![Organization: Schaerr Jaffe LLP [DC DLCP registry number P00005333031]](assets/profiles/org_schaerr_jaffe.png)
Schaerr Jaffe LLP
Washington, D.C. litigation boutique (offices in Washington, San Francisco, Los Angeles and Salt Lake City per its site). It appears in this project as a paid outside counsel of America First Legal Foundation and as the registered lobbyist of Rebel News in 2022. Court records name it as counsel for the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities, an intervenor defending Title IX's religious exemption against a challenge by LGBTQ+ students (the LGBTQ+ students' case against the U.S. Department of Education); the records show who pays it, not what each payment bought.
What the firm says it is
- "A Washington D.C. boutique law firm specializing in high-profile trial and appellate litigation" (2, 2026-11-10). Practice pages: U.S. Supreme Court, appellate, trial, media, investigations, governmental and regulatory affairs. Its media page lists "Defense against defamation claims", "Defense against efforts to block programming" and "Filing of lawsuits to prevent the de-platforming of assets" with no client named (3).
- Its "Representative Clients" page lists, among others, the States of Georgia, Indiana, North Carolina, Utah, Idaho, Louisiana, Alabama and Alaska "as parties" and about half the states as amici; religious institutions; and religious higher education including the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities. The religious-institutions section refers to a "Title IX religious exemption" practice; no client or case is tied to it on that page. It does not list Rebel News or America First Legal. (4)
- Registry: District of Columbia professional entity P00005333031, formed 2016-02-03, "Active - In Good Standing"; Texas taxpayer 32094941914; FEIN 81-1378264 as given in Labor Department visa filings; House lobbying registrant 44521 and Senate 401105389; FARA registration 7526 (active). (District of Columbia DLCP business registry; Texas taxpayer records; U.S. Department of Labor OFLC visa disclosure data; House and Senate lobbying disclosures, 5; Department of Justice FARA registrations, 6)
Lawyers the firm presents
Attorney directory (7): partners Gene Schaerr, Erik S. Jaffe, H. Christopher Bartolomucci, Donald M. Falk, Jeffrey W. Munk, Brian J. Field and Edward H. Trent; senior counsel Charles B. Burnett and Nicholas P. Miller; counsel Hannah Smith, James A. Heilpern, Stephanie L. Freudenberg and Joshua J. Prince; academic affiliates including Thomas R. Lee and Eugene Volokh.
- Gene Schaerr: his firm biography lists a post as Associate Counsel to the President, White House, 1991-1993 (8). Wikipedia dates the appointment 1991-04-17 and says Utah chose him as outside counsel to defend its ban on same-sex marriage in Kitchen v. Herbert (2014; Utah Attorney General press release dated 2014-10-28 cited there) and that he filed an amicus brief in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) for 100 scholars of marriage (9). These are same-sex-marriage matters, given as context, not trans matters. He testified on the firm's behalf at a congressional hearing on court packing in 2026 (congressional hearing record).
- Jeffrey Munk is the signatory on the firm's 2025 FARA short form (FARA 7526, 10). LittleSis lists Mark Paoletta and Ken Klukowski as positions at the firm (LittleSis 418317, secondary); neither is on the firm's attorney page (7, accessed 2026-11-16).
- Mark Paoletta: the President-elect's statement of 2024-12-09 says "Mark is a partner at the Law Firm, Schaerr Jaffe" and that he will return as General Counsel of the Office of Management and Budget (The American Presidency Project, 11). The Plum Book record lists him as General Counsel, Executive Office of the President, Office of Management and Budget, dated 2025-01-27 (Plum Book, 12), and the firm's attorney page does not list him, so he is no longer a partner at the firm. He is listed on a firm lobbying filing for the period ending 2023-12-31 and appeared as a witness for the firm on 2022-04-27 and 2022-12-08 (House hearing records and lobbying disclosures, 5). Ken Klukowski: a firm House lobbying filing dated 2022-03-31 lists him as a lobbyist with the titles "Special Counsel for the Office of Management and Budget; Senior Counsel, DOJ Civil Division" (lobbying disclosure, 5); he is not on the firm's attorney page (7, accessed 2026-11-16). The firm's biography page for him, as captured on 2023-04-01 (archive copy, 13), says "Ken Klukowski is senior counsel at Schaerr Jaffe LLP" and lists his earlier posts: "senior counsel in the Civil Division of the U.S. Department of Justice", "special counsel in the Office of Management and Budget" and "senior advisor for constitutional rights on the policy staff of the Presidential Transition Team of President Donald J. Trump". Two Federal Election Commission contribution records dated 2024-05-03 and 2024-05-17 (committee C00001305, 14) give 'SCHAERR JAFFE LLP' as the employer and 'LAWYER' as the occupation of a contributor of his name; the employer line is the contributor's own statement. A later archive copy of the same biography page (15, captured 2025-01-15, 16) gives him the title "Senior Counsel" and says he "is senior counsel at Schaerr Jaffe LLP"; it lists as earlier appointed posts senior counsel in the Civil Division of the U.S. Department of Justice and, before that, special counsel in the Office of Management and Budget. The same copy carries firm news items, one of them dated August 20, 2024. That capture shows the firm presenting him as senior counsel after the May 2024 contribution records.
