![Organization: Christian Legal Society [EIN 36-6101090]](assets/profiles/org_christian_legal_society.png)
Christian Legal Society
Christian Legal Society (CLS) is a 501(c)(3) in Springfield, Virginia (IRS master file). The IRS e-Postcard data of 2026-11-07 also hold a Form 990-N under this EIN for tax year 2016, from a Chicago address, marked as for gross receipts normally of $50,000 or less (2); for the same tax year the Society filed a full Form 990 reporting total revenue of $1,393,580 (IRS Form 990 e-file, object 201701829349300000, 3). Its own site says: "Christian Legal Society is a non-denominational Christian membership association" and gives its mission as "To inspire, encourage, and equip Christian attorneys and law students ... to proclaim, love, and serve Jesus Christ through the study and practice of law, ... and the defense of religious freedom and the sanctity of human life." It says its founding chapter filed the Articles of Incorporation on 1961-10-19 (4, accessed 2026-11-11, 5). Its advocacy arm is the Center for Law & Religious Freedom.
Money received
Total revenue by return (IRS Form 990 e-file records, EIN 36-6101090; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6): TY2010 $1,779,338; TY2011 $1,364,102; TY2012 $1,390,556; TY2013 $1,320,867; TY2014 $1,242,323; TY2016 $1,393,580; TY2017 $1,643,838; TY2018 $2,380,454; TY2019 $2,151,276; TY2020 $1,839,564; TY2021 $2,829,213; TY2022 $2,780,312; TY2023 $3,399,271; TY2024 $5,380,584.
Grants whose rows carry CLS's EIN and its name (IRS Form 990 e-file grant rows that carry CLS's EIN; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6; same period on two returns counted once). There are 14 givers (by EIN) and 59 rows as listed on returns ($3,624,184); counted once and with CLS's name, 56 rows and $3,315,680 (the 2022-12-31 row of the National Christian Charitable Foundation is on two returns; the 2022-06 Fidelity Charitable row is on two returns, once filed to another name; the $182,204 row of Alliance Defending Freedom is stated apart):
- Christian Community Foundation Inc (EIN 75-1750059, Colorado Springs; does business as WaterStone): $1,644,600 in 6 rows (2018 to 2025).
- National Christian Charitable Foundation (EIN 58-1493949; filed "NATL CHRISTIAN CHARITABLE FDN INC"): $815,832 counted once in 13 rows, 2012 to 2024 (14 rows and $888,882 as listed; the 2022-12-31 row of $73,050 is on two returns, objects 202323179349311657 and 202333179349303063).
- Fidelity Charitable (EIN 11-0303001; filed "FIDELITY INVESTMENTS CHARITABLE GIFT FUND"): $342,559 in 9 rows (periods ending 2017-06 to 2025-06; 10 rows and $395,809 as listed). The period ending 2022-06-30, $53,250, is on two returns: the return with object 202430459349302913 files it to CLS (Springfield VA) and is counted; the return with object 202321309349304807 files the same amount and period with CLS's EIN to "BOSTON COLLEGIATE CHARTER SCHOOL FOUNDATION INC", Dorchester MA, and is stated apart, not counted.
- Schwab Charitable (EIN 31-1640316; filed "SCHWAB CHARITABLE FUND" and "DONOR ADVISED CHARITABLE GIVING INC"): $142,474 in 10 rows (2016 to 2025).
- United Charitable (EIN 20-4286082): $112,651 in 4 rows (2017 to 2020).
- Alliance Defending Freedom (EIN 54-1660459; filed "ALLIANCE DEFENSE FUND INC" and "ALLIANCE DEFENSE FUND"): $137,029 in 2 rows (periods ended 2010-06-30 $101,944 and 2011-06-30 $35,085). A third row of $182,204 (period ended 2012-06-30, return 201311159349300321) carries CLS's EIN but is filed to "BRENA BELL & CLARKSON PC", Anchorage, and is stated apart, not counted.
- Dallas Seminary Foundation (EIN 75-2188543): $34,000 in 4 rows (2022 to 2025). GiveWell Community Foundation Inc (EIN 59-3649871): $30,000 (2025). Christian Service Charities Inc (EIN 94-3193374): $14,762 in 2 rows. American Endowment Foundation (EIN 34-1747398): $12,200 (2024). Tulsa Community Foundation (EIN 73-1554474): $10,000 (2023). Raymond James Charitable Endowment Fund (EIN 59-3652538): $10,000 (2025). CHC Creating Healthier Communities (EIN 13-6167225): $8,573 (period ending 2022-06; purpose as filed "RESEARCH/PUBLICEDUCATION"). Chattanooga Christian Community Foundation (EIN 62-1536731): $1,000 (period ending 2020-12; purpose as filed "IN FURTHERANCE OF FOUNDATION'S PURPOSES").
- The row of $182,204 for the period ended 2012-06-30 on Alliance Defending Freedom's return (object 201311159349300321) carries the purpose "SANCTITY OF LIFE LEGAL WORK". The same law firm (Brena Bell & Clarkson PC) appears on Alliance Defending Freedom's returns under its own EIN 92-0127640: period ended 2011-06-30, $30,296, purpose "SANCTITY OF LIFE LEGAL WORK" (on the same return, object 201240629349301354, that files the Society's $35,085); 2014-06-30, $38,883, "SANCTITY OF LIFE"; 2016-06-30, $41,625; 2017-06-30, $26,157; 2018-06-30, $25,494. Alliance Defending Freedom's rows to the Society itself carry the purpose "RELIGIOUS LIBERTY LEGAL WORK". By name, place and purpose the $182,204 row is a payment to the law firm; the return states no payment to the Society for that period, and the row stays outside the Society's totals. (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 54-1660459; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 7)
- The John Stiger Ferry Charitable Foundation Inc (EIN 35-2405388; page on this site) paid $25,000 in 1 row, period ending 2017-12-31, "GENERAL SUPPORT", filed "CHRISTIAN LEGAL SOCIETY", Springfield VA; matched by the recipient's full name and place (990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN). (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, object 201843049349100224; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 8)
- Stated apart, in no total: two rows from Schwab Charitable (EIN 31-1640316), $53,420 in all (period ending 2024-06-30 $25,860, object 202541069349300729; 2025-06-30 $27,560, object 202611199349300601, purpose as filed "RELIGION RELATED"), are filed to "CHRISTIAN LEGAL SOCIETY", Springfield VA, with the EIN 55-0801197 instead of this body's EIN 36-6101090. The IRS records list EIN 55-0801197 as a Form 990-N filer named "Christian Legal Society" at Springfield VA (2022) and on the revocation list (exemption revoked 2026-05-15). The rows are counted for neither EIN, and the Schwab Charitable line above (10 rows, $142,474) excludes them; they carry a different EIN with the same name and place, so the identity of the recipient is not established. (IRS Form 990 e-files, giver EIN 31-1640316, 9; IRS Form 990-N and revocation list, EIN 55-0801197, 10)
- The IRS exempt-organization data as shown by ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer lists EIN 55-0801197 as "Christian Legal Society" (also listed as "Cls Advocates Llc"), Springfield VA, a 501(c)(3) with Form 990-N postcards only for fiscal years 2009 to 2022 (several years missing, among them 2015, 2019 and 2021) and no financial details; the page says it is not on the IRS's most recent list of tax-exempt organizations. The page gives no ruling date, officers or link to the body at EIN 36-6101090, so whether the two are related is not established; the two Schwab Charitable rows ($53,420) stay outside every total. (10, accessed 2026-11-11)
- National Christian Charitable Foundation (EIN 58-1493949), tax year 2011, from the list attached to its Schedule I: row filed as "Christian Legal Society", recipient EIN 36-6101090, $67,850.00 (page 79 of the 217-page return). The foundation is a donor-advised-fund sponsor, so donors are not disclosed. This 2011 row is stated apart and is in no total above (IRS Form 990 for tax year 2011 as filed, a scan read as page images; list at 11).
