The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
The three things the transgender movement cannot abide and must destroy:
—Pluralism, which protects the right to belief and unbelief
—Liberalism, which protects the right to free speech and conscience
—Democracy, which holds that the will of the people should rule
Quotes a post by A1617; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There’s a thing people do where they put a paraphrase into quotes on Twitter in a parodic way. I do it too.
When it comes to trans activist messaging, the actual direct quote just says what the parody would say.
Quoting @JamieWhistle: The Trans News Network shares their thoughts post election, “We must be willing to deceive and manipulate liberal politicians, pollsters, and journalists the same way they treat us. Pocket their concessions, then run roughshod over them.”
No trans-identified person is banned from playing sport. They must play the sport that corresponds to the material fact of their sex because male bodies, which all trans-identified men have, cannot compete fairly against female bodies. "Freedom" does not mean that other people and institutions must pretend that a person's belief that they are something they are not is true. Everyone else must play sports that conforms to their sex; there is no special exemption for people who mimic the opposite sex.
Quotes a post by T43433; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The three things that transgender ideology cannot withstand and must overturn:
— pluralism, which protects the freedom of belief and disbelief
— liberalism, which protects freedom of speech and conscience
— democracy, which says the basis of government is the will of the people
Quotes a post by T32880; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The key point in this strategy is to trigger fanatics like Erin Reed into lashing out at you -- this reframes you as a moderate, and gives you leverage to define moderation. Over time, you used this label to redefine moderation to encompass -- all trans activist goals, with some of them rebranded.
Washington state progressive with a trans ex married to another Washington state progressive with a trans ex explains why they both voted for the referendum restricting girls sports to girls.
"It seems to us that the uninformed ones are those like you who refuse to understand our position that under no circumstances are we ok with someone who has or ever has had a penis being on a girls or women only sports team."
"We can't all have everything we want. This is where we draw the line. You need to accept that your position is wildly unpopular across basically all voting strata and if you don't like the mechanism of enforcement the propose another way to accomplish the same wildly popular goal."
No lies detected.
Quotes a post by T38598; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yglesias laid out the playbook for how to win trans rights in 2022 and 2023. You stay mum about your support for whatever is unpopular, fake support for whatever is popular, and then evolve toward full support as the public evolves to your position through a process of negative partisanship.
Folx like Talarico and Annie Andrews are executing his playbook.
Andrews put out a TV ad saying: "I don’t support biological men playing women’s sports, and I don’t support and haven’t ever performed gender surgery for minors."
Andrews of course was never asked about whether she supports freezing 8-year old boys in a pre-pubertal state or putting teenage girls on steroids, and she was never asked if she would vote for legislation restricting athletic competition by sex, and she was never asked if she supports teachers using a cross-gender name and pronouns for a child without parental notice or consent.
And she was never asked whether she now disavows this 2023 tweet that she never took down, in which she casts herself as morally virtuous for her uncritical support of transing children and others who have reservations about this as "assholes."
She was never given an opportunity to say "you know, I said a lot of things that I didn't understand and I've learned a lot since then about the problems with the medical evidence about medicalizing children."
She wasn't given the opportunity to say it and the chances that she would say it are essentially nil. She wouldn't have said it, and won't say it, because people who put out tweets like this are not curious about the underlying relying.
They are not good faith seekers after the truth who really care about whether what they are saying is true, or whether their agenda is actually helping the people they claim to be helpful -- they are apparatchiks running a playbook of politically expedient deceit in order to gain power and push through their agendas.
https://x.com/annieandrewsmd/status/1632502770073837570?s=46
Quoting @AnnieAndrewsMD: Periodic reminder that I support trans kids because I am not an asshole. 🏳️⚧️
Conservatives have trouble of thinking of trans as something other than weird nonsense you can mock out of existence rather than the legitimizing mythology of a multi-billion dollar NGO complex
The way you win on trans issues is you find ways to allow people to register their preferences on the discrete issues, untethered to other issues or partisan affiliations, and you seek input from the largest possible constituency. This is why state referenda in Washington, Colorado, and Arizona passed.
This is why the Missouri ballot initiative that bundled restrictions on pediatric gender medicine with abortion restriction was the only such measure to fail -- and why it absolutely does not count as a repudiation of restriction of pediatric gender medicine, but does count as an instance of bumbling by conservatives producing failure.
Quoting @ProtectKidsCO: The people of Colorado have spoken. The children of Colorado have WON!
Three propositions. Three victories. One incredible grassroots movement. We’re just getting started.
THANK YOU, COLORADO! 🙌🏼
Newsom explained the fundamental antagonism at work here. Trans inclusion is zero sum with safety, privacy, comfort, and fairness for women. He was speaking about sports, but it applies generally. To grant the former is to compromise the latter, and only desperate sophistry or campaigns of state repression that punish people for knowing and saying otherwise can prevent this from being manifest in policy.
There is no "moving the culture leftward" through persuasion: there is only seizing sufficient power to silence those with whom you disagree, a group that will always have a critical mass because the antagonism that Newsom identifies is real and irreducible.
Quotes a post by T07851; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Washington and Colorado banned trans inclusion in women's sports
Deep Red States elected trans-identified legislators.
Trans-identified candidates in Blue States all campaigned on rolling back state restrictions on trans activists movement goals.
Trans-identified candidates in Red States all campaigned on affordability and economics.
Quotes a post by T42285; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
David vs Goliath.
Goliath is the mega-billionaire-funded Trans Activist NGO Borg doing all it can to stamp out the will of the people, high on its own supply of moral righteousness and rendered insensate to the myriad harms they are inflicting in the process.
David is ordinary people trusting the American democracy can be made to work on behalf of the will of the people.
Can it?
Quotes a post by A1775; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
52 percent of the voters who delivered a historic bloodbath to the GOP told pollsters that transgender rights have gone too far.
Voters in Washington state and Colorado voted to ban trans inclusion in women's sports.
Democrats who moderated on trans in their advertising and messaging ran the table.
This means that the Supreme Court has a constitutional duty that the framers saw as just as important as thwarting majoritarian tyranny: preventing powerful minority factions from thwarting the legitimate will of the majority.
The Democrats are resolved to fend off the popular will, including that of their own voters, for another generation, in spite of widespread opposition to their agenda, as they did with affirmative action, which lost eight out of nine state ballot initiatives, was persistently unpopular, and remained entrenched in elite institutions for decades before the Supreme Court found that race-conscious admissions programs at Harvard and UNC violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.
The Court has a responsibility to protect the rights of women to privacy and bodily dignity. It has a responsibility to ensure women's equal rights to educational opportunity and the rights of parents to direct the upbringing of their children.
It also has a duty to protect majority rights when a powerful minority threatens the rights of individual citizens who happen to comprise a majority.
Democracy, after all, is a system designed to ensure that majorities rule. Constitutional rights limit that power; they do not confer upon minorities a general right to rule in its place.
The majority of Americans who want to keep a naked man out of a woman's locker room must prevail over the powerful minority of Americans that want to give him a right to be there and punish the women who want him out.
If democracy is to mean anything, a powerful faction cannot be in a position to thwart that will forever. It falls to the Court to protect a woman's right to privacy—and, in the process, to protect the right of the people to govern themselves.
Quoting @wesyang: A man with a visible erection showering in a women’s locker room of a community pool announced that he was trans and was permitted to remain, in accordance with Washington state law that forbids any women from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman
Dems who moderated on trans (often insincerely, but nonetheless putting themselves on the record taking sane positions) are running the table while the 6th most Democratic state in America, Washington, has voted to ban men in women's sports.
It was important to depolarize this issue. The moment when the source of the most intense negative polarization, Donald Trump, is likely to go into rapid eclipse is as good time for that to happen as any.
We now know from the Washington results that while most of the party leadership, including its ostensibly moderate figures (such as Josh Shapiro) are full on gender cultists, the rank and file are not.
Now, more than a decade after the launch of this misbegotten crusade, we can finally begin the deliberative process that the movement forbade because it knew that its dogmas could not survive any adversarial scrutiny. We can ask aloud, and also answer, questions like: "Is this true?" "Can it be accommodated at tolerable cost?" "What is a gender identity, anyway?"
At the end of this process, we will discover that the only moderate approach is the refusal of all trans activist demands because all the movement's demands are extreme.
Quoting @benryanwriter: 1:15am ET update: Dems have won 21 of 21 races called in which the candidates went against the transgender platform
The latest wins:
Christina Bohannan: IA-1, wins against Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meek
Rep. Henry Cuellar: TX-28, wins against Tano Tijerina
Rep. Tom Suozzi: NY-3, wins against Mike LiPetri
In an October ad Ms. Bohannan said: “As the only one in this race who ran track in high school, it matters to me that girls’ sports are fair,” suggesting that she opposed cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports.
Mr. Cuellar @[private account] ast a number of votes for bills that would counter the main tenets of transgender activism, including those that would make it a violation of Title IX for schools receiving federal funds to permit cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports; the two 2026 Mace amendments; HR 2616; and HR 498, which would bar coverage of gender-transition interventions by Medicaid for minors.
In November 2024, @[private account] told The New York Times: “The Democrats have to stop pandering to the far left.” He further said: “I don’t want to discriminate against anybody, but I don’t think biological boys should be playing in girls’ sports.” And then he finally said: “Democrats aren’t saying that, and they should be.” He also voted for the 2025 service-academy amendment.
For all the details of these and other races, see the link in the quote tweet:
Amidst a historic GOP bloodbath, the 6th and 12th most Democratic states in America appear poised to ban trans inclusion in women's sports
Quoting @wesyang: The men in women's sports ballot initiatives in two Blue states are looking good.
Washington voted Harris +18 in 2024; Colorado voted Harris +11.
Yet Washington's measure restricting males from girls' school sports is getting 56% support, compared with 52% for Colorado's.
In King County (Seattle), 43% support the ban, compared with just 29% in Denver.
The more Democratic state is showing greater support for the restriction—even in its largest metropolitan county.
Washington is the 6th most Democratic state in America.
A comfortable victory there means victories in less Democratic states such as California, New York, Minnesota, Illinois, New Mexico, Maine are very plausible.
Right now -- Senate is already lost for R's, however
-- Moderating on trans is looking like a great strategy for the D's who did it, thus committing the party to less dogmatism on the issue.
https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/2117806828134318274?a=Y3GQ20LdMZa9ToHTS5g&s=20
Quoting @benryanwriter: Transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed has established Josh Turkek, the Dem running for Senate in Iowa, as her bête noire for his stance on trans issues, her number one she wants to lose.
With 16% of the vote in, he is at 62.2% to 35.4% for Hinson.
I get a fraction of the engagement under Elon's X than I used to get under Woke Twitter. (About 1/3.)
I found this puzzling. But the story is increasingly clear: when trans activists learned that posts and accounts are throttled when they are widely blocked, muted, and downranked, they organized a network of thousands of NPC's to do this to gender critical posts.
Trans activist dominated online discourse for a decade through policies of explicit bans. When they lost the ability to do that, they found a loophole in X's content ranking algorithm to suppress their opponents through coordinated activity.
This surely can't be what X intended for its policies, and the site should be looking for ways to fix this.
Quotes a post by A0267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
None of the politicians across the United States, Canada, Britain, Australia, and New Zealand working tirelessly to embed transgender dogmas into law can answer this question without melting down. None. That none of them has been subjected to the same degree of scrutiny that Rowling is subjecting a random reply girl is entirely the function of a media across the entire Anglophone world that is unified in evading this scrutiny. Not one member of those institutions can themselves answer this question without melting down.
Quoting @jk_rowling: You haven't once told me what makes a man a woman. This is pretty fundamental stuff. You believe some men are women. The very least that should be expected is that you can answer what makes a man a woman.
I think most of the Dem apostates on trans who aren't entirely faking it will just have one meeting with Sarah McBride and cave totally. But they've already shown you're allowed to say something (I oppose boys in girls sports) that necessarily commits anyone saying to the true proposition that trans girls are boys.
De-partisanizing the issue is important. Much of the moderation is fake and cosmetic, but even fake moderation widens the Overton Window, perhaps at some point, wide enough for the truth get in.
The truth is that the moderate position on trans is to refuse all trans activist demands, because all trans activist demands are extreme.
It will take a long time and a lot of back forth before we get to this realization. But because it is truth and the truth can only be held back through repression, and repression delegitimatizes the repressive force over time, we will get there someday. The question is how long it will take: the USSR lasted for about a single human lifespan.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Fake moderation by the Dems on the trans issue has really worked.
At some point, fake moderation has to become real moderation.
And real moderation on the trans issue means refusing every demand of the transgender movement because forcing people to pretend that other people are who they are pretending to be but are not is an extreme incursion on the most basic liberty any of us has.
Quotes a post by T06512; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans women in women's sports is a top tier issue for humanity because it's a proxy for the following questions:
-- Are we liberal society? (Or are we a progressive authoritarian society?)
-- Are we a pluralistic society? (Or are we social justice theocracy?)
-- Are we a democratic society? (Or are we governed by the unrepresentative consensus of a tiny, delusional elite?)
-- Are we a reason-based society? (Or are we a cargo cult that worships idols?)
-- Are we a reality-based society? (Or do we treat falsehoods as truths when told by people in power that it is virtuous to do so?)
-- Can we put a stop to obvious insanity? (Or are we in the thrall of ridiculous dogmas that no one can dispute because a powerful lobby calls it virtuous to clap along to absurdities and cruelties that destroy fairness?)
Yes, trans ideology is the terminal stage of one lopsided vision of the relation between the individual and the collective -- in which all are subordinated to each. Every man a tyrant, all of society his subjects.
Quotes a post by A2987; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"In 2022, an elderly woman, Julie Jaman, was showering at her local YMCA when she heard a male voice in the locker room. She then observed a young male employee, who identifies as a woman, watching little girls pull down their bathing suits to use the toilet. Jaman complained to the management, and she was banned from the YMCA for life."
Thread on what trans inclusion looks like in practice
https://x.com/ErinFriday75490/status/2117439457540620532?a=LrXtEx1B5rKFCw-bk-U&s=20
Quotes a post by A0924; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I am not a single-issue anti-gender inquisition voter. but the best outcome for those who oppose the gender inquisition is:
-- GOP retains control of Senate (and judicial appointments)
-- Democrats like Josh Turek and Amy Acton win -- putting prominent Democrat official who are on record opposing key dogmas of the gender inquisition, and thus helping to departisanize an issue that must be departisanized
-- Washington and Colorado referendums against trans inclusion in girls sports win
If the only thing that happens is the referendums pass, those who oppose the gender inquisition should be relatively happy
Jailing parents for not agreeing their daughter is a son is exactly what the transgender inquisition seeks everywhere in the world and what it will impose wherever it obtains power
Quoting @joannaccherry: After the incoherent & Orwellian evidence given by witnesses to the pre-legislative scrutiny committee yesterday this report with its cogent legal analysis is a breath of fresh air - Parents ‘could face jail’ for saying no to gender transition, PM warned.
https://www.thetimes.com/article/e779c341-6b28-4476-a9fb-76e9c2220a73?shareToken=10686a7e310ef40068459c4bac6803c1
A man with a visible erection showering in a women’s locker room of a community pool announced that he was trans and was permitted to remain, in accordance with Washington state law that forbids any women from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman
Quotes a post by A0924; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Of course there would not be "stacks of complaints" in a military that has made clear through its JAG's that it gives a right to trans soldiers to be included and none have a duty to conform for other people's comforts. It is in the courts today because a relentless lobby supported by the prior administration has limitless resources to litigate.
Pennsylvania is sure to make it an actionable infraction to call a man a man if the man says he is a woman if the Democratic party regains control of the legislature. Josh Shapiro promised to codify "trans rights" into law (all trans rights are imperious demands for special rights to violate sex-based boundaries granted to a privileged caste) and to ensure that no one can prevent the chemical castration and dismemberment of confused children caught up in the ongoing social contagion that figures like Admiral Rachel Levine oversaw a whole of government effort to propagate as widely as possible under the Biden Administration.
Shapiro, who is often cited as the model of Democratic moderation, has a record of permitting no daylight between himself and the most extreme trans activist.
Quoting @MegEBrock: Democrat Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro pledged to protect “our trans children” and welcomed Admiral Rachel Levine back to the Governor’s mansion at his fourth annual pride reception, video obtained by The Daily Wire shows.
DEI Training for Judge Advocate Generals who serve as legal advisors to US Army officers on policy and practice advised that every soldier must be instructed to expect to encounter penises in the women's barracks, showers, and bathrooms, and vaginas in the men's barracks, showers, and bathrooms:
"4. “Understand anyone may encounter individuals in barracks, bathrooms, or shower facilities with physical characteristics of the opposite sex despite having the same gender marker in DEERS.”
5. “All Soldiers should be respectful of the privacy and modesty concerns of others. However, transgender Soldiers are not required or expected to modify or adjust their behavior based on the fact that they do not ‘match’ other Soldiers.”
@[private account] obtained and published these materials for a long article in his Substack documenting the priority placed on identity-based accommodations and mandates by the Biden Administration, including long disquisitions on the dangers and harms of microaggressions in the military.
Microaggressions listed in the training, which was given by a trainer with the rank of colonel, included asking a trans-identified person if they've gotten surgery, making accurate references to a person's sex to any person engaged in the falsification of their sex, (calling a man a man or using the pronouns "he" to refer to him), or saying "being gay is no big deal.”
Identity-based accommodations included: race, sex, and sexual identity-based preferences in assignments and promotions, and command-level support for chemically castrating the confused children of soldiers.
The military was used by Truman as a vehicle for promoting racial integration after the Second World Warm when integration meant allowing black people to serve alongside white people.
The military was used by Biden as a vehicle for the replacement of the standard emphases on individual merit, uniform standards, and mission-focused cohesion with group-based preferences, self-ID accommodations, and sensitivity to “microaggressions” in the age of transgender accommodation, when "integration" was replaced by "inclusion" -- that is to say by forcing people to falsify reality on behalf of another person's claim to be something they are not.
All "trans rights" are imperious demands for entitlements accorded to a privileged caste at the expense of the actual rights of others.
All "trans rights" are demands that state and judicial power be deployed to destroy the rights of any person who won't falsify reality of behalf of any person claiming to be the sex they are not.
Quotes a post by T21564; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Transgender Inquisition is global and seeks the same power everywhere: it seeks to make calling a man a man if the man says he is a woman punishable by the state or judicial system.
Colorado joins California and New York in embedding this demand of the movement into law. But the global movement is unitary and will impose the same mandates wherever it obtains the power to do so.
Quotes a post by A0606; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"You must not misgender your rapist" is the law being enforced in Germany.
Transgender inclusion requires nothing less.
Quoting @reduxx: GERMANY: A teenage rape victim was reportedly questioned after accidentally referring to her transgender rapist with male pronouns in court.
The girl was forced to clarify that she did not mean to "misgender" her rapist.
https://reduxx.info/germany-teenage-rape-victim-was-questioned-by-lawyer-of-transgender-rapist-for-misgendering-him-in-court/
Amy Hamm is a nurse who was subjected to a yearslong inquisition by the state authorized entity that regulates and licenses nurses in British Columbia, driven out of her livelihood, and charged $94K for the administrative cost of the destruction of her livelihood.
They found her guilty of "unprofessional conduct" for saying "Human Beings Cannot Change Sex," and putting up a billboard saying "I love JK Rowling."
Hamm is Patient Zero in the Orwellian shock treatment that the Transgender Inquisition is working tirelessly to impose everywhere in the world.
"Trans Rights" are the right for any person engaged in the falsification of their sex to invoke state and judicial power to destroy the livelihood of anyone who declines to join in the falsification or resists the false dogmas that buttress those acts of falsification.
The British Columbia Supreme Court now confronts the opportunity to ratify and entrench this nightmare into law, or to place a limit on it.
Quoting @preta_6: November 10, 12 & 13: The dates of my appeal trial at the BC Supreme Court.
I am appealing a ruling that found me guilty of "unprofessional conduct" for advocating for the rights of women and children in my off-duty time.
My regulator, the BC College of Nurses, investigated me at the behest of a cancellation mob after receiving complaints from members of the public I've never met. I have never had a patient complaint. I was dragged through years of disciplinary hearings, lasting longer than a murder trial. (My fight was made possible by @JCCFCanada and @[private account].)
After my guilty verdict, I was told I would face a 1 month suspension and had to pay $94,000 to the BCCNM. My employer of 13 years, Vancouver Coastal Health, fired me with no severance, and no way to even collect EI. I was a single mom with 2 young boys. The suspension and $94k was put on hold for the appeal. My name is blacklisted and I essentially was pushed out of the profession entirely.
I first noticed the rise of gender ideology a decade ago, and I was fascinated and repulsed that women were being told to shut up about their experiences to make way for people who identify as us. Then I came to understand that paediatric "gender affirming care" is a terrible medical scandal, probably worse than the lobotomy. I began to write about the topic and, with another BC woman, began to organize events to discuss gender ideology. We faced vicious threats, protests, and attempts to shut us down. Later, of course, I was involved in a billboard project that drew a lot of ire from trans activists.
Never could I have imagined that life would go in this direction: being smeared as a bigot across the country; losing my career and long-term financial stability; and spending 6+ years in a protracted legal battle.
I'm still fighting because I care about the truth, free speech (for all of us, but especially for regulated professionals, who don't deserve to be policed in their private lives and forced to go along with state orthodoxy), and women's rights. Please follow along for updates.
(To be clear, neither state documentation nor any form of medicalization or diagnosis is required in most Blue states for access to any cross-sex segregated space — just that anyone who has meet these bars is of course far beyond question in any trans affirming setting.)
https://slate.com/culture/2012/10/jewish-jocks-and-renee-richards-the-life-of-the-transsexual-tennis-legend.html "If I’d had surgery at the age of 22, and then at 24 went on the tour, no genetic woman in the world would have been able to come close to me. And so I’ve reconsidered my opinion." - Renee Richards, the first trans-identified male to play a professional women's sports
The NYT referred to the man who murdered his Oberlin professor father and his wife as a "son" and used "he/him" pronouns throughout its coverage. (He is male.)
Other outlets are referring to him by using they/them pronouns and referring to him as the professor's "child." (He told the court he is "gender neutral" and goes by the name "Asia.")
Underscores the fact that a "trans person" is any person who claims a cross-sex identity or another "gender identity" other than their sex with no reference to any anatomical or chromosomal fact about themselves, and that the population of troubled, mentally comorbid young people drawn into trans identification heavily overlaps with the population of troubled, mentally ill young people capable of committing serious violence such that anytime a middle-class young person under the age of 30 has killed someone, a reasonable question to ask is: "What are their pronouns?"
Quoting @mtracey: Bizarre situation happening in Ohio where an Oberlin professor and his wife were just found murdered, and the suspect (his son) had to be carried in and out of court like this
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcrime casedenialmedia pronoun complaintmental illnessviolence terror
Sometimes people throw the fact that @martina was coached by a trans-identified male for a few years in her face when she forthrightly opposes the inclusion of men in women's sports. But Renee Richards, now 92, regrets winning the first lawsuit conferring a right onto a man to compete in women's sports.
In addition to coaching Martina, Renee Richards went on to the women's doubles' finals at the 1977 US Open and went on to rank among the top 20 best players in the world in the women's division, starting his professional career at the age of 43.
It seems the author of the new book about Richards was seeking to celebrate a pioneering transfeminine athlete and was frustrated to discover that Richards simply considered the issue of trans inclusion in sports on its merits:
""We know more than we did in the 70s, although still not enough," the book's author notes, expressing frustration that Richards does not connect today's attacks on trans sports with those directed at the entire community."
The transgender movement in the US knows that its attempted public roll-out was a bust. The strategy is to return to stealth manipulation of administrative law and judge-made law.
The EU never diverged from this strategy.
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: One of the most shocking aspects of the transgender takeover of women's rights in Europe is that at an EU level, almost nobody is aware that it's going on.
The very people who are voting to queer EU law and policy aren't even aware they are doing it.
Brussels media has largely complied with the activist-enforced omerta on discussing it. The bureaucrats themselves, the ones responsible for the erasure of sex in law (particularly via strategic litigation projects) don't want anyone to know what they are up to.
This Atena event (Tuesday 3 Nov) is an opportunity for Brussels to find out what's really been going on.
I'll be tweeting it all live. Tune in from 6PM.
None of the brazen assaults on the most basic rights that Blue states have made routine in the name of trans affirmation has received any coverage at all in the mainstream press. Most of the world will be learning about them for the first time when the Supreme Court addresses them.
Expect a rushed recitation of gaslighting propaganda right before oral arguments.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is scarcely any difference between an adversarial expose of "LGBTQ history" and the celebrations of it being blasted out by its advocates.
Here we have a woman who pretends to be a man glorying in how trans-affirming her death from AIDS will be.
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: A despicable early trans masc influencer, Lou Sullivan
It is trivially easy to prove that gender clinicians routinely violate criminal law in order to engage in billing fraud in order to fund the chemical castration of confused children because 1.) the clinicians advertise their use of fraudulent billing codes on their websites, 2.) trans activist academics write approvingly of such practices in peer-reviewed papers, 3.) a major hospital paid $10 million to avoid billing fraud prosecution, and 4.) anyone who calls and pretends to be a parent seeking to chemically castrate their 11 year old child will be told in confidence that the clinic engages in billing fraud.
It couldn't be more self-evident that this is an openly embraced, not at all hidden practices that occurs routinely. Now it's just a matter of prosecuting this serious crime it at the scale of its commission.
Quotes a post by A0381; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It should not surprise anyone that the transgender NGO network is operating as a criminal conspiracy to violate the law across half the country that has banned the chemical castration of confused children caught up in the social contagion that the transgender NGO network is propagating.
Parents brainwashed into believing that chemical castration is evidence-based, medically necessary, lifesaving healthcare" of course will do anything to prevent their children from committing suicide (despite the fact that ACLU lead trans rights litigator Chase Strangio admitted that there is no evidence that puberty blockers prevent suicide) and a vast network of NGO's stands ready to violate the law. Transgender clinicians have been openly violating criminal laws against billing fraud as an openly avowed part of their practice for more than a decade -- deceit and lawbreaking have always been foundational parts of transgender medicine.
Quoting @buttonslives: NEW UNDERCOVER INVESTIGATION: I spent several months investigating a nationwide network of advocacy organizations and medical providers helping families continue medically transitioning their children in defiance of state laws.
My investigation centers on Campaign for Southern Equality (CSE), an LGBT advocacy nonprofit that connects families with cooperating medical providers across the country. CSE has distributed over $1 million in travel grants to more than 1,200 families, plus another $1 million to partner organizations, including funding for medical appointments.
With CSE's knowledge, providers in its referral network told me the ways that they circumvent state restrictions on gender-transition treatments for minors.
Some discussed using alternative diagnosis codes, such as “endocrine disorder,” to facilitate prescriptions or insurance coverage. Others described mailing medications directly to families' homes or sending prescriptions to pharmacies in states where these interventions are banned.
Providers also discussed conducting virtual appointments with patients in those states. Others required patients to cross state lines for telehealth but did not appear to have a reliable method for verifying their physical location.
My primary undercover scenario involved an 11-year-old girl in Tennessee who had only recently begun identifying as nonbinary, with no long history of gender-related distress. The providers I shared this scenario with seemed eager to treat her. Many indicated that puberty blockers could be prescribed after an initial evaluation lasting just one to several hours.
My investigation uncovered practices that may violate state and federal laws and pose medical risks to children living hundreds or thousands of miles from their treating physicians.
Read my full @[private account] investigation: https://www.city-journal.org/article/pediatric-gender-transition-treatments-bans
The vast majority of trans-identified people do not pass and the majority of them do no medicalize. The reason to seek a birth certificate change is to claim the right to cross sex-based boundaries despite not passing.
As usual, mainstream media has uncritically broadcast Trans Activist propaganda as fact on an important public controversy.
The public has an opportunity to reject this gaslighting at the ballot box.
Quoting @LeorSapir: A social media platform accurately fact-checking @[private account] raises the question: whence the darkness in which democracy dies?
Detransitioners threaten the sacramental enchantment with which Talarico has imbued the figure of the transgender child. They harsh his buzz. From his position of legislature power, he acted to spite and thwart their quest for medical assistance to partially (for that is all can be done) heal from the grotesque harms that gender doctors inflict on children and denied them an audience.
Quotes a post by A2664; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My point would be that even if your worst speculation was true, it's a hazard of being trans (and of sex integration generally) that is best resolved by separation. If other girls aren't going to dispute the accusations, it's because they want him gone. Nobody asked the girls if they were comfortable with a boy in their changing room. The boy mattered more than them. His comfort mattered, theirs didn't. These matters are inextricably zero sum, and must eventually be resolved by majority will.
There is no blood libel. When you make no effort to distinguish between "real trans people" and obvious perverts and psychos (not that any are "real", but there was once a basic effort not to affirm and medicalize obvious perverts and psychos) you create this problem. That's my point and nobody reasonable can dispute it.
I was indulging your baseless speculation that the accusation were groundless. Of course we have no reason to assume this apart from your partiality toward a trans identified male.
It's him using the term "genocide," you using the term "fascist" and the mass murderer who posed with a gun that he used to kill eight people with a trans flag around its muzzle and sent it to is trans-identified male friend in US who egged him on. QED.
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
Basically any doctor that is involved with transitioning a child will likely lie. This might mean every trans identified male student athlete has a doctor who lies for him.
https://x.com/MrAndyNgo/status/2114901060162646339?a=hFdkWk323C2DVFMMTgM&s=20
I'll tweet it out now.
1.) There is no definition of a "trans person" other than "someone who claims to be the sex they are not."
"Being trans" requires no psychological gatekeeping on principle; indeed, the practice of differential diagnosis has given way to its opposite, compelled affirmation by any and all, including "medical professionals" whose duty is to accept any person's claim to be the sex they are not, and start them on a course of hormonal interventions with volatile effects on cognition and mood if the person requests it.
2.) Transgender identities have always been mentally comorbid with other mood and personality disorders and sexual paraphilias (which cluster). There is a high incidence of autism, depression, anxiety, disordered eating and cutting in this mentally comorbid cohort, along with suicidal ideation.
3.) Transgender identities are rebellious and oppositional adolescent postures that naturally attract troubled and disaffected children with identity issues. Indeed, rather than being seen by clinicians as the product of other comorbidities, wherever it is claimed, "minority stress" becomes the favored explanation for all other comorbidities, with social affirmation and gender medicalization being prioritized, leaving other diagnoses and treatments for the underlying distress that manifests as trans identity unaddressed. Trans identification piles atop all these unaddressed problems, the inherent stresses and difficulties of making your self-esteem radically dependent on others accepting you as something you are not, making daily life a gauntlet of humiliations for the vast majority of trans identified people who do not pass as the sex they are not.
4.) Adopting a transgender identity comes with a host of social and political privileges and immunities; you acquire the right to violate sex-based boundaries based on a claim to be something you are not; you obtain deference to imperious demands that other people affirm an inner conception of yourself that you claim to have. It's a great tool to bully and control other people and a great way to extract special treatment either compelled by law or offered voluntarily by believers in transgender dogmas and therefore exerts a gravitational pull not just on fragile narcissists seeking to buttress a weak and dissociated sense of self but also on malignant narcissists and psychopaths who will flow toward social affordance that grants them power over others.
5.) The movement relies on emotional blackmail and threats of suicide in the first instance -- when parents are told that failure to consent to transgender medicalization presents a virtual certainty of suicide -- and relies on hysterical, histrionic, hyperbole claims to create ingroup solidarity through a compelling LARP and to extract further tribute from the political apparatus in thrall to them. Transgender ideologues routinely equate excluding men from women's volleyball teams or domestic violence shelters or accurate verbal references to the material fact of a person's sex with "genocide," thereby teaching troubled and mentally comorbid young people that mass violence is self-defense against genocide.
The photo on the left is of two of one of two film director brothers who began claiming to be women after immersion in transgender porn and BDSM subcultures claiming that JK Rowling's exclusion of men from a women's domestic violence shelter is genocidal. The photo on the right is of an 18-year old who had been affirmed as a "girl" since the age of 12, an intervention purported to protect him against the risk of suicide, who murdered his murder and brother and six people at a middle school in a rural town in British Columbia.
The photo of him posing with a gun with a trans flag wrapped around its muzzle was sent right before his murder rampage to another trans-identified male in the US, who egged him on in reply, who has been charged as a co-conspirator in the murder. US prosecutors released the photo which Canadian police hid. Canadian media continues to refer to both the mass murderer and his accomplice as "women," honoring the gender identities of two male "partners in crime," since affirming transgender identities takes priority over providing a factual account of who the murderers of Canadian children actually are.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: The DOJ is seeking research grant applications from scholars wanting to research what’s behind the rise in violence from trans-identified people. There have been many killings and threats of m—rder from that small demographic. https://thepostmillennial.com/doj-offers-1-million-federal-grant-for-study-on-trans-crime?utm_campaign=64470
One of Chase Strangio's virtues is her honesty. She is always making admissions against interest. She doesn't pretend to be a man, she is merely "trans", thus unsettling a core tenet of the trans-medicalist paradigm that she was forced to defend before SCOTUS. When trans-identified prisoners asked for a separate wing in the men's prisons, Strangio plowed ahead with placing them in women's prisons because she didn't consider a wing in the men's prisons to be affirming enough. We know this because Strangio told the New Yorker this. She admitted before SCOTUS that there is no evidence that puberty blocking kids reduces suicide. She admitted before SCOTUS that transgender identities are not immutable but can change over time, conceding that yet another key tenet of the trans-medicalist paradigm she was defending is untrue, and also that the entire basis for claiming to be a discrete minority group to whom a right of recognition can be conferred by a court is untrue.
Here, Strangio admits that her purpose in seeking to propagate child transition is to build a cadre of children to "organize for liberation." When I pointed out that one of the purposes of transgenderism was to manufacture an army of biologically altered social justice super soldiers on a medical leash who had sacrificed everything to a cause in childhood and lived in total dependency on a political party to secure the conditions of their recognition as that which they were not and could never be, it was at least partly a rhetorical provocation.
But as usual, Strangio was years ahead of me in claiming it her explicit goal all along.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Defending trans ideology makes smart people stupid, scrupulous people unscrupulous, and honest people into liars. Once you see it, you can never unsee it -- and you will never not see it, because it is always, without exception, what happens.
It cannot be otherwise because defending the most self-evident bullshit ever enshrined into law is beyond the capacities of even the most brilliant person, and there is no way to persist in it without recourse to sophistry and lies. When you tell someone deeply invested in their own goodness that membership in the sorority of the good requires them to defend the worst nonsense of the age, the result is always a scandal of some dimension.
This is the most comically picayune of all such scandals, but it shares in common many key aspect of the great ongoing scandals that has left thousands of confused children sexually dysfunctional, sterilized, and on a medical leash for life (in addition to being explicitly aimed at the propagation of that scandal.)
Quotes a post by T06909; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Key point:
"The only reason medical verification is needed at all is that these states have allowed falsification of birth certificates, driver's licenses and other ID so that the drafters of the ballot language could not simply rely on them."
The ultimate purpose of all the transgender movement's moves is to bury reality beyond the reach of recovery.
Quotes a post by A0381; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Nothing is funnier than the "Do you even know any trans people??!" rejoinder -- as if seeing a self-evident mental comorbidity masquerading as an identity up close doesn't make the self-evident mental comorbidity at the root of the imposture more rather than less self-evident
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Some folx claimed that if the pro-Palestinian contingent successfully tanked the election and gave it to Donald Trump, that would do the opposite of endearing them to Democrats. It's unclear whether Palestine hurt Biden in the 2024 election, but certainly some pro-Palestine types have been eager to take credit for it. And we can know for sure that this group's power is vastly greatly today it was before the election.
While of course trans activists and allies lack the numbers to tank any election and hand it to the GOP, I do think their loud advocacy for tanking the election will not endear them to Democrats.
"If you put on a Harry Potter costume this Halloween, you are NOT an ally to the trans community."
Noted.
(It's OK to not be an ally of the trans community.)
Quoting @DefiantLs: JK Rowling trolled them so hard that Harry Potter isn't even an option for them 😂
The Colorado and Washington state voter referendums are the single best chance that anyone will ever have to turn the tide on the trans issue in Blue States.
Polling shows that clear majorities of Democrats join with strong majorities of independents and overwhelming majorities of Republicans in opposing the imposition of men and boys into girls and women's sports and the chemical castration of confused children.
Democrats have until now obstinately refused to represent the views of their own voters -- this is the best chance for all voters to register their preferences on this question and this question alone, apart from their other partisan and policy commitments. If they answer the question on the merits, and avoid being propagandized by gaslighting campaigns (such as false claims that sex verification requires "genital checks"), they have a golden opportunity that may not come again to remove this divisive issue from the political agenda by resolving it through an act of popular will.
A great many Democrats -- indeed a majority of them -- will be relieved if and when this happens.
Quoting @Erin4Parents: We now have at least EIGHT Democrat candidates, all in red states, publicly breaking with their party on aspects of gender ideology—including men in women’s sports, taxpayer-funded sex changes, and secret school transition.
➡️ They see the writing on the wall: a cultural shift is underway, and they want to win.
*** @jonahowheeler went first in a purple state. He’s a rare exception because his convictions are genuine.
Trans ideology is a religious cult that demands absolute fealty. It is a house of cards built on lies and ultimately cannot withstand dissent.
But the TRUE test will be Democrats in BLUE states breaking with their party on these issues.
That will require a cultural shift in a blue state — voters sending a clear message that they no longer support these policies.
Colorado is that litmus test.
If Props 134 and 135 pass, Colorado will become the first blue-state domino to fall.
We MUST pass Prop 134 & 135❕
The Associated Press and NPR both referred to Chase Strangio as the first "out" or "openly" transgender person to argue before SCOTUS, a practice that is standard across media.
According to your definition here, it's impossible for there to have already been a Trans President because it's impossible to be a closeted trans person -- that it is to say that a necessary condition of being a trans woman is having once been a man who is now a woman because he tells people to refer to him as one.
But most middle-aged male cross-dressers who declare themselves to be woman claim to have known they were trans from earliest childhood. According to dogmas that are being taught to millions of schoolchildren, your doctor merely made a guess about what your gender identity might be based on an anatomical clue and assigned you a sex at birth that may or may not align with who you really were.
(Which is why we are now socially transitioning and puberty blocking young children, to spare them years or decades "in the closet", as well as ensuring that puberty does not deny them the female-presenting appearance that they seek in order to be perceived as their true self.)
If this process happened to prior Presidents, then of course one or many of them might have been trans women who remained in the closet throughout the duration of their lives while hiding their true selves from a transphobic, cisnormative world.
Do you reject claims of Rachel Levine and Brianna Wu and Jessica Riedl and to have been women since earliest childhood and say they only "became trans" when they began claiming to be women?
That is to say, do you believe that there is no inherency in who and what is trans, that trans is just an activity that some people engage in at their discretion? If so, what is the basis of declaring them to be a minority group at all, or to install protections for them in law?
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
According to your definition here, it's impossible to be a closeted trans person. But most middle-aged male cross-dressers who declare themselves to be woman claim to have known they were trans from earliest childhood. (Which is why we are now socially transitioning and puberty blocking young children.) Do you reject claims of Rachel Levine and Brianna Wu to have been women since earliest childhood and say they only became trans when they began claiming to be women? That is to say, that there is no inherency in who and what is trans, just an activity that some people engage in that must nonetheless be treated as the basis for recognition in law?
NPR, the Associated Press, and others all referred to Chase Strangio as the first "out" or "openly" transgender person to argue before SCOTUS. This is standard nomenclature whenever discussing the first transgender person to do anything.
Pro-Palestine activists who sought to tank the Democrats and hand the election to Donald Trump wanted to gain veto power over the issue within the party. They succeeded.
Transgender activists hoping to tank Democratic Congressional candidates making moderates noises on trans issues want to prevent the loss of the veto power they have had over the issue until this election cycle.
Even in the likely event that Turek and Kaptur don't make good on their election messaging on trans issues, their victory will mean the end of the embargo on Democrats explicitly rejecting some trans activist demands.
The end of that embargo means that eventually someone will actually mean it when they say the oppose men in women's sports or public funding for cosmetic surgeries for people seeking to mimic the opposite sex. They will mean it because not all Democrats have joined the gender cult -- indeed a solid majority of them have not.
Eventually someone will muster the courage to represent the will of the majority of Democratic voters.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Infuriated transgender activists are hoping that Democratic candidates in red areas who have taken stands against cross-sex sports participation or even federal funding for gender-transition treatment will lose. Victory by such candidates, activists such as Harvard Law School clinical instructor and trans activist Alejandra Caraballo fear, could further erode the transgender movement’s political capital. Losses, on the other hand, could provide an opportunity to blame their positions on trans issues.
Biden actually had a history as a moderate who rose to power opposing busing and was a leading advocate for the Crime Bill of 1996. But he outsourced immigration and domestic policy entirely to the Borg and did not refuse the most extreme transgender, BLM, or open borders activist a single demand.
Talarico is as woke as a human being can be and has made only the most perfunctory gestures of moderation, which he is on tape assuring people are fake. https://x.com/GSmiley247/status/2114451206168830212?s=20
Quotes a post by T33704; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal fined a former school trustee $750K for resisting the imposition of a transgender brainwashing curriculum onto every public school in the province. What "Queer and Trans people" fear is that every child in the province will stop being propagandized to believe that a boy can have a vagina and girl can have a penis. What they fear is that the Human Rights Tribunal will cease inflicting ruinous penalties on people for declining to falsify reality.
They understand, accurately, that when the state stops punishing people for declining to affirm falsehoods, people will decline to affirm falsehoods. They know that their social movements cannot survive without state repression.
Quotes a post by T05159; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hopefully Stuart is wrong but he is knowledgeable about the province's politics. The incoming Premiere is on record saying that the transgender propagandizing of schoolchildren should end, but we'll see if he's willing to expend political capital toward that end. https://x.com/stuartlosaltos/status/2114258163260088534?s=20
Quotes a post by T22994; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Pedestrian traffic signal near the National Gallery in London is a conjoined male-female signal meant to signify state fealty to and promotion of transgender identities. They have been in place since 2016 at fifty crosswalks around Trafalgar Square.
Seeing this ad underscore with what gingerness and restraint the GOP has treated messaging on this issue. It would be trivially easy for them to create a compilation of disgusting men brandishing their erections in women's restrooms or as, in this case, saying "I'm allowed to be in here...I'm transgender" while masturbating in a Planet Fitness locker room.
But their restraint created an opening to be mogged by a made up propaganda scenario that nonetheless underscores how frightening it is for women to encounter strange men in their private spaces.
https://x.com/listen2tish/status/2007959774604984591/video/1
Quotes a post by T06292; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Protester ejected from a women's soccer game for provoking an assault against herself by wearing a shirt asserting a true fact is abandoned mid-ride by a Lyft driver and then expelled from the Lyft platform itself despite earlier claims that the driver would be disciplined her mid-ride.
This is the world that the Transgender Inquisition is working tirelessly to create for everyone.
Quotes a post by A2593; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"What makes this fraudulent bad actor 'transgender'?"
What makes anyone transgender?
The whole point of the transgender movement is to demand social and legal recognition of anyone who claims to be something they are not as the thing they are not based solely on the claim to be the thing they are not because the movement defined the term "woman" to mean "anyone who says they are a woman."
He was only arrested for falsely claiming to be a teenager, not for falsely claiming to be a girl. But he is not more of a girl than he is a teen. He is neither. He is an adult male sex offender. He would not be either a girl or a teen if he wasn't a sex offender because he is an adult male. Both of his false claims would remain false if he was a law-abiding citizen. They would both be equally false if he was the assistant secretary of the department of Health and Human Services. They would both be equally false if he was an elected member of the House of Representatives.
One of these false attestations got him in trouble with the law. The other is legally compulsory for everyone to affirm. If you tried to deny this adult male sex offender access to a ladies room in Minnesota , it would you be that violated and you that would be arrested for harassment in Minnesota.
Quoting @reduxx: A transgender sex offender has been arrested in Minnesota after posing as a teen girl to try and enroll at a local high school.
"Makayla" Alec Ray Craig, who identifies as a female cat, had previously been arrested for the same crime in Oregon last year.
https://reduxx.info/transgender-sex-offender-caught-attempting-to-register-at-minnesota-high-school-as-a-teen-girl/
When people assault you for wearing clothes emblazoned with slogans stating a true fact and security expels you for provoking the assault by wearing clothes emblazoned with slogans stating a true fact: this is the world that the Transgender Inquisition intends to impose everywhere.
Quotes a post by A2749; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Expelled by security for wearing a shirt emblazoned with the true statement that there are only two sexes. This is the telos toward which trans activism was always aimed.
Quoting @BrandiKruse: In 2026, this is how women are treated for peacefully standing up for their rights. There was no way I was going to leave that stadium of my own free will. We did nothing wrong.
The NYT continues to accept the framing of the transgender rights movement as a civil rights cause rather than the medical scandal, scientific fraud, and cannibalistic raid on the rights of other groups that it is.
Despite this, the paper is routinely blamed by the trans rights establishment for the many political and legal setbacks it has faced for having done nothing other than covering in a fairly cursory fashion the absence of any real evidence behind the claim that pediatric gender medicine is evidence-based.
There is something to this ascription of responsibility to the Times because even one deviation, however perfunctory, from the script threatens to expose the endemic fraud at the foundation of the entire edifice.
The blame directed at the Times exhibits a realistic understanding that the movement is not a movement like other movements that can withstand adversarial scrutiny along some dimensions: like the actual people caught up in its dogmas, it is either the subject of uncritical affirmation at all times, or it is simply a thing pretending to be something it is not, spouting easily debunked falsehoods upon which everything depends requiring total loyalty at all times to prevent reality from entering the picture and exposing the foundational debility of all its claims.
Quoting @JamieWhistle: I have never seen the @nytimes report on suspected billing fraud or breaking of the state laws restricting puberty blockers, cross sex hormones, or surgery (in children). I have never seen investigations from the Times like these from @LeorSapir
https://www.city-journal.org/article/oregon-transgender-puberty-blocker-hormones
A generational effort to manufacture someone able to break the mold and establish a new fairy tale, just ends up being ludicrously on the nose and impossible to hide -- typical of all trans activist efforts
"My sexual orientation is an attraction to misogyny." Hunter Schaefer was being unusually candid about autogynephilic desire in his diary. This was not something scripted by his adversaries. This was something he said while in a confessional mood. Not that we need his confession to know this -- the etiology of this inescapably male sexual fetish has been exhaustively documented.