Money received
Source unless stated: IRS Form 990-series e-file of the payer, EIN as shown (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 17 followed by the payer's EIN digits). Payer matched by EIN; the firm by name (payee EIN is not on contractor schedules; two grant rows carry EIN 81-1378264).
Payers in this project
| Payer (EIN) | Profile | 2023 | 2024 | Purpose as filed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| America First Legal Foundation (86-2190372) | the America First Legal Foundation page | $314,738 | $404,757 | "Legal Services"; "Outside Counsel" |
| Rebel News (House LD-2 client, lobbying registrant 44521) | the Rebel News Network Ltd page | 2022: $10,000 (Q1) | "Issues related to banking practices, including support for H.R. 1729 and S. 563, the Fair Access to Banking Act" |
Rebel News: one House engagement row dated 2022-03-31, $10,000, and two registration rows with no amount (House lobbying disclosures, registrant 44521, 5); the subject is banking access; the firm filed a termination report for the client for the quarter ending 2023-03-31. The client is matched by name only (no identifier on the rows).
Other payers on the returns (no profile in this project)
- Project for Privacy and Surveillance Accountability (84-2387106): $618,584 (2019), $944,235 (2020), $1,250,633 (2022), $1,309,288 (2023), $1,679,244 (2024), "LEGAL SERVICES"; also its lobbying client, eight years of House rows, $2,280,000.
- Protect the 1st (86-1181131) $423,005 (2021 and 2022 filings), $459,297 (2023), $473,680 to $496,530 (2024); Protect the First Foundation (87-1163444) $369,361 (2024). Where two rows for one year show different figures they are different schedules of the same return and are not added.
- Airline Employees 4 Health Freedom (87-2507103) $1,652,289 (2022), $644,793 (2023), $1,772,272 (2024), $418,521 (2025); Council for Christian Colleges and Universities (52-1247182) $453,239 (2022), $332,685 (2023), $156,082 (2024), "LEGAL SERVICES"/"Legal work"; America First Policy Institute (85-4202763) $567,663 (2024), "LITIGATION"; Firearms Policy Coalition (47-2460415) $109,325 to $147,858 (2020-2023); North Carolina Farm Bureau Legal Foundation $51,304 (2022, amicus brief); Center of the American Experiment (36-3611426) $99,900 (2024, "Community Support", payee EIN 81-1378264).
- Lobbying clients 2021-2026 include Project Veritas (7 rows, $100,000, FBI raid on its offices), Oracle America ($990,000), Entergy, Southern Methodist University (Title IX and name-image-likeness bills) and The Democracy Fund, a Canadian charity (2025, no amount).
- FARA: registration 7526 lists a foreign principal, the Ministry of Financial Services and Commerce of the Cayman Islands (2025-2026 filings).
- Campaign payers (payee matched by name only): Meuser for Congress (FEC C00654723, 18) $6,984.88 (2025) and Tiffany for Wisconsin (FEC C00718635, 19) $6,984.88 (2024, printed "Schaerr Jaffee LLP"). The two FEC records show identical amounts, which may be a repeat entry.
Governments
The firm's client page lists eight states "as parties"; it does not show the matters or any fees.
- Reporting on two states: Two states, from reporting. Mississippi: Mississippi Today (republished on OurTupelo, 2021-12-02) reports a contract with the firm for February 2020 to 28 February 2023, capped at $450,000 (raised from $300,000), at $385 an hour for partners, $285 for associates and $125 for paralegals, and that "as of early August" 2021 the state had paid the firm $369,537 since April 2020; the Attorney General's chief of staff said the firm did no work on the Dobbs case argued at the Supreme Court and was working on a different abortion case in the lower courts, which the article does not name. Indiana: the Indiana Capital Chronicle (Casey Smith, 2024-05-29, via Inside INdiana Business) reports that the Attorney General's office first signed a contract with the firm in 2020 for one federal case and has amended it six times to add other matters, including defending Attorney General Todd Rokita's law license in a Disciplinary Commission matter; the office released 86 pages of invoices (August 2022 to October 2023; an earlier batch of 44 pages was heavily redacted); May 2023 billing exceeded $105,000, much of it attributed to the Bernard case (the state's medical-licensing case against Dr Caitlin Bernard); and the office said "We will continue using Schaerr Jaffe as this office has done throughout multiple administrations". Mississippi is not among the states that page lists (Georgia, Indiana, North Carolina, Utah, Idaho, Louisiana, Alabama, Alaska; 20). [Mississippi Today via OurTupelo, 21; Inside INdiana Business, 22
Money given
Republican Attorneys General Association (527, EIN 46-4501717): 2021 $27,500; 2022 $25,000; 2023 $75,200; 2024 $75,575; 2025 $75,000. Republican National Lawyers Association $2,500 (2024); Todd Rokita Election Committee (Indiana) $1,000 (2022). (IRS 527 and Indiana filings.)
