![Organization: American Values [EIN 52-1762320]](assets/profiles/org_american_values.png)
American Values
American Values is an Arlington, Virginia 501(c)(3) (IRS exempt-organization master file: publicly supported charity, first date 1992-03). Its filed mission reads "AMERICAN VALUES IS DEDICATED TO DEFENDING THE FOUNDING PRINCIPLES OF OUR NATION AS ARTICULATED IN THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE AND THE CONSTITUTION. AMERICAN VALUES WORKS TO EDUCATE THE PUBLIC AND POLICY MAKERS ABOUT CRITICAL ISSUES, INCLUDING THE SANCTITY OF LIFE, RELIGIOUS LIBERTY, FREE ENTERPRISE, A STRONG NATIONAL DEFENSE AND A ROBUST ALLIANCE WITH ISRAEL." (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 52-1762320 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 2), object id 202632239349301328). Wikipedia says that Gary Bauer "is president of the advocacy organization American Values" and that he was president of the Family Research Council from 1988 to 1999 (Wikipedia, 3). A body of the same name, "American Values", appears as a topic label on America First Policy Institute's site; that is a different use of the name and is not this organization.
Records: IRS Form 990 e-file returns for 2020 to 2025 (6 returns). Grants received are rows naming EIN 52-1762320 on the grantors' returns, counted once where a grant is repeated on two returns.
Money received
- Returns (year; total revenue; object id): 2020 $1,285,567 (202112319349300406); 2021 $1,872,672 (202240959349300104); 2022 $1,552,058 (202321169349301912); 2023 $1,589,322 (202412209349301691); 2024 $1,491,262 (202511759349300886); 2025 $1,595,125 (202632239349301328) (IRS Form 990 e-file).
- Schedule C of the organization's returns for 2024 and 2025 reports no lobbying: total lobbying expenditures, direct lobbying and grassroots lobbying are each $0 on both returns, against total exempt-purpose expenditures of $1,241,560 (2024) and $1,297,930 (2025) (Schedule C, Part II-A). (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 52-1762320, objects 202511759349300886 (period 2024-01-01 to 2024-12-31) and 202632239349301328 (period 2025-01-01 to 2025-12-31, submitted 2026-08-11); 4)
- Grants received as filed by the grantors: 67 rows, $2,737,239, 2010 to 2025 of the grantors' periods (a floor). One further row carries this EIN but is filed to another name and place (the Community Foundation of Harrisonburg & Rockingham County, 2016-06-30, $12,000, "GENERAL SUPPORT", filed to "FAMILY RESEARCH COUNCIL", Holland MI, object id 201741299349301819); it is stated apart and not counted. Largest grantors with pages on this site: National Christian Foundation (EIN 58-1493949) $870,566 in 13 rows, 2012 to 2024 (a grant on two returns counted once); WaterStone (Christian Community Foundation Inc, EIN 75-1750059) $600,000 in 7 rows, 2011 to 2023; Moriah Foundation (EIN 84-1547618) $535,000 in 16 rows, 2010 to 2024; Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund (EIN 11-0303001) $272,172 in 8 rows, 2018 to 2025; Schwab Charitable Fund / Donor Advised Charitable Giving Inc (EIN 31-1640316) $205,150 in 6 rows, 2015 to 2025; Servant Foundation (EIN 43-1890105) $53,050 in 5 rows, 2020 to 2024; The Signatry Charitable Trust (EIN 82-5070897) $8,500 (2024). Other grantors include Chattanooga Christian Community Foundation ($100,200 in 5 rows) and The Fairbrook Foundation ($60,000 in 2 rows) (IRS Form 990 and 990-PF e-file grant rows).
- The James and Joan Lindsey Family Foundation (EIN 77-0390011) gave American Values $761,725 in 7 rows, filed to "AMERICAN VALUES" at a post-office box in Washington DC; 990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN, and Washington DC is not a place the recipient's own records show (its own returns and records for every year 2013 to 2025 and the IRS master file give Arlington VA), so the rows are stated apart and not counted: TY2020 $110,575; TY2021 $100,000; TY2022 $150,575; TY2023 $50,575; TY2023 $100,000; TY2024 $135,000; TY2025 $115,000; purposes as filed "VARIOUS CHARITABLE PURPOSES"; "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT"; recipient name as filed "AMERICAN VALUES" (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 77-0390011 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 5), object ids 202121189349100237, 202201159349102325, 202310989349100311, 202441359349102379, 202541349349103329, 202641359349104224).
- Natan Foundation (EIN 83-0380273) gave American Values $5,000 in 1 row, matched by the recipient's full name and place (Arlington VA; the place the recipient's own returns show; 990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN): TY2013 $5,000; purposes as filed "Unite America around the vision of our founding fathers."; recipient name as filed "American Values" (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 83-0380273 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6), object ids 201421329349101957).
