All profiles

Organization
Organization: For Women Scotland [Companies House SC669393]
Logo of For Women Scotland, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_Women_Scotland, used for identification [image page1]

For Women Scotland

Anti-trans advocacy group, Scotland

At least $132.5Kreceived on fileOther records and reporting · 0 funders
14documented ties12 names on file
4people with a direct roleofficers, directors, founders, staff

Scottish company limited by guarantee, incorporated 2020-07-30 (former name For Women Scotland Limited until 2020-09-01), micro-entity accounts, last accounts 2025-07-31. Its documented links include Sex Matters' intervention in its Supreme Court case, J.K. Rowling's reported pledge, and the legal costs the Scottish Government paid it. All amounts GBP. The company number is confirmed by the group's own statement: "For Women Scotland registered as a not-for-profit company in July 2020 (Company number: SC669393)" (forwomen.scot/about, accessed 2026-11-09). Not on the OSCR charity register.

Founding and early history

  • For Women Scotland describes itself as "a grassroots women's group founded in June 2018 in opposition to the Scottish Government's plans to reform the Gender Recognition Act 2004 to allow for self-declaration of sex"; the same page says it registered as a not-for-profit company in July 2020 (company number SC669393) and that "Currently, we are all volunteers" (2, read 2026-11-20). The June 2018 date is the group's own statement. The incorporation date of 30 July 2020 comes from Companies House (3) and stands beside it.
  • A post of 18 August 2019 on the group's site names Magdalen Berns as "one of our FWS's co-founders" and says the group marched in the Pride Glasgow march as a contingent tagged "Celebrating Lesbians", carrying a portrait of her. The site gives no founding role or dates for her beyond that wording. The list of three directors below (People on file; the only officers on the Companies House register) is not a list of founders (4, read 2026-11-20).
  • Women's Spaces Scotland, February 2018: in a post of 6 January 2020 the group says "one of our co-founders" attended a meeting with the Scottish Government's Family Law Department "at the time of the first consultation in Feb 2018, as part of Women's Spaces Scotland", where, in the group's account, officials conflated sex and gender. The post does not name the co-founder. It is mainly the group's dispute with the Government's 2019 consultation paper, which (as the group reports) says a member of the group met officials in February 2019; the group says it never met officials, saw no minutes and requested the minutes on 19 December 2019, to which the Department said it would treat the request as a Freedom of Information request. These are the group's claims; the page reports the Department's reply only as the group relays it (5, read 2026-11-20).

Money received

  • Sex Matters paid £62,500 to For Women Scotland in the financial year to 2025-06-30. Its accounts for the period 1 April 2024 to 30 June 2025 state: "Charitable expenditure includes grant funding of £62,500 to For Women Scotland for campaigning and engagement" (Sex Matters, registered charity 1207701, accounts, 6). Civil Society names FWS as the recipient ("Sex Matters paid £62,500 to For Women Scotland in 2024-25, its accounts show"; Civil Society, 2026-05-13, 7). The register's "grants to institutions" line for Sex Matters, £62,500, names no recipient (Charity Commission register, charity 1207701, 8).
  • Scottish Government payment of costs to For Women Scotland after it won, reported by two sources. (1) the Scottish Government's own cost page (gov.scot, "For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers: legal costs", accessed 2026-11-09) lists £242,500 for the Supreme Court and £150,000 for the Court of Session (a total of £392,500, which The Scotsman headlines as a settlement); For Women Scotland's own page of 2026-02-10 says the money will be used for its current judicial review on prison guidance and any future legal action "necessary to ensure the Scottish Government complies with the law" (entry on that page below). (2) Irish News: the government paid For Women Scotland £540,000 for the first and second cases together after the April 2025 Supreme Court ruling, made up of £147,500 from the first case (Court of Session, 2022) and £392,500 from the second case (Court of Session and Supreme Court stages), and spent more than £760,000 in all (£766,498.80, including its own legal costs of £68,682.50 in the Court of Session case and £157,816.30 in the Supreme Court case, the latter described as not final) (Irish News, 2026-02-10, 9; a photo caption in the same article gives £549,000, which conflicts with the body text). The two sources describe two different cases. For Women Scotland's own page of 2026-02-10 (forwomen.scot/?p=14606) puts costs paid to it at £147,500 for the first case (Court of Session, 2022) and £392,500 for the second (£150,000 for the Court of Session stage and £242,500 for the UK Supreme Court), so the Irish News's £147,500 is the 2022 case and not the Court of Session stage of the later one; £147,500 plus £392,500 is £540,000. The Government's own legal costs per the same page are £68,682.50 (first case) and £171,615.30 (second case); the Irish News gave £157,816.30 for the second case, described there as not final, the same figure as the Government's freedom-of-information release of May 2025 (entry below), which said final costs were "still being determined". The group's page says, in an update of 16 February 2026, that the Scottish Government had then published its final legal costs for the second case and that the table had been updated accordingly, so the two figures are of different dates: £157,816.30 before final costs were known, £171,615.30 after. The Government's own statement of final costs, published 12 February 2026, bears out the later figure: its counsel, court-fee and law-accountant costs for the UK Supreme Court (£105,462.50, £160 and £3,234) and for the Court of Session (£53,487.50, £7,552 and £1,719.30), exclusive of VAT, come to £171,615.30 (Scottish Government, "For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers: legal costs", 10, read as a Wayback Machine archive copy of 2026-06-19, 11). These are costs paid by ministers after FWS won, not donations.
  • Crowdfunded legal fund: Wikipedia's article states that donations for the legal challenge totalled £197,000 from 4,023 donors, including £70,000 from J.K. Rowling (1, accessed 2026-11-10; the closing date and the primary fundraiser page are not given there). The group's own donation page lists PayPal, card and bank-transfer routes, states "We rely completely on donations made by our supporters", and gives no totals (forwomen.scot/donate/, accessed 2026-11-10).
  • J.K. Rowling's pledge of £70,000 is reported by the Scottish Daily Express and the Daily Mail; the Express (published 2024-02-17, 12) says the crowdfunder, which "went live on Friday", stood at £101,900 from 807 pledges and that she pledged £70,000 after permission to appeal to the Supreme Court was granted on Friday, which places the pledge on or about 2024-02-16. No filing shows the payment, and micro-entity accounts would not.
  • Crowdfunder at an earlier date: PinkNews (2024-02-19, 13) says "the crowdfunder has raised more than £133,400 from over 2,000 individuals" and reports that J.K. Rowling "reportedly donated £70,000" to it, citing The Times, Telegraph, Scottish Daily Express and Daily Mail.
  • The Daily Mail reported that J.K. Rowling's £70,000 donation came "within hours of Scottish courts granting permission for the appeal to go ahead", with the message "You know how proud I am to know you. Thank you for all your hard work and perseverance. This is truly a historic case.", and that the group's fundraiser had "raised £229,365 so far". The Daily Mail text gives no date for the figure. It differs from the Scottish Daily Express figure already in this profile (£101,900 from 807 pledges), which suggests the two were taken at different times. (Daily Mail, 14)
  • For Women Scotland's own page "UK Supreme Court - recovery of costs", posted 10 February 2026, states that a "full and final settlement" had been reached with the Scottish Ministers, with amounts of £150,000 (Court of Session) and £242,500 (UK Supreme Court), a total of £392,500, and that the funds "have been retained in a deposit account with Balfour+Manson solicitors". It states that the money will cover "the costs of our current judicial review on prison guidance" and "any future legal action necessary to ensure the Scottish Government complies with the law". The page gives no payment dates (forwomen.scot/?p=14606; the group's own statement).
  • The same page sets out the Government's spending as a table: the first case (Court of Session, 2022, "FWS1") Government legal costs £68,682.50 and costs paid to For Women Scotland £147,500.00, total £216,182.50; the second case (UK Supreme Court, 2025, "FWS2") Government legal costs £171,615.30 and costs paid to For Women Scotland £392,500.00, total £564,115.30; and says the two judicial reviews cost the Government "£780,297.80 of taxpayers money". It adds that the third case (prison guidance) had cost £134,104.50 as of 2026-01-09 and £187,957 at the 1 April 2026 update (forwomen.scot/?p=14606; these are the group's own figures for the Government's costs, the group's statement and not a Government release).
  • The Scottish Government's freedom-of-information release FOI/202500462293 (received 16 April 2025, responded 19 May 2025, published 16 September 2025) gives figures in answer to a request for "The total legal costs to the Scottish Government": "For Women Scotland - Petition for Judicial Review" counsel fees £61,930.50, court fees £4,898.00, other £149,354.00, total £216,182.50; "Petition 2" (Outer House, Inner House and Supreme Court) counsel fees £148,925.00, court fees £7,552.00, other £1,339.30, total £157,816.30, adding "Final costs in relation to the case are still being determined and are not yet available." The release sets out the costs under these three headings; it does not say what the "other" amounts consist of, whether they include costs paid to For Women Scotland, or the date of any payment to it (Scottish Government, 15, accessed 2026-11-16). For the first case its total of £216,182.50 is the same as the total on For Women Scotland's own page of 2026-02-10, which divides it into the Government's legal costs of £68,682.50 and costs paid to For Women Scotland of £147,500.00 and labels the Government's figures "(see FOI)" (entry above).
  • Timing of the payment: Holyrood reported on 2025-10-08 that the Government had not yet paid For Women Scotland's costs, quoting director Marion Calder ("We are still waiting for them to settle up from April"), that the Supreme Court costs were understood to have been lodged in August, that total costs were reported as £417,000, and quoting a Government spokesperson that final costs "will be calculated and published in due course"; Scottish Legal News reported on 2026-02-11 that a "full and final settlement" of £392,500 had now been agreed, on the strength of the group's statement of the previous day. The Irish News, carrying a Press Association report dated 2025-12-24 ("Campaigner fears ministers 'trying to run us out of cash' after gender ruling", 16), quotes For Women Scotland director Susan Smith: "They have not paid us yet, because they owe us costs." The same report says hearings were set for 2026-01-22 (Court of Session expenses) and 2026-02-13 (Supreme Court bill of costs). The group's statement "issued yesterday" confirmed receipt of £392,500 (Scottish Legal News, 2026-02-11). On these reports the sum had not been paid on 2025-12-24 and had been received by 2026-02-10; none gives the day of payment (holyrood.com, "scottish-government-still-to-pay-for-women-scotland-legal-bill-according-to-womens-rights-campaigner"; 17; both attribute the figures to the group or to the Government's spokesperson).
  • J.K. Rowling's own statement: PinkNews (2025-04-17) reports that she wrote on X on 2025-04-16 that "HK Rowling" had never given the group money, adding: "JK definitely has." The same article reports that in 2024-02 a donor shown as "JK" gave £70,000 to the group's crowdfunder with the comment "You know how proud I am to know you." and that her representatives told PinkNews they would not comment on her personal donations. Her post states no amount (18; her words as quoted by PinkNews). The same Irish News report of 2025-12-24 (address in the entry on the timing of the payment) says Susan Smith described the group's spending of "more than £400,000" on the earlier case as crowd-funded and boosted by a "large donation" from J.K. Rowling, which the group is "very grateful for". This is the group's own director confirming that a donation was received; the report states no amount and no date, and the £70,000 figure rests on the press reports cited above.
  • Wikipedia's figure of £197,000 from 4,023 donors cites three reports: The Times (2024-02-17), The Telegraph (2024-02-18) and The Sunday Times (2024-11-23). The latest is dated 2024-11-23, so the date of the figure is not fixed and it is not shown to be a total at close (1; reference list).
  • The CrowdJustice case page "UK Supreme Court: The Definition of Sex in the Equality Act" (case owner For Women Scotland; lawyers Balfour + Manson LLP) gives no closing date, and its case updates say, on 19 November 2024, that costs had increased from the original estimate and that "Reaching the target of £200k is now the minimum that is needed", with the target extended above that figure; on 10 December 2024, "We are also waiting on the final fee notes from our legal team and we estimate that we are still a few thousand short of the total needed ... so we will leave the CrowdJustice page open for a while longer"; the latest update is dated 19 April 2025 (the judgment). The page shows no list of individual pledges. (CrowdJustice, 19, accessed 2026-11-16; the group's own statements on the page) An archive copy of the case page (captured 2026-05-25) carries the same updates and says "This case is currently not accepting new pledges" (Wayback Machine, 20, archive copy of 2026-05-25).
  • CrowdJustice's own description of its targets: "If the target is not reached within 30 days, cards will be refunded and we do not collect any fees. Once the initial target is met, funds will be transferred to your lawyer (or associated organisation), net of fees & charges", after which a case may move to a stretch target; the platform fee is "3% + payment processing" (CrowdJustice, How it works, 21, accessed 2026-11-16). The case page's status line says the case was funded on 16 February 2024, the date on or about which the Scottish Daily Express places J.K. Rowling's pledge (Scottish Daily Express, 2024-02-17, 12). Neither CrowdJustice page states when any single pledge was charged.
  • First public crowdfunder: a review post of 5 May 2020 says the group "launched our first public crowdfunder" on 18 December 2019, "raising £14,730 for our campaign funds in 28 days", from "252 individual donations", for its #BinTheBill campaign against the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill consultation (campaign launched 1 February 2020). The figures are the group's own; the post names no platform (22, read 2026-11-20).
  • Judicial review fundraising claims in 2021 (the group's own statements): "almost £100,000" raised "collectively" to challenge the redefinition of "woman" in the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018, in the group's feedback post of 12 February 2021 (23, read 2026-11-20); and "almost £175,000 raised to date to fund legal costs", in its post of 3 August 2021, which gives the appeal's hearing date as 3 November 2021 (24, read 2026-11-20). These are running claims on different dates, not totals at close, and are not added to the other crowdfunding figures on this page.
  • The group's own count of its first-case crowdfunder: in its submission of 19 January 2024 to the Scottish Parliament's Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee on the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill, the group wrote "on behalf of the 5,278 people who generously contributed £196,815 to our CrowdJustice fund for the legal costs". The sentence comes in a submission about the judicial review the group says it won in February 2022; it gives no date for the figures and does not say whether £196,815 is gross or net of platform fees. It predates the second crowdfunder (the group's page of 19 January 2024 and the Scottish Daily Express article of 17 February 2024, 25, which says the fundraiser "went live on Friday", read together), so the figures are not the totals of the Supreme Court fundraiser (5,021 pledges, per the CrowdJustice case page cited above). The £196,815 is also not the net figure of £183,399.50 on the group's finance page; the pages do not reconcile the two (26, read 2026-11-20).
  • The group's finance post of 21 September 2022 states expenses, legal and court fees of £195,047.43; income from the CrowdJustice fundraiser (net) of £183,399.50, interest of £5.02 and general donations to the group of £11,642.91; and that "following the Court of Session ruling which found the Scottish Government liable for our legal costs, we have now received a full and final settlement of £147,500". An update dated 15 October 2022 says two Freedom of Information responses showed the Scottish Government's legal bills totalling £216,063.60, made up of £32,819 (initial case), £35,744.60 (appeal) and the £147,500 paid to the group. That update's figure for the Government's own costs (£68,563.60) differs from the £68,682.50 on the group's page of 2026-02-10 (total £216,182.50); the pages do not say why (27, read 2026-11-20).
  • The group's page of 10 February 2026 carries later updates that give running totals of Scottish Government spending on the group's cases; these are the group's own figures and are not a Government release. Update of 22 February 2026: costs of the prison-guidance judicial review of £134,104.50 as of 9 January 2026 (the group cites the Daily Record), a total of £914,402.30 for the three judicial reviews; £370,474.24 spent by the Government "challenging the Section 35 Order" on the Gender Recognition Reform Bill; and a total of £1,284,876.54 on what the group calls "legal actions attempting to dismantle women's rights" (the group's characterisation). Update of 1 April 2026 (citing the Scottish Daily Express): prison-guidance costs of £187,957, a total of £968,254.80 for the three judicial reviews and £1,338,729.04 including the Section 35 challenge. The sums agree with the earlier figures on the same post (£780,297.80 plus £134,104.50 or £187,957; plus £370,474.24). The £392,500, its split (£150,000 and £242,500) and the deposit account with Balfour+Manson solicitors are as the entries above hold them (28, read 2026-11-20).
  • Filed micro-company accounts (Companies House SC669393; the register's own xhtml documents) show a balance sheet only: each year says the average number of employees was nil and no income statement is filed. Figures as filed (GBP, at 31 July):
YearCurrent assetsCreditors within one yearNet assets and reserves
2021173,330111,06463,133 (total assets less current liabilities)
202220,21316,9473,700
202352,34588952,931
2024134,1961,848133,086
2025103,1911,000102,191

The 2021 and 2022 figures are from the 2022 accounts (the 2021 column is its comparative). Net assets are net current assets (current assets less creditors) plus fixed assets, which the table does not show: 867 (2021), 434 (2022), 1,475 (2023) and 738 (2024); the 2025 accounts show no fixed assets. Accounts for 2025 were filed 27 July 2026 and signed by one director on 24 July 2026. The settlement of £392,500 (own page of 2026-02-10) is not in these balance sheets: the money is described as held in a deposit account with the solicitors, and the 2026 year has not been filed. The micro-entity accounts do not show crowdfunder income or the final total. (29, documents for years to 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025)

People on file

Persons with significant control (Companies House register of persons with significant control, 30); all three are publicly named as FWS directors who speak for the group (Wikipedia and FWS's own site): Trina Budge (voting 25-50% and right to appoint and remove directors, notified 2020-07-30); Marion Calder (voting 25-50%, 2020-08-21); Susan Smith (voting 25-50%, 2020-08-21).

