![Organization: Maine Heritage Policy Center, now Maine Policy Institute [EIN 22-3888250]](assets/profiles/org_maine_heritage_policy_center.png)
Maine Heritage Policy Center
A Maine nonprofit think tank in Portland, Maine (IRS Form 990 filer, December year end; the returns carry the name "The Maine Heritage Policy Center", PO Box, Portland ME, for TY2010 to TY2024). Wikipedia says its former name was Maine Heritage Policy Center, that it was established in 2002, that Matthew Gagnon is its chief executive, that Scott Wellman is its chair, that Dick Jackson is its founder and that it is a member of State Policy Network (2; the page gives no date for the rename). Its returns give its mission as "TO FORMULATE AND PROMOTE CONSERVATIVE PUBLIC POLICIES BASED ON THE PRINCIPLES OF FREE ENTERPRISE; LIMITED, CONSTITUTIONAL GOVERNMENT; INDIVIDUAL FREEDOM; AND TRADITIONAL AMERICAN VALUES." (TY2020, object id 202143169349313219). Sponsor and foundation rows on other organizations' returns carry this EIN under the names "THE MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER DBA MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE", "MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE (MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER)" and "Maine Policy Institute". Form 990-PF rows from the Klingenstein fund and the Bradley foundation filed "MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE" or "Maine Policy Institute", Portland ME, carry no EIN and are counted by the name the Center now operates under and its own place. A different filer named "MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE" with EIN 45-3639767 (an automatic-revocation list entry and a 990-N record) is a separate organization and is not used here ("not a tie (name match)").
It is profiled here because its own pages and a news report document its work against trans students in Maine schools (the sections below), and because grants to it are recorded from 13 grantors that have pages on this site and a former chief executive who has a page.
Sources: IRS Form 990 e-file returns (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3), unless a line says otherwise. Grant rows were matched by EIN 22-3888250 and by the exact name "Maine Heritage Policy Center" (and the name "Maine Policy Institute" in the returns of the two private foundations named above), a grant that appears twice with the same grantor, period, amount, purpose and recipient was counted once.
Money received
- Revenue, expenses and assets as filed (total revenue; IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 22-3888250; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3): TY2010 $1,071,606 (expenses $1,153,631; assets $296,968) [object id 201133199349308873]; TY2011 $716,761 (expenses $855,821; assets $104,328) [201203199349304335]; TY2012 $693,212 (expenses $711,650; assets $77,659) [201303189349301855]; TY2013 $661,260 (expenses $710,251; assets $36,622) [201403189349304820]; TY2014 $557,262 (expenses $533,244; assets $44,991) [201503209349303120]; TY2014 $557,262 (expenses $550,581; assets $44,991) [201713199349305276]; TY2015 $621,593 (expenses $517,871; assets $143,228) [201613149349302461]; TY2015 $621,593 (expenses $561,862; assets $143,228) [201713199349304821]; TY2016 $646,421 (expenses $646,901; assets $187,326) [201703199349305075]; TY2017 $650,843 (expenses $631,379; assets $203,490) [201803129349301840]; TY2018 $599,535 (expenses $717,288; assets $121,916) [201923169349305087]; TY2019 $639,746 (expenses $674,147; assets $123,221) [202003189349310450]; TY2020 $688,189 (expenses $655,594; assets $188,791) [202143169349313219]; TY2021 $1,075,647 (expenses $940,028; assets $318,158) [202223189349314217]; TY2022 $1,063,765 (expenses $1,017,008; assets $363,655) [202343219349301114]; TY2023 $1,699,340 (expenses $1,409,240; assets $693,463) [202423209349321527]; TY2024 $1,946,538 (expenses $1,731,079; assets $891,365) [202503159349305675]. Two returns each for TY2014 and TY2015 carry the same revenue and different expense figures; both are shown.
- Grants received from organizations that have pages on this site: $3,621,249 in 49 paid rows from 13 grantors (the same grant on two returns counted once; no row is identical to another in the same return; rows from private foundations (Form 990-PF) are matched by the recipient's full name, or the name it now operates under, and place, Portland ME, and carry no recipient EIN; all other rows carry EIN 22-3888250):
- Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc (Schwab Charitable): 2 rows, $770,100 (2022 $10,000; 2023 $760,100), filed "MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER", purposes as filed "EDUCATION" (objects 202330939349300403, 202411039349301716).
- The 85 Fund: 1 row, $760,000 (2024), filed "Maine Policy Institute", purpose "General Support" (object 202533219349303288).
- DonorsTrust (filed "Donors Trust Inc"): 5 rows, $509,500, 2020 to 2024 (2020 $37,000; 2021 $22,500; 2024 $450,000 in 3 rows), purposes "for general operations", "for the Maine Eduation Report Project" and "to support the Maine Education Report Project" as filed (objects 202133199349305758, 202243199349308799, 202513179349312256).
- State Policy Network: 8 rows, $380,950, 2012 to 2025 (purposes "COMMUNICATIONS EDUCATION", "ECONOMIC FREEDOM RESEARCH", "ECONOMIC FREEDOM RESEARCH; TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH", "FISCAL & REGULATORY").
- National Philanthropic Trust: 5 rows, $140,000, 2021 to 2025 (purposes "CULTURE & ARTS" and "RELIGION").
- Thomas D Klingenstein Fund: 4 rows, $589,089, all purpose "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT": $15,045 (2014, filed "MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER", Portland ME; object 201523209349101677) and three rows filed "MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE", Portland ME, the name the Center now operates under and its own place: $249,044 (2021, object 202223199349101637), $125,000 (2022, object 202343149349100019) and $200,000 (2023, object 202443199349103554), $574,044 in all.
- National Christian Charitable Foundation (filed "NATL CHRISTIAN CHARITABLE FDN INC"): 7 rows, $120,000, 2016 to 2023 (purposes "JUSTICE" and "SOCIAL, CIVIC AND PUBLIC POLICY").
- Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund: 7 rows, $103,360, 2018 to 2025 (purpose "FOR GRANT RECIPIENT'S EXEMPT PURPOSES"). A row of $16,200 (period ending 2022-06-30, object 202321309349304807) carries this EIN but is filed to "SHENANDOAH UNIVERSITY", Winchester VA; stated apart and not counted (the same grant appears on a later return, object 202430459349302913, filed to this organization and counted).
- The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation Inc: 3 rows, $150,750: $50,000 (2020, filed "Maine Policy Institute", "To support a 2020 Bradley Freedom Grant", object 202103189349100000); $50,750 ("To support a 2022 Bradley Freedom Grant", listed on the TY2022 return, filed "Maine Policy Institute", object 202323189349105992, and again on the TY2023 return, filed "The Maine Heritage Policy Center", object 202403209349104125; the same amount and purpose, counted once); and $50,000 (2024, "To support general operations", object 202523219349106577). All filed with the Center's own place, Portland ME.
- State Solutions Inc: 1 row, $55,000 (period ending 2021-09-30, "SUPPORT MISSION OF ENTITY", object 202202279349302995), filed to "MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE", Yarmouth ME, carrying this EIN: the name is the organization's current name; the place Yarmouth is not on its own returns.
- Morgan Stanley Global Impact Funding Trust Inc: 2 rows, $20,000 (2023 $10,000; 2024 $10,000; "UNRESTRICTED GENERAL SUPPORT").
- Greater Houston Community Foundation: 3 rows, $15,000 (2018 to 2020, $5,000 each; purposes include "2018 MHPC Leadership Circle contribution" as filed and, for 2020, "General Operating Grant" followed by the name of a donor, which is not given here).
- Charles Koch Institute (name as filed): 1 row, $7,500 (2014, "EDUCATION") (IRS Form 990 and 990-PF e-files).
- Stated apart and out of totals: the same Klingenstein return (period ending 2022-12-31, object 202343149349100019) also lists $125,000 ("GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT") to "THE MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER", Yarmouth ME, in addition to the $125,000 row filed "MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE", Portland ME that is counted above. The Form 990-PF row carries no EIN and the place Yarmouth does not appear on any return of the Center (its own about page gives a Portland post office box), so it is "not a tie (name match)"; whether the two $125,000 rows are one grant listed under two names is not known, and the total counts only the Portland row.
- The Center announced on 2020-03-09 "that it is changing its name to Maine Policy Institute, effective March 11, 2020"; the release gives the reason that the name "reflects the organization's commitment to independent, nonpartisan policy analysis" and quotes board chairman Scott Wellman (4). The Maine Wire (Jacob Posik, 2020-03-10, 5; page updated 2026-08-19) reports the same and quotes CEO Matthew Gagnon. Neither says the legal name changed. The returns for TY2020 to TY2024 are all filed under "THE MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER", a post-office box in Portland ME (objects 202143169349313219, 202223189349314217, 202343219349301114, 202423209349321527, 202503159349305675), and the IRS master file carries the same name; the latest return is for period 2024-12. The Institute's own about page (6) gives a Portland post-office box and says nothing about the former name.
- Yarmouth: the Center's job posting of 2016-06-20 on its own site (7) calls it "based in Yarmouth, Maine"; its returns and the IRS file give only the Portland post-office box, and its current about page gives only that box. So the Yarmouth place of the State Solutions row (period ending 2021-09-30) and of the Klingenstein TY2022 row is a place the Center itself has used.
- The Thomas D Klingenstein Fund's TY2022 return (EIN 20-1450695, object 202343149349100019; 45 grant rows, $4,550,939; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 8) lists "MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE", Portland ME, $125,000 and "THE MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER", Yarmouth ME, $125,000, both "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT", both with recipient status "PC" and relationship "N/A", as two separate rows. The return does not say whether they are one grant listed twice. The fund's rows to the Center are $249,044 (TY2021, one row) and $200,000 (TY2023, one row). The page's treatment (count the Portland row, state the Yarmouth row apart) stands; with the 2016 posting above, the Yarmouth place is no longer foreign to the Center, and whether the rows are one grant or two is not known.
People on file
- Matthew Gagnon: chief executive; the TY2024 return lists "MATTHEW GAGNON", CEO, $284,107 (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 22-3888250, object id 202503159349305675; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3); Wikipedia names him as chief executive.
- Scott Wellman: listed as chairman on the TY2024 return; Wikipedia names him as chair (both read).
- Tarren Bragdon: Wikipedia says "Bragdon headed MHPC, a conservative think tank, from 2008 through 2011" (9; see his page).
- Harris Van Pate: policy analyst for the Institute; author of two posts on its site (below) and quoted by The Maine Monitor as "a policy analyst for the conservative Maine Policy Institute" (2025-12-02).
- Other directors appear on the return by name only and are not listed here.