- Natan Foundation (EIN 83-0380273) gave American Values $50,000 in 4 rows, filed to "American Values" with the place Merrifield VA; 990-PF rows carry no recipient EIN, and Merrifield VA is not given as the organization's own address on any of its records (its own returns and records for every year 2013 to 2025 and the IRS master file give Arlington VA), so the rows are stated apart and not counted; the 21 rows of other givers that give Merrifield VA (below) are counted because they carry the organization's EIN: TY2016 $10,000; TY2018 $15,000; TY2019 $20,000; TY2020 $5,000; purposes as filed "Promotion of conservative values."; "PROMOTION OF CONSERVATIVE VALUES"; recipient name as filed "American Values", "AMERICAN VALUES" (IRS Form 990-PF e-file, giver EIN 83-0380273 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 6), object ids 201712439349100406, 201922319349100182, 202022539349100727, 202113039349100201).
- Place check for the rows filed to "AMERICAN VALUES" with Washington DC (James and Joan Lindsey Family Foundation, 7 rows, $761,725) and Merrifield VA (Natan Foundation, 4 rows, $50,000): the organization's own site gives its mailing address as Arlington VA (7); its six Form 990 returns (TY2020 to TY2025) all give Arlington VA; the IRS exempt-organization master file and the Oregon charity register give Arlington VA, and the California charity register lists it at Arlington VA for the period ending 2005-12-31. No return, register or page of its own shows Washington DC or Merrifield VA. A charity-evaluator page lists a post office box at Merrifield VA as its headquarters address (8; undated, and not the organization's own record). The 11 rows therefore stay stated apart and in no total. (IRS Form 990 e-files, EIN 52-1762320 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 2); IRS exempt-organization master file; Oregon DOJ and California Attorney General charity registers)
- Place check, rows carrying the organization's EIN: California's charity register and Oregon's charity register (the Attorney General's registry of charitable trusts, 9, and the Oregon Department of Justice charity search) give the organization in Arlington VA, and the IRS exempt-organization master file (10) gives Arlington VA too; none gives Merrifield. Twenty-one grant rows from six givers (National Christian Charitable Foundation, Servant Foundation, Chattanooga Christian Community Foundation, Moriah Foundation, Christian Community Foundation and Greater Horizons) filed to "American Values" at Merrifield VA carry the organization's EIN 52-1762320 as recipient identifier, return periods ending 2014-12-31 to 2024-12-31, so the givers' returns record Merrifield as the place for this EIN while the organization's own returns, pages and registrations show Arlington. (IRS Form 990 e-files of the givers, recipient EIN 52-1762320; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, 2)
- The post-office box in Washington DC given on the Lindsey rows: the organization's own place on its returns and records for every year 2013 to 2025 is Arlington, VA; the care-of place on the TY2023 return of American Values Action (EIN 27-2299035) is the same Arlington building; the FEC record of the Campaign for Working Families committee (C00325076, 11) gives the same building. None of these records gives the Washington DC box, so the Lindsey rows filed at it stay apart.
- The organization's own Forms 990 for the years ending 2013-12-31, 2014-12-31, 2015-12-31, 2016-12-31 and 2017-12-31 (EIN 52-1762320; 12 and endings 201412, 201512, 201612, 201712) each give Arlington, VA 22206 as the organization's place on the first page. None of the five gives Washington DC or Merrifield VA as the organization's own address. With the 2018 and 2019 returns (Arlington VA, from the Nonprofit Explorer pages) and the six returns TY2020 to TY2025, every year 2013 to 2025 is Arlington VA on a record of the organization's own.
- The TY2016 return lists in Schedule R, Part II (related tax-exempt organizations) "Campaign-for-Working-Families", a post-office box in Merrifield, VA, EIN 52-2000441, primary activity "advocacy work", legal domicile VA, exempt code 527. So the one Merrifield VA address on the organization's own filings of 2013 to 2017 is that of a related 527 named in its Schedule R, not its own. Gary Bauer is named as chairman of Campaign for Working Families PAC (FEC committee C00325076, 11, matched by name); this row is a filing of American Values that lists a body of that name as related to it. The EIN 52-2000441 differs from the identifier of that FEC committee, so this is not equated with the FEC committee. The Schedule R pages of the 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2017 returns list no such body.
- Purposes as filed on the rows of Moriah Foundation and National Christian Foundation. Moriah Foundation (EIN 84-1547618), 16 rows, $535,000, 2010 to 2024: 15 rows, $482,000, "GENERAL SUPPORT"; one row, $53,000 (2020-12-31, object 202103009349301800), "MINISTRY AND GENERAL SUPPORT". National Christian Foundation (EIN 58-1493949), 13 rows, $870,566 (a 2022 grant of $103,750 on two returns counted once): "SOCIAL, CIVIC AND PUBLIC POLICY" 5 rows, $249,475 (2012 to 2016); "CULTURE" 7 rows, $532,491 (2017 to 2023); "RIGHT TO LIFE" 1 row, $88,600 (2024-12-31, object 202513109349303201). A donor-advised sponsor's purpose entry is the sponsor's category, and the donors behind it are undisclosed. No row states a purpose that names trans people (IRS Form 990 e-file returns, recipient EIN 52-1762320).