Money given
- The Association of Faith Based Organizations: the Society's returns list it in nine returns, TY2010 to TY2014 and TY2016 to TY2019 (no return for TY2015 is in the records; objects including 201132069349300073, 201401349349302345, 201701829349300000 and 202023219349316832) as a related organization described as a "disregarded entity", with the Society's own EIN (366101090) shown in the row and domicile VA, so it files no return or EIN of its own and is part of the Society for tax purposes. The Virginia State Corporation Commission register lists "Association of Faith-Based Organizations, LLC" (number S1810508), a limited liability company formed 2006-03-07 and shown as inactive. Four federal suits by that association appear in federal court dockets (CourtListener, 12): W.D. Wis. 3:06-cv-00175 (against Bablitch), N.D. Fla. 4:06-cv-00200 (against Bush), W.D. Mich. 1:06-cv-00790 (against Granholm) and S.D. Iowa 4:08-cv-00111 (against Anderson). Alliance Defending Freedom's own case page for the Iowa matter says that attorneys of the Alliance and of the Society's Center for Law & Religious Freedom "filed a lawsuit" (the docket gives 2008-03-19) over an Iowa state-employee charity program that barred faith-based charities, and that "the rules were changed to allow religious organizations to receive donations" afterwards. None of this concerns trans people, and the entity has no identifier of its own, so it does not meet the standard for a page of its own. (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 36-6101090, 6; Virginia State Corporation Commission business organization search, 13, entity number S1810508; federal court dockets, CourtListener, 12; 14)
People on file
- David Nammo: shown as "President & CEO" on CLS's team section (who-we-are page, accessed 2026-11-11); listed on its TY2020 return as Executive Director & CEO with reported compensation of $132,231 (IRS Form 990 e-file, object 202143199349324479; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6).
- Kim Colby: shown as "Of Counsel, Center for Law & Religious Freedom" (same page); listed as key employee on the TY2020 return with compensation of $112,119 (same object). Steve McFarland is shown as "Director, Center for Law & Religious Freedom".
- The TY2020 return lists the officers, including a President & Chair, a Past President, a President Elect, a Secretary, a Treasurer and directors; they are not named here because the return alone is the source.
Documented work on trans people and LGBT people
- 2010-06-28: CLS was the petitioning student group in Christian Legal Society v. Martinez, 561 U.S. 661; the Supreme Court held 5-4 (Justice Ginsburg writing; Justice Alito dissenting) that Hastings College of the Law's policy requiring recognised student groups to accept all students was reasonable and viewpoint-neutral. Wikipedia reports that CLS's bylaws required members and officers to affirm that sexual activity belongs only in marriage between a man and a woman and that CLS read them to exclude "unrepentant homosexual conduct" (15, accessed 2026-11-11).
- 2017-01-10: CLS was among the groups that joined an amicus brief to the Supreme Court, dated January 10 by Baptist News Global (Baptist News Global, 2017-01-20, accessed 2026-11-11, 16). The article calls it "The Jan. 10 amicus brief by groups including the SBC Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission" and names the organizations joining the brief as "the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America, National Association of Evangelicals, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod and Christian Legal Society". It says the brief asks the Supreme Court to reverse a 2016 Fourth Circuit decision "that a Virginia school district unlawfully discriminated against a transgender student by barring him access to the boy's restroom at his high school". The brief itself, "Brief of Major Religious Organizations as Amici Curiae Supporting Petitioner" in Supreme Court No. 16-273, was reviewed in a copy hosted by the ACLU (Supreme Court of the United States, No. 16-273, read in full); its interest statement lists the seven bodies the article names.
- 2017-01-10: the "Brief of Major Religious Organizations as Amici Curiae Supporting Petitioner" in the Gloucester County School Board case, Supreme Court No. 16-273 (certiorari to the Fourth Circuit; the last page is dated January 10, 2017), lists Christian Legal Society as an amicus in its interest statement, with the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America, National Association of Evangelicals, the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and The Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod. The statement says the amici submit the brief "to inform the Court about the sharp clashes with religious belief and practice that will arise if the Court interprets the term 'sex' in Title IX to include gender identity". The brief says "Major religious traditions--including those represented by amici--share the belief that a person's identity as male or female is created by God and immutable" and that affirming the Fourth Circuit would "unleash conflicts over religious liberty resembling the conflicts over same-sex marriage". It also says amici "acknowledge the serious challenges faced by a small number of people who experience gender dysphoria", who "deserve kindness and compassion", and leaves their needs to "Congress and other legislators". Arguing against recognising a trans student's gender identity by recasting it as a threat to religious liberty is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric, whatever its tone; the evidence brief documents the case for access to affirming care. (Brief PDF, ACLU-hosted copy, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 16-273, read in full)
- 2019-09-16: Christian Legal Society and the National Association of Evangelicals sent a joint letter to the Department of Labor's Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs supporting the proposed rule on the religious employer exemption in the Equal Opportunity Clause (RIN 1250-AA09; 84 Fed. Reg. 41677, 2019-08-15; Docket OFCCP-2019-0003). The letter asks the agency to read the exemption as shielding religious employers even when a worker alleges discrimination on a basis other than religion, and names "sex, sexual orientation, gender identity" among the protected classes in Executive Order 11246. It says that "sexual orientation and gender identity are protected classes under the plain text of EO 11246", and, in a footnote on the Supreme Court cases then pending (including R.G. & G.R. Harris Funeral Homes v. EEOC), that the two bodies believe the Sixth Circuit's decision for a trans employee "was wrong, at least to the extent it extends to religious organizations subject to Title VII". Seeking to shield religious employers from discrimination claims by trans workers is bad-faith anti-trans advocacy, whatever its religious-liberty framing. (Comment, 17, posted 2019-09-20)
- 2015-11-06 and 2016-01-19: the Society was one of ten bodies on whose behalf two coalition letters were sent, each with the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, National Association of Evangelicals, Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance, Christian Medical Association, Family Research Council, the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission and Liberty Institute (both letters name Liberty Institute, now First Liberty Institute, and the National Catholic Bioethics Center; the 2015 letter also lists World Vision (US); the 2016 letter also lists the National Association of Catholic Nurses U.S.A.). The 2015 letter to HHS on the proposed Section 1557 rule (RIN 0945-AA02) says that "the inclusion of 'gender identity' in the definition of sex discrimination is an erroneous interpretation of the law" and objects to the proposed requirement that insurers cover "services related to gender transition". Calling protection from gender-identity discrimination in health care "an erroneous interpretation of the law", and opposing coverage of transition-related care, is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric; the evidence brief documents the case for access to affirming care. The 2016 letter to HUD (FR-5863-P-01) opposes equal access to shelters and programs in accordance with gender identity and says that if a women's shelter "were required to admit a biological man based merely upon his assertion that he 'identifies as' a woman" the statute's allowance of single-sex facilities "would be unenforceable"; calling a trans woman a "biological man" is bad-faith anti-trans framing. Co-signed letters only. (18 and 19)
- 2019-09-06: the Society filed its own comment supporting HHS's proposed 2019 Section 1557 rule (84 Fed. Reg. 27846, 2019-06-14; docket HHS-OCR-2019-0007). It says the earlier regulations "(mis)interpret[ed]" the ban on sex discrimination "to forbid discrimination based on termination of pregnancy and gender identity", that the proposed rule "would correct the previous administration's misinterpretation", and that "the prohibitions on sex discrimination in Title VII and Title IX do not extend to prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity". Calling protection from discrimination on the basis of gender identity in health care a "misinterpretation" of the law is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. (Comment and attachment, 20)