What's striking about it is that Hunter Schaefer is the entire purpose of propagating the myth of the trans child -- the puberty blocking experiment aimed at the manufacture of adult males who look like pretty teenaged girls who could be paraded around on television as proof that the middle-aged autogynephile was always a girl on the inside and just needed to be frozen in a pre-pubertal state to pass as a girl.
An unstated premise of this was the hope that you'd replace the population of hulking men in dresses who need their jaws broken and their ribcages shattered to resemble uncanny valley early generation AI women with folx who look like Hunter Schaefer -- "real girls" who have disappeared into their cross-sex identities, not men consumed by bizarre paraphilias. But Schaefer was too honest and couldn't help but publicize the fact that he too seeks in his mimicry of women the consummation of his sexual desire to be consumed by misogyny.
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: Hunter Schafer, a man, said he feels like a woman because of an "attraction to misogyny" and a "need to be used by men", and trans activists are responding by saying this is a normal experience for women.
1. He's a man with a fetish
2. Women aren't defined by misogyny and being used by men
3. I can't believe this even has to be said - that a man can claim to be a woman explicitly because he hates us, and he is the one who is taken seriously, while women who disagree are called hateful
Anyone who says "trans people must have the same rights as everyone else" is refusing the entire "trans rights" agenda because all "trans rights" (apart from those already granted) are imperious demands for special privileges granted to a favored caste seeking to violate sex-based boundaries.
I agree completely that trans people should have the same rights as everyone else, and no more -- and that they already have them.
"You kill trans people by suicide..." Yes, it's only you that thinks that saying no to a movement's imperious demands makes the refuser responsible for what people do to themselves when they don't get their way, and gives you a right to kill in retaliation -- that's your own brilliant moral reasoning and not the reasoning shared by the whole movement.
https://x.com/Tratuits1/status/2113541640618942628?s=20
Quotes a post by T17400; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I tweeted that before this is over there would likely be a Trans Weather Underground, a Trans Jonestown, and a Trans Manson Family -- and literally a week later, news came out of a murder of a border agent at the Canadian border. Not long afterward, we learned that the border agent's killer was a member of a cult of vegan AI Doomers, most of whom were trans-identified, that also were linked to seven other murders.
I am not claiming any particular prescience about this -- millions of people were told that chemically castrating and dismembering themselves was evidence-based and lifesaving medicine that children need in order to live, that feeling like a woman is what makes a woman a woman and that men who feel like women are women, and that excluding men from women's changing rooms is Nazi-like bigotry.
While the dominant political party of institutional America will deploy the coercive power of the state against anyone who resists this agenda, it should not surprise anyone that some factions among the overwhelmingly mentally comorbid category of persons who took refuge in these falsehoods are impatient for political victories that may never come and will seek catharsis by seeding the suicide contagion that the movement's messaging is aimed at inducing in its followers, or the acts of insurrectionary violence that its adherents are constantly fantasizing about.
Quoting @KDansky: People need to know the truth about "trans." Andy's book is a great resource.
This is what I said by way of endorsing it:
"Our society is not prepared for the violence likely to be unleashed because of the lie that sex is not real or that it doesn't matter. This book tells one story of the deadly violence that has already occurred because of that lie."
C3 dehumanizingdenialmedical harmmental illnesssuicide tauntviolence terror
The ACLU is committed to both free speech and Trans activism. Trans activism requires the destruction of free speech. It's no surprise that a they/them working for the ACLU opposes free speech.
Quoting @jessesingal: Who would have thought someone who doesn't believe in free speech or the rule of law would have been a bad fit for the ACLU? Really shocking stuff here! Anyway I'm sure lessons will be learned.
https://www.indystar.com/story/news/politics/2026/10/22/indiana-aclu-in-turmoil-leadership-change-leads-to-attorney-resignations/92136571007/?taid=6ad9f73ee84f6e000170341b&utm_campaign=trueanthem&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter
Brazil is doing what the Transgender Inquisition intends to do everywhere it possesses the power to do it. It is working tirelessly everywhere to obtain that power -- in the European Union, in Canada, in Australia, in New Zealand, and the United States. It will gain this power wherever it is not stopped.
Quoting @ADFIntl: 🇧🇷 BREAKING: Brazil is attempting to reopen a case against Isadora Borges, a veterinary student who previously faced up to 10 YEARS in prison for 'transphobia'.
Her only "crime" was a social media post, stating what we all know to be true: Men cannot become women.
By seeking to reopen this case, Brazil is showing once again that it will go to great lengths to silence speech it doesn’t like.
If the court agrees to reopen the case, Isadora will once again face trial, with a potential 10-year prison sentence for nothing more than stating biological facts.
👇 Read our full release:
As I said, there is absolutely nothing in the fake mailer that any trans activist opposes. It is merely a restatement of what trans activists are working tirelessly to enact in every Blue states. https://x.com/EliErlick/status/2112913121128173692?s=20
Quotes a post by T00074; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedideology cultstate takes children
"There is nothing in it that is actually bad."
The mailer is fake -- it is somebody's false flag -- but it accurately represents what trans NGO's and state legislators believe and are doing.
The express and explicit purpose of trans sanctuary state laws across Blue America is to create a trans Underground Railroad for those being denied medicalization by non-affirming parents or state laws.
There is nothing in it that any trans activist would disavow, and nothing in it that any trans activist isn't working tirelessly to enact.
Hard to know how it will affect the election -- whether it's a GOP psyop or a TRA psyop. It may end up discrediting actual documented realities once it is declared a hoax. (It is a hoax, but only in its provenance, not in its claims.)
Quoting @SaraHigdon: The interesting thing about this fake mailer hoax in Texas is it could have been either side. Someone on the right could have done it thinking it would scare people into voting against the Dems. But also someone on the left could have done it because they knew it would be shown as a hoax, and blamed on the GOP.
It is clear though that these were meant to be opened by parents, and cause controversy before the election. I’m not sure this constitutes election interference, but crazy times we live in where nothing is real.
C2 false claimshand-codedconspiracypolitical enemystate takes children
Hmm, who is better off mentally -- the person who cut off his genitals to affirm a belief that can never be true, or the person who notes that it's unhealthy to cut off your genitals to affirm a belief that can be true?
It must be the person noting it! Ha ha! What an incredibly clever rhetorical inversion I've come up with!
Oh wait -- you're saying it's the same rote, copypasted inversion that trans activists and allies always do? Oh. Right.
Quotes a post by T01486; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Every study finding "evidence" that medical transition is beneficial is like 53 people sent a questionnaire two years after transition with a 40 percent loss to follow up rate.
Meanwhile, Finland has rigorously tracked the mental health of every single patient who received gender medicalization over decades in the entire country and found that the rate at which patients required mental health treatment more than doubled after transition.
The study is orders of magnitude larger and more methodologically rigorous than anything ever attempted by those claiming transition is medically necessary and lifesaving. And yet trans activists pretend that the vastly stronger study is weaker than their collection of hundreds of laughably weak, underpowered, and self-evidently tendentious studies. Any multiple of zero is zero.
Quoting @BillboardChris: The entire premise of ‘gender transition’ is a fraud.
After cross-sex hormones and surgery, the share of young Finns needing psychiatric care went from 19% to 49%!
Finland tracked every young person sent to its gender clinics, for up to 25 years. Among those given cross-sex hormones or surgery, 19.2% had needed specialist psychiatric care before their first clinic visit. After their last procedure, 48.9% did. Their matched peers stayed flat.
We were told cross-sex hormones and surgery would fix these young people's mental health. Finland checked. After the drugs and the surgery, far more of them needed psychiatric care, not fewer.
What Finland found
Finland sends every young person who wants a medical "gender reassignment" to one of two university hospital clinics, in Helsinki and Tampere. Researchers led by Dr. Sami-Matti Ruuska, an adolescent psychiatrist, and Prof. Riittakerttu Kaltiala, a professor of adolescent psychiatry at Tampere University, pulled the national health records for every one of them.
That's 2,083 people under 23 who went to those clinics between 1996 and 2019. Each was matched with eight people of the same birth year and hometown, 16,643 in all. Some were followed for up to 25 years.
The new numbers
Critics claimed the first analysis might have counted people who hadn't had their drugs or surgery yet. So in September the authors ran it again, starting the clock only after each person's last step: cross-sex hormones, breast removal, or genital surgery.
•Before their first gender-clinic visit, 19.2% had needed specialist psychiatric care.
•At some point after their last procedure, 48.9% did.
•Their matched peers, counted from the same dates, went from 14.4% to 13.2%.
After their last procedure, these young people were about six times as likely as the general population to need specialist psychiatric care. That held for both males and females.
https://www.billboardchris.com/news/2026-10-18-finland-study-psychiatric-care
If the people of Colorado, saddled with one of the most extreme trans activist legislatures in the world, are able to make their voices heard, and make the first inroads for reason and reality in any Blue state, it will truly be a sign that real change is coming. The dominos could fall very quickly soon thereafter.
Quoting @MorrellMDmph: Didn’t think I’d live to see it.
Colorado’s #1 paper, @[private account] printed an op-ed in favor of protecting girls’ sports and kids from permanent surgery!!!!
Colorado and Washington are on track to make girls’ sports fair—get out and vote! Bring your friends!
@ProtectKidsCO
“Trans activism sought access to medical interventions while simultaneously arguing that transgender identity was not pathological.”
Trans activism is built on an endless series of fractal self-contradictions.
-- "It is healthy and natural to destroy the functioning of crucial biological systems."
-- "You become your true self by pretending to be something you can never be."
-- "You actually are the thing you are not -- look we've redefined the word to encompass both a thing and its opposite."
If you notice the contradiction, you are a bigot.
Quoting @Bernard_Lane: “Gay rights sought freedom from psychiatric and medical interventions,” Dr Stella O’Malley said. “Trans activism sought access to medical interventions while simultaneously arguing that transgender identity was not pathological.”
Link below.
The most telling part of this exchange is not Wu's instant recourse to calling gay men pedophiles.
It's his response to someone saying he respects women's boundaries.
To Brianna Wu, respecting a woman's boundaries is "trans hating."
Think about it.
Does he have a point?
Can you affirm transgenderism while respecting a woman's boundaries?
You can't, can you?
Quoting @wesyang: "Reasonable moderate transsexual" Brianna Wu lashes out at a gay man saying he respects women's boundaries by accusing gay men of being pedophiles
Most trans-identified males don't seek reassignment to women's prisons. You have to think about why: homosexual transsexuals want to be with men and often have boyfriends. Autogynephilic straight males (and just straight fakers) want to be with women.
When Chase Strangio asked trans-identified prisoners what they wanted, they said they wanted their own separate wing in the men's prisons. Strangio rejected this request because it wasn't affirming enough.
There is some ambiguity about the sex of the trans-identified neo-Nazi who plotted a mass murder at a Hindu temple. NBC News reported that the judge ordered the continuation of the cross-sex hormones he is taking for the purpose of gender affirmation while in jail, but did not specify whether he is taking male or female hormones. All the court documents refer to him as male, but Illinois has a policy of colluding in the sex falsification of any man who says he is a woman and any woman who says she is a man.
The reason I think this is likely an MTF is that an early transitioning male would be growing his hair out while a woman pretending to be a man would cut her hair off.
Quotes a post by A0364; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You get seven trans kids in one family because "trans kids know who they are" and "social contagion is a transphobic myth" and because there is no definition of "trans" other than "says they are the sex they are not."
Canada is perhaps the most trans-affirming country in the world. It propagandizes its children from earliest age that any of them can change sex and places anyone caught up in the ensuing social contagion onto a conveyor belt to chemical castration. The oppressive force the ostensible beneficiaries of this state mandated, whole of society effort are railing against are simply the constraints of reality itself.
What has not already been done that these people demand? That other people retain their right to disbelieve their claims to be something they are not is all that remains to be done at scale. That is what the transgender movement seeks everywhere -- to use repressive state power to punish those who won't pretend that their false claims are true.
Quoting @OliLondonTV: 🇨🇦Transgender woman claims there is a trans “crisis” in Canada.
“There’s a decrease in people coming out and sharing who they are. People are going back in the closet. People are detransitioning for their safety.”
Do you think a murderous trans-identified neo-Nazi jailed for plotting a massacre in a Hindu temple should be receiving taxpayer funded estrogen shots to affirm his gender?
The ACLU should send a questionnaire to every Democratic candidate with the following question:
Do you think a murderous trans-identified neo-Nazi jailed for plotting a massacre in a Hindu temple should be receiving taxpayer funded estrogen shots to affirm his gender?
Reasonable Moderate Trans-Identified Male Brianna Wu schools Noah Smith on the dangers of allowing a murderous male neo-Nazi who plotted a massacre at a Hindu temple (and has almost certainly not undergone castration) to go without cross-sex hormone injections in jail https://x.com/BriannaWu/status/2111148856498880932
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The institutional authority and resources that transgender cultists hijacked from the country's most prestigious hospitals was a crucial part of the movement's power. Though the practice of chemically castrating and dismembering confused children continues apace in small clinics, that authority is well on its way to being lost.
Quotes a post by A0381; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When they need you to be a white man to feed a narrative and absolve trans-medicalization of any influence, you become a white man.
When you merely murdered a bunch of schoolchildren after posing with a rifle with a sticker with trans colors wrapped around the barrel, you must be affirmed as a woman.
(They are both white men.)
Quoting @libbyemmons: The New York Times isn't using preferred pronouns for the trans would-be mass shooter who wanted to kill Indians in Illinois, but they do use preferred pronouns for the trans school shooter in Tumbler Ridge.
Could the use of preferred pronouns be ideological? 👀
This article refers to court documents referring to him by his prior name without saying the prior name (Nicholas John). It refers to him being detained in a men's federal (because he is a man) prison without having established that "Sophie Roske", who showed up at Supreme Court Justice's house with a rifle, is a man. It does not refer to the fact that the federal judge who sentenced him to a mere 8 years in prisons (sentencing guidelines recommend 30) did so while citing Trump's executive order requiring prisons to house male convicts by their sex as reasons for shortening the sentence from what it otherwise would have been. (With time served he will be ought in three years.) It did not refer to the judge saying she was "heartened" that this murder plot resulted in his family affirming his transgender identity.
Through all this "Sophie Roske" was referred to solely as a "woman". . https://x.com/Kat_Highsmith/status/2110806268864782426?s=20
Quotes a post by A1555; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There does seem to be a nonzero chance that this is a woman on T pretending to be male . All the police and court documents say he is male, but Illinois is one of the state most captured by trans activism. Let's wait and see -- it will have to come out eventually.
And the latest in a series of murder plots by trans-identified males... https://x.com/wesyang/status/2110753242325897720?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: The 19-year-old white supremacist planning a mass murder at a Hindu temple in Illinois was transgender.
NBC News Chicago refers to him throughout the story as a male and by he/him pronouns while noting that he "receives hormone injections for gender transition."
Meanwhile, Canadian newspapers continue to refer to both the 18-year old man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia and the US-based male charged as his co-conspirator solely as women, honoring the preferred pronouns of both murderer and co-conspirator, with no reference to their sex or their trans identification.
All of these people are men.
C2 false claimshand-codedmotive displacementshooter attributionviolence terror
https://chicago.suntimes.com/crime/2026/10/14/palatine-man-19-plotted-a-mass-shooting-penned-manifesto-targeting-hindu-place-of-worship-police Chicago Sun-Times support omits reference to transgender hormones that the killer was taking that were reported by NBC News
Interesting that the story omits his trans identity and medicalization https://x.com/wesyang/status/2110753242325897720?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: The 19-year-old white supremacist planning a mass murder at a Hindu temple in Illinois was transgender.
NBC News Chicago refers to him throughout the story as a male and by he/him pronouns while noting that he "receives hormone injections for gender transition."
Meanwhile, Canadian newspapers continue to refer to both the 18-year old man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia and the US-based male charged as his co-conspirator solely as women, honoring the preferred pronouns of both murderer and co-conspirator, with no reference to their sex or their trans identification.
All of these people are men.
Robin Westman, who killed two children and wounded 18 in a Minneapolis church, said that he was "tired of being trans, I wish I never brain-washed myself," and went on to say that "I regret being trans… I wish I was a girl I just know I cannot achieve that body with the technology we have today. I also can’t afford that,” and “Gender and weed [expletive] up my head”
https://x.com/rentedillusions/status/2110784508190454226?s=20
Quotes a post by T32094; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Clarification: the 19-year old man who plotted a mass murderer in an Illinois Hindu temple is a man who is taking female gender hormones to transition to a woman.
All of the press is disregarding his gender identity and referring to him as a male (he is male) with he/him pronouns rather than their standard practice of referring to male mass murders who say they are women with she/her pronouns. (NPR actually scolded Amy Klobuchar for calling a trans-identified male who murdered two children in a church as "a man.")
C2 false claimshand-codedmedia pronoun complaintmotive displacementshooter attributionviolence terror
Mentally ill youth are being incentivized to identity into transgender identity, an "identity" with no distinguishing characteristics or differential diagnosis other than "says they are the sex they are not." This is why it always reasonable to ask of any young person crazy enough to kill strangers: "what are his pronouns?"
The point here is not that trans identification causes mass murder but that transgender ideation is one mental health comorbidity that accompanies other mental health comorbidities and a mental health comorbidity that is "treated" by affirmation as something that the sufferer is not and manipulation of the endocrine system in ways that have volatile effects on mood and emotional regulation. Thus the underlying problem both festers unaddressed and is instead greeted with further ensnarement in a set of false solutions that exacerbates rather than quells the problem.
He is trans https://x.com/wesyang/status/2110753242325897720?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: The 19-year-old white supremacist planning a mass murder at a Hindu temple in Illinois was transgender.
NBC News Chicago refers to him throughout the story as a male and by he/him pronouns while noting that he "receives hormone injections for gender transition."
Meanwhile, Canadian newspapers continue to refer to both the 18-year old man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia and the US-based male charged as his co-conspirator solely as women, honoring the preferred pronouns of both murderer and co-conspirator, with no reference to their sex or their trans identification.
All of these people are men.
The rule is basically: if there's a racist motive to your mass murder plot, you are detransitioned by the media and become a white male.
If it's just a bunch of children at your local school, you remain a stunning and brave woman whose trans-identity is honored and whose sex is deliberately hidden.
He is trans https://x.com/wesyang/status/2110753242325897720?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: The 19-year-old white supremacist planning a mass murder at a Hindu temple in Illinois was transgender.
NBC News Chicago refers to him throughout the story as a male and by he/him pronouns while noting that he "receives hormone injections for gender transition."
Meanwhile, Canadian newspapers continue to refer to both the 18-year old man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia and the US-based male charged as his co-conspirator solely as women, honoring the preferred pronouns of both murderer and co-conspirator, with no reference to their sex or their trans identification.
All of these people are men.
He is trans https://x.com/wesyang/status/2110753242325897720?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: The 19-year-old white supremacist planning a mass murder at a Hindu temple in Illinois was transgender.
NBC News Chicago refers to him throughout the story as a male and by he/him pronouns while noting that he "receives hormone injections for gender transition."
Meanwhile, Canadian newspapers continue to refer to both the 18-year old man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia and the US-based male charged as his co-conspirator solely as women, honoring the preferred pronouns of both murderer and co-conspirator, with no reference to their sex or their trans identification.
All of these people are men.
He is trans https://x.com/wesyang/status/2110753242325897720?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: The 19-year-old white supremacist planning a mass murder at a Hindu temple in Illinois was transgender.
NBC News Chicago refers to him throughout the story as a male and by he/him pronouns while noting that he "receives hormone injections for gender transition."
Meanwhile, Canadian newspapers continue to refer to both the 18-year old man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia and the US-based male charged as his co-conspirator solely as women, honoring the preferred pronouns of both murderer and co-conspirator, with no reference to their sex or their trans identification.
All of these people are men.
C2 false claimshand-codeddenialmedia pronoun complaintshooter attributionviolence terror
He was trans and on cross-sex hormones https://x.com/wesyang/status/2110753242325897720?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: The 19-year-old white supremacist planning a mass murder at a Hindu temple in Illinois was transgender.
NBC News Chicago refers to him throughout the story as a male and by he/him pronouns while noting that he "receives hormone injections for gender transition."
Meanwhile, Canadian newspapers continue to refer to both the 18-year old man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia and the US-based male charged as his co-conspirator solely as women, honoring the preferred pronouns of both murderer and co-conspirator, with no reference to their sex or their trans identification.
All of these people are men.
The 19-year-old white supremacist planning a mass murder at a Hindu temple in Illinois was transgender.
NBC News Chicago refers to him throughout the story as a male and by he/him pronouns while noting that he "receives hormone injections for gender transition."
Meanwhile, Canadian newspapers continue to refer to both the 18-year old man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia and the US-based male charged as his co-conspirator solely as women, honoring the preferred pronouns of both murderer and co-conspirator, with no reference to their sex or their trans identification.
All of these people are men.
Quoting @Telugu360: BREAKING: Mass Shooting Plot Targeting Sri Venkateswara Temple in Aurora, Illinois, Foiled
A 19-year-old suspected white supremacist, Alexandros Paporakis, has been arrested for allegedly plotting a mass shooting at a Hindu place of worship in Aurora, Illinois.
Investigators say the suspect had been planning the attack for two years and allegedly targeted Indians and South Asians.
Police recovered an AR-style rifle, ammunition and tactical gear.
A potentially devastating hate-driven attack may have been prevented.
Paporakis worked as a cashier at a Taco Bell in Arlington Heights for nearly seven months.
According to a co-worker who spoke to investigators, Paporakis regularly made racist remarks, particularly targeting Indians. He openly identified himself as a white supremacist and frequently spoke about Nazis and armed struggle.
C2 false claimshand-codedmedia pronoun complaintshooter attributionviolence terror
The Transgender Inquisition will seek your ruin if you dispute its false dogmas. Once it gains political power, there is no limit to the repression it will deploy to stamp out dissent.
Quotes a post by A2437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The attempt to isolate GC's as an ideological faction rather than the vast majority of human beings who have not been inducted into the transgender cult will eventually fail as GC successes in sports and other domains makes it clear that GC's are merely the small fraction of the overwhelming majority of human beings who have not been inducted into the gender cult who found the wherewithal to speak and advocate in the face of a campaign of repression that successfully, for a time, silenced the vast majority of human beings who have not been inducted into the gender cult.
Quotes a post by A2493; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
What newspaper all do in unison is intended to alter language and does alter language. The other part is then deploying state power to entrench those linguistic changes into law by punishing people who don't comply with evolving norms. The transgender movement is entirely movement driven by word trickery, nothing else, because a man who pretends he is a woman is just a man who says he is a woman until professional elites start calling him a "trans woman" and conferring rights onto him on the basis of his claim.
We are starting to see a wider variation in the manner in which news outlets refer to gender expansive criminal suspects and convicts. A male substitute teacher who calls himself “Sophie”, who threatened to murder his own students and even to cannibalize one of them, is referred to by pronouns that correspond to his sex throughout this report in a small local news outlet.
Meanwhile the Globe and a Mail took pains to honor the gender identity of the US-based accomplice of the 18-year man who murdered eight people in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia. The Tumbler Ridge shooter sent a photo of himself with a gun whose barrel was wrapped with a sticker in the trans colors next to a trans flag to his Washington state based accomplice, who egged him on. The Globe and Mail have referred to both the killer and his accomplice, who are both men, as woman throughout their coverage in order to affirm that their transgender identification is real so that readership will be educated that when any man says he is a woman, we all have a moral duty to join him in making the same false claim ourselves.
The difference seems to be that small local news outlets are less likely to be controlled by an astroturfed pseudo-consensus that it’s wrong to make an accurate reference to a person’s sex if it diverges from his claim to be the opposite sex, and more likely to be accountable to a small local community who have yet to take on this belief.
Quotes a post by A2437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Tumbler Ridge shooter was an 18-year old man. The male accomplice to whom the Tumbler Ridge shooter sent a photo of himself posing with a gun with a sticker of the transgender colors wrapped around the barrel was also a man. The Globe and Mail is calling the male accomplice who egged on the Tumbler Ridge shooter as he prepared the mass murder that he went on to commit a "woman" because the male accomplice says he is a woman because affirming the "gender identity" of all men who say they are women is written into the Globe and Mail's style guide.
Quoting @globeandmail: Woman who allegedly aided Tumbler Ridge shooter to remain in custody pending further court appearances https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-tumbler-ridge-shooter-alleged-conspirator-remain-custody-pending/
The trans issue showed that anyone can be made into an outgroup by mere stipulation that their beliefs disqualify them from membership in the human family. It was of particular significance that this belief (that sex is binary and immutable and cannot be treated otherwise without ruinous externalities) was a true belief and a self-evidently true belief requiring self-lobotomy to stop believing since all of mammalian life is a continual demonstration of its truth and all attempts by human beings to falsify it are a continual demonstration of the contrary truth.
That it was done so easily within the corridors of power across the Western world shows the malleability of human beings in the face of institutional consensus. The question that remains to be answered is whether our societies remain democratic enough to beat back the authoritarian cascade that this consensus is in the process of institutionalizing. This is the ideal test in which total institutional consensus is being deployed on behalf of total error.
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: No comment on Gaza itself but I’m pretty sure that if someone of high prestige on the left declared that ok yeah it’s not really about Palestine I just hate the jews and its ok to hate the jews, millions of people would go along with it.
That’s what we learned from the trans insanity. The issue is not the issue (for the vast majority of people).
The issue is secondary to being seen to have the same opinion as the people you hold in high esteem. Were one drunk Hasan Piker tweet away from pogroms. I saw it in the European Parliament yesterday. Gender critical women and Christians were called a “contamination” by the good-thinking people of the NGOcracy, and everyone in the room nodded enthusiastically. I know loads of people who have been fired for speaking at work about the importance of telling the truth about sex, but nobody stands up for us because they didn’t want to risk their own social standing.
People will go along with anything at all as long as they think it puts them in the “camp of good”.
When Robert Trivers described, in email correspondence with Jeffery Epstein, the trans-identified male engineered from early childhood to resemble the opposite sex but remaining male in its appetites as "the best of both worlds," this is what he meant. (The female made to resemble a man was the polar opposite in his schema.) https://x.com/Suspiria451/status/2109654446624080079?s=20
Quotes a post by T08071; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A trans-identified male stabbed a man with whom he had quarreled about his gender thirteen times in the neck and head and upper shoulder, killing him.
The bulk of this story about a trans-identified male killing someone with a knife is a long sermon on "how quickly violence can affect the trans community."
They literally turned a story about a trans-identified man murdering someone into a story about the victimization of trans people.
Quotes a post by T02475; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This tweet is a deliberate distortion—a falsification—of what the appellate court found.
This was not a “trans panic” case in any ordinary sense of the term. The classic “trans panic” defense involves someone claiming that discovering the presumptive woman they've taken home is actually male provoked the ensuing violence. Whatever you think about such a defense, that isn't what happened here, and this ruling has done nothing to give anyone “impunity” to kill trans-identified people.
The killer in this case had been in a two-year relationship with the trans-identified male he killed and knew his sex. He claimed self-defense—the man he shot was armed—but the jury rejected his claim and convicted him of voluntary manslaughter.
But the trial judge had barred the defense from referring to the victim's sex, forcing everyone to go through an elaborate charade that the man who presented himself as a woman was in fact a woman throughout the trial. This included redacting crime-scene and autopsy photographs to conceal his male genitalia, and redacting the autopsy report to remove information establishing his sex.
One aspect of the defense thereby rendered inadmissible was that the victim was a 5'11", 262-pound biological male—a fact inescapably germane to the defendant's assessment of the danger he faced in a violent confrontation. The appellate court found that the falsification of the victim's sex misled the jury into believing “a male defendant killed a female victim.” It called Lee's biological sex “relevant and full of probative value” to Ward's self-defense claim and held that its exclusion prejudiced Ward and prevented him from fully presenting his defense.
Truthout's framing is par for the course in treatments of trans issues—as was the trial judge's elaborate falsification of reality. This is not incidental to trans inclusion but intrinsic to its present form: once a falsehood is granted standing as fact in language and law, ordinary institutional practices must be altered to accommodate it. Here that meant altering photographs, an autopsy report, testimony, and the vocabulary permitted in a criminal trial—and, according to the appellate court, misleading the jury in the process. Here it meant using references to a "trans panic"' defense that do not apply in reporting on the decision.
Transgender inclusion always means corrupting ordinary standards of evidence to collude in the falsification of reality. Kudos to the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals for doing its part to contain this ongoing mania.
Quotes a post by T08653; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Because the transgender inquisition seeks to jail people for calling a man a man, those who contest the right of states to jail people for calling a man a man must call men men and go to prison when the state persecutes them for doing so in order to illustrate to the world that the aims of the transgender inquisition are totalitarian.
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: I really love that they use that photo of Dora Moutot. Are they trying to make her look awesome? Her face is literally saying: "trannies aint women am I bovvered"
Claims that transgender identification among young people has declined were based on weak data. In fact, it is at an all-time high. 5.2 percent of college students identify as transgender.
It's progress that they now feel they must lie and disavow the fervently avowed positions of just a few years ago. It's good that Democrats now refer to "biological males" in women's sports and claim to oppose them and state their opposition to transgender surgeries for children. There is no reason to think that any would vote against the Equality Act which will require every public accommodation in America to allow access to women's spaces to any man who says he is a woman. But the breaking of the unanimity in messaging on trans issues is valuable because the only reason you call someone a "biological male" is that you know they aren't women because you know they are men.
Quotes a post by T06602; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
But it makes me conscious that "men who look like trans men" is a funny new type of guy. (Of course they always looked like that before trans men (women on steroids pretending to be men) existed. But now that trans men exist, we know what the men who resemble them look like.
Oh but you see they have to defend themselves against the nonexistent "transgender genocide" ongoing in the one of the most relentlessly trans-affirming cities in the world, where delusional beliefs about violence, hatred, and bigotry toward the trans-identified are constantly blasted out at children brainwashed from the earliest the age to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered in order to feed a suicide contagion that can then be leveraged to extract further concessions to the movement that profits off of them
Quoting @TPostMillennial: EXCLUSIVE: Transgender students report highest rates of bringing weapons to school in Seattle area: data
https://thepostmillennial.com/exclusive-transgender-students-report-highest-rates-of-bringing-weapons-to-school-in-seattle-area-data
The DOJ is right to note that the Washington state-based trans-identified male to whom a British Columbia-based trans-identified male sent photos of his gun next to a transgender flag right before murdering eight people is a man.
It is always fine to make an accurate reference to a person's sex. It would be fine to do so if the press release did not concern the co-conspirator of a trans-identified make mass murderer. James Cody Bryant is a man because he is an adult human male. This would be true if Bryant was merely a fraudster. It would also be true if Bryant had no criminal record at all. It would be true if Bryant was an assistant secretary in the Department of Health and Human Services. It would be true if Bryant was an elected member of the House of Representatives. In all cases, accurate references to the sex of any adult human male violate no law, ethical code, or social norm. The attempts of those trying to change this fact are illegitimate on their face.
Quoting @BrandiKruse: BREAKING: The DOJ has updated its press release to reflect that trans school shooter Jesse Van Rootselaar is, in fact, A MAN.
The 18-year old trans-identified male who murdered his mother, brother, and five people at a school sent a photo with his gun wrapped with a transgender sticker around the barrel next to a transgender flag to a trans-identified male in the US who now faces charges as a co-conspirator in the mass murder he went on to conduct.
His trans-identified male co-conspirator responded "love the stickers. [] stickers would be so funny to be seen in photos of the incident."
Canadian media has omitted any reference to the sex of both the trans-identified male murderer of seven people and his co-conspirator, choosing instead to the honor the gender identities and preferred pronouns of both by referring to both men exclusively as women in their coverage.
Quotes a post by A2076; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"If someone asserts that self-ID is an all-encompassing prime truth that demands maximal accommodation over all potential objections,"
That is what Trans Women Are Women means.
Jesse Van Roootselaar was an 18 year old man who had been affirmed as a girl since the age of 12. He murdered his mother, who was no doubt told that affirming his trans identity would help him become his true self and protect him from suicide, and brother right before murdering six people at a nearby school.
He sent this photo of his knees protruding from his miniskirt with the gun he would use in the ensuing massacre
Quotes a post by T04978; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There are no contexts in which the legal or institutional recognition of men as women is any more tenable than it is in sports.
People who affirm “trans women are women” are refusing this calculus on principle by asserting that the ontological claim resolves this question in advance. Esper’s claim that we can make this calculus in some domains and not others is a refusal of TWAW.
He has taken the position "trans women are women", which is an ontological claim, and also the position that "trans women" (who are by his account women) should be excluded from playing women's sports. That's not coherent. The exclusion of trans women from women's sports is a tacit confession that trans women are men. "Some people will be called what they are not" is exactly the position that "trans women are women" exists to forbid.
"Are not women" is not the claim. The claim is "are men." They a biological advantage over women in sports because they are men. Their presence in a women's locker room an invasion of privacy because they are men. Their passports must reflect the fact of their sex. "Are men" is a claim about sex and a judgment that sex is what matters rather than their private fantasies about being something they are not, which has no bearing on any of the questions of trans rights. If some people want to join in make believe about being something they are not, no laws forbids them, but no law can force you call a man a woman without violating a right that everyone holds.
Cunningham opposes trans inclusion in women's sports and women's locker rooms because all trans women are men, a fact that applies to every other demand of the trans movement and is the basis for the refusal of any and all of them.
Quoting @reduxx: A transgender sex offender has avoided the death penalty after striking a plea deal for the horrific murder of a young woman in Arizona.
Zion Teasley blamed his gender identity for the brutal killing, claiming he was jealous of his victim's beauty.
https://reduxx.info/us-man-who-brutally-murdered-female-hiker-blames-gender-identity-struggles-avoids-death-penalty/
The reason a male convicted child rapist was allowed into a women’s locker room at a Massachusetts Planet Fitness was that Planet Fitness has a policy to allow any man who says he is a woman into the women’s locker room and a practice of punishing any woman who disputes the inclusion of any man who says he is a woman in women’s private spaces as a hateful bigot. In this, the corporation is enacting the policy that House Democrats have twice voted to impose on every public accommodation in America and that the Biden Administration’s Department of Education imposed on every school that accepts federal funds in America before courts vacated the rule as violating Title IX and the US Constitution. He was there because Democrats are united in treating the inclusion of any man who says he is woman in women’s private spaces as the civil rights movement of the 21st century. When Democrats say “we can’ t throw trans people under the bus,” they mean “we will force your daughter to change alongside a convicted male child rapist and punish her if she protests.”
Quoting @reduxx: A convicted child rapist is in custody after sexually assaulting multiple women in an "inclusive" female locker room at a Massachusetts Planet Fitness.
The franchise has previously defended its policies allowing males to enter the women's areas.
https://reduxx.info/man-arrested-after-sexually-assaulting-women-in-inclusive-planet-fitness-locker-room/
Today's trans-identified folx bristle at the description of themselves as "cross-dressers" -- they are not cross-dressers, they are bearer of "gender identities" that confer upon them rights of legal recognition and the ability to breach sex segregated boundaries.
Were any of those people "transgender"? Or is that a term that was made up in the 1990's? I know a college instructor who was removed from a class for using the term "transvestite" to refer to a transvestite.
What the transgender movement has aimed to do. and has largely done, is expand the definition of "oppression" to encompass "not joining in a falsehood that another person demands you tell" and expand the definition of a "right" to encompass "the right to force others to conform to the false self-conception of a designated class of person." It should be self-evident that these expansions of the concept of what we owe our fellow citizens are untenable.
Esper is saying that when women pretend to be neither male nor female, it isn't valid because everybody is either male or female, which is true. He goes on to say that when women pretend to be men, it is valid because people who pretend to be the opposite sex are an oppressed minority with a long history of other people pretending to be the opposite sex, which is obviously not true.
Of course people who pretend to be something they are not have always existed and have always encountered inconveniences that accompany pretending to be something you are not (as people who tattoo their faces or pretend to be dead historical figures have always encountered inconveniences, chief among them the incredulity and fear that these practices incite in those exposed to them) but they have never been oppressed and they are not a "minority group."
The main inconvenience that people who pretend to be the opposite sex have encountered historically is that many or most people respond by noting that their claim to be something that they are not is untrue. This is of course a true response to someone trying to falsify a fact about themselves that the transgender movement exists to deploy social pressure and state and institutional power to forbid by stigmatizing and punishing people who respond as most people always have to people pretending to be something they are not: by disbelieving the attempt because it isn't true.
That's all transgenderism is: people pretending to be what they are not oppressing people who won't falsify reality on their behalf. Every other part of the movement -- its corruption of science and hijacking of key institutions, its brainwashing of schoolchildren to believe its dogmas, its invasion of sex segregated sports and spaces, and its medicalizing of gender nonconformity is in the service of this agenda. The goal is to rewrite social reality to make a false things true, in the process destroying liberalism, pluralism, and freedom of speech and conscience along the way.
They didn't hold out at first -- they joined everyone else. Years later, after 17 comprehensive evidence reviews all reached the same conclusion about the claim that pediatric gender medicine was evidence-based (that it was false), ASPA was alone in aligning its guidance with reality. The question is why they moved when others didn't -- it's partly that the Biden Administration rescinded its endorsement of trans surgery for minors.
While trans-identified males do give birth sometimes (because they are women), I would think the default assumption is that the biological mother is the women who doesn't pretend to be a man.
This of course will feed the narrative that the trans movement seeks to propagate. I wonder if they will glom onto this story or just keep it under the radar with the victim remaining a man.
Virtually all violence against trans-identified folx consists of 1.) domestic violence, often by other LGBTQIA+ ID folx, and 2.) violence against black and brown trans prostitutes by black men.
But as gender insanity proliferates wildly into other parts of society, further insanity is likely to happen.
Yes, a very reasonable surmise.
The scenario that seems plausible is that the trans-identified female was encouraging their grandchild to go trans. In advance of a custody proceeding before a Bay Area judge, the couple took matters into their own hands. https://x.com/BonitasMomToo/status/2104930864404763107?s=20
Quotes a post by T17754; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedcontagioncrime casemotive displacementstate takes children
Nor of course would it have made any material difference in my point if in fact he started identifying at 16 rather than at 12. The BBC used his preferred pronouns and presented him as a woman, lying by omission about the fact that he is a man. You refer to him as "they". Why? Why are you disputing that BBC's claim that he is a woman? Don't you believe that Trans People Are Real? What's the basis for denying his trans identity is real that doesn't apply to you?
Here is an instance of state media simply lying about the sex of a mass murderer in order to affirm his gender identity. No reference to the fact of his sex at all. This is what "trans people existing" means in practice. https://x.com/wesyang/status/2103632107427750105?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: He was affirmed as a girl from the age of twelve, dropped out of school a few years later, sank deeply into drugs, mental illness, obsession with guns and violence and then murdered eight people at a middle school in cold blood. The BBC takes care to affirm his trans identity as his mother did starting at the age of 12 until he murdered her just before murdering five students and a teacher. To the BBC it is imperative that he be honored as a woman and remembered as a woman. To the BBC he was a woman.
C2 false claimshand-codeddenialmedia pronoun complaintshooter attributionviolence terror
Every elementary schoolchild in California is taught that a boy can have a vagina and a girl can have a penis. Orwell's novel was not just about a repressive state apparatus, but what that repressive state apparatus did: it commanded those within its power to believe a falsehood that the state designated as virtuous.
So California doesn't have a Ministry of Love into which people disappear, that's true. But it does command you to ignore the evidence of your senses and believe a state approved dogma.
When we say that the transgender movement is Orwellian, we are not claiming that people who dispute state-enforced dogma are being disappeared into torture chambers. That is only one part of Orwell's dystopia that we haven't yet reached -- and that hopefully we never reach. (Which is one of the many reasons we resist the transgender movement.) We are noting that the state is teaching children to repeat a falsehood -- a lie -- as the only truth. We are noting that children are being disciplined for stating a truth and refusing to lie. We are noting that people have been sentenced to prison in Brazil for making an accurate reference to a person's sex, and that ruinous financial penalties have been imposed by courts in Australia and Canada for disputing transgender dogmas. We know what the movement seeks: the redefinition of sex classes to be inclusive of both sexes and the top-down re-engineering of language and law enforced by the state. We know this because the movement has exerted its power to this end wherever it obtains the power to do so.
To say that a movement that uses state power to punish people for stating truths and denying falsehoods should not be analogized to Orwell, who warned of exactly this, is to participate in Orwellian machinations yourself. ("But there is no system of Gulags to punish people who believe that man can't become a women!" Indeed there is not, and we want to keep in that way.) To say that state enforced re-engineering of language is "just how language works" is to be a liar on behalf of this movement, which is exactly what the movement does to everyone who supports it: it makes them a liar and an enemy of human freedom.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We are seeing 9/11 being recast before our eyes as an attack on Muslims. We are already seeing violence by trans-identified folx as being treated from day one as occasions for renewed piety, deference, and solicitude toward the victimization of the perpetrator.
C2 false claimshand-codedvictim dismissalviolence terror
He was affirmed as a girl from the age of twelve, dropped out of school a few years later, sank deeply into drugs, mental illness, obsession with guns and violence and then murdered eight people at a middle school in cold blood. The BBC takes care to affirm his trans identity as his mother did starting at the age of 12 until he murdered her just before murdering five students and a teacher. To the BBC it is imperative that he be honored as a woman and remembered as a woman. To the BBC he was a woman.
Quoting @jo_bartosch: Omg the Tumbler Ridge school shooter is being referred to as a woman on @[private account] The World Tonight. No mention of a trans identity, or indeed his male sex
The relevant context is: men stay out of women's sports, changing rooms, shelters, and prisons, and their official documents records the fact of their sex rather than their private reveries about their sex.
Also, as you know, the whole point of the transgender movement is to secure legal recognition for anyone who claims a cross-sex identity without reference to how much they resemble the opposite sex in any context, which as you also know, few do in the vast majority of cases.
You see, the male transgender pedophile said he is a woman and the word "woman" has been redefined to be inclusive of any man who says he is a woman, therefore he has a civil right to be locked up with women
Quoting @reduxx: A transgender pedophile is suing the state of Alaska for "gender affirming" surgeries and a transfer to a women's prison.
Emmanuel Cancel, now known as Emalee Rain Wagoner, is serving a 40-year sentence for the horrific sexual abuse of three children.
https://reduxx.info/transgender-pedophile-serving-40-year-sentence-for-sexually-abusing-multiple-children-files-lawsuit-seeking-surgery-transfer-to-womens-prison-in-alaska/
"Man" and "women" are references to the material, empirical realities of sex. That some people in a neighborhood, friend group, or social scene might agree to use those terms to refer to someone of the opposite sex in deference to their private reveries about their sex has zero bearing on whether such personal, private phenomena can be scaled up to the level of state or institutional policy without negative externalities that vastly outweigh any possible good that such an act of redefinition might do. Today's transgender movement exists solely for the latter purpose. To glibly say "society accommodates trans people" is to elide this core distinction in a way that removes the problem.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The transgender movement exists solely to seize state power and use it to coerce the world into accepting their redefinition. People are free to play along with other people's make believe, but that was true before a transgender movement existed and sold people on the notion that forcing people to adopt their beliefs and forbidding women to draw a boundary between themselves and any man who says he is a woman was a civil rights movement. It is not, it is simply a movement to seize state power and repress people into acquiescence. All attempts to portray it otherwise is colluding with that project.
People with face tattoos exist. People who believe they commune with spirits exist. Neither is a minority that has been systematically disadvantaged even though people with face tattoos likely struggle to be hired and people who believe they commune with spirits are seldom affirmed outside of a small coterie of believes.
No one owes either group any deference to their beliefs or their claims to be something other than what they are.
That is all a "trans person" is: an individual who perceived themselves to have a problem (that they are the sex they are) who adopted beliefs that they believe help them contend with that problem (that they are the sex they are not.)
The attempt to make other people affirm their belief is inherently an assault on a right that other people have that no one can take away -- a right that can only be overridden through repression.
A trans person is a person who pretends to be the opposite sex. I've never doubted that such people existed. What I know isn't true is the claim that a person with a penis can be a girl if he feels like a girl or a person with a vagina can be a boy if she feels like a boy.
Nothing in the bar is any "sillier," or any more false than this claim.
The third bullet point is wrong -- trans and Queer identification are also the basis for identitarian deference.
These categories have expanded to encompass any person that claims to be them without reference to any other factor.
Quotes a post by T06199; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
James' Transgender Map wound up being an excellent resource for finding other reason and reality-based people https://x.com/DonnaMaeGP/status/2102935022303084895?s=20
Quotes a post by T13126; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Transgender Inquisition is an assault on the mental sovereignty of everyone subject to the power of the astroturfed pseudo-consensus. It trained people in the habit of doublethink and anxious self-scrutiny for conformity to a self-evident lie. It was a moral and epistemic tax that left people helpless to resist other exactions on their will to resist ostensibly virtuous dogmas.
Quoting @wesyang: The transgender movement ended the possibility of anything functioning as a reductio ad absurdum for any claim emerging from the left. It immunized any claim from susceptibility to rational disproof.
Whatever falsehood you are commanded to take seriously, you have already been trained to believe an even more flagrant lie or face expulsion from the human family.
You see, when you make note of the fact that violence against trans-identified people has gone down under Trump, (and frame this as a welcome development), that is "anti-trans."
Being "pro-trans" means terrorizing people into baseless panic over non-existent threats because it leads to more donations flowing to trans NGO's.
Quoting @SwipeWright: I legitimately can't stand the lies. Transgender activist Andrea James is upset that @[private account]'s op-ed was featured on The Boston Globe's front page.
"There is a longstanding journalistic convention that newspapers generally keep opinion columns...off the front page."
That just...isn't true.
Here are the current front pages of the New York Times, the Washington Post, and the Wall Street Journal.
Look at those opinion columns!
These people just lie with every breath. About literally everything. It drives me absolutely BONKERS. 😵💫
The reply is notable for not making reference to any threat (for the moment we will leave in brackets the question of whether any or all of these threats are real) that applies to the trans-identified and not to the non-trans-identified
Quotes a post by A0718; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You have to be totally divorced from reality to believe that there is a Trans Genocide.
You have to be totally divorced from reality to think a man who takes estrogen is a woman.
https://x.com/luce_lexi/status/2102738884685672599?s=20
Quotes a post by T05497; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans-identified folx who begin posting moderate political opinions on unrelated subjects have already left the cult and begun to detransition. They too reached their woke breaking point, and whether they accept it or not, their transition depends on the wider cult and its beliefs. We all know it and they do too.