  • The organization's own "About" page says "The three directors are Trina Budge, Marion Calder, and Susan Smith", gives the company number SC669393, describes it as "a not-for-profit company limited by guarantee" and says it registered "in July 2020" (2, accessed 2026-11-10).
  • The Companies House officers page for SC669393 lists three directors, none resigned: Trina Budge (appointed 30 July 2020), Marion Calder (21 August 2020) and Susan Smith (21 August 2020), the same three names as the group's About page (31; primary register).
  • Counsel: For Women Scotland's About page says it commissioned a legal opinion from a King's Counsel, which the page describes as covering local authorities' obligations on single-sex toilets in schools, and that the group sent it to every local authority in Scotland (2, read 2026-11-19; the group's own statement). The group's page of 2 October 2023, "Note of argument", publishes the speaking note for the oral submission "for the reclaimers For Women Scotland" in the morning session of the hearing of 4 October 2023, and a right of reply for the reclaimers, both by a King's Counsel (32, read 2026-11-19; the group's own statement). The counsel is not named here.
  • Magdalen Berns is named on a For Women Scotland page of 8 September 2019, "Lesbian Strength March", a guest post on the march in Leeds on 7 September 2019. It says the author took "a beautiful banner, on loan from Magdalen Berns" to the march and quotes a speech in Berns's honour describing her YouTube channel, begun in 2016, as having about 30,000 subscribers (33, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page, filed under Guest Posts). Wikipedia (as of 2026-10-01, secondary; 34) says she was a British YouTuber who died in September 2019, that she described trans women as "blackface actors" and said "Trans women are men" and that there is "no such thing as a lesbian with a penis", and that she signed an April 2018 open letter to The Times opposing the admission of trans girls to the Girl Guides. That is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented as a sincere or legitimate position. The group's own post of 18 August 2019 (see Founding and early history) calls her one of its co-founders; Holyrood's piece of 12 March 2024 (35, read 2026-11-19) names Marion Calder, Susan Smith and Trina Budge as the group's founders and does not mention her.
  • Maren Smith is listed on the "Events in 2021" page, "Rhona Hotchkiss (LGB Alliance), Maren Smith (For Women Scotland), Eva Comrie (Alba)", as a speaker at "The Implications of Self-ID in Scotland's Schools and Prisons", Bowmar Community Centre, Alloa, on 6 December 2021 (36, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). The listing is an appearance, not a board or staff role. An interview in the German daily taz introduces her as a women's-rights activist of For Women Scotland and "a spokesperson" ("eine Sprecherin") of the group (37, read 2026-11-19; the interview's own introduction). Her views there oppose the Scottish gender recognition reform and are anti-trans rhetoric, not a sincere or legitimate position.
  • Marion Calder, speaking appearances listed by the group, 2021 to 2022: the "Events in 2021" page lists her first among the speakers at the "FWS Women's Rights Demonstration, Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh" of 2 September 2021 (36, read 2026-11-19). The "Events in 2022" page lists her as speaking "about GRA reform" at the Women's Festival, Alloa, on 5 March 2022; as attending "The Claimants" event in London on 1 April 2022 "on behalf of FWS" to talk about the group's judicial review win; as a speaker at the Scottish Women's Rally at the Scottish Parliament on 6 October 2022; and as speaking in the discussion "Call to courage: Is anything worth fighting for?" at the Battle of Ideas Festival, Buxton, on 5 November 2022 (38, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). Holyrood's profile of the three directors (12 March 2024) quotes her: "The bottom line for us is that you can't change sex but that categorically does not make us transphobic." In the same exchange she says that telling someone they cannot change their sex is treated as if "we have committed literal violence" (35, read 2026-11-19; reporting of her words). The statement is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position; the denial of transphobia is her own characterisation.
  • Susan Smith: Beira's Place's board page describes her: "Susan is a co-director of For Women Scotland, the largest grassroots women's organisation in Scotland set up to strengthen and protect women's rights. She has served on the boards and committees of various children's charities and organisations and has a background in finance." (39, read 2026-11-19; the organization's own description; the organizations named are not identified on the page). Holyrood's profile (12 March 2024) records the three directors' account that J.K. Rowling put "us" on the board of Beira's Place; the article does not say which director said it, and Beira's Place's own board page lists only Susan Smith among the three (35, read 2026-11-19).
  • Trina Budge: Holyrood's profile (12 March 2024) says she describes herself, jokingly, as the "only Terf [trans exclusionary radical feminist]" in her village and that before the gender recognition reforms she might not have described herself as a feminist (35, read 2026-11-19; her words as reported). The same article says the three first made contact through postings on Mumsnet and formed the group in 2018. Wikipedia adds that Magdalen Berns was a co-founder and that Calder, Berns, Budge and Smith "began making plans for the group in 2017" after seeing each other's posts on Mumsnet (1, as of 2026-10-01, secondary; not used alone for any claim about conduct).

Speakers, guests and allies named on the group's own pages (each is public by the organization's own listing):

