![Organization: Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights (caWsbar) [Corporations Canada 16123147; BN 766561229]](assets/profiles/org_cawsbar.png)
Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights
Federal not-for-profit; plaintiff in a prison-housing challenge
Federal not-for-profit corporation, status Active. It appears here as the plaintiff in a Federal Court challenge to Commissioner's Directive 100 on trans women in women's federal prisons, backed by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, and as the group whose Steering Committee page lists Amy Hamm among its members (2, accessed 2026-11-17).
Money received
No filed amounts. Its own site says it receives no public funding or corporate sponsorship and takes donations by PayPal (3). It is not a CRA charity. The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms says its funded lawyers filed the claim (see below). The Justice Centre's own 2025 Annual Report (p. 24) says "With help from the Justice Centre, CAWSBAR filed a lawsuit with the Federal Court on April 7, 2025, seeking an end to the practice of forcibly confining female inmates alongside trans-identifying male inmates." (the report's wording misgenders trans women; it is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith) and quotes Heather Mason as "CAWSBAR board member"; the report names no other funder of the claim and does not mention Charter Advocates Canada. The same page repeats statistics about trans women prisoners without a source; they are the Justice Centre's figures, put in the anti-trans "sex-based rights" framing, and are not repeated here as fact (4, p. 24).
- Counsel's charity, Charter Advocates Canada (CRA BN 753651546RR0001): its FY2024 T3010 (period ending 2024-12-31; its only return in the CRA open data for 2013 to 2024; its FY2025 return is in the next item) records total revenue of CAD 2,315,000, and the only gift to it in that data is a gift of CAD 2,315,000 from the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms to Charter Advocates Canada (a gift to a qualified donee, recorded under the name "CHARTERE ADVOCATES CANADA"; document id 817174865RR0001|2024-12-31|2); expenditures 1,878,600, of which charitable programs 1,732,848 and management and administration 145,752; total assets 1,070,659. These are the finances of counsel's charity, not the plaintiff's. The return does not state a purpose for the gift, and its fiscal year ended before the claim was filed on 2025-04-07 (CRA List of charities, T3010 open data 2013-2024, BN 753651546RR0001).
- Charter Advocates Canada's T3010 for the period ending 2025-12-31 (BN 753651546RR0001) reports total revenue of CAD 2,602,566: gifts from other registered charities CAD 2,577,017 (99.02%), receipted donations CAD 25,000 (0.96%) and other revenue CAD 549; expenses CAD 2,455,603 (charitable programs CAD 2,092,660; management and administration CAD 362,943); no gifts to other charities; 8 full-time and 4 part-time employees (CRA List of charities, 5, accessed 2026-11-16). The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms' T3010 for the same period (BN 817174865RR0001) reports gifts to qualified donees of CAD 2,577,017, and its qualified donees worksheet lists one donee, "CHARTER ADVOCATES CANADA" (753651546RR0001, Toronto ON), total CAD 2,577,017 (6 and 7, accessed 2026-11-16). The two figures are equal. The same Justice Centre return reports receipted donations of CAD 4,726,040 and gifts from other registered charities of CAD 1,581,594. The parts of the two returns cited here (the financial summaries and the Justice Centre's qualified donees worksheet) state no purpose for the gift and do not mention caWsbar or the claim (filed 2025-04-07, within this fiscal year, with Charter Advocates Canada's lawyers as counsel). Apart from the Justice Centre's gift, the only revenue on Charter Advocates' FY2025 return is CAD 25,000 of receipted donations and CAD 549 of other revenue; the return does not name donors.
- Its own donations page says "100% of donor contributions go to our basic administrative costs such as website and email hosting fees, as well as any events or initiatives we undertake", that it is "an all-volunteer, all-women led grassroots organization", and "We receive no public funding or corporate sponsorship whatsoever"; it names no other recipient or funder and does not mention litigation costs (8, accessed 2026-11-11).
- Counsel's Litigation Director swore on 2025-12-04 that Charter Advocates Canada "receives grant funding" and will fund expert reports and other disbursements in the claim; the affidavit names no funder (Federal Court T-1146-25, affidavit hosted by JCCF, paragraph 13).
- A charity, The Democracy Fund (CRA BN 779176676RR0001, Ontario), sponsored the group's first "Reality Based Women" conference of 2024-03-08 (the event's name is the group's anti-trans framing, which denies that trans women are women; it is made in bad faith): the post by Amy Hamm of 2024-03-11 says the event "was also sponsored by The Democracy Fund" and thanks two organizers; it states no amount (Substack post "IWD 2024: caWsbar's first annual 'Reality Based Women' event", 9). A critical site (Transgender Map, an advocacy site) says the event was "significantly funded" by The Democracy Fund; that wording is the site's and is not confirmed by a filing. This is event sponsorship, not funding of the Federal Court claim. The Democracy Fund's FY2024 T3010 (period ending 2024-12-31): total revenue CAD 1,756,166; expenditures CAD 1,725,814, of which charitable programs 1,486,678 and management and administration 192,779; total assets 784,564; gifts to qualified donees 29,200. Besides charitable programs and management and administration, the expenditures include those gifts and a grant of CAD 17,156 to a non-qualified donee (CRA List of charities, T3010 open data 2013-2024, BN 779176676RR0001). The charity's own site says it is "entirely donor-funded, without any government support" (thedemocracyfund.ca homepage, accessed 2026-11-11).
- The 2025 edition of the group's International Women's Day event was also sponsored by The Democracy Fund, on the charity's own account. The Democracy Fund's 2025 Annual Review (dated 2025-12-16, 10), in its list of events it sponsored besides its own journalism conference, says: "The Democracy Fund was again a proud sponsor of an International Women's Day event organized by Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights (caWsbar) titled "Reality Based Women Unite" in Calgary. This event featured prominent speakers such as Amy Hamm, Drea Humphry, and Kara Dansky and focused on women's rights and protections." The review states no amount and gives no date for the event itself; the review covers 2025, and the group's own news page already links a video of the 2025 edition in Calgary. The description "focused on women's rights and protections" is the charity's wording; the event is one organized by a group that campaigns against trans women's access to women's spaces, and its name, like the group's other anti-trans rhetoric, is made in bad faith. The review does not mention the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms or any gift to it.
- The Democracy Fund's T3010 rows record a gift to a qualified donee of CAD 50,000 from The Democracy Fund (the giver) to the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (the receiver) (period ending 2023-12-31; document id 779176676RR0001|2023-12-31|1). The Justice Centre says it funded the lawyers for the claim; the filing does not link the gift to the claim (CRA List of charities, BN 779176676RR0001).
- The CRA open data for The Democracy Fund runs to fiscal year 2024 (the FY2024 return, given above, shows no gift row to caWsbar, which is not a charity and could not receive a qualified-donee gift). (CRA List of charities, BN 779176676RR0001.)
- The group's own posts name the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms as the funder of the legal action and Charter Advocates Canada as its counsel. Its post of "May 14" (the page prints no year; 2026 follows from the Federal Court order cited below), "Breaking: Our Charter challenge to make prisons single-sex will proceed!", says "We extend our gratitude to the JCCF for funding this legal action, and to Charter Advocates Canada for representing caWsbar" (11, accessed 2026-11-20). Its post of 2025-04-07, "Charter challenge launched on behalf of caWsbar", says the challenge was "brought forward by Charter Advocates Canada, a law firm associated with the JCCF" and "developed in close collaboration with caWsbar co-founder Heather Mason", that "To proceed with the case, caWsbar formally incorporated as a non-profit organization in June 2024", and is signed "The caWsbar Board of Directors and Steering Committee" (12, accessed 2026-11-20). Its year-end post of 2025-12-31, "Moving Courageously into 2026 with Momentum", says "We owe a debt of gratitude to the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (JCCF) for funding the Challenge, and to Charter Advocates Canada for representing caWsbar in this ground-breaking legal action" (13, accessed 2026-11-20). None of the three gives an amount or says how the funding is arranged; the Chair's affidavit (below) says counsel acted pro bono, and the two statements are reported side by side, not reconciled.
- The year-end post of 2025-12-31 describes the Calgary event "Reality Based Women Unite 2025" as "Our Second Annual Conference" and says "Our thanks go out the The Democracy Fund for their ongoing support of our annual conferences." (the doubled "the" is in the post) (13, accessed 2026-11-20). This is the group's own statement of support from The Democracy Fund (CRA BN 779176676RR0001) for its conferences; it gives no amount. The post names the Montreal 2026 event but ties no sponsor to it. It agrees with the 2024 sponsorship (Amy Hamm's post of 2024-03-11) and the 2025 sponsorship (The Democracy Fund's 2025 Annual Review) given above, and sets this thanks beside its thanks to the Justice Centre for funding the Charter challenge.
- The group's "What You Can Do" page ("Make a donation") says donations help "our volunteers cover the costs of educating the public" and that "Our current fundraising effort focuses on our Charter challenge to protect incarcerated women from being housed with male offenders." The page states no amount and names no recipient of the money, and it does not say that donations pay for counsel's fees or the court costs of the claim; it sits beside the donations page's statement that all donor contributions go to administrative costs, events and initiatives, so the group's own pages describe the use of donations in two ways (14, accessed 2026-11-20; 8, accessed 2026-11-11). The "male offenders" wording misgenders trans women and is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- The group's Statement on Non-Partisanship says, in point 5, "if any legitimate donor or sponsor wishes to fund our activities with an arms-length approach, we retain the right to entertain the proposal", and, in point 7, that it remains "strictly grassroots, woman-centred and women-led, while being open to accepting financial and practical assistance from men who advance our cause whenever necessary" (15, accessed 2026-11-20). This sits beside the donations page's statement that it receives "no public funding or corporate sponsorship whatsoever": the non-partisanship page reserves the right to consider a sponsor's offer, and it names no sponsor.
- Its own online shop lists 31 products in all, priced in dollars with a stated range of CA$15 to CA$38, from CA$15 (40-sticker packs) to CA$38 (unisex long-sleeve tees): t-shirts and tank tops (CA$32 to CA$34), stickers (CA$15 to CA$30), 50-packs of postcards (CA$20), mugs and a mouse pad (CA$22), a tote bag and embroidered caps (CA$32). The shop states no sales figure and does not say who runs it or where the proceeds go, so no shop revenue is given here (16 and 17, accessed 2026-11-20). Several items carry slogans such as "Biological reality" and "Woman: fact, not feeling"; slogans of this kind are made in bad faith.
People on file
- Corporations Canada, corporation 1612314-7 (18, accessed 2026-11-17): incorporated 2024-06-13 by certificate of incorporation, status Active, registered office in Ontario (Oshawa), minimum 1 and maximum 10 directors. It lists four directors. One, Maureen Sullivan, also signed the group's parliamentary brief as "Board Member" (see below). A second, Heather Mason, states in her affidavit that she is a director and chairs the Board (see Founding and Chair below). The other two directors are not named here as directors, because that role appears only in the registry record. The record gives the status of annual filings as "Filed" for 2025 and for 2026 (accessed 2026-11-17). LittleSis (19) lists eight board-member positions, among them Esme Vee (a pseudonym, who signed the brief below); these are LittleSis entries only; for the persons also listed on the group's Steering Committee page the role is sourced there, and for the others it remains a lead, not a tie.
