The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
You guys will LITERALLY ride for any scum opposed to mainstream America.
Sure - we have some gross political crooks on squad too, but this really is amazing. Somali fraudsters ("How important IS it for a school to spell 'learning' correctly?!")....international narco-traffickers ("THAT is now confirmed - but all we've found so far is weed bales!!!")....male illegal alien human traffickers of girls ("Kilmar belongs in his HOME!!!")....plain Black criminals who try to kill cops (Michael Brown, Jacob Blake, Rayshard Brooks, get the encyclopedia out)....transgender male rapists in women's prison, etc.
I would ask what the goal is, but who cares. We'll break it and make it stop.
Quoting @krassenstein: Imagine if a random Liberal Youtuber, with a history of lies, who supports an alleged PEDO in office, tried busting into daycares to film minor children without their parents or guardians present...
I see a few methods critiques in the comments, but there have been several analyses of this kind, and there already exists an updated version of the slide/data set I used (attached w their own note on full transparency).
Even if we are 1,000% good faith, and assume TW simply have the same rate of sexual offending as other males....that rate is 122.5x the female rate. The actual trans rate cited below is 294.25x the female rate. The key predictor variable is XX vs XY.
There is no coherent argument that sex-integrated prisons are not dangerous for women. THINK about this!
This is one of those very technical facts that thin-telligent people throw out, which has almost nothing to do with the real trans debate. Only .018% of people (Genspect, 2024) have DSDs in any actual, medical sense.
So, literally 99.982% of the time, when your college lover or whatever says that she is "now non-binary," the question at table is whether a very very explicitly male or female person can simply decide that they are - in practice - part of the other sex or no sex at all.
Wot say you?
Quotes a post by T04206; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Well...no.
The right is angry about Gavin Newsom weaponizing Elon's trans-ID'd son, who is 19, as part of a quarrel between the two powerful men.
Wildly different.
I mean, I AM a doctor, if "PhD statistician" counts.
And, part of "full trans acceptance" has been the incarceration of men in female prison. The results were predictable.
The core question of the transgender debate is:
Is it more important to cater to the feelings of mentally ill men, or to keep women and girls safe while affirming reality?
A very simple way to translate content like this is just to sub in (1) the actual sex labels or (2) the word "fake" for "trans."
So, the question becomes something like:
"Are you saying teenage boys pose a danger to girls?"
Quotes a post by A2696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
But......Meghan.....being potentially attracted to 19 year old cheerleaders or quarterbacks is not a "fetish." This is a thing true for 89-93% (yes, I can source that) of all people. The issue re public discussion of that as vs trans is identical: can the obvious true thing - "That woman has a dick" - be said?
As a "published social scientist," basically: some societies decide that many true things should not be said, and others do not. The very feminist Iroquois and very masculine Japanese have always been famously open, to good result. In societies that DO restrict truth, "leading women and effeminate men" often specifically do so. Results vary.
I basically like truth. It's idiotic to pretend that whole categories of obvious reality (Black crime, most women are subs or switches, war is often good) are off-limits on politeness grounds. Rad-fems seriously pretending that 89% of men ARE pedophiles......while skipping totally over the women...are just doing a lower-IQ and more physically defenseless version of Christianity, with some totally fake science thrown in.
That's bad. There are no ultimate rules, and human nature is nothing to be embarrassed about. Set up protective barriers for the weak, but talk about it honestly.
Even if you take the idea of "privilege" seriously, this clearly is NOT a uni-variate concept. At least 30 variables would logically contribute, including - totally off-hand:
IQ
Social CLASS
Sex
Sexual Orientation
Race
Ethnicity
Nationality/Language-Tribe
Physical Fitness
Attractiveness
Aggression/Prey Drive
Urban/Rural
North/South
Appalachian/Not
"Trans/Cis"
Age
Disability
Height (certainly for males)
Criminal History
English Fluency
Native-Citizenship
Faith Tradition - Majority/No
Political Ideology
Education Level
Just on and on. Easily 7-8 of these outpace race and even sex as predictors of life outcomes. It might almost be better, one begins to think, to return to judging people as individuals.
Wild talk?!
This is not how sexuality works.
As an ex-rave kid...I also strongly suspect that "political lesbian separatists," trans people yapping about killing "genital preference," and so forth are a lot less helpful and innocent than they pretend.
"I have a bed TOO!!!"
Quotes a post by T02253; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
These arguments both strike me as pretty silly.
So, first, the claim that the great men's organizations - fraternal orders, country clubs, war academies, Scouting, specifically Rotarianism and the Masons - have a great deal of power/social capital and should be accessible to women was EXPLICITLY made by "RBG" and other top feminist lawyers and debaters. I went to law school: I think we both may have. This is said verbatim in 100+ cases.
