![Organization: Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies [EIN 87-1196853]](assets/profiles/org_defense_of_freedom_institute_for_policy_studies.png)
Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies
A 501(c)(3) policy and legal group (IRS exempt-organization master file: Alexandria VA, exempt from 2021-12, NTEE B05 education; Form 990 filer under the name "Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies Inc"; latest return TY2025, total revenue $2,629,405). Its home page says "Our mission is to defend and advance freedom and opportunity for every American family, student, entrepreneur, and worker" (1, accessed 2026-11-11). Its About page names Robert S. Eitel as "co-founder and President" and Jim Blew as a co-founder; it lists earlier posts for both at the U.S. Department of Education (Eitel: "Senior Counselor to the Secretary of Education 2017 through 2020") and names Betsy DeVos, the Secretary, in Blew's biography (2, accessed 2026-11-11). It is on this site because it files Title IX complaints, briefs and a model law that deny trans students' identities, because it co-filed a 2025 complaint with the Liberty Justice Center, and because the Dick and Betsy DeVos Family Foundation, the Heritage Foundation and the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, each with a page here, gave it money. Its own release of 2024-10-16 carries the dateline "WASHINGTON", which is the place the foundations' grant rows use for it.
Records covered: IRS Form 990 e-file returns TY2021 to TY2025 (objects 202232659349300628, 202313049349300946, 202432979349301108, 202513219349301811, 202642309349302229; the TY2022 and TY2023 returns also appear as 202530509349301718 and 202540509349301529 with identical figures, counted once) (IRS Form 990 e-files and the IRS exempt-organization master file; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3). Form 990 (Schedule I) rows carry the recipient EIN and are matched by it. Form 990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN: they count only where the filed name and place are the Institute's own (Alexandria VA from its returns; Washington DC from its own press-release dateline), matched by name and place; names that drop "for Policy Studies" are counted as truncations of the full name.
Money received
- Revenue as filed: $1,400,026 (TY2021), $1,671,990 (TY2022), $1,705,146 (TY2023), $2,047,413 (TY2024), $2,629,405 (TY2025). Expenses as filed: $411,237, $1,538,093, $1,810,630, $2,057,161 and $2,447,435. Year-end assets: $998,270, $1,177,883, $1,103,392, $1,098,666 and $1,450,941 (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 87-1196853; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).
- Grants from donor-advised-fund sponsors and public charities, matched by recipient EIN 87-1196853 (rows as filed on the givers' returns; a grant on two returns counted once):
- National Philanthropic Trust: $1,734,500 in 3 rows (year ending 2023-06-30 $584,500, "EDUCATION"; 2024-06-30 $500,000, "HUMAN SERVICES"; 2025-06-30 $650,000, "CULTURE & ARTS").
- Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund: $600,700 in 4 rows (year ending 2022-06-30 $100,050; 2023-06-30 $100,050; 2024-06-30 $150,550; 2025-06-30 $250,050; "For grant recipient's exempt purposes"). The 2022-06-30 grant of $100,050 is on two returns and is counted once. On the first (object 202321309349304807) the row filed to the Institute's name carries the typed EIN 27-4097662, which belongs to Mission Church of Roselle, and a row of the same amount filed to "MISSION CHURCH OF ROSELLE" carries this Institute's EIN: the two EINs are swapped, and the Mission Church row is stated apart and is in no total. On the later return (202430459349302913) the row is filed to the Institute's name with this EIN.
- Donors Trust Inc (DonorsTrust): $447,250 in 2 rows (2022-12-31 $297,250; 2023-12-31 $150,000; "for general operations").
- Vanguard Charitable Endowment Program: $250,000 (year ending 2025-06-30).
- The Heritage Foundation: $100,000 (2022-12-31, purpose as filed "INNOVATION PRIZE", object 202311789349301501; filed "DEFENSE OF FREEDOM INSTITUTE", Alexandria VA).
- Bradley Impact Fund Inc (EIN 45-4678325): $35,000 (2024-12-31, "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT.").
- Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc: $50,000 in 2 rows of $25,000 (years ending 2024-06-30 and 2025-06-30, "EDUCATION"; filed under that name).
- Yes Every Kid Foundation: $10,000 (2022-12-31, "GENERAL OPERATIONS"; a giver with no page here).
- Grants from private foundations (Form 990-PF rows, matched by name and place; filed as "Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies", with the trailing word "In" on some rows, or as "Defense of Freedom Institute"):
- Dick and Betsy DeVos Family Foundation: $900,000 in 2 rows (2022-12-31 $650,000, object 202313189349102756; 2023-12-31 $250,000, object 202413209349102201; "GENERAL OPERATING"; Washington DC).
- The Searle Freedom Trust: $1,200,000 in 3 rows (2022-12-31 $500,000; 2023-12-31 $350,000; 2024-12-31 $350,000; "EDUCATION AND OUTREACH"; Alexandria VA; filed "Defense of Freedom Institute").
- Beth and Ravenel Curry Foundation (EIN 23-7411083, the foundation that has a page under the name Ravenel and Elizabeth Curry Foundation): $425,000 in 3 rows (2022-12-31 $100,000; 2023-12-31 $150,000; 2024-12-31 $175,000; "UNRESTRICTED"; Washington DC; filed "Defense of Freedom Institute").
- Sarah Scaife Foundation Incorporated: $225,000 in 2 rows (2023-12-31 $100,000; 2024-12-31 $125,000; "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT"; Washington DC).
- The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation Inc: $150,000 in 3 rows of $50,000 (2022-12-31, 2023-12-31 and 2024-12-31; "To support general operations"; Alexandria VA).
- Thomas W Smith Foundation Inc: $150,000 (2025-12-31, "PUBLIC POLICY"; Washington; filed "Defense of Freedom Institute").
- John William Pope Foundation: $45,000 in 2 rows (year ending 2022-06-30 $20,000; 2023-06-30 $25,000; "UNRESTRICTED").
- Adolph Coors Foundation: $25,000 (2023-11-30, "GENERAL OPERATING GRANT"; Alexandria VA; filed "Defense of Freedom Institute").
- Daniels Fund: $500,000 in 2 rows (2023-12-31 and 2024-12-31, $250,000 each; "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT"; a giver with no page here); National School Choice Awareness Foundation Inc (the giver's own EIN 87-2081402) $3,000 (Form 990-PF for the year ended 2025-03-31, object 202503189349103100, one row filed to "Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies", Alexandria VA, purpose as filed "SUPPORT EDUCATION AWARENESS EVENTS"; the row carries no recipient EIN, so it is matched by name and place; 4).
- The returns of the foundations list the rows with year-end dates; the dates above are the dates the returns give.
- Google political advertising: the transparency data list "Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies, Inc." (EIN 87-1196853) as an advertiser from 2025-03-30 to 2026-11-01, 19 creatives, 21 weeks with spend, a total-spend field of $900 and 21 weekly rows of $100 each, which sum to $2,100; the two figures do not agree and are given as the data publish them, neither adjusted to the other (Google Political Ads Transparency Report data as downloaded 2026-11-08, 5).
Money given
- Contractor payment as filed: Choice Education Services (Valencia CA), "CONSULTING", $108,375 (TY2023; the row is on two returns, objects 202432979349301108 and 202540509349301529, and is counted once) (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 87-1196853; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).
People on file
- Robert S. Eitel: President and secretary on every return TY2021 to TY2025, reported compensation $145,833 (TY2021), $246,614 (TY2022), $270,000 (TY2023), $332,031 (TY2024) and $303,016 (TY2025). The Institute's About page presents him as "co-founder and President" (2, accessed 2026-11-17).
