Parents Defending Education
Education-advocacy nonprofit
Education-advocacy nonprofit that files as Defending Education by its TY2024 return. Its documented work concerning trans people includes lawsuits against school districts over policies on pronouns and gender-identity support (Linn-Mar, Olentangy, Croton-Harmon), a challenge to a Colorado law on chosen names (Sullivan), suits against two universities (Stewart, Anguiano), a joint complaint to federal agencies over a Milwaukee district's policy and comment letters on federal rules (Title IX in 2022 and 2023; HHS and HUD in 2026). These cases and letters argue against protections for trans people, which is anti-trans rhetoric presented as parental rights and free speech. It appears in this project through Edward Blum, who is listed as its Trustee and is also Treasurer/Director of Do No Harm, and through the funders below.
Money received
Grants as filed from funders' Form 990s (IRS Form 990 e-file). As filed; lower bound.
- Project on Fair Representation (EIN 47-2593047) $1,395,500 (1 row, TY2021; purpose "see Sch O").
- Edelman Family Foundation (IRS Form 990-PF, EIN 37-6624335; see the Edelman Family Foundation page): $615,000 in 4 rows, all filed to Parents Defending Education, Arlington, VA and matched by full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN): $200,000 (TY2021), $50,000 (TY2022), $350,000 (2023-02-17) and $15,000 (2024-10-23); the last two are from the lists attached to the TY2023 and TY2024 returns. All four come from one giver's filings in one record set (IRS Form 990-series e-file) and are filed to the organization's full name at its own place, so they count together. Edelman is a private foundation and not one of the donor-advised sponsors, so nothing overlaps the sponsor total of $10,221,091. Detail: $200,000 (period ending 2021-12-31, object id 202222829349100102, "TO PROVIDE GENERAL SUPPORT TO DEFEND EDUCATION"), $50,000 (period ending 2022-12-31, object id 202341359349103194, "TO PROVIDE GENERAL SUPPORT IN DEFEND EDUCATION"), $350,000 (2023-02-17, "To Provide General Support in Defend Education", list attached to the TY2023 return, page 22) and $15,000 (2024-10-23, "Program/Project support", list attached to the TY2024 return, page 25) (TY2023 and TY2024 return pages, 1 and 2, read as page images of a scan).
- DonorsTrust $2,197,550 (5 rows, periods ending 2021-12 to 2024-12, a lower bound: grant lists for periods ending before 2020-12 and for TY2025 are not in the records; return ids 202243199349308799, 202323049349300742, 202423189349304787, 202513179349312256; IRS Form 990 e-file grant rows, sponsor EIN 52-2166327, recipient EIN 86-1596460; "for general operations", "for Public School Advocacy Initiative"; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).
- Donor-advised-fund and community-foundation sponsors (pass-throughs; donors undisclosed): $10,221,091 in 31 rows from 11 sponsors (12 names: Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc and Schwab Charitable Fund are one body, EIN 31-1640316), TY2021-2025 (a duplicated Fidelity row is counted once): Vanguard Charitable $2,781,500; National Philanthropic Trust $2,764,750; DonorsTrust $2,197,550 (5 rows, periods ending 2021-12 to 2024-12); Fidelity Charitable $1,781,273; Donor Advised Charitable Giving $319,350 and Schwab Charitable Fund $216,200 (together $535,550); Morgan Stanley Global Impact Funding $75,000; California Community Foundation $25,000; Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia $20,000; American Online Giving Foundation $16,218; American Endowment Foundation $14,250; The Chicago Community Trust $10,000. All of these are inside the $10,221,091; none of them is added again anywhere in this profile. Not added to other datasets. (DonorsTrust is also counted in the sponsor total, so the two lines overlap.)
- Funders found from the recipient side, as filed; each amount is at least that much (a floor), and nothing is added across datasets. Source: IRS Form 990 e-file grant rows. A grant shows money moved for the filed purpose, not an anti-trans purpose.
- The Searle Freedom Trust C/O Kinship Llc (EIN 36-7244615): $750,000 in 4 rows, TY2021-2024 (by year of the period end: 2021 $250,000; 2022 $125,000; 2023 $125,000; 2024 $250,000), purpose as filed "EDUCATION AND OUTREACH" on every row; matched by the recipient's full name and place, "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION", VA (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN; object ids 202203199349103100, 202343199349106704, 202433209349102098, 202513189349102186; IRS Form 990-PF e-file grant rows, giver EIN 36-7244615; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 4).
- Diana Davis Spencer Foundation Inc (EIN 20-3672969): $350,000 in 2 rows, TY2022-2023, purpose as filed "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT; PUBLIC EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH"; recipient as filed "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION", Arlington, VA, matched by full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN); object ids 202333169349100258 and 202433199349102773 (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 20-3672969; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 5).
- The Marcus Foundation Inc (EIN 58-1815651): $300,000 in 2 rows, TY2023-2024, purpose as filed "TO SUPPORT THE EXEMPT PURPOSE OF THE RECIPIENT ORGANIZATION"; recipient as filed "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION", VA, matched by full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN); object ids 202403189349102110 and 202503189349104080; an amended TY2024 return, 202513219349106486, carries the same row and it is counted once (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 58-1815651; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6).
- Bradley Impact Fund Inc (EIN 45-4678325, Milwaukee WI): $1,505,500 in 3 rows: $505,000 (TY2022, "GENERAL CHARITABLE PURPOSES"), $500,500 (TY2023, "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT."), $500,000 (TY2024, "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT."); object ids 202323199349323507, 202403199349311950, 202523189349302832 (IRS Form 990 e-file; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 7).
- Summ Foundation (EIN 92-1428532, New York): $175,000 (TY2023, purpose as filed "DONATION TO PROMOTE RESTORATION OF A SCHOOL CURRICULUM AND ENVIRONMENT FREE FROM POLITICAL IDEOLOGY."; object id 202443209349309549) (IRS Form 990 e-file; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 8).
- Merona Leadership Foundation $64,680 (TY2022, "GENERAL SUPPORT"; object id 202331399349300838), which is not among the sponsors and is outside the $10,221,091 total (IRS Form 990 e-file). Inside the total, not additional: American Endowment Foundation $14,250 in 2 rows ($5,000 TY2022 "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT"; $9,250 TY2023 "EDUCATIONAL") and Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia $20,000 (TY2022), both sponsors already counted in the $10,221,091. Not inside the total: Bradley Impact Fund and Summ Foundation (above), Merona, the Project on Fair Representation, Edelman Family Foundation, the Searle, Diana Davis Spencer and Marcus foundations.
- Paulson Family Foundation (EIN 26-3922995; John Paulson is listed as a director on its returns): $500,000 (TY2022), purpose as filed "TO PROMOTE THE ORGANIZATION'S GOAL OF RESTORING A HEALTHY, NON-POLITICAL EDUCATION FOR KIDS"; recipient line "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION", Arlington, VA; matched on full name and place, no recipient EIN on the filing (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, EIN 26-3922995, object id 202313179349101431; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 9).
- Further funders are not listed here.
- The Bader Family Foundation (EIN 27-6359747) gave it $787,000 in 4 rows, matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN); by year of the period end: 2021 $130,000; 2022 $160,000; 2023 $250,000; 2024 $247,000; purposes as filed: "CHARIITABLE CONTRIBUTION"; "CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTION"; "GENERAL CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTION"; recipient name as filed: "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION" (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 27-6359747, object ids 202213199349109381, 202343189349102434, 202433209349104413, 202513219349106376; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 10).
- Adolph Coors Foundation (EIN 51-0172279) gave it $15,000 in 1 row paid (year ended 2023-11-30, "GENERAL OPERATING GRANT"), recipient as filed "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION", Arlington; matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN) (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 51-0172279, object id 202411039349100611; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 11).
- Sponsor rows by sponsor, as filed, counted once (11 sponsors by EIN, 31 rows, $10,221,091): Vanguard Charitable Endowment Program (EIN 23-2888152) 4 rows, $2,781,500; National Philanthropic Trust (EIN 23-7825575) 4 rows, $2,764,750; DonorsTrust (EIN 52-2166327) 5 rows, $2,197,550; Fidelity Charitable (EIN 11-0303001) 4 rows, $1,781,273 (the row of $158,810 for the period ending 2022-06-30 is on two returns and is counted once); Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc (Schwab Charitable, EIN 31-1640316) 4 rows, $535,550, of which 2 rows, $319,350, are filed "DONOR ADVISED CHARITABLE GIVING INC" (periods ending 2024-06 $133,400; 2025-06 $185,950) and 2 rows, $216,200, are filed "SCHWAB CHARITABLE FUND" (periods ending 2022-06 $90,950; 2023-06 $125,250); Morgan Stanley Global Impact Funding Trust Inc (EIN 52-7082731) 3 rows, $75,000 ($25,000 in each of 2022, 2023 and 2024); California Community Foundation (EIN 95-3510055) 1 row, $25,000; Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia (EIN 23-1500085) 1 row, $20,000; American Online Giving Foundation Inc (EIN 81-0739440) 2 rows, $16,218 ($7,648 for the period ending 2023-03; $8,570 for 2024-03); American Endowment Foundation (EIN 34-1747398) 2 rows, $14,250; The Chicago Community Trust (EIN 36-2167000) 1 row, $10,000. (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant rows, recipient EIN 86-1596460.)
- The DonorsTrust row for the period ending 2021-12-31 is $20,250 ("for general operations"; object id 202243199349308799); it is one of the 5 rows and $2,197,550 stated for DonorsTrust and is counted in the $10,221,091 sponsor total. (IRS Form 990 Schedule I grant row, recipient EIN 86-1596460.)