- Corporations Canada open data (corporation 1612314-7, 18): anniversary date 2024-06-13, last annual meeting 2025-10-29, director range 1 to 10. The open data lists no directors or officers.
- The site's Steering Committee page lists ten members (three marked as pseudonyms): Amy Eileen Hamm, Carol Bamford, Esme Vee (pseudonym), Heather Mason, Linda Blade, Maureen Sullivan, Raine McLeod, Tania A (pseudonym), Toni Vonk (pseudonym) and Trish Oliver (2, accessed 2026-11-10). The page does not say which members are directors. It describes Amy Eileen Hamm as a columnist at the National Post, Reduxx and The New Westminster Times and co-host of the Gender Critical Story Hour; it does not call her a co-founder; the group's Critical Thinkers page, however, reproduces her X bio, which says "co-founder of #GIDYVR and @cawsbar" (20, accessed 2026-11-19), and the group's letter of 2025-08-18 to the Speaker of the Senate calls her "one of our founding members" (21, accessed 2026-11-20). It describes Heather Mason as a former incarcerated woman who advocates for women in the justice system, Linda Blade as a track and field medallist and coach and author of "Unsporting: How Trans Activism and Science Denial Are Destroying Sport" (a title that is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith), and Trish Oliver as a researcher, writer and educator and a founding member of the Women's Liberation Front (WoLF). Mia Hughes does not appear on that page, so a "founding member" claim from Transgender Map is unconfirmed.
- The Corporations Canada record page for Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights (corporation 1612314-7, accessed 2026-11-11) lists four directors and a type of "Soliciting"; the name history shows one name only, Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights, from 2024-06-13; by-laws were received 2024-10-04; the status of annual filings reads "Filed" for 2025 and for 2026 (read again 2026-11-17). The four director names on that page are the same as four of the ten members listed on the group's Steering Committee page, one of them the Board Member who signed the 2025-12-12 brief to the House of Commons committee. One of the other three, Heather Mason, states in her affidavit that she is a director and Chair of the Board (see Founding and Chair below); the remaining two are not named here as directors, because that role appears only in the registry record. (Corporations Canada, 18, accessed 2026-11-11; 2, accessed 2026-11-10.)
- The registry's four directors do not include the persons whom LittleSis lists as board members and who are not on that list (Amy Hamm, a second person named only by LittleSis, Esme Vee (a pseudonym), a pseudonymous Steering Committee member and one more). So the LittleSis "board" entries for those persons are not confirmed by the registry page accessed 2026-11-11 (the registry may lag). (Corporations Canada, 18, accessed 2026-11-11; LittleSis relationships 1940898 to 1940905, 22 to 23)
- The Corporations Canada record page for corporation 1612314-7 (accessed 2026-11-11) lists as documents the Certificate of Incorporation (2024-06-13) and by-laws (received 2024-10-04) and offers only the ordering of copies. The registry record gives no offices and no first board. (Corporations Canada, 18, accessed 2026-11-11.)
- Founding and Chair: Two court documents say it was founded in 2019 as an unincorporated association and name its chair. The affidavit of Heather Mason (sworn remotely 2025-12-05, Federal Court T-1146-25, Motion Record of the Moving Party, tab 2a, hosted by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms at 24) says: "CAWSBAR was founded in 2019 as an unincorporated association of women who support sex-based rights. I was a founding member and a member of the steering committee" (paragraph 2); "In June of 2024 CAWSBAR was formally incorporated as a non-profit corporation... I am one of five listed directors of the corporation. I serve as the Chair of the Board of Directors and have done so since June of 2024" (paragraph 3); "CAWSBAR was founded in December of 2019" (paragraph 18). The affidavit, sworn 2025-12-05, gives five listed directors; the Corporations Canada record page, accessed 2026-11-11 and again 2026-11-17, lists four (see People on file). Neither source explains the difference; both counts are reported as given, each with its date. The Articles of Incorporation (form 4001, Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act, exhibit A) carry one incorporator's declaration, signed by Heather Mason. The Federal Court's order and reasons of 2026-05-14 (Case Management Judge Catharine Moore, T-1146-25, public interest standing, 25) records at paragraph 4 that she is "one of its founding members and a member of its steering committee" and "also serves as a Director and chairs the Board of Directors". Her own exhibit of publications lists a talk titled "Women in Prison: Heather Mason founding member of CaWsbar Canada" (Women's Declaration International, 2021-04-03). These documents give her roles as founding member, steering committee member, incorporator and, since June 2024, Chair of the Board. The group's own Steering Committee page (2) lists her among its members.
- Founders in the group's own words: its year-end post of 2023-12-31, "Reflecting on our wins in 2023 and looking ahead to more in 2024", says "On December 12, we celebrated the 4th anniversary of our founding. What started as 10 concerned women banding together has now blossomed into a cross-country movement" (26, accessed 2026-11-20). The post gives no year for the founding itself; a fourth anniversary on December 12 in a post dated 2023-12-31 agrees with the founding date of 2019-12-12 given below, and the post names no one among the ten. Heather Mason is called "caWsbar co-founder" in the group's post of 2025-04-07 (12, accessed 2026-11-20), which names no one else as a founder. The group's letter of 2025-08-18 to the Speaker of the Senate, signed "Heather Mason, Chair, Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights - caWsbar", calls Amy Hamm "one of our founding members" and calls Esme Vee (a pseudonym; no operator is named here or in the letter) "fellow caWsbar founding member" (21, accessed 2026-11-20); the letter concerns a sitting senator's social media post and Hamm's employment as a nurse in British Columbia, and gives no date or committee seat for the founding. The Chair's signature agrees with her affidavit and the Federal Court's order of 2026-05-14 cited above. The group's pages do not say which of the ten women are the three named here. The Steering Committee page does not use the word (see the Steering Committee bullet above, which also gives the Critical Thinkers bio), and no filing or registry record dates the founding claim.
- Heather Mason also signed the joint submission of Women's Declaration International (WDI) Canada and caWsbar to the federal Employment Equity Act Review Task Force, letter dated 2024-06-22, as "Heather Mason - Founding member, Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights"; caWsbar posted it on 2024-07-08 (27; the same letter on WDI's own site: 28, accessed 2026-11-19). The letter's framing is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith (see Lobbying, testimony and legal matters). The Critical Thinkers page lists her with her own X bio text.
- Steering Committee members, from the group's own page (2, accessed 2026-11-19). Carol Bamford: "25 years working with and advocating for people with disabilities in Alberta before moving to Saskatchewan to become a librarian for a decade before retirement", "a long history of social justice and community work" and "now dedicated to the restoration of women's rights and the protection of children"; she is not among the committee names in the 2024-06-22 joint submission. Maureen Sullivan: described as "a businesswoman" who became involved after hearing Meghan Murphy testify at the Bill C-16 hearings in 2017, with the objective that "all our daughters' Charter rights be restored with the repeal of C-16" (Bill C-16 added gender identity to federal human-rights law; the framing is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith); her Board Member signature on the brief of 2025-12-12 and the Corporations Canada listing are given above. Raine McLeod: a writer, coordinator, student and activist from Calgary. Women's Declaration International's own page thanking her says she "served two crucial years as national coordinator of the Canada chapter of WDI, from its founding in fall 2020", that she put together two "Alberta Women Speak" protests in summer 2021 (Edmonton Legislature and Calgary City Hall), and that she authored and submitted a brief for WDI on the "dangers" of Bill C-6, later passed as Bill C-4 (29, accessed 2026-11-19; the page carries no date); the page describes Bill C-6 as a bill that "putatively outlawed conversion therapy", and opposing it is anti-trans advocacy made in bad faith. "Toni Vonk": the page marks the name with an asterisk as a pseudonym and describes the member as a coordinator, writer and arts communication specialist; no operator is named. Trish Oliver: a researcher, writer, educator and sculptor, and "a founding member of the Women's Liberation Front (WoLF)" (the founding-member statement is the group's own).
- Liza Vespi is named as a member of caWsbar's Steering Committee in the joint submission of 2024-06-22 (posted by the group on 2024-07-08), in a list of eight Steering Committee members that also names Amy Hamm, Heather Mason, Linda Blade, Trish Oliver and Maureen Sullivan (the two addresses given above, accessed 2026-11-19). She does not appear on the Steering Committee page as accessed on 2026-11-19, so her role is documented for mid-2024 only; the two sources give no occupation, other affiliation, statement or funding for her.
Lobbying, testimony and legal matters
- Federal Court T-1146-25, filed 2025-04-07: the statement of claim asks the court to declare Commissioner's Directive 100 of no force or effect. Paragraph 4 says "CAWSBAR is a federally incorporated non-profit organization. Since 2019, CAWSBAR has worked to preserve the sex-based rights and protections of women and girls across Canada", including "prisons, washrooms and changing rooms, sporting competitions". Counsel: Charter Advocates Canada; the statement of claim names three of its lawyers as counsel for the plaintiff. The pleading is limited to that directive. The group filed it as a public interest litigant for women prisoners and asks the court to declare that Commissioner's Directive 100 (Gender Diverse Offenders) violates sections 7, 12 and 15 of the Charter as the claim describes the rights of women prisoners, and that it is therefore void and of no force or effect (p. 19; the claim's own wording misgenders trans women and is not reproduced here). The claim defines sex as "either of the two main categories (Male and Female) by which humans are distinguished on the basis of their reproductive functions, as observed at or prior to birth." (p. 22). Case status: on 2026-05-14 the Federal Court dismissed the Crown's motion to strike this claim and granted the plaintiff public interest standing; the Crown denied the claim on 2026-08-31 and the case is pending. (Statement of claim (party), Federal Court (Canada), No. T-1146-25, 2025-04-07, pp. 19, 22; 30; copy hosted by a third party)
- JCCF's page of 2026-05-14 (31) says "Lawyers funded by the Justice Centre filed the claim", that the Crown's motion to strike was dismissed and public interest standing granted, and that no next hearing was scheduled (JCCF's account). The orders themselves, both dated 2026-05-14 and issued by Judge Catharine Moore (Case Management Judge; the standing order's signature block reads "Associate Judge") (Federal Court, T-1146-25, hosted by JCCF), confirm it: the first dismisses the Crown's motion to strike and makes no findings on the merits (32); the second finds that "the Plaintiff satisfies the test for public interest standing", states "I grant CAWSBAR public interest standing" and orders that "The Plaintiff shall have its costs in any event of the cause" (25). The Crown's Statement of Defence is dated 2026-08-31 and says CD 100 is an ameliorative policy and "wholly denies" the alleged harms (Statement of Defence, Federal Court T-1146-25, 2026-08-31, 33). The group's own site (cawsbar.ca) headlines the result "Breaking: Our Charter challenge to make prisons single-sex will proceed!", with the summary line "Our first victory!", and carries a "Donate Today" button. The post says "We extend our gratitude to the JCCF for funding this legal action, and to Charter Advocates Canada for representing caWsbar", and asks readers to help "with the administrative costs we're incurring to hold the Government of Canada to account" through its donation page (11). The claim targets adult trans women's housing, not children; the group's rhetoric is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith (Tracking Trans Hate assessment of the group's own words quoted under "Anti-trans work: documented moments" and "Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext"; method in the report).
