Speech First Inc
A Washington DC nonprofit that files Form 990 (TY2018 to TY2025 in the records; the TY2021 return appears twice, with identical Part I figures (the Schedule A figures differ; see Ties), object ids 202223089349302092 and 202223519349300202, counted once). Defending Education's announcement "Speech First And Defending Ed Join Forces To Expand The Shared Mission Of Fighting For The First Amendment In Education" (1) says Speech First "has made the strategic decision to merge with Defending Education" (the group profiled here as Parents Defending Education), that Nicole Neily "founded and leads both organizations, and their missions have increasingly converged", that "The Speech First name will go away, but its mission will not", and that "All legal rights associated with Speech First's court cases are being transferred to Defending Education, including the ability to return to court if an institution backslides on a settled matter"; the page now at 2 carries the same decision. Neither page gives a date for the decision or for the legal transfer. Both organizations filed separate Forms 990 for the period ending 2025-12-31 (see Ties). Documented work on trans people: Speech First, Inc. is one of eight plaintiffs, with the States of Alabama, Florida, Georgia and South Carolina, Independent Women's Network, Parents Defending Education and Independent Women's Law Center, in State of Alabama v. Cardona, No. 7:24-cv-00533 (N.D. Ala., filed 2024-04-29). The Clearinghouse summary (3) says the plaintiffs challenged three aspects of the 2024 Title IX Final Rule: its interpretation of "sex discrimination", its definition of "sex-based harassment" and its alteration of procedures for Title IX grievances, and says the rule protects students from discrimination based on, among other grounds, gender identity. Per the summary (last updated 3/19/2025): the court denied a preliminary injunction on 2024-07-30; the Eleventh Circuit granted an injunction pending appeal; and, the summary states, the district court stayed the proceedings on 2024-10-22 (the docket lists a joint motion to stay filed 2024-10-07). On the docket as accessed 2026-11-11 (updated 2026-10-28), the entry of the 2024-07-30 denial (Doc. 58) is marked "VACATED pursuant to USCA Order 95" (modified 2026-05-27). The plaintiffs' motion of 2026-05-22 in the Eleventh Circuit (No. 24-12444) asked to dismiss the appeal as moot, because the Kentucky court's vacatur of the 2024 rule became final when the intervenors' appeal was dismissed on 2026-05-13, and to vacate the denial; the Independent Women's Law Center reports that the court granted the request. CourtListener's docket record for the district case gives it as terminated on 2026-05-29 (4, docket data as of 2026-09-30); the record gives the date only, not how the case ended. The suit is stated here as Speech First's own act as co-plaintiff; the plaintiffs are states and organizations. Its other cases are described under Ties from the complaints and case pages: Speech First v. McCall (Fifth Circuit decision of 2025-05-14), Shrum, Khator, Sands and Whitten. The Bader Family Foundation gave it $2,058,000 in 7 rows (TY2018 to TY2024), and the records show its payments to law, public-relations and fundraising vendors below.
Records: IRS Form 990 e-files for EIN 82-3599047 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 5). Each grant was counted once. Money in is read from other filers' grant rows that carry this organization's EIN as recipient (Form 990 Schedule I); Form 990-PF grant rows carry no recipient EIN, so the Bader Family Foundation's rows are matched by full name and place, as each line says.
Money received
- Revenue, expenses and assets as filed (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 82-3599047; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 5): period ending 2018-12-31: revenue $1,253,461, expenses $1,476,793, assets $33,993, Form 990, object id 201943199349308254; period ending 2019-12-31: revenue $1,262,640, expenses $1,556,841, assets $37,867, Form 990, object id 202003219349315135; period ending 2020-12-31: revenue $2,294,011, expenses $1,671,802, assets $360,527, Form 990, object id 202133199349320688; period ending 2021-12-31: revenue $2,272,281, expenses $2,281,390, assets $350,578, Form 990, object id 202223089349302092; period ending 2021-12-31: revenue $2,272,281, expenses $2,281,390, assets $350,578, Form 990, object id 202223519349300202; period ending 2022-12-31: revenue $2,325,417, expenses $2,152,448, assets $543,967, Form 990, object id 202323179349309932; period ending 2023-12-31: revenue $2,596,032, expenses $2,399,427, assets $776,504, Form 990, object id 202413209349306676; period ending 2024-12-31: revenue $2,800,339, expenses $2,269,853, assets $1,449,583, Form 990, object id 202543109349300029; period ending 2025-12-31: revenue $438,009, expenses $1,307,344, assets $399,368, Form 990, object id 202611499349301516.
- Donors are not shown on the public returns.
- The Bader Family Foundation (EIN 27-6359747) gave $2,058,000 in 7 rows, filed "SPEECH FIRST", Washington DC, purpose as filed "GENERAL CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTION" (period ends: 2018 $30,000; 2019 $145,000; 2020 $300,000; 2021 $298,000; 2022 $435,000; 2023 $420,000; 2024 $430,000) (IRS Form 990-PF e-file grant rows, giver EIN 27-6359747, object ids 201903239349100005, 202033219349105833, 202143239349100409, 202213199349109381, 202343189349102434, 202433209349104413, 202513219349106376; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6).
- Fidelity Charitable (EIN 11-0303001): $3,258,240 in 7 rows, by year of the period end: 2019 $500,250; 2020 $503,900; 2021 $611,850; 2022 $108,600; 2023 $504,750; 2024 $756,450; 2025 $272,440 (the period ending 2022-06-30 is on two returns, object ids 202321309349304807 and 202430459349302913, which list the same $108,600 gift, once under another body's name with Speech First's EIN; counted once); purposes as filed: "For grant recipient's exempt purposes" (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows, recipient EIN 82-3599047; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 7)
- The 85 Fund (EIN 20-2466871): $750,000 in 2 rows, by year of the period end: 2020 $500,000; 2021 $250,000; purposes as filed: "general support"; "General Support" (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows, recipient EIN 82-3599047; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 8)
- The Heritage Foundation (EIN 23-7327730): $100,000 in 1 row, by year of the period end: 2023 $100,000; purposes as filed: "INNOVATION PRIZE" (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows, recipient EIN 82-3599047; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 9)
- The Heritage Foundation's 2023 award of $100,000 (filed with the purpose "INNOVATION PRIZE"; IRS Form 990 grant row for the year ending 2023-12-31, recipient EIN 82-3599047, 5) is described by Philanthropy Daily of 2023-04-27 (10), reporting the foundation's 2023 Innovation Prize winners: "Speech First received a $100,000 award to bolster their critical litigation work of defending students' constitutional rights to free speech at universities across the country." The article does not mention Title IX or trans people.
