The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Share your experiences all you want, I'm not interested in deplatforming you.
The fact remains that being trans means having some for of gender dysphoria. For you, it's social dysphoria. But that discomfort is still there. Hence the desire to transition.
So, there's still dysphoria. doesn't matter if it's body related, social related etc. Trans people are people who suffer from gender dysphoria - that's why they transition.
There are detrans folk. Trans people who regret. One doesn't invalidate the other. Neither should be silenced.
Med transition is serious, very taxing on the body. Nobody should undergo it without serious thought. I didn't do it without serious thought, yet still regret it. 2/
Regarding detrans stories being used as a weapon against trans people:
The existence of detransitioners does not mean all trans people will experience regret. Many, many trans people are out yhere living normal, productive lives and are very happy with there transition. 1/
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] I can only speak ancedotely here, but most of the detransitioners I've spoken to/seen posting online still suffer from gender dysphoria after detransition. They certainly didn't just get "bored" with being trans.
Twisting my words appears to be a penchant for you. I'll repeat my stance:
I don't think trans people are deluded. I think people, regardless of identity, who think sex can be changed are deluded. It's deluded to believe biological reality doesn't exist. Many trans people agree.
You wanna talk empathy? You've been tweeting accusations of transphobia at me since yesterday. You don't have to school me on what it's like to be trans, Aidan. I was a trans man for years. I've suffered from dysphoria my entire adult life. But go ahead, try to educate me.
Why do you call them trans women and trans men and not just women and men? Why add the trans prefix? Is it because trans women are, in fact, different from women in some way? A biological way perhaps?
Trans women are trans women. Trans men are trans men. Women are women. Men are men. Deal with it, Aidan. You don't get to change reality because it hurts your fragile sensibilities.
Keep that in mind when you attack someone for transphobia simply because some trans activists claimed so, even though you haven't personally heard their views.
Your community can be wrong. You can disagree with the majority, and that's a good thing. Be you, not your group 3/3
Just because you're trans does not mean you get to speak for the trans community. It's a big community - there will be differing opinions among its members, and that's a good thing.
Never aim to be part of a political hive mind. Practice what you preach; embrace diversity 2/3
Trans ideology, like all forms of identity politics, is harmful because it encourages you to identify yourself and your beliefs based soley on your group identity - leading to tribal thinking, where independent thought is shoved aside in favour of blind adherence to ideology 1/3
It is a strange accusation that's often unfounded. I appreciate my trans friends because they're the only ones who really understand what dealing with dysphoria is like. We have far more in common than not.
She's not using me agasint my wishes. She shared an article that compassionately and honestly discussed transition regret, which will surely offer comfort to anyone dealing with transition regret. Nothing in that article is anti trans.
You started this by saying the article was "a very disappointing direction" for Laura because you claim it's being "used as a stick to beat trans people." This is disingenguous and insidious on your part. You just can't let detrans folk share their stories without smearing them.
I wouldn't call trans people 'blackaface actors,' nor did I agree with many of the things Magdalen Bern's said. But that has nothing to do with the detransition article, so I'm not quite sure why you felt the need to include it.
I'm one of the detransitioners featured in Laura's article; her goal was to hear our stories and give voice to a horrible situation so others in that situation know they're not alone. There's nothing anti trans about it, it's there to help people like me/families like mine
How is Laura's article being us d to beat trans people? It's an honest account from the mouths of detrans women, sharing their stories and experiences. What's wrong with that?
@[private account] @jk_rowling Funny indeed. Every single detransitioner I've spoken to denied transphobia was a factor and, in fact, many put off detransition for fear of backlash from the trans community.
It's bullshit, and it takes away from genuine trans folk who go through the process of getting a professional diagnosis for the purpose of making sure that only those who will likely benefit from transition will move further along in the transition process.
The problem with identity/labels is how they can trap you. When I identified as trans - when that first niggling pang of regret happened - I pushed it down because I was *trans,* period. Regret was wrong.
The label I'd given myself stopped me from detransirioning for a year 1/3
@[private account] Hear hear. There are many wonderful trans people out there who have detransitioners backs and want to work with and support us, which unfortunately makes them a target for their own community.
Non-binary identies are bullshit. You're male or female. If you're male, you're a man or a trans woman. If you're female, you're a woman or a trans man. How do I know this? Who can get pregnant? Who can impregnate? Who has sperm? Who has eggs? It's all there, folks. We all know.
While I'm at it, you adult trans folks are no different. Most of you are cool and reasonable, but a subsection of you are fucking mental.