- Rows filed to PDE's name with no recipient EIN, not listed above, found by the exact names "Parents Defending Education" and "Defending Education". Together these come from 20 further givers: 39 grant-paid rows, $526,225 as filed (a floor; recipient place Arlington VA, the place on PDE's returns; a row "approved for future payment" is not counted). Largest, by giver, with rows and periods as filed: Thomas W Smith Foundation Inc (EIN 47-3862135) 4 rows, $200,000 ($50,000 each, periods ending 2022-12 to 2025-12, purpose "EDUCATION"; object ids 202342139349100939, 202411349349102346, 202501299349101820, 202621339349102182); Bertrand Hopper Memorial Foundation (EIN 37-6026794) 5 rows, $110,000 (2021-12 $35,000 and 2022-12 $20,000, "CHARITABLE DONATION"; 2023-12 $20,000, 2024-12 $15,000 and 2025-12 $20,000, "GENERAL OPERATING PURPOSES"; object ids 202241309349103574, 202321359349101512, 202431279349102203, 202500919349100540, 202641189349101514); Clifford F Favrot Family Fund (EIN 72-6018687) 3 rows, $68,000 (2023-12 $15,000; 2024-12 $18,000; 2025-12 $35,000; "GENERAL"); PM Foundation Inc (EIN 38-1802049) 2 rows, $35,000 (2024-12 $15,000; 2025-12 $20,000; "SUPPORTING ORGANIZATION AND ADVOCACY"); The Tina Snider Foundation (EIN 93-1369489) 3 rows, $35,000 (periods ending 2023-06 $10,000 "GENERAL OP"; 2024-06 $5,000 "OPERATIONS"; 2025-06 $20,000 "GENERAL OPERATIONS"; object ids 202411299349102121, 202500239349100860, 202523179349102252); The Achelis & Bodman Foundation (EIN 13-6022018, filed "c/o Manice & Budd LLP") 1 row, $25,000 (2021-12, "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT"; object id 202233199349107778); The Snider Foundation (EIN 23-2047668, a different foundation from The Tina Snider Foundation) 1 row, $20,000 (2022-06, "OPERATING SUPPORT"); Ralph L Smith Foundation (EIN 44-6008508) 2 rows, $12,500 (2022-12 $10,000; 2023-12 $2,500). The other 12 givers each gave $5,000 or less ($20,725 together in 18 rows; among them Hamilton Roddis Foundation $5,000, Sandra & Lawrence Post Family Foundation $4,000, K & E Fund $3,750 in 5 rows, McCarthy Family Charitable Foundation $2,000 in 2 rows, The Pfizer Foundation $1,625). Not counted: rows to a "Defending Education" with another place (James E and Edith Margaret Brandon Foundation, $500, Pueblo CO; R Bruce Hezlep Family Foundation, $1,000, and one $2,500 McCarthy Family Charitable Foundation row, both Washington DC) and The Dickson Foundation Inc's $25,000 row (period 2024-12), which is "approved for future payment", not paid. The rule is the one used for the funders already on the page: filed name and place, no EIN. Grants show money moved for the filed purpose, not an anti-trans purpose. (IRS Form 990-PF e-file grant rows of the givers named.) Thomas W Smith Foundation has a page on this site (the Thomas W Smith Foundation Inc page); the other givers above do not.
- The four sets of rows, and who the givers are: Each of the four sets (Thomas W Smith Foundation, 4 rows, $200,000; Bertrand Hopper Memorial Foundation, 5 rows, $110,000; The Tina Snider Foundation, 3 rows, $35,000; The Achelis & Bodman Foundation, 1 row, $25,000) is filed to "PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION" at Arlington VA, the place on PDE's returns, so each meets the page's own rule. From the IRS master file and the givers' returns: Thomas W Smith Foundation Inc is a private non-operating foundation at Boca Raton FL (exempt from 2015-06; Thomas W. Smith is president and chairman on its returns; revenue $15,529,852 and assets $24,071,543 for TY2025). Bertrand Hopper Memorial Foundation is a private non-operating foundation at Taylorville IL (exempt from 1958-10; assets $6,793,923 for TY2025). The Tina Snider Foundation is a private non-operating foundation at Gloucester MA (first return for the year ending 2023-06; a president, a secretary and a treasurer, by role; revenue $33,516,802 and assets $31,320,594 on the return for the year ending 2025-06). The Achelis & Bodman Foundation is a private non-operating foundation at New York NY (exempt from 1941-07; assets $143,063,829 for TY2024; website as filed WWW.ACHELISBODMAN.ORG). All four are grantmaking foundations; no grant purpose is about trans people.
- Summ Foundation: Summ Foundation (EIN 92-1428532; a social-welfare organization, mission "to promote social welfare ... sensible policies that expand liberty", legal domicile DE; New York NY, later "c/o PKFOD Family Office" at Harrison NY; related to LUM Foundation, EIN 85-4229703) filed four returns. Its grants as filed: TY2023 (total expenses $2,092,680): American Unity Fund $1,167,000 ("donation to advance democracy, freedom for LGBTQ Americans, and religious freedom"), Winning for Women Inc $200,000, Defending Democracy $200,000, Parents Defending Education $175,000, National Black Empowerment $150,000, Ukraine Freedom Project $100,000, Drug Policy Action $50,000; TY2024 (total expenses $3,191,474): With Honor Action Inc $2,270,000, American Unity Fund Inc $500,000, Welcome PAC $300,000, Democracy First PAC $100,000 ("advocacy activities" and "political campaign activities"). The TY2022 return shows total revenue $5,000,000 and no expenses; the TY2025 return (Form 990-EZ) shows total expenses $29,935 and no grants in the records. No other grantee on these returns is an anti-trans body by name, and none has a page on this site; PDE's $175,000 (filed purpose "restoration of a school curriculum and environment free from political ideology") is the only row to a body on this site. A fund that also pays an LGBTQ-rights group does not make the PDE grant neutral: PDE's gender-ideology work is documented on the page. (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 92-1428532, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 8, object ids 202323199349318372, 202443209349309549, 202543219349319524, 202631429349200008.)
- Donor-advised funds: The $10,221,091 stays attributed to the sponsors only. The purposes filed on the sponsors' rows carry no donor names ("PUBLIC, SOCIETAL BENEFIT", "For grant recipient's exempt purposes", "FOR RECIPIENT'S EXEMPT PURPOSE", "GENERAL AND/OR PROGRAM SUPPORT - DONOR ADVISED FUNDS" and similar), and PDE's returns in the records carry no donor rows (only grants paid, contractors and Schedule R rows). A donor-advised fund's donors are undisclosed, so none is named.
- The Thomas W Smith Foundation, the Bertrand Hopper Memorial Foundation, the Tina Snider Foundation and the Clifford F Favrot Family Fund also fund other profiled bodies (the four lists below; the Achelis & Bodman Foundation has no list). Recipients are matched by the recipient's full name (Form 990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN) and the place filed; a grant that appears on two returns is counted once (11 repeats for the Thomas W Smith Foundation); amounts as filed, lower bounds; periods are the period ending (December unless stated); each giver's rows are matched by the giver's EIN (IRS Form 990-series e-file). The lists are partial: some profiled recipients are omitted from them and are added after the four lists. Rows to Parents Defending Education are listed above and not repeated.
- Thomas W Smith Foundation Inc (EIN 47-3862135), recipients with profiles: Institute for Justice (Arlington VA) 6 rows, $1,150,000 (2016, 2017, 2020, 2021, 2023, 2024); State Policy Network (Arlington VA) 6 rows, $1,193,600; Texas Public Policy Foundation (Austin TX) 4 rows, $1,175,000 (2020, 2021, 2024, 2025); American Legislative Exchange Council (Arlington VA) 6 rows, $1,000,000; Claremont Institute 4 rows, $550,000 (Upland CA 2020, 2021, 2024; Claremont CA 2025); Daily Caller News Foundation (Washington DC) 4 rows, $525,000 (2020, 2023, 2024, 2025); Independent Women's Forum 7 rows, $325,000 (2017 $25,000 Washington DC; 2020 to 2025 $50,000 each, Cross Junction VA); Turning Point USA (Lemont IL) 4 rows, $275,000 (2016, 2017, 2020, 2021); Hillsdale College 5 rows, $215,200; Young America's Foundation (Reston VA) 4 rows, $181,000; Discovery Institute (Seattle) 1 row, $150,000 (2020); Judicial Watch 3 rows, $100,000; Libertas Institute (Lehi UT) 3 rows, $100,000; Blexit Foundation (Washington DC) 1 row, $100,000 (2020); Citizens for Self-Governance (Houston) 1 row, $100,000 (2017); FreedomWorks Foundation (Washington DC) 1 row, $100,000 (2017); American Studio (Gig Harbor WA) 1 row, $50,000 (2022); Media Research Center (Reston VA) 2 rows, $20,000 (2016, 2017). Some of these rows are already on other pages.
- Bertrand Hopper Memorial Foundation (EIN 37-6026794): Do No Harm (Glen Allen VA) 2 rows, $35,000 (2024 $15,000; 2025 $20,000); Turning Point USA 3 rows, $80,000 (2022 $20,000; 2023 $30,000; 2024 $30,000, Phoenix); Samaritan's Purse (Boone NC) 1 row, $20,000 (2023); American Studio 1 row, $20,000 (2022). The Tina Snider Foundation (EIN 93-1369489): Do No Harm 3 rows, $25,000 (2023 $10,000; 2024 $5,000; 2025 $10,000); Institute for Justice 3 rows, $125,000 (2023 $50,000; 2024 $50,000; 2025 $25,000); Hillsdale College 1 row, $350 (2025); some of these rows are already on the Do No Harm page. Clifford F Favrot Family Fund (EIN 72-6018687): Hillsdale College 3 rows, $48,000 (2022, 2023, 2024); Project Veritas (Mamaroneck NY) 1 row, $50,000 (2020); America First Policy Institute (Arlington VA) 1 row, $40,000 (2021); Turning Point USA 1 row, $35,000 (2025, filed "PHEONIX"); America First Legal Foundation (Washington DC) 1 row, $15,000 (2023); The Leadership Institute (Arlington VA) 1 row, $15,000 (2022); Samaritan's Purse 3 rows, $14,000 (2020 $2,000; 2022 $4,000; 2023 $8,000; a further $16,000 is filed under a misspelled name, so $14,000 is a lower bound).
