The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
The two most annoying groups of people to argue with online are radical feminists and trans rights activists - for the same reason: the constantly hysterical and dishonest tone.
A take like "I do not think the government should regulate 'face-riding' or fake choking during sex" or "We probably should not give puberty blocking drugs to kids" quite literally draws responses like: "Why do you want to MURDER WOMEN, pervert?!!"
Trans people "are" 3% of young people - which means hundreds of thousands of basically mutilated kids. Check our r/detrans sometime. Gas cost more under Biden.
Many issue are like this - either non-partisan or edge areas for the right: crime, mass illegal migration, phonics education, family stability/child support enforcement, welfare reduction, gun rights, election security, affirmative action in the middle class, etc.
There are actually some reasons, but it is worth occasionally noting that the trans movement is 2/3 female.
Moving further left, here are virtually 0 "non-binary" men.
Quotes a post by T15543; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Let white nationalism become for the right what trans is for the left."
Thoughts?
Quoting @RichardHanania: Asian and Hispanic turnout is surging in Texas.
The best case scenario for the election is non-whites punishing Republicans for the last few years.
Let white nationalism become for the right what trans is for the left. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/why-non-white-voters-must-crush-republicans
Kirk was murdered by a bisexual, trans-dating furry radical - who snuck INTO ~our event and shot him. #seems_relevant
So many of these takes are a la: "MLK was murdered by a fellow Southern ladies' man."
Ok, but...
Quotes a post by T04470; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
One in the Nazi column, one in the trans column.
*Shakes head in guilty relief, as now-Southern Black guy.
You know what all these shooters really have in common, and what matters most? They're fucking nuts.
Quotes a post by T07670; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is getting annoying, man. I literally make fun of all three groups in the same sentence: H1Bs are "indentured servants," half or more of the Black guys are "DEI," etc. Welfare is not mentioned at all: all of these people have five-to-six figures tech jobs, by definition.
More seriously: the argument "White advocates might get ANGRY, and hurt Indian-Americans and legal immigrants (?), if Indians perform well and advocate for their own interests (i.e. your other post)" is just a TOTAL non-starter. This argument never boils down to anything more than: "Trans kids will KILL themselves!!!"
Most Americans and legals, regardless of race, are not cowards. It is simply bizarre not to expect Indian Americans to oppose a fairly openly racist politician - think Mr. French on to the right - because people might then......feel or say racist things toward them?
I fail to follow the logic there: allowing as much racist ranting as possible without slap-back seems unlikely to avoid that outcome.
Basically just correct.
All of critical theory breaks down to describing the normal as evil and thus - generally - the evil or at least abnormal (a sexless marriage a man is "morally" expected to never leave, Hamas, trans surgeries for kids) as correct.
Their wordplay is shocking, until you realize it's just meaningless: "being used as a toilet" means swallowing before he gives a massage, "tearing apart a sapient near-equal" means eating BBQ pork, "barbarous torture-murder of children" means shooting a 17 year old Hamas warrior in the stomach in self defense...
Etc. There is just nothing here for civilization. You WANT your husband to look at you like he wants to fuck you, and you are not an "object" because he does.
Quotes a post by T02418; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Depends on the type, but they all are one or the other - maaaybe absent Mosaic Syndrome or almost-mythical actual "hermaphroditism."
More importantly, this whole faculty-lounge-level conversation is almost totally irrelevant to the actual trans debate. Lia Thomas does not have "Mosaic Syndrome." He is a six-foot-plus, XY biological man who pretty clearly had a penis and balls.
Quotes a post by T04245; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No. This is important.
First, basically no (modern, rad) feminist talking points are true. Shoot me any that come to mind (DM preferred). I and the page will respond in genuine good faith. But, more seriously and specifically: "oppression" is organized institutional down-holding of Group X by Group Y.
The fact that Black criminals regularly prey on other groups in city downtowns, say, is not thought to be institutional oppression of Irishmen or whatever by Blacks. That argument is NEVER made, because it is so inherently absurd - and the same applies to the fact that most criminals are male.