- LittleSis entries (a "TERF organization" blurb and board links to Amy Hamm and others) are leads only and are not used.
- Counsel on the claim: Charter Advocates Canada's affidavit names its four assigned lawyers; a plaintiff affidavit and the notice of motion were filed on 2025-12-05 (JCCF case page, 34; the address is the Justice Centre's own, and its wording misgenders trans women; notice of motion, 35).
- What the LittleSis entries record (relationships unlabelled by date unless shown; leads only, none used as a tie): the group is listed as "Co-organizer" (2023) of "1 Million March 4 Children"; as "Collaborators" with LGB Alliance, Our Duty and Detrans Alliance Canada; as a related entity of Canadian Gender Report and AB Radical Feminists (no label); Trinity Productions as "Sponsor"; Scott Newgent as "Collaborators" (LittleSis relationships 1940897, 1957102, 1957123, 1957124, 1969139, 1969140, 1969141, 1952583; 19). The co-organizer entry was tested against two press reports of the march, PressProgress of 2023-09-19 and Xtra of 2023-10-20; neither names the group among organizers or sponsors. It stays unconfirmed.
- 2026-05-14 orders: The order of 2026-05-14 on standing records, from the Chair's affidavit, that the group "has neither the resources nor expertise to bring this claim on its own and that their counsel has accepted to work on the claim on a pro bono basis" (paragraph 11), and, from the Litigation Director's affidavit, that "four counsel are assigned to this case, that CAC receives grant funding to support its activities" (paragraph 14, which runs onto the next page). The Justice Centre says "lawyers funded by the Justice Centre" acted (Justice Centre case page, 34; the address is the Justice Centre's own, and its wording misgenders trans women); the Justice Centre thus names itself as the funder of the lawyers, while the Litigation Director's affidavit, as the order records it, names no source of the "grant funding"; the statements are reported side by side. The companion order of the same date on the Crown's Rule 221 motion (32) ends "The motion is dismissed" with costs to the plaintiff in any event of the cause; paragraph 36 says a claim struck for lack of material facts would have carried leave to amend. Both orders are procedural; neither decides the merits.
- 2025-12-12: caWsbar's brief to the House of Commons Standing Committee on the Status of Women, "How Gender Identity Ideology is Anti-Feminist", makes three recommendations to the Government of Canada, among them "Establish a commission to investigate government-funded hatred toward women, and particularly lesbians" (recommendation 1, p. 8) and "Acknowledge that the sex-based protections enshrined in the Charter are inviolable and supercede “gender identity and expression” rights" (recommendation 3, p. 8). The brief's summary claims that "Canadian 2SLGBTQIA+ influencers – including ones funded by the federal government – regularly espouse anti-feminist, hate-motivated incitement to violence against women who advocate for our Charter-enshrined sex-based protections." (p. 2). These are the group's claims and requests, and they are anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith: the brief's title calls gender identity an "ideology", its third recommendation asks that sex-based protections "supercede" the "gender identity and expression" rights that protect trans people, and its summary presents 2SLGBTQIA+ influencers as inciting violence against women who advocate for sex-based protections. (Brief to the Committee on the Status of Women on How Gender Identity Ideology is Anti-Feminist, House of Commons of Canada, Standing Committee on the Status of Women, 2025-12-12, p. 8; 36)
- 2026-01-23: motion record of the defendant, filed by the Attorney General of Canada under Rules 221(1)(a), (c) and (f), asking the Federal Court to strike the statement of claim in its entirety without leave to amend, with costs (p. 71). The defendant's representations say "The Plaintiff’s Statement of Claim (the “Claim”) is entirely devoid of material facts and should be struck without leave to amend." (p. 54; the defendant's words). The text is heavily redacted. Case status: The Federal Court dismissed this motion to strike on 2026-05-14 and granted the plaintiff public interest standing; the Crown filed its defence on 2026-08-31 and the case is pending. (Motion record of the defendant, on the motion to strike (party), Federal Court (Canada), No. T-1146-25, 2026-01-23, pp. 54, 71; 37; copy hosted by a third party)
- Joint submission, 2024: caWsbar posted on 2024-07-08 a "joint submission to the Employment Equity Act review consultation from two of Canada's national grassroots women's organizations", with Women's Declaration International - Canada (WDI Canada), in a letter dated 2024-06-22 to the Employment Equity Act Review Task Force. It argues that "woman" in the Act must be defined as "adult female human being", that forms should ask for biological sex, and that gender is "a social construct, based on sex stereotypes". The letter is signed by a WDI Canada coordinator and by Heather Mason as "Founding member, Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights", and lists eight caWsbar Steering Committee members, among them Linda Blade, Amy Hamm, Heather Mason, Trish Oliver, Maureen Sullivan and Toni Vonk (marked as a pseudonym on the Steering Committee page). It describes WDI Canada as "the Canadian component of the international organization" Women's Declaration International; the page does not itself describe a partnership between caWsbar and the international body. The submission calls trans women "males" and "men" who "take opportunities and protections", which is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith (27, accessed 2026-11-20). With the CEDAW submission above, this is the second joint submission with WDI Canada that the group's own site shows. WDI Canada's page lists its own submission to the same task force, dated 2024-06-22, and the joint CEDAW submission of 2024-09-03 (38, accessed 2026-11-19).
- Amy Hamm's professional-discipline case: on 2022-09-24 caWsbar posted, under its own name, a transcript of her counsel's opening statement at the hearing of the British Columbia College of Nurses and Midwives (BCCNM) of 2022-09-21; the post says the panel was hearing the matter on complaints from two members of the public that she made "discriminatory and derogatory statements regarding transgender people" (the group's news pages, post of 2022-09-24, accessed 2026-11-19). The post is a one-sided statement by her counsel, and its labels for trans people are anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. It is dated about two years before the group's incorporation (2024-06-13). In the statement counsel says the defence would call four witnesses: Kathleen Stock, Miriam Grossman, Linda Blade ("a former Canadian national athlete and now coach") and Heather Mason ("a former federal inmate"); it is a statement of intended witnesses. Her counsel is named only by firm here: the petition for judicial review of the BCCNM decision, filed in the Supreme Court of British Columbia, gives the petitioner's address for delivery as "c/o Libertas Law" (39, accessed 2026-11-19). The outcome of the hearing and the status of her appeal are on her own page. The group's post of the same date links "Mia Ashton for The Post Millennial", the article "EXCLUSIVE: 'Expert' witness testifies that being a lesbian is transphobic in trial against BC nurse", dated 2022-09-24, which reports day two of the hearing and describes Hamm as a co-founder of caWsbar (40, accessed 2026-11-19).
People named by the organization
- Maureen Sullivan, "Board Member", and Esme Vee, "Steering Committee Member", signed caWsbar's brief to the House of Commons Standing Committee on the Status of Women, "How Gender Identity Ideology is Anti-Feminist", dated 2025-12-12 (41). The Corporations Canada record lists Sullivan among the corporation's four directors (18, accessed 2026-11-17); its open data lists no directors (see People on file). Heather Mason, a member of the Steering Committee, chairs the Board of Directors, as her affidavit and the Federal Court's order of 2026-05-14 state (see Founding and Chair above).
- Mia Ashton: the group's year-end post of 2023-12-31 names her, with Heather Mason, Amy Hamm and Linda Blade, as one of its "spokeswomen", who "provided commentary on the big stories of the week every Thursday afternoon throughout the year on The Richard Syrett Show on Sauga 960 AM radio" (26, accessed 2026-11-20). She is not on the Steering Committee page, and the post gives her no other role and no dates beyond 2023. The Post Millennial's author page lists a Mia Ashton as "Reporter", the byline on the article about the Hamm hearing cited above (42, accessed 2026-11-19).
- Amy McKay is named in the group's year-end post of 2025-12-31 as one of three "associates" who in 2025 "stepped into the legal ring to challenge anti-woman laws and policies"; the post says she and a second associate "are also represented by the JCCF" (13, accessed 2026-11-19). The Justice Centre's release of 2025-11-14 says lawyers funded by the Justice Centre sent a legal letter to the Ontario College of Teachers for her, a former occasional teacher with the Ottawa-Carleton District School Board, after the College told her on 2025-05-13 that the board had filed a complaint about her social media posts on 2023-06-27 and offered her the choice of surrendering her teaching licence or facing an investigation; the release says she will not sign the undertaking and was awaiting the College's decision (43, accessed 2026-11-19; the Justice Centre's account, which describes her posts as "concerns about gender identity ideology, gender-affirming medical interventions, and women's sex-based rights"; that framing is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith).
- Bryony Dixon is named in the same post as one of the three associates who took legal action in 2025 and as represented by the Justice Centre (13, accessed 2026-11-19). The Justice Centre's release of 2025-10-20 says a complaint was filed with the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal on her behalf against the Board of Education of School District No. 68 (Nanaimo-Ladysmith), alleging it barred her from its Homestay program because of her political views, and describes her as "an advocate for sex-based rights" who has "been outspoken in her criticism of the Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity (SOGI) school curriculum" and has organized and taken part in public speaking events (44, accessed 2026-11-19; the Justice Centre's account; the release says the Tribunal had yet to decide whether to accept the complaint). Quoted in the release she says the district "denies girls their voice"; the release gives no evidence for that claim, and SOGI education is not evidence of any harm to girls.
- Kathy Drake is named in the same post as the third of the "associates"; the post says the other two are represented by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms and that "Kathy has had to engage private counsel at her own expense", and does not say what her case is (13, accessed 2026-11-19). Rebel News, an advocacy outlet, reported on 2025-11-28 that legal action followed a post she made on X on 2024-11-18, that her legal costs had grown and that a defence fund had been set up in her name; the article does not name the court or tribunal, the other party or the claim, or say whether she is claimant or respondent, and the two accounts are not shown to be the same matter (45, accessed 2026-11-19). The article reproduces the post, which opens "GROOMERS at MRU" and describes a table at an arts and craft sale at the university supporting a legal fund for trans-affirming families in Alberta; calling people who support trans people "groomers" is dehumanizing, bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. The article is the outlet's account.
- April Halley is listed on the group's "Critical Thinkers" page, which the page introduces as "A global who's who of inspiring women and men standing up for women's sex-based rights", with the description "Investigating and writing about the impact of gender identity policies on women and children in Canada" (20, accessed 2026-11-19). The listing is the group's own choice of people to feature and states no role in caWsbar. Her own brief on Bill C-6 (conversion therapy), submitted as Coordinator for the Newfoundland and Labrador branch of the Women's Human Rights Campaign, asks that "gender identity" be removed from the bill, calls gender-affirming care "inappropriate medical experiments" on children and says that treatments "can lead to a child's sterilization" (copy hosted by Women's Declaration International, 46, accessed 2026-11-19; the copy is undated in its text and is not the House of Commons address). Asking to strip gender identity from a ban on conversion practices, and calling care "medical experiments", is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- Barbara Kay is listed on the same page, described as "Weekly columnist at thepostmillennial.com. Monthly at the Epoch Times"; the listing states no role in caWsbar (20, accessed 2026-11-19). The Justice Centre's release of 2026-04-15 says lawyers it funds are representing her against three complaints to the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal, two arising from her social media posts of March 2025 and a March 30, 2026 interview, the third alleging retaliation; the release says the complaints concern her use of a prior name and male pronouns for the complainant, and quotes her: "I would never give credence to something as a reality when it is not a reality." (47, accessed 2026-11-19; the Justice Centre's account; the release says the Tribunal had not decided whether to accept the complaints). Refusing a person's name and pronouns is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. The group's post of 2020-01-17 reposts a National Post column by her of 2020-01-16 (see Diane Guilbault below).
