All profiles

Profile

TheRabbitHole (display name "The Rabbit Hole"; bio "Navigating the discourse")

@TheRabbitHole

Facts cutting the other way, stated accurately: some posts are jokes about X itself (2026-09-26, a pun that Twitter was "the first transgender social media application"), and one reply says trans people should be "decoupled" from "gender ideology" (2023-05-22). Neither is criticism of anti-trans actors, and none of the 40 posts reviewed here criticizes them.

1. Public identity and role

  • Self-description: display name "The Rabbit Hole", bio "Navigating the discourse", verified, about 1.1M followers (the account's X profile as recorded in the project archive, last seen 2026-11-14).
  • Who runs it: conduct only. No page of the account's own, no statement by it and no reputable report ties a named public figure to it. No person is named, and none is inferred.
  • PolitiFact, "Anonymous X account shares falsehoods to Elon Musk, top US officials. What we know about 'Amuse'" (2025-03-31, 1), lists The Rabbit Hole among the accounts Musk reposts or responds to "whose owners are not disclosed". The article names no one behind The Rabbit Hole.

2. Posting record (project archive, all posts coded)

  • Followers 1,100,000 (tier 1M+). Keyword posts (weighted) 61.2; views on keyword posts 14,215,768; influence rank 230 under equal weighting (not in the top set under every weighting).
  • Coded posts: 260, every post, reply and quote by the account that matched the search terms (archive as of 2026-11-16). Severity: C0 28; C1 171; C2 14; C3 31; C4 15; C5 1. Share at C2 or above: 23.5% (61 of 260).
  • Shield framing (the post justifies itself by protecting children or women): 62 of 260 coded posts (23.8%).
  • Targeting events: 16. Adult-care posts verified: 2. Aurora-case posts: 0.
  • Top narratives (coded posts carrying each): DENIAL 72; MEDICAL_HARM 42; IDEOLOGY_CULT 41; POLITICAL_ENEMY 38; GOV_SPENDING 23.
  • What the coded posts show: Most of the account's coded posts are anti-trans (232 of 260), mainly in 2023 to 2025, and fewer in 2026. Its main lines are denial of trans people's identity (72 posts, with "trans logic" memes and "trans pseudoscience"), claims of medical harm (42), calling trans identity an ideology or cult (41) and framing political opponents as enemies (38), together with the "let's not trans the kids" slogan. 62 posts carry a protective claim, mostly about children, while 170 make none and 55 of those deny identity; 28 are dehumanizing or single out a person. Among the C4 and C5 posts, 7 single out private individuals, 5 minors and 4 public figures. Dehumanizing posts peak in 2025, and some false claims are stated as fact, including desistance figures and a shooting's supposed motive.
  • Adult-care posts verified: 2, both about care for prison inmates (2025-06-16 and 2024-09-25).
  • Lines of attack in the 40 posts read:
    • "Trans logic" memes (2026-01-15; 2026-06-25; 2025-08-13).
    • "Child trans was peak woke insanity" (2025-01-29).
    • A "vegan cat" line about trans children (2024-12-04; again in a post of 2024-01-09).
    • Bathrooms (2023-07-11, 12.8M views).
    • Women's sports (2025-06-07).
    • A transracial analogy (2025-03-19).
    • Government spending on "transgender monkeys" (2024-11-13, 15,749,933 views, a quote of a post about a Department of Government Efficiency). The claim distorts a small NIH-funded HIV-research grant; the fact-checks of the claim as it circulated that month are set out under Open questions.
  • Examples from the full coded record (the highest-reach posts by severity level and main line of attack):
    • @TheRabbitHole Quote

      If documenting madness was grounds for suspension, then how many trans activists would lose their accounts? I suspect these activists lack self awareness and organized a mass reporting campaign to get a rival account banned. Platform manipulation might be something 𝕏 wants to investigate.

      Quoting @WokeArchive: MALES IN DISGUISE HAS BEEN SUSPENDED. All he does is document so-called "trans women" via their own internet posts. @elonmusk, please fix this!
      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded activist harassment denial mental illness political enemy speech persecution

      73,993 views

      What it says Quote post asking "If documenting madness was grounds for suspension, then how many trans activists would lose their accounts?" and accusing trans activists of a mass reporting campaign. It frames trans people as mad and as a coordinated enemy.

    • @TheRabbitHole Post

      We really don’t need to validate every belief a child might hold. Kids need guidance not blind affirmations. So let’s not trans the kids. Especially given the evidence that many do grow out of it and would suffer their entire lives if they were put through transcare.