And, in fact, men are targeted for outdoor brawls, robberies, and all other non-sexual crimes at ~7x the rate that women are targeted: most fighting men won't even hit a woman. Are men "oppressing" other men, or young poor women oppressing old rich men?
A HARD-core feminist might try to tie some of this together, arguing that all men back rapists and such because female terror benefits us. But...again....nah. Men favor far stiffer sentences for male criminals, less 3rd world male migration, less mandatory trans acceptance in nude spaces, etc than women do. 85% or so of the street cops who gleefully lock up perverts are men.
Maybe a lot of critical theory is just stupid horse-shit?
What the Hell are you talking about, man? I'm not going to argue all night, but - after maybe 20 posts of this kind - it's worth a response.
First, as re "institutionalized anti-whiteness:" AA is a program that discriminates against groups in reverse proportion to their degree of success. It does not exclusively impact whites. Groups that are on average more successful than whites, like Asians and E. Indians, face MORE discrimination in virtually every hiring and admissions process I am familiar with - not less (ie., the graphics below). Blacks do get an edge over whites, but Natives get an edge over US and Caucasian Hispanics have one vs everyone who scores above them.
I'm also not acting like Indians deserve MORE than whites. Again...what? The question is whether we should get rid of all these identity groups, or alternatively add one more big one for Caucasians. Your suggestion is not even an option that I proposed. It is ALSO not true that 2nd-generation Asian Americans are "foreigners," as a btw.
Finally, and importantly: it is absurd to argue that the people advocating FOR Indian/Asian (or Jewish) countrymen are "putting a target on their^ backs," because this might piss off a white guy online who disagrees. First, most Americans of all colors can take care of themselves. But, more importantly, this is just the trans terrorist argument: "Don't discuss mostly true things in a heated time, because this might make a looney hurt himself or someone else!"
That's...just not how anything works, and we can't host the same nonsense ideas on the right. RW groups, like former soldiers and hard-working, laid-off software men, are a looot more sympathetic than "the opps." But, we cannot simply smile and nod when someone says that South Asian men (!!!) benefit from DEI, and be taken seriously.
The last thing we need is our own election-torpedoing NPCs, huge on twitter and barely present at the polls.
IIRC, my first "hero and/or villain of the Internet" moment came when I said that fully intact male rapists who have ID'd as trans for <2 years should not go to women's prison.
Hotly contested, as it turns out.
It would be ~accurate to say that the social role of the liberal/leftist is to advance and promote new genetic or memetic mutations - while the social role of the conservative is to smash these down (if un-productive).
This creates a unique reality: The right wing is in fact almost always right about new behaviors (think trans, disco, rioting, No Nuke, drugs, BLM, Defund the Police, 4th Wave)...but the left almost always gets the credit for improving society.
Quoting @ArtemisConsort: Genetic mutations are bad on average. Our genomes are much closer to optimal than a random genome, so most changes are bad. Evolution only works because nature relentlessly culls the bad mutations. The same is true in the realm of ideas: most new ideas are worse than old ones.
I'm only going to jump in once, but the two pics below are:
(1) The 2016 1-2-3 winners in the women's 800 meters at the Rio Olympics...all inter-sex or technically trans. This is the "Queen Race," the biggest in many/most women's meets.
(2) The WOMEN'S NATIONAL SWIMMING CHAMPION a few years back.
Come on. Everyone in this thread is a very pro-sex, not unnnnn-feminist person from a big city. But, all of that leads into WHY I know men are not women. This shit is absurd.
"That was at most 5-10% of truly high profile competition in those years! Likely less!"
That's a lot. And, every female competitor vs these people had to see what - in at least 1-2 cases - were large-ish intact dicks in the locker room. Wot?
I've thought this before, but a great deal of feminism and almost all trans-masc stuff is an attempt to mimic the WORST male traits, but sadly in a way that doesn't really work for women.
"I got raw-dogged from behind by four dominant guys this week: I have such a ROSTER!" sounds...a little different to the boys.
Quotes a post by T04138; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
With this and so much else, you just have to ask the questions correctly.