- Parents' Rights in Education, Maine, relation to the national group and its EIN: The national site's donate page (10) prints "PRIE EIN# 47-3448838" and a Tigard, Oregon mailing address. The IRS exempt-organization master file, IRS Form 990-EZ returns (tax year 2022 revenue $70,488; tax year 2025 revenue $154,556) and the Oregon Department of Justice charity register all list "Parents Rights in Education" / "Parents' Rights in Education" under EIN 47-3448838 (the IRS file at Hillsboro OR, the Oregon register at Tigard OR) (IRS exempt-organization master file; Form 990-EZ e-file objects 202341219349201959 and 202601079349201120; Oregon DOJ charity register, EIN 47-3448838). The national site's "State Websites" page (11) lists "Maine" at 12 under "State Affiliates"; the Maine site carries the same footer, "Parents Rights in Education is a 501(c)(3) organization", shows no EIN, no legal name and no address of its own, and says it is "Developed and managed by Hostdoodle, a service of Burnett Media Group". The Maine site (12, accessed 2026-11-16) links its "Donate" and "Make an Impact" buttons to the national group's donate page cited above (accessed 2026-11-16). The national site's "Affiliate Application" page (13, accessed 2026-11-16) invites a person to "apply to start your own" affiliate through a form asking for a name, city and state, and lists the "Affiliate Responsibilities" as using the national Leadership Center, submitting content "for National and State Websites", getting certified in both training-center courses, completing a "Weekly Affiliate Check-In" and joining "Club 12 x 12". Neither page names a separate legal body or identifier for the Maine affiliate. The Maine Monitor (Daniel O'Connor, "Meet the groups pushing Maine school boards to change transgender policies", 2025-11-02, 14) calls it "the Topsham-based chapter of a national nonprofit", identifies "Allen Sarvinas" as "the director of Maine's PRIE chapter" and says that at an August training he "claimed credit for 'flipping' boards in RSU 73 and RSU 24". The sources present the Maine unit as a chapter of the national organization whose EIN is 47-3448838.
Anti-trans work: documented moments
- The Institute runs Fix Maine Schools, whose home page reads "A Project of Maine Policy Institute" (15); the site offers model school-board policies and a Title IX resolution and refers to the Maine Education Initiative; the pages reviewed here do not themselves mention trans people. Its page "Title IX Complaint Model Letter for Parents" is dated April 30, 2025 and June 27, 2025 and links a downloadable template; the page reviewed here does not describe what the letter complains about (16).
- 2025-02-28 (the date on the cover of the template): the "Title IX Complaint Template for Maine Parents", a four-page PDF on the Institute's Fix Maine Schools site (17). Its introduction says the federal administration will "interpret Title IX... to require schools to separate bathrooms, locker rooms, and sports teams by sex rather than gender identity", calls this "a major victory for privacy, safety, and fairness for girls", and says "many Maine schools continue to allow boys who identify as girls into girls' bathrooms, locker rooms, and onto their sports teams. This is unacceptable." It tells parents to file a complaint using the template below it and to email it to the Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights. The template letter says the district has "implemented a policy that allows male students who identify as female to use bathrooms and locker rooms designated for female students", a policy "that allows male students to play on female sports teams" or one that lets such students share overnight accommodations on school trips, asks the Office to investigate the district "for noncompliance with Title IX and with President Trump's recent executive orders on protecting women and girls from gender ideology", and asks for enforcement "up to and including revoking federal funds". Calling trans girls "boys who identify as girls" and trans people's existence "gender ideology" is the bad-faith framing used to deny them equal treatment; a mass-complaint template of this kind also turns a false picture of how many trans athletes there are (an NCAA spokesperson put the number in women's sports at "effectively zero") into pressure on schools. [Institute's Fix Maine Schools template]
- The Fix Maine Schools site also offers a model "Title IX Resolution for School Boards", "Ensuring Compliance with Title IX and Protection of Sex-Based Privacy" (18). It cites Executive Order 14201 ("Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports"), and resolves that the school board direct the superintendent to amend all district policies to align with Title IX "recognizing only the two sexes, male and female", to designate and give access to bathrooms, locker rooms and overnight field-trip accommodations "according to sex", and to separate extracurricular activities and athletic teams by sex; its instructions tell districts to contact the Maine Education Initiative. A resolution that recognizes "only the two sexes" denies trans people's existence in district policy, and the resolution applies to "all district policies", not only to children's sports. [Institute's Fix Maine Schools template]
- 2025-04-17: Harris Van Pate, "What Mills and Frey Get Wrong About the Trump Admin's Title IX Lawsuit Against Maine", on the Institute's site, opens "Earlier this week, the United States Department of Justice filed a lawsuit against the Maine Department of Education" and ends by saying the courts "will determine whether Maine can continue denying girls the level" playing field; the post argues for the federal suit against Maine over trans girls' participation in girls' sports, which is anti-trans rhetoric in bad faith (19).
- 2025-04-24: Van Pate, "Where do federal courts stand on transgender student athletes?", concludes: "Regardless, federal courts are certainly more split on this issue than Maine Attorney General Aaron Frey has indicated." (20) The post is part of the Institute's campaign against trans student athletes; presenting the matter as a question on which courts are "split" gives bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric the look of a neutral legal dispute.
- 2025-05-14: the Institute's site lists a post titled "Parsing Aaron Frey's Strategy: A Closer Look at Maine's Rebuttal to the Title IX Lawsuit" (21; title and date only).
- 2025-12-02: The Maine Monitor (Daniel O'Connor, "Maine school boards scramble to respond to lawsuit over transgender policies", 22) describes Harris Van Pate as "a policy analyst for the conservative Maine Policy Institute, which pushed school districts across Maine to bar trans athletes". That is what the outlet reports the Institute did; pushing districts to bar trans athletes is anti-trans work, and the arguments used for it are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. In a photo caption the outlet says several school districts passed resolutions matching "a sample policy created by the Maine Education Initiative" (the outlet's statements).
- Facts the framing leaves out: The Bulwark reported that an NCAA spokesperson, speaking to Pablo Torre Finds Out, put the number of trans athletes in women's sports at "effectively zero" (The Bulwark, 23). The girls' sports argument rests on a false picture of reality and is anti-trans rhetoric.