  • Alison Weir is listed, with Caroline McAllister, Elaine Miller and Eva Comrie, among "other speakers" at the Women's Festival, Alloa, on 5 March 2022, whose videos are on Forth Valley Feminist's YouTube channel (38, read 2026-11-19). The page gives no topic for her talk and does not say For Women Scotland organised that festival. A video on that channel is titled "FVF Women's Festival 2022 - Alison Weir, Women's Sport" (40; title read 2026-11-19); no source gives a further identification of her.
  • Elaine Miller is named on the same 2022 events page as a speaker at the Women's Festival, Alloa, on 5 March 2022, as one of the speakers at the Scottish Women's Rally at the Scottish Parliament on 6 October 2022, and in the line "The Critic published Elaine Miller's reflection on witches: 'Women won't wheesht'" in connection with the 8 March 2022 gathering at the Witches' Well, Edinburgh (38, read 2026-11-19). The page gives no description of who she is.
  • Alison Dowling is listed among the speakers at the "Scottish Women's Rally, Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh" on 6 October 2022 (38, read 2026-11-19); the group's page "Women's Rally, October 2022" describes her as "Scottish Labour councillor, Renfrewshire Council" (41, read 2026-11-19). Renfrewshire Council's elected-member page lists Councillor Alison Ann-Dowling, "Labour and Co-operative Party", Ward 10 (Houston, Crosslee and Linwood), elected 6 May 2022 (42, read 2026-11-19). The Canary (24 October 2022, updated 26 October) links the two names: it names her as Labour councillor Alison Ann-Dowling of the same ward and reports that she spoke at the rally (43, read 2026-11-19). The Canary reports that a co-convener of the Renfrewshire and Inverclyde Greens said in a Green Party press release that complaints about her appearance had been sent to the Labour Party, the Co-operative Party and the Labour group leader on Renfrewshire Council, and that the party had not replied when the article was written; the same article quotes the Green press release describing the group as "widely described as an anti-trans group". The article carries no statement from her.
  • Ash Regan, panellist at "In Conversation with For Women Scotland", Edinburgh, 11 April 2026: the group's "Previous Events" page lists the panel on "women's rights and how Parliament can better support and represent women", chaired by Susan Dalgety, with panellists Ash Regan (Ind), Marie Claire Munro (Scottish Conservatives), Carol Mochan (Scottish Labour) and Susan Smith (For Women Scotland) (44, read 2026-11-19). She was Member of the Scottish Parliament for Edinburgh Eastern from 2016 (at the time of the events cited). She resigned as Minister for Community Safety on 27 October 2022; her letter to the First Minister said her "conscience will not allow me to vote with the government at the stage one of the bill" on gender recognition reform (Holyrood, 27 October 2022, 45, read 2026-11-19). On 23 April 2024, as an Alba Party MSP, she lodged a motion of no confidence in the Scottish Greens co-leader over his response to the Cass Review, saying: "The Scottish Greens wish to side with ideology over clinical evidence" (Holyrood, 46, read 2026-11-19). Using the Cass Review this way is part of the anti-trans framing this page documents; it is not an evidence-based critique. The Parliament's motion page for 6 January 2026 lists her as "Ash Regan, Edinburgh Eastern, Independent" (47, read 2026-11-19). The Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee (9th Report, 2025, published 18 December 2025) found she breached section 9.1 of the Code of Conduct by posting on X about a letter reporting another MSP to the Presiding Officer; the letter followed that MSP's comments on the Supreme Court's 16 April 2025 judgment in For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers, and her post called the comments a "dangerous dismissal of the Supreme Court's ruling" (48, read 2026-11-19). On 6 January 2026 the Parliament agreed the recommended exclusion from the Parliament and its committees for two sitting days, 84 for, 18 against, 8 abstentions (motion page above).
  • Bec Wonders, guest speaker, "Lessons from Canada", University of Strathclyde, 24 May 2019: the "Events in 2019" page lists the meeting and names her in a photograph caption, "Trina Budge, Susan Smith, Bec Wonders, Meghan Murphy and Marion Calder" (49, read 2026-11-19). The group's compilation of its live posts from the evening quotes her on feminist publishing and on the protest at the opening of the Vancouver Women's Library, which she and a friend opened in February 2017 (50, read 2026-11-19; the group's own summary). VICE (Dene Moore, 13 March 2017) names her as one of the founders of the Vancouver Women's Library, opened 3 February 2017, and quotes her, as the library's side, calling the protest against it "very aggressive and hostile" and saying the library has a trans literature section; the same article carries an open letter from 101 groups and individuals calling the library "opened by individuals with a history of transphobic and anti-sex worker practices" (51, read 2026-11-19). UnHerd (Julie Bindel, 11 April 2022) describes her as "a feminist researcher at the Glasgow School of Art" and co-founder of the library (52, read 2026-11-19; an opinion piece).
  • Caroline McAllister, speaker at the Women's Rights Demonstration, Scottish Parliament, 2 September 2021 (36, read 2026-11-19) and at the rally of 6 October 2022, where the group's "Women's Rally, October 2022" page calls her "former deputy leader, West Dunbartonshire Council" (41, read 2026-11-19). She was elected to West Dunbartonshire Council for Leven as a Scottish National Party candidate in 2017 and was an Alba Party candidate on the West Scotland regional list in 2021, not elected (Who Can I Vote For?, 53, read 2026-11-19). The Democrat (31 March 2021) reports that she left the SNP for Alba, gave up her post as deputy leader of the SNP administration on the council and her seat on the SNP national executive, and quotes her describing herself as "the former SNP National Women's Convener" (54, read 2026-11-19). PinkNews (19 October 2020), an LGBT outlet, reports that she was co-convener of the SNP Women's Pledge, launched in 2019 with a petition about "single-sex spaces", that The Times reported she had failed the SNP's vetting as an MSP candidate, and that she had posted photographs of herself in a "Woman = adult human female" T-shirt sold by a campaigner whom PinkNews describes as having appeared alongside white nationalist YouTubers (55, read 2026-11-19). PinkNews (30 January 2022) reports that on 27 January 2022 she submitted a motion to West Dunbartonshire Council against the Scottish Government's non-statutory guidance on supporting trans pupils, saying staff "may not have the skill set or expertise" and that trans pupils using toilets and changing rooms matching their gender removes "girls the right to privacy and dignity", and, in PinkNews's words, advising the Education Department to consider guidance from "anti-trans groups such as Transgender Trend" (her motion text says "other LGBT School Guidance"); PinkNews quotes Stonewall Scotland's director calling it "grim" and the Equality Network calling it "appallingly transphobic" (56, read 2026-11-19).
  • Charlie Evans is listed under "Other speeches: Charlie Evans, Boudicca Rises, Louise Moody" on the group's post "Lesbian Strength March" (dated 8 September 2019, a guest post on the march of 7 September); the post does not say what she said (33, read 2026-11-19). The post says one of the group's members spoke on the stage.
  • Claire Heuchan is listed among the speakers at "Women's Sex-Based Rights: What does (and should) the future hold", University of Edinburgh, Moray House School of Education, 5 June 2019, with Julie Bindel, Rosa Freedman, Lucy Hunter Blackburn, Louise Moody and Sarah Pedersen (49, read 2026-11-19). Her own blog, Sister Outrider, describes her as "a Black radical feminist from Scotland", a contributor to AfterEllen, and an author of essays in the anthology Nasty Women (57, read 2026-11-19). In "Keeping Faith: Towards a More Compassionate Gender Discourse" (14 June 2021) she writes that she disputes that everyone has an innate gender identity, likening the concept to a faith (she also writes that people who identify as transgender exist), and that "No radical feminist would ever advocate violence against transgender people" (58, read 2026-11-19). Her dispute that gender identity is innate is part of the gender-critical framing this page documents; it is not a neutral position. Hachette Schools lists her as a contributor to a children's book, "What is Race? Who are Racists? Why Does Skin Colour Matter? And Other Big Questions" (59, read 2026-11-19).
  • Eva Comrie is listed as a speaker, "Eva Comrie (Alba)", at the event of 6 December 2021 in Alloa (see Maren Smith above), and on the 2022 events page in the listing of the Women's Festival in Alloa on 5 March 2022 (36 and 38, read 2026-11-19). Reporting says she left the Alba Party after calling its women's convener a "fraud" over a remark that trans women had been "assigned male at birth", and announced she would stand as an independent in Alloa and Grangemouth in 2024 (60, read 2026-11-19). A candidate register lists her as an independent in the 2024 UK general election (881 votes, not elected) and as a candidate for the Alliance to Liberate Scotland in the 2026 Scottish Parliament elections (Clackmannanshire and Dunblane constituency and Mid Scotland and Fife region, not elected) (61, read 2026-11-19).
  • Gillian Philip is listed among the guest speakers at the group's Speakers' Corner event on The Mound, Edinburgh, on 2 August 2020 (62, read 2026-11-19). In her own article of 22 April 2024 she says she was a children's author employed by the book packager Working Partners, that she tweeted "#ISTANDWITHROWLING" in June 2020, and that she was then dropped by that company and by a publisher (63, read 2026-11-19; her own account). Her Substack describes its subject as "Women's sex-based rights, creative freedom, fighting back" (64, read 2026-11-19).
  • Isabelle Kerr is listed as a signatory, "Isabelle Kerr OBE, former manager, Glasgow and Clyde Rape Crisis Centre", of the joint letter to the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women that For Women Scotland published on 5 December 2022 (65, read 2026-11-19). The group's 2022 events page lists "Isolbelle Kerr" among the speakers at the Scottish Women's Rally on 6 October 2022 (38, read 2026-11-19); no page opened links that listing, under a different spelling of the first name, to the signatory of the letter. Her honour is given as OBE on the letter and as MBE on Beira's Place's own page, which describes her as its first chief executive (39, read 2026-11-19).
  • Evie Hill is listed on the group's guest-posts page as the member who contributed the post "The Taboo of Sexual Fetishism" (66, read 2026-11-19).
  • Johann Lamont, whom the group's About page describes as "former MSP & leader of Scottish Labour", is quoted there as saying "While Scotland suffers this madness, we are also blessed with heroically brave women who are fighting and winning." The same page says the group's #SixWords campaign to amend the Forensic Medical Services Bill was "spearheaded by Johann Lamont MSP" (2, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). The 2022 events page lists her among the speakers at the Scottish Women's Rally on 6 October 2022 and gives no text of her remarks (38, read 2026-11-19).
  • Julie Bindel is listed as one of six panellists at "Women's Sex-Based Rights: What does (and should) the future hold", University of Edinburgh, Moray House School of Education, 5 June 2019, with Rosa Freedman, Claire Heuchan, Lucy Hunter Blackburn, Louise Moody and Sarah Pedersen; the group says the panel addressed "a packed meeting" and publishes some of the speakers' texts, none of them hers (49, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). The page shows an appearance at one event only.
  • Dr Kate Coleman is listed among the speakers (with Marion Calder, Rhona Hotchkiss, Lisa Mackenzie, Caroline McAllister, Shereen Benjamin, Susan Dalgety and Lisa Keogh) at the group's Women's Rights Demonstration at the Scottish Parliament on 2 September 2021 (36 and 67, read 2026-11-19; the group's own pages). The group's rally page for 6 October 2022 lists "Kate Coleman - director, Keep Prisons Single Sex" among its speakers and links to the text of her speech (41, read 2026-11-20); its events-2022 listing instead says Rhona Hotchkiss was standing in for her, so the group's two pages disagree on whether she spoke that day. The Battle of Ideas festival's speaker page calls her "founder and director of Keep Prisons Single Sex", established in 2020, which campaigns on the importance of "sex registered at birth" in criminal justice (68, read 2026-11-19; the organizer's own biography of her).
  • Jackie Mearns is named on the group's page about its demonstration at the Scottish Parliament on 7 March 2020 in a list of speeches whose text the group says it will publish; she is not named in the line listing the speakers, and no text of her speech is on the page (69, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page).
  • Laura Rimmer wrote a guest post for the group, "Reply to Garavelli" (19 March 2019), answering a Scotsman column by Dani Garavelli. In it she calls self-identification "the notion that a man can say he is a woman and be treated as such in the eyes of the law", says women must make room "for people who are essentially male", calls the comparison of the campaign for access to female space with the gay marriage movement "disingenuous at best", and calls the charge of being anti-trans "particularly invidious" (70, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). Describing trans women as men is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position. The page gives no description of the author.
  • Louise Moody and the panel of 5 June 2019: the events page lists six speakers, Julie Bindel, Professor Rosa Freedman, Claire Heuchan, Lucy Hunter Blackburn, Dr Louise Moody and Professor Sarah Pedersen. The group hosts the text of Moody's speech, in which she calls the concept of gender identity "presently an ill-defined and confused one with no legal force" and ends by calling for clarification of how organisations use the notion of gender identity "if women as a sex-class are not to disappear" (49 and 71, read; the group's own site). Her institution is not given on the group's page or in the speech text.
  • Maureen O'Hara, Nicola Williams and Rhona Hotchkiss are listed on the 2020 events page for a For Women Scotland meeting on 16 January 2020 at the Radisson Blu Hotel, Royal Mile, Edinburgh, O'Hara for the Women's Human Rights Campaign and Williams for Fair Play for Women (62, read). Women's Declaration International (the campaign's later name) names O'Hara among the authors of its Declaration on Women's Sex-Based Rights and describes her as "a feminist activist, lawyer, and legal academic" (72, read); Wikipedia (as of 2026-10-01, secondary) says the declaration was launched in March 2019 and co-authored by her, Sheila Jeffreys and Heather Brunskell-Evans, and describes the group as an anti-transgender advocacy group (73). FiLiA's page of 20 October 2020 calls Dr Nicola Williams "campaign director and public spokeswoman" of Fair Play for Women (74, read). The Law Society of Ireland Gazette of 18 March 2021 calls her director of Fair Play for Women, the group that brought a judicial review against the Office for National Statistics over the 2021 census guidance on the sex question; it reports that the court gave permission for a full review, that the Office agreed to change the guidance, and that the court ordered it to pay the group's legal costs (75, read).
  • Speakers' Corner, The Mound, Edinburgh, 2 August 2020: the 2020 events page lists guest speakers Susan Smith, Venice Allan, Magi Gibson, Shereen Benjamin, Gillian Philip, Lucy Hunter Blackburn and Victoria Whitworth (62, read). Magi Gibson is a Scottish poet and was Makar of Stirling from 2009 to 2012 (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary: 76). Susan Dalgety wrote on 22 September 2023 that Gibson edited the anthology "Unbridled: Women's poetry for our times" and that she and Gibson had connected online during the campaign against the Gender Recognition Reform Act (77, read; Dalgety's own account). The group's page gives no text of Venice Allan's remarks.
  • Victoria Whitworth is listed on the same 2020 events page among the speakers at the group's demonstration at the Scottish Parliament on 7 March 2020 (speakers listed: Lucy Hunter Blackburn, Fatina Liza, Susan Smith, Nicole Jones, Victoria Whitworth, Shereen Benjamin, Malcolm Clark, Marion Calder) and among the guest speakers of 2 August 2020. The group published her speech as a PDF (78, read 2026-11-20). In the text, written after a 4 March 2020 exchange in the Scottish Parliament, she rejects the word "cis" as "a slur", says "We are not ciswomen. We are women", and tells a named member of the Scottish Parliament that women "won't shut up and we won't lie down". No page opened ties the speaker to a writer of the same name, so the following is not attributed to her: Wikipedia describes a Victoria Whitworth as a British writer, archaeologist and art historian who was from 2012 to 2016 a lecturer at the Centre for Nordic Studies, University of the Highlands and Islands, Orkney (79, as of 2026-10-01, secondary), and the Transgender Map, an advocacy site, lists "Victoria Whitworth, writer" among the 58 signatories of the letter of 27 September 2020 in the Sunday Times supporting J. K. Rowling (80, read, attributed); Wikipedia states the same (secondary). The 58 signatories and the date are confirmed by STV News, 28 September 2020 (81, read), which does not list her name.
  • Lisa Keogh is listed among the speakers at the demonstration of 2 September 2021 (the list above; the page gives no text of her speech). STV News reported on 9 June 2021 that she was a mature law student at Abertay University, Dundee, aged 29, and that the university's Student Disciplinary Board cleared her of misconduct, finding no evidence that she discriminated against another member of the university (82, read). PinkNews (an LGBT outlet, attributed) reported on 21 December 2022 that Dundee Sheriff Court dismissed her Equality Act action against the university; the sheriff said the university was "entitled to take steps to investigate complaints"; the complaint against her had alleged transphobic remarks, which she denied (83, read). The Democracy Club candidate database lists her as the Alba Party candidate for Arbroath West, Letham and Friockheim in the Angus council election of 5 May 2022; the entry shows "not elected" (84, read).
  • Pam Gosal, Scottish Conservative MSP for West Scotland (2021 to 2026; Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary). The 2023 events page says the group had a stand at the Scottish Conservatives Conference, Glasgow, on 28 and 29 April 2023 with Keep Prisons Single Sex and "spoke at a panel discussion hosted by Pam Gosal MSP and Russell Findlay MSP"; it lists Gosal as host of the panel, not as a speaker (85, read). On 22 December 2022 she voted against the motion that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed (S6M-07312; agreed 86 to 39: 86, read). In a column for the Dumbarton and Vale of Leven Reporter (undated) she wrote that she voted against the Bill at Stage 1, was "not convinced" it balanced trans people's rights with the safety of women and girls, and cited women's spaces being put at risk by "bad-faith actors" (87, read). The Clydebank Post (undated) reports that she said the government must rule out "transgender sex offenders accessing women-only spaces" and called for a permanent ban on convicted sex offenders who change gender accessing women-only spaces, and that her amendments to the Bill were rejected (88, read).
  • Rachael Hamilton, Member of the Scottish Parliament for Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire and deputy leader of the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party. The group's "South Scotland" election-guide page lists her as the Conservative candidate for Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire and first on the party's South Scotland regional list, and says "Rachael's been a great ally in the last session - we need her back!" (89, read; the page carries no date). She was appointed Scottish Conservative deputy leader by the party leader on 28 September 2024 (90, read). The Scottish Parliament's own division page for Stage 3 Amendment 93 of the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill lists her among the Scottish Conservative members voting against that amendment ("Result 9 for, 115 against, 0 abstained, 5 did not vote. Disagreed"; the page does not say what the amendment would change or give a date) (91, read). Border Telegraph reported her reaction to a court ruling on the UK Government's block of the Bill, undated on the page: "The SNP's dangerous gender self-ID bill, which would have put women's safety at risk, has been stopped" (92, read). Calling a law that lets trans people change their legal sex a danger to women's safety is rhetoric made in bad faith. The page shows an ally of the group, not a speaker at its events.
  • Professor Rosa Freedman: the 2019 events page lists a For Women Scotland meeting on 31 January 2019 at the Apex Hotel, Edinburgh, with speakers Rosa Freedman, Maggie Mellon and Susan Smith, chaired by Marion Calder, and Freedman among the six speakers of the panel of 5 June 2019 (49, read). She is described in 2018 as professor of law, conflict and global development at the University of Reading (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary; no primary page of the university was opened). With a co-author she wrote on the Oxford Human Rights Hub on 17 August 2018 that "Self-identification will allow anyone to access women's spaces at any time" and that "Being a woman is about sex and biology" (93, read; her own article). Those claims frame trans women as a danger to women's spaces, a framing made in bad faith.
  • Roz Adams: For Women Scotland's About page says "The Freedom of Information requests we submitted were key items in evidence for Roz Adams' successful employment tribunal" (2, read). The Employment Tribunal (Scotland) judgment in case 4102236/2023, entered 14 May 2024, held that Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre unlawfully discriminated against the claimant on the grounds of religion or belief, the belief relied on being "gender critical beliefs", and unfairly constructively dismissed her; she had started as a Counselling Support Worker in about February 2021; remedy was left to a later hearing (94, read; the tribunal's own text). STV reported on 6 November 2024 that the remedy ruling awarded her £68,989 and ordered an apology (95, read). The judgment does not mention For Women Scotland or Freedom of Information requests, so the group's statement stands on its own page only.
  • Professor Sarah Pedersen is one of the six listed speakers of the panel of 5 June 2019 (49, read). The events page gives no institution. Wikipedia (as of 2026-10-01, secondary) describes a Professor of Communication and Media at Robert Gordon University, Scotland, who has written on Mumsnet and on protests against the Gender Recognition Act reform; no primary page ties the speaker to that person.
  • Sinead Watson is listed with Lucy Hunter Blackburn and Malcolm Clark (LGB Alliance) on a panel at the Scottish Conservatives Conference, Aberdeen, on 18 and 19 March 2022, hosted by Murdo Fraser MSP (38, read). She is a detransitioner who has spoken publicly. The Edinburgh Conservatives site carries a column by Sue Webber MSP dated 30 May 2022 citing "the harrowing experiences of" two detransitioners, one of them Sinead Watson (the other is not named here) (96, read). An UnHerd opinion column of 24 November 2022 says she told MSPs at the Scottish Parliament that "the voices of detransitioners have not been heard" by the Scottish Government (97, read). Her own regret is her own account and is not presented here as evidence about trans people.