Not "Should trans girls play on the team that fits their presumed chromosomal order or their internal spirit (?)," but "Should 18 year old men dress and compete with girls?"
Quoting @nypost: Vast majority of Americans don't want trans athletes on sports teams that don't match their birth sex https://trib.al/Vd57DQz
Thanks!
Ours is quite different and better designed (IMHO), but this is to some extent a needed counter to things like this: corporations being ranked by how trans-friendly they are and so forth...https://www.hrc.org/resources/corporate-equality-index.
Re some things I'm seeing on the right: Caitlin Clark is no more "cowardly" than any other athlete. First, no one in that type of elite situation is going to say some bullshit a la: "I'm being bullied, and it might be targeted at my race or good looks! Help me!!!"
Can you even imagine Larry Bird, Jackie Robinson, or Tiger Woods going that route? The idea that a female "killer" should is...actually sexist.
Re the trans thing: how many big guys - NFL players with D1 sisters - have you heard speak up?
Do you think the reason that men are 40-60% more massive (at least in muscular terms), have 1500% as much testosterone...have cocks...etc etc is that "patriarchy" causes these things to happen?
If so, why do we see pretty much these same gaps across ~all human societies - which display wildly different levels of male dominance?
Much of later-wave feminism - and almost all of trans rights activism - consists almost literally of arguing that the sky is green and grass is red.
Not my arena/role, but this was a piece someone...really needed to write.
Are gay couples, especially gay male ones, exactly like straight couples re behavior and ethics? Was PRIDE begun by Black trans women? Do lesbians have a moral duty to suck cock?
OP's themes don't track exxxactly with my lead-ins, but you get the point.
Quotes a post by T01474; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I am not into "trans women" because they are male and I am straight.
Quoting @JillFilipovic: I do think if your immediate reaction is "I would never date [x] kind of person," it's worth taking a few seconds to consider why, and assess whether your reaction is a knee-jerk one or if it's genuinely about attraction / values / etc. How much of the reaction is you? How much of it is a bunch of messages you've internalized that may not actually be genuinely felt if you consider them? I do think a lot of people say "I would never date a trans person" without really thinking about it, or under which conditions you actually might.
But it's also fine to not be attracted to certain categories of people. I'm not particularly into women (sorry, wish I was). For many people, a particular set of genitals are a dealbreaker. For many others, dealbreakers may include intelligence, religion, politics, and so on. Many people demonstrate clear preference patterns when it comes to things like body type ("boob guys" never dated me, and that was fine!). Some people fetishize particular categories of people (including trans women), and *that* should be considered and unpacked. But someone is not "bigoted" and in need of moral and sexual reeducation because they have strong preferences when it comes to the alignment of genitals, reproductive systems, gender identity, and gender presentation. They should give it some thought for sure, because thinking things through is good -- "why *would* I date a cis woman but not a trans woman?" -- but there are actually a number of totally justifiable answers, just as it is totally justifiable for lesbians to exclusively date women and gay men to exclusively date men.
I said "at need," random hysterical.
But...notice your verbal slip here^. Funny male punks and grad students and similar ~normal leftys aren't dating a ton of "trans women," now are ya?
Why is the Planned Parenthood logo up on the other side of the screen?
As always: what do leftists MEAN by "healthcare for women?" You guys oppose even most rape crisis centers because they don't allow trans males and older teen boys - are we juuuust talmbout late term abortion again?
Quotes a post by T03826; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The problem with the "Mike" argument re sport - "Well, Phelps and Jordan have a BIGGER advantage than the average trans athlete" - is that we segregate athletic competition by size and sex and age...not by skill.
Obviously, we WANT to see who the best (young + male + American) athlete is. That's...the whole point.
Obviously, the weekly space from Unified Solutions America (http://www.unifiedsolutionsamerica.com) will be back on, tomorrow, at 6pm EST!!!
We'll be live across X and Facebook, have figured out how to enable real-time comments/audience talk, and will be discussing triggered trans college men, Mamdani's recent rape/SA comments, whether gentle parenting is hurting merit (yes), whether masculinity is toxic or good, and whether things like "masculinity" can even be quantified.