- The Maine Monitor (Daniel O'Connor, 2025-11-02, 14) describes the Maine Education Initiative as "an offshoot of the conservative think tank, Maine Policy Institute," which "directs them on how to pass conservative policy on trans rights", says RSU 73 and RSU 24 "recently passed anti-trans resolutions", and says at least eight districts changed their policies that year, several with resolutions matching the Initiative's sample language; it names no other district as having passed a resolution and gives no vote. (The Maine Monitor)
- The Bangor Daily News (Sabrina Martin, 2026-09-09, 24) reports that RSU 24 passed a resolution barring trans students from sports and from spaces matching their gender identity (a 4 to 4 vote that passed under the district's weighted voting; the policy took effect July 1), after the board rescinded a 2019 policy in May 2025; and that documents a resident group obtained (more than 900 pages) show the Institute's education initiative director, Heidi Sampson, emailed two board members sample Title IX policies on 2025-10-08, the day after the vote, and was in "consistent communication" with board members, including on how a policy could be enforced. The same report says a Maine First newsletter said its counsel had given board members "a legal opinion and a model parliamentary motion", that the board later hired that lawyer, and that the Maine Human Rights Commission sued RSU 24 and four other districts. The article names no Office for Civil Rights complaint. (Bangor Daily News)
- The Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights opened Title IX investigations of two Maine districts, RSU 19 (Newport) and RSU 57 (Waterboro), reported on 2026-01-14: the department said the districts are accused of policies that "discriminate on the basis of sex by permitting students to participate in sports" by gender identity, and said the investigations followed complaints; the report names no complainant and no use of the Institute's template. (Bangor Daily News, Marie Weidmayer, 2026-01-14, 25) No source reviewed here ties either investigation, or any Office for Civil Rights finding, to the Institute's complaint template.
- The Fix Maine Schools site's about page (26) says "The Maine Education Initiative, a project of Maine Policy Institute" works "to restore public trust and academic excellence in Maine public schools" by "empowering parental involvement in K-12 education" and encouraging school boards to adopt model policies; the header reads "A Project of Maine Policy Institute". Its staff page (27) lists Heidi Sampson, "Executive Director"; Sam Whiting, "Legal Counsel"; Jonah Davids, "Research Fellow"; Mike Quatrano, "Director of Civic Engagement"; Jacob Posik, "Director of Communications"; and Allen Sarvinas, "Strategic Partner: State Director, Parents Rights in Education Maine". The Institute's "20+ Years of Impact" page (28) dates the launch of the Maine Education Initiative to 2025 ("a new effort to engage local school boards to improve student outcomes") and does not mention trans students, Title IX or the "Maine Education Report Project". The Bangor Daily News calls Sampson the Institute's "education initiative director" (2026-09-09, as the page already cites).
- What the reports reviewed here give (none ties a district's vote to the Initiative's text unless stated): MSAD 70 (Hodgdon): the board voted unanimously, on Monday 2025-04-14 by the dates of the reports, "to only recognize two sexes of students" and to bar students from private spaces of the opposite sex, and directed the superintendent to "evaluate and potentially change" policies (Bangor Daily News, 2025-04-17, 29; The County, 2025-04-15, 30); neither mentions the Institute, Fix Maine Schools or a model resolution (the Initiative's resolution PDF sits in the site's 2025/04 upload folder; whether it preceded the vote is not known). RSU 73 (Jay and Livermore Falls): the board voted 8 to 3 on a Thursday reported on 2025-06-30 to alter policies to match the federal reading of Title IX and bar "transgender-identifying males" from girls' sports, locker rooms and restrooms, with a later vote needed on the committee's wording (The Maine Wire, Seamus Othot, 2025-06-30, 31); the article does not name the Institute or a model resolution; The Maine Wire is operated by the Institute (Wikipedia, 2: "operates" it, listed as a subsidiary). RSU 24: the board voted on 2025-10-07 to align with the federal reading of Title IX, "a resolution aimed at barring transgender students from sports and private spaces that align with their gender identity"; the Bangor Daily News says RSU 24 is "at least the sixth district to buck the Maine Human Rights Act this year" and that "Conservative groups like the Maine Policy Institute and Parents Rights in Education have pushed Maine school boards, including RSU 24, to adopt similar policies"; it does not link the resolution to a template (2025-10-08, 32; the vote count is not given there). The Maine Monitor (2025-12-02, 22) says "several" districts passed resolutions matching a Maine Education Initiative sample policy and names Baileyville as seeking counsel; it gives no votes and does not clearly say RSU 73 passed such a resolution. RSU 24's board minutes of 2025-10-07 are read (see below). Passing a resolution that recognizes "only two sexes" is anti-trans policy in bad faith, whatever its sponsors say about girls' sports.
- Posts and episodes on the Institute's site that mention trans people (its search page, 21; 17 results, 10 shown): Harris Van Pate, "Maine Human Rights Commission's New Lawsuit a State-Level Battle in a National Storm" (2025-11-20, 33), which says the Commission's case rests on Doe v. RSU 26 (2014), under which "schools cannot deny transgender students access to facilities", argues the case has weaknesses on student privacy, standing and "federal-state harmony", and calls the legal dispute "inseparable from the parallel national fight over Title IX"; "Episode 72: Live from the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy" (page undated; the hosts, given by first names Matt, Jake and Harris, discuss the Commission's suit against five districts over "policies related to transgender athletes" and criticize a Press Herald article on parent groups and funding; no transcript) (34; listed 2025-12-04); "Episode 54: Maine Democrats Light Themselves on Fire" (listed 2025-06-13; one sentence: "Multiple bills that seek to reform Maine's policy on transgender athletes have also been heard (and rejected)"; no transcript) (35); also listed by title and date only: "The Good, Bad & Ugly of Maine's 2025 Legislative Session" (2025-07-16) and "Parsing Aaron Frey's Strategy..." (2025-05-14, as the page has). Calling a bill to end trans girls' sports participation "reform" and the Commission's suit a "battle in a national storm" present anti-trans campaigning as a legal and political contest.