  • Susan Dalgety, a columnist and writer, former deputy leader of City of Edinburgh Council (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary). The About page carries her endorsement: "For Women Scotland, three women who sacrificed much to fight for women's rights all the way to the Supreme Court, and won. Damn right they are feminist heroes." (2, read). She spoke at the group's Women's Rights Demonstration at the Scottish Parliament on 2 September 2021 (36, read). She co-edited, with Lucy Hunter Blackburn, the 2024 essay collection "The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht", described in her own newsletter post of 16 May 2024 as "a collection of over thirty essays and photographs" (98, read).
  • Liz Truss, then Minister for Women and Equalities: the group's site republishes a Women Uniting press release of 21 June 2020 (99, read 2026-11-19). It says Women Uniting UK was "inspired by For Women Scotland", that an open letter of 23 April 2020 was sent to the Minister for Women and Equalities, "the Rt.Hon Elizabeth Truss", and that For Women Scotland was among the "new signatories to this letter"; it states "We support Liz Truss in saying NO to Self ID". The Government's written statement of 22 September 2020, made by the Minister for Women and Equalities, says the Equality Act 2010 "allows service providers to restrict access to single sex spaces on the basis of biological sex if there is a clear justification" and that the balance struck in the Gender Recognition Act "is correct", and proposes moving the certificate process online and cutting its fee (100, read 2026-11-19). The group's page shows a signature on a letter to her and support from an allied coalition; it does not show a meeting or other contact between her and the group.
  • Alex Massie, journalist: the About page prints, under his name, "An era of magical thinking comes to an end and vindication is a dish to be enjoyed at any temperature. Three cheers for the ladies of For Women Scotland." (2, read 2026-11-19; the page gives no date or outlet for the quotation). His own newsletter post of 22 April 2025, "The Vindication of Women", names "the women of For Women Scotland" among those who "spent years deploring" a political consensus on "gender identity" (101, read). Wikipedia (as of 2026-10-01, secondary) describes him as Scotland editor of The Spectator and a columnist for The Times (102).
  • Carla Lockhart, Member of Parliament for Upper Bann: the group's account of its London visit of April 2026 carries a photograph captioned "FWS with Carla Lockhart MP" (the caption also names others), at the first anniversary of the Supreme Court judgment (103, read 2026-11-19).
  • Cathy Larkman, retired police Superintendent: the group's article of 14 October 2024 quotes her as "a retired Superintendent in the South Wales Police" on the College of Policing's use of a domestic-abuse guide (104, read 2026-11-19). The Women's Rights Network's own directors page describes her as a "retired police Superintendent", "Wales WRN coordinator and national policing lead", and author of its report "State Sanctioned Sexual Assault" (105, read 2026-11-19).
  • Harriet Wistrich, solicitor: she is the last of the individual signatories, "Harriet Wistrich, Solicitor", of the joint letter of 5 December 2022 to the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women that the group published with 28 other organisations and individuals, welcoming the Rapporteur's call to pause the Gender Recognition Reform Bill (65, read 2026-11-19). Wikipedia (as of 2026-10-01, secondary) describes her as a solicitor at Birnberg Peirce and founding director of the Centre for Women's Justice (106).
  • Dr Margaret McCartney, general practitioner (Beira's Place's board page: "a GP, academic, freelance writer, and broadcaster", 39, read 2026-11-19). The group's 2023 events page lists her as a panellist, with the group's Susan Smith, on "The Importance of Listening to Evidence and Women's Voices" at FiLiA, Glasgow, 13-15 October 2023 (85, read 2026-11-19). Her own newsletter page lists her writing on gender, including a BMJ piece of December 2022 on the Scottish gender recognition reform, a Spectator piece of December 2023 on the reform bill, and a "Letter to CMO November 22" (107, read 2026-11-19, titles as she lists them).
  • Tracy Gilbert, Labour MP for Edinburgh North and Leith: the "Media impact" section of the group's About page quotes her welcoming the Minister's statement after the Supreme Court ruling and thanking the group "for its tireless work over a number of years"; the page, in its own words, attributes to her the statement that the Supreme Court "held up the rights of lesbians to be able to associate with same-sex attracted women" (2, read). The same section quotes Kemi Badenoch, Harriet Cross, Johann Lamont and Tess White. Tracy Gilbert has been MP for Edinburgh North and Leith since 2024 (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary: 108).
  • Vivienne Hayes MBE is among the individual signatories of the joint letter that the group published on 5 December 2022 to Reem Alsalem, the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women, about the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill, sent by the group, 28 other women's organisations and individuals, as "CEO, Women's Resource Centre" (65, read). The Women's Resource Centre described her as its chief executive on a page that is undated and carries a 2014 copyright line, so it does not show a current role (109, read).
  • Liam Kerr, Member of the Scottish Parliament (Scottish Conservatives, North East Scotland region; the party's justice spokesperson 2017 to 2021, Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary). On 5 March 2021 the group published "Hate Crime Bill - email MSPs", asking supporters to urge their MSPs to support "Amendments 6-10 and 13 by Liam Kerr to leave out Part 2 of the Bill" (which the group calls a free-speech matter) and to back amendments by Johann Lamont adding sex as a characteristic; the page also calls for "cross-dressers" to be removed from the Bill, in language that treats them as a fashion choice or a sexual fetish (110, read). The page asks supporters to back his amendments; it does not describe any joint work with him. The parliamentary record of the final vote on the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill on 22 December 2022 (passed 86 to 39) lists him as voting No (111, read; a republication of the parliamentary division, secondary).
  • Murdo Fraser, Member of the Scottish Parliament (Scottish Conservatives, Mid Scotland and Fife region since 2001, Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary). The group's events page for 2022 records that at the Scottish Conservatives Conference in Aberdeen on 18-19 March 2022 it "had a stand at the conference and spoke at a panel discussion hosted by Murdo Fraser MSP", alongside speakers from MurrayBlackburnMackenzie and LGB Alliance and one further named speaker (the group's own listing; 38, read). The division record of 22 December 2022 lists him as voting No on passing the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill (111, read).
  • Ian Smart: the group's post of 25 February 2022 on the Court of Session ruling quotes "Former President of Law Society of Scotland, Ian Smart", saying that if the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill redefines "a woman" it is beyond the legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament; the quote is followed on the page by the title "A Dead Duck" (112, read; the quoted words and his title are as the group gives them). The post is the group's own account of its judicial review win over the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018.
  • Rosemary Auchmuty, a signatory of a letter by "a group of senior lawyers" that the group published on 30 March 2019 as a rebuttal of the TIE (Time for Inclusive Education) open letter, stating that the Equality Act 2010 gives trans people protection from discrimination but not "a general right of access to single sex spaces and services" and that exemptions for sports and communal accommodation can be invoked "for biological women only"; she is listed there as "Professor at Reading Law School" (113, read). The University of Reading's staff page gives her as Professor of Law Emerita, professor of law at Reading from 2007 to 2024, and lists her chapter with Rosa Freedman, "Sex and Gender in Law", in Sex and Gender: A contemporary reader (Routledge, 2024) and a forthcoming "Gender critical" entry in the Elgar Concise Encyclopedia of Gender, Sexuality, and the Law (114, read).
  • Dr Claire Methven O'Brien: the group's page of 21 March 2025 on a City of Edinburgh Council meeting describes her as "human rights expert and member of the Scottish Human Rights Commission" and cites her statement that failing to provide a single-sex service for survivors of violence against women is inconsistent with the Istanbul Convention (115, read). She is a commissioner of the Scottish Human Rights Commission and writes "in a personal capacity" in Holyrood magazine, where on 20 February 2025 she wrote on the Labour Party's support for the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill in 2022 in connection with the Sandie Peggie case (116, read). Scottish Legal News of 20 July 2026 reports that she has begun an employment tribunal case against the Commission alleging she was harassed because of her views on sex and gender; it says she had objected in October 2022 to the Commission's earlier submissions to Parliament on the bill, and that the group said it had long suspected the Commission of being "a de facto wing of the Scottish government". The specifics of the case were not disclosed and no outcome is reported (117, read).
  • Susan Sinclair, "of Scottish Women": the group's page of 21 June 2019 (118, read) carries a statement by Joan McAlpine MSP on the Scottish Government's announcement on reforming the Gender Recognition Act, which says "Women and Girls Scotland, Susan Sinclair of Scottish Women and For Women Scotland should all take credit for campaigning so hard to achieve some of these concessions". The same statement appears on Woman's Place UK's site (119, read).
  • A member of the Survivors Reference Group, quoted by the group: its post of 7 December 2020 about the amendment to the Forensic Medical Services (Victims of Sexual Offences) (Scotland) Bill says "the last word comes from" a member of the Survivors Reference Group, "who were enlisted to help shape this Bill", and quotes a statement from her (120, read). The post is the group's case for substituting "sex" for "gender" in the Bill (the amendment was moved by Johann Lamont); the group added on 10 December 2020 that Parliament voted for the amendment, 113 for, 9 against, 1 abstention. Rape Crisis Scotland's own post says it "worked alongside the Survivor Reference Group in shaping this Bill" (121, read). The group presents her as quoted by it, not as a member or officer of the group.
  • Akua Reindorf KC is named, with other barristers, on the group's post of 20 April 2025 on the Supreme Court judgment, in a line listing a "9 May 2025, LSE Law School: For Women Scotland v The Scottish Ministers - panel discussion" (122, read). The panel line rests on the group's page. Her chambers page describes her as a barrister at Cloisters Chambers, called in 1999, silk 2023, and lists the University of Essex "Reindorf Report" on the no-platforming of two speakers accused of transphobia (123, read; the description is her chambers' own). Her appointment as an Equality and Human Rights Commission commissioner for a four-year term was announced on 20 December 2021 (124, read); LSE Law School lists her as Visiting Senior Fellow in Practice (125, read). A speaker listing on the group's page shows an appearance at one event; it gives no formal relationship with the group.
  • A barrister of Great James Street Chambers is one of five signatories named on the open letter from "a group of senior lawyers" that the group published on 30 March 2019 rebutting the TIE open letter; the letter says the claim that trans women already have a right in law to access women's spaces and services is "incorrect" (113, read). The barrister is given here by chambers only, as a lawyer on the letter. One signed letter; no continuing relationship shown.
  • Anas Sarwar, then Scottish Labour leader and a Glasgow regional MSP, is one of four MSPs the group thanks on 17 June 2022 "who made the time to speak with us" after its press conference with two Olympic athletes against the Gender Recognition Reform Bill (126, read). On 22 December 2022 he voted for the Bill's passage (Scottish Parliament division on motion S6M-07312: 86 for, 39 against; 86, read). On 17 August 2023 he said "everybody has lost" since it passed, that he continued to support the Bill "in principle" and declined, asked three times, to say whether he would vote for it again, and that work remained "to make sure we are protecting single-sex spaces based on biological sex" (STV News, 127, read). The group records a conversation only; no joint work.
  • "Andrea Williams" is named, with other people, in the group's photo caption of 22 April 2026 ("FWS with Carla Lockhart MP ... and Andrea Williams ...") from its London visit for the first anniversary of the Supreme Court judgment (103, read). The caption gives no role and no organization, so it does not say which Andrea Williams this is. A person of the same name is Founder and Chief Executive of Christian Concern: its own page lists "Andrea Minichiello Williams, Founder & Chief Executive, Christian Concern & Christian Legal Centre" (128, read). Companies House lists Andrea Rose Minichiello Williams as a director of Christian Legal Centre Limited (company 06387800), appointed 2 October 2007 and active (129, read, 2026-11-20). In Christian Today on 18 April 2025 she wrote of the group's judgment that "trans women are not women, and trans men are not men", that no one can change their sex "only their appearance", and that "this judgment is not enough" (130, read). These statements are made in bad faith: they deny trans people's identities. Whether the caption's Andrea Williams is her is not shown; a caption would in any case show presence at one event.
  • Annabelle Ewing, SNP MSP for Cowdenbeath (2016 to 2026, Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary), is named in the group's update of 16 August 2025 on its legal action over the Scottish Government's prison and schools guidance: the group says "numerous questions have been raised in Parliament, most recently by Annabelle Ewing and Pam Gosal" (131, read). The Parliament's question list shows her written question S6W-36271, lodged 2 April 2025 and answered 24 April 2025, asking "what up-to-date assessment it has made of the safety of biological women, on the basis of the protected characteristic of sex, in the prison estate" (132, read). The Scottish Parliament's division record shows her among the nine SNP MSPs voting against the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill on 22 December 2022 (86, read). The group names her as a questioner, not as a partner.
  • Brian Whittle, Conservative MSP for South Scotland (2016 to 2026, Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary, 133), is named on the group's page for its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 among "MSPs who came out to support us" (41, read). On 22 December 2022 he voted against the motion "That the Parliament agrees that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed", which was agreed 86 to 39 (Scottish Parliament vote record S6M-07312, 86, read).
  • Carol Mochan, Scottish Labour MSP for South Scotland (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary, 134), is listed as a panellist at "In Conversation with For Women Scotland", Edinburgh, 11 April 2026 (see Ash Regan above). On 22 December 2022 she voted against the motion that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed (86, read).
  • Dr Caroline Johnson, Conservative MP (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary, 135), is named among those pictured with the group in Westminster on the first anniversary of the Supreme Court judgment (post of 22 April 2026, 103, read). As Shadow Minister (Health and Social Care) she moved the Opposition motion in the House of Commons on 23 June 2026 that the House "calls on the Government to take steps to prevent the PATHWAYS clinical trial into the effect of puberty suppressing hormones on children with gender incongruence" (Hansard via TheyWorkForYou, 136, read). A motion to stop a clinical trial of puberty suppressing hormones is part of the anti-trans campaigning this page documents; it is not an evidence-based position.
  • Claire Baker, Scottish Labour and Co-operative MSP for Mid Scotland and Fife (since 2007, Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary, 137), is the Labour candidate for Kirkcaldy in the group's Scottish Election 2026 guide, which calls her "one of the Labour MSPs who voted against Gender Recognition Reform" (138, read). The Scottish Parliament's record shows her voting against the passing motion on 22 December 2022 (86, read).
  • Clarrie O'Callaghan, listed as "Director, Femicide Census", is one of the signatories of the joint letter that the group and 28 other women's organisations and individuals sent on 5 December 2022 to the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women welcoming her intervention on the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill (65, read). The Femicide Census's 10-year report (UK Femicides 2009-2018) credits Karen Ingala Smith and "Clarissa O'Callaghan" as the people it was written "with", and its foreword is signed Karen Ingala Smith and Clarrie O'Callaghan (139, read, pages 2 and 3). The report says the Counting Dead Women project started a process which, through the intervention of O'Callaghan, then of Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP, led to the development of the Femicide Census (page 4).
  • Bethany Hutchison is named in the caption of the group's post of 22 April 2026 about the Supreme Court judgment's first anniversary ("FWS with ... Andrea Williams, Jo Marshall, Maria Kelly Bethany Hutchison and Jennifer Melle"); the post gives no role for her (103, read). Christian Concern describes a Bethany Hutchison as a Darlington nurse backed by the Christian Legal Centre in a tribunal claim over a hospital changing room, who spoke with Andrea Williams, chief executive of Christian Concern and the Christian Legal Centre (also named in the caption), at the She Leads the Nations summit in Washington DC on 4 February 2026 (140, read; the organisation's own account; the same-name match rests on Williams appearing in both).
  • Colin Smyth, Scottish Labour MSP for South Scotland (regional member) from 5 May 2016 to 20 August 2025, then an independent MSP for the same region until 8 April 2026 (Scottish Parliament member page 141, read). The group's page on its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 lists him among Labour MSPs "who came out to support us" (41, read). The page shows an appearance only. He voted for the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill on 22 December 2022, when Parliament passed it by 86 votes to 39. Final division86
  • Craig Hoy, Scottish Conservative MSP for South Scotland (regional member) from 6 May 2021 to 8 April 2026 and MSP for Dumfriesshire from 7 May 2026 (Scottish Parliament member page 142, read). The group's page on its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 lists him among Conservative MSPs who "came out to support us" (41, read). The page shows an appearance only. He voted against the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill on 22 December 2022, when Parliament passed it by 86 votes to 39. Final division86
  • Daniel Johnson, Scottish Labour and Co-operative MSP for Edinburgh Southern since 5 May 2016; his member page says "I am a member of the Cooperative Party" (Scottish Parliament member page 143, read). The group's page on its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 lists him among Labour MSPs who "came out to support us" (41, read). The page shows an appearance only. He voted for the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill on 22 December 2022, when Parliament passed it by 86 votes to 39. Final division86
  • David Henry, independent candidate in Edinburgh West at the UK general election of 4 July 2024. The group's election guide of 27 June 2024 lists him with other independent candidates "who support women's rights" (144, read). The page shows a listing by the group only. In June 2024, the Scottish Daily Express reported that Henry wanted the Equality Act to define sex in biological terms and that he opposed the drafting of the gender recognition bill. Scottish Daily Express145
  • Dianne Whitfield, listed as "former CEO, Coventry Rape and Sexual Abuse Centre", is one of the signatories of the joint letter of 5 December 2022 that the group and 28 other women's organisations and individuals sent to the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women about the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill (65, read). The letter's own text says it was assembled with limited time and that others might add their support; no other role with the group is shown. An undated Centre of expertise on child sexual abuse biography lists her as an advisory board member and as chief officer of the Coventry centre. The two sources give different titles and do not date her tenure. Centre biography146
  • Dickie James, listed as "MBE, CEO, Staffordshire Women's Aid", is one of 15 individuals who signed the joint letter of 5 December 2022 that the group published, sent to Reem Alsalem, the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women, in response to her letter to the UK Government about the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill (65, read). The letter says policies of this kind "can amount to a form of coercive control". The role is given only on the group's page.
  • Douglas Lumsden, Scottish Conservative MSP for North East Scotland from 6 May 2021 to 23 June 2026 (Scottish Parliament member page, 147, read), is named in the group's post of 17 June 2022 among "the MSPs who made the time to speak with us" after its press conference on women's sport: "Brian Whittle, Douglas Lumsden, Sue Webber and Anas Sarwar" (126, read). The post does not say what he said. The parliamentary record lists a vote against the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill at both stage 1 on 27 October 2022 and stage 3 on 22 December 2022. Stage 1148 · Stage 386
  • Edward Mountain, Scottish Conservative MSP for Highlands and Islands from 5 May 2016 to 8 April 2026 (149, read), is named in the group's post of 8 October 2022 among Conservative MSPs "who came out to support us" at its Women's Rally (41, read; the post is dated 8 October 2022, and an embedded tweet in it is dated 6 October 2022). The parliamentary record lists a vote against the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill at both stage 1 on 27 October 2022 and stage 3 on 22 December 2022. Stage 1148 · Stage 386
  • Elaine Smith, Scottish Labour MSP for Coatbridge and Chryston (6 May 1999 to 23 March 2016) and for Central Scotland (5 May 2016 to 4 May 2021) (150, read), is cited in the group's briefing of 7 March 2021 on the Hate Crime Bill: the group refers to "Parliamentary Questions lodged by Elaine Smith MSP on 5th February" (S5W-35023 and S5W-35024) on the Scottish Government's consultation with women, when it wrote to the Permanent Secretary (151, read). In February 2021, Smith asked which organisations the Scottish Government consulted for women’s views and which advisory groups included Engender. Christina McKelvie replied that consultation depended on the policy area. In the separate answer, she said Engender was represented on several groups, including the Trans Inclusion and Women’s Rights Guidance Advisory Group. Consultation question152 · Advisory groups question153