- Brad Hunter is named on the group's post of 2019-11-29 "Trans killers & baby rapists terrifying female inmates" as the author of the article it reposts, "Written by Brad Hunter for the Toronto Sun, Nov 28, 2019", with an excerpt and a link to the full article (48, accessed 2026-11-19). The Toronto Sun page carries his byline on the column "HUNTER: Trans killers, baby rapists terrifying female inmates", published 2019-11-28, which opens at Grand Valley Institution (49, accessed 2026-11-19). The repost excerpt quotes Heather Mason on trans prisoners being placed "around women and children". The headline's "trans killers, baby rapists" is used for trans prisoners in general: dehumanizing anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. The repost is the group's choice; the pages cited say nothing of Hunter working with the group.
- Derrick Jensen is named on the group's Resources page under Videos and Podcasts: "Derrick Jensen interviews Susan Cox on queer theory" and an item titled "Queer Theory Pedophilia Jeopardy w/ Derrick Jensen" (50, accessed 2026-11-19). A title linking queer theory to pedophilia is a smear and anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. His own site carries a post of 2013-06-21 by him and Lierre Keith, "The Emperor's New Penis", which describes queer activists' objections to Deep Green Resistance as male supremacy and says feminism "is being disappeared" (51, accessed 2026-11-19). Gizmodo reported on 2022-02-09 that a Deep Green Resistance activist and the organization's two co-founders wrote a 2019 Feminist Current essay opening with "Hands up everyone who predicted that when Big Brother arrived, he'd be wearing a dress", that Jensen's radio show features guests with anti-trans views, and that Aric McBay, an original author of the organization's 2011 book, left in 2012 "after a trans inclusive policy was canceled by Derrick Jensen and Lierre Keith" (52, accessed 2026-11-19). The Resources page states no role for him in caWsbar. Jensen is also the interviewer in an item listed with Susan Cox (below).
- Lierre Keith is named on the group's post of 2019-10-05, "It's time for us all to stand up against Big 'Sister'", which says it was "written by DERRICK JENSEN, LIERRE KEITH, MAX WILBERT for Feminist Current" and reposts an extract (53, accessed 2026-11-19). The extract says "Fight for the children, especially the lesbian and gay kids, who are being sterilized and forever denied their future sexual function"; that is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith, and is the authors' claim, not a fact. Gizmodo (2022-02-09) quotes the opening line of a 2019 Feminist Current essay by the same three authors, which mocks trans women, and reports that Keith described people who have gender-affirming surgery as like people who glorify anorexia and called trans people "genderists" at a Deep Green Resistance fundraiser livestream (the outlet's account). Deep Green Resistance Inc (EIN 83-1753748) lists Lierre Keith as Treasurer, with compensation of $25,473, and Derrick Jensen as President on its Form 990-EZ for the year ending December 2025, filed 2026-03-26 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 54, accessed 2026-11-19). The post states no role for Keith in caWsbar.
- Max Wilbert is named in the same post of 2019-10-05 as one of the three authors (53, accessed 2026-11-19). His publisher's biography says he "serves on the Board of Directors of Deep Green Resistance", is editor-in-chief of the Deep Green Resistance News Service and produces the podcast The Green Flame, and that Bright Green Lies is his second book (55, accessed 2026-11-19). Gizmodo reports that Wilbert told Earther that he is a paid contractor for Deep Green Resistance, that Deep Green Resistance's co-founder described the group as the fiscal umbrella of the Thacker Pass protest effort he helped run, that a partner group cut ties after learning of Deep Green Resistance's views on trans people, and that he and others have complained those views made it hard to find a publisher; it says he declined to comment to that reporter on his own views on gender (52, accessed 2026-11-19; the outlet's account). The post states no role for him in caWsbar.
- Eva Kurilova is named on the group's news post of 2024-03-18, "Reality Based Women Unite - watch our International Women's Day event online now", as one of "some of our amazing speakers" at its 2024 International Women's Day event; the post links her Substack reflection on the event, "The Inaugural Reality Based Women Unite!" (56, accessed 2026-11-19). The event's name is the group's anti-trans framing; it is made in bad faith. Her Substack profile describes her as "a writer from Calgary, Alberta" and her publication as "Eva's Essays" (57, accessed 2026-11-19). In a guest post of 2022-07-25 on the Substack "Reality's Last Stand" she argues against treating childhood gender nonconformity as a medical matter, criticizing the path from social transition to puberty blockers, hormones and surgery (58, accessed 2026-11-19). Presenting access to gender-affirming care as medicalizing children is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- felicia rembrandt is named, under that spelling, on the group's year-end post of 2023-12-31 in a list of its 2023 activities: "Eva Kurilova and felicia rembrandt wrote regular Substacks" (26, accessed 2026-11-19). The post does not call her an associate or give her an office. Her Substack profile reads "Former Editor, genderdissent.com" (59, accessed 2026-11-19). The page uses a pen name as listed; no other name is given or inferred.
- Jerry Agar is named on the group's repost "There was nothing wrong with Canada's J.K. Rowling billboard" as "Written by Jerry Agar for the Toronto Sun, Sept 14th, 2020"; the repost is dated 2020-09-20 on the group's site (60, accessed 2026-11-19). Wikipedia (secondary; dump of 2026-10-01, 61) describes him as host of the Jerry Agar Show on CFRB since 2010. The repost is the group's choice; the page says nothing of Agar working with the group.
- Julia D. Robertson is named on the group's repost of 2019-09-24, "No one is born in the wrong body", as a co-author with two others of the Quillette essay of the same date (62, accessed 2026-11-19). The Quillette essay (63, accessed 2026-11-19) lists the same three authors and says "no child is actually born in the wrong body" and calls gender affirmation an approach that "makes gender dysphoria less likely to resolve"; this is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith, and runs against the evidence brief's standing statements on gender-affirming care. The page and the repost say nothing of her working with the group.
- Julian Vigo is named on the group's repost of the Quillette essay "At the NHS and BBC, Important Steps Toward Restoring Balance in the Gender Debate" ("Written by Julian Vigo for the Quillette, Aug 5th, 2020"; the repost is dated 2020-08-24 on the group's site) (64, accessed 2026-11-19). Quillette's author page describes her as "a freelance writer, journalist, and filmmaker" and lists, among her articles, "Trans Activists' Campaign Against TERFs Has Become an Attack on Science" (2018-10-18), "Confronting a New Threat to Female Athletics" (2019-02-27) and the essay above (65, accessed 2026-11-19). The page and the repost say nothing of her working with the group.
- Karen Finlay is named on the group's repost dated 2019-11-28, "Canadian women launch petition against Bill C-16", as "Written by Karen Finlay for Women are Human" (66, accessed 2026-11-19). The repost opens "On November 21, 2019, a group of Canadian women publicly launched a petition calling for the repeal of..." and says Bill C-16 added gender identity or expression to the prohibited grounds of discrimination in the Canadian Human Rights Act. Calling for repeal of Bill C-16 is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- Lindsay Shepherd is listed on the "Critical Thinkers" page; her entry reads "Campus Free Speech Fellow, @JCCFCanada. Investigative Journalism Fellow, @TrueNorthCentre. Columnist, @TPostMillennial." (20, accessed 2026-11-19). The entry is her own self-description as the page prints it and states no role in caWsbar. The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms' own announcement of 2019-02-07 says it was "pleased to welcome Lindsay Shepherd to its growing team" as Campus Free Speech Fellow (67, accessed 2026-11-20). In a spiked interview of 2019-07-23 she discusses her Twitter ban after a clash with a trans woman litigant, misgenders her and describes her with sexualized and demeaning language (the target is not named here) (68, accessed 2026-11-19); the interview's framing and her wording are anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- Libby Emmons is named on the group's post of 2021-07-11, "Canadian nurse under investigation by College of Nurses for expressing gender critical views", which consists of a headline and the line "Read the full story by Libby Emmons at The Post Millennial" (69, accessed 2026-11-19). The Post Millennial article carries her byline and the date 2021-07-10; it presents the nurse's disciplinary investigation by the BC College of Nurses and Midwives as harassment and calls trans people "transgender ideologues" (70, accessed 2026-11-19); the framing is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. The group's post only links her story and states no role for her in caWsbar.
- Meghan Murphy: the Critical Thinkers page lists her with the line "Meghan Murphy is a freelance writer and journalist, and is the founder and editor of Feminist Current"; the same entry appears on 50 (20, accessed 2026-11-20). The page presents anti-trans activism as "inspiring"; that is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. She is one entry among many, and the pages do not say she took part in a caWsbar event. The Standing Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs lists "Meghan Murphy, as an individual" as a witness on 2017-05-10, when it was considering Bill C-16, "An Act to amend the Canadian Human Rights Act and the Criminal Code" (71, accessed 2026-11-20; the page gives the witness and date, not her words). Global News's results page for Vancouver East in the 2025 federal election lists "People's Party: Meghan Murphy" among the candidates, without identifying her as the writer (72, accessed 2026-11-20).
- Michele Moore: the group's "Videos & Podcasts" page lists a talk, "A Woman's Place takes nerves of steel (Sheffield, 20th September 2018) Michele Moore", described as "the Co-Editor of the ground-breaking book Transgender Children and Young People, Born in Your Own Body from Cambridge Scholars", who "will be discussing ideas from the book - the implications of self-declaration of gender for children and young people, including disabled children" (50, accessed 2026-11-20). The book is listed as by Heather Brunskell-Evans and Michele Moore, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, published 18 April 2018 (London South Bank University research portal, 73, accessed 2026-11-20). The Times Higher Education review of 15 March 2018 by a Newcastle University geographer reports that the editors identify as "gender critical feminists" and says Moore's own account of transgender theory "leans on dated and inaccurate stereotypes of trans identities" (74, accessed 2026-11-20; the reviewer's view). Woman's Place UK's post of 21 June 2019 calls her "Professor Michele Moore, the editor" of the journal Disability & Society, says she "spoke at our Sheffield meeting", and says the video of the speech had been viewed "nearly 26,000 times" (75, accessed 2026-11-20; the organization's own account). The group's page links a third-party talk; it does not say she took part in a caWsbar event.