- MSAD 70, motion text: The Maine Wire (Seamus Othot, 2025-04-15, 36) quotes Superintendent Tyler Putnam giving the motion as "MSAD 70 policies to align with Federal Title IX by recognizing only two sexes – biological male and biological female", adds a separate clause on private spaces, and says the board approved it unanimously and accepted the "Keeping Men out of Women's Sport" executive order as the basis for its Title IX guidelines. The article does not describe the motion as a resolution or model template and does not name Fix Maine Schools. The Maine Wire is operated by the Institute (see above).
- OCR complaints: The Maine Wire (Seamus Othot, 2026-01-15, 37) does not name who filed the complaints against RSU 19 and RSU 57. It quotes RSU 57's superintendent saying the district was notified that "a complaint has been filed alleging discrimination"; the report names no complainant, and names none of the Maine Policy Institute, the Maine Education Initiative, Fix Maine Schools or Parents' Rights in Education as party to the complaint. It reports that RSU 19's superintendent said the Office for Civil Rights told the district it violated the law.
- The Institute's search page for "transgender" (38) lists 17 results in all; the seven on its second page (numbers 11 to 17) are: "Part 5: Will Laurel Libby's Lawsuit Succeed?" (2025-03-19, blog post); "Episode 41: Janet Mills is in Trouble" (2025-03-07, apparently a podcast episode); "Why Gov. Mills will likely lose her fight with Trump over Title IX" (2025-02-28, blog post); two pages that appear to belong to the Institute's school board member survey (2024-10-18, "Political Polarization" and "District Issues"); a release of 2022-08-23, "Release: New analysis shows critical social justice is pervasive in Maine's K-12 education system"; and a blog post of 2022-06-20.
- 2025-02-28: "Why Gov. Mills will likely lose her fight with Trump over Title IX" (Harris Van Pate, 2025-02-28, 39) frames the dispute as the federal reading of Title IX excluding transgender athletes from women's sports, says the Maine Human Rights Act is read by the state to "protect the right of trans students to join the sex-based sports teams of their choice", and argues Maine's case is weak. It is dated the same day as the template listed on the page; the post does not mention the template. The post calls the President's reading of Title IX "non-trans inclusive" and says that the Maine Human Rights Act, while it "technically" supports the Governor's stance, "does not circumvent federal law".
- The Institute's podcast page for Episode 41, "Episode 41: Janet Mills is in Trouble" (40; listed on the Institute's search page as 2025-03-07), says the episode covers "the Trump administration finding Maine in violation of Title IX over the state's transgender sports policy and what is likely to happen as a result", and continues "the fallout from the censure of Rep. Laurel Libby". It gives a description only, with no transcript.
- The Institute's page for "Episode 40: The Censure of Laurel Libby" (41) describes a Facebook post "about a biological male winning a girl's high school track and field event" and Maine's decision "to continue to allow trans athletes to compete in girl's sports". It says the Democrats' censure of Rep. Laurel Libby was "really a punishment for bringing public attention to a deeply unpopular policy". Calling a trans girl "a biological male" is anti-trans rhetoric in bad faith. It gives a description only, with no transcript.
- "Part 5: Will Laurel Libby's Lawsuit Succeed?" (Institute blog post, listed as 2025-03-19; 42) says Libby "was censured for making a Facebook post about a transgender athlete" and that "it was likely her outspoken stance on trans issues that lead to the ban, not how she presented them". The Institute presents this as giving her "a compelling argument".
- 2022-06-20: "Why isn't Maine's preferred K-12 gender identity curriculum more accessible to parents?" (Nick Murray, 2022-06-20, 43) attacks a kindergarten lesson on LGBT activism and the OUT Maine materials the state recommends, says pronoun lessons "may be more confusing than enlightening for the kindergarteners, first graders, and second graders", and calls for a state review of gender- and sex-related curricula. It is part of the campaign against teaching about gender identity in schools. The post itself writes that "queer—especially transgender—youth face higher rates of bullying, suicide, and depression" while arguing against the lessons.
- RSU 24, the board's own minutes: RSU 24's minutes of 2025-10-07 (44, listed on the district's 2025 minutes page 45; read as text) record: "The board listened to comments from the community in regards to amending the Title IX policy"; business item 1, "Proposal to Adopt a Resolution to Support the President's Executive Order 14201 - Ensuring Compliance with Title IX and Protections of Sex-Based Privacy", moved by a board member, which resolved that the superintendent "1. Amend all district policies to align with Title IX as reaffirmed by Executive Order 14201, recognizing only the two sexes, male and female; 2. Ensure that all private spaces within the district (such as, but not limited to, bathrooms, locker rooms, and overnight accommodations for field trips) are designated and accessed according to sex; 3. Require all applicable extracurricular activities and athletic teams to be separated by sex to preserve safety and fairness; 4. Provide written notice to the district and public ...", with the directive "immediately implemented and executed by the superintendent upon passage". The minutes record the motion to move the question as passing and the vote on the resolution as "Votes in Favor: 4832 & Student Rep. Opposed: 2497 (AM,TN,ST,JA) Absent: 430 (JD) This motion passes" (the district's weighted votes, per the minutes' table of vote shares). The four directives and their order match the model "Title IX Resolution for School Boards" quoted on this page, and the title matches the model's ("Ensuring Compliance with Title IX and Protection of Sex-Based Privacy"; the minutes read "Protections"). The minutes do not name the Institute, Fix Maine Schools or the Maine Education Initiative. A resolution that recognizes "only the two sexes" denies trans people's existence in district policy. (RSU 24 minutes.)
- RSU 24, minutes: The district's "2025 Minutes" page lists 10-07-2025 with a minutes PDF and a recording.
- Office for Civil Rights complainants, RSU 19 and RSU 57: The Bangor Daily News report of 2026-01-15 does not say who filed the complaint. It gives the allegation as "that the District discriminated against female students on the basis of sex". No source reviewed here names a complainant. The Department of Education announced the 18 Title IX investigations on 2026-01-14; its release is not quoted here.