- Profiled recipients omitted from the four lists above (rows as filed, from the same returns): Thomas W Smith Foundation to DonorsTrust 3 rows $650,000; New Civil Liberties Alliance 6 rows $1,882,666; Federalist Society 8 rows $1,010,000; Heritage Foundation 3 rows $400,000; American Enterprise Institute $200,000; Goldwater Institute $50,000; Fair Elections Fund $100,000; Ethics and Public Policy Center $25,000; Defense of Freedom Institute $150,000. Tina Snider Foundation to Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression $80,000 (two name spellings). Clifford F Favrot Family Fund to Heritage Foundation 2 rows $25,000. What it shows: none of these four foundations (Smith, Hopper, Snider and Favrot) is a single-issue funder of Defending Education; each also gave to groups whose documented work includes anti-trans campaigning (for example Do No Harm from Hopper and Snider; Turning Point USA from Smith, Hopper and Favrot; Independent Women's Forum from Smith; America First Legal Foundation from Favrot). The filings give purposes only ("EDUCATION", "GENERAL", "CHARITABLE DONATION"); they do not show what any recipient did with a grant, and none says the money funded work on trans people.
- Thomas W Smith Foundation Inc (EIN 47-3862135) to the Manhattan Institute (New York NY): 21 rows, $9,331,458 as filed, periods ending 2016-12 (8 rows, $1,054,186), 2017-12 (7 rows, $993,671; the same seven grants appear on two returns for the period and are counted once), 2020-12 ($1,305,595), 2021-12 ($1,450,000), 2022-12 ($982,988), 2023-12 ($1,345,904), 2024-12 ($1,097,178) and 2025-12 ($1,101,936); purposes as filed "EDUCATION", "PUBLIC POLICY" and "EDUCATION/PUBLIC POLICY"; matched by the recipient's full name and place (Form 990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). It is the largest recipient of that foundation among profiled bodies. The total counts paid rows only (rows approved for future payment are excluded). Amounts are as filed and a lower bound. (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 47-3862135, object ids 201721319349102082, 201813529349100701, 201843109349100024, 202111319349101836, 202211369349103551, 202342139349100939, 202411349349102346, 202501299349101820, 202621339349102182; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12)
- Three further recipients with profiles, from the same grant rows of three of those foundations (Smith, Favrot and Snider), are not among the four lists. Thomas W Smith Foundation to Prager University Foundation (filed as "PRAGER U FOUNDATION", Sherman Oaks CA): 5 rows, $800,000 (periods ending 2020-12 $100,000; 2021-12 $250,000; 2022-12 $250,000; 2024-12 $100,000; 2025-12 $100,000), purpose as filed "EDUCATION" (object ids 202111319349101836, 202211369349103551, 202342139349100939, 202501299349101820, 202621339349102182). Clifford F Favrot Family Fund to First Liberty Institute (filed as "FIRST LIBERTY", Plano TX): 5 rows, $153,000 (2021-12 $40,000; 2022-12 $45,000; 2023-12 $15,000; 2024-12 $18,000; 2025-12 $35,000), purpose as filed "GENERAL" (object ids 202211649349100811, 202341229349101149, 202421379349100032, 202520729349100617, 202601259349103005). Tina Snider Foundation to Mackinac Center for Public Policy (Midland MI): 1 row, $50,000, period ending 2025-06-30, purpose as filed a five-month targeted social media campaign aimed at teachers' union members in Massachusetts (object id 202523179349102252). Matched by the recipient's name and place as filed; amounts are as filed and a lower bound. (IRS Form 990-PF e-file returns of EINs 47-3862135, 72-6018687 and 93-1369489; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 12, 13, 14)
- Name variants of profiled bodies among the funders' other grants: the Thomas W Smith Foundation Inc and the Tina Snider Foundation file their Form 990-PF grant rows without a recipient EIN, and some recipients are written in a shortened form. Two rows to profiled bodies were filed under such variants (IRS Form 990-PF e-file returns; amounts as filed, lower bounds; recipients matched by filed name and place): the Thomas W Smith Foundation Inc (EIN 47-3862135) paid $100,000 for "PUBLIC POLICY" to the Foundation for Government Accountability, filed as "FDTN FOR GOV'T ACCOUNTABILITY", Naples FL (year ended 2021-12-31; Form 990-PF, IRS object id 202211369349103551; 12); and the Tina Snider Foundation (EIN 93-1369489) paid $100,000 to DonorsTrust, filed as "DONORS TRUST INC", Alexandria VA, with the purpose "GEVURA FUND OF DONORSTRUST" (year ended 2025-06-30; Form 990-PF, IRS object id 202523179349102252; 14). The recipient is a donor-advised sponsor; nothing is attributed to any of its donors.
People on file
Edward Blum, "Trustee" TY2022-TY2025 (objects 202323199349302792, 202442979349301779, 202512839349300016, 202612159349301091). Kenneth Marcus is Treasurer on the 990s. President Nicole Neily is listed at $302,500-$401,700 (2022-2025) on the returns. Public roles: Neily is president and founder (15, 2026-11-18, where the organization appears as Defending Education); Blum is the founder (2005) and director of the Project on Fair Representation, the grantor listed above (Wikipedia Edward_Blum_(activist), offline copy of 2026-10-01, secondary); Marcus was US Education Department Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights from 2018-08-06 to July 2020 and is founder and chairman of the Brandeis Center (Wikipedia Kenneth_L._Marcus, offline copy of 2026-10-01, secondary).
Spending and related entities
- Legal services: Consovoy McCarthy PLLC $1,000,000 (TY2022), $1,000,000 (TY2023), $1,200,000 (TY2024), $1,709,858 (TY2025), as listed in the independent-contractor section of the 990s (object ids 202323199349302792, 202442979349301779, 202512839349300016, 202612159349301091). Public relations and strategy: CRC Advisors $355,107 (TY2022), $429,226 (TY2023), $501,385 (TY2024), $415,000 (TY2025). Digital advocacy and fundraising: Red Edge LLC $324,839 (TY2022), $323,779 (TY2023); American Philanthropic $209,800 (TY2022), $163,269 (TY2023) (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 86-1596460; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16). The filings do not say which matters the fees covered.
- Related organization: PDE Action, an advocacy (social welfare) entity listed on Schedule R of the TY2022 return, with transactions with a related organization of $39,130 (time allocation) and $4,498 (actual cost) in TY2022 (object id 202323199349302792).
- Revenue as filed: $3,178,345 (TY2021, a return covering 2021-01-21 to 2021-12-31), $4,301,156 (TY2022), $5,098,994 (TY2023), $5,331,408 (TY2024), $6,635,388 (TY2025). The organization changed its filing name from Parents Defending Education to Defending Education by the TY2024 return (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 86-1596460; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16).
- Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, TY2021 and documented matters: The TY2021 return (object id 202233199349321538; revenue $3,178,345) lists Consovoy McCarthy PLLC at $800,000, "LEGAL FEES", before the $1,000,000 (TY2022), $1,000,000 (TY2023), $1,200,000 (TY2024) and $1,709,858 (TY2025) on the page (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 86-1596460; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16). The filings do not say which matters the fees covered. One matter in which the firm is documented as PDE's counsel is America First Legal Foundation v. Cardona, No. 1:22-cv-1947 (D.D.C.), 630 F.Supp.3d 170, decided 2022-09-22: plaintiffs America First Legal Foundation, Fight for Schools and Families and Parents Defending Education, challenging the Department of Education's creation of the National Parents and Families Engagement Council; a Consovoy McCarthy lawyer appears for PDE, with counsel from America First Legal Foundation and Spero Law (17). That case is not about gender identity. The opinions' counsel blocks in the Olentangy and Croton-Harmon appeals name the firm as counsel for Defending Education (see Counsel below); the Linn-Mar opinion and the Olentangy order of 2026-01-27 list no counsel; the Linn-Mar complaint itself is signed by Consovoy McCarthy PLLC (see below), so which matters the fees covered, and whether any concerned gender identity, stays open.
- Revenue, TY2021: PDE's TY2021 return shows revenue $3,178,345 (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 86-1596460, object id 202233199349321538; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16).
Named staff and trustees (organization pages and 990s)
- Defending Education's own about page lists Nicole Kurokawa Neily as President and Founder, Sarah Parshall Perry as Vice President and Senior Legal Fellow, and Phil Willard as Chief Financial Officer and Chief Operating Officer (15, 2026-11-18). The page lists "Gender Ideology" as one of five core issue areas.
- The 990s list as trustees Karol Markowicz (a newspaper columnist), Edward Blum and Kenneth Marcus (Treasurer), and two further trustees who are given by role only (TY2022-TY2025, unpaid). Staff with reported pay include Erika Sanzi (Director of Outreach, $129,167 TY2022; $134,792 TY2023; $142,583 TY2024; Senior Director of Communication $150,000 TY2025) and a Director of Advocacy named only in the filing ($149,146 TY2023; $163,626 TY2024; $158,620 TY2025) (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 86-1596460; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16).
Anti-trans work: documented moments
- 2026 issue page: Defending Education's "Gender Ideology" page says it challenges K-12 and higher-education policies that "replace biological sex with gender identity", and lists as 2026 items: Defending Education et al. v. Sullivan et al. (reply brief 2026-09-08); Defending Education v. Regents of the University of California, et al. (reply on a preliminary-injunction motion 2026-08-13); a second amicus brief in Mirabelli et al. v. Bonta et al. (2026-09-01); a complaint against the State of Minnesota under the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (filed 2026-07-28; the page marks it "UNDER INVESTIGATION"); incident reports on Framingham Public Schools (2026-07-29, headline beginning "Framingham Public Schools' 'LGBTQ Support' webpage promotes healthcare centers that provide access to...") and Jefferson County Public Schools (2026-07-16, headline beginning "Jefferson County Public Schools pays DC law firm $400 per hour to defend policies allowing males..."); and a "Supreme Court Decision on Women's Sports" resource (18, 2026-11-18).