Federal lobbying
- For the client PROTECT THE 1ST, INC. (2021 first to fourth quarters; income reported by the firm $20,000, $20,000, $40,000, $10,000; $90,000 in all, the second-quarter amendment counted once), the filings state the client's issue as: "Protect the 1st also lobbied with respect to certain portions of H.R. 5, the Equality Act, that threaten Americans religious liberty, and analogous portions of a competing bill, H.R.1440 or the Fairness for All Act, that would protect religious liberty." The filings were made by the registrant, Schaerr Jaffe LLP (Washington DC), for the client; the issue stated is the client's, and the firm is named only as filer. Filings 2d735c2e-5076-4c74-8ff4-babc75bc08ba (Q1), c8d5e172-ad12-4d6f-9242-715f46822e09 (Q2), 0d492e6b-81c7-4efe-b663-005653fc8f35 (Q2 amendment), 3893a2cf-8856-4b14-ba72-333580f9c2af (Q3), a73ee55a-2b34-45cb-85a8-6a55dd915b6b (Q4). [lobbying disclosure database, 23
- Schaerr Jaffe LLP filed 8 federal lobbying filings (a registration and seven reports, 2025 first quarter to 2026 third quarter) for Southern Methodist University that list "Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972" with name-image-likeness and antisemitism bills, with no position stated and no mention of trans people. [filings 71a1359d-e840-43a6-b6a0-5fece9e9c2ed, 1cf27918-ace2-4fc8-a1c0-3edac46c14ee, 28912622-e9ae-4ce5-9008-382b8128307d, 65b5d337-d616-4444-8ae8-563b83e9cb23, 5f5220bd-bf7d-4c84-833a-99876aa56339, 862634de-6ac4-41d5-a7ea-90337d56537c, ff516c56-a1f5-4898-80e0-a518dc0dd5a3, b966e94a-205f-4c29-8713-b81edd3be446]
Name variants
Accepted: "SCHAERR JAFFE LLP", "Schaerr Jaffe LLC" (printed on Protect the 1st returns), "Schaerr-Jaffe LLP" (FARA), "Schaerr Jaffee LLP" (campaign payee, name-only), "Schaerr Jaffe" (grant row with EIN 81-1378264).
Anti-trans work: documented moments
- 2021 to 2024-08-30: the LGBTQ+ students' case against the U.S. Department of Education, D. Or. No. 6:21-cv-00474-AA (Judge Ann Aiken), appeal Ninth Circuit No. 23-35174. The Ninth Circuit's summary describes it as an action brought by LGBTQ+ students against the Department of Education challenging the religious exemption to Title IX, which prohibits sex discrimination at federally funded schools but exempts religious institutions whose tenets require it; Volokh Conspiracy describes the plaintiffs as forty LGBTQ+ people who applied to, attended or attend religious colleges and universities. The Council for Christian Colleges & Universities, Western Baptist College (Corban University), William Jessup University and Phoenix Seminary were intervenor-defendants. Volokh's post of 2023-01-12 names three lawyers of Schaerr Jaffe LLP, with a lawyer in Oregon, as representing the intervenor Council for Christian Colleges & Universities in the district court; the Ninth Circuit opinion lists two lawyers of Schaerr Jaffe LLP, one of whom argued, with Alliance Defending Freedom lawyers, for the intervenor-defendants-appellees. Outcome: the district court dismissed the claims (plaintiffs' equal protection, Establishment Clause, First Amendment and RFRA claims rejected, per Volokh) and the Ninth Circuit, argued 2024-07-16, affirmed on 2024-08-30, holding that the exemption does not violate the Establishment Clause and, applying intermediate scrutiny, affirming dismissal of the equal protection claim, and finding no standing for the challenge to the Department's regulations. (Ninth Circuit opinion, the LGBTQ+ students' case against the U.S. Department of Education, No. 23-35174, filed 2024-08-30 (cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov); Volokh Conspiracy, reason.com, 2023-01-12.)
