All profiles

Account

Defiant L's

1documented tie1 name on file
@DefiantLs account

Anonymity and privacy: the account posts without a name, and Fox News and the Washington Examiner (both February 2022) described it as anonymous. Rolling Stone (2025-10-08) names its owner and operator, Rumen Naumovski; a court disclosure by his company and his own Daily Wire byline bear on that report (section 1). He is named on that basis, because public sources tie him to the account, with no address, home location or family detail. Rolling Stone dates his management of the account from 2023, so this page does not say who ran it at the 2022 suspension. People named in its posts who are not public figures, and any victim who may be a minor, are not named or described.

Framing note: the account's trans content is bad-faith anti-trans rhetoric. Its method is to post a clip or screenshot of one trans person, or one crime with a trans suspect, with a short caption that presents it as typical of trans people or of the political left.

1. Public identity and role

  • X account created 2021-05-07 (account record in the archive). Bio: "Exposing hypocrisy, one day at a time. | DM submissions". Verified. 1.7 million followers (archive). Fox News (2022-02-16) describes it as an anonymous account that posts side-by-side screenshots of "alleged hypocrisy" (Fox News). The Washington Examiner (2022-02-16) says it specialized in "posting screenshots featuring the changing stances of liberal" accounts and had more than 342,000 followers then.
  • Fox reported that the operator relayed a statement through another Twitter user, which directed followers to Instagram and GETTR accounts (Fox News).
  • Owner and operator: Rolling Stone, "The Viral MAGA Accounts Run by a Man Who Has Never Been to America" (2025-10-08, 1; also read in the copy republished by Yahoo News UK, 2) describes Rumen Naumovski, a Macedonian national, as "the owner and operator of both accounts", meaning Defiant L's and the X account Resist the Mainstream. It reports that he runs both through the same Florida company, citing court documents, his own statements and a person with knowledge of his company. It says he "has been managing Defiant L’s via a Florida company since 2023, according to a source with knowledge of the account", that he wrote in a 2025 opinion piece for The Daily Wire that Defiant L's is "one of our accounts", and that the two accounts are listed as "affiliates" of each other on X, a paid feature for businesses.
  • The company is Raww Digital LLC (Rolling Stone). Its disclosure in a copyright suit lists "Rumen Naumovski – 100% Owner" (section 8). The filing does not name Defiant L's; the link between the company and the account rests on Rolling Stone's report.
  • His own opinion piece: The Daily Wire published "I Am Living Proof The American Immigration System Is Broken" under his byline on 2025-02-18. It opens: "I run a growing media company with 11 American employees" (3).
  • Rolling Stone reports that "a year before obtaining Defiant L's" Naumovski made two donations totalling $3,127 to Ron Watkins' 2022 congressional primary campaign in Arizona; that donating to US campaigns as a foreign national is a federal crime, according to the Federal Election Commission; that Watkins refunded the two donations in April 2022; and that Naumovski told Rolling Stone he did not know he was barred from donating. The Federal Election Commission's itemized records for Ron Watkins for Congress (committee C00791715, 2022 cycle) show two contributions from Rumen Naumovski dated 2022-02-21, of $2,900 and $227 (aggregate $3,127), employer filed as Raww Digital, and two payments back to him dated 2022-04-25, of $2,900 and $227, filed on the line for refunds of contributions to individuals (4; 5). The records do not state why the money was returned; the foreign-national explanation is Rolling Stone's.
  • Same report: Republican lawmakers Mike Lee, Nancy Mace, Andy Biggs, Eli Crane and Dan Crenshaw, and Elon Musk, share the two accounts' posts on X; Musk called Defiant L's "one of the best accounts on X" in 2024. Sharing posts is amplification, not a tie.
  • No organization or publication tie beyond the company is documented in public sources.