  • Elena Whitham, Scottish National Party MSP for Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley from 6 May 2021 to 8 April 2026 (154, read), is named in a note added on 7 February 2026 to the group's post of 26 January 2026 as one of the SNP MSPs who "opposed the party whip to vote in support of" Ash Regan's Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill at Stage 1 on 3 February 2026 (155, read). The vote concerned prostitution law, not trans people. The parliamentary record lists a vote for the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill at both stage 1 on 27 October 2022 and stage 3 on 22 December 2022. Stage 1148 · Stage 386
  • Euan McColm is quoted on the group's About page, in its Background section: "We are, I believe, witnessing the birth of the biggest, most powerful feminist movement in British history." The page prints no publication or date for the quote (2, read). In a July 2023 Spectator column, McColm wrote about the position of Scottish Labour MSPs who had backed gender recognition reform after the UK party leadership reversed its position on self-identification. The Spectator156
  • Harriet Cross, Conservative MP for Gordon and Buchan (elected at the 2024 UK general election; Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary: 157), is quoted on the group's About page: "I welcome the Supreme Court's ruling and congratulate For Women Scotland and others who have campaigned tirelessly on this issue despite the abuse, threats and attempts to silence them." The page gives her title as "Conservative MP, Gordon and Buchan" and no date for the quote (2, read 2026-11-20).
  • Iain Macwhirter, a Scottish political journalist (spelled "Iain McWhirter" on the group's page), is quoted on the About page: the three directors "took on the media, the medical profession, and the political establishment and helped to spark a debate about women's sex-based rights that has gone global." The page gives no date or outlet for the quote (2, read 2026-11-20).
  • Iqbal Mohamed, independent MP for Dewsbury and Batley, is named on the group's page of 22 April 2026 in a photo caption listing those pictured with the group in London, among other MPs (103, read 2026-11-20). The caption states only that he was pictured with the group.
  • Foysol Choudhury, MSP for Lothian (Scottish Labour from 6 May 2021 to 26 September 2025; independent from 26 September 2025; term ended 8 April 2026, per 158, read 2026-11-20), is named in the group's account of its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 among the Labour MSPs "who came out to support us" (41, read 2026-11-20).
  • Fergus Ewing, former MSP for Inverness and Nairn (Scottish National Party until 20 June 2025, then independent; term ended 8 April 2026, per 159, read 2026-11-20), is given "special mention" in the group's Scottish election guide of 24 April 2026 as one of "three former MSPs who are now standing as strong independent candidates", with Ash Regan and Jeremy Balfour (160, read 2026-11-20). The Herald reported that he was one of nine SNP MSPs who voted against the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill, which passed 86-39 (161, read 2026-11-20; syndicated piece, no date in the text).
  • A Scottish Solicitor Advocate (a lawyer, so not named here), described so on the group's page of 25 February 2022, is quoted from a blog saying the Court of Session decision in the group's case was "a defeat of catastrophic proportions for the Scottish Government" and that the Government's "trans inclusive" funding policies were unlawful in his opinion (112, read 2026-11-20). He is quoted as a commentator, not named in a filing.
  • Jackie Baillie, Scottish Labour deputy leader since 2020 and MSP for Dumbarton since 1999 (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary, 162). The group's page on its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 at the Scottish Parliament says "MSPs who came out to support us included" a list of Conservative, SNP and Labour MSPs, which names her (41, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). The page gives no more than the listing. On the Scottish Parliament's division of 22 December 2022 on motion S6M-07312 ("That the Parliament agrees that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed"; 86 for, 39 against), the TheyWorkForYou copy of the division records her as Aye (111, read 2026-11-19; a copy of the parliament's division, not the parliament's own page). Attending one rally is an appearance, not a continuing relationship.
  • Jeremy Balfour, Lothian regional MSP from 2016 to 2026. The group's page on its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 names him among the Conservatives who "came out to support us" (41, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). The TheyWorkForYou copy of the division of 22 December 2022 on motion S6M-07312 (86 for, 39 against) records him as No (111, read 2026-11-19). Attending one rally is an appearance, not a continuing relationship.
  • James Cleverly, Conservative MP for Braintree since 2015, Home Secretary from November 2023 to July 2024 (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary, 163). The group's "Events in 2025" page says that at the Scottish Conservatives Conference in Edinburgh on 13-14 June 2025 it had a stand and a fringe event on the Supreme Court ruling, "chaired by Pam Gosal MSP with speakers Susan Smith (FWS), Jenny Willmott (Scottish Lesbians) and James Cleverly MP" (164, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). One shared fringe event; no continuing relationship is shown.
  • Jane Meagher, Leader of the City of Edinburgh Council (announced 19 December 2024, 165, read 2026-11-19). The group's account of the council meeting of 20 March 2025 (page dated 21 March 2025) says that at its protest on the morning of the meeting several councillors "came out to speak to women, including ... Council Leader Jane Meagher" (115, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). The page carries a transcript of the debate on a Scottish Green motion about Edinburgh Women's Aid, in which Meagher (Scottish Labour) is recorded as saying that under the Equality Act 2010 it is lawful for a service provider such as Edinburgh Women's Aid to provide single-sex facilities, and that she was content with the deputation's account that it also offers support to trans women; the transcript is the group's own, not the council's. One protest; no continuing relationship is shown.
  • Jeane Freeman, Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport from 2018 to 2021 (Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary, 166). The group's statement of 10 December 2020 says it was "delighted by Jeane Freeman's decision to back Johann Lamont's amendment to the Forensic Medical Services Bill", which substituted "sex" for "gender" in the wording on who may examine a victim (167, read 2026-11-19; the group's own page). Holyrood magazine reported on 11 December 2020 that "ministers backed the amendment" after the government "initially rejected this argument", and that the change "was backed by 113 MSPs" (168, read 2026-11-19; the article does not state the vote date or quote Freeman on the amendment).
  • Jennifer Melle is named on the group's page of 22 April 2026, on the first anniversary of the Supreme Court judgment, in a list of people pictured with the group at Westminster beside seven MPs and others, without a role (103, read 2026-11-19). Premier Christianity's author page describes her as a Christian NHS nurse from south London "at the centre of a high-profile legal case with the NHS", supported by the Christian Legal Centre (169, read 2026-11-19). Christian Today reported on 12 February 2026 that St Helier and Epsom University Hospitals NHS Trust had reinstated her after a disciplinary hearing, following a nine-month suspension over her refusal to use a transgender patient's pronouns; that she met the Minister for Women and Equalities about single-sex spaces; that an employment tribunal was due in April; and that the Nursing and Midwifery Council was running two fitness-to-practise investigations (170, read 2026-11-19; a Christian outlet reporting the Christian Legal Centre's account). One anniversary visit; no continuing relationship with the group is shown.
  • John Mason, SNP MSP: the group's own post on its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 lists "MSPs who came out to support us" and names "John Mason from SNP" (41, read; the post gives no detail of what he said or did there). On 22 December 2022 he voted against the motion that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed (motion S6M-07312, agreed 86 for, 39 against, 4 did not vote; he is one of nine SNP members listed as voting against): 86 (read).
  • Kenneth Gibson: the group's post of 26 January 2026 names him among SNP MSPs who "opposed the party whip to vote in support of" the Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill at its stage one vote (the post dates it 3 February 2026) and among SNP MSPs who "have spoken out against their Ministers decision to defend the prison policy in court" (155, read). On 22 December 2022 he voted against the motion that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed (86, read). In a debate on transgender women in prisons he said, "If a fox identified as a chicken would you put it in a hen house? Of course not." (as reported by the Irvine Times, 171, read; the article gives no date). The remark compares trans women to a fox among hens and is anti-trans rhetoric, not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position. The Scottish Parliament's member page lists him as Presiding Officer, with no party affiliation, from 14 May 2026 and as SNP MSP for Cunninghame North from 3 May 2007 to 13 May 2026 (172, read). The group’s West Scotland election guide praised Gibson’s opposition to gender recognition reform and welcomed his return as a candidate. Parliament lists two periods as convener of the Finance and Public Administration Committee between June 2021 and April 2026. Election guide173 · Committee record172
  • Katherine Sangster: the group's Scottish Election 2026 guide entry for Edinburgh Eastern, Musselburgh and Tranent lists "Katherine Sangster - Labour Party" and says "Katherine Sangster is very clear that she supports women's rights" (174, read; that is the group's wording, not her own). The Scottish Parliament's member page lists her as a Scottish Labour member for the Edinburgh and Lothians East region, in office from 7 May 2026 (175, read).
  • Katie Cosgrove: the group's post of 4 February 2025 on the UN Special Rapporteur's report quotes "the co-chair, Katie Cosgrove" of Glasgow and Clyde Rape Crisis (the role as the group gives it) as saying "We believe very strongly in the rights of women to have single-sex services within a rape crisis setting" and that "it should be an all-female workforce" (176, read).
  • Jim Allister: the group's post of 22 April 2026 on the first anniversary of the Supreme Court judgment has a photo caption beginning "FWS with Carla Lockhart MP, Tracy Gilbert MP, Iqbal Mohamed MP, Dr Caroline Johnson MP, Rosie Duffield MP, Claire Coutinho MP, Jim Allister MP" and naming others (103, read). The Traditional Unionist Voice's own page records that its leader and North Antrim MP Jim Allister tabled a Commons motion "That this House welcomes the Supreme Court judgement of 15 April 2025 that the legal definition of a woman is based on biological sex" and calling on government departments, arms length bodies and all operating in the public sphere to make their language, definitions, guidance and approach fully accord with the ruling (177, read; the page text gives no date for the motion). A pictured appearance plus his own motion; no further tie to the group is shown.
  • Marie-Claire Munro (the Scottish Conservative Party's own page spells her first name "Marie-Clair"), Conservative councillor for Morningside on the City of Edinburgh Council, elected at the council elections of 2022 (178, read). The group's page on the council meeting of 20 March 2025 (115, read, dated 21 March 2025) says that "several councillors came out to speak to women" at its protest that morning, "including Conservative Councillor Marie-Claire Munro", a Labour councillor and the Council Leader. The same page reproduces the council debate on a Scottish Green motion about Edinburgh Women's Aid's single-sex policy; it records Cllr Munro moving a Scottish Conservative amendment, saying "we must always strive for inclusivity in the protection and the rights of all individuals, including trans individuals, but we must ensure that women's services remain intact" and that the Conservatives "will continue to protect the rights of women and girls to have single sex spaces". The page is the group's own account and transcription of the debate. It shows an appearance and a speech, not funding, a role in the group or joint work. The Scottish Conservatives listed her as their 2026 candidate for Edinburgh Southern. The group’s April 2026 event listing used the spelling “Marie Claire Munro.” Candidate list179 · Event listing44
  • Marlyn Glen, former Labour MSP for North East Scotland (1 May 2003 to 22 March 2011; Scottish Parliament member page 180, read), is one of four former MSPs listed as signatories, with the group and 13 other women's organisations named on the page, of the statement of 18 December 2022 about the Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee's emergency evidence session of 19 December 2022 on the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill. The statement calls the Committee's scrutiny of the Bill "biased" (181, read). The page names her only as "former MSP"; no other role with the group is shown.
  • Meghan Gallacher, Scottish Conservative MSP, regional member for Central Scotland from 2021, Deputy Party Leader from 8 September 2021 to 29 June 2023, and elected in 2026 for Central Scotland and Lothians West (Scottish Parliament member page 182, read). The group's Scottish Election 2026 guide for Central Scotland and Lothians West lists her as the Conservative candidate for Uddingston and Bellshill and says "Voters also have the option of Meghan Gallacher who was a great support in the last session" and, of the Conservative list, "It would be a shame if Meghan Gallacher is not returned to Holyrood" (183, read). This is the group's endorsement of a candidate; it shows no funding or joint work.
  • Michael Marra, Scottish Labour MSP for North East Scotland since 8 May 2021. The group's page on its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 lists him among Labour MSPs "who came out to support us" (41, read). The Scottish Parliament's Stage 3 marshalled list for the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill shows him as the lodger of amendments 106 (a countersignatory requirement for applicants) and 141 (184, read). The National reported that he had voted to progress the Bill at Stage 1 and then proposed the countersignatory amendment, which the co-convener of Rainbow Greens, the Scottish Greens' LGBT+ wing, quoted in the report, said "could make it actually harder for most trans people" (185, read). The rally page shows an appearance only.
  • Pauline McNeill, Scottish Labour and Co-operative MSP, member for Glasgow Kelvin 6 May 1999 to 22 March 2011 and regional member for Glasgow from 5 May 2016 (Scottish Parliament member page 186, read). The group's Scottish Election 2026 guide for Glasgow lists her as Labour and Co-operative candidate for Glasgow Baillieston and Shettleston and describes her as "one of their more high profile MSPs ... who has been a strong supporter of women's rights" (187, read); the same guide tips Labour's return of "Sarwar and McNeill" on the Glasgow list. The Stage 3 marshalled list shows her as lodger of amendments 117 (guidance on the effect of a gender recognition certificate), 128 (reporting on sex: "nothing in Act affects any requirement to collect data on sex") and 84A (184, read). Her 8 October 2022 rally attendance is also listed on the group's rally page (41, read).
  • Roz McCall, Scottish Conservative MSP for Mid Scotland and Fife, 6 September 2022 to 8 April 2026 (Scottish Parliament member page 188, read). The group's page on its Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 lists her among Conservative MSPs who "came out to support us" (41, read). The rally took place about a month after her term began. The page shows an appearance only.
  • Russell Findlay, Member of the Scottish Parliament (MSP), at the Scottish Conservatives Conference as co-host of a panel: the group's 2023 events page lists a panel discussion at the Scottish Conservatives Conference, Glasgow, 28-29 April 2023, that the group "spoke at" and that was "hosted by Pam Gosal MSP and Russell Findlay MSP" (85, read). He is among the MSPs listed as voting against the motion that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed on 22 December 2022 (motion passed, 86 to 39; 189, read; the same division is recorded at 111, aggregator, read, consistent). One event; no continuing relationship shown.
  • Ruth Maguire, Scottish National Party (SNP) MSP at the time: the group's account of the Women's Rally of 8 October 2022 quotes her message "Solidarity with you all and thank you to each and every one of you standing up for women's rights" (41, read). She is among the MSPs listed as voting against the motion that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed on 22 December 2022 (189, read; the article prints a misspelt name for one other MSP; the division is also recorded at 111, aggregator, read, consistent). One message; no continuing relationship shown.
  • Sharon Dowey, Conservative MSP at the time: the same rally page lists her among MSPs who "came out to support us" at the rally of 8 October 2022 (41, read). She is among the MSPs listed as voting against the motion that the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill be passed on 22 December 2022 (189, read; the division is also recorded at 111, aggregator, read, consistent).
  • Ruth Wilkinson, Women's Equality Party candidate on the Glasgow regional list at the Scottish Parliament election of 6 May 2021 (candidate list: 190): the group's election guide of 9 May 2021 names her in its closing note ("Ruth Wilkinson for WEP in Glasgow"); the page says nothing more about her (191, read).
  • Sally Hughes, independent candidate for Perth and Kinross-shire at the UK general election of 4 July 2024: the group's election page names her among candidates who "support women's rights" (the group's wording). She received 679 votes, 1.4 per cent, sixth place (144, read; 192, read).
  • Sophie Walker, founding leader of the Women's Equality Party (2015-19): signed, as "Founding Leader, Women's Equality Party (2015-19)", the group's open letter of December 2022 to the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women, which argues against Scotland's Gender Recognition Reform Bill; the letter lists 14 organisations and 15 individuals as signatories (65, read; leadership dates: Wikipedia, as of 2026-10-01, secondary, 193).
  • Sharron Davies, an Olympic swimmer, is listed on the group's own site as a speaker. The group's post of 17 June 2022, "Press Conference: Protecting Female Sports", says it invited Davies and the runner Mara Yamauchi, with Fiona McAnena of Fair Play for Women, to a press conference in Edinburgh while the Scottish Parliament considered gender recognition reform, and lists the media coverage it drew (126, read). The group's events page for 2025 lists "06-08 October 2025, Conservative Party Conference, Manchester": "Marion Calder and Sharron Davies interviewed by Claire Coutinho MP" (164, read). The Companies House officers page for THE WOMEN'S SPORTS UNION LIMITED (company number 16721172) lists Sharron Elizabeth Davies as director and a secretary, both appointed 16 September 2025 (194, read). This is Davies's other affiliation only; the page shows no link between the company and the group, and no payment between her and the group is shown.
  • Caroline Connelly is quoted on the group's post of 13 June 2021, "NHS Scotland Pride Badge", as having "represented patients service users carers and relatives on the Greater Glasgow Health Council for 20 years"; the group publishes her objections to the NHS Scotland Pride badge scheme (195, read). The page is a statement hosted by the group; it shows no membership or paid role.
  • Mary Gordon: the group's post of 2 March 2024, "Be More Mary", launched the #BeMoreMary campaign for International Women's Day 2024 "in honour" of Mary Gordon, whom it calls "an infamous yarn bomber/chalker/uppity woman" who "died on International Women's Day last year"; it says, in the group's account, that police came to her door after she chalked "Women's rights are not a hate crime" on a wall at St Andrew's House (196, read).
  • Scottish Family Party: the group's election guide of 27 June 2024 on the UK general election summarises the Scottish Family Party manifesto, including its call to oppose the Gender Recognition Act and to stop "transgender 'treatments' for under 16s" (summarised by the group without comment; the call to deny care to young people is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith), and then writes: "We agree with the SFP that buying sex should be criminalised and women helped out of prostitution, however we disagree that these women should be criminalised". It adds that "many of their other policies would be damaging to women's hard-won rights" and lists abortion limits and a repeal of the Equality Act's sex-specific job provisions among them. It also writes "We also agree that pornography is extremely harmful, especially to young people". The page states agreement on criminalising buying sex and on pornography being harmful, and disagreement on several other policies; no joint work is shown (144, read; the group's own page).
  • On 23 April 2025, Tess White lodged motion S6M-17241 welcoming the Supreme Court judgment of 16 April and praising For Women Scotland and Sex Matters for their part in the case. Parliament records the motion as fallen. Scottish Parliament motion197
  • For Women Scotland thanked Michelle Thomson for speaking at its 9 February 2023 demonstration. Thomson had voted against the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill at its final stage. Group’s account198 · Parliamentary division86
  • In a February 2021 article, the group quoted former Fawcett Society chief executive Sam Smethers on making misogyny a hate crime. The quotation concerns violence against women and girls. Group’s article199
  • A photograph caption in the group’s account of FiLiA 2023 identifies Annemarie Ward of FAVOR UK. TFN identified Ward as the charity’s founder and chief executive in August 2024. Event page85 · TFN200
  • In its November 2018 statement on self-identification, For Women Scotland thanked David Davies for his support without specifying an action. In 2022 PinkNews reported his earlier public remarks portraying trans rights as overriding women’s rights. Group’s statement201 · PinkNews202
  • For Women Scotland named Labour councillor Lezley Marion Cameron among the councillors who spoke to women at its protest outside the City of Edinburgh Council on 20 March 2025. Its account gives no statement by Cameron. Group’s account115
  • In January 2026 For Women Scotland recommended a column by Holyrood editor Mandy Rhodes advocating the exclusion of trans women from the women’s prison estate. Group’s recommendation155 · Holyrood column203
  • The group’s October 2023 FiLiA listing named Mariam Ahmed of Amina as a panellist. Amina Muslim Women’s Resource Centre identifies Ahmed as its chief executive. Event listing85 · Amina204

