All profiles

Organization
Organization: Mountain States Legal Foundation [EIN 84-0736725]
FelixABQ, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (Mountain States Legal Foundation logo.jpg) [image page1; CC BY-SA 4.02]

Mountain States Legal Foundation

EIN 84-0736725
At least $4.2Mreceived on fileIRS Form 990 filings · 17 funders
45documented ties42 names on file
7people with a direct roleofficers, directors, founders, staff

A Colorado public-interest law firm (501(c)(3), Lakewood CO; founded 1977) that describes itself as a nonprofit public interest legal foundation representing clients pro bono and taking no government funding. In this project it appears as co-counsel with Southeastern Legal Foundation for Moms for Liberty and Young America's Foundation in the 2024 Kansas suit against the Title IX rule protecting transgender students, and as an amicus in the Supreme Court case on West Virginia's ban on transgender girls in girls' school sports. Most of its docket is unrelated (property rights, guns, energy, farming).

Sources: IRS Form 990 e-files (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3) and other public records, unless a line says otherwise. Quotation marks appear only where the page text gave the words. Amounts are as filed; recipient-side funder lists are floors and are not added across datasets.

Money received

Revenue as filed (calendar-year returns; the last return covers a six-month period ending 2025-06-30): $2,823,293 (TY2018), $2,062,828 (TY2019), $1,865,482 (TY2020), $2,557,512 (TY2021), $2,030,878 (TY2022), $3,234,209 (TY2023), $4,506,791 (TY2024), $852,425 (period ending 2025-06-30, expenses $2,573,381, assets $5,323,530). TY2024 expenses $5,342,038 and assets $7,019,577 (IRS Form 990 e-files, object ids 201931349349309753, 202041629349300724, 202101669349300935, 202201619349300610, 202302299349300340, 202441849349300129, 202531929349300223, 202630509349301543; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).

  • Funders found on other organizations' returns (grants matched by the recipient EIN 84-0736725; a grant on two returns counted once; floors; IRS Form 990 e-file grant rows):
    • DonorsTrust (EIN 52-2166327) $850,083 in 19 rows, periods ending 2020-12 to 2024-12, purposes as filed "for the Center to Keep and Bear Arms" (several spellings), "for the 2nd Amendment project", "for general operations" and "for the area of highest need" [a lower bound: grant lists for periods ending before 2020-12 and for TY2025 are not in the records; return ids 202133199349305758, 202243199349308799, 202323049349300742, 202423189349304787, 202513179349312256]; pass-through, donors undisclosed.
    • Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund $661,522 in 9 rows (2017-2025; one 2022-06-30 grant of $26,380 appears on two returns and is counted once); Vanguard Charitable $466,250 in 5 rows (2021-2025); Schwab Charitable Fund $448,775 in 9 rows (2015-2023); National Philanthropic Trust $308,000 in 7 rows (2019-2025); Donor Advised Charitable Giving $150,825 in 2 rows (2024-2025). All are donor-advised sponsors; donors are undisclosed.
    • Other named funders: Independent Petroleum Association of America $40,000 (2011-2014, "EDUCATION"); American Farm Bureau Federation $35,500 in 5 rows (2015-2024); Innovia Foundation $25,000 (2020); Montana Farm Bureau Federation $19,000 (2024 and 2025); The Denver Foundation $15,500 (2015, 2019); National Christian Charitable Foundation $15,000 (2013-2017); The Jackling Foundation $10,100 (2018).
  • Name matches (not in the EIN-matched totals above): the Sarah Scaife Foundation Incorporated (EIN 25-1113452) 990-PF rows list grants to "MOUNTAIN STATES LEGAL FOUNDATION", Lakewood CO, filed as "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT": $75,000 (2020-12-31, object id 202113169349103251), $125,000 (2022-12-31, 202323189349101532), $100,000 (2023-12-31, 202403209349104590) and $110,000 (2024-12-31, 202523189349102237), $410,000 in 4 rows. The rows carry no recipient EIN, so the match rests on the recipient's name and city (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, grantor EIN 25-1113452; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 4).
  • DonorsTrust also funds Southeastern Legal Foundation, Young America's Foundation, Do No Harm and the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (see their profiles).
  • Charles Koch Foundation (EIN 48-0918408) gave $50,000 in 2 grant-paid rows (TY2015 $25,000; TY2018 $25,000), purpose as filed "General Operating Support"; matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). A shared funder shows only that it paid the grant; no purpose beyond the filer's wording is shown. [IRS Form 990-PF e-file, EIN 48-0918408, object ids 201643209349104119, 201903199349102110; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 5
  • The Bader Family Foundation (EIN 27-6359747) gave it $805,000 in 11 rows, matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN); by year of the period end: 2014 $20,000; 2015 $50,000; 2016 $30,000; 2017 $64,000; 2018 $75,000; 2019 $51,000; 2020 $50,000; 2021 $40,000; 2022 $140,000; 2023 $135,000; 2024 $150,000; purposes as filed: "GENERAL CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTION"; recipient name as filed: "MOUNTAIN STATES LEGAL FOUNDATION" (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 27-6359747, object ids 201523139349100647, 201643209349102594, 201703189349100975, 201813199349101526, 201903239349100005, 202033219349105833, 202143239349100409, 202213199349109381, 202343189349102434, 202433209349104413, 202513219349106376; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6).
  • Adolph Coors Foundation (EIN 51-0172279; see its page) gave Mountain States Legal Foundation $150,000 in 2 rows paid: year ended 2019-11-30 $75,000 ("general operating"); year ended 2021-11-30 $75,000 ("general operating"). Recipient as filed: Mountain States Legal Foundation, Lakewood. Basis: matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, giver EIN 51-0172279, object ids 202000639349100310, 202240639349100809; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 7)
  • William S & Ann Atherton Foundation (EIN 73-1520309, Tulsa OK; page on this site): $1,500 in 2 rows (TY2016 $1,000; TY2017 $500), Lakewood CO (Form 990-PF rows matched by name and place; TY2016 to TY2017). (IRS Form 990-PF e-files, EIN 73-1520309; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 8)