- Jim Blew: vice president and treasurer on every return, reported compensation $72,917 (TY2021), $123,308 (TY2022), $0 (TY2023), $267,301 (TY2024) and $242,878 (TY2025); the About page presents him as a co-founder (2, accessed 2026-11-17).
- Other officers, directors and staff are on the returns by role only (a chairman, directors, senior counsel, a senior fellow, policy and legal staff; compensation of $111,490 to $175,928 for staff in TY2024 and TY2025); no public source presents them in a role, so none is named. The Institute's own About page (2, accessed 2026-11-18) lists a team: Virginia (Ginny) Gentles, Education Freedom and Parental Rights Director; Jay P. Greene, Senior Fellow; Paul Zimmerman, Senior Counsel, Policy & Regulatory; Angela Morabito, Director of Media Outreach and Spokesperson; Clairece Marker, Digital Media Manager; Jesse Stiller, Communications Associate; Trisha Ruckart, Director of Operations and Development; Holly Pitt Young, Chief Development Officer. The page lists no board.
Anti-trans work: documented moments
- 2022-09-11 (posted 2022-11-08): DFI filed a public submission on the Education Department's proposed Title IX rule (docket ED-2021-OCR-0166). It objects to redefining "sex" to include "gender identity, sexual orientation, sex stereotypes, sex characteristics, and pregnancy or related conditions," and lists among its objections that the rule would "fail to assure the reasonable privacy and safety interests of female students (in the use of restrooms, locker rooms, and other intimate facilities)" and would require "transgender (i.e., biological male) participation in those female-only athletic activities". "Transgender (i.e., biological male)" denies trans students' identities, and presenting their use of restrooms, locker rooms and sports as a threat to female students is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric (6).
- 2023-01-30: DFI filed an amicus brief in the Sixth Circuit appeal (No. 22-5807); Alliance Defending Freedom reproduced it among its exhibits to its comment of 2023-05-15 (7).
- 2023-03-30: DFI's release "DFI supports female athletes in legal battle for recognition after they were forced to compete against men in violation of Title IX" says DFI filed an amicus brief in the Connecticut girls' track case and describes the athletic association's policy as one that "allows males who identify as female to compete in girls' athletic events". It quotes Eitel saying the Biden administration and others have "contorted Title IX to advance a radical gender ideology that would make Title IX unrecognizable". "Males who identify as female" and "radical gender ideology" deny trans girls' and women's identities and are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric (8, accessed 2026-11-11).
- 2023-05-15 (posted 2023-05-18): DFI filed a submission on the proposed athletics rule (docket ED-2022-OCR-0143), arguing that Congress, not the Department, has authority over "participation in sports on the basis of one's gender identity" (9).
- 2024-09-19 and 2024-09-20: DFI's release says it filed a brief on 2024-09-19 as co-counsel for the States of Louisiana, Mississippi, Idaho and Montana in Louisiana v. U.S. Department of Education, on appeal at the Fifth Circuit from a preliminary injunction against the 2024 Title IX regulations, and says the regulations expand Title IX "to include 'gender identity'"; the release says DFI argued in a Tennessee amicus brief that the administration "does not have the legal authority to rewrite Title IX to include 'gender identity'" (10, accessed 2026-11-11).
- 2024-10-16: DFI's release says it filed an amicus brief supporting Kansas, Alaska, Utah and Wyoming in State of Kansas v. U.S. Department of Education at the Tenth Circuit, and that it represents Mississippi, Louisiana, Montana and Idaho in the Louisiana case; it quotes Eitel: "If a man can be a woman, then the entire point of Title IX" is undermined. "If a man can be a woman" denies trans women's identities and is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric (11, accessed 2026-11-11).
- 2025-03-18: DFI and the Liberty Justice Center filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights against the Illinois State Board of Education and Chicago Public Schools. The Center's page, headed "Complaint Against the Illinois State Board of Education and Chicago Public Schools Arising from 'Gender Identity' Policies and Practices in Violation of Title IX", says the filers allege the bodies are "forcing students to share bathrooms, locker rooms, and overnight accommodations with members of the opposite sex" (12, accessed 2026-11-11). "Members of the opposite sex" denies trans students' identities; it is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. 2025-03-20: the Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights (Denver office) wrote to the Illinois State Board of Education and to Chicago Public Schools that it had received on 2025-03-18 a complaint alleging that they have policies that "force students to share intimate facilities, including restrooms, locker rooms, and overnight accommodations, with members of the opposite sex" and, under its case numbers 05-25-4050 (State Board) and 05-25-1447 (Chicago Public Schools), opened an investigation; the letter adds that the opening "is not itself evidence of a violation" and sent a data request due 2025-04-09. The letter names neither the Defense of Freedom Institute nor the Liberty Justice Center; the complaint it describes is the one of 2025-03-18 above (same date, same bodies, same allegation). (Office for Civil Rights letter of 2025-03-20 as forwarded within the State Board on 2025-03-21 and published on the Institute's website, 13) "Members of the opposite sex" denies trans students' identities and is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric; the letter repeats the complaint's wording as an allegation.
- 2025 (undated page; linked files dated May 2025): DFI publishes "The RESPECT Title IX Act" (Respect Equality in Sports, Privacy, and Education and Campus Transparency Act), a model law it presents as a way to make Title IX changes permanent. The page says schools and colleges would keep girls' sports, locker rooms and bathrooms separate on the basis of "binary, biological sex—not gender identity". "Binary, biological sex—not gender identity" denies trans people's identities and is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric (14, accessed 2026-11-11).
- 2026-01-22: DFI's release says it filed an amicus brief asking a federal court to uphold the Education Department's decision to end Magnet Schools Assistance Program funding to New York City public schools, and says the city's "Guidelines on Gender Identity" go beyond Title IX's limits and conflict with a reading of Title IX as protecting against discrimination based on biological sex (15, accessed 2026-11-11).
- 2026-09-25: Southeastern Legal Foundation's case page for the New York suit lists Defense of Freedom Institute among four amicus organizations (as recorded on that foundation's page here).