“Death By Detransition” — part of the ongoing effort by the transgender movement to induce a suicide contagion that can be leveraged to exact political concessions for the movement
Quoting @benryanwriter: Protesters are assembling at @[private account] in East Midtown Manhattan to protest the settlement the hospital reached with the Justice Department to keep shuttered its pediatric gender clinic and to pay an $8.5 million fine.
Quick explainer: "Birthing People" is a form of deference to "trans men" (women who pretend to be men) who can get and do get pregnant (because they are women).
You can't call a person who gives birth to a child a mother, because "mother" is a sexed term that excludes men and you can't exclude "trans men" from the category of people who give birth. (They are actually mothers because they are actually women.)
Quoting @EndWokeness: Kamala Harris is campaigning with Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan today
The topic? "Black birthing people"
Wokeness is NOT over
Of course there is no transgender genocide. Trans-identified people are murdered at a rate lower than the general population. "Transgender genocide" just means: 1.) you don't get to inflict the ultimate sexual violence on children, 2.) some of your imperious demands to be recognized as something you are not will be declined.
That's all it means.
Quoting @SwipeWright: The Boston Globe has just published a shockingly sober article about the nonexistent genocide supposedly targeting the transgender community.
In it, they cite a report I coauthored showing that the murder rate is actually lower for trans-identifying people than the general population. Our report was responding to the HRC's annual reports pushing the narrative that there is an ongoing "Epidemic of Violence" against the transgender community.
The reporter says he "offered the Human Rights Campaign's key researcher, the transgender woman Charleigh Flohr, or anyone else with the organization an opportunity to rebut the Manhattan Institute finding, but they didn't reply to me."
That's unsurprising because the HRC is engaging in fundraising propaganda. They don't care about the truth, only promoting the narrative.
Our report presenting the actual data is irrefutable. That's why they have nothing to say in response.
You can read our report summary in @[private account] here:
🔗https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
Or explore our comprehensive report here:
🔗https://dont-shoot-the-data.github.io/TCLEAR/
Read the Boston Globe article here:
🔗https://archive.ph/VqhlI
Trans Age is not more delusional or less false than transgender. They are both entirely false and entirety absurd. It’s just that the latter is being propagated by the medical, legal, cultural, educational, and political establishments of the Western world.
Whenever Newsom does something good, like veto a bizarre and extreme law that would have immunized some of the most deranged figures in modern medicine from any accountability for their abuses, it just underscores all the bad he has done over the past decade and a half, like sign a dozen bizarre and extreme laws that empower some of the most deranged figures in modern medicine in their abuses every bit as much as the one he vetoed. This said, we should be glad that Democrats now feel, for the first time ever, that they must not just dissemble away their disgraceful records on the trans issue, but in a few isolated cases, take actual actions that will, if not actually roll back the ongoing mania, at least keep it from getting worse, at least for now.
Quotes a post by A3058; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Ohio Democratic incumbent Congresswoman Marcy Kaptur notes in her latest ad that:
"I voted WITH Republicans to keep transgender ideology out of schools, and let me be clear, boys should NOT play in girls' sports."
Nice to see Democrats stating views aligned with reason and reality. While Kaptur did vote for HR. 2616 (Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act / PROTECT Kids Act), which would have withheld federal funds from schools that socially transitioned children without seeking parental consent, propagandize children that any of them can change, and let boys use the girls changing room, she voted twice against bills that would have excluded boys from girls sports. So while she did vote with GOP to keep trans ideology out of schools, she voted against their efforts to keep boys out of girls sports.
At the time all these bills were introduced in the House, it was generally understood that none would pass the Senate, where Democrats are united in support of the party line on trans issues.
After being hugely ratio'd for endorsing a paper that systematically misconstrues the issue at hand by authors with long records of dishonest public statements, Guyatt stands tall by once again posting it again with an even more florid endorsement. Guyatt is the founder of the Evidence-Based Movement who undertook a comprehensive evidence review of pediatric gender medicine (one of 17) that concluded that evidence in the field is low to very low quality. Under pressure by trans activists, Guyatt has since then undertaken a shameless campaign of sycophancy toward those corrupting the practice of medicine in order to continue chemically castrating and dismembering confused children.
See replies for the relevant facts.
Quotes a post by T03939; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A woman who pretends to be a man was subject to the same background testing that every other employee must undergo. Because this testing required the disclosure of prior legal names and her prior legal name aligns with her sex (rather than her private reverie to be a member of the opposite sex), she claims that the process was traumatizing.
The state employment tribunal agreed that forcing a person who pretends to be something they are not to disclose their prior history violates a right that some people have to deceive others about their sex and awarded her $35,000, in effect establishing the principle that nobody who is falsifying their sex (including for positions where the applicant is working with young children) can be subject to the same scrutiny that all other employees must undergo.
Transgender "rights" are always demands for special privileges and exemptions. They provide a pathway to unravel the system of child safeguarding. And they use state power to coerce individuals and institutions to join people in pretending to be something they are not, a violation of everyone's rights that the system is working tirelessly to make universal.
Quotes a post by A1607; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A magistrate in Oregon issued an injunction in April that would have sent more than 100 men who claim to be women into Oregon's only women's prison, including a man who sexually assaulted a woman with a footlong plastic object.
The man who sexually assaulted a woman with a footlong plastic object was one of the plaintiffs in that case. The judge ruled that affirming the male rapist's false claim to be a woman overrode any concern that female inmates in Oregon's only women's prisons might have about being locked in a cage with a man who sexually assaulted a woman with a footlong plastic object. You see, the Democratic party declared forbidding any woman to draw a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman to be "the Civil Rights Movement of the 21st century."
What this means in practice is that when balancing the rights of women to safety and privacy in places that were once sex segregated and the rights of male rapists to be affirmed in their claims to be women, the former right is annulled by the latter right, and any woman who seeks to defend the former right must be stigmatized as a hateful bigot and punished.
The Ninth Circuit appellate court overturned the injunction while the case moves forward.
The Courthouse News Service suavely, sagely notes that "The opinion included some curiously worded — one might say Trump-coded — language. For example, most uses of transgender used quotation marks, and Tung referred to transgender women as “male inmates who claim to be female,” rather than the more common phrase “identify as female.”
This is to say that judges used plain language to explain that a "transgender woman" is just a man who claims to be a woman. The male plaintiff who inserted a footlong plastic object into a woman's vagina against her will is not a woman. He is a man. He is not a man because he is a convicted rapist. He is a man because he is an adult human male and pretending to be a woman doesn't change his sex. But the Courthouse News Service writer sees a reference to this fact in a court proceeding as grounds to snicker and engage in contemptuous partisan finger-pointing because the Trump-appointed judges aren't using the cult language that is pervasive in court proceedings to euphemize away the locking up of women with male rapists.
1.) There has never been any evidence that chemically castrating a child prevents suicide. The ACLU's lead trans rights litigator was forced to admit this before SCOTUS. All claims to the contrary were always self-conscious lies used by the movement to emotionally blackmail and bully parents to giving consent to the medicalized self-harm of their children.
2.) There is no evidence that restricting transgender procedures to adults has increased the rate of teen suicide. All claims to the contrary are attempts to emotionally blackmail and bully the public into acquiescence to a non-evidence based medical protocol.
It is just another in a long line of lies that the transgender movement tells.
Quotes a post by T04491; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Spanberger faced more than one transgender controversy during her race -- the revelation that a male sex offender was able to loiter naked for hours in the girl's locker of a high school pool in front of female minors at a Fairfax County school, and the punishment of boys who filmed a girl in their own locker room in a Loudon County school, both of whom were placed there by transgender inclusion policies.
Spanberger equivocated weakly and sought out a rhetorical middle ground and survived the attacks, stating that transgender inclusions should be decided at the district rather than the state level.)
In office, she has shut down an effort to protect the private spaces and sporting competitions of girls, thus establishing a template that other Democrats will follow on these issues where they face opposition from a supermajority of the electorate -- equivocate in order to win office, and impose the full trans activist agenda in office.
Quoting @DIAGdemocrats: “Let’s just go back to saying the quiet part quietly.”
I talked to a guy in NYC who is attracted to tomboys and has dated multiple "trans men" -- all are completely medically untransitioned girls who do nothing to medicalize or present as anything but female in dress and manner and exclusively have vaginal intercourse with straight men while still insisting that they are men
Quotes a post by T01892; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Sex work is only good when it is Queer, Trans, Fat, Black, Brown, LatinX, disabled, and other marginalized Bodies doing it. Famous wealthy White Girlbosses with large hooters must remain clothed and behave modestly.
I won't presume to opine on the whole race but I'll note that Acton did a couple of things that seemed like sensible tactics that both contributed to her +3 polling lead in a state that elected Trump by 11 points:
-- She attacked Vivek for his viral tweet urging Americans to start hitting the books in order to compete with the world -- that is to say, she used an attack on Vivek originating from the nativist online Right against him to good effect with the general electorate
-- She unequivocally endorsed the substantive correctness of restricting women's sports to women and excluding men who say they are women and gave trans activist seeking to bully her into acquiescence the hand
Trans issues are not high salience in themselves, but showing independence from one of the most rabid lobbies dominating the party is a strong sign of cultural normalcy with broader implications. (Whether or not the posture is real.)
The popularity of trans inclusion among fans of women's professional sports is a key example of how easy it is to manipulate people into annulling their own values by telling them that values antithetical to the ones they hold are compulsory.
Transgender inclusion, which is popular among the left-wing fan base for women's sports is a project explicitly aimed at not just rejecting the moral intuition that "biological differences between men and women require separation of the sexes in order to ensure safety and fairness" but at vilifying those who defend the intuition and seek to enshrine it in policy.
The problem for trans-inclusive fans of female sports, is that this intuition is the conceptual foundation for women's sports to exist at all.
In the case of trans inclusion in women's sports, the moral intuition that is being annulled is "biological differences between men and women require separation of the sexes in order to ensure safety and fairness."
https://x.com/mattyglesias/status/2100195183459455119?s=20
Quoting @mattyglesias: Notably, the actual fan base for women's sports is very left-wing so the status quo where the WNBA's stated policy is unclear but there aren't actually any trans women playing serves everyone's interests.
https://www.slowboring.com/p/destroying-womens-sports-in-order
The Transgender Inquisition is global and seeks to criminalize any dissent from its false dogmas. It brought criminal charges against a janitor in Brazil who called a man a man. It has imposed ruinous financial penalties on a school trustee in Canada who criticized a curriculum that teaches every elementary schoolchild in the province that any of them can change sex. And it has arrested a documentary filmmaker in Colombia for making a film critical of the brainwashing of children to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered.
Quoting @genspect: 🚨 Samuel Adrian a documentary maker has been arrested in Colombia for his expose, Colombia: Factory of Trans Children
This is incredibly serious, please share and let them know the eyes of the world are watching.
OK. But you said the bloke who dresses like a 9-year old girl had to reapply. That wasn't just your personal opinion, it was your hypothetical reply to how you would handle him if you were in the office of trans identity verification.
You're right that it does not mean that. It does, however, mean that Trans Women Are Men. (Which also does not mean trans people should fuck off and die. It just means that saying you are a woman when you are a man does not confer onto you a right to violate any sex-based boundary.)
Quotes a post by T08522; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Pro-Palestine activists who sought to tank Biden were not seeking to minimize Palestinian death by working to replace Biden by Trump. They were seeking to obtain control over the Democratic party's Israel policy and were happy to maximize Palestinian death in order to do so. This is a policy consistent with Palestinian policy itself, and it worked out well for them.
Trans activists who seek to tank the Democratic Congressional majority want to shore up flagging party discipline on the trans issue. If gestures toward moderation (largely cosmetic gestures when they are not overt lies) contribute materially to Democrat victories in Blue and Purple states, the embargo on Democrats acknowledging the biological reality that Trans Women Are Men (which all acknowledgments that there are safety and fairness issues with trans inclusion necessarily do) is broken.
Pressure from trans activists forces Democrats making moderate gestures on trans issues either to signal that their gestures toward moderation are fake (they are largely fake, especially in Talarico's case) in order to shore up progressive support or to commit themselves to a decisive break to which they can then be held accountable.
Quoting @benryanwriter: On Bluesky, Will Stancil lambasts transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed for her hardline policies on Democratic politicians’ stance on trans issues. Reed said it was better that Republicans should win than Dems give even an inch on such matters. Stancil said he was “shocked by this.” He called it “Unbelievably foolish, short-sighted, self-sabotaging nonsense.”
He continued: “I'd argue that there are certain viewpoints and claims that are so ill-conceived and detached from reality that they should be discrediting for the person who is making them. ‘We must defeat Democrats in swing states, in 2026, to teach Third Way a lesson about moderation’ is easily on that list.”
These comments underscore 1.) How delusional and divorced from reality the transgender movement has always been and 2.) How trapped the Democratic party remains after its president, Joe Biden, declared that forbidding any women from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman was the "civil rights movement of the 21st century."
All attempts at finding "moderation" on this issue will inevitably fail because using state power to coerce people into pretending that a false claim is true (no men are women; all men are men) is extremism.
Moderation just means scrapping the entire project.
Quotes a post by T08544; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No challenger to Mamdani offered an alternative position. Democrat moderates (including Josh Shapiro and Gretchen Whitmer) are as trans affirming as the DSA.
But the polling shows that 2 out of 3 Democrats oppose men in women's sports and solid and stable majorities oppose the chemical castration of children.
Democrats are learning this cycle that they must moderate on trans to have a chance in Red and Purple states.
It will take a couple more cycles for moderates to learn they can defeat progressives by actually running on the issue.
Quotes a post by T08025; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
More than anyone else, Gen Z witnessed what encouraging people to believe they were born in the body yields in practice -- medicalized self-harm, sterilization, loss of sexual function, and increasing rather than decreasing dysphoria among those pretending to be something they are not and can never be.
More than anyone else, Gen Z saw that the claims of young people caught up in the social contagion were simply untrue. "Talk to some actual trans people." That's exactly what Gen Z did.
Quotes a post by T05530; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It is a deranged and appalling and defamatory lie that flows naturally from the mania and bombast that is intrinsic to the transgender movement. And it is also an incitement to violence -- it does not even pretend not to be an incitement to murder. In the same interview, Wachowski talks about his attempts to bring Gretchen Martin-Felker's novel Manhunt to the screen, a novel which includes a scene in which Rowling is burned to death.
Felker is a deranged, sociopathic trans-identified male whose comic book was canceled by DC a year ago after he responded to the murder of Charlie Kirk by posting on BlueSky that he "hoped the bullet is OK after touching Charlie." A chorus of other trans-identified people and their allies and enablers on BlueSky responded to the murder of Kirk by calling for Rowling to be next.
Such is the malignant narcissism pervasive in a movement whose political project consists of deploying state power to coerce the whole world into treating a falsehood as the only truth. Right now, the political and legal and medical and cultural establishments of the Western world are working in concert on behalf of this authoritarian project -- on behalf of men like Wachowski who allowed his sexual obsession (in his case a BDSM force feminization fetish first accessed through pornography, later through a relationship with a dominatrix) to swallow his entire personality and confer onto him an overpowering sense of entitlement to command others to falsify reality on his behalf. (This is distinct from handing Wachowski himself tens of millions of dollars to make sociopathic revenge fantasies, which Hollywood did not do -- it is other, less floridly deranged, but equally delusional, creators that Hollywood executives are mainlining money toward to brainwash children into believing they were born in the wrong body.)
The movement is so deeply immersed in fantasies of persecution ("trans genocide" just means "sometimes women will draw a boundary on where you can impose yourself," "sometimes the answer will be no") that absolutely no one seeks to restrain. Indeed, absolutely all of its leaders do everything to stoke these fantasies with zero concern over who kills themselves or kills others as a result.
It is an absolutely indefensible slander that Rowling should not hesitate to pursue in a legal proceeding for maximum damages. Doubtful it will ever get to that If Wachowski has competent lawyers, who will command him to grovel publicly while retracting his defamation.
Quotes a post by T03391; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C4 targetinghand-codeddenialmental illnesspolitical enemyviolence terror
It's true that every Democrat who says there are fairness issues with men in women's sports are saying that because they are endorsing the true fact that all Trans Women Are Men
Quotes a post by T04410; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Moderation means refusing all of the transgender movement's demands without exception because conferring a right onto people to coerce other people to regard and treat them as something they are not is extreme
Remember, when women have a domestic violence shelter that is reserved for women only, that is "Trans Genocide."
When people are free to call an adult male forced feminization fetishist "a man" -- that is Trans Genocide.
When doctors aren't allowed to chemically castrate and dismember confused children who have been brainwashed by cultists that they were born in the wrong body, that is Trans Genocide.
And if you enjoy the most popular children's book series in world history and associated products, that is Trans Genocide.
Quoting @CantEverDie: @[private account] yes if you watch the new harry potter show you are explicitely supporting trans genocide as jk rowling funds efforts to assault the trans community
So, a bearded man who dresses as a 9-year old girl has a right to have preschoolers coerced into calling him a woman by the state.
Thank you for illustrating what "reasonable moderation" in a trans advocate consists of.
Boys play sports and change alongside girls solely as a function of a nationwide, whole of government effort supported by an army of lawyers, bureaucrats, and Democratic party officials at every level of government from President Biden, who declared trans inclusion "the civil rights movement of the 21st century, down to thousands of Superintendents of Schools educating millions of schoolchildren across Blue states.
Quotes a post by T08609; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans Activists say that there is only Reed because Reed is lying about what she witnessed and there is no one else who has seen what she has seen. But everyone in gender clinics has seen what she has seen. Eric Anderson and Laura Edward-Leeper have testified to the same effect. All have simply brainwashed themselves into denying the harm they witnessed.
The reason Trans Activists are seeking to punish Democrats for making concessions on trans inclusion in sports is that the reason to exclude trans girls from girls sports is that trans girls are boys and any acknowledgment of this fact in one domain necessarily carries over to all other domains, regardless of what the person making those concessions claims.
The transgender movement chose to invest billions of dollars and a decade and a half of energy into framing the basis of their claim to inclusion as an ontological claim -- "Trans Women are Women." The advantage of this ontological claim was that it resolved every question in a single shot. It's the reason that male rapists and murderers are imprisoned in women's prisons, it's the reason a 40-year-old man swam and changed alongside 12-year old girls in competitive swim meets, and it's the reason a male convicted sex offender was permitted to loiter naked in the girls room of a Fairfax County pool.
The disadvantage of the ontological claim is that it isn't true. The ontological claim cannot be prised apart and be recognized as valid only under some conditions and not in others.
Giving up on sports is giving up on transgenderism.
The Democrats must give up entirely on transgenderism.
Quotes a post by T04410; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Transgender Inquisition is global and unitary and will enact the same measures wherever it obtains the power to impose its will.
British Columbia is one region where the movement has unrestricted power to work its will. Accordingly, it has fined a school trustee $750K for criticizing a mandatory gender indoctrination program that teaches every child enrolled in the public school in the province that any of them can change sex, and now has fined a doctor an immigrant doctor $28K for declining to chemically castrate a child.
Meanwhile, a court in Colorado has ruled that a hospital must defy the federal government and risk all federal funding in order to continue inflicting irreversible medical harms on children. The doctors who would ordinarily be quite eager to continue sterilizing confused children are refusing to continue while under threat of criminal liability.
This is what transgenderism seeks everywhere: 1.) to brainwash every quirky child that they were born wrong and can be fixed by sterilizing treatments that will leave them on a medical leash for life, 2.) to compel doctors to participate in the sterilization of children, and 3.) to forbid women from drawing a boundary between themselves and any man who claims to be a woman and 4.) to deploy state power to coerce every person to falsify reality on behalf of anyone claiming to be a sex other than the sex they actually are.
The Biden Administration punted on trans surgeries for minors in 2023. After Admiral Rachel Levine intervened in the formation of WPATH's Standards of Care 8 to influence the organization to strip out all age minimums for any transgender procedure (including surgery) in 2022, the administration did an abrupt about face in 2023.
The real question is whether Talarico still supports using puberty blockers to chemically castrate confused children after making repeated maudlin speeches in defense of them while leading the opposition to the Texas legislature's bills banning them.
Quotes a post by A2277; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Of course everyone is allowed to make their private judgments and calculations about personal interest.
The transgender movement seeks to move beyond private judgments to use the law or policy or institutional sanctions or social pressure to force people to conform. It seeks consequences beyond the private judgments of specific individual. (And I think you do too.)
It's been very successful in remaking norms in large swathes of the bourgeois West -- to make it tantamount to a racial slur to refer to a person seeking to portray themselves as the opposite as the sex they are. But it's done so on an emotional knee-jerk basis and through campaigns to embed itself into law and regulation that never really came into the open as subjects for deliberation and debate. And I think we need to have a real process of deliberation and debate and at the end of it, we will all understand that the only consequence anyone should ever be able to impose on another is the one you specify.
Very typical and expected Trans Activist line of inquiry
Quoting @reddit_lies: "Why didn't JK Rowling's abusive first husband kill her when he had the chance?"
Is this that "healthcare" they keep talking about?
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
I wonder if they affirmed their trans-identified male staff by excluding them too -- and if they didn't, whether any of them complained
Quoting @salltweets: We’re in a bizarre phase where knowing exactly who the women are and pretending to not know who the women are is happening simultaneously and both positions are being used to punish women.
A lot of people are still under the impression that the proposition that the transgender movement is demanding you accept or face expulsion from society, which is being taught to millions of elementary schoolchildren across the Western world, is that "a castrated man in a dress is a woman" when in fact what they are teaching them is that "girldick is valid (and it's genocidal when a lesbian doesn't want to suck it.)"
The second proposition is not more of a falsehood or an absurdity than the first -- they are both entirely false and entirely absurd. But the second proposition is less abashed about the movement being about coercing people into a compulsory break with reality.
The NYT Magazine, in a long feature on the Skrmetti SCOTUS case (which found that there is no constitutional violation when a state prohibits the use of chemical castration drugs on nine-years old who have been brainwashed to fear puberty) quoted the ACLU's lead trans right litigator writing in Slate that "a penis isn't a male body part, it's just an unusual body part for a woman to have" in Slate in 2015. In the context of the story, which seeks to portray its author as an outlying figure whose poor judgment about optics helped to doom the case, the quote is meant to underscore its author's zany extremism.
But Chase Strangio, who is a woman who injects herself with testosterone in order to grow a beard, who doesn't even claim to be a "man", but instead identifies as "trans" (while insisting on being referred to by male pronouns) wasn't saying anything in 2015 that isn't being taught to tens and tens of millions of elementary schoolchildren across the Western world as a quotidian fact that any of them can expect to be ostracized and punished for denying today. The movement, which is in possession of every left and center-left political party in the Western world and Anglosphere. demands nothing less of any of its adherents -- it demands that they stand up and declare that JK Rowling is wrong that a woman can't have a penis, and it demands that they vote for legislation that ensures that anyone who doesn't agree face the destruction of their livelihood.
Quoting @jk_rowling: I see that Stella Creasy is accusing me of leading a pitchfork mob against her, because I opined that she is less likeable and more hypocritical than the wild parakeet she mistook for an escaped pet.
For those who don’t know, Creasy is an elected politician and self-proclaimed ‘old-fashioned feminist’ who is ‘still fighting the patriarchy’. She’s more than once publicly defined herself against me (and my reaction was not to accuse her of leading a mob, even though I was probably averaging a dozen death threats a day at the point when the article below appeared.)
I thought it might be instructive for those of us who don’t share Creasy’s brand of ‘feminism’ to examine her campaigning record, so we can learn to do better.
Creasy wants women admitted to the male-only, exclusive, London-based private members Garrick Club, a change that would benefit rather privileged women like Creasy. Creasy is a mother who wants better accommodations for working mothers, a change that would benefit Creasy. Creasy takes selfies at a men-only Muslim march because that reminds everyone how non-racist she is, which benefits Creasy. Creasy asserts that ‘trans women are women’, which keeps her in good odour with her party’s most aggressive activists, and benefits Creasy.
However, keeping cross-dressing heterosexual men out of nurses’ changing rooms doesn’t benefit Creasy, because Creasy has never had to mop up other people’s piss, blood and vomit at work. Challenging the notion that a male basketball player becomes a girl if he says he is doesn’t benefit Creasy, who has no sporting ambitions. Speaking up against the patriarchy as practised by non-white men doesn’t benefit Creasy, who wants those selfie-opportunities. Criticising an ideological movement that persecutes, harasses and openly threatens women who don’t believe some women have penises wouldn't benefit Creasy, because she's already fully-signed up to self-id, where any man who says he's a woman must be taken at his word.
As the late Gloria Steinem said: ‘“Feminism has never been about getting a job for one woman. It's about making life more fair for women everywhere.’
Creasy the patriarchy-challenger is provably more than happy to cosy up to men and misogynist movements when it suits her public profile and career advancement, no matter the harms those men might be causing less privileged women. By Steinem’s definition, what Stella espouses is not feminism, but Creasyism, and I suggest the emblem for this brave new rights movement should be an indignant parakeet with severely ruffled feathers.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/life/stella-creasy-jk-rowling-wrong-woman-can-have-penis/
I'm converging on the view that the transgender movement won everything when they successfully pressured everyone to use their language and won't relinquish that victory until all are free to use it or not use it as they see fit
Quoting @wesyang: The question is whether I have a duty to defer to your sense of offense or whether you have a duty to cultivate resilience to an accurate reference to a fact about yourself without recourse to dishing out consequences (which will in turn invite consequences.) The fact that I am referring to a material fact and you are referring to an inner desire for something untrue to be treated as true means that I think I have the stronger case that must eventually prevail.
Becerra was Biden's chief hatchet man implementing the trans agenda in the federal government. Tempting as it is, not every one of Erin Reed's enemies is our friend, alas.
Feminists didn't want to be confined by their biology and saw that the rhetoric of natural and immutable distinctions was a key instrument in their confinement to the sphere of domesticity.
After definitively escaping their confinement to the private sphere by seizing control of their fertility, (and indeed becoming entrapped in market relations dictated by linear time fundamentally hostile to childbearing and family formation) they somehow ended up endorsing the view that any man who says he is a woman is a woman, up to and including a male serial murderer of women.
Along the way, they wound up colluding with the agenda of a group of male fetishists sexually aroused by the thought of themselves as women who sought to validate their own demands for inclusion in women's spaces and competitions by chemically castrating and dismembering confused children caught up in a social contagion, thus creating a subpopulation of biologically damaged human shields who could serve as leverage in their pursuit of the legal privileges (to compel others to recognize them as the sex they claim to be, which is the sex they are not) that are the aim of all trans rights activism.
Along the way, a burgeoning cohort of teenaged girls sought an escape from the vicissitudes and burdens of womanhood by refashioning their bodies to present as men (by dosing themselves with steroids and chopping off their breasts) and came to outnumber male to female transitioners by ratio of at least 2 to 1 in less than half a decade.
Is it "feminist" to cut off your breasts and take steroids? Is it "feminist" to call a castrated man a woman? The leaders of all the most richly funded feminist organizations speak in unison in saying "yes".
This seething mass of internal contradictions is generative of endless mindless discourse and endless crazed spectacle -- but it is also mortifying the bodies of thousands upon thousands of confused young people and tearing apart families who wish to protect their children from ritualized self-harm. It is a kind of moronic singularity in which all the hypertrophied aspirations of those seeking new moral horizons amidst the terminal boredom at the end of history reach a terrible apotheosis.
Quoting @LeorSapir: For decades scholars in various disciplines including evolutionary biology filled university bookshelves with writings explaining why sex categories are socially constructed and why failure to appreciate this fact is a reflection of “patriarchy.”
The overwhelming majority of that scholarship was done by women who described themselves as feminists. Some used the label “queer” in addition or instead of “feminist.”
My early work on this topic tried to trace how these ideas infiltrated over time into law and policy. The process often happened through the adoption of the ideas in law review articles and mainstream news or opinion articles, where sex denialism was often strategically framed in terms amenable to “living constitutionalist” judges and civil rights state bureaucrats.
Some of these articles were directly cited by courts in rulings that inscribe gender identity into law at the expense of sex. (A good example is the 3rd circuit case Doe v Boyertown Area School District.)
Administrative agencies especially under Obama and Biden cited those court rulings to further institutionalize gender identity in education, prisons, healthcare, and more.
The point is that academic feminists whose views were treated as authoritative by key institutional decision-makers. Those academics sincerely believed that social recognition of sex categories as biologically rooted and socially relevant was scientifically wrong and unjust. Their work was a major and in some venues decisive contributing factor to the institutionalization of gender identity. They were not unwitting agents of “perverted men with porn addiction.” They did not speak for all feminists, of course, but their viewpoint was unquestionably dominant in elite academic, policy, and NGO circles, and they had reasons for doing what they did. Reasons they took care to articulate and defend. They had agency.
DeVries was the Dutch clinician who embarked on the crazed experiment of puberty blocking children in pursuit of better cosmetic results. She is now pivoting with the rest of her field toward a repudiation of the (always false) claim that transgender identities are immutable.
https://x.com/maanvis81/status/2097075091825627158?s=20
Quotes a post by T05549; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans identities are not immutable -- they do change. That's just observable fact (while trans identities are not observable facts) based on the existence of detransitioners and others who change their gender identification (from M to F to nonbinary to genderqueer and back). The German law that allows anyone to change their gender identity once a year also contains a provision allowing for people to sue others for using a prior gender identity under certain circumstances. A German neo-Nazi who is housed with women because he claims to be a woman is suing journalists who made an accurate reference to his sex.
Trans activists looking for a scapegoat for the movement's downward spiral are blaming Chase Strangio for telling the truth before SCOTUS (she admitted that trans identities are not immutable because they are subject to change, a key tenet of gender ideology that lead Germany to allow anyone to change their gender identification once a year) and for admitting that there is no evidence that puberty blockers prevent suicide (despite the willingness of her co-counsel, the Solicitor General of the United States, Elizabeth Prelogar, to lie in the same hearing, and claim that they do, as she did.)
But the fault here is with a movement built on self-evident falsehoods.
Quotes a post by T07864; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans Activists in NYC will throw a tantrum in front of Mt. Sinai, once one of the largest providers of chemical castration drugs to confused children who had been brainwashed to believe that sterilizing themselves and destroying their sexual function will change their sex, and pretend that declining to sterilize a child is genocide.
Mt. Sinai's gender practice was headed up by Jess Ting, a close friend of Jeffrey Epstein who offered concierge medical service to various friends of Epstein and sought funding from Epstein for a propaganda film marketing gender surgeries and visited Epstein's island.
Kamala Harris sent Dylan Mulvaney a letter on White House stationary. congratulating him on 365 days of girlhood.
He is not more or less of a woman than Royce White, who is not more or less of a woman than the "trans women" with whom he is debating here.
All are men who say they are women, nothing less or more.
Quotes a post by T01176; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
State governments across Blue America will have to make the same admission -- trans-identified male criminals have raped female inmates -- and make the same contorted argument -- it's OK to let male criminals rape women in prison if the men say they are women and the policy must continue
Quoting @reduxx: The Canadian government has finally admitted that trans-identified male criminals placed in women's prisons have raped female inmates.
Despite the assaults, the government has said its policies do not infringe on the women's rights.
https://reduxx.info/canada-government-admits-trans-identified-male-prisoners-have-raped-female-inmates-denies-infringing-womens-rights/
A similar lawsuit is happening in New Jersey. The Transgender Inquisition is global and unitary and is assaulting the core rights of parents to direct the upbringing of their children in every part of the Western world and Anglosphere. A US Supreme Court ruling found this to be a Constitutional violation, but Blue states across the country have issued legal guidance permitting the states to disregard the ruling, necessitating a further round of litigation.
Quoting @News24Aust: A wealthy school district has been hit with a lawsuit for allowing students to change their names and gender identities on school records without telling their parents, according to reports.
https://www.news24.com.au/world/united-states/wealthy-new-jersey-district-sued-for-allowing-kids-to-change-their-names-and-gender-on-school-records-without-parents-knowing/news-story/4201d1d09b829a55970fe8b03c86f941
The transgender movement ended the possibility of anything functioning as a reductio ad absurdum for any claim emerging from the left. It immunized any claim from susceptibility to rational disproof.
Whatever falsehood you are commanded to take seriously, you have already been trained to believe an even more flagrant lie or face expulsion from the human family.
Quotes a post by A2848; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The country's largest pediatric gender clinics are shuttering.
They all committed criminal billing fraud.
They all engaged in non-evidence based medical procedures that inflict irreversible lifelong harms on children.
Tish James has threatened NYC hospitals with legal consequences if they don't start chemically castrating and dismembering confused children, claiming that declining to sterilize a child is violation of NYC Human Rights law. She has not followed through with these threats.
One of the largest youth transgender clinics in America just called her bluff.
Let's see if she makes good.
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: Major New York Hospital Settles With DoJ Over Youth Gender Clinic, Keeps It Shuttered
Substack link: https://benryan.substack.com/p/major-new-york-hospital-settles-with
Given Mt. Sinai Health System had a large pediatric gender clinic and is in a blue state with a supportive attorney general, this settlement serves as a grim harbinger for this beleaguered field.
Mt. Sinai Health System in New York City, which until early this year operated a substantial pediatric gender clinic, has reached a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice in which it will keep the clinic shuttered, pay a monetary penalty, and provide treatment to those who were harmed by gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
Given Mt. Sinai operates in a Democrat-led state with an attorney general, Letitia James, who is broadly supportive of gender-transition interventions for minors, this settlement serves as an ominous harbinger for what remains of the embattled field of pediatric gender medicine as the Trump admin has sought to destroy it.
According to an analysis of medical billing records conducted by the nonprofit Do No Harm, which opposes pediatric gender medicine, Mt. Sinai’s billing for related services was in recent years the highest in the nation.
While the precise details that triggered the settlement remain opaque, the Trump administration had apparently accused Mt. Sinai that it had violated federal law by submitting fraudulent billing codes for gender-transition interventions.
Mt. Sinai has agreed to pay an undisclosed monetary penalty and to dedicate $2 million to patients who, in the words of a Justice Department release on the settlement, have suffered “harmful consequences” of the gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
“In working towards this resolution,” the release states, “the United States acknowledged that Mount Sinai took significant steps entitling it to credit for cooperation with the Department in its investigation. At all times during the investigation, Mount Sinai remained cooperative, proactive, and solution-driven, as evidenced by its multimillion-dollar commitment to detransition care.”
“The Department of Justice is committed to holding accountable medical providers that violate federal law and endanger children through so-called gender-affirming care,” Attorney General Todd Blanche @AGToddBlanche said in a statement. “This agreement puts an end to these practices at Mount Sinai and provides meaningful relief for individuals who have already suffered harm.”
"Transgender women" are men who mimic women. There is zero biological basis for the claim that "gender identity", a non-observational subjective inner essence knowable solely through self-report has any scientific basis. All putatively "scientific" claims to this effect are merely convoluted restatements of the same circular reasoning and were published solely as a result of the corruption of scientific journals through campaigns of institutional capture. The claims all unravel at the barest scrutiny and were manufactured solely for the purposes of laundering self-evident falsehoods as fact by liars and propagandists.
Gloria Steinem was skeptical of the transgender movement and favorably cited Janice Raymond's The Transsexual Empire in the 1970's, referring to gender surgeries as "mutilation".
But like the rest of US feminist leadership, she moved where the funding went in the 2010's and became a full-on trans activist, claiming that feminist and transgender movements were engaged in the same struggle. (In fact, there has never been a more zero-sum contest than the one between women's desire for privacy and safety in intimate spaces away from men and the imperious demands for inclusion of any man who says he is a woman that is the foundation of the transgender movement.)
Like everyone who went down the waterfall to mindless delusion, she often made sage reference to an evolving understanding of sex and gender that was never actually articulated because all the understanding consisted of was mule-like obeisance to though-terminating cliches, dogmas, slogans, and cheap rhetorical ploys that any child can see through.
The book industry did a report that found that the industry was more than 70 percent female and like 8x the population baseline trans-identified and concluded "there's so much more work to be done to achieve gender equity" that necessarily implied that any remaining men in the industry who weren't pretending to be women meant gender equity had not been achieved.
So it goes for all diversity initiatives.
Quotes a post by T04136; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Aella is a TERF and a transphobe because she knows that a man can't become a woman. That's all the term means. It doesn't mean animus toward the trans-identified or wishing harm on them. It doesn't even mean not using their preferred pronouns and welcoming them into women-only spaces, which Aella happily does. She is socially proximate to a literal transgender murder cult and continues to post frenetic and entirely sincere affirmations of her adoration for and acceptance of trans folx.
But the only way to not be a TERF and a transphobe is to believe transgender dogmas which Aella does not believe because they aren't true. She can deny but will be instantly confronted by an army of angry trans-identified folx who will point out that believing in data and the reality that the data records means being a TERF and transphobe. They will be right, because both terms are made-up smear words invented by trans activists to mean anyone who disputes their claims to be something they are not and can never be, and when they apply that term to Aella, they are applying it correctly, and they know it because Aella hasn't hidden her grounding in reality well enough for them not to know it.
In this, she is like the overwhelming supermajority of the world's population who knows that a man can't become a woman. This population includes roughly 95 percent of all the people who use preferred pronouns and consider it kind to enable trans-identified folx in their false belief that they were born in the wrong body and that medically harming themselves and destroying their sexual function and fertility has restored them to their authentic selves.
All are TERF's and transphobes because being a TERF and a transphobe just means knowing that the things you must believe to not be a TERF and a transphobe are untrue.
Quotes a post by T00099; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialideology cultviolence terror
We should understand that the editorial -- and the underlying story that it misconstrues -- is the normal product of the dominant sensibility that controls the truth-seeking and certifying apparatus of the Western world.
If you believe that there is "a scientific consensus" on behalf of the proposition that 1.) gender-affirming care is lifesaving and medically necessary, that 2.) science has shown that trans women have no athletic advantages over women or that 3.) we have moved beyond a binary understand of sex, it is solely because of the workings of an apparatus that launders scientific fraud in the pages of the most prestigious journals as part of its normal operation.
Quotes a post by T03331; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Good news:
“The executive director of the Transgender Law Center, which describes itself as the largest national trans-led organization, shared that there has been a “near complete exodus” of philanthropy from the transgender rights movement.”
Take such claims with a grain of salt from professionals seeking more donations. But if some people are waking up to the authoritarian falsehoods the transgender movement is seeking to entrench in law and choosing not to fund them, it’s for sure a good sign.
Trudeau invoked the Emergency Act, an act that Canada's high court ruled to be unlawful, and debanked the leaders of the trucker protest.
And, no, it's dry hyperbole to say non-rural Canada generates nothing but woke and trans -- how obtuse does one have to be to think otherwise? -- but the flip statement does refer to the true fact that totalitarian wokeness of the sort that American wokes sought to impose in the US is an accomplished fact in Canada.
They are also dangerous for female bodybuilders but fine for pregnant women who pretend to be men and are only seen as a problem by some because of prejudicial biases for "normative bodies" and against trans-folx
This is because all mentally disturbed youth are routed into transgender identification, an amorphous designation with no stable, coherent meaning that confers special privileges onto anyone claiming it
Quotes a post by A2687; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When you say that "there are fairness issues when it comes to trans inclusion in girls sports," what you are saying is that trans women are men.
Democrats can't fight back against trans inclusion in sports because it means saying that trans women are men.
Whenever Democrats gingerly say "there are fairness issues when it comes to trans inclusion in girls sports," an army of Trans Activists confronts them with the reality that what Democrats are saying is that Trans Women Are Men.
The Democrat then shuts down and votes against Republican sponsored bills protecting girls sports.
The symbols of trans-national sectarian power-seeking movements that attack the foundational rights of every individual have no place being imposed by state institutions onto children or citizens of any age
Quotes a post by A2174; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The reason you can't let Trans Women compete in women's sport is that they are men.
The reason you can't let Trans Women into women's bathrooms, changing rooms, spas, shelters, or prisons is that they are men.
The reason you can't force people to use gender-based pronouns is that compulsory lying violates a right that everyone holds not to be coerced into saying things they don't believe.
The reason you can't chemically castrate and dismember confused children is that children can't consent to medicalized harm.
The reason gender medicine isn't medicine is that it's never been evidence-based and it's inherently self-harming.
The reason you can't teach children that any of them can change sex is that the claim is a lie.
The reason you can't build a civil rights movement out of people pretending to be something they are not is that "people pretending to be something they are not" is not an actual group, the group has never been oppressed (except by the binary and immutable nature of sex which is beyond the reach of any act of human self-determination), and there is no such thing as a duty to see someone as they see themselves or treat them as something other than what they are.
The whole thing has to be refused in its entirety.
Greenwald did a great post on his attempts to do a documentary about @martina directed by Kimberley Peirce and how trans activist wrecked it:
https://archive.is/e2iv0
The signaling by Trans Activists that their own preferences override the interests of the broader Left and Democrat coalition should (but likely won't) signal to those coalition that they are free to reciprocate
Extending the statute of limitations for transgender procedures is the silver bullet that will end the gender industry the instant it goes into effect without any need for further legislation.
We know this because Missouri allowed gender clinics to keep giving out puberty blockers to existing clients for an additional year when it banned them for minors and extended the statue of limitations. The clinic elected to cease chemically castrating children immediately rather than continue for another year as permitted by law.
“Trans Kids know who they are” is what the doctors say before accepting vast payments for implanting chemical castration drugs into a child as young as 9 — when compelled to reveal their true preferences, they show they don’t actually believe it. They don’t believe it because it isn’t true.
It takes many years for children brainwashed into believing they were born in the wrong that they were medically harmed by their doctors. If the law reflects that reality, all the doctors will end their practices the day the law goes into effect.
Quotes a post by A0760; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Erin Reed recently said he prefers Republican gubernatorial victories to any Democrat moderation on any trans issue.
Various Trans Activists recently said in unison that they reject Medicare For All if it means that the non-evidence based cosmetic procedures that produce endocrine disorders and destruction of sexual function and fertility on those who inflict them on themselves are less likely to be covered by taxpayer subsidy.
For the ones who identify as leftists or progressives, it's a clear signal that the interests and needs of the broader Democrat and left coalitions take a backseat to their own interests and desires.
Quoting @AriDrennen: Can you guys help me understand something? I’ve realized that when I say “I do not think a specific policy (Medicare for All) is good for my community,” many of you are hearing “I don’t think people deserve healthcare,” which is not at all what I mean.
Blue states will remain Blue states. It's being attempted in the Red States and if real gains for the party come from it, the party will have to become at minimum more tolerant of dissent everywhere.
Moulton made a statement but then voted against girls sports in the House and with Markey on his transgender bill of rights, so he lost the passionate trans-affirming Dem minority without making any real gains with the less invested Dem majority that agrees with him.
Trans activists like Erin Reed are open and explicit that they prefer Republicans beating Democrats to Democrats moderating in any way on any trans issue in order to beat Republicans.
Sand joins with Amy Acton, the Ohio Dem nominee for gov, in making explicit statements supporting restricting women's and girl's sports to female people. If a Democrat wins back a Red State through moderation on trans issues, the partisan firewall will come crashing down, party discipline on this issue will unravel, and Democratic candidates across the spectrum will be free to represent what polling has shown is a supermajority of Democrat voters on this issue.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Zero Tolerance
Transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed asserts that Rob Sand, the Dem nominee for gov in Iowa, has crossed her red line for coming out against cross-sex participation in sports. She calls such a position “a cancer” and said it’s better that Republican wins than a Democrat espouses such a philosophy. She has absolutely zero tolerance, she insists.
The campaign to make lactation sexual is not coming from critics of men who lecture about how to induce lactation in men for sexual gratification.
It is coming from men who lecture about how to induce lactation in trans-identified men for sexual gratification.
Quotes a post by T05010; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Because Moulton cucked on supporting female athletes like his daughter, he gets no credit for his empty rhetoric on the issue and comes off as a weakling to anyone who was momentarily interested by it while also losing the primary voters invested in trans affirmation
https://x.com/mandyzhang08/status/2094167660179173590?s=20
Quotes a post by T33842; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Moulton is no better substantively than Markey, signing on to Markey's "transgender bill of rights" -- but in usual trans-activist fashion, Markey is seeking to portray Moulton as an enemy of human rights for simply stating that he doesn't want his daughters dominated by a boy on the athletic field and that he shouldn't be anathematized for saying so.
Tracy Coyle has said that properly gatekept gender medicine would result in a reduction of 99 percent of FTM transitions and 90-95 percenrt of MTF transitions. (For this reason, of course, it is a political non-starter that would never be accepted by any existing transgender movement.) I'm curious if you agree with [Coyle's] assessment of what properly gatekept gender medicine would look like.
Tracy Coyle has said that properly gatekept gender medicine would result in a reduction of 99 percent of FTM transitions and 90-95 percenrt of MTF transitions. (For this reason, of course, it is a political non-starter that would never be accepted by any existing transgender movement.) I'm curious if you agree with his assessment of what properly gatekept gender medicine would look like.
There may be some utility in pretending that the sports issue is severable in order to sever it and then in the aftermath underscore what was thereby done (that Trans Activists are right to be fighting tooth and nail.) But we should not ourselves be deceived by this instrumental deceit, and it seems that all "reasonable moderates" are more self-deceived than deceiving on this front. (Though of course I may be deceived.)
It’s OK to call a man who claims to be a woman a man when he assaults his ex-boyfriend. He’s not a woman. He is a man. Making an accurate reference to someone’s sex is not dehumanizing because a man is a type of human. The state has no business forcing its agents to pretend a man is a woman.
This statement would be true if the man pretending to be a woman hadn’t assaulted his ex-boyfriend. It would be true if he was an elected representative in Congress. It would be true if he was employed by the Central Intelligence Agency.
Transgenderism is the claim that a person’s inner belief that they are something they are not confers upon them a right to be regarded and treated by others as the thing they are not, which necessarily entails a duty enforceable by law, for others to treat them as the thing they are not. It is a totally novel kind of right that is the very opposite of the equal treatment that civil rights laws have always compelled. It is a special privilege to special treatment that masquerades as a right to equal treatment.
It is a novel claim that must be refused because making unprovable and unfalsifiable claims to bear an otherwise non-observable inner identity at variance with a material fact about oneself the basis for an imposition of duty is not just “open to abuse”.
It literally defines any possibility of a false claim out of existence. It has already produced dozens of cases of male rapists and murderers who are in women’s prisons, a classic reductio ad absurdum that no one has any idea how to prevent (or will to prevent it) because the very possibility of a false claim has already been defined out of existence. You cannot create a legally protected class out of such claims.