The women's societies have often been argued to have at least as much influence (Faludi 1991, etc), since women traditionally ran more of this informal side of society while men did more formal business - and we now see "trans women" and some men trying to enter them.
Re the second point: obviously, being desired by your own partner is a potential source of soft power (the...definition of SP is the power that comes from others wanting to get to and please you). So is control of sexual access, skilled management of the home, access to the divorce courts under modern law, the ability to destroy your man's reputation, the plain fact you two love each other, etc etc.
Most women don't think in these terms, any more than men walk around muttering "Me stronger and richer!" - but these are all measurable dynamics discussed by relationship analysts from Dobson to Paglia. The outlier case of Jeffrey Epstein, a famous predator who fed 15 year old girls to clients like the ~King of England, doesn't change the rest of reality.
Women held a great deal of the power - I'd off-hand estimate about 40% - in society even under patriarchial models, because of factors like V-IQ, networking, and female sexuality. Now that women are also equal in the formal sector, feminist "power dynamics" models that ignore those still-relevant skills strike me personally as absurd.
Can you?
I notice that none of you have the confidence to use your names. Many of you, per the recent Red Pill Media, AF Post, etc revelations, seem to be from Pakistan. My own take would be that this crap^, at least on the margins, is the equivalent of "Black trans gworls rock" for the libs: political parties might have to do some embarrassing base service, but one just can't let that bloc of loons take over...or the OTHER party wins for 15 years.
I'm not really teasing.
This never EXPLAINS the female porn and crime data, but a 6pp swing re any of these three variables could easily be due to the fact that almost this percentage of people "are" now trans or enby.
In that men are allowed to have multiple safe spaces - such as clubs, fraternal organizations, military schools, gay bars, and gyms - that no left-leaning, pro-trans women...or women who ID as males....would every try to invade?
Why, one wonders, would this guy want to legalize what IS in fact almost always clear gay, trans or child hooking?
With no defamatory purpose, one wonders.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Up to 91% of "trans kids" do literally just grow out of it.
Quoting @donoharm: "Researchers have found that about 80% of kids who believe they’re born in the wrong body ultimately abandon that belief, so long as they don’t receive medical treatment."
https://www.wsj.com/opinion/the-cdc-can-help-those-disfigured-by-gender-affirming-care-c61d81ec?st=jN8ipQ
Just for fun, let's try "Pattern Recognition" out through an overall lens. I want to make sure this is isn't just W and B racists fighting. Of course you understand :).
What do the demographics for "trans kids" look like, across all racial groups?
The trans thing really became THE symbol of woke insanity because (1) the core claims ("Male criminals can become women;" "Binary sex is too simplistic," etc) are facially Tom-o-Bedlam crazy and/but (2) anyone to say this...for a DECADE...was gas-lit to the point of firing and self-harm.
Shout to Rowling, much of this page, and the others who stood strong.
Trans activists are THE craziest people I have debated online.
Quoting @TTExulansic: Craig is "formally calling for a blood hunt on any member of @Genspect," and suggests people gouge out our eyes and send them to Craig for money.
No offense, but what could you possibly mean by "enforced?" Are you suggesting that most large donors to, and street-fighting activists for, groups like WOMEN NOW and Feminist Majority and so forth were men...or that any number of women can be cowed by any much smaller number of men.
If either of those things is true, of course, then feminism was always sort of a joke propped up by guys. But, I'm more than willing to believe that's NOT the case. Per all anon data, women are far more empathic than men, 60% of young trans people are female, and women's groups expressed some real support for this cause early on.
This "the shooter was a Groyper" thing seems about to become the next Michael Brown-style Big Lie.
The shooter was a bisexual furry with a trans room-mate and lover, who opposed Charlie Kirk's "hate" and wrote literal AntiFa slogans on his damn bullets.
But...it's not.
You can just go on the various alt-platforms and see.
What is the empirical basis for the Groyper claim? Bro's trans lover is talking to the cops right now.
Words have to have meanings.
No - fucking a Discord Kitten is not "right wing behavior." This is a guy who really did apparently have a trans partner, is described by the BBC as below (https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy04p4x21e5o), wrote "Hey, fascist - catch!" on his bullet...etc. Some of this is retracted now, but the Guardian ran an entire piece where at least one friend described him in detail as very hard left.
It's just not surprising that a lib would shoot Charlie Kirk, man.
This is all just....total bullshit, though.
Robinson was a college kid with a trans lover who wrote "Catch this, fascist!!!" on his ammo. Nick Fuentes and others have repeatedly DENIED groyper involvement.