- National Philanthropic Trust (EIN 23-7825575): $2,670,000 in 6 rows, by year of the period end: 2019 $500,000; 2020 $550,000; 2021 $500,000; 2022 $400,000; 2023 $370,000; 2024 $350,000; purposes as filed: "PUBLIC, SOCIETAL BENEFIT" (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows, recipient EIN 82-3599047; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 11)
- Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc (EIN 31-1640316): $10,250 in 1 row, by year of the period end: 2025 $10,250; purposes as filed: "PUBLIC, SOCIETAL BENEFIT" (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows, recipient EIN 82-3599047; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12)
- Bradley Impact Fund Inc (EIN 45-4678325): $800,000 in 2 rows, by year of the period end: 2023 $100,000; 2024 $700,000; purposes as filed: "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT." (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows, recipient EIN 82-3599047; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 13)
- DonorsTrust (EIN 52-2166327): $433,100 in 4 rows, by year of the period end: 2022 $228,100; 2023 $102,000; 2024 $103,000; purposes as filed: "for Campus Free Speech Project"; "for general operations" (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows, recipient EIN 82-3599047; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 14)
- Morgan Stanley Global Impact Funding Trust Inc (EIN 52-7082731): $200,000 in 1 row, by year of the period end: 2020 $200,000; purposes as filed: "UNRESTRICTED GENERAL SUPPORT" (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant row, recipient EIN 82-3599047, object id 202143219349301454; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 15)
- Payments to vendors as filed (IRS Form 990 Part VII contractor rows; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 5): Consovoy McCarthy PLLC (filed also "CONSOVOY MCCARTHY PARK PLLC") "LEGAL SERVICES" $950,000 (TY2018), $750,000 (TY2019), $1,350,000 (TY2020), $1,100,000 (TY2021), $1,035,000 (TY2022), $1,100,000 (TY2023), $1,062,000 (TY2024), $550,000 (TY2025); CRC Public Relations (also filed "CREATIVE RESPONSE CONCEPTS INC DBA CRC P...") $106,830 (TY2018), $193,176 (TY2019), $255,525 (TY2021), $151,983 (TY2022), $168,905 (TY2023), $155,000 (TY2024), $370,000 (TY2025); Engage LLC ("WEBSITE DESIGN") $110,000 (TY2018); American Philanthropic LLC (fundraising) $164,279 (TY2021), $259,125 (TY2022), $186,710 (TY2023), $198,806 (TY2024), $159,828 (TY2025); Active Engagement LLC (fundraising) $298,905 (TY2021), $145,489 (TY2023); Athos Media Strategies (media consulting) $127,200 (TY2022), $159,600 (TY2023), $141,900 (TY2024).
- Adolph Coors Foundation (EIN 51-0172279) gave Speech First Inc $45,000 in 2 rows paid: year ended 2021-11-30 $20,000 ("general operating"); year ended 2024-11-30 $25,000 ("GENERAL OPERATING GRANT"). Recipient as filed: Speech First, Washington; SPEECH FIRST INC, Washington. Basis: matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 51-0172279, object ids 202240639349100809, 202511019349100016; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16)
- John William Pope Foundation (EIN 58-1691765) gave Speech First Inc $85,000 in 3 rows paid: year ended 2021-06-30 $25,000 ("GENERAL OPERATING EXPENSES"); year ended 2022-06-30 $30,000 ("UNRESTRICTED GRANT"); year ended 2023-06-30 $30,000 ("UNRESTRICTED"). Recipient as filed: SPEECH FIRST, Washington. Basis: matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 58-1691765, object ids 202231229349100038, 202321299349103292, 202410799349100871; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 17)
- Diana Davis Spencer Foundation Inc (EIN 20-3672969) gave Speech First Inc $1,000,000 in 4 rows paid, recipient filed "SPEECH FIRST INC", Washington DC; by year of the period end: 2021 $100,000 ("STRATEGIC CAMPUS FREE SPEECH LITIGATION PROJECT"); 2022 $250,000 ("CAMPUS EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS"); 2023 $350,000 ("CAMPUS EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS"); 2024 $300,000 ("CAMPUS FREE SPEECH PROJECT"). Matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 20-3672969, object ids 202243199349104294, 202333169349100258, 202433199349102773, 202503189349104390; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 18)
- The Searle Freedom Trust C/O Kinship Llc (EIN 36-7244615) gave Speech First $550,000 in 4 rows paid, recipient filed "SPEECH FIRST", Washington DC; purpose as filed "LITIGATION" on every row; by year of the period end: 2020 $125,000; 2021 $125,000; 2022 $125,000; 2023 $175,000. Matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 36-7244615, object ids 202113199349108526, 202203199349103100, 202343199349106704, 202433209349102098; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 19)
- Sarah Scaife Foundation Incorporated (EIN 25-1113452) gave Speech First Inc $475,000 in 4 rows paid, recipient filed "SPEECH FIRST INC", Washington DC; purpose as filed "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT"; by year of the period end: 2021 $100,000; 2022 $125,000; 2023 $125,000; 2024 $125,000. Matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 25-1113452, object ids 202223189349101212, 202323189349101532, 202403209349104590, 202523189349102237; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 20)
- The Stanton Foundation (EIN 13-3598005) gave Speech First $249,600 in 2 rows paid, recipient filed "SPEECH FIRST", Washington DC; purpose as filed "TO ACHIEVE CHARITABLE PURPOSE"; year ended 2020-12 $99,600; 2021-12 $150,000. Matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 13-3598005, object ids 202143079349101514, 202223149349100527; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 21)
- Smaller rows matched by name and place (990-PF), 21 rows in all, $57,612: The Robertson-Finley Foundation 7 rows, $17,500 (2019 to 2025); Creigh Family Foundation 4 rows, $16,500 (2022 to 2025); Melvin S Cohen Foundation Inc 1 row, $10,000 (2020); The Armstrong Foundation 1 row, $5,000 (2024); The Conru Foundation 1 row, $5,000 (2019); Chiavacci Family Foundation 2 rows, $2,000 (2020, 2025); Farrell Family Foundation 1 row, $1,500 (2022); AmazonSmile Foundation 4 rows, $112 (2020 to 2023). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, each foundation's filings on ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 22)
People on file
- Officers on the returns by role only; Defending Education's announcement of the merger (2) says Nicole Neily "founded and leads both organizations"; no other individual is named here.
Ties
- Funding (money in): the Bader Family Foundation ($2,058,000) and the profiled givers listed above (by recipient EIN), among them the Morgan Stanley Global Impact Funding Trust ($200,000, TY2020), the Bradley Impact Fund ($800,000 in 2 rows, TY2023 and TY2024), The 85 Fund ($750,000, TY2020 and TY2021) and the Heritage Foundation ($100,000, TY2023).
