation Properties Inc), and its date of formation there (the register's business profile is at 33).

Sources

IRS Form 990-PF e-files for EIN 58-1817816 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3); IRS exempt-organization master file; the profile pages of the four recipients (for EINs and places).

Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.

Sources

  1. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/841480014
  2. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/364277119
  3. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/581817816
  4. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2023/2023_TEOS_XML_05A.zip
  5. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2024/2024_TEOS_XML_05A.zip
  6. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2023/index_2023.csv
  7. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2024/index_2024.csv
  8. https://prosperitydenverfund.org/our-stories/prosperity-and-progress-the-challenge-foundation
  9. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/581817816/201523209349102812/full.
  10. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2021/2021_TEOS_XML_01A.zip
  11. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2022/2022_TEOS_XML_01A.zip
  12. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2025/2025_TEOS_XML_05A.zip
  13. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2026/2026_TEOS_XML_05A.zip
  14. https://www.northcarolina.edu/apps/campus_profiles/member.php?id=8132
  15. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/811808142
  16. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/262778821.
  17. https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2026/2026_TEOS_XML_05B.zip
  18. https://ncnewsline.com/2011/04/20/charters-conservative-backers-raise-questions/
  19. https://www.wweek.com/portland/blog-29575-rob-kremer-will-lead-charter-school-network.html
  20. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/581817816.
  21. https://www.challengefoundation.org/
  22. https://web.archive.org/web/20230610114355/http://www.challengefoundation.org/
  23. https://www.coloradogives.org/organization/TheChallengeFoundation
  24. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202420859349300727/IRS990
  25. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/832200839
  26. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202440549349300314/IRS990
  27. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202440549349300314/IRS990ScheduleL
  28. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/832200839.
  29. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/841480014/202543519349301039/full
  30. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/364277119/202631319349202203/full
  31. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/462829206.
  32. https://denverscholarship.org/stories/prosperity-denver-fund-partners-with-nonprofits-to-boost-student-success-in-college/
  33. https://sosnc.gov/online_services/search/Business_Registration_profile/14114955