But, first: check out LAST week, where we and top lawyer @[private account] discuss whether Candace Owens killed Charlie Kirk. #lb
Quoting @wil_da_beast630: "Robinson, Candace Craziness, and Trust in Experts!!!" https://x.com/i/broadcasts/1RJZzzZYDzoJB
I think the Aristotealian or early Christian perspective - certainly Nagarjuna's, in Buddhism - would be that you DO earn that, by being smart and tough enough to function without controls...and then not bothering anyone else.
If you seem bizarre or very weak, and then DO bother people - trans woman in the women's loo - these rights are rapidly revoked.
"Therapist Pat Lockwood Live on "Cut the Bull!!!"
The re-upload series continues. Does therapy work? When? For men too?! When might...sexing your spouse and training in the gym work BETTER? Are trans kids real?
Notably honest convo with an OG in this field - and he wins some major points! Video here: https://youtu.be/cpXdgDJEEYQ?si=-vlKFDbVRN4JLKSG via @YouTube
Yes.
Trans people are people with a very well known, widely studied, mental...condition. They should be treated as normally as possible, but not allowed in the women's loo.
Quotes a post by A0616; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Same thing with sex work being great but hooking your beloved husband up with a bj being "coercive abuse," late-term abortion being great but eating meat being murder, trans surgery at 16 being great but dating that varsity guy at 17 being "rape," etc.
What makes something good is it harming normalcy.
Quotes a post by T03227; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Did they adjust for sexual orientation?
Also - since both male and female brains (think Ann Rice to Margaret Thatcher) cover the full human spectrum, there is no such thing as "brain sex." All this means is that gay and trans males - along with Prince and a bunch of other guys who kill with women - are in the most feminine 12-15% of men.
Any brain in a 6'1" XY body with a cock is, by definition, a man's brain.
Quoting @FondOfBeetles: I’ve requested the subject-level Brain Sex Index data behind Kurth et al., 2022. Brain sex in transgender women is shifted towards gender identity. JCM.
While I wait, some open questions on the published methods and conclusions.
One of the problems with "state" services is that no one above the stable working class is willing to use them.
"What we got here is a creche of 53 strange kids, whose parents are hood ni*gas and recent immigrants from Chechnya. It is supervised by an elderly trans woman called Big Gretch. You pay $400 per year toward this.
Wanna leave little Jimmy here?!"
Quotes a post by T02952; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans men pass better than trans women, until you ask: "Why is bro 5'1" tall, with child-bearing hips?"
Quoting @PrishaMosley: Ellen Paige wrote a book about her own sexual abuse (Pageboy) and everyone around still cheers as she destroys herself. She is small even for a woman, and now damaged irreversibly. What good comes from cheering on the mutilation of victims?
This is unironically the pitch for "trans-maxxing" in nerd hive/IT spaces.
"Would you rather be guy #8 in the flower-line meme...or the lady at the end?!"
Quotes a post by T00306; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Fair.
Will say: an entertaining part of debating/bantering with feminists is the very high No True Scotswoman level.
If no one who supports Palestine or trans activism is a "real" feminist, that's...maybe 80% of feminists.
This whole thing, if you've talked to an older buddy who happens to be either gay or into history, is one of the craziest-ever inventions of a hero.
Simply put, a very male, gay-identified drag queen who was on that white girl and not at the riot became "The Trans Woman Who Threw The 1st Brick at Stonewall." He was later found OD'd (likely) in a river.
@[private account] - takes?
Quoting @PopBase: LGBTQ+ activist and icon Marsha P. Johnson died 34 years ago today.
Her body was discovered floating in the Hudson River, with her exact cause of death remaining unsolved.
Against a tide of "girl-bossing," one important thing the trans sports debate does remind us of is that men are On Average far far better athletes and warriors (and thus explorers, etc) than women are.
With apologies to Supergirl, this has real implications for things like military integration. The average female Olympian is as good as my slightly faster buddies in high school.