- 2021-12-08: the Society, Thomas More Society, National Association of Evangelicals and Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance filed a joint comment (RIN 1250-AA09; docket OFCCP-2021-0001) opposing the Labor Department's proposal to rescind the religious-exemption rule of 2020 (85 Fed. Reg. 79324). It frames "the principal question" as "whether federal religious contractors always have to comply with the restrictions on employment discrimination on the bases of sexual orientation and gender identity". Seeking to free religious federal contractors from the bar on employment discrimination on the basis of gender identity is bad-faith anti-trans advocacy, whatever its religious-liberty framing. (Comment, 21)
- 2022-09-09: Christian Legal Society, Thomas More Society and the National Association of Evangelicals submitted a joint 13-page comment on the Department of Education's proposed Title IX rule (Docket ID ED-2021-OCR-0166; 87 Fed. Reg. 41309 to 41579, 2022-07-12; "Comments submitted via the Federal eRulemaking Portal"). Its numbered points include "Proposed 106.10 (inclusion of sexual orientation and gender identity as protected classes)", "Proposed 106.10 (sexual orientation and gender identity and the provision of health insurance)", "Proposed 106.10, 106.31(a)(2) (conscience; privacy)" and "Biological females and single-sex sports"; on the last it says the three bodies "withhold our comments on the subject" for now because the Department announced separate rulemaking on sports. (comment PDF, 22; the same comment, posted 2022-10-26, is at 23)
- The same comment asks that the regulations "state that it is not unlawful sex discrimination under Title IX for religious recipients to refuse to provide health insurance to students and/or employees to cover gender-transition procedures (e.g., puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and sex-change surgeries)"; on names and pronouns it says "Individuals should not be coerced into using gender-affirming terms or pronouns that convey approval of a person's gender identity"; on school facilities it speaks of "a male who declares to have transitioned to a female" in restrooms and locker rooms and proposes privacy panels and separate stalls. Describing a trans girl or woman as "a male" and describing her care as "sex-change surgeries" is anti-trans framing in bad faith; the evidence brief documents the benefits of gender-affirming care for adults and adolescents. (the comment)
- 2022-09-30 (posted 2022-10-26): Thomas More Society, Christian Legal Society, National Association of Evangelicals and Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance filed a joint comment on HHS's proposed Section 1557 rule, "Nondiscrimination in Health Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance" (87 Fed. Reg. 47824 to 47920; Docket ID HHS-OS-2022-0012; RIN 0945-AA17). It opposes proposed provisions that treat sexual orientation and gender identity as protected classes ("Proposed 92.101(a)(2) (inclusion of sexual orientation and gender identity as classes ..."), says the rule "will implicate privacy in hospital and nursing facility rooms and restrooms, as well as preferred pronouns of patients", and says "There has been a surge in gender dysphoria and transgender-identification among American adolescents, especially adolescent girls. This rise tracks the rise in social media use by minors." Its concluding remarks say a "major effect of Part 92 will be an increase in the United States of gender confusion and irreversible medical transitioning followed by regret" and "At its core, the individual who takes on a transgender identity rejects the physiological fact and significance of the sexed body". They post an opinion article by Leor Sapir "not because it necessarily states the correct side of the debate (we think it does)". These claims are the filers' own; the social-media-surge and regret claims are false or unsupported (regret after transition is rare), and describing trans people's identity as a rejection of fact is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. The request reaches adult patients and employees, not only minors. (Comment, 24)
- 2023-01-17: Amicus filing only: CLS, Thomas More Society and the National Association of Evangelicals filed a brief for the appellees in State of Tennessee et al. v. United States Department of Education, Sixth Circuit No. 22-5807 (Document 37). Its table of contents (Point Two) says "the Bostock Court pointedly stated that it was not deciding applications such as single-sex sports and privacy concerns in the common use of bathrooms and locker rooms", and its Point Three argues that applying Bostock "with its but-for rule of causation to Title IX makes no sense if the plain text and title's context are to carry any weight" (brief, filed 01/17/2023, read via the CLS site 2026-11-11, 25).
- 2023-02-15 (posted 2023-03-10): Thomas More Society, Christian Legal Society, National Association of Evangelicals, Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance and Center for Public Justice filed a joint comment on HHS's proposed conscience rule (88 Fed. Reg. 820, 2023-01-05; RIN 0945-AA18; docket HHS-OCR-2023-0001). It says conscience rights "More recently ... extend to those who would decline to become involved in hormone therapy and surgery for gender transition". Presenting a refusal to take part in gender-affirming care as a matter of conscience is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric; the evidence brief documents the case for access to affirming care. On 2023-03-16 the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities filed its own comment saying it "supports the attached letter". (26 and 27)
- 2023-03-06: the Society, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, National Association of Evangelicals, Thomas More Society and Council for Christian Colleges & Universities sent a joint comment to nine agencies on the proposed rule "Partnerships with Faith-Based and Neighborhood Organizations" (88 Fed. Reg. 2395, 2023-01-13). It concerns the Title VII religious-employer exemption and Free Exercise case law. It names trans people only in describing a case, Bear Creek Baptist Church v. EEOC, in which "a church and Christian-owned business that did not wish to employ those who engaged in homosexual or transgender conduct" sued the EEOC. The words are the comment's own; describing being transgender as "conduct" is bad-faith anti-trans framing. (28)
- 2023-10-10: the joint comment of the Society, Thomas More Society, Christian Medical & Dental Associations, Council for Christian Colleges & Universities and National Association of Evangelicals on the EEOC's proposed Pregnant Workers Fairness Act rule objects to the inclusion of abortion as a "related medical condition"; the comment contains none of the words "transgender", "gender identity" or "sexual orientation". (29)
- 2024-03-19: the Society, the Accord Network, Samaritan's Purse, the Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance, the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission and CRISTA Ministries (World Concern) filed a joint comment on the State Department's proposed "Nondiscrimination in Foreign Assistance" award terms (dockets DOS-2023-0014 and DOS-2023-0015). It comments on the proposed ban on employment discrimination "on the basis of religion, sex, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, or sex characteristics" and asks that religious organizations be categorically exempt from it. The ban concerns employees, so the request reaches adults. (30)
- 2025-03-10: Amicus filing only: Christian Legal Society filed a brief at the petition stage (2024-10-14) and a merits brief on 2025-03-10. The cover of the merits brief lists Christian Legal Society with Agudath Israel of America, First Liberty Institute, Focus on the Family, the National Association of Evangelicals and the Islam and Religious Freedom Action Team of the Religious Freedom Institute; the brief's interest statement also describes the Association of Christian Schools International, which the cover does not list. The brief supports the parents in the Montgomery County curriculum case, Supreme Court No. 24-297, about a Maryland school board's refusal of opt-outs from storybooks. Its interest statement for Focus on the Family says the group believes parents have the right to oversee what their children are taught in schools "about issues of gender and sexuality", and its argument says the book "Intersection Allies" "tells children about being non-binary and transgender". Treating a book's telling children about non-binary and transgender people as grounds for an opt-out is anti-trans advocacy made in bad faith, whatever its parental-rights framing. The Court's docket lists both briefs and shows the Court reversed and remanded on 2025-06-27 (docket 31, brief on the Society's own site).
- 2025-06-13: Amicus filing only: Christian Legal Society, alone, filed a brief supporting the petitioner in the Colorado counseling case, Supreme Court No. 24-539, a challenge to Colorado's law barring licensed counsellors from "conversion therapy" with minors. The brief describes the law as prohibiting counselling conversations with minors that might encourage them to change their "sexual orientation or gender identity, including efforts to change behaviors or gender expressions", and argues that the law regulates speech; it also argues against American Bar Association Model Rule 8.4(g). The docket shows the brief filed 2025-06-13 and, on 2026-03-31, judgment reversed and case remanded (opinion by Justice Gorsuch, Justice Jackson dissenting). Advocacy for counselling aimed at steering minors away from a trans identity is anti-trans rhetoric (docket 32 and brief on the Society's own site).