- Rosie DiManno: the group's post of 2020-03-03 republishes an extract of her Toronto Star article of 2020-02-20, "As transgender rights improve, prisons struggle with tough decisions", with the line "Written by Rosie DiManno for the Toronto Star, Feb 20, 2020" and a link to the full article (76, accessed 2026-11-20). The extract describes one prisoner in a women's prison and its wording misgenders a trans woman. She has been a columnist with the Toronto Star since 1989 (77, accessed 2026-11-20). The post is the group's use of a newspaper column; the sources cited show no tie between her and the group.
- Shahdin Farsai: the group's post of 2021-02-05 (updated 2021-03-04) republishes an opinion piece, "British Columbia's directions on pronouns in court are problematic", "Written by Shahdin Farsai for the Canadian Lawyer Magazine, Feb 5th, 2021", with a note attributed to Canadian Gender Report that says the magazine's editors removed it "under pressure from activists" (the note's claim). The piece objects to the BC Supreme and Provincial Courts' practice directions of 2020-12-16 asking parties and lawyers to state their pronouns, calling them "potentially compelled speech in court", a breach of privacy rights and a harm to "the perception of judicial impartiality"; opposing trans people's pronouns in court is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith (78, accessed 2026-11-20). Canadian Lawyer's own notice of 2021-02-07 says the article "has been removed" and does not name the author (79, accessed 2026-11-20). A May 2021 essay in C2C Journal describes its author as "a lawyer practising in Kelowna, B.C." and says the magazine took the piece down within about three days after a letter signed by fewer than 200 lawyers, plus a number of law students and paralegals (80, accessed 2026-11-20; the author's account). The post republishes an article; the sources cited show no tie between the author and the group.
- David Menzies: the group's post of 2024-03-18, "Reality Based Women Unite! Watch Our International Women's Day Event Online Now", says "Watch exclusive coverage of the event by David Menzies of Rebel News featuring interviews with Heather, Amy, Meghan, Eva and April" (56, accessed 2026-11-20); the event is the group's first "Reality Based Women Unite" event of 2024-03-08 given above. Menzies' Rebel News article of 2024-03-19 says Rebel News covered an event called "An International Women's Day Celebration" where Heather Mason "played a key role in organizing", and that her advocacy on moving prisoners from male to women's prisons led her to a grassroots group "known as Canadian Women's Sex-based Rights, or CaWsbar" (81, accessed 2026-11-20); the article's wording misgenders a trans woman and calls transfers of trans women "ludicrous", which is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. The two pages name the event differently. Rebel News calls Menzies its "Mission Specialist". The post shows a reporter covering and interviewing speakers; it shows no appearance on stage, no funding and no joint work with caWsbar. The group's caption points to the coverage but does not reproduce it, and states no payment or agreement with Rebel News.
- Madeleine Kearns is listed on the "Critical Thinkers" page with the bio "Writer @NRO | Also @Spectator, @WSJ, and @Telegraph" (20, accessed 2026-11-20). The page shows no appearance, event or joint work with caWsbar. She is a contributing writer at The Free Press, "previously ... a staff writer at National Review" (82, accessed 2026-11-20; no dates given for the National Review post), and was named a visiting fellow of the Independent Women's Forum in a post of 2022-01-20 that describes her as "a staff writer at National Review and a contributor to The Spectator" (83, accessed 2026-11-20). Her Spectator pieces on trans people (for example "The grim reality of gender reassignment", 2021-11-13, and "Elliot Page's memoir is a tale of tragic self-destruction", 2023-07-17) are given on the Spectator page (84).
- Natasha Chart is listed on the same page with the bio "Heretic. Women are female. No pomo, no tankies, no authoritarians." (20, accessed 2026-11-20). The page shows no appearance or joint work with caWsbar. Her role at the Women's Liberation Front (board chair and executive director) is given on that organization's page; its own interview post is headed "An Interview with Wolf Board Chair Natasha Chart" (85, accessed 2026-11-20).
- "Posie Parker" is listed on the "Critical Thinkers" page with a YouTube bio beginning "Being female has shaped my life from the moment I was born" (20, accessed 2026-11-20). The name is the public pseudonym of Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull: Radio New Zealand writes "Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull, known as Posie Parker" and reports analysts saying online hatred of trans people in New Zealand rose markedly after her 2023 visit (the analysts' view) (RNZ, 2023-04-10, 86, accessed 2026-11-20). The Let Women Speak site says the movement was "founded by the fearless British campaigner Kellie-Jay Keen" (87, accessed 2026-11-20). The listing shows no appearance or joint work with caWsbar.
- Dr Ray Blanchard is listed under "Critical Thinkers" on the group's Resources page with the bio "Researcher in sexual orientation, paraphilias, & gender identity disorders" (50, accessed 2026-11-20). It shows no appearance or joint work with caWsbar. His 1989 paper "The classification and labeling of nonhomosexual gender dysphorias" (Archives of Sexual Behavior 18, pp. 315-334) classifies "biological males" with "nonhomosexual gender identity disorders" (88, abstract). His listing on the Gender Dysphoria Alliance advisory board is given on the Christina Buttons page.
- Diane Guilbault is named in the group's post of 2020-01-17 reposting a National Post column by Barbara Kay (written 2020-01-16), which says a Quebec group, Pour les Droits des Femmes (For Women's Rights), asked the federal government as early as November 2016 to release the gender-based analysis done for Bill C-16 and that "a women's rights activist who goes by the name of 'Jennifer Anne' joined forces with Diane Guilbault of PDF" to keep pressing; the column adds that this activist "is now affiliated with, and supported by caWsbar" (89, accessed 2026-11-20). The post shows no role for Guilbault at caWsbar. Reading the column's "PDF" as the Quebec group, La Converse's report of 2022-04-15 says she "was president of PDF Québec at the time" and quotes her telling Le Devoir that its provincial funding was "financial assistance to help [its members] pursue [their] projects" (90, accessed 2026-11-20). The same report says the group has received annual funding since 2019 from Quebec's Ministry of Labour, Employment and Social Solidarity (119,553 for 2019-2020, 123,545 renewed in 2020, and 124,780 in the budget announced in March 2022, for that year, as the article gives them, in dollars), that it backs Quebec's Bill 21, and that trans women and a Quebec Liberal member of the provincial National Assembly (the English text of the source says MP) criticised the funding; those are the critics' words, reported by the outlet.
- Andreia Nobre is listed on the "Critical Thinkers" page with the bio "Jornalista, poetisa, ativista, sometimes comedienne." (20, accessed 2026-11-20). The page shows no appearance or joint work with caWsbar. Transgender Map, an advocacy site critical of her, says she is a Brazilian writer who has written for QG Feminista, 4W and Uncommon Ground Media and, it says, dozens of anti-trans pieces since about 2019 (91, accessed 2026-11-20; the site's characterisation). A 4W article of 2023-03-21 on a Brazilian list of women is bylined Andreia Nobre (92, accessed 2026-11-20); no source links that byline to the name on caWsbar's listing, which gives a Portuguese-language bio only.
- Ani O'Brien is listed on the same page with the bio "Woefully gynocentric ... Gender-critical radical feminist. DMs open for respectful, confidential chats." (20, accessed 2026-11-20). The page shows no appearance or joint work with caWsbar. Speak Up For Women, a New Zealand group formed in 2018 whose stated mission is to "advocate for the sex based rights of women and girls" (93, accessed 2026-11-20), published on 2019-11-19 a report of its "Feminism 2020" event in Wellington, which calls her its "spokesperson" and quotes her ("These events demonstrate that feminism that centres women is alive and well") (94, accessed 2026-11-20). The same report says the event featured Meghan Murphy and that Murphy was banned from Twitter for "misgendering" a Canadian trans woman; misgendering is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. A Good Oil podcast page of 2025-04-24 describes her as "a founding member of the Free Speech Union" (95, accessed 2026-11-20); the Free Speech Union's own about page (96) does not name her.
- Women's Declaration International Canada coordinators: the joint submission of 2024-06-22 (posted by the group on 2024-07-08) carries a list headed "Women's Declaration International (WDI) - Canada coordinators" under its signature block, whose first signatory is the Coordinator of WDI Canada; the page does not say which listed people signed (27, accessed 2026-11-20). The list names Charlotte Garrett, "Coordinator, WDI Saskatchewan"; Ghislaine Gendron, "Coordinator, WDI Quebec"; Kathleen Hays, "Coordinator, WDI Manitoba"; Leslie Cameron, "Coordinator, WDI Alberta"; Mary Catharine Kennedy, "Coordinator, WDI Ontario"; and Nina Tryggvason, "Coordinator, WDI BC & Yukon". WDI's own copy of the same submission lists Garrett in that role and carries one signature line naming the Coordinator of WDI Canada (28, accessed 2026-11-20), and lists Hays in the same role. WDI's own page thanking Raine McLeod, the first national coordinator of WDI Canada (founded fall 2020), says "In this role Raine worked closely with Ghislaine Gendron, Francophone coordinator" (29, accessed 2026-11-20; undated). The submission asks that women stay a designated group under the Act, defined as "adult female human beings", and its framing of women's protections against trans people is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. It lists the eight caWsbar Steering Committee members beside the coordinators. One joint filing; no continuing relationship is shown.
- Emma Hilton is listed on the "Critical Thinkers" page as "Dr Emma Hilton - UK" with the bio "Developmental biologist. Research fellow and occasional lecturer. All views are my own. Manchester." (20, accessed 2026-11-20). The page shows no appearance or joint work with caWsbar. Her curriculum vitae, attached to her Supreme Court amicus brief of 2025-09-19, lists her as postdoctoral research fellow at the University of Manchester from 2019-04, with earlier research posts there from 2003 (97, Appendix A). In that brief, filed with the International Consortium on Female Sport in Supreme Court Nos. 24-38 and 24-43 in support of the petitioners, she argues for sex-verification screening of athletes for the female category of sport; the brief says she and the Consortium alone funded it (same address, p. 1 and note 1). The brief supports state laws that exclude trans girls and women from girls' and women's sport; presenting that exclusion as protection of women's sport is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. In her own sworn statement in the brief's appendix she says: "Since 2021, I have served as a board member and now trustee of Sex Matters", unpaid (same address, p. A-16).
- Graham Linehan (the site spells the surname "Lineham") is listed on the "Critical Thinkers" page with the line "Be brave. Stop apologising to bullies." (20, accessed 2026-11-19). Both reports cited call him the co-creator of Father Ted. The Irish Times reported that he was arrested at Heathrow on 2025-09-01 on suspicion of inciting violence over three posts on X from April 2025; he was released on bail pending investigation (98). RTE reported that on 2025-11-25 Westminster Magistrates' Court found him not guilty of harassing a transgender woman and guilty of criminal damage to her phone, with a 500 pound penalty, and that his barrister told the court he would appeal (99). The listing on the page is the only tie to caWsbar shown.
- Elisa Rae Shupe appears under "Critical Thinkers" on the group's Resources page, listed under the name she used before 2022, with the quoted line "I reclaimed my male birth sex after becoming America's first legally non-binary person because transgenderism is a fraud and gender identity is legal fiction." The wording is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith (50, accessed 2026-11-19). Mother Jones reported in March 2023 that she had since retransitioned, disavowed much of her earlier activism and shared her copies of a working group's emails with reporters (100).
