Replying to T05897
Anyone raising a baby as “trans” is guilty of extreme child abuse

Owner of X (formerly Twitter)
Framing note: Musk's posts and public statements on trans people, and the 2026 ads of America PAC, which he funds, are bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric: posts saying "trans violence is EXTREMELY FAR above normal levels" and "Trans sex hormone drugs are driving extreme violence and should be banned", gender-affirming care called "child mutilation and sterilization", clinicians called "modern day Mengeles", and the PAC's ads against Democratic candidates (the Tracking Trans Hate assessment of the coded posts in section 2 and of the statements in sections 3 and 4; method in the report). Nothing below treats them as a concern or a position.
The account of his rhetoric below comes from public reporting and documents.
If this material is distressing: in the United States, call or text 988 (the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, 6). The Trevor Project supports LGBTQ young people at 1-866-488-7386, by text (START to 678-678) or at 7. Trans Lifeline runs a peer support hotline staffed by trans people at (877) 565-8860 in the US and (877) 330-6366 in Canada, on weekdays (hours at 8).
Replying to T05897
Anyone raising a baby as “trans” is guilty of extreme child abuse
What it says Reply stating that anyone raising a baby as "trans" is "guilty of extreme child abuse", casting parents of trans children as abusers.
What are the statistics on trans violence? The probability of a trans person being violent appears to be vastly higher than non-trans. Hormone injections cause extreme emotional volatility. That is simply a fact.
Quoting @defiyantlyfree:
What it says Quote post claiming the "probability of a trans person being violent appears to be vastly higher than non-trans" and that hormone injections cause extreme volatility, which it calls "simply a fact".
Correction No data show trans people are more violent; trans people are far more often victims of violence, and hormone therapy has not been shown to cause violence.
Something is seriously wrong. Trans sex hormone drugs are driving extreme violence and should be banned.
Quoting @reduxx: CANADA: A trans-identified male has been arrested after breaking into a family's home and sexually assaulting their toddler. Daniel "Dani" Senecal, who uses "she/her" pronouns, was recently released early from prison for a previous child sex attack. https://reduxx.info/male-who-uses-she-her-pronouns-violently-sexually-assaults-toddler-in-ontario-canada/
What it says Quote post over a report of a single crime saying "Trans sex hormone drugs are driving extreme violence and should be banned".
Correction No evidence shows hormone therapy drives violence; one criminal case does not make a trend, and trans people are more often victims of violence than perpetrators.
Silence of the Lambs was literally about a trans serial killer who wanted to become a woman by wearing their skin …
Quotes a post by A2532; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
What it says Quote post asserting that a famous horror film "was literally about a trans serial killer", tying trans people to murder.
Correction The film's own dialogue says the killer is not a transsexual; small samples of offenders do not show trans people commit murder, and being trans is not a motive.
My observation is that a major driver of white males becoming trans is the relentless propaganda portraying white men as the worst human beings. If those lies land, especially during vulnerable teen years, and they are given an option to be a “celebrated” group, some will do it.
What it says Post claiming that "a major driver of white males becoming trans is the relentless propaganda portraying white men as the worst human beings", a social-contagion claim.
Replying to @DonaldJTrumpJr
Violent crimes per capita by trans-identifying individuals is ~10 times higher than the overall population! Large doses of artificially-administered hormones are driving them to extreme violence and murder. These extreme hormone treatments should be withdrawn by the FDA.
What it says Reply claiming violent crime per capita by "trans-identifying individuals" is "10 times higher" than overall, that hormones are driving "extreme violence and murder", and that the FDA should withdraw them.
Correction Trans people are not 10 times more violent; they are far more likely to be victims of violence, and no data shows hormones cause violence.