- 2025-06-13: the Society's own case page on the Colorado counseling case gives "Center's Role: Amicus" and says "On June 13, 2025, the Center filed an amicus brief with the Supreme Court on behalf of Kaley." The page says faith-based counsellors "help youth experiencing gender dysphoria by talking with children", "helping them to accept their bodies without resorting to irreversible life-altering medical intervention", that "This approach is supported by scientific evidence", and that state law "requires counselors to affirm children in their belief that they were born in the wrong body". Those claims are the Society's own and are anti-trans rhetoric; presenting counselling to steer a young person away from a trans identity as science is bad faith, and the evidence brief documents the case for access to affirming care. The page records that the Court agreed to hear the case in March 2025. The docket lists the Society's brief ("Brief amicus curiae of Christian Legal Society filed.", 2025-06-13). On the same day Summit Ministries, with Family Policy Alliance and the Colson Center, filed a separate brief supporting the petitioner in the same case (see the Summit Ministries page). (CLS case page; Supreme Court docket No. 24-539, accessed 2026-11-11)
- Legislation: the Center for Law & Religious Freedom's legislative page lists its opposition to the Equality Act (2021) and describes it as expanding the definition of "sex" to include sexual orientation and gender identity (33, accessed 2026-11-11); the page mentions gender identity only in this entry, "The Equality Act (2021)", which says the Center "opposed passage of the Equality Act, which seeks to expand the definition of 'sex' to include 'sexual orientation' and 'gender identity'", and holds no other entry on the subject.
- The Society's news archive page (34, read in full, items from April 2011 to December 2023) uses the words "transgender", "gender identity" or "gender" in no item dated before the item on the Bostock decision of June 2020 (headed "COURT RULES TITLE VII PROTECTS SEXUAL ORIENTATION AND GENDER IDENTITY IN EMPLOYMENT", which records that the Society joined an amicus brief urging the Court "not to re-define 'sex' in Title VII to include sexual orientation and gender identity"). The items before September 2016 concern same-sex marriage (the Windsor and Hollingsworth rulings of June 2013, the Society's 2013 amicus briefs, and 2016 briefs on judges and magistrates who declined to officiate at weddings), the HHS contraceptive mandate, ABA Model Rule 8.4(g), the Conscience Protection Act and campus non-discrimination policies. The archive does not list the 2017 Gloucester County brief described above (Supreme Court No. 16-273), so it is not a complete record of the Society's filings. Later items on gender identity are already on this page (2022 Title IX comment, 2022 HHS comment, 2023 comments to HHS, EEOC and OMB, the 2023 amicus brief in Tennessee v. Department of Education).
- The Center's court page (35, accessed 2026-11-11) shows 10 cases (a "Load More" control is on the page): St. Herman's Table v. City of Phoenix and Bethany Christian Services v. Corbin and the Gateway Pregnancy Centers matter (role "Counsel") and, as "Amicus", Chabad of Surfside v. Town of Surfside, a case about a student pro-life club against Noblesville School District, a case against the City of Brandon, the Colorado counseling case, First Choice Women's Resource Centers v. Platkin, Fellowship of Christian Athletes v. District of Columbia and the Montgomery County curriculum case. Of the 10, the case pages for the Colorado counseling case and the Montgomery County curriculum case concern gender identity; the page for Fellowship of Christian Athletes v. District of Columbia (Society role "Amicus") concerns a school district's anti-discrimination policy and the group's leadership standards, and does not mention gender identity (36). The Society's public index of case pages, described in the next item, lists 51 case pages. The court page's summary of the Montgomery County curriculum case (No. 24-297) describes books that "champion pride parades, gender transitioning, and pronoun preferences for children" (the Society's own wording; describing books that include trans people as championing "gender transitioning" for children is anti-trans rhetoric made in bad faith); its summary of Chiles speaks of "youth experiencing gender dysphoria".
- Case pages: The Society's public index of case pages (37, accessed 2026-11-16) lists 51 case pages, and all 51 were opened on 2026-11-16 and searched for the words "transgender", "gender identity", "gender ideology", "gender dysphoria", "pronoun", "gender", "Title IX", "LGBT" and "sexual orientation". Three use gender-identity terms: the Colorado counseling case (38), the Montgomery County curriculum case (Supreme Court No. 24-297; the Society's case page) and Bostock v. Clayton County (39), all already described on this page. Four other pages use "LGBT" or "LGBTQ" (303 Creative v. Elenis, Masterpiece Cakeshop, Demkovich v. St. Andrew the Apostle Parish, and the Montgomery County curriculum case page) and one uses "Title IX" in its religious exemption (Maxon v. Fuller Theological Seminary, 40); the other 44 use none of these words. On the Groff v. DeJoy page "Trans" occurs only in the name Trans World Airlines. The Sigma Alpha Omega page says "sex-based exceptions" in a university's nondiscrimination law, not gender identity.
- News items, stated positions: The Society's public index of news items (41, accessed 2026-11-16) lists 84 items; all were opened and searched for the same words, and nine use gender-identity terms. Three of them state positions not described elsewhere on this page. The undated item "CLS Supports the Fair Treatment of Religious Organizations Act" (42, accessed 2026-11-16) says the Society "lent its support" to a bill introduced by Congressman Blake Moore that would bar the IRS from "considering a religious organization's beliefs or practices concerning marriage, sexuality, or gender identity when making tax-related determinations" and bar federal agencies from conditioning funding on a religious organization's "positions on marriage, sexual conduct, or gender identity policies", and quotes its President and CEO David Nammo. The undated items "Center Files Amicus Brief in Support of Student Group" (43) and "Equal Access Means Equal Access for All" (44) say that the Center "filed an amicus brief in support of the Gay Student Alliance Network arguing that the new Texas law violates the First Amendment and the Equal Access Act of 1984", in Gay Student Alliance Network et al. v. Morath (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas), a challenge to section 27 of Texas Senate Bill 12, which bars school districts from sponsoring "a student club based on sexual orientation or gender identity"; the Society says it did so "regardless of whether CLS agrees with the message in the student group's meetings" because its Center "had much to do with the drafting and passage of the Equal Access Act". The second item says a federal judge "temporarily blocked" three school districts from enforcing the club ban on 2026-02-20. That status is the Society's account. Five of the other six items concern the Polk, Chiles and Montgomery County curriculum cases, described above; the sixth (45) says the Center is "disappointed" that the Illinois Supreme Court adopted a rule, mirroring ABA Model Rule 8.4(g), that makes harassment or discrimination in the practice of law on the basis of 15 protected classes, "including sexual orientation and gender identity", professional misconduct.