- Context: Kitchen v. Herbert (2014) and the Obergefell amicus brief (2015) as above (9), same-sex marriage matters. Which of the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities payments ($942,006 across the returns for the fiscal years ending June 2022, 2023 and 2024) were for the LGBTQ+ students' case is not established.
- Council payments and the LGBTQ+ students' case, period labels and docket: Period labels: the three Council for Christian Colleges and Universities payments are on returns for periods ending 2022-06-30 ($453,239, "LEGAL SERVICES", object 202341309349304044), 2023-06-30 ($332,685, "Legal work", object 202411369349304191) and 2024-06-30 ($156,082, "Legal Services", object 202531339349304068). The page's "TY2022, TY2023, TY2024" are the period-end years (the IRS tax years on those returns are 2021, 2022 and 2023). The Council's return for the period ending 2021-06-30 (object 202241309349301459) lists no payment to the firm (the contractor list holds only payees over $100,000). The case's dated docket: the Council's motion to intervene was filed 2021-05-12 (Dkt. 26; the case page lists an Oregon lawyer for the Council and three Schaerr Jaffe LLP lawyers among the attorneys; the Council's own news item of 2021-05-12 says it filed a motion to participate in the case and a motion to dismiss); the Oregon intervenors (Corban University, William Jessup University, Phoenix Seminary) moved on 2021-04-09; the court granted intervention on 2021-10-08 and the motion to dismiss on 2023-01-12; plaintiffs appealed on 2023-03-13 (Clearinghouse docket page; Ninth Circuit No. 23-35174 as on the page). All three payment periods overlap the case (July 2021 to June 2024), but the returns do not say what each payment covered, and the payments can include other work; the amount for that case alone is not established. No other litigation by the firm for the Council or other religious colleges over the Title IX religious exemption is documented in the sources reviewed here. [IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 52-1247182, 24; 25; the Council's own news update on the case (Council for Christian Colleges and Universities news list, 26, item of 2021-05-12, accessed 2026-11-17; the item's own address was not captured)]
- America First Legal Foundation's payments: America First Legal Foundation's returns list payments to the firm as "Legal Services" and "Outside Counsel" lines ($314,738 in 2023 and $404,757 in 2024 as filed). America First Legal Foundation is listed as co-counsel with the firm in International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc. v. Ferguson (below). What the payments covered is not established. [IRS Form 990 e-files, America First Legal Foundation, EIN 86-2190372, 27
- Docket entry 26 in the LGBTQ+ students' case against the U.S. Department of Education, who filed the Council's intervention motion: The district court docket, as reproduced by the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse from the court's electronic record, lists entry 26, dated 2021-05-12: "Motion to Intervene. Oral Argument requested. Filed by Council for Christian Colleges & Universities." with three exhibits, entered under the name of a lawyer for the Council. On 2021-05-13 three lawyers of Schaerr Jaffe LLP each moved for leave to appear pro hac vice for the Council (entries 27, 28, 29). Later Council filings were entered under that lawyer (reply on the motion to intervene, 2021-06-23; response to the motion for a temporary restraining order, 2021-08-09) and under a lawyer of the firm (motion for leave to file a motion to dismiss, 2021-08-18; motion for leave to file an opposition to the motion for a temporary restraining order, 2021-08-24). The docket text names the lawyer who entered each filing, not the signature block. (25) The filing itself, "Proposed Defendant-Intervenor CCCU's Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support" (Document 26, filed 2021-05-12, with oral argument requested, p. 1), carries one electronic signature, that of the Oregon lawyer for the Council, dated 12 May 2021. Beneath it the three Schaerr|Jaffe LLP lawyers are listed on the signature block as "Counsel for Defendant-Intervenor Council for Christian Colleges & Universities", each marked with an asterisk that reads "Pro hac vice application forthcoming" (p. 29 of 31); the certificate of service on p. 30 is signed by the Oregon lawyer alone. So the firm is on the signature block as the Council's counsel, but its lawyers were not yet admitted in the case and did not sign electronically on that filing; their pro hac vice motions followed on 2021-05-13 (entries 27 to 29). The later steps of the case (intervention granted 2021-10-08, claims dismissed 2023-01-12, appeal) are as given above. (U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon, No. 6:21-cv-00474-AA, Document 26, 2021-05-12, pp. 1, 29, 30, 28)
- What the Council's motion to intervene says (the same filing, Document 26 of 2021-05-12, pp. 7-9, 13-14, 19-21, 29, 28): the motion says the Council represents "over one hundred colleges controlled by religious organizations" and asks to intervene as of right or, alternatively, by permission, to defend the Title IX religious exemption against the plaintiffs' claim that it is unconstitutional "as applied to LGBT students". It says that removing the exemption "as applied to LGBT students or otherwise, will deprive religious colleges of the oxygen that gives them life", and argues that the federal defendants will not defend the exemption adequately because the Administration "has already promised to 'reverse' what it calls the 'misuse of broad exemptions' to 'discriminate against LGBTQ+ people'" (the Council's words, citing the Biden-Harris campaign page). It quotes the plaintiffs' requested relief as, among other things, "requiring the government to respect the sexual orientations and gender identities of all students at all federally funded institutions" (Compl., Dkt. 1, at 66), and pleads that its members hold "core religious tenets on gender and sexuality" that would conflict with Title IX if "sex" were read to include "sexual orientation" and "gender identity". These are the Council's words in its own filing; the effect sought is a carve-out that lets federally funded colleges treat LGBTQ+ students, trans students included, differently.