SJWs rely on the Big Lie more than anyone else outside of Palestine.
Quotes a post by T03868; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Slightly different wording:
Do you believe that all differences in performance or behavior between men and women - for example, women being on average more "submissive" or far more tolerant of trans/gay identities - are due to sexism or some form of "oppression?"
One of the more remarkable ideas of our modern era is that no group currently deemed oppressed - these can change overnight - is ever responsible for the things its members do.
Why are women far more pro-trans and darkly kinky than men? Because the men who hate that shit made them be! Don't ask questions, boot!!!
The problem with this argument, again, is that the pro-trans position of liberal women placed you in opposition to the toughest 80% of men - Black guys, rednecks, soldiers, etc.
You guys frequently, publicly, had screaming arguments with normal male warriors about this. There are tens of thousands of videos of blue-hairs spitting on fraternity wrestlers, and so on. There were major marches: one Slut-Walk focused on trans issues. This is all on record.
This was a thing WOMEN drove. If everything that women do is a reaction to physically, hormonally, aggressively superior men, women really should...not have rights. But, even I don't believe that, and it's a damned odd "feminist" position.
Citizens have guns now, sis (which the left wants to take away from women).
But, also - the people in charge of the left" were YOU!!!! The US left is about 56% female. ~All non-trans backers of Trans were female: we've had about 46 - a feminist debater in comments could easily correct me - referenda on trans stuff. Lib women have ALWAYS anonymously voted for it, men always against.
If the argument is just "Women cannot logically function while more dangerous and skilled men exist, no matter what the men want," that's...Repeal the 19th. I do not currently believe that.
Let's poll:
Over the last 5-6 years, did you ever PRETEND to believe that "Trans women are women" - by saying that GD or AGP males should be able to do the most basic female things......such as playing female varsity sports or changing in a women's nude locker room?
Let's poll:
Did you ever truly believe that "Trans women are women" - in the sense of believing that GD or AGP males should be able to do the most basic female things......such as playing female varsity sports or changing in a women's nude locker room?
The actual "trans" population - as vs the cast of wealthy girls and pansies - wasn't the focus of the joke.
But, also: ~60% of trans-ID'd people are female, IIRC my Genspect notes.
This is an obviously accurate summary of the trans/gender issue.
Quoting @jk_rowling: Western society is currently divided between people who know this is a man and are prepared to say so and those who know this is a man but lie out of obedience to an ideology. There is no third option. Literally nobody on earth thinks "Roxanne Tickle" is actually a woman.
I think the general take is that, if bold women or trans men want to run with the guys, and finish 9th out if 12, they sure can!
The obvious risk here is to women's sport.
Quotes a post by T08032; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Every time a feminist friend asks me "So - what's one example of evil WOMEN do (?!)," I genuinely think they expect me to say some shite like "say no to sex or paying bills."
Nope - this. Smaller, smarter, less directly aggressive people tend to do evil by creating lairs: controlled areas where they can manipulate even weaker humans. How many "trans kids" are there? Total Munchausen cases? Infanticides and medically unnecessary surgical abortions just annually?
Etc.
The "root of the trans phenomenom" is that a mezcla of feminists and male perverts developed a thing called "gender ideology," and bored activists who had just won on gay marriage then started teaching it in schools and workplaces.
Absent this - absent the IDEA that a sexually atypical man is a woman, nothing else matters. Some guys may BE turned on by images of men being sexually dominated - but captured soldiers and such have reported similar phenomena forever. What changed is society's legal decision to treat sex as flexible.
Quotes a post by T03745; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Also, I respect what the hard-body feminists, many of them lesbians, did vs gender ideology. But, that was a thing from THEIR WORLD!!! From THEIR DEPARTMENTS!!!
I'm 'shouting' as a joke, but come on. No loving-but-bro male warriors types ever...thought men could be women, and the balance in the trans wars swung (in the USA: shout to Brit TERFS) when that group jumped in.
This is important, actually: he claims a fake disability, which makes him a Holy Person, who far outranks white women.
Straight white women, and middle-class Black/Asian men ftm, get 1-2 oppression points. A bisexual, pro-trans, neorodivergent Latino lib outweighs that by at least five.
Quotes a post by T04703; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There are multiple, giant, Reddit/Facebook/Tik-Tok platforms telling women that their gender atypical kids are trans, that they should feel no need to sexually satisfy their spouse or play any domestic role ("He has two hands!"), that they should get divorced over minor fights, etc. "Call Her Daddy" is the #2 podcast/media platform in the country.
We all enjoy sparring with the Tate bros on the right, but there just really is no male equivalent.