You can only create a system of state repression of anyone who knows what a woman is and is not, which, thankfully a tribunal in Australia has declined to do, despite Australia’s commitment to “trans rights.” Anyone writing weepy articles about how they are being “denied bathroom access” (no one is denied bathroom access, you are free to use the one that corresponds to your sex) seeks state repression on their behalf.
Quotes a post by A0799; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Post-feminist, gay-friendly Westerners see trans as a kind of Gay+ but traditionalist cultures (Iran, Puerto Rico, African-Americans, some evangelical whites) see it as a way of preserving the gender binary. If you are the former it is *really* hard to understand the latter.
These violent male criminals who have been recognized as women by Maine prison authorities and moved into women's prisons on the basis of the claim that they are women are Real Trans Women. Enes Kanter is a fake trans women. Because when some men falsely claim to be women, it is true that they are women, and when other men falsely claim to be women, it is false.
Quotes a post by T04265; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You see, Enes Kanter is a bad faith troll, but the... convicted male pedophiles incarcerated in a women's prison in Minneapolis who have been using photos of female inmate's children to threaten them into silence are Stunning and Brave Trans Women whose gender identity must be honored
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: The child sexual abusers - convicted pedophiles - in the women's prison in Minnesota, Shakopee, have been using photos of female inmates' children to threaten them into silence
The claim that 400K trans-identified people have fled their states is based on an extrapolation from a non-representative poll that found a total of ten (10) people had fled a state
Quoting @benryanwriter: This Washington Post article claims that an NORC survey found 400,000 trans people have recently fled to another state.
As @kittypurrzog pointed out on @[private account], the 400K figure was, with some faulty math, extrapolated by Erin Reed based on the NORC survey, which included just 10 trans people who said they’d fled a state. The survey did not provide a representative sample either. So this figure has been all but plucked out of the air and was not actually reached by NORC themselves. It is a figment of Erin Reed’s work with a calculator.
This is not to say that trans people are not fleeing red states. But it is extremely unlikely that 400,000 of them have.
Looks like the trans-identified woman who played in the WNBA may have been on Performance Enhancing Drugs -- taking steroids in order to affirm her trans identity. This of course is straightforwardly cheating. https://x.com/Anne_on_gd/status/2093437856496615925?s=20
The Transgender Inquisition is global and has already succeeded in inscribing its preferences into state law in the United States -- Colorado mandates that every owner of a public accommodation in the state falsify reality on behalf of any man who says he is a woman or face punishment
Quotes a post by A0606; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This person removed her breasts and remained a woman because removing your breasts does not change your sex. The league allowed her to play because Trans Men are Women. The league is not allowing Enes Kanter to play because Trans Women are Men.
Now they just need to clarify this in policy, aligning their policy with that of the International Olympic Committee, World Athletics, and the Women's Tennis Association, and this stupid controversy is over for all time as it already is for most women's sports.
Quotes a post by T08988; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Josh Shaprio has worked tirelessly throughout his whole career to ensure there was no daylight between himself and the most extreme trans activist.
https://x.com/luce_lexi/status/2093350795076841874?s=20
Quotes a post by T05497; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Every reputed moderate Democratic party elected official has worked tirelessly to ensure that no daylight exists between themselves and the most extreme trans activist
Quoting @MegEBrock: Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro is quietly trying to erase women and mothers from his state’s health code.
The Democrat’s administration has removed female terminology and replaced it with transgender-inclusive language in a proposed overhaul to Pennsylvania’s health code.
Donald Trump won Ohio by 11 in 2024, cementing the fact that Ohio is no longer a swing state.
Acton is showing what happens when Democrats support keeping men (trans women are men, didn’t you know?) out of women’s sports. She is the first major Democratic candidate with the balls to break with the death grip the transgender movement holds over the party.
Quoting @AFpost: Amy Acton is now projected to defeat the Ohio Grinch, Vivek Ramaswamy, for Governor of Ohio, overtaking him in election odds, giving Acton nearly a 10% higher probability of winning.
Follow: @AFpost
In a major ruling, a federal appeals court in New Hampshire found that a school that banned parents who engaged in silent protest of policies that put boys in athletic competition against girls from seeing their children compete had violated the First Amendment rights of those parents.
"The court highlighted evidence that school officials viewed the “XX” message as “hateful,” “anti-trans,” and “exclusionary,” concluding that the record showed a likelihood that officials punished the plaintiffs because of the viewpoint expressed. The court explained that school officials “cannot favor one side of a debate involving parental speech on an issue of prominent public concern, and which, in those parents’ views, concerned the safety of their children.”
The First Circuit also found no evidence that the wristband protest itself caused a disruption, or that any player even saw the wristbands. Instead, the court concluded that the protest “fell short of harassment and disruption,” and that school officials could not rely on predictions of possible disruption to suppress the right of the plaintiffs to engage in passive, silent speech."
In your view, would there have been no increase in the trans-identified population if the prior protocol that you transitioned under remained in place today?
"This is a totally fake non-issue! No trans woman is trying to play in the WNBA! "
1.) The whole point of aligning the rules of the WNBA with the global standard set by World Athletics, the International Olympic Committee, and the Women's Tennis Association is to ensure that it stays that way.
2.) You would support any man who says he is a woman (who is not obviously doing so for effect) playing in the WNBA if he tried.
Quoting @wesyang: They let this man win world titles and set a record in women's swimming because he said he was a woman
You see, Enes Kanter and Royce White are bad faith trolls, but the world record holding male swimmer on the left and the male powerlifter who obtained a Minnesota Supreme Court ruling that any sport that excludes men who say they are women from competition against women on the left are Stunning and Brave Trans Women.
Quoting @wesyang: The man on the left was allowed to win multiple world women's swimming titles and to set a world record because he said he was a woman. He is a man. He is not a woman
The man on the right successfully filed a lawsuit against Minnesota that resulted in the state Supreme Court forbidding any women's sporting league from excluding any man who says he is a woman from competing against women. He is a man. He is not a woman.
Despite the claims of both of these men to be women, they are both men because they are both adult human males.
Claiming you are a woman is not what makes someone a woman. Being a woman is a material, biological fact that exists independently of whether a person claims to be one.
If either of these men claimed to be Napoleon Bonparte, I would be in a position to know better than them that they are not Napoleon Bonaparte, because Napoleon Bonaparte died in the early 19th century and both of these men are alive in 2025.
Somehow the dominant institutions of social consensus in the Western world, including the US Democratic party have successfully imposed a taboo against calling these men men and persuaded people that only a "fascist" would deny any man's attempt to falsify his sex. A man in Switzerland is serving a ten day jail sentence for denying that a man can become a woman. It is these institutions that are responsible for the "culture war," not anyone responding to these impositions by pointing out that they are all based on falsehoods and absurdities in the service of actively harmful demands.
The state has already determined that he is a woman because he said he is a woman. He has not had his male genitals removed.
You've repeatedly said you support reasonable gatekeeping of trans identities. If you were in charge of the trans woman licensing board would you certify him or not?
The more interesting test case would have been a player with a history of gender nonconformity like Rodman, who could make a more plausible claim to having realized late in life that he had always been a woman on the inside. (An academic Queer theorist wrote a book in earnest claiming Rodman as Queer and trans.) In that case, I think he would have to be welcomed into the league and anyone speaking against him would be forced into silence by the league.
It's possible he made some missteps along the way. Of course, if he had presented himself differently, he would have had the support of the transgender movement and the law, as did the male serial murderer of women seeking entrance to the women's shelter.
"Trans Women don't owe you femininity."
Dylan Mulvaney did a video about "normalizing women having bulges" in trans women.
Studies show that between 5-13 percent of trans identified males have removed their testicles or had vaginoplasty.
The 2022 US Transgender survey reported that 60 percent of trans-identified males have medicalized in some way.
Fully intact male rapists and murderers are imprisoned in women's prisons because they've said they are women.
The work of making Royce White a valid trans women is the work of the last two decades of the transgender movement.
That was literally the explicit aim of the movement, now accomplished.
It is what trans activist and their allies in parliaments across Europe have worked feverishly to make a human rights violation to deny. A man every bit as masculine as Royce White obtained a $100K+ judgment in an Australian court because a woman-only app denied him entry.
Quoting @Highway_30: Autobots vs. Decepticons — That's what this is turning into. My new Trans basketball nickname is Toptimus Prime! WE HAVE ANOTHER ONE... This decepticon is telling me I'm not transitioning correctly! Let me explain something to you boo boo, the Kweeeen does't answer to anybody about my hormones, genitalia or wardrobe.
Now I can't wear a wig and a suit? Says who? Is there an ITC (International Trans Court) that oversees the Trans dress code? When a beautiful Black woman transitions we don't follow the trends, we set the trends. Beards and Suits is the new deconstruction of cis normative wardrobing. You're late with the nails... That's cis woman stuff!
P.S. Once I drop the allspark in this Birkin bag it's over for you haters! Okkkkur 🤏🏽🧔🏽♀️
Royce White for President
WNBA #LetRoyshaPlay
There is no "sincerity" requirement or test in NYC Human Rights Law for who receives access to the women's changing room, domestic violence shelter, prison, or sporting competition. New York City jailed a male serial murderer of women who beheaded and dismembered a woman with women because he said he was a woman after allowing him to access a women's shelter over and against the fears of women in the shelter because he said was a woman. (He has since then ceased referring to himself as a woman.) Enes Kanter and Royce White are well within the parameters of who will be treated like a woman if they say they are women (any man who says he is a woman) according to the letter of New York City Human Rights Law and the practice of NYC Human Rights Law. If the league wishes to contest their designation in court, they can make reference to no criteria encoded in NYC Human Rights Law, or to the concept of gender identity as the transgender movement and the Democratic party constructs it and as the latter entity enforces it in policy and law. No one has attempted to spell out how to differentiate the subset of men who claim that they are women that are women from the subset of men who claim to be women who that are not women. (None are women because all are men.)
Quoting @RealDanZak: OutKick asked the WNBA to explain why Enes Kanter Freedom and Royce White are ineligible, given that the league’s CBA says only women may play but does not define “woman.”
The league didn't respond.
Pinker wrote a piece in 2006 in the (Jeffrey Epstein funded) publication http://Edge.Org saying that we would discover genetic difference between human populations. He said it would be fine for us to investigate such questions so long as we rigorously adhered to evaluating people as individuals without allowing group-based differences to bias us in the individual case.
He has since changed his mind as scientists close in on discovering those differences. In fact, he changed his mind while in conversation with me in Washington Square Park in advance of a debate he would have with Steve Hsu and Dalton Conley about the role that genomics should play in social science.
None of this has any bearing on transgender dogmas, which are simple falsehoods being imposed through academic groupthink and state power.
"Transphobia" is just disbelief in the false dogmas of the transgender movement. Open inquiry will in all cases reveal the debility (the incoherence, invalidity, and falseness) of transgender arguments. Anyone seeking to prop up false arguments that will necessarily be exposed as false through open inquiry will of course seek restriction on open inquiry.
Yes, of course: free inquiry is bad for those committed to imposing a falsehood on the whole world as the only truth. That is why the transgender movement has done its utmost to destroy free inquiry.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s because 1.) keeping boys off the girls volleyball team necessarily implies that trans people aren’t real and 2.) the Democratic Party made using state power to coerce people into acting as if trans people are real into the civil rights movement of the 21st century.
It was a very dumb thing to do, but they did do it through innumerable speech acts and legislative acts and there is no way to retreat.
Quoting @mattyglesias: The idea that we need absolute deference to mass opinion on technical questions of utility regulation but no compromise with the electorate on “who plays on the girls volleyball team?” is a really perverse way of thinking about politics.
“Accurately and fairly reporting events as they happened” should not be a cause for celebration when it happens, but it happens so rarely with the trans issue that it is
Quotes a post by A3058; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There are three things that transgender ideology cannot withstand and must eradicate in order to secure its victory: 1.) liberalism, which protects people's individual freedom of speech and conscience; 2.) pluralism, which protects people against the imposition of a state-mandated dogma and requires all social movements to respect limits on the power they can exercise over unbelievers; and 3.) democracy, which allows the will of the people to rule.
Colorado's ballot initiatives is the best (and possibly last) chance for the will of the people to be brought to bear in a state captured by extreme trans-affirming dogma inscribed into law by a political party that has worked feverishly to allow no daylight between itself and the most extreme trans activists.
Solid majorities of Democrats and supermajorities of the electorate oppose the chemical castration and dismemberment of confused children and the imposition of men into women's sport, but the mere voters count for nothing compared to the astroturfed pseudo-consensus that controls every legislator.
The ballot affords them a chance to speak, and to break the dam everywhere.
Quoting @Erin4Parents: In November, Colorado will be the FIRST blue state to protect kids from irreversible mutilation — the FIRST by the will of the people — and the FIRST volunteer army to stand up & stop this harm on children.
LET’S GO COLORADO!!! 💪🏼
Vote Yes, Yes, Yes! ✅ ✅ ✅
This is not a hardline view. It is a logically coherent, consistent view. It is a view dictated by the dogmas of the transgender movement itself. They asserted a claim which served as the foundation upon which every accommodation rested. The claim is false. Everything that rests upon the false claim must be refused.
The person from Massachusetts who brought firebombs to the US Capitol to murder Scott Bessent is not a woman. He is a man. He is a man who says he is a woman, but his saying so does not change the fact that he is a man.
Trans-identified males have plotted to kill Bret Kavanaugh, Scott Bessent, and JD Vance. The sentencing of Bessent’s would-be killer by a trans-identified male is barely even news: just another dog bites man story.
Quotes a post by T01089; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C3 dehumanizingdenialmedia pronoun complaintmotive displacementshooter attributionviolence terror
Eventually a Democrat was going to emerge who was going to be undaunted by the astroturfed pseudo-consensus that dominates the party that says forbidding any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman is the civil rights movement of the 21st century.
It was inevitable this would happen because the pseudo-consensus is built on an absurdity and a lie and people of integrity will notice that. It helps that the first person to contest the movement’s hegemony is a 23-years old New Hampshire state legislator who was part of the first cohort to be brainwashed from the earliest age to believe transgender dogmas as the only truth. A growing number of them who see the results of this mindless ideological mania on their peers understand what he does.
It does not, btw, help in any way that he is black: none of his D colleagues defer to him; indeed they take great relish in comparing him to the white Southern racists who resisted integration— their faces brim over with delight at how cleverly apt they are being as they repeat these canned talking points. They feel that doing this to a black man is the most delicious thing in the world.
Quoting @jonahowheeler: Gender ideology is an illiberal, backwards way of thinking that I make no apologies for opposing.
Heres a bit of my explanation as to why.
Yes, that’s what it means to be transgender — a man who says he is a woman or a woman who says she is a man. In both cases, people are claiming to be something they are not.
People seeking legal recognition of the falsification of their sex do exist, but making a false claim to be something you are not does not confer a right of recognition onto anyone or a duty of affirmation onto anyone else.
This is what should have been said at the outset of the transgender movement — *before* we memed hundreds of thousands of confused youth into believing they were born in the wrong body. But it will have to be said now because it was always true and always will be true. There will be collateral damage here that is solely and entirely the responsibility of the people that set us on this course that we must refuse.
Quotes a post by T05450; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Strangio had y’all checkmated from day one. No, you cannot make the nonsensical claim that trans folx aren’t real in a boxing ring or a Korean spa but are real in your daughter’s bathroom and an infantry barracks and your lactation support group or that it’s fine to do the will of 2 out of 3 Democrats and keep them out of the boxing ring while deploying state power to force every public accommodation in America to let them violate sex-based boundaries.
You are either with Strangio because trans women are women and trans men are men and will fight for men in women’s sport or you are against her because trans women are men and trans men are women and will fight to put an end to all the ridiculous absurdities and cruelties that trans inclusion necessarily inflicts wherever it is imposed.
Quoting @wesyang: There is no principle at stake in the sports issue different than any other domain where we are called to deploy state power to force people to treat any man who says he is a woman as if he is a woman. The same objection applies in a boxing ring or an infantry barracks or a Korean spa or a YMCA changing room — the claim is not true and is no basis for either the conferral of a right onto a man making it or a duty on anyone else to affirm it.
There is no principle at stake regarding trans inclusion in sports different from the principle at stake in falsifying a driver‘s to list a man’s private reverie of being a woman in lieu of his sex or his desire to get naked in a woman’s changing room rather than the one designated for members of his sex.
It’s the same principle in all cases, and the application of it in all cases is either always “egregious discrimination” or always the reasonable and correct policy that any sane polity would enact.
Yes, I reject the claim that there is anything egregious about returning to the transgender policy that obtained from 1789-June 2016, the year Obama changed the policy
There is no truly egregious discrimination against trans people imposed by the Trump Administration, just a rollback of policies requiring that state institutions pretend that men are women if they say they are women
Quotes a post by A0507; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hundreds rallied in Germany to protest the deportation of Afghan rapists and murderers
Canada went into a paroxysm of self-flagellation over a completely fake "genocide" and is considering legislation to ban "denial" of a thing that never happened
Across the Western world, transgender activists march in the street threatening rape and murder of those who would prevent them from chemically castrating and dismembering confused children who have been brainwashed by the public school system to believe they were born in the wrong body
Thousands rallied in London to mourn a serial liar and plagiarist who was elevated to the position of Cambridge's youngest ever tenured professor after he committed suicide following the exposure of his serial lies and plagiarism
Quotes a post by T06196; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedchild indoctrinationmedical harmmental illnessviolence terror
Maybe it’s surprising to you to learn the ACLU is suing to force Indiana taxpayers to pay for a convicted pedophile rapist’s transgender medicalization.
It shouldn’t be. This has been a leading priority for the ACLU for more than a decade.
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨EXCLUSIVE🚨
The ACLU has stepped in to support a transgender pedophile in his fight to force Indiana taxpayers to cover "gender affirming" surgeries for inmates.
Wayne "Astrid" Allison is serving a 27-year sentence for raping his 11-year-old sister.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-transgender-pedophile-backed-by-aclu-suing-indiana-prison-officials-for-tax-payer-funded-surgeries/
Trans activists always rely on bullying, intimidation, defamation, and censorship to get their way
Quoting @FoxNews: Sophie Cunningham's name has been banned from the WNBA subreddit — and users who question the restriction risk getting banned themselves.
A moderator on the r/WNBA subreddit confirmed that content using Sophie Cunningham's name is being filtered out because it "tends to bring out trolls and people who aren't fans of the W."
Cunningham has been at the center of controversy after taking a stand against biological males in women's sports, and as the league itself struggles to specifically define what a woman actually is as it pertains to WNBA eligibility.
Vindman's House colleague, Sarah McBride, a trans-identified male who supported a rule to force every school in Delaware to lie to parents about the mental health of their children if they believed themselves to be the wrong sex, is no doubt reaching out to Vindman to use the gentle art of persuasion on him and bring him to heel. https://x.com/TwisterFilm/status/1890230634490237079?s=20
Quoting @TwisterFilm: 7./ At @[private account] McBride championed new laws in Delaware including one that insisted girls' changing rooms and restrooms were opened to males. Regulation 225 also prevented schools informing parents if their child self-identified as "transgender". McBride said this was "life-saving".
Because virtually all trans-identified folx have multiple mental health comorbidities, the social clusters are drama prone and are constantly alienating, persecuting, ostracizing, and undermining members of the group
After the love bombing comes the hazing that never ends
"No. You can't fucking talk to me that way."
D Representative Eugene Vindman briefly stood up to bullying from transgender activists and allies confronting him over his vote for a House bill requiring that schools notify parents before changing the names and pronouns of their children. (He later issued an apology.)
A small but growing group of Democrats are getting tired and bored of the mania and bombast of trans activists and allies because they fundamentally understand that the affirming dogmas that the party has imposed across institutions are false. (They would not be tired and bored if they thought those dogmas were true.)
Not a new observation but it’s always funny to see in the flesh how much more diverse — Black, Brown, Queer, Trans, Non-binary, AZN, Latinx — and warmly integrated the Dissident Right NYC dance party is than the DSA one
The reason this claim is only a little bit of an exaggeration is that accusing Singal of transphobia is dispositive proof of being disconnected from reality.
There is a real critique to be made of Singal on the trans issue, and it is not of his transphobia.
There is no "sincerity" requirement or test in NYC human rights law, which is why the league couldn't reach a decision after a meeting whose purpose was to make a decision. They can be sued and will not be able to rid themselves of the suits without arguing that self-ID is an unsustainable standard that the courts should overturn. But nobody at WNBA wants to do that, since this is the demand of the transgender movement and the league and the Democratic party is self-ID.
Some actual triangulation from a Democrat on the trans sports issue.
As I always say, remember what ACLU lead trans rights litigator Strangio pointed out in the screenshot below. House Democratic candidate opposes men in women’s locker rooms because she doesn’t think trans women are “real” women.
She joins Ohio Democrat gubernatorial candidate Amy Acton in taking this normal, reasonable, self-evidently correct stance (grounded in and affirming the true recognition that trans women are men) supported by a supermajority of Democrats.
Quoting @daveweigel: Obviously Gaines isn't going to take the W here, but it's a gender critical W: This is a Dem in a +4 Trump seat (which Dems held from 2019-2023) saying she "oppose[s] letting men in women's locker rooms."
Rs aren't letting them get credit for that position, pointing out that they voted against the 2023 omnibus GOP gender bill. Trans rights groups saw that coming: Change your position and you'll get hit anyway.
But significant that the Dem ticket in Iowa (inc Sand and Turek) have abandoned the bathroom bill/locker room fight and conceded the issue to Rs so they can focus on something else.
https://www.iowapublicradio.org/state-government-news/2023-03-22/iowa-transgender-kids-are-now-barred-from-getting-gender-affirming-care-and-using-certain-school-bathrooms
Until silence gives way to explicit attempts by Democrats to appropriate GOP stances on transgenderism, we should assume that they are merely behaving strategically in hopes of regaining power and reimposing the full trans activist agenda on day one.
This said, recognizing they are constrained by public opinion to moderate their rhetoric is a baby step toward recognizing they are constrained by reality to abandon delusional falsehoods.
Quoting @daveweigel: Sidebar to the "Woke 1 was crazy" discourse...
On Tuesday, the Trump administration announced that Medicaid and CHIP would no longer pay for youth gender medicine. This had been in the works for a while, but there was a full-scale media push; video announcement with Kennedy and Vance, etc.
How have Democrats responded?
Well, the Congressional Equality Caucus, which had lobbied against the rule, condemned it. And...
and that's it. No comment from Dem leaders, nothing from swing state candidates (many of whom are getting GOP attacks on their pro-trans positions).
The House isn't in DC right now, so you weren't going to see members gather and make a statement at the Triangle or something. But you're not seeing many Dems jump to criticize this; instead they're leaving it to the caucus focused on this and letting the Trump media push happen without a bigger response, which would draw more attention to the policy.
https://equality.house.gov/cms-rule-aug11-2026
Michelle Goldberg wrote a piece in Slate more than a decade ago trying to alert the world to the fact that under the new rules governing gender identity, any man who declares himself to be a woman is entitled to recognition as a woman.
Since then, a few things have happened: 1.) the governing institutions of the Western world have all worked feverishly to inscribe this standard into law and policy, 2.) an army of hundreds of thousands of young people were memed into existence claiming cross-sex identities, only a small minority of whom have medicalized in any way, 3.) the state has promised this army a right to violate sex-based boundaries on the basis of a claim to a cross-sex identity, 4.) while the public somehow remains oblivious to this fact and cynical trans activists and allies lie and say that medicalization is required when it serves their interest to do so.
Quotes a post by T05497; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
They aren't Trans Women! They are just men pretending to be women! Wait...
Quoting @Polymarket: JUST IN: WNBA denounces “bad faith” transgender claims after ex-NBA players Enes Kanter Freedom & Royce White declared themselves women & vowed to enter the 2027 WNBA Draft.
Yes, the WNBA allows a woman who claims not to be a woman to play on a woman's league because trans men and female people who claim to be nonbinary are women.
All it needs to do now is act on the reality that trans women are men (as the International Olympic Committe, World Athletics, and the Women's Association has already done) and the issue is resolved. Couldn't be simpler.
It is a complicated conundrum only because the WNBA and its lawyers are part of the Blue Borg that is dedicated to the proposition that the Civil Rights Movement of the 21st century is allowing any man who says he is a woman to violate sex-based boundaries.
Quotes a post by T01944; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Non-discrimination means treating one category of person the same as you would another category of person.
Transgender ideologues do not seek non-discrimination; they seek the imposition of a duty that others violate their consciences in deference to their personal claim to be something they are not
I think it's actually quite possible to reconcile the claims that WPATH's Standards of Care are mere opinion and that they are "Gold Standard of Transgender Healthcare." It's just that this realization concerns the nature of transgender healthcare.
https://x.com/HelloKameHaHaHa/status/2087546542064333028?s=20
Quotes a post by T26362; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It was easy for the transgender ideologues to allow hope to triumph over reality and to lie and persecute people in the service of this hope because triumphing over reality is the very essence of what they are attempting https://x.com/wesyang/status/2087162252252110857?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: They were sure they were right and so were willing to lie to ensure the societywide experiment went forward, which would vindicate them in the long run
Another trans identified male murders a parent, and it’s barely news.
Just another dog bites man story.
Quoting @IfindRetards: Maine mother Angela Caprioli was beaten to death with a hammer by her trans son in his Laguna Beach home.
He had a social media account describing himself as a “trans girl looking for fun in LA”. Almost no media are reporting him as trans, I wonder why.
C2 false claimshand-codedcoverupcrime casedenialviolence terror
It’s doing the reading by depolicing, open borders, decolonizing and transgender child advocates that removes any doubt that there is absolutely anything of merit to any of these movements
Quoting @mattyglesias: I strongly recommend reading Vitale's book, "The End of Policing" for yourself, because until you crack it open you might assume there is secretly some plan or answer to the obvious problems with police abolition and ... there isn't.
Trans women are men and should be barred from women’s sports and all other domains where men seek inclusion as women because mimicking women does not change anyone’s sex and does not confer a duty on any other person to accommodate the mimicry
Quotes a post by T02299; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The reductionistic views of women and racial minorities to which OP alludes were susceptible to defeat by civil rights campaigns because the stereotypes were crude heuristics that could be disproven by counter-examples while all men who mimic women are men and no men who mimic women, regardless of how well they manage it, are women.
It is not a stereotype that trans women are men, it is a fact.
People will not cease seeing men who mimic women as men. Some will invest in treating the charade as real but a critical mass will always remain reality based in any world that remains liberal, pluralistic, and democrat. You will only succeed in doing for men who mimic women what was done for prior subjects of civil rights movements by eradicating liberalism, pluralism, and democracy and replacing it with a totalitarian social justice regime that brainwashes children from the earliest age to deny reality and revile and oppress anyone who won’t pretend that mimicking a woman is what defines women.
We can know this for sure by looking at what transgender activists and the state officials in their thrall have done and continue to do and we can also know this by applying basic logic to the question of what happens when you try to confer a duty of participation in the false claims made by a legally privileged class of person seeking recognition as something they are not. The actual movement has done exactly as the hypothetical movement would do because that is the only way to do the thing that the actual movement is in fact attempting to do.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
1.) Co-owners of a business are not supposed to verbally abuse teenagers who are paying customers until they cry
2.) Adults are not supposed to verbally abuse any teenager until they cry whether they are paying customers of the businesses they own or not.
3.) Then again, no one is supposed to show up to a public event dressed in hate insignia (XX-XY Athletics) amidst an ongoing genocide (of misgendering) holding signs (“Thank You, Sophie”) that invalidate the identities of a marginalized group (“Trans Women”) by supporting a player who just spoke out in favor of forcing members of that group out of sporting competition without expecting vigorous counter-speech.
4.) So the question is this: Is the 80 percent of the public who supports ensuring that only female people should compete in women’s sports because only female people are women factually and morally correct? (They are.)
Or is the 20 percent of the public who believe that “trans women are women” and therefore any man who says he is a woman should be regarded and treated as a woman morally and factually correct? (They are not.)
5.) The problem cannot be resolved without reference to the ontological claim upon which the entire project of transgender inclusion and transgender rights rests. (Trans Women are Women.) Are "trans women" not actually women but instead men claiming to be something they are not and can never be? (They are.)
And if this reality determines the outcome of the project of trans inclusion in sports, must it necessarily determine the outcome of trans inclusion in all other domains? (It must.)
6.) The problem for the ruling institutions of the Western world (and those subject to their power) is not that they have chosen the 20 side of an 80/20 issue -- it is that they have chosen to deploy their powers to shape reality and establish a regime of truth and morality in furtherance of a false claim ("trans women are women") that is a self-evidently false claim that can only be propped up by a war on truth and reality that can only be won by campaigns of re-education aimed at the youngest children and by campaigns of repression aimed at destroying the right held by each individual to say what they know to be true and not be coerced into saying what they know to be false.
7.) That the WNBA of all institutions disciplined one of its own owners for verbally abusing a teenage girl until she cried for supporting a woman who opposed transgender inclusion marks a key limit on how far the private sector will go in repressing the public for defying transgender dogmas.
8.) If the Democrats return to power and pass the Equality Act, everything flips in an instant.
Quoting @JackThompsonFOX: The WNBA has confirmed to me that Seattle Storm co-owner Celeste Keaton has been suspended from attending the team's next five home games and has been fined.
Is there anything the transgender movement can do that would cause you to question its dogmas? Anything at all?
Quoting @GBPolitcs: 🚨NEW: Over £700,000 was allocated to a “Queer Milk” charity by the Scottish Government, prompting criticism from women’s rights groups
The charity holds weekly sessions in order to help transgender women try to give human milk to their babies
[@GBNEWS]
If you look at the video of Cunningham from HS, it's clear that she hasn't had any major work done. She has denied it while admitting to getting some botox on her forehead and there's no reason to suspect that she did when you look at the record of her photos and videos over the year. She lost her college freshman year babyfat and that's it.
As usual, it's just the usual ridiculous cope from trans activists and allies. Calling it "gender affirming care" is of course an admission that "gender medicine" is merely cosmetic elective procedures and should not be paid by insurance or Medicare.
And after attending closely to Rowling's output for years, I am sure that she, like me, is informed and instructed by Reduxx's work (which she has shared on her TL) without actually being motivated by a gleeful hatred of trans-identified people. She simply rejects the political project and rejects it on the basis that the claims it makes (that trans women are women and belong in women's spaces) are not true, she does so uncompromisingly (for the most part, she does have that one friend whose pronoun she uses) and grants herself the license to say true things that some people don't want to hear. I don't see transphobia (defined as hatred of the group) in any of that, but I do see transphobia (defined as rejecting the dogmas of the movement) in it. But the latter usage, which is the most common usage of the term, ascribing the former meaning to the latter action and disposition is just a smear and we don't have to defer to it.
You invited me to "own my transphobia" in the same way, but I don't own it because I don't feel it. I do see the work that Anna does in documenting the negative externalities of trans inclusion as crucial but I don't share a gleeful hatred of an entire category of person -- while also recognizing that a category that anyone can enter based on a claim to be it that aids the person in breaching sex-based boundaries is inherently problematic and must not serve as the basis for the conferral of a right
Let's be concrete. I rt'd this story. This is a story about an individual but its claim to relevancy is not based on "all trannies are bad" but rather that transgender inclusion policies (starting with ID) and predispositions are enabling abuses -- contributing to them, making them easier, more likely to happen, and decreasing the possibility of justice. I'm against all those latter things and also aware that self-ID means more perverts and psychos will be id-ing as trans, a point I make repeatedly. It's fundamentally not about bigotry but about pointing out the negative externalities of trans inclusion as it is practiced today.
You can say well "why is Anna documenting all this except because she hates trannies" and Anna would QT you and say "yeah I do" and get 30K likes. But that doesn't change the fact that ultimately Reduxx is assembling a case for a policy argument that is legitimate to have.
https://x.com/Slatzism/status/2081183388141060410?s=20
Quoting @Slatzism: so to summarize:
🏳️⚧️ volunteers at a youth shelter
takes pics of himself jerking off at the shelter
police find out
don’t arrest him, for some reason
he then goes and gets a job as a babysitter
rapes every child in the home, including an infant
the child victims are taught to refer to him as a woman
media refers to him as a woman
I don't pretend they don't exist. I just don't think they matter to the transgender politics. It's an interesting curio for sure am and I'm sympathetic to those who benefitted from the prior status quo who had it hijacked by the transgender movement. But that hijacking did happen, it happened decades ago, and it's not really a part of the conversation. Now the big trans movement confronts other forces and the conflict is there.
Of course I can defend my position in the face of any kind of questioning, good faith or otherwise, as I have done it. But I don't think it's worth investing time in fending off an ambush if there's no reason to enter an ambush. Sophie Cunningham has been called a transphobe thousands of times for wanting to protect girls sports. Of course she is not and has not ever stated or implied any animus toward people presenting themselves as the sex they are not. She has only been smeared for not agreeing with a dogma that the trans activist movement requires you to believe in order to extract the political concesssion they seek.
She has never read Reduxx, she would never refer to "trans people" as "people presenting themselves as they sex they are not." I do that daily, but none of that is an instance of negative predisposition of animus toward the people engaged in these practices. In both cases, we are called "transphobes" because we resist transgender dogmas. That is all the word means.
The position I've staked is the rejection of all trans rights claims and the reversion of the identity to a private eccentricity that some people are free to pursue without imposing either legal or social obligations on any other person to hinder or to aid them. That is a hardline position but grounded in reality and arrived at through the continuing observation of the reductio ad absurdum we see documented daily by Reduxx of what happenes when you try to give legal status to the private reveries of individuals. It is not prejudice. It is postjudice.
But it's clear that I never said that all trans people are that way, only that self-ID meant the end of any effort to differentiate, with the results we see documented at Reduxx daily. This not prejudice -- it is an observed outcome.
An accurate claim I have repeatedly made is that self-ID and rainbow celebrations have created a structure of incentive for disturbed and mentally comorbid people to identify into transgenderism, resulting in a long cascade of monstrous messaging and acts issuing from the trans-identified. But that is not the same as a negative predisposition apart from a rational recognition of observed behavior.
It's true that I am afraid of what is depicted in these screenshots, but phobias are *irrational* fears. https://x.com/wesyang/status/2081201265883705842?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: Despite the creepy tone of this piece, it's frankly good advice for Cunningham to use caution -- not in the stances she takes, which are reasonable and correct, but in protecting herself from a social cause without peer in its indulgence of murderous rhetoric
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcontagiondenialmental illnesspolitical enemyviolence terror
Many "identify as disabled" and are LARPing as part of an ongoing grift/fashion. But many others have destroyed their endocrine systems and bodies with puberty blockers and wrong sex hormones. (They then get to be both disabled and "trans" without having to fake the disabled part -- which is to say that pretending to be the opposite sex actually made them disabled for real.)
(And "doctors" administered them the controlled substances that left them disabled, promising to help them "be their authentic selves" by destroying their endocrine systems.)
Quoting @StandingforXX: Can we address the elephant in the room? #TransPrideLondon
Creativity at the London Trans March: alongside the usual incitements to murder folx who don’t believe that men can become women, here is a sign calling for the cannibalization of folx who don’t believe that men become women.
Quotes a post by A1931; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Incitements to murder on signs and crowds attentively listening to a speech by a man convicted of attempted murder and torture who cut off and ate his own testicles while in prison: oh, it must be another London Trans Pride parade...
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Trans activist Sarah Jane Baker, who served years in prison for attempted m—rder and kidnapping and torture, was one of the speakers at the London Trans Pride today in Trafalgar Square.
One of the trans activists held a sign declaring “OFF WITH THEIR HEADS” and the photo of @jk_rowling and the Queen.
http://www.ngocomment.com
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
The British Columbia Human Rights tribunal charged a nurse $95K for the cost of her own yearslong inquisition for saying "human beings cannot change sex." It later imposed a $750K fine onto a former school trustee for resisting the imposition of transgender propaganda onto the whole province.
Now an Australia appeals court has upheld a $95K judgment against a woman for "vilifying" two men who say they are women by calling them men and publicizing their participation in women's sports.
The transgender movement is global and unitary, seeking to make it illegal or financially ruinous to resist its dogmas. It will do the same wherever it obtains the power to do so.
Quoting @reduxx: A women's rights campaigner in Australia found guilty of "vilifying" two trans-identified males has lost her appeal.
@[private account] has been ordered to pay them $95,000 for referring to them as "men" and condemning their participation in female sports.
https://reduxx.info/aus-womens-rights-campaigner-guilty-of-vilification-for-calling-trans-identified-male-athletes-men-loses-appeal-ordered-to-pay-95000/
Boys who say they are girls are not actually girls: this is the inescapable fact that determines the trans sports issue, but also all other "transgender rights" claims. It is this way because the transgender movement made it this way. The transgender movement made it this way because there was no other way to attempt this that had a prayer of working.
Either the ontological claim that drove this moment -- "Trans Women Are Women" -- is true, in which case every trans right must be granted, or it is not true (it is not true), in which case no transgender rights are to be granted and all of them are to be denied.
This was the wager that the movement itself initiated, in the process meme-ing into existence a subpopulation of tens of thousands of medically harmed children who are now held as hostages against the recognition of reality.
The Women’s Tennis Association just instituted sex testing to enforce a female-only rule consistent with Cunningham’s views on men in women’s sports. A motive force in reaching this decision was the greatest female tennis player of all time, @Martina. Martina is a relentless anti-Trump poster.
Martina is also a relentless advocate for the defense of women’s sports (which requires the exclusion of men) and a relentless critic of all transgender dogmas. A majority of Democrats agree with Martina, and with Sophie Cunningham about women’s sports. And they all agree for the reason that Clarence Thomas asserted as fact (because it is true) in his concurrence on the decision that gave constitutional blessing to the 27 state laws requiring participants in girls sports to be female: boys who say they are girls are not actually girls.
The issue is bipartisan. It encompasses MAGA and anti-MAGA individuals. The Democratic Party leadership has committed itself to an assault on reality and on the privacy, safety, and comfort of women. Its voters have not. It has made suppressing a reality that Clarence Thomas pointed out a litmus for membership in the human family despite a majority of its own voters correctly seeing it the other way.
Quoting @washingtonpost: Trump officials are amplifying WNBA player Sophie Cunningham’s comments that transgender athletes should not participate in women’s sports, seizing on her remarks to reinforce President Trump’s position on the issue. https://wapo.st/4htFcPM
They did not cancel Sophie Cunningham for saying that women have a right to fair competition against other members of their sex class because the statement is overwhelmingly popular, supported by 80 percent of the public as a whole and a supermajority of Democrats, because it aligns with the polices of the International Olympic Committee, World Athletics, the Women's Tennis Association, and 27 of 50 of the United States, the latter laws having had their constitutionality validated by the US Supreme Court, and because it is a reasonable and correct opinion that aligns with biological reality, and because the load-bearing claim upon which trans inclusion in women's sports rests -- that men who say they are women are women by virtue of the claim -- is not true, the whole world knows it, and the whole world is reclaiming its right to say aloud what it knows to be true and to act on the basis of what is true.
They did not cancel Sophie Cunningham for saying that women have a right to fair competition against members of their own sex class because the decade-long campaign of gaslighting and defamation has finally reached the limit of its power to impose an astroturfed pseudo-consensus onto the behavior of corporations, because holders of reasonable and correct opinions have found their voices and lost their fear and proved that when given an opportunity to put an end to a regime of preference falsification enforced by campaigns of defamation against those stating reasonable and correct opinion, they will take that opportunity and make their preferences clear.
They did not cancel Sophie Cunningham for saying that women have a right to fair competition because she is a luminous star, a competent basketball role player who just happens to have as much beauty and charisma as any Hollywood movie star of old, and anything she touches will turn to gold.
Her sneaker sold out within the first hour of its release in every size.
Quotes a post by T01285; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The germ of truth here is that macho, homophobic cultures where you can't be gay and where being the receptive partner = "being a woman" are more likely to force gender nonconforming children into a female role, which is why Puerto Ricans were so heavily overrepresented among the "homosexual transsexual" cohort that Mike Bailey described in the Man Who Would be Queen.
Of course this has little bearing on the autogynephilic fetishism indulged by white male heterosexuals that drives such a large share of transition. Wealthy white male autogynephilic fetishists are of course the motive force behind the coining of the term "transgender" and the institutional push to confer a right to violate sex-based boundaries onto any man who claims to be a woman.
Quotes a post by T03565; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
While a solid supermajority of the first generation propagandized to believe transgender dogmas from middle school onward still remains in contact with reality, it's disturbing to see that they succeeded in brainwashing so many.
Quoting @FrankLuntz: 75% of Americans agree with Sophie Cunningham, including 64% of Gen Z.
👉🏻 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/poll-americans-oppose-trans-women-competing-female-sports-2-3-gen-z-rcna203658
Wow, extremely toxic white male conservative views from leading candidate to challenge Susan Collins for the Maine Senate seat. And isn't it transphobic not to be supporting the Stunning and Brave Trans Woman in the race?
Quoting @KFILE: NEW: As Democrats make abortion rights central to Maine’s Senate race, newly reviewed questionnaires from a Maine anti-abortion group show Troy Jackson’s past hardline anti-abortion positions, including selecting “abortion should never be legal” in 2010, backing mandatory ultrasound viewing before abortions, opposing over-the-counter access to the morning-after pill and supporting a range of other abortion restrictions.
"The attack on sports is just a prelude to a broader assault on trans lives."
Protecting safety, privacy, comfort, and fair competition for women means refusing every demand by the transgender movement to break down sex-based boundaries. Since "Trans Rights" consists entirely of imperious demands that women sacrifice safety, privacy, comfort, and fair competition in order to accommodate any man who says he is a woman, the protection of safety, privacy, comfort, and fair competition for women necessarily entails the rejection of all "Trans Rights" and the permanent shuttering of that political project.
People will continue to pretend to be the opposite sex but without the overbearing hand of state power coercing people to play along.
The reason trans women are ineligible to compete against women in athletics (they are men) is the same reason they must not be permitted to falsify their official records, enter women's changing rooms, prisons, or domestic violence shelters, or be granted a right to compel others to pretend they are the sex they are not. They are men who are exercising a right to falsify their sex which imposes no obligations on any other person to join in that act of falsification.
If trans women were women, it would be fine for them to compete against women in athletics. But trans women are not women (they are men) and thus are ineligible to compete against women in athletics because no one has a right to be regarded and treated as something they are not.
The article is thin gruel, compiling a bunch of Xeets from randos.
Cunningham stated a view that comports with the policies of the International Olympic Committee, World Athletics, the Women’s Tennis Association, and 26 out of 50 of the United States, in keeping with state laws that the US Supreme Court has declared to be constitutional.
It is the mainstream view and the correct view that happens to be supported by 80 percent of the US, grounded in the fact that all men who say they are women are in fact men and therefore ineligible for inclusion in women’s sports or any other domain where the sexes are separated for the privacy, comfort, and safety of women.
I predict the league will not punish Sophie Cunningham and, as more female athletes see that they face no risk of punishment for saying what they really think, more will say that they agree with Cunningham because “trans women” are not women.
Rahm Emanuel told @megynkelly that a man can't become a woman last year. Here he boasts of having mandated bathroom access for any boy he says he is a girl in 2016 as Chicago mayor.
Remnick calls him out for using the trans issue to try to "differentiate" himself and analogizes mandating that no woman can draw a boundary between herself and any man who claims to be a woman in intimate spaces where they undress to the struggle to end Jim Crow by referencing "Letter From a Birmingham Jail."
But differentiating himself would require actually stating an intention to do something different than the Biden Administration, which launched a whole of government effort to embed transgender dogmas into law and policy on day one. Emanuel's evasiveness with Weigel on the actual policy shows that his combativeness with Remnick on whether the party should "prioritize" inflicting any boy who says he is a girl over its incapacity to bring more than half of all students to a 3rd grade reading level is just another rhetorical gambit to give him a cosmetic gloss of difference on an issue where a majority of Democrat voters oppose the party line.
If he won't even promise to do anything different, he will of course not do anything different in office. (Which he won't win, because winning would require showing courage that the rest of the field lacks -- that is to say, he would have to differentiate himself in some meaningful way, which evasive equivocation will definitely not do.)
Quoting @daveweigel: Unenlightening exchange. Emanuel is very comfortable talking about the focus, but not the policy. When I asked if the next president should undo Trump’s EO on gender he pivoted and said he’d be focused on corruption.
(Not saying I’m the best interviewer ever, just that asking about emphasis gets talking point answers, asking about the policy is more interesting.) https://www.semafor.com/article/04/01/2026/they-dont-care-and-i-dont-care-emanuel-on-trans-rights-israel-and-hyperloops
It's OK to be normal. It would be strange to back down from a reasonable and correct position. The weird thing is that men were ever allowed to compete in women's sports. (Transgender women are men. Didn't you know?)
Quoting @TheAthletic: Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham doubled down Wednesday on comments she made in a recently published ESPN article, saying it’s “common sense” to bar transgender athletes from competing in women’s sports.
https://nyti.ms/4fhSVrt
It was September 2022 when we all witnessed Macy Grey forced to grovel before the Transgender Inquisition and renounce a truth that neither she, her inquisitor, nor the audience watching doubted. All were made to understand that we were to be forced to pretend a thing we knew to be false was the only truth into perpetuity.
Quoting @JackThompsonFOX: Sophie Cunningham addresses her recent comments to ESPN about wanting to protect women's sports.
"I said what I said, I think it's kinda common sense."
"Transphobia" just means "doesn't think a man can be a woman." Saying that a man who claims to be a woman is actually a man actually is "transphobia."
It's not a fringe of the trans activist movement that maintains that any man who says he is a woman is a woman and must be granted the right to violate sex-based boundaries. It is what schools in Blue states are teaching every child from the earliest age. It's what the Democratic party has twice passed through Congress with the Equality Act and what it will as a matter of certainty pass the instant it has the votes to do again.
All "trans rights" hinge upon this belief. The instant you disbelieve it, all trans rights are annulled. The movement staked everything on an ontological claim -- a false one -- and it must live or die on the basis of that wager.
It must either succeed in creating an authoritarian social justice theocracy where false belief is compelled and stating the truth is punished, or it must fail in its attempt to do so and allow society to remain liberal, pluralistic, democratic, and free.
One of these two things will happen. There is no third option.
Quotes a post by T03987; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
As recently as 2013, it was satire about the lunatic fringe of the Left.
Today, it's being taught to tens of millions of schoolchildren as the only truth from the earliest age.
"I accept you're a man. I accept you have a penis."
This satirical gloss on the transgender dogmas of 2013 would literally be grounds for cancellation two years later. By 2018, you could be silenced on any of the major social media platforms for it.
