The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Nicely put:
"No mechanism exists by which transgender strippers can reduce homelessness, racially conscious public utilities can combat white supremacy, or a “resistance and liberation” curriculum can boost standardized math scores."
Quotes a post by A0569; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] I don't, but I'm pretty sure they, working with their healthcare professionals, etc., can figure it out.
The more pressing question is what this has to do with trans people, as they're not actually intersex in most cases.
I think I'm about one cancellation and/or trans rights activism meltdown away from deciding that dropping everything and learning Mandarin is the best individual course of action going forward in this culture war.
@[private account] @washingtonpost Here's something I wrote over two years ago about trans rights and issues. You're not saying anything new or interesting to me here, but I appreciate your enthusiasm to chime in.
https://areomagazine.com/2017/09/27/an-argument-for-a-liberal-and-rational-approach-to-transgender-rights-and-inclusion/
A medical student talking about his fears about the ways trans activism is affecting medicine.
https://www.kelseycoalition.org/pubs/A-Concerned-Medical-Student-Speaks-Out
I have to guess a little here. "Trans women are women" is easier -- they want to disrupt stable categories of sex and gender and allow people to choose according to how their (alleged) lived experience. The other side is probably forcing the acknowledgement of one's privilege.
Everyone having to announce pronouns all the time "validates" the trans/GNC experience around pronoun use, which is otherwise "invalidated" by "cisnormative assumptions." And that "invalidation" is why they say that cisnormativity "literally" denies their humanity.
So, if EVERYONE declares their pronouns all the time, then trans/GNC people aren't forced to mark themselves as different (read: abnormal, read: less good) people. That's more or less the primary thing behind the push to make everyone declare their pronouns all the time.
In short, if trans/GNC people have to declare their pronouns, but no one else does, that marks them as "different," which under a Derridean understanding of power dynamics in language automatically implies "worse." (Butler tied in Foucault here too.) This is postmodernism. So...
The first thing is that it's about "acceptance" and "inclusion." As it stands, trans and gender nonconforming (GNC) people don't go by the pronouns they were born with. Everyone else does. So if EVERYBODY declares their pronouns, it makes it not weird to declare pronouns.
I think this would result in all of the top brackets in most sports being men, then some that are men and some intersex/trans women, then some that are a blend of all three. Women in sports STILL lose. Plus, all the cheating (sandbagging) that would be going on to win.
I think the odds that trans women athletes competing as women in most sports will be accepted by the public at large is very close to zero percent, and this has absolutely nothing to do with systemic oppression or cultural power dynamics.
You see, identifying and passing as a man, in the end, would grant otherwise impossible access to homosocial male spaces (Michael Flood), and by being subversive there as a MtFtM trans person, patriarchal norms could be disrupted (Judith Butler).
Was going to be an autoethnography of a (bearded) man who is trans but doesn't transition but then decides to identify and live subversively as a man (who is a trans woman identifying as a man) because of a felt responsibility to dismantle patriarchy from within.
I'd refine the point you quoted. Some of the T are like that, but most aren't. The fault line isn't between the various letters. It's between those who push queer theory and those who don't. The trans activists do. Most trans people don't and rather wish they'd shut up.
If you caught that: good. You get it now. Dave Chappelle being black doesn't give him a Theoretical license to speak, it gives him the ability to speak from a view of black oppression (first impression he did). He can't joke about women, sexual minorities, trans, even Chinese.
There are few greater threats to gay, lesbian, bisexual, and trans rights, circumstances, and liberties than queer Theory, even as it positions itself as their champion (thus grifting off them). What does it mean to be a lesbian if "gay" and "woman" aren't stable categories?
Why is queer Theory interested in unmaking categories of sex, gender, and sexuality? Its Theorists believe these categories are intrinsically oppressive to those who are categorized. Here, trans women "lose out" on potential romantic and sexual partners by being assigned "trans."