Also, unrelated, but: 60% of young trans people are female, and the driving factor behind this youth epidemic seems to be the mass promotion of Judith Butler/women's studies-style gender theory in schools (look up "Gender Unicorn," "Genderbread Man," etc). I've never seen porn/erotica exposure score higher than 4th as a reason young people give for gender transitions.
In an era where both sexes and all races accurately accuse each other of never accepting responsibility for anything, there's something deeply......annoying about the female-coded libs responsible FOR gender ideology saying things like: "No! The real problem is Evil Men watching porno!!!"
Literally just tell ten average-looking XX virtue signalers daily: "Oh, I didn't know you were a trans woman - but I can see it!" and the infestation rapidly ends.
Okay - from a follow-up, it looks like both the ~10% figure and the 15% figure represent the percentage of "female" inmates who ARE trans.
That's not disputed - but I honestly don't think we know how many are housed with women.
That doesn't really change the "This is an insane circus" point, though - may intensify it.
The unpopular, real answer is "It depends on what the laws and collegiate policies were during the trans frenzy."
An analogy made in the comments is that in Britain, where the age of consent is 16, the government cannot simply start prosecuting people for "sex with a woman under 18."
We might think that's generally BAD, but you need a set legal hook for a crime.
Quotes a post by T04958; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I keep hearing this - that "trans men" are rape victims and such fleeing Misogyny, while "trans women" are "porn addicts" displaying Misogyny. But, are these^ what any large-N data shows trans people's primary motivations to be?
My own feeling, and my strong impression from the papers, is that a decade of in-school and online indoctrination about how gender atypical people ARE trans (Mermaids, the Gender Unicorn, the Gender Spectrum, the Gender Scale, the transition of Women's Studies to Gender Studies) is the big factor here - with young autists hardest hit.
Quotes a post by T01417; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Also, ~60% of young trans people are female.
Women's advocates never note this, for very obvious reasons - but same in reverse for you lasses and ladies.
To be clear: no one...literally no one...thinks "trans women" are actual women.
The question, now mostly resolved in the right direction, was about politeness.
This take, past a certain point, gets pretty annoying.
60% of young trans people are female. Gender ideology, at least post 1986, comes directly out of Butlerian women's studies. Last year, prior to the collapse, ~75% of women and ~25% of men backed it.
We lads are still down to help the TERF minority of women - myself, James Lindsay, and even Matt Walsh have spoken at women's events focused on gender. But, come ON: "When will the MEN see the light that most WOMEN have been trying so hard to SHOW them, the rubes?!" is a zany take here.
I've felt this^ most strongly in the context of adults trying to trans children, but I suspect that the "cleansing fire" sensation goes back a loooong time - at least to the 1st human to jog over a ridge-line with his/her spear, and realize that the enemy fighters coming closer weren't exactly........people. #monstrosity #abomination
Random ~serious point: liberal friends often note that gay rights, trans rights, and later-wave feminism correlate positively with the wealth and power of nations. Obvious implication: these are self-evident good things.
But, that's a univariate analysis - the catch is that these things are only POSSIBLE for rich countries. With no real hate, you can't have a ton of girl-bosses until most wolves and pirates are dead...and being unsure of what sex you are when horny is a whole different level of wealthy theater kid shit.
If you adjust FOR WEALTH or for years as a developed country and then look at the effect of the other three var.s given on happiness, patriotism, GINI, etc, feminism seems to be at best a null while the other two are negatives.
I Quite Openly haven't run this beyond the back-of-napkin, scrape-CIA-Factbook-data-into-STATA level - but I encourage people to! Prove me wrong, libs!
The problem with this take is that 70+% - 90% of "trans kids" come to fully and ~happily accept their bio sex during puberty.
Letting children transition before they even understand sexuality would guarantee a large population of broken adults w/o normal sexual function - almost flashlights for un-mutilated men.
Quotes a post by T02312; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Almost EVERYONE who advocates for "trans rights" is a woman or gay dude.
"Mysogyny" just is not the issue here. 56% of trans people - admittedly per a younger data set - are female.
Quotes a post by T05062; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Why wouldn't this apply to frank discussion of all these groups, though - why are white people more likely (?) to be trans, etc.
That's sort of MY goal online, and in work. The IQ thing, in particular, would seem to matter most as re how groups involved in current mass migration do.
Trans activists sort of...can't have a sense of humor.
If you're an adult man with a diaper fetish, wearing a dress and cheering for the sex integration of high school sports, you must have a sneaking suspicion about where the jokes are likely to fall.
Quotes a post by A0875; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In an almost-too-on-the-nose example of the trend discussed on the page earlier today, thousands of "cis" leftist women are advancing likely the largest pro-trans petition ever.