- Outcome of the appeals over the 2024 Title IX rule (Clearinghouse's docket summaries, a secondary source): in Louisiana v. U.S. Department of Education (Fifth Circuit No. 24-30399) the court denied the government's partial stay 2-1 on 2024-07-17, the parties filed a joint motion to dismiss the appeal on 2025-03-13 and the appeal was dismissed with prejudice on 2025-03-14, with no merits opinion; the only court relief on the rule on the docket was the district court's preliminary injunction of 2024-06-13 (Louisiana, Mississippi, Montana, Idaho), and the court stayed the case on 2025-05-01; the docket also records the Supreme Court's denial of the stay applications on 2024-08-16 (No. 24A78). In State of Kansas v. U.S. Department of Education (Tenth Circuit No. 24-3097) the appeal was dismissed on 2025-03-13, with no merits opinion (see the court's own order, below); on 2025-03-21 (this date rests on the docket summary text) the district court ordered the parties to show cause why the case should not be dismissed as moot. (16 and 17; neither shows a court opinion on the rule.) The courts' own orders: the Fifth Circuit's order in No. 24-30399, filed 2025-03-14, reads: "IT IS ORDERED that the joint motion to dismiss the appeal under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 42(b)(1) is GRANTED. The appeal is DISMISSED with prejudice. Each party bears its own costs." (unpublished order, Smith, Willett and Douglas, Circuit Judges; 18). The Tenth Circuit's order in No. 24-3097 of 2025-03-13 reads: "The stipulation filed by the parties to dismiss the captioned appeal is granted. See Fed. R. App. P. 42(b)(1). Each party shall bear its own costs. A copy of this order shall stand as and for the mandate of this court." (Doc. 333; the clerk's letter of the same day, Doc. 334, says the order dismissed the case and the mandate issued that day). The dismissal was on the parties' joint stipulation (Doc. 331), not on the defendants' request, as Clearinghouse's docket summary has it; the Institute is listed in the caption of the order. (US Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, No. 24-3097, 19)
- 2026-06-08: the plaintiffs in Louisiana v. U.S. Department of Education (W.D. La. No. 3:24-cv-00563, lead case) filed a notice of voluntary dismissal under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(i) (Doc. 100). It says the consolidated cases challenged the 2024 Title IX rule, had been stayed since May 2025 (the order of 2025-05-01, Doc. 92, stayed them pending Carroll Independent School District v. U.S. Department of Education, N.D. Tex. No. 4:24-cv-00461, and Tennessee v. Cardona, E.D. Ky. No. 2:24-072) "pending resolution of appeals in two related cases that resulted in final judgment vacating that regulation" (Tennessee v. McMahon, Sixth Circuit Nos. 25-5205 and 25-5206; Carroll Independent School District v. U.S. Department of Education, Fifth Circuit No. 25-10651), that "Both related appeals have now been voluntarily dismissed", and that "Because the dismissal of these appeals means the underlying judgments vacating the 2024 Title IX Rule are final, this case is now moot." The Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies is listed as counsel for the plaintiff States. The notice is a filing by the plaintiffs. (US District Court, W.D. La., No. 3:24-cv-00563-TAD-KDM, Doc. 100, 2026-06-08, filed on the Louisiana Attorney General's website, 20; stay order Doc. 92, 21) The Louisiana Attorney General's release says the State filed a notice of voluntary dismissal after the remaining appeals were dismissed and quotes the Attorney General: "I'm dismissing that suit because the Biden Title IX Rule is finally and completely dead" (22); the release gives no court order. Alliance Defending Freedom's case page lists a Notice of Voluntary Dismissal dated 2026-06-08 and says "the case was dismissed as moot" (23) without stating an order. The docket record of State of Louisiana v. U.S. Department of Education, U.S. District Court, W.D. Louisiana, No. 3:24-cv-00563 (filed 2024-04-29; nature of suit "899 Other Statutes: Administrative Procedures Act/Review or Appeal of Agency Decision"), gives 2026-06-08, the date of the plaintiffs' notice of voluntary dismissal, as the date of its last filing, and records no termination date (CourtListener docket record as of 2026-09-30, 24). The record does not say whether the clerk closed the case on the notice. The Institute's "Guide to the New Title IX Rule" (25, accessed 2026-11-16) lists Kansas and Louisiana under "Blocked by statewide preliminary injunctions", mentions no vacatur and no dismissal, and shows no update date. The Institute's news listing (26, pages 1 to 6, accessed 2026-11-16) runs from 2024-06-13 to 2026-11-03; none of its items reports the March 2025 dismissals of the Fifth and Tenth Circuit appeals or the notice of 2026-06-08. The Institute's release of 2026-04-20 on the Department of Education's findings after its complaints (27) is the only item of that list on the Department's findings in Kansas (see the entry of 2026-04-20).
- 2026-06-11: in State of Kansas et al. v. United States Department of Education et al., No. 5:24-cv-04041-JWB-ADM (D. Kan.), the parties filed a "Joint Stipulation to Dismiss" on 2026-06-11 (Document 114) "pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii) without prejudice with each party to bear its own attorneys' fees and costs". It recites that the Final Rule had been vacated by two district courts (Tennessee v. Cardona, E.D. Ky., 2025-01-09; Carroll ISD v. U.S. Department of Education, N.D. Tex., 2025-02-19), that the Kansas court had issued a show-cause order on 2025-03-21 and the parties had agreed on 2025-06-25 to a stay pending the intervenors' appeals, that those appeals were dismissed (Sixth Circuit, 2026-05-13; Fifth Circuit, 2026-05-19), and that "the parties maintain that the at-issue case is now moot warranting dismissal" (28, 5 pages). Alliance Defending Freedom's case page records "June 2026: The state of Kansas, ADF, and the U.S. Department of Education agreed to dismiss the case" (29). Status: dismissed by stipulation filed 2026-06-11.
- 2025-04-07: DFI's release says it filed a Title IX complaint with the Office for Civil Rights against the Minnesota Department of Education, Minneapolis Public Schools and Saint Paul Public Schools, alleging that their gender-identity policies make students share "locker rooms, bathrooms, and overnight sleeping quarters with members of the opposite sex" (the release as summarised: Minneapolis's June 2024 "Gender Inclusion" policy gives access "consistent with the student's gender identity"; Saint Paul assigns overnight roommates by gender "as listed on the District's student information system"). It quotes Eitel: "Congress enacted Title IX to bar discrimination in education on the basis of sex, not gender identity." It asks the Office to investigate and, if necessary, end federal funds. The release states no fact about any named student and reports no outcome. "Members of the opposite sex" denies trans students' identities and is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. (30)
- 2025-09-16: the Acting Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights wrote to the president of the Chicago Board of Education that Chicago Public Schools' "Guidelines Regarding the Support of Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Students" are "facially discriminatory on the basis of sex in violation of Title IX" (letter, p. 2), that "As a result of these findings, I will not certify CPS' grant under 20 U.S.C. § 7231d(c)" and the district's magnet-school grant would not be continued (p. 3), and required, among other steps, that the district "Adopt biology-based definitions for the words 'male' and 'female'" and keep locker rooms and bathrooms "strictly separated on the basis of sex" (p. 4). The same letter makes a separate race-discrimination finding about the district's Black Students Success Plan. It does not cite case numbers 05-25-4050 or 05-25-1447 or name the Institute, so it is not shown to be the outcome of the complaint of 2025-03-18; Chalkbeat's report of 2025-09-17 says the Department opened its transgender-related investigation in March 2025 covering Chicago Public Schools, the Illinois State Board of Education and Deerfield District 109, without saying what prompted it. The letter concerns Chicago Public Schools only. The letter's phrase "trans-identifying" males treated "as if they were 'females'" denies trans students' identities and is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric; the Department's authorship does not make it otherwise. (Letter of 2025-09-16 as published by Chalkbeat, 31, read pp. 1-4; Chalkbeat, 32)
- 2025-09-24 (the complaint's own date; news report dated 2025-09-25): DFI filed a Title IX complaint with the Office for Civil Rights against Fairfax County Public Schools for a freshman girl and her mother, alleging that a sophomore, whom the school says identifies as female, entered the girls' locker room at their high school several times during physical education and that administrators said district policy kept them from barring the student. Fox 5 DC reports that the school system said it had not received a complaint from the Department of Education, was working with the students and families, and could not comment because of student confidentiality, and that the Department had not publicly responded. These are the complainant's allegations as reported; the students are minors and are not named. The framing treats a trans student's use of a locker room as a harm to another student, which is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. (33) The Office for Civil Rights' District of Columbia office notified the Institute on 2025-09-29 that it had received the complaint of 2025-09-24, which the Office carries as case No. 11-25-1848. On 2025-11-18 the Institute sent that office a supplement to the case, disputing the school's own finding of 2025-10-13 that the matter was "unfounded" and asking the Office to find that the district violated Title IX; the supplement is the Institute's account, the student is a minor and neither she nor her family is named here, and the supplement does not say the Office has opened an investigation. (Defense of Freedom Institute, "Supplemental Facts Relating to Case No. 11-25-1848 (Fairfax County Public Schools)", 2025-11-18, to the Office for Civil Rights, District of Columbia office, published on the Institute's website.)