Reporting me for saying 'only females can give birth,' man, go fuck yourselves.
If the truth is too much, that's *your* problem.
My heart breaks when I interact with teen trans people. They scream how they know they're right, and I'm a bigot.
Some of you will benefit from transition, most of you won't. You can't call me 'fake' when I had 5 years of T & a mastectomy while you think your haircut means a lot
I've been waking up drunk for a while, in a blur. This isn't a plea for sympathy, just an observation; The people who've stuck by me really have taught me a lot. Gay, straight, trans, detrans, male, female. None of that matters. Friends are friends. Honesty is what matters.
@[private account] Of course. Many of those who detransition support trans people. Everyone is different, and all our journey's are unique. I'm sorry you're reconsidering your transition - I hope whatever happens, you find yourself.
I've been sober for almost a week and it's been hard. Everything is amplified, including my dysphoria. I don't know how other detransitioners get through this.
The messages I've gotten from young detransitioners & trans people regretting their transition make me feel ashamed.
I don't personally know a lot about it. I don't want kids, so whether I'm able to have them anymore or not doesn't bother me. But trans men get pregnant now and again, so clearly T doesn't immediately sterilise females.
There are several "camps" in the "detrans community."
One: "I don't want my experience to be used to hurt trans people."
That's understandable. But people need to stop setting themselves on fire to keep others warm. Your experiences don't hurt others; they help those like you.
From what I've gathered, most trans people don't spend time bitching about trans issues online. They have jobs, families and hobbies they're happy to get on with without getting involved in online political shouting matches.
If you don't know many trans folk, you may be forgiven for assuming most are as mental as the outspoken trans activists.
Rest assured, the only people I know who're more pissed off with the "trans community" than concerned parents and detransitioners, are other trans people.
I love being told by self-proclaimed "trans allies" that detransition doesn't happen - but if it does - it's due to transphobia and societal pressure.
I lived as a trans man for years. Not once did I experiance transphobia or societal pressure to revert.
It's funny that when I, as a homosexual, say I'm uncomfortable with a term being included in everyday conversation I'm told to just ignore it's there.
But when I say "trans women are trans women" rather than "trans women are women" I'm attacked for making people uncomfortable.
If you transition while family members are very young, they have no idea you're trans. My niece was told she had an aunt called Sinead she'd never met when she saw old photos of me, so now she firmly believes Sean and Sinead are two different people.
Trans & detrans, how did the kids in your life react to the change?
My nephews remember me pre-transition but my niece only knew uncle Sean and she's devastated he's "gone."
I've said I'm the same person, she doesn't have to call me aunt etc. but she just wants her uncle back.
It is widely known that gay and lesbian kids are far more likely to exhibit gender non-conforming interests and behaviours.
Now, many of those kids are being thought of as "trans kids," despite the fact that most who are diagnosed with Dysphoria outgrow it by adolescents.
I know, transition certainly does help many trans people. My issue is that it's very often presented as *the* treatment for dysphoria, when it has actually harmed people like me.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Not necessarily. Some of them are avid LGBTQIAETC activist's, and supporting a trans kid is more admirable than supporting a gay kid. If something else comes along, they'll take that up.
@[private account] @[private account] You're twisting the topic. This was about TT criticising Mermaids for encouraging trans kids - not gay kids - to keep information from their parents.
TT has never said gay kids must out themselves to their parents. Not once.
@[private account] Thriving, probably.
Most reasonable, average folk couldn't care less if someone wants to transition. But when the PC activists started ranting about the spectrum, about the fuckin gender unicorn, a lot of those good people said "NO."
And normal trans folk suffered for it.
Just the other day I was called scum, nazi and terf by the same person in one conversation.
But one that sticks out: TRA told me he hoped I'd kill myself because that's the "only treatment for transphobia." I said I used to be trans, so he called me a traitor and blocked me lmao
"Some opponents of the new draft law ... believe trans women pose a threat in spaces that are for women."
This is not true. Trans women are not the problem. It's male predators who would exploit the reforms. The proposed reforms are vague and poorly defined - at best.
I think they genuinely fear detrans stories being used by anti-trans groups in order to take away trans care.
The problem starts when they assume all detrans people must be anti-trans, and so lash out at us.
Anti-trans groups taking advantage of detrans stories doesn't justify trying to silence or blame detransitioners for their mistreatment at the hands of their clinics.
If anyone tried to use me as proof that transition (for adults) should be banned, I'd tell them to fuck off.