- Formal joint work: co-plaintiff with Parents Defending Education in State of Alabama v. Cardona (N.D. Ala., 7:24-cv-00533).
- Vendors (paid for services; not funders): Consovoy McCarthy PLLC and CRC Public Relations (filed also as "CREATIVE RESPONSE CONCEPTS INC DBA CRC P..."), as listed above.
- An address on Speech First's own site for its news item on the Biden administration's Title IX rule (23) redirects to 2, consistent with the merger into Defending Education described above.
- Narrative alignment only (not a tie): none listed.
- The appeal in State of Alabama v. U.S. Secretary of Education, 11th Cir. No. 24-12444 (from N.D. Ala. 7:24-cv-00533), ended as moot. Documents reviewed here (CourtListener RECAP copies): plaintiffs' letters of 2025-01-24 and 2025-03-12 (CA11 docs 101, 107) on the Eastern District of Kentucky's vacatur of the 2024 Title IX rule (Tennessee v. Cardona, 2025 WL 63795, 2025-01-09) and Carroll ISD (N.D. Tex., 2025-02-19); the Eleventh Circuit's order (doc 111) asking for briefs "on or before August 25, 2025" on whether the appeal of the denial of the preliminary injunction is moot; and the plaintiffs' motion of 2026-05-22 (doc 122, signed for the private plaintiffs by Consovoy McCarthy PLLC and for Alabama, Florida, Georgia and South Carolina by their counsel) "to dismiss this interlocutory appeal as moot" and "to vacate the district court's July 30, 2024 order denying Plaintiffs' motion for a preliminary injunction", with the Department of Education consenting to dismissal and taking no position on vacatur. The motion says the intervenors appealing the Kentucky vacatur stipulated to dismissal of their appeal on 2026-05-08 and the Sixth Circuit dismissed it on 2026-05-13, so the 2024 rule "is now vacated by a final judgment"; it adds that plaintiffs "do not yet agree that the entire case is moot, just their motion for a preliminary injunction and this interlocutory appeal". The Independent Women's Law Center's release of 2026-06-03 (24) says "The Eleventh Circuit granted that request, dismissing the appeal as moot and vacating the lower court's decision"; the district docket's entry of the denial (Doc. 58) is marked "VACATED pursuant to USCA Order 95" (modified 2026-05-27). The Eleventh Circuit's order granting the motion is Document 124-2, filed 2026-05-27, by Judges Newsom, Grant and Abudu; it reads in full 'Appellants' motion to dismiss this appeal as moot and vacate the district court's order denying a preliminary injunction is GRANTED. This appeal is DISMISSED AS MOOT and the district court's order denying a preliminary injunction is VACATED.' It gives no reasons and does not mention remand (25, read as text). The plaintiffs' motion did not treat the district case itself as over: the plaintiffs' motion asks for remand "for any further proceedings that might be necessary". (26; 27; 28; 29, read as text) CourtListener's docket record for the district case, State of Alabama v. Cardona, N.D. Ala. No. 7:24-cv-00533, gives it as terminated on 2026-05-29, with its last filing on 2026-05-29, two days after the Eleventh Circuit's order of 2026-05-27 (4, CourtListener docket data as of 2026-09-30). The record gives the date only; it does not say how the case ended. A press release of 2026-06-03 from Independent Women's press team about its Law Center describes "the successful conclusion of its legal challenge" and quotes the Law Center's senior legal counsel: "This litigation has reached a victorious conclusion". The release ties that conclusion to the Eleventh Circuit's order, which "granted the parties' motion to dismiss the appeal as moot and vacated the district court's denial of a preliminary injunction"; it does not say how or when the district case itself ended (24).
- Merger timing: Defending Education's announcement (1) and its page on Speech First (2) give no date for the decision to merge ("has made the strategic decision to merge with Defending Education") or for the transfer of Speech First's legal rights in its court cases to Defending Education. The records give a floor and not a date: Speech First (EIN 82-3599047) filed its own Form 990 for the period ending 2025-12-31 (object id 202611499349301516: revenue $438,009, expenses $1,307,344, assets $399,368, mission text of its own: "SPEECH FIRSTS MISSION IS TO DEFEND STUDENTS..."); Defending Education (EIN 86-1596460, Arlington VA; formerly Parents Defending Education) filed its own for the period ending 2025-12-31 (object id 202612159349301091: revenue $6,635,388, expenses $6,279,870, assets $1,288,901; mission "National grassroots organization working to reclaim our schools from activists promoting harmful agendas"). Both are separate filers on those returns, and the records do not carry a Schedule N or a statement of merger; Defending Education's assets are not shown to include Speech First's. Speech First's revenue fell from $2,800,339 (TY2024) to $438,009 (TY2025). (IRS Form 990 e-file, Speech First, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 5; Defending Education, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 30)
- Merger timing, the returns for 2025 and the home page: Speech First's own return for 2025 does not report the merger. Its Form 990 for the year ending 2025-12-31 (signed 2026-05-29 by the board chair) answers "No" to Part IV line 31 (whether the organization liquidated, terminated or dissolved and ceased operations) and "No" to line 32 (whether it sold, exchanged, disposed of or transferred more than 25 percent of its net assets), and reports net assets of $376,292 at the end of the year. Defending Education's Form 990 for the same year (submitted 2026-08-03) also answers "No" to lines 31 and 32, carries no Schedule R, and does not name Speech First. (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 82-3599047, object id 202611499349301516, 31, and EIN 86-1596460, object id 202612159349301091, 32) Speech First's own home page, in an archive copy of 2026-10-17, said that "the Speech First board has made a strategic decision to merge our efforts with Defending Education" and that "all legal rights to Speech First court cases have been transferred to Defending Education"; it gives no date for either (33, archive copy of 2026-10-17). So by 2026-10-17 Speech First said the transfer of its legal rights had taken place, while its return for 2025 reports no termination and no transfer of more than 25 percent of its net assets in that year.