Money given

No Schedule I grants appear. Contractor payments over $100,000 as filed: Cooper & Kirk PLLC $415,685 (TY2024, "CO-COUNSEL") and $315,677 (period ending 2025-06-30, "Case Co-Counsel"); Nextafter LLC $603,155 over two returns (TY2022-2023, "CONSULTING"); American Solutions for Business $264,623 (TY2022-2023, "PRINTING") (IRS Form 990 e-files, 3). The filings do not say which cases the co-counsel payments were for. MSLF's own pages show one joint matter: its press release of 2022-06-06 says the plaintiffs in a challenge to Washington's ban on large-capacity magazines (individual and organizational plaintiffs against Washington's attorney general, W.D. Wash., complaint dated 2022-06-03 per MSLF's case page) are "represented by Mountain States Legal Foundation's Center to Keep and Bear Arms (CKBA) and Cooper & Kirk, PLLC", and its case page says "Represented by the Center to Keep and Bear Arms and Cooper & Kirk, PLLC" (9 and MSLF's case page for the magazine-ban challenge, mslegal.org); that case concerns firearms, not transgender people. The signature block of the 2024 Kansas Title IX filing lists no Cooper & Kirk lawyer (see below). Do No Harm also paid Cooper & Kirk (see that profile). The Foundation's case page for that challenge lists it as W.D. Wash. No. 3:22-cv-05403 (MSLF's case page for the magazine-ban challenge, mslegal.org, accessed 2026-11-16), gives the case status as "Active" and lists as its latest case entry the motion for summary judgment the Foundation filed in August 2023. The court's order of 2023-11-21 (W.D. Wash. No. 3:22-cv-05403, Dkt. No. 153, copy posted by co-plaintiff Firearms Policy Coalition) grants the motion to stay brought by the intervenor-defendant Alliance for Gun Responsibility and defendants Ferguson, Batiste and Cole Tindall, staying the case pending the Ninth Circuit's en banc decision in No. 23-55805. Firearms Policy Coalition's case page for W.D. Wash. No. 3:22-cv-05403 (firearmspolicy.org, accessed 2026-11-16) lists no document after that order.

  • Cooper & Kirk, further pages read: MSLF's press release of 2025-09-02 on its suit over Colorado's SB25-003 (six individual plaintiffs and the Colorado Shooting Sports Association) says MSLF represents the plaintiffs and names no other counsel (10); MSLF's list of active cases names no counsel for any case. The MSLF pages cited here name Cooper & Kirk as co-counsel only in the 2022 Washington magazine-ban challenge, and none links the $415,685 (TY2024) and $315,677 (period ending 2025-06-30) payments to a case.
  • Cooper & Kirk and the Colorado case (SB25-003): the complaint (U.S. District Court, District of Colorado, case 1:25-cv-02725, filed 2025-09-02; copy hosted by AmmoLand, ammoland.com, 28 pages) is signed by two lawyers of Mountain States Legal Foundation as attorneys for the plaintiffs and names no other firm. The court's order of 2026-11-04 (document 99; Courthouse News copy of the order, courthousenews.com) denied the plaintiffs' motion for a preliminary injunction.
  • Cooper & Kirk: MSLF's press release of 2025-04-28 on its suit for the Gas and Oil Association of West Virginia against New York's law (West Virginia et al. v. James) names an MSLF senior attorney and no co-counsel; it does not state the court or docket number. [11
  • In West Virginia v. James (N.D.N.Y., lead No. 1:25-cv-00168, member No. 1:25-cv-01307), the decision dated 2026-08-31 lists three lawyers of Mountain States Legal Foundation as counsel for plaintiff Gas and Oil Association of West Virginia, Inc., and four lawyers of Cooper & Kirk, PLLC as counsel for a different plaintiff, Alpha Metallurgical Resources, Inc. (Leagle, 12). The two firms therefore appear on the same side of one case for different clients; the decision does not call either firm co-counsel of the other and the case concerns a New York climate statute, not transgender people. The filings of Mountain States Legal Foundation do not say which matters the Cooper & Kirk payments of $415,685 (TY2024) and $315,677 (period ending 2025-06-30) covered. The decision is as reproduced by Leagle; the payments are as filed on the returns cited above.

