Rule of Law Trust
Virginia trust (c)(4); Leonard Leo is trustee
Intro
Rule of Law Trust is a Virginia-based (Vienna, VA) trust, EIN 83-1047727. ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer lists it as a 501(c)(4) filing Form 990-O (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 1). It was registered in DC as a foreign statutory trust in 2020 (status: withdrawn; state registry extract). Marble Freedom Trust's Schedule R lists it as a related tax-exempt organization ("support", 501(c)(4)). Leonard Leo is its trustee. It is a funder and pass-through hub, not a campaigning group, and it holds large assets ($187,864,450 at the end of 2022; $170,124,340 at the end of 2023; $174,002,529 at the end of 2024; Form 990 Part I total assets, end of year; IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 83-1047727, objects 202333199349307073, 202413209349306556 and 202523219349303432; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 1).
Filed totals (Form 990 e-file): 2020 revenue $1,493,794, expenses $38,447,824, assets $52,683,753; 2022 revenue $2,275,161, expenses $11,168,424; 2023 revenue $3,065,418, expenses $30,379,617; 2024 revenue $7,864,959, expenses $16,253,155. The 2021 return (object id 202213199349301476) shows revenue of $160,580,040, expenses of $4,799,057 and assets of $202,362,093, and lists the 2021 grants.
Money in
- Marble Freedom Trust: $153,000,000 (FY ended 2021-04-30) and $400,000 (FY ended 2025-04-30), "General Operating" (IRS Form 990 e-file, Marble EIN 85-0784793; the trust's own returns list Marble as a related organization). Total $153,400,000. The same money appears on the Marble Freedom Trust page and is counted once.
- Marble was funded by Barre Seid's gift, per ProPublica reporting (2022-08-22) summarized as cited on the Marble Freedom Trust page. The Marble-to-trust step is documented by filings; the Seid step is reporting, and Rule of Law Trust's own return does not name Seid.
- 2020 (before Marble's first grant): revenue of $1.49M against $38.4M in expenses and $52.7M in year-end assets. The source of the funds is not disclosed; Schedule B donor names are not public (IRS Form 990 e-file for 2020, EIN 83-1047727, object id 202113199349330006: total revenue $1,493,794, total expenses $38,447,824, total assets at the end of the year $52,683,753; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 1).
- BH Fund (EIN 81-1263832) gave the trust $4,065,780 in 2 rows ($2,915,780 and $1,150,000), "General Operating", for the period ending 2021-12-31 (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows in BH Fund's return, giver EIN 81-1263832, object id 202203199349302735; the rows carry the trust's EIN; 2).
- Contributions are not itemized by giver on the public return (Schedule B of the 2021 return, object id 202213199349301476, shows every contributor field as restricted; IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 83-1047727; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).
- What BH Fund (EIN 81-1263832) is: a Virginia 501(c)(4) organization formed in 2016 whose stated mission on its returns is "To promote the rule of law and limited, constitutional government". Roles as filed: Leonard Leo, Director and President (returns for 2020-12-31, 2021-12-31 and the final return for the period ending 2022-11-30); a second director who is Treasurer and Secretary (same returns; signed the final return as Director), given here by role. Its earliest record is a Form 990-N entry for 2016 naming that officer as principal officer. (IRS Form 990-series e-file, EIN 81-1263832, objects 202113199349315406, 202203199349302735 and 202320109349200127; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 4)
- BH Fund's own money in: the IRS financial extract for the period 2017-12 shows revenue $24,339,910, of which contributions $24,250,000, expenses $3,382,164 and assets $20,964,164 (IRS Statistics of Income extract; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 5; no donors named). Return for 2020-12-31: revenue $181,171, expenses $1,531,626, assets $6,089,801. Return for 2021-12-31: revenue $31,165, expenses $6,444,282, assets $0 at year end. Final return (Form 990-EZ, period ending 2022-11-30): revenue, expenses and assets $0, so the fund wound down in 2022. Marble Freedom Trust's Schedule R for the year ended 2021-04-30 lists BH Fund as a related tax-exempt organization (object 202240749349301569; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6); the return shows "not applicable" as direct controlling entity for the three 501(c)(4)s, so it does not show Marble controlling them. Who gave BH Fund its money is not in the filings (Schedule B is not public). LittleSis (entity 405835, 7) quotes Lisa Graves of the Center for Media and Democracy: "launched with a secret $24 million donor and gave $20 million to George Mason University's law school"; the BH Fund returns described above (2017, 2020, 2021) name no donor and list no gift to George Mason University or its foundation.
- BH Fund's own grants, return for 2021-12-31 (object 202203199349302735): Rule of Law Trust $4,065,780 in 2 rows ($2,915,780 and $1,150,000, "General Operating"; the rows above); Donor's Trust $700,000; People United for Privacy $600,000; America Engaged $195,000 (all "General Operating"); a payment to Baker Hostetler LLP of $770,895 ("Legal Services"). Grants named on that return total $5,560,780, of which the trust's $4,065,780 is 73.1% (arithmetic on the filed rows). The 2020 return (object 202113199349315406) lists $500,000 to People United for Privacy and $238,000 to America Engaged ("General support"). No BH Fund grant is filed for a trans-related purpose.
