The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
I argue with this guy a lot, but this one question...flattens the extremes of both trans and the men's movement.
Why are we enforcing, as hard rules, ANY 1950s gender stereotypes? If you're Prince, you're Prince, not "somehow truly a girl."
Same experience.
The left side of the trans debate is strictly religious.
Quoting @wesyang: A right-wing friend of mine said that she made a rule to control her penchant for hate reading by exclusively reading left-wing writers whom she judged to be honest, good-faith, and fact-based.
There are some on every issue, she said, with a single exception: transgenderism.
People keep saying "Probably some TRANS women on there!!!"
Sure. Let's assume they're over-reptesented by 2,000%, and make up fully 20% of the forum. That would leave the remaining 80% of the female and male posters, some of whom post their pictures, to explain.
Some people are just freaky. The question is whether extreme variants on sex-kink, etc are more common now...or just easier to find.
It is not illegal for trans people to have sex.
It is illegal for trans people to have penetrative sex without first telling a partner their birth sex. Like some forms of condom stealthing, but unlike having a few drinks, this is over the coercion/manipulation line for rape.
Thoughts?
Quotes a post by A2843; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I like Jesse Singal, but he keeps engaging with Communists like they're human.
Like, that's^ obviously a debater's line. But, yes - she's lying. ALL trans advocates, racial crits, feminists discussing any sex or violence stat, Pallywood promoters, etc are lying. And, they know they are lying. And, they know you know they are lying, after the first "p = (X)?" question. And, you know that they know that you know that they are lying.
After 1-2 tweets, a calm assumption of good faith is just acceptance of exploitation by an enemy.
Quoting @jessesingal: She just... keeps lying. PHI means a specific thing. It isn't PHI. I feel like I'm taking crazy pills. This is a Harvard instructor! Then again, she's been pretty explicitly clear about what her goal is -- to ensure I never have a moment of peace again.
Where feminism is right now is - no hate - absolutely hilarious.
Why don't right-wingers want males in women's bathrooms?
Well, you see, because those are trans WOMEN, and we live to control women.
Quoting @esjesjesj: Very clear that this is not about gender identity but about controlling women
At random: just as a quick tell for working-class origins among successful people is "teeth," THE tell for trans folX is "height."
Some trans men actually do pass, until you think: "Why is bro 5'3" with those hips?"
This is why I used the sorority and JL "peer" examples - i.e., very specifically one-sex spaces, one-sex for a reason, where networking is done.
But, it is worth noting that "trans women" are more common than "trans men" - and a fragrant presence in gym locker rooms and such.
This always was basically the sane-right position. "Trans women" are men dealing with the DSM-5-recognized mental condition of gender dysphoria.
Obviously, dysphorics "exist." No one should abuse them. But, they are not literal, actual women.
A major gay/trans difference is that you simply can BE gay. If you like D as a man, and say you are gay, you're gay.
If you say you are a woman as a man, you...aren't - in 99% of the senses that anyone means. Being rude sucks, but we all SEE this.
Biological sex IS (very mildly) complicated by the existence of a large number of inter-sex conditions, including rare but real hermaphroditism.
But, this is relevant to the trans debate - the only reason anyone ever talks about it - only if an apparent male claiming to be a woman ACTUALLY IS intersex.
That almost never happens, since something like .2% of humans are IS. The more common question of "Can a full-on XY dude, with small gametes, a penis, balls...etc be a woman?" has the same answer it always did.
Quotes a post by T04921; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is why the trans debate matters.
Saying that a male convicted wife batterer is a beautiful woman who should go to the women's jail is a statement of faith. Someone willing to say this is willing to say whatever his side demands.
Quotes a post by T03561; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trapping someone in a radically unsatisfying relationship - not telling a man you have a very low libido, and in fact pretending for months that this is not the case; not telling a woman that your "true self" is trans - should be considered a form of abuse.
This is the problem, re trans issues.
If, as a guy, you actually pull an AGP out of the bathroom with your daughter, every left-leaning woman will call the cops and you will get a night in jail.
You still should given any risk, o/c.
Quotes a post by A2259; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The trans issue comes down to liberal and feminist women backing feminine liberal men who want to be women.