Eh.
I like women's sports (did buy the Cunningham).
I don't think they are at the same level as men's sports.
This is WHY men should not play in women's sports. Trans women are men.
None of this is hard.
As I pointed out long ago (https://www.nationalreview.com/2023/11/there-is-no-trans-genocide/) - there's some good data work from Noah Carl here as well (https://unherd.com/newsroom/there-is-no-epidemic-of-trans-violence/) - there is not and has never been any "trans genocide" in the USA.
"Trans women" are about 1/35th as likely to be murdered as Black men, and far less likely than lower-income whites, members of many immigrant groups, and just guys overall.
This meme paper is hilarious - a 30 page critique of Internet shite-talking that totally refuses to show it.
"Yeah, we've got the trans kids, but you guys are still living in *(well-built earthen dwellings)*!"
Quotes a post by T04571; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
First, I think - for good statistical reason - that maaaaybe 2% of women overall ACTUALLY have the hysterical take on sex we see from ex-trans rad-fems on X. Commercial lube costs $3.99 per bottle, and guys happily go down now.
But, beyond that...maybe Predatory Woman X should not in your scenario have MARRIED "the wrong man," to triple her income, get a dad for her kids, get 400% more protection, lock down that young pension, access OUR sexuality and monogamy (?!) etc :). It is impossible to feel sympathy for her then being asked to fulfill normal relationship roles - and I notice that a guy confidently asking/telling her that generally ends this problem.
There is actual research on this. Having "B-average" sex with your man - or going down on a fragrant girlfriend, or even being cheated on once - has maybe 2% of the negative effects of actual stranger rape. The claim of much more than that is goofy and sorta offensive, if you think about it.
Overall: you shouldn't abuse people, and I recommend guys go to the gym, trading floor early, dojo, range, and indeed your courses to get more attractive.
But, the response to quite simple test questions before any of that happens - "Would you rather I get a mistress/watch hard-core porn/start a trial separation than sleep with you?" indicates that ~0 women think mid sex is even close to rape. And, I doubt adult "fighting men" will near-future allow rape to be re-designed again.
A celibate permanent room-mate, or even parasite, is not an option - and couples do in reality have to work forward from that.
Alt-righters generally write the best and clearest death threats.
The worst are from - in no particular order..
Antifa blue-hairs
Campus feminists
South Asian guys
Hood Black dudes
Trans rights activists (often include rape threat or offer to sub for you).
Quotes a post by T09040; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
AS A MINOR, one in every 250 Oregon girls is not only "diagnosed" as trans - that's 1/98 - but is being "medically treated."
Quoting @benryanwriter: Over 1 in 250 Natal Girls Were Taking Testosterone By Age 17 in Oregon, From 2016 to 2023
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/over-1-in-250-natal-girls-were-taking
This rate, from a study of data about insured adolescents in Oregon, represents an average over this period. Given swift increases in hormone uptake over time, the rate was likely much higher by 2023.
The use of gender-transition drugs among adolescents in Oregon soared between 2016 and 2023, charting a nearly 10-fold increase among biological girls and a 14-fold increase in natal boys. Across this period, about 1 in 100 insured youth ages 8 to 17 in the Pacific Northwest state were diagnosed with gender dysphoria, a psychiatric condition involving distress stemming from a conflict between an individual’s natal sex and their gender identity.
By age 17, about 1 in 240 insured natal girls were taking testosterone and about 1 in 630 natal boys were taking estrogen in Oregon. These figures are nearly three-fold higher for natal girls and nearly twice as high for natal boys as figures from a study published last year that analyzed national data on commercially insured youth from 2018 to 2022.
I'm looking through old "Cut the Bull" (@[private account]) episodes, and we really have had a remarkable lineup of guests on over the years.
For those interested in the "trans v TERF" debate - in 'honor' of PRIDE month, this is @BuckAngel on what trans-sexuality is, whether gender is real, and the adult industry. Feminist writer Lisa Selin Davis spars with us and Buck on several points!