An entire pro-trans lib-feminist group has apparently formed.
I've said this before, but the feminist attempt to paint trans ideology as driven by "conservative mysogyny" or "traditional gender roles" strikes me as almost delusional.
Does anyone truly think it is right-wing men calling for mentally ill males to play attractive women onscreen? How do we poll on this issue, vs liberal women?
Quotes a post by A2282; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The problem with this take is that male perverts came up with at least half OF trans ideology.
Women tend to be insanely tolerant of stupid, predatory shite ("Open the borders!!!"), but most actual predators are men.
Quotes a post by T07286; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
One random thing that the trans movement did was ~totally eliminate blank slatist "Anything YOU can do I can do BET-TER!!!" feminism.
After watching random mediocre men become women's global champions in everything from swimming to Mongol-style archery - and women on T regress and start committing crimes at the male rate, before the boys gloat too much - no serious person still says drivel like "sex roles are 100% a social construct."
The (1) discovery that 5-8% of bad-ass warriors in SOME societies were "shield-maids" and then (2) their reclassification as men by trans people is the least feminist thing I have ever seen.
It's not a category I keep a close eye on - but there's your winner.
Quotes a post by T07303; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Often true, depending on your definition of these terms.
A society where I actually was Emperor would be great for women, in terms of crime policy, immigration, acceptance of those gender roles ~everyone actually wants, trans issues, norms of gentlemanliness, etc.
Gotta ACCEPT basic biology, as a starting point.
Quotes a post by T02377; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No. We focus on AGPs because they're potentially dangerous, but something like 3% of ALL young people think they are trans and are at least considering surgical medicine - and they are VERY heavily female...https://abcnews.go.com/US/3-us-high-schoolers-identify-transgender-cdc-survey/story?id=114619209
This is complete bullshit. It seems to literally represent every time a gun was discharged on school grounds. Notice that there are 35 Black "shooters," and well under 20 victims.
Mother Jones - surprisingly - keeps an excellent list of real "school shootings" and "mass shootings:" i.e., situations where three or more people are KILLED in one location by a rogue gunman.
There are less than 300 all time, 50+% white, heavily trans in recent years for some reason.
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
This is a fascinating incidental piece of data. Given that the "initiating or supportive parent" for "trans kids" is the mother something over 80% of the time, that might mean MOST of the fathers.
Quotes a post by A2585; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Lore for new followers: I once took one of the major gender scales after a friendly online argument with the Sociologist Rod Graham.
After answering four consecutive questions about cats v dogs (cats), gardening (pro), oral for women (down), and cooking (do), the test flipped my score from Very Manly Hairy Man or whatever to "Probably a Woman."
I posted this online. TERF buddies had a lot of fun with it, but at least 5-6 people dead seriously DM'd me, saying that I was trans and needed to "break my bubble" or some such shite. #now_you_know
Per the major gender scales posted online and used to convince kids they are trans ("masculine style of personal communication?"), yes.
My girl LIZ is a dude.
Quotes a post by T05407; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is what I mean when I say that a lot of questions about the gender issue are intentionally confusing.
When faced with "Should trans female athletes compete with runners of their preferred sex or their preferred gender (?)," 30-60% of people have no idea what is being asked.
When we ask "Should men with penises run with the girls (?)," and 86/14 issue is revealed.
Quotes a post by T00360; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Social scientist here:" this idea that there is an epidemic of female rapists is one of the......more bizarre things I regularly see online.
To clarify: what's going on here is that men's rights and trans rights activists (but do I repeat myself?) are taking niche radical feminist definitions of rape - "any sex I did not enthusiastically want, did not explicitly consent to, or which was at all influenced by alcohol or drugs (paraphrase)" - and using them to survey males. AS WITH WOMEN, every poll suddenly finds that 25-70% of males have been sexually assaulted.
When we use the real definition of "forcible sex past a final no," in a case serious enough to involve a charge, quite literally 99.1% of rape perps are men.
Quotes a post by T06518; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
As I note from time to time, recent radicalization in the West re migration, trans/gender issues, socialism, etc is driven almost entirely by college-educated women.
Men are the blue line on this graphic. "We" haven't budged at all.
Quoting @RichardHanania: Young German women are much more left-wing than young German men.
The craziest thing about post-trans liberal treatment of women is that the labels ("bleeding inseminated front hole") are all things I would literally swat a younger male mentee for saying in a bar.
"You've come a long way, baybee."
Quoting @EricLDaugh: JUST IN: Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers (D-WI) is backing a proposed law to replace the word "mother" with "inseminated person" in a state statute.