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: "I don't know what a woman looks like."
Somehow this 2013 skit from Portlandia is funnier now than it was then.
People were banned from social media for pointing out that Nike’s former ad pitchman was a man just a few years ago.
Does Adidas have the balls to put Sophie Cunningham in an ad? She called transfeminine athletes men! Don’t you know that attacks on trans women are attacks on all women”?
Cunningham has a sneaker coming out on Friday with Adidas.
I predict that Adidas will ignore the screeching of the transgender lobby and release the sneakers to huge sales to girl athletes whose admiration for Cunningham has only increased with the knowledge that Cunningham has their back and will not bow to the transgender inquisition.
Quotes a post by T07232; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“We both have freedoms.” This is what the trans activist movement cannot abide. It came into existence to deploy state power to extinguish the freedoms of any who would not acquiesce to its dogmas.
Quotes a post by T05204; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Ooh bad optics for the trans movement! We have to take more care to put a Real Trans Woman and not a delusional, mentally ill man who thinks he is a woman onstage next time. Wait…
Quotes a post by A1663; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Transgender children do not exist apart from adults brainwashing quirky kids to label themselves trans.
What is measured by the statistics in Oregon and Mississippi is the incidence of adults brainwashing quirky kids to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered.
Quoting @LeorSapir: In Oregon, 1 in 65 girls received a transgender-related clinical diagnosis between 2016 and 2023.
1 in 240 girls received hormones.
Kids in Oregon were almost 20 times more likely than kids in Mississippi to have a "gender dysphoria" diagnosis.
How did this happen?
Trans ideology is what unites antifa street militants and the HR directors of Goldman Sachs and BlackRock — and the teacher’s union and NGOsphere and universities and every moderate Democratic politician with every Eurocrat and center Ledt parties across the Anglosphere. Denying any woman a right to draw a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman, brainwashing every quirky child to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered, forcing every citizen to pay obeisance to the most brazen lie ever told at scale, is the golden thread that runs through the Western world order.
Quotes a post by T07617; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
UCSF psychiatrist Diane Ehrensaft said that if a baby boy undid the snaps on his onesie to make it resemble a dress, that was a message that he was really a girl.
Chase Strangio told Jake Tapper the night before she went before SCOTUS to lose the Skrmetti case that trans kids can know they are trans at the age of 2 and by the time they are nine have already been waiting seven years to be medicalized.
These are not fringe views (though they are falsehoods.) They are being taught by public school systems to millions of elementary schoolchildren as the only truth.
Quoting @RigoIrizarry: Charlize Theron is a racist, hateful bitch.
Why else would she adopt two little black boys from Africa and immediately say they’re girls and put them in dresses?
The only answer that comes to mind is that she hates black men. The argument that a three year-old knows its gender is absolute trash.
Wouldn’t do you agree? @[private account]
A white male who mass murdered black people in cold blood in a church didn’t even have to come out as a trans woman to be referred for clemency by a Biden DOI attorney. All he had to do was be a smol bean suffering from mental health challenges.
Quoting @KatiePavlich: Wow. Murderer Dylann Roof was referred for clemency by Biden DOJ Attorney Elizabeth Oyer because he “suffered from anxiety.”
What the hell is going on?
Nothing says "we are seeking to win back the country by taking a fresh approach to unpopular cultural issues that have hobbled the Democratic party in recent years" than...employing and urging everyone attend to the trans-identified male founder of a pioneering trans-activist legal group who pressed Kamala Harris on whether she supported taxpayer funded gender surgeries for incarcerated illegal immigrants, thus generating the viral ad moment that did more than any other to move the needle toward Trump in all the swing states he swept in 2024.
Quotes a post by T01350; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
He didn't answer the question about non-biological women because he doesn't actually know any of the dogmas he is forced to parrot in order to remain in good standing within the university: only biological women have babies; some of those women who have babies pretend to be men, ("Trans men,") and thus "men can have babies" because "Trans Men are Men."
Men who pretend to be women ("trans women") do not have babies because they are men and only women (including women who pretend to be men, whom we are all obliged to call "men" because "Trans Men are Men") can give birth.
Quotes a post by T04560; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I have no basis for thinking that Barrett has allowed fear of assassination to change any decisions.
I do know that a federal court judge told a trans-identified man who brought a semi-automatic rifle to Bret Kavanaugh's house after Googling the addresses of three of the other justices that she was "heartened" that his murder plot had led his family to start affirming his claim to be a woman and cited a Trump administration order requiring that male federal prisoners be housed with men even if they say they are women as one of the reasons she reduced his sentence from the 30 years dictated by the guidelines to eight years.
The man explicitly declared that he had targeted the justices for murder in order to preempt the overturning of Roe v Wade with violence.
With time already served, he'll be out in four years.
Quoting @BreannaMorello: Justice Amy Comey Barrett is discussing all the threats she’s facing.
It’s sad and shouldn’t happen, but this shouldn’t be an excuse to cave.
Her rulings have been out of character.
If these threats are an issue for her family, she should step down now.
They proudly announced that they were emotionally blackmailing parents into consenting to the chemical castration and dismemberment of their children on television and went on to do it to thousands of parents before the ACLU's lead trans rights litigator admitted in December 2024 to the Supreme Court that there had never been any evidentiary basis for the claim. (Then they went right back to telling it to thousands of more parents and will continue doing so into perpetuity until someone stops them.)
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: Here’s one of the world’s leading gender quacks — Johanna Olson-Kennedy — proudly explaining the approved narrative to ABC News in 2016.
It was always Bash First from day one for the transgender movement, which came into existence threatening women who denied that men could be women with assault, rape, and murder.
Quotes a post by A3088; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Many thought that Cass's elevation to the nobility was a reward for having told many important truths about transgenderism in her report. But maybe it was an incentive to disregard those truths in favor of endorsing some of the most bizarre trans activist sophistries?
Quotes a post by A1099; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I just worry that Spanberger created an actionable playbook for how you equivocate and pay no penalty for egregious abuses inflicted on girls by your party in the name of trans and thus the elections cease to provide sustained contact with reality.
Which isn't a bad attempt apart from the fact that it can only fail totally to mollify anyone.
But maybe they don't actually want to mollify the movement but simply buy some cover with the rest of their voters, a supermajority of whom oppose men in women's sports.
But it then raises the question of whether they are actually trying to moderate or just to find an acceptable pitch that gives them cover to return to power and then impose the full trans activist agenda.
"They should be protected from any form of discrimination."
The foundational claim of the transgender rights movement is that refusing to accept the false claims of men to be women as true (and thus confer a right to violate sex-based boundaries on sporting fields, changing rooms, domestic violence shelters, and prisons) is discriminatory and must be prohibited by law.
Edsall thus screwed up his courage to make a proposal that will result in a giant pile-on that nonetheless grants the transgender rights movement everything it seeks anyway.
Pointing out that "trans rights" are imperious demands for the destruction of other people's rights isn't "anti-rights."
It is a defense of rights against those who would usurp the term and deploy it to destroy the rights of others.
Of course your gloss of Brianna is incredibly credulous and fatuous; Wu seeks to trans children, silence TERF's, and force people to pay obeisance to his delusions through emotional blackmail and vicious invective. He has told more documented lies than virtually any other public figure since 2015. None of this has any bearing on whether a person can be anti-woke and pro-LGBT, a thing I've never denied.
Every reply is a just another nonsequitur. Hanania went from saying (in a long post) that pronouns are worse than genocide to saying (in a long post) that Brianna Wu taught him that trans women are women and (in a sincere non-trolling tweet) that Elite Human Capital's moral greatness is on display because of a transgender flag display in airports in two years because he is one of the most brazenly unprincipled and disingenuous figures in all public life. You can like his books or w/e and praise them but calling him "principled" is false and ridiculous.
NGO’s captured by trans activists have been defaming people who don’t believe that men can be women or that children should be chemically castrated for many years with impunity because they are hugely powerful institutions punching down on individuals and organizations lacking the means to fight back.
That impunity will soon be ending.
Quoting @jk_rowling: Should any of the women's organisations targeted by @AmnestyUK's recent 'anti-rights' blacklist wish to take legal action, applications can be made to the JK Rowling Women's Fund. https://jkrwf.org
This is an important one as Shapiro is feted as a moderate with cross-partisan appeal but like all other Democrat moderates has worked relentlessly to permit no daylight between himself and the most extreme trans activists https://x.com/JoshShapiroPA/status/1293277563737997312?s=20
Quotes a post by T00024; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I tweeted that Grok listed only four politicians who had said that "Trans Women Are Women," which I thought was curious.
The simple explanation is that Grok was wildly wrong: ChatGPT came up with more than 100.
Quotes a post by T03785; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's interesting to see that while virtually every Democrat at every level of government has allowed zero daylight between their policies and the demands of the most extreme trans activist, there has been such message discipline in not being caught repeating the mantra.
The transgender movement is the same everywhere. It tells the same lies, it engages in the same medical fraud, it broadcasts confidence in its methods that it knows to be groundless. It seeks to destroy people who tell the truth.
Quotes a post by A0021; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
These individual cases may be outlying in their mania and bombast but they are merely the future that the global transgender inquisition has all along intended and continues to work tirelessly to make the baseline of how its dogmas are enforced everywhere
Quoting @HJoyceGender: This is one of most shocking cases I've read from the Trans Madness Era.
A Democrat running for governor of Ohio has declared "I do not support boys playing in girls sports. This is already settled law in Ohio, and as governor I will enforce and uphold the law."
The way for Democrats to neutralize the trans issue is to co-opt GOP positions on sports, private spaces, child transition, and compelled speech, supporting the removal of gender ideology instruction from schools, bans on child transition, and the removal of recognition of gender identity in law at every level of state, local, and federal government.
Everybody wants to think there is some other way. But there is no other way.
Quotes a post by T01523; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Gender identity policy at one of NYC's most elite all-girls prep schools, Spence.
"With respect to admissions, Spence will continue to consider any student who identifies as a girl."
"With respect to students who no longer identity as girls, they will be welcome to remain at Spence."
That is to say that the schools will admit boys who say they are girls because Trans Women are Women, and will retain girls who say they are boys because Trans Men are Women. (Only the second proposition is true.)
Women who pretend to be men can (and often do) get pregnant because they remain women despite the pretense of being men. When folx say "trans people need abortion care too"! They are referring to this fact.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A systematic review of transmasculine people (natal females identifying as male) found that about 5.6-8.5% became pregnant.
“The conception rates during testosterone use were low, but insufficient to rely upon as contraception; miscarriage rates appeared high—31.6%-40%…The limited data available suggested that testosterone use before pregnancy seemed to be associated with fewer conceptions compared to never having taken it, even where transmasculine people had stopped for several months before attempting conception. Pregnancy loss seemed to be higher in those exposed to testosterone antenatally.”
The one issue that these successful moderates have not seen fit to moderate one iota on is of course the imposition of any boy who says he is a girl into the athletic fields and changing rooms of girls, the brainwashing of gender nonoconforming children to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered, and the infliction of males rapists and murderers into women's prisons. On these issues, all moderates (Fetterman included) have made a pact to allow no daylight between themselves and the most extreme trans activists. Unfortunately, the issue is sufficiently low salience to purple state voters, that they pay no penalty for taking the 20 side of an 80-20 issue.
Quotes a post by A0040; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is the arsenal seized from a trans-identified Las Vegas man who threatened to commit a mass murder. Police referred to him by his preferred pronouns when describing the arrest.
Things can exist at a certain scale and not at others. People impelled by an overpowering inner desire to live as something they are not can exist as individuals but not as a movement that society can accommodate without grave harms and externalities. We don't have a developed language and framework for saying no -- the transgender movement provide the impetus for creating one.
ACLU lead trans rights lawyer Chase Strangio in 2019:
"I am a civil rights and constitutional lawyer who fundamentally doesn’t believe in the Constitution and the legal system."
Perhaps this disbelief contributed in some way to the ongoing fiasco of Strangio's serial failed Constitutional claims.
Periodic reminder that anyone can say they are trans and be granted the right to violate sex-based boundaries, immediate social deference, and medicalization that promises magical self-transformation; that disaffected, sexually deviant, and mentally disordered personalities are going to be drawn to such charades that confer privilege and make outlandish promises to anyone claiming them; and that the small set of young people capable of mass murder will come to intersect with the larger set of young people brainwashable and brainwashed into claiming cross-sex identities ever more tightly over time.
The response of the media, which was once to scold people for failing to honor the gender identities of mass murderers, will increasingly be to obfuscate and lie about those identities.
Quotes a post by A2437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
What Newsom says about athletics is true generally. There is an irreconcilable clash between the interests of women and the interests of men who wish to be recognized as women that no amount of sophistry will ever bridge.
While Newsom is a hypocrite and a liar, he broke the taboo on leaders of the Democratic party saying so. It is now on the record and it cannot be unsaid. It is the germ of a recognition that will unravel the transgender movement totally over time.
Hundreds of headlines written in the mutilated jargon of the trans activist movement contrasted with one headline written in plain, clear, and direct English, underscores the importance of using plain, clear, and direct language, and not using the mutilated jargon of the trans activist movement.
Quoting @WSJopinion: Women’s sports win at the Supreme Court. The Justices say states can ban biological men from women’s teams.
https://on.wsj.com/4wkwEik
Newsom has argued in public that trans inclusion is necessarily zero sum with women's athletics. To grant the movement's demands to permit inclusion of any boy who says he is a girl in girl's sports is to deny a girl a place on the podium or a place on the team.
Today his office announced that it will continue to deny the rights of girls to fair competition.
Quoting @JackThompsonFOX: Newsom's office has responded to the SCOTUS Title IX ruling, saying California will continue to let males compete in girls' sports, and boasting his record of appointing trans judges and making it making it easier to update gender markers on documents.
https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/newsoms-office-responds-scotus-ruling-womens-sports-california-faces-ongoing-trans-athlete-wave
Scott Wiener says that a bill that would prohibit convicted sex offenders from running for public office risks taking us down "a dangerous road", arguing that those convicted of "minor crimes" should not be denied opportunities to make and enforce our laws.
In a recent viral video, a heckler who eventually drove him out of the Trans March in SF prefaced his attacks on Wiener's prior reluctance to call Gaza a genocide (he reversed course on this prior to announcing his candidacy for Nancy Pelosi's House set) with effusive praise for Wiener's efforts on behalf of Queers.
This is a prime example of what his heckler was praising
https://x.com/EndWokeness/status/2072319493230010636/video/1
Yes, your passport and all other official documents will list the material fact of your sex, and not your private reveries about your sex, which will have no standing before the law.
Yes, you will play in the sport and use the private facilities that correspond to the material fact of your sex, and not your baseless claim to be something you are not.
Neither of these constraints push anyone out of public life. What they do is preserve the right that we all have to pretend to be something we are not, while preserving the rights of others not to be coerced into joining the pretense. Neither of these rights can be infringed upon except through totalitarian coercion and defiance of the will of the people.
In response to a movement whose imperious demands for "rights" trample on the rights of others, two things will happen: the rights of the many will be preserved, and the demand that the rights of the many be sacrificed to the maudlin exigencies of the few will be refused.
The trans rights movement will be forced to observe the same limits on the scope of its demands that every other social movement must respect in a pluralistic, liberal, and democratic society. And the volume on the screeching of would-be totalitarians like you will be turned down and forgotten.
Quotes a post by T02826; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Lead ACLU trans rights litigator Chase Strangio confirmed that transgender identities are not immutable in the Skrmetti case.
Thomas is merely following up on the implications of this admission. No heightened scrutiny.
No rights conferred onto anyone by virtue of their belief that they are something are not, no duties imposed on any other person. You are your sex, your belief to the contrary will have no standing before any organ of the state, and everyone you meet retains their inalienable right to affirm or not affirm your false beliefs as they see fit.
There is no other possible stable resolution to this issue.
Quotes a post by T07423; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Lia Thomas moment was an absurd travesty of the Jackie Robinson moment.
The transgender movement is an absurd travesty of a civil rights movement.
It would be comical if the forces arrayed on behalf of inflicting this absurd travesty on the world weren't so powerful, and if they weren't chemically castrating and dismembering tens of thousands of children they've brainwashed to believe a falsehood.
Quoting @LeorSapir: If you sincerely believe Lia Thomas is the Jackie Robinson of the pool, today might hit hard for you.
The second photo is of a "trans man" -- a biological woman who would actually be welcome in women's sports, provided she isn't taking performance enhancing testosterone
Quoting @disclosetv: JUST IN - Supreme Court upholds state laws keeping transgender athletes out of girls' and women's sports in 6-3 decision.
The Daughters of the American Revolution has permitted men who say they are women to join for many years. The recent vote shut down an internal revolt that attempted to expel those men and require that all members have been born female.
Seems like the thousands of resignations that the five trans-identified men who joined in prior years generated may have determine the outcome of the vote, which was lost 1,481-984. This of course is how institutional capture happens: they create a loyalty test and consolidate their grip on the institution by driving out all dissenters. They control a rump institution, but it still bears the name.
It proves what insecure moorings everything in America rests upon: absolutely nothing is safe from the Current Thing.
Quoting @roddreher: Here's how far the trans insanity has gone among US elites: the Daughters of the American Revolution is now permitting male-to-female trannies to become Daughters. My poor DAR granny must be rolling in her grave.
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2026/jun/27/daughters-american-revolution-defeats-proposal-block-transgender/
I'll say that @[private account]'s proposal for a system of state certification, border control, and passports into the female sex is an attempt to be more than mere empty filibustering, but of course there is no chance that it would ever make any inroads with today's transgender movement, whose constituency is the gender self-identified who are 90 percent or more of the transgender category most of whom would regard such gatekeeping as tantamount to a Holocast.
The legacy "transsexual" population can spin out theories of how things were better in 2006 and how we can go back, but it is just verbiage with zero relevancy to actual policy.
Perhaps a key inflection point in the evolution of European Human Rights law concerning gender identity. The court has denied a legal claim by a woman who was correctly identified on a birth certificate as the mother of a child she bore that she is in fact the father of the child she bore because she is in possession of a Gender Recognition Certificate stating that she is a man.
The court notes the legitimacy of balancing the rights of those claiming cross-sex gender identities against the "rights of others," in this case the right of children to who know their parents are.
Of course, we all know (as do Trans Activists) that any right held by others to live in reality must necessarily unravel the right held by some to live in a state-enforced unreality, (and vice versa) which is why all reference to countervailing rights has been rigorously excluded in gender identity discourse.
The reference to the "rights of others" before one of the world's most trans-affirming legal tribunals contains the germ of what could well grow into the mechanism for the (possibly swift) euthanizing of the most absurd legal and medical folly of the post-Enlightenment age
Quotes a post by A1929; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My general read of "people with x" or "people who y" language is that it does refer to the actual organ or activity while allowing it to float free of a sex. In practice it may go as he says but I think the gender police will actually want to enforce this. I wouldn't be shocked if I ended up being wrong, but I don't think they will be giving menstrual or pregnancy accommodations to "trans women".
The ACLU's lead trans rights litigator wrote that a penis is "not a male body part, it's just an unusual body part for a woman to have" in 2015. This has always been the core contention of today's trans rights movement, and the conceptual basis of all Democrat legislation and executive action on trans rights.
If you don't accept this proposition as true, you reject trans rights.
Quotes a post by A0354; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It should not surprise anyone that trans activists seriously assaulted two detransitioners. Trans Activist messaging both online and in street protest bristles with threats of assault, rape, and murder. Those threats were never idle, were always earnestly intended, and will be enacted again and again and again before any of this is over.
Quoting @legaltweetz: We were mobbed and attacked by Trantifa last night in Seattle. I was maced by like 6 different trans identified males, beaten all over, kicked in the face multiple times, and was completely blinded by being maced so many times in a row.
Full account from @[private account]:
“Last night, while peacefully recording video footage in a public space, we were subjected to a vicious, unprovoked physical assault by a group of masked Antifa agitators. The attack was swift and coordinated. One individual delivered a forceful kick directly to Hendrix’s face. Both of us were sprayed in the eyes and respiratory system with chemical irritants (mace/pepper spray), causing intense burning, temporary blindness, and respiratory distress.
My hat was forcibly taken, along with portions of my recording equipment. Hendrix’s phone was stolen outright. I was thrown to the ground, slammed onto gravel on my knees, and immediately surrounded by multiple assailants who continued to spray me at close range while I was vulnerable. The assault left me in fear for my life; the cumulative force and tactics employed could easily have resulted in fatal injuries.
Law enforcement personnel who responded to the incident informed me that individuals perceived as critical of transgender ideology, often labeled “transphobes” by such groups, are routinely targeted for severe violence in this area, which the attackers evidently consider their controlled territory. Officers expanded by explaining there were cache’s of weapons hidden around the park. Officers explicitly warned that continued presence could lead to lethal retaliation.

One officer expressed concern that they would be called one day to aide in the recovery of a deceased detransitioned gay man’s body from Cal Anderson Park.
This incident underscores the documented pattern of intimidation and physical suppression faced by detransitioners and those who challenge prevailing narratives on youth medical transition, particularly in certain urban environments.”
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentpolitical enemyviolence terror
Learn what it means to "beg the question," and you'll have a richer understanding of reasoning, and, incidentally, will have deleted all arguments for the trans rights movement
Quotes a post by A1240; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
So yeah, there is a whole ass transgender murder cult that is linked to eight murders, including two by a they/them who executed her parents, and it's barely even news. Just another Dog Bites Man story.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Breaking: A member of the trans death cult, the Zizians, has finally been charged over the double m—rder of her parents in Pennsylvania.
Richard and Rita Zajko were shot—execution style—on New Year's Eve 2022. Michelle Zajko ("they/them"), the suspected m—rderer, has extensive writings expressing hatred for Christians, whom she calls transphobes, genocidaires and "Christofascists."
At least eight deaths have been linked to the Zizians. I've been reporting on the cult for over a year. https://www.ngocomment.com/p/elusive-trans-death-cult-members?utm_source=publication-search
C2 false claimshand-codedcrime caseviolence terror
They aren't hiding their motives for manufacturing a subpopulation of stunted perma-children. They are advertising it.
Robert Trivers in an email to Jeffrey Epstein:
"if your fantasy is to suck a man's dick, otherwise you are completely heterosexual, it would be much nicer if the rest of the organism is female, then you get the best of both worlds"
Trivers goes on to refer to the ever earlier ages at which trans medicalization were occurring:
"so you notice your three-year old son has trans tendencies, so now you intervene with hormones..."
Quotes a post by A2813; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
All women are female. Being female is constitutive of being a woman. You cannot be male and a woman. The expansion of the category of women to encompass any man undoes the category of woman. A "trans woman" is a type of man.
Adoptive fathers can be fathers because fathers are male. Adoptive mothers can be mothers because mothers are female. Neither expansion violates the category.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Those aren't trans women! Those are disordered men consumed by their sexual fetishes who pretend to be women...wait...
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨A pedophile, a rapist, and a man who beat a woman to death are behind a major legal push to move all trans-identified male inmates to women's prisons in Oregon.
The men were anonymized as "victims" in the lawsuit, but Reduxx can reveal their identities.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-pedophile-rapist-and-murderer-are-behind-oregon-lawsuit-demanding-transfer-of-trans-identified-male-inmates-to-womens-prisons/
When people refer to "trans genocide," they mean that 1.) some people don't use the preferred pronouns of men who claim to be women, 2.) some men who claim to be women aren't allowed to get naked in the women's changing room, 3.) some states don't let teachers brainwash children into yearning to be chemically castrated and dismembered, and 4.) some states don't snatch children from parents who don't believe their 11-year old daughters when they claim to be boys in need of being dosed with steroids and having their breasts lopped off.
When people fight back against "trans genocide" by threatening or committing mass murder, they are merely acting in accordance with the imperative to prevent "genocide."
Quoting @jessesingal: This sick guy sent threats of deadly violence to girls' schools, claiming pupils there had misgendering trans people and explicitly calling out 'TERFS.' Original BBC reporting excluded *any* details of his motivations. Fixed in major updates but insane.
https://archive.is/EdpNU
Why is the omerta among "normal" Democrat officials and pundits stronger on this aspect of the trans mania than on any other part of it?
Occasionally one of these folx will cock an eyebrow slightly at claims that men have no advantage over women in athletics or gingerly note that the evidence for chemically castrating and dismembering confused children is weak.
None will ever even acknowledge this most bizarre and egregious ongoing human rights abuse.
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨A pedophile, a rapist, and a man who beat a woman to death are behind a major legal push to move all trans-identified male inmates to women's prisons in Oregon.
The men were anonymized as "victims" in the lawsuit, but Reduxx can reveal their identities.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-pedophile-rapist-and-murderer-are-behind-oregon-lawsuit-demanding-transfer-of-trans-identified-male-inmates-to-womens-prisons/
A terminological problem here is that all "trans women" are biological males. What the school wants to say is something like "cisgender males" but obviously that's a non-starter. There's no good term for "identifies as the sex they are" because the language of self-identification already has the whole gender ideology baked into it, and exists in no other way. There's no good way to refer to it, even to repudiate it, without invoking it.
Quotes a post by T02495; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I am agreeing that they should moderate, and specifying that moderation means abandoning the inherently extreme incursions on liberty that are at the heart of trans rights activism
Once you establish that trans women are women by forcing compliance with the pretense that anyone claiming to be the opposite sex deserves recognition as the thing they are claiming to be, then of course competing in sports will be granted. This is not theoretical -- this is exactly what happened!
Yes, as in — you are free to pretend to be something you are not, and others are free to decline to join you in the pretense.
Yes, as in — tolerance is non-interference in legal activity to which everyone is entitled, and nothing more: no enforced affirmation or celebration, no brainwashing of other people’s children to affirm or celebrate or believe.
We don’t have to depart from these basic principles of liberalism to coexist — but coexistence means the refusal of any and all demands of the trans rights movement, all of which seek to extinguish the right of any and all to withhold themselves from affirmation and belief.
Quotes a post by A1184; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is not telling “queer, gay, and trans people exist.” This is a propagandistic lie meant to prime quirky children for induction into a cult of medicalized self-harm and the rest of society for submission to that cult.
Quotes a post by A3058; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's a mischaracterization to say that "butthurt" is a Reddit male term? Now your defensiveness and piling on of other insults seems very typical of the Reddit male as well. (And the female gastroenterologist, according to you.)
As you know, I pegged the stat to the actual rate of gender affirming male genital surgery.
The problem of self-ID in a non-gatekept world is that you ended the (already imperfect) safeguards aimed at keeping out pervs and psychos and created a situation where any psycho or perv gets access to vulnerable women in vulnerable spaces and nobody can tell any of them no. That is the problem that Reduxx documents. It is not a problem that relies on every trans-identified male being a perv or psycho -- it's a problem that cannot be solved so long as self-ID without any gatekeeping is the rule. Your proposed solution has a problem that there are vastly more TIM's that rely on self-ID for their claim to be women than there are TIM's who have some other basis for the claim, which means your proposed solution, while an interesting though experiment, is nothing more than a thought experiment. There is no way to get there without the comprehensive defeat of today's movement involving the overwhelming supermajority of trans-identified folx.
The problem for you is what happens when the trans movement figures out that you are calling for the disqualification of 90-95 percent of self-identified trans-folx by a state authority that certifies only the small remnant of mentally sound, non-violent, sexually self-controlled, psychologically functional folx willing to make irrevocable changes to their biology and morphology as eligible for inclusion in cross-sex spaces. Even if you could obtain consensus from the minority of those meeting all these criteria, you will always be outvoted by a 9 to 1 margin.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnessviolence terror
Reduxx isn't making a strictly quantitative argument. It is showing how trans-identified males who commit crimes in a male patterned way (and of course they do so at a male rate -- and not just at a male rate, because they are men, but at a paraphilic rate, because they are paraphilic men) are so often coddled, abetted, and affirmed both before and after their crimes, by courts and media who honor their pronouns and often treat them with striking leniency in sentencing, and penal systems that inflict them on women in prison in order to affirm their lady feelings, and give them cosmetic surgeries in order to keep affirming them on the taxpayer dime. They show how this coddling and affirming is also done to men who say they are women competing in athletics and how the ensuing absurdities and cruelties are all the same and grounded in the same absurdity -- that of conferring a right onto a class of person ("men who say they are women") that exposes another class of person ("actual women") to gratuitous and unwarranted risk, danger, fear, and discomfort that the latter class of person has no duty to bear.
The first transgender person elected to a state legislature in the United States already had a criminal record, for credit card fraud, when he was first elected in 2012.
He resigned once this prior conviction was revealed and was later arrested for making a bomb threat to a hospital -- but was elected a city selectman and then re-elected to the New Hampshire House.
He was arrested for multiple false E-911 texts in 2021 and then re-elected to House despite these two criminal convictions in 2022.
He was then arrested again for stalking in 2022, resulting in his second resignation from the House before his arrest for sexual exploitation of children and conviction to 33 years in prison.
Given this prior record, there is no guarantee he won't be elected again upon his release.
Throughout this entire time, he used the women's bathroom in the state legislature and demanded that everyone use she/her pronouns to refer to him.
So, the thing about Reduxx is -- you wouldn't think it was possible to have an entire publication that only covered sexual misconduct by 0.5 percent of the population.
People who are mad about the existence of a publication that somehow manages to fill its webpages each day with new acts of sexual misconduct by trans-identified folx should worry less about the existence of the publication and more about that publication's ability to fill its webpages each day with new acts of sexual misconduct.
C2 false claimshand-codedchild predatordenialviolence terror
The first transgender person elected to a state legislature in America exchanged 10k sexually explicit messages with a woman who worked at a daycare center, including photographs of the genitals of boys and girls as young as 3 years old
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨The first openly transgender person elected to a US state legislature has been sentenced to 33 years in prison for child sexual exploitation.
Stacie Marie Laughton's defense had argued for a lower sentence on the basis of his possible "retardation."
https://reduxx.info/first-openly-transgender-state-legislator-sentenced-to-33-years-in-prison-for-child-sexual-exploitation/
They are calling her "a man". There are grounds for objection to her calling her that even if it's true that she is trans. In fact, those are the sole grounds to object, even when one is asserting that she is not trans.
Who that claims to be trans is not? On what basis is that person excluded? Right now there are male rapists and murderers of women incarcerated with women because they began claiming to be women in prison. This is not a trick question -- it is one that the California agency that administers funds set aside exclusively for LGBT Californians will have to answer.
This is not the way. Trans Activists are the ones who send rape and murder threats to women who resist their imperious demands. They are the ones who spread paranoid "trans genocide" fantasies that give warrant to the many disturbed people in their ranks to enact murderous violence.
Those who reject this movement's imperious demands and false claims must avoid mimicking its worst aspects.
Quoting @RT_com: MMA Sean Strickland CELEBRATES gay month by posting AI Bud Light ad showing him THRASH Dylan Mulvaney
‘We're BACK’
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyvictim dismissalviolence terror
It's barely even news when another major transgender study crumbles: just another dog bites man story
Quoting @LeorSapir: Another Major Transgender Suicide Study Crumbles
A widely cited study published in the prestigious @[private account] claimed that “anti-transgender laws” encouraged teen suicide attempts.
A new methodological review dismantles that finding.
New from me in @[private account]
To take a practical example, an appellate court just struck down the ban on trans in the military because the administration exhibited animus in their statements about the move that was in fact gratuitous. Statements without ill-will would have been more effective in securing the goal.
The police in Madrid are acting out the unitary agenda of the global Gender Inquisition, which seeks to deploy state power to coerce the whole world into treating a falsehood as if it were the only truth.
The movement is working tirelessly to obtain the power to arrest, imprison and/or destroy the livelihood of anyone who disputes state enforced dogmas and will do so wherever it succeeds.
When US Democrats say "we can't throw trans people under the bus," what they mean is: "We must deploy state power to imprison anyone who stands in the way of our goal of chemically castrating and dismembering any confused child whom we have successfully brainwashed into believing they can change sex."
Quoting @BillboardChris: I have just been arrested by the police in Madrid, Spain.
My phone and passport have been seized but I had a second phone in my pocket so I’m writing this from the back of the police car.
I was at Puerta del Sol for just 5 minutes.
Police told me I cannot have conversations in the public square. I researched the law and spoke with a lawyer and.they are wrong.
It is genuinely a promising precedent that a left-wing Democratic politician can make promises to the transgender movement and then renege on them.
I still worry that centrist Democrats will make moderate noises and then work tirelessly to advance the transgender agenda at any cost once the party is back in power.
But this ray of light should not be overlooked.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Mamdani insists his administration “will not back down in the face of federal attacks against trans New Yorkers.” But in effect it already has. He pledged $65 million in his campaign to back gender-transition treatment for New Yorkers of all ages. But the $15 million he has pledged toward such treatment will only go to people age 19 and older. The Trump administration’s attacks have focused on gender-transition treatment for people under age 19. Multiple large pediatric gender clinics in New York have shuttered accordingly.
It is unclear, then, who this new funding is actually for, since such treatment is already widely covered by insurance, including Medicaid; and clinics like Callen-Lorde already serve low income trans patients. Perhaps it is just for uninsured transgender adults? Unclear.
The people that used to cite WPATH as the premiere authority on transgender "healthcare" have stopped doing so. This means they know that the organization's authority has collapsed. But the other organizations whom they are now citing all refer to the authority of WPATH as the basis of their own recommendations.
It was always a self-conscious lie from day one -- but there is now an implicit acknowledgment that they know what we have always known that they know.
Quoting @LeorSapir: At no point did the Senate Democrats or their expert witness, @[private account] of the National Center for LGBTQ (formerly Lesbian) Rights (@[private account]), refer to or cite the authority of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH (@[private account]).
It's self-evidently the opposite. As people watch autistic, mentally ill, gender non-conforming, and merely quirky children being indoctrinated and consumed by a cult of medicalized self-harm being fed by the organs of acculturation, as they witness revolting spectacles of these brainwashed children being inflicted into girl's changing rooms and athletic competitions, as they see adult male autogynephiles performing their sexual fetishes in absurd and degrading public spectacles, as they see reports of male rapists and murderers being inflicted on women in prison, as the see the pervasive violence in the online and street messaging of transgender activists, they conclude that the movement is the most pernicious and ludicrous travesty of a civil rights movement in their lifetimes. It is not lack of familiarity with the products of this movement but growing familiarity with it that drives its ongoing nosedive in popular acceptance.
Quotes a post by T03332; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Canadian political class knows that you cannot serve two Gods. Either you serve the jealous DEIty and the chemical castration of transgender children, or the power of the state will be deployed to silence and punish you.
The vision of American Critical Race Theorists is four decades old: it just so happens that Canada happens to be situated in a place to bring this vision to life. The vision is global and unitary and will be implemented wherever the balance of forces enable it. The United States has a First Amendment that serves as a constraint on the realization of this vision, but by no means an absolute one.
Quoting @WellsJorda89710: 🚨Canada Just Killed the Bible Defense: Pastors Now Face Jail for Quoting Scripture🚨
Canada just gutted a 56-year-old shield protecting religious speech.
Bill C-9 — the so-called “Combatting Hate Act” — passed the House and Senate this spring and is now sitting on the Governor General’s desk awaiting Royal Assent.
For decades, Canadian law explicitly protected sincere religious belief and the public reading of Scripture from hate speech prosecutions. That defense is now gone.
One vote in Senate committee killed every attempt to save it.
Pastors, parents, and believers can now face criminal hate speech charges for quoting the Bible on marriage, sexuality, or human nature — with zero religious exemption left to stand on.
This isn’t some far-off country. Canada shares a 5,000-mile border with America, the same language, overlapping culture, and increasingly similar political instincts.
When a Western democracy reclassifies biblical truth as potential hate speech, the Overton Window just shifted.
Isaiah 5:20 hits different now:
“Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who put darkness for light and light for darkness.”
American Christians — are you watching this closely? Because the same cultural and legal trends are already active south of the border.
The pulpit is being put on notice in real time.
#Canada #BillC9 #ReligiousFreedom #FreeSpeech #HateSpeech #ChristianPersecution #BiblicalTruth #WakeUpChurch #FaithUnderFire #CulturalShift
I didn't think it would result in a massive drop. It may have capped his surge, not in any direct way, but simply as part of branding him within a specific niche in the Democratic party of those willing to go beyond the standard pro-trans histrionics.
Millions of schoolchildren are receiving transgender propaganda from the earliest age. The combined expenditures of this whole of society effort to deploy state and institutional power to make a falsehood true implicate funding that vastly outstrips the combined power of every right wing billionaire by many orders of magnitude.
There is zero evidence that Barre has given one dollar to Genspect or SEGM or anything as directly engaged in the trans issue as the ACLU and HRC are involved in pro trans advocacy.
There is zero evidence that any amount of that bequest was earmarked for this issue. Some organizations it funds do litigation on women’s sports and other issues, but these organizations without exception have a fraction of the budget of ACLU.
It is their belief that "trans kids know who they are" and that doctors have a duty to affirm and not question (and chemically castrate and dismember at the child's urging.)
When that belief turns out to be untrue to the lifelong detriment of a child, the failing is not in the doctor, who merely did as he had a duty to do, but in the confusion of the child for which the child is not to be blamed (sorry that happened to you), but which gives the child no standing to contradict any other child who "knows who they are" and thus are owed a duty of "care" (chemical castration and dismemberment.)
Quotes a post by A0447; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think it's probably true that this is too far out for the Texas electorate of today. But the glee with which the Right is responding is misplaced. There is a political cult that has parasitized mainline Christianity. It has gone much further than most people understand. Queer Theory is in all of the theology schools and may even be the dominant force within those schools.
Does it surprise you to know that the Episcopal House of Bishops passed a resolution in 2018 opposing "all legislation that restricts public restroom, locker room and shower access for transgender and gender non-conforming people, recognizing that such bills disproportionately impact and contribute to a pattern of violence against transgender women and non-binary identified people?"
The church is in the midst of precipitous decline that adoption of Critical Race Theory and Queer Theory has done nothing to staunch and may have acted to hasten. But there is solid institutional grounding for the progressive memeplex within a venerable institution. It's not just the Established religion of the corporate and cultural and NGO and educational and medical and legal sectors. It is the official position of the religionussect that for most of the country's history was the seat of its ruling elite.
Talarico is not just a weird individual -- a "freak" -- he is an apostle of a faith tradition that, however superannuated, still has an enduring historical relationship to vast social and political power in America that has not been entirely severed. He is the herald of change that has already happened without your noticing it, and while it may be true that the 2026 Texas electorate will prefer an ethically compromised Republican by 5-10 points, he is just one eddy in a roaring current.
Quoting @LoneStar_PAC: What does James talarico call women?
"neighbors with a uterus"
Reminder that "neighbors with a uterus" is ugly jargon used in deference to "trans men" (women who pretend to be men while having uteruses, because they are women)
Quoting @LoneStar_PAC: What does James talarico call women?
"neighbors with a uterus"
It means that women who pretend to be men can still have vaginal sex with men and get pregnant and might therefore need abortions because trans men are women
Quoting @realBrandonGill: "Our trans community needs abortion care too."
What exactly does that even mean?
It's hard to keep track of the math, but it seems that "trans menstruators" is a reference to women who pretend to be men ("trans men") and still menstruate (because they are women), so it's interesting that the "National Organization of Women," is co-sponsor of the event, since as we all know, and as they certainly know, Trans Men are Women
Quoting @libsoftiktok: Boston Mayor Michelle Wu’s “office of lgbtq advancement” is holding a “trans period pride” event to discuss menstrual equity & the experiences of transgender menstruators
The office received nearly $1 million in taxpayer funding this year
This is real
What a time to be alive
Facebook's post-election promise to be less driven by maniacal trans activism has proven to be a lie
Quoting @salltweets: Today, I was given a permanent ban of posting on my Facebook page, @[private account]. The page can exist - apparently - but I am not allowed to post on it anymore. The page has been deemed controversial due to the Giggle v Tickle case and increased popularity of 25,000 new followers in a week. I don't want to labor the irony of being banned on a social networking platform while fighting in court for the right to ban men from a woman only social networking platform, it is what it is. Frankly, I'd love to have the same right that you do, @[private account].
Women are routinely punished for not accepting men as women. It doesn't turn those men into women. Nothing will.
We don't have debates because the pro-trans side doesn't want debates because their own propaganda is just a tissue of obvious falsehoods that none can defend:
https://x.com/wesyang/status/2059478524130447501?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: Of course the suicide claim is an odious lie, a self-evident absurdity that no remotely numerate person would entertain for a moment. (Over a half-decade, out of 15K British youth on the waiting list for the UK's only pediatric gender clinic, a total of four children committed suicide.)
Of course even if it were true, it is a nonsequitur that has zero bearing on whether boys should compete against girls in sports rather than in their own sex category. In neither case would male or female athletes be responsible for anyone ending their lives anymore than a coach who cut a student who feels like he cannot live without being on a varsity athletic team is responsible for that death.
Of course it's the same cheap emotional blackmail and bullying from a cult that brainwashes children to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered and programs them to coerce parents into consenting to the sterilization of their children with threats of suicide being deployed by a major candidate for the governorship of California.
Of course Tom Steyer is indifferent to whether anybody is being helped or harmed by his ridiculous grandstanding, or whether what he is saying is false or true.
Of course he is content to know nothing, repeat mindless talking points handed to him the woke staffers, and bask in his virtue and goodness.
All of it reveals a person devoid of moral and epistemic integrity who has no business leading anything.
The Abigail Spanberger playbook was to equivocate weakly on these issues in a purple (trending blue) state and it worked well for her. (2/3rd of Democrats oppose the inclusion of men in women's sports.) That seemed like it would be the model.
But the transgender lobby must have gone to work on the party in the interim, and there's a sudden surge of enthusiasm among the emerging crop of D candidates for letting it all hang out.
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: “If I was Governor I would have vetoed the Riley Gaines Act”
Georgia Democrat running for Governor, Keisha Lance Bottoms, wants boys to compete with the girls.
GA, VOTE like your daughter's future depends on it. Because it does
Why is unhinged advocacy for the furthest extreme of trans activist dogma an instant ticket to the leadership of medical institutions?
Quoting @benryanwriter: Dr. Natasha Johnson, a pediatrician at McMaster University, has become president of the Canadian Paediatric Society.
Dr. Johnson said at a 2022 WPATH conference that "parents' feelings" about their child's medicalized gender transition "should not be prioritized over the youth’s experience.” In other words, she argued for discounting parental objections to prescribing their children puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to treat gender dysphoria.
Dr. Johnson was instrumental in stirring up the protests against the recent systematic reviews of pediatric gender medicine out of Dr. Gordon Guyatt's lab. These protests ultimately led Dr. Guyatt and some of his colleagues to denounce their funder, the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine @SEGM_EBM, and seek to pull their names off of pending review papers, putting them in limbo.
More on the WPATH videos here: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
More on the McMaster protests here:
https://archive.is/20250903011815/https://unherd.com/2025/09/the-taming-of-a-gender-researcher/
https://www.nysun.com/article/pressured-by-transgender-activists-star-academic-backs-out-of-his-own-research?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
https://benryan.substack.com/p/if-im-a-funding-body-i-would-think
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-gordon-guyatts-values-and-preferences
https://benryan.substack.com/p/what-internal-emails-reveal-about
You refer to "trans realities". They are private counter-realities that you are entitled to indulge that do not -- and must never -- impose a duty on any other person to join you in indulging. That is the whole of it. You are free to ask people to pretend that your desire to be something you are not makes you into that thing while others are free to decline to pretend.
This what it means to tolerate diversity -- we tolerate your belief in a counterfactual reality, and you refrain from trying to conscript state power to force us to join in the affirmation of this counterfactual reality. Anything apart from this equilibrium, (which the trans rights movement and its enablers is working relentlessly to bend toward forcing the whole world to join) -- is inconsistent with a society that wishes to remain liberal, pluralistic, and democratic.
Quotes a post by T07666; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You refer to "trans realities". They are private counter-realities that you are entitled to indulge that do not -- and must never -- impose a duty on any other person to join you in indulging. That is the whole of it. You are free to ask people to pretend that your desire to be something you are not makes you into that thing while others are free to decline to pretend. This what it means to tolerate diversity -- we tolerate your belief in a counterfactual reality, and you refrain from trying to conscript state power to force us to join in the affirmation of this counterfactual reality. Anything apart from this equilibrium, (which the trans rights movement and its enablers is working relentlessly to bend in the direction of forcing the whole world to join -- is inconsistent with a society that wishes to remain liberal, pluralistic, and democratic.
NGO-run shelter for "Trans Refugees" from around the country in Portland already in disarray over internal infighting and claims of abuse
https://werqt.org/
The truth is that the better heuristic to bring to these cases is the assumption that there is no transphobic motive in any particular killing of a trans-identified person.
That doesn’t rule out the possibility that transphobic murder can happen, but the balance of probabilities derived from prior cases counsels that, in advance of specific evidence, one should wait for specific evidence to emerge and adopt a default attitude of skepticism toward those claiming transphobia as a motive in advance of such evidence.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Behind the transgender movement is the desire for there to be a brave new frontier of human freedom. A decade into the public rollout of that movement, we can already see that the movement marks an inflection point in the history of Western societies: the end of the age of emancipation.
Trans people are not a historically oppressed group because they are not a group and they have never been oppressed. There is no history of discriminatory state action against them. There are no rights they don't have. Their only grievance is the existence of sex segregated facilities designed for the safety and privacy of women. What the transgender movement calls "rights" are imperious demands to allow anyone who claims to be something they are not to violate sex-based boundaries and coerce others to affirm them as they thing they are not, inherently an assault on the civil rights and liberties of others that masquerades as a civil right belonging to themselves and as a psychic necessity they require for their survival, which in turn serves as a pretext for threatening suicide and committing violence in pursuit of that alleged imperative to survival.
They are a psychiatric diagnosis that was inflated into an astroturfed identity category in the last thirty years by a small cabal of wealthy male sex fetishists who wanted to cross-dress full time and conspired to brainwash a subpopulation of autistic and gender nonconforming children into medically harming themselves with drugs that stopped their maturation, creating an army of hostages that could be used to blackmail the state into coercing the whole world into granting their imperious demands. Along the way, this cabal corrupted medicine and science and law, turning each of these institutions into a font of misinformation in the service of trans activists goals. Literally nothing that issues from these discourses is true, from denials that men have athletic advantages over women to claims that blocking the puberty of children has ever had an evidence base.