| Date | Event | Source (status) |
|---|---|---|
| 2020-07 / 2020-12-16 | Tweeted "Pronouns suck." (July 2020); on 16 Dec 2020 tweeted "I absolutely support trans, but all these pronouns are an esthetic nightmare." | Wikipedia "Political positions of Elon Musk", citing The Independent |
| 2022-11 | After acquiring Twitter, relaxed hate-speech enforcement; Gizmodo described the policy protecting trans people as "effectively dead." | Wikipedia "Twitter under Elon Musk" |
| 2022-12 | Tweeted that his pronouns were "Prosecute/Fauci." | Wikipedia "Political positions" |
| 2023-04 | Twitter quietly removed its rule against targeted deadnaming and misgendering. | Wikipedia "Political positions" |
| 2023-04-14 | Tweeted "Any parent or doctor who sterilizes a child before they are a consenting adult should go to prison for life" (reply to a story on Florida). | Hannity.com page |
| 2023-06 | At the start of Pride month, pledged that he will be "actively lobbying to criminalize" what the Washington Blade calls healthcare interventions for transgender youth. | Washington Blade, 2023-06-02 (9); the "actively lobbying" wording also appears in Wikipedia "Political positions" |
| 2023-06 | Musk confirmed that a policy against misgendering would not be enforced, saying not using preferred pronouns is "at most rude and certainly breaks no laws." | Wikipedia "Twitter under Elon Musk" |
| 2023-06-21 | Tweeted that "cis" and "cisgender" "are considered slurs on this platform." On 2024-01-11 tweeted "Cis is a heterophobic word. Shame on anyone who uses it." Both posts are anti-trans rhetoric: they treat the word "cis" as an insult, and the first came in the same month (June 2023) that he said not using preferred pronouns "certainly breaks no laws" (see the 2023-06 row and section 4, item 4). | Wikipedia "Political positions" |
| 2023-10 | The option to report transphobic abuse was scrapped. | Wikipedia "Twitter under Elon Musk" |
| 2024-01-04 | After a school shooting in Iowa, replied with two exclamation marks to a Libs of TikTok post that PinkNews describes as spreading misinformation about the suspect. | PinkNews, 21 Aug 2024 |
| 2024-03 | X restored a rule against targeted misgendering and deadnaming that had been removed in April 2023, but in a weakened form: where local law requires, X would limit the reach of posts that "purposefully use different pronouns to address someone other than what that person uses for themselves"; the targeted person must complain; Musk said "You're not going to get suspended" and later that it applies only to "repeated, targeted harassment of a particular person". The Advocate (2024-03-01) dates the change to January; 9to5Mac and the Advocate reported the restored rule on 2024-03-01, and Metro Weekly on 2024-03-04. | Metro Weekly, 2024-03-04 (10); 9to5Mac, 2024-03-01 (11); Advocate, 2024-03-01 (12); Engadget, 2024-03-04 (13) |
| 2024-07-16 | Said a California law on student gender-identity disclosure was the "final straw" in moving SpaceX and X headquarters to Texas. | Wikipedia "Political positions"; Them |
| 2024-07-22 | Told Jordan Peterson that gender-affirming care is "child mutilation and sterilization", called "gender-affirming care" "a terrible euphemism", said "It wasn't explained to me that puberty blockers are actually just sterilization drugs", said "your son is dead" about deadnaming. | Them, 23 Jul 2024; Salon, 23 Jul 2024 (the deadname is omitted and the family account is not repeated) |
| 2024-07 | Gave a public account of his child's transition that she publicly disputed; the details are health and family matters and are not repeated here. | Wikipedia "Political positions" and "Vivian Jenna Wilson" |
| 2024-08 | During the Olympic boxing row involving Imane Khelif, replied "Absolutely" to a post by Riley Gaines that "men don't belong in women's sports." The IOC said Khelif's inclusion was "not a transgender issue" because she was born female. Khelif's lawyer said a legal complaint over cyber-harassment named Musk and J.K. Rowling. | PinkNews |
| 2025-02 | Responded to a story that India's first transgender healthcare centre closed after US aid cuts: "That's what American tax dollars were paying for." | Economic Times |
| 2025-03-06 | Shared a study with "Sex change surgery is extremely damaging to mental health." | Economic Times |
| 2025-09-02 | Wrote on X: "My observation is that a major driver of white males becoming trans is the relentless propaganda portraying white men as the worst human beings. If those lies land, especially during vulnerable teen years, and they are given an option to be a 'celebrated' group, some will do it." | The National Desk, 4 Sep 2025 |
| 2025-12-11 / 12 | Newsom's press office replied to a clip shared by America PAC with "Correct. We're sorry your daughter hates you, Elon." Musk answered that his child "has a tragic mental illness caused by the evil woke mind virus you push on vulnerable children", adding "I love (Vivian) very much and hope (she) recovers". PinkNews renders the reply with the adult daughter's chosen name. Wilson answered by adding the phrase "Tragic mental illness caused by the evil woke mind virus" to her Instagram bio. | PinkNews, 2025-12-15 (14) |
| 2026-01-03 | Posted that The Silence of the Lambs was "literally about a trans serial killer who wanted to become a woman by wearing their skin"; International Business Times UK reports that the people behind the film clarified that the character was not meant to represent a real transgender individual. | International Business Times UK, 2026-01-03 (15) |
| 2026-01-31 (derived; see below) | Reacting to a detransitioner's malpractice verdict, wrote "There will be thousands of court cases of children who were mutilated by evil doctors, modern day Mengeles." | IOL, reposting RT News (16; RT is a Russian state-funded outlet, so this is a weak source). Plaintiff not named here. |
| 2026-06-01 | Replied "True." to a post saying that he "never would have gotten involved, never would have purchased Twitter" without a particular family event. | PinkNews, 2026-06-02 (17) |