Takes? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtvFpjIL3tM
Gotta say: this running on a major center-right page and pulling 78% "Yes" is sort of answers "Why do these dumb broads keep ignoring the GOP - to vote for trans stuff and mass migration?"
For the next Unified Solutions America space, we're talking with @[private account] and several other friends about where the trans and "TERF" movements are RIGHT NOW TODAY, whether DEI policies cover gay and trans-ID'd folX, and her own experience with "pre-surgery XY female genitals" - i.e., penises - in the club locker room. @[private account] will likely also wrap up our last "matriarchy/patriarchy" space.
On the hard business front, we'll also discuss what merit actually is, in the context of @[private account], @wokal_distance, myself, @SwipeWright, and @CBHeresy currently trying to quantify it into an Index. Does race EVER count?
Stop by Thursday 06/04/26 at 6pm!!!
https://x.com/i/spaces/1qKVmmnbVgVxB
Quoting @BillMelugin_: BREAKING: In a 2-1 ruling, a federal appeals court finds the Trump administration policy to ban transgender individuals from serving in the US military is unconstitutional.
From Judge Roger Wilkins who wrote the majority opinion:
"The Hegseth policy is both arbitrary and based upon animus, and for those reasons the Policy violates Plaintiff-Appellees' constitutional right to equal protection of the law."
I mean, it is obviously bad to kill a trans-ID'd person for...being alive- especially in a situation where the brutal crime and their struggle likely saved the life OF a woman ("I came to kill one").
Does anyone really disagree?
Being xx-feminine, softer, mothering, and sometimes submissive is not "a tool created by men."
What these nut jobs hate, as with "trans women," is their own biology and nature.
Quotes a post by T06924; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"My religion is the white race."
Trans Mexican Nazis vs Muslims, eh?
Well, today, these people from Grand Theft Auto will see how their moral positions are received in HELL!!!
This is the basic problem with the trans movement.
I see a goofy and likely perverse dude in a dress, am fiscally stable enough to help "my sisters" out and say that - and no one will ever see anything else.
Correct.
Many people, perhaps including some of you, mutilated children for no reason.
This, in fact, is why total close-out on the trans era will be so hard.
Quoting @nationalpost: A new Finnish study suggests that “gender affirming care” doesn’t actually improve the mental health of trans-identifying youth, and may, in fact, significantly worsen it, writes Adam Zivo
https://nationalpost.com/opinion/adam-zivo-so-much-for-life-saving-gender-affirming-care?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=NP_social&utm_content=comment
Denial of the impolitic obvious is an EXTRAORDINARY time waster among, very specifically, middle-middle class adults.
Why don't girls want to change with "trans women?"
*Because they are men
Why do people ~invariably dump sexless partners?
*Because they are just very expensive friends
Why do young men, especially Black and ethnic, get stereotyped as criminals?
*Because they commit most of the CRIMES
On and on. Just say the true thing.
Charles: "conversion therapy" for TRANS kids is telling them what sex they actually are.
The only alternative is affirmation of whatever a confused eight year old says.
Quotes a post by T02083; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Conversion therapy" for "trans kids" - the focus here - quite literally just means telling people they are the sex they are.
Quoting @AP: BREAKING: The Supreme Court ruled against a law banning “conversion therapy” for LGBTQ+ kids in Colorado, one of about two dozen states that banned the discredited practice. https://apnews.com/article/supreme-court-conversion-therapy-colorado-92b34295f9ef497a4a1cbeb56c9b74c6?utm_campaign=trueAnthem%3A+New+Content+%28Feed%29&utm_medium=trueAnthem&utm_source=twitter
As re this whole question of whether the white-led "Trans-Atlantic" portion of the global slave trade was (1) truly unique and (2) the worst thing in history....
My own recent book, linked below, answers it in Chapter 1 ("No"), discussing the Romans, Aztecs, Arabs, Vikings, and more. You should...BUY it, and check out the debate! https://www.amazon.com/Lies-My-Liberal-Teacher-Told/dp/0063265974/ref=sr_1_1?crid=4N9X9XDQGDD6&keywords=lies+my+liberal+teacher+told+me&qid=1703200620&sprefix=lies+my+libe%2Caps%2C126&sr=8-1
Good critiques.