Blaming this on "conservative MALE misogyny," or something, is just a bizarre take.
I don't really disagree with this at all. Virtually all successful modern men would agree that women deserve - in the actual "fought for" sense - rights, access to executive jobs if qualified......orgasms and driver's licenses, etc.
The problem is that almost 0% of 3rd or 4th wavers are referring to those things, as vs trans rights, misandry, changing sexual politics, etc when they say "feminism."
It's worth noting that this doesn't mean later-wave feminism is good. It just means that it is not...possible in primitive ass countries that still face real problems like "wolves in the highlands."
AMONG developed countries, the few times I and others have even looked at this data, adopting feminist-preferred policies like trans inclusion, open borders, legal sex work, therapy culture, 'feminized' education, and a mass "don't need no man" welfare support network for women appears to correlate with DECREASED quality of life.
The only real reply is: "Those are the WRONG feminist policies!"
You don't hate journalists enough.
Almost literally every major left-wing hype story is a lie. Recall this, the Hunter Biden laptop, Jessie Smollett, "Black genocide" overall, Sarah Braasch and Amy Cooper, "W-on-B inter-racial crime" overall, "hands up: don't shoot," Russiagate, the sharp-as-a-tack Joe Biden, "trans genocide," "Palestinian genocide" overall, the Very Fine People hoax, the efficacy of masks, the Canadian Mass Graves hoax...etc...every time liberal sparring partners bring up "right-wing misinformation."
Quoting @emilykschrader: The New York Times appears to have published completely fake news in order to falsely accuse the IDF of committing war crimes and shooting children “at point blank range” which Gazan and foreign medics testify they witnessed.
The only problem with this is the “evidence” provided by those same “experts” appears, according to analysis from numerous ballistics experts, radiologists, trauma nurses, medics, and more, to be digitally altered or completely falsified.
The NYT needs to answer for this. This is completely irresponsible and incitement to violence at a time when Jews are being actively attacked globally fueled by disinformation like this.
Here is the NYT article: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/10/09/opinion/gaza-doctor-interviews.html?unlocked_article_code=1.RU4.aKAi.2JuzZxYawEZ-&smid=url-share
There are the x-rays that purport to show children who were treated after being “shot by the IDF” with what they claim is 5.56 caliber bullets … yet there are no skull fractures, no exit wounds, and no change in the bullet itself from a rifle? Come on… as people far more knowledgable than me would say, there’s no way these x-rays show what the “experts in Gaza” claim they show — which of course makes their entire testimony highly suspect.
The total amount BLM took in was, by fall of 2020, 11.6 billion (Economist, 2021).
The $90-100 million figure, which I once unpacked for Spiked UK, was simply donations to one group - Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation (BLMGNF). Most of THAT money was re-directed to say and trans causes, btw: not the hood.
Quotes a post by T05927; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Every smart leftist argument is based on pure word-play.
"Immigrants are fine/good" - sure, but not illegal aliens
"Trans people are real" - in the sense that there are people with gender dysphoria, who are NOT members of the opposite sex
"Nazis are very bad" - he means you, or like Elon Musk.
Etc.
Quotes a post by T08970; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Serious question for feminist friends: the trans debate aside, is there a commonly referenced "women's right" that does not break down to late-term abortion?
Like, are there...other rights modern businesswomen have fewer of than goodwives in the hedge-witch era, or activists in 1985?
Quotes a post by T01723; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is not new evidence, although the piece is quite good.
We have known for literally decades that 65-91% of "trans kids" just grow up to be gay. What has happened in a few Western countries is that politicized fanatics have stopped science/medicine from following up on the obvious conclusions to draw from this.
Quoting @benryanwriter: New Evidence Challenges Institutionalized Belief That Transgender Teens Become Transgender Adults, Undermining Core Defense of Medical Gender Transitions for Minors
🧵New from me for @[private account]:
A pair of analyses of insurance-claims data each found that the majority of youths diagnosed with gender-related distress saw that diagnosis vanish from their medical chart within six years.
This is unbelievably annoying, and one reason most businessmen are so unsympathetic to the trans issue.