2. Posting record (project archive, all posts coded)

  • Followers 1,700,000 (tier 1M+). Keyword posts (weighted) 255.7; views on keyword posts 57,310,347; influence rank 89 under equal weighting (not in the top set under every weighting).
  • Coded posts: 548, every post, reply and quote by the account that matched the search terms (archive as of 2026-11-16). Severity: C0 56; C1 236; C2 23; C3 30; C4 201; C5 2. Share at C2 or above: 46.7% (256 of 548).
  • Shield framing (the post justifies itself by protecting children or women): 105 of 548 coded posts (19.2%).
  • Targeting events: 203. Adult-care posts verified: 0. Aurora-case posts: 0.
  • Top narratives (coded posts carrying each): DENIAL 180; POLITICAL_ENEMY 99; WOMEN_SPORTS 59; CHILD_INDOCTRINATION 43; VICTIM_DISMISSAL 38.
  • What the coded posts show: Of 548 coded posts, 492 are anti-trans (C1 or above). Only 105 of those carry a protective claim, mainly about women's sport (47), denial of identity (31) and children (29); the other 387 make no appeal to protecting anyone, and in those 149 deny trans people's identity and 194 are dehumanizing or single out a person. Across all coded posts the leading lines of attack are denial of identity (180), casting trans people as a political enemy (99), women's sport (59) and child indoctrination (43). Most of the coded posts date from 2025 and 2026, and the C4 and C5 posts single out private individuals (125), public figures (68) and minors (10).
  • Archive holds 547 posts from 2024-06-22 to 2026-10-26, 123,270,277 views. No post carries a community note in the archive.
  • C4 posts (private people not named):
    • A post of 2026-03-06 (not linked: it singles out a private person), 300,220 views: a caption quoting a trans woman's statement about feeding babies (wording not reproduced here), with a link to a clip from a bot account. A trans woman's statement is presented as the mainstream.
    • A post of 2026-04-28 (not linked: it singles out a private person), 34,995 views: "Islamic scholar says his religion loves and protects gay and trans people." (an ISLAM_LINK post).
    • A post of 2025-09-11 (not linked: it singles out a private person), 313,070 views: a clip of one person describing their own gender identity (wording not reproduced here).
    • 2026-05-11, 49,016 views: about a non-binary elected member of the Scottish Parliament: "I am a transgender Tamil immigrant. My pronouns are they/them." "What a mess." (a public official; the post mocks both identity and immigration status).
    • A post of 2026-05-28 (not linked: it singles out a private person), 36,511 views: names a sex offender (not reproduced) as the voice of "my civil rights as a transgender person allow me to use a public facility".
  • High-view posts (from the archive): 2026-02-26, 23,096,282 views ("The first openly trans lawmaker, a Democrat, pleads guilty to child sex charges involving kids as young as 3-years old"); 2026-02-21, 7,289,652 views (an update on a victim of the Canadian school shooting that labels the shooting suspect by gender identity; victim details not reproduced); 2025-09-13, 1,248,855 views (makes an unsupported claim about a private individual in connection with the Charlie Kirk shooting; name not reproduced); 2025-03-08, 1,859,744 views; 2025-09-02, 1,786,745 views ("Percent of U.S. adults identifying as transgender, by birth year", a chart).
  • Examples from the full coded record (the highest-reach posts by severity level and main line of attack):
    • @DefiantLs Post

      Trans Democrat Maine Senate candidate Webb: "I also leak, like, a mucus, which they can't really explain."

      C4 targeting hand-coded appearance political enemy

      1,047,189 views

      What it says Holds up a trans political candidate's remark about a bodily symptom for ridicule, labelled "Trans Democrat"; coded C4 as mockery of appearance and singling out a public figure.

    • @DefiantLs Post

      Spot the trans person.

      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded appearance denial

      671,758 views

      What it says Posts only the caption "Spot the trans person." over an image, inviting readers to judge people by appearance; coded C3 as denial of identity and an appearance line.

    • @DefiantLs Post

      "I am no longer gonna be sitting here and pandering and feeding into the fantasies of trans people anymore. I am sick and tired of pretending that being transgender is not a mental illness"

      C3 dehumanizing hand-coded denial mental illness

      467,555 views

      What it says Amplifies a speaker who says he is "sick and tired of pretending that being transgender is not a mental illness" and calls trans identity "fantasies of trans people"; coded C3 as a mental-illness claim.

    • @DefiantLs Post

      Rogan: “Do you know who’s killed more people than ICE this year? Trans shooters.”