- The Gay Student Alliance Network v. Morath brief itself: "Brief Amicus Curiae of Christian Legal Society in Support of Plaintiffs", GSA Network, et al. v. Mike Morath, et al., U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, Houston Division, Civil Action No. 4:25-cv-04090. It "focuses solely on one discrete section of Senate Bill 12", Texas Education Code section 33.0815(b), which bars school districts from "authoriz[ing] or sponsor[ing] a student club based on sexual orientation or gender identity", and argues that the section "prohibits what the EAA requires and therefore 'must yield'" to the Equal Access Act; that a student group's speech at its meetings is not government speech; that Christian Legal Society v. Martinez "actually reveals § 33.0815(b)'s unconstitutionality"; and (Part IV) that "The EAA Protects LGBT Student Groups' Meetings". It gives as its reason that "A state law that denies LGBT students their rights under the EAA could easily be adapted by another state to deny religious students their rights under the EAA". Its statement of interest says the Society "embraces biblical teachings on sexual conduct and marriage" and lists its amicus briefs against LGBT nondiscrimination claims in 303 Creative, Fulton and Masterpiece Cakeshop. (Amicus brief, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, Civil Action No. 4:25-cv-04090)
- The court's order of 2026-02-20: in GSA Network, et al. v. Mike Morath, et al. (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, Houston Division, Civil Action No. 4:25-cv-04090), Judge Charles Eskridge signed on 2026-02-20 an "Opinion and Order Dismissing Commissioner of Texas Education Agency and Granting Preliminary Injunction" (reported at 821 F.Supp.3d 753) and the preliminary injunction itself (Document 90, entered 2026-02-20). The injunction orders that the Houston, Katy and Plano Independent School Districts and those acting with them "are ENJOINED from implementing policies pursuant to Sections 3, 7, 24, and 27 of SB 12, or otherwise enforcing those provisions, during the pendency of this litigation", citing Texas Education Code sections 11.005, 11.401, 28.0043 and 33.0815; section 33.0815 is the section the Society's brief addressed. It adds that it does not compel access to the districts' campuses or alter their existing access procedures, and waives a bond. The appearances printed with the reported opinion list the Society as amicus. Status, from the order itself: a preliminary injunction entered on 2026-02-20 to last "during the pendency of this litigation". (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, Civil Action No. 4:25-cv-04090: preliminary injunction, Document 90, entered 2026-02-20; opinion and order of 2026-02-20, 821 F.Supp.3d 753, heading and appearances read)
- Blog posts: the Society's public list of blog posts (46, accessed 2026-11-17) holds 254 posts on its own site; all were opened and searched for "transgender", "gender identity", "gender", "pronoun" and "biological sex". Two posts use gender-identity terms, both on Bostock v. Clayton County. "Symposium: Free exercise, RFRA and the need for a constitutional safety net" (by Kim Colby, re-posted from a SCOTUSblog symposium) says Bostock "re-interpreted Title VII of the Civil Rights Act to include sexual orientation and gender identity as protected classes" and that "many state officials are likely to apply Bostock's rationale" further, and calls the Equality Act's proponents "willing to forfeit all Americans' religious freedom in order to suppress religious dissent" (47). "Textualism Had a Great Fall" says the decision "amends Title VII to include sexual orientation and gender identity" and argues that the Court "equated 'gender identity' with 'transgendered status'" and that a person's nonbinary identity "has no connection with the person's biological sex", calling the result "no form of legitimate textualism" (48). Neither post carries a date on the page. The other matches were the grammatical word "pronoun" in two devotionals. Presenting trans people's protection from discrimination as a threat to religious freedom is anti-trans rhetoric made in bad faith.
- Supreme Court dockets read for a Christian Legal Society brief and showing none: United States v. Skrmetti (No. 23-477, 86 amicus briefs counted), the Idaho sports case (No. 24-38, 49) and the West Virginia girls' sports case (No. 24-43, 50) (dockets accessed 2026-11-11; Nos. 24-38 and 24-43 accessed 2026-11-17).
- Federal lobbying (Senate Lobbying Disclosure Act database, 51, accessed 2026-11-11): CLS appears as its own client in 53 quarterly filings (reports and amendments) from the first quarter of 2013 to the second quarter of 2026: 47 report activity and six are "No Activity" reports (first and second quarters of 2013, first to third quarters of 2022, and the fourth-quarter 2024 amendment) (52, accessed 2026-11-17). For 2021 (four filings) the issue codes are CON ("First Amendment issues") and REL ("Freedom of religion"); for 2023 (four) and 2024 (two, first and second quarters) the text reads "Freedom of religion and other First Amendment issues", with "comments to NPRMs affecting religious freedom" from the third quarter of 2023 to the first quarter of 2024; for 2025 (four) and 2026 (two) the issue is "equal campus access for belief-based student organizations, including religious student organizations", with, from the second quarter of 2026, comments on guidance on prayer and religious expression in public schools. The issue text reviewed here states no position on trans people; income and expenses are null.
- Federal lobbying filings, as read on the lobbying disclosure database (53, accessed 2026-11-11): 2022: the first, second and third quarters are "No Activity" reports; the fourth-quarter report lists the issue "Constitution: Religious freedom and First Amendment issues" and the agency Health & Human Services. 2023: first and second quarters, "Freedom of religion and other First Amendment issues; NPRMs regarding conscience protections, faith-based partnerships, and religious freedom at post-secondary educational institutions" (agencies including Agriculture, Education, Health & Human Services, Homeland Security, Housing & Urban Development, Justice, Labor and Veterans Affairs in the first quarter); third quarter, "Freedom of religion and other First Amendment issues; comments to NPRMs affecting religious freedom" (Health & Human Services); fourth quarter, the same text (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Health & Human Services, Office of Management & Budget). 2025: all four quarters, "equal campus access for belief-based student organizations, including religious student organizations", House and Senate. No filing names a bill or states a position on trans people.
- Federal lobbying, further filings on the lobbying disclosure database (53, client Christian Legal Society, accessed 2026-11-11): for 2024 the first-quarter report lists "Freedom of religion and other First Amendment issues; comments to NPRMs affecting religious freedom", the second-quarter report "Freedom of religion and other First Amendment issues" and a fourth-quarter amendment is marked "No Activity"; the second-quarter 2026 report (posted 2026-08-11) lists "Equal campus access for belief-based student organizations, including religious student organizations" with comments on guidance on prayer and religious expression in public schools and on exempting religious programs at religious institutions from the new earnings framework. No filing reviewed here names a bill, a rule or trans people, and income and expenses are blank.
- Federal lobbying filings for 2016 to 2020, read on the lobbying disclosure database (53, client Christian Legal Society, accessed 2026-11-11): twenty reports (four for each year), all with income and expenses blank. 2016 (posted 2016-06-06, 2016-07-25, 2016-11-10, 2017-02-16): "Religious Liberty Issues." and "Religious Liberty and Constitutional First Amendment Issues." (later reports "Religious Freedom Issues." and "Religious Freedom and Constitutional First Amendment Issues."). 2017 (three quarterly reports, first, second and third, posted 2017-05-01, 2017-07-31 and 2018-01-30, and an amendment to the fourth-quarter report posted 2018-01-26): "Constitutional law" and "Religious freedom". 2018 (posted 2018-08-27, 2018-08-22, 2018-10-31, 2019-01-28): "Religious freedom and First Amendment issues" (the first-quarter report: "Constitutional law - religious freedom and First Amendment issues") and "Religious freedom" (the second-quarter report lists the first issue only). 2019 (posted 2019-05-28, 2019-07-30, 2019-10-24, 2020-01-21) and 2020 (posted 2020-05-06, 2020-08-19, 2020-11-20, 2021-02-02): "Religious freedom and First Amendment issues" and "Religious freedom". No report for these years names a bill, an agency rule or trans people, and none states a position.
- Federal lobbying filings for 2013 to 2015: the four filings the lobbying disclosure database returns for each of 2013, 2014 and 2015 (client Christian Legal Society; income and expenses blank on all) carry no mention of a proposed rule, a bill by name or trans people. 2013: first and second quarters "No Activity" (posted 2013-04-11 and 2013-07-30); third quarter (posted 2013-11-08), issues "Religion", text "Religious Liberty Issues and Legislation", and a second issue "Abortion Issues and Legislation", House and Senate; fourth quarter (posted 2014-04-21), "Civil Rights/Civil Liberties", "Religious Liberty issues", House. 2014: first and second quarters (both posted 2014-08-04) "Religious Liberty Issues"; third quarter (posted 2014-11-24) "Religious liberty legislation potential." (House, Senate and White House Office); fourth quarter (posted 2015-01-20) "Religious liberty issues". 2015: first quarter (posted 2015-04-29), a second-quarter amendment (posted 2015-08-07), third quarter (posted 2015-10-19) and fourth quarter (posted 2016-03-09): "Religious Liberty and Constitutional First Amendment Issues." and "Religious Liberty Issues.", House and Senate. The wording "NPRMs" first appears in the 2023 reports already on this page (53, client Christian Legal Society, filing years 2013, 2014, 2015, accessed 2026-11-12).
Framing trans students' use of restrooms and sports as a privacy and fairness question is a bad-faith framing used to deny trans people equal treatment; these filings are listed as documented, not as neutral positions. The same holds for every comment, letter, brief and publication in this section that argues against protecting trans people from discrimination or against their access to care, whatever its legal, religious or privacy framing. The arguments of the 2017 and 2019 amicus briefs described in this section against trans students' equal treatment are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric in the same way.