Prior to 1979-84, men in the USA/UK had a whole range of veterans' clubs, golf courses, cigar bars, pubs, supper clubs, sporting leagues, etc for men only. Women sued to invade almost all of these and imposed a whole series of unwanted rules: membership - think Eagle Scouts - often dropped by half.
Thoughts?
Quotes a post by T02812; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I usually don't say this phrase on "simp cliche" grounds, but this is what "not all men" means. The point isn't that only (say) half of guys are perverts - "Forgive ME, m'lady!"
Rather, it's what's outlined below- that a 10% minority OF a 6% minority of men ("trans women" and recent migrants combined, in Europe) commit literally 55-75% of many/most serious sex crimes.
Most people - including MANY women - could probably get better at stuff at the level of "drinking less on dates" or "being less touchy in clubs" or even "remembering the safe word." But, at some level, we all know that there are no packs of normal doctors rampaging through downtowns groping women.
Quotes a post by A2532; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Prison rape is one of those things that's really hard to at all care about ("Shouldn'ta robbed all them banks, Bubba"), but is actually a massive indictment of a current system.
Zero female goons should be getting raped/abused by guards or "trans women" and - yes - zero male burglars should be getting piped down because they happen to be white/Black/Blood/cuz inside the wrong compound.
Gotta say: it is extraordinarily easy to (basically) confirm this.
Step One: go to source one. Confirm the number of convicted/jailed/accused sex offenders in each category.
Step Two: norm each population for 1,000,000 - multiply the trans figure by (X), and divide the M and F figures by (Y).
That's literally it. Took two minutes.
Quoting @esjesjesj: So I actually followed the rabbit hole of all this data and can confirm none of it. One of the listed sources says that the data is essentially unreliable
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedchild predatorviolence terror
The idea that gender ideology is "a conservative, male-driven men's rights movement," or some such, is beyond insane. "Trans women" are male, but they want to be liberal women and the ONLY group that supports their distaff dream is liberal women.
I'm for solutions as vs everyone fighting, and the Bro Community is down to help out. But, come ON. We've had powerful "Departments of Women's and Gender Studies" for 50 years now. Abdicating responsibility for the Judith Butler in the room and saying "coulda been anything - slightly more of you BOYS watch porn!!!" - is Monty-Python-skit level shit.
This is a really obvious question, from an interesting new-ish GC account.
Worded differently: if denying "the reality for trans kids" makes them kill themselves, why wasn't the teen suicide rate twice as high as it is today forever......from man-dawn until Obergefell? Why are we, in fact, seeing it surge to record levels, in today's psych-meds-and-surgery era?
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Tr@[private account] 🏳️⚧️ people, if you’ve existed since the dawn of time:
Why do you need the techno-medical infrastructure of a thriving, modern, first world country in order to keep you from self-deleting?
Quoting @TRobinsonNewEra: Here we go again.
A 32-year-old woman has stabbed five people in the German city of Siegen.
Three people are currently in a critical condition.
Truly astonishing.
And, let's be real: the Bro Community has a serious point about women generally being more willing to accept Wokist nonsense. That 58% is the elephant in the room with "trans is a male-driven mens' rights movement," etc.
Quoting @wesyang: 58 percent of women and 34 percent of men aged 18-34 think that saying "there are only two genders" is a red flag in a partner
The public at large has never been propagandized to believe made up nonsense so rapidly
Every single study ever done shows that 69-91% of "trans kids" basically just grow out of it - realize they were gay or had external problems by mid-puberty.
Quotes a post by T06842; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Russiagate
Black police genocide
Very fine people
W-on-B race crime
Rittenhouse the murderer
Trans genocide (~25 deaths year)
Hunter Biden laptop
Peak oils 1-7
Hands up, don't shoot
Unprovoked Gaza genocide
What would you add?
It must be hard for sincere people on the modern left just to talk.
"Well, she's an unhoused justice-impacted person who was born biologically male - I'm sorry, biologically trans-female - but identifies more as..."
Quotes a post by T01355; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Most "trans people," especially among young party kids, are literally just people who say they are trans.