      C2 false claims hand-coded shooter attribution violence terror

      949,088 views

      What it says Repeats a podcast host's line asking who has "killed more people than ICE this year" and answering "Trans shooters"; coded C2 as shooter attribution.

      Correction No data support a trans shooter epidemic; trans people are a very small share of shooters and are more often victims of violence.

    • @DefiantLs Post

      Female boxer abandons her fight early against trans opponent. Y'all think this is justified or disrespectful?

      C2 false claims hand-coded denial women sports

      702,191 views

      What it says Frames a boxer abandoning a fight as one "against trans opponent" and asks whether this is "justified or disrespectful"; coded C2 as a false claim, with a protective claim about women's sport.

      Correction The opponent in the bout was not trans; she competed as a woman throughout her career, and trans athletes are a tiny share of elite women's sport.

    • @DefiantLs Post

      Jordan Peterson was absolutely spot on with his assessment here. "The joint probability that you have a trans kid and a pansexual kid is one in nine million. The odds that you're a pathological narcissist sacrificing your own children to the glorification of your compassion is eight million, nine hundred and ninety-nine thousand, nine hundred and ninety-nine to one."

      C2 false claims contagion parent abuser

      258,458 views

      What it says Endorses a quoted claim that the "joint probability" of having a trans child and a pansexual child is "one in nine million" and that the parent is "a pathological narcissist sacrificing your own children"; coded C2 under parent-abuser and contagion claims.

      Correction The one-in-nine-million figure is not an estimate from any data; trans, bisexual and pansexual identities are common among young people, so co-occurrence in a family is not rare.

3. Documented moments

  • 2022-02-15/16: Twitter suspends the account for alleged "ban evasion"; the account's statement says it had no earlier suspension and no ban to evade; followers use #FreeDefiantLs; Fox News says its operator appealed and that the account had "yet to be restored" at publication (an early report that predates the reversal). Reinstated 2022-02-16 (Washington Examiner, 2022-02-16; MRC Free Speech America, advocacy source). Conservative outlets (Daily Wire, OutKick, Blaze, Reclaim The Net) covered it.
  • 2025-09-11 to 2025-09-13: posts about Charlie Kirk's killing include one making an unsupported claim about a private person linked to the suspect (2025-09-13). The suspect is not trans; fact-checkers documented false or unconfirmed "trans shooter" claims after the Kirk shooting.
  • 2025-11-03: a former New Hampshire legislator pleads guilty to federal child sexual exploitation charges (reported 2025-11-07, Maine Wire); sentenced on 2026-06-18 to 400 months, about 33 years (CBN); New Hampshire Public Radio (2026-06-19, 6) also reports the 33-year sentence and the November guilty plea to three counts of sexual exploitation of children, and says that in 2012 the person was believed to be the first transgender person elected to a state legislature. The account's post of 2026-02-26 says "pleads guilty" (see section 4).
  • 2026-02-10 to 02-21: after the Tumbler Ridge, B.C. school shooting, the account's 2026-02-21 post labels the shooter "a transgender person." CTV News (2026-02-12) reported that false claims spread online after reports about the shooter's gender identity, and Global News (2026-02-13) quoted advocates and the B.C. Human Rights Commissioner on anti-trans disinformation (their views; the article does not measure its spread). CBC News (Kevin Maimann, posted 2026-02-11, last updated 2026-02-13, 7) reported that claims of an "epidemic" of trans shooters circulating on social media are false and that experts say there is no evidence for such a trend; it quotes James Densley, co-founder of The Violence Prevention Project, who says that in the U.S. 97.5 per cent of mass shootings in his database were carried out by cisgender men, 2 per cent by cisgender women and 0.5 per cent by trans people, and attributes the false perception partly to "base rate neglect". The article names an Independent B.C. legislator (Tara Armstrong) and the commentator Matt Walsh among those who posted such claims on 2026-02-11, and does not name this account. Details of the suspect's personal history are not given here.
  • 2026-08-10: posts a clip of a former NBA player saying "I realized my fear of flying really wasn't a fear of flying. It was the transgender trapped inside of me" (2026-08-10, 1,055,398 views).