      C2 false claims hand-coded contagion medical harm

      135,312 views

      What it says Says "let's not trans the kids" because "many do grow out of it and would suffer their entire lives" if given care. It is coded C2 because the claim that many trans kids "grow out of it" conflates desisting with trans identity.

      Correction Regret after transition is rare, and most who detransition cite outside pressure; the claim that many trans kids "grow out of it" conflates desisting with trans identity.

    • @TheRabbitHole Post

      Looks like the Charlie Kirk shooter was indoctrinated with trans and antifa ideology.

      C2 false claims hand-coded political enemy shooter attribution violence terror

      78,486 views

      What it says Says "the Charlie Kirk shooter was indoctrinated with trans and antifa ideology". It is coded C2 because being trans is not a motive and the claim rests on an unconfirmed early report.

      Correction Being trans is not a motive; the post draws a motive from an unconfirmed early report of engravings, while investigators said motive was unclear.

    • @TheRabbitHole Post

      Let’s not trans the kids

      C2 false claims hand-coded child indoctrination medical harm

      71,011 views

      What it says Posts the slogan "Let's not trans the kids". It is coded C2 because medical transition is not provided to 5-year-olds and puberty blockers start only at puberty after assessment.

      Correction Medical transition is not provided to 5-year-olds; at that age care, where any, is social support, and puberty blockers start only at puberty after assessment.

    • @TheRabbitHole Post

      "Yes, it’s possible for men to become pregnant and give birth to children of their own." ― @[private account] https://www.healthline.com/health/transgender/can-men-get-pregnant

      C1 anti-trans rhetoric hand-coded denial

      3,712,564 views

      What it says Posts a quote from a health site that "it's possible for men to become pregnant", presented with a link as an absurdity to deny trans men's identity. It reached millions of views.

    • @TheRabbitHole Post

      Institutional Trust is down; frankly, many of these institutions have only themselves to blame. They compromised political neutrality in favor of cosplaying as resistance fighters. The medical system is a horrible offender. It's hard to take medical institutions seriously when they legitimize pseudoscientific nonsense like Trans Ideology. The medical establishment also undermined its own public health recommendations during the COVID-19 Pandemic by making exceptions for BLM activists to riot across the country. At the same time, everyone else was supposed to be isolating as best they could. These institutions are unworthy of trust and (I suspect) too arrogant to realize it's their own fault.

      C2 false claims hand-coded ideology cult institutional capture medical harm

      156,785 views

      What it says Says medical institutions "legitimize pseudoscientific nonsense like Trans Ideology" and have only themselves to blame for falling trust. It is coded C2 because major US medical associations support gender-affirming care.

      Correction Major US medical associations (AAP, AMA, Endocrine Society, APA) support gender-affirming care; low-certainty ratings reflect study design in a field where randomized trials are widely considered unethical, not an absence of evidence.

3. Documented moments (from its own posts)

  • 2023-06-10: posted that many accused of being "anti-trans" or "transphobic" "merely want to protect children" (2023-06-10, 3.1M views). This is the child shield, used as a pretext: section 4 sets out the posts beside it that target adults and the whole group.
  • 2023-06-12: posted a list of genocide death tolls ending "Transgender Genocide Death Toll: ????" (2023-06-12, 2.1M views).
  • 2024-04-01: on a Scotland hate-crime law, posted "The trans stuff is concerning for two major reasons: 1) Targeting of children 2) ..." (2024-04-01). The same template was reposted 2024-04-19 and 2024-07-20 (2024-04-19, 2024-07-20). The template puts the child shield first; section 4 sets out how the account uses that shield as a pretext beside posts that target adults and the whole group.
  • 2025-08-10: quoted a post about a person's death and called trans people "cultists", blaming the group for it (2025-08-10, 140k views). Treating a death as a point against trans people is the opposite of safe messaging.
  • 2025-12-13: "Leftists will need to understand there is no compromise on this issue... the rest of sane society will do everything in its power to crush their movement" (2025-12-13, 837,301 views). The same post uses the child shield and calls care "Woke Frankensteinian procedures": dehumanizing language beside the shield (section 4).

If this material is distressing: in the United States, call or text 988 (the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, 2). The Trevor Project supports LGBTQ young people at 1-866-488-7386, by text (START to 678-678) or at 3. Trans Lifeline runs a peer support hotline staffed by trans people at (877) 565-8860 in the US and (877) 330-6366 in Canada, on weekdays (hours at 4).