H/t @[private account]
I mean...every single party ever to propose legalizing anything from CSA possession to cross-age sex among gay men to trans surgeries for minors was on the political left. This is...not even disputed.
The context here^ was me saying that, of course, the sex abuse scandal in the Catholic Church was VERY BAD - but that you could have found similar behavior anywhere from gay clubs to hood public schools had anyone bothered to look...and there is a reason no one did.
Responding by saying "No - anime-loving furries are DECENT PEOPLE and you moderate conservatives are ALL RAPISTS!!!" is just obviously bullshit. But, it is a reminder of one of the classic questions in politics.
Wot is the only thing SJWS do?
Quotes a post by T01581; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Worth noting: because OF both hood and true-upper-class contempt for bourgeois morality, the trans-kid zone is actually the middle class and the low end of the upper-middle class. This was VERY clear, when I looked for Genspect.
A genuinely UC person (conservative Senator's wife, world's top Asian art dealer) or X-class person (Quillette writer) would be very likely just to laugh at a teen daughter who said she was a "non-binary demisexual" - "Well, at least you won't be fucking a lot!" - and a true ghetto mom might slap the crap out of her and the sense back in.
To a large extent, the middle-middle class is the group that believes in "fashion:" the group which is told every decade or so what society's new norms are, and which then accepts them as having always be true.
And, while we need some core standards ("fatherhood") for society to function, this pattern is why so many people feel contempt for the petit bourgeois. Most "Never up my nose or in my mouth (!);" "Sure, some women have dicks!" sort of standards are clearly driven mostly by hypocritical fear. Rejecting them has to be carefully managed to avoid decadence - but I reject most of them myself, and it's hard to hate the honest rogue who doesn't care very much about the HR lady.
~Every modern "civil rights hero" story is like this - Mike Brown, Trayvon Martin, Jacob Blake, Stonewall (mob run bar, no "trans women"), Jussie Smollett, Covington Catholic, Yasmin Seweid, blah-blah-my-1st-two-books.
Bit depressing tbh.
Eh. All human relationships are "transactional" to a significant extent - common sense and all studies show this.
You should obviously like and be attracted to your partner. But, long-term, people are not going to remain with mated partners who do not meet their sexual, emotional, protective, or (to an extent) financial needs. Unqualified love exists mainly for very young children and puppies.
In my experience, the best way to handle this reality is to treat relationships as a "long-term game." Instead of doing the direct trading memes joke about - pulling down a partner's pants at the end of a 45 minute massage, and ruining the calm - focus long-term on "making her very happy" and confidently expect "her" to do the same for you.
But, the reality......exists. If I suddenly became a verbally abusive, coke-sniffing transgender, the female exec I'm bonded with would not "unconditionally" stick around forever.
Next level just dropped.
54-56% of trans people are female. The focus on "these pervert men," as vs formal gender studies curricula from...err...Women's and Gender Studies departments...is bizarre.
Quoting @BuckAngel: Did you all notice that the majority of the “ voices” representing “ trans rights” are transgender women (males)? If not please notice this because the transsexual men ( female) like myself are often shut out or stamped on as “ transphobic “ or a “ terf” which on some level can be considered misogyny. Of maybe it is just misogyny.
TERF GiveSendGo - I hardly ever share these, but I vetted this one and it seems like a genuinely crazy story.
TLDR form - a normal woman has been sued 3+ times, at a cost of $17,000, after an altercation with two male neighbors and their "trans daughter," which involved things like posting a sign that said "Transing Kids Is Abuse and Homophobia."
Read through: give if you feel the urge! https://www.givesendgo.com/signwar
I mean, today there is something called "trans kids."
Draw your own conclusions.
Quoting @FischerKing64: Women are not angels guys.
Back in the day there was something in the news called Munchausen syndrome by proxy. These women would make their children ill, all for sympathy and attention. Poison them, sicken them - and then act like they didn’t know what was wrong. There was also a big thing called ‘sudden infant death syndrome’ which was supposedly random, but was mostly women murdering their babies.
Guys get all the attention with mass shootings, bar fights - activities which create a lot of noise and blood and evidence.
But evil women are subtle. They can be nurses who ‘get the medication wrong’ and kill the patient.
I've always thought of the 1st wave as "voting," 2nd as "jobs and orgasms," 3rd as what you're talking about, and 4th as full-on trans plus Internet stuff.
They're all pretty internally incoherent. But, I'm down with most pre-1993, outside-of-a-campus stuff: the CRA should include women if it exists at all, female execs are fine, you can't rape your wife or stab your husband, girlfriends should also get oral, women can play sports, etc.
Let's do some "Cut The Bull" recruitment!
