![Organization: Macdonald-Laurier Institute [CRA BN 855716585RR0001; Corporations Canada 4414993; US EIN 98-0578530]](assets/profiles/org_macdonald_laurier_institute.png)
Macdonald-Laurier Institute
Think tank, Ottawa
An Ottawa think tank (Canadian registered charity). It appears here because Mia Hughes is described on its own page as an MLI Senior Fellow.
Sources: CRA T3010 filings, IRS 990 e-file, Corporations Canada, USAspending (UEI S77DLNB6ZUS2). Public addresses: CRA List of charities (2); IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 98-0578530 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).
Money received
- T3010 FY2024: revenue CAD 3,999,639; expenditures CAD 4,378,458 (charitable programs 3,344,819; management and administration 303,970; fundraising 350,850); assets CAD 2,073,398; liabilities CAD 1,924,674; 18 full-time positions, compensation CAD 1,425,816. The return also shows a fourth expenditure line, "Other", CAD 378,819; the four lines add to CAD 4,378,458, the stated total (the three lines named add to CAD 3,999,639, which happens to equal the revenue figure) (CRA List of charities, T3010 open data, 2).
- T3010 FY2024 compensation schedule: 18 full-time positions, with the ten highest-paid employees in the bands CAD 40,000-79,999 (2), 80,000-119,999 (5) and 120,000-159,999 (3), one part-time employee (CAD 36,790) and total compensation CAD 1,425,816; the return gives no breakdown of fellows. The charity filed 12 returns (fiscal years 2013-2024), designated a charitable organization (CRA BN 855716585RR0001; CRA List of charities, T3010 open data, 2). The CRA directors list also carries Sean Speer among the "Member" entries and names Brian Lee Crowley as Managing Director from 2010-02-04; earlier chairs on the list include Keith Gillam, Pierre F. Casgrain (listed as "Chair (former)") and one further former chair (name omitted) (CRA List of charities).
- US Form 990 (separate return, USD, not added to CAD): revenue 2018 $1,677,171; 2019 $1,749,598; 2020 $1,807,361; 2022 $2,367,725; 2023 $2,460,118; 2024 $2,920,297.
- Gifts reported on funders' T3010s by donee business number (CAD; lower bound, 148 linked rows): Donner Canadian Foundation 1,547,130 (11 filings, 2013-2023); Aurea Foundation 1,155,000 (6 filings, 2013-2018: five by the Institute's registered number, CAD 905,000, 2013-2017, and one of CAD 250,000 for the period ending 2018-06-30 filed to the Institute's own name and place, Ottawa, with business number 876186585RR0001, which matches no registered charity); Nicola Wealth Private Giving Foundation 501,800 (2024 and 2023); Hunter Family Foundation 450,000 (4 filings, 2021-2024); John Dobson Foundation 270,000 (7 filings, 2017-2024; a further filing of CAD 150,000 for 2018, filed to the name of The Study School Foundation, is stated apart below); Crabtree Foundation 275,000 (7 filings, 2015-2023). CanadaHelps CanaDon 698,367 (12 rows, pass-through, donors undisclosed; matched by name). Purposes are not stated in the open data.
- Charles Koch Foundation: USD 115,000, tax period 2017, "General Operating Support" (matched by name and city; no EIN on the row; USD, not added to CAD). DeSmog lists a Charles G Koch Charitable Foundation gift of $115,000 and Xtra says the Charles Koch Foundation has funded MLI (both cited on this page).
- US Department of State: 3 awards, 9 transactions (two negative), net USD 130,275.84 (2019-11-19 to 2024-03-28): speaker travel to Ottawa (2019), speaker programs on Russia, Hong Kong and NATO, and a COVID-19 and foreign disinformation monitoring platform (USAspending).
- DeSmog's compilation from nonprofit disclosures (page undated; its funding spreadsheet link suggests mid-2022, an inference) lists, in CAD or as given without a stated currency: Aurea Foundation $1,605,000; Donner Canadian Foundation $1,329,441; Wilson Foundation $225,000; Crabtree Foundation $155,000; John Dobson Foundation $140,000; Charles G Koch Charitable Foundation $115,000; Max Bell Foundation $65,000; Weston Family Foundation $50,000; the Gluskin and Granovsky Gluskin foundation $18,800; and smaller gifts, for a grand total of $3,741,883. These are DeSmog's figures from a different record set and period than the CRA rows above; they are not added to or reconciled with those rows (the CRA rows give Aurea 1,155,000 in 6 filings, 905,000 of them by donee BN, and Donner 1,547,130, 2013-2023). DeSmog also says private corporations are not required to disclose donation amounts and that MLI stopped listing donors with its 2021 annual report; Xtra says MLI has not published a donor list since 2019. MLI's own reports differ from both: the 2018 report is the last to print a donor list, and the 2020 and 2021 reports say "A list of donors is available on request at MLI's offices" (see the annual-report items below). (DeSmog, 4; Xtra.)
- The Lotte and John Hecht Memorial Foundation (CRA BN 119310241RR0001, Vancouver; 231 gift rows, CAD 46,668,866, 2013-2024) gave the Institute 1 row of CAD 150,000 (period end 2024-12-31; filed "THE MACDONALD-LAURIER INSTITUTE", Ottawa, BN 855716585RR0001; document id 119310241RR0001|2024-12-31|12). Its filed rows include 8 rows, CAD 4,043,882 (2013-2023) to the Fraser Institute, which is not its largest recipient by total; it also gave the Canadian Constitution Foundation 4 rows (CAD 75,000 for 2017; 375,000 for 2018; 250,000 for 2019; 225,000 for 2024) (CRA List of charities, funder BN 119310241RR0001).
- The row of CAD 150,000 filed by the John Dobson Foundation (period end 2018-12-31, document id 119239531RR0001|2018-12-31|12) is filed to "THE STUDY SCHOOL FOUNDATION", Westmount, QC, with the Institute's business number. The Study School Foundation is a separate charity (BN 105252845RR0001, Westmount, T3010 filed through fiscal year 2024), and the same funder's rows to it under its own number are CAD 75,000 each for period ends 2016-12-31, 2019-12-31 and 2020-12-31. The name and place on the row are the Study School Foundation's and the number typed is the Institute's, so the row is stated apart and is in no Institute total. (CRA List of charities, BN 119239531RR0001 and BN 105252845RR0001.)
- Two further rows of the Crabtree Foundation (BN 119236966RR0001) are filed to the Institute's name with no business number and no place: CAD 55,000 (period end 2022-12-31) and CAD 90,000 (2024-12-31). They are stated apart; the 7 filings of CAD 275,000 on the page are the rows with the Institute's number (CRA List of charities, funder BN 119236966RR0001).
- 2018 annual report, supporters: MLI's own 2018 annual report (5, "Our supporters", p. 34) lists "Aurea Foundation" among its donors and, on p. 35, among its event sponsors; no amount is printed. It also lists as donors Atlas Economic Research Foundation, the Donner Canadian Foundation, the John Dobson Foundation, the Lotte and John Hecht Foundation and Geneva Network, among others, and carries a note that some donors asked for anonymity and are omitted. This confirms that Aurea Foundation was a donor in 2018; the report states no figure or business number for any donor, and no purpose for the Atlas Economic Research Foundation's gift. (MLI 2018 annual report.)
- Donor lists of the 2016 and 2017 annual reports: the 2016 report (6, "Our Supporters", p. 16) and the 2017 report (7, "Our supporters", p. 32 (PDF page 33)). Neither prints amounts. What each lists under "Donors":
- 2016: Atlas Economic Research Foundation; Aurea Foundation; BCE Bell Canada Enterprises; Biotechnology Innovation Organization; Canadian Real Estate Association; Coril Holdings Ltd.; Crabtree Foundation; DFH Public Affairs; Donner Canadian Foundation; Eli Lilly Canada Inc.; Embassy of Ukraine; Lodestar Security Services; Lotte & John Hecht Memorial Foundation; Magna International Inc.; Martinrea International Inc.; Michael Young Family Foundation; Mining Association of Canada; Modern Miracle Network; Motion Picture Association - Canada; Oakwest Corporation Ltd.; RBC Foundation; Robson-Pellerin Communications Inc.; Rogers Communications Inc.; Wesbild Holdings Ltd.; Wilson Foundation. The report adds thanks to "the many individual donors".