- Nonprofit Explorer listing of the organization (2): Arlington VA; Form 990 listed for every fiscal year 2013 to 2025 and total revenue for 2011 to 2019 (2019 $1,559,209; 2018 $1,257,457; 2017 $1,600,737; 2016 $1,157,448; 2015 $1,368,681; 2014 $1,106,688; 2013 $1,173,809; 2012 $1,168,642; 2011 $1,225,531). The pages for the 2018 and 2019 returns show Arlington VA. No record or page of the organization's own shows Washington DC or Merrifield VA.
- National Christian Charitable Foundation (EIN 58-1493949), tax year 2011, from the list attached to its Schedule I: row filed as "American Values", recipient EIN 52-1762320, $41,000.00 (page 54 of the 217-page return). The foundation is a donor-advised-fund sponsor, so donors are not disclosed. This 2011 row is stated apart and is in no total above (IRS Form 990 for tax year 2011 as filed, a scan; list at 13).
Money given
- Schedule I of the organization's own returns (EIN 52-1762320), cash grants as filed, in US dollars, with no non-cash assistance; these are the rows each return lists and are stated as filed, in no total. Each return's rendered Schedule I page on ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer is given with its object id.
- TY2025 (object 202632239349301328, 14): Council for National Policy $16,500, "Annual membership"; American Principles Project Foundation (EIN 26-4442148) $10,000, "Gala sponsorship".
- TY2024 (object 202511759349300886, 15): Council for National Policy (EIN 72-0921017) $16,500, "ANNUAL MEMBERSHIP"; Dr. James Dobson Family Institute (EIN 27-1394708) $15,000, "GENERAL OPERATING SUPPORT" (grant paid by American Values to the Institute); American Principles Project Foundation (EIN 26-4442148) $10,000, "GALA SPONSORSHIP"; all three are 501(c)(3) organizations.
- TY2023 (object 202412209349301691, 16): Family Research Council (EIN 52-1792772) $40,108, "Summit Sponsorship"; Council for National Policy $17,975, "Membership & Meeting"; American Principles Project (EIN 26-4613397, a 501(c)(4)) $10,000, "Gala Sponsorship".
- TY2022 (object 202321169349301912, 17): Council for National Policy $15,159, "MEMBERSHIP & MEETING"; Christians United for Israel (EIN 20-4413244) $7,000, "GENERAL SUPPORT".
- TY2021 (object 202240959349300104, 18): Council for National Policy $16,659, "Membership & meetings"; Christians United for Israel $14,500, "General support"; Family Research Council $12,500, "Values Voter Summit".
People on file
- Gary Bauer, president, $212,705 (2020), $215,314 (2021), $226,529 (2022), $236,887 (2023), $246,121 (2024), $259,267 (2025) (IRS Form 990 e-file); Wikipedia presents him as the organization's president (as above). A secretary and treasurer, a director of finance and three to four directors are given by role.
Anti-trans work: documented moments
- American Values' president, Gary Bauer, wrote three pieces on the James Dobson Family Institute's site that attack trans people: 2023-05-26, "Abortion and Trans Radicals Join Hands"; 2024-01-05, "What Was He Thinking? Ohio's Governor Stands With Trans Insanity", urging an override of a veto; and 2024-07-12, "Our Bodies, Our Sports" (quotations below). Each byline carries a bio that calls him senior vice president of Public Policy and Culture at the Institute and president of American Values; all three bios also give him as chairman of Campaign for Working Families PAC.
- 2023-05-26, "Abortion and Trans Radicals Join Hands": names "Two great dangers to America's children — abortion and so-called 'transgenderism'", and calls gender-affirming medical care "chemical-castration drugs and genital surgeries" and parents' being blocked "from protecting their children from these life-changing interventions". The wording is dehumanizing: surgery on trans minors is extremely rare and is already banned in much of the United States, and the care itself is supported by the evidence (see the team's evidence brief). (19)
- 2024-01-05, "What Was He Thinking? Ohio's Governor Stands With Trans Insanity": writes "We are deeply disappointed in Ohio Governor Mike DeWine" over his veto of an Ohio bill, writes of a bill that "would have prevented a minor child from being given powerful chemicals to block their normal puberty", writes "Parental rights does not include the right to physically abuse your children", and urges "There are sufficient votes to override Governor DeWine's veto and they should do so ASAP." Calling care that the evidence supports "abuse" is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric under the "parental rights" and child-protection shield. (20)
- 2024-07-12, "Our Bodies, Our Sports": writes "Women's sports in the United States are under siege from proponents of radical transgender ideology", says "Men and boys "identifying" as women and girls are stealing honors and awards meant for actual females" and describes "trans females" as "(men)". The framing denies trans women's identity and presents a near-nonexistent presence in women's sports as a siege. (21)
- American Values' own site (22) lists Bauer's daily "End of Day" commentary; the title shown ("Honoring Our Heroes", 2026-11-11) does not concern trans people.