~All obv. addressed in any actual survey do, but I like it that the page has NO MERCY for bad methods!!!
That said, you get four lines on X, and this'll be about 80% accurate. If it goes hyper-viral, I'll add a Survey Monkey link - as I/we famously did for the finding that 98% of people don't see "trans women" as women.
The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade isn't even the worst slave trade.
It was Very Bad, but I'd rank slave trades in this order:
1.) Arab Slave Trade (in blacks and whites)
2.) Roman Slave Trade
3.) Aztec/Tlaxcalan "120 year trade in humans as meat"
4.) Trans-Atlantic Trade
5.) Muslim trade in defeated Hindu Indians
6.) Barbary Slave Trade
Should I keep going?
Quotes a post by T05312; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
With a shout to @[private account] for posting: probably the best evidence for the claim that the de-transition/trans regret rate among young adults is not "1%" is the fact that the established five-year desistance rate for "trans teenagers" is 70-80%.
Almost by definition, something must be wrong with the first-cited, newer set of studies. No?
"You betcha they do, and I'll be here as long as any of Trump's Gestapo are causin' fear to a heckin' trans toddler or an undocumented immigrant dealing with HIV while also facing the burden of a rape charge in this racist system - buckaroo!"
Hard right honestly baffled about how to feel.
"That's right, Aztec boy! Our slightly higher tested IQ strongly predicts support for modern ideas...like trans rights, gay divorce, and Smashing The Patriarchy!"
I mean, this is "ha ha" level funny, and a good race-banter line, until you look at fertility rates or levels of trans, etc. identification by nation and ethnicity.
Quotes a post by T08709; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The "trans issue" is very very very very astonishingly easy to resolve.
Trans women are men. Any guy to disagree must date one.
Quoting @salltweets: In a very, very strong field, this is one of the stupidest things ever said in response to gender ideology.
“It’s irresolvable” - @[private account]
They’re men. They compete in men’s sports & use men’s spaces. Men accommodate them.
There, solved it.
By the way, 2x is a LOT! One of my core themes is that we need to honestly deal with on Black crime in the hood, just as "you guys" took on opiate drug use, trans insanity, etc.
But, the online multiplier games - like focusing on the Black/POC percentage only of non-self-defense homicides only in the year George Floyd died while calling that category "crime" - are pretty silly.
At some level, it should be just objectively obvious that there isn't 1,200-4,800% as much Black as poor white crime, that 96% or whatever the figure would be in that first scenario of attackers of Caucasians are not Blacks (it's actually ~15%: BJS-NCVS 2023), etc.
So, I mean, there's that.
All trans data is like this.
It's really awkward, and has affected a few of my friendships.
The whole "these perverted anti-feminist MEN" take doesn't really make a ton of sense - about 60% of young trans-ID'd people are women and, in at least the USA, women support gender ideology 2x as much as guys.
Quotes a post by T04437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I mean, lesbians love to party...and the cooler half of all women are bi. A top-two reason there are so few lesbian bars is that horny "trans women" and even straight men kept invading them - keeping them open becomes annoying and mildly dangerous.
I used to co-promote with The Fish Bowl in Chicago. It was a constant, obnoxious problem.
Quotes a post by T08806; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Well, to be fair, all they do is lie about literally everything - Black police murder epidemics, rampant inter-race crime (right can do this too...but with more data), trans "genocide," Gaza "genocide," univariate white privilege, hidden mass graves at every rural boarding school in Canada....it's just totally shameless.
Trump, for good and ill, fights back in kind - so the national bullshit volume is at 11 right now.
Quotes a post by T04926; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
See, this is what I am talking about.
It is just nonsensical - meaningless in any empirical or measurable sense - to say that Bill Clinton or Hunter Biden is clearly "superior to Trump in terms of ethics and morality." This is not a sentence that makes logical sense. Against what metric - treatment of women?