- 2026-07-14 and 2026-09-15: commentary by staff in the Daily Wire, including a piece by Erika Sanzi titled "When A School's Transgender Secret Becomes a Family's Nightmare" (same page, accessed 2026-11-18: lists the piece, 'September 15, 2026, Erika Sanzi, Daily Wire'; the 2026-07-14 item is no longer on the page and is not re-confirmed). Its framing around secrecy and parental notification is a recurring anti-trans line; the cases it covers are not described on this page.
- Context: InfluenceWatch describes the group's founding-era work (2021) as race-focused complaints and lawsuits, such as the 2021 Wellesley equity-plan suit; gender-identity work is a later and now central strand (InfluenceWatch, 2026-11-18).
- Earliest dated items from the organization's own pages: (1) 2022-11-07, an incident report on the organization's site, in its "Gender Ideology" category, about the Upper Moreland School District (Pennsylvania): the district's codes of conduct say "School personnel should not disclose information that may reveal a student's gender identity or gender nonconformity" (19). (2) 2023-03-14, the organization filed a complaint with the Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights against the Lower Merion School District (Pennsylvania) under Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause over a "Girls + STEM Night" announced for "girls and gender diverse students"; the organization's page records that the Office for Civil Rights opened an investigation on 2023-05-01 and closed the complaint on 2023-06-26. The complaint concerns an event, not a gender-identity policy (20). The organization's own Office for Civil Rights complaint pages dated 2021-03-30 to 2022-10-04 (Hopkins Public Schools, Orange County Schools and Webster Groves School District, 2021-03-30; Columbus City Schools, 2021-05-10; Wellesley Public Schools, 2021-05-12; New York City Public Schools, 2021-12-02; Centennial Elementary School and Downers Grove South High School, 2021-12-17; Pickens Middle School, 2022-04-21; Manhattan Beach Unified, Avonworth, Berea City, Jackson Public School District and Hudson School District, 2022-05-16; Jeffco Public Schools, 2022-09-16; Newton North High School, 2022-10-04) describe complaints whose text, as given on those pages, contains none of the words gender, transgender, pronoun or LGBT; the earliest of its complaint pages that concerns gender identity is the Lower Merion complaint of 2023-03-14 described above, and the earliest that invokes the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment over a gender-identity policy is the Milwaukee complaint of 2025-04-02. (The pages listed, each at an address of the form 21 and 22, each accessed 2026-11-16; the list of complaint pages is the site's own sitemap, 23, whose post sitemap 24 held the complaint addresses on 2026-11-16.) (3) 2023-08-03, an incident report in the same category on the Dallas Independent School District's apparent use of transgender guidance written by the Texas Association of School Boards (25).
- 2022 to 2026, gender-identity cases (court records): Earliest gender-identity case in the court records: Parents Defending Education v. Linn-Mar Community School District, No. 1:22-cv-00078 (N.D. Iowa), docket opened 2022-08-02, terminated 2024-02-22 (the date on the docket record; the joint stipulation of dismissal and the settlement agreement were filed on 2024-02-21, Documents 57 and 57-1), with appeal No. 22-2927 (8th Cir., opened 2022-09-13, closed 2023-09-29) (CourtListener dockets 64865566 and 66800017, 26 and 27). The Eighth Circuit's opinion of 2023-09-29 says "In August 2022, Parents Defending sued" the district over its policy on transgender and gender-nonconforming students, on due-process and free-speech grounds; it describes the policy's "Gender Support Plan", confidentiality section and names-and-pronouns section; records that the district court denied a preliminary injunction; dismisses the parental-notification claim as moot after Iowa Senate File 496 (effective 2023-07-01); and reverses on the "respect" provision as too vague, remanding for a preliminary injunction. It records that the members who brought the speech claim "believe that biological sex is immutable, and that people cannot 'transition'" (court opinion, 28). Next: Parents Defending Education v. Olentangy Local School District Board of Education, No. 2:23-cv-01595 (S.D. Ohio), preliminary-injunction motion filed 2023-05-11 against anti-harassment and conduct policies that, in the court's words, "would prohibit the intentional misgendering of transgender students"; denied July 2023; a divided Sixth Circuit panel affirmed (109 F.4th 453, 2024); vacated and reheard en banc (Sixth Circuit No. 23-3630, last docket date 2025-11-06); the en banc court reversed (158 F.4th 732, 2025) and remanded for a "narrow" injunction against "punishing students for the commonplace use of biological pronouns"; on 2026-01-27 the district court entered the parties' agreed injunction. PDE notified the Sixth Circuit on 2025-04-11 that it had renamed itself Defending Education. The order records that the en banc majority did not foreclose enforcing the anti-harassment policies against abuse of transgender students (S.D. Ohio, order of 2026-01-27, Doc. 46, 29; CourtListener dockets 30 and 31). Earlier dated dockets are race-related (Wellesley, D. Mass. 1:21-cv-11709, opened 2021-10-19) or concern a Department of Education advisory council (D.D.C. 1:22-cv-1947). Defending Education's "investigations" index page lists five entries, all dated 2026, none on gender identity.
- 2025-08: a Defending Education complaint over the intimate-facilities policy of the Contoocook Valley School District in New Hampshire, after which the Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights opened a Title IX investigation of the district on 2026-03-31 (Boston 25 News, 2026-04-01, 32; the article does not name the complainant). Defending Education also complained to the Department of Education over Albuquerque Public Schools' "gender identity and expression" policy and Carlsbad Unified's facilities, and a July 2026 Title IX complaint over Jurupa Unified's athletics bylaw; these show the strand running in 2025 and 2026, not its start.
- 2025-04-02: Parents Defending Education, the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty and Alliance Defending Freedom sent a joint complaint to the Secretary of Education and the Attorney General against the Milwaukee Public School District under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act and the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment. The letter, dated April 2, 2025, says the district has a policy "to hide student gender transitions at school from their parents", cites the district's "Gender Inclusion Guidance" (2023), its "Gender Support Plan" and "Gender Communication Plan", and asks the Department to "revoke MPS's federal funding if MPS will not rescind these policies"; it cites the executive order of 2025-01-29, "Ending Radical Indoctrination in K-12 Schooling". It is signed for the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (Milwaukee), Alliance Defending Freedom (Scottsdale) and Parents Defending Education (by its president). The organization files it under "Gender Ideology, Surveys". (Complaint PDF, 33; the organization's page of 2025-04-03, 34) A policy that lets a student be addressed by the name and pronouns that fit their gender identity is support for trans students; seeking to cut off a district's federal funding over it is anti-trans rhetoric presented as parental rights. Education Week reported on 2026-09-17 (Mark Walsh, "Trump Admin. Turns to Student Privacy Laws in Gender Identity Fights With Schools") that the Milwaukee complaint under FERPA and the PPRA "is pending and has been referred to the Justice Department", as Defending Education's vice president, Sarah Parshall Perry, told the paper. The article gives this status only as her statement and gives no date for the referral. Defending Education's own page on the complaint, dated 2025-04-03, carries no later update (accessed 2026-11-17). (35, accessed 2026-11-17; 36, accessed 2026-11-17.)
- Defending Education's page "List of School District Transgender - Gender Nonconforming Student Policies" (37, first posted 2023-03-07, last updated 2026-06-29) lists "1219 Total Districts", "21,352 Total K-12 Schools" and "12,380,103 Total K-12 Students", describing them as districts whose policies "openly state that district personnel can or should keep a student's transgender status hidden from parents". These are the group's characterizations and counts.
- 2024-04-29: Parents Defending Education was one of eight plaintiffs, with the States of Alabama, Florida, Georgia and South Carolina, Independent Women's Network, Independent Women's Law Center and Speech First, Inc., in State of Alabama v. Cardona, No. 7:24-cv-00533 (N.D. Ala.), a challenge to three aspects of the 2024 Title IX rule (its interpretation of "sex discrimination", its definition of "sex-based harassment" and its alteration of procedures for Title IX grievances), a rule the Clearinghouse summary says protects students from discrimination based on, among other grounds, gender identity. Per the summary (last updated 3/19/2025) the court denied a preliminary injunction on 2024-07-30, the Eleventh Circuit granted an injunction pending appeal, and, the summary states, proceedings were stayed on 2024-10-22 (the docket lists a joint motion to stay filed 2024-10-07); on the docket as accessed 2026-11-11 the entry of the 2024-07-30 denial (Doc. 58) is marked "VACATED pursuant to USCA Order 95" (modified 2026-05-27). This is stated as the organization's own act as co-plaintiff. Defending Education's page says Speech First, which Nicole Neily also founded, is merging into Defending Education. [Clearinghouse, 38; Defending Education, 39
- Identity: Defending Education is Parents Defending Education. Defending Education's own site (40, accessed 2026-11-12) says in its footer "Our federal tax identification number is 86-1596460", "Copyright 2026 Defending Education", and calls itself "a 501(c)(3) charitable organization"; 86-1596460 is the EIN of this organization. The dated rename statement (PDE notified the Sixth Circuit on 2025-04-11 that it had renamed itself Defending Education) is noted above. The about page does not itself say "formerly Parents Defending Education"; the Sixth Circuit's caption ("Defending Education, fka Parents Defending Education") is a second source.