- 2023-11-29, Supreme Court, No. 23-450: American Values, through its president, was one of 23 amici (the lead amicus and counsel being Advancing American Freedom, Inc.) on a brief at the certiorari stage supporting two parents against the Indiana Department of Child Services. The petitioners' adolescent child had been removed from their home in a child-in-need-of-services case in which the parents' statements about the child's transgender identity were at issue. The amici asked the Court to grant the petition and rule for the parents. The brief says that "because there are no claims of abuse or neglect, this Court has the opportunity to clearly state the principle that a disagreement between parents and their child’s asserted gender identity does not warrant state intervention." (p. 11). It says "the rights of parents do not end where transgender identification begins." (p. 20). It describes the child as "an adolescent child who is suffering from confusion about his gender identity" (p. 10; the brief's characterisation of the child). The brief asserts that "A more plausible explanation for this significant increase is that at least many adolescents, influenced by teachers, school administrators, friends or peers, and online influencers, are concluding that they are transgender as an explanation for, or solution to other difficulties they are facing," (p. 26; the sentence continues on the next page) and that "Parents have ample reason not only to doubt their child’s sudden assertion of gender identity but also to doubt the reliability of medical professionals in this area given its politicization." (p. 28). These are the amici's claims. Calling the child "confused" about gender identity, presenting adolescents' trans identity as the product of teachers, peers and "online influencers", and telling parents to distrust the medical professionals who treat them is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith under the framing of parental rights; the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Medical Association and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health still support access to gender-affirming care as of 2026 (The Evidence Case for Access to Gender-Affirming Care, section "Where professional bodies stand now"). Case status: the Supreme Court denied the petition for certiorari on 2024-03-18, so this amicus brief supported a petition that was not granted. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in Support of Petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-450, 2023-11-29, pp. 10, 11, 20, 26, 28; 23)
- Eighth Circuit, No. 22-2927, opinion of 2023-09-29: American Values is listed in the caption (p. 2) among the amici on behalf of the appellant, Parents Defending Education, which appealed the denial of a preliminary injunction against a school district policy on transgender and gender-nonconforming students. The court dismissed as moot the parental-rights due process claim, because an Iowa statute passed after submission gave the relief requested. It held that the plaintiff is likely to succeed on a First Amendment vagueness claim, and remanded "with directions to grant a preliminary injunction against enforcement of the portion of the policy prohibiting an intentional or persistent refusal “to respect a student’s gender identity.”" (p. 13), that clause only. The document is the court's opinion, not the amici's brief, so what American Values argued is not established. The opinion (83 F.4th 658) was not vacated, but the school district settled in February 2024 by rescinding the challenged clause and paying the plaintiff $20,000 through its insurer, as the AP reported on 2024-02-21. (Opinion, Parents Defending Education v. Linn Mar Community School District, United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, No. 22-2927, 2023-09-29, pp. 2, 13; 24)
- First Circuit, No. 23-1069, opinion of 2025-02-18 in a case brought by the parents of two minor students (a parents' due process challenge to a school protocol of using a student's requested name and pronouns at school without telling the parents unless the student consents). American Values is named in the joint amicus list led by Advancing American Freedom, Inc. (p. 2); the same list is reprinted in the appendix to the petition for a writ of certiorari, No. 25-77, at p. 53. The parents argued that the protocol violated their parental due process rights; the court affirmed the dismissal, holding the parents had not plausibly alleged that the protocol restricted a fundamental parental right. The First Circuit affirmed the dismissal on 2025-02-18, and the Supreme Court denied review on 2026-04-20 (the docket of the Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-77, lists "Apr 20, 2026: Petition DENIED"; the petition was filed 2025-07-18, the respondents' brief in opposition 2025-10-20, the petitioners' reply 2025-11-03, and 16 amicus briefs at the petition stage, among them "Advancing American Freedom, et al." filed 2025-08-21; the docket does not list the signers of that amicus brief); the list shows the name only and does not show that American Values wrote any part of the brief. (Opinion, U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, No. 23-1069, 2025-02-18, p. 2; Petition for a Writ of Certiorari, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-77, 2025-07-18, p. 53; 25)