More importantly, it does not make sense to say that Big Orange's "moral crimes" - meme-poasting, immigration enforcement, even private legal troubles - are so grave that one is forced to back the other party and instead support gender ideology and 'trans kids,' 2,000,000 illegal aliens per year, abortion until birth, formalized anti-white/Asian discrimination in hiring and collegiate admissions, and the localized ~legalization of crime.
Many people, probably most, think the things and people I just listed are significantly "morally" worse than the things and people YOU dislike, James. You can disagree with that. But you cannot simply say: "No they are not! Neener neener! Since Ted Kennedy, we have been a party of GREAT AND GOOD MEN!!!"
Ummm...
Quoting @JamesSurowiecki: All of them are superior to Trump in terms of ethics and morality, since Trump has no ethics and doesn't care about morality. Those words are meaningless to him.
This is what we smart right-leaning people call "a joke."
The guy QT'd is...not actually saying these are verbatim federal laws.
That said, there is a lot of truth to the point: look up "speech is violence" or "trans genocide" to clarify what he's talking about.
There IS a very prevalent idea in modern up-middle-class America, especially among married women and sooome of their spouses, that to be "good" or "pro-social" basically means to be female - polite no matter how absurd someone's ideas are, almost excessively empathic, totally non-physical with discipline and play, etc etc.
A "good" thing for a large male to do, per Reddit and at least five books I'm currently reviewing in my agony aunt columnist role, would be "helping with all domestic chores and providing as much care for young infants as possible." A "bad" thing, per the majority of these authors, would be owning guns for home defense or spanking a son and successfully stopping his misbehavior.
I love women, but frankly find this attitude absurd. There just obviously are "male-coded" virtues - bravery, trained strength, innovation/invention and exploration, martial skill, brutal honesty, leadership, controlled ruthless aggression - that helped get me this smart phone I'm typing on in this large free country I live in. These are at least as "pro-social," in any real sense, as "being kind to trans women."
Wot?
The 1st one - structural, anthropological/intellectual, even radical - feminism can get a bit whiny and absurd in the modern context and...uncomfortable when it examines the past. But, makes sense for women.
I'd also shout to the alternative of "femininity,' from Iriquois scouts (as vs front liners) to Evie Magazine....which notes that men and women like building and talking and sexing in different ways and this is GOOD.
Anyhow, lib-fem/trans/4th Wave/Hugh Hefner feminism has always struck me as crazy - not least because 30+% of the writers have been men for quite a while.
We've made this point before on the page.
There almost certainly ARE quite a few people - perhaps a sizable chunk of those who currently claim these diagnoses - who have fully real ADD, OCD, PTSD, GD and body dysmorphia, etc. And, there are actual scans of the brain that could diagnose most if not all of these pretty reliably.
But, trans and disability advocates ~universally oppose (please point out any major outliers I'm missing) real research into this tech.
Now, why might that be the case?
Quotes a post by A2445; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Quoting @stclairashley: I feel immense guilt for my role. And even more guilt that things I have said in the past may have caused my son’s sister more pain. Idrk how to make amends for many of these things but I have been trying incredibly hard privately to learn + advocate for those within the trans community that I’ve hurt.
I also haven’t said much on this bc I have gone back and forth over whether my voice would be helpful on the issue since it will be framed as disingenuous or just turning bc I’m “scorned.” Even this reply will become right wing hysteria but yeah I am sorry. Let me know how I can help
Very true!
Zoomer men are more conservative, more religious, less trans...
Banter to some extent, but recall that there are pluses and minuses to everything. The whites not having kids are big-city leftist radicals. The "minorities" that are are Caucasian Hispanics, and Asians and bi-racial athletes from the suburbs.
Which group do you prefer as countrymen?
Quotes a post by A2239; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is, I think, the key point here.
"Trans woman" is not just another sub-class of woman. It's an actual bi-partite oxymoron, like saying "badger cat" or "married bachelor."
Quoting @jk_rowling: If a tall woman was short, she'd still be a woman.
If a trans women wasn't trans, he'd be a man.