4. Evidence the child framing is pretextual

  • It states the shield outright (2023-06-10) and reuses it as a template (2024-04-01, 2024-04-19 and 2024-07-20, 2024-04-01 to 2024-07-20). It sits beside posts that target adults and the whole group: "trans cultists" (2025-08-10), "Trans logic" memes, the transracial analogy, and "crush their movement" (2025-12-13).
  • Adult care: two posts attack care for prison inmates (2025-06-16, 2024-09-25). Those are not about children.
  • It repeats "Studies have found anywhere between 60-90% of trans-kids will turn out to be no longer trans by adulthood" as fact (2023-04-27, "H/T" another public account). Unverified: the post names no study. The evidence brief shows 98% (704 of 720) still on hormones at follow-up in the Dutch adolescent cohort (Lancet Child & Adolescent Health, 2022); that cohort began treatment as adolescents and does not measure the same population as the "desistance" figures. The post itself cites nothing for the figure, and the 2026 review by Wall, McLamore and Sakaluk and the VCU release on it, set out below, find that the evidence does not support the 60-90% estimate.
  • On the desistance figure: Wikipedia's article on gender dysphoria in children (5) gives no 60-90% figure. It cites two published critiques of desistance research: Temple Newhook et al. (2018, International Journal of Transgenderism, "A critical commentary on follow-up studies and 'desistance' theories about transgender and gender-nonconforming children"), which argued earlier follow-up studies included children who would likely not meet current DSM-5 criteria, and Karrington and Baer (2022, Transgender Health), a systematic review that found the concept poorly defined (as described in the Wikipedia article). That is a published methodological critique of the studies behind such figures, and the post names none of them; it does not show which study the account had in mind. Wall, McLamore and Sakaluk, "Desistance": A multimethod review of the literature on gender identity variability in transgender and gender diverse youth, Psychology of Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity (American Psychological Association), published online 2026-04-02 (6; abstract as reproduced in the OpenAlex record, 7). The abstract says that political and legal action restricting gender-affirming care rests on a claim that 60-90% of youth presenting for care "desist" from a transgender identity, an estimate "originally popularized by a researcher's blogpost" and drawn from 11 datasets that were reviewed informally. The authors report that their meta-analytic estimates are "very heterogeneous and fickle", that their simulations show volunteer bias "compromises how informative these estimates can be", and that a qualitative review finds "serious conceptual problems, outdated assumptions, and substantial methodological limitations". They conclude that the analyses "undermine the popularized '60-90%' desistance estimate", and that attempts to justify policy initiatives with this estimate "reflect, at best, a misunderstanding of the nature of the scientific literature and, at worst, a motivated reading of the scientific literature." It is a peer-reviewed review article and does not mention the account.
  • The account's 2023-04-27 post (2023-04-27; its words are quoted above) gives the same range, in close wording, as a 2016 blog post by the sexologist James Cantor, "Do trans- kids stay trans- when they grow up?" (Sexology Today!, 2016-01-11, 8). That post lists follow-up studies and says that "roughly 60–90% of trans- kids turn out no longer to be trans by adulthood". The account's post names no study and credits another account, so whether it drew on this blog post is not established. VCU News (Virginia Commonwealth University, 2026-04-27, 9) reports a study led by Catherine Wall, assistant professor of psychology at VCU. The study found that the claim that 60% to 90% of trans and gender-diverse youth come to identify with their gender assigned at birth "is not supported by statistical analyses of published scientific research". It analysed the 11 studies compiled in "a commonly referenced 2016 blog post" and five more recent publications. The release does not name the blog post's author; the match to Cantor's post rests on that description, which fits the post's table of 11 studies, seven of them from before 1990. The same release says that, depending on the assumptions made, desistance could be estimated anywhere from zero to 100%; that seven of the studies were conducted before 1990, three of those examined effeminate behavior in young boys and never directly focused on gender identity, and the youth in the other four did not explicitly identify as transgender; that all but two studies included participants who did not respond to follow-up, and these were often counted as desisting; and that persistence rose by nearly 5% with each study added since 2016. It also says opponents of gender-affirming care for minors cited the original 11 studies in arguments leading to United States v. Skrmetti (2025), and reports Wall as saying that the results disprove the statistical foundation for the narrative that most trans youth desist. How it fits: the post repeats a figure that a 2026 published analysis finds the evidence does not support, and the post itself cites nothing. It is anti-trans rhetoric offered as fact.
  • It says "children are being put through transgender treatment including surgeries" (2023-06-02, a reply that links a Reuters investigation). Surgery on trans minors is extremely rare and banned in much of the US.
  • Dehumanizing language sits beside the child shield: "trans cultists" and the "Woke Frankensteinian procedures" post (2025-12-13).
  • The genocide-toll post (2023-06-12) trivializes violence against trans people.
  • Most of the account's anti-trans posts use no protective claim. 170 of its 232 anti-trans posts make no appeal to protecting anyone, 55 of those deny trans people's identity and 28 are dehumanizing or single out a person; for example 2025-08-19 calls trans people a "cult", and 2024-10-23 calls a presidential candidate's stance "Trans Pseudoscience".