I'm not saying this from "a place of hate," or any such shit: Aella is like the 10th researcher to find this. The sole real qual to be a "trans woman" is that you are male.
Quotes a post by T00099; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Does this include "non-binary" people, "childhood gender influencers," and so forth?
If so, way over. I see Jeffree Marsh and a 'trans kid threatened by legislation' just casually glancing at the card.
I don't think this is an M/F thing at all, actually.
With the advent of social media, what we have very measurably seen is the disproportionate influence of people who believe "moral"-sounding but fringe things - trans advocates, professional Blacks, the "you need a contract for party sex" people. No one wants to sound cruel or creepy or un-woke by disagreeing with these idiots, so their abnormal ideas trackably spread.
Most people never come to believe in them - in my 1st large-N anon poll on this page, only 2% of citizens said women could have penises - but they not infrequently become formal technical norms. This is a pattern to recognize, and stop.
Quotes a post by T08830; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Men."
This approach is unbelievably annoying, and maaaay be quietly radicalizing me. There are essentially no normal men issuing terror threats to the concerts our ladies go to on girls' night. In EVERY case, the people doing stuff like this - recent Islamic migrants, ghetto and Antifa thugs, "trans women" - are members of some tiny, dysfunctional pet group that every mainstream feminist/left-wing organization coddles and cossets.
I mean, just sayin'.
Quotes a post by T03136; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codeddenialislam linkpolitical enemyviolence terror
What's key on gender issues is how you ask the question.
Left-leaning polling houses don't cheat-cheat, but they're fond of confusing items like "Should transgender girls be allowed to compete with their preferred gender?"
If you just ask: "Can any woman have a dick?" you get that 2-11%.
The entire liberal feminist establishment in the US and UK backs trans rights and ~open borders, and it is quite easy to point to examples of the pattern I'm critiquing here - for example, heavy liberal support for sharia courts, which have different takes on domestic abuse and marital rape than the law itself.
Glad to have a quick exchange by DM: there are dozens of "such cases."
This actually is a really good point, which isn't made very often.
If you're going to have sex ed at all, it should logically focus on what pleasure, consent, etc look like for the ~85% of people who - even today - are going to be married heterosexuals. Rationally speaking, 1% of the population - trans or hard kinksters - should get 1% of the slides.
My dead-honest take is that the concept of "gender" is totally useless and meaningless. The self-ID definition of "trans" literally is: someone says they feel female/male...and so they are. It's an unsustainable idea.
If you peck at the non-biological concept of the feminine, it mostly breaks down to old hyper-sexist stereotypes that I learned as a working class kid, but even that is often described as non-mandatory ("Trans women don't have to look female - normalize the bulge"). This is why the simple question "What is a woman?" wins every argument.
It's pretty constant: "The hidden pressure of the social gender roles assigned by MEN," etc.
This, of course, offers 0% explanatory power as re the recent 5,000% or so percent surge in trans-ID.
Which of these things do you consider MOST responsible for the spread of "gender ideology" and growth of trans identification among youths (primarily) and others?
The idea that the trans movement is somehow due to "conservative misogyny" is a fascinating example of the Everything Must Fit the One Theory phenomenon.
The issue here is that liberal women are backing liberal men who want to be liberal women. A lot of conservative bros are "benevolent sexists" - i.e. normal people - but only ~9% of us think you can really even BE trans.
The word game here is pretending that conservatives are rubes who don't know what DSDs are, and they/we think this Muslim boxer is trans.
No. The point is that he...I guess...is more than technically male. The concept of "gender identity" plays no role here.
Quotes a post by T06327; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I mean, men and women have different pathologies. Clearly, basically all rapists are men - this^ is a post about sex crimes.
But, "toxic feminity" - a sort of pathological and corrupted empathy - is also a huge problem at the societal level. ~The ONLY large groups of people that support "trans inclusion," opening the border, and defunding the police are educated white and ADOS liberal women...particularly if single and childless...particularly if self-described as feminists. Between 46-54% of young liberal white women, an overlapping group, have a diagnosed mental illness. This impacts others: most of the 100K plus children who have transitioned gender at least socially describe mom or female peers - almost never dad - as a massive influence (Shrier 2020, etc). This tracks with all previous studies of both Munchausen's and anorexia.