- 2023-11-01: Christian Legal Society's Center for Law & Religious Freedom filed, with the National Association of Evangelicals, the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities, the Christian Medical & Dental Associations, the Center for Public Justice and its Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance, a joint comment on the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's proposed enforcement guidance on workplace harassment (the comment is printed with "Document Number 2023-21644" and the Society's letterhead; the Society's news archive says "On November 1, the Center filed comments with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC),"). The comment asks the Commission to clarify "that religious employers will not be accused of harassment for merely enforcing a religious creed or conduct standard on abortion, transgender issues, or bathroom privacy", speaks of an employer's "sincere religious belief against transgender practices", says "many religions for millennia have understood gender to be a fixed and immutable gift from God", says an employee "may not claim a Title VII right to have his or her belief be verbally reinforced" at a religious workplace and, on restrooms, that an exempt employer can protect privacy "by requiring employees to use the restroom that corresponds to their sex". The comment also says "This does not mean that a transgender employee at a religious organization must submit to bullying." Describing a trans employee's identity as a "belief" and "practice", and asking that employers may bar employees from the restroom that matches their gender, is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric; the request reaches adult employees, not children, which bears on the "protect the children" framing. (54; 34, accessed 2026-11-11.)
- 2023-09-05: a joint comment on the Department of Health and Human Services' proposed grant regulations, signed "Thomas More Society, Christian Legal Society, National Association of Evangelicals, and Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance, a division of the Center for Public Justice". On a maternal and child health program it says the proposed provision "makes gender-identity concerns nonsensical" and that "A biological male parent with the gender identity of a woman cannot qualify for support because a biological male cannot get pregnant or bear a child". The Society's news archive says of the item "In July, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services published for comment a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking". Calling a trans woman a "biological male" with a "gender identity" in a federal-grants comment is bad-faith anti-trans framing. (55; the Society's site holds the same document, with the same text, at 56; the news archive.)
- 2023-12-04: a joint comment to the Office of Management and Budget, Docket No. OMB-2023-0017-0001 ("Guidance for Grants and Agreements", 88 Fed. Reg. 63690, October 5, 2023), signed by the Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance, the Center for Public Justice, the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities, Christian Legal Society (David Nammo, Executive Director and CEO), the National Association of Evangelicals, the Church Educational System of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and The Catholic University of America. It urges that proposed changes to 2 CFR 200.300 "not be made", argues that a proposed provision that officials "seek to prohibit sexual orientation and gender identity" discrimination in grants "is not legitimate and may not even be internally coherent", and reads Bostock v. Clayton County as limited to secular employers. Calling a bar on gender-identity discrimination in federal grants "not legitimate" is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. (57)
- Federal lobbying, the "NPRMs" items of 2023 and the Society's own comments correspond by period and agency (the lobbying filings name no rule or comment; the match is the Society's own news archive against the filing periods): the third-quarter 2023 report (agency Health & Human Services, "comments to NPRMs affecting religious freedom") with the 2023-09-05 HHS comment; the fourth-quarter 2023 report (agencies Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Health & Human Services and Office of Management & Budget) with the 2023-11-01 EEOC comment, the 2023-09-05 HHS comment and the 2023-12-04 OMB comment; the first-quarter 2024 report ("comments to NPRMs") names the State Department only and corresponds to the joint comment of 2024-03-19 to the State Department. All three comments concern gender identity, as stated above. The fourth-quarter 2023 report also corresponds to the EEOC pregnancy-accommodation comment of 2023-10-10. The first-quarter 2023 items ("NPRMs regarding conscience protections, faith-based partnerships, and religious freedom at post-secondary educational institutions") correspond by period and agency to the HHS conscience comment of 2023-02-15, the nine-agency faith-based partnerships comment of 2023-03-06 and the Education Department comment of 2023-03-24; the Society's news archive lists each of these comments in the same periods. In every case the filings name no rule, and the match is by period and agency. The 2025 to 2026 "equal campus access" items are covered under the Equal Campus Access Act item below. (Lobbying disclosure records; the Society's news archive, 58)
- 2019 (the brief carries no date in the text reviewed here; it cites web pages last visited August 20, 2019): Amicus filing only: Christian Legal Society is one of the eleven amici on a brief in Supreme Court Nos. 17-1618, 17-1623 and 18-107 (Altitude Express v. Zarda, Bostock v. Clayton County, and R.G. & G.R. Harris Funeral Homes v. EEOC, the last of which concerned a trans employee); the amici named are the National Association of Evangelicals, the Church of God in Christ, American Islamic Congress, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the General Conference of Seventh-day Adventists, Agudath Israel of America, the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod, Christian Legal Society, Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty, Orthodox Church in America and The Christian and Missionary Alliance; the cover lists The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty and the firm Kirton McConkie as counsel on the brief. The table of contents says "Construing 'sex' in Title VII to encompass 'sexual orientation' and 'gender identity' seriously threatens religious liberty", and the brief's examples include "A transgender woman sues when not hired as a chapel architect" and a shelter's choice to "decline to hire a transgender woman as a counselor". The Society's news page says the Court ruled on 2020-06-15 that Title VII "prohibits discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity". Presenting the equal treatment of trans workers as a threat to religious liberty is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. (59; 60)
- 2026-07-30: Christian Legal Society's Center for Law & Religious Freedom filed a "Brief amici curiae of Christian Legal Society, et al." in a case against Montgomery County Public Schools (U.S. Supreme Court No. 26-8, from Fourth Circuit No. 25-1136). The brief's cover names three amici, Christian Legal Society, the National Association of Evangelicals and the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, "in support of petitioner"; counsel of record is a lawyer of the Society's Center, with three other lawyers. It describes the petitioner, a substitute teacher, as unable to comply with district "policies involving student preferences around their gender identity": the school board's "new guidelines requiring teachers to address students by the pronoun corresponding to their asserted gender identity and not to disclose information about the student's transgender status to parents". It says the case "is not just another culture war battle" and is "dangerous for all teachers regardless of their views on gender identity issues". The brief is anti-trans advocacy framed as free speech and religious liberty: it asks the Court to review a teacher's free-speech claim against school guidelines on pronouns and on not telling parents of a student's trans status. The docket, accessed 2026-11-17, lists no order on the petition. (Docket 26-8, 61, accessed 2026-11-12; brief: 62, 33 pages; "Interests of Amici Curiae" at printed page 1, the quotations at printed pages 3 and 4.)
- Counsel on petition No. 26-8: The petition's cover page lists, under "Counsel for Petitioner": three lawyers of Alliance Defending Freedom (Lansdowne VA); a lawyer of Claybrook LLC (Washington DC), "Counsel of Record"; a lawyer of Gammon & Grange, P.C. (Vienna VA); and two lawyers of National Legal Foundation (Chesapeake VA). The signature block ("Respectfully submitted") repeats the same names. The Court's docket page for No. 26-8 lists only a lawyer of Claybrook LLC as the petitioner's counsel (Counsel of Record), so the docket's list is shorter than the cover page; the two do not conflict. Alliance Defending Freedom's own case page (63) says the petitioner "is represented by a coalition of attorneys with Alliance Defending Freedom, Claybrook LLC, Gammon & Grange PC, and National Legal Foundation". Alliance Defending Freedom attorneys are on the petitioner's cover page alongside Claybrook LLC. The Society's brief supports this petition as an amicus; no source reviewed here says the Society acted with those counsel. The petition describes the policy at issue as the district's "Guidelines for Student Gender Identity" and the teacher's refusal to use "preferred" pronouns "inconsistent with a student's biological sex". (64; 65)
- Docket 26-8: After the reply of 2026-10-13, the docket (accessed 2026-11-12) lists "DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 11/6/2026" (2026-10-14), "Rescheduled" (2026-11-05) and "DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 11/13/2026" (2026-11-09). The docket also lists, among the amicus briefs filed 2026-07-23 to 2026-07-31: NC Values Institute, First Amendment Scholars, America First Legal Foundation, Pacific Justice Institute, Christian Legal Society et al., Coalition for Jewish Values, West Virginia et al., Robertson Center for Constitutional Law, Liberty Justice Center's Parents Initiative, the plaintiffs in a California class action on parental notification, Christian Educators Association International et al., Manhattan Institute, Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies, Center for American Liberty, First Liberty Institute et al., Our Duty-USA et al. and Upper Midwest Law Center et al.; the respondents' counsel of record is a lawyer of Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP (brief in opposition 2026-09-29).