- Fairfax County Public Schools, earlier federal action: Fairfax County Public Schools were already one of the five Northern Virginia divisions that the Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights found in violation of Title IX on 2025-07-25 (FFXnow, 2025-07-25, and K-12 Dive, 2025-08-20: Alexandria City, Arlington, Fairfax County, Loudoun County and Prince William County; the proposed resolution agreement asked each to rescind policies on use of "intimate facilities" by gender identity, notify schools, and adopt the federal definitions of "male" and "female"). Education Week (August 2025) reports that the divisions refused to sign by 2025-08-15 and that the Department placed them on "high-risk" status on 2025-08-19; K-12 Dive (2025-08-20) says the placement came "on Tuesday" (2025-08-19). DFI's complaint is dated 2025-09-24, after both. FFXnow and K-12 Dive (2025-08-20) both credit America First Legal: K-12 Dive says AFL filed a complaint with the Office for Civil Rights against the five divisions earlier in 2025 and "had asked the department in its February complaint to 'cut off all federal funding' if necessary." Fox 5 DC's report of 2025-09-25 (see the entry of 2025-09-24 above) says the school system had received no complaint from the Department about the locker-room allegation.
- 2026-04-20: DFI's release says the Education Department's Office for Civil Rights and Student Privacy Policy Office found, on complaints DFI filed about four Kansas school districts, violations of the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act in all four districts (policies that let staff keep a student's pronouns or preferred name from parents) and of Title IX in Kansas City (Kansas), Topeka, Olathe and Shawnee Mission (policies on restrooms, locker rooms and changing rooms by gender identity, and for the first two also sports); the release says each district must take corrective action or risk further enforcement. (34; the findings are given as DFI states them. The complaint letter of 2025-06-24 brings Title IX against three of the districts and names Olathe under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (see the entry of 2025-06-24); its subject line, like DFI's release of 2025-06-24, names all four districts, and DFI's release of 2026-04-20 quotes the Department's finding that Olathe Public Schools violated Title IX.)
- 2026-02-23: Southeastern Legal Foundation and DFI filed a joint supplemental complaint with the Office for Civil Rights against Shawnee Mission School District, Kansas, for Kansas parents and their elementary-school-age daughter, challenging district policies ("Code AC" and a "Transgender Practices + FAQ" document) that let students use sex-separated facilities by gender identity and call for "preferred" names and pronouns. The page says a first-grade girl met "a biological male identifying as female" in the girls' restroom, was distressed and was moved to a staff bathroom, and says the policies infringe student speech. It quotes SLF's Kim Hermann and DFI's Bob Eitel; it names no attorney and reports no finding. The page treats a trans child's use of a restroom as an injury to another child, which is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric; it states no fact about the other child's conduct. (35)
- State bills: DFI's own page presents the RESPECT Title IX Act as a federal model law for Congress to enact (documents dated May 2025; the page states no release date), with a summary and an annotated text (36); the resources listing on dfipolicy.org shows federal documents only.
- DFI's own letter of 2025-02-18 to the Director of the White House Office of Legislative Affairs, written with Parents Defending Education, says (PDF from 37): DFI and PDE "filed separate lawsuits against the Biden Administration's 2024 Title IX rule, which illegally redefined the law to prohibit discrimination on the basis of 'gender identity' and to force schools to allow biological males to access intimate facilities designated for women and girls", that their litigation "obtained preliminary injunctions against implementation of that rule in a total of eight states before the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky ultimately vacated the rule entirely on January 9, 2025" (State of Tennessee v. Cardona, E.D. Ky.), and thanks the President for Executive Order 14168, writing "to express our deep appreciation of President Trump’s landmark executive action to protect women and girls from the harms of gender ideology in American education" (p. 2). Its footnote 1 names the two orders: State of Louisiana v. U.S. Department of Education (W.D. La., 2024-06-13; Louisiana, Mississippi, Montana, Idaho) and State of Alabama v. U.S. Secretary of Education (11th Cir., 2024-08-22; Alabama, Florida, Georgia, South Carolina). The phrases "force schools to allow biological males" and "harms of gender ideology" deny trans students' identities and are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. Source: 38 (the file name spells the surname "Baird"; the letter text reads "Braid").
- Four DFI complaint letters, each read as the PDF on dfipolicy.org:
- 2025-03-03: with the California Justice Center, APC, a complaint to the Office for Civil Rights against the California Department of Education, Los Angeles Unified, San Francisco Unified and Capistrano Unified School Districts, "Arising from 'Gender Identity' Policies and Practices in Violation of Title IX"; it says students are required "to share intimate facilities with members of the opposite sex" and asks for investigation and, if needed, withdrawal of federal funding (39). "Members of the opposite sex" denies trans students' identities and is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric.
- 2025-06-24: the original complaint on Kansas (Shawnee Mission USD 512, Kansas City Kansas USD 500, Topeka USD 501 under Title IX; those three and Olathe USD 233 under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, over staff keeping a student's chosen name and pronouns from parents; the letter's subject line names all four districts "in Violation of Title IX and FERPA"), sent to the Office for Civil Rights and the Student Privacy Policy Office; it asks for sanctions and notice that failure will bring withdrawal of federal funding (40). This is the complaint on which the findings of 2026-04-20 (see that entry above) rest. The Kansas Reflector (Grace Hills, 2026-03-10, via States Newsroom) says the Department confirmed an ongoing Title IX investigation of Shawnee Mission School District and that DFI's complaint prompted it. The Institute's release of 2025-06-24 says the Kansas Attorney General sent a letter to the Department of Education asking its Office for Civil Rights to investigate the Institute's Title IX complaint against the Shawnee Mission, Kansas City, Olathe and Topeka districts, while the Institute separately notified the Student Privacy Policy Office of possible violations of the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act; it quotes Eitel: "These districts are flouting both laws in pursuit of a radical gender ideology." The release quotes no statement of the Attorney General and reports no outcome; the findings of 2026-04-20 are above. "Radical gender ideology" is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. (41)
- 2025-09-24: the Fairfax County Public Schools complaint is dated 2025-09-24; it is filed for a freshman at a Fairfax County public high school and her parent, the student unnamed; it asks that the Office put the district "on clear notice" and demands "immediately restoring sex-separated access by its students to its locker rooms and other intimate facilities" (42). The letter is of a minor and is not quoted further.
- 2026-09-11: complaints on four undergraduate women's colleges, described below.
- DFI sent four letters dated 2026-09-11 to the Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights and the Chief Operating Officer of Federal Student Aid, one each on Agnes Scott College, Bryn Mawr College, Stephens College and Wesleyan College (the Bryn Mawr and Stephens letters read in full as PDFs; the Agnes Scott and Wesleyan letters also read in full as PDFs (see the next item); The Federalist's report says Agnes Scott's policy covers trans men, while the letters speak of "men who identify as female"). Each says the college holds itself out as a women's college while admitting students who identify as women, and asks for action under Title IX and under Title IV of the Higher Education Act (misrepresentation, which bears on federal student aid eligibility) (DFI's letters of 2026-09-11, linked in this item and the next). The Bryn Mawr letter says the college "allows biological men who identify as female to enroll in the institution, use women's intimate housing and facilities, and participate on women's athletic teams" (43). The Federalist (Breccan F. Thies, 2026-09-14, 44) quotes Robert Eitel: "these schools have willingly sacrificed this unique identity on the altar of gender identity", and reports no Office response; the article's own wording calls trans men "actually women claiming to be men", which is the outlet's language and not DFI's. Source also: 45 (Stephens College, Columbia MO).