Treating any of this like it is real, like it is a civil rights movement, inexorably will result in the infliction of a cascade of absurdities and cruelties on actual vulnerable populations -- woman and children -- above all those confused children who are being brainwashed from the earliest age the falsehood that any of them can change sex.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
60 percent of Democrats recently told pollsters that they want the party's transgender policies either to stay the same or move Left. Do they know that giving out taxpayer supported sex changes to illegal migrants is the party's current transgender policy?
Quoting @ManhattanInst: Dozens of transgender migrants told @[private account] reporters that they came into the U.S. not only for free housing and healthcare, but because Gavin Newsom and the California Health Department were giving them free sex change surgeries.
"We reached out to the governor’s office and said, 'Hey, this is what’s happening.' And instead of trying to back away from it, they said, 'Absolutely. We provide gender affirming care to illegals.'"
@christopherrufo on Pod Force One with @mirandadevine
Guy who opposes the chemical castration and dismemberment of children caught up in a social contagion sustained by brainwashing children that any of them can sex change from the earliest age in public schools, but doesn’t want the Democrats to “move to the right” on trans issues: majority of Democrats
Quoting @MorrellMDmph: I think it’s polarization. The poll apparently asked whether they need to “move the party to the right”? That’s a no for many Dems.
Last year, when asked without partisan context, should kids under 18 even be allowed to get “gender” meds, 67% Dems said No.
Gender medicine claims to be medicine and markets itself on the basis of an authority to affirm people in transgender or nonbinary identities. It is thereby guided by standards of care that require psychiatric evaluation.
The gender inquisition seeks to deploy state power to punish people for infractions such as making an accurate reference to a person's sex, or noting that men have penises and women do not. This is what "trans rights" has always meant. It has always been a hijacking and warping of the concept of a "right" to encompass an assault on everyone's right to say what they know to be true and not be coerced into saying what they know to be false. This is why it is a form of kryptonite with the capacity to dismantle liberal, pluralistic, democratic society from within while affecting to be the fulfillment of its promise.
Quoting @reduxx: A women's rights advocate in France has been convicted of transphobia for "insulting" men who identify as women.
Dora Motout's "crimes" include not validating the identity of a transgender politician and referring to the fact that males have penises.
https://reduxx.info/france-womens-rights-activist-convicted-of-insulting-transgender-women-by-discussing-their-male-attribute-fined-e4500/
The Democratic politicians directly responsible for imposing the transgender inquisition on California and the United States as a whole stand poised to be rewarded politically with higher office for their efforts
Quotes a post by A0924; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Party discipline is beginning to erode ever so slightly on the most insane aspects of the transgender movement. But each and every one of the 198 Democrats that voted to continue this vile and unconstitutional assault on parental rights is an enemy of mankind.
Quotes a post by T06512; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Nobody is claiming that trans-identified males are actually biologically female! We don't conflate gender and sex, which are completely different!"
Actual trans-identified folx everyday on every platform:
Quotes a post by T03248; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
1 out of 5 women in the women's federal prison in Tallahassee identity as trans men.
None are attempting to get into a men's prison because trans men are women and like all other women, require private spaces from which men are excluded.
Here's what happens when you put a "trans man" in a men's space.
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: A woman who claims to identify as a man was placed into an all-male NHS psychiatric ward with dangerous men, and was raped within an hour.
"Male patients chanted 'no Adam’s apple' when the 5ft 3in biological female arrived on the ward and within an hour the victim was raped in a cupboard.
The South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust ignored dozens of requests for records from detectives investigating the attack.
Staff accidentally forwarded an internal note saying 'don’t give them any more'. The obstructive behaviour meant a mentally ill patient wrongly stood trial for the rape."
I dispute the claim that she got darker in any way. The thousands of death and rape threats did not traumatize her and cause to her become irrationally polarized, as this narrative would have it.
The thousands of rape and death threats Rowling received merely made manifest the authoritarianism at the foundation of the transgender movement that was fully on display by the time @MForstater was fired for not believing that a man can become a woman, the event that caused Rowling to come out as gender critical.
Rowling understood this authoritarian danger and set out to oppose it forthrightly, up to and including daring the Scottish state to arrest her for the crime of calling a man a man.
The principle reasons for her opposition were clear from day one and she has remained grounded in the same principles at all times.
Quotes a post by A1220; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There are no sources for the claim that the mosque shooters are trans-identified. It's just speculation based on the fact that one has long hair. It's not impossible that one or both of them are trans-identified, but it has not been shown to be true and all accounts claiming that it is a fact are making it up.
Still worth taking the occasion to underscore the key fact that "being trans" just means "someone claims a cross-sex identity." There are no diagnostic or political criteria beyond such claims.
The trans-identified man who murdered children in a Minneapolis Church had spent years identifying as a woman and changed his name with the self-declared intent of affirming his trans identity.
But in a journal he posted to YouTube right before murdering children in a church, he referred to his regret at having spent years "brainwashing myself to believe I was female."
Was he a woman at the time of his murder?" Was he ever one? NPR scolded Amy Klobuchar when she referred to the man as a man.
Klobuchar was right and NPR was wrong. He was never a woman, he was always a man, being "trans" just means "a person claiming to be something they are not."
One would have to know more of the context leading up to this moment to know whether that is the message or whether it's an acknowledgement (consistent with statistical reality) that trans-identified males are not less violent than other men
Quotes a post by T04409; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Transgender ideology cannot withstand impartial scrutiny because it is grounded in self-evident falsehoods.
It has obtained the enormous power it wields through campaigns of bullying and intimidation inside major institutions.
A former senior BBC editor explains how it was done.
Quoting @unherd: Inside the capture of the BBC, by Rob Burley (@[private account])
In his 13 years as a senior BBC editor, Rob Burley saw the Corporation’s defining commitment to impartiality undermined by transgender ideology, a blind commitment to Diversity & Inclusion schemes, and a culture of intolerance.
Informed by his experiences at Newsnight alongside other prestige shows, his major investigation reveals how the BBC took a side in the culture wars.
He draws on extensive interviews with current and former staff — including journalists at the very top.
Speaking out for the first time since leaving the Corporation, Fran Unsworth, the former director of BBC News, reveals in an explosive interview: “I would actually say it drove me out, just dealing with the progressive editorial issues and the bullying around them all. It was incredibly difficult.”
Read more below ⬇️
https://buff.ly/7Fv4Ry8
Pantsuit moderates and ogre-like white males like Fetterman and Platner seem even more enthusiastic than radicals to ensure that there is no daylight between themselves and the most extreme trans activists
Quotes a post by A0961; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yeah. "Trans men" seem happy remain in women's prisons, play on women's sports teams, and attend women's colleges, because they know -- as we do -- that trans men are women
It's a bit more than this. He's said that self-ID shouldn't be the rule, that there should be state certification of valid medicalized trans people and penalties for those who transgress sex-based boundaries without certification. I don't agree but I also think on utilitarian grounds much of the harm that people care about would be mitigated.
Yes, I didn’t think it was. In fact, your point contains the germ of what J regard as the key point about the entire project of trans rights: there is not even an actual collective to which “rights” can be conferred.
The classical liberal position on trans rights is “no law or state action can prevent a person from pretending to be something they are not,” and “no law or state action can coerce other people into believing or playing along with another person’s pretense to be something they are not,” because each of us has a right to to say what we believe to be true and a concomitant right not be coerced into saying what we believe to be false.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I don't think the powerful autogynephilic males who drove the political project of transgender inclusion anticipated that their movement would sweep up a new cohort of emotionally and mentally fragile teenage girls into its net. For a while, that cohort was a net benefit for that agenda, as teen girls caught up in a social contagion were some of the most enthusiastic footsoldiers for the trans movement. But as the inevitable wave of disillusion and detransition sets in among the first cohort of teen girls brainwashed into thinking that dosing themselves on steroids and cutting off their breasts would make them male, a misogynistic disdain for this cohort will set in as they come to be blamed (with some justice) for unraveling the movement that was designed to serve the interests of powerful autogynephilic males.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think it's been really useful for the progressives to quarantine themselves into a crab bucket in which Jamelle Bouie gets canceled for transphobia and Will Stancil for white supremacy. (Bouie is every bit the transphobe I am, because transphobia means expressing one iota of hesitation about any aspect of the trans agenda. Ultimately "transphobia" just means knowing that pretending to be the opposite sex doesn't actually change your sex, and in this regard, no one who isn't a self-lobotomized member of the cult is not a transphobe. Of course, many people who know this still do desperate mental contortions to try to justify an agenda that now generates a fresh reductio ad absurdum each day out of a variety of personal motives, a herd-like conformism being chief among them. All of them are exhibiting personal qualities that should preclude any of them having a role in public affairs. Unfortunately, there isn't one member of the leadership class of the Democratic party who hasn't done their utmost to ensure that there is no daylight between themselves and the most extreme most deranged trans activst. )
Quoting @Noahpinion: David Roberts is a great climate writer, but he's also a jerk who gets on his high horse and says aggressive and mean things to people, using politics as a justification for his behavior.
Now he's realizing the downsides of the toxic online culture he's part of. Good!
The transgender movement and the party that acts as its enforcer is determined to violate the First Amendment in order to compel people to aid in the falsification of the sex of anyone who demands it.
This is a core demand of the movement and it is one in irremediable conflict with a pluralistic and liberal society. The court must -- and will -- reject it.
There are many pathways into the rabbit hole (including just being white and thus tempted into going trans), I don't think this one is more tempting than the others.
Trans inclusion requires universal success in doing one of two things:
1.) Brainwashing every 11-year old girl into believing that a boy is a girl when he claims to be one and thus having no qualms about sharing a bed with him
or
2.) Punishing and stigmatizing that girl as a hateful oppressor if she persists in correctly observing that claiming to be a girl doesn't turn a boy into a girl until she is too afraid to state her discomfort with sharing a bed with him aloud.
The Democratic party, which has declared that forbidding any women or girl from drawing a boundary between herself and any man or boy who claims to be a woman is the Civil Rights Movement of the 21st Century is attempting to do both things: they are brainwashing every child to believe that any boy can be a girl by claiming to be one, and they are treating 11-year old girls who don't want to share intimate spaces with boys as the New Bull Connor who must be subject to punishment and repression and consigned to the dustbin of history.
I predict that neither strategy can be made to work universally in any society that remains liberal, pluralistic, democratic, and free.
Quotes a post by A1628; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Every part of the trans affirming narrative is constructed out of question begging dogmas that no one is allowed to interrogate and shoddy and manipulated data from corrupted sources, Part XXIV
Quotes a post by A1663; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yeah this is why @AbigailShrier first wrote a book on the ongoing social contagion of trans-identification among teen girls and then wrote a book about the wider phenomenon out of which the contagion grew, the medicalization of the ordinary vicissitudes of child development -- it was while observing the former phenomenon that she saw the larger secular trend of which it was a peculiarly harmful manifestation
Quoting @nickwallis: Oh this is goooood: "The rise in trans identification did not emerge in isolation. It emerged from a much broader cultural and psychiatric shift in which growing numbers of ordinary human experiences came to be understood through diagnostic frameworks...
Yes and all gatekeeping was stripped out for medicalization and anyone can say they are trans and be socially affirmed. There is no barrier against perverts, psychos, and sickos from "being trans" -- to the contrary there is sanctioned affirmation.
https://x.com/haynes_wiley/status/2054235051538182327?s=20
Quotes a post by A1170; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We agree that the end of psychological gatekeeping for trans medicalization has been a disaster. I don't believe as a practical matter that it's possible to restore it.
A reminder that removing sex-based language was a feminist imperative that predates the transgender movement. Also interesting that Ginsburg, who argued for the permissibility of sex segregated bathrooms and locker rooms also argued for sex integration of prisons -- hard to conceive of a safety and privacy concern applicable to bathrooms that wouldn't apply more strongly to prisons.
Quotes a post by T03212; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This quote is fake. The tell that it is a fabrication is the claim that Fetterman doesn't believe men should use the girls room. Fetterman has repeatedly stated he supports transgender inclusion in all its guises.
Quotes a post by T01214; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I mostly don't address the issue of the importance of transgenderism in my replies to you, but this reply that i sent this morning, does make that case. Whether truth and reality matter and whether state power should be used to force people to affirm falsehoods is a top-tier issue for humanity, and an important issue for Democrats to grapple with in the discrete instance of trans inclusion in women's sports: https://x.com/wesyang/status/2053096336816222285?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: It's truly amazing that affirmative action managed to be for six decades an issue that Democrats could have benefitted from moderating on more than any other but never did (and in fact spent the 2010's seeking to increase the scope and intensity of its practice). But the Democrats never had to moderate on affirmative action because the Republican never opposed it in any systemic way at the national level (8 of 9 state level referendums, including one in California all sought to do away with it, to little pracitical effect,) until Donald Trump rescinded LBJ's executive order that created it on the first day of his second term.
That is to say that both parties did without the political gains that both of them might have reaped by opposition to it in deference to a moralizing discourse with the power to put certain commitments beyond the reach of political contestation.
Is there a right to equal outcomes? The Civil Rights Act of 1964 was written explicitly to say no there is no such right. But within a year, LBJ was also rationalizing the proposition that "the way to stop discriminating by race is to keep discriminating by race forever."
The elite consensus that made affirmative action untouchable for six decades in the face of unswerving supermajority opposition that neither party saw fit to manifest politically served as the model for moralizing elite consensuses emerging along a range of other issues which a would-be moral vanguard sought to place beyond the reach of political contestation.
Is there a right of free movement without regard for borders? Is there a right for non-citizens to vote? Is there a right for me to have the coercive power of the state at my disposal to force other people to believe me when I claim to be something I am not? Is there a right for me to be accommodated in my dream to be airplane pilot despite my neurological deficits in spatial processing? Is there a right for me, a 50-year old man, to swim against 12 year old girls in a race and to get naked with them in their changing room because I have a compulsion to pretend to be a woman? Is there a right to make the state destroy the livelihood of anyone who would try to stop me from entering that race because they don't agree that a 50-year old man's compulsion to wear girl's underwear makes him a girl?
These are all questions similar to the question of affirmative action in that a supermajority of the public opposes the answers to these questions that the stewards of elite consensus want to give. These are issues that are unlike affirmative action in that the public is (at least for now) showing itself to be willing to treat these issues as within the scope of their political discretion. They are not willing to treat these issues as sacred commitments that transcend the popular will that neither party has a right to oppose.
One of those parties has shown some ability to try to work the people's will on these questions. And the other party might compete more successfully against that party by moving its positions closer to the will of the people. But the party of affirmative action of course is so habituated to wielding power by generated moralizing discourses that place its priorities beyond the reach of politics, and has so bought into the urgency and righteousness of its designated causes (even when they have so plainly plunged into moral and epistemic and practical dysfunction) that it simply doesn't know how to moderate and cannot and must double down at any cost. It has blown too much smoke up its own ass about the fake shit to which it demands the rest of the world to genuflect to do otherwise.
Your view was that Ray Alex Williams was a woman "when he was trans." Harvey Marceline spent decades identifying as trans. I believe he is post-op as Ray Alex Williams is not. It's not a strawman of your views to say that Harvey Marceline was a woman when he was trans if we are to take your conclusion about Williams as being based in the principle that someone is a woman when they are trans.
This is different from saying you want Harvey Marceline in a women's prison, which I did not say. My inquiries concerned what principle you would bring to bear to exclude him (from the category of women).
No, I've acknowledged that you don't want to treat serial rapists in prison as women. I'm just asking how you will do a thing that no Blue States has even attempted to do. I don't think you will manage it because there's a reason no Blue State has even attempted it. I'm asking you to think about it. And if you can't come up with an answer, I'm asking you to consider that the reason nobody can come up with an answer may be intrinsic to the way the issue is framed conceptually by a movement that declares "trans women are women." All the motives you ascribe here are false. All the claims about "what I am doing," "what am I seeking" are false. They don't describe what is in the record of your exchange.
No, I am fairly and accurately representing your views in precisely the terms you framed them to me. You said "trans women are women" in a cultural/legal sense if they are doing the work of femininity. They aren't acutally biologically female. And our concept of the cultural and legal should be able to distinguish between the good faith and the bad faith.
Yes, you said they shouldn't be allowed but the answer I was seeking was why not? What's the underlying principle that no Blue state correctional system seems able to find? My question was how do you operationalize "trans women are women" in the cultural sense you spell out in a way that can exclude anyone at all who makes the claim? Which is really what's at issue here, with the serial murderer or women acting merely as an illustrative for the basic problem of gatekeeping something that is a matter of self-report. It can't be done in practice because the principle excludes it.
You claim that your stance on whether Harvey Marceline was a woman "when he was trans" should be clear from his replies. It is not. Anyone can see that. This is precisely the question you evaded. And continue to evade with accusations of bad faith and obsession on my part.
There are female rapists and murderers in women's prisons. If trans women are women why wouldn't a transfeminine rapist or murdered be imprisoned with women? This is not a gotcha question -- it is a practical question that the federal Bureau of Prisons, and the corrections departments in CA, Mass, NJ, NY, OR, Wash, ME, and MINN have all deliberated on and answered in same way. They provided a principled answer. You've not provided a principled answer. I sought one. You never provided one while claiming to have provided one and then grown increasingly irascible and hostile in order to keep evading the demand for principle. That's what any competent reader who reads the thread will see.
My statement above was a reference to the principle you laid out here. For context, Ray Alex Williams is an autogynephilic fetishist who used to pretend to be a woman and no longer does. He does not allege to have ever been women; he does not agree with you that he was a woman "while he was trans." The principle applies to Marceline no more or less so than it does to Williams. Do you deny that it does? This does not concern the question of his inclusion of exclusion from women's prisons, it only concerns the question of whether Marceline was ever a woman.
Hopefully you don't end up in front of the judge who said she was "heartened" by the choice of the family of the man who plotted to murder Bret Kavanaugh to begin affirming his trans-identity and cited the threat that he would not be incarcerated with women under Trump's federal prison policy as one of the reasons that she cut hi sentence from the 30 recommended by the sentencing guidelines to 8 years.
https://x.com/Bridgetdonegal1/status/2053040909760287125?s=20
Quotes a post by A0414; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This was all resolved in 2009. Trans-medicalists lost decisively and now are a minor and insignificant subgroup of the wider umbrella, the vast majority of whose members claim a gender identity outside of any medical framing
Quotes a post by T00055; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It is not happening anywhere in the country, but Hurabiell is attempting to model it in the very heart of trans-affirming territory
https://x.com/BorisSpider14/status/2052743828428271982?s=20
Quotes a post by A0381; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Trans genocide" means:
-- People retain their right to make accurate references to your sex
-- Women are allowed to draw a boundary between themselves and men who say they are women
-- You can't brainwash a child to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered
Quotes a post by T01657; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Further spending on "progressive media" is a great boon to the GOP -- like "transgender visibility," exposing the wider public to the content of progressive ideas does more than anything else to cast the party captured by those ideas in disrepute
Quoting @daveweigel: NEWS: The Democracy Alliance, the progressive donor network that's spent $2bn on causes/think tanks/campaigns, is directing "tens of millions" of dollars into new progressive media. https://www.semafor.com/article/05/01/2026/progressive-megadonors-bet-big-on-content-creators
While it's empirically true that people who like Obama outnumber those who do not, people are now realizing that every aspect of Blue state failure mode was initiated in Obama's second term. (The EO's on transgender inclusion, equity in student discipline, etc.)
https://x.com/wesyang/status/2050092580709315049?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: Duncan was the testing and standards czar under Obama. Like everyone else who tried to do education reform, he groveled to the woke in 2020.
A faction of the party is now tacitly acknowledging that the equity agenda was a failure.
No one is acknowledging that the transgender agenda is a travesty of a civil rights movement.
https://x.com/nwpealan/status/2050172414852776312?s=20
Quotes a post by T06423; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Gender science is a travesty of science just as gender medicine is a travesty of medicine just as the transgender movement is a travesty of a civil rights movement.
In every guise, the movement pretends to be something it is not in order to wield the power associated with the thing it is pretending to be -- with science and medicine and civil rights.
But even the most cursory examination of the conduct of gender researchers, gender clinicians, and gender activists reveals a collective (and every individual operating within that collective) that is fundamentally hostile to truth-seeking, to healing sickness, and to civil rights, pluralism, and democracy.
There is only subversion of the principles that make science scientific, that separate medicine from cult rituals, and attacks on core civil rights and civil liberties. There is only the most perfunctory mimicry of the forms of these practices and the associated ideals, and no good faith attempt to fulfill the mission of these various callings.
It cannot be otherwise, because the movement is about coercing the world into treating a falsehood as the only truth.
Quotes a post by T06998; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Frank tried to introduce an anti-discrimination law that protected gays and not trans-identified people (the bill lacked the votes for the latter) in 2007. The LGBT Borg went nuclear on him, revealing its ability to control anyone who resisted the trans agenda.
I want you to either demonstrate that you can provide cogent answers that address these concrete problems that we know flow inexorably from the project of trans inclusion because they have in fact manifested in every place where the project of trans inclusion has been embarked on or confess that you can't defend the claim that a man is a woman when he says he is a woman. Either of these responses would be good faith responses; all of this other filibustering and shade throwing is just a way of evading doing either while affecting to be above it all.
He has done good work on the FAA and other subjects, but he is annoying on trans (I get particularly annoyed when people smart enough to know better remain in the rabbit hole) and would have responded differently to my questions if he didn't know his views on it are nonsensical
Using their full power to force states to lock women up with male prisoners who claim to be women and to ensure that male rapists and murderers receive taxpayer-funded transgender surgeries
https://x.com/markjos05095724/status/2048964577170468963?s=20
Quotes a post by T16942; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When Chase Strangio asked trans identified male prisons what they wanted, the male prisoners said they wanted a separate wing in the men's prisons. Strangio overrode their preferences because their actual preference was not affirming enough. Do you agree with Strangio that trans women are women and that a penis isn't a female body part? You did say that Ray Alex Williams was a woman when he was claiming to be one and isn't one now. How was he any more of a woman than the convicted child sex offender who masturbated his intact penis in front of his female cellmate?
No, I have only one argument. There is no need to spend time or money on the myriad accommodations required to make trans inclusion in the military work -- to give anyone dilation time, to ensure their hormone injections are with them on the battlefield, to force women to shower next to men, to have male officers in skirts yell at everyone that tolerance is not enough, it's just the bare minimum. You can just go back to the policy of 1789-2016 with no injury to the functioning of the US military. The only thing that would make you eager to do all this is a social agenda to use the federal government and its agencies as a tool of pushing trans inclusion on the public -- in the military as well as in prisons. And if the people in the charge of the federal government decide they don't want they do all this, they can stop.
What compelling necessity requires the military make extensive accommodations for trans-identified people (including taxpayer funded vaginoplasty) when all sorts of minor disabilities and medical conditions (including being on Prozac) are disqualifying on their face? The only compelling interest here is the Democrat's interest in recognizing cross-sex identities in federal policy. The same interest drives both military and prisons, and the shape of the policies (including taxpayer funded vaginoplasty in both settings) reflect this agenda. I agree that you just followed existing policy and feel burned -- but it's just a fact that policies imposed by executive fiat (as trans in military was) can be removed by executive fiat. Sure, there was a cost to removing accommodations as there was to imposing them, but the removal is a one time cost while the policy is a permanent recurring cost.
They were free to do so in private prior to the existence of a transgender movement. The transgender movement exists to coerce the world into serving as accessories to what was hitherto a private kink.
We have a decades old clinical literature describing the etiology of the condition that drove the Wachowski brothers to start pretending to be women. It is called autogynephilia.
A prerequisite to the success of the modern transgender movement was the cancellation of that literature through brutal campaigns of personal destruction aimed at the authors of that clinical literature.
When trans activists refer to that literature as "debunked" what they mean is, "we conducted a scorched earth campaign of personal destruction to marginalize this set of claims whose truth is demonstrated each day by those afflicted by the condition we claim doesn't exist."
This campaign then served as a model for the politics in a new key that came to dominate academia and the world beyond in the 2010's.
Quoting @IfindRetards: This is the Wachowski brothers who wrote and directed the original 1999 film, The Matrix.
Unfortunately, they took the wrong pill and became the whatever the bottom image is.
Trans activists have gone further in opening a breach in the mechanism that we rely on to separate truth from reality than any other faction ever has, and on a domain where the brazen falsity of the dogmas they are laundering as science could not be more self-evident.
It is in itself a fiasco and a scandal, but as a model for what can be done through manipulation of language and corruption of science, it poses an existential risk to a society governed by science and law.
Quoting @SwipeWright: Once a biological anchor for the term “sex” is gone, policy will go wherever activists want to pull it.
When enough papers circulate claiming that sex has “no consensus” definition, judges can present themselves as choosing among competing expert views.
https://x.com/SwipeWright/status/2048759907185275009
School districts conspiring to deceive parents about the mental health of their children is one of the most egregious systemic abuses undertaken by institutions captured by the transgender movement.
The court has already ruled that this practice violates the Constitution in Mirabelli v. Bonta. But it refuses to take up a case that would extend this ruling to the whole country, creating a bizarre situation where the Ninth Circuit is (nominally) more protective of Constitutional rights than the rest of the country, where the practice continues unabated. (And even in California, the state itself and its districts are deliberately flouting and defying the law by issuing guidance that lies about the SCOTUS ruling.)
For some reason, the court resists taking action on the most flagrant of all the violations of the rights that issue from this movement.
Quotes a post by A2541; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's not the solution the Biden Administration sought which sought the same remedy here as it did in federal prisons -- Trans Women Are Women. And why is it a problem that needs a solution when reversion to the policy of 1789-June 2016 is at hand?
Indeed, the whole point of "trans inclusion" in the US military, like trans inclusion in women's prisons is to advance the trans agenda in settings where the US government has absolute discretion and control to push an agenda onto people who have no right to refuse.
The military houses everyone in sex segregated settings. If there is any aspect of the trans agenda you don't support, you have to reverse that opposition and support the whole agenda to accommodate one or 10,000 "trans people," each and every one of whom claims a right to violate sex-based boundaries at all times.
He is there because the ideology that you invoke when you say "trans women are women" dictates it. We can convene again to discuss at such time as when he is gone under a trans-affirming regime rather than because the trans-affirming regime has been defeated.
I didn't engage with your analogy about immigrants and womanhood but obviously it's a very strained one that does a lot to discredit your rationalization -- and of course offensive to many naturalized citizens, but it's not important to dwell on the latter. There's a clear checklist articulated by law about what conditions one has to satisfy to be a citizen whereas self-ID ("say he is a woman") is the rule wherever trans ideology holds sway for the simple reason that there are no clearly articulable criteria that are coherent, your sarcastic reference to "peering into the soul" is premised upon that understanding. If this were not correct, the male serial rapist of women would not be in the women's prison in the first place.
I see no harm in making people get passports that state the fact of their sex. I see no harm in reverting the US military's policy on trans accommodation in the military to the one that obtained for 44 of the 48 months of the Obama Presidency. I see no harm in keep boys out girl's bathrooms and sports in school, etc. All I see the GOP doing is undoing the work of the last decade by Democrats, which leave trans-identified folx no worse than they were ten years prior, which was fine apart from the imperious demand that all these special privileges that impinge on the rights of women.
I think the ensuing discussion is unavoidable and in many cases, including yours, fair and reasonable. I think we do want to be open to people who engage in this private conduct in some circumstances also working to ensure that there is no legal recognition of trans-identification.
Seven years is a long time to wait for the very first audience granted to the critics of gender medicine within one of the medical lobbies that astroturfed a fake consensus in support of it. But it's a very good thing that it is happening in the face of trans activist tantrums and hopefully a real inflection point.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Update: This panel has not been canceled, despite the better efforts of infuriated transgender activists. It is set for Sunday at 8am in Boston.
"All of these bad actors in the trans movement are making the trans movement look bad."
Maybe this is what the trans movement actually is and it looks bad because it is what it looks like?
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
While this is true and lamentable, I see the overall issue differently. The takeaway here should be: "A person can use pronouns in private settings with specific individuals of their choosing while publicly campaigning to prevent the recognition of trans-identification and ensure the enforcement of sex-based boundaries in law."
The major problem with transgenderism is its conscription of the law to impinge on people's right to say what they know to be true and not be coerced into saying what they know to be false.
When it ceases to be a travesty of a civil rights cause enforced by public authority, it reverts to being what it should never have ceased being: a private eccentricity that some people are free to indulge and others are free to decline to indulge.
This will mean that the issue will remain a contentious matter that will continue be the source of social friction, but it will not be a totalitarian threat.
Rowling is unambiguous and unambivalent about committing her name, reputation, and resources to defusing that threat.
Quotes a post by A1164; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I would say the atmospherics of prisons are extreme but the actual case is not extreme (and thus it is not treated as extreme by trans affirming policy.) It is squarely the same principle being tested as in sports and other domains. And it is all resolved in the same way if "trans women are women" is true, and all resolved in the same way if "trans women are women" are false.
I will submit to you that there is no possibility of a rigorous system when "trans women are women" is true.
Those operating within that framework can act to prove me wrong -- but have done absolutely but prove me right thus far. I say it's because it can't be otherwise and can offer you a mountain of evidence in support of that contention.
You say it can be otherwise but can offer nothing but airy rhetoric.
So when he later stopped being trans, it's not because he realized that his prior claim to be a woman was untrue but rather that what was true was determined by what he was saying in the present?
Cancellation was the tactic of first resort for the trans activists in medicine because they knew they could not win on the merits.
They knew their sole chance at victory was astroturfing a false consensus through cancel culture.
They may still win.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Only TRA's are pursuing a totalitarian course -- and are close to attaining it. The hypothetical I posited was meant to clarify conceptually what general principle is being defended when we oppose "trans rights": the right of people to decide what language they use.
The trans rights movement is totalitarian fanaticism because it seeks to make a private matters and make it mandatory that it be enforced in some way. It has come very close to getting its way and may eventually do so in the near to medium term.
The stable equilibrium consistent with individual liberty is to allow people to pretend to be what they are not and to allow others to refuse. Those who were exercising their free speech in criticizing Rowling are free to do so, she is free to be affronted by it, and so forth.
There is no similar possibility emerging from the gender critical -- but if the gender critical were in a position to legislate that no one may pretend to be something they are not and no one can play along in that pretense, it would be operating in the realm of totalitarian fanaticism. Of course you can't make all people see a man as a woman -- and you also can't make all people intent on pretending that a man is a woman cease doing so except through coercion.
A person can use pronouns in their private life while publicly working to defeat the recognition of transgender identity in law without any cognitive dissonance because they've worked through the consequences of taking a private matter and fixing it in law. (Male rapists and murderers in women's prisons, children subjected to a macabre medical experiment, etc.)
A person can actively work to ensure society refuses every demand of the trans rights movement while calling an old friend who is male "she" without any inconsistency because the trans rights movement is by definition working to deploy state power to determine an individual choice that people must be free to make or not make in one way.
This is what I mean when I say that the resolution of this issue is the reversion of transgenderism to a private eccentricity that some people are free to indulge and others are free to decline to indulge. It's the only reasonable, liberal, and moderate approach to this question. Any other approach is form of totalitarian fanaticism.
As a private, personal matter, we are free to refer to some by wrong sex pronouns if they desire it and if we desire to indulge them. Others are likewise free to decline to participate. It must never acquire the force of law or general social sanction behind it.
Forms of make believe that can function at the level of the individual or the subculture or the neighborhood ("the urban art and fashion demimonde") cannot be scaled up to encompass to the whole of society and be enforced by state power without trampling a fundamental right we all have to say what we know to be true and not be coerced into saying what we know to be false. Rowling zealously defends this right and therefore rejects the Trans Rights Movement while also exercising her own right to indulge an individual man who pretends to be a woman in a way that pleases her to indulge. He knows he's not a woman, he's not invading women's spaces, it pleases him to be referred to in a certain way and it pleases her to indulge him. If he was invading women's spaces, Rowing I am sure would want the law she advocates ensuring that private spaces reserved for women exclude all men to be applied to him.
There is no contradiction between these two exercises of her judgment and her rights.
Quoting @jk_rowling: Nothing's changed. I was being honest about how I feel about an individual trans woman I know, who was a gay man pre-transition, and who I met for the first time post-transition. Objectively speaking, she has physical characteristics that make it fairly obvious she wasn't born female, but she's a gentle, funny person I've never referred to as anything other than 'she' and 'her'. I find it perfectly easy to reconcile my fond feelings towards her, and my experience of her as someone with very female-coded energy, with a belief that she hasn't literally changed sex (and incidentally, she doesn't believe she's literally changed sex, either).
Just as there is zero daylight between the most moderate-presenting Democratic elected official and the most extreme trans-activist, there is zero daylight between the most extreme open borders fanatic and the leading Democratic presidential primary contender, Gavin Newsom, who gave million in taxpayer to this NGO CEO to fight deportations and work tirelessly to advocate open borders.
In both cases, whatever moderate noises these officials make in their quest to regain power will be purely instrumental -- instantly shelved on day one for the maximal agenda of opening the border and brainwashing children to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered.
I am not saying that all trans-identified folks are dangerous -- most are not. I am saying that the most floridly narcissistic dangerous will tend to ID as trans because of the rewards we offer to those who do so, and their latent danger will be exacerbated and unleashed by the bogus scenario of oppression and "genocide" in which it plunges everyone who identifies into it.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnessvictim dismissalviolence terror
The rise is inexorable because who is "trans" is defined solely by self-identification as something you are not, creating a magnet for the most self-hating and screwed up people in the world.
Virtually anyone who is narcissistic and disturbed enough to kill indiscriminately will also be narcissistic enough to claim a neo-identity that lets them violate sexed boundaries, became the center of attention, and control the speech and thought of others in proximity to themselves first.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: The rise of trans killers is real.
I'm speaking in London this Saturday, April 18, at the LGB Alliance @AllianceLGB conference. Come see me speak on a topic many want silenced. https://www.ngocomment.com/p/andy-ngo-speaking-live-in-london
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
Children who are disturbed to the point of murderous ideation had other pretexts for doing so in the past.
They will all cluster toward transgender ideation because it's a self-declared neo-identity with no definition beyond claiming to be something you are not that acts as a magnet toward the mentally ill and violently disturbed because it both rewards that self-identification with social cachet and plunges the person who identifies in into an inherently violent para-political fantasy of oppression by a cisgender majority.
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨A "non-binary" male student killed 8 children and 1 teacher in a horrific school shooting in southern Turkey this week.
İsa Aras Mersinli, 14, reportedly went by the Japanese female name "Konata" and used "she/they/it" pronouns.
https://reduxx.info/turkiye-non-binary-shooter-kills-8-students-1-teacher-at-secondary-school-in-kahramanmaras/
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
Ways you know that "trans women" are men:
-- Do a DNA test
-- Live with them
-- Observe their behavior for any length of time
-- Talk to them for three minutes
-- Look at them from any reasonable distance in real life for more than 5 seconds
Quoting @_ConnieShaw: Serena Worley, one of the founders of Cambridge University Society of Women @[private account] being interviewed by @bindelj.
Serena spoke about how sharing a tiny dorm room in Oregon with a man who said he was a woman resulted in her realising that trans women weren’t women.
Every time she would ‘accidentally misgender him in my [her] head’, she had learned online that she should then repeat five sentences about him using she/her pronouns to recondition herself into referring to him as a woman.
Screwed up people all have a strong incentive to identify as trans (receiving social deference, a right to violate sex-based boundaries, and a right to control the speech and thought of anyone in proximity to oneself that no one can dispute.) This means that the category of person capable of mass shooting will become ever more strongly convergent with the category of person falsifying their sex over time.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: The teen who carried out a mass school shooting, killing eight children and a teacher, in Kahramanmaras, Turkey, is believed to be trans nonbinary. A manifesto believed to belong to the deceased shooter İsa Aras Mersinl was published by his lover, who said he used "she/they/it" pronouns.
Trans mass killings have now been spreading out of the U.S. into multiple other countries. https://reduxx.info/turkiye-non-binary-shooter-kills-8-students-1-teacher-at-secondary-school-in-kahramanmaras/
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialfetish fraudmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
The key intervention by Trans Activists since the early 2000's was to "expand access to transgender healthcare." This has meant 1.) stripping out all psychological gatekeeping for access to transgender medicalization while simultaneously 2.) declaring that anyone who claims a cross-sex identity simply is what they declare themselves to be by virtue of a verbal claim.
The purpose of psychological gatekeeping of gender medicalization, back in the days when it was done, was to ensure that perverts and psychotics and psychopaths didn't have access to it. Transgender medical pioneer Ray Blanchard, who ran Canada's only transgender medical service for decades, would get a new patient every day and recommend ten a year for cross-sex medicalization. Blanchard was not in possession of any science determining who is "actually trans" and who is not (because this is a completely meaningless category) -- but he was able to use basic common sense to rule out the many obvious perverts and psychos who came to him in search of answers that would only harm them.
Trans Activists succeeded in their push to end all medical gatekeeping and to require everyone to recognize any claim to any person claiming a cross-sex identity as a matter of law and policy and custom. This means, of course, that any schizo or psycho who claims a cross-sex identity (and the right to violate sexed boundaries that accompanies it, along with the enforced deference to their whims and demands) now can confer onto themselves a right to be treated as something they are not. And it means that the already very strong nexus between the myriad mental health comorbidities that gives rise to cross-sex ideation and violent criminality has increased -- and will continue to increase exponentially over time.
It is a problem of the Trans Activist Movement's own making, and over time, it will prove (and should and must) prove fatal to their movement.
Quoting @ScottPresler: Transgender Murderer Kills Himself During Attempted Arrest After He & Wife Dismembered Another Transgender Ex-Lover
You read that correctly.
America is so sick & screwed up.
Sarah Buzzard was married to Corey Buzzard in Columbus, Ohio.
A transgender woman named Naria Jenna Whitaker lived w/ them & was in a relationship w/ Sarah.
Ryan Zimmerman — who was transgender & went by “Emma” — moved in to have a relationship w/ Corey (Sarah’s husband).
Corey warned Ryan (Emma) that Naria felt transgender females needed to portray themselves as female.
Ryan had not yet begun transitioning or hormone therapy.
At some point, Corey asked Ryan (Emma) to leave & Corey left for the weekend.
It was during the time Corey was gone, that Sarah & Naria devised a plan to murder Ryan (Emma).
Sarah strangled him to death, dismembered his body, & dispersed his body parts throughout Ohio.
Sarah ended up marrying Naria — her partner in murder — & divorcing Corey.
When the police attempted to arrest Naria, he killed himself.
Sarah Buzzard was sentenced to life in prison.
If you want a picture of the future, imagine a naval gunship flying a transgender flag beneath a caption threatening you with criminal prosecution for not clapping, forever
The Equality Act that the Democrats have twice passed through the House and introduced in the Senate would impose the same requirement that any man who says he is a woman has a right to be in a woman’s sex-segregated space that placed the man this woman describe into a bathroom with her daughters in California onto every public accommodation in America.
When the Democrats say “we can’t throw trans ppl under the bus,” they mean that they will forbid any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who claims to be a woman in any intimate space reserved for women anywhere in America
Quoting @WallStreetApes: California resident says she was in the women’s restroom with her very young children at Whole Foods
A man walked into the women’s restroom, “He's like a pretty buff guy wearing this itty bitty girl's skirt”
She tells him multiple times this is the women’s restroom and he needs to not be in there, he’s making her and her kids uncomfortable
“And he's just like ignoring me. And I tell him again. And then he looks up at me finally and he's like, do you not know the California law? I don't care about the rules, the law. Like get your butt into the men's restroom. Like there's a woman in here, girls in here, kids in here. Like that is so inappropriate.
It was at Whole Foods in Roseville and that just made me feel so uncomfortable and just disgusted and honestly pissed off. So stay in your lane, like go to the men's bathroom. Like why is it that hard?”
The problem that would-be "moderates" have in seeking to remove the recognition of men who claim to be women as women in some settings and not in others isn't just that there exists a richly funded transgender lobby that dominates the party that insists on maximalist outcomes that no one has the courage to defy -- it is that the lobby is in fact acting in a way that logic compels: if "trans girls" aren't "real girls", (they are boys) the claims that are the purported basis for the movement's demands in domains are false.
And if the claims are false (they are false), no one attempting to falsify their sex belongs in any other sex-segregated domain, and no one is obliged to aid anyone in the falsification of their sex.
The movement made the decisive strategic choice to frame their quest for inclusion on a truth claim.
It was a fateful choice that the truth claim that would resolve all questions in their favor if it was true happened to be false.
The problem that would-be "moderates" have in seeking to remove the recognition of men who claim to be women as women in some settings and not in others isn't just that there exists a richly funded transgender lobby that dominates the party that insists on maximalist outcomes that no one has the courage to defy -- it is that the lobby is in fact acting in a way that logic compels: if "trans girls" aren't "real girls", (they are boys) the claims that are the purported basis for the movement's demands in domains are false.
And if the claims are false (they are false), no one attempting to falsify their sex belongs in any other sex-segregated domain, and no one is obliged to aid anyone in the falsification of their sex.
Quoting @wesyang: When a man claims to be a woman, he remains a man. He is the sex he is by virtue of a material and immutable fact that is not altered by his claim to be something he is not. This is the reason for the exclusion of men who claim to be women from women’s athletics. It is also the reason for the exclusion of men who claim to be women from all other sex-segregated settings.
The only reasonable and moderate resolution of the trans issue is the refusal of all demands made by the trans movement because all the demands of the movement (which they try to recast as “rights”) are irrational and extreme
A Democratic candidate running to replace Nancy Pelosi in Congress answers a question about whether “trans women are women” forthrightly, honestly, and correctly.
The question is not why Hurabiel is willing to break this ridiculous taboo but why everyone else abruptly began observing it a decade ago with no deliberation or debate. (The answer is not: “we learned something that was true.”)
Quotes a post by T07927; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We keep getting ever higher resolution documentation of a fact we have known with certainty since 2021: that gender medicine was never evidence-based, explicitly eschews the application of any diagnostic criteria apart from a person's unfalsifiable claim to be trans on principle, and is therefore not medicine at all but a cult ritual based on pseudo-mystical claims to bring forth a non-observable inner self known and knowable only through subjective self-report through the mortification of the body by damaging endocrine function and amputating healthy body parts, whose practitioners have infiltrated the organs of medical consensus to portray itself as something it has never been: an actual medical practice that observes any of the normative standards that distinguish medicine from cult ritual. It in fact merely mimics those normative standards through a cascade of weak "studies," none of which prove what they purport to prove, or ever could prove, because all *beg the question* -- they assume the existence of faith-based constructs ("gender identities") that can by their nature never be proven, which then serve as the basis to claim that some actual justification for indisputably harmful procedures that damage the body exists.
This can be known in multiple ways; by scrutinizing the corpus of purported scientific literature establishing the claims, by listening to the direct public pronouncements of gender clinicians, by reading the websites of gender clinics which proudly boast of their refusal of all diagnostic criteria apart from a claim to be transgender -- and also by looking at the internal deliberations of these organizations
None of what is said behind closed doors is fundamentally different from what is routinely said in public.
It's good to do these exposes of internal deliberations which add detail and dimension to what we already know, it's good to keep this all in circulation so that some people who actually want to know the truth can know for sure that the field of gender medicine has no good faith practitioners, no normative process of self-scrutiny, and no capacity to self-police itself in accordance with basic standards of reason and reality, because it is fundamentally a movement devoted to imposing unreality on the world. But these ever higher resolution dives into a world of unreality merely elaborate and illustrate with more detail the same ultimate conclusion: this is all totally fake shit that masquerades as medicine and science representing a systemic failure of the medical and scientific apparatus to separate out truth from falsehood with wide and devastating implications for every institution caught up in the cascade.
Quoting @LeorSapir: From @benryanwriter's new piece out today in @[private account].
Gender doctors and their allies argue that parents should be allowed to decide on hormonal and surgical options. But it's hardly a secret at WPATH that great pressure can be--and often is--put on parents to agree to Rx.
Wright dives into the Human Rights Campaign's database of murderous violence against trans-ID people and finds:
-- The homicide rate for trans-ID individuals is lower than that of the general population
-- Most of it was done by intimate partners
-- Most of the perpetrators were black
It was obvious at the time (remember when the huge BLM march in Brooklyn turned into Black Trans Live Matter rally?) that all claims of an epidemic of white supremacist anti-trans violence were maudlin nonsense weaponized to advance a fake narrative of oppression. Now we have exhaustive documentation of that self-evident fact along with confirmation that HRC and others who were making this claim knew the claims to be false at the time they were making them.
If you didn't have a built-in heuristic rejecting the made up nonsense, develop one now.
None of this shit is ever remotely real.
Quoting @SwipeWright: That narrative has been pushed for over a decade by the Human Rights Campaign (@[private account]) in their annual "Epidemic of Violence" reports, and has been referenced by presidents, medical organizations, journalists, activists, and even used to justify legislation and government programs.
But when we independently verified all 304 transgender homicide cases in HRC’s own comprehensive victim lists from 2015–2024, their narrative completely collapsed.
What we found:
- And among identified suspects, most perpetrators were black, not white.
- Transgender homicide rates are below the general population rate.
- Only 3.3% of cases resulted in confirmed hate-crime determinations.
- The leading identified circumstance was intimate partner violence, not anti-trans bias.
In 2020, when the “white-supremacy-fueled epidemic of violence” narrative was being pushed especially hard, there were ZERO identified white suspects.
We also show how the HRC manufactures their false narrative. In a 2021 report, HRC pointed to the deaths “four Black transgender women” that HRC cited in a report titled “Black LGBTQ People and Compounding Discrimination” as proof that “white supremacy” was driving an “epidemic of violence.”
But the actual facts did not match their narrative.
One case remained unsolved, with no public evidence of anti-trans bias or anything tied to white supremacy.
In the other three cases, every identified suspect was a black man.
By the time HRC published its report, arrests had already been made and these basic facts were public.
In other words, HRC took four cases and spun them into evidence for a political narrative that the known facts did not support.
The truth matters, not just for its own sake, but because false narratives will inevitably produce ineffective solutions. If the deaths of transgender people are the result of a hate-crime epidemic driven by white supremacy and transphobia, then a reasonable response might be more anti-bias campaigns.
But if the main problem is intimate partner violence, then the most-effective interventions would likely include domestic-violence services tailored to trans-identified victims, emergency housing for people trying to flee abusive relationships, and other violence reduction efforts in the places where these killings occur.
Federal government and state governments have already spent hundreds of millions of dollars implementing ineffective policies based on the HRC's lies.
Now that the facts are finally public, ignorance is no longer an excuse. The HRC has a choice: keep repeating a false story that serves progressive ideology, or finally face facts and respond to the problem as it actually exists.
Read about our detailed findings in our new @[private account] article below.