- Parents' Rights in Education, Maine: Testimony to the Judiciary Committee on L.D. 492 (a resolution proposing a state constitutional amendment on parental rights), 2025-03-04 (46, read as text), is headed "Parents' Rights in Education Maine, Testimony of Allen Sarvinas In Support of L.D. 492" and opens "I am Allen Sarvinas, Maine state director of Parents' Rights in Education". It gives a Maine school case as an example, saying a mother "discovered that school officials had been secretly transitioning her daughter's gender from girl to boy without her knowledge" and that Child Protective Services "found all claims to be unfounded". The national group's site (47; the.org address redirects) says it "train[s] & support[s] parents & their allies" and, in its footer, that it is "a 501(c)(3) organization"; it shows no EIN and no list of state affiliates. A Parents Rights in Education (EIN 47-3448838, Hillsboro OR) is listed by the IRS (TY2022 revenue $70,488; TY2025 $154,556), and the national site's donate page prints that EIN; the sources present the Maine unit as a chapter of the national organization (see People on file). The Bangor Daily News of 2025-10-08 (Daniel O'Connor, 32) says: "Conservative groups like the Maine Policy Institute and Parents Rights in Education have pushed Maine school boards, including RSU 24, to adopt similar policies." The Fix Maine Schools staff page (27) lists "Allen Sarvinas" as "Strategic Partner: State Director, Parents Rights in Education Maine"; the name appears nowhere else on that page.
- MSAD 70, minutes of 2025-04-14: The district's 2025 minutes page (48) links "April 14, 2025" (49, read as text). The minutes, headed "School Board Meeting Minutes April 14. 2025" (the opening paragraph carries over "Monday, March 10, 2025" from the earlier meeting), record under information item 4 "Title IX Policy" this action item: "For MSAD 70 policies to align with Federal Title IX by recognizing only two sexes - biological male and biological female and that all private spaces be separated by biological sex." "It was moved by one director and seconded by another... Motion carries unanimously." The board had been in executive session from 6:00 to 7:35 p.m. for a "Consultation" with its attorneys. The public-comment list has 22 speakers, 18 of whom list "Title IX" among their topics, including two state representatives and "Allen Sarvinas - Title IX" (the page names him as the Maine state director of Parents' Rights in Education); the "Public Present" list includes three state representatives and one attendee entered as "of Parents Rights in Education". The minutes do not mention the Maine Policy Institute, the Maine Education Initiative, Fix Maine Schools or a model resolution. The motion and the unanimous vote are as the Bangor Daily News and The County reported them; the minutes add the exact wording and the list of speakers. Not stated: whether the wording came from the Initiative's model resolution.
- RSU 73, 2025-06-26, the motion as reported: The district's agenda folder (50) holds "June 26, 2025 School Board Meeting Agenda.pdf" (modified 2025-06-24): item 4.1 reads "Enter executive session for legal advice regarding Title IX pursuant to 1 M.R.S.A. § 405(6)(E)" and item 16.1 reads "Discussion and possible vote on Title IX- based on executive session-legal advice."; item 6.1 is the minutes of 2025-06-12. The Portland Press Herald (Rebecca Richard, "Jay-based school board says district will recognize only 2 sexes", 2025-07-01, 51) gives the motion as introduced by a director in five numbered parts: "Amend all district policies to align with Title IX as reinforced by Executive Order 14201, recognizing only two sexes;" "Ensure that all private spaces — such as bathrooms, locker rooms and field trip accommodations — are designated by sex;" "Require all applicable extracurricular activities and athletic teams to be separated by sex;" "Provide written notice to the public to ensure transparency and compliance;" "Review and revise all gender-applicable policies through the policy committee for board review." It says the vote was on Thursday 2025-06-26 and "passed with three dissenting votes" and gives no total (The Maine Wire's 8 to 3, already on the page, agrees on three opposed). The Press Herald article does not mention the Institute, MSAD 70 or a model policy. The motion's wording and the three opposing votes are from the Press Herald, the total from The Maine Wire.
- Maine Human Rights Commission v. Maine School Administrative District 70, Regional School Unit 24, Regional School Unit 73, Baileyville School Department and Richmond School Department, Kennebec County Superior Court, docket CV-25-188, complaint stamped filed 2025-11-17 (52; case page 53). The complaint alleges: MSAD 70's board met 2025-04-14 and voted unanimously to recognize "only two sexes — biological male and biological female and that all private spaces be separated by biological sex", and the district "officially adopted" the policy on 2025-06-09; Baileyville adopted a policy on 2025-09-16 separating bathrooms, locker rooms and certain athletic teams "by sex" and defining sex as "biological sex"; RSU 73 adopted a policy on 2025-10-09 requiring its schools to "recognize only two sexes: biological male and biological female"; Richmond adopted a policy on 2025-10-16 restricting restroom, locker-room, overnight and interscholastic athletic participation by "biological sex". It names RSU 24 as a defendant but gives no adoption date for it. No paragraph of the complaint (12 pages, a scanned document read by optical character recognition of every page, so its wording should be checked against the page images) mentions the Maine Policy Institute, the Maine Education Initiative, a model resolution or any outside group, and the complaint gives no vote count for RSU 73. For RSU 73 there are two dated steps: a board vote on 2025-06-26, reported by the Maine Wire as 8 to 3, and the policy the complaint says the district adopted on 2025-10-09. The suit named five districts when filed (MSAD 70, RSU 24, RSU 73, Baileyville and Richmond). Drew Johnson of the Portland Press Herald (Bangor Daily News, 2025-12-07, 54; first published by the Maine Trust for Local News) reports that the board of MSAD 52 (Turner, Greene and Leeds) "voted 5-4 on Thursday" to pass a policy aligning with the President's executive order, after a motion to table failed, and that the Commission's executive director said MSAD 52 "had been added as a defendant to the lawsuit Friday". The article gives no calendar date for either day; it is dated Sunday 2025-12-07 and says the director "did not respond Friday night", so the Thursday is 2025-12-04 and the Friday 2025-12-05. The Maine Wire, operated by the Institute (Seamus Othot, 2025-06-02, 55) reports an earlier MSAD 52 board vote of 5 to 3 to have the superintendent seek legal advice on recognizing only biological sex; that vote adopted no policy. The Portland Press Herald (Riley Board, 2026-06-16, 56) reports that attorneys for seven districts (the five above, MSAD 52 and East Grand School in Danforth) argued motions to dismiss in Kennebec County Superior Court that day: six districts argued the Commission may not sue without first investigating; MSAD 52 filed a separate partial motion to dismiss the counts against it, and its attorney said its policy does not apply to bathrooms or other sex-separated facilities; the judge did not rule, questioned the Commission's standing, and said she might delay the case until the Maine Supreme Judicial Court decides on a ballot-initiative question. The Maine Monitor (2026-06-26, 57) reports RSU 73's superintendent telling his board that a ruling on dismissal could take weeks or months. The Bangor Daily News of 2026-09-14 (58) says "Maine's lawsuit against school districts continues" and reports no ruling on the districts' motions to dismiss argued on 2026-06-16. As of 2026-11-16 the Judicial Branch's case page (53) lists only the original complaint among its documents and posts no ruling on the motions to dismiss.