- Jane Wheeler is listed on the "Critical Thinkers" page with the line "President, Rethink Identity Medicine Ethics Inc. - Promoting ethical identity medicine for children and youth." (20, accessed 2026-11-19). ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer lists Rethink Identity Medicine Ethics Inc (EIN 83-3053400, Dover, Delaware) with Jane Wheeler as President; a Form 990-EZ for fiscal year 2022 (filed 2023-05-15) reports $49,000 in contributions, and Form 990-N e-Postcards were filed for 2019-2021, 2023 and 2024 (101, accessed 2026-11-19). Its stated aim of restricting gender-affirming care for young people is anti-trans advocacy, made in bad faith.
- Kaeley Triller (Wikipedia names her Kaeley Triller Haver) is listed on the "Critical Thinkers" page with a bio that includes "Co-founder Hands Across The Aisle Women's Coalition. Writer. Speaker." (20, accessed 2026-11-19). The Federalist's author page lists her as a contributor with 15 pieces dated 2015-11-23 to 2023-12-18, most on trans people and women's shelters, bathrooms and sports, among them "Transgender Demands Are An Attack On Real Human Rights" (2019-12-09) (102; the page may be incomplete). Wikipedia's article on the Hands Across the Aisle Coalition (103, secondary) describes a US group founded in 2017 that joins anti-trans feminist and Christian-right campaigners, names her as co-founder, and lists a 2017 petition to the HUD Secretary on women's shelters and 2019 amicus briefs in Doe v. Boyertown Area School District.
- Katie Barker and Lily Maynard are among the accounts the "Critical Thinkers" page lists by display name with each account's own profile text; Lily Maynard's listed text says "Transitioning kids is child abuse", which is dehumanizing anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. The Resources page carries the same list and adds Lara Adams-Miller. The pages give no employer or office for these three, and the listing is the group's endorsement of the accounts, not a joint activity (20; 50).
- Sonia Poulton is listed on the Resources page under "Critical Thinkers" with the line "Journalist. Broadcaster. Social Commentator. Film Maker. Activist." (50, accessed 2026-11-20). Her own site describes her as a journalist, broadcaster and documentary film maker who presents the live show "Wake Up With Sonia Poulton & Guests" (104, accessed 2026-11-20).
- Susan Cox: the Resources page, under Videos & Podcasts, lists an interview in which Derrick Jensen interviews Susan Cox on queer theory, and describes Cox as "a feminist writer, activist, and educator in Philosophy" (50, accessed 2026-11-20). A Canadian blog post dated 2018-03-25 excerpts a January 2017 interview of that title with Cox and Jensen (105, accessed 2026-11-20); Feminist Current's site search lists pieces bylined "Susan Cox" (106), but the byline is a same-name lead, not shown to be the same person as the interviewee.
- Anna Slatz and Linda Blade are among the people the "Critical Thinkers" page lists, a page introduced as "A global who's who of inspiring women and men standing up for women's sex-based rights": Anna Slatz with the bio "Criminology (hons), BA Sociology (hons), MA/IDST student, professional pain-in-the-ass", "Words in @Quillette @PsychReg", "@TPostMillennial", and Dr Linda Blade with "A sport performance coach [PhD Kinesiology; ChPC in T&F] who develops athletes, mentors coaches, thrives on innovation, and honours positive nation-builders". The page gives each as a listed Critical Thinker and shows no role in the group's governance for Slatz (20, accessed 2026-11-19). Linda Blade, a Steering Committee member, signs the group's post of 2024-09-14 on its written submission for the 89th session of the UN CEDAW committee as "Dr. Linda Blade - caWsbar expert lead on women's sports"; the post says the session "will be held October 7 to 25 in Geneva, Switzerland" (year not stated on the page) (107, accessed 2026-11-19).
What the records don't show
Directors beyond those named above, a legal entity name on the website, or how the group was organized before 2024 (the December 2019 founding comes from the Chair's affidavit and Feminist Current, above). "Canadian Association for Women's Sex-Based Rights" is not the legal name: the Corporations Canada record gives the corporate name as "Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights", with no other name in its name history. (Corporations Canada, 18, accessed 2026-11-11.)
Anti-trans work: documented moments
- 2021-03-05 and 2021-03-06: a Toronto Sun article reposted on the group's own site quotes Heather Mason (now the group's Chair, since 2024-06 per this page) on a planned protest outside the Grand Valley Institution in Kitchener: "We're targeting the entire policy, we want them all removed, not just the violent ones". The page, "Activists protesting trans inmates at Kitchener prison for women", reposts an abridged text of an article "Written by Brad Hunter for the Toronto Sun, March 5, 2021", which says activists "plan to protest in front of the Grand Valley Institution in Kitchener" "On Sunday", names her only as "of Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights", and also quotes her saying the policy "does a disservice to trans women". The article opens by pointing to people convicted of violent and sexual offences; in its account the aim is the whole policy, not only the cases it describes as violent. The page reports a planned protest and does not say it took place. The article's wording misgenders trans women throughout; that wording, repeated on the group's site, is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith (108, accessed 2026-11-20).
- 2025-04-07: files Federal Court T-1146-25 against the Crown over Commissioner's Directive 100 (statement of claim); lawyers funded by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms act for it (JCCF, 2026-05-14).
- 2025-12-12: signs a brief to the House of Commons Standing Committee on the Status of Women titled "How Gender Identity Ideology is Anti-Feminist" (ourcommons.ca brief BR13842322).
- 2026-05-14: Federal Court (Case Management Judge Catharine Moore) dismisses the Crown's motion to strike and grants the group public interest standing; no finding on the merits (orders).
- 2026-08-31: the Crown's Statement of Defence (JCCF-hosted, 33).
- Its 2020-11-23 brief to the House of Commons Justice committee (BR11006622) says about 80% of trans-identifying children desist and calls a fixed gender identity "a falsehood". This is the group's claim. Against it, the evidence brief reports that in a Dutch cohort of 720 people who started puberty blockers then hormones as adolescents (Lancet Child & Adolescent Health, 2022), 98% (704 of 720) were still on hormones at follow-up (the evidence brief, "Persistence and regret"). "In fact, research in multiple countries, including Canada, reveals that about 80% of trans-identifying children desist (stop seeing themselves as the opposite sex) after experiencing a natural puberty.2 The presumption of a fixed “gender identity”, therefore, is a falsehood." (Conversion Therapy Bans for Gender Identity: The Harmful Consequences for Women and Girls in Canada, 2020-11-23, p. 2; 109)
- In its submission to CEDAW the group says "males may now self-identify as women" and gain access to gyms, prisons, rape shelters and sports. The wording calls trans women "males"; that misgendering is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. "Males may now self-identify as women and legally demand (and receive) access to female-only spaces (e.g. women’s gyms, prisons), services (e.g. rape shelters), resources (e.g. employment services, battered women support services) and sports." (Written submission for the 89th session of CEDAW from WDI-Canada and caWsbar, undated, no page numbers (web page); 107)
- 2019-12-12: the group launched publicly; Feminist Current reported on 2019-12-13 that "a coalition of Canadian women" had launched Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights, announced by a post on 2019-12-12 (Feminist Current, "What's Current: Canadian women launch organization to defend sex-based rights", 2019-12-13, 110; the article names no founders). Its 2020-11-23 brief to the House of Commons Justice committee calls the group "a cross-Canada, non-partisan coalition of women and male allies" (brief BR11006622). The group therefore operated, before it was incorporated on 2024-06-13, as an unincorporated coalition with the same name; no earlier federal corporate name exists in the Corporations Canada name history.
- 2024-03-08: first annual "Reality Based Women Unite" conference (Amy Hamm's Substack, 2024-03-11; the post does not name the city). The event's name is the group's anti-trans framing, which denies that trans women are women; it is made in bad faith. A speech at "CAWSBAR IWD Montreal" is posted under the title "The Pedophilic Roots of Gender Identity"; the post is subtitled "My speech for CAWSBAR IWD Montreal" and calls the venue the Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights Conference, so that conference is the group's own International Women's Day event (post dated 2026-04-07). The title of the speech equates trans identity with sexual abuse of children, a dehumanizing claim and bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric.
- 2026-03-06 to 2026-03-08: caWsbar's own news post "WATCH: Truth wins the day! And join us at Reality Based Women Unite 2026" calls it the group's "3rd annual International Women's Day celebration" in Montreal, in person or by livestream, with "a line-up of speakers on March 7"; it names no speakers and no sponsors, and offers ticket registration through a ticketing site. The same page links a video of the 2025 edition in Calgary. caWsbar's home page lists the 2026 event and the 2024 recording and names no sponsor; its news page lists three posts and thanks no sponsor. So the group's own pages confirm the Calgary 2025 and Montreal 2026 editions (the Calgary place from the page) and name no sponsor for either on those pages. The group's year-end post of 2025-12-31 (13) calls the Calgary 2025 event its "Second Annual Conference" and thanks The Democracy Fund "for their ongoing support of our annual conferences"; the post names the Montreal 2026 event but gives no sponsor for it. (111, 3 home page and news page, accessed 2026-11-11.) The group's ticketing page (112) names the organizer as Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights and no sponsor. The event's name and the post's title ("Truth wins the day!") are the group's anti-trans framing, which denies that trans women are women; they are made in bad faith.
- 2019-12 to 2025, protests and events: the Chair's affidavit of 2025-12-05 (paragraphs 26 and 27) says the group has "held regular protests" outside prisons, courthouses and Parliament, and in 2023 hung banners reading "no males in women's jails" over highway overpasses in Toronto (2023), Ottawa (March 2023) and Calgary (March, June and September 2023); paragraph 24 lists events it joined, among them "Save Women's Sports" (Atlanta, 2022), "Let Women Speak" (Belfast and Dublin, 2023) and a Women's Declaration International USA convention (Indianapolis, 2025). This is organised campaigning against trans women's housing and participation, in the framing of "sex-based rights"; the housing claim, the banner's wording and the event names "Save Women's Sports" and "Let Women Speak" are anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. (Affidavit of Heather Mason, sworn 2025-12-05, Federal Court T-1146-25, paragraphs 24, 26 and 27, 24)
- 2023 year in review: the group's year-end post of 2023-12-31 (26, accessed 2026-11-20) says it "grew our Twitter/X presence to over 15K followers and garnered 2.2 million post impressions", that its "network of trusted caWsbar associates increased by 32%" and that it held "over 40 virtual meetings"; these are the group's own figures. It says its four "spokeswomen" (Heather Mason, Amy Hamm, Linda Blade and Mia Ashton; the radio show is given under Mia Ashton above) gave weekly commentary, that associates held "Operation Overpass" demonstrations "to protest males being housed in Canadian women's prisons" in Toronto, Ottawa, Calgary, Halifax and Vancouver, and that Linda Blade presented a policy proposal on sex-based Charter protections at the Conservative Party of Canada's fall convention that "was resoundingly adopted with 87% in favour". It speaks of "the true cost of gender identity ideology to women and children". The words "males being housed in Canadian women's prisons" misgender trans women, and "gender identity ideology" is the group's anti-trans framing: anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. The same post lists, among its 2023 activities, "We strengthened our alliances with sister organizations in Canada and around the world, including the newly formed Red Tent Collective"; it says nothing more about Red Tent Collective.