- How courts describe it, the Olentangy decisions and the amici (counsel blocks of the opinions, accessed 2026-11-12; not every amicus supported Defending Education, and the opinion does not sort them): the en banc opinion (Sixth Circuit No. 23-3630, argued en banc 2025-03-19, decided 2025-11-06; 41) lists the amici on brief: the Ohio Attorney General's office, the South Carolina Attorney General's office, First Liberty Institute, Institute for Free Speech, Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute, the Manhattan Institute, Advancing American Freedom, Southeastern Legal Foundation, Alliance Defending Freedom, Foundation for Moral Law, The Lonang Institute, Defense of Freedom Institute, William J. Olson P.C., the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund, Peters Kalail & Markakis, Herron Law, Giorgianni Law, and the American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio Foundation (listed with the other amici; the opinion's block does not say which side each supported, and the ACLU of Ohio's position is not stated here). The order of 2024-11-01 granting rehearing en banc (42) lists amici on the petition and reply: the South Carolina Attorney General's office, Alliance Defending Freedom, Manhattan Institute, First Liberty Institute, Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute, Institute for Free Speech and Foundation for Moral Law. So the Sixth Circuit appeal in which FIRE and the Manhattan Institute filed on 2023-10-02 was decided by the panel (affirming, 2024), vacated for rehearing en banc on 2024-11-01, and reversed en banc 10 to 7 on 2025-11-06; Alliance Defending Freedom, Manhattan Institute, Advancing American Freedom and FIRE are among the en banc amici. The pronoun policy at issue is described by the court as one that "would prohibit the intentional misgendering of transgender students", and the group's own filings call that anti-trans position protected speech.
- Counsel: Consovoy McCarthy PLLC is Defending Education's counsel in the Olentangy and Croton-Harmon matters. Olentangy (Sixth Circuit No. 23-3630): the en banc opinion lists a lawyer of Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, Arlington, Virginia, as arguing en banc "for Appellant", and lawyers of Consovoy McCarthy PLLC and of Robinson Law Firm LLC, Cleveland, Ohio, on the supplemental brief "for Appellant" (en banc opinion); the order of 2024-11-01 lists three lawyers of Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, Arlington, Virginia, "for Appellant". Croton-Harmon (Second Circuit No. 24-1900, appeal from S.D.N.Y. 7:24-cv-04485): the opinion at 43 lists for "Plaintiff-Appellant Defending Education" four lawyers of Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, Arlington VA, and one lawyer of Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, Boston MA; panel Calabresi, Parker and Nardini, Judge Nardini writing; "Submitted and decided April 22, 2025"; "On reconsideration September 15, 2026" (as the listing gives it). Sullivan (D. Colo. 1:25-cv-01572; Tenth Circuit No. 26-1101): Clearinghouse's case page (44) lists three lawyers as plaintiffs' counsel without a firm name; the same three names appear for Consovoy McCarthy in the Olentangy and Croton-Harmon blocks. The Clearinghouse case page for Sullivan does not name the firm. The complaint itself (Document 1, filed 2025-05-19, caption "DEFENDING EDUCATION; COLORADO PARENT ADVOCACY NETWORK; PROTECT KIDS COLORADO; DO NO HARM; and [a physician]" against the Director of the Colorado Civil Rights Division, six Commission members and the Attorney General) ends with a signature block dated "May 19, 2025", "CONSOVOY MCCARTHY PLLC", Arlington, Virginia, three lawyers (one with "Application for admission pending"), "Counsel for Plaintiffs" (complaint, p. 49, 45). The complaint documents Consovoy McCarthy PLLC as counsel in this case; the opinions of the Olentangy and Croton-Harmon appeals and the Stewart and Anguiano complaints name the same firm, so it is documented as counsel in these five gender-identity cases (Olentangy, Croton-Harmon, Sullivan, Stewart and Anguiano) and in a sixth, Linn-Mar (2022 to 2024), where it signed the joint stipulation of dismissal of 2024-02-21 as counsel for the plaintiff (46).
- What the cases are about. Croton-Harmon (S.D.N.Y. 7:24-cv-04485, opened 2024-06-12; Second Circuit No. 24-1900): the Second Circuit's opinion describes the action as "challenging a set of student speech policies adopted by the Croton-Harmon Union Free School District" (Leagle). A local newsletter (The Croton Chronicle, 2024-07-11, 47) says the policies were "anti-harassment, anti-bullying, anti-racist, and pro-DEI policies", that Judge Seibel dismissed the case and the preliminary-injunction motion after a thirty-minute hearing, and that the plaintiffs knew they lacked standing under Second Circuit precedent because the three parents wanted to remain anonymous.
- Defending Education v. Sullivan (D. Colo. 1:25-cv-01572, filed 2025-05-19): Clearinghouse lists the plaintiffs as Defending Education, Colorado Parent Advocacy Network, Protect Kids Colorado, Do No Harm, a physician and the physician's medical practice (added by the amended complaint of 2025-06-13); defendants in their official capacities are the Director of the Colorado Civil Rights Division, six members of the Colorado Civil Rights Commission and the Attorney General; the page says House Bill 25-1312 amended "gender expression" under the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act to include the use of a "chosen name" and other words by which an individual "chooses to be addressed". Docket events: amended complaint and amended preliminary-injunction motion 2025-06-13; motions to dismiss filed 2025-09-19; the latest entry on the page is dated 2025-11-18. A Tenth Circuit appeal (No. 26-1101, from the District of Colorado, opened 2026-04-02, last entry 2026-09-11) is in CourtListener docket 73138559 (48). The suit is a challenge to a state law that protects trans people from deliberate misnaming: the plaintiffs' framing is compelled speech, the effect sought is to strike down the protection. Joint filers are profiled bodies: Do No Harm (co-plaintiff), Protect Kids Colorado (co-plaintiff) and Truth and Liberty Coalition (amicus).
- 2026-09-25, Defending Education v. Sullivan (D. Colo. 1:25-cv-01572): Judge Regina M. Rodriguez, in an Order Adopting Magistrate Judge Recommendation (Document 139, 28 pages, in the three Colorado civil actions decided together, 1:25-cv-01572, 1:25-cv-01668 and 1:25-cv-02177), accepted the magistrate judge's recommendation, overruled the objections of the state defendants and of the plaintiffs, granted in part and denied in part the two motions to dismiss, and dismissed without prejudice, for lack of standing, the claims of Defending Education, Colorado Parent Advocacy Network and Protect Kids Colorado. For Defending Education the court found that it sues through its members, that the two executive directors named as members "operate in places of public accommodation" only by hosting events in hotels, restaurants and similar venues, and that "just because" they "partner with public accommodations does not mean they offer services as representatives of places of public accommodation", so the organization "lacks standing to move forward with its claim". The order describes Defending Education as an organization whose members "strongly oppose the spread of 'harmful gender ideology'" (the plaintiffs' own description in their pleading, ECF No. 25, quoted by the court) and records the plaintiffs' view that sex is "immutable" and "fixed at birth". It also records that the court had earlier denied the preliminary-injunction motions (2026-03-31) for the scope of relief sought and for want of "a 'clear showing' of a credible threat of enforcement", and that no plaintiff alleged that the Colorado law had been enforced against them. The order records the magistrate judge's conclusion that each plaintiff other than these three has shown a credible threat of enforcement or a chilling effect on its speech, so the case continues for the other plaintiffs (the order's pp. 11 and 14). (Order of 2026-09-25, Document 139, 49, pp. 1-3, 10-11, 14, 26-28)
- Defending Education v. Stewart (W.D. Mo. 6:26-cv-03237), the Missouri State University suit:
- Complaint (Doc. 1, filed 2026-04-21, 30 pages, 50): "DEFENDING EDUCATION, Plaintiff, v. RICHARD B. WILLIAMS, in his official capacity as President of Missouri State University; DEE SISCOE...; RABEKAH D. STEWART, in her official capacity as Assistant Vice President for Student Affairs..." and other university officials, bias response team members and Board of Governors members. It is a verified complaint under the First and Fourteenth Amendments and 42 U.S.C. section 1983 against the university's bias policy and Bias Response Team (the policy lists "gender identity" among its categories). The docket (CourtListener docket 73219718, 51) was opened 2026-04-21, shows its last entry on 2026-06-16 and names judge Megan Blair Benton. Bloomberg Law (52) reports the suit in the W.D. Mo. before Judge Benton. The docket short name "Stewart" is the third-named official; the president is the first.
- Counsel (signature block dated April 21, 2026): Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, Arlington VA (three lawyers, pro hac vice applications forthcoming) and Graves Garrett Greim LLC, Kansas City MO, "Counsel for Plaintiff".
- Gender identity content: the complaint's standing rests on three anonymous student members. It says one "does not believe that 'gender identity' is a coherent category separate from biological sex", "does not think it is appropriate to refer to someone using biologically inaccurate 'preferred pronouns' or 'chosen names'" and "thinks that affirming someone's non-biological 'gender identity' is harmful to that person"; another "thinks it is harmful to affirm someone's non-biological gender identification, especially for children" and says conversations about "so-called transgender identity too often focus on individuals' emotions as opposed to biological fact and medical reality". The same members hold views on abortion and immigration. The suit, framed as campus speech, is built on members who want to refuse to affirm trans people: anti-trans rhetoric in a free-speech frame, with the "medical reality" claim set against the evidence for care in the evidence brief.
- Settlement of 2026-06-16, what it changed (the settlement agreement was reviewed; two news and tracker accounts agree with it on the team):
- The College Fix (Jennifer Kabbany, "Missouri State U. permanently deletes Bias Response Team to settle free speech lawsuit", posted 2026-06-16, 53; an outlet that covers campus speech from the right, so its account is attributed): the university "pledged to never reinstate the Bias Response Team or create another similar program" for handling "bias incidents", unless a law or regulation requires it; Defending Education's counsel is quoted saying the university agreed to "terminate its bias policy and dismantle its bias response team". The article says the university stated that on 2026-03-12, before the suit, officials had "independently decided to discontinue the Bias Response Team effective July 1", that Defending Education said it could not verify this, and that two days after the 2026-04-21 filing the university deactivated the team's online presence. The article does not describe changes to the bias-reporting procedure or the policy's definition, and does not mention fees or the terms of dismissal.