Lobbying, testimony and legal matters

Sex Matters intervened with written submissions in For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers (lodged October 2024; hearing 26-27 November 2024; judgment 16 April 2025, [2025] UKSC 16).

  • The judgment header of For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers, [2025] UKSC 16 (judgment 16 April 2025), lists For Women Scotland as appellant (counsel instructed by Balfour + Manson LLP, Edinburgh) and the Scottish Ministers as respondent (instructed by the Scottish Government Legal Directorate) (205; header; the court's own text).
  • The same header lists four interveners: Sex Matters (counsel instructed by Gilson Gray LLP, Edinburgh); "Scottish Lesbians; The Lesbian Project; LGB Alliance (written submissions only)" (counsel instructed by Doyle Clayton, London); the Equality and Human Rights Commission; and Amnesty International UK (written submissions only; instructed by Russell-Cooke LLP). The Supreme Court's case page for UKSC 2024/0042 gives the hearing as 26 and 27 November 2024 and lists no interveners. The header does not say which side each intervener supported (205; header; 206).
  • Scottish Legal News reported on 2024-10-11 that Scottish Lesbians had been "granted permission to submit a written intervention" and that The Lesbian Project and LGB Alliance joined it; it quotes the group's director Jenny Willmott: "Lesbians are exclusively same-sex attracted women." (207; trade press, dated).
  • The Scottish Union for Education's newsletter No 114 of 24 April 2025, titled "Themes: Supreme Court on the definition of woman; and judges and politicians", shows the heading "Marion Calder, Co-Director, For Women Scotland" directly under its lead image and above the opening article. The article carries no byline and is written in the newsletter's own voice (it speaks of the group's "founding conference" and ends with the newsletter editor's sign-off), so the page does not show that a For Women Scotland co-director wrote it. No contributed-article tie is recorded. What the page documents is the group's own statement "Back in November 2022 the Scottish Union for Education held its founding conference" and a mention of For Women Scotland among those involved: an appearance or listing at most. The group describes itself as a non-party "Education Not Indoctrination" group. (208)
  • In the reclaiming motion at the Court of Session, Inner House, Second Division (P578/22, [2023] CSIH 37), For Women Scotland Limited was the petitioner and reclaimer against the Scottish Ministers (p. 1). The issue was "whether the Lord Ordinary erred in holding that the revised guidance is lawful" (p. 2), the guidance under the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018. On 1 November 2023 the court refused the reclaiming motion: "A person with a GRC in the female gender comes within the definition of 'woman' for the purposes of section 11 of the EA, and the guidance issued in respect of the 2018 Act is lawful." (p. 30). The court recorded that it had granted Sex Matters Limited leave to intervene by written submissions only (p. 3). Case status: The UK Supreme Court reversed this Inner House decision on 2025-04-16 ([2025] UKSC 16), holding that sex in the Equality Act 2010 means biological sex; the holding quoted here is therefore not the law. (Opinion of the Court: For Women Scotland Limited v. The Scottish Ministers, Court of Session, Inner House, Second Division, No. P578/22 ([2023] CSIH 37), 2023-11-01, pp. 1, 2, 3, 30; 209)
  • In its appeal to the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom (UKSC 2024/0042), For Women Scotland Limited filed, as appellant, a written case and a speaking note. The written case (undated; p. 11) asked the court to allow the appeal, recall the orders of the courts below, make orders of declarator or reduction of "the offending parts of the statutory guidance", and award expenses. Its first ground (p. 51) was that the meaning of "sex", "man" and "woman" in the Equality Act 2010 "is always and only a reference to the facts of immutable biological criteria". It argued that a gender recognition certificate alters the birth certificate "by a legal fiction imposed by legal fiat" (p. 8), and that section 212(1) refers to "women's biology" and "by definition it excludes those who are biologically male" (p. 36). The speaking note of 2024-11-26 adopted the written case, endorsed the written submissions of the first intervener, Sex Matters, and of the second intervener, Scottish Lesbians and others (p. 2), and asked the court to find that "in the EA 2010 'sex' just means 'sex'" (p. 3). Its closing relief (p. 72) asked for findings that sex means immutable biological criteria throughout the Act, that a full certificate in the female gender does not make a person a woman under the Act, and that the Scottish Ministers' guidance is unlawful. The speaking note says (p. 5) that "it is not 'transphobic' for For Women Scotland and Sex Matters and Scottish Lesbians to make that argument"; this is the appellant's own characterisation of its argument. These are the appellant's claims, reported as its claims. Calling a gender recognition certificate "a legal fiction" and trans women "biologically male" is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position. Case status: On 2025-04-16 the UK Supreme Court allowed the appeal ([2025] UKSC 16), the result these papers asked for; the decision under review (the Inner House opinion of 2023-11-01) was reversed. (Appellant's Written Case, Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, UKSC 2024/0042, undated, pp. 8, 11, 36, 51; 210, copy hosted by a third party. Appellant's Speaking Note, Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, UKSC 2024/0042, 2024-11-26, pp. 2, 3, 5, 72; 211)
  • Commissioned poll: the group's leaflet catalogue says that "The 78% figure in the leaflets is from an independent poll that we commissioned Panelbase to conduct in December 2021", in the notes to its April 2022 leaflet for the council elections of 5 May 2022. The leaflet ("Council Elections: Respect My Sex Campaign") carries four "questions for candidates" and a closing line that "only 36% are more likely to vote for a party that supports legal self-identification of sex". It frames trans women as "men" and asks candidates to protect single-sex services and not to make funding conditional on including "men": anti-trans rhetoric, not presented as a sincere or legitimate position (212 and 213, read 2026-11-20).
  • Security at meetings: in a post of 27 February 2019 (on the census debate in the Scottish Parliament) the group wrote that its meetings and those of other groups "have been subject to such vicious campaigns that we have had to pay for security in order to congregate and discuss law", and that a protest at its meeting of 31 January 2019 "resulted in heightened security measures after the venue received a barrage of threats throughout the day". Both are the group's own accounts: the post gives no amount paid, no venue, no security firm and no other meeting dates, and the threats are not documented there (214, read 2026-11-20).
  • Lobbying Register statement: in an open letter to the Scottish Parliament's Presiding Officer dated 6 December 2023, signed by its three directors, For Women Scotland said a visitor to a Parliament committee meeting had been asked by security to remove its Venus-symbol lapel badge, which the group sells and uses as its logo, because the badge was said to be associated with a lobbying group. The letter states: "it can easily be checked that we are not registered as a lobbying group on the Lobbying Register", and calls the group "a grassroots women's group" that is "not a political group". A Parliament spokesman, quoted by the group from The Telegraph, said the badge was removed in line with the visitor behaviour policy, which "prohibits the display of banners, flags or political slogans". The page records an update of 18 January 2024: the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body was due to consider the Visitor Behaviour Policy in February and would take the correspondence into account. The registration statement is the group's own (215, read 2026-11-20, with updates of 21 December 2023 and 18 January 2024).
  • LGB Alliance in the second judicial review: the group's own account of the hearing of its second Court of Session judicial review (9 and 10 November 2022, before Lady Haldane) says two interveners lodged written submissions: the Equality Network, "who supported the Scottish Government's position", and LGB Alliance, "who made a submission in support of our position". The same page says the Equality and Human Rights Commission supported the Scottish Government's claim that the revised guidance was substantially accurate in law and that the case turned on whether "sex" in the Equality Act 2010 means biological sex or legal sex. This is the group's description of the submissions (216, read 2026-11-20).
  • Balfour + Manson from August 2020: the group's news release of 28 August 2020 says a pre-action letter was sent on 31 July 2020 "by lawyers acting on behalf of For Women Scotland" to the Scottish Government, which replied on 19 August 2020 that it was satisfied the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018 was within devolved competence; the group then "instructed solicitors Balfour + Manson to lodge a petition to proceed with a judicial review", which the release says "has now been registered and accepted by the Court of Session". The release was issued under the heading "Scottish Government Faces Judicial Review for redefining 'Woman' to Include Men", language that denies trans women are women; it is the group's rhetoric and is not presented as sincere or legitimate. It quotes director Trina Budge. Balfour + Manson LLP is named on the group's own page as the solicitors instructed to lodge the petition in August 2020; the page does not name the firm that sent the pre-action letter (217, read 2026-11-20).
  • Joint statement of 31 January 2022: the group published on its own site a joint statement, "Joint statement in response to the EHRC intervention", which the page says 20 campaign groups joined, responding to the Equality and Human Rights Commission's letter to the Scottish Government on Gender Recognition Act reform and its response to the UK Government's conversion therapy consultation. The statement calls the Commission's responses "a breath of fresh air", refers to "gender identity activists" and "one group's interests", and says the signatories "will continue to lobby all Governments". The signature list names: LGB Alliance Scotland, LGB Alliance Cymru, Labour Women's Declaration Working Group, For Women Scotland, Fair Play for Women, Conservatives for Women, Transgender Trend, Liberal Voice for Women, AEA, Sex Matters, Lesbian Labour, Safe Schools Alliance, FiLiA, Merched Cymru, Lesbian Fightback, Women Uniting, Woman's Place UK, LGB Alliance, Women's Equality Party Sex-Based Rights Caucus and Green Feminists (20 names, as the page gives them). Framing trans people's recognition as a lobby that destroys the rights of others is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position. The page shows this one statement; it does not show how the groups worked together otherwise (218, read 2026-11-20).
  • Third case, schools guidance: the group's page on its third case says it lodged a summons in the Court of Session on 15 August 2025, an ordinary action for reduction, not a petition for judicial review, of two policies it said conflicted with the UK Supreme Court judgment of 16 April 2025 ([2025] UKSC 16): the Scottish Government's schools guidance "Supporting Transgender Pupils In Schools: Guidance for Scottish Schools" and the Scottish Prison Service's "Policy for the Management of Transgender People in Custody: Operational Guidance". Updates on the page, in the group's words: on 17 September 2025 the Ministers lodged a response saying both policies were lawful and moved to have the action converted into a judicial review; on 29 September 2025 "The school guidance has been removed and new school guidance published which addresses the sections inconsistent with the Supreme Court judgment. The prison guidance remains in place."; on 5 November 2025 it was agreed the case would proceed as a judicial review after the Ministers conceded they would not contest the group's standing or any time limits, with "the sole focus" on the lawfulness of the prison policy, and the Ministers described only the prison guidance as "live"; on 8 January 2026 a three-day hearing was set for 3 February. These are the group's own statements (131, read 2026-11-20, with updates to 17 January 2026). The Court of Session's opinion in the prison case is dated 19 June 2026 ([2026] CSOH 59; Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service, 219, read 2026-11-20).

Filing record

Companies House filing history for SC669393 (29, accessed 2026-11-10): micro-company accounts filed 2022-05-20 (to 2021-07-31), 2023-04-26, 2024-04-26, 2025-04-28 and 2026-07-27 (to 2025-07-31); confirmation statements with no updates each year from 2021-09-13 to 2026-07-31; director Susan Smith appointed 2020-08-21; director's details changed for Trina Budge 2026-07-30.

Anti-trans work: documented moments

Dates and outcomes from Wikipedia's article (accessed 2026-11-10) unless another source is named. Wikipedia and several outlets (PinkNews, MSNBC, Time, Gay Times) describe the group as anti-trans; the group calls itself a women's rights group. Its case rests on denying that trans women are women, which is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric whatever the legal result.

  • 2020-05-05: in a post of 5 May 2020, "Review of our #BinTheBill GRA Consultation Campaign", For Women Scotland reviews its campaign against the Scottish Government's proposed reform of the Gender Recognition Act 2004, run during its 2019-20 consultation. The post says the campaign was launched on 1 February (2020) with "hubs" in Glasgow, Edinburgh and Aberdeen. It states: "This is not an ant-trans campaign. This is a pro-female campaign" (spelling as on the page). In the same post it calls the Act "a legal mechanism for male people to enter the protected characteristic of the female sex" and says "if any man can become a woman just because he says so, then the word becomes meaningless and so do female rights", which treats trans women as men and is anti-trans rhetoric whatever the group calls the campaign. It also describes "Government funded transgender" groups as "powerful" "interest groups". It says "several of our group spoke at the LGB Alliance launch in Glasgow on 18th January" (2020). It reports 60,000 leaflets distributed by the hubs, a further 8,000 sent by post, and full-page adverts in the Herald (17 January) and the Scotsman and Metro (6 March) (22, read; the group's own account of its campaign).
  • 2021-03: lost its first judicial review at the Court of Session against the inclusion of trans women in the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018; won on appeal in 2022-02, when the act was held outwith legislative competence.
  • 2021-07: organised a rally in support of an accountant charged over tweets about trans people; proceedings against her were discontinued in 2021-10.
  • 2022-03-03: For Women Scotland posted "Census action - 'believer in biology'", recommending that people write "Believer in biology" in the religion section of the Scottish census "as a protest" against census guidance that the answer to "What is your sex?" could differ from the birth certificate and that a Gender Recognition Certificate was not needed. It asked supporters to request household and individual paper copies, saying this "will not only cause the authorities inconvenience but also means that a historical record is preserved", and advised against answering "non-binary". An update of 10 March 2022 cites a Scottish Daily Express report that the census was struggling to send out paper copies owing to thousands of requests (220, read 2026-11-20; the group's own page).
  • 2022-05-01: For Women Scotland published the results of a survey run in its newsletter from 27 March to 3 April 2022 on the Gender Recognition Reform Bill. It says 580 people responded and that 550 responded to question 7, "Should the Gender Recognition Act be repealed?". The other questions asked whether the requirement for a diagnosis of gender dysphoria should be removed, whether the period of living in the acquired gender should fall from 2 years to 3 months, whether the minimum age should fall from 18 to 16, whether people who detransition should be able to revoke a Gender Recognition Certificate, and whether sex offenders should be barred from applying for one. The page gives the answer counts as graphics, and no result is stated here (221, read 2026-11-20; the group's own page).
  • 2022-06: wrote to 32 councils seeking single-sex school facilities.
  • 2022-10: led protests against the Gender Recognition Reform Bill.
  • 2022-10-08: the group's page on its Women's Rally at the Scottish Parliament names these MSPs as having come out to support the rally: for the Conservatives Pam Gosal, Rachael Hamilton, Roz McCall, Sue Webber, Sharon Dowey, Liam Kerr, Russell Findlay, Craig Hoy, Jeremy Balfour, Murdo Fraser, Brian Whittle and Edward Mountain; for the SNP John Mason; for Labour Jackie Baillie, Pauline McNeill, Michael Marra, Daniel Johnson, Colin Smyth and Foysol Choudhury (41, read).
  • 2022-12: shared a Battle of Ideas platform with members of the Scottish Family Party (Wikipedia, For Women Scotland).
  • 2022-12: Wikipedia says Rowling announced that its director Susan Smith would join the board of Beira's Place (Wikipedia, For Women Scotland); Beira's Place's own board page lists Susan Smith as a director (39, accessed 2026-11-10).
  • 2022-12-13 and 2023-11: Wikipedia says a second judicial review, on the Scottish Government's guidance that "woman" includes a trans woman with a Gender Recognition Certificate, was dismissed by the Court of Session on 2022-12-13, and that the group lost its appeal in 2023-11 (Wikipedia, For Women Scotland, secondary; for the appeal, the Inner House opinion [2023] CSIH 37, P578/22, delivered 1 November 2023, 209, ends "The reclaiming motion is refused."; the 2022-12-13 date of the first-instance decision is not in that opinion and is still Wikipedia only; the Supreme Court later allowed the group's appeal, [2025] UKSC 16, 16 April 2025, 205, judgment read: "We would allow the appeal.").
  • 2024-02-16: announced permission to appeal to the UK Supreme Court (Scottish Daily Express).
  • 2024-09-12: a statement of 12 September 2024 on the group's site, "FWS Statement on Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre", responds to the published review of Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre. It calls the centre's approach "a particularly extreme and egregious version of gender identity ideology", demands that a staff member of that centre be removed from post (not named here), says the position of the head of Rape Crisis Scotland (named on the page, not here) is "untenable", and writes: "we believe that Rape Crisis Scotland should, as a matter of urgency, confirm that Beira's Place will be able to take on referrals. Beira's Place should also be involved in restructuring both the local and national services." It describes Beira's Place as "an alternative women-only service" for women in the Lothians; the page does not use the word "preferred". This is the group's own call that the national rape crisis body work with the service whose board its director sits on (board link: 39) (222, read; the group's own page).
  • 2024-10-04: a report of 4 October 2024 on the group's site, "Rape Crisis Centres - by women and for women?", reviews each of the "17 independent rape crisis centres in the network" and Rape Crisis Scotland, listing for each its founding purpose, its latest constitution, what its website says about who it supports, and its LGBT Youth Scotland charter award (the page says eleven of the seventeen centres hold a charter award). It calls an inclusion policy under which "women" includes people who identify as women "wilfully unlawful" and describes support open to trans women as "mixed-sex". It rests on the group's two Court of Session wins and says the Supreme Court appeal "is due to be heard ... very shortly". It ends: "a return to by women and for women would be very welcome". The report concerns trans women's access to adult services; several entries also mention services for young people from age 11 or 12 (223, read; the group's own page and its own characterisation of each centre).
  • 2025-01-03: the group's submission to the Equality and Human Rights Commission consultation on its draft Services Code of Practice (consultation closed 3 January 2025), posted 3 January 2025, argues that biological males can "simply be excluded" from women-only services "regardless of whether they hold a GRC", objects to the terms "trans woman", "trans man" and "legal sex" in the earlier version, and objects to the earlier version's example of a trans woman asking to live in the women's wing of a nursing home. It also says that women who hold a certificate in the male gender "may need to attend women-only clinics ... or access women-only rape crisis centres" and that "it would not be safe to house such 'trans men' in the male prison estate"; it calls the EHRC's treatment of them as men "chilling". The page does not ask for trans women to be removed from prisons; its prison litigation is a separate matter. The submission reaches adults (care homes, clinics, prisons, rape crisis centres) (224, read; the group's own page).
  • 2025-04-16: Supreme Court judgment, [2025] UKSC 16: "woman", "man" and "sex" in the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex; the justices said they were not ruling more broadly, and Lord Hodge stressed trans people remain protected under gender reassignment. Source: For Women Scotland Ltd (Appellant) v The Scottish Ministers (Respondent), [2025] UKSC 16, on appeal from [2023] CSIH 37, judgment given 16 April 2025, heard 26 and 27 November 2024, Sex Matters intervening (225). Para 266 (p. 86): "A person with a GRC in the female gender does not come within the definition of "woman" for the purposes of sex discrimination in section 11 of the EA 2010", so the Scottish Government's guidance was incorrect; para 267 (p. 87): "Nothing in this judgment is intended to discourage the appointment of trans people to public boards or to minimise the importance of addressing their under-representation on such boards. The issue here is only whether the appointment of a trans woman who has a GRC counts as the appointment of a woman"; para 268: "We would allow the appeal." Para 21 states the relief sought: "a declarator that the guidance is unlawful and an order for its reduction". The holding is quoted as the court's, not endorsed.
  • 2025-08-15: lodged a summons in the Court of Session (served 15 August 2025 on the Scottish Ministers, the Lord Advocate and the Advocate General for Scotland) for reduction of the Scottish Government's schools guidance on transgender pupils and the Scottish Prison Service's guidance on transgender people in custody. By the group's own account the schools guidance was removed and new schools guidance published on 29 September 2025, and from 5 November 2025 the case proceeded as a judicial review whose sole focus was the prison policy (For Women Scotland, 131, read 2026-11-20).
  • 2026-06-19, Court of Session, Outer House, opinion of Lady Ross, Petition of For Women Scotland for Judicial Review, [2026] CSOH 59, P1183/25 (respondents the Scottish Ministers and the Lord Advocate; the Scottish Human Rights Commission and the Equality and Human Rights Commission intervened). For Women Scotland asked the court to review the Scottish Prison Service's 2024 guidance on managing transgender people in custody, contending that, after the Supreme Court judgment, "the applicable provisions of the EA 2010 can only be read as referring to biological women" so that no trans woman may be accommodated in women's prisons (p. 19, the court's account of the petitioner's argument). The court held that prison sex segregation follows biological sex, that the guidance conflicts with the statutory scheme in so far as it allows accommodation in a prison for the opposite biological sex (p. 81), and that "In all the circumstances, the Prisons Guidance is unlawful and the petitioner is entitled to orders for declarator and reduction." (p. 82). The court rejected a general right under Article 8, 2 or 3 to placement by gender identity but left open an exceptional individual case (p. 82), which cannot be part of a general policy. Case status: The Scottish Government cabinet decided on 2026-06-23 not to appeal this opinion of 2026-06-19 and transfers of prisoners began that day; the opinion reserved the terms of the order. For Women Scotland's own page on the judgment records a further hearing on 13 August 2026 to finalise the court order and, in an update of 24 August 2026, that the judge has issued the interlocutor (the order itself is linked from that page as a PDF) (226, read 2026-11-20; the group's own account). (Opinion of Lady Ross, Petition of For Women Scotland for Judicial Review, Court of Session, Outer House, P1183/25, 2026-06-19, pp. 19, 81, 82; 219)
  • 2026-06-19 to 2026-08-24: the group's own post on the prison guidance judgment quotes paragraphs 178, 179, 181 and 184 of the Court of Session judgment, calls the result "a comprehensive victory", and names its solicitors as Balfour+Manson. Its update of 23 June 2026 says the Scottish Ministers confirmed they would not appeal, and its statement of that date says the Government "must now reflect on the corrosive effect funded lobbyists have had on single-sex provision", naming Scottish Trans, the Equality Network and Stonewall. The statement speaks of trans women prisoners as "men" and "male prisoners"; that is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented as a neutral description (226, read 2026-11-20; the group's own page, so its characterisations are reported as its own).
  • 2026-07-13: the group posted an open letter to the chairs of the Amnesty International UK Selection Board and Charitable Trust about Amnesty's report "A Growing Threat: the Anti-Rights Movement in the UK", published 8 July 2026. It describes the report as "seriously false and defamatory", says the report was "now under review", and says it asked for a full apology and the report's permanent withdrawal. The page adds an update of 13 July 2026 saying the group received an email from the Chief Executive of Amnesty International UK, shown on the page; the letter is linked from the page as a PDF (227, read 2026-11-20; the group's own page; its description of the report is its own claim).
  • Pretext note: the prisons case concerns adult trans prisoners, and the group's litigation, protests and campaigns target trans adults' legal recognition, not only children.
  • 2019-08-31: its response to Scottish Rugby said the Equality Act "permits the exclusion of all biological males" from women's sport whatever certificate is held: "permits the exclusion of all biological males from women's and girls' sporting events regardless of identity, status under the protected characteristic of gender reassignment, or whether a gender recognition certificate is held." (Scottish Rugby consultation: guidance for non-binary players, response by Forwomen.Scot, 2019-08-31, p. 1; 228). Calling trans women and girls "biological males" to be excluded from women's and girls' sport is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position.
  • 2022-05-16: its submission to the Scottish Parliament on the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill says self-declaration "has been abused by predatory males and other criminals and fraudsters". It gives a footnote number and no source in the text: "There has been no evaluation of how this has impacted society in those countries and the evidence4 we do have shows it has been abused by predatory males and other criminals and fraudsters to the detriment of women and children." (Submission to the Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee on the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill, 2022-05-16, p. 2; 229). Presenting legal self-declaration as a route for "predatory males and other criminals" is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position.
  • FWS published its litigation papers on its own site: the written case, statement of facts and issues, speaking note and final reply in the UK Supreme Court appeal (UKSC 2024/0042; 2024), and the grounds of appeal and note of argument in its second Court of Session case (2023). In the written case, FWS describes the 2018 Act as one that "excluded all and any women who also had the protected characteristic of gender reassignment" from its definition (pdf 6).
  • FWS's parents' guide on school toilets (Sept 2024, 230) says (pdf 4): "60% of secondary schools allow girls who identify as transgender to use the boys' toilets but only 5% of schools provide sanitary bins in the boys' toilets." The figure is FWS's, from its Freedom of Information requests to schools (pdf 3); presenting trans girls' use of school toilets as a problem is an anti-trans claim. A second guide covers classrooms (Aug 2024).
  • FWS sent a brief to a Canadian House of Commons committee on Bill C-6 (conversion therapy, 2021), arguing against a ban's effect on treatment protocols for children (Brief, 231). The brief says (pdf 2): "Until recently, a medical transition as a treatment for gender dysphoria which results in irreversible changes to healthy bodies has therefore been embarked upon only as a measure of last resort, reserved for adults alone and undergone only after years of intense psychological counselling". That is the brief's description of past practice, not a statement of FWS's position on adults. Describing transition as "irreversible changes to healthy bodies" is anti-trans rhetoric. Against it: a Johns Hopkins systematic review of 20 studies found hormone therapy associated with higher quality of life and lower depression and anxiety (232), and a meta-analysis of 27 studies covering 7,928 surgical patients found pooled regret of 1% (233).