- Amicus brief of 2026-07-30, argument headings: The brief of 2026-07-30 has a table of contents with four argument headings: I, "The Court Below Erred as a Matter of Law..."; II, "This Case Is an Important Opportunity to Clarify the Complexity and Layering of First Amendment Rights in the Public School Setting"; III, "Preserving Protection for Teacher Speech in the K-12 Public School Setting Is Consistent with This Court's Precedent" (A to C: public universities, religious freedom, education); IV, "This Court Should Consider Revisiting its Free Exercise Doctrine in Employment Division v. Smith..." The words "gender", "transgender" and "pronoun" occur only in the brief's statement of the petitioner's case, its interests section and the opening paragraph of Argument I, which recounts the petitioner's case; the one other hit is "engendered". The brief cites a Sixth Circuit decision on a university professor's pronoun claim and the Supreme Court's decision on parents' opt-outs from instruction. The brief is anti-trans advocacy framed as a teacher's free-speech and religious-exercise claim against a school's guidelines on pronouns and on not telling parents of a student's trans status, and it is bad-faith rhetoric. (66)
- Equal campus access items of 2025 to 2026: The 2025 items "equal campus access for belief-based student organizations, including religious student organizations" correspond to the Equal Campus Access Act of 2025. The Society's own item (67) names Senators Lankford and Tim Scott and Rep. Walberg as sponsors; says it "would prevent universities from discriminating against religious student groups". It is a bill, not a Department of Education rule. Neither that item nor the coalition letter of support dated 2025-09-16 (signed by the Society's chief executive David Nammo with Cru, InterVarsity, the Orthodox Union, the Islamic Society of North America, the Catholic bishops' religious-liberty committee and others, among them state family-policy groups such as Frontline Policy Council (Georgia), Kansas Family Voice, New Jersey Family Policy Center and Maryland Family Institute; 68) mentions gender identity or sexual orientation. The second-quarter 2026 item on "guidance on prayer and religious expression in public schools" corresponds to the Society's group letter of 2026-04-27 to Education Secretary McMahon about the Department's guidance of 2026-02-05 (69): it asks that language from the 2020 guidance on student groups and the Equal Access Act be restored and does not mention gender identity. On the text reviewed here, none of the 2025 to 2026 "equal campus access" items concerns trans people. The earlier regulatory fight (comment of 2023-03-24, Docket ID ED-2022-OPE-0157, against rescinding 34 C.F.R. 75.500(d) and 76.500(d); 70, 63 pages) does not use the terms "gender identity" or "transgender"; "sexual orientation" appears only inside a quoted study on campus diversity.
- Status of petition No. 26-8 after the conference of 2026-11-13: The Supreme Court's docket for No. 26-8 (61, accessed 2026-11-17) still ends with "DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 11/13/2026" (entry of 2026-11-09) and lists no order. The Court's order list of Friday 2026-11-13 (71) grants two petitions, neither No. 26-8, and its order list of Monday 2026-11-16 (72) does not list No. 26-8.
- 2015: the Society published Religious Schools & Colleges: Guidance for Same-Sex Issues, Sample and Model Policies, which gives Christian schools and colleges sample doctrinal statements, bylaws, a handbook and conduct text "to be approved by the school’s governing body and used in its key governance documents" (p. 2). One sample states "all conduct with the intent to adopt a gender other than one’s birth gender is immoral and therefore sin" (p. 2). Another says "we do not affirm attempts to change one’s given biological birth sex via medical intervention" and "We will make institutional decisions in light of this policy regarding housing, student admission and retention, employment hiring and retention, and other matters." (p. 6). A school sample lists "gender identity different than the birth sex chromosomal level" among grounds "to refuse admission of an applicant or discontinue enrollment of a current student" (p. 19), and describes "Gender confusion and dysphoria" as consequences of "the human race’s fallen condition" (p. 20). These are the guide's own words; calling transition "immoral and therefore sin", treating a gender identity different from the birth sex as grounds to refuse or end a student's enrollment, and describing gender dysphoria as a consequence of a "fallen condition" is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric; the evidence brief documents the case for access to affirming care. (Religious Schools & Colleges: Guidance for Same-Sex Issues, Sample and Model Policies, Christian Legal Society, 2015, p. 2; 73)
- The 2023-09-05 joint comment to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (Thomas More Society, Christian Legal Society, National Association of Evangelicals and Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance) contains further passages. The filers state "Sex is therefore not a protected class within the TANF program, nor indeed is sexual orientation or gender identity." (p. 3). They write "We oppose 45 CFR 75.300(e), which imposes on recipients of HHS funding, whether secular or religious, a duty to not discriminate against beneficiaries on the bases of sexual orientation and gender identity in (at least)3 13 listed programs." (p. 5) and "we expect the future Court will hold that Congress, when first enacting each of these 13 programs, meant only to prohibit discrimination on the basis of a binary understanding of sex (i.e., biologically male or female)." (p. 6). These are the filers' claims; opposing protection from discrimination on the basis of gender identity in federal programs, and reducing sex to "a binary understanding of sex (i.e., biologically male or female)", is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. (Comments on Health and Human Service Grants Regulation: Proposed Rule to Advance Nondiscrimination in Health and Human Service Programs for LGBTQI+ Community, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights (comments by Thomas More Society, Christian Legal Society, National Association of Evangelicals and Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance), No. HHS-OCR-2023-0011, 2023-09-05, p. 3; 74)
- 2016-08-12: Christian Legal Society was one of eleven organizations on whose behalf a coalition comment letter on proposed Medicare and Medicaid hospital conditions of participation (CMS-3295-P; 81 Fed. Reg. 39448) was submitted to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. The letter is co-signed: its signature pages carry the signatures of officers and counsel of the eleven bodies, among them Christian Legal Society's executive director and chief executive and the director of its Center for Law & Religious Freedom. The letter asks CMS to delete "sexual orientation" and "gender identity" from the proposed rule, or else to add exemptions for hospitals that object on ethical, privacy or religious grounds, and it reaches adult patients (the letter's text is set out on the Family Research Council and Thomas More Society pages). Asking that protection on the basis of gender identity be deleted from hospital rules, or that objecting hospitals be exempt from it, is bad-faith anti-trans advocacy, whatever its ethical, privacy or religious framing. Co-signed letter only: no further joint work is shown. (Comment letter of the coalition to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services on CMS-3295-P, 2016-08-12, pp. 1, 8-10; 75; copy hosted by a third party)
Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext
CLS's own bylaws position (reported in Martinez) bears on gay members and officers, adults.
- The 2022 joint comment asks that religious schools may refuse to cover gender-transition care for "students and/or employees": the request reaches adult employees, not only minors, so it is not confined to protecting children (the 2022 comment).
- Two passages reach adults. The 2015 guide's sample employee handbook text reads "ACME University views the actions or intentions of those seeking fundamental changes of any kind from one’s sex at birth as a rejection of the biblical and theological understandings... and hence as grounds for removal from consideration for employment for an employment applicant, and as grounds for termination of employment for a current employee (faculty or staff)." (p. 14; 76). The 2023 joint comment says of staff at shelters for victims of domestic violence "Given the clients, a man presenting as a female is per se unqualified. The trauma for these battered women is too high." (p. 8; 55), and says the rule "will implicate privacy in hospital rooms and restrooms, as well as the preferred pronouns of students and patients." (p. 11). These are the guide's and the filers' statements; treating a person's transition as grounds to refuse or end their employment, and calling a trans woman "a man presenting as a female", is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
Christian nationalism: documented ties
No source reviewed here ties CLS to Christian nationalism. The Council for National Policy's January 2022 membership directory, as published by Documented, lists a person with the title "Executive Director and CEO" under CLS (see Ties).