- 2017: AstraZeneca Canada Inc.; Atlas Network; Aurea Foundation; BCSG Enterprises; Charles Koch Foundation; Coril Holdings; Crabtree Foundation; Canadian Council for Aboriginal Business; Donner Canadian Foundation; First Nations LNG Alliance; International Centre for Law & Economics; John Dobson Foundation; Lotte and John Hecht Foundation; Martinrea International Inc; Max Bell Foundation; Merck Canada Inc.; Ministry of Defence of Latvia; Mining Association of Canada; Mortgage Professionals Canada; Motion Picture Association - Canada; P23 Entertainment Inc.; PhRMA; The Penny and Gordon Echenberg Family Foundation; The Wilson Foundation; Wesbild Holdings Ltd. A footnote says some donors asked for anonymity and are not listed. Finding: the Pirie Foundation is in neither the 2016 nor the 2017 list, and the M-E Squared Foundation is in neither (it is in none of the reports of 2013 to 2018). Aurea appears in all six reports (2013 to 2018).
- "Atlas" in the donor lists: the 2016 report prints "Atlas Economic Research Foundation" (as the 2018 report does) and the 2017 report prints "Atlas Network"; the 2015 report's "Atlas Foundation" carries no longer name, so that the 2015 entry is the same body is not stated by the report. The 2017 report also quotes "Atlas Network CEO Brad Lips" on MLI's work with Aboriginal communities. The body's US filer is EIN 94-2763845 (IRS Form 990 e-file returns, filed as Atlas Economic Research Foundation and as Atlas Network, 2014-2024; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 8). The returns' detail rows (492 in all) show 329 grant rows in which the Atlas filer is the payer, dated 2014 to 2025, all to recipients with US state or Puerto Rico places; none to the Institute and none to a Canadian body. The other 143 grant rows among them are grants received by that EIN. Grants to foreign bodies may not be in that set, so no Atlas amount to the Institute is documented; the donor lists show only that the Institute named it a donor in 2016, 2017 and 2018 (and "Atlas Foundation" in 2015). The Narwhal and Atlas's own page (already on the page) report a grant for an Indigenous-policy project.
- BCSG Enterprises in the 2017 and 2018 lists: The Institute's 2017 and 2018 reports also list "BCSG Enterprises" under donors (2017, p. 32; 2018, p. 34), so that name is a donor in 2013, 2014, 2017 and 2018. On the Institute's US returns, the payments to "BCSG Enterprises LTD" and "BCSG Enterprises Inc" carry descriptions typed on the return. For the contractor-payment rows (USD 313,469 for 2022; USD 302,181 for 2023; USD 311,961 for 2024) the description is "Managing Director"; the business-transaction rows with an interested person give the relationship "Managing Director" and the descriptions "Contract Fees and Bonus" (USD 308,148 for 2023; USD 311,961 for 2024) and "Approved Reimbursements" (USD 6,112 for 2023; USD 6,374 for 2024) (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 98-0578530, object ids 202333189349306133, 202421359349307297 and 202523179349303012; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3). So the Institute's own returns describe the payee by reference to its Managing Director; the return names no officer of the payee company. Whether the "BCSG Enterprises" donor named in the 2013, 2014, 2017 and 2018 reports and the payee on the Institute's US returns (filed as "BSCG Enterprises Ltd" on Schedule L for tax years 2018 to 2022, as "BCSG Enterprises Inc" on Schedule L for 2023 and 2024, and as "BCSG Enterprises LTD" among the independent contractors for 2022 to 2024) are one company is not established: no registry entry for a company of that name is documented here. It remains a same-name lead, not a tie.
- The 2018 report's donor list and financial page: the 2018 report's "Donors" list (p. 34) includes Atlas Economic Research Foundation, Aurea Foundation, BCSG Enterprises, Donner Canadian Foundation, Geneva Network, Imperial Oil Limited, Innovative Medicines Canada, International Centre for Law & Economics, John Dobson Foundation, Lotte and John Hecht Foundation, Max Bell Foundation, Merck Canada Inc., Ministry of Defence of Latvia, Pirie Foundation, PhRMA Association, Rothmans Benson & Hedges Inc., The Wilson Foundation and W. Garfield Weston Foundation; its event sponsors (p. 35) include Aurea Foundation, PhRMA Association and Janssen Inc. The figure of 453,786 is the Corporate line, not foundation donations; foundation donations are $1,171,943. Read in the page's own order (p. 36, "Financial report", "Year ended December 31"), 2018 revenue is: Donations, Foundation $1,171,943 (2017: $1,465,825); Corporate $453,786 (2017: $305,394); Individual $102,297 (2017: $22,226); In-kind and travel recoveries $253,949 (2017: $219,589); Event registration and sponsorship $187,911 (2017: $73,534); Publication (Inside Policy) $876 (2017: $1,633); Interest $2,348 (2017: $1,537); total $2,173,110 (2017: $2,089,738). The seven 2018 lines sum to the printed total, and so do the 2017 lines. Expenditures 2018 $2,066,094; excess of revenue over expenditures $107,016. No currency is printed. The 2016 report (p. 17, "Year Ended December 31, 2016") gives Foundation $1,075,268 (2015: $742,565), Corporate $295,969, Individual $22,985, in-kind and travel recoveries $163,250, event registration and sponsorship $72,310, Inside Policy $11,901, interest $132 (2016 total $1,641,815 per the 2017 report); foundations are 66% of 2016 revenue in the 2016 report's chart and 70% of 2017 revenue in the 2017 report's. The headings "Year ended December 31" are the source for the statement that the reports' fiscal year is the calendar year. Aurea's CAD 250,000 row (its period ending 2018-06-30, filed to the Institute's own name and place) is a fiscal-year period that overlaps 2017 and 2018, not calendar 2018 alone; the report prints no per-donor amount, so it neither confirms nor contradicts that row.
- Annual-report revenue by donation type, 2023 and 2024: MLI's 2023 annual report (9, p. 46), "Revenue by donation type, 2023": foundations $1,803,591; corporate and associations $729,177; individual $191,282; in-kind and travel recoveries $401,193; event registration and sponsorship $156,151; interest $39,028. Expenditures $3,317,596; excess of revenue over expenditures $2,826 (the six figures sum to $3,320,422, which matches the excess). The 2024 report (10, p. 26): foundations $1,973,271; corporate and associations $535,518; individual $210,664; in-kind and travel recoveries $458,075; event registration and sponsorship $790,517; interest $31,594; expenditures $4,378,458; deficiency $378,819 (the six figures sum to $3,999,639, which matches). The 2023 and 2024 reports print no donor names. These are MLI's figures as printed in its own reports, a different record set from the US Form 990 figures already on the page; the two are not added.
- Annual-report donor lists, 2013, 2014 and 2015: the Institute's own annual reports list donors by name, without amounts, for 2013, 2014 and 2015 (the donor lists of the 2016 and 2017 reports are given above). What each report prints:
- 2013 annual report ("Thank you to our supporters", p. 14; 11): under "Donors": Aurea Foundation; Bank of Montreal; BCSG Enterprises; Donner Canadian Foundation; Google Canada Corporation; Intuit Inc.; Laidley Foundation; Lotte and John Hecht Memorial Foundation; Martinrea International; Mining Association of Canada; Ocean Capital; Pirie Foundation; RBC Foundation; RBH Inc.; TD Bank Group; Torrance and Andrée Wylie Foundation; W. Garfield Weston Foundation; Wilson Foundation. No M-E Squared Foundation.
- 2014 annual report (p. 19; 12): under "Donors": Aurea Foundation; BCSG Enterprises; Canadian Fuels Association; Donner Canadian Foundation; Google Canada Corporation; Imperial Oil; Isles Foundation Incorporated; Johnson & Johnson Family of Companies in Canada; Laidley Foundation; Lodestar Security Solutions Inc.; Lotte and John Hecht Memorial Foundation; Martinrea International; Merck Canada Inc.; Mining Association of Canada; Oakwest Corporation Ltd.; Pirie Foundation; RBC Foundation; Tata Consultancy Services Canada Inc.; TD Bank Group; Torrance and Andrée Wylie Foundation; Wesbild Holdings Ltd.; Wilson Foundation. No M-E Squared Foundation.