I've gotten in a lot of fights recently for noting this, as I research a probable next book - which is about sex and "gender," and not at all anti-woman. But, this data...is real and does matter. Opening the national boundaries because "Like, we can't NOT" would be far far more damaging to the USA than occasional sex crimes by perverts that most tough men would just burn alive - and I'd bet $500 that any look into who specifically blocked the death penalty for pedos would produce data that tracks with the point above. #book_length_comment
Well, there are levels here.
The most dangerous trans athletes and venue users just are men, and many do have an unusual and arguably "pornified" - perhaps the only time I'll ever use this term - take on womanhood.
The rest of Walsh's point is clearly true.
Quoting @MattWalshBlog: Women support trans ideology more than men and feminism laid the groundwork for the theories of gender that the trans myth is grounded in. This has nothing to do with “men’s rights” or “misogyny.”
Obviously, this was one of the things that led to the trans movement.
People like the President of Harvard were fired, for stating that minor mental and physical differences between men and women...exist.
Quoting @MsMelChen: Women don’t want to hear this but those of you second-wave feminists who pushed gender egalitarianism by denying biological realities between men and women…
The same ones who got offended by and campaigned for James Damore and Lawrence Summers to get fired from Google and Harvard for merely stating that innate differences between women and men result in different outcomes…
You paved the way for a world where women are getting their skulls knocked out by men in sports.
You made the bed, now we all have to lie in it
Next round - with a big shout to the wits in the comments...
"Democracy" - the left winning
"Riot" - peaceful protest
"Deplorable MAGAT" - poor white
"White adjacent" - successful minority
"Trauma" - any bad memory
"Abuse" - normal conflict
"Fascism" - conservatism
"Misinformation" - facts we dislike
"Trans woman" - man/male
Good clear point from a female friend - when Dems say "women's rights," they literally just mean abortion.
The GOP is just objectively far better on women's sport and prisons, transition of girls, trans and gender issues in general, limiting Title 9 abuses of both sexes, business climate, prosecuting VAWG, etc.
Quotes a post by A1775; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There were 36 trans students in a sample of 5,000 people, 1,800 of whom answered in full and about 60% of whom liked rough sex (IIRC).
Really well known sexological study.
There were only 36 trans students on this study, which is really famous.
It says that in your screenshot. All this can be debated, consent is important, etc, etc - but it's just nuts to argue that "all the women here were men" or something.
As a male quant, I would point out that men are male, and we don't need to take the convo any further.
I.e., even if "trans women" could PROVE TO BE the bigger victims - excluding them from (say) women's sport would hurt them more than inclusion would hurt real women - they have no case because they are not women. Cold fact > empathy.
"Trans women" by definition are men, and this person has a rape conviction for a crime vs a woman.
I get that "nightlife cases can be complex," etc - but you literally couldn't make this up and use it as a Monty Python skit. Just too offensive and on the nose.
Quotes a post by T04359; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Oh come on. You can't Even Further Woke your way out of his point.
The obvious point is that you, looking and acting exactly as you did two minutes ago, would be quite annoyed to be perceived as a trans-woman - because a trans woman is a man.
This is the exact reverse of the truth, though. This is like saying whites always win - IN liberal America today.
Imagine a dog park argument between a normal white woman, normal Hispanic Catholic man, and Black "trans woman" with AIDS. Who does The Daily Beast treat w max sympathy?
Just watched this.
Why is the trans-ID'ing man described as the one who feels unsafe?
Also, this seems like more "everything is trauma" b/s. I'm a big guy meself. If a woman doesn't want to ride an elevator with me at night, so what?
Quoting @salltweets: Why are men unsafe when a woman *leaves* an elevator, @[private account]?
There...is no male right to ruler-ship over women. You may feel - accurately enough, despite our overall trend toward gynocratic lunacy - that there is a fair amount of individual sexism in society. But, sex bias in either direction is highly illegal.
As w Blacks, etc, modern radical feminist and gay/trans movements are drawing blowback because they are raging against a thing that does not exist. Adjusted simply for the variables of work people do and hours worked, the M/F pay gap is 1 cent (https://www.payscale.com/research-and-insights/gender-pay-gap/).