- Supreme Court, No. 24-43 (the West Virginia girls' sports case), petition-stage brief dated 2024-08-15: American Values is one of the amici named as supporting West Virginia's petition; Advancing American Freedom, Inc. signed as counsel for the amici. The amici asked the Court to grant the petition and rule for the State, so that a state may limit girls' sports teams by sex determined at birth. The brief frames its first question as "Whether Title IX prevents a state from consistently designating girls’ and boys’ sports teams based on biological sex determined at birth." (p. 3). It uses pronouns by policy, "this brief uses pronouns that correspond to the referent person’s biological sex." (p. 16), which misgenders trans people. About half the brief asserts, citing the Cass Review, that puberty blockers for trans minors are harmful and likens care for trans minors to child sacrifice, castration and genital mutilation; these are the amici's claims. Calling gender-affirming care mutilation and castration is dehumanizing rhetoric meant to turn the public against trans people, made in bad faith: surgery on trans minors is extremely rare and is already banned in much of the United States. Invoking the Cass Review is anti-trans rhetoric too: a peer-reviewed appraisal rated all seven systematic reviews behind it at high risk of bias (BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2025, 26), and the studies collected in The Evidence Case for Access to Gender-Affirming Care (section "Adolescents: hormones and puberty blockers") link puberty blockers and hormones to lower depression in youth. On 2026-06-30 the Supreme Court reversed the Fourth Circuit judgment under review and remanded (judgment issued 2026-08-03); this petition-stage brief supported the petitioners, the side that prevailed. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in Support of Petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-43, 2024-08-15, pp. 3, 16; 27)
- Supreme Court, No. 25-840, International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc., et al. v. Governor of Washington, et al., merits-stage brief dated 2026-09-15: American Values is one of the amici named as supporting the petitioner parents; Advancing American Freedom, Inc. signed as counsel for the amici. The amici asked the Court to rule for the petitioners, arguing that parents have standing to challenge a Washington law under which shelters notify the state child-welfare department rather than parents when a runaway minor seeks gender-affirming treatment, and claiming that the provision incentivizes minors to run away. The brief says "No parent should have to live in fear that, without their consent, the government will hold their children and facilitate life-altering medical interventions." (p. 17). These are the amici's claims. Presenting a law under which shelters notify the state child-welfare department as an incentive for minors to run away, and calling gender-affirming care "life-altering medical interventions" that the government facilitates, is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith under the framing of parental rights; the studies collected in The Evidence Case for Access to Gender-Affirming Care (section "Adolescents: hormones and puberty blockers") link puberty blockers and hormones to lower depression in youth. The Supreme Court granted certiorari on 2026-06-29; argument is set for 2026-12-07 and no decision had been entered at the docket's last entry (2026-11-09). (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in Support of Petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-840, 2026-09-15, pp. 1, 17)
- In the petition-stage brief of Advancing American Freedom et al. in the West Virginia girls' sports case (Supreme Court, No. 24-43), which asks the Court to uphold a girls' sports rule, a long argument about medical care, which is outside sports, also appears. The brief says: "In fact, certain horrors of the past are resurfacing today under the guise of care." (p. 31, following its comparison of care for trans minors with child sacrifice, castration and genital mutilation). This comparison is dehumanizing rhetoric meant to turn the public against trans people, made in bad faith: surgery on trans minors is extremely rare and is already banned in much of the United States, and the care itself is supported by the evidence (see the team's evidence brief). Case status: on 2026-06-30 the Supreme Court reversed the Fourth Circuit judgment under review and remanded (judgment issued 2026-08-03); this petition-stage brief supported the petitioners, the side that prevailed. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in Support of Petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-43, 2024-08-15, p. 31; 27)
- 2025-07-07, Third Circuit No. 24-3278 (on appeal from D.N.J. No. 3:24-cv-00107): American Values signed as an amicus (named on the cover with American Encore and others) in the amicus brief of Advancing American Freedom, Inc. and others supporting the plaintiff-appellant, brought by a parent against a school board, a superintendent, a school counselor and New Jersey state officials over what the parent alleges was a school's social transition of his minor child without his knowledge. The amici asked the court to rule for the plaintiff-appellant, and argued that parental rights are fundamental and that the school's gender policy should be compared with its medication policy. The brief is limited to a minor's social transition at school. The brief asserts that "Parents may be kept completely in the dark as school officials coax their children into deep personal confusion." Describing school staff who accept a student's gender identity as coaxing children "into deep personal confusion" is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith under the framing of parental rights; it is the amici's characterization, not a finding. It quotes the school district's Policy 5756, which the brief attributes to the board: "The school district shall accept a student’s asserted gender identity; parental consent is not required." The brief closes: "For the foregoing reasons, the Court should rule for plaintiff-appellant." (Amicus brief of Advancing American Freedom and others supporting the plaintiff-appellant (a parent), U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 24-3278, 2025-07-07, pp. 1, 15, 32, 34; copy hosted by a third party.) Case status: the district court denied the parent's preliminary injunction on 2024-11-27, and the parties jointly dismissed this Third Circuit appeal in 2026-01 (per the plaintiff-side page), so the court never ruled on this brief's arguments; the case continues in the district court.