| 2026-09-08 / 09 | America PAC launched ads in four states attacking Democrats over "transgender athletes and gender-affirming care" (see section 7). | Advocate, 9 Sep 2026 |
| 2026-09 | The 19th reported that America PAC released at least 38 social media ads in under a week, and that most of its ads in the Meta and Google libraries focus exclusively on trans people. Two ads showed people implied to be trans women; The 19th could not confirm whether they were real actors or AI-generated, and America PAC did not answer. Google briefly removed them for an unspecified "policy violation" after The 19th asked about its AI-disclosure policy; they were reinstated by publication. | The 19th, Sep 2026 |
| 2026-10 | Reposted an America PAC ad with the words "Talarico wants to trans your kids and destroy the border." The Guardian reported a single America PAC Google ad against Talarico (US Senate, Texas), costing between $300,000 and $350,000 in October, said he "supports parents being charged with child abuse if they do not support transitioning their children" and was shown more than 10 million times over eight days. | The Guardian, 31 Oct 2026 |
| 2026-09 | Advocate reported three lines from America PAC's first midterm ads. Against James Talarico (Texas): "James Talarico believes there are six genders". Against Sherrod Brown (Ohio): "Just two years ago, we fired Sherrod Brown because Brown put the trans agenda ahead of Ohio's values". Against Josh Turek (Iowa): "Josh Turek voted to spend our tax dollars on sex change surgeries for children". All of this is anti-trans rhetoric aimed at defeating Democratic candidates. | Advocate, 2026-09, 3, read |
| 2026-09 | The Human Rights Campaign's national press secretary said of the ads, in a statement Advocate quoted: "Elon Musk is scapegoating LGBTQ+ Americans to distract voters from the cuts he made and the chaos he has caused." | Advocate, 2026-09, 3; the speaker's role is as Advocate gives it |
| 2026-09 | IBTimes Australia wrote that, according to AdImpact, a firm that tracks political advertising spending, the America PAC campaign was "the first large-scale, trans-focused advertising push of the 2026 midterm cycle from a major Republican-aligned outside group". The same article attributes the figure of more than $100 million authorized for the cycle to The New York Times reporting. | IBTimes Australia, 2026, 18; the outlet reports the AdImpact and Times figures |
| 2026-09 | The 19th described two America PAC ads. In the ad against Brown, "an image of a crossing guard with a blowout and dark eyeshadow, implied to be a trans woman, looms in the background as a voiceover declares that Brown 'gave the green light to the radical trans agenda'". In the ad against Talarico a narrator asks "Tired of grown men dunking on female athletes?" while "a person who is implied to be a trans woman, wearing a sequined, rainbow-colored jersey" slam-dunks a basketball in front of a group of young girls. The 19th wrote that the ads "present harmful stereotypes of trans women"; it quoted Kelly Dittmar, whom the article describes as "a professor of political science at Rutgers University": "They are trying to create a caricature of trans people that, to your average person, appears outlandish." | The 19th, 2026-09, 19, read |
| 2026-09 | Uprise RI reported that a second Form 24 filed by America PAC on September 11 itemized $502,078.48 in independent expenditures, including $20,000 of digital media opposing Abdul El-Sayed (Michigan) and supporting Republican Mike Rogers, $19,292.48 of texting services opposing Turek, and printing and postage aimed at Turek, Mary Peltola and Dan Sullivan (Alaska). Uprise RI gives the filing's date and figures. | Uprise RI, 20, read |
He owns the platform, so there is no enforcement history against his account. Policy changes affecting trans users, by date, are in section 3: November 2022 loosening; April 2023 removal of the targeted misgendering and deadnaming rule; June 2023 statement that misgendering would not be enforced and "cis" treated as a slur; October 2023 reporting option scrapped. Wikipedia's "Political positions" article says the misgendering policy was reintroduced in 2024 and that Musk said it would be sparingly enforced, to reduce visibility of posts he considered "repeated, targeted harassment of a particular person". Metro Weekly (2024-03-04) and Tech Policy Press (2024-03-14; next item) report that the restored 2024 rule is narrow: reach is limited, not removed, only where local law requires and only on a complaint by the targeted user. Also noted: in June 2023 Twitter flagged What Is a Woman? as hateful conduct; Musk called that "a mistake" and the restriction was reduced (Wikipedia "Twitter under Elon Musk").
| Level | Counterpart | Relationship | Source (status) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Role | X Corp / Twitter | completed the $44 billion acquisition and put himself in charge (securities filing reported 2022-10-27/28) | CNN, 28 Oct 2022 |
| Role | Tesla / SpaceX | CEO, as the Advocate describes him in September 2026 | Advocate, 9 Sep 2026 (3) |
| Role | DOGE | announced by President-elect Trump as co-leader (undated statement); a 2025 tenure is not shown by that page | presidency.ucsb.edu statement |
| Funding | America PAC | gave $197,662,036 in 2024 and $20,100,000 in 2025 and early 2026 (itemized rows through 2026-06-30, partial; 11 further rows after 2026-06-30 total $157,600,000, see section 7), non-memo rows as filed; purpose not stated | FEC individual contributions, committee C00879510 (4) |
| Funding | America PAC 2026 midterm ads | "backed by" Musk; reported $100 million plan (the Advocate links its "reported $100 million" to a New York Times article of 2026-07-30, 31) | Advocate, 9 Sep 2026 (3) |
| Appearance or listing | Jordan Peterson | podcast interview, 22 Jul 2024 | Them |
Narrative alignment only (not a tie): Riley Gaines (replied "Absolutely" to her post, Aug 2024); Libs of TikTok (replied to its Iowa post, Jan 2024).
Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.