One of the oddest claims to come out of the whole trans movement, and the insane level of general "M v. F" sparring today, is that you need a damned doctor's note to tell what sex people are.
Think about this. How would night-clubs or dating apps even work, if it were true? How often have you ever been confused?
Quotes a post by T03380; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is a crazy overall story, and probably my next long article.
Charles, Maud, and 1-2 other friends on the NYC School Board are being consistently attacked for their insistence that "trans girls" are not female and cannot - say - play sports or dress with young women.
After a meeting where multiple parents showed up with male children in dresses to confront @againstgrmrs , my understanding is that at least @[private account] has been removed from the board. #await_details
Quotes a post by A1871; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
He's right on this one. You can't be gay - or trans, etc - as a kid.
Know why? Because you can't be sexual at all as a kid. You literally have no adult "I like to date girls" conception of sexuality whatsoever.
Quotes a post by T09096; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
One of the weirdest things going on in Anthropology right now is that, now that we know beyond a doubt that women warriors existed historically - too many "shield-maidens" to ignore - activists are trying to argue that they were all trans or had DSDs, and thus were men.
The average person seems to "be trans" from 2-5 years, while a teen.
Quoting @buttonslives: 🚨 GROUND-BREAKING NEW STUDY: A long-term study from Germany on insurance data reveals that the majority of youth outgrow their transgender identity, with 72.7% of 15-19-year-old females with a gender identity diagnosis desisting after five years.
Thread and Link Below⬇️
I mean, probably? They're certainly not trans in massive numbers, in urban India.
Computers are still a middle-class on up tool in the LDC world, and women are as freaky as men.
I mean, only .6% of the population is trans, so that wouldn't explain 25% of unique individual searches under any circumstances :).
But, the general trick with these surveys is to have people ID by sex first and gender at most secondarily, and then compare actual M and F.
I mean, only .6% of the population is trans, so that wouldn't explain 25% of unique individual searches under any circumstances :).
But, the general trick with these surveys is to have people ID by sex first and gender at most secondarily, and then compare actual M and F.
The Black pearl at the heart of Wokism is the idea that, if you are in a currently non-dominant social group nothing you do can ever be your fault.
Sparring online this past week, I learned that - if 78% of women support "trans rights" and women have darker fantasies than men on average - this is entirely because men MAKE them feel this way.
More seriously, if Black kids score 159 points behind white sprigs on the SAT, the test must be racist. If it's provably NOT (see Ogbu 2003, etc), and scores track with simple study time at .9, then a racist society is clearly not allowing Black people - ar any income level - time to study.
Etc, etc, in every context. This crap is all nonsense, of course (Sowell: All), but incredibly prevalent and influential.
The problem here is that you have to...prove this^. At present, something like 3% of American young people identify as "trans," and hundreds of thousands have at least socially transitioned (Buttons 2023, IIRC). Rates of transition seem pretty similar across porn users and non-users, the one time I looked for NRO, and very heavily driven by regular social media.
To parse out a "porn effect," you'd basically have to adjust for exposure to social media, exposure to gender studies/Butlerian women's studies ideology in school (probably the giant stat-sig predictor here), peer group contagion, etc, and find a residual role for some niche category of pornography. It's still possible - kids shouldn't watch porn - but it would be putting it very mildly to say that no one has ever done this.
They fear the Appleyard. The very few times I've looked at trans Reddit, people talked about (say) the old Troony Toons account like they were pilots discussing the Red Baron.
The Now Un-Nameable John Derbyshire called this the Cold Civil War 20-25 years ago.
This whole intense "are Black trans women in fact white women" 'moral' debate is taking place entirely among upper-middle class white people. We might jump in for the sane side, but Asian and Black bidness types DO NOT CARE.
Quoting @FischerKing64: The reason anti-white racism persists is that there is a white civil war based on class. Highly educated white professionals don’t like working class whites, see them as rubes, and take out their aggression on them because it’s acceptable. They aren’t allowed to hate anyone else.