- The group's post of 2024-03-18 says Rebel News covered its 2024 International Women's Day event (see David Menzies above). Its post "Just dropped! Our latest Save Women's Sports ad" (113, accessed 2026-11-20; the page prints "Aug 10" and no year) says its first public service announcement "debuted on the streets of Toronto last month", that the video "was seen by tens of thousands of residents and visitors ... on the Rebel billboard truck during the final match of the FIFA World Cup (which was also a Blue Jays game day!) and again the week after driving around the city", that it got "coverage by Rebel News", and asks readers to donate "to get our newest PSA out on the streets on the Rebel billboard truck"; the viewer numbers are the group's own claim. The new advertisement says "The time has come to tell the WNBA to keep women's basketball female"; the post thanks "Serena Williams, Martina Navratilova and Sophie Cunningham whose words are featured in our latest video", and the home page says "thanks to Sophie Cunningham's bravery in telling it like it is: men don't belong in women's sports". Calling trans women "men" is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. The pages show that the group features the three athletes' words; they do not show that any of the three took part in making the video or has any role in the group, and they state no price and no agreement with Rebel News beyond use of the truck.
- Glossary: the group's glossary page (114, accessed 2026-11-20) defines "Autogynephilia (AGP)" as "a male's propensity to be sexually aroused by the thought of himself as a female" and "Rapid onset gender dysphoria (ROGD)" as "children who suddenly—seemingly out of the blue—decided they identify strongly with the opposite sex". It presents the list as "compiled from today's leading reputable dictionaries" and defines woman as "adult female human" and man as "adult male human". Putting these two labels into a glossary of the "real meaning" of words presents them as settled terms; the first reduces trans women's identity to a sexual motive and the second casts children's gender identity as a social fad. Both are anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- Vision statement: the group's Who We Are page (115, accessed 2026-11-20) ends its "Our Vision" section with "Indeed, where all Canadians are liberated from gender ideology -- an ideology that reinforces gender stereotypes while denying our sex-based Charter rights." The same section envisions "Where children are told they are perfect just the way they are, and are not treated with dangerous drugs, hormones or surgery because an adult told them they were 'born in the wrong body'." The vision is addressed to "all Canadians", not only to prisons or to women in custody. "Gender ideology" and the claim of "dangerous drugs" are anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- Position statement: the group's Position Statement page (116, accessed 2026-11-20) says "Humans cannot change their sex" and that including "males in the definition of 'woman'" is "regressive, unfair and perilous", and demands that "spaces and resources previously used only by women and girls continue to be sex-segregated". Its list of such spaces "(but are not limited to)" runs: homeless shelters and hostels; change rooms/locker rooms; washrooms; rape relief and domestic violence shelters; prisons; sporting divisions; shared rooms in hospitals and university/college dorms; extracurricular groups (e.g., Girl Guides); academic scholarships and grants; positions on committees; conferences, seminars and retreats; lesbian resources and events; housing co-ops; music and art festivals; university/college women's centres. It says the group will act through press releases, public talks, letter writing, organized protests and legal challenges. The demand to exclude trans women from this range of services, scholarships, committee seats and events is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith.
- Non-partisanship statement: the group's Statement on Non-Partisanship (15, accessed 2026-11-20) says, in point 2, that it keeps women of all political orientations together "by remaining focused on our singular objective: the repeal of Bill C-16". Bill C-16 amended the Canadian Human Rights Act and the Criminal Code of Canada to include "gender identity" and "gender expression" (see the group's brief on hate-motivated violence under "Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext"). A stated single aim of repealing the law that added gender identity and expression to those two statutes is an aim of removing legal protection for trans people: anti-trans rhetoric and advocacy, made in bad faith, whatever the page says about being non-partisan. The page also says (point 6) that the group praises elected officials who advance "women's sex-based rights and child safeguarding" and criticizes those who oppose its goals; those phrases are the group's anti-trans framing.
- Allies the group lists: its "Global Movement" pages list other organizations under the heading "grassroots organizations that are standing firm on women's sex-based rights": by region (the index also lists an Australia/NZ section, not covered here), Canada (Vancouver Rape Relief, PDF Quebec, #GIDYVR, Canadian Gender Report, We the Females), USA (The Kelsey Coalition, Save Women's Sports, Women are Human, WoLF, Feminists in Struggle, 4th Wave Now, Gender Health Inquiry, ReIME, Women's Liberation Radio News), UK (Woman's Place UK, LGB Alliance, Fair Cop, Safe Schools Alliance, Our Duty, RadFem Collective, Sex Matters, Fair Play For Women, FiLiA, ForWomen.Scot, Transgender Trend, Sex Not Gender, Justice For Women, OBJECT) and International (WHRC, SEGM, Space International). Each entry is a link with the listed body's own mission text; the pages say nothing about any joint work, funding or contact with these bodies (117, 118, 119, 120, 121, all accessed 2026-11-20). The listing shows which bodies the group presents as its movement; it is not shown here to be a working relationship, and the LittleSis "collaborator" entries remain unconfirmed. Several of the mission texts it reproduces are themselves anti-trans framing, made in bad faith (for example LGB Alliance's "current gender ideologies are pseudo-scientific", Transgender Trend's reference to "the current trend to diagnose children as transgender" and Women are Human's statement that "the gender identity ideology movement dehumanizes women and girls").
- Bill 17 brief, further sentence: in its brief on Ontario Bill 17 (122, accessed 2026-11-20; brief dated 2021-11-25) the group says of gender-affirming care for young people: "We believe this approach is harmful for all children and adolescents, but particularly so for the cohort of teenage girls who may be experiencing a new, atypical form of late-onset gender dysphoria." The same paragraph says watchful waiting "was highly successful – studies show desistance rates of up to 98%". The claim of harm for all children and adolescents is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith; the Dutch cohort study reported in Lancet Child & Adolescent Health, 2022 (123) found that 704 of 720 people who started puberty blockers then hormones as adolescents continued hormones at follow-up (98%); this measures persistence on hormones after blockers, not desistance under watchful waiting, and the group's 98% figure is its own claim.
Evidence that the protective framing is a pretext
- caWsbar and WDI Canada asked the UN CEDAW committee to ask Canada to repeal or amend the amendment to the Canadian Human Rights Act that added gender identity. This applies to adults. Asking for the protection of gender identity in the Canadian Human Rights Act to be repealed or amended is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. "To repeal or amend the amendment to the Canadian Human Rights Act, per the findings of the GBA(s)" (Written submission for the 89th session of CEDAW from WDI-Canada and caWsbar, undated, no page numbers (web page); 107)
- Its brief to the House of Commons Standing Committee on the Status of Women says Bill C-16 (2017) "essentially eliminated" sex-based rights. Presenting the protection of trans people under Bill C-16 as the loss of women's rights is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. "These sex-based rights were essentially eliminated with the passage of Bill C-16 into law in 2017, which amended the Canadian Human Rights Act and the Criminal Code of Canada to include the concepts “gender identity” and “gender expression”." (Brief to the Committee on the Status of Women on Hate-Motivated Violence in the 2SLGBTQIA+ Community, undated, no page numbers (web page); 124)
- Its 2021 brief on Ontario Bill 17 asks to "remove all reference to gender-affirming care in the bill" and to remove the "Informed Consent Model of care". The text is not limited to minors. The call to remove all reference to gender-affirming care is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith; as of 2026, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Medical Association and WPATH still support access to gender-affirming care (the evidence brief, "Where professional bodies stand now"). "Recommendations 1. Remove all reference to gender-affirming care in the bill, including in the name of the proposed committee, and instead commit to forming a committee dedicated to providing evidence-based care to all members of the transgender community, including detransitioners. 2. Remove reference to the risky Informed Consent Model of care." (Our Brief to the Province of Ontario's Standing Committee on Social Policy (Bill 17 - Gender Affirming Health Care Advisory Committee Act, 2021), 2021-11-25, no page numbers (web page); 122)
- Its 2020 brief on Bill C-6, which covers children and adults, calls the idea that questioning someone's gender identity is conversion therapy "a falsehood". Calling it a falsehood, and casting a ban on conversion practices aimed at gender identity as a risk of harm, is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. "However, the notion that neglecting to immediately affirm, or questioning, one’s gender identity is a form of conversion therapy is a falsehood that, if legislated, runs the risk of causing harm to Canadians." (Conversion Therapy Bans for Gender Identity: The Harmful Consequences for Women and Girls in Canada, 2020-11-23, p. 2; 109)
- Its brief of 2025-12-12 to the Committee on the Status of Women asks that "women- and lesbian-only spaces" be restored, in person and online: "We need women’s hard-fought sex-based rights to be restored, including women- and lesbian-only spaces – in person and online." (p. 8). It says of the term TERF that it "is typically launched at women by trans-identifying males who are angered when women seek to prevent them from entering our private spaces, or participating in our sports and other sex-segregated activities." (p. 2). On lesbians it says they "should not be shamed into silence about their sexuality nor discriminated against for asserting that their orientation excludes people with penises." (p. 6). The requests reach adult women and online spaces, not only children or sport. "Trans-identifying males" and "people with penises" are the brief's misgendering terms for trans women: anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith. (Brief to the Committee on the Status of Women on How Gender Identity Ideology is Anti-Feminist, House of Commons of Canada, Standing Committee on the Status of Women, 2025-12-12, pp. 2, 6, 8; 36)
Open questions
- Who else sat on the steering committee of "Canadian Women's Sex-Based Rights" between its founding in December 2019 and incorporation (2024-06-13), beyond Heather Mason (founding member, steering committee member and Chair since 2024-06, per her affidavit and the Federal Court's order of 2026-05-14): the Federal Court record names only the Chair. A Corporations Canada copy of the notice of directors would give the directors as of 2024-06-13. The group's Who We Are page says only that it is "a cross-Canada, non-partisan coalition of women and male allies" and does not mention founders, a founding date or who led it before incorporation; the 2020 brief to the House of Commons Justice committee (BR11006622) carries no named officer in the text; the launch date of 2019-12-12 comes from Feminist Current, 2019-12-13, and the group's own 2020 brief. The Transgender Map page (an advocacy source) names a pseudonymous founding member and several others. The answer would be in the Ontario Business Registry (name search) or in the Corporations Canada certificate of incorporation and first notice of directors. The legal name matches the corporate record, so "Canadian Association for Women's Sex-Based Rights" is not the legal name.
- Which of the four registry directors hold which office, and whether Hamm, Esme Vee and the other LittleSis "board" names hold any seat: the registry page lists four directors (the same names as four Steering Committee members, one of whom matches Sullivan, who signed the brief as "Board Member"); the group's pages do not say who sits on the board.
- Whether LittleSis' "Co-organizer" entry for "1 Million March 4 Children" (2023), its "Collaborators" entries (LGB Alliance, Our Duty, Detrans Alliance Canada, Scott Newgent) and its "Sponsor" entry (Trinity Productions) rest on any public page: none of the press reports reviewed here names the group; AB Radical Feminists and Canadian Gender Report appear without a relationship label.