- The Agnes Scott and Wesleyan letters of 2026-09-11, read in full: The Agnes Scott and Wesleyan letters are the PDFs at 46 (21 pages) and 47 (20 pages), addresses taken from The Federalist's report of 2026-09-14. Both are dated September 11, 2026, are addressed to Kimberly M. Richey, Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights, and Richard Lucas, Chief Operating Officer of Federal Student Aid, are headed "Policies and Practices of [college] in Violation of Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 and Title IV of the Higher Education Act", and are signed by two DFI senior counsel (Litigation; Policy & Regulatory). Each says "DFI brings this federal civil rights complaint" under Title IX and asks the Office and Federal Student Aid to investigate, "consider potential sanctions" and "place the College on clear notice that failure to comply will result in the limitation, suspension, or termination of federal funding" (Agnes Scott letter p. 3); the conclusion asks Federal Student Aid for a "program review" and, failing corrective action, proceedings to "suspend, limit, revoke, and/or terminate federal financial assistance". The Title IV claim is "substantial misrepresentation": a college that calls itself a women's college misleads applicants, "including taking on federal student loan debt" (p. 2).
- Agnes Scott College (Decatur, Georgia): the letter quotes the college's Undergraduate Admissions Policy, which admits "students who were assigned female at birth as well as those who were assigned male or female at birth who now identify as female, transgender, agender, genderfluid, or non-binary" and says "The college does not admit individuals who were assigned male at birth and continue to identify as male"; it is "proud of the women, trans women, trans men and non-binary individuals who have enrolled" (p. 6). The letter says the policy dates, "to our knowledge", from the Board of Trustees in May 2015. It quotes the athletics handbook (updated July 2023): "Transgender student-athletes may use the locker room, bathrooms and showers in accordance with their gender identity" (p. 8). It calls the policy "radical gender ideology" and says it lets "male applicants claiming a female 'identity'" "invade women's spaces on campus"; the factual section ends "Agnes Scott has freely chosen to sacrifice on the altar of gender identity its own identity" (p. 9). It cites as the Department's own work "U.S. Department of Education Opens Title IX Investigation into All-Women's Smith College for Admitting Men," dated May 4, 2026 (footnote 3, p. 3). These are DFI's allegations: "radical gender ideology", "male applicants claiming a female 'identity'" and "invade women's spaces" deny the identity of trans women and are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric.
- Wesleyan College (Macon, Georgia): the letter quotes the college's 2024-2025 catalog: "Wesleyan will consider for admission all applicants who live and identify as women, regardless of biological sex, or who were assigned female at birth and identify as nonbinary or gender non-conforming if they feel they belong at a women's college" (p. 6), and says the policy does not affect students who transition while enrolled. It argues that because most dormitories have shared bathrooms "female students are forced to share living and intimate spaces with members of the opposite sex" (p. 7) and that a student who objects "could be subject to discipline" under a nondiscrimination policy covering "gender identity" and "gender expression". It uses "radical gender ideology" for the college's definitions of gender (p. 7). It says, "to our knowledge", that the policies are still in place. These are DFI's allegations: "radical gender ideology" and "members of the opposite sex" deny the identity of trans women and are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric.
- These are DFI's allegations in letters to the Department, not findings. "Biological men", "members of the opposite sex" and "radical gender ideology" deny the identity of trans women and are anti-trans rhetoric.
- DFI says in the same letter of 2025-02-18 (above) that it prepared the model law, "with essential assistance and contributions from PDE", and encloses it "to help you execute your responsibility under Section 6 of EO 14168 to prepare legislative text incorporating these definitions", which is the order's instruction to the Assistant to the President for Legislative Affairs to present bill text to the President; the letter does not mention any state. It defines "sex" as "an individual's immutable biological classification as either male or female, as opposed to one's perceived 'gender identity'" and would revoke agencies' authority to issue Title IX rules. The Federalist (Breccan F. Thies, 2025-05-19, 48) frames it for Congress, quoting Eitel that the whiplash continues "unless Congress acts", and names no state bill or sponsor. The Act is a model for Congress, as DFI's letter and the Federalist piece present it. The definition's wording "as opposed to one's perceived 'gender identity'" treats trans people's gender identity as a perception; it denies trans identities and is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric.
- California and Minnesota complaints, other federal action: None of the sources cited shows what the Office for Civil Rights did with DFI's California (2025-03-03) or Minnesota (2025-04-07) complaints. What was found is other federal action: the Department found the California Department of Education and the California Interscholastic Federation in violation of Title IX on 2025-06-25 after an investigation announced in April 2025 (K-12 Dive, 2025-06-25), issued a proposed resolution agreement of 2025-06-25 that both rejected on 2025-07-07, and the Justice Department sued on 2025-07-09 (Lozano Smith client brief, 2025-07-28); none of those pages names DFI, the California Justice Center, or Los Angeles, San Francisco or Capistrano Unified. The Justice Department notified Los Angeles Unified by a letter dated 2026-03-25 of an investigation of its policy that lets schools decide whether to tell parents about a student's gender identity; GV Wire (2026-04-08) says documents reviewed by the New York Times show the investigation was sparked by a parents' lawsuit (a separate student complaint is also part of the investigation), and does not mention the Institute or the California Justice Center. It is not shown to concern the complaint of 2025-03-03 (49). For Minnesota, a joint Education Department and Health and Human Services finding against the Minnesota Department of Education and the state high-school league was announced on the Tuesday before 2025-10-01, that is 2025-09-30 (Valley News Live, 2025-10-01). The report says the Education Department's Office for Civil Rights had opened its investigation after the League stated it would not follow President Trump's February 2025 executive order, that in June 2025 the Department elevated its existing investigations and the Health and Human Services Department opened a compliance review after a high-school softball match, and that the two bodies were given 10 days to resolve the violations. The report does not mention Minneapolis Public Schools, Saint Paul Public Schools or the Institute, so the finding is not shown to arise from the Institute's complaint of 2025-04-07 (50). None of the three complaints is shown to have been opened, closed or merged into those matters.
- Department response to the four college complaints: DFI's news page (26) lists items to 2026-11-03; the only item on the four colleges is its press release of 2026-09-14, "DFI Urges the Education Department to Investigate Four Women's Colleges for Violating Title IX and Engaging in Substantial Misrepresentations to the Public" (51). It says DFI "is urging OCR to open an investigation under Title IX" and "FSA to conduct a program review under Title IV... of each institution", conditioned on "Failing immediate corrective action by the colleges", and states no Department action. The Department announced a Title IX investigation of Smith College on 2026-05-04, on a Defending Education complaint of 2025-06-20 (the release is cited in footnote 3 of the Agnes Scott letter, above). As of 2026-11-12 DFI's news page reports no Department action on the four complaints. 2026-09-14 is the date of DFI's release, which says the complaints were filed "Today"; no earlier letter date is stated on the page.
- 2026-10-20: DFI's press release "DFI urges Supreme Court to protect parental rights and reject qualified immunity claim for California government officials who proceeded with gender surgery on minor without parental consent" (title as the news listing gives it, shortened at the end of the address) announces an amicus brief in a petition for certiorari, Supreme Court No. 26-180, from the Ninth Circuit (lower-court No. 24-7360). The petitioner is a parent in a custody dispute and is not named here; the child is a minor and is not named. The release says, as an account of the complaint, that officials at the University of California, San Francisco proceeded with a gender-transition-related surgery on the minor despite a custody order that gave the father authority over that decision. It says the Ninth Circuit granted the officials qualified immunity because the father had not identified clearly established law on sufficiently similar circumstances, and that DFI argues the officials, unlike officers facing an emergency, had time to seek court authorization for an elective procedure. It names Don Daugherty, DFI senior litigation counsel, as its spokesman and says the brief builds on DFI's amicus brief in the Montgomery County curriculum case (Supreme Court No. 24-297). The release gives no docket number and describes no ruling on the merits. (52; DFI's news listing 53) No source reviewed here establishes that the surgery occurred as alleged: the release states allegations, and the Ninth Circuit decided on qualified immunity. DFI uses the phrase "gender surgery on a minor", an anti-trans framing of what is a rare event, in an argument about officials' immunity.