- 2015 annual report (p. 16; 13): under "Donors": Atlas Foundation (as printed; whether it is Atlas Economic Research Foundation, named in the 2018 report, is not stated); Aurea Foundation; British Columbia Chamber of Commerce; Canada's Research-Based Pharmaceutical Companies; Canadian Fuels Association; Chartered Professional Accountants of Canada; Crabtree Foundation; Dawson Strategic; Donner Canadian Foundation; Economic Club of Canada; John Dobson Foundation; Lotte and John Hecht Memorial Foundation; Martinrea International Inc.; Max Bell Foundation; Saskatchewan Indian Gaming Authority; Shaw Communications Inc.; The Wilson Foundation; U.S. Chamber of Commerce; Vector Media; W. Garfield Weston Foundation; the Crabtree Foundation also as an event sponsor. No Pirie Foundation, no BCSG Enterprises and no M-E Squared Foundation. The report prints revenue for 2015 and 2014: foundations $742,565 and $829,240; corporate $349,486 and $181,372; individual $9,282 and $19,001 (no currency stated on the page). Its revenue chart ("Percentage of Revenue") prints foundations 53%, corporate 26%, events 10%, in-kind 9%, Inside Policy 1%, individual 1%. Finding: the Pirie Foundation appears as a donor in the 2013 and 2014 reports (and in the 2018 report already on the Pirie page); it is not in the 2015 report. The M-E Squared Foundation is in none of the reports 2013, 2014, 2015 or 2018. The Aurea Foundation is in all four. These lists name donors without amounts, so they do not test the CRA rows. The Pirie rows on the T3010s (7 rows, CAD 16,600, period ends 2013, 2014, 2015, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022) are consistent with the 2013 and 2014 lists.
- The 2013 and 2014 reports list "BCSG Enterprises" under "Donors". The Institute's US returns name the payee "BSCG Enterprises Ltd" (Schedule L, tax years 2018 to 2022), "BCSG Enterprises Inc" (Schedule L, 2023 and 2024) and "BCSG Enterprises LTD" (independent contractors, 2022 to 2024) (see People on file). The lists give no number or place for the donor and nothing read states that the donor (named in the 2013, 2014, 2017 and 2018 reports) and that payee are one company; this is stated as a same-name lead only and is not a tie.
- Annual reports 2020, 2021, 2023, 2024 and 2025: the 2021 annual report ("Leading in uncertain times", 14, "Our supporters", p. 37) prints no donor names: it says "A list of donors is available on request at MLI's offices." Its revenue chart gives percentages: domestic foundations 43%; corporations and associations 16%; aligned governments and international foundations 15%; in-kind and travel recoveries 12%; individuals 7%; other revenue 5%; event registration and sponsorship 3%. A footnote reads "MLI only accepts foreign funding from liberal democratic countries that are aligned with Canada's interests and values". The 2020 report (15) carries the same sentence about a donor list on request. The annual-reports page of macdonaldlaurier.ca (accessed 2026-11-12) lists only three reports: 2023 (9), 2024 (10) and 2025 (16); it lists no report for 2022. The 2023, 2024 and 2025 reports carry no donor names. The 2025 report prints foundations $2,102,216; event registration and sponsorship $847,472; corporate and associations $948,359; in-kind and travel recoveries $537,300; individual $298,624.
- Atlas Network or Atlas Economic Research Foundation, tax years 2015 to 2018: IRS Form 990 e-file returns of EIN 94-2763845 (filed as Atlas Economic Research Foundation and as Atlas Network), detail rows (492; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 8): the filer is the payer in 17 grant rows dated 2015, 25 dated 2016, 20 dated 2017 and 20 dated 2018 (USD 429,500; 458,582; 627,559; 604,737 as filed), all to recipients with a US state or Puerto Rico place. None names the Institute or a Canadian body. A search of the returns by the donee name "Macdonald-Laurier Institute" (199 rows) shows one grant paid to an Institute-named donee in the returns searched, the Charles Koch Foundation's USD 115,000 for 2017, already on this page, and no Atlas row. The rows searched are the grant rows the returns carry for payments to organizations with a US place; Atlas's returns may carry grants to organizations abroad on a separate schedule that the rows searched do not hold, so the absence of a row is not proof that Atlas gave nothing.
- Atlas's grants abroad, Schedule F: the Atlas Economic Research Foundation returns (EIN 94-2763845, Form 990, tax years 2014 to 2025; IRS Form 990 e-file, 8) list grants outside the United States by region, purpose and amount and give no recipient name, so no row can be assigned to the Institute or to any named foreign body. The region line "North America - Canada and Mexico" (Schedule F Part I, total expenditures for the region with the activity "Grants to recipients located in region", USD as filed) reads: TY2017 $406,234 (object 201812059349300336); TY2018 $267,534 (201921309349301067); TY2019 $286,727 (202041229349300319); TY2020 $346,275 (202140959349300244); TY2021 $389,522 (202231409349300803); TY2022 $439,254 (202321089349300812); TY2023 $291,157 (202411169349300321); TY2024 $337,422 (202541279349303279). The TY2025 return (object 202621219349302017, filed 2026-05-01) lists no North America region; its eight regions total $12,698,170. The returns for TY2014 to TY2016 use an older layout with the region "North America": $81,647 (TY2014, object 201521749349300317; the same return lists a further $280,000 for North America as "grants from contributors"), $149,571 (TY2015, 201622109349300857) and $220,615 (TY2016, 201743189349305204); the foreign grants on those returns are described as economic education (spelled "ECONOMIC EDUCTION" on one row). The Schedule F purpose on the foreign grant rows of TY2017 to TY2025 is economic education. Part II carries one North America row for 2014 (81,647), one for 2016 (220,615), seven rows for 2017 (7,700 to 175,533) and seven for 2018 (9,000 to 125,000), each with the purpose "Economic education" and no recipient; the returns for 2019 to 2024 carry such rows every year, also without recipients. The TY2022 return also has a separate North America program line (not a grant line) of $150,000. The Atlas return therefore shows grants to recipients in the region but does not show whether any went to the Institute, and the "Atlas Foundation" of the Institute's 2015 donor list is not tied to any of these rows; Atlas's own statement of a "Poverty & Freedom grant" for an Institute project (atlasnetwork.org, 2020-08-06) is cited under the affiliations below. Currencies are USD as filed; region totals are not added across years (Schedule F, tax years 2014 to 2018: 17; 18; 19; 20; 21; tax years 2019 to 2024: 22; 23; 24; 25; 26; 27).
Money given
The Institute's US returns report grants and similar amounts paid of $0 for each of tax years 2018 to 2024 (IRS Form 990, Part I, line 13, EIN 98-0578530; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).
People on file
- Brian Lee Crowley, Managing Director (ex officio), listed every year 2013-2024. Gerard Protti, Chair (title filed FY2023-24; director from 2019-06-15). Directors in FY2024 include the Vice Chair, the Secretary and a further director (names omitted). MLI's own "Who Makes MLI Work" page lists Protti as Chair. MLI's own 2023 annual report prints Vaughn MacLellan as Chair and Gerry Protti as Secretary, so the CRA title and the report's list differ; neither source says when the roles changed.
- Board of Directors, 2023 annual report ("Our People", p. 40; 9): Chair Vaughn MacLellan (DLA Piper (Canada) LLP, Toronto); Vice-Chair Jacquelyn Thayer Scott; Managing Director Brian Lee Crowley; Secretary Gerry Protti (Chairman, BlackSquare Inc, Calgary); Treasurer Martin MacKinnon; directors Richard Boudreault (CEO, AWN, Nanotech, Montreal), Wayne Critchley, Colleen Mahoney, Jayson Myers, Dan Nowlan, Hon. Christian Paradis, Vijay Sappani, Veso Sobot, Elizabeth Burke-Gaffney and Nigel Wright. Affiliations are as MLI prints them.
- The Chair's letter in the same report (p. 6, signed Vaughn MacLellan) says "Our institutions have been compromised by atrophy, wokeness, and a myopic government seized by green ideology and handicapped by a milquetoast worldview" (MLI's own words; "wokeness" is the rhetoric of the Institute's chair, not a finding).