- Duke University's Campus Speech Incidents tracker (54): the parties announced a settlement on 2026-06-16 "resolving the lawsuit"; the university "permanently removed the Bias Response Team and its related reporting system" and "agreed not to reinstate the program or establish a similar bias response system unless required by law or regulation". The page says nothing of fees or payment and lists no docket entries.
- The settlement agreement does not rescind, reword or replace the written bias policy by name: it records that the University discontinued the Bias Response Team, bars a similar entity for "bias incidents" unless the law requires it, and has the University remove substantive references to the team and to "bias incidents" from its websites and publications; each party bears its own attorneys' fees, costs and expenses, and no payment is provided. A Defending Education vice president is quoted by The College Fix (2026-06-16) as saying the university has "seen fit to terminate its bias policy"; the agreement does not say that.
- Defending Education v. Sullivan, amicus brief of 2025-08-01: Clearinghouse's docket text (44, accessed 2026-11-12) gives three entries: ECF 50 (2025-07-31) "Unopposed MOTION to File Amicus Brief" by "Truth and Liberty Coalition, Inc." and "Dr. James Dobson Family Institute"; ECF 51 (2025-08-01) "ORDER granting 50 Motion to File Amicus Brief"; ECF 52 (2025-08-01) "BRIEF of Amici Curiae Truth and Liberty Coalition and James Dobson Family Institute" "in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for a Preliminary Injunction".
- Defending Education v. Anguiano (C.D. Cal. 8:26-cv-01574):
- Complaint (Doc. 1, filed 06/18/26, 65 pages, 55): header "Case 8:26-cv-01574", caption "DEFENDING EDUCATION, Plaintiff, v. MARIA ANGUIANO, RUSTY AREIAS..." (the Regents of the University of California and officers), "VERIFIED COMPLAINT"; counsel for plaintiff Consovoy McCarthy PLLC (Arlington VA) with Altview Law Group LLP, Beverly Hills CA, as local counsel. The docket (CourtListener docket 73501454, 56) lists dates from 2026-06-18 to 2026-09-25 and the judge as Fred W. Slaughter. The docket number is on the complaint's own header and the caption names Anguiano.
- The Croton-Harmon complaint (S.D.N.Y. 7:24-cv-04485), gender identity and pronoun claims:
- The complaint (Doc. 1, dated June 12, 2024, 57) raises gender identity and pronoun claims. It says the district's policies "compel speech by requiring students to use a classmate's 'preferred pronouns,' even when those pronouns do not match the person's biology and the speaker firmly believes that sex is immutable" (para. 9); it has a section headed "The Growing Use of Speech Codes to Punish Student Speech Involving Gender Identity and Other Controversial Topics in K-12 Schools" (para. 28 and following); "gender identity" appears 40 times and "pronoun" 33 times in the text. Its members' views are given as including "that sex is determined at birth and is immutable", beside views on DEI and immigration. Signed by Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, "Counsel for Plaintiff".
- Other dockets of the court-records set:
- Parents Defending Education v. U.S. Department of Education, D.D.C. No. 1:24-cv-00551 (docket record: filed 2024-02-28, judge Royce C. Lamberth) (complaint, 58; counsel Consovoy McCarthy PLLC): a Freedom of Information Act suit over a request of 2022-07-12 by PDE's president for Department correspondence with Governing for Impact, the National Student Legal Defense Network and the New Venture Fund (2021-01-20 to 2022-07-12) containing terms including "gender-affirming", "gender identity", "gender support plan", "Transgender" and "LGBT".
- Same parties, D.D.C. No. 1:25-cv-00833 (docket record: filed 2025-03-20, judge Sparkle L. Sooknanan) (complaint, 59; counsel Consovoy McCarthy PLLC): five FOIA requests from July 2022 to February 2024 that the Department "ignored": records on a parents' engagement council; one employee's correspondence; calendars and meeting logs of two officials; and a February 2024 request for the phrase "river to the sea". Not about gender identity.
- IntegrateNYC, Inc. v. State of New York, N.Y. Court of Appeals APL-2024-00099: PDE is an intervenor-defendant-appellant (caption of the New York City Bar Association's motion and brief, March 2025, 60); the service list names Consovoy McCarthy PLLC as attorneys for the intervenor-defendant-appellant. It is a school-integration and Education Article suit, not about trans people.
- The firm that holds PDE's largest legal-fee payments represented it in the FOIA suits and the IntegrateNYC appeal, in addition to Linn-Mar, Olentangy, Croton-Harmon, Sullivan, Stewart and Anguiano. Of these, only the first FOIA suit touches gender identity (as search terms).
- Olentangy, Sixth Circuit panel opinion (No. 23-3630). The panel opinion of 2024-07-29 records that Parents Defending Education (PDE), on behalf of certain parents and students, sought to enjoin three school district policies on speech about gender identity under the First Amendment (p. 2). It says PDE filed declarations from parent-members who explain that their children "have been raised to believe that biological sex is immutable and that individuals cannot transition from one sex to another" (p. 5, the panel majority's description of the declarations). The dissent summarizes the relief in PDE's complaint as including an injunction barring the district from “compelling speech to affirm another person’s gender identity” (p. 32, the complaint's words as quoted by the dissent). The panel majority affirmed the denial of the preliminary injunction (p. 25). Case status: The Sixth Circuit vacated this panel opinion on 2024-11-01 when it granted rehearing en banc, and on 2025-11-06 the en banc court reversed the denial of the preliminary injunction (10-7), so the panel opinion is no longer the court's holding. (Parents Defending Education v. Olentangy Local School District Board of Education, opinion and dissent (panel opinion of 2024-07-29, vacated), U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, No. 23-3630, 2024-07-29, pp. 2, 5, 25, 32)
- In its opinion of 2024-09-09 on the preliminary injunction against applying Arizona's Save Women's Sports Act to the plaintiffs, the Ninth Circuit lists Consovoy McCarthy Park PLLC under the amicus designation “Counsel for Parents Defending Education” (Nos. 23-16026 and 23-16030, p. 7). The panel affirmed the preliminary injunction. The Supreme Court vacated this Ninth Circuit judgment on 2026-06-30 and remanded for further consideration in light of its decision in a West Virginia sports-law case. The panel's holding therefore no longer stands as the law. (Opinion, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 23-16026, 2024-09-09, p. 7)
- Parents Defending Education appeared as an amicus curiae urging reversal in the Supreme Court case brought by parents in Montgomery County, Maryland, who asked for notice and opt-outs from school instruction using LGBTQ+-inclusive elementary storybooks, among them books with a transgender child (No. 24-297, decided 2025-06-27). The opinion's list of amici urging reversal includes Parents Defending Education (p. 8). The Court (6-3, Justice Alito writing) held that the parents are likely to succeed on a free exercise claim, reversed the Fourth Circuit and remanded, and held that until all appellate review is completed the board should be ordered to give advance notice and allow opt-outs from those books and any similar book. The Supreme Court's holding of 2025-06-27 stands; the case ended in the district court with a consented judgment and permanent injunction entered on 2026-02-19, according to a case summary on Clearinghouse. (Opinion, parents and a parents' association v. Montgomery County Board of Education and school officials, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-297, 2025-06-27, p. 8)
- The en banc opinion of the Sixth Circuit of 2025-11-06 in the Olentangy case reports what Parents Defending Education (named in the opinion as Defending Education) asked for after the district amended its policies in September 2024: the court says the plaintiff "now asks for an injunction that bars the School District only" from punishing students for misgendering other students, citing the plaintiff's own anti-trans claim that only two genders exist and that people cannot change their genders (p. 11; the claim is the plaintiff's, as recorded by the court). The court also quotes the president's declaration for the association's stated purpose, to protect against efforts to usurp parents' rights and to silence students who express opposing views (p. 8). This item reports the relief the association sought. The en banc court reversed the denial of the preliminary injunction on 2025-11-06, and an agreed injunction was entered on 2026-01-27 (Doc. 46) and a consent judgment and order on 2026-05-15 (Doc. 61), which ended the case without costs or attorneys' fees to any party. (Opinion, Defending Education v. Olentangy Local School District Board of Education and officials, United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (en banc), No. 23-3630, 2025-11-06, p. 11)
- 2022-11-09, United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, No. 22-2927, Parents Defending Education v. Linn-Mar Community School District. Atlantic Legal Foundation filed an amicus curiae brief, with Reeves Law LLC, in support of the appellant and reversal (p. 1: "BRIEF OF ATLANTIC LEGAL FOUNDATION AS AMICUS CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF APPELLANT AND REVERSAL"). Parents Defending Education is the plaintiff-appellant the brief supports. The amicus asked the Eighth Circuit to reverse the denial of a preliminary injunction and to enjoin the district's whole policy on transgender and gender-nonconforming students. It argued from parents' rights cases and common-law history, and asserted that the policy lets students from the seventh grade up choose names, pronouns, facilities and clothing without their parents' knowledge. The brief is a filing in support of the association's position and is reported here only as that. Case status: The Eighth Circuit vacated the denial of the preliminary injunction in part on 2023-09-29 (enjoining only the "respect a student's gender identity" provision) and the case then ended by a settlement agreement signed on 2024-02-19 and a joint stipulation of dismissal with prejudice, both filed on 2024-02-21 (N.D. Iowa, No. 1:22-cv-00078-CJW-MAR, Documents 57 and 57-1). (Brief of Atlantic Legal Foundation as Amicus Curiae in Support of Appellant and Reversal, United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, No. 22-2927, 2022-11-09, p. 1; 61. Joint Stipulation of Dismissal and Settlement Agreement, 46)
- Linn-Mar, how the suit ended (Parents Defending Education v. Linn-Mar Community School District, N.D. Iowa, No. 1:22-cv-00078-CJW-MAR; Eighth Circuit No. 22-2927). On 2024-02-21 the parties filed a joint stipulation dismissing the action with prejudice (Document 57) with a settlement agreement attached (Document 57-1). The agreement records that the district "voluntarily and in their sole discretion rescinded the Policy" in March 2023, before the Eighth Circuit's opinion of 2023-09-29, and that the district court issued a preliminary injunction on 2023-10-02 against "the portion of Board Policy 504.13-R that prohibits an intentional or persistent refusal 'to respect a student's gender identity'" (Dkt. 49). In it the district states it "has rescinded and will not reinstate" that portion of the policy as adopted on 2022-04-25; the district pays the organization $20,000 within five days (the agreement does not call it fees, and says the parties otherwise bear their own attorneys' fees, costs and expenses); the organization releases the district, its board members, an insurer and others from claims over that policy, but not over future policies; and the agreement "shall not be interpreted to confer prevailing party status on any Party". The district denies liability. Both parties signed it on 2024-02-19, subject to approval by the district's board (para. 13). The district's own announcement and the Associated Press say the district's insurer pays the $20,000; the agreement as read names the district as the payer, so who funds the payment is left open here. (Joint Stipulation of Dismissal and Settlement Agreement, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Iowa, No. 1:22-cv-00078-CJW-MAR, Documents 57 and 57-1, filed 2024-02-21, pp. 1-4 of the agreement; read as page images of a scan.)