- 2026-10-19: DFI's own brief in Supreme Court No. 26-180 was reviewed: "Brief of Amicus Curiae Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies in Support of Petitioner", dated 2026-10-19, with DFI's own staff as counsel of record (cover). Its statement of interest says DFI "focuses on protecting parental rights like those threatened in this case" and cites DFI's amicus brief in No. 24-297 and DFI testimony to a House subcommittee hearing of 2026-02-10 (p. 1). It argues that the officials "blew past a specific parental right... expressly carved out in an enforceable court order to perform life-altering, elective surgery on a minor, assuming qualified immunity would forgive them later" (summary of argument), that the surgery "was elective, and could have waited until Minor reached the age of maturity" (p. 8), and that nothing shows the officials "ever bothered to try to get a court order that would have authorized them to perform the surgery" (p. 15). It closes: "this Court should grant his petition" (p. 17). The brief also quotes the Ninth Circuit as having said that "it was not clear the implant procedure fell within Provision 7b's 'surgery' exception in the custody order" (p. 15, quoting the Ninth Circuit's 2025 decision), so the lower court treated the dispute as one over whether an implant procedure was "surgery" under a custody order; DFI's release and headline call the event "gender surgery on minor". Footnote 3 (p. 8) says the argument "often put to parents for performing gender transition procedures on their minor-children... that it is better to have a live son/daughter than a dead daughter/son" is "a pernicious, false dichotomy", and cites the Cass Review of 2024 for the statement that a conclusion that gender-affirming treatment reduces suicide risk "was not support[ed] by the [Cass] systematic review". That is anti-trans rhetoric that disputes suicide risk and leans on the Cass Review: the evidence brief sets low certainty ratings in a field where randomized trials are widely considered unethical and low certainty ratings are common across pediatric medicine, and sets against the Cass Review its published methodological critiques (the peer-reviewed ROBIS appraisal of the seven reviews commissioned for it, rated at high risk of bias, and the Yale Integrity Project paper). The brief does not describe a ruling on the merits. (Supreme Court of the United States, No. 26-180, brief of amicus curiae Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies, 2026-10-19, pp. 1, 8, 15, 17; docket 54; the brief accessed 2026-11-14.) Support resources for this entry: If you or someone you know is thinking about suicide, the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline can be reached by calling or texting 988 or by chat at 988lifeline.org, and the Trevor Project's crisis line for LGBTQ+ young people is 1-866-488-7386, by text (START to 678-678) or by chat at 55 (both free and open at all hours; contact details checked 2026-11-14).
- Supreme Court No. 26-180, the docket: The Supreme Court docket for No. 26-180 (docketed 2026-08-10; petition filed 2026-08-07; Ninth Circuit decision 2025-10-21, rehearing denied 2026-03-11) lists amicus briefs by NC Values Institute (2026-08-26); Sutherland Institute, Independent Women's Law Center et al., American College of Pediatricians and Our Duty-USA et al. (2026-09-09); and on 2026-10-19 Thomas More Society, Do No Harm Inc., Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies, International Partners for Ethical Care, Genspect-USA et al., America's Frontline Doctors et al. and Dr. Leor Sapir. The respondents' response is due 2026-11-18 (extension granted 2026-09-25); the docket shows no order on the petition as of its last entry (2026-10-19). DFI's brief is listed under 2026-10-19; its release is dated 2026-10-20. (Supreme Court of the United States docket No. 26-180, 56) The petition was distributed for the conference of 2026-10-09 on 2026-09-16 and the Court requested a response on 2026-09-17; the petition has not been acted on. Twelve anti-trans organizations and individuals, DFI among them, filed amicus briefs on one docket; each is on its own page where it has one. As of 2026-11-17 the latest entry is still 2026-10-19 (amicus briefs), the respondents' response is due 2026-11-18 (extension granted 2026-09-25), and the docket shows no response, no order and no new distribution for conference. (Supreme Court of the United States docket No. 26-180, 54, accessed 2026-11-17.)
- 2025-07-07: DFI is named, as one of 39 amici (Advancing American Freedom, Inc. and 38 other organizations and individuals), on the brief of Advancing American Freedom, Inc. and others supporting a parent (the plaintiff-appellant) in the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 24-3278 (appeal from D.N.J. No. 3:24-cv-00107). The parent sued a regional high school board, a superintendent and a school counselor over what he alleges was the school's social transition of his minor child without his knowledge. DFI appears on the cover list ("Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies, Inc.", p. 1) and in the statement of interest (ECF p. 12), which says the amici "believe that the fundamental right of parents to direct the upbringing of their children is essential to liberty and is deeply rooted in American tradition and practice"; the statement gives no separate interest for DFI. The brief asks the court to "rule for plaintiff-appellant" (ECF p. 34). It is limited to a minor's social transition at school. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom, Inc. and others in Support of Plaintiff-Appellant, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 24-3278, 2025-07-07, ECF pp. 1, 12, 34; read as a PDF hosted by the plaintiff-side organization.)