People on file

  • Cristen Wohlgemuth, President and CEO: $230,882 (TY2023), $255,085 (TY2024) (IRS Form 990 e-files, 3). MSLF's staff page lists her as President and CEO and Austin D. Scott as Chief Operating Officer, with Michael McCoy (General Counsel and Director of the Center to Keep & Bear Arms), Grady Block (Deputy General Counsel) and Kole Kelley (Director of the Center for American Prosperity & Energy) (13).
  • Other pay as filed (TY2024; roles only, the people appear only in the filing): a deputy general counsel ($258,842), two senior attorneys ($185,789 and $162,198), a development director ($151,311) and the director of the Center to Keep & Bear Arms ($118,015). The return for the period ending 2025-06-30 lists a General Counsel and a Chief Operating Officer.
  • Board (all $0): the return for the period ending 2025-06-30 names Richard Royce Fletcher (Chairman), Russ Hendricks (Vice Chairman), Peter I Wold (Treasurer), John E Rockwell (Secretary) and directors including Nick Dranias, Roy Cohee, Ken Johnson, Don Shawcroft and Brad Allen; the returns for TY2021 to TY2024 also list a further director, named in the filings only, who is not on the board page. MSLF's own Board of Directors page, set out in the next item, gives other officers: Russ Hendricks (Idaho Farm Bureau) as Chairman of the Board, William McGrath as Vice Chairman and Brad Allen as Secretary. The return covers the period to 2025-06-30; the board page is undated and lists Richard Fletcher, the return's Chairman, as "Immediate Past Chair"; neither source dates the change.
  • MSLF's own Board of Directors page (undated; 14, accessed 2026-11-10) lists, as the Executive Committee: Russ Hendricks (Chairman of the Board), Peter I. Wold (Treasurer), Richard Fletcher, Esq. (Immediate Past Chair), William McGrath (Vice Chairman), Brad Allen (Secretary) and Jordan Evert (Litigation Advisory Council Chair); as Directors: Brian Cebull, Roy Cohee, Barbara True, Nick Dranias, Esq., James Henderson, Ken Johnson, Art Johnston, David Kleinfeld, Esq., John E. Rockwell, P.E., Melissa Simpson and Larry Reagan (listed as President of New Mexico Farm & Livestock Bureau); as Director Emeritus: Roger M. Cymbaluk, Ernest Angelo, Jr., Don Thorson and Don Shawcroft. The page does not list the further director named on the returns for TY2021 to TY2024.
  • InfluenceWatch's MSLF page (undated, accessed 2026-11-11) lists an older board (Ernest Angelo Jr., Roy Brown, Roy Cohee, John Gibson, Dale Newton, Don Shawcroft, Mark Trupp, Peter Wold; emeritus Roger Bill Mitchell and Mark Sexton) and does not mention that director. [15