- A second Title IX religious-exemption case, amicus brief in an appeal against Fuller Theological Seminary: 2021-06-21: four lawyers of Schaerr | Jaffe LLP, one of them counsel of record, signed a brief of amici curiae for the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities, Agudath Israel of America, the Coalition for Jewish Values, the International Alliance for Christian Education and 32 religious colleges and universities, supporting the defendants-appellees in a Title IX religious-exemption appeal against Fuller Theological Seminary, Ninth Circuit No. 20-56156 (appeal from C.D. Cal. No. 2:19-cv-09969). The brief describes the case as beginning when the appellants claimed that Fuller violated Title IX "when it expelled them for entering same-sex marriages". It argues that "Title IX’s religious exemption is constitutionally required whenever a student at a religious college or university challenges that institution’s decision to discipline the student for violating its standards on sexuality or gender." This is the amici's argument for a religious exemption, not a finding. It cites the Council's own page on the LGBTQ+ students' case against the U.S. Department of Education (dated May 12, 2021). (Brief as published by the Coalition for Jewish Values, 29) Which payments from the Council to the firm, if any, covered this brief is not stated in any source reviewed here. The Ninth Circuit, argued and submitted 2021-11-18, affirmed the dismissal on 2021-12-13 in a memorandum marked "NOT FOR PUBLICATION" (not precedent except as Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3 provides). It held that Title IX's religious exemption does not require the controlling religious organization to be legally separate from the school, and that the seminary's differential treatment of same-sex marriages "fell squarely within Title IX's religious exemption", so dismissal with prejudice was proper (pp. 2 to 8 of the memorandum; the quoted words are on p. 8). The case concerned students expelled for same-sex marriages, not trans people. (Memorandum, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 20-56156 (appeal from C.D. Cal. No. 2:19-cv-09969), 2021-12-13, p. 8; 30)
- A further filing in the same line of work: on 2023-03-30 the firm filed a petition-stage brief of the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities as amicus curiae supporting the petitioner in The School of the Ozarks, Inc. (College of the Ozarks) v. Biden, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 22-816 (on petition from the Eighth Circuit, No. 21-2270). The brief's cover names the firm as "Counsel for Amicus Curiae", with one of its lawyers as counsel of record (PDF p. 1). The questions presented concern whether a notice-and-comment violation alone gives a regulated entity Article III standing (PDF p. 2). The brief's introduction says: "The executive branch's redefinition of the term 'sex' to include sexual orientation and gender identity across a range of federal statutes poses a grave and imminent threat, not just to Petitioner, but to religious colleges across the country." (PDF p. 7), and its first argument heading is "Religious Exemptions to the Fair Housing Act, Title VII, and Title IX Are Vital to Religious Colleges' Missions." (PDF p. 11). The brief treats recognition of gender identity in federal law as a threat; that is the amicus's anti-trans rhetoric, not a finding. It is a case on the Fair Housing Act and a Department of Housing and Urban Development notice (the brief itself is about the standing question and the exemptions), not a Title IX religious-exemption suit; the Title IX exemption appears as one of three exemptions the brief says are at risk. Amicus filing only. The Supreme Court denied the petition on 2023-06-20; the Council's brief is entered on the docket on 2023-03-30 without a description. (Brief of the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities as Amicus Curiae Supporting Petitioner, No. 22-816, 2023-03-30, PDF pp. 1, 2, 7, 11; 31; Supreme Court docket No. 22-816, 32)
- 2022-09-12 (posted 2022-11-08): Schaerr | Jaffe LLP is the counsel listed in the signature block of three comments that Independent Women's Law Center and Independent Women's Forum filed on the Department of Education's proposed Title IX rule (docket ED-2021-OCR-0166, comment titled "Comment on FR Doc # 2022-13734"). One argues the proposed rule's addition of "gender" and "gender identity" is an "assault on the separation of powers" and should be withdrawn (33); one objects that the proposed definition of harassment would punish speech, and says that redefining "sex" to include "gender" and "gender identity" is wrong (34); one argues the rule would harm "parental rights" (35). Each is signed for the two bodies; the firm appears as co-counsel under the Independent Women's Law Center's lawyer. The arguments quoted here are the commenters' anti-trans rhetoric, not findings.