- US Form 990, fiscal year ending December 2021 (USD, EIN 98-0578530; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3; filed 2022-11-10 per the listing): contributions $2,024,579 (82.7% of total revenue), executive compensation $777,056 (31.8% of total expenses), other salaries and wages $963,245 (39.4%), total assets $1,205,886, total liabilities $803,346; Part VII Section A lists Brian Lee Crowley, Managing Director, as a director with reportable compensation of $328,711 (Schedule J: base $285,544 and bonus $43,167), and Part VII Section B of the same return gives the same $328,711 for him as an independent contractor (see below) (IRS Form 990 e-file, object id 202213149349301441, 28; the listing's FY2022 block carries $322,644). The listing shows no fellow among the key employees. USD, not added to CAD.
- The Institute's own returns (IRS Form 990, EIN 98-0578530, Schedule L Part IV; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3) report business transactions with an interested person (payee names as filed, "BCSG/BSCG Enterprises"), in US dollars as filed:
- Tax year 2018: BSCG Enterprises Ltd, relationship "Entity Owned by Director", 296,685, "Monthly retainer for services".
- Tax year 2019: the same payee and relationship, 321,436, "Monthly retainer for services".
- Tax year 2020: BSCG Enterprises Ltd, relationship "Entity Owned by Director", 321,436, "Monthly retainer for services".
- Tax year 2021: BSCG Enterprises Ltd, relationship "Entity Owned by Director", 331,490, "Monthly retainer for services".
- Tax year 2022: BSCG Enterprises Ltd, relationship "Managing Director", 313,469 "Contract Fees and Bonus" and 7,851 "Approved Reimbursements".
- Tax year 2023: BCSG Enterprises Inc, "Managing Director", 308,148 "Contract Fees and Bonus" and 6,112 "Approved Reimbursements".
- Tax year 2024: BCSG Enterprises Inc, "Managing Director", 311,961 "Contract Fees and Bonus" and 6,374 "Approved Reimbursements". For tax years 2018 to 2022 the amounts add to 1,592,367. For tax years 2023 and 2024 they add to 632,595.
- On the Institute's returns for tax years 2022, 2023 and 2024 (IRS Form 990, EIN 98-0578530, Part IV, line 28), the Institute answers "No" to line 28a (a business transaction with a current or former officer, director, trustee or key employee) and "Yes" to line 28c (a business transaction with a 35% controlled entity of one or more such persons or their family members). The Schedule L, Part IV payee of those years is listed above (29; 30; 31).
- On the same returns, Part VII lists Brian Lee Crowley as Managing Director every year from tax year 2018 to 2024, and the returns of tax years 2018 and 2022 are signed by him as Managing Director. Part VII Section B (independent contractors) names Brian Lee Crowley personally, description "Managing Director", for tax years 2018 (336,760), 2020 (277,133) and 2021 (328,711); the tax year 2019 return also lists him in that section, with no amount readable on the page. In the IRS Form 990 e-file data for that return (object 202031819349300203; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3), the Part VII Section B row gives the description "Managing Director" and carries no compensation amount. For tax years 2020 and 2021 the Section B amount is the same figure as the compensation the same return reports for him in Part VII Section A and Schedule J ($277,133 for 2020; $328,711 for 2021); the returns do not say whether the two sections report one payment, so the amounts are not added. For tax year 2018 the two differ (Section B 336,760; Section A $259,906). From tax year 2022 the same section names "BCSG Enterprises LTD", description "Managing Director" (313,469 for 2022; 302,181 for 2023; 311,961 for 2024). The returns do not say in words who owns the company; the Institute's own description of the payee for tax years 2018 to 2021 is "Entity Owned by Director".
- The contractor payments and the business transactions come from different row kinds and may overlap; the two schedules are not summed.
- Brian Lee Crowley, compensation as filed on MLI's US Form 990 as officer/director, Managing Director: $259,906 (2018), $312,247 (2019), $277,133 (2020), $328,711 (2021), $322,644 (2022), $329,015 (2023), $305,187 (2024) (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 98-0578530, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3). He is also listed as a beneficial owner on MLI's revoked DC registration (DC Department of Licensing and Consumer Protection, registration N00007841478). The Wikipedia article calls him Managing Director and founder of the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies.
- Mia Hughes: MLI's own page of 2025-07-08 calls her "MLI Senior Fellow Mia Hughes" and her signature "Senior Fellow, Macdonald-Laurier Institute" (MLI page). An earlier description of her as an MLI senior fellow: a column in The Bridgehead dated 2025-05-14 says "Mia Hughes... is a senior fellow at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute" and discusses her National Post piece of 2025-05-09 headed "Canada must launch review of paediatric gender clinic practices" (32; the description is the column writer's). MLI's own expert page for her lists her as "Senior Fellow", describes her as "the director of Genspect Canada, and the author of The WPATH Files" and carries no date (33). The column and the piece it discusses present anti-trans rhetoric in bad faith; the evidence brief shows the care they attack is supported by the evidence. No fellows list or pay is documented here.
What the records don't show
No Elections Canada, BC or Toronto lobbying, or Canadian grants and contracts under the MLI name. The US IRS list carries an automatic-revocation row dated 2011-05-15 and a later exempt-organization row; they are not interpreted here. The Aurea Foundation gift of CAD 250,000 (period end 2018-06-30) is described under Money received, where it is counted in the Aurea total; two Crabtree gifts (CAD 55,000, 2022; CAD 90,000, 2024) carry no donee BN.
Affiliations reported in public sources
- Atlas Network: Wikipedia's article says the Guardian reported a multi-year MLI campaign linked to the Atlas Network, which MLI disputes; Wikipedia lists MLI as affiliated with the Atlas Network (Wikipedia article on the Macdonald-Laurier Institute). No Atlas Network funding of MLI is documented.
- Russia designated MLI an "undesirable organisation" in August 2022 (Wikipedia); DisinfoWatch, an MLI project, is funded in part by the US State Department's Global Engagement Center per Wikipedia, consistent with the State Department awards above.
- Atlas Network: The Narwhal, with Floodlight and the Guardian (Geoff Dembicki, 2022-07-18, updated 2022-08-23), reports a 2020 Atlas Network document stating "Atlas Network supported this initiative with a Poverty & Freedom grant", about an MLI-led campaign on Indigenous participation in the natural-resource economy. The article's own wording is that Atlas "appears to have provided funding"; it gives no amount and no year, and an MLI spokesperson did not address the grant directly and said questions about the Atlas report are better directed to Atlas. DeSmog adds that Atlas's 2018 case study said the project helped MLI raise "roughly Can $500,000 more" over five years, mostly through foundation support, and that Atlas Network is listed as a donor in several of MLI's annual reports. The case study itself, Atlas Network's "Engaging non-traditional allies to create free-market change: Aboriginal Canada and the Natural Resource Economy Project" (February 2018; 34, archive copy of 2021-08-14), says on p. 9: "Brian Lee Crowley, MLI's managing director, estimates that over the course of the project, MLI raised roughly Can$500,000 more than they would have without the project mostly through foundation support." It gives the figure as his estimate and states no Atlas grant amount. The project concerned natural-resource policy, not trans people: no Atlas Network funding of MLI's work on trans people is documented in any source reviewed here. (The Narwhal, 35; DeSmog.)
- Xtra says MLI describes itself as "the most cited think-tank in Canada's parliament", presents itself as nonpartisan, and that the Charles Koch Foundation has funded it; this matches the USD 115,000 row (tax period 2017) already on the page.
- Atlas Network's own article "MLI Promotes Individualistic Legislative Approach For Canada's Indigenous Communities", dated 2020-08-06 (atlasnetwork.org), says "Atlas Network supported this initiative with a Poverty & Freedom grant." The page gives no amount, so no amount for the grant is documented.
- 2022-09-06: the Institute's own statement "Disproving disinformation perpetuated in the Guardian and the Narwhal", dated September 6, 2022, answers the article of 2022-07-18 co-published by the two outlets. It says "Though MLI is an Atlas network partner, no Atlas network funding had been allocated toward MLI's work on UNDRIP or the ACNRE project at the time of the publication of Atlas' report", and, of the article's statement that Atlas "appears to have provided funding for the campaign": "Atlas did not provide funding for this work." It also says that MLI Distinguished Fellow Ken Coates pitched a project, "Building Indigenous Economic Freedom: Pathways for Autonomy and Prosperity", at the 2022 Antigua Forum. Atlas Network's own article of 2020-08-06 (cited above) says "Atlas Network supported this initiative with a Poverty & Freedom grant." The two bodies' statements differ, and neither gives an amount (36, accessed 2026-11-16).
