The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Having spoken to people who work with these clinics, what they mean is that they have medical professionals from several disciplines who all practice the affirm-first/affirm-only approach.
Psycho-"therapy" means helping the presumed "trans kid" cope with "minority stress."
And, unlike obesity, there’s no objective and reliable diagnostic test for being trans or (arguably) for permanent gender dysphoria (in youth). It might makes sense to recommend low evidence treatments when the body is ill anyway, but not when the body is healthy.
“Trans kids know who they are”
“Gatekeeping is dehumanizing”
“Embodiment goals”
Quoting @buttonslives: Layla Jane is seeking justice against the Permanente Medical Group, Kaiser Foundation Hospitals, and the clinicians who facilitated her transition from age 12 to 17, including a double mastectomy performed when she was just 13 years old.
(I am aware of the argument that disorders of sex development prove that sex is a social construct. I don't buy it. Even if it were true, however, the vast majority, if not all, of transgender-identified youth do not have DSDs, so the argument wouldn't apply to them anyway.) 2/
The affirmers deny this key point about desistance. They argue that the desistance studies are unreliable because they were over-inclusive b/c they included mere gender non-conformity) (citing, e.g., Temple-Newhook, 2018). They also say that desistance, where it exists, is almost always the result of lack of affirmation (citing Olson, 2022). Ergo: "trans kids know who they are."
In fact, if going through the “wrong puberty” is agonizing and life-threatening, and if some kids realize they’re trans only in adolescence, and if denying your kid’s demand for these drugs is “child abuse” (looking at you, CA), why not mandate them by law for all kids?
Can we please--PLEASE--stop the anti-parent rhetoric? It seems like the only thing people on either side of the gender issue can agree on these days is that America's jails need more parents in them.
The truth is that parents can legally do a whole lot worse to their kids than to bring them to Pride events, even ones with highly sexualized displays.
Let's focus on helping parents with trans-identified/distressed kids navigate the maze of disinformation and confirmation bias that underwrites "gender-affirming care." Let's equip them with the knowledge and resources they need to push back against irresponsible teachers and staff in schools.
Affirmers tell us this all the time: the role of mental health professionals is not to "gatekeep" (e.g., exploratory therapy), but to help the child (who is assumed trans because s/he said so) receive desired drugs/surgeries and cope with being trans in various domains of life.
The "individualized" part means that the contours of gender affirmation--e.g., how to navigate being trans at school--differ from case to case, not that some cases are affirmed and others not.
What's really meant is that there's a team of professionals from various therapeutic disciplines who are all committed to agreeing with a kid that her self-declared trans ID should be taken at face value and serve as sufficient grounds for medicalization.
“The public figures who have received the most flak for their criticisms of trans activism are disproportionately women… and yet so, too, are the movement’s most devoted allies. This is, in the main, an intra-female conflict.”
Quoting @KonstantinKisin: This week's guest piece is from the superb @[private account] who argues that we increasingly talk to the "offended" and "marginalised" as we do to children. And that we should stop.
If you believe that non-binary exists, you believe that trans women and trans men are gender conforming. Perhaps even more conforming than “cis” people since make an effort to adopt stereotypical appearance and behavior in order to “pass.” The inclusion of non-binary and binary trans in one movement creates incoherence within the movement. Movement theorists like Paisley Currah have recognized this, as have pro-movement sociologists who have written on this like Rogers Brubaker.
Did I mishear that, or did Chelsea just define non-binary as those who don’t conform to stereotypes? If so, then binary trans identity = conforms to stereotypes. Queer theorists themselves recognize that binary “gender identity” is based on stereotypes. Why can’t we?
The belief that federal involvement in education is, at heart, a civil rights project is actually quite accurate. It’s just that the meaning of civil rights has changed dramatically, and with it the scope and complexity of federal involvement. Imagine telling Earl Warren about transgender bathrooms and “Dear Colleague” Letters.
Quotes a post by T30453; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If we’re supposed to take trans adults at their word that they knew—not believed, but knew—they were trans when they were kids, why shouldn’t we take gay/lesbian and former tomboy adults at *their* word when they say they would have identified as trans and sought unnecessary medicalization had these things been available and celebrated when they were kids?