4. Evidence that the child and sports framing is pretextual

The account uses a "hypocrisy" frame, not a child-protection frame (mostly about women's sport, denial of identity and children, while most of its anti-trans posts carry no protective claim), so section 4 concerns the pattern of rhetoric:

  1. It posts clips and screenshots of single trans adults as typical, with the caption doing the mocking: the "milk" post, the clip of one person describing their gender identity, the post about a Member of the Scottish Parliament (coded C4, where the words of one person stand for the group).
  2. It links trans people to sex offences: the 2026-02-26 post foregrounds the legislator's trans identity and party ("a Democrat") over any documented motive, and the 2026-05-28 post uses a sex offender's quote about facilities. The legislator's plea was reported in November 2025 (Maine Wire), so the February 2026 caption describes older news as if new. A single person's conviction says nothing about trans people as a group; separately, FactCheck.org (2025-09-17) puts confirmed trans shooters at under 0.1% of mass shootings.
  3. Motive displacement: the post about a private person linked to the Kirk suspect and the Canadian shooting post foreground trans identity. For Kirk, the suspect is not trans and fact-checkers rejected "trans shooter" claims; for Canada, the RCMP was reported to have said the attack was not targeted (secondhand; not confirmed from an RCMP statement).
  4. Mental-illness and "predator" tags apply to adults.
  5. Sports: the 2025-08-24 post (10.3 million views) about a school athletic result, and the post on the former NBA player's WNBA declaration (2026-08-10), amplify "men in women's sports." The post about a school athlete is not described here because the athlete may be a minor. NCAA says trans athletes in women's sport are "effectively zero".
  6. Immigration and religion: the post about the Member of the Scottish Parliament and the "Islamic scholar" post (ISLAM_LINK) tie trans identity to immigrants and Muslims. This is political targeting beyond "protecting children."
  7. The account rarely states a position on transition or an adult ban, only captions; this is not evidence of good faith.
  8. Most of the account's anti-trans posts carry no protective claim: 387 of 492 make no appeal to protecting anyone, 149 of those deny trans people's identity and 194 are dehumanizing or single out a person, for example 2026-06-02 (932,042 views), which calls trans identity a "delusion", and 2026-05-13 (774,492 views), which mocks a trans actor with a misgendered label.

5. Platform enforcement

  • The 2022-02-15/16 suspension and reinstatement are in section 3 (Washington Examiner; MRC). MRC (advocacy) says most of roughly 354,000 followers lost had not returned; this differs from the Washington Examiner's follower figure in section 1, and the two outlets' counts are not reconciled.
  • Further follower counts at the February 2022 suspension: Fox News, Reclaim The Net and The Post Millennial each give "350,000" or "over 350,000" followers (8; 9; 10). The figures are rounded and not reconciled with the other counts.
  • Reclaim The Net carries an update, "Twitter has reversed its decision to ban Defiant L's after public outcry", a further outlet for the reinstatement. It says the suspension followed a post by the account highlighting a 2012 tweet by Justin Trudeau on dissent, set against his invoking the Emergencies Act that week (the outlet's own sequence; no platform reason is given for it).
  • No later enforcement reported.
  • Reversal date: The Quartering reported on 2022-02-16 that the account "is now back and no longer banned", gave the suspension date as Tuesday, 15 February, and gave no hour for either event; it reported the account saying it had appealed and did not know why it was restored (The Quartering, 2022-02-16, 11). With the Washington Examiner of the same date, two outlets place the reinstatement on or before 2022-02-16. These sources give neither the hour nor the platform's stated reason for the reversal.
  • Reported timing of the February 2022 reinstatement, and a reported reason: Newsmax (2022-02-16, 12) reports that Twitter suspended the account on Tuesday citing a "ban evasion" violation and that it was "restored on the service Wednesday afternoon" (Wednesday was 2022-02-16). It gives no exact hour.
  • MRC Free Speech America, an advocacy group, writes on its NewsBusters site (Gabriela Pariseau, 2022-02-16, 13) that a Twitter spokesperson told it the account was "permanently suspended for violations of our ban evasion policy", and that "Two hours after Twitter responded to MRC’s request for comment, the platform restored the account." It gives no clock time and no reason from the platform for the reversal.