Anti-trans work: documented moments

  • 2024-05-14: MSLF was co-counsel with Southeastern Legal Foundation for Moms for Liberty and Young America's Foundation, with the states of Kansas, Alaska, Utah and Wyoming, in the suit against the Department of Education over the Title IX rule (Southeastern Legal Foundation post, 16; docket reported as Kansas v. Department of Education, D. Kan., No. 5:24-cv-04041). The suit asked the court to block a rule that protects transgender students; the plaintiffs said it would force students "to use incorrect pronouns", an anti-trans claim. Education Week describes an injunction covering schools attended by members of Moms for Liberty, Young America's Foundation and Female Athletes United (Education Week, 2024-09-05, 17; the article does not mention MSLF).
  • The signature block of the plaintiffs' memorandum in State of Kansas v. U.S. Department of Education, case 5:24-cv-04041-JWB-ADM (D. Kan.), Doc. 25 filed 2024-05-24, lists two lawyers of Mountain States Legal Foundation as "Counsel for Plaintiffs Moms for Liberty and Young America's Foundation", alongside three SLF lawyers under the same words; it lists Alliance Defending Freedom lawyers as counsel for a student plaintiff and Female Athletes United (U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas, No. 5:24-cv-04041; ADF's release of 2024-05-14, 18, says ADF attorneys represent Female Athletes United). SLF's case page lists an "Order Granting Preliminary Injunction" dated 2024-07-02 and a Tenth Circuit order of 2025-02-10 granting the Department's motion to hold its appeal in abeyance (19).
  • 2024-06-14: the Sixth Circuit's opinion in the Title IX gender identity case brought by twenty states against the Department of Education, with intervenors (No. 22-5807), lists a lawyer of Mountain States Legal Foundation, with lawyers of other organizations and firms, as counsel "for Amici Curiae" (p. 2); the counsel block does not say which amicus brief the Foundation's lawyer signed (the Foundation's own amicus brief of 2023-01-31 in the appeal is described below). The panel, 2 to 1, affirmed a preliminary injunction, limited to the twenty plaintiff states, against three 2021 Education Department documents stating that the Department would enforce Title IX against discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity; it held that the states likely have standing; one judge dissented. (Opinion with dissent, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, No. 22-5807, 2024-06-14, pp. 2-3)
  • 2026-06-11: MSLF posted "Victory for Free Speech!" saying it "proudly represented Moms for Liberty" in the challenge, that an injunction was secured in summer 2024, that federal courts in Texas and Kentucky struck down the rule and that the final appeals have ended (20). The title presents the suit to block a rule that protects transgender students as a win for free speech; that framing is anti-trans rhetoric.
  • 2025-09-19: the Supreme Court's docket for No. 24-43, the case on a state law that bars transgender girls from girls' school sports (21, accessed 2026-11-12; certiorari petition filed 2024-07-11), lists "Brief amicus curiae of Mountain States Legal Foundation filed" on Sep 19 2025 and lists a lawyer of the Foundation as counsel of record for it; Do No Harm appears on the same docket with counsel of record at Cooper & Kirk, PLLC. The Foundation's page says the brief argues a First Amendment issue. The docket gives "Argued" on Jan 13 2026 and, on Jun 30 2026, "Judgment REVERSED and case REMANDED. Kavanaugh, J., delivered the opinion of the Court, in which Roberts, C. J., and Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, and Barrett, JJ., joined" (with concurring and partly dissenting opinions, "Opinion also for No. 24-38"), and "Judgment Issued" on Aug 03 2026. A reproduction of the opinion gives the decision date 2026-06-30, Nos. 24-43 and 24-38 (Leagle). The Foundation's case page gives the ruling as 2026-06-30, the date on the docket; its news list dates an item "Supreme Court Upholds West Virginia Law Protecting Women's Sports" to 2026-07-06 (22). The page lists the case under the heading "Biology, Not Ideology: The Fight for Sports and Free Speech" on its cases page (23). The news title presents a law that bars transgender girls from girls' school sports as protecting women's sports, and the cases-page heading sets "biology" against "ideology", a framing that denies trans people's existence (see the evidence for pretext below); both are anti-trans rhetoric.
  • 2025-03-12: The Tenth Circuit appeal in the Kansas Title IX case (State of Kansas v. U.S. Department of Education, No. 24-3097) ended by a joint stipulation to dismiss under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 42(b)(1), each party to bear its own costs; the stipulation carries a certificate of service dated 2025-03-12. It is signed for the appellees by counsel for Kansas, Alaska, Utah and Wyoming, by Alliance Defending Freedom lawyers as counsel for an individual appellee and for Female Athletes United, and by one lawyer of Mountain States Legal Foundation and two lawyers of Southeastern Legal Foundation as "Counsel for Appellees Moms for Liberty and Young America's Foundation"; the Department of Justice signs for the appellants. (Joint Stipulation to Dismiss Appeal, Tenth Circuit No. 24-3097.)
  • The Colorado counseling case: the Foundation's case page (24; case listed as "Closed") links the brief titled "Brief for Amici Curiae Americans for Prosperity Foundation and Mountain States Legal Foundation in Support of Petitioner" (the case page gives no filing day; the file sits in the Foundation's June 2025 uploads). The Foundation's news post "Supreme Court Win for Free Speech in [the Colorado counseling case]" (25; dated 2026-03-31, by its staff writer) says the Foundation filed an amicus brief in June 2025 supporting the counselor, says Colorado "disguised its censorship by labeling its law as a mere regulation" of "conversion therapy", and quotes the Court: "The First Amendment is no word game." The post does not mention the Americans for Prosperity Foundation.
  • Kansas Title IX case, Clearinghouse's page (26, accessed 2026-11-12): "On March 13, 2025, the Tenth Circuit granted the defendants' request to dismiss the appeal"; on 2025-03-21 the court "ordered the parties to show cause why the case should not be dismissed as moot", and the defendants answered on 2025-03-26 that the case "was not technically moot" because of "ongoing litigation in Tennessee v. Cardona" but "might soon become moot"; "The case is ongoing as of April 19, 2025"; its docket list for the district court stops at entry 70 (2024-07-19) and its document list ends with the Tenth Circuit order of 2025-03-13 (district docket entry 105) and a notice in appeal No. 24-03097 of the same date; its docket section says "Last updated Oct. 21, 2026", while the page's citation line says last updated 4/11/2025 (the page's own dates conflict). The Tenth Circuit stipulation above and the Clearinghouse's 2025-03-13 order are consistent; the Clearinghouse calls the dismissal the defendants' request, the filing reviewed here is a joint stipulation.