- Tenth Circuit, No. 24-3097 (State of Kansas and other plaintiffs against the United States Department of Education), brief dated 2024-10-10: American Values is among the amici on the cover (p. 1) and is listed in the statement of interest (p. 12); Advancing American Freedom, Inc. is counsel of record. The amici asked the court to affirm the injunction against the Department of Education's 2024 Title IX rule, which treats sex discrimination as including gender identity, and closed by asking that "this Court should rule for Plaintiffs-Appellees." (p. 40). The brief argues that "If women and girls are to have the opportunity to compete and excel in fair competition, males must be excluded from women’s and girls’ sports." (p. 21), which calls trans women and girls "males" and so denies their identity, anti-trans rhetoric made in bad faith under the framing of fairness in girls' sports, and it says it "uses pronouns that correspond to the referent person’s biological sex." (p. 14, footnote), which misgenders trans people by design. Case status: the Tenth Circuit dismissed the appeal in No. 24-3097 on 2025-03-13 at the federal defendants' request. (Brief of Advancing American Freedom and others as amici curiae in support of plaintiffs-appellees, United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, No. 24-3097, 2024-10-10, pp. 1, 12, 14, 21, 40)
- Supreme Court, No. 24-38 (Idaho's law limiting girls' and women's sports to females), brief dated 2025-09-19: American Values is among the amici on the cover (p. 1); Advancing American Freedom, Inc. is counsel of record. The amici asked the Court to rule for Idaho, stating the exclusion they ask the Court to uphold: "males must be excluded from women’s and girls’ sports." (p. 16), which calls trans women and girls "males" and so denies their identity, anti-trans rhetoric made in bad faith under the framing of fairness in girls' sports. A footnote says "To avoid confusion and in an effort to be faithful to reality, this brief uses pronouns that correspond to biological sex." (p. 15), which misgenders trans people by design. Part II of the brief takes up puberty blockers, outside the sports question. Case status: on 2026-06-30 the Supreme Court reversed the lower-court judgment under review and remanded, the result these amici asked for; the brief's claims remain the amici's claims. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in support of petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-38, 2025-09-19, pp. 1, 15, 16)
- The same comparison of care for trans minors with historic mutilations appears in two filings: the Tenth Circuit brief in No. 24-3097 (p. 39) and the Supreme Court brief in No. 24-38 (p. 35), both signed on by American Values as an amicus. The text is the same in both, so it is one statement filed twice. The brief says: "Such destruction of young bodies is not unlike those mutilations discussed above of young boys’ and girls’ bodies now rightly seen as barbaric relics." The Tenth Circuit brief also says "In fact, certain horrors of the past are resurfacing today under the guise of care." (p. 34), and the No. 24-38 brief argues that "No child can consent to procedures that will radically alter their natural development, especially where such procedures often leave the person infertile and with other physical disabilities." (p. 35). These are the amici's claims, filed by Advancing American Freedom, Inc. as counsel for a list of amici that includes American Values. Comparing gender-affirming care with mutilation and calling it the "destruction of young bodies" is dehumanizing rhetoric meant to turn the public against trans people, made in bad faith: surgery on trans minors is extremely rare and is already banned in much of the United States, and the care itself is supported by the evidence (see the team's evidence brief). Case status: No. 24-3097 was dismissed on 2025-03-13 at the federal defendants' request; in No. 24-38 the Supreme Court on 2026-06-30 reversed the lower-court judgment under review and remanded, the result the amici asked for. (Brief of Advancing American Freedom and others as amici curiae in support of plaintiffs-appellees, United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, No. 24-3097, 2024-10-10, pp. 34, 39. Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom et al. in support of petitioners, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-38, 2025-09-19, p. 35)
- Supreme Court, No. 23-477, brief dated 2024-10-15 (American Values an amicus, p. 11): the brief states "The idea that a boy can become a girl or that a girl can become a boy is the most current of notions, and one that is likely transitory." (p. 14), which denies trans people's identity; and it gives a figure that it sources to the Stop the Harm Database: "At least 5,747 minors in the United States have received surgeries of some kind to address their gender dysphoria." (p. 26; the figure is the brief's). Presenting surgery on trans minors as common is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith: surgery on trans minors is extremely rare and is already banned in much of the United States. Case status: the Supreme Court affirmed the Sixth Circuit 6-3 on 2025-06-18, upholding Tennessee SB1, the result this brief urged; the judgment issued on 2025-07-21. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom, America First Policy Institute, American Encore, American Values and others in support of respondents, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-477, 2024-10-15, pp. 11, 14, 26)