🔗https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
"This has nothing to do with Trans Day of Visibility! He's not a Trans Woman! He's just a middle-aged married father with a sex fetish for dressing up like a woman and wearing huge prosthetic breasts! Wait..."
Quotes a post by T04661; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
ACLU lead trans rights litigator published a piece in 2015 stating that "a penis is not a male body part. It's just an unusual body part for a woman to have." There is no argument for the inclusion of men in women's intimate spaces that does not ultimately hinge on this claim. A federal appellate court just ruled that this was true.
At some point, in some form, the Supreme Court will have to say whether they agree.
Quoting @KDansky: “'It is truly a testament to where we are as a society today that it must be said in the context of federal civil rights litigation that women don’t have penises.'
I wrote those words in an amicus brief filed by the U.S. chapter of Women’s Declaration International in the case Olympus Spa v. Armstrong. In his March 12 dissent to a decision in the case, Judge Lawrence VanDyke of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit put it more colorfully: 'This case is about swinging d—s,' he wrote, using a vulgar term for male genitalia.
The language caused an uproar, and rightly so. But Judge VanDyke is not wrong."
Thanks to @thehill for publishing this. Please share far and wide.
https://thehill.com/opinion/judiciary/5807533-the-court-case-where-gender-identity-made-womens-rights-unspeakable/
The trans sports question is just this: Should you have to be female to be classified as a woman?
The way you answer this question won't just apply to sports.
Don't laugh -- people like this dominate the education and social welfare system across Canada. They imposed a $750K fine on a school trustee who resisted the imposition of gender indoctrination on every student in British Columbia, festoon public schools across Canada in trans flags, and teach children from the earliest age that any of them can change sex. They engaged in a state-sponsored campaign to shut down a women's shelter in Vancouver because it refused to allow in men and apologized for putting on a Harry Potter-theme children's event that ended up having to be extended by weeks because it was by far the best attended event in history.
Quoting @DailyMail: Progressive political party's conference plunged into turmoil after giving minority groups 'equity cards' to let them cut line-with trans woman furious a biological woman was allowed to go before her https://trib.al/EXi1wah
Recall the way everyone wrote Biden off in 2019 as a relic of the party that Democrats were pledged to leave behind. He swept through the primary field with ease because of his blanket support from Southern black voters who were the backbone of the legacy party. Biden's superannuated state reflected that of the party machinery for which he served as figurehead.
Newsom's X feed has brought back fat (and class) shaming and now fag baiting, explicitly pandering to the framing created by a 19-year old avatar of an incel adjacent neo-fascistic online subculture.
In office, like Biden, he will pursue mass immigration, racial preferences and transfers, and the manufacture of transgender children without limit.
Quotes a post by A2349; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Mahr’s view is actually incoherent and at odds with everything we know about material reality.”
This is not some devastating Gore Vidal like witticism. It’s just a blunt factual observation — one that applies to the entire corpus of trans-affirming discourse in every guise it takes throughout academia.
Quoting @SwipeWright: I totally reject the notion that Mahr's response to my paper represents a legitimate, equal alternative to my view that many aspects of reality are mind-independent.
We are not merely "talking past each other" from different epistemological starting points. Mahr's view is actually incoherent and at odds with everything we know about material reality. And the fact that I even have to respond to such thorough nonsense is truly shocking.
These ideas have no place in academia because they have no guardrails whatsoever. There is no limiting principle or empirical anchor that makes them self-correcting over a long enough timescale like the sciences. This means that, over time, these fields actually get more, not less, disconnected from reality. And then they start infecting legitimate fields like biology and try to tear down legitimate knowledge.
These fields rooted in Critical Theory are totally fraudulent. They have no place in academia and do not deserve to be supported with taxpayer dollars.
Lead ACLU Trans Rights litigator Chase Strangio wrote "a penis isn't a male body part. It's just an unusual body part for a woman to have" in 2015.
This was quoted in a long NYT Mag piece trying to pin the blame for the debacle of the Skrmetti on Strangio as an example of the bizarre reality-denying extremism of Strangio.
But as you can see here, there is nothing extreme about what Strangio said relative to the belief system being enshrined as the only truth throughout mainstream medical institutions. He was simply stating the same doctrine that the American Academy of Pediatrics has officially endorsed.
Yes, the beliefs are bizarre reality-denying extremism. But those beliefs are all endorsed (and increasingly enforced) all across institutional America and by every Democrat politician at every level of government. The beliefs are false and they are crazy. But they constitute the mainstream, which is working tirelessly to marginalize actual truths at the behest of those false dogmas.
In this case, the truth that what we are witnessing here is a straight women discussing her sexual relations with a straight man.
Quotes a post by A2621; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A trans woman is a man who claims to be a woman. The claim does not alter the sex of any man making it. Nor do endocrinological and cosmetic body alterations. All they do is alter or destroy body functions without changing anyone’s sex. Sex remains a material and immutable fact that is the sole basis for classification in law and public policy. Every trans woman is a man and will be regarded and treated as one.
Yes, Khelif is not “trans.” Khelif is, however, indisputably male — the one thing that has been definitively proven.
The ban is not of “trans women” but of male athletes from women’s competition.
“Trans women” are one subset of the category of “males” that also encompasses males with disorders of sexual development that result in an incorrect attribution of female sex at birth.
Neither should ever have been eligible to compete against female athletes in athletic competition. And now they are not.
Quotes a post by T02881; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Sigh. OK I guess I have to watch
(“Trans genocide” = you’re allowed to refer to reality in speech and women are permitted to draw a boundary between themselves and all men, including those who claim to be women.)
Quoting @CantEverDie: if you watch and support this you are funding trans genocide globally by the way
The transgender inquisition is global and unitary, seeking and imposing the same dictates wherever it obtains the power to do so.
The criminal investigation of an Icelandic man who posted online that men cannot breastfeed children is what the movement seeks the power to impose everywhere -- the power to punish those who dispute the movement's false dogmas, which it seeks to enshrine through state power as the only truth.
Quoting @libsoftiktok: INSANE. A man in Iceland is facing an investigation by police and potential jail time for posting online that men cannot breastfeed children.
Imagine getting thrown in jail for speaking the TRUTH.
WTF is going on in Iceland???
There are dozens, even hundreds, of cases every bit as absurd as this covered by @reduxx. They continue unabated because the core proposition of the transgender movement requires it and permits of no possibility of withdrawing recognition from the neo-Nazi who declares himself a woman while serving his prison sentence because the basis of his recognition as a woman is the same basis as the recognition of every other trans-identified male in the world. (All say they are women and they are therefore women.)
Quoting @spikedonline: German neo-Nazi Sven Liebich was sent to a women’s prison after declaring himself a female. Now he wants to be called ‘Anne Frank’ and have his gender listed as ‘diverse’. This is the lunacy of ‘trans rights’ in action, says Georgina Mumford
https://buff.ly/fGJEPXq
@[private account] If he wanted to be called a girl, he would demand she/her. It's possible he's gone back to he/him to avoid association of his mass murder with transgenderism and the press will engage in a massive coverup that it's a trans-identified male. We'll have to see.
The Biden Administration convened a meeting of government officials, donors, and transgender NGO's seeking to pressure families into affirming their children who had been caught up in the transgender social contagion as members of the opposite sex.
The implicit flipside of pressuring families to affirm in order to prevent them from ending up in foster care is establishing a norm that families that do not affirm are harming their children in ways that could get them placed in foster care.
Expect all the forces pressing for such outcomes, which continue to operate unabated throughout Blue America, to resume their ongoing cooperation to snatch confused children from their families the instant any Democrat returns to power.
Quoting @MegEBrock: The Biden administration hosted a “speed dating” event for trans activists, major donors, and government officials called “Our Family Values: Building the Evidence Base for Child Well-Being,” took place just three weeks before the presidential election.
C3 dehumanizingcontagionpolitical enemystate takes children
Good question. Most likely. Virtually all trans-identified female prisons in the US are in women's prisons, because as we all know, trans men are women.
A convicted child sex predator was a moderator at three of the most popular transgender subreddits.
@PrishaMosley explains why this is not surprising.
Quoting @IWF: 🚨 How did a child sex predator end up moderating 3 of the most popular transgender subreddits?
And who knew?
This is bigger than one platform. It’s about protecting kids.
Read the latest from @PrishaMosley ⤵️
https://www.iwfeatures.com/commentary/what-the-transgender-child-predator-epidemic-reveals-about-gender-ideology/
Searchable database of men incarcerated in women's prisons after claiming to be women in Canada.
Canada is housing male sex offenders in women's prisons because the central dogma of the transgender movement holds that any man who claims to be a woman is a woman.
Quotes a post by A3057; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Existential denialism" perfectly articulates the stakes of the transgender movement. "My false claim about myself must be accorded the status of truth. Your true claim about myself must be accorded the status of defamation unto death."
Do not underestimate the implications.
Portugal was among the first to impose trans-affirmation by law and learned what everyone else who follows suit will also learn: it's untenable, and it has to be repealed.
Everyone else has the option of learning from Portugal's experience ahead of time and not repeating their mistake in the first place.
Quotes a post by T01776; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Strangio understands that civil liberties (the freedom to say what you know to be true and not to be coerced into saying what you know to be false) and "trans rights" are radically zero sum.
To permit the one is to destroy the possibility of the other and vice versa
ACLU lead trans right litigator Chase Strangio: "The starting premise of this and all anti-trans arguments is that women and girls who are transgender are *really* male."
Yes. Yes it is.
Quoting @benryanwriter: ACLU litigator Chase Strangio in a 2021 Medium essay: "The assumption behind the anti-trans rhetoric is that there is a single biological characteristic that one can locate and name that demarcates the so-called biological line between the binary of maleness and femaleness."
Actually, there is: the gametes. There is no spectrum. They do not come in size medium. There is only large or small.
When Ray Blanchard ran Canada's only gender clinic in the 1980's, he would get a new prospective patient every day and put ten of them on cross-sex hormones a year.
There was no science to his selection process. But when you are as selective as Blanchard was, you would of course do a much better job screening out the mentally unwell, the sexually depraved, and the criminally inclined than you would under a model that affirmed anyone who showed up claiming to be the opposite sex as a member of the opposite sex and immediately put them on cross-sex hormones.
The transgender movement moved to the affirmative model around 2010 and will be reaping the bitter harvest of this totally insane decision for decades to come.
Quoting @bindelj: Why would any 'gender medic' sign off a profoundly mentally unwell man for 'sex change surgery' and be in the slightest bit surprised when it exacerbates the problems? The case of Vivienne Taylor, Britain's Barbie Kardashian (post in reply):
Governor Cox, who positioned himself as a trans-affirming Republican by vetoing a bill banning boys in girls sports in 2022 and giving his pronouns ("he/him") to a group of high school students, signs into law a permanent ban on chemically castrating and dosing confused children with steroids.
His veto on boys in girls sports was overridden in 2022, and by 2023 he had educated himself on the pediatric gender medicine issue, coming to understand that the astroturfed pseudo-consensus in support of it among US medical lobbies had always been fraudulent.
Moral and intellectual growth is possible, even for those who previously pandered to the Borg.
Study his trajectory and do likewise.
Quotes a post by A2156; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
What we are seeing here is the poisoned fruit of a decadeslong policy of containment. The grievance studies programs were created in the first place to quell left insurrections on campus. It bought a generation or so of relative peace -- but at the cost of the eventual capture of the teaching and helping professions. From there came the public and then the private sector unions, the entire NGO apparatus. No the Democratic party itself serves as an instrument of the apparatus rather than the other way around.
The absorptive power of capitalism is such that it integrates and defangs radical ideas and movements and turns them into further marketing opportunities. The Trans Child is the paradigmatic construct of this ongoing process, explaining why it is equally sponsored by the HR directors of Goldman Sachs and BlackRock and anarchist street militants. It is an unstable equilibrium propped up by vast agglomerations of capital and an army of those invested in its propagation.
Yes he would deliberately bit pay any fine, be held in contempt and go to jail on purpose to expose the repressive character of the tribunal and the assault on the core civil liberty at the foundation of the transgender movement.
Various victims classes who have new euphemisms manufactured to name them — “the unhoused”, “justice involved individuals”, “undocumented citizens”, “Trans Youth” — become the pretext for vast transfers of taxpayer and donor funding to a new class of functionaries within the therapeutic state: graduates of grievance studies programs with no skills other than the propagation of new sophistries
This is generically a true statement, but the transgender movement is notable in the striking degree to which a single set of monomaniacal imperatives dominate for the simple reason that it is really is a movement to enshrine falsehoods as the only truth and extract deference to those falsehoods from the whole world through force.
There are of course many people -- maybe most trans-identified people -- who resort to sex mimicry for private, personal reasons that don't rise to the level of the political -- but by definition none of that has any bearing on the vast institutional apparatus that comprises the movement.
It is defined by its institutional goals and its actions taken in pursuit of those goals. They are remarkably consistent across nations in what they seek in legislatures and through executive and judicial action -- Tickle vs Giggle in Australia, rulings by the BC Human Rights Tribunal in Canada, prosecutions in Brazil and Switzerland and Iceland -- all reflect a global and unitary will.
Strangio is not an outlier in any way. He is the lead trans rights litigator for the dominant trans activist organization in America and under a different court, one that would have been made by a 2016 HRC victory, we would be much closer to other parts of the Anglosphere than we have ended up being because of the exogenous shock of the 6-3 Trump majority.
I don't think it's ACLU's position. I do think it is the fundamental objective of the trans rights movement and when the ACLU made itself the spearhead of the trans rights movement, it pledged itself to pursuing two radically incompatible goals.
Sure, but Strangio does not accept "I'll call he without actually believing you are a real male." You can decide your own reasons for playing along but it fundamentally means you are prepared to bargain away all of the trans agenda, because all of it is conditioned on acceptance the ontological claim. (That we both agreed is false.)
My position has always been that people are allowed to affirm gender identities if they like and others are allowed to not affirm them. The issue is that the trans movement's constitutive goal is to prevent the latter from being permissible through the exercise of both state and non-state power.
The practice you invoke by saying you're fine with "misgendering" (using accurate sex-based pronouns) sex offenders and murderers is of course just as much a denial of the reality of the central dogma of transgenderism as my more thoroughgoing defense of it as a socially acceptable practice. The question was meant to draw that out of you -- to point out that as a believer in civil liberties, you reject the primary thrust of the transgender movement because those two things are radically incompatible.
You are blithe about this and so answered readily because you remain in denial about this being the central objective of the transgender movement. But there is no transgender movement without this imperious demand for special privileges recast as a right. This demand is what the movement is.
It's a difficult question because forcing the whole world to treat a falsehood as it were true is the central objective of the transgender movement everywhere in the world and rejecting it makes you just as much of an anti-trans extremist as me.
"Anti-trans extremist" just means "someone who doesn't believe anyone has a duty to help anyone else falsify their sex."
This of course is a moderate view, contrary to the extremist (and untrue) view held by the transgender movement that a man becomes a woman when he says he is a woman.
Quotes a post by T06531; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I do by the way believe that there are people who 1.) are consumed by an urge to mimic the opposite so strong that it can't be overcome and 2.) who actually do become happier and more fulfilled as a result of doing so.
This first group is vanishingly small, and a tiny fraction of those who pursue trans-identification today. The second group is a small fraction of the first group, consisting of people with the material and mental means and an unusual combination of robust mental health (somehow, improbably) coexisting with the desire to mimic the other sex.
None of them change sex or belong in cross-sex spaces. Some who pass will be able to enter those spaces undetected. None of them require any form of legal requirement or accommodation. They are part of the diversity of a planet of eight billion and have the same rights as anyone -- and no more and no less -- and are thus free to make eccentric choices about how they live and of course, absolutely no standing to coerce anyone else into participating in their mimicry.
An unbelievably pernicious piece of hackery published by the NYT chronicles the replacement of the familiar profile of the typical mass shooter -- "a middle-aged man who was socially isolated and in despair" -- with an emerging new cohort of young person, citing two recent trans-identified male mass shooters without acknowledgement of their trans-identification or their maleness, thus implicitly suggesting that in addition to the new crop of being shooters being young, they are also female, and also ruling out any discussion of the role trans-identification may be playing in this dynamic.
The shooters are still male -- with a notable exception of a young mass shooter who was a woman pretending to be male -- and they are, in the very examples cited in this article, both men pretending to be women, both men who were affirmed in their sex imposture by a medical and educational and social welfare system that tells us that declining to affirm children in their sex confusion places them at risk of suicide. Colluding in that sex falsification after affirmation went disastrously haywire out of deference to they very set of taboos that left the mental health comorbidities that afflict trans-identified young people to fester unaddressed is an extraordinarily bad faith act.
Newsom has made a few moderate statements on trans athletes (calling it "deeply unfair" to allow boys into girls sports,) while doing absolutely nothing to prevent them from being inflicted on female athletes as the state puts at risk billions in federal funding in order to continue what he himself called a deeply unfair practice.
But the real play now is a vast expansion of the Therapeutic State involving billions in taxpayer funding and thousands of new state employees who will serve as footsoldiers for the party, propagandizing every child to believe that any of them can change sex, creating a school to gender clinic pipeline that will leave no quirky children behind (to grow into their healthy, intact bodies) along with propagating a vast range of other deranged beliefs about race, gender, and climate that will lead to neurosis, personality disorders, and orient the children toward activism.
This army of patronage recipients will ensure that the party keeps its grip on political power all while affording the professional managerial class bountiful opportunities to loot the public treasury for various forms of useless to harmful make work that exacerbates the problems they are purporting solve while masquerading as a moral vanguard.
Quotes a post by T05008; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is no middle ground. Either the transgender serial murderer of women who claims to be a woman is a woman because he claims to be a woman and belongs in the women's shelter or he doesn't because the claim isn't true. Either a 6'1" man belongs competing against women in NCAA swim meets because he says he is a woman or he doesn't because men don't become women when they claim to be women. Either it's a good policy to brainwash millions of children to believe any of them can change sex because any of them can change sex or it isn't because none of them can change sex. Either it's lifesaving and medically necessary to chemically castrate and dismember children who have been brainwashed from the earliest age to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered or the claims that there is medical evidence supporting these claims were always lies that are beginning to unravel now that actual scientists have scrutinized them. Either there is a good reason for the state to falsify the official records of people claiming to be the opposite sex or it's a bad idea because this harms the integrity of public records and begs the question of whether people falsifying their sex belong in cross-sex spaces.
All of these questions hinge on the question of whether someone becomes the opposite sex by claiming to be the opposite sex. They all hinge on the question of whether that premise is true. If the premise is true, then all the policies listed above must be imposed on the American public. If the premise is false, all of it must be repealed.
Quotes a post by T06987; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If a billionaire with a face tattoo funded a movement claiming that their face tattoos constituted those who had tattoo'd their faces as a minority class to whom certain privileges and immunities applied, it would be similar to the transgender movement.
"Trans rights" seeks the recognition of the man who acts on his desire to falsify his sex as having thereby established the truth of the false claim for which he seeks recognition.
Both are subjective desires. A gay man who acts on the subjective desire fully satisfies all conditions for being a gay man. A man wants to wear a dress and acts on that desire fully satisfies his desire to be a man wearing a dress -- what he does not satisfy is the condition of being a woman who has a right to occupy women's spaces, which is the entire point of the transgender movement.
Neither a facial tattoo nor a desire to falsify one's sex, however that expresses itself (and the transgender movement seeks to, and has, permitted self-declaration alone to establish the claim of a cross-gender identity), creates an objective new fact that would entitle the group to redefine nondiscrimination. (The transgendered are different from those with facial tattoos in that the former group makes such a claim while the latter group does not.)
A gay man is a gay man by virtue of his sexual orientation which creates objective facts in the form of his conduct that can in turn become the basis of discriminatory behavior against him. This is remedied by the demand that he be entitled to the same treatment as a non-gay man would receive.
A trans-identified man who claims to be a woman on the inside remains a man. Nothing about his conduct (dressing differently, mimicking the vocal patterns of women, harming his endocrine system or removing healthy body parts) changes his sex. His demand is that non-discrimination against him includes participating in the pretense that his desire to falsify his sex obliges other people, as a matter of law, to join in that falsification -- by giving him access to women's spaces, by addressing him in the manner that he regards as consistent with his desire to falsify his sex, by falsify official state records to reflect his private desires to falsify his sex rather than the fact of his sex. These are fundamentally different, and more authoritarian, demands from what the gay person seeks, they impinge on the rights, privacy, and safety of others in a way that the equal treatment for gay people does not.
"Trans Americans" are Americans who wish to falsify their sex. There are various reasons for this, various etiologies and belief systems that underlie this desire. The issue enters politics when it takes the form of a demand that state power assist those who wish to falsify their sex to compel other people and institutions in the falsification of their sex. It is an inherently coercive demand that impinges on the rights of others.
The distinctive demand of the transgender movement is that nondiscrimination against them necessarily entails acceptance of the truth of their claim to be something they are not. This is what distinguishes "transgender rights" from all other minority rights. The claim is thus 1.) people who wish to falsify their sex are not a minority group at all and moreover 2.) transgender rights are different from other group's nondiscrimination claims in that they exceed the demand for equal treatment and replace it with a demand for compelled speech and belief.
I am not saying that. I am saying transgender rights are necessarily aimed at forcing an employer to let Doug into the ladies room when he begins claiming to be a woman. We know this because NY state among others imposes this requirement. It is the very core of trans rights to make this demand and enshrine it into law.
It's true that Spanberger survived these questions and won handily.
It's true that the party has taken this as a lesson that the transgender issue is not salient enough to require moderation on their part.
This is true in many Blue and Purple states.
It's likely not true in national elections, though other problems could easily override the effect of this issue, which is not high salience.
However, the Democratic party is less popular than Donald Trump in no small part because of this issue which has effects on the party's image that exceed the discrete issue. It reveals the party to be wedded to a policy of deploying state power to force people to affirm absurdities and endure cruelties inflicted on their children.
Moderating on "trans rights" means giving up on trans rights because it is not moderate to use state power to force people to believe absurdities and all "trans rights" are imperious demands that state power be used to force the whole world to believe an absurdity
Quoting @wesyang: The NYT reported about how a male serial murderer of women was allowed into a women’s shelter in NYC despite the terror of the women forced to be confined with him. He went on to behead and dismember yet another woman weeks later. He is back in a women’s prison. The people working relentlessly to inflict male murderers and rapists onto women locked in prisons and shelters are zealots who think they are the best people in the world at the vanguard of humanity as they inflict danger and humiliation onto vulnerable women.
They are carrying out the will of center-Left political parties across the Western world. There has never been a cult this deranged with this much power in the post-Enlightenment world.
The "anti-trans attacks" were asking Spanberger to clarify whether an adult male sex offender who was allowed to loiter naked for hours in a girls high school changing room in front of children had a right to be there and to clarify whether boys who say they are girls should be allowed into girls private facilities and sports. (Her answers were to equivocate and say that individual schools should determine the answer.)
Quotes a post by T06987; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's the creation of a fact that departs from nondiscrimination doctrines, or requires a redefinition of nondiscrimination. Listing everyone's sex, including those with compulsion to falsify their sex, is equal treatment. The gay person wants equal treatment, the tattoo guy seeks nothing, (he's just a guy who made a choice, not making claims to have become a "Tattto American",) the trans-identified person seeks to force you to call him something he is not.
I said it doesn't matter whether the inner compulsion to falsify your sex is innate or a choice. It doesn't create a fact that can be the basis for classification in accordance with the false sex. The man with a facial tattoo is just a man with a compulsion, he is not a "Tattoo American." The man in a dress is just a man in a dress, not a "transgender American."
Nondiscrimination for gays just means not treating a person who sleeps with members of their own sex differently than you would a straight person. Innateness does not matter.
"Nondiscrimination" for a "trans person" means treating a person's desire to falsify their sex as if a truth is generated by that desire. Whether the desire to falsify one's sex is innate or acquired also does not matter here: sex is real, material, objective, and therefore the basis for classification while one's private reveries and inner compulsions are not and therefore cannot serve as a basis of classification.
"Transgender Americans" are no more a distinct class of person to whom minority rights and legal recognition can be conferred than "Americans with facial tattoos."
"Transgender Americans" are people subject to the compulsion to falsify their sex, a private endeavor that no law can constrain, but that no law can impose on others without trampling on the rights of those who decline to aid in the falsification of another person's sex.
"Legal attacks" "transgender Americans." There is no thought in any of these terms, just question-begging rhetorical formulations that unravel the instant they are scrutinized.
Your official documents will legal list your sex, not your private reveries about your sex because your sex is a material fact and your private reveries about your sex are mere private reveries.
No one is prevented from traveling abroad or driving because their documents list their sex. This is equal treatment: everyone's documents list their sex, regardless of whether they are subject to a psychological compulsion to falsify their sex. There are no special privileges granted to those demanding that the state aid them in the falsification of their sex.
There is no way to give legal status to anyone's counterfactual claims about their inner selves without creating situations such as a judge requiring rape victims of a fully intact man in a women's prisons to address their male rapist as "she" or a chief of police in Fairfax Virginia declaring that an adult male sex offender found with children's swim lesson schedules and child porn on his phone after loitering naked for hours in a women's changing room around children because he says he is a woman.
It's cruel and absurd and any reality-based political system will avoid doing it.
Quotes a post by T06987; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
All the polling shows that a robust majority of Democrats (and a robust supermajority of all voters) oppose the inclusion of men in women's sports.
All that keeps this issue propped up in Blue States is the unanimity of the Democratic party's representatives in their drive to thwart the will of their own voters to forbid any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman, a cause that the party has decreed "the civil rights movement of the 21st century Blue States have exhibited a willingness to place at risk billions in federal funding in order to defy the federal government and the majority of their own voters.
Fortunately, the transgender movement's goal of thwarting pluralism, liberalism, and democracy, which the movement rightly regards as necessary to the attainment of its agenda, faces a serious challenge in the form of ballot initiatives that will allow voters to participate in the legislative process directly.
Democrats who feel that the astroturfed pseudo-consensus that keeps them pledged to fight this losing issue should welcome this opportunity to be defeated by their own voters and get this ludicrous travesty of a civil rights movement off of their back across Blue America.
All those stupid or venal or sheeplike enough to believe that forbidding women to draw a boundary between themselves and any man who claims to be a woman is a real civil rights cause rather than dispositive proof that the civil rights narrative has reached its terminus should understand that they are headed toward the dustbin of history.
Congratulations to Erin Lee for her tremendous work in making this happen against unbelievable odds. Democracy is still alive in America.
Quoting @Erin4Parents: 🚨BREAKING: WE DID IT AGAIN, COLORADO! 🎉🔥
Our 2nd @ProtectKidsCO ballot measure — Girls Sports Initiative #109 — has OFFICIALLY MADE THE BALLOT! 🏆
The legislature won’t protect our daughters. DC isn’t stepping up. So the PEOPLE of Colorado are taking charge — we WILL protect girls’ sports and private spaces! ⛹🏼♀️
This massive win belongs to YOU:
THOUSANDS of incredible volunteers — over 3,300 petition carriers, 1,900+ notaries, 500+ churches, and hundreds more who donated, hosted us, shared our message, and cheered us on from everywhere.
They said a volunteer effort like this was impossible.
We said WATCH US — and proved grassroots power wins. 🙌🏼
Huge THANK YOU to every single one of you who made this happen. Your heart, hustle, and faith carried us here. ❤️
Now just a few more days until we hear that Initiative #110 to Protect Kids from Irreversible Sex-Change Procedures also qualifies! 🙏🏼
The fight is ON — and we’re just getting started.
Together, we’re building a Colorado where girls can compete fairly and kids are protected. 💪🏼
#ProtectGirlsSports #ProtectKidsCO #SaveGirlsSports
“Politics has absolutely zero to do with how this policy came out,” — former president of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons tells NYT that the organization, which recently both changed its recommendation in support of dismembering confused children to one of opposition and called into question the entire practice of chemically castrating and dosing confused teenagers who have been brainwashed to believe they are the opposite sex with steroids, explains that the organization had been working to change its recommendations since 2024.
His statement cleanly debunks desperate cope by trans activists clinging to (and propagating) the lie that the organization was pressured by the Trump Administration into the change rather than responding to the fact that there has never been good evidence to support the claim that inflicting the ultimate sexual violence on children is good for them, (as if any such evidence could ever exist) thus putting themselves in alignment with a growing consensus of reality-based institutions and states (including the national health services of Sweden, Finland, the UK, and New Zealand.)
There are a few other non-trans folx in this photo and dozens more detransitioners who elected not to appear in it for fear of being harassed by trans activists. (71 total at the conference.)
Fox Varian's $2 million malpractice judgment was the first and only transgender medical lawsuit to reach a jury verdict.
There have numerous other such cases that have settled. They are not all detransition cases either: several are suicides.
Those receiving settlements are constrained from characterizing the outcomes (beyond being "resolved") which presents a further obstacle to informing the public on the routine abuses within the medical industry.
Detransitioned young person Joni Skinner describes the evidence of malicious intent he found in his medical records — fabricated claims that he had identified as a girl since the age of two and tried to castrate himself.
Skinner’s doctors assured his parents that the late onset of testosterone in utero had left him with a female brain while his body had been masculinized and that 60 percent of trans kids killed themselves if not medically transitioned. (Two utterly false claims.)
At Genspect’s Detrans Awareness Day in Washington DC
I do know what it is and it’s not being used as a bludgeon in that reply. Dysphoria and “transgender” were both terms that sought to widen the scope of who was a part of a category that would have been too small to gain any political salience
Actually several of the most prominent boys who were celebrated as pioneering trans woman athletes have already stopped pretending to be girls a few years later. Your pseudo-religion is false and has been proven to be false.
Quotes a post by T02555; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Everyone knows that trans girls are boys, including those who are risking billions in federal educational funding in order to violate Title IX to allow them to dominate girls sports.
They take actions that are premised on that understanding, and they tell people that this implied understanding is correct because everyone knows this understanding is correct and they have a human instinct not to lie to people (even though they are implementing a vast institutional lie that imperils billions in federal funding.)
This is what people mean when they say "it is complicated": when they feel torn between the impulse to treat a false claim as if it was true and recognizing that treating a false claim as it was true leads to all kinds of absurdities and cruelties that cannot be stopped and indeed must be mandated so long as we are committed to treating a false claim as if it was true.
Once you give up on treating a false claims as if it were true, the issue resolves itself entirely and reveals itself to be the simplest of all issues.
The school violated a beloved teacher's constitutional rights because that is what transgender inclusion requires. Transgender inclusion is not a project that can succeed in any world where people retain their right to say what is true and not be coerced into saying what they know to be false. Transgender inclusion can only succeed in a world where those rights have been eradicated.
The trans rights question boils down to whether a group can successfully manufacture a "right" to violate the rights of everyone else. Can I make it compulsory for you to regard and treat a false claim I make about myself as the only truth? Can I punish you if you refuse to participate in the falsehood? Those are the powers that the transgender movement seeks -- not powers that any state that purports to be liberal, democratic, pluralistic, and free can ever grant.
Quoting @ADFLegal: BREAKING: An Indiana school district has settled with former music teacher John Kluge, to the tune of $650K, after it wrongfully revoked his religious accommodation and forced him to resign for declining to refer to students using transgender terms.
Good summary of the underlying issues that seek and find an outlet in trans ideation that is sold to confused, vulnerable children as a panacea that will give them a new self. The most cursory viewing of the people sucked into the contagion confirms; only willful blindness can hold this knowledge at bay.
Quotes a post by A0447; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is no principled rejoinder to this within the tradition of Anglo-American rights and liberties. No society where those rights and liberties obtain can complete the project of trans rights. Only a social justice theocracy in which those rights have been extinguished can fulfill that project.
Moderation on "trans rights" means giving up the claim that a man claiming to be a woman confers the right to force other people to pretend he is what he is not and to give him access to spaces where he doesn't belong.
Moderation on trans rights means giving up on trans rights because the core proposition of trans rights is false and forcing people to accept a falsehood as true destroys their most fundamental right, which is a form of extremism with no place in a democracy that honors people's rights to not be coerced into pretending fake shit is real.
Forbidding any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman in any and all sex-segregated settings, whether it be the athletic field, the changing room, the domestic violence shelter, the prison, the lactation group, or the lesbian dating app, is, according to US Democrats and center-Left parties across the entire globe, “the civil rights movement of the 21st century,” (as Joe Biden declared it in 2019), and any woman or girl who resists is the new Bull Connor who must be silenced, with lawful force if necessary, and consigned to the dustbin of history.
This is table stakes for the trans rights movement and the political parties that represent them. This is the minimum viable demand that all trans movements came into existence to secure and that Democrats at every level of government are working in lockstep unison to secure and will fight to the last breath to impose on the whole country. To do anything less would be to “throw trans people under the bus.”
As Talarico put it, to allow a girl’s insistence on fair competition on the sporting field for herself poses an imminent danger that a boy will become so sad that he hasn’t been affirmed as a girl that he will kill himself, and that suicide will be on the head of the girls who sought fair competition and on the legislature that responded to their demand for fair competition. Of course the demand for fair competition counts for nothing when placed on balance with the life or death of the boy who needs to be affirmed as a girl or else die by his own hand.
This is table stakes for Democrats, elected and unelected, at every level of government. Any deviation from this position is violence.
Quoting @jbarro: I'm sorry, who decided that males have a right to play in girls' sports leagues? Some people just made this shit up and decided it was a civil right.
Ben Appel, who authored a piece in the Atlantic urging transgender ideologues to stop brainwashing effeminate boys to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered in the vain hope that inflicting the ultimate sexual violence on themselves will turn them into women, describes a conversation disclosing a predictable and familiar situation: many within the LGBT Borg share his views but have been silenced by radical colleagues
He calls it "mutilation surgery" but still says it's fine with "express written approval" from parents.
All transgender mutilation of children has been done with parental consent, usually after emotionally blackmailing parents with threats of suicide.
The point is that it's not evidence-based, it's not medicine, no child is capable of understanding the risks and harms associated with it such that none can offer informed consent and no parent can offer that consent on their behalf just as no parent can consent to have their child have sex with an adult on their behalf. Trump had better walk this one back.
Quoting @conservmillen: Sorry, but I really don’t care if parents consent to abusing their kids. It should still be illegal
There will be a transgender Manson Family, Weather Underground, and Jonestown. No prediction could be easier to make given what they continuously broadcast about themselves and what is inherent in the violent and delusional belief system that frames any and all denial of its imperious demands for special privileges as genocide.
A network of trans-identified murderers is already on trial for multiple murders.
Quoting @KatieDaviscourt: NEW: Seattle Antifa extremist Alex Randall has shared videos and images of firearms training being conducted for transgender members of his new leftist group, "Moto Hooligans."
Randall, also known as "Squid Tips," says his training team is comprised of "entirely trans people" who believe that "armed minorities are harder to oppress."
The group has been conducting their firearms trainings in wooden areas of Washington state.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialmental illnesspolitical enemyviolence terror
Gay rights are like the integrationist civil rights movement — the cause generated a durable consensus
Trans rights are like bussing — an invasive overreach that stirred up intense and enduring political resistance and had to be scrapped
Quotes a post by A1780; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The folx celebrating pioneering trans woman Stacey Laughton’s election to the New Hampshire state house didn’t think it would end up this way. Perhaps some people had some private reservations but knew that to air them publicly would have been to court social death.
Quotes a post by A2075; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Rogan has done his homework. Most of the kids receiving gender dysphoria diagnoses have multiple mental health comorbidities. We are inviting screwed up kids to identify into a class that has no diagnostic criteria other than "claims to be the opposite sex," pumping many of them full of hormones, subordinating all their other problems to their transgender identity as if their only problem is "minority stress" associated with being transgender, therefore leaving their comorbidities unaddressed while vesting faith in a falsehood that can never be true as their promise of salvation, and introducing the difficulties and stresses of trying to be something you are not as a complicating factor. We are then putting them in proximity to a class of pseudo-political fanatics who interpret any and all resistance to their imperious demands for special privileges as a genocidal assault on their rights, a framing that the entire trans industrial complex, which encompasses every Democratic leader at every level of government, ramps up by telling them that their rights are under attack if gender clinicians are no longer free to inflict irreversible lifelong harms on the bodies of confused children. This class of fanatics is saturated in suicide and murder imagery and messaging, relying on threats of suicide to extract recognition, and using threats of violence to intimidate those who resist their imperious demands for special privileges. Of course these explicit appeals to the most mentally unbalanced in our midst will culminate in acting out, in mass murder and in an audience of other trans activists and the politicians who champion their cause to respond to those acts of violence by framing the transgender category as victims of the very violence they inflict.
Quoting @joeroganhq: Joe Rogan: "Do you know who’s killed more people than ICE this year? Trans shooters."
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcontagioninstitutional capturemedical harmmental illnessviolence terror
This is true but it’s also true that 1.) many more women than men support trans inclusive policies and 2.) women police each other’s opinions on this with great zeal
Quotes a post by A2782; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Two things on display here: the susceptibility of good hearted ignomaruses to being snowed by maudlin trans propaganda — and the ease with which they can be brought back to reality by a dose of reality.
This is why punishing all reminders of reality was so crucial to the movement.
Quoting @overton_news: Joe Rogan dragged Steve-O out of his bubble and forced him to confront the truth about transgenderism.
Steve-O told a story of meeting a transgender person and said it broke his heart at the level of “oppression” they were experiencing.
But Rogan hit him with a cold, hard dose of reality.
STEVE-O: “But in this situation, talking to this transgender person, I’m like, hey can I run something by you.”
“And I spoke with them…they described to me a level of oppression that genuinely f*cking broke my heart.”
“They said, hey, let me tell you, like I am not allowed to use the bathroom at my own place of work.”
ROGAN: “That’s not true.”
“They’re just not allowed to use the bathroom that doesn’t align with their biological sex.”
STEVE-O: “Okay…”
ROGAN: “I genuinely think there’s people that feel like they are in the wrong biological sex. But there’s also people that are f*cking perverts.”
“And they have a thing called autogynephilia and what that is, is they get a turn on by pretending to be a woman, and they get excited by it.”
“And they want to be around women, and they’re creeps. So you give them a f*cking Willy Wonka golden ticket to go into the women’s locker room and the women’s bathroom to stare at women and pretend you’re a woman, when you’re just a crazy man.”
STEVE-O: “I don’t doubt that that’s real, and I know that it’s a super complex, nuanced thing and I don’t—”
ROGAN: “Yeah, but here’s what’s not complex. What is your chromosomes?”
“Okay, this is the same thing for competing…all these f*cking mental gymnastics that seemingly intelligent people do to justify biological males competing with females.”
LGBTQ+ lobbies declared that there was a state of emergency for LGBTQ+ people in 2024. A year later, the murders of trans-identified people fell by 40 percent in 2025.
All claims of anti-LGBTQ+ violence crises are fake, the organizations that claim them are liars, the lies are deployed to prevent any scrutiny of the movements false dogmas and to destroy the rights of free speech and free speech that they know cannot coexist with the dogmatic falsehoods they seek to immunize against any scrutiny, the organizations have done nothing but harm their own causes while continuing to grow cancerously at the behest of mindless rich people who don't do any due diligence; it's a matter of urgency that all of them be dismantled
Quotes a post by A0718; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Wiener is directly responsible for an increase in open child prostitution on the streets of Los Angeles, but it wasn't actually the worst thing that he did.
The worst thing that he did was to mandate that no school district could have a policy requiring teachers to fulfill their constitutional duty to keep parents informed about the health and well-being of their children -- and engaged in actively harmful messaging about it such as the odious messaging you see here, which repeats false and propagandistic claims that isolating a child from his parents could ever help rather than harm that child's mental health, and implies that parental knowledge about the actual state of their children's mental health will result in dead children. In fact, parents have discovered that schools were actively deceiving them about name and pronoun changes made by the school without their knowledge or consent when the child attempted suicide. This is an absolutely indefensible claim both empirically and morally; it is a monstrous lie and should be disqualifying for any holder of public office.
Wiener stands poised to replace Nancy Pelosi in Congress, where he will be a voice pushing propagandistic misinformation of this sort onto the national stage and be yet another bulwark against any moderation within the party on trans issues.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Transgender Inquisition is global and unitary and seeks to destroy the right of people to think freely and speak freely wherever it obtains the power to do so because the dogmas it seeks to impose onto language and law are self-evident falsehoods that cannot withstand people able to think freely and speak freely
Quotes a post by T03120; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Alberta judge is proud of his severity in sentencing a trans-identified male who stabbed his eight year old daughter in the neck, severing 75 percent of her upper esophagus, calling the...5 year sentence... he imposed "A clarion call of deterrence and denunciation."
Quotes a post by T08948; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Do you think it’s hatred to tell girls they can be healthy and whole?”
The response to this and other questions was a promise to hunt down and murder the woman posing them because the transgender cult is a dogmatic faith that cannot defend itself using reason and spreads by propagating the virulent lie that failure to accept its false dogmas results in the death of children.
The movement believes its own manipulative falsehoods and uses them as a warrant to threaten murder and commit it.
Quoting @bourne_beth2345: Here’s the entire interaction in one clip.
Before she threatens to k*ll me, I asked her a series of questions:
1. At what age is a girl mature enough to have top surgery?
2. How did you feel about your body changing as you were going through puberty?
3. Do you think it’s hatred to tell girls they can be healthy and whole?
4. Do you know any transgender children?
5. Do you have a transgender child?
6. And how did they know they were transgender?
7. At what age did you know you were a c-i-s woman?
8. And why did your child think they were transgender?
9. Does your child go to a public school in California?
10. Did they learn there could be 13 gender identities?
11. How much money does a surgeon make off of giving a girl top surgery?
12. Do you think your transgender child might one day have top surgery and a phalloplasty?
13. Is that something you would allow them to have?
This was last Saturday at the @[private account] Democratic Party convention in San Francisco.
C2 false claimshand-codedideology cultmedical harmviolence terror
You have some basic libertarian impulses that you are applying without regard for any other utilitarian or ethical calculus. This is what happens when “because I want it” is the only measure of value.
It’s behind MAID (recently given to a physically healthy 26 year old in Canada, recently given at same day appointments) and harm reduction in drug policy, and in both cases a few years of implementing it has already shown that you can’t make “because I want it” the only measure of the good. Vancouver went furthest with harm reduction and has stopped. The Zombie Apocalypse scenes in SF, Portland, and Seattle are the direct manifestation of this approach.
To render someone paraplegic is to harm them grievously — it’s also to impose a lasting cost on society. Should doctors be fulfilling the mad compulsions of someone mentally ill enough to seek to be made paraplegic? I say no.
Should this be different if the person wants to cut off their breasts and genitals? The important thing for me is not that we create a police force that hunts down surgeons willing to cut off healthy breasts and genitals but that we allow no one to commit medical fraud by claiming this will change anyone’s sex and that we don’t have the state acting as an enabler of these compulsions by promising that undergoing these procedures (or not undergoing them and simply claiming to have a cross gendered soul) confers any right of recognition or legal entitlement to enter sex segregated spaces. (“Stop treating fake shit as if it was real.”)
Transgenderism must remain a private eccentricity that some people are free to choose to indulge for themselves and on behalf of others and that others are free to not indulge on behalf of others. (“Stop forcing people to treat fake shit as if it was real.”) Libertarians (and not just libertarians) should recognize that compelled obeisance to quasi-mystical beliefs violates people most basic rights — and the more you know about what the transgender movement seeks and has obtained around the world, the better you understand that the movement is a movement to compel speech and punish dissent.
The reason you think there is a moderate position on transgenderism is because: 1.) You know nothing about it, 2.) You've had not thoughts about it beyond what occur to a total ignoramus who knows nothing about it.
Whereas, I know that there is only one possible resolution to the transgender issue (all public and private institutions must stop treating fake shit like it is real and stop forcing others to treat fake shit like it is real) because 1.) I know a lot about it and 2.) I've thought a lot about it based on what I know about it.
“She frequently promoted the idea that trans kids are actually a vulnerable population of mentally ill children being preyed upon by a sinister medical establishment eager to castrate them.” 👀
Quoting @HadleyFreeman: This is abject misogyny and the National Magazine Award has totally discredited itself. No serious journalism award would celebrate a journalist attacking another journalist, and especially not for *telling the truth*
That UK state institutions refused to provide this data in the first place is in itself a gigantic scandal. What possible justification can there be for withholding it? What possible justification can there be for allowing those wholly taxpayer-funded institutions to withhold?
Of course there is and can be none. Just one of the many dimensions along which trans medicalization exists in a zone of exception to every standard practice and norm.
We know of course the only motive that there could possibly be for hiding the data. If the data contained proof that chemically castrating and dismembering confused was good for their mental health, the institutions would have been full of zeal to present it.
Open AI should have to release the full transcripts of the trans-identified mass murderer's murderous ideation with Open AI that led a dozen employees to convene and consider whether to report him to authorities before choosing to do nothing. It should have to release all internal deliberations leading up to these decisions.
But so then should the BC police be held accountable for returning the guns they had seized that the trans-identified mass murderer used to kill children in a school, so should the justice system be held accountable for allowing a man who had tried to burn down his own house to be free to kill eight, including his mother and brother.
So should the inquiry consider without fear of favor how the trans-identification of a boy who had been affirmed as a girl since the age of 12 did or did not play into the chain of wrong decisions made on the path to his murder of eight.
Quotes a post by T08129; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codeddenialmotive displacementshooter attributionviolence terror
The Human Rights Tribunal has ruled that "woman" is a class inclusive of "men who say they are women" and has acted to demonstrate that any and all who dispute this dogmatic falsehood are subject to having their livelihoods destroyed.
This was always the telos of trans activism -- the end to which the entire apparatus was built, the use of state power to compel acquiescence and punish refusal of the movement's dogmas. A social justice theocracy was always the goal. And we have already arrived.
Quotes a post by T01456; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It is only a coincidence that the eight year legal inquisition to which a former school trustee was subjected by the BC Human Rights Tribunal happened to conclude (with a $750,000 judgment for disputing transgender dogmas) less than two weeks after an 18 year old trans-identified male who had been affirmed as a girl since the age of 12 went on a murderous rampage in a small town in British Columbia.
But it is a telling coincidence nonetheless, because the small town police officer who told his story took pains to refer to the male murderer as "female" and the local press all acted in lockstep to suppress the fact that the murderer was a trans-identified male: in all cases all the various parties were acting in accordance with that which the Human Rights Commission has just announced it will destroy the livelihood of any who decline to do.