  • Kansas Title IX case, district court, June 2026: Alliance Defending Freedom's case page (27, accessed 2026-11-12): its timeline reads "June 2026: The state of Kansas, ADF, and the U.S. Department of Education agreed to dismiss the case", and its documents table lists, under "U.S. District Court", a "Joint Stipulation of Dismissal" dated 06/11/2026. The Foundation's post "Victory for Free Speech!" (20), by its staff writer, is dated Jun 11, 2026 and says "the final appeals have come to an end, and the regulations are gone." The CourtListener docket (docket 68527706, PACER case 152561, D. Kan. No. 5:24-cv-04041, 28) lists the docket as terminated with dates 2024-05-14 to 2026-06-11. So the district docket closed with a joint stipulation of dismissal filed on or about 2026-06-11 (the document title and date are ADF's listing); the stipulation, Document 114, is set out in the next item.
  • Kansas Title IX case, the stipulation of dismissal: The joint stipulation of dismissal is Document 114 in No. 5:24-cv-04041-JWB-ADM (D. Kan.), filed 06/11/26, captioned "State of Kansas et al. v. United States Department of Education et al.", No. 24-4041-JWB (ADF's copy). It is "a joint stipulation to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii) without prejudice with each party to bear its own attorneys' fees and costs". It recites that the 2024 Title IX rule was vacated in its entirety by two district courts (E.D. Ky. 2025-01-09; N.D. Tex. 2025-02-19); that this Court issued an order to show cause on 2025-03-21 (ECF 106), denied the pending motions without prejudice (ECF 109), and that the parties filed a status report on 2025-06-25 (ECF 111) and agreed to a stay; that the proposed intervenors' appeals in the Sixth and Fifth Circuits were dismissed on 2026-05-13 and 2026-05-19; and that "the parties maintain that the at-issue case is now moot warranting dismissal". The stipulation (5 pages, signed for the parties) carries no order, judge's signature or "so ordered" line; under that rule a stipulation signed by all parties who have appeared dismisses the action when filed, without a court order, so the dismissal took effect on the filing date, 2026-06-11. The signature block of Document 114 carries lawyers of Mountain States Legal Foundation and of Southeastern Legal Foundation marked "Counsel for Plaintiffs Young America's Foundation and Moms for Liberty"; the other plaintiffs' lawyers sign separately for each state and for the other plaintiffs, so both clients appear on the filing that ended the case. The stipulation does not say whether the Court entered any further order. (District of Kansas, No. 5:24-cv-04041, Document 114; cited by court and docket number.)
  • 2022-05-23: Mountain States Legal Foundation (MSLF) moved the Supreme Court of Virginia for leave to file an amicus brief supporting a high school teacher, the plaintiff-appellant, in a suit against a school board and three school officials sued in their official capacities. The teacher had been dismissed after declining to use a transgender student's pronouns. The motion gives MSLF's reason for filing: "This case is particularly appropriate for MSLF to speak to the Court as it involves the proper interpretation of Title IX and its implementing regulations." (p. 2). The attached brief argued that Title IX covers sex only in a binary sense and not gender identity, that the school relied on a 2016 federal guidance letter that the brief says was enjoined and rescinded and had no binding effect, and that one accidental use of a pronoun plus general avoidance is not harassment under Title IX. It says of the teacher: "His declination to adopt pronouns reflecting non-biological gender identity is based on his religious conviction that sex is unchangeable." (p. 17). Its conclusion states: "Gender identity is distinct from, not encompassed within, “sex” as that term is used in Title IX." (p. 50). It asked the court to hold that "its demurrer should not have been sustained, and the case should be reversed and remanded to proceed on the merits." (p. 51). The brief's argument against recognizing gender identity and its refusal of a trans student's pronouns are anti-trans claims. Case status: On 2023-12-14 the Supreme Court of Virginia reversed the circuit court's ruling that had sustained the demurrer, the result this brief asked for, and a settlement was reported in September 2024. (Motion of Mountain States Legal Foundation for Leave to File Brief Amicus Curiae in Support of Plaintiff-Appellant (with attached Brief of Amicus Curiae), Supreme Court of Virginia, Record No. 211061, 2022-05-23, pp. 2, 17, 50, 51; 29; copy hosted by a third party) The appellant's reply brief of 2022-08-24 (Record No. 211061, p. 23) lists the Foundation among the amici: "See generally brief of Amici Curiae Bader Family Foundation, et al., and both briefs of Amicus Curiae Mountain States Legal Foundation."
  • 2023-10-02: MSLF and the Manhattan Institute filed an amicus brief in the First Circuit supporting a middle school student, by his parents, in a suit against a Massachusetts town, its school committee and two school officials sued in their official capacities. The student's claim is that the school violated his First Amendment rights by barring a shirt reading "there are only two genders". The amici asked the court to reverse the dismissal and argued that a student's speech on a matter of public concern cannot be suppressed because listeners are upset. The brief describes the shirt's message as one that "could reasonably be interpreted as a critique—albeit a mild one—of fashionable elite ideologies concerning sex and gender." (p. 9). The brief makes the anti-trans claim that the Supreme Court has reaffirmed, including in Bostock v. Clayton County, "as a matter of foundational legal principle: there are in fact, only two genders." (p. 11). It also asserts, in an anti-trans claim that denies trans women's identity, that "A male person’s internal feelings of “femaleness” or “neither- male-nor-femaleness” can presumably constitute genuine feelings, but they cannot, as if by magic, change the objective fact of that person’s sex." (p. 29). Case status: The First Circuit affirmed the dismissal in June 2024, the opposite of what this brief asked, and the Supreme Court denied certiorari on 2025-05-27. (Amicus Curiae Brief of Mountain States Legal Foundation and Manhattan Institute in Support of Plaintiff-Appellant and Reversal, U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, Nos. 23-1535 and 23-1645, 2023-10-02, pp. 9, 11, 29)