Does anyone want to come on a - by now quite large - podcast and discuss...
(1) Migration and H1Bs, from either a "Vivek" or dissident right perspective or..
(2) Support for the trans movement, from a feminist, "pro-male," or autogynephile perspective?
I always respect your takes, man - but what do you mean? We men almost universally vote against gender ideology in referenda, vote at a 60% rate for the party that opposes it, often send fighters and such to help out "Let Women Speak"-style events in at least the USA, and have produced much of the more prominent content in this space (What Is A Woman?, Genspect speakers by clicks/downloads) "ourselves."
At some level, if Group A and Group B have ~equal rights, Group A opposes a bill 65/35, but Group B supports it 70/30, the bill...passes. It really sort of is that simple. States with female-elected blue/Dem Reps have "strong trans rights."
Modern "women's rights activists," especially on the pro-trans side, strike again.
For the guys: remember that these are the people calling you a misogynist, for such thoughts as "Gender roles exist in nature, because of pregnancy, and aren't caused by us beating women."
Quotes a post by T01373; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Taking responsibility really is not the strong suit of the latter-wave feminist movement, eh?
I don't mean to be brutal about this, but I'm going to hammer away at it until the point is made. This is something made possible ONLY by liberal, feminist women. NO other group of citizens supports this ideology. This below is the data. It just...is.
It might be true that trans women are male. But trans MEN, who who brutalize themselves far worse, file a variety of insane allegations against men pretty frequently, and can currently enter "men's spaces" in most states, are female. Liberal feminists support Their Truth too!
Of...course I am not going to allow shaming techniques from a near-stranger to persuade me to feel guilt about a movement that "your" group supports and "mine" does not. I love the TERFS! If YOU do not support gender ideology, great! But, painting this as a conservative men's issue is beyond any concievable reach of the brush of absurdity.
Is this...sincerely supposed to be a serious reply? Is the 'joke' that I am a "trans woman?"
Your response to this data below is that I - the "TERF-y" writer from the Matt Walsh movie - should "stay out of women's spaces?"
With no real hate, it's almost literally impossible to imagine sillier middle-class parodies of white-knighting than multiple actual comments here.
Not to keep doing this, but another data set below
The ONLY people who support gender ideology are highly empathic, liberal, mostly feminist women.
At some point, these damned elephants in the room have to be discussed. If you import 10,000 rapists because leftists demand this, and they start raping people, the reason for that isn't "porn is available" or "skirts are a bit short."
Same here. Obviously, some people in any group are criminals or nuts. But, the people making society ACCOMMODATE the criminals/nuts - the traditional ~100% target for criticism in any analysis of this kind - are not the normal men who see that very idea as insane.
Sorry to beat this to death.
Also...55% of trans people are trans men. :)
Quotes a post by T01738; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedideology cultmental illnessviolence terror
Yup.
Unless, by "men," you literally JUST mean "trans women" - and you are willing to totally ignore the bigger cohort of female trans men for whatever reason - there is empirically no doubt that the driving force behind gender ideology is liberal/lib-fem women.
These are some data sets gathered, 1-2 by heavily female teams, in different Western contexts. In real academic literature, this is not debated by anyone. Trying to pawn the whole thing off on rightist men...borders on insane.
In the trans debate, feminist women often try to distract from the fact that 60-70% of feminist women support "full trans inclusion" - in those terms - by pivoting to the fact that "trans women are (themselves) men."
So, the REAL problem is again Evil Men, right? Well, not quite. Notably, TRANS MEN are biological women, are more common than trans women, and are again supported for "full/total access" by 60-70% of feminist women.....despite the accompanying final loss of MEN'S spaces, risk of pregnancy and dubious post-4th Wave assault claims, etc.
Honestly, this is a situation where almost literally all liberal women - 2/3 on waaay up - support The Current Thing, and almost no men do. Absent The Current Ideology, there would be - as a smart hood guy, quant analyst, or any other thing I am - nooooo possible way to blame us.
Take responsibility! Ask for HELP (Rohan will ANSWER!). FIX THE PROBLEM!
YES - women should......vote with virtually all men to ban the small number of people (about half female...once again) who aare doing the thing you object to from doing so.
Your framing of the argument makes sense only if you (1) reject conventional ethics, and assign blame to an entire group for outlier members of that group, rather than to the bloc of non-insane/criminal citizens (cops, failed electorate) who are refusing to regulate them and...
(2) just somehow IGNORE the fact that half the outliers are members of the other/your group.
What is going on here is that women support full access to opposite-sex spaces for female and male trans-ID'd people and men DO not. I have provided the data showing this. This is, indeed, not a complex point.
