The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
A very basic point, from a legal perspective, is that the Civil Rights Act covers whites - to a far more significant degree than gays or trans-identifying people, who were partially added to it by later cases.
It is...illegal to hold public events and bar Caucasians. You guys just have not, until recently, been suing.
I mean...this is a famous stat-sig difference.
I don't mean to mock, but almost every problem ACTUAL feminists complain about - trans issues, mass migration, hood crime, Lila Rose-style abortion policy - would be...way worse if only women voted.
Nothing wrong with chill, strong allies.
Sounds to me like serious trauma might make you question your sexuality in unhealthy ways.
What percentage of "trans men" had frat, hood, or porn-ed out lovers who (non-consensually) referred to them as something a la "my hole," and made them desire the safety of being a tough male warrior? #just_askin
Quotes a post by T04969; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My point here's a bit glib, but makes an important point about "discourse." People, in general, don't want you to Seriously Talk About important issues ("Sure, Israel's crossed the line 1-2x, but their opponents are literally Hamas...") - they want you to briefly glance at an issue and then agree with them.
A: "Why is my gender so important to you?!"
B: "Because you bring it up constantly. You have a trans flag in your twitter and FB bios. We're arguing about 'Trans Day of Remembrance.'"
A: "Well...I didn't expect THIS take!"
This is basically correct. More than three dozen - we can chop this up, if you want to - leading #MeToo activists have endorsed the #HamasRapists.
Committed leftists have no principles separate from their goofball analysis of "power dynamics." Why can a Black guy say "Kill all whites" but a white guy not note the crime rate? Because the Black guy is Black.
Let the Black guy piss off a trans Palestinian tho, and it's a WRAP.
Quotes a post by A1618; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is why so many normal guys always found Hollywood #MeToo annoying.
We knew that the second some group of men ("trans women," migrants) claimed a victim status superior to that of women, the whole thing would collapse- making 80% or whatever of assaults un-pursuable and leaving only unfashionable men to have their lives ruined. #just_sayin
Quoting @bungarsargon: We will never forgive and never forget those who on October 7 flipped from "Believe all women" to "Surely these noble freedom fighters who told us they mass raped Jewish women were lying."
This is a key point.
Even I'd you think - as I suppose I do - that there exist complex exceptions to the sex binary like "hermaphroditism," almost no trans people...have these conditions. 99.9% are simply XY males who ID as females.
Quotes a post by T02499; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Counter: there is no such thing as a "trans child."
That's all I really need to say, but: every single study shows that 69-91% of gender dysphoric children either desist totally or go on to simply become gay. Taking these kids and giving them drugs which block normal puberty, in ways which cause permanent sexual dysfunction, is utterly insane.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is no "trans genocide" or "epidemic of anti-trans murders."
There are at most 30 such murders annually, almost none are hate crimes, most killers are minority men.
Quoting @NRO: The “trans genocide” hysteria is wholly untethered from reality. Here are the numbers to prove it. | By Wilfred Reilly https://trib.al/szSRsiG
One of many opinions on sex/dating/"gender" shared by right-wingers and feminists is that almost no one truly has gender dysphoria - "trans women" are fetishists and perverts inspired by porn or whatever.
Thoughts?
Quoting @MattWalshBlog: As I have been saying for years, in the vast majority of cases “transgenderism” is just a very weird and sexualized form of narcissism. These people don’t care about anyone but themselves.
This actually did happen, though.
Bathroom monitoring isn't a thing I do, but there were a decent number of "passing trans women," like Meghan and ~'Shape Shifter' at Genspect.
This is an interesting point.
I focused on men, because men are ~75% of all murder victims. But, if the government IS going to pretend to care about outliers, why not the 5,000 dead female citizens (many brutally murdered by partners) as vs the 26 "trans women?"
Quotes a post by A2306; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Quoting @Telegraph: 🔴 Roman Emperor was trans, Hertfordshire museum declares
The ill-fated Elagabalus will now be referred to as 'she', although experts say a transgender category did not exist in ancient Rome ⬇ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/11/20/trans-roman-emperor-hitchin-museum-claim-pronouns-woke/?utm_medium=Social&utm_campaign=Echobox&utm_source=Twitter#Echobox=1700508643
If we assume "26" is an accurate figure, and just 1% of the population is trans - recall that the current youth estimate is 3% - the trans murder rate = 26/3.4 million.
That's .76/100,000, or roughly 2.5% of the Black murder rate - and far far below the murder rates for Latinos, whites in the South...and just "men."
Quoting @Breaking911: KJP: "Today, on Transgender Day of Remembrance, we grieve the 26 transgender Americans who were killed this year. Year after year, we see that these victims are disproportionately black women and women of color."
Women did hunt historically, but - looking at the data below - prevalence ranged from 6% to ~15%, if we're talking about significant representation and larger animals. Male hunters out-numbered female 10:1.
There's something silly about taking this "Well, there were SOME riot grrrrls" finding - and arguing either that ancient societies were feminist OR that all these women were actually trans.
Quotes a post by T07512; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Recent debates aside, it just simply is true that the huge majority of social science "theory" from the Studies Fields - including most feminist theory and ~all trans/queer theory - is unfalsifiable qualitative bullshit.