Awkward elephant in the room: female feminists are, by far, the group most likely to support gender ideology.
Love you guys, enjoy sparring: but statements like "Once again, men's wants TRIUMPH!" mean 0 unless you're specifically referring to the male 1/2 of trans-ID'd people.
In which I discuss the remarkable fact that 4-5 of the ~50 most recent "true" mass shooters identified as trans or "enby," and propose the novel theory that giving high doses of pure testosterone to mentally ill teenage kids is risky.
Quoting @NRO: .@wil_da_beast630 with two theories regarding recent mass shootings by trans-identifying individuals. https://trib.al/Dbbwbw4
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialmedical harmmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
"Trans women" are men with gender dysphoria.
That's a real condition. We should not abuse citizens with it (or, I suppose, anyone else).
But, these conversations a la "When can girls like ME play women's varsity ball?!" are beyond absurd, and everyone at some level knows this.
The Cass Review - of how "child gender transition" came to happen in the UK and to some extent States - is a must-read.
My perhaps-unexpected position: the "trans kids" types will triple down now. No healthy person could easily admit they just did a bunch of evil for no gain.
Quoting @GoodwinMJ: Just read the Cass Review. If you want to know why ordinary people are sceptical of the "expert class" read it. The supposed experts put ideology before evidence & subjected kids to nothing short of child abuse
https://www.mattgoodwin.org/p/what-they-did-to-children
Errrr...people note constantly that the Black violent crime rate is 2.4x the white VCR (before you adjust for age, SES, etc). This is consistently one of the top-20 topics on post-Elon Twitter.
But, the male VCR is 10x the female, and only one of these facts is relevant to the trans debate.
This sophisticated debate between Copeland and Dawkins as re whether sex is binary or bimodal...does not really matter at all, re the gender debate.
The question re trans-ID'ing people is: "Are YOU inter-sex?" Almost no one is, and an XY male with a penis is simply not an XX female with a vagina.
Quotes a post by T04206; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Y'all notice that at least half of these recent mass shooters are obvious left-wing activists - trans men, climate campaigners, and so forth - and their motivations keep getting coded as "complex and unknowable?"
Quotes a post by T02031; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedcoveruppolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
Expanding on the numbers I used at @genspect, I discuss the insanity of the "trans kids" movement.
Quoting @NRO: We are physically altering thousands of young kids, because they say something that few if any previous societies would have taken seriously. | @wil_da_beast630 https://trib.al/ajP0h4u
New term just dropped.
In this context, "Holocaust denial" or "Holocaust atrocity denial" means denying that...err...the Nazi German Holocaust was heavily focused on trans-ID-ing people.
Quotes a post by T04973; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Why would a female warrior be trans?
Women were 5+% of hunters/warriors in a ton of societies. These people did not, per an extensive overall record, think of themselves as men.
Quotes a post by T05928; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There has apparently been quite a lot of media coverage of my empirical writings on this topic - which are honestly pretty uncontroversial, and based on murder rate data either from the pro-LGBT HRC or various national governments.
Hey - look at this: https://www.foxnews.com/media/trans-genocide-accusations-not-backed-data-political-scientist-says.
Hey - I am an internationally known "anti-trans voice."
Or, everything leftists say is made-up bullshit: you be the judge.
https://www.transgendermap.com/issues/academia/wilfred-reilly/
Worth noting, whenever someone says that "the whole world" recognizes the existence of transgender four year olds or the right of fake asylum claimants to cross all national borders - almost literally NO states in East Asia, the Arab world, Eastern Europe, West Africa, the Sub-Continent, or any other historical rival of the West recognize any of these things.
You're speaking very specifically of <25 suicidal Western powers. So, I mean, there's that.
I shout out MY MAN, and make a broader point: what appears to be obviously true generally is.
Policing reduces crime.
Mandatory gender-ID lessons cause more people to ID as trans.
Strength avoids war.
Etc. If "two partisan Sociology articles" appear to reach conclusions different from "all historical/philosophical/theological/logical understanding of human nature," the latter is still probably correct.