- The other cases on Defending Education's page, from each case's own page on defendinged.org (accessed 2026-11-12): Speech First v. McCall (Texas State University and the Texas State University System, W.D. Tex. and the Fifth Circuit; challenge to a harassment policy covering "unwelcome verbal, written, graphic, or physical conduct" based on protected traits and to a computer-use policy; district court ruling of 2023-09-01 blocked the computer policy as applied to non-employee students and denied relief on the harassment policy; Fifth Circuit decision of 2025-05-14 vacated the dismissal as moot and remanded; listed as pending); Speech First v. Shrum (Oklahoma State University, W.D. Okla., Tenth Circuit reversed the standing dismissal in 2024-02; settled 2024-04-15, university to disband its Bias Response Team, change its harassment and computer policies and pay $18,000 in fees); Speech First v. Khator (University of Houston, S.D. Tex., filed 2022-02-23, preliminary injunction 2022-05-19, settled 2022-06-10 with $30,000 in fees); Speech First v. Sands (Virginia Tech, W.D. Va., filed 2021-04-08; Fourth Circuit 2-1 on standing 2023-05; Supreme Court vacated in 2024-03 as to the moot bias claims; settled 2024-04). On the McCall page, gender identity appears in the list of protected traits in the challenged harassment policy ("directed at someone because of their race, sex, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, or other traits"), and the words "gender ideology" appear in its discussion of chilled speech ("Students who might be accused of harassment for sharing their views on topics like abortion, immigration, or gender ideology"), so that page touches the subject in both places while the suit itself challenges campus speech policies. The Shrum, Khator and Sands pages do not mention gender identity, pronouns, transgender people or Title IX. Of the suits read, only State of Alabama v. Cardona is brought against protections for trans people; none is brought on behalf of trans people.
- What the foundation grants funded: the filings give the purpose only (The Searle Freedom Trust, "LITIGATION", $550,000 in 4 rows, TY2020 to TY2023; Diana Davis Spencer Foundation, $1,000,000 in 4 rows, with the purposes listed above). The cases Speech First filed in 2021 to 2023 (Sands 2021, Khator 2022, Shrum and McCall 2023) fall within the Searle years, and a 2024 case (Whitten) and the 2024 Title IX suit follow; none of the cited pages concerns protections for trans people, and no cited source ties either foundation's dollars to a case, so the Searle and Spencer rows cannot be shown to fund the Title IX suit (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 36-7244615, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 19; giver EIN 20-3672969, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 18).
- Evidence on the framing: the suit in which Speech First is a plaintiff, Alabama v. Cardona, was brought against a rule that protects students from discrimination on the basis of gender identity (as the page's Clearinghouse source states); the plaintiffs' own letter to the Eleventh Circuit (CA11 doc 101, dated 2025-01-24) tells the court of the executive order of 2025-01-20 "Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government" and quotes its statement that Title IX does not require "gender identity-based access to single-sex spaces". The letter, signed by the plaintiffs' counsel, shows the plaintiffs presenting that order as bearing on their case; it concerns Title IX protection for students of any age, college students included, and is not about campus speech. The order's title and its phrase "gender identity-based access to single-sex spaces" are anti-trans framing, quoted here as the plaintiffs presented them, not as findings; the rule the suit challenged extended Title IX protection to discrimination based on gender identity (as the Clearinghouse source states) and has since been vacated.
- Filed program description, TY2022: Speech First's Form 990 for the year ending 2022-12-31 (object id 202323179349309932; IRS e-file XML read) describes its programs in Part III as "litigation, advocacy, and education" with program service expenses of $1,601,167. The text says that in FY22 it "filed a federal lawsuit against the University of Houston", won that case in the Southern District of Texas and "won its case against the University of Central Florida in the Eleventh Circuit", "submitted additional public comments to the US Department of Education regarding its newly proposed Title IX rules", filed an amicus brief in the SFFA v. Harvard and UNC cases, published reports on bias reporting systems and freshman orientations, and that its president made media appearances and published op-eds. The text does not name the Searle Freedom Trust or the Diana Davis Spencer Foundation and does not say which program any grant supported. (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 82-3599047, object id 202323179349309932, tax year 2022, IRS TEOS e-file XML (2023_TEOS_XML_11A))
- Filed program description, TY2021: Speech First's Form 990 for the year ending 2021-12-31 was filed twice. The IRS e-file XML of each was reviewed (IRS TEOS 2022 archive, 2022_TEOS_XML_02A). Part I figures are the same in both (revenue $2,272,281, expenses $2,281,390, program service expenses $1,678,426). Part III reads, as filed (capitals in the original): mission "SPEECH FIRST'S MISSION IS TO SUPPORT STUDENTS WHO SEEK TO PROTECT THEIR RIGHTS TO FREE SPEECH, EXPRESSION OR ASSOCIATION"; program text "SPEECH FIRST DEFENDS STUDENTS' FREE SPEECH RIGHTS ON CAMPUS THROUGH LITIGATION, ADVOCACY, AND EDUCATION. IN FY21, SPEECH FIRST FILED AN ADDITIONAL MOTION TO INTERVENE IN FEDERAL TITLE IX LAWSUITS AS WELL AS SUBMITTED PUBLIC COMMENTS TO THE US DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ON ITS NEWLY PROPOSED TITLE IX RULES. SPEECH FIRST ALSO FILED 2 AMICUS BRIEFS FOR SCOTUS CASES, AND FILED FEDERAL LAWSUITS AGAINST THE UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA AND VIRGINIA TECH UNIVERSITY ALLEGING THAT VARIOUS POLICIES VIOLATED STUDENTS' FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS THROUGH OVERBROAD, VAGUE POLICIES DESIGNED TO CHILL STUDENT SPEECH AND EXPRESSION.... SPEECH FIRST INITIATED ITS FIRST IN-DEPTH RESEARCH PROJECTS ON BIAS REPORTING SYSTEMS AND FRESHMAN ORIENTATIONS." The text names no grantor, so it does not show what the Searle Freedom Trust's 2021 grant of $125,000 (purpose as filed "LITIGATION") or the Diana Davis Spencer Foundation's 2021 grant of $100,000 ("STRATEGIC CAMPUS FREE SPEECH LITIGATION PROJECT") supported. The text does not mention trans people or gender identity. It does state that in FY21 Speech First moved to intervene in federal Title IX lawsuits and commented on the Department of Education's proposed Title IX rules; the return does not say which lawsuits or which rules. (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 82-3599047, object ids 202223089349302092 and 202223519349300202, tax year 2021, IRS TEOS e-file XML)
- Where the 2021 comments were sent: in calendar 2021 the Department had no proposed Title IX rule. It held a virtual public hearing on 2021-06-07 to 2021-06-11 and took written comments by e-mail only, to a mailbox the notice names, not on a regulations.gov docket (Announcement of Public Hearing, 86 Fed. Reg. 27429, 2021-05-20; comments due 5:00 p.m. Eastern on 2021-06-11; 34). The proposed rule came on 2022-07-12 (docket ED-2021-OCR-0166), so the 2022 comment on that docket is a FY22 filing; the TY2021 return's wording for FY21 does not fit it and does not say which filing it means. The TY2021 return names no document as its FY21 comment.