- 2025-06-27: In the Montgomery County curriculum case (Supreme Court No. 24-297), the Court's opinion lists the Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies, with others ("et al."), among the amici curiae urging reversal (p. 8). What the brief argued is not stated here. Parents in Montgomery County, Maryland, asked for a preliminary injunction requiring notice and opt-outs from instruction using LGBTQ+-inclusive elementary school storybooks, among them books with a transgender child. The Court, 6-3, held that the parents are likely to succeed on a free exercise claim, reversed the Fourth Circuit and remanded, and held that, until all appellate review is completed, the board should be ordered to give advance notice and allow opt-outs from those books and any similar book (pp. 26, 49-50). The Supreme Court's holding of 2025-06-27 stands; the case ended in the district court with a consented judgment and permanent injunction entered on 2026-02-19, according to a case summary on Clearinghouse. (606 U.S. 522 (2025) (United States Reports, preliminary print, vol. 606, part 2, pp. 522-655), Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-297, 2025-06-27, pp. 8, 26, 49-50)
- In November 2024 Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies (DFI), with the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty and Southeastern Legal Foundation, published "Protecting Title IX: A Resource Guide for School Boards", a 43-page guide for school boards on the Department of Education's 2024 Title IX rule. The guide says of its publishers: "The Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (WILL), Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies (DFI), and Southeastern Legal Foundation (SLF) are 501(c)(3) nonprofit law and policy organizations that are providing this guide as a resource for anyone to review and use." (p. 3). It says of the rule: "The new Rule requires schools to allow students to participate in school-related activities and use facilities, including bathrooms and locker rooms, based on whatever gender identity they assert, rather than their biological sex." (p. 14). It tells public schools: "Public schools should defer to parents’ decisions regarding gender identity transitions for their children, as affirmed by statements by the Department in the preamble of the Rule." (p. 21). It says of the Department: "Even though the Department has indicated in the new Rule that it will defer to parents, its intent has been clear from the start: to compel conformity to gender ideology in schools." (p. 22). The guide's phrases "whatever gender identity they assert, rather than their biological sex" and "compel conformity to gender ideology" deny trans students' identities and are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric; they are the publishers' characterizations of the rule. (Protecting Title IX: A Resource Guide for School Boards, Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty, Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies and Southeastern Legal Foundation, 2024-11, p. 3; 57)
- Leon County school board case, Supreme Court No. 25-259: the Institute is among the amici on the petition-stage brief of Advancing American Freedom et al. filed 2025-10-06 in support of two parents who sued a school board (the list includes American Values, Concerned Women for America, Eagle Forum, Southeastern Legal Foundation and about 40 further bodies). The amici ask the Court to grant certiorari and rule for the petitioners, arguing that the Eleventh Circuit wrongly applied a "shocks the conscience" test to a parental-rights claim and that school officials may not conceal a student's gender transition from parents. The brief says "the Court should grant the petition for certiorari and rule for Petitioners." (p. 35) and "School officials may not conceal from parents some of the most sensitive matters a family may face, except in the most extreme circumstances." (p. 35). Case status: the Supreme Court denied the petition for certiorari in No. 25-259 on 2026-04-27 (per the Court's docket); supplemental briefs filed in March 2026 had argued mootness after the school board withdrew its policy. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in Support of Petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-259, 2025-10-06, p. 35; 58)
- International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc. v. Ferguson, Supreme Court No. 25-840: the Institute and the Parents Initiative of the Liberty Justice Center filed a joint amicus brief on 2026-09-15 in support of the petitioner parents. The cover places both as amici ("BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE PARENTS INITIATIVE AND DEFENSE OF FREEDOM INSTITUTE IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS", p. 1). The brief asks the Court to hold that parents have Article III standing, and states the position the amici want adopted: "when the State withholds critical information from parents and takes liberties with the medical care of their children, parents have standing to sue in federal court." (p. 20). The brief asserts that Washington is harboring runaway minor children (p. 8) and links the Washington law to school non-disclosure policies elsewhere; these are the amici's claims. Case status: the Supreme Court granted review in No. 25-840 on 2026-06-29 and set argument for 2026-12-07; the docket read through 2026-11-09 shows no decision. (Brief of Amici Curiae Parents Initiative and Defense of Freedom Institute in Support of Petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-840, 2026-09-15, p. 20)
- The Ninth Circuit's opinion of 2025-06-17 (No. 23-35288, D. Or. 1:21-cv-00859-CL) in the suit by two school employees against Grants Pass School District No. 7 lists DFI's attorneys as counsel for DFI as amicus curiae (p. 7); the counsel block does not say which side the amicus supported. The employees had been terminated, later reinstated and transferred, over their public campaign against the district's guidance on transgender students, and sued; Alliance Defending Freedom and Pacific Justice Institute were counsel for them. The panel affirmed summary judgment for the individual defendants on the damages claims on qualified immunity, vacated it for the district on those claims and for all defendants on the declaratory and injunctive claims, and remanded: "However, for those damages claims, we vacate the grant of summary judgment to the District; for the related claims for declaratory and injunctive relief, we vacate the grant of summary judgment to all Defendants." (p. 69, the Ninth Circuit). Case status: in November 2025 the plaintiffs' counsel announced that the plaintiffs and the school district had settled after this opinion's remand; the case was not confirmed as formally dismissed, and the status rests on the plaintiffs' counsel's own announcement. (Opinion, two school employees v. Grants Pass School District No. 7, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 23-35288, 2025-06-17, pp. 7, 69; 59)
- 2026-02-10: the Institute's litigation counsel gave testimony to the U.S. House Committee on Education and Workforce, Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education, at a hearing on the Montgomery County curriculum case (Supreme Court No. 24-297, 606 U.S. 522 (2025)). The testimony records the Institute's role: "At the Supreme Court, DFI filed an amicus curiae brief on behalf of ten current and former educators who, collectively, had 166 total years of experience" (p. 2). It describes the objected-to books as depicting "Pride parades, gender transitioning, preferred pronouns, nonbinary identification, a drag queen, playground same-sex romance, and other controversial topics centered on sexuality and gender identity." (p. 1). Describing books that show trans and nonbinary people and pronouns as "controversial topics" treats trans identities as a contested subject; it is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. It tells the committee "Going forward, the [Supreme Court's] decision can be a useful tool for parents of faith to push back against overreach by public schools." (p. 3), says the Supreme Court has recognized a parental "Substantive Due Process right" under the 14th Amendment and asks federal courts to clarify it beyond religion (p. 4), and ends "[The decision] shows that parents can and must speak up and take back their children’s public schools, and that the First Amendment can assist them in doing so." (p. 6). (Testimony Before the U.S. House Committee on Education and Workforce, Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education: Hearing on Defending Faith and Families Against Government Overreach: [the Montgomery County curriculum case, Supreme Court No. 24-297], U.S. House Committee on Education and Workforce, Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education, hearing of 2026-02-10, p. 2; the committee minority's hearing page for 2026-02-10)
Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext
- The model law and the Institute's releases treat the matter as one of "biological sex" for "schools and colleges" and for bathrooms and locker rooms, which reaches adult college students, not only children or athletes (14).
- Eitel's quoted words, "radical gender ideology" and "If a man can be a woman", and the Institute's description of trans girls as "males who identify as female", deny trans identities and are not child-protection claims (releases of 2023-03-30 and 2024-10-16).
- The complaint of 2025-03-18 that DFI and the Liberty Justice Center filed against the Illinois State Board of Education and Chicago Public Schools concerns bathrooms, locker rooms and overnight accommodations for all students, and the Liberty Justice Center's page on it states no allegation about a specific child's conduct (12, accessed 2026-11-17).
- The four college letters of 2026-09-11 (above) ask the Department of Education to act under Title IV, which governs federal student aid, against women's colleges that admit adult trans women. The Bryn Mawr and Stephens letters allege Title IX harms to enrolled women ("women's intimate housing and facilities", "women's athletic teams", locker rooms and bathrooms) alongside the Title IV claim of "misrepresentation". The letters concern adult students at women's colleges, not children. The framing of "protecting women and girls" is applied to the admission of adult trans women.
- The Agnes Scott and Wesleyan letters of 2026-09-11: The Agnes Scott and Wesleyan letters of 2026-09-11 concern adult college students, not children: the policies they attack admit adult applicants, and the remedy asked for (withdrawal of federal funding and a Federal Student Aid program review) would reach every student at the college, including through federal student loans (Agnes Scott letter pp. 2 and 21). The policies quoted in the Agnes Scott and Wesleyan letters also admit people assigned female at birth who are trans men or non-binary, and the letters present the colleges' welcome of those students as part of the violation (the Agnes Scott statement "proud of the women, trans women, trans men and non-binary individuals" is quoted as evidence). Neither letter invokes protecting children. (The Agnes Scott and Wesleyan letters are the PDFs linked in the Anti-trans work section; the Bryn Mawr and Stephens letters are cited there too, as PDFs on dfipolicy.org.)
- The guide's claims reach adult employees as well as students. It says of the Department's rule: "The Department has also lowered the standard for harassment, making it easier to discipline a student or teacher for harassment based on sex." (p. 12). (Protecting Title IX: A Resource Guide for School Boards, Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty, Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies and Southeastern Legal Foundation, 2024-11, p. 12; 57)
Ties
- Funding, money received: National Philanthropic Trust $1,734,500 in 3 rows; Fidelity Charitable $600,700 in 4 rows; DonorsTrust $447,250 in 2 rows; Vanguard Charitable $250,000; The Heritage Foundation $100,000; Bradley Impact Fund $35,000; Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc $50,000 in 2 rows (matched by EIN); Dick and Betsy DeVos Family Foundation $900,000 in 2 rows; The Searle Freedom Trust $1,200,000 in 3 rows; Ravenel and Elizabeth Curry Foundation $425,000 in 3 rows; Sarah Scaife Foundation $225,000 in 2 rows; The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation $150,000 in 3 rows; Thomas W Smith Foundation $150,000; John William Pope Foundation $45,000 in 2 rows; Adolph Coors Foundation $25,000 (matched by name and place) (IRS Form 990 and 990-PF e-files; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 3).