  • 2023-12-15: MSLF was one of four amici (with Americans for Prosperity Foundation, Southeastern Legal Foundation and the Manhattan Institute, each through its own counsel) in a brief to the Supreme Court of Colorado supporting Masterpiece Cakeshop, Inc. and its owner, the petitioners, against a customer. The amici asked the court to reverse the Court of Appeals, which had held that Colorado's public accommodations law applied to the bakery's refusal of a custom pink-and-blue cake and that making the cake would not compel speech. The brief frames the order as a cake to celebrate a gender transition and argues that making it would compel the owner's speech; that framing is the amici's characterisation, not the lower court's holding, and it is an anti-trans claim. The brief says the cake would communicate "that human beings can change their sex, and that a decision by a human to “identify as” the opposite sex (or perhaps as both sexes, or neither sex) is something to be celebrated." (p. 10). It closes: "creative talents to celebrate gender transitioning specifically. That is unconstitutional. This Court should reverse the Court of Appeals." (p. 24). Case status: The Colorado Supreme Court dismissed the case 4-3 on procedural grounds on 2024-10-08 without deciding the First Amendment question this brief argues, and vacated the trial court's findings of discrimination. (Brief of Amici Curiae Mountain States Legal Foundation, Americans for Prosperity Foundation, Southeastern Legal Foundation, and Manhattan Institute in Support of Petitioners and for Reversal, Supreme Court of Colorado, No. 2023SC116, 2023-12-15, pp. 10, 24; 30)
  • 2024-08-15: Mountain States Legal Foundation is one of the amici in a brief that Advancing American Freedom, Inc. filed as counsel for the listed amici, at the petition stage, in support of the State of West Virginia's petition in State of West Virginia, et al. v. a minor plaintiff, by her next friend and parent, No. 24-43, Supreme Court of the United States (p. 2). The amici asked the Court to grant the petition and rule for the State, so that a state may limit girls' sports teams by sex determined at birth, including against a trans girl. About half the brief argues, citing the Cass Review, that puberty blockers for trans minors are harmful and likens them to child sacrifice, castration and genital mutilation; these are the amici's claims, and they are anti-trans rhetoric. Its conclusion reads: "For that reason, the Court should grant certiorari in this case and rule for petitioners." (p. 38). On 2026-06-30 the Supreme Court reversed the Fourth Circuit judgment under review and remanded (judgment issued 2026-08-03); this petition-stage brief supported the petitioners, the side that prevailed. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in Support of Petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-43, 2024-08-15, pp. 2, 38; 21)
  • 2025-06-17: Mountain States Legal Foundation was one of two amici (jointly with Southeastern Legal Foundation) in the Ninth Circuit case brought by two school employees (a teacher and an assistant principal) against Grants Pass School District No. 7, its superintendent, a principal and three board members, after the district terminated them (later reinstated and transferred) over their public "I Resolve" campaign against the district's guidance on students' gender identity. The opinion's counsel block lists Foundation attorneys for the two amici; the opinion does not say what the amicus brief argued. The panel affirmed summary judgment for the individual defendants on the damages claims on qualified immunity, and held: "However, for those damages claims, we vacate the grant of summary judgment to the District; for the related claims for declaratory and injunctive relief, we vacate the grant of summary judgment to all Defendants." (p. 69). It also vacated summary judgment on the prior restraint and compelled speech claims and on the Title VII claim, affirmed it on the facial viewpoint claim and the Oregon constitutional claim, and remanded. Case status: In November 2025 the plaintiffs' counsel announced that the plaintiffs and the school district had settled after this opinion's remand; the status rests on the plaintiffs' counsel's own announcement. (Opinion, two school employees v. Grants Pass School District No. 7, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 23-35288, 2025-06-17, pp. 6, 69; 31)
  • 2022-09-12 (posted 2022-11-07): MSLF filed a comment objecting to the Education Department's proposed Title IX rule (docket ED-2021-OCR-0166). It asks the Department to "scrap its Proposed Rule," argues that including gender identity would "violate the Major Questions doctrine," and says that if Title IX were read to require "preferred pronouns inconsistent with biological sex," the Department "should anticipate being sued by groups like Mountain States Legal Foundation." The comment says MSLF gave live comment at the Department's listening session of 2021-06-10 and met Department and Office of Management and Budget officials on 2022-03-21. (32)
  • 2023-01-31: MSLF filed an amicus brief "in support of appellees and affirmance" in the Sixth Circuit appeal over the Education Department's 2021 Title IX documents (No. 22-5807); Alliance Defending Freedom reproduced the brief among its exhibits to its comment of 2023-05-15 in docket ED-2022-OCR-0143. (Amicus brief, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, No. 22-5807, 2023-01-31)
  • 2023-03-30: MSLF's counsel was counsel of record on an amicus brief for "21 Athletic Officials and Coaches of Female Athletes" supporting the appellants in Second Circuit No. 21-1365 (a case with minor parties, so cited by court and docket number only); Alliance Defending Freedom reproduced it among its exhibits to the same comment. (Amicus brief, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, No. 21-1365, 2023-03-30)
  • 2023-05-15 (posted 2023-05-19): MSLF filed a comment objecting to the proposed athletics rule (docket ED-2022-OCR-0143), saying the rule "would have disastrous effects on the safety of women of all ages" and that the earlier proposed rule "purports to re-write the definition of sex to include sexual orientation and gender identity." (33)
  • 2024-09-10: in Sixth Circuit No. 23-5293 a Mountain States Legal Foundation lawyer appeared with a Washington firm on a brief of amici curiae (the counsel list does not say which side); the appellee, a psychiatrist who had spoken on childhood gender dysphoria with the Heritage Foundation and sued over the non-renewal of his contract, was represented by Alliance Defending Freedom. The court affirmed the denial of immunity defences. Source: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, No. 23-5293, opinion of 2024-09-10.

Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext

  • The plaintiffs' memorandum of 2024-05-24 in State of Kansas, et al. v. United States Department of Education (D. Kan., No. 5:24-cv-04041-JWB-ADM, Document 25), whose signature block lists lawyers of the Foundation as "Counsel for Plaintiffs Moms for Liberty and Young America's Foundation", argues beyond children and school sports. Its introduction says: "Defendants seek to utilize the rulemaking process to remake our schools and universities to conform to the radical gender ideology of the Biden administration and its allies." (ECF page 11 of 68). It argues that the 2024 rule "brings within its purview nearly any speech about the important public issues of how to treat and understand gender dysphoria, men's participation in women's sports, name and pronoun usage, restroom use, and gender identity generally." (ECF page 44) and gives as an example that the rule "would require a state university to engage in viewpoint discrimination by investigating and disciplining a student who wrote "men cannot become women" on a sidewalk" (ECF page 55). The passages reach universities, adult college students and speech about transgender people generally, and the memorandum calls recognition of gender identity "gender ideology". These are the plaintiffs' arguments; the memorandum was filed for a group of plaintiffs by several sets of lawyers, so the words are not the Foundation's alone. Case status: the district court granted the preliminary injunction on 2024-07-02 (Document 54); on 2026-06-11 all parties filed a joint stipulation to dismiss without prejudice under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii), each party to bear its own fees and costs (Document 114), reciting that the 2024 rule had been vacated in its entirety by two other district courts (E.D. Ky., 2025-01-09; N.D. Tex., 2025-02-19) and that the parties "maintain that the at-issue case is now moot warranting dismissal". (Memorandum in support of a stay or preliminary injunction, U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas, No. 5:24-cv-04041-JWB-ADM, Document 25, 2024-05-24, ECF pages 11, 44, 55, 66-67; Joint Stipulation to Dismiss, same court, Document 114, 2026-06-11, pp. 1-3; docket page 28)
  • The cases page headline "Biology, Not Ideology" uses the "ideology" framing, which denies trans people's existence (23).
  • In the Virginia amicus brief (Record No. 211061, 2022-05-23) MSLF argues against covering gender identity under Title IX at the college level, which concerns adult students: "At the postsecondary level, in addition to athletics and school-sponsored single-sex activities such as sororities or fraternities, wrapping gender identity into Title IX would force colleges to create new separate and equal facilities, such as dormitories, each for men, women, intersex individuals, pansexual individuals, bi- gender individuals, and members of each of the many other currently published genders." (p. 30). The passage reaches colleges and their dormitories and fraternities and sororities, not children or sports teams alone. The passage ridicules the recognition of trans and nonbinary people and is anti-trans rhetoric. Case status: On 2023-12-14 the Supreme Court of Virginia reversed the circuit court's ruling that had sustained the demurrer, the result this brief asked for, and a settlement was reported in September 2024. (Motion of Mountain States Legal Foundation for Leave to File Brief Amicus Curiae in Support of Plaintiff-Appellant (with attached Brief of Amicus Curiae), Supreme Court of Virginia, Record No. 211061, 2022-05-23, p. 30; 29; copy hosted by a third party)
  • 2024-08-15: The same brief, on which Mountain States Legal Foundation is one of the amici and which was filed in a case about girls' sports, states in a footnote: "this brief uses pronouns that correspond to the referent person's biological sex." (p. 16). The footnote applies that rule to every trans person the brief names, so it reaches beyond children and sports. Refusing a trans person's pronouns denies the person's identity and is anti-trans rhetoric. On 2026-06-30 the Supreme Court reversed the Fourth Circuit judgment under review and remanded (judgment issued 2026-08-03); this petition-stage brief supported the petitioners, the side that prevailed. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in Support of Petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-43, 2024-08-15, pp. 16; 21)