- 2023-05-03 (filed in the docket 2023-05-15): an exhibit to Alliance Defending Freedom's comments on the Department's proposed athletics rule (docket ED-2022-OCR-0143) reproduces an amicus brief filed in a Fourth Circuit appeal involving a minor, United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, No. 23-1078, in which the firm is listed as counsel for the amicus Independent Women's Law Center. Cited by court and docket number only.
- 2023-05-15 (posted 2023-05-19): the same two bodies filed a comment on the Department's proposed athletics rule (docket ED-2022-OCR-0143), again with the firm in the signature block (36).
- 2023-05-15: the comment of the Governor of South Dakota and the South Dakota Department of Education on the same athletics proposal, "Seeking Withdrawal of Proposed Title IX Athletics Rulemaking", opposes the proposed rule and says South Dakota will defend its 2022 law limiting girls' teams to "female students, based on their biological sex". From its second page on, the comment's page headers carry the letterhead of Schaerr | Jaffe LLP (a partner's contact block and the firm's website): the firm's name is on the filing (37).
- 2023-11-13: Schaerr|Jaffe LLP, with the Independent Women's Law Center, was counsel for four amici (Independent Women's Forum, Women's Liberation Front, Concerned Women for America and Women's Declaration International USA) on a petition-stage brief supporting the school district in Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-392. The cover names the firm as counsel for the amici, with one of its lawyers as counsel of record (PDF p. 1). The amici asked the Court to grant the petition against a Seventh Circuit ruling (No. 22-1786) that a trans boy could use the boys' bathroom. The brief argues that Title IX and its regulations permit bathrooms by sex, that Bostock does not apply to Title IX, and that rational-basis or intermediate scrutiny should let the policy stand. It says: "Amici write to emphasize three reasons that this Court should grant review" (PDF p. 11) and "Bostock does not govern the application of Title IX to school bathroom policies for three reasons:" (PDF p. 14). It asserts, without citing evidence in that passage, that sex-separated bathrooms serve an interest against "sanctioned voyeurism and exhibitionism" (PDF p. 28), an assertion that casts trans students as a danger. In a footnote it asserts: "'Sex' refers to the objective, observable differences between male and female that reflect reproductive potential. And sex is not 'assigned' at birth-it is observed at birth." (PDF p. 8), and in the text that recognizing gender identity in Title IX "threatens to erase women" (PDF p. 8); both are the amici's anti-trans rhetoric, not findings. The Supreme Court docket for No. 23-392 shows the amici's brief filed 2023-11-13 and the entry "Petition DENIED." on 2024-01-16, which left the Seventh Circuit ruling in place. (Brief for Independent Women's Forum, Women's Liberation Front, Concerned Women for America, and Women's Declaration International USA as Amici Curiae in Support of Petitioner, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-392, 2023-11-13, PDF pp. 1, 8, 11, 14, 28; Supreme Court docket No. 23-392)
- 2024-04-16: In the Fourth Circuit's published opinion in the West Virginia anti-trans sports law case brought on behalf of a minor transgender girl (Nos. 23-1078 and 23-1130), the counsel listing gives Schaerr | Jaffe LLP, with the Independent Women's Law Center, as counsel for the amicus curiae Independent Women's Law Center, among the amici listed in support of the defendants (the State and the school bodies). The same listing gives the National Association of Evangelicals, with the Thomas More Society, among those amici. The court dismissed No. 23-1130 and, in No. 23-1078, vacated in part, reversed in part and remanded with instructions to grant summary judgment to the minor plaintiff on her Title IX claim. What the firm's brief argued is not stated here. (Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, Nos. 23-1078 and 23-1130, filed 2024-04-16, counsel listing and first pages)
- 2024-06-09: In the First Circuit's opinion in a public middle school dress-code case (No. 23-1645), the counsel listing gives the firm, with the Independent Women's Law Center, as counsel for the amicus curiae Independent Women's Law Center. The case concerns the "hate speech" provision of the school's dress code as applied to a student's t-shirt carrying an anti-trans message (the student is a minor and is not named here); the shirt's message is the student's anti-trans slogan, not a finding. The First Circuit affirmed the District Court's rulings on the ground that the school could rely on Tinker's "material disruption" limitation, "albeit on somewhat different grounds", except for one facial claim, for which it found the student lacked Article III standing. What the amicus brief argued is not stated here. (Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, No. 23-1645, filed 2024-06-09, pp. 1 to 4 and counsel listing)