- Formal joint work: Liberty Justice Center, co-filer of the 2025-03-18 complaint (the Center's page).
- Formal joint work: Southeastern Legal Foundation (page on this site), co-filer of the 2026-02-23 supplemental complaint against Shawnee Mission School District; an appearance or listing: the foundation's amicus list of 2026-09-25 (recorded on its page).
- Narrative alignment only (not a tie): none recorded.
- DFI and Parents Defending Education (EIN 86-1596460; page here) wrote the letter of 2025-02-18 together and each is described in it as a plaintiff-side litigant against the 2024 rule: formal joint work (38). DFI and the California Justice Center, APC co-filed the complaint of 2025-03-03: formal joint work (39; no page here).
What the records don't show
Who funds the Institute beyond the rows above (rows filed to other names or by bodies that file no return); what the Institute's releases do not say, namely any client other than the four States, and any report by the Institute of the dismissals of the Fifth and Tenth Circuit appeals (both dismissed in March 2025 without a merits opinion, by the courts' orders) or of the notice of 2026-06-08; the Institute's Schedule O or program text (the returns give header fields only); whether the 2022 Heritage Foundation "Innovation Prize" grant concerned any work on trans people (the row, filed on The Heritage Foundation's 2022 return, states only its purpose wording).
Open questions
- Did the Institute report the dismissals of the Fifth and Tenth Circuit appeals (March 2025) on its own pages, and what has it said since about the Kansas and Louisiana cases?
- Did the Office for Civil Rights act on the Institute's California (2025-03-03), Minnesota (2025-04-07), Fairfax County (2025-09-24) and Illinois (2025-03-18, with the Liberty Justice Center) complaints, and what did the Department of Education find about each? The Kansas findings of April 2026 are in Anti-trans work.
- What did the Department do with the college letters of 2026-09-11?
- Did the Institute file other complaints beyond California (2025-03-03), Kansas (2025-06-24), Illinois, Minnesota, Fairfax and the four colleges (2026-09-11)?
- Is there any state bill citing the RESPECT Title IX Act? The Institute sent the model law to the White House.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- image page: https://dfipolicy.org/
- https://dfipolicy.org/about/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/871196853
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/872081402/202503189349103100/full
- https://transparencyreport.google.com/political-ads/home
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2021-OCR-0166-229040
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2022-OCR-0143-141962
- https://dfipolicy.org/press-release-dfi-supports-female-athletes-in-legal-battle-for-recognition-after-they-were-forced-to-compete-against-men-in-violation-of-title-ix
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2022-OCR-0143-149332
- https://dfipolicy.org/press-release-dfi-fights-biden-harris-administrations-radical-title-ix-rule-in-the-u-s-court-of-appeals-for-the-5th-circuit
- https://dfipolicy.org/press-release-dfi-joins-four-additional-states-in-their-legal-battle-to-block-the-biden-harris-administrations-radical-title-ix-rule
- https://libertyjusticecenter.org/?p=7034
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/FW_-OCR-Case-Nos.-05-25-4050-05-25-1447__Redacted.pdf.
- https://dfipolicy.org/titleix/
- https://dfipolicy.org/press-release-dfi-files-amicus-brief-supporting-u-s-department-of-educations-federal-funding-cuts-to-new-york-city-schools-violating-title-ix/
- https://clearinghouse.net/case/45610/
- https://clearinghouse.net/case/45705/
- https://adflegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/state-of-louisiana-v-us-dept-ed-2025-03-14-5th-circuit-dismissal.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca10.88682/gov.uscourts.ca10.88682.333.0.pdf.
- https://aglizmurrill.com/Files/Article/538/Documents/2026.06.08PlaintiffsNoticeofVoluntaryDismissal.pdf
- https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.lawd.205659/gov.uscourts.lawd.205659.92.0.pdf.
- https://ag.louisiana.gov/Article/538
- https://adflegal.org/case/state-louisiana-v-us-department-education/
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68479494/state-of-louisiana-v-education/
- https://dfipolicy.org/title-ix-guide/
- https://dfipolicy.org/news/
- https://dfipolicy.org/department-of-education-finds-title-ix-and-ferpa-violations-following-dfi-complaints/
- https://adflegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/kansas-v-us-dept-of-education-2026-06-11-joint-stip-of-dismissal.pdf
- https://adflegal.org/case/state-kansas-v-us-department-education/
- https://dfipolicy.org/?p=4329.
- https://projects.chalkbeat.org/2025/uploads/OCR_Chicago_Redacted.pdf
- https://www.chalkbeat.org/chicago/2025/09/17/chicago-public-schools-to-lose-federal-grant-black-student-success-plan-transgender-policy.
- https://www.fox5dc.com/news/title-ix-complaint-filed-against-fairfax-county-schools-over-locker-room-policy.
- https://dfipolicy.org/?p=5930
- https://slfliberty.org/southeastern-legal-foundation-and-defense-of-freedom-institute-file-federal-civil-rights-complaint-against-kansas-school-district-for-policies-that-violate-title-ix-and-student-free-speech/.
- https://dfipolicy.org/?p=486
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/DFI-PDE-Letter-to-James-Baird-Model-Title-IX-Law-and-Summary-02.18.2025.pdf
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/DFI-CJC-Title-IX-Complaint-CDE-and-Districts.pdf
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/DFI-Title-IX-Complaint-Notice-KS-Districts-06.24.2025-1.pdf
- https://dfipolicy.org/press-release-kansas-attorney-general-calls-on-department-of-education-to-investigate-dfis-title-ix-complaint-against-several-school-districts-in-the-state/.
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Title-IX-FCPS-Complaint-09.24.2025-redacted.pdf
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/DFI-Complaint-BMC-09.11.2026.pdf
- https://thefederalist.com/2026/09/14/exclusive-four-womens-colleges-are-fleecing-federal-programs-by-admitting-trans-men/
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/DFI-Complaint-SC-09.11.2026.pdf
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/DFI-Complaint-ASC-09.11.2026.pdf
- https://dfipolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/DFI-Complaint-WC-09.11.2026.pdf
- https://thefederalist.com/2025/05/19/exclusive-new-title-ix-proposal-could-end-gender-theory-whiplash-forever/
- https://gvwire.com/2026/04/08/trump-administration-investigating-los-angeles-schools-gender-disclosure-policies/
- https://www.valleynewslive.com/2025/10/01/federal-investigation-says-minnesota-violated-title-ix/
- https://dfipolicy.org/press-release-dfi-urges-the-education-department-to-investigate-four-womens-colleges-for-violating-title-ix-and-engaging-in-substantial-misrepresentations-to-the-public/
- https://dfipolicy.org/press-release-dfi-urges-supreme-court-to-protect-parental-rights-and-reject-qualified-immunity-claim-for-california-government-officials-who-proceeded-with-gender-surgery-on-minor-without-parental-co/
- https://dfipolicy.org/news.
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-180.html
- https://www.thetrevorproject.org/get-help/
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-180.html.
- https://will-law.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Protecting_Title_IX_Resource_Guide_School_Boards.pdf
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-259.html
- https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2025/06/16/23-35288.pdf