- What became of the Olentangy case after the en banc amicus brief of 2024-12-18 (Sixth Circuit No. 23-3630; S.D. Ohio No. 2:23-cv-01595). The en banc court heard argument on 2025-03-19 and on 2025-11-06 reversed the denial of a preliminary injunction and remanded, ten judges in the majority and seven dissenting (the opinion lists "Defending Education, fka Parents Defending Education"). After the mandate, the parties filed a joint status report with a proposed preliminary injunction (Doc. 45, 2025-12-23), and on 2026-01-27 the district court granted it, as modified for clarity (Doc. 46): it bars the school district, while the suit is pending, from enforcing the challenged policies against the organization's members or their children for referring to another student, in a commonplace way, using pronouns consistent with the other student's birth sex but inconsistent with that student's gender identity, and says the district may still enforce its anti-harassment policies against the abuse of transgender students as it does for all other students. On 2026-05-12 the parties moved jointly for a consent judgment (Doc. 59); on 2026-05-15 the court entered the Consent Judgment and Order (Doc. 61), which bars the district from enforcing the same policies against any student for the same use of pronouns, again keeps its power to enforce them against the abuse of transgender students, requires training of all district employees who interact with students before the first day of the 2026-2027 school year, keeps the court's jurisdiction to enforce or modify it, and "fully resolves all claims and demands in this action without costs, disbursements, or attorneys' fees to any party". The relief the organization obtained protects the misgendering of transgender classmates; the judgment is the court's. The docket shows the case terminated on 2026-05-15 (a second, clerical termination entry is dated 2026-05-19). (Opinion, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (en banc), No. 23-3630, 2025-11-06, pp. 1-3; Opinion and Order Granting Preliminary Injunction, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, No. 2:23-cv-01595, Doc. 46, 2026-01-27, pp. 1-3; Joint Motion for Entry of Consent Judgment and Order, Doc. 59, filed 2026-05-12; Consent Judgment and Order, Doc. 61, 2026-05-15, pp. 1-5; the date of Doc. 45 and the terminations from the docket list on 62)
- Olentangy, outside briefs supporting the organization, as a listing (the amici's words are not carried on this page: they belong to the filers). Alliance Defending Freedom filed three amicus briefs in Sixth Circuit No. 23-3630 supporting the organization: on 2023-10-02 (Document 51), on 2024-08-30 (Document 95, supporting rehearing en banc) and on 2024-12-18 (Document 159, at the en banc stage). The Independent Women's Law Center and the Manhattan Institute filed an amicus brief on 2024-09-02 supporting the petition for rehearing en banc and an en banc merits brief on 2024-12-18 "supporting appellant and reversal". The en banc court reversed in the organization's favor on 2025-11-06 (above). (Briefs of amici curiae, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, No. 23-3630: Documents 51 (2023-10-02), 95 (2024-08-30) and 159 (2024-12-18) of Alliance Defending Freedom; the Independent Women's Law Center and Manhattan Institute briefs of 2024-09-02 and 2024-12-18 (en banc brief, 18 pages, cover dated December 18, 2024).)
- Missouri State, the settlement agreement itself, signed 2026-06-15 (organization) and 2026-06-08 (university, dated by hand) (Defending Education v. Williams, W.D. Mo., No. 6:26-cv-03237; "Agreement and Release", with the signature page and the attached Notice of Dismissal, 4 pages in all). Terms, as the agreement states them: the University "has discontinued the Bias Response Team and associated practices"; it "will not reinstate the Bias Response Team or create another similar entity with responsibility for addressing 'bias incidents' unless required by applicable law and/or regulation"; it "will take reasonable steps to remove any remaining references to the Bias Response Team and 'bias incidents' that are substantive in nature from its websites and other online publications"; and nothing in the agreement precludes the University from receiving, investigating or acting on reports of illegal discrimination, harassment or retaliation. The recitals say that on 2026-04-23 the University eliminated and deactivated the team, removed its landing page and removed it from the University Committees Handbook, and that the complaint challenged "the University's bias policy as administered by the University's Bias Response Team". The agreement does not rescind, reword or replace the written bias policy by name. The organization releases the claims over the policies and practices challenged as of 2026-04-21 but keeps the right to challenge any reinstated or revised policy (para. 2) and to challenge any other University policy (para. 6). Fees: "The Parties shall bear their respective attorneys' fees, costs, and expenses" (para. 4); no payment term. The University denies liability and states that on 2026-03-12 it had independently decided to discontinue the team effective 2026-07-01; the organization says it could not verify that, that no such decision was made public and that no change was made until after it filed (para. 5). The organization was to file the attached notice of dismissal within three business days; the notice dismisses all claims without prejudice, each party bearing its own costs, expenses and attorney's fees. (Agreement and Release, Defending Education and Missouri State University, with Notice of Dismissal, Case No. 6:26-cv-03237-MBB (W.D. Mo.), 63, pp. 1-4; read as page images of a scan; the organization's page 64, links the agreement and says "DE then filed a notice dismissing its case".)
- 2022-09-12 (posted 2022-11-03): Parents Defending Education (since 2025 "Defending Education") filed a comment letter, addressed to the Secretary of Education, on the Department of Education's proposed Title IX rule of 2022-07-12 (87 Fed. Reg. 41390; docket ED-2021-OCR-0166), with the cover text "See the attachment for comments filed by Parents Defending Education." The letter calls itself "a nationwide, nonpartisan, grassroots organization" of parents and says the proposed rule "would be unlawful and unconstitutional". Its first objection is that the rule "unlawfully shoehorns amorphous concepts of gender identity onto Title IX"; its second says the rule "would violate the Title IX rights of female athletes to compete in single-sex sports" by "requiring schools to allow biological males who identify as female to compete in women's sports" (the group's wording); its fifth says the rule "would invite schools to unconstitutionally compel student speech by exposing students to Title IX discipline for 'misgendering' another student or failing to use that student's 'preferred pronouns'". It also argues the rule lacks an assessment of its effect on parental rights (65).
- 2022-09-20: the order of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Iowa in Parents Defending Education v. Linn-Mar Community School District, No. 1:22-cv-00078, denied the organization's motion for a preliminary injunction against the district's gender-support policy, finding that the organization had not shown irreparable harm to its members or their children and, on the child-rearing claim, that it had not shown "any certain, impending action taken under the Policy" that would interfere with parents' rights, because it did not allege that any member's child had been given a plan or that any parent had been excluded or denied information; the court added that this did not mean the policy's language raised no legitimate concerns about disclosure to parents. This is the denial that the Eighth Circuit's opinion of 2023-09-29 partly reversed. (Order, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Iowa, No. 1:22-cv-00078, 2022-09-20, pp. 10-12, 21-22, 28; 66)
- 2023-05-15 (posted 2023-05-19): the group filed a comment letter on the Department of Education's proposed Title IX athletics rule of 2023-04-13 (88 Fed. Reg. 22860; docket ED-2022-OCR-0143), sent with a cover note signed by its vice president. The letter says the rule "establishes a new standard" for deciding whether a school may limit "participation on an athletic team associated with one's gender identity rather than one's biological sex", calls the rule "not only confusing" but "unlawful", argues that it "extends the definition of 'sex' to include gender identity", and says it "risks compromising 'privacy' for all pubescent students, especially in the 'private' and 'separate' spaces of biological female athletes like restrooms, locker rooms, lodging accommodations for competitive sports travel, and medical facilities on school property" (the group's wording) (67).
- 2023-07-28: the order of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio in the Olentangy case (No. 2:23-cv-01595) denied the motion for a preliminary injunction: after a hearing on 2023-07-24 the court found that the organization had "failed to establish a substantial likelihood of success on its First Amendment claim", reasoning that K-12 educators keep comprehensive authority to prescribe and control conduct in the schools (Tinker). (Opinion and Order, 2023-07-28, pp. 1-2, 41; 68)
- 2024-04-16, Fourth Circuit, Nos. 23-1078 and 23-1130 (a case brought for a minor transgender girl against West Virginia's law limiting girls' school sports teams to students of the female sex): the court's opinion of 2024-04-16 lists Parents Defending Education among the amici curiae supporting the appellees (the State of West Virginia side), in a list that includes Concerned Women for America, Samaritan's Purse, Women's Declaration International USA, the Independent Women's Law Center, the Defense of Freedom Institute and seventeen states led by Alabama and Arkansas. The court dismissed No. 23-1130 and, in No. 23-1078, vacated in part, reversed in part and remanded with instructions: it held that the district court erred in granting summary judgment to the defendants on the equal protection claim and vacated that part of the judgment for further proceedings. (Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, opinion, Nos. 23-1078 and 23-1130, 2024-04-16, caption and pp. 31-32.)