Quotes a post by T05097; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
After a trans-identified female in Nashville killed six people in a Christian school, trans activists protesting Tennessee's ban on puberty blockers at the statehouse held up seven fingers, thus including the trans-identified mass murderer as one of the victims of her own shooting rampage. (Police shot her dead amidst the rampage.)
A small trans activist organization justified the murder and portrayed it as the one of the consequences of the push to impose age limits on trans medicalization.
C2 false claimshand-codeddenialshooter attributionvictim dismissalviolence terror
The paradox of uber trans-affirming states like CA is that these have become the places where women most likely to encounter men beating off in their bathrooms and locker rooms -- they are therefore the sites of a silent preference cascade
https://x.com/WomenAreReals/status/2027056969933324352?s=20
Quotes a post by A3058; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hurabiell is a Democrat aligned with SF's Mayor Daniel Lurie, who has taken a moderate turn in running the city.
Her opponents have handed out fliers documenting her criticisms of Critical Race Theory and a statement that "Trans Women Are Not Women."
Let the oppo research serve as her most effective advertisement.
Quotes a post by T05873; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There may be other "pro-social integrationist minded" trans-identified people than yourself, but this is the dominant attitude of trans activists online and their allies in power: turning cases of trans violence into occasions for self-pity, blame, and justification of violence
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
The Boston Globe article on the trans-identified attempted murderer of a Border Patrol agent in New Hampshire refers to "an individual" and avoids all pronouns, following the lead of the US Attorney's office, whose press release also omits any reference to the perpetrator's sex.
https://archive.is/Mxo5Z
The transgender inquisition aims to use state power to silence anyone who disputes their false dogmas
Quoting @reduxx: A women's rights advocate in France is on trial for "violent" transphobia after stating that women needed to be wary of "people with penises" in female spaces.
The complaint against Dora Moutot was filed by a male politician who identifies as a woman.
https://reduxx.info/france-womens-rights-activist-on-trial-over-criminal-transphobia-after-stating-that-women-must-be-wary-of-people-with-penises/
Another casualty of transgender ideology which in order to succeed in its stated goal of forcing the world to pay obeisance to false dogmas must destroy free speech, subvert democracy, and undermine scientific rigor in the name of inclusion but in the service of a cult of child sterilization
Quoting @jonkay: A reminder that while numerous US & UK medical groups now (rightly) retreat from position statements defending “affirmation” of gender-distressed children, Canadian Paediatric Society still peddles debunked 2010s-era trans-activist misinfo on the subject
https://quillette.com/2026/02/06/the-canadian-paediatric-society-is-trapped-in-a-pre-cass-time-warp-gender-medicine/
The transgender movement showed you could shake an etch-a-sketch and rewrite the moral intuitions of the entire political class instantaneously and turn what everyone knew to be a horror from the childhood of humanity to something no one could oppose without risking their livelihoods
Quotes a post by T02955; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The gender inquisition deploys state and corporate power to force people to affirm its dogmas because in the absence of coercion, no one would believe or comply with them because they are untrue.
So long as the people are free to think and speak freely in accordance with what they know to be true, and so long as the political system is a mechanism for translating their preferences into policy, the movement cannot attain any of its goals. Victory for the transgender movement requires snuffing out those freedoms and annulling whatever remains of democracy's power to register the will of the people. And thus it works tirelessly to end free speech and supplant democracy with an authoritarian social justice regime.
Quoting @nationalpost: $750,000 fine for questioning gender ideology is extremely chilling, writes Michael Higgins
https://nationalpost.com/opinion/michael-higgins-human-rights-tribunal-seeks-to-bully-and-punish-trans-heretics
Wiener launched his Congressional campaign with a video retracting his prior resistance to referring to Israeli military action in Gaza as genocidal.
Put in brackets that contentious question for the moment: at minimum Israeli military action did in fact entail tens of thousands of civilian deaths.
Whereas, the "genocidal campaign" referenced here includes:
-- keeping male rapists and murderers who claim to be women out of federal women's prisons
-- restoring the ban on people claiming cross-sex identities that obtained throughout the first 7.5 years of Barack Obama's two presidential terms
-- listing everyone's sex on their passports with no exception for people subject to private reveries of being a member of the opposite sex or no sex
-- declining to use taxpayer funds to pay for bras, panties, estrogen, and sex reassignment surgeries for federal inmates
-- incentivizing hospitals that receive federal taxpayer funds to cease the chemical castration and dismemberment of minors
It is a strangely expansive definition of genocide that encompasses "refusing to spend public funds to castrate mentally ill men who've been brainwashed to believe that doing so will turn them into women" -- but this claim is at the very heart of the transgender movement, which relies on fraudulent science, emotional blackmail, and fake claims of violence to force the world to work its will.
https://x.com/i/status/2010467570986401792
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Wiener launched his Congressional campaign with a video retracting his prior resistance to referring to Israeli military action in Gaza as genocidal.
Put in brackets that contentious question for the moment: at minimum Israeli military action did in fact entail tens of thousands of civilian deaths.
Whereas, the "genocidal campaign referenced here includes:
-- keeping male rapists and murderers who claim to be women out of federal women's prisons
-- restoring the transgender ban that obtained throughout the first 7.5 years of Barack Obama's two presidential terms
-- listing everyone's sex on their passports with no exception for people subject to private reveries of being a member of the opposite sex or no sex
-- declining to use taxpayer funds to pay for bras, panties, estrogen, and sex reassignment surgeries for federal inmates
-- incentivizing hospitals that receive federal taxpayer funds to cease the chemical castration and dismemberment of minors
It is a strangely expansive definition of genocide that encompasses "refusing to spend public funds to castrate mentally ill men who've been brainwashed to believe that doing so will turn them into women" -- but this claim is at the very heart of the transgender movement.
Japan hasn't yet found a way to recast this bizarre male sex fetish as a form of identity politics such that any woman failing to provide the affirmation these male perverts seek would risk ostracization, the loss of her livelihood, or even civil or criminal charges.
But since the transgender inquisition is global and unitary, it too is making rapid inroads in Japan as it is in all the Western comprador states whose Westernized bourgeoisie compete with each other to do literal and (even more) cringe renditions of the ongoing imported mania.
Quotes a post by T08651; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Basically, Singal has to soft-pedal the mendacity of the trans medical complex in order to preserve credibility with an audience unprepared to accept how brazen of a con job the whole thing always was. You must collude in the lie in order to have the underlying truth accepted.
Quoting @wesyang: Singal is still constrained to persist in the conceit that there are good faith actors who might undertake good faith research into "trans youth." But he's doing so largely as a rhetorical concession to make his message palatable to good liberals still unable to grasp the enormity of the con to which they've been party.
No there aren't. There are people who profess in all sincerity to being happier while mimicking the other sex than before, but nothing about such claims, even if true, establishes, or ever could establish, that there are "real trans people."
Singal is still constrained to persist in the conceit that there are good faith actors who might undertake good faith research into "trans youth." But he's doing so largely as a rhetorical concession to make his message palatable to good liberals still unable to grasp the enormity of the con to which they've been party.
However, his ultimate goal is to lie (come across as more normal) in order to placate the public just enough to neutralize the issue, regain power, and hand over the White House and the whole of government to the most extreme trans activists. This is a given for any Democrat who doesn't explicitly co-opt the reasonable, moderate, evidence-based, and correct Republican approach to trans issues.
He understands that "trans rights" are zero sum, not just with women's rights to their own sports and private spaces but also to the right of every person not to be coerced into affirming falsehoods. He understands the public opposes the trans agenda.
https://x.com/Moonust_Aeon/status/2026273610004844932?s=20
Quotes a post by T30390; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Very minimal. Some free speech protections, and non-interference in allowing states that want to regulate child transition. Otherwise, the more populous half of the states are not at the moment constrained in any way from pursuing that maximal trans activist agenda by any court.
Newsom made doing the will of the most extreme trans activists in the world a priority from which he never wavered during a decade as governor of California. He will say whatever is necessary to recapture the White House and then, like Biden, he will work tirelessly to permit zero daylight to come between himself and the most extreme trans activists. He will spare nothing in imposing a whole of government effort to coerce every American into advancing the transgender agenda at any cost.
Quoting @LeadingReport: BREAKING: Gov. Gavin Newsom says the Democratic Party needs to be more “culturally normal” and focus less on things like pronouns.
If these ballot measures pass, they will be bar none the most effective of all possible measures toward ending the transgender inquisition in Blue States
Quoting @Erin4Parents: 🚨 HISTORIC BREAKING NEWS 🚨
Today @ProtectKidsCO delivered **170,000+** signatures for Ballot Measure # 109 — Protect Women and Girls Act — AND **164,000+** for # 110: Protect Children from Irreversible Sex Change Surgery Act!
This follows **170,000+** signatures turned in Tuesday for # 108: The Children Are Not for Sale Act! 🔥
💪🏼 More than 3,300 volunteers collected over **HALF A MILLION** signatures across all three measures.
UNPRECEDENTED❗️in Colorado history. Against all odds. This movement is UNSTOPPABLE.
Coloradans are rising to PROTECT OUR KIDS. 🛡️💪🏼
📢RT & SHARE!!! #ProtectKidsColorado #ProtectOurKids #SaveGirlsSports
The transgender inquisition will destroy livelihoods of countless individuals and core freedoms of the entire population across the Western world to placate the demands of a disordered movement of reality denial in the service of child sterilization, in the process destroying the moral and epistemic integrity of its governing class — all in pursuit of a mad delusion that will remain untrue no matter how much harm they inflict in trying to enshrine it as the only truth
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: Threaten me all you like. I still won’t pretend to believe in gender identities.
Transgender totalitarianism is up for a vote in Minnesota, placed on the docket by an erstwhile married father who now claims to be a woman and recently made a speech passionately advocating for the rights of “Queer Kids” to access pornography
Quotes a post by T03242; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A lot of weird lacunae in the story, including any exploration of whether the dozen people who wished to inform authorities about the murderous ideation that the person who would go in to murder 8 people had typed into ChatGPT knew the killer was a trans-identified male and whether this knowledge had any influence on the decision not to inform the authorities, thereby allowing the mass murder to go on. The fact that the story makes no mention of this fact and instead honors the gender identity of a male mass murderer raises questions about why these questions weren’t raised.
The Wall Street Journal reports that a dozen OpenAI employees considered alerting law enforcement about a user who had entered various scenarios involving gun violence into ChatGPT in June. The company decided against alerting authorities. The user went on to murder eight people in British Columbia.
The Journal's report refers to the trans-identified male mass murderer solely by "she/her" pronouns through the report and makes no reference to the fact that the murderer was male.
The trans-identified male Minnesota state legislator arguing for allowing Queer Kids access to porn understands the inextricable link between gender ideological indoctrination and porn. He knows it is an, if not the, essential recruitment tool and he is therefore going to fight like hell to ensure kids can access it.
Quotes a post by A0489; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Just one gender doctor has been paid $4.3 million in taxpayer funds for doing transgender surgeries on prisoners in Washington State since 2019.
Quoting @thehoffather: 🧵NEW: Dr. Geoffrey Stiller has received over $4.3 million from the WA State Health Care Authority since July 2019 to perform trans surgeries on Dept of Corrections inmates. Surgeries are covered through the state’s Medicaid program, Apple Health.
The most damning things ever said about transgender medicalization have all come out of the mouths of the gender clinicians themselves. All you have to do is listen to them for a half hour to know for sure that they are utterly depraved maniacs who are knowingly inflicting harm.
Quotes a post by A0306; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is not an accidental part of the transgender agenda. This is the beating heart of the transgender agenda. All those who give advice to the movement to seek better optics -- "please stop excusing the violent extremists in your midst who threaten women that oppose them with rape and violence, please adopt an appealing new strategy of persuasion, etc." -- are angling to help the movement proceed patiently to acquire the power to destroy all freedom of speech and conscience once power is in their hands to execute it.
C2 false claimshand-codedideology cultpolitical enemyviolence terror
Using state power to compel belief was always the endgame for the transgender movement from day one. It is the foundational goal of the movement that it will impose wherever it has the means to do so. It would do so to JK Rowling today for calling a male murderer a man if it felt that it could do so without undermining its own power to be able to do so in the long run. If it ever succeeds in brainwashing enough children to tilt public opinion in its own direction, it will as a matter of certainty do it to her, thereby giving notice to the whole world that no one may dispute the movement's dogmas and expect to remain solvent or free.
Quotes a post by A0334; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Centrists would say "using state power to compel people to parrot transgender dogmas was a tactical mistake" by the otherwise righteous and just transgender movement, which is why there has been a backlash and the popularity of the movement has declined by 8 points in three years, which threatens the ability of the Democratic party to win elections.
But because the movement's dogmas are false, the use of repressive power to enforce them is necessary, which is why the movement makes recourse to repressive power.
Any world where people are free to believe and say aloud what they know to be true will reject transgender dogmas and the movement will fail. The movement understands this and that is why it seeks to extinguish the right of people to think freely and speak freely.
There is no way to support transgenderism without supporting the destruction of free speech. If you want to allow people the freedom to disagree with what they regard as false dogmas, you must reject transgenderism entirely.
Quoting @salltweets: Fining people for not believing that men can be women won’t make people believe that men can be women, nor will it turn men into women. This is all a very futile war against reality & reality will definitely win.
It is what the transgender movement has always sought and will seek to impose everywhere it is not stopped. The movement cannot succeed in any world where people are free to disagree with its dogmas. It can only succeed by extinguishing all freedom of conscience and speech.
Quoting @HJoyceGender: I have donated to help Barry with his legal costs. I find this ruling genuinely terrifying - a COURT seriously saying that unless you profess to believe someone else's bonkers theory about humanity and themselves, you are committing a hate crime against them. This cannot stand
So yeah, Finke is a man who says he is a woman, and he is arguing in the Minnesota state legislature that "Queer kids" need access to pornographic websites.
You could posit the existence of a trans-identified male state legislator who isn't deeply concerned to ensure that "Queer kids" have access to pornographic websites because you wouldn't want to jump to conclusions about what a trans-identified male legislator's concerns would be.
But your scrupulosity and your hesitation to assume that the worst stereotypes applied on this front would be absolutely misplaced.
Quoting @GrageDustin: 🚨 WATCH: Minnesota Republicans proposed age verification for websites that host adult content.
Rep. Leigh Finke (D) argues that queer kids should have access to it for educational purposes.
WTF?
The Transgender Inquisition is global and unitary. It seeks the same things everywhere and will impose the same measures wherever it acquires the power to to do so.
In Canada, it has destroyed the livelihood of a man who tired to resist the imposition of one of the inquisition's dogmas. It will do the same thing everywhere.
It does this because this is what recognition of gender identity requires, nothing less.
When people say "we can't throw trans people under the bus," what they mean is: we must imprison or destroy the livelihoods of anyone who doesn't believe that any man who says he is a woman is a woman by virtue of his saying so..
They will do it. They are doing it already in multiple places. They will do it in the United States if they can. They will do it everywhere they are not stopped.
Quoting @BillboardChris: 🚨 BREAKING: Barry Neufeld, a former school trustee who opposed gender ideology in schools, has been ordered to pay $750,000 to the Chilliwack Teacher’s Assocation.
The BC Human Rights Tribunal literally stated the following:
“If a person elects not to ‘believe’ that gender identity is separate from sex assigned at birth, then they do not ‘believe’ in transpeople. This is a form of existential denial.
“A person does not need to believe in Christianity to accept that another person is Christian. However, to accept that a person is transgender, one must accept that their gender identity is different than their sex assigned at birth.”
The Tribunal has declared that all British Columbians must believe in gender identities.
"Restores a uniform, biologically grounded definition of sex, protects privacy and safety in public facilities, and ensures state records like birth certificates and driver’s licenses reflect that definition consistently" -- this is the only tenable resolution of the transgender issue.
It is the only resolution that can possibly work because it is the only resolution grounded in truth and reality.
All the mental contortions presently being indulged by centrist Democrats to try to keep alive the notion of anything short of this are mere wind.
Quotes a post by T01207; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's great that the hospitals are stopping this, but it will not in itself reduce the number of children receiving transgender surgeries. The hospitals are simply referring out patients to private practitioners.
Quoting @EricLDaugh: 🚨 BREAKING: Democrats are furious after a MASSIVE LIST of hospitals has been released that ENDED transgender operations on children
President Trump threatened to withhold federal funding, so they CAVED.
Massive victory for the children. I VOTED FOR THIS. 🇺🇸
Obama used a stealth policy to impose transgender inclusion on an unwitting public through judicial and executive agency fiat because the trans activist agenda of destroying the rights of women to private spaces, propagandizing children from the earliest age that any of them can change sex, chemically castrating and dismembering confused children caught up in a social contagion, incarcerating male rapists and murders in women's prisons in order to honor their gender identities, and destroying the rights of free speech and free conscience of every citizen to describes reality as it is would never have been implemented by any society that respected the will of the people.
Once these policies were in place and immediately began inflicting absurdities and cruelties on an unwitting public, the backlash set in. All attempts to gaslight the public into ignoring the absurdities and cruelties that attend attempts to give legal status to people making a false claim about their sex will fail. Imposing the trans activist agenda by stealth was the best chance the movement had at success but the reality was that the absurdities and cruelties that necessarily flow from that agenda were always going to reach the public and generate widespread refusal. So long as the public has a say in how it is governed, the answer will always be no.
The trans activist can succeed long term solely by destroying the ability of the public to register its will, which of course the movement is moving to do wherever it has the means to do so.
Quotes a post by A1184; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The transgender movement is a travesty of a civil rights movement — all trans rights are imperious demands to destroy the rights of women to private spaces, and of every citizen to say what they know to be true and not to be compelled into saying what they know to be false
Quoting @salltweets: This is just mind numbingly stupid and frankly insulting at this stage of the issue in 2026.
First of all, if housing, employment & basic healthcare was the center of the fight for “trans rights”, they’d have it. They do have it. But that has never been the fight.
The fight has always been getting males access to female spaces. It has not just been the number one goal, it’s the only goal, & everything else is in service to that one goal (including “gender affirming care” for minors). I am happy to elaborate on this.
One thing to remember about human/civil rights is they aren’t human/civil rights if they’re taking away actual human rights from other people, and this has always been the problem “trans rights” has.
It could be possible to create a new legal demographic of people (trans) and give that group legal protections specific to their needs and there would be no pushback *so long as no one else’s rights were impacted*. The fact that this has never even been tried is very telling.
Currently, the demands that make up “trans rights”, infringe directly on women’s rights, gay & lesbian rights, parental rights, freedom of speech, freedom of belief & freedom of association. It was always a fools errand to think the large percentage of the population was going to sit back & give up these hard won rights that are still necessary.
You are simply wrong that trans rights is a civil rights movement. It doesn’t meet even the most basic threshold.
Until a Democrat is willing to say "transgender inclusion policies are unpopular because they are wrong," rather than "we have to find a strategy to trick people into thinking we have moderated so that we can regain power and impose transgender inclusion," none of this posturing means anything at all.
Newsom has come closest among Democrats to making a statement recognizing that "trans rights" and women's rights are zero sum in a way that can't be triangulated or finessed out of existence. (Newsom will not do anything to change policy, but he has gone furthest rhetorically to making the necessary acknowledgment of the decisive fact.) The one must simply give way to the other.
Quotes a post by T01350; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If your position remains the same, and you wish to placate the trans activist critics who drove you off of BlueSky, and prove to them that you are a true believer in trans activist dogmas, you could easily do so by QTing and affirming once again that "only weirdos" hesitate the "basic decency" of using the preferred pronouns of a male rapist accused of a multiple assaults on women in a British women's prison or a male mass murderer of children or a man with a neo-Nazi tattoo who removed his genitals to affirm his female gender identity who murdered his wife and children.
In reply to your trans activist critics, you assured them that you continued to be a supporter of "trans rights" and emphasized that documenting the unpopularity of trans rights was a descriptive not to be conflated with prescriptive act of questioning any trans activist dogma on the merits.
I think it does, however, bear asking whether and to what degree the recognition of the unpopularity of trans activist dogmas translates into any questioning on your part of any trans activist dogma. Is it possible that any of these dogmas are unpopular because they are wrong?
A few months ago, NPR scolded Amy Klobuchar for referring to a male mass murderer of children as "a man." The male mass murderer of children had changed his name at 17 to a female name in order to affirm his trans identity.
In your view, was NPR right to scold Klobuchar for failing to honor the gender identity of a male mass murderer of children? Was it important for NPR to scold Klobuchar for failing to honor his claim to be a woman?
Is the question of preferred pronouns, still, in your mind, resolved by the blanket injunction you articulated in 2023, that everyone must always use preferred pronouns, that it is a matter of basic decency, and that anyone who declines to do so is a weirdo? Has your position on this evolved in any way since? If so, why? If not, why not?
Actually, no. That hasn't been true until now. The ACLU has repeatedly litigated on behalf of male rapists and murderers who began claiming to be women in prison. NPR scolded Amy Klobuchar for calling a trans-identified mass murder of children a man.
https://x.com/jamiezerofour/status/2024098042064875865?s=20
Quotes a post by T09407; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Everyone claiming to "support transgender civil rights" and "anti-discrimination protections for trans folx" must clarify whether they consider it 1.) a civil right to be referred to by preferred pronouns and 2.) an act of discrimination to refer to the untruth of transgender dogmas
https://x.com/wesyang/status/2023928016162939123?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: The Transgender Inquisition is global and unitary. The movement seeks the same things everywhere it has the power to impose its will.
What is happening in Brazil -- the criminal prosecution and potential imprisonment of a young woman for stating that transgender women were born male -- is what will happen everywhere the movement obtains power.
This is after a solid decade of the media and educational system serving as overt propaganda outlets suppressing the reality of the absurdities and cruelties that transgender inclusion policies inflict on women and children and the giant medical fraud conducted by advocates of child transition that has only just begun to unravel with the American Society of Plastic Surgery's defection from the astroturfed pseudo-consensus on behalf of a practice that was never evidence based.
If the truth were more widely known, the figures would be far more lopsided and this ongoing mania would be over.
Quotes a post by T06907; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Transgender Inquisition is global and unitary. The movement seeks the same things everywhere it has the power to impose its will.
What is happening in Brazil -- the criminal prosecution and potential imprisonment of a young woman for stating that transgender women were born male -- is what will happen everywhere the movement obtains power.
Quoting @spikedonline: Brazil is in thrall to trans tyranny. A young woman could be jailed for social-media posts stating that transgender women were born men. She is being persecuted for stating a biological fact, says Raquel del Rosario Sánchez
https://buff.ly/27gTWqk
One of the first male prisoners moved into a women's penitentiary under trans-inclusive federal prison policy was a neo-Nazi.
A German male Neo-Nazi prisoner is suing several media outlets under the German gender recognition law for referring to him as a man.
Both of these men rely on the same legal basis for recognition as you do. They are just as much women as you are (not at all) for the same reason that you are recognized as one (they claimed to be women.)
Quoting @AriDrennen: The Pawtucket shooter praised Hitler, followed Nick Fuentes, and used white power shorthand. The right-wing accounts calling this “trans violence” are the same accounts the shooter followed. http://open.substack.com/pub/aridrennen/p/right-wing-media-is-using-two-shootings
We seem to be entering a phase shift where news outlets with a propagandistic interest in promoting trans activism have ceased insisting on using the preferred pronouns of trans identified murders to hiding the fact that the murderer was trans-identified. The Globe includes no photo, makes no mention of trans -- but still avoids using any pronouns for the killer lest they "misgender" him with accurate ones or lie about him being female.
As we enter a period where "strategic considerations" are coming into play, the ultimate goal of lying about criminals being female is temporarily on hold for lying by omission about them by avoiding all pronouns.
Quoting @GerryCallahan: Unreal. The Boston Globe has 24 paragraphs on the trans shooter but doesn't mention the word 'trans.' They're careful not to make any references to 'he' or 'him' and they don't include any photos of the trans freak.
It was just a "family dispute," according to the Globe.
Quality journalism here.
They are all such fucking liars.
https://www.boston.com/news/local-news/2026/02/16/3-dead-3-injured-after-shooting-at-r-i-high-school-hockey-game-mayor-calls-shooting-targeted-family-dispute/?p1=recirc_mostpopular
There is no coherent or consistent use of pronouns across media because there is no stable or coherent meaning of "being transgender" apart the expediency of the movement.
https://x.com/geraldposner/status/2023771995456835915?s=20
Quoting @geraldposner: I am not talking about “trans shooters.” I am again focused on mainstream media’s failure to report fully and consistently about a killing spree.
Last week, legacy outlets called a biological male killer in one of Canada’s worst mass murders “female.”
In yesterday's Rhode Island hockey shooting, USA Today, PBS, Reuters, and The New York Times — to name a few — all correctly report that police “identified the shooter as Robert Dorgan, 56, who also went by the name Roberta Esposito.”
Not one uses the word transgender.
Not one has published a single image from the suspect’s social media.
Either sex and "gender identity" are factual descriptors — or they aren’t.
Selective emphasis and selective omission aren’t journalism. They’re message management.
And readers notice.
It's of course not what the "anti-trans" movement did but what the trans movement itself chose to prioritize that determined these priorities.
The "anti-trans" movement was entirely a reactive movement: the Biden Administration's whole of government effort to brainwash every child to believe they could change sex at the earliest age, chemically castrate and dismember any person of any age who had submitted to this brainwashing, and forbid any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman in the changing room, domestic violence shelter, or sporting field, was not dictated by the administration's opponents but by the administration itself.
There are no "trans rights" that aren't imperious demands for special privileges and there are no protections against discrimination in housing and hiring that don't already exist. All other demands that call themselves "rights" entail compelled adherence to a belief system that cannot be imposed without destroying the rights to free speech and free conscience held by others.
The sole path forward is to shutter an untenable movement that will face ever metastasizing opposition from the public as the reality of its imperious demands are more widely understood. The Democratic party has instead chosen to continue the Biden Administration's crusade without constraint in Congress and at every level of state power where Democrats control power.
Quoting @JillFilipovic: The anti-trans movement did a great job at focusing the public's attention on women's sports and surgeries on adolescents. In reality, most people support the policies that will help many more trans people: Antidiscrimination laws in housing, hiring, etc. There is a path fwd
A supermajority of Americans subject to a virtual mainstream media blackout on the reality of what transgender clinicians actually believe, say, and do still reached the correct conclusion on their practices. If they knew the whole story, the figures would be far more lopsided.
Quoting @LeorSapir: This is actually quite remarkable. The question on surgeries contained the unusual caveat "when deemed medically necessary by doctors, with parental consent."
And still, 62% opposed and only 27% were in favor.
Americans, on average, seem to distrust doctors on this issue.
As people have learned what "transgender inclusion" actually means in practice (forbidding women from drawing a boundary between themselves and any man who claims to be a woman,) support for transgender inclusion has nosedived
Quotes a post by A1780; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You have a few choices when dealing with transgender mass murderers if you are not functioning as an actual news outlet but instead as the propaganda arm of a deranged social movement:
-- You can insist on using the preferred pronouns of a male mass murderer because adherence to preferred pronouns in any and all case is the rule upon which all other recognition of transgender people depends while withholding any mention of the actual sex of the male mass murder
-- You can downplay the transgender identification of the male mass murderer by stripping the article of any reference to sex or gender by stripping out all pronouns, therefore not alerting people to yet another male mass murderer who claims to be a woman
-- You can freeze up and avoid covering it at all
BBC is going with the third option.
Quotes a post by A2437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
All good liberals blithely assume that there is a way to fix this quirk of transgender self-ID by restricting recognition of trans people to those who are "really trans." But as soon as they try to establish criteria for who is "really trans" they quickly discover that the transgender movement defined a "trans person" as "anyone who says they are trans" because there is no actual way to identify who is "really trans" because transness is solely a matter of internal conviction with no reference to any morphological or psychological fact knowable by any means other than self-report.
The German neo-Nazi who began claiming to be female in prison is no more or less a woman than Admiral Rachel Levine or Rep. Sarah McBride or Brianna Wu or Dylan Mulvaney or Ari Drennan or Alejandro Caraballo. They are all women to the exact same degree as the German neo-Nazi (not at all) and for the same reason (because he claims to be one.)
Quoting @wesyang: A German neo-Nazi who began claiming to be female in prison is suing the German media for referring to him as a man, in accordance with Germany's gender recognition which allows anyone to change their legal gender once a year based solely on self ID
https://www.dw.com/en/germany-extremist-trans-neo-nazi-gender-law-v2/a-73779265
A German neo-Nazi who began claiming to be female in prison is suing the German media for referring to him as a man, in accordance with Germany's gender recognition which allows anyone to change their legal gender once a year based solely on self ID
https://www.dw.com/en/germany-extremist-trans-neo-nazi-gender-law-v2/a-73779265
A German neo-Nazi who began claiming to be female in prison is suing the German media for referring to him as a man, in accordance with Germany's gender recognition which allows anyone to change their legal gender once a year based solely on self ID
https://www.dw.com/en/germany-extremist-trans-neo-nazi-gender-law-v2/a-73779265
The victim narrative is right there in court documents. His father-in-law threatened to "have him murdered by an Asian street gang" if he didn't move out after his gender reassignment surgery. His wife then filed for divorce.
Perhaps if she had accepted him as a stunning and brave trans woman and herself as a lesbian married to another woman, she and her children would be alive today.
Oh yes, trans activists will themselves be the first portray him as a victim of his wife's disbelief that he is a woman.
https://x.com/Tachardiella/status/2023744878987903301?s=20
Quotes a post by T00485; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
At some point, the national press will pivot away from honoring the pronouns of trans-identified mass murderers (who will continue to emerge with metronomic regularity, since we've convinced an army of confused children that failing to grant them special privileges or inflict the ultimate sexual violence on them is genocide) to trying to hide their trans-identification. But it won't work, the knowledge will be too easily disseminated on social media and it will merely cause further erosion of the credibility of the media.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcontagioncoverupmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
The association between trans identification, murder, and sex crime is only going to grow stronger over time as a direct result of trans activist success in changing gender medicine and in turning transgender identity into a matter of self-ID: https://x.com/wesyang/status/1970828584584397083?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: Gatekeeping of cross-sex medicalization was never very rigorous but there were attempts by pioneering gender clinicians to keep gender medicalization away from people who wouldn't pass, from sexual fetishists, and from the mentally ill. Though there was never any real science to it, there was at least a functional notion that a distinction could and should be made between an "actual transsexual" and a psychotic person whose delusions included cross-sex ideation.
Now there is no such distinction, and misfit children are all being incentivized to identify into transgenderism, an identity that anyone can claim and that everyone around them is required to affirm.
Since there is no psychological assessment and thus no attempt to distinguish between perverts, psychos, and those who would be able to remain functional while investing all their energies in trying to be something they are not, the nexus between perverts, psychos, and the trans-identified will become ever more pronounced over time.
It's why whenever there is a berzerk shooting involving an ordinary middle class suburban kid, it's reasonable to ask about the pronouns of the shooter and whether they match their sex.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedfetish fraudmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
Actually, this is a departure for the NYT and the national press, which usually takes pains to honor the gender identity of a trans-identified murderer. (NPR, for instance, scolded Amy Klobuchsr for calling a man who shot multiple children at a school “a man.”)
Quotes a post by T02767; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedcoverupmedia pronoun complaintshooter attributionviolence terror
Yes, male pedophiles who hoard 125,000 child sexual abuse images become vulnerable victims too fragile to be jailed if they claim to be women and must be allowed to live freely near primary schools. Didn't you know that this is what trans inclusion requires?
Quoting @reduxx: UK: A transgender pedophile who was spared jail despite hoarding 125,000 child sexual abuse images is reportedly now living near multiple primary schools.
Peter Selby was allowed to walk free because the judge was concerned about his safety in prison.
https://reduxx.info/uk-pedophile-avoided-jail-due-to-transgender-status-now-living-near-multiple-primary-schools/
The reason trans women are men is that they are all adult human males. The reason trans women aren't women is that women are adult human females. You will not be able to provide a non-circular definition of "woman."
https://x.com/atalanta44/status/2023182947407552772?s=20
"Trans-identified male," "man who says he is a woman, "man pretending to be a woman," "male sex mimic," "men with a compulsive urge to falsify his sex," are some other synonyms for "trans woman."
"Trans woman" is a confusing term that some people have been led astray into thinking is a "woman," and thus should generally be avoided by a speaker -- but where one encounters it as a reader or listener, it should be understood to be a synonym of those other terms.
They claimed that gender affirmation was evidence based and medically necessary (it never was) and that it would save the lives of trans-identified children:
Quotes a post by T06106; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedmedical harmshooter attributionviolence terror
"The risk of violence to others is real as well. In the last five years, there have been 12 school shootings in the United States and Canada where at least one person died. A male identifying as transgender was the killer in 4 of those 12. These statistics indicate that transgenders committed 33% of these deadly school shootings in the US and Canada despite making up about only 3% of the youth population."
Quotes a post by T08129; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
The obvious correlative to this is now domestic -- some of us know what the transgender cult is while the rest of the Western intelligentsia (or whatever remnant of it survives) wallows in stupidity, ignorance, and indifference to reality
I Told You So You Fucking Fools would be a great title for my book on transgenderism were it not for the fact that we are still in the early Brezhnev years of this retarded ideological mania. I Fucking Tweeted it All out in 2021 You Imbeciles another working title.
Quoting @robkhenderson: "When we read the writings of Soviet dissidents and exiles, we are struck by one recurrent theme: their amazement,indignation and anger in the face of the stupidity,ignorance and indifference of Western opinion and especially of the Western intelligentsia" https://a.co/d/gUvv5dL
There were no false claims that the mass murder of nine was trans-identified because the killer was trans-identified.
There were only false claims (from the police) that the mass murder of nine was female because the killer was male.
Quotes a post by T08254; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
HRC was able to force the NBA, the NCAA, and many other large corporations to boycott the state of North Carolina when it a passed a law reserving girls bathrooms for girls in 2015. This was when people didn't understand that any "transgender inclusion" meant that any man who claimed to be a woman could invade any female space.
Now people know. Since then, hundreds of state laws that HRC claims to be transphobic (restricting the use of puberty blockers, ensuring that women's sports and spaces are for women) have passed without any corporation lifting a finger to oppose them. The power of this leviathan has declined and is declining but must be cut off entirely.
Quoting @Tyler2ONeil: 🚨IN RETREAT
The Human Rights Campaign, acts like an LGBTQ mafia, has lost more than half its Fortune 500 partners.
HRC's stranglehold over Corporate America is loosening, as detransitioner lawsuits succeed and "gender-affirming care" loses support.
https://www.dailysignal.com/2026/02/14/retreat-lgbtq-mafia-human-rights-campaign-hrc-loses-more-than-half-fortune-500-partners/
A book dedicated to a doctor who glorified the suicide of a trans-identified child that models to children how to force their parents to chemically castrate them by threatening to commit suicide if they don't get their way. Books like this, when they end up the subject of parent activism to get them removed from elementary and middle school school libraries end up on lists of #BannedBooks that are celebrated.
Quotes a post by A1663; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The institutionalized mania in Canada is metastatic. The trans activist goal of forcing the whole world to affirm lies as the only truth is essentially fulfilled.
Quotes a post by T07466; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Spend 20 minutes listening to what the doctors who trans patients actually say: I guarantee that no sane person will conclude at the end of this that this field is legitimate medicine
Quoting @LeorSapir: 🚨A group of gender surgeons, some affiliated with @[private account], has launched a pressure campaign against @[private account] after ASPS recommended that gender surgeries be deferred to age 19+.
Leading the group is Dr. Blair Peters, a.k.a. “Queer Surgeon,” of @[private account] 👇
You can confirm that there is no stable, coherent definition of a trans person by listening to how the doctors who manufacture trans people talk about them
Quotes a post by A3058; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Three days after a mass murder of six, including three 9-year olds by a trans-identified female, this is what the spokeswoman for the President said: "LGBTQI+ kids are resilient. They are fierce. They fight back. They’re not going anywhere. And we have their back. This administration has their back."
When a trans-identified male who was affirmed as a girl at the age of 12 murders his mother, brother, six children ages 11-13, and one teacher at a school in his town of 2,000, Canadian media rushes to portray "the transgender community" as victims.
The collective narcissism of a cluster B online community to whom the suffering of innocent others counts for nothing compared to their own compulsion to be affirmed as something they are not and will never be is all that matters is axiomatic across Canadian media and Canadian institutional messaging.
It is a moral catastrophe.
Quotes a post by T02386; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialmental illnessshooter attributionvictim dismissalviolence terror
The Global Transgender Inquisition, whose core mission is to capture state power and deploy it to force the whole world to affirm a falsehood as the only truth, has captured the regulatory apparatus of supranational Europe and now seeks to do the same at the United Nations.
Quoting @geraldposner: 340–141.
That’s the vote by which the European Parliament adopted a resolution yesterday calling for the full recognition of trans women as women across EU policy.
It also rejected an amendment stating that "only biological women can become pregnant."
Read that again.
233 MEPs voted against affirming that pregnancy is biologically female.
This isn’t about courtesy or pronouns. It’s about law, language, and the destruction of biological clarity in public policy.
While resolutions may be nonbinding, they shape funding priorities, institutional language, legal frameworks, and educational standards across the EU.
When legislative bodies struggle to affirm basic biological realities, it signals something deeper than tolerance. It is another flashing warning sign that delusional ideology is overtaking empirical fact.
Once institutions lose the ability to define clearly sex-based categories, the consequences ripple far beyond semantics — into medicine, sport, prisons, data collection, and women’s legal protections.
This is not about bigotry. It is about governance.
The transgender movement exploited a middle school girl's psychic distress to turn her into a pawn and a resource from which they harvested profit, financial and political, from inflicting lifelong irreversible harms on her hitherto healthy body. They brainwashed her to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered and then chemically castrated and dismembered her while boasting of how they had saved her life and helped her to be her true self, as they led her down the garden path and clapped as she pretended to be something she is not and can never be.
Quotes a post by A0447; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This completely fabricated lie has already propagated throughout BlueSky and trans Reddit, where it will endure as the sole truth about the mass murder of nine by a trans-identified male in British Columbia for all time
Quotes a post by T02672; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedmedical harmshooter attributionviolence terror
After Audrey Hale, a trans-id female, murdered six people, including three 9-year olds, in a Nashville religious school, trans activists at the capital held up seven fingers to refer to the seven victims of the mass shooting, including its perpetrators, who was killed by police.
Quoting @reddit_lies: “The shooter was a victim too”
Fuck you, we’re not doing this anymore.
C2 false claimshand-codeddenialpolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
Every claim made by transgender ideologues is built on a lie
Quoting @buttonslives: The results: once psychosocial factors were controlled for, neither surgery nor cross-sex hormones significantly reduced depression or anxiety. Coping style and social support were actually the strongest predictors of mental health.
The man who murdered children in a Minneapolis church wrote in a diary whose pages he posted to YouTube just before his child murder rampage that he was embarrassed by his failed attempt to brainwash himself into believing he was female. But still NPR scolded Amy Klobuchar for referring to him as “a man.” They could have taken the opportunity to dissociate themselves from a murderer of children by saying “he gave up on being trans because he was never trans,” but they instead wanted to claim the murderer of children as one of their own own and force the whole world to use his preferred pronouns.
“Moreover, these kids are told over and over again that transition will cure all of their mental distress, and because of the culture in trans spaces, they feel compelled to pretend that this is so. That causes a lot of repressed anger and pain they feel unable to express verbally, and whereas girls who are angry and depressed at this level are more likely to self-harm (although there are exceptions), boys — as we continue to see — tend to lash out instead. “
Quotes a post by A2532; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codeddenialmedia pronoun complaintshooter attributionviolence terror
What promises and threats were made to Moulton sufficient to cause him to abandon his concern for his daughters well-being, and by whom? Or was his concern for his daughter's well-being itself feigned in the face of what looked for the moment like an electoral exigency and now that the consensus within the party has shifted back to confidence that they will be able to force through the transgender activist agenda onto the country without penalty, he ceases with the charade?
It's clear that the Democratic party and the Vertically Integrated Messaging Apparatus has coalesced around the view that the Trump victory was a minor speed bump on the path to the triumph of the transgender inquisition
https://x.com/MeghanEMurphy/status/2021826122967597180?s=20
Quoting @MeghanEMurphy: Here's what @[private account] wrote about the 18-year-old male who murdered HIS mother and stepbrother before opening fire at Tumbler Ridge Secondary School, killing a teacher and five students between 12 and 13 years old:
"Van Rootselaar was 18 years old at the time of the shooting.
RCMP said they 'identified the suspect as they chose to be identified in public and social media,' explaining that Van Rootselaar was born biologically male.
She was a resident of Tumbler Ridge."
Then continued to refer to the young man as "she" for the remainder of the piece.
Imagine typing "born biologically male" then proceeding to type "she" over and over again, and continuing to consider yourself a journalist https://x.com/CTVNationalNews/status/2021768791701565844
The @nytimes did it too, so did the @[private account].
How pathetic and shameful.
The Global Transgender Inquisition's capture of transnational institutions is nearing completion. The EU Parliament has endorsed the view that women may not have their own domestic violence shelters or changing rooms from which men are excluded.
Forbidding women from drawing a boundary between themselves and any man who says he is a woman now goes to the UN for ratification as a goal of the international community to be implemented everywhere.
The goal is to make it impossible to escape this mad imposition anywhere in the world.
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: BREAKING: The EU Parliament has voted to recognise "trans women" as women for all purposes, explicitly calling for them to be granted access to women-only domestic violence shelters and refugees.
An EU delegation will present this radical recommendation at the UN Commission on the Status of Women in New York next month. It is not binding, but intended to be adopted/followed as an "international standard". It also demonstrates the ideological makeup of the European Parliament.
Few speakers mentioned the "trans women" part of the recommendation during the debate leading up to the vote. Parties could have asked for a vote on the individual paragraph, but having failed to do so, MEPs were left with a choice between rejecting the entire resolution, or adopting it with no possibility of removing the trans paragraph.
The chamber was almost empty for the debate. Left-wing parties and centre-right parties concentrated on the Epstein files, "gender" stereotypes, the "gender pay gap", and the "anti-gender movement" as well as ICE operations in the US. MEPs from both the Patriots party and the European Conservatives and Reformists, spoke up in favour of protecting the category of woman in international fora. They were defeated.
*Trans women are males who identify as women, a dissociative disorder linked to paraphilia/fetishism. This identity is mostly adopted by heterosexual men.
340 YES
141 NO
68 ABSTAIN
See next tweet for list of YES voters.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @SexMattersOrg
If passed into law, this would be the first legislative act anywhere in the country seeking to put a stop to the most insidious, pernicious, tyrannical, and abusive of the many insidious, pernicious, tyrannical, and abusive aspects of the transgender inquisition.
We need this law in every state.
Quoting @libsoftiktok: BREAKING: Ohio State Rep. Josh Williams (R) just introduced legislation BANNING state agencies from retaliating against parents who protect their children from radical transgender ideology.
AMAZING 👏
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedchild indoctrinationideology cultspeech persecutionstate takes children
The trans-identified male who murdered his mother and sister and six children aged 11-13 at a school, began his transition at the age of 12. The school where he murdered six children aged 11-13 had a trans flag of equality in its window.
https://x.com/MrAndyNgo/status/2021686095382286727?s=20
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Police in Canada have finally confirmed the B.C. school mass sh—ter is trans. He is 18-year-old Jesse van Rootselaar. (Prior independent reporting reported he had his mother’s surname, Slang, but that was inaccurate.) Police say the gunman began transitioning about six years ago, when he was about 12.
He had dropped out of school when he was about 14. Police confirm that all of the deceased child victims are between 11–13 years old.
Van Rootselaar killed nine people, including his mother, who affirmed his transgender identity, and his 11-year-old brother.
Screenshot of the school in Tumbler Ridge, B.C. where the second part of the sh—ting occurred:
Also good to remember that the man in this photo in a gun shop showed up at the house of Supreme Court Bret Kavanaugh with that gun after researching the addresses of Kavanaugh and two other justices online before losing his nerve and turning himself in.
At the sentencing, the federal court judge told the man in this photo that she was "heartened" that his murder plot had resulted in his family's choice to affirm his trans identity and cited the Trump administration's executive order requiring that federal prisons house inmates according to their sex as one factor in her reduction of his sentence from the thirty years dictated by the sentencing guideline to eight years.
With time served, he will out in four years.
Quoting @Babygravy9: Since we're talking about trans shooters again, it's a good time to remember that a transgender man, Ryan Michael English, tried to assassinate Scott Bessent a year ago and burn down the Heritage Foundation. He said he was inspired by Luigi Mangione.
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
Deputy police commissioner confirms that the 18-year old trans-identified murderer of nine people and himself is male only after first insisting that he was female in reply to a direct question.
Quotes a post by T33528; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This came out the day before yesterday’s mass shooting of nine by a 17-year old trans-identified male ina small Canadian town:
Quoting @SwipeWright: Yesterday’s horrific school sh*oting in Tumbler Ridge is a grim reminder of something we’re not allowed to talk about honestly: the rise in transgender-linked extremist violence and the conditions that can fuel it.
In this must-read essay for @[private account], psychologist @[private account] examines the pattern and offers a framework: identity instability + nihilism + apocalyptic “victimhood” narratives + revolutionary moral certainty can, in a small subset of alienated young people, erode restraints and make violence feel justified.
This piece was published a day before the Tumbler Ridge attack. This is a problem we can't shy away from.
Gender Nihilism and the Revolutionary Impulse:
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/gender-nihilism-and-the-revolutionary
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
24 hours after the shooting, the entire global mainstream media apparatus has not caught up to Juno News, which has let confirmed that the mass murderer of nine in Tumbler Ridge is a trans-identified male https://x.com/cosminDZS/status/2021612478313230438?s=20
Quotes a post by T02672; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is similar to how @reduxx investigates the posting and criminal histories of any newly visible trans activist and finds sex offender or fetish porn histories in a large fraction of them
Quoting @reddit_lies: u/jesseboy347 is the Reddit account of the Tumbler Ridge mass shooter.
@[private account] posted this screenshot of u/jesseboy347 back in 2023.
Turns out if you post enough random screenshots from r/MtF you'll eventually post a mass shooter.
I've repeatedly tweeted the prediction that there will be a trans Manson Family (already happened, see Zizians), a trans Weather Underground, and a trans Jonestown (arguably there are slow motion versions of both ongoing.)
https://x.com/Lekowitz/status/2021608413956915608?s=20
Quotes a post by T05283; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The trans-identified male murderer of nine was on Reddit three years ago, at the age of 15, lamenting that he was too large (and, ultimately, male) to look like his favorite anime girls https://x.com/reddit_lies/status/2021600761667293328?