- The 2018 Atlas case study (13 pages, "Atlas Network's Leadership Academy - Think Tank Impact Case Study"; cited above) does not mention an Atlas grant or any Atlas payment to the Institute; the Can$500,000 figure is its account of the managing director's estimate (p. 9). The case study also says "MLI was one of the six finalists for the 2017 Templeton Freedom Award" (p. 2). So neither Atlas document reviewed here names an amount for an Atlas grant to the Institute, and the Can$500,000 is not an Atlas grant (34; archive copy of 2021-08-14 captured by the Internet Archive, 37).
- Atlas Network's own page "2017 Templeton Freedom Award winners and finalists" (dated Oct 31 2017) lists "Macdonald-Laurier Institute for Public Policy (Ottawa, Canada)" among the six 2017 finalists, for the project "Aboriginal Canada and the Natural Resource Economy", and states of the award: "The winner is awarded $100,000 and the other finalists are awarded $25,000. The award, generously supported by the Templeton Religion Trust, is presented annual during Atlas Network's Liberty Forum & Freedom Dinner." Atlas Network's article of 2017-11-09 reports that the Instituto Mexicano para la Competitividad's "3de3" campaign won the 2017 award; it does not name the other finalists. Neither page gives the date of any payment to the Institute, and the Institute's own statement of 2022-09-06 (cited above) does not mention the award (38, accessed 2026-11-17; 39, accessed 2026-11-17).
- Atlas Network's press release of 2017-11-10 announcing the 2017 Templeton Freedom Award states: "IMCO was awarded $100,000 for winning the award, and the five other finalists were each awarded $25,000." The release does not name the other finalists (Atlas Network's finalist page, cited in the item above, lists the Institute among them) and gives no date of a payment to the Institute (40, Atlas Network release, accessed 2026-11-17; 38).
Anti-trans work: documented moments
- 2025-07-08: MLI's own page presents "MLI Senior Fellow Mia Hughes", author of the report "The WPATH Files" (Environmental Progress, 2024-03-04). That report is anti-trans rhetoric built on leaked WPATH forum posts; an advocacy fact-check counted 216 errors or misrepresentations in it (Erin in the Morning, 2024-03-06, summary; see the Environmental Progress profile). Other MLI items on trans people are documented below. Wikipedia's article on MLI mentions no work on gender or trans issues.
- 2021-08-04 to 2025-05-14: Transgender Map lists 22 MLI publications and events on trans people under its heading "Selected anti-trans publications by MLI", by MLI staff and outside authors: sports polling and a webinar (2021-08-04, 2021-08-05, 2021-12-07), a fundraiser for a "Protect Women and Girls" campaign by a coach (dated 2023-03-10 by the tracker; MLI's own page, carries publication metadata of 2023-03-10 and a last-modified date of 2023-04-02), prison housing papers (2023-02-02 to 2023-09-26), Alberta trans policy papers (2024-06-04), a paper on care for minors (2024-05-08) and a statement on gender medicine with 14 physician signatories (2025-05-14) (Transgender Map; the dates and titles are the tracker's). MLI pages also republish Mia Hughes pieces from the National Post (2025-02, 2025-03-18) and the Toronto Sun (2025-04-22). The prison housing papers listed concern adult prisoners; the sports items are not sorted by age in the tracker's list, and the list also includes items on prisons and women's sport beyond care for minors.
- 2021-08-04 to 2026-07-30: the Institute's website files items under an issue category "Gender Identity". Its seven pages, as accessed 2026-11-16, show 82 distinct items (81 dated list items and one featured item of 2026-07-30 shown above the list) dated from 2021-08-04 ("Canadians' Views on Women's Sport and Gender Identity" and the poll release of the same day) to 2026-07-30 ("Euthanasia, transgenderism, and transgression: Peter Copeland and Carl Trueman for Inside Policy Talks"): papers, commentaries, columns republished from newspapers, podcasts and events. Items of 2026 in the category include "Major U.S. medical groups take science-based approach to ‘gender-affirming’ care: Mia Hughes in the National Post" (2026-02-17), "Finnish data shows gender treatments linked with worsening mental health. Canada lags behind: Mia Hughes in the National Post" (2026-04-28) and "The debate is over – Women's sports need protection from biologically male trans athletes: Marty York for Inside Policy" (2026-05-14). The category is the Institute's own filing: some items in it, such as "Kamala Harris and Justin Trudeau: A Political Déjà Vu?" (2024-09-20) and "Heather Exner-Pirot calls out ideological bias in Canadian research funding" (2025-01-22), do not name trans people or gender identity in their titles, so 82 is the size of the category, not a count of items about trans people. Describing trans women athletes as "biologically male", as the 2026-05-14 title does, is anti-trans rhetoric aimed at adults as well as minors. The titles of 2026-02-17 and 2026-04-28 cast gender-affirming care as unscientific and harmful: that is anti-trans rhetoric in a medical framing; the American Academy of Pediatrics supports access to gender-affirming care and reaffirmed that policy in 2023 (41). (42 and 43 to /page/7/, accessed 2026-11-16)
- 2022-09: an MLI commentary opens by calling the interventions "aggressive and clearly harmful". The commentary carries a disclaimer that the views are the author's. The evidence brief reports that 98% (704 of 720) of a Dutch adolescent cohort were still on hormones at follow-up and a pooled regret of 1% after surgery (27 studies, 7,928 surgical patients, PRS Global Open, 2021). "Despite the absence of supportive evidence, the American Academy of Pediatrics recently suggested that aggressive and clearly harmful medical and surgical interventions might be appropriate for many children who express reservations about their biological sex" (Gender dysphoria in children: Risking harm from well-intentioned parents and doctors, 2022-09, p. 1; 44)
- 2025-02: an MLI commentary describes the gender-affirming care model as one that "is used for children, adolescents, and adults" and criticizes it. The commentary relies on the Cass Review. Against it, a peer-reviewed appraisal (BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2025, using the ROBIS risk-of-bias tool) rated all seven systematic reviews commissioned for the Cass Review at high risk of bias. "This model assumes that the concept of gender identity is valid and that thus, a patient’s self-declared gender identity is real. The role of the doctor, therefore, is not to help the patient examine the source(s) of their gender distress, but to provide medical, psychological, and social support to help individuals transition so they may present as their self-identified gender. This approach is used for children, adolescents, and adults." (Why is Canada falling behind the science in treating gender-distressed youth?, 2025-02, p. 2; 45)
- 2023-03-10: MLI's own page "Protect women and girls from extreme gender ideology worldwide" is a donation appeal for a fundraising campaign led by a sport-performance coach, Linda Blade (the page names her as leading it). The page's metadata gives publication 2023-03-10 and last modification 2023-04-02. It argues that "gender ideology" harms women and girls, cites trans women in women's sport and in women's prisons, whom it calls "biological males" and "trans-identified male prisoners" (wording that misgenders them), and medical care for minors, asks for gifts of $10, $50 or $100 (currency not stated on the page), and offers a match (for every $5 raised, the coach and a private donor each give $1). It carries no individual author and does not mention Mia Hughes. This is anti-trans campaigning by MLI itself, framed as protecting women and girls, and it lists adult prisoners and women's sport alongside minors' care. (MLI page 46; the page's date comes from its metadata.)
- 2025-08-13: Xtra Magazine (Denio Lourenco, "This Canadian think tank is claiming 'victory' over anti-trans legislation") reports that since 2021 MLI has published material on trans inclusion in sport, gender-affirming care for youth and the housing of trans prisoners "by biological sex"; that MLI published 628 items in 2024, of which "more than 20" concerned gender identity; and that MLI's 2023 annual report claimed credit for provincial changes, quoting "This is a victory that MLI has played a leading role in creating" and "Since our thought leadership on this issue began, three provinces have now adopted some of our recommendations and revised their own gender policies". The article adds that experts say MLI's influence is hard to prove, and that a Conservative Party of Canada member who promoted a 2023 party-convention resolution "to protect single-sex spaces" (passed with more than 86 percent support, per the article) is the coach MLI's fundraiser features. The counts and quotations are Xtra's account of MLI's own reports. (Xtra Magazine, 47)
- The Xtra article names the authors of MLI's 2021 sports report as Jon Pike, Emma Hilton and Leslie A. Howe, a report that proposed restricting the women's category to cis women; Xtra says they are listed as anti-trans activists by Transgender Map, a monitoring site, and that they reject the label. (Xtra Magazine.) Restricting a sports category to cis women excludes trans women of every age, including adults.