But, this empirically does not make sense, because women are 2-6x AS "indifferent to" or "supportive of" the spread of trans ideology.
This is my entire, quite data-based point. I'm using North Euro data here, but all data in existence...says the same thing.
Literally all data shows this.
I wasn't just, for some odd-ass reason, trolling the Rowling. Liberal women, especially self-identified "feminists," are THE only large social group which supports full trans inclusion.
Quotes a post by T06206; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
First, before anything else, about 55% of trans-ID'D people are female, and liberal women back their claims also (Genspect 2023).
That said, this^ just isn't how any policy analysis I've ever read or conducted works - it's the exact equivalent of saying that "women" are at fault for infanticide and (non-coerced) prostitution, or "men" (or Black people) are at fault for gun homicide and robbery...because the majority of these problems involve members of the named groups, even though <1% of X members are involved with the problem.
In reality, all sane people are aware that every group contains weird outliers, and there is a strong convention in every major society against assigning group-level blame for weird-ass outlier behavior. No one says "crime" is the fault of "young people, both sexes," as vs "criminals." HOWEVER, we DO expect citizens to behave in a coherent, sensible, and responsible manner - so we DO blame cops for not catching criminals, electorates for voting foolishly, etc. It's in this context that it is notable that (say) 60% of women and only 25% of men are pro-trans.
Continuing on, a lot of the things you're saying seem to objectively not...be true or at least provable. Women and men DO NOT support and oppose gender identity to "about the same extent." Men are far more opposed to trans inclusion in every country where data has been collected. I have attached some of the Northern Euro data from tweet #2 - glad to attach of DM the US chart. That 1st claim is just, with no hate, not real anywhere. Non-TERF liberal feminists are the group MOST supportive of "full trans inclusion" when this is polled on.
Also, the idea that "these (trans) men" themselves "took away women's rights" doesn't really summarize what happened. Women voting in referenda like California's, or Democratic candidates elected in almost every case by female blue-state majorities, passed current trans rights into law. "Trans women" themselves make up less than 2% of the population of every state.
Other than the fact that some portion of the trans-ID'd population is biologically male, there id just no plausible way to label trans rights a "men's issue." Doing 30m of research during this debate, it may be THE single issue normal men - employed conservatives, independents, and centrists, especially those with daughters - are LEAST sympathetic to.
Probably my last post here, but - you seem to have...simply ignored both points above.
(1) Almost exclusively women voted for this "invasion" to happen. No non-trans men wish to enter "women's spaces" (the shower?).
(2) There are trans folX in both directions. Boy Scouts are now Scouting USA. Naked, bearded 'non-binary' females are not uncommon in the gents' locker room, these days.
Very few men supported any of this. Blaming "males" for a female voting priority we opposed, because half of the people WITH gender dysphoria are male is, as I noted above, bizarre.
I don't objectively think this makes a ton of sense.
If 1% of the population is made up of lunatics who think they are the opposite sex...70% of the less empathic 49% of the normal people want to get them treatment...but 70% of the more empathic 51% of the normal people argue that the lunatics are correct and write this into law, it would be bizarre for anyone to look at this situation and put primary blame on the lunatics.
Also, more prosaically, there are more "trans women" than "trans men" - and liberal women support them too.
Love your work, but liberal women are far, far more likely to cheer FOR "trans inclusion" than are any group of men I have ever seen surveyed, anywhere - and the phenemenon we are discussing here is liberal men who are begging to BE liberal women.
Unless, maybe, you are speaking only of FtMs themselves, it makes no sense to describe a major factor here as "misygony" or "male indifference." A large majority of female feminists believe "gender is not defined by sex," while male voting alone would have ended the issue in weeks.
Quoting @jk_rowling: You realise that if men weren't insisting they were women and forcing their way into women's spaces, there would be literally no problem, right?
I don't want to do "gender wars" content today, but the feminist take on this issue is just genuinely bizarre.
Virtually all men oppose trans "inclusion" in women's prisons, sport, etc - just as HUGE majorities of men are hard-liners on rape law, the death penalty, criminal justice overall, and illegal immigration.
Lenient policy across these sectors is...very famously driven by liberal women. The majority of self-ID'd feminists SUPPORT trans self-ID; TERFS are by definition a hated minority among their own kind. "Sex work is work" is not a GOP slogan, btw.
Pretending that the issue here is "misogyny" takes real effort.
Quoting @jk_rowling: The number of men who don't see women as fully human can be measured by their indifference to trans-identified males invading women's spaces. 'What's the harm?' they shrug. 'Who's it hurting?'
Women. It's hurting women. And the essence of misogyny is thinking that doesn't count.