- 2024-09-09: In the Ninth Circuit's published opinion in a challenge to Arizona's anti-trans law titled the Save Women's Sports Act (No. 23-16026, consolidated with 23-16030), the counsel listing gives Schaerr Jaffe LLP, with the Independent Women's Law Center, as counsel for the amicus curiae Independent Women's Law Center (p. 7; the listing names lawyers, so it is not quoted). What the brief argued is not stated here. The panel affirmed the preliminary injunction against enforcing the Act against the plaintiffs, holding that the district court did not clearly err in its factual findings and that the ban likely fails heightened scrutiny; it did not reach the Title IX claim. The Supreme Court vacated this Ninth Circuit judgment on 2026-06-30 and remanded for further consideration in light of its decision in a West Virginia case on that state's anti-trans sports law. (Opinion of the Ninth Circuit, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Nos. 23-16026, 23-16030, 2024-09-09, p. 7)
- 2025-02-18: In the First Circuit's opinion in the case brought by parents against a school committee over a middle school's unwritten protocol of not telling parents about a student's gender-related expression without the student's consent (No. 23-1069; the student is a minor and is not named), the counsel listing gives the firm, with the Independent Women's Law Center, as counsel for the amicus curiae Independent Women's Law Center; the same listing names Alliance Defending Freedom, Advancing American Freedom, Parental Rights Foundation, Goldwater Institute and National Legal Foundation (as counsel for five amici) as other amici for the parents. The court held that the parents had "failed to state a claim" that the protocol violated their constitutional right to direct the upbringing of their child, said the protocol "bears a rational relationship to the legitimate objective of promoting a safe and inclusive environment for students", and affirmed the dismissal, with costs to the appellees. A petition for certiorari in this case is Supreme Court No. 25-77. (Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, No. 23-1069, filed 2025-02-18, counsel listing, pp. 44 to 46)
- International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc. v. Ferguson (Ninth Circuit No. 24-3661; Supreme Court No. 25-840). Schaerr Jaffe LLP is listed as counsel for the plaintiffs-appellants, two national nonprofit organizations and five sets of parents suing under pseudonyms, with Mitchell Law PLLC and America First Legal Foundation; the Ninth Circuit's opinion of 2025-07-25 gives the counsel line as "Schaerr Jaffe LLP, Washington, D.C." (p. 4). The plaintiffs challenged three Washington laws on minors' access to mental health care and shelter services, particularly for transgender minors, under the Due Process, Free Exercise and Free Speech Clauses, and asked for "a declaration that the Statutes are unconstitutional and an injunction preventing their enforcement" (p. 17). The panel held that the plaintiffs had not shown Article III standing and affirmed the dismissal: "we agree with the district court that Plaintiffs have failed to demonstrate standing under Article III, and we affirm the dismissal of their action." (p. 25). The Supreme Court granted certiorari on 2026-06-29. In the petitioners' merits brief of 2026-09-08, filed through First Liberty Institute and Schaerr Jaffe LLP, the petitioners ask the Court to reverse the Ninth Circuit ("The Ninth Circuit should be reversed.", p. 69). The brief asserts that the Washington laws cause "concrete harms arising from Washington laws that deliberately lure children to run away when they disagree with their parents on gender identity." (p. 15). The brief also uses the phrase "gender confusion" for transgender minors' identities: it describes outpatient mental health treatment for minors aged 13 and over as including "psychological therapy to affirm gender confusion" (p. 21) and asserts in a footnote that referral to affirming counseling is "cementing" a confusion (p. 22); these are the petitioners' anti-trans rhetoric, reported as their claims and not as findings; gender-affirming care is supported by the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Endocrine Society and the American Medical Association. Case status: the panel affirmed the dismissal on 2025-07-25; rehearing was denied on 2025-12-05. The Supreme Court granted certiorari in No. 25-840 on 2026-06-29; argument is set for 2026-12-07 and no decision was listed as of the docket entry of 2026-11-09. (Opinion of the court, International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc. v. Ferguson, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 24-3661, 2025-07-25, p. 4) (Brief for the Petitioners, International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc. v. Ferguson, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-840, 2026-09-08, p. 15)
Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext
The sources cited on this page record the firm's filings as counsel and the arguments of its clients and amici; they carry no separate evidence about the firm's own motives, and none is claimed.
Ties
- Funding: America First Legal Foundation (payments above); Council for Christian Colleges and Universities (payments above; also formal joint work below); Project for Privacy and Surveillance Accountability; Protect the 1st.