- Supreme Court, No. 23-477, brief dated 2024-10-15, p. 29: in a brief whose stated aim is protecting children, the amici write that "States have a compelling interest in ensuring that only properly informed and consenting adults receive unproven elective chemical or surgical procedures." This reaches care for adults, which the brief calls "unproven elective" procedures; elsewhere the brief says the Tennessee law "has no effect on adults" (p. 31), so the sentence is a statement of what the amici say states may regulate for adults. Calling this care "unproven" is anti-trans rhetoric, made in bad faith: across the reviews and large cohorts collected in The Evidence Case for Access to Gender-Affirming Care (section "Adults: the broadest evidence base"), hormone therapy and surgery are associated with better quality of life and lower depression and distress in adults. Case status: the Supreme Court affirmed the Sixth Circuit 6-3 on 2025-06-18, upholding Tennessee SB1, the result this brief urged; the judgment issued on 2025-07-21. (Brief of Amici Curiae Advancing American Freedom, America First Policy Institute, American Encore, American Values and others in support of respondents, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-477, 2024-10-15, pp. 29, 31)
- Tenth Circuit, No. 24-3097, brief dated 2024-10-10, p. 19: the brief argues that students could face consequences under the Title IX rule for using "pronouns consistent with biology", for using a previous name for someone who identifies as transgender, or for saying that there are only two sexes. The claim reaches students on campus generally, not children or sports, and is the amici's claim about what the rule would require. The same brief defines sex by saying "There are two sexes: male and female." (p. 14, quoting a view the brief attributes to "virtually everyone in history until very recently"). Case status: the Tenth Circuit dismissed the appeal in No. 24-3097 on 2025-03-13 at the federal defendants' request. (Brief of Advancing American Freedom and others as amici curiae in support of plaintiffs-appellees, United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, No. 24-3097, 2024-10-10, pp. 14, 19)
- 2024-05-15: in the Fourth Circuit's published opinion in the Montgomery County storybooks case (parents of elementary-school children and an association of parents and teachers against the county school board, asking for notice and an opt-out from classroom use of LGBTQ-inclusive storybooks), the counsel listing names American Values among the amici supporting the appellants, in a group led by Advancing American Freedom, Inc. (p. 5; the listing names a lawyer, so it is not quoted). The opinion does not show what the amici argued or that American Values wrote any part of the brief. The court records that “The Parents do not challenge the Board’s adoption of the Storybooks or seek to ban their use in Montgomery County Public Schools.” (p. 14). The majority affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction, writing “we are constrained to affirm the district court’s order denying a preliminary injunction.” (p. 7); one judge dissented. The Supreme Court reversed this Fourth Circuit judgment and remanded on 2025-06-27 (Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-297, 6-3); the holding of this opinion no longer stands. (Published opinion of the Court of Appeals, with a dissent, United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, No. 23-1890, 2024-05-15, p. 5)
Ties
- Role: Gary Bauer, president (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 52-1762320, 2; Wikipedia, 3, says he was president of the Family Research Council, a body with a page on this site, 1988 to 1999).
- Role: Gary Bauer, the organization's president, is presented by the Dr. James Dobson Family Institute (EIN 27-1394708; page on this site) as its senior vice president of Public Policy and Culture (bylines 2023-05-26 to 2024-07-12, above), and as chairman of Campaign for Working Families PAC (FEC committee C00325076, matched by name; all three bios give the role).
- Funding, money received: National Christian Foundation; WaterStone; Moriah Foundation; Fidelity Charitable; Schwab Charitable / Donor Advised Charitable Giving; Servant Foundation; The Signatry Charitable Trust (grantors' IRS Form 990 e-file returns naming EIN 52-1762320, 2).
- Formal joint work: none documented.
- Not a tie (name match): The James and Joan Lindsey Family Foundation, 7 rows, $761,725 (TY2020 to TY2025), place not shown by the recipient's own records; stated apart and not counted.
- Funding, money received: Natan Foundation $5,000 (1 row, TY2013; matched by the recipient's full name and place).
- Not a tie (name match): Natan Foundation, 4 rows, $50,000 (TY2016 to TY2020), place not shown by the recipient's own records; stated apart and not counted.
- Funding, from National Christian Charitable Foundation (EIN 58-1493949): $41,000.00 in 2011 (list attached to Schedule I of its Form 990 for tax year 2011).
- Same president, separate filer: American Values Action (EIN 27-2299035), Form 990 for the year ended 2023-12-31 (object 202423199349303987): total revenue $40,000 (all "other contributions"); total expenses $155,781, of which program services $135,000 and management and general $20,781; net assets fell from $522,912 to $407,131. Program expenses as filed: compensation of current officers and directors $81,000 (the president, Gary Bauer, five hours a week); "Researcher/Writer" $27,000; "Researcher" $19,500; grants to domestic organizations $7,500 (one grantee, Family Talk Action, "General support"; already on that organization's page). Management and general: accounting fees $19,500 and office expenses $1,281. The Part III program statement for 2023 reads: "IN 2023 AMERICAN VALUES ACTION ENGAGED IN A SERIES OF EDUCATIONAL INITIATIVES INTENDED TO PROMOTE TRADITONAL VALUES, INCLUDING THE SANCTITY OF LIFE AND RELIGIOUS LIBERTY. IN ADDTION, GARY BAUER, PRESIDENT OF AMERICAN VALUES ACTION SPOKE TO VARIOUS COMMUNITY EVENTS ON TRADITIONAL VALUES OF FAITH, FAMILY AND FREE-ENTERPRISE AS WELL AS IN DEFENSE OF ISRAEL AND JUDEO-CHRISTIAN VALUES." The mission text is to advocate for "traditional values of faith, family, and free-enterprise in the public policy arena". The return names no bill, campaign or policy fight and does