- 2024-06-09, First Circuit, No. 23-1645 (an appeal by a minor middle-school student against a Massachusetts town and school officials over a dress-code ruling on a shirt reading "There Are Only Two Genders"): Parents Defending Education is listed as an amicus curiae on brief, through Consovoy McCarthy PLLC. The court affirmed the judgment for the town and school officials, resting the affirmance on the school-disruption limit in Tinker v. Des Moines. (Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, opinion, No. 23-1645, 2024-06-09, counsel listing and pp. 1-2, 70.)
- 2024-08-28: in the Olentangy case the court denied the district's motion to dismiss for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction and standing, describing the organization as one that "represents several anonymous students and parents" and the challenged policies as ones covering harassment and bullying based on characteristics including gender identity. (Opinion and Order, 2024-08-28, pp. 1-2, 13; 69)
- 2026-01-20 (posted 2026-03-07): Defending Education's vice president and legal fellow filed a comment in the organization's name supporting HHS's proposed rule on disability nondiscrimination under section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act (docket HHS-OCR-2026-0034, RIN 0945-AA27). It argues that gender dysphoria falls under the statutory exclusion of "gender identity disorders not resulting from physical impairments", calls the Fourth Circuit's contrary reading an "outlier decision", and says covering gender dysphoria would "flood systems with demands for accommodations" and divert resources from "truly disabled individuals"; it also objects to "gender-affirming facilities or counseling" in schools (70).
- 2026-06-26: Defending Education's vice president filed a comment supporting HUD's proposed "Equal Access to Housing in HUD Programs Revisions" (regulations.gov docket HUD-2026-0529; the letter's own number FR-6518-P-01; RIN 2501-AE12; published 2026-04-28), which would base placement in single-sex shelters and facilities on "biological sex rather than self-identified gender identity". The comment calls gender identity "internal, subjective, malleable, and often transitory". The comment concerns adult housing programs (71).
- 2026-07-21, Ninth Circuit, Nos. 25-5641 and 25-8039 (an appeal by an employee of an Oregon education service district, a licensed clinical social worker, from the denial of a preliminary injunction after he was told to remove three books from his school offices; the court says two share the theme that gender is binary and cannot be changed and one allegorically comments on transgender issues, and the district treated the display as a "bias incident" under its policy): Defending Education is listed as an amicus curiae, through "Consovoy McCarthy Park PLLC", the firm's name as the opinion's counsel listing gives it (elsewhere on this profile it is Consovoy McCarthy PLLC). The panel affirmed the denial of the injunction (2 to 1), holding that his display in school offices while meeting students on the job was speech as a government employee, outside the First Amendment's coverage; the dissent would have protected it. The opinion's counsel listing does not say which side Defending Education's brief supported, so it is stated only that it was listed. (Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, opinion, 2026-07-21, summary and pp. 4-8; 72)
Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext
- Its gender ideology issue page (73, accessed 2026-11-17) says the group will "investigate and challenge policies and practices in K-12 schools and higher education that replace biological sex with gender identity". The scope includes higher education, where students are adults.
- In both comments (2022-09-12 and 2023-05-15) the group's lead argument is about the meaning of "sex" in the statute, not about children: that Title IX's "sex" means biological sex only (citing Bostock v. Clayton County as limited to Title VII). The letters do not themselves say the argument reaches adults (65 and 67).
What the records don't show
Whether any funder paid for anti-trans work specifically; the filings give only general purposes. Donor-advised-fund donors are undisclosed (IRS Form 990 e-file grant rows listed under Money received; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16).
Open questions
- Grants filed to the organization under other places or spellings of its name are not included in the funder lists above (IRS Form 990 e-file grant rows listed under Money received; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16).
- Which matters the Consovoy McCarthy fees ($800,000 for TY2021; $1,000,000 to $1,709,858 a year from TY2022) covered? The filings give no split by matter. The firm's signature blocks and counsel listings show it as the organization's counsel in the Olentangy appeal, the Croton-Harmon appeal and the Sullivan, Stewart and Anguiano complaints (all gender-identity cases; the Linn-Mar complaint, below, is a sixth), in the two Freedom of Information Act suits against the Department of Education, in America First Legal Foundation v. Cardona and in the IntegrateNYC appeal; the filings do not say which matters the fees paid for or how much went to which. The TY2021 fees pre-date every gender-identity case listed, and the Stewart and Anguiano complaints were filed after the latest return period. The TY2022 return covers calendar 2022 (tax period 2022-01-01 to 2022-12-31), and the Linn-Mar complaint of 2022-08-02 is signed by Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, Arlington VA, as 'Counsel for Plaintiff' (complaint dated 'August 2, 2022', Parents Defending Education v. Linn-Mar Community School District, N.D. Iowa, 74; the organization's case page, 75, gives 'Date Filed August 2, 2022' and says the case 'ended in a settlement in February 2024'). So the firm was counsel in a gender-identity case during the TY2022 period; the filings still do not split the fees by matter (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 86-1596460, object id 202323199349302792, independent-contractor section: Consovoy McCarthy PLLC, "LEGAL SERVICES", $1,000,000). (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 86-1596460, independent-contractor section, object ids 202233199349321538, 202323199349302792, 202442979349301779, 202512839349300016, 202612159349301091; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 16; complaint, 45, p. 49)
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/cor/376624335_202312_990PF_2025011022985672.pdf
- https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/cor/376624335_202412_990PF_2026062524389677.pdf
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/522166327
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/367244615
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/203672969
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/581815651
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/454678325
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/921428532
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/263922995
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/276359747
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/510172279
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/473862135
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/726018687
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/931369489
- https://defendinged.org/about
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/861596460
- https://leagle.com/decision/infdco20220923921
- https://defendinged.org/issues/gender-ideology
- https://defendinged.org/incidents/upper-moreland-school-district-mandates-that-teachers-keep-the-gender-identity-of-students-secret-from-parents-even-in-elementary-school-encourages-transgender-students-to-report-perceived-bullying/
- https://defendinged.org/complaints/ocr-complaint-lower-merion-school-district-2/
- https://defendinged.org/ocr-complaints/ocr-complaint-hopkins-public-schools/
- https://defendinged.org/ocr-complaints/ocr-complaint-newton-north-high-school/
- https://defendinged.org/sitemap_index.xml
- https://defendinged.org/post-sitemap3.xml
- https://defendinged.org/incidents/dallas-independent-school-district-appears-to-use-transgender-guidelines-created-by-texas-association-of-school-boards/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/64865566/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/66800017/
- https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/CA8-ruling-in-Linn-Mar-schools-case.pdf
- https://clearinghouse-umich-production.s3.amazonaws.com/media/doc/169684.pdf
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67367179/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/
- https://www.boston25news.com/news/local/feds-investigating-nh-school-district-accused-letting-boys-girls-only-spaces/VQUO2DA2CFAQJKWPDGDNEINHRA/
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/MPS-FERPA-and-PPRA-Complaint-04.02.2025.pdf
- https://defendinged.org/complaints/parents-defending-education-files-joint-complaint-against-milwaukee-public-schools-district-for-violations-against-ferpa-and-ppra/.
- https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/trump-admin-turns-to-student-privacy-laws-in-gender-identity-fights-with-schools/2026/09
- https://defendinged.org/complaints/parents-defending-education-files-joint-complaint-against-milwaukee-public-schools-district-for-violations-against-ferpa-and-ppra/
- https://defendinged.org/investigations/list-of-school-district-transgender-gender-nonconforming-student-policies/
- https://www.clearinghouse.net/case/45609
- https://defendinged.org/speech-first/]
- https://defendinged.org/about/
- https://www.michbar.org/Portals/0/opinions/us_appeals/2025/110625/84647.pdf
- https://hallapproved.com/us/cases/ca6/2024/10184522/
- https://www.leagle.com/decision/infco20260915060
- https://clearinghouse.net/case/46701/
- https://clearinghouse.net/doc/171001/
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/57_Stipulation-and-Settlement-Agreement-1.pdf
- https://thecrotonchronicle.substack.com/p/parents-defending-education-v-croton
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/73138559/
- https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/defending-education-v-aubrey-sullivan-order.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.mowd.190534/gov.uscourts.mowd.190534.1.0.pdf
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/73219718/
- https://news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation/missouri-state-bias-response-team-unconstitutional-group-says
- https://www.thecollegefix.com/missouri-state-u-permanently-deletes-bias-response-team-to-settle-free-speech-lawsuit/
- https://campus-speech.law.duke.edu/campus-speech-incidents/defending-education-v-williams-missouri-state-university/
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/DE_vs_UC_Regents.pdf
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/73501454/
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.623068/gov.uscourts.nysd.623068.1.0.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.265496/gov.uscourts.dcd.265496.1.0.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.278585/gov.uscourts.dcd.278585.1.0.pdf
- https://www.nycbar.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/20221436-NYCBarIntegrateNYCAmicus_FINAL_MARCH2025.pdf
- https://atlanticlegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Parents-Defending-Education-v-Linn-Mar-Community-School-District-No.-22-2927-8th-Cir.pdf
- https://clearinghouse.net/case/47685/.
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/DE-MSU_6.15.26.pdf
- https://defendinged.org/legal-updates/defending-ed-successfully-settles-bias-response-case-against-msu/
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2021-OCR-0166-210913
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9666310/parents-defending-education-v-linn-mar-community-school-district/.
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2022-OCR-0143-151644
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9916196/parents-defending-education-v-olentangy-local-school-district-board-of/.
- https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10198620/parents-defending-education-v-olentangy-local-school-district-board-of/.
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/HHS-OCR-2026-0034-0240
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/HUD-2026-0529-3744
- https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2026/07/21/25-5641.pdf.
- https://defendinged.org/issues/gender-ideology/
- https://defendinged.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Parents-Defending-Education-V-Linn-Mar-Community-School-District-1.pdf
- https://defendinged.org/lawsuits/parents-defending-education-v-linn-mar-community-school-district-et-al/