Quoting @NRO: Nayib Bukele’s no-tolerance crackdown on El Salvador’s gangsters produced a predictable result. | @wil_da_beast630 https://trib.al/sxQdG8u
Language itself is, often and very intentionally, a real barrier to frank discussion of this issue.
"Transgender women" here obviously means "males," right - not "females who say they are men?"
Quoting @WashTimes: The lieutenant governor of North Carolina said transgender women should be arrested if they use women's bathrooms. https://trib.al/l9sSBN0
This is actually a great, completely unironic example of how "woke" methodology works.
A: "So, everyone you interview about youth transgender medicine will be a currently trans person, happy with the state of practice and not considering detransition, who is still in contact with their doctor?"
B: "Yes. Who else would be worth talking to?"
Quotes a post by T06500; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
May drop in.
Once again - the trans murder rate is leagues (sometimes orders of magnitude) below the MRs for Black people, poor whites, Hispanics, Southerners, and just men.
When I looked at this for @Quillette years ago, the total number of reported anti-trans murders annually was <30, and almost none were hate crimes.
Quotes a post by T01773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Edgy" conservatives saying things like "Only IQ 105+ tax-payers should be able to vote" have no idea what that would mean in practice.
Here's a list of the average whites-only IQs by state - from a frankly alt-right site that...did not deflate them (highest scores I've ever seen for WVa and KY, although certainly arguable). Take a look at how many populations are over that mark...https://www.unz.com/anepigone/average-white-iq-by-state-2019/.
First trans President when?
3% of young people ID'ing as trans or "enby" is not the result of "us finally diagnosing gender dysphoria correctly," or some such - as vs various paraphilias and plain lying.
Quotes a post by T05346; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I don't like the "posing as transgender" take I'm seeing on these prison stories.
If a heterosexual male rapist is ACTUALLY mentally ill and thinks he is a woman, he still should not be in the women's jail.
Quoting @TimcastNews: Former Female Inmate Says a Man Posing as Transgender Raped Her While Jailed at Rikers Island https://scnr.com/article/former-female-inmate-says-a-man-posing-as-transgender-raped-her-while-jailed-at-rikers-island_a744be5ebb9411ee9c930242ac1c0002
How would you - honestly and anonymously - react to a 50 year old male who insisted in swimming against and changing with your 13 year old daughter during YMCA/Open Water events because this was his "trans truth?"
An obvious logical/amoral conclusion here is that many activist-class trans people want there to be more activist-class trans people.
Quoting @BillboardChris: The cure for gender dysphoria in the vast majority of cases is puberty, itself.
Now we block puberty. We block the cure.
And parents are told to go along with it or their kid will commit suicide.
Porn may play some role with older men, but much of this debate seems to involve "ignoring the very obvious."
A huge part of the reason trans-ID is up 4000% among young people is simply that gender-woo theory developed out of the Studies departments in the 1970s and 1980s, and we now teach it to millions of kids. The Gender Unicorn is in the schools in Appalachia, of all places.
At some level, it is just obviously true that trans identity is not explained by some general variable like "misogyny" - because rates of sexism, marital and overall rape, domestic violence (from both sexes, actually), open corporate glass-ceilingism, etc are down dramatically from say 1970...while trans is almost totally a modern phenomenon.
What we saw with the short-lived "all the experts say" take on "pre-teen transgender health care"/child mutilation was an all-out-blitz attempt by captured organizations to take control of a narrative before the core weaknesses of their position could be revealed.
This failed, and now major players like WHO are admitting there is almost no evidence here and the whole idea of transit young kids seems sketchy-to-insane.
Quoting @SwipeWright: 🚨BREAKING: The @[private account] will not be making any recommendations for children and adolescents, saying that "the evidence base for children and adolescents is limited and variable regarding the longer-term outcomes of gender affirming care for children and adolescents."
This is HUGE!
The thing about Western white liberals isn't that they are aggressively sociopathic - most high-IQ people are, if we put aside lies and rationalizations and look honestly - but that they use classic hyper-aggressive protest/violence/etc strategies almost entirely against their own group interests.
What do I mean? "Queers for Palestine." "Feminists for Trans Freedom." "Labor for Migration." "School and STEM Strike for Climate," ftm. ALL the classic slogans.