- 2023 annual report, MLI's own statements: MLI's 2023 annual report (p. 17) says: "A growing body of evidence from around the world has revealed the damage caused to women and girls by an uncritical embrace of the demands of gender activists and the denial of the reality of biological sex"; that MLI "prioritized this issue in 2023, producing a major research paper with Jo Phoenix titled Rights and wrongs: How gender self-identification policy places women at risk in prison"; that its commentary "Gender diverse prisoners and sex-based patterns of offending" reached "well over a quarter million people on X" in 24 hours; that Coach Linda Blade spoke with its Domestic Affairs Director "about her experience with gender ideology in sport"; and, as the statement of "victory": "Since our thought leadership on this issue began, three provinces have now adopted some of our recommendations and revised their own gender policies. This is a victory that MLI has played a leading role in creating." The report names no province and no policy; the claim is MLI's own and is not verified here. The same page praises a senior fellow's essay on being targeted by "woke" activists for "refusing to blindly follow all the dictates of pro-trans ideology", and lists "harmful gender ideology" among the topics MLI "spoke out" on. The report's media list (p. 15) includes a 2023-09-03 Epoch Times column by Peter Menzies headed "Schools keeping parents in the dark on gender issues is about power, not safety". This is anti-trans rhetoric: "ideology" is used for the existence of trans people, and "damage to women and girls" is the shield framing.
- 2024 annual report: MLI's 2024 annual report (p. 8) describes "MLI's influential paper on Canadian culture wars" and says "Based on national polling, the report showed Canadians overwhelmingly oppose policies rooted in identity politics, gender ideology, and historical revisionism", and (p. 22) lists Mia Hughes as a fellow with "Areas of expertise: Gender medicine, psychiatric epidemics, social contagions, the history of transgender rights, and the impact of gender identity ideology on society, with a particular focus on women's rights and child safeguarding", and Roy Eappen with "Healthcare, gender medicine and policy". "Social contagion" is a debunked anti-trans claim; "psychiatric epidemics", "gender identity ideology" and "gender ideology" cast the existence of trans people as an epidemic or an ideology: this is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith; the evidence brief records that regret after transition is rare.
- The 2021 annual report's publications and events lists name, under 2021: "Fairness in Sport Virtual Roundtable, May 20, 2021" (p. 22); "A level playing field: Sex, gender and fairness in women's sport, August 4, 2021" (p. 22); "Fair game: Biology, fairness and transgender athletes in women's sport, by Jon Pike, Emma Hilton, and Leslie A. Howe, December 7, 2021" (p. 26); and "Canadians' views on women's sport and gender identity, polling, August 4, 2021" (p. 27). The report has no narrative section on these items beyond the listing. Excluding trans women from the women's category affects trans women of every age, adults included.
- The September 2023 commentary by Jo Phoenix (48) opens that accommodating prisoners "according to gender identity is a problem" and asserts that "a significant proportion of transwomen prisoners do, in fact, have histories of violent and sexual offending"; it is about adult prisoners, draws on a Correctional Service Canada study, and is anti-trans rhetoric that casts trans women as a danger on the strength of one prison population.
- "Social contagion", the framing in the 2024 report's description of a fellow's areas of expertise, is not supported by the evidence: in a Dutch cohort (Lancet Child & Adolescent Health, 2022) 98% (704 of 720) of adolescents who started blockers then hormones were still on hormones at follow-up, and a meta-analysis (PRS Global Open, 2021; 27 studies, 7,928 surgical patients) found pooled regret of 1% after surgery.
- 2024-05-08: the Institute published on its own site "Canada's dangerous commitment to trans-affirming care for minors" by James Pew, filed under its Domestic Policy, Health, Gender Identity and Social Issues categories, with a linked PDF (49). The page describes the author as an independent writer and researcher. The commentary says Western governments are reversing course on care for minors, relies on the American College of Pediatricians for claims about risks of puberty blockers and hormones and for the claim that some minors receive double mastectomies at 13, treats social transition as a step toward medicalization, criticises school policies that allow a student's transition to be kept from parents, describes the leaked WPATH files and the April 2024 Cass Review as undermining care, names the New Brunswick, Alberta and Saskatchewan policies, and urges Canada to follow the Cass Review and to cancel a federally funded educator toolkit on trans-affirming education (the author's claims are his). This is anti-trans rhetoric: surgery on trans minors is extremely rare and is already barred in much of the United States, and published methodological critiques of the Cass Review exist. The commentary asks for restrictions on trans young people's care and on school recognition of their names, which are measures aimed at trans people, not a neutral review of evidence.
- June 2024: the Institute published a paper (the Institute's page for the paper, with its PDF: 50), marked "A Macdonald-Laurier Institute publication, June 2024": "The Children's Charter: Alberta's trans policies and legislated rights for children", by Stephane Serafin (University of Ottawa, Faculty of Law) and Geoffrey Sigalet (University of British Columbia Okanagan), with the notice "Copyright 2024 Macdonald-Laurier Institute". The executive summary (p. 4) says "Alberta recently announced that it would follow New Brunswick and Saskatchewan by enacting policies requiring schools to notify and obtain consent from parents in order to change the names and pronouns of children under the age of 15" and that Alberta would go further by "restricting the availability of medical interventions such as puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to children under the age of 16 and sex reassignment surgeries to children under 18", and proposed "restrictions on the participation of biological males in female sports". It argues the policies "are best understood as protecting the rights of transgender-identifying children and their parents, as well as the rights of girls and adult women", cites "The Cass Report" (Cass 2024, p. 31), and says "growing evidence of the uncertain benefits and grave risks of 'gender affirming' medical interventions" helps justify the age limits. On p. 16 it says the New Brunswick and Saskatchewan policies "feature exceptions aimed at those cases where disclosure might give rise to a risk of abuse" and "Alberta's policies are expected to follow a similar approach". Its bibliography lists earlier MLI items: David Zitner, "Gender dysphoria in children: Risking harm from well-intentioned parents and doctors", 2022-09-29; Dave Snow, "When Rights Clash: The Notwithstanding Clause and Saskatchewan's Pronoun Policy", 2023-10-10; and Pike et al., December 2021. This is anti-trans rhetoric, including its appeal to the Cass Review: a peer-reviewed appraisal (BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2025, ROBIS tool) rated all seven systematic reviews commissioned for it at high risk of bias, and low certainty ratings are common across pediatric medicine, where randomized trials are widely considered unethical. The sports section would bar "biological males" from women's and girls' sport at every age, which excludes adult trans women; surgery on trans minors is extremely rare and is already banned in much of the United States. Which three provinces the 2023 report's "victory" sentence means: the 2023 report names none and no source says. What is documented is MLI's own material on three provincial policies (New Brunswick, Saskatchewan, Alberta) in 2023 and 2024; that these are the three of the sentence is not stated by any source and is not inferred here.
- MLI's own publication "The Politics of the Culture Wars in Contemporary Canada" by Eric Kaufmann (February 2024; 51) reports an online survey of 1,503 Canadian adults fielded by Maru Voice Canada on 2023-09-18 to 2023-09-20, margin of error plus or minus 2.5 percent, 19 times out of 20. Its highlights include: oppose teaching "There is no such thing as biological sex, only gender preference" 85 to 15; oppose "attempts to cancel gender-critical feminists J.K. Rowling and Kathleen Stock" 80 to 20; "Canadians oppose gender reassignment surgery for under-16s by 4 to 1"; 2 to 1 want parents informed when children under 16 change pronouns at school; 2 to 1 "do not want transgender women to enter women's sports competitions". Its own summary says the structure of opinion "indicates that there is considerable potential for right-of-centre parties to increase the salience of culture wars issues". These are the paper's wordings and results; surgery on trans minors is extremely rare, so a poll on it measures the reach of the framing, not the facts. Polling whether trans women may enter women's sports competitions and whether parents must be told of a child's pronouns treats trans people's lives as "culture wars issues": this is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith, and the sports item concerns adult trans women as well as minors. The 2024 annual report (p. 8) describes "MLI's influential paper on Canadian culture wars" and says "Based on national polling, the report showed Canadians overwhelmingly oppose policies rooted in identity politics, gender ideology, and historical revisionism"; it names no author, title or date, so the equation with this paper is consistent with the heading but not stated by the report. The Institute's own release of 2024-02-15, "Canada is a lot less 'woke' than you might think...", announces the paper by name: "In a new report, The politics of the culture wars in contemporary Canada, senior fellow Eric Kaufmann uses a nationally representative survey to examine public opinion on how Canadians respond to culture war issues, including: cancel culture, critical race theory, and transgender policy." The release repeats that Canadian attitudes "lean about 2 to 1 against the cultural socialist position" and lists, as the Institute's own findings from the survey, that respondents "oppose gender reassignment surgery for under-16s by 4 to 1" and, "by a 2 to 1 ratio, do not want transgender women to enter women's sports competitions" (republication of the Institute's release, 52). These are the Institute's reported survey figures and its own framing.