- The two TY2021 returns differ. Object id 202223089349302092 carries a return timestamp of 2022-11-04 and a signature date of 2022-10-15. Object id 202223519349300202 carries a timestamp of 2022-12-17, a signature date of 2022-12-12 and the amended-return mark ("AmendedReturnInd" X). Their Schedule A Part II figures differ: "substantial contributors" total $2,289,360 against $886,008 and total public support $5,043,033 against $6,446,385. Part I figures and Part III text are identical; the Schedule A figures differ. (same two returns)
- Filed program description, TY2023: the return for the year ending 2023-12-31 (object id 202413209349306676; program service expenses $1,714,485) says that in FY23 Speech First launched suits against Texas State University (W.D. Tex., on a harassment policy and a computer-use policy) and Oklahoma State University (W.D. Okla., on a bias response team, a harassment policy and a computer-use policy), pursued a petition for certiorari in its Virginia Tech case, and was "leading the charge educating students and coalition allies on the Biden-Harris administration's new Title IX rule that will lead to coercion and compelled speech". That is Speech First's own wording, not a finding; the rule it opposed extended Title IX protection to discrimination based on gender identity and has since been vacated, and presenting that protection as coercion is anti-trans rhetoric. It says it testified before the House higher-education subcommittee and in the Ohio legislature on SB 117, and "partnered with the Goldwater Institute to create two model policies", a "Freedom from Indoctrination Act" aimed at DEI course requirements and a "Protecting Students from Bias Reporting Systems Act"; and that its president "conducted over 500 media hits". The text names no grant or grantor. (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 82-3599047, object id 202413209349306676, tax year 2023, IRS TEOS e-file XML (2024_TEOS_XML_11A))
- Filed program descriptions, TY2020, TY2024 and TY2025. The return for the year ending 2020-12-31 (object id 202133199349320688; program service expenses $1,502,655) says that in FY20 Speech First "FILED THREE MOTIONS TO INTERVENE IN FEDERAL TITLE IX LAWSUITS, FILED AND SETTLED A FEDERAL LAWSUIT AGAINST IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY, SETTLED ITS LAWSUIT AGAINST THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS, AND CONTINUED ITS LITIGATION AGAINST THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS". The return for the year ending 2024-12-31 (object id 202543109349300029; program service expenses $1,604,488) says that Speech First "SUED THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION IN THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ALABAMA IN PARTNERSHIP WITH THE STATES OF ALABAMA, FLORIDA, GEORGIA, SOUTH CAROLINA, PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION, AND THE INDEPENDENT WOMEN'S FORUM TO CHALLENGE THE ADMINISTRATION'S TITLE IX REWRITE", filed its suit against Indiana University, won its Texas State appeal in the Fifth Circuit and settled the Oklahoma State and Virginia Tech suits. The return for the year ending 2025-12-31 (object id 202611499349301516; program service expenses $1,020,789 on that line) says it "continued to litigate a Title IX case in the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals". None of the three texts names a grantor or says which program a grant supported, so they do not show what the Searle Freedom Trust's "LITIGATION" rows or the Diana Davis Spencer Foundation's rows paid for. The TY2024 text is Speech First's own statement that it brought the suit against the 2024 Title IX rule, which extended Title IX's protection against sex discrimination to discrimination based on gender identity and has since been vacated. (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 82-3599047, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 35)
- Speech First v. McCall complaint: the verified complaint in Speech First v. McCall (W.D. Tex., No. 1:23-cv-00411, Doc. 1, filed 2023-04-13, 33 pages; read as text) goes beyond a list of protected traits. It sets out the beliefs of three student members (Students A, B and C, anonymous in the complaint) as the speech the Texas State harassment policy would chill. Student A is said to believe "that sex is inherent and immutable and that there is no such thing as a 'gender spectrum'", that "the exponential growth in adolescents and young adults who identify as transgender or 'non-binary' is evidence that many people now claim a certain 'gender identity' because they want attention", and that "minors are too young to make decisions about their gender identity" (paragraph 63); Student B is said to believe that biological sex "cannot change based on someone's internal feelings" and not to want "to be forced to affirm that a biological male is actually a female" (paragraph 74). Each of the three students says he or she wants to argue against classmates on "gender identity" among other topics (paragraphs 66, 77 and 88). The complaint also cites a 2022 FIRE campus survey in which 52 percent of students said campuses should ban a speaker who says that "[t]ransgender people have a mental disorder" (to argue that students fear speaking). The claim that trans people identify as trans for attention, and the statement that trans people have a mental disorder, are anti-trans rhetoric; the plaintiff presents a right to voice them on campus as what is at stake. (Complaint, Case 1:23-cv-00411, Doc. 1 (copy at 36)
- The complaints in Speech First v. Shrum, Khator, Sands and Whitten: the verified complaints in four more Speech First cases were reviewed in the copies Defending Education hosts on its case pages. Each describes anonymous student members and the beliefs they say they want to voice, and in all four those beliefs include anti-trans views. This is how the complaints present Speech First's members; it is not a finding of any court, and the views are anti-trans rhetoric.
- Speech First, Inc. v. Shrum (U.S. District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma, No. 5:23-cv-00029, Document 1, filed 01/10/23, 33 pages): the complaint quotes Oklahoma State University's bias-incident policy as covering "Incorrect name or pronoun usage" (paragraph 49, p. 13). As the speech its members want to engage in, it pleads the anti-trans beliefs of all three pseudonymous student members: Student A's view that there is no "gender spectrum" and that the growth in young people identifying as transgender or "non-binary" shows that "many people now claim a certain 'gender identity' because they want attention or affirmation" (paragraph 59, pp. 15-16); Student B's wish not to "be forced to affirm" that a person is of the sex they identify as, and to answer the statement "trans women are women" (paragraph 74, p. 18); and Student C's refusal to accept that a trans woman is a woman (paragraph 88, pp. 20-21). Gender identity is also named among the topics each student wants to argue about (paragraphs 62, 78 and 93). The Student A and Student B passages use nearly the same words as the McCall complaint described above (37).
- Speech First, Inc. v. Khator (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, No. 4:22-cv-00582, Document 1, filed 02/23/22, 22 pages): beyond the University of Houston policy's list of protected classes (paragraph 33, which includes "gender identity or status, gender expression"), the complaint pleads that Student A does not want to use "preferred pronouns" for people who are transgender or non-binary and objects to trans women competing in women's sports (paragraphs 47 and 48, p. 11); that Student B does not want to use "preferred pronouns" (paragraph 64, p. 13) and wants to argue against "using transgender people's 'preferred pronouns'" (paragraph 67, p. 14); that Student C objects to trans women competing in women's sports (paragraph 75, p. 15) and disputes "whether 'transgender women' are really women" (paragraph 82, p. 16); and, for each student, that a university administrator told student government in a presentation on the University's website that continual use of "improper pronouns" can violate the harassment policy (paragraph 57, p. 12, and the matching paragraphs for Students B and C) (38).