Ties

  • Formal joint work: Moms for Liberty (client, 2024 Title IX suit; MSLF post); Southeastern Legal Foundation (co-counsel); Young America's Foundation (co-plaintiff in the Kansas suit; separately a case MSLF's site lists as Young America's Foundation v. U.C.L.A., a campus free-speech case not about transgender people: MSLF press release "UCLA Faces Lawsuit for First Amendment Violations" dated 2024-10-04, 34, and case page 35; the case page does not name counsel of record).
  • Funding: DonorsTrust $850,083 [19 rows; periods ending 2020-12 to 2024-12; a lower bound: grant lists for periods ending before 2020-12 and for TY2025 are not in the records; return ids 202133199349305758, 202243199349308799, 202323049349300742, 202423189349304787, 202513179349312256]; donor-advised sponsors as above (grantor returns).
  • Role: board and staff as above (IRS Form 990 e-files, 3).
  • Narrative alignment only (not a tie): the amicus brief in the West Virginia girls' sports case aligns it with the other sports-ban litigants.

What the records don't show

  • MSLF's own 2026 post (20) names Moms for Liberty as the client it represented, but the signature block of Document 25 in the Kansas Title IX case (U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas, No. 5:24-cv-04041-JWB-ADM, 2024-05-24) lists it as counsel for both Moms for Liberty and Young America's Foundation.
  • Whether any funder paid for the transgender-related cases: the filings give only general purposes (IRS Form 990 e-files; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3). The amounts it paid Cooper & Kirk are not linked to cases (see Money given).

Open questions

  • Whether the district docket shows any entry after the joint stipulation of dismissal in the Kansas Title IX case (Document 114, filed 2026-06-11), which dismissed the action on filing without a court order (see Documented moments); MSLF's post of 2026-06-11 does not name the court in which the Kansas case was dismissed.
  • What the Cooper & Kirk "co-counsel" payments of $415,685 and $315,677 covered: MSLF's pages show Cooper & Kirk as co-counsel in the Washington magazine-ban case (firearms); the 2024 Kansas signature block lists none of its lawyers; MSLF's press releases of 2025-09-02 (Colorado SB25-003) and 2025-04-28 (West Virginia et al. v. James) name no co-counsel; no source cited ties the payments to the Title IX or sports cases.
  • Who the further director listed on the returns for TY2021 to TY2024 is (hours 1.00; object ids 202201619349300610, 202302299349300340, 202441849349300129 and 202531929349300223): the filing gives only a name, and MSLF's own Board of Directors page (undated) does not list the director.

Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.

Sources

  1. image page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mountain_States_Legal_Foundation
  2. CC BY-SA 4.0: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0
  3. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/840736725
  4. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/251113452
  5. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/480918408]
  6. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/276359747
  7. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/510172279.
  8. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/731520309
  9. https://mslegal.org/press-releases/ckba-challenges-washingtons-firearm-magazine-ban-in-federal-court/
  10. https://mslegal.org/?p=40529
  11. https://mslegal.org/press-releases/new-case-mountain-states-legal-foundation-defends-energy-producers-from-new-york-overreach/]
  12. https://www.leagle.com/decision/infdco20260901c71
  13. https://mslegal.org/staff/
  14. https://mslegal.org/board-2/
  15. https://www.influencewatch.org/non-profit/mountain-states-legal-foundation/]
  16. https://slfliberty.org/?p=5079
  17. https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/how-moms-for-libertys-legal-strategy-has-upended-title-ix-rules-for-schools/2024/09
  18. https://adflegal.org/press-release/more-states-girls-sue-biden-admin-illegal-attempt-rewrite-title-ix
  19. https://slfliberty.org/case/moms-for-liberty-and-young-americas-foundation-et-al-v-u-s-department-of-education
  20. https://mslegal.org/news/victory-for-free-speech/
  21. https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/24-43.html
  22. https://mslegal.org/news/
  23. https://mslegal.org/cases/
  24. https://mslegal.org/?p=39982
  25. https://mslegal.org/?p=41150
  26. https://clearinghouse.net/case/45705/
  27. https://adflegal.org/case/state-kansas-v-us-department-education/
  28. https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68527706/kansas-state-of-v-united-states-department-of-education/
  29. https://statecourtreport.org/sites/default/files/2023-12/mountain-states-legal-foundation-amicus-brief-05.23.2022.pdf
  30. https://slfliberty.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/20231215-Br.-of-MSLF-SLF.pdf
  31. https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2025/06/16/23-35288.pdf
  32. https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2021-OCR-0166-224738
  33. https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2022-OCR-0143-150916
  34. https://mslegal.org/press-releases/ucla-faces-lawsuit-for-first-amendment-violations/
  35. https://mslegal.org/cases/young-americas-foundation-v-u-c-l-a/