- 2024 annual report, page 8 (10, printed page 8): under the Domestic Policy program the box headed "MLI's influential paper on Canadian culture wars" says "In one of the most comprehensive analyses of Canadian attitudes on cultural issues to date, MLI revealed that public opinion leans strongly against the dominant 'woke' narratives found in media and elite discourse. Based on national polling, the report showed Canadians overwhelmingly oppose policies rooted in identity politics, gender ideology, and historical revisionism". The page names no author, title, date or pollster. The only MLI paper read whose subject matches the heading is Eric Kaufmann's "The Politics of the Culture Wars in Contemporary Canada" (February 2024, a national online survey of 1,503 adults by Maru Voice Canada, described above), and page 19 of the same report lists a 2024 event with Chris Rufo and "Senior Fellow Eric Kaufmann". The report is therefore consistent with referring to that paper, but it does not say so. The February 2024 paper (executive summary on PDF page 4) and the 2024 annual report box (printed page 8) agree on four points: both rest on national polling; the paper says Canadian attitudes "lean about 2 to 1 against the cultural socialist position" and the report says opinion "leans strongly against the dominant 'woke' narratives"; the paper says Canadian opinion "is astoundingly similar to that in the United States and Britain" and its highlights say opinion "on cancel culture, critical race/history, and transgender issues is almost identical to that in Britain and the United States", while the report says the results mirror "trends in the US and UK"; and both are about "culture wars". The report names no title, author or date, so the link remains one of matching content, not a statement by the report. Calling policies on trans people "gender ideology" is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- 2023 annual report, printed page 17 (9) says "Since our thought leadership on this issue began, three provinces have now adopted some of our recommendations and revised their own gender policies. This is a victory that MLI has played a leading role in creating." The passage names no province and no policy; the preceding sentences name MLI's 2023 paper with Jo Phoenix on prison housing, a commentary on prisoners, and a coach's discussion of "gender ideology in sport".
- December 2021: the Macdonald-Laurier Institute published a policy paper by three credited authors, titled "Fair Game: Biology, fairness and transgender athletes in women's sport" on one copy and "Faster, Higher, Stronger: The biological and ethical challenges to including transgender athletes in women's sports" on another (the Institute's 2021 annual report lists it as "Fair game"). A statement on p. 3 of both says the authors worked independently and are solely responsible for the views; the Institute published the paper. The paper sets out the authors' claim that trans women should not compete in the women's category: "Where sex categories are justified, we hold the view that it is not appropriate to include transwomen in the women’s category." (Faster, Higher, Stronger, p. 10). It defines terms by sex: "We take the term “woman” to mean adult human female." (Faster, Higher, Stronger, p. 10; Fair Game, p. 11). It recommends "the male category as “Open” and the women’s category as “Female” where female refers to the sex recorded at birth." (Fair Game, p. 32) and asks sports bodies to act: "We urge national and international sports organizations, in Canada and beyond, to develop a similar policy." (Fair Game, p. 32). It criticises the International Olympic Committee: "Likewise, the focus of the IOC on preventing discrimination based on gender identity is misplaced." (Fair Game, p. 31). The paper asserts that "There is neither a medical intervention nor a clever philosophical argument that can make it fair for transwomen to compete in women’s sport." (Fair Game, p. 31). Several sentences appear word for word in both copies. Defining a woman as an "adult human female" and barring trans women from the women's category deny trans women's identity: this is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith, and it excludes trans women of every age, adults included. (Macdonald-Laurier Institute, Fair Game, December 2021, p. 3; 53; and Macdonald-Laurier Institute, Faster, Higher, Stronger, December 2021, p. 3; 54)
- 2024-12: Inside Policy, the Institute's magazine (Volume 4, December issue, 28 pages), carries trans content on pp. 3, 8-10 and 14-15. The imprint says the contributors worked independently and are solely responsible for their views. The editors' introduction says the issue's article will "challenge a misguided and dangerous federal policy that permits biologically male trans inmates to be transferred to women’s prisons." (p. 3). An article headed on ignoring the science describes gender policy as extreme gender ideology and says "In April 2024, Britain’s Cass Report recommended against such surgeries for minors and urged restrictions on puberty blockers, leading the United Kingdom to restrict these treatments." (p. 9). The standfirst of the prisons article by an Institute senior fellow and deputy director reads: "When a nation jettisons reality and allows public policy to be guided by an incoherent belief system such as gender ideology, anything is possible." (p. 14). Calling trans women prisoners "biologically male" and gender identity part of "an incoherent belief system" denies trans women's identity: this is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith, aimed at adults in federal prisons. A peer-reviewed appraisal (BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2025, ROBIS tool) rated all seven systematic reviews commissioned for the Cass Review, which the p. 9 article cites, at high risk of bias (the evidence brief; 55). (Macdonald-Laurier Institute, Inside Policy, Volume 4, 2024 (December issue), p. 3; 56)
- 2025: the Institute's Annual Report 2025 claims its work informed policy shifts in Alberta on higher education, DEI and gender identity: "Provincially, our work has informed significant policy shifts in Alberta regarding higher-education, DEI and gender identity." (p. 4). The Domestic Policy summary repeats the claim: "Alberta has also advanced policies addressing DEI influence over higher-education, gender identity, and Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD) that reflect MLI’s work." (p. 7). These are the Institute's claims of influence; the report gives no further detail. (Macdonald-Laurier Institute, Annual Report 2025: A Year of Growth (2025), p. 4; 16)
- 2023-09: the Institute published the commentary Gender diverse prisoners and sex-based patterns of offending by an outside author, with a disclaimer that the views are the author's. It summarises a Correctional Service Canada study of gender diverse federal prisoners. It concludes that "the approach of conflating gender identity with biological sex necessarily involves denying half-a-century of research about the differences between the needs, risks and histories of men and women who end up in our corrections systems." (p. 8). This is the author's claim, published by the Institute; like the opening of the same commentary (described above), it is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith, that denies trans women prisoners are women. (Gender diverse prisoners and sex-based patterns of offending, Macdonald-Laurier Institute, 2023-09, p. 8; 57)
Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext
- 2025-11-04: in an MLI Inside Policy column, senior fellow Mia Hughes wrote that governments "wrote into law an activist-crafted concept that lacks any grounding in evidence". The column is about gender identity in human rights law for adults. "In short, governments across Canada wrote into law an activist-crafted concept that lacks any grounding in evidence – one that has profound implications for women’s rights, legal clarity, and the material basis of equality itself." (Gender identity in Canadian law: definition, origins, and societal impact, 2025-11-04, no page numbers (web page); 58)
- The same column called on policymakers to "examine the validity of the concept" of gender identity and "act to restore clarity" to Canada's legal framework. "Now, more than a decade later, it falls to today’s policymakers to do what their predecessors neglected to do: examine the validity of the concept, assess its real-world impact on women’s rights and child protection, and act to restore clarity, coherence, and reason to Canada’s legal framework." (same source). Calling gender identity "an activist-crafted concept that lacks any grounding in evidence" and asking policymakers to "examine the validity of the concept" deny trans people's identity and target their protection in human rights law as adults: this is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- The same December 2021 paper reaches past sport to gender identity itself: "We think that gender identity in this sense is unstable at best, and meaningless at worst." (Fair Game, p. 21; Faster, Higher, Stronger, p. 20; the same words in both copies). The paper also asserts that "DSDs form discrete conditions that affect only males or only females, and do not represent novel sexes." (Fair Game, p. 20). The paper's main subject is adult athletes. Calling gender identity "unstable at best, and meaningless at worst" denies trans people's identity: this is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith, beyond sport. (Macdonald-Laurier Institute, Fair Game, December 2021, p. 21; 53)
- In the same December 2024 issue, the article on trans prisoners concerns adults in federal prisons and asks a future government to act on a definition. Its authors write: "A woman is an adult human female—a fact even the Correctional Service of Canada (CSC) tacitly acknowledges." (p. 15), and claim that CSC practice "clearly indicates that CSC recognizes these individuals as men" (p. 15). They ask a future Conservative government: "That stand should begin by firmly reinstating the definition of a woman as an adult human female." (p. 15). The request would restore a definition of a woman that excludes trans women, and it concerns adults in federal prisons. Describing trans women prisoners as men and asking for a definition of a woman that excludes them is anti-trans rhetoric aimed at adult trans women. (Macdonald-Laurier Institute, Inside Policy, Volume 4, 2024 (December issue), p. 15; 56)
- The commentary concerns adult prisoners. Its opening says: "It undermines very hard fought for women’s rights to single sex spaces." (p. 1). Presenting trans women in women's prisons as a threat to women's rights is the shield framing named above: anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith, aimed at adult prisoners. (57)
Open questions
- Whether MLI's fellows are paid, and when Mia Hughes' fellowship began: the T3010 return gives pay bands for the ten highest-paid employees but no fellow list, and the US returns list no fellow pay. MLI's own page of 2025-07-08 already calls her senior fellow; the sources reviewed here give no start date. MLI's published announcements of new senior fellows do not name her; the 2024 annual report's "New fellows" section (p. 22) lists her.