Other campaigns

  • Prostitution law: on 2024-09-23 For Women Scotland posted its response to the consultation on the Proposed Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill, a Member's Bill proposed by Ash Regan MSP to create an offence of paying for sexual services, repeal the offence of soliciting by people in prostitution and support people in or exiting prostitution (consultation closing 30 September 2024). It answered "Fully supportive" to the new offence and to repealing section 46 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982, says it supports "the Nordic Model approach" with new or strengthened laws against pimping and profiting from others' prostitution, and says commercial sexual exploitation "in all forms" is "violence against women". This is a position on prostitution law, not on trans people; the post does not mention pornography (234, read 2026-11-20; the group's own page).

Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext

  • 2022-05-16: in its evidence to the Scottish Parliament on the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill, For Women Scotland opposed ending medical diagnosis for people seeking a gender recognition certificate (the submission also discusses 16 and 17 year olds). "The intention of the 2004 Act was to restrict Gender Recognition Certificates (GRC) to the small, objectively identifiable group of people who have a demonstrated medical need. The Scottish Government has not recognised that by removing this fundamental criteria the law will no longer be about trans people – it opens up the ability to change the sex recorded on your birth certificate to 100% of the population." (Submission to the Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee on the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill, 2022-05-16, p. 1; 229). Presenting gender recognition without a medical diagnosis as opening a change of recorded sex "to 100% of the population" is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position.
  • 2020-03-17: in its answer to the Scottish Government consultation it asked that the Bill be rejected in full. "We do not agree that the female sex class is a category that men can self-identify into. The GRA 2004 was an accommodation to meet the needs of those with extreme gender dysphoria and should not be reformed in this manner; we believe the Bill should be rejected in full." (Gender Recognition Reform Bill consultation: For Women Scotland response, 2020-03-17, p. 3; 235). Describing trans women as "men" who "self-identify into" the female sex class is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position.
  • 2022-02-04: it described the idea of an innate gender identity as an "unevidenced and unscientific belief" in a response about banning conversion therapy that applies to all ages; the claim is anti-trans: "The proposals as they relate to gender identity are problematic. 1) Gender identity, and conversion therapy in relation to gender identity, is not properly defined in the proposals. The proposals appear to be based on an unquestioning acceptance of the contested, unevidenced and unscientific belief that individuals (including very young children) have an innate gender identity which constitutes their 'true self'." (UK Government conversion therapy consultation: For Women Scotland submission, 2022-02-04, p. 1; 236)
  • 2025-01-10: its response to NHS Grampian, citing the Court of Session ruling [2023] CSIH 37, says people without a certificate "have no right to access services provided for members of the opposite sex". This covers adult patients: "Individuals without a gender recognition certificate, whether they have the protected characteristic of gender reassignment or not, retain the sex in which they were born and have no right to access services provided for members of the opposite sex." (For Women Scotland response to the NHS Grampian equality outcomes consultation, 2025-01-10, p. 1; 237). Holding that trans people without a gender recognition certificate "retain the sex in which they were born" and have "no right to access services provided for members of the opposite sex" is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position.
  • 2025-06-22: it asked Police Scotland to change its definition of sex to "an objective, biological characteristic": "We would suggest an alternative definition of: "Sex means being male or female. It is an objective, biological characteristic about a person that is observed at birth."" (For Women Scotland response to the Police Scotland sex and gender consultation, 2025-06-22, p. 1; 238). Asking Police Scotland to define sex as "observed at birth" is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position.
  • In its response to the Scottish Government consultation on ending conversion practices (2 April 2024, 239), FWS answered "Do not support" to the question of whether to use "a package of both criminal and civil measures" and wrote the following anti-trans claim (pdf 2): "We are rather surprised that the Scottish Government is drawing on the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU), a document which most now feel is unfit for purpose and which grew out of trans activism rather than genuine medical concerns." The consultation questions quoted in the response do not limit it to minors.
  • In its response to the Law Commission's hate-crime consultation (24 Dec 2020, 240) FWS wrote (pdf 1): "While women are not specifically covered as a group, transgender identity is." and questioned whether "transgender identity" has a coherent definition, an anti-trans argument. This concerns hate-crime protection for trans people of any age.
  • FWS brought a third judicial review (Court of Session, petition as adjusted 12 Dec 2025, 241), headed (pdf 1) "PETITIONER for Judicial Review of (i) SPS Policy for the Management of Transgender People in Custody Operational Guidance".
  • The filings in the Supreme Court appeal reach adults, in the speaking note and the written case. The speaking note of 2024-11-26 argues (p. 5) that "a man remains a man even if he has the protected characteristic of gender reassignment and even if he has been issued with a gender recognition certificate stating the legal fiction that his "acquired gender is the female gender"." It says of lesbian associations (p. 31): "Lesbian associations have no choice but to admit men into their ranks." It describes (p. 22) a woman at a rape crisis centre or women's refuge whose support session is "conducted by a man who holds a certificate of acquired gender as the female gender", and a lesbian support group told that it must admit "a heterosexual man who holds a certificate"; on p. 36 it asks the Equality and Human Rights Commission to explain how women-only hospital wards can work on its second definition. It also raises (p. 24) women athletes who compete against "individuals who have undergone male puberty but who now choose to 'identify' as women". In the passages on pp. 5, 22 and 31 the filing's own words call trans women with a certificate men; the passages on pp. 24 and 36 do not use that word. These are the appellant's claims, reported as its claims and not as fact; the framing of trans women as men is anti-trans rhetoric and is not presented here as a sincere or legitimate position. The written case says (p. 47): "The idea that a party's acquisition of a GRC transforms a non-consensual homosexual encounter or relationship, into a consensual heterosexual one (or vice versa) is simply a pernicious absurdity." That passage concerns adults and criminal law. Case status: On 2025-04-16 the UK Supreme Court allowed the appeal ([2025] UKSC 16) and held that sex, man and woman in the Equality Act 2010 mean biological sex, reversing the Inner House ruling under appeal. (Appellant's Speaking Note, Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, UKSC 2024/0042, 2024-11-26, pp. 5, 22, 24, 31, 36; 211. Appellant's Written Case, Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, UKSC 2024/0042, undated, p. 47; 210, copy hosted by a third party)

What the records don't show

The crowdfunder total at close and the date and amount of the Rowling payment. A shared-director link between Beira's Place and FWS beyond the 2022 board appointment is not established (see Open questions). (Tracking Trans Hate assessment of the sources cited in this profile; Companies House filing history, 29; Wikipedia, 1, accessed 2026-11-10)

Open questions

  • When the crowdfunder closed and what its final total was: Wikipedia gives £197,000 from 4,023 donors, citing three reports (The Times 2024-02-17, The Telegraph 2024-02-18, The Sunday Times 2024-11-23); PinkNews (2024-02-19) gave more than £133,400 from over 2,000 individuals at that date; the CrowdJustice case page "The Definition of Sex in the Equality Act" (242) gives a status line of "Funded on 16th February 2024" with £232,005 pledged against a £230,000 stretch target from 5,021 pledges; no figure here is confirmed as the total at close. Holyrood (2025-10-08) reports the group's total costs as £417,000. The group's finance page (243, accessed 2026-11-10; first posted 21 September 2022, updated 15 October 2022, so it covers the earlier 2022 litigation) lists a CrowdJustice fundraiser (net) of £183,399.50, general donations of £11,642.91, interest of £5.02 and legal and court fees of £195,047.43, and a Scottish Government settlement of £147,500. Scottish Legal News, in an article dated 2022-09-22 about the earlier case (244), says the group "raised £183,399 through a crowdfund and another £11,642 through general donations" and states legal fees of £195,047. CrowdJustice's own case page (19) is the primary source for the final total.
  • Whether Rowling's pledge of £70,000 was paid, and when, and the amount of her gift in a source other than the press: her own post of 2025-04-16 confirms she gave money and states no amount; no filing shows the payment and micro-entity accounts would not.
  • Whether Beira's Place and FWS share directors in a way beyond the 2022 board appointment already noted: Beira's Place describes itself as the operating name of WFRS Edinburgh Limited, registered number SC716085, registered in Scotland (39, accessed 2026-11-10), and its board page lists seven directors including J.K. Rowling, Rhona Hotchkiss, Susan Smith, Johann Lamont, Tess White, Isabelle Kerr MBE and Dr Margaret McCartney. Companies House shows WFRS Edinburgh Limited as active, incorporated 25 November 2021, SIC 74990 non-trading company, last accounts made up to 30 November 2025, with seven active directors: four appointed on 12 December 2022, one appointed on 25 November 2021, and two appointed on 17 July 2026 (245 and /officers, accessed 2026-11-10). The register lists one director appointed 12 December 2022 under a name form that differs from the one the organization presents, while For Women Scotland's register (SC669393) lists a director "Susan Smith"; the other register entries match the names Beira's Place presents (Rhona Hotchkiss; Dr Margaret McCartney; Isabelle Kerr, appointed 17 July 2026; Johann Macdougall Lamont, the full name Wikipedia gives for Johann Lamont; Teresa Mary White, appointed 17 July 2026, presented as Tess White). Wikipedia says Rowling provided an interest-free loan of at least £1.9 million secured against the Edinburgh property, citing Companies House documents (246, accessed 2026-11-10); the Telegraph article it cites (2024-09-11) says the loan is secured on the company's property and is repayable only on any future disposal of it (see the WFRS Edinburgh Limited page). Beira's Place's own board page says of its director Susan Smith "Susan is a co-director of For Women Scotland, the largest grassroots women's organisation in Scotland" (39, accessed 2026-11-10), so the two organizations themselves state the shared director; whether the register entry under the different name form is the same person is not stated in any cited source and is not inferred.
  • How and when the Scottish Government's £392,500 for the Supreme Court case was paid: the Irish News report of 2026-02-10 says it was paid after the April 2025 ruling. The Government had not paid on 2025-10-08 (Holyrood) or on 2025-12-24 (a Press Association report carried by the Irish News; entry on the timing of the payment in Money received), and the group's own page of 2026-02-10 reports the settlement as held in a deposit account. STV and Scottish Legal News report the group's statement of 2026-02-10 that it had received the sum; no source cited gives the payment date.

Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.