not mention trans people; its answer on political campaign activity (Part IV line 3) is No. "Traditional values" is the organization's own phrase; the organization's documented anti-trans conduct is on this page and is unchanged by this return. Schedule O carries governance notes only (IRS Form 990, EIN 27-2299035, tax year 2023, object 202423199349303987). The TY2023 figures are confirmed by ProPublica's data for EIN 27-2299035 (revenue $40,000, expenses $155,781, net assets $407,131; 28). TY2024: total revenue $475,903 (all contributions), total expenses $155,357, grants paid $0, net assets $727,677; the return repeats the 2023 program wording and names no campaign. The return covers 2024-01-01 to 2024-12-31 and was signed 2025-11-13 and submitted 2025-11-14; revenue less expenses was $320,546, net assets were $407,131 at the start of the year, liabilities $0 and employees 0. Part IX as filed: compensation of current officers and directors $81,000; "Researcher/Writer" $27,000 and "Researcher" $19,500 (program services); accounting $19,500 and office expenses $8,357 (management and general); total program services $127,500, management and general $27,857, fundraising $0. Part III repeats the TY2023 mission text and program statement with "IN 2024" in place of "IN 2023"; the return does not mention trans people, answers No on political campaign activity (Part IV line 3), and has no Schedule I and no Schedule J. Part VII lists the president, Gary Bauer, at 10 hours a week (5 on the TY2023 return) with reportable compensation of $81,000 from the organization and $0 from related organizations, and four voting board members, two of them independent. Schedule O carries governance notes only (IRS Form 990, EIN 27-2299035, tax year 2024, object 202523189349311937; the return's rendered text at 29 and the IRS electronic return).
- Not a tie (same-name registration): Virginia State Corporation Commission data list "CAMPAIGN FOR WORKING FAMILIES", type Corporation, status Active, formed 2003-07-03, jurisdiction DC (a District of Columbia corporation registered in Virginia), entity F1554197. The District register lists a domestic nonprofit "CAMPAIGN FOR WORKING FAMILIES", number 963651, active in good standing, formed 1996-11-13. Neither record carries the 527's EIN (52-2000441), an officer or a place, so neither is tied to the 527 or to the FEC committee.
What the records don't show
- Individual donors behind the donor-advised sponsors' grants (IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 52-1762320, 2).
- Any statement by the organization about trans people (its filed mission, IRS Form 990 e-file, EIN 52-1762320, 2).
- Schedule R of the TY2013 to TY2015 and TY2017 returns: the Forms 990 (EIN 52-1762320; 12 and endings 201412, 201512, 201712) carry no Schedule R: the copies have 36 pages (2013), 38 (2014), 33 (2015) and 36 (2017), none with a page headed "Schedule R". Form 990 Part IV line 34 ("related to any tax-exempt or taxable entity") is marked No on the 2017 page image (page 4); for the other three no Schedule R pages exist. So "Campaign-for-Working-Families" (EIN 52-2000441, exempt code 527, a PO Box in Merrifield VA, "advocacy work") appears in Schedule R Part II only in the TY2016 return (page 34 of the 38-page copy), not in TY2013, TY2014, TY2015 or TY2017.
Open questions
- Whether American Values' own pages document work against trans people: the title shown on its own site (2026) does not; the only documented pieces are Gary Bauer's three bylines on the James Dobson Family Institute's site.
- Does any record or page of American Values' own show a Washington DC or Merrifield VA address? Such a source would make the 7 rows from The James and Joan Lindsey Family Foundation ($761,725, TY2020 to TY2025, filed with a post-office box in Washington DC) and the 4 rows from the Natan Foundation ($50,000, TY2016, TY2018, TY2019 and TY2020, filed with Merrifield VA) funding ties.
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.
Sources
- image page: https://ouramericanvalues.org/
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/521762320
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Bauer
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/521762320.
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/770390011
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/830380273
- https://www.ouramericanvalues.org/contact-us
- https://volunteer.charitynavigator.org/organizations/american-values-merrifield-va
- https://oag.ca.gov/charities/search
- https://apps.irs.gov/app/eos/
- https://www.fec.gov/data/committee/C00325076/
- https://990s.foundationcenter.org/990_pdf_archive/521/521762320/521762320_201312_990.pdf
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/581493949
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202632239349301328/IRS990ScheduleI
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202511759349300886/IRS990ScheduleI
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202412209349301691/IRS990ScheduleI
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202321169349301912/IRS990ScheduleI
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202240959349300104/IRS990ScheduleI
- https://drjamesdobson.org/articles/abortion-and-trans-radicals-join-hands
- https://drjamesdobson.org/articles/what-was-he-thinking-ohios-governor-stands-with-trans-insanity
- https://www.drjamesdobson.org/policy-culture/our-bodies-our-sports/
- https://www.ouramericanvalues.org
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/23-450.html
- https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/23/09/222927P.pdf
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-77.html.
- https://research.gold.ac.uk/id/eprint/38983
- https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/24-43.html
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/272299035
- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202523189349311937/IRS990