- The Maine Wire (Maine Wire Staff, 2025-12-05, 59) names, as districts with changed Title IX or sports policies feeling legal pressure from the Commission's suit: RSU 73, MSAD 70, RSU 24, MSAD 52 (Greene, Leeds and Turner) and "schools in Danforth and Richmond"; it gives no vote counts or dates for them and does not mention a model resolution or the Initiative. The Maine Wire was founded by the Maine Policy Institute, according to the Maine Wire's own page.
Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext
No source reviewed here shows the Institute supporting restrictions that reach adults. The documented work is aimed at trans students in school sports and school policy: the "girls" and "level playing field" argument is a shield, and The Maine Monitor says the Institute pushed school districts across Maine to bar trans athletes.
Ties
- Role: Matthew Gagnon, chief executive (TY2024 return; Wikipedia). Role (past): Tarren Bragdon, headed the Center 2008 to 2011 (Wikipedia).
- Funding: grants received from the 13 grantors above: Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc $770,100 in 2 rows; The 85 Fund $760,000; DonorsTrust $509,500 in 5 rows; State Policy Network $380,950 in 8 rows; National Philanthropic Trust $140,000 in 5 rows; National Christian Charitable Foundation $120,000 in 7 rows; Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund $103,360 in 7 rows; The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation $150,750 in 3 rows; State Solutions Inc $55,000; Morgan Stanley Global Impact Funding Trust Inc $20,000 in 2 rows; Greater Houston Community Foundation $15,000 in 3 rows; Thomas D Klingenstein Fund $589,089 in 4 rows; Charles Koch Institute $7,500.
- Not a tie (name match): Thomas D Klingenstein Fund $125,000 (2022) filed to "THE MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER", Yarmouth ME, a place no return of the Center shows.
- Narrative alignment only (not a tie): none recorded.
What the records don't show
Whether the Maine Education Initiative is a program of the Institute in so many words (the Fix Maine Schools site is "A Project of Maine Policy Institute" and presents the initiative's model policies). The reports reviewed here give votes by RSU 73 (8 to 3, 2025-06-26 by the report date), RSU 24 (2025-10-07) and MSAD 70 (2025-04-14) to recognize only two sexes; none of the reports reviewed here ties the vote to the Initiative's text, except that the Bangor Daily News says the Institute and Parents Rights in Education have pushed boards, including RSU 24, to adopt similar policies. The Institute's donors. What the "Maine Education Report Project" funded by DonorsTrust did. The Fix Maine Schools home page (15) reads "A Project of Maine Policy Institute" in its header, offers "five model policies all Maine school boards should enact" and the model Title IX resolution, and invites readers to events of "the Maine Education Initiative"; it does not say what the Initiative is or who runs it, and does not mention the "Maine Education Report Project". [Fix Maine Schools site]
Open questions
- Which school districts adopted the model Title IX resolution (its own text) and when: RSU 24 (policy effective July 1, 2026) and RSU 73 are named as adopting resolutions; the Maine Monitor says at least eight districts changed policies in 2025 and names no others as having passed resolutions; MSAD 70's motion is quoted by The Maine Wire (see above); RSU 24's minutes of 2025-10-07 and MSAD 70's minutes of 2025-04-14 are read above.
- What are the Maine Education Initiative and the "Maine Education Report Project" (the initiative's own pages; the Fix Maine Schools home page names the Initiative without describing it, and does not name the Report Project)? The Maine Monitor calls the Initiative "an offshoot" of the Institute. Did any complaint made with the template of 2025-02-28 lead to an Office for Civil Rights finding: the investigations of RSU 19 and RSU 57 (2026) name no complainant in the reports read (Bangor Daily News, The Maine Wire).
- Does the change of name appear on a later return (TY2025)? The Center announced the change on 2020-03-09, effective 2020-03-11 (its release); its returns for TY2020 to TY2024 still file under the old name. The Form 990 for the year ended December 2024, filed 2025-11-11, is the latest return listed, under the name "The Maine Heritage Policy Center" (EIN 22-3888250; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).
- Are the two $125,000 rows on the TY2022 Klingenstein return (one filed "MAINE POLICY INSTITUTE", Portland ME, one filed "THE MAINE HERITAGE POLICY CENTER", Yarmouth ME) one grant listed under two names?
- Did the motions of RSU 73 (2025-06-26) and MSAD 70 (2025-04-14) use the model resolution? MSAD 70's minutes give the motion's wording and do not say where it came from; RSU 73's motion is known from press reports. RSU 24's minutes of 2025-10-07 do: its resolution follows the model's four directives in order, without naming the Institute.