Honestly, the amount of times I've read a thread about detransition - with no mention of trans people - only to have some random Twitter tit turn up to accuse the poster of being "anti-trans" is staggering.
I've spoken to dozens of detransitioners over the last few months. Hundreds have contacted the detrans advocacy network, at least 35 clinicians walked out of the Tavistock over poor treatment they saw there.
This isn't about being "anti-trans," there is real harm being done.
Detrans: *talks about personal experience*
TRA: youre wrong that doesn't happen
Detrans: it literally happened to me
TRA: wow 1 time
Detrans: there's other detrans talking about it too
TRA: omg why you hate trans people?
Detrans: I didn't mention trans people
TRA: ok terf
I saw talk like that on blogs back in 2014/2015. "Non-binary" girls pretending to be trans to get testosterone from clinics. They intended to inject only long enough to appear 'gender confusing.'
I hope their Drs told them T doesn't work like that before prescribing it to them.
@[private account] I don't know how many times I've been told by TRAs that I'm hateful and bigoted because I'd never date a pre-op trans woman. I don't give a damn how well they pass, if they have male genetalia I'm not interested.
That's all anyone can do at this stage. I know so many amazing, intelligent and compassionate trans people and every single one of them are done with the "trans community." So we just get drunk and talk about our ongoing existential crisis lol
I was called truscum when I was trans because I opposed the affirmation and transition of children. The pro-trans activists are "pro-trans" so long as you're not the wrong-think kind. Be a good little tran and agree with everything they say.
Trans people deserve better. There is genuine transphobia out there, and it should be dealt with severely. But the word has become so diluted it garners eye-rolls more than concern. The activists who use use it to smear anyone and everyone should be ashamed.
I get called a lot of really nasty shite on here. But I think this one takes the cake.
Tonight, I was accused of hating trans people so much, I'm literally working to get them raped. Yes, really. https://x.com/rozietoez/status/1245506243638071296
You accused me of attacking trans people when I've done nothing of the sort. Nothing I've said even remotely resembles me "attacking" trans people. So forgive me for assuming you're sheltered, because you speak like you are.
I was a trans man for 5 years and many of my dearest confidants from that time, who happen to be trans, still have my back. If I want to tweet about TDOV, I will.
For me, a lack of lesbian role models was never an issue. But I have seen some younger detrans women citing that as one factor among many.
The issue is gender nonconformity is now linked to being trans. Even the NHS cites boys liking girls toys as a "sign" of dysphoria.
There's so many potential reasons. The ones I see popping up most often in detrans conversation are 1. Social contagion - getting swept up by online trans trends. 2. Dysphoria as a result of trauma, homophobia and eating/general body image issues.
Strange. I attended an LGB Alliance event once. I met many wonderful gay, lesbian, bi and trans people there. We all had a lovely time. Where's this "divide" you speak of, Owen?
Trans people are people, Amnesty, they have human rights. What they don't have, and what nobody is entitled to, is the "right" to deny biological facts. In my experience, most trans people don't. But those aren't the ones you're pandering to, are they?
I agree, compulsory speech/pronouns should never be tolerated. I'm happy to show courtesy to trans people with regards to their preferred pronouns, but that's my choice. No law should dictate what words we use.
Happy #TransDayOfVisibility everyone!
Remember,
Trans women are trans women, and there's nothing wrong with that.
Trans men are trans men, and there's nothing wrong with that.
We can all love and support one another without denying biological reality.
Have a good day!
I'm not a fan of Raymond. The only work of hers I've read was the transexual empire, which I found disgusting. Regardless, I don't recall her discussing "cis" lesbians seeing trans women as fellow lesbians in it.
If any trans or detrans folk wish to share their thoughts, but would rather not do so on your own feed, please DM me and I will share your story anonymously on my own.
I will not share anything without your permission. I'm here if you need someone to vent to. 8/8
"I enjoyed the fantasy of being male, then I needed to make that fantasy a reality. Within 2 years I went from being a lesbian to being a gay trans boy who needed to transition or die. I started T When I was 22 and got top surgery at 23..." 5/8
"I didn't initially want facial hair or top surgery or anything like that, I wanted to be a "pretty boy." By 2014 I was convinced I was trans and suddenly, T and surgery seemed necessary. Like, viewing online trans stuff gave me dysphoria..." 4/8
"I can't remember exactly how but one vid led to another and I found myself watching stuff by trans guys talking about coming out. I started Googling trans guys and when I saw their before and after pics I was immediately enthralled..." 3/8
I talk to trans and detrans folk who don't like sharing particular thoughts on their feeds.