Ties
- Funding: grants received from Alliance Defending Freedom, National Christian Charitable Foundation, Fidelity Charitable, Schwab Charitable, Christian Community Foundation, and the other givers as listed.
- Appearance or listing: Amicus filing only: Thomas More Society and the National Association of Evangelicals (Sixth Circuit No. 22-5807, 2023-01-17); Amicus filing only: the Southern Baptist Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, with the other groups named by Baptist News Global as joining the brief (Supreme Court, 2017-01-10).
- Appearance or listing: the Council for National Policy's January 2022 membership directory, as published by Documented, lists a person with the title "Executive Director and CEO" under Christian Legal Society (the person is not named here).
- Appearance or listing: Amicus filing only: First Liberty Institute and Focus on the Family, with the other groups named above, in the Montgomery County curriculum case (Supreme Court No. 24-297, 2025-03-10).
- Formal joint work: joint comment with Thomas More Society and National Association of Evangelicals on the Title IX proposed rule (Docket ID ED-2021-OCR-0166), 2022-09-09. (CLS-hosted comment)
- Appearance or listing, co-signed comments to agencies: Thomas More Society, National Association of Evangelicals, Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance, Council for Christian Colleges & Universities, United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Samaritan's Purse and the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission signed one or more of the joint comments listed under Documented work above (2021-12-08 to 2024-03-19). Co-signed letters only: Family Research Council and First Liberty Institute (2015 and 2016 coalition letters).
- Appearance or listing, amicus filing only: United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, in the Gloucester County School Board case (Supreme Court No. 16-273), brief dated January 10, 2017, which lists both in its interest statement; the same brief lists the Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and The Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod (ACLU-hosted copy of the brief).
- Funding, from National Christian Charitable Foundation (EIN 58-1493949): $67,850.00 in 2011 (list attached to Schedule I of its Form 990 for tax year 2011).
What the records don't show
The Association of Faith Based Organizations is a disregarded entity of CLS and has no page of its own.
Open questions
- Which other briefs has CLS joined on trans people, and does it have a stated position on trans people beyond its amicus filings, the 2017 brief in No. 16-273 and the 2022 Title IX comment? All 51 case pages in the Society's public index of case pages have been reviewed; three of them (Chiles, the Montgomery County curriculum case and Bostock) use gender-identity terms.
- What is the body at Springfield VA holding EIN 55-0801197 under the name "Christian Legal Society" (Form 990-N filer for 2009 to 2022 with several years missing, exemption revoked 2026-05-15; also listed as "Cls Advocates Llc" on ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer), and is it related to this body? The IRS exempt-organization master file and the Virginia business registry show no separate entry: the Virginia registry shows one "Christian Legal Society" (F0404436, active, formed 2003-03-26, jurisdiction IL), which is the Illinois corporation of the Society's own EIN 36-6101090, not a second body. A giver filed as "Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc" (EIN 31-1640316) filed $25,860 (2024) and $27,560 (2025), $53,420 in all, to the revoked EIN.
- What will the Supreme Court order on the petition in No. 26-8? Its docket, accessed 2026-11-17, lists no order after the conference of 2026-11-13, and the order lists of 2026-11-13 and 2026-11-16 do not list it. (docket 26-8 and the Court's later order lists.)
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- image page: https://christianlegalsociety.org/
- https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/data-download-epostcard.zip
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/366101090/201701829349300000/full
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/who-we-are
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/who-we-are/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/366101090
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/541660459
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352405388
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/311640316
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/550801197
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/581493949
- https://www.courtlistener.com/
- https://cis.scc.virginia.gov/
- https://adflegal.org/case/association-faith-based-organizations-v-anderson/.
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Legal_Society_v._Martinez
- https://www.baptistnews.com/article/religious-groups-say-public-restrooms-should-be-segregated-by-sex-not-gender-identity/
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/OFCCP-2019-0003-107570
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/HHS-OCR-2015-0006-0851
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/HUD-2015-0104-0108.
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/HHS-OCR-2019-0007-114095.
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/OFCCP-2021-0001-2062.
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/d3d3eccb-77aa-4be2-aa06-3eb99ccdbc8d.pdf
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/ED-2021-OCR-0166-184296
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/HHS-OS-2022-0012-54550.
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/2023-01-17-Tenn-v-Dept-of-Educ-EEOC-Brief-Amici-final-as-filed.pdf
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/HHS-OCR-2023-0001-0836
- https://www.regulations.gov/comment/HHS-OCR-2023-0001-0864.
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/2023-03-06-final-Comments-NPRM-Nine-Agencies-Faith-Based-Partnerships-pdf.pdf.
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Comments-to-EEOC-on-PWFA-NPRM-FINAL-101023.pdf.
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Comments-FINAL-1025-031924.pdf.
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/24-297.html
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/24-539.html
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/in-the-legislature/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/news-archive/
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/in-the-courts
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/case/fellowship-of-christian-athletes-v-district-of-columbia-et-al/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/site_cases-sitemap.xml
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/case/chiles-v-salazar/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/case/bostock-v-clayton-county/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/case/maxon-v-fuller-theological-seminary/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/site_news-sitemap.xml
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/news-articles/cls-supports-the-fair-treatment-of-religious-organizations-act/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/news-articles/center-files-amicus-brief-in-support-of-student-group/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/news-articles/equal-access-means-equal-access-for-all/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/news-articles/illinois-supreme-court-adopts-discrimination-and-harassment-rule/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/post-sitemap.xml
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/blog/symposium-free-exercise-rfra-and-the-need-for-a-constitutional-safety-net/
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/blog/textualism-had-a-great-fall/
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/24-38.html
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/24-43.html
- https://lda.gov/
- https://lda.gov/api/v1/filings/?client_name=Christian+Legal+Society
- https://lda.gov/api/v1/filings/
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Final-Comments-to-EEOC-on-Harassment-Guidelines.pdf
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/2023-09-05-NPRM-HHS-grants-Comments-TMS-CLS-NAE-IRFA-CPJ-_.pdf
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/2023-09-05-NPRM-HHS-grants-Comments-TMS-CLS-NAE-IRFA-CPJ-_.pdf
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/2023_12_04-Comment-on-proposed-OMB-Universal-Guidance-changes.pdf.
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/news-archive/.
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Bostock_Amicus_Brief_Final_Version_CLS_Center_for_Law_and_Religious_Freedom-1.pdf
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/case/bostock-v-clayton-county/.
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-8.html
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-8/417602/20260730124036492_26-8_Amici%20Brief.pdf
- https://adfmedia.org/case/polk-v-montgomery-county-public-schools/
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-8/415078/20260626113049134_USSC%20Petition%20for%20Writ%20of%20Certiorari.pdf
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-8.html.
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-8/417602/20260730124036492_26-8_Amici%20Brief.pdf.
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/news-articles/equal-campus-access-act-2025-can-end-40-years-of-discrimination/
- https://walberg.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/walberg.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/2025-09-16-group-letter-of-support-for-ecaa-final-1.pdf
- https://christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/2026.04.27-Group-letter-re-prayer-guidance-final.pdf
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/2023-Christian-Legal-Society-Free-Inquiry-Reg.-Comment-Letter.pdf
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/111326zr_09m1.pdf
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/111626zor_cb7d.pdf
- https://www.clsnet.org/document.doc?id=874.
- https://www.christianlegalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/2023-09-05-NPRM-HHS-grants-Comments-TMS-CLS-NAE-IRFA-CPJ-_.pdf.
- https://www.usccb.org/sites/default/files/about/general-counsel/upload/Comments-on-Medicare-and-Medicaid-Programs-August-2016.pdf
- https://www.clsnet.org/document.doc?id=874