Sources

  1. image page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_Women_Scotland
  2. https://forwomen.scot/about/
  3. https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/SC669393
  4. https://forwomen.scot/18/08/2019/pride-glasgow/
  5. https://forwomen.scot/06/01/2020/meeting-with-scotgov-officials/
  6. https://opencharities.uk/ew/1207701/files/2025-06-30-accounts.html
  7. https://www.civilsociety.co.uk/news/sex-matters-records-1-43m-income-in-first-year-as-charity.html
  8. https://register-of-charities.charitycommission.gov.uk/charity-search/-/charity-details/1207701
  9. https://www.irishnews.com/news/uk/scottish-government-bill-for-gender-court-case-totals-over-760000-2ZOF36Z7DZLZXA4ITXFOCZLIVM/
  10. https://www.gov.scot/publications/for-women-scotland-ltd-v-the-scottish-ministers-legal-costs/
  11. https://web.archive.org/web/20260619212541/https://www.gov.scot/publications/for-women-scotland-ltd-v-the-scottish-ministers-legal-costs/
  12. https://scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-news/proud-jk-rowling-donates-70k-32149025
  13. https://www.thepinknews.com/2024/02/19/jk-rowling-for-women-scotland-donation-legal-definition-woman
  14. https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-13098085/JK-Rowling-donates-Scottish-feminist-campaigners-help-Supreme-Court-appeal-against-definition-woman.html.
  15. https://www.gov.scot/publications/foi-202500462293/
  16. https://www.irishnews.com/news/uk/campaigner-fears-ministers-trying-to-run-us-out-of-cash-after-gender-ruling-XKVESJ5AUFIE3CCUAD7S3HLF6Y/
  17. https://scottishlegal.com/articles/for-women-scotland-secures-ps392500-in-costs-after-supreme-court-victory
  18. https://thepinknews.com/2025/04/17/jk-rowling-terf-ve-day-supreme-court-ruling-for-women-scotland
  19. https://www.crowdjustice.com/case/uksc-definition-of-sex-in-equality-act/
  20. https://web.archive.org/web/20260525035536/https://www.crowdjustice.com/case/uksc-definition-of-sex-in-equality-act/
  21. https://www.crowdjustice.com/how-it-works/
  22. https://forwomen.scot/05/05/2020/review-of-our-binthebill-gra-consultation-campaign/
  23. https://forwomen.scot/12/02/2021/draft-guidance-on-collecting-sex-and-gender-data-feedback/
  24. https://forwomen.scot/03/08/2021/the-status-of-women-in-scotland-gender-representation-on-public-boards-act/
  25. https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-news/proud-jk-rowling-donates-70k-32149025
  26. https://forwomen.scot/19/01/2024/gender-representation-on-public-boards-amendment-scotland-bill/
  27. https://forwomen.scot/21/09/2022/judicial-review-finances/
  28. https://forwomen.scot/10/02/2026/uk-supreme-court-recovery-of-costs/
  29. https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/SC669393/filing-history
  30. https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/SC669393/persons-with-significant-control
  31. https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/SC669393/officers
  32. https://forwomen.scot/02/10/2023/note-of-argument/
  33. https://forwomen.scot/08/09/2019/lesbian-strength-march/
  34. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magdalen_Berns
  35. https://www.holyrood.com/inside-politics/view,the-women-who-wouldnt-wheesht
  36. https://forwomen.scot/events/events-2021/
  37. https://taz.de/Aktivistin-ueber-Schottlands-Trans-Gesetz/!5906396/
  38. https://forwomen.scot/events/events-2022/
  39. https://beirasplace.org.uk/about/
  40. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eDGg8Ox4K-0
  41. https://forwomen.scot/08/10/2022/womens-rally-october-2022/
  42. https://www.renfrewshire.gov.uk/node/3516
  43. https://www.thecanary.co/uk/news/2022/10/24/politician-accuses-scottish-labour-of-ignoring-complaints-raised-against-anti-trans-councillor/
  44. Event listing: https://forwomen.scot/events/
  45. https://holyrood.com/news/view,ash-regan-quits-scottish-government-ahead-of-gender-recognition-vote
  46. https://www.holyrood.com/news/view,albas-ash-regan-tables-noconfidence-motion-in-greens-patrick-harvie
  47. https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/votes-and-motions/S6M-20269
  48. https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/committees/committee-reports/sppac/2025/12/18/sppacs062025r09rev2/decision-of-the-committee
  49. https://forwomen.scot/events/events-2019/
  50. https://forwomen.scot/?p=1198
  51. https://vice.com/en/article/how-a-feminist-library-opening-became-all-about-the-definition-of-a-woman
  52. https://unherd.com/2022/04/the-corruption-of-the-feminist-library/
  53. https://whocanivotefor.co.uk/person/21261/caroline-mcallister
  54. https://democratonline.net/2021/03/31/politics-cllr-caroline-mcallister-to-stand-in-the-west-of-scotland-for-alba-party/
  55. https://www.thepinknews.com/2020/10/19/caroline-mcallister-msp-dumbarton-snp-womens-pledge
  56. https://www.thepinknews.com/2022/01/30/scotland-trans-youth-alba-caroline-mcallister
  57. https://sisteroutrider.wordpress.com/about/
  58. https://sisteroutrider.wordpress.com/2021/06/14/keeping-faith-towards-a-more-compassionate-gender-discourse/
  59. https://www.hachetteschools.co.uk/contributor/claire-heuchan/
  60. https://www.alloaadvertiser.com/news/24165594.eva-comrie-stand-alloa-grangemouth-ward-independent/
  61. https://www.whocanivotefor.co.uk/person/73804/eva-comrie
  62. https://forwomen.scot/events/events-2020/
  63. https://www.spiked-online.com/2024/04/22/will-the-trans-activists-who-cancelled-me-ever-apologise/
  64. https://gillianphilip.substack.com
  65. https://forwomen.scot/05/12/2022/united-nations/
  66. https://forwomen.scot/category/guest-posts/
  67. https://forwomen.scot/04/09/2021/womens-rights-demo-september-2021/
  68. https://archives.battleofideas.org.uk/2023/speaker/kate-coleman/
  69. https://forwomen.scot/08/03/2020/demonstration/
  70. https://forwomen.scot/19/03/2019/reply-to-garavelli/
  71. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Louise-Moody-Edinburgh-Uni-speech.pdf
  72. https://womensdeclaration.com/en/about/
  73. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women's_Declaration_International
  74. https://www.filia.org.uk/latest-news/2020/10/19/dr-nicola-williams-fair-play-for-women-why-sex-based-policies-matter-for-womens-sport
  75. https://www.lawsociety.ie/gazette/top-stories2/uk-census-gender-id-ruling-declared-victory-for-good-data/
  76. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magi_Gibson
  77. https://susandalgety.substack.com/p/unbridled-womens-poetry-for-our-times
  78. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/IWD20-speech-Victoria.pdf
  79. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victoria_Whitworth
  80. https://www.transgendermap.com/issues/topics/media/outlets/the-sunday-times/2020-sunday-times-open-letter/
  81. https://news.stv.tv/entertainment/literary-figures-show-jk-rowling-support-amid-transphobia-row
  82. https://news.stv.tv/north/student-cleared-of-misconduct-following-gender-debate
  83. https://thepinknews.com/2022/12/21/gender-critical-lisa-keogh-law-university-trans
  84. https://whocanivotefor.co.uk/person/85229/lisa-keogh
  85. Event page: https://forwomen.scot/events/events-2023/
  86. Final division: https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/votes-and-motions/S6M-07312
  87. https://www.dumbartonreporter.co.uk/opinion/23116340.pam-gosal-scotgov-gender-recognition-bill-leaves-questions-answer/
  88. https://clydebankpost.co.uk/news/23342976.pam-gosal-calls-scottish-government-protect-womens-spaces
  89. https://forwomen.scot/blog/south-scotland/
  90. https://news.stv.tv/politics/russell-findlay-picks-rachael-hamilton-as-scottish-tories-deputy-leader
  91. https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/votes-and-motions/S6-SP-Bill-13-Amendment-93
  92. https://www.bordertelegraph.com/news/23978951.msp-rachael-hamilton-welcomes-court-ruling-gender-reform-bill/
  93. https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/womens-rights-and-the-proposed-changes-to-the-gender-recognition-act/
  94. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/66618ed3fa3a410907e67be7/Ms_R_D_Adams_v_Edinburgh_Rape_Crisis_Centre_-_4102236.2023_-_Judgment.pdf
  95. https://news.stv.tv/east-central/edinburgh-rape-crisis-centre-ordered-to-pay-former-employee-68000-over-discrimination
  96. https://www.edinburghconservatives.org.uk/news/gender-dysphoria-debate-needs-sensitive-handling-sue-webber
  97. https://unherd.com/thepost/will-nicola-sturgeon-listen-to-detransitioners/
  98. https://susandalgety.substack.com/p/breaking-news-the-women-who-wouldnt
  99. https://forwomen.scot/21/06/2020/women-uniting-press-release/
  100. https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/response-to-gender-recognition-act-2004-consultation
  101. https://alexmassie.substack.com/p/the-vindication-of-women
  102. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Massie_(journalist)
  103. https://forwomen.scot/22/04/2026/uk-supreme-court-one-year-later/
  104. https://forwomen.scot/14/10/2024/abused-or-abuser/
  105. https://www.womensrights.network/wrn-directors
  106. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harriet_Wistrich
  107. https://margaretmccartney.substack.com/p/the-cass-review
  108. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tracy_Gilbert
  109. https://thewomensresourcecentre.org.uk/causes/our-ceo-vivienne-hayes-awarded-a-mbe/
  110. https://forwomen.scot/05/03/2021/hate-crime-bill-email-msps/
  111. https://votes.theyworkforyou.com/decisions/division/scotland/2022-12-22/2
  112. https://forwomen.scot/25/02/2022/we-won-scottish-government-redefinition-of-woman-is-unlawful/
  113. https://forwomen.scot/30/03/2019/tie-letter-legal-response/
  114. https://reading.ac.uk/law/our-staff/rosemary-auchmuty
  115. Group’s account: https://forwomen.scot/21/03/2025/city-of-edinburgh-council-meeting/
  116. https://www.holyrood.com/comment/view,peggie-v-nhs-fife-more-casualties-to-come
  117. https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/human-rights-body-faces-discrimination-claim-from-senior-lawyer-over-gender-critical-views
  118. https://forwomen.scot/21/06/2019/its-a-start/
  119. https://womansplaceuk.org/2019/06/20/the-fight-by-women-has-just-begun-and-scotland-is-at-the-forefront/
  120. https://forwomen.scot/07/12/2020/sixwords/
  121. https://www.rapecrisisscotland.org.uk/news/news/forensic-medical-examinations-and-a-social-media-break
  122. https://forwomen.scot/20/04/2025/uk-supreme-court-the-judgment/
  123. https://www.cloisters.com/barristers/akua-reindorf
  124. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/akua-reindorf-appointed-as-new-ehrc-commissioner
  125. https://www.lse.ac.uk/law/people/visiting-fellows/akua-reindorf
  126. https://forwomen.scot/17/06/2022/press-conference-protecting-female-sports/
  127. https://news.stv.tv/politics/anas-sarwar-everybody-has-lost-since-scotlands-gender-reforms-were-passed-by-holyrood
  128. https://christianconcern.com/about/people/
  129. https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/06387800/officers
  130. https://www.christiantoday.com/news/the-supreme-court-ruling-on-women-was-a-step-forward-but-more-needs-to-be-done
  131. https://forwomen.scot/16/08/2025/fws-v-scottish-ministers-iii/
  132. https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/questions-and-answers?msp=1742&page=5
  133. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Whittle
  134. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carol_Mochan
  135. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caroline_Johnson_(politician)
  136. https://www.theyworkforyou.com/debates/?id=2026-06-23d.255.0
  137. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claire_Baker
  138. https://forwomen.scot/blog/mid-scotland-and-fife/
  139. https://claudiajones.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Femicide-Census-10-year-report.pdf
  140. https://christianconcern.com/news/andrea-and-bethany-address-global-womens-summit/
  141. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/colin-smyth
  142. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/craig-hoy
  143. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/daniel-johnson
  144. https://forwomen.scot/27/06/2024/general-election-2024/
  145. Scottish Daily Express: https://scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/election-candidate-backed-jk-rowling-33100598
  146. Centre biography: https://csacentre.org.uk/team/diane-whitfield
  147. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/douglas-lumsden
  148. Stage 1: https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/votes-and-motions/S6M-06459
  149. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/edward-mountain
  150. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/elaine-smith
  151. https://forwomen.scot/07/03/2021/hate-crime-bill-stage-3-briefing/
  152. Consultation question: https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/questions-and-answers/question?ref=S5W-35023
  153. Advisory groups question: https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/questions-and-answers/question?ref=S5W-35024
  154. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/elena-whitham
  155. Group’s recommendation: https://forwomen.scot/26/01/2026/last-chance-saloon/
  156. The Spectator: https://spectator.com/article/labours-self-id-mess
  157. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harriet_Cross
  158. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/foysol-choudhury
  159. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/fergus-ewing
  160. https://forwomen.scot/24/04/2026/scottish-election-2026-guide/
  161. https://www.heraldscotland.com/politics/23209433.nine-snp-msps-break-whip-vote-gender-recognition-reforms/
  162. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jackie_Baillie
  163. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Cleverly
  164. https://forwomen.scot/events/events-2025/
  165. https://www.edinburgh.gov.uk/news/article/14126/new-council-leader-announced-in-edinburgh
  166. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeane_Freeman
  167. https://forwomen.scot/10/12/2020/fws-statement-on-the-vote-for-lamont-amendment/
  168. https://www.holyrood.com/news/view,msps-back-amendment-to-replace-gender-with-sex-in-new-law-supporting-rape-victims
  169. https://www.premierchristianity.com/jennifer-melle/3004.bio
  170. https://www.christiantoday.com/news/christian-nurse-alarmed-after-phillipson-says-guidance-on-single-sex-spaces-will-not-apply-to-nhs
  171. https://irvinetimes.com/news/23210843.north-ayrshire-msps-react-passing-gender-recognition-reform-bill
  172. Committee record: https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/kenneth-gibson
  173. Election guide: https://forwomen.scot/blog/west-scotland/
  174. https://forwomen.scot/blog/edinburgh-lothian-east/
  175. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/katherine-sangster
  176. https://forwomen.scot/04/02/2025/un-special-rapporteur-on-violence-against-women-and-girls-report-to-hrc/
  177. https://www.tuv.org.uk/allister-tabled-motions-on-supreme-court-ruling-on-the-legal-definition-of-a-woman-and-omagh-bomb-inquiry/
  178. https://www.edinburghconservatives.org.uk/people/councillor-marie-clair-munro
  179. Candidate list: https://www.scottishconservatives.com/2026-scottish-parliament-candidates/
  180. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/marlyn-glen
  181. https://forwomen.scot/18/12/2022/emergency-evidence-session-by-ehrcj-committee/
  182. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/meghan-gallacher
  183. https://forwomen.scot/blog/central-scotland-and-lothians-west/
  184. https://www.parliament.scot/-/media/files/legislation/bills/s6-bills/gender-recognition-reform-scotland-bill/stage-3/marshalled-list-at-stage-3.pdf
  185. https://www.thenational.scot/news/23110878.labour-msp-michael-marra-seeks-water-gender-reform-bill/
  186. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/pauline-mcneill
  187. https://forwomen.scot/blog/glasgow/
  188. https://www.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps/roz-mccall
  189. https://thepinknews.com/2022/12/24/scottish-gender-reform-who-voted-for-and-against-trans-bil
  190. https://whocanivotefor.co.uk/elections/sp.r.glasgow.2021-05-06/glasgow/
  191. https://forwomen.scot/09/05/2021/election-2021-guide/
  192. https://electionresults.parliament.uk/elections/3703
  193. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sophie_Walker
  194. https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/16721172/officers
  195. https://forwomen.scot/13/06/2021/nhs-scotland-pride-badge/
  196. https://forwomen.scot/02/03/2024/be-more-mary/
  197. Scottish Parliament motion: https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/votes-and-motions/S6M-17241
  198. Group’s account: https://forwomen.scot/11/02/2023/roundup-no-males-in-female-jails-demonstration/
  199. Group’s article: https://forwomen.scot/07/02/2021/sex-and-the-hate-crime-bill/
  200. TFN: https://tfn.scot/news/ceo-of-anti-drugs-charity-to-step-back-from-frontline
  201. Group’s statement: https://forwomen.scot/21/11/2018/proposals-to-allow-self-identification-of-gender-debate/
  202. PinkNews: https://www.thepinknews.com/2022/10/28/david-tc-davies-wales-lgbtq-trans/
  203. Holyrood column: https://www.holyrood.com/news/view,john-swinney-is-allowing-the-trans-prisoners-row-to-become-an-election-issue
  204. Amina: https://mwrc.org.uk/who-we-are/
  205. https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/uksc/2025/16
  206. https://supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2024-0042
  207. https://scottishlegal.com/articles/scottish-lesbians-to-intervene-in-for-women-scotlands-supreme-court-appeal
  208. https://scottishunionforeducation.substack.com/p/scottish-union-for-education-newsletter-58d
  209. https://www.pa.web.scotcourts.gov.uk/media/l1imtxvx/court-of-session-judgement-reclaiming-motion-by-for-women-scotland-limited-against-the-scottish-ministers-01-november-2023.pdf
  210. https://sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/For-Women-Scotland-v-Scottish-Ministers-Written-Case-for-the-Appellant.pdf
  211. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Speaking-Note-for-FWS-26Nov2024.pdf
  212. https://forwomen.scot/leaflet-catalogue/
  213. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Council-election-A5-leaflet-back.pdf
  214. https://forwomen.scot/27/02/2019/sex-matters/
  215. https://forwomen.scot/06/12/2023/letter-to-presiding-officer-re-badges/
  216. https://forwomen.scot/12/11/2022/judicial-review-2-substantive-hearing/
  217. https://forwomen.scot/28/08/2020/news-release-judicial-review/
  218. https://forwomen.scot/31/01/2022/joint-statement-in-response-to-the-ehrc-intervention/
  219. https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/media/pnbpzgex/2026csoh59-petition-of-for-women-scotland-for-judicial-review.pdf
  220. https://forwomen.scot/03/03/2022/census-action-believer-in-biology/
  221. https://forwomen.scot/01/05/2022/gender-recognition-reform-bill-survey/
  222. https://forwomen.scot/12/09/2024/statement-on-edinburgh-rape-crisis-centre/
  223. https://forwomen.scot/04/10/2024/rape-crisis-centres-by-women-and-for-women/
  224. https://forwomen.scot/03/01/2025/ehrc-code-of-practice/
  225. https://www.supremecourt.uk/uploads/uksc_2024_0042_judgment_aea6c48cee.pdf
  226. https://forwomen.scot/19/06/2026/fws-v-scottish-ministers-iii-the-judgment/
  227. https://forwomen.scot/13/07/2026/letter-to-amnesty/
  228. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Scottish-Rugby-guidance-for-non-binary-players-FWS-response-31Aug2019.pdf
  229. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Gender-Recognition-Reform-Call-for-Views-FWS-submission-16May2022.pdf
  230. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Whats-Happening-to-Your-Childs-School-Toilets.pdf
  231. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Federal-Bill-C-6-Submission-by-For-Women-Scotland.pdf
  232. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7894249/
  233. https://eld.bl.uk/catalog/100143933984_0x000001
  234. https://forwomen.scot/23/09/2024/proposed-prostitution-offences-and-support-scotland-bill/
  235. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Gender-Recognition-Reform-Bill-Consultation-FWS-response-17Mar2020.pdf
  236. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/UKGov-Conversion-Therapy-FWS-submission-04Feb2022.pdf
  237. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/FWS-to-NHS-Grampian-Equality-Consultation-10Jan2025.pdf
  238. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/FWS-response-to-Police-Scotland-sex-gender-consultation-22Jun2025.pdf
  239. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/FWS-submission-on-ending-conversion-practices-02Apr2024.pdf
  240. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/UK-Hate-Crime-FWS-response-24Dec2020.pdf
  241. https://forwomen.scot/wp-content/uploads/FWS-Petition-as-adjusted-12Dec2025.pdf
  242. https://crowdjustice.com/case/uksc-definition-of-sex-in-equality-act/
  243. https://forwomen.scot/?p=6851
  244. https://scottishlegal.com/articles/scottish-government-pays-for-women-scotland-ps147500-after-losing-case-over-definition-of-woman
  245. https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/SC716085
  246. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beira%27s_Place