- The relationship of BCSG Enterprises (filed as "BCSG Enterprises LTD" and "BCSG Enterprises Inc"; $927,611 in contractor payments and $632,595 in business transactions (contractor payments 2022-2024; business transactions 2023-2024; the business transactions of tax years 2018 to 2022 are filed to "BSCG Enterprises Ltd", see People on file); the two schedules overlap, since both list the same $311,961 payment in 2024, so the figures are not added) to the institute's management: the returns do not say in words who owns the company (they describe the payee as "Entity Owned by Director" for tax years 2018 to 2021 and give its relationship as "Managing Director" from 2022), the records name no officer of that company, and a separate record shows a federal contract to a "BCSG Enterprises Ltd." (4 contracts, CAD 81,976, Department of Finance Canada, 2008-2013), which is a name match only. The returns describe the contractor payments as "Managing Director" and the business transactions as "Contract Fees and Bonus" and "Approved Reimbursements", with the relationship "Managing Director" (object ids 202333189349306133, 202421359349307297, 202523179349303012); the "BCSG Enterprises" donor of 2013, 2014, 2017 and 2018 is a same-name lead only.
- How many MLI publications, events or staff statements address trans people or gender-affirming care: Transgender Map, an advocacy tracker (page reviewed here), lists 22 MLI items from 2021-08-04 to 2025-05-14 under "Selected anti-trans publications by MLI" and two MLI videos (2024-10-03 and 2025-01-17); that is the tracker's selection, not a complete count (59). Xtra Magazine reports that of 628 MLI items in 2024, "more than 20" concerned gender identity.
- Whether Atlas Network or its donors have funded MLI's work on trans people: no Atlas Network or Atlas Economic Research Foundation grant to MLI appears in the CRA gift rows (148 rows, funders' T3010s) or in the US returns searched by name. The Narwhal reports an Atlas "Poverty & Freedom grant" to an MLI project on Indigenous participation in the resource economy, with no amount or year, and DeSmog lists Atlas Network among MLI's annual-report donors; neither concerns trans issues. Whether any Atlas money reached MLI's gender-policy work: MLI's annual reports of 2021, 2023, 2024 and 2025 carry no donor list, so this is not shown. For tax years 2015 to 2018 the Atlas EIN's returns carry 17, 25, 20 and 20 grant rows to recipients with US or Puerto Rico places, none to the Institute; Atlas's own returns report grants abroad on Schedule F by region, purpose and amount, and its Schedule F rows for tax years 2014 to 2025 name no recipient (see the Schedule F item under Money received).
- Whether MLI published a 2022 annual report: the Institute's annual-reports page lists none; the 2021, 2023, 2024 and 2025 reports print no donor list, and the 2018 report is the last to print one. Which provinces the 2023 report's statement of "victory" refers to: the report (p. 17) names none; MLI's June 2024 paper covers the New Brunswick, Saskatchewan and Alberta policies, but no source states that these are the three of the sentence.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- image page: https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/
- https://apps.cra-arc.gc.ca/ebci/hacc/srch/pub/dsplyBscSrch
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/980578530
- https://www.desmog.com/macdonald-laurier-institute/
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/files/pdf/2018_MLI_annual_report_Fweb.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/files/pdf/MLIAnnualReport2016_web_Final.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/files/pdf/2017_MLI_annual_report_FINALWeb.pdf
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/20240522_2023-MLI-ANNUAL-REPORT-v5.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/Macdonald-Laurier-Institute-Annual-Report-2024.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/files/pdf/MLIAnnualReport2013-WebReady.pdf
- https://www.macdonaldlaurier.ca/files/pdf/MLIAnnualReport2014-WebReadyV6.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/files/pdf/MLIAnnualReport2015-WebReady.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/20220603_2021_MLI_ANNUAL_REPORT_FWeb.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/files/pdf/20210526_2020_MLI_ANNUAL_REPORT_FWeb.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MLI-Annual-Report-2025-Final-Web.pdf
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/201521749349300317/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/201622109349300857/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/201743189349305204/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/201812059349300336/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/201921309349301067/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/202041229349300319/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/202140959349300244/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/202231409349300803/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/202321089349300812/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/202411169349300321/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/942763845/202541279349303279/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/980578530/202213149349301441/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/980578530/202333189349306133/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/980578530/202421359349307297/full
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/980578530/202523179349303012/full
- https://thebridgehead.ca/2025/05/14/canadian-media-is-shielding-horrors-of-transgenderism-behind-a-crumbling-wall-of-propaganda/
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/cm-expert/mia-hughes/
- https://www.atlasnetwork.org/assets/uploads/misc/MLI_Aboriginal_Canada_Case_Study_Final.pdf
- https://thenarwhal.ca/atlas-network-indigenous-rights/
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/disproving-disinformation-perpetuated-in-the-guardian-and-the-narwhal/
- https://web.archive.org/web/20210814223222/https://www.atlasnetwork.org/assets/uploads/misc/MLI_Aboriginal_Canada_Case_Study_Final.pdf
- https://www.atlasnetwork.org/articles/templeton-freedom-award-winners-and-finalists
- https://www.atlasnetwork.org/articles/instituto-mexicano-para-la-competitividads-3de3-campaign-wins-2017-templeton-freedom-award
- https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/imcos-anticorruption-reform-initiative-for-mexico-3de3-wins-prestigious-2017-templeton-freedom-award-300553494.html
- https://publications.aap.org/aapnews/news/25340/AAP-reaffirms-gender-affirming-care-policy
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/category/issues/domestic-policy-program/gender-identity/
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/category/issues/domestic-policy-program/gender-identity/page/2/
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/SEPT2022_Gender_dysphoria_in_children_Zitner_COMMENTARY_FWeb.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/20250117_Gender-distressed-youth-Moruzi-COMMENTARY-v5-MR.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/protect-women-girls-from-extreme-gender-ideology-worldwide/
- https://xtramagazine.com/?p=275781.
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/20230922_We-were-right-Phoenix-COMMENTARY-v5.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/canadas-dangerous-commitment-to-trans-affirming-care-for-minors-james-pew/
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/the-childrens-charter-albertas-trans-policies-and-legislated-rights-for-children/
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/20240129_Culture-wars-Kaufmann_PAPER-B-v2-FINAL.pdf
- https://unpublished.ca/node/837832
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/files/pdf/Dec2021_Fair_game_Pike_Hilton_Howe_PAPER_FWeb.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Dec2021_Faster_higher_stronger_Pike_Hilton_Howe_PAPER_FWeb.pdf
- https://research.gold.ac.uk/id/eprint/38983
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/202412_DECEMBER-Inside-Policy-v4-FINAL.pdf
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/20230922_We-were-right-Phoenix-COMMENTARY-v5.pdf.
- https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/gender-identity-in-canadian-law-definition-origins-and-societal-impact-mia-hughes-for-inside-policy/
- https://www.transgendermap.com/issues/academia/gender-critical/macdonald-laurier-institute/