6. Ties

  • Role: Rumen Naumovski, owner and operator of the account through his Florida company Raww Digital LLC since 2023 (Rolling Stone, 2025-10-08); the company-account link rests on Rolling Stone's report.
  • Narrative alignment only (not a tie): reposts and amplification in the archive; a Twitter user who shared the operator's 2022 statement, per Fox (Fox names no advocate). Not ties.

7. Income and funding (publicly disclosed only)

  • None documented. The account is verified on X; X's creator revenue share is not publicly disclosed for any account. The account invites DM submissions and points to Instagram and GETTR (2022). No amount is estimated.
  • A Substack publication named Defiant L's with the same tagline as the X bio exists (14); its pages show a free Subscribe button and no price, tier, subscriber number or author name, and do not link to the X account. A post titled "Ls Of The Day", dated Nov 12, 2026, is at 15; the publication's home page and its About page (16) carry the tagline "Exposing hypocrisy, one day at a time.", the footer "(c) 2026 Defiant L's" and a "Subscribe" button. The tie between the publication and the X account rests on the identical name and tagline; no page states it. Whether a paid tier exists is not shown. No income is documented.

8. Legal matters

  • Raww Digital, LLC, the company Rolling Stone reports runs the account, was the defendant in a copyright suit brought by a photojournalist who alleged that Resist the Mainstream repeatedly took his work (an allegation): US District Court for the Middle District of Florida, Tampa Division, No. 8:23-cv-02488 (the case number shows it was opened in 2023; Rolling Stone calls it a 2024 lawsuit). The company's "Certificate of Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure Statement" of 2024-02-05 lists "Rumen Naumovski – 100% Owner" (17); it does not name Defiant L's.

Open questions

  • Whether a fact-check outlet or a monitor such as Media Matters has covered specific posts, including the 2026-02-26 post (23,096,282 views) and the Tumbler Ridge post.
  • The platform's stated reason for the 2022-02-16 reversal, and the hour: two outlets give the date only. Newsmax and an MRC post (section 5) give the suspension reason as "ban evasion" (MRC attributes it to a Twitter spokesperson) and place the restoration on the afternoon of 2022-02-16; neither gives an hour or a reason for the reversal.
  • The account's pre-2024 archive is not collected (earliest post 2024-06-22), so its earlier trans-related posting cannot be described.
  • Who ran the account before 2023, including at the February 2022 suspension: Rolling Stone dates Naumovski's management from 2023, and the sources cited here do not say who ran it earlier.

Information packet: the full written profile, every claim, table and source, to read, print or save as PDF.

Sources

  1. https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/viral-maga-social-media-accounts-rumen-naumovski-1235441739/
  2. https://uk.news.yahoo.com/viral-maga-accounts-run-man-143000221.html
  3. https://www.dailywire.com/news/i-am-living-proof-the-american-immigration-system-is-broken
  4. https://www.fec.gov/data/receipts/?committee_id=C00791715
  5. https://www.fec.gov/data/disbursements/?committee_id=C00791715
  6. https://www.nhpr.org/nh-news/2026-06-19/stacie-laughton-nh-newhampshire-state-lawmaker-nashua-sentenced-prison-child-exploitation
  7. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/tumbler-ridge-shooting-trans-community-false-claims-9.7085078
  8. https://www.foxnews.com/us/defiant-ls-twitter-account-suspended
  9. https://reclaimthenet.org/twitter-bans-popular-account-defiant-ls
  10. https://thepostmillennial.com/news/breaking-twitter-suspends-defiant-ls-account-best-known-for-highlighting-liberal-hypocrisy
  11. https://portal.thequartering.com/news/epic-win-twitter-forced-to-re-instate-popular-liberal-roasting-account-defiant-ls-after-backlash/
  12. https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/twitter-censorship-defiant-ls-conservative/2022/02/16/id/1057162/
  13. https://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/free-speech/gabriela-pariseau/2022/02/16/im-back-defiant-ls-twitter-account-censored-0
  14. https://defiantls.substack.com/
  15. https://defiantls.substack.com/p/ls-of-the-day-bb1
  16. https://defiantls.substack.com/about
  17. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.flmd.420284/gov.uscourts.flmd.420284.21.0.pdf