- Speech First, Inc. v. Sands (U.S. District Court for the Western District of Virginia, No. 7:21-cv-00203, Document 1, filed 04/08/21, 50 pages), from the page images: besides Virginia Tech's lists of protected traits (gender identity and gender expression among them), the student-member allegations are that Student A "believes people often change their gender identity because they want to be noticed or be part of a group, because of childhood trauma, or because they want to fill an empty spot in their lives" and "doesn't want to be forced to use someone's 'preferred pronouns' simply because that person believes that his or her 'truth' involves being 'non-binary'" (paragraph 94, pp. 24-25); that Student B "doesn't want to be forced to call someone a 'he' or a 'she' when that is not the person's biological sex" and objects to trans women playing women's sports (paragraph 112, p. 28); and that Student C "doesn't want to be forced to call someone a 'him' or a 'her' or 'they' or 'them' because that person claims to have a new gender identity" and is "strongly against allowing children to 'choose' their gender" and receive hormone treatment (paragraph 128, p. 31). Pleading the misgendering of trans people as the speech to be protected is anti-trans rhetoric and is not made in good faith. (39, PDF pages 24, 25, 28 and 31, from the page images)
- The beliefs these complaints plead (that trans people's genders are not real, refusal to use their pronouns, opposition to their place in sport and to their care) are anti-trans rhetoric, and the complaints present them as the speech the universities' policies chill. The Shrum, Khator and Sands suits challenge campus harassment, bias-response and computer-use policies.
- Speech First, Inc. v. Whitten (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, No. 1:24-cv-00898-JPH-MG, Document 1, filed 05/29/24, 29 pages): the complaint quotes Indiana University's definition of a "bias incident" as conduct "motivated in whole or in part by bias or prejudice... based on that individual or group's actual or perceived identities" (paragraph 38, p. 11) and gives no list of protected traits there. Beyond that, it pleads the anti-trans beliefs of four of its five pseudonymous student members as the speech they want to engage in: Student A does not believe "that 'gender identity' is an inherent trait that is separable from sex" and wants to argue that "most children who identify as transgender or 'non-binary'" "should receive counseling instead of surgical interventions" (paragraph 48, p. 14); Student C believes that trans women "should not be allowed to compete in women's sports" (paragraph 75, p. 19); Student D believes that "gender-identity theory is divorced from reality" (paragraph 87, p. 21); and Student E does not want "to be forced to use 'preferred pronouns'" and wants to answer the statement "trans women are women" (paragraph 98, p. 23), and objects to trans women using women's bathrooms and locker rooms and competing in women's sports (paragraph 99, pp. 23-24). Gender identity, or "sex, gender", is also named among the topics Students A, C, D and E want to argue about (paragraphs 54, 78, 91 and 103). The pattern is the same as in the McCall, Shrum, Khator and Sands complaints described above. Pleading the misgendering of trans people and their exclusion from public life as the speech to be protected is anti-trans rhetoric and is not made in good faith. (40; Defending Education's case page, 41, lists the case status as "Settled")
- The four complaints were accessed 2026-11-16 as PDFs on Defending Education's own case pages (42, 43, 41, 44).
- Speech First's own filings as the courts describe them: in its 2018 suit against the University of Michigan the complaint is described as saying its student members wanted to voice "criticism of the Black Lives Matter and 'gender identity' movements, welfare, affirmative action, and Title IX" and feared being reported (E.D. Mich. Civil Case No. 18-11451, 45); in its suits against the University of Texas at Austin (W.D. Tex. No. 1:18-CV-1078 and Fifth Circuit No. 19-50529) "gender identity" appears among the protected categories in the challenged rules (46), and the Fifth Circuit's opinion quotes the president's sworn declaration as saying its members "hold a wide array of different views and opinions on matters such as politics, race, religion, gender identity, abortion, gun rights, immigration" (47). In those suits "gender identity" is a topic of members' views and a protected category in the challenged policies; the opinions do not describe the views.
- 2020-07-28 (Seventh Circuit No. 19-2807, University of Illinois bias-response team; the panel majority affirmed denial of the injunction) and 2023-05-31 (Fourth Circuit No. 21-2061, Virginia Tech; affirmed): the dissenting judges quote examples from the universities' bias reports (the Fourth Circuit dissent quotes the district court's list of reports). In the Seventh Circuit the partial dissent lists "an instructor 'fail[ing] to use [a student's] preferred gender pronouns and ma[king] statements about gender identity being a matter of choice'"; in the Fourth Circuit the dissent cites a report of a classroom joke that used a public figure's former name, filed as discrimination on the basis of gender identity. These are incidents as the dissenting judges describe them, not findings. (48 and 49)
- 2024-03-04 and 2025-03-03: Justice Thomas, dissenting from the Supreme Court's denial of review in Speech First v. Sands (No. 23-156, Virginia Tech) and Speech First v. Whitten (No. 24-361, Indiana University), argued that the bias-response policies are broad; in No. 24-361 he describes Speech First's members as five Indiana University students holding unpopular views "on issues such as 'gender identity, immigration, affirmative action, and the Israel-Palestine conflict'". (50 and 51)
- 2025-05-14: the Fifth Circuit (No. 23-50633, Speech First v. McCall, Texas State University) wrote that Speech First "contends that this policy will be used to target politically disfavored speech on sensitive topics like abortion, immigration, racial preferences in educational admissions, and transgender ideology", and described its student members as holding, among other views, that the "gender spectrum" is fictional. It held the request for a preliminary injunction not moot and vacated and remanded for the district court to decide it. "Transgender ideology" is the court's wording of Speech First's contention and an anti-trans framing, not a finding. This is the appeal in the case whose complaint is described above. (52)
- Eleventh Circuit order of 2024-08-22: the Eleventh Circuit's order granting the plaintiffs' motion for an injunction pending appeal in State of Alabama v. U.S. Secretary of Education (No. 24-12444; panel of Judges Wilson, Branch and Luck; Judge Wilson dissenting) says the 2024 Title IX rule expands "the definition of discrimination on the 'basis of sex' to include discrimination based on gender identity"; the dissent says "the challenged provisions largely pertain to transgender students, who remain at risk of substantial harm in the face of discrimination the Rule aims to eliminate". The order is dated 2024-08-22 on the plaintiffs' own later citation ("2024 WL 3981994 (11th Cir. Aug. 22)", CA11 doc 122); the copy read carries no date line. The order says an administrative injunction had been granted earlier; the date 2024-07-31 for it comes from the Clearinghouse case page only, and the order gives none. (Order, 11th Cir. No. 24-12444 (copy at 53); CA11 doc 122 (54)
- Formal joint work: Goldwater Institute: Speech First's TY2023 return says it "partnered with the Goldwater Institute to create two model policies" (IRS Form 990 e-file, object id 202413209349306676; no date for the partnership is given).