- Whether anyone besides the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms funds the claim: the group's Donations page says funds go to administration, events and initiatives and that it takes no public funding or corporate sponsorship; The Democracy Fund (CRA BN 779176676RR0001) sponsored its 2024-03-08 conference, amount not stated; the Justice Centre says only that it funded the lawyers; Charter Advocates Canada's FY2024 return shows revenue of CAD 2,315,000 equal to the Justice Centre's gift with no other gift or donor in the CRA open data; its FY2025 return (period ending 2025-12-31) shows gifts from other registered charities of CAD 2,577,017, equal to the Justice Centre's gift to it for that year, and CAD 25,000 of receipted donations, with no donors named (see Money received); caWsbar is not a registered charity and files no T3010.
- Whether The Democracy Fund (CRA BN 779176676RR0001) or anyone else sponsored the Montreal 2026 edition: the group's pages name no sponsor; The Democracy Fund's 2025 Annual Review names it as sponsor of the Calgary 2025 edition (above) and says nothing of 2026. The Fund's T3010 for the period ending 2025-12-31 would show any gift to the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms; the CRA open data runs to the period ending 2024-12-31.
- What registers and primary pages show of Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull's other organizations: the Let Women Speak site names her as founder; a primary page for each further group she is said to lead, such as the Electoral Commission's party register entry with its registration date and officers, would answer it.
- Which dates Madeleine Kearns held her National Review staff post: The Free Press bio says "previously" and gives none.
- On what date Emma Hilton was appointed a trustee of Sex Matters: the group's own pages or its charity register entry (125) would show it.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- image page: https://cawsbar.ca/
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/steering-committee
- https://www.cawsbar.ca
- https://www.jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/2025-Annual-Report_Justice-Centre-for-Constitutional-Freedoms-1.pdf
- https://apps.cra-arc.gc.ca/ebci/hacc/srch/pub/dsplyRprtngPrd/753651546RR0001
- https://apps.cra-arc.gc.ca/ebci/hacc/srch/pub/dsplyRprtngPrd/817174865RR0001
- https://apps.cra-arc.gc.ca/ebci/hacc/srch/pub/t3010QlfdDns_dsplyovrvw/817174865RR0001/0
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/donations
- https://preta6.substack.com/p/iwd-2024-cawsbars-first-annual-reality
- https://www.thedemocracyfund.ca/2025_annual_report
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/breaking-our-charter-challenge-to-make-prisons-single-sex-will-proceed
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/charter-challenge-launched-on-behalf-of-cawsbar
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/moving-courageously-into-2026-with-momentum
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/what-you-can-do
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/non-partisanship
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/all-products
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/all-products?page=2
- https://ised-isde.canada.ca/cc/lgcy/fdrlCrpDtls.html?corpId=16123147&lang=eng
- https://littlesis.org
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/critical-thinkers
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/trans-activist-senator-condemns-amy-hamm-from-behind-a-block-cawsbar-responds
- https://littlesis.org/relationship/1940898
- https://littlesis.org/relationship/1940905.
- https://www.jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Motion-Record-Public-Interest-Standing-of-the-Moving-Party-T-1146-25_Redacted35.pdf
- https://www.jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/ID-54-T-1146-25-Order-14-may-2026.pdf
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/reflecting-on-our-wins-in-2023-and-looking-ahead-to-more-in-2024
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/submission-to-the-employment-equity-act-review-task-force-the-importance-of-clearly-defining-women
- https://womensdeclaration.com/documents/404/Submission_letter_-_EEA_Review_Feedback_-_June_22_2024.pdf
- https://womensdeclaration.com/en/resources/statements-and-letters/wdi-thanks-raine-mcleod
- https://jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/CAWSBAR-Statement-of-Claim-Filed-Redacted.pdf
- https://www.jccf.ca/federal-court-delivers-major-procedural-wins-for-women-challenging-prison-transfer-policy/
- https://www.jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/ID-55-T-1146-25_Order-14-may-2026.pdf
- https://www.jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/T-1146-25-CAWSBAR-v-HMK-Statement-of-Defence-August-31-2026_Redacted.pdf
- https://www.jccf.ca/court_cases/the-forcible-confinement-of-female-inmates-with-trans-identifying-males-is-challenged-in-court/
- https://www.jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/2025.12.05-Notice-of-Motion-Public-Interest-Standing_Redacted.pdf
- https://www.ourcommons.ca/Content/Committee/451/FEWO/Brief/BR13842322/br-external/CanadianWomensSexBasedRights-e.pdf.
- https://www.jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/T-1146-25-Motion-Record-to-strike-January-23-2026-Redacted61.pdf
- https://womensdeclaration.com/en/country-info/canada/
- https://jccf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Petition_Redacted.pdf
- https://thepostmillennial.com/expert-witness-testifies-that-being-a-lesbian-is-transphobic-in-trial-against-bc-nurse
- https://www.ourcommons.ca/Content/Committee/451/FEWO/Brief/BR13842322/br-external/CanadianWomensSexBasedRights-e.pdf
- https://thepostmillennial.com/authors/mia-ashton
- https://www.jccf.ca/ontario-college-of-teachers-pressures-former-instructor-to-surrender-her-licence-over-social-media-posts/
- https://www.jccf.ca/complaint-filed-against-nanaimo-ladysmith-school-district-for-political-discrimination/
- https://www.rebelnews.com/canadian_woman_faces_legal_battle_over_social_media_post
- https://womensdeclaration.com/documents/124/WomensHumanRightsCampaignNewfoundlandAndLabradorChapter-e.pdf
- https://www.jccf.ca/journalist-barbara-kay-faces-multiple-human-rights-complaints-over-commentary-on-gender-identity/
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/trans-killers-baby-rapists-terrifying-female-inmates
- https://torontosun.com/news/national/hunter-trans-killers-baby-rapists-terrifying-female-inmates
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/copy-of-resources-4
- https://derrickjensen.org/2013/06/the-emperors-new-penis/
- https://gizmodo.com/the-environmental-movement-isn-t-ready-for-transphobia-1848505309
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/it-s-time-for-us-all-to-stand-up-against-big-sister
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/831753748
- https://www.monkfishpublishing.com/max-wilbert/
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/reality-based-women-unite-watch-our-international-women-s-day-event-online-now
- https://substack.com/@evakurilova
- https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/i-would-have-been-a-trans-kidstop
- https://substack.com/@feliciarembrandt
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/there-was-nothing-wrong-with-canada-s-j-k-rowling-billboard
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Agar
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/no-one-is-born-in-the-wrong-body
- https://quillette.com/2019/09/24/no-one-is-born-in-the-wrong-body/
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/at-the-nhs-and-bbc-important-steps-toward-restoring-balance-in-the-gender-debate
- https://quillette.com/author/julian-vigo
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/canadian-women-launch-petition-against-bill-c-16
- https://www.jccf.ca/lindsay-shepherd-joins-the-justice-centre-as-campus-free-speech-fellow/
- https://www.spiked-online.com/2019/07/23/i-was-banned-for-trans-heresy/
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/canadian-nurse-under-investigation-by-college-of-nurses-for-expressing-gender-critical-views
- https://thepostmillennial.com/news-analysis/nurse-investigation-gender-critical
- https://sencanada.ca/en/Content/Sen/Committee/421/LCJC/53308-e
- https://globalnews.ca/news/11130725/canada-election-2025-results-vancouver-east/amp
- https://researchportal.lsbu.ac.uk/en/publications/transgender-children-and-young-people-born-in-your-own-body-3/
- https://www.timeshighereducation.com/books/review-transgender-children-and-young-people-heather-brunskell-evans-and-michele-moore-cambridge-scholars
- https://womansplaceuk.org/2019/06/21/in-defence-of-michele-moore
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/as-transgender-rights-improve-prisons-struggle-with-tough-decisions
- https://ontariosportshalloffame.com/inductees/sports-specialties/journalism/rosie-dimanno/
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/republished-british-columbia-s-practice-directions-on-preferred-gender-pronouns-in-court-are-proble
- https://canadianlawyermag.com/news/opinion/statement-regarding-a-recent-opinion-posted-on-our-website/337574
- https://c2cjournal.ca/2021/05/compelled-speech-comes-to-b-c-s-courts/
- https://www.rebelnews.com/_it_is_dangerous_activist_addresses_concerns_on_allowing_male_inmates_in_female_prisons
- https://www.thefp.com/w/madeleine-kearns
- https://www.independentwomen.com/2022/01/20/iwf-welcomes-madeleine-kearns-as-a-visiting-fellow/
- https://www.spectator.co.uk/writer/madeleine-kearns
- https://womensliberationfront.org/news/interview-with-wolf-board-chair-natasha-chart
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/487640/police-urge-anyone-including-the-rainbow-community-to-report-threats-violence
- https://www.letwomenspeak.org/
- https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01541951
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/barbara-kay-why-won-t-the-liberal-government-make-its-gender-based-analysis-public
- https://laconverse.com/en/articles/des-femmes-trans-denoncent-le-financement-provincial-dun-organisme-feministe-juge-transphobe
- https://www.transgendermap.com/people/andreia-nobre/
- https://4w.pub/brazil-terf-list/
- https://speakupforwomen.nz/about
- https://www.speakupforwomen.nz/post/feminists-have-spoken-up
- https://goodoil.substack.com/p/episode-3-ani-obrien
- https://www.fsu.nz/about
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/24/24-38/375333/20250919165954136_Emma%20Hilton.pdf
- https://www.irishtimes.com/world/uk/2025/09/02/father-ted-writer-graham-linehan-arrested-over-x-posts-on-trans-issues
- https://www.rte.ie/news/2025/1125/1545727-graham-linehan
- https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2023/03/anti-trans-transgender-health-care-ban-legislation-bill-minors-children-lgbtq/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/833053400
- https://thefederalist.com/author/kaeleytriller/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hands_Across_the_Aisle_Coalition
- https://www.soniapoulton.co.uk/
- https://deadwildroses.com/2018/03/25/susan-cox-on-queer-theory/
- https://www.feministcurrent.com/?s=susan+cox
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/written-submission-for-the-89th-session-of-cedaw-from-wdi-canada-and-cawsbar
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/activists-protesting-trans-inmates-at-kitchener-prison-for-women
- https://ourcommons.ca/Content/Committee/432/JUST/Brief/BR11006622/br-external/CanadianWomensSexBasedRights-e.pdf
- https://feministcurrent.com/?p=36691
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/watch-truth-wins-the-day-and-join-us-at-reality-based-women-unite-2026
- https://cawsbar.ticketbud.com
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/just-dropped-our-latest-save-women-s-sports-ad
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/glossary
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/who-we-are
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/position-statement
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/global-movement
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/global-movement-canada
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/global-movement-usa
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/global-movement-uk
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/global-movement-international
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/our-brief-to-the-province-of-ontario-s-standing-committee-on-social-policy
- https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/968593
- https://www.cawsbar.ca/post/brief-to-the-committee-on-the-status-of-women-on-hate-motivated-violence-in-the-2slgbtqia-community
- https://register-of-charities.charitycommission.gov.uk/charity-search/-/charity-details/5204776