@[private account] Almost invariably. Every time I've gotten into a serious argument with one or had one jump in DMS, "trans girl sex worker" - or some such - comes up almost immediately.
I think giving any "trans aid" to kids, of any kind, ever, is nuts. Men can't ever be women.
I also think calls to criminalize (or close) male dress-wearing are nuts - and these began days before some specific troll tweet or people reading and anger-quoting this guy's book.
There are a lot of wildly hostile comments here.
I obviously agree men should not be in women's spaces- or vice versa - but a lot of people seem to basically think no one should ever present as trans of gender-non-conforming publicly.
Regardless of who you side with in the war, it's absolutely astonishing to see global leaders behaving in this schoolgirl fashion ("Trans women ARE women!!! Trans...").
You're the fucking United Nations. Privately call both leaders to the table. This went out across social media? What are you DOING?!
Quotes a post by T08730; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Didn't expect this, did you?
The CTB team recently set down with @[private account] to discuss a range of issues - recent controversies, whether he would ever use women's spaces, and...perhaps more importantly...why he thinks more than 50% of "trans women" are autogynephiles who don't have gender dysphoria at all.
Quotes a post by T06744; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This, which seems pretty obvious to me, is the basic argument that feminism - Judith Butler, etc - has a lot to do with modern gender theory.
The reason for the 10,000% growth in youth trans identity isn't "porn" or whatever - it's the fact that whole academic departments and NGOs teach this stuff. There are handouts and flag posters in every school.
Quotes a post by A2733; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No one specific target here, but I'm reading through some of these Genspect debate posts...and frankly a bit surprised by the level of "All men who ID as trans are 'porn-sick' perverts, which is unsurprising, because most men PERIOD are perverts who do not deserve us!"
Is this supposed to be some kind of weird gotcha? About 80% of men and 55% of women sometimes watch porn - and, for the rest of the ladies, "50 Shades" is the 4th (?) best-selling book of the century. This has been pretty constant since the 1980s.
But, that's the...point, right? Trans and "queer" youth identities haven't surged 240% since 2010 "because porn exists."
I...mostly blame the massive diffusion of gender ideology, through curricula in every 2nd school (Gender Unicorn, Genderbread Man), whole departments of Gender/Women's Studies, YouTube, influencers like Dylan Mulvaney (literal face of Bud Light), etc.
Older AGP types may sometimes be influenced by porn, but IIRC 3.9% of ALL US/UK young people say they are trans or enby, and porn consumption doesn't influence rate-of-ID much if at all.
This really is the logic of "equity."
During a 'the races go back and forth conversation the other day, I mentioned rates of mental illness and trans identification among young whites. A Black therapist chimed in, 129% unironically, with "We underdiagnosed."
"All must be sick and slow, Harrison."
Quotes a post by T05388; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans Awareness Month is different from Gay Pride Month, Trans Pride Month (these can be co-celebrated), Transgender Awareness Day, National Coming Out Day, National Pronouns Day, and Pride Fall, correct?
I mean, if you're trying to be serious about this, there was never any Palestinian state. "Palestine" was part of the oppressed British protectorate of Trans-Jordan. Following WW2, Britain gave Israel to the Jews, gave the larger Jordan to the Palestinian Arabs, and provided substantial funds for relocation. Further, Israel made all Arabs on their then-lands Israeli citizens: Israel today is 21% Arab.
People in territories later acquired via war, like the West Bank, have some legit beefs...but these are self-governing regions that have been offered independent statehood 7 times. #just_sayin
Factual statement with no "moral" component: one reason men tend to laugh at the trans phenomenon is that high-T feminists spent the last 50 years breaking into male rooms with names like "The Sacred St. Joseph's Italian-Men's Only Golf Club - One Day's Relief from the Family!"
"What kind of MALE PERVERT would notice and critique Pink Slit Jeans - a (trans) woman-owned young women's brand distinguished by that one bright ass-level stripe down each side of our pants?!!"
@[private account] There are 12 studies I'm aware of on "trans kids." Every single one finds that, if left alone, between 69-91% of gender-nonconforming youths just go on to be gay or Prince - they're quite happy and no longer ID as trans at all.
The catch here is that what Birdie's describing is what the "genocide" is.
"Trans genocide" literally just means stuff like gay kids not being transitioned.
Quotes a post by A2812; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Random comment: the unspoken trans bathroom rule, forever, was that people with actual gender dysphoria, who "passed," used whatever bathroom they wanted to.
It was very specifically the "post-Charlotte" battle between self-ID activists and right-wingers that made this a thing.
I don't believe you think all the men and 1/2 (?) the women in this thread are Evil Perverts. This technique ("Who would NOTICE a trans woman in an women's spa") is ~just done to shut people up.
But, nah: this isn't a big issue of mine, but free citizens can talmbout anything.
@[private account] Hasn't been my experience at ALL. I spar with them re HBD, but every crazy threat mob I've gotten has been standard SJWs or trans rights folks.
Different issue tho. Not many frogs are going to skillfully sync your face onto words from another published article as a viral post.
The two options when it comes to trans people and "trans kids" are not full affirmation or suicide. As so often, there is no evidence whatsoever for this common claim.
Most recent study I've seen tracked 3,700 trans-ID'ing people for years and recorded 12 suicides.
Quotes a post by T05695; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.