- 2021-05-24: the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, the Independent Women's Law Center and Speech First, Inc. filed a motion to intervene as defendants (Doc. 35) in The Women's Student Union v. U.S. Department of Education, N.D. Cal. No. 3:21-cv-01626 (Judge Edward M. Chen), a suit brought on 2021-03-08 by a high-school student group against the 2020 Title IX rule that narrowed schools' duties on sexual harassment. The Clearinghouse summary says the three moved "to allegedly protect their interests in safeguarding free speech and due process rights"; the docket shows opposition from the plaintiff and the Department and a reply by the three on 2021-06-21. The summary reports that the court granted the Department's motion to dismiss with leave to amend (2021 WL 3932000); the docket shows that this order of 2021-09-02 (Doc. 75) also vacated the scheduled hearing on the motions to intervene (Doc. 19 and Doc. 35). (55)
- The motion was not decided on its merits. When the amended complaint (Doc. 78, 2021-10-04) came to be decided, the three organizations' motion to intervene before the court was Docket No. 88 (with the State of Texas's, Docket No. 82); the order does not say how No. 88 relates to Doc. 35. By order of 2022-02-16 (Doc. 114, N.D. Cal. No. 3:21-cv-01626-EMC) the court granted the Department's motion to dismiss the first amended complaint for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction because the plaintiff had not shown standing, dismissed it with leave to amend within thirty days, and denied "as moot and without prejudice" the motions to intervene (Docket Nos. 82 and 88), so that the three organizations could file again if a second amended complaint was filed (N.D. Cal. No. 3:21-cv-01626-EMC, Doc. 114, order of 2022-02-16, pages 8 and 19-20). The FIRE case page lists a hearing on 2022-01-20, the dismissal of 2022-02-16 and a deadline of 2022-03-18 for another amended complaint (56, accessed 2026-11-14).
- 2021-07-19: the same three organizations, as petitioners, asked the Supreme Court (No. 21-84) to review the First Circuit's decision of 2021-02-18 (No. 20-1748) upholding the denial (2020-07-27) of their motion of 2020-07-21 to intervene as defendants in Victim Rights Law Center v. DeVos, D. Mass. No. 1:20-cv-11104, another challenge to the 2020 rule. The petition says they "moved to intervene to protect their interests and to advance a legal theory that the Department of Education will not": that any definition of sexual harassment broader than the Davis standard would infringe First Amendment speech. It also says the District of Columbia federal court had let them intervene permissively in Pennsylvania v. DeVos, No. 1:20-cv-01468-CJN (minute order of July 6, 2020). Counsel on the petition: Consovoy McCarthy PLLC and Cooper & Kirk, PLLC. (57)
- The Supreme Court's docket (58), "Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, et al., Petitioners v. Victim Rights Law Center, et al.", lower court First Circuit No. 20-1748 (decided 2021-02-18), docketed 2021-07-21: petition filed 2021-07-19; both respondent groups waived a response on 2021-08-18; amicus briefs of Alliance Defending Freedom, Institute for Justice, Mountain States Legal Foundation and Liberty Justice Center filed 2021-08-20 (the docket entries name no side); response requested 2021-09-01; briefs in opposition from the United States and from the Victim Rights Law Center and its co-respondents filed 2021-11-01; reply 2021-11-15; distributed for conference four times (2021-09-27, 2021-12-03, 2021-12-10 and 2022-01-07), twice rescheduled; "Petition DENIED." on 2022-01-10.
- These suits concerned the 2020 rule's sexual-harassment standard and grievance procedures; neither source reviewed here mentions gender identity.
- 2022-09-09: the Department of Education's docket ED-2021-OCR-0166 (the proposed rule of July 2022, FR Doc 2022-13734) holds comment ED-2021-OCR-0166-174721, organization "Speech First, Inc.", received 2022-09-09 and posted 2022-10-24, with the text "Speech First, Inc. submits its comment on the proposed rule via the attached document." and one attachment titled "Speech First Title IX Comment - Sept 8" (59; comment page 60).
- The attachment (nine pages, dated 2022-09-09, addressed to the Secretary of Education, signed "President, Speech First, Inc.") opposes the proposed rule of July 2022 "in its entirety". Its argument is that the new definition of harassment ("unwelcome sex-based conduct" that is "sufficiently severe or pervasive") would let a single instance of speech be punished, and it says on page 7 that "speech about sex-based issues (which now include controversial topics of public debate such as gender identity)" could be treated as unwelcome. On pages 8 and 9 it argues that the rule would "compel" student speech, naming "preferred pronoun" policies "requiring students to refer to other individuals by their self-described gender identity rather than their biological sex", and says on page 8 that "the Proposed Rule does not provide specific examples of harassment based on gender identity". It cites the Department's 2016 Dear Colleague Letter and its Notice of Interpretation of 22 June 2021 (86 Fed. Reg. 32637), the injunctions against them (Texas v. United States, N.D. Tex. 2016; Tennessee v. United States Department of Education, E.D. Tenn. 15 July 2022) and Meriwether v. Hartop (6th Cir. 2021). It closes (page 9) with the claim that "Millions of students across the country believe that biological sex is immutable and that a person cannot 'transition' from one sex to another" and it compares the proposed rule to the compulsory flag salute struck down in West Virginia Board of Education v. Barnette. The comment does not argue from any harm shown to a student; by its own words the rule gave no example of gender-identity harassment, and the argument is that a rule recognizing gender identity must be fought because it would oblige others to use trans students' names and pronouns. That is anti-trans rhetoric presented as a free-speech argument; the premise that sex "is immutable" is the rhetoric's own, not a finding. The comment names no trans person and no minor. (Attachment 61; page numbers are the comment's own footer numbers.)