5. Platform enforcement

None documented.

6. Ties

  • Appearance or listing: none documented.
  • Narrative alignment only (not a tie): credits another account for the desistance claim (2023-04-27); promotes an article on European gender-care policy (2023-06-28).

7. Income and funding

No public disclosure is documented. Not estimated.

  • The Substack publication "The Rabbit Hole" (hero text "Navigating the discourse", created 2022-05-03) shows "Over 10,000 subscribers" on its home page. Substack's public data for the publication states that payments are enabled and names a "Super Fan" founding-subscriber plan; the 12 most recent posts, dated 2025-03-23 to 2026-08-22, are all open to everyone, and each is bylined "The Rabbit Hole" (10 and 11). The data gives no subscription price and no income figure. The X account that Substack lists as connected to the byline has a handle that differs from this account's handle, so the data does not show that the publication is this account's own, although the hero text matches the bio word for word.

8. Legal matters

None documented.

Open questions

  • Who runs the account: no public source ties a named public figure to it, so only its conduct is covered.
  • The government-spending claim about "transgender monkeys" (2024-11-13, 15,749,933 views): the fact-checks below are of the same claim as it circulated that month, not of this post. Al Jazeera, publishing a fact-check credited to PolitiFact (2024-11-19, 12) rated false a claim that $33.2 million was spent on "transgender monkey research", saying it "conflates spending on a monkey lab research site with a single study": the NIH awarded three projects $477,121 in total starting in 2020, in which monkeys were given feminizing hormone therapy to test whether it raised susceptibility to HIV and how it affected response to HIV treatment, and the $33.2 million went to a colony housing about 3,500 rhesus monkeys that has existed since the 1970s. The PolitiFact article (2024-11-18; the Al Jazeera page may be a republication of this or of a related PolitiFact piece, so the two are not counted as separate fact-checks, 13) likewise found the $33.2 million refers to a monkey colony in South Carolina, not to transgender research, and gives the grant title as "A nonhuman primate model to study the immunological effects of feminizing hormone therapy in transgender women"; the Al Jazeera page notes that transgender women face a high risk of HIV, the human health problem the work addressed. The claim is therefore a distortion of a real, small HIV-research grant, and it is not stated here as fact. The post's own text is "Why are we spending money doing HIV research on transgender monkeys? Lol, this is beyond parody." It is a quote-post of another post that asks "Why do we need a Department of Government Efficiency?" and says "In 2020, the U.S. government spent $4.5 million to spray alcoholic rats with bobcat urine." The post states no dollar figure for the monkey research; its wording names the HIV aim of the grant and then mocks it, and the only figure in it is the $4.5 million of the quoted post. Al Jazeera's fact-check (credited to PolitiFact, 2024-11-19, 12) rates that quoted figure wrong: the study was real but not the only thing the grants funded; a 2020 report by Senator Rand Paul gave $4.575 million in grants from the NIH and the Department of Veterans Affairs; a spokesperson for LSU Health New Orleans said the grants totalled about $5.6 million from 2014 to 2024; the work aimed to improve care for people with post-traumatic stress disorder and alcohol use disorder. Whether a fact-checker covered this exact post is not established.
  • The "60-90%" desistance figure (2023-04-27): the post cites no study. The published critique of desistance research above bears on it. The Dutch adolescent cohort (98%, 704 of 720, still on hormones at follow-up, Lancet Child & Adolescent Health 2022) is a separate finding about people who started treatment, not a test of the childhood follow-up studies the post refers to; which study, if any, the account relied on is not established.

Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.

Sources

  1. https://politifact.com/article/2025/mar/31/anonymous-x-account-shares-falsehoods-to-elon-musk/
  2. https://988lifeline.org
  3. https://www.thetrevorproject.org/get-help/
  4. https://translifeline.org/hotline/
  5. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_dysphoria_in_children
  6. https://doi.org/10.1037/sgd0000912
  7. https://api.openalex.org/works/doi:10.1037/sgd0000912
  8. http://www.sexologytoday.org/2016/01/do-trans-kids-stay-trans-when-they-grow_99.html
  9. https://news.vcu.edu/article/claim-most-transgender-youth-renounce-identity-is-not-supported-by-statistics-vcu-research-finds
  10. https://therabbithole84.substack.com/
  11. https://therabbithole84.substack.com/api/v1/archive?sort=new&limit=12
  12. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/11/19/fact-check-is-the-us-government-spending-millions-on-transgender-monkeys
  13. https://politifact.com/article/2024/nov/18/fact-checking-elon-musks-amplified-posts-on-us-spe/