- BH Fund 2017 grants: BH Fund's Form 990 for calendar year 2017 (EIN 81-1263832; Leonard Leo named as principal officer; mission "To promote the rule of law and limited, constitutional government.") lists three grants on Schedule I, Part II: Donor's Trust, Alexandria VA (EIN 52-2166327, 501(c)(3)) $200,000, "General Support"; Freedom Opportunity Fund, Washington DC (EIN 81-1199959, 501(c)(4)) $400,000, "General support"; America Engaged, Vienna VA (EIN 81-2072162, 501(c)(4)) $2,300,000, "General support". The three rows total $2,900,000 (arithmetic on the filed rows; the return's page 8 line 13 grants total is the same figure, read on the scanned page). No grant to George Mason University or the George Mason University Foundation is on that schedule. (BH Fund Form 990 for 2017, copy published by UnKoch My Campus with its supporting documents, PDF pages 8 and 24, figures read from the scanned pages: 8)
- BH Fund, later years: the IRS public e-file indexes for 2018, 2019 and 2020 list no BH Fund return (9, 10, 11); the first e-filed return the indexes list is for the period ending 2020-12-31 (index for 2021, object 202113199349315406, 12). No return for 2018 or 2019 is available to show whether BH Fund granted to George Mason University or its foundation in those years.
- BH Fund and the 2016 George Mason gift, as reported: an update published by UnKoch My Campus, an advocacy group (2018-12-20), states that under the 2016-03-31 Grant Agreement that renamed George Mason's law school after Antonin Scalia, BH Fund was given "the right to enforce all of the Donor’s rights in th[e] Agreement", and that Leonard Leo signed BH Fund's first Form 990 on 2018-11-14 (13). Slate (Mark Joseph Stern, 2018-05-02) wrote: "That anonymous donor was later revealed to be the “BH Fund,” a tax-exempt group of which Leo is president." (14). The two accounts differ: UnKoch My Campus describes BH Fund as the agreement's third-party beneficiary, Slate as the donor. BH Fund's 2017 Schedule I, above, lists no payment to the university or its foundation.
Money out to our network
Grants paid, as filed (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 83-1047727; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 1):
- The Concord Fund (formerly Judicial Crisis Network): $24,500,000 in 2 rows, "General Operating": $21,500,000 (2020, filed "Judicial Crisis Network") and $3,000,000 (2021, filed "The Concord Fund").
- Schwab Charitable Fund (DAF): $6,000,000 (2022), $24,000,000 (2023), $13,750,000 (2024); total $43,750,000.
- Fidelity Charitable (DAF): $9,000,000 (2020).
- DonorsTrust: $5,793,800 (2020).
- Knights of Columbus Charitable Fund: $8,100,000 in 3 rows, "General Operating": $2,650,000 (2022), $4,050,000 (2023), $1,400,000 (2024).
- Right Vote Inc: $235,541 (2023, "Restricted Operating Grant"); Chicago Freedom Trust: $50,000 (2023).
- No direct grant to any organization this site documents as campaigning against trans rights, to Restoration of America, or to the 85 Fund appears in the filed grant rows. Anything reaching the network would pass through Concord or the DAFs. The records cannot trace those dollars onward, and they are not counted again with Concord's or the DAFs' own grants.
- Purposes are only "General Operating" or "Restricted Operating Grant". None names gender, trans, Title IX, sex or "protect kids". This page does not claim an anti-trans purpose for these grants.
- Contractors: Holtzman Vogel firms, legal services ($306,201 in 2020; $344,543 in 2021; $419,464 in 2022); Baker Hostetler ($412,500 in 2022; $284,979 in 2023); Semmes Associates LLC, consulting ($125,000 in 2020, $275,000 in 2021, $350,000 in 2022, $440,000 in 2023, $200,000 in 2024); Yaas LLC ($175,000 in 2020).
People on file (public roles only)
- Leonard Leo: Trustee and signing officer. Reported compensation $0 (2020), $550,000 (2021), $400,000 (2022), $600,000 (2023), $500,000 (2024). Public figure; also Trustee and Chairman of Marble Freedom Trust.
- No other officer, director or trustee is listed in Part VII of the trust's returns for 2020 to 2024 (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 83-1047727, objects 202113199349330006, 202213199349301476, 202333199349307073, 202413209349306556 and 202523219349303432; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 1).
What the records don't show
- Who gave the 2020 money, and what Marble's gifts were spent on in 2021 (the 2021 return lists one grant, $3,000,000 to The Concord Fund, within expenses of $4,799,057).
- Where Schwab, Fidelity, DonorsTrust, Knights of Columbus and Concord money went after receipt.
- What Right Vote Inc does (IRS lists a Washington DC nonprofit with $7.8M and $16.2M of 2023 and 2024 revenue).
- Any anti-trans purpose in Rule of Law Trust's own grants. None is filed.
Sources
IRS Form 990 e-file EIN 83-1047727, object ids 202113199349330006, 202213199349301476, 202333199349307073, 202413209349306556, 202523219349303432; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 1; the Marble Freedom Trust page.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/831047727
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/811263832/202203199349302735/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/831047727/202213199349301476/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/811263832.
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/811263832
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/850784793
- https://littlesis.org/entities/405835
- https://ia601503.us.archive.org/9/items/PDFAttachmentsToUpdateToReportOnFedSocTakeover1272018_201812/PDF%20Attachments%20to%20Update%20to%20Report%20on%20Fed%20Soc%20Takeover%2012%207%202018.pdf
- https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2018/index_2018.csv
- https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2019/index_2019.csv
- https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2020/index_2020.csv
- https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/990/xml/2021/index_2021.csv
- http://www.unkochmycampus.org/dec-20-2018-donor-control-at-gmu-update
- https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2018/05/we-now-know-how-the-koch-brothers-and-leonard-leo-buy-special-favors.html