- 2023-04-10: order in Speech First v. Shrum (W.D. Okla., Case No. CIV-23-29-J, Doc. 35, 5 pages): the court granted Oklahoma State University's president's motion to dismiss the amended complaint on standing grounds, holding that "Because Plaintiff has failed to name the members on behalf of whom it brings suit, it lacks standing to press the claims asserted here", and dismissed the case without prejudice; the motion for a preliminary injunction was denied as moot. The order decides standing only and does not reach the challenged policies; it does not mention gender identity or pronouns. (Copy hosted by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, 62)
- 2024-02-09: the Tenth Circuit, in No. 23-6054, reversed that dismissal and remanded. It says the sole issue on appeal was "whether the use of pseudonyms by the declarants precluded Speech First from establishing Article III standing", that three members had each filed a pseudonymous declaration (Students A, B and C), and that "anonymous persons may have standing to bring claims"; it reads Summers v. Earth Island Institute, 555 U.S. 488 (2009), as not addressing anonymity (opinion, copy hosted by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, 63). The opinion decides standing only.
- Speech First, Inc. v. Khator (S.D. Tex., No. 4:22-cv-00582), preliminary injunction ruling (FindLaw copy, 64): the University of Houston's Policy 1 says students will be disciplined if they "subject an individual on the basis of their membership in a protected class to unlawful severe, pervasive, or persistent treatment"; "On May 13, 2022, the University changed its policy. The amendments to the policy eliminate the definition of behavior that constitutes harassment." The University argued that Speech First lacked standing because it had no evidence that the students whose speech was restricted intended to target other students. The ruling's discussion of the policy does not mention gender identity or pronouns.
What the records don't show
- What Speech First's other cases concern: its pages for Speech First v. McCall, Shrum, Khator and Sands concern campus harassment, bias-response and computer-use policies (Texas State, Oklahoma State, Houston, Virginia Tech); none concerns protections for trans people, although the McCall, Shrum, Khator and Sands complaints plead students' anti-trans beliefs as the speech at stake (see Ties). The McCall page lists gender identity among the protected traits of the challenged policy and uses the words 'gender ideology' in its discussion of chilled speech.
- Who funds it beyond the givers named on other filers' returns.
Open questions
- When did the merger into Defending Education, and the transfer of Speech First's legal rights in its court cases, take effect? (Neither organization's page gives a date; both filed separate Forms 990 for the period ending 2025-12-31; the records hold no Schedule N.)
- How did the district case, N.D. Ala. 7:24-cv-00533, end on 2026-05-29 (a notice of voluntary dismissal or an order), and what does that docket entry say? (Start: the CourtListener docket, 65)
- Which federal Title IX lawsuits did Speech First move to intervene in during 2021 (TY2021 Part III), and which document is its comment of 2021 to the Department of Education? Partly answered for the lawsuits: two suits are documented above (The Women's Student Union v. U.S. Department of Education, N.D. Cal. No. 3:21-cv-01626, and Victim Rights Law Center v. DeVos, D. Mass. No. 1:20-cv-11104, with a permissive intervention in Pennsylvania v. DeVos, D.D.C. No. 1:20-cv-01468-CJN), and its comment on the 2022 proposed rule is docketed as ED-2021-OCR-0166-174721; what that comment says about gender identity is set out above; it is a 2022 filing, and no document is cited as the 2021 comment, which is the part still open. (Start: the Department's 2021 hearing notice, 34, and the dockets of the 2021 Title IX cases.)
Sources
Read: IRS Form 990 e-files for EIN 82-3599047 (5); IRS Exempt Organizations Business Master File; Bader Family Foundation Form 990-PF filings (6); Defending Education page on Speech First (2); Clearinghouse summary of State of Alabama v. Cardona (3); the court dockets, filings and public pages cited above.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- https://defendinged.org/speech-first-and-defending-education-join-forces-to-expand-the-shared-mission-of-fighting-for-the-first-amendment-in-education/
- https://defendinged.org/speech-first/
- https://www.clearinghouse.net/case/45609
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68483533/alabama-state-of-v-cardona/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/823599047
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/276359747
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/110303001
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/202466871
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/237327730
- https://philanthropydaily.com/the-heritage-foundation-awards-new-innovation-prizes/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/237825575
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/311640316
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/454678325
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/522166327
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/527082731
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/510172279
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/581691765
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/203672969
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/367244615
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/251113452
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/133598005
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/
- https://speechfirst.org/news/bidens-new-title-ix-rule-is-the-beginning-of-the-end-for-free-speech/
- https://www.independentwomen.com/2026/06/03/independent-womens-law-center-secures-major-victory-against-biden-title-ix-rewrite/
- https://adflegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/alabama-v-us-secretary-of-education-2026-05-27-order-dismissing-appeal.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955.101.0.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955.107.0.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955.111.0.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955.122.0.pdf
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/861596460
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/823599047/202611499349301516/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/861596460/202612159349301091/full.
- https://web.archive.org/web/20261017074948/https://speechfirst.org/
- https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2021-05-20/pdf/2021-10629.pdf
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/823599047.
- https://media.reclaimthenet.org/speech-first-vs-mccall.pdf)
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Complaint-Filed-1.pdf
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/1_Complaint-1.pdf
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/VTComplaintApril7.pdf
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/IU-As-filed-complaint-1-1.pdf
- https://defendinged.org/lawsuits/speech-first-v-whitten-et-al/
- https://defendinged.org/lawsuits/speech-first-v-shrum-et-al/
- https://defendinged.org/lawsuits/speech-first-v-khator-et-al/
- https://defendinged.org/lawsuits/speech-first-v-sands-et-al/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/7332093/speech-first-inc-v-schlissel/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/7336272/speech-first-inc-v-fenves/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4801276/speech-first-incorporated-v-gregory-fenves/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4771280/speech-first-inc-v-timothy-l-killeen/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9403633/speech-first-inc-v-timothy-sands/.
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9480637/speech-first-inc-v-sands/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10348568/speech-first-inc-v-whitten/.
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10584088/speech-first-v-mccall/.
- https://alabamaag.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/CA11-Op-Granting-IPA.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955/gov.uscourts.ca11.87955.122.0.pdf)
- https://clearinghouse.net/case/18144/
- https://www.fire.org/cases/womens-student-union-v-us-department-education
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/21/21-84/184255/20210719151522474_USSC%20Petition%20for%20Writ%20of%20Certiorari.pdf
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/21-84.html
- https://api.regulations.gov/v4/comments/ED-2021-OCR-0166-174721?include=attachments
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2021-OCR-0166-174721
- https://downloads.regulations.gov/ED-2021-OCR-0166-174721/attachment_1.pdf
- https://www.uschamber.com/assets/documents/Lower-Court-Order-Speech-First-Inc.-v.-Shrum-W.D.-Okla.pdf
- https://www.uschamber.com/assets/documents/Opinion-Speech-First-Inc.-v.-Shrum-10th-Cir.pdf
- https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/us-dis-crt-s-d-tex/2173142.html
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68483533/alabama-state-of-v-cardona/.