- Whether the Maine unit of Parents' Rights in Education is registered as a separate Maine body.
- The text of the Commission's amended complaint adding MSAD 52 and the other districts (not posted on the case page) and any order on the motions to dismiss: the Kennebec County Superior Court docket for CV-25-188.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- image page: https://mainepolicy.org/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maine_Policy_Institute
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/223888250
- https://mainepolicy.org/?p=28143
- https://www.themainewire.com/2020/03/the-maine-heritage-policy-center-changes-name-to-maine-policy-institute/
- https://mainepolicy.org/about/
- https://mainepolicy.org/mhpc-is-now-hiring/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/201450695
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tarren_Bragdon
- https://parentsrightsineducation.com/support-the-cause-donate/
- https://parentsrightsineducation.com/affiliates/
- https://maine.parentsrightsineducation.com/
- https://parentsrightsineducation.com/affiliate-application/
- https://themainemonitor.org/groups-pushing-schools-change-transgender-policies/
- https://www.fixmaineschools.com/
- https://www.fixmaineschools.com/title-ix
- https://fixmaineschools.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/OCR-Template-Letter-BY.pdf
- https://fixmaineschools.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Title-IX-Resolution-for-School-Boards.docx.pdf
- https://mainepolicy.org/what-mills-and-frey-get-wrong-about-the-trump-admins-title-ix-lawsuit-against-maine/
- https://mainepolicy.org/where-do-federal-courts-stand-on-transgender-student-athletes/.
- https://mainepolicy.org/?s=transgender
- https://themainemonitor.org/school-boards-scramble-respond-transgender-policy-lawsuit/
- https://www.thebulwark.com/p/new-poll-bulwark-pablo-torre-finds-out-survey-americans-politics-sports-masculinity-betting
- https://bangordailynews.com/2026/09/09/hancock/hancock-education/rsu-24-maine-school-anti-trans-policies
- https://www.bangordailynews.com/2026/01/14/politics/state-politics/2-maine-schools-title-ix-investigation-trump-administration
- https://www.fixmaineschools.com/about
- https://www.fixmaineschools.com/staff
- https://mainepolicy.org/?p=30726
- https://www.bangordailynews.com/2025/04/17/aroostook/aroostook-education/hodgdon-applauds-school-board-msad-70-vote-transgender-students/
- https://thecounty.me/2025/04/15/houlton/maine-school-board-adopts-trump-language-recognizing-only-2-sexes/
- https://www.themainewire.com/2025/06/jay-school-board-votes-to-bar-males-from-female-sports-and-private-spaces-marking-another-maine-district-to-comply-with-federal-guidelines/
- https://www.bangordailynews.com/2025/10/08/down-east/downeast-education/rsu24-transgender-sports-ban
- https://mainepolicy.org/maine-human-rights-commissions-new-lawsuit-a-state-level-battle-in-a-national-storm/
- https://mainepolicy.org/podcast/episode-72-live-from-the-vast-right-wing-conspiracy/
- https://mainepolicy.org/podcast/episode-54-maine-democrats-light-themselves-on-fire/
- https://www.themainewire.com/2025/04/hodgdon-school-board-first-to-defy-mills-and-comply-with-federal-law-by-barring-males-from-female-sports/
- https://www.themainewire.com/2026/01/doe-launches-title-ix-investigation-into-two-maine-school-districts-for-allowing-males-in-girls-sports/
- https://mainepolicy.org/page/2/?s=transgender
- https://mainepolicy.org/why-gov-mills-will-likely-lose-her-fight-with-trump-over-title-ix/
- https://mainepolicy.org/podcast/episode-41-janet-mills-is-in-trouble/
- https://mainepolicy.org/podcast/episode-40-the-censure-of-laurel-libby/
- https://mainepolicy.org/part-5-will-laurel-libbys-lawsuit-succeed/
- https://mainepolicy.org/why-isnt-maines-preferred-k-12-gender-identity-curriculum-more-accessible-to-parents/
- http://rsu24.edliotest.com/10072025%20RSUB%20Minutes_docx.pdf
- https://www.rsu24.org/apps/pages/index.jsp?uREC_ID=205529&type=d&pREC_ID=2648471
- https://legislature.maine.gov/testimony/resources/JUD20250304Sarvinas133855766990009920.pdf
- https://parentsrightsineducation.com/
- https://www.msad70.org/board-minutes-25/
- https://www.msad70.org/__static/jdj5jdewjehfzmiws0fnnxbenna3dxbt/Board-Meeting-Minutes-April-14,-2025.pdf
- https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1n6TmZqKprihmC6X7h_pEoH1dGSaTqGxB
- https://www.pressherald.com/2025/07/01/jay-based-school-board-says-district-will-recognize-only-two-sexes/
- https://www.courts.maine.gov/news/mhrc/complaint.pdf
- https://www.courts.maine.gov/news/mhrc/index.html
- https://www.bangordailynews.com/2025/12/07/central-maine/central-maine-education/maine-human-rights-commission-msad-52-lawsuit-transgender-policy/
- https://www.themainewire.com/2025/06/androscoggin-district-votes-to-put-proposed-policy-change-on-title-ix-to-legal-counsel-for-guidance/
- https://www.pressherald.com/2026/06/16/maine-school-districts-argue-in-court-to-dismiss-human-rights-commission-lawsuit/
- https://themainemonitor.org/rsu73-hears-gender-lawsuit-update/
- https://www.bangordailynews.com/2026/09/14/hancock/hancock-education/maine-school-district-donald-trump-stance-transgender-students/
- https://www.themainewire.com/2025/12/school-boards-holding-firm-for-now-against-mhrc-efforts-to-strong-arm-them-on-title-ix-policies/