- Formal joint work: counsel for the intervenor Council for Christian Colleges & Universities in the LGBTQ+ students' case against the U.S. Department of Education (D. Or. 6:21-cv-00474-AA; Ninth Circuit 23-35174), documented by the Ninth Circuit opinion and Volokh Conspiracy.
- Appearance or listing: Independent Women's Law Center: counsel for the amicus in four circuit opinions (First, Fourth and Ninth Circuits, 2024-04-16 to 2025-02-18; Nos. 23-1645, 23-1078 and 23-1130, 23-1069, and 23-16026), in addition to the Supreme Court bathroom brief above.
- Lobbying client: Rebel News, one lobbying engagement row of $10,000 (2022-03-31, House registrant 44521, name-only client match); a shared law firm is not a tie between AFL and Rebel News.
- Role: Gene Schaerr, partner (firm site).
- Narrative alignment only (not a tie): none.
What the records don't show
Which payments to the firm were for the LGBTQ+ students' case; counsel of record in any case on trans people's rights beyond those documented above; fees from state governments; the matters behind AFL's payments.
Open questions
- Which of the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities payments ($453,239, $332,685 and $156,082, on the returns for the fiscal years ending June 2022, June 2023 and June 2024) paid for the firm's work in the LGBTQ+ students' case against the U.S. Department of Education? Does the firm act for the Council or other religious colleges in other litigation over the Title IX religious exemption? Partly answered: the three payment periods overlap the case (July 2021 to June 2024), but the returns do not say what each payment covered; the other filings of the firm on the Title IX religious exemption documented above are the Ninth Circuit No. 20-56156 amicus brief and the intervenor's counsel in this case; one further Council amicus brief by the firm (Supreme Court No. 22-816) concerns the Fair Housing Act and mentions Title IX only as one of three religious exemptions. The three payments cover the period in which the case continued, and the 2023-03-30 brief falls in the year ending 2023-06-30; the returns do not say what each payment bought, so the payments cannot be assigned to one case. The firm's brief of 2021-06-21 falls before the first of the three periods.
- Which states paid the firm, and for which matters (Idaho in particular)? Partly answered: the Mississippi and Indiana contracts are documented from reporting (see Governments); Idaho is on the firm's client page with no contract or payment documented.
- What did America First Legal Foundation's $314,738 (TY2023) and $404,757 (TY2024) cover? Partly answered: America First Legal Foundation is listed as co-counsel with the firm in International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc. v. Ferguson (see above); what the payments covered is not established.
- Is Ken Klukowski still with the firm (LittleSis lists him; the question for Mark Paoletta is answered in the section on the lawyers the firm presents)? Partly answered (a firm lobbying filing of 2022-03-31 and two contribution records of May 2024 list him with the firm; the firm's biography page presented him as senior counsel in April 2023 (archive copy of 2023-04-01, 13) and in January 2025 (archive copy of 2025-01-15, 16); the firm's attorney page (7) accessed 2026-11-16 does not list him).
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- image page: https://schaerr-jaffe.com/
- https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/
- https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/practices/media/
- https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/representative-clients/.
- https://lda.gov
- https://efile.fara.gov.
- https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/attorneys/
- https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/attorneys/gene-schaerr/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene_Schaerr
- https://efile.fara.gov
- https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/statement-president-elect-donald-j-trump-announcing-the-appointment-mark-paoletta-general
- https://www.govinfo.gov/collection/plum-book
- https://web.archive.org/web/20230401140655/https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/kenneth-a-klukowski
- https://www.fec.gov/data/committee/C00001305/
- https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/attorneys/kenneth-a-klukowski/
- https://web.archive.org/web/20250115001357/https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/attorneys/kenneth-a-klukowski/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/
- https://www.fec.gov/data/committee/C00654723/
- https://www.fec.gov/data/committee/C00718635/
- https://www.schaerr-jaffe.com/representative-clients/
- https://ourtupelo.com/attorney-general-lynn-fitch-paying-outside-law-pr-firms-for-fight-against-abortion/
- https://www.insideindianabusiness.com/?p=169827]
- https://lda.gov/api/v1/filings/]
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/521247182
- https://clearinghouse.net/case/43970/
- https://www.cccu.org/news-publications/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/862190372]
- https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ord.159668/gov.uscourts.ord.159668.26.0.pdf
- https://coalitionforjewishvalues.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Fuller-CCCU-FinalPaperFiling.pdf
- https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/memoranda/2021/12/13/20-56156.pdf
- https://adflegal.org/case/college-ozarks-v-biden/attachment/amicus-brief-of-the-council-for-christian-colleges-universities
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/22-816.html
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2021-OCR-0166-229227
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2021-OCR-0166-230632
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2021-OCR-0166-231165
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2022-OCR-0143-155361
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2022-OCR-0143-149775