Which is a shame, as a lot of what they have to say warrants some serious consideration. With the permission of one young detrans woman, I share with you now some of her experiences:
1/8
If I may elbow my way in here, when I was trans I phrased it, "socially and legally I'm a man, though biologically I'll always be female."
When you're socially perceived as the opposite sex for years, you "live as" that sex. Passing trans men are treated as men, seen as men etc.
I'm not agaisnt trans adults transitioning. Children are another matter entirely because they are immature, incredibly suggestable and still developing both mentally and physically.
A 5 year old cannot even begin to comprehend a complex concept like their gender identity.
The limited (but growing) support available to those who regret transitioning is almost solely focused on women. This is largely due to GC feminists supporting us, sharing our voices and spearheading the pushback agaisnt trans ideology lunacy. 2/8
Never seen those numbers before.
This study, of 767 people found a 2.2% regret rate. No
This was before the huge surge in young people self-id'ing as trans. Detransitioners (myself included) tend not to report our regret and aren't counted in results.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/262734734_An_Analysis_of_All_Applications_for_Sex_Reassignment_Surgery_in_Sweden_1960-2010_Prevalence_Incidence_and_Regrets
"Then one day my five-year-old asked me if she could be a girl. Contrary to what some might think, my first thoughts weren't 'Oh, my child is trans'. I just thought that my kid, wanted to try being a girl for a while."
You were right the first time, chief.
The desire to go back on T was something I initially thought was unique to me, because I never really saw it discussed. Now, a lot of d trans women have told me they have the desire, too. It's comforting in a very sad kind of way.
We do need more research.
And sure, maybe many good HCPs do know. But I have to say, anecdotally, the sheer number of people I've spoken to - both trans and detrans, who were fast tracked through transition as if it was nothing, concerns me on a staggering scale.
I'd like to see trans activists and allies, who care about dysphoric youth, bringing attention to this issue.
There should NOT be detrans people, who regret transitioning, turning to HRT because their untreated dysphoria is consuming them. 5/5
Dysphoria is a mental illness and requires treatment.
Transition may help some people but it evidently doesn't help them all.
Lack of alternative treatment creates more detrans folk, lack of help creates more retrans folk, lengthening clinic wait lists, harming trans folk. 4/5
I don't attack trans healthcare, I criticize immediate affirmation and fast-tracking - both of which I and many other detransitioners were subject to at our clinics.
I know transition helps some dysphoric people. I also know it harms others. That's why I urge caution.
I'm glad that you're doing better and that transition helped you.
I never said it wasn't true for other trans people. I know people like you whose suicidal ideation ended after transition.
I was suicidal pre-transition. And for years after, I felt better. Until I didn't.
Most trans folk I know are just getting on with their lives, they don't give a shit about politics. They're just as pissed off with obnoxious TRAs as anyone else.
A TRA once told me that detransitioners don't exist, only trans people with internalised transphobia who've been bullied into feeling regret. Even when they're staring reality in the face, many of them scoff.
The influence that online trans communities have on young people can't be overstated.
I can't say how many times I saw kids being told they were trans simply for expressing typical teen angst.
How many wouldn't have transitioned if they hadn't found such sites?
I'd bet most.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @MetroUK @[private account] Trans women are trans women. Women are women. They're not the same.
@[private account] @[private account] @MetroUK @[private account] @ForwomenScot Uneffected? It's already happening self-IDing pre-HRT, pre-surgery male prisoners have been put in women’s prison. The proposed reforms will only make things worse for women. See https://www.lawsociety.ie/gazette/top-stories/male-bodied-transgender-inmate-housed-with-women-prisoners/
@[private account] @[private account] @MetroUK @[private account] If these reforms go through, one only needs to self-ID as the opposite sex for 6 months to get a GRC - no diagnosis of GD, no checks. These people with then have access to opposite sex spaces.
Trans people are not the issue. Those who'd abuse such easy access are.
Trans people say "identity politics has gone too far," and non-trans people say "that's transphobic!"
They don't even listen to the people they purport to support.
When I was trans, I argued with RadFems. Now I'm detrans, I'm welcomed with open arms. Most are genuinely lovely and empathetic, but some are just hateful.
Fair enough. Greer is labelled as radical, if memory serves me well, because she believes women are oppressed due to sex. Many trans women support her. But online, radfem seems to be interchangeable with Gender critical.
I use preferred pronouns out of courtesy, but admittedly if the trans individual doesn't pass I can slip up. It's never intentional, though.
For predators like Jessica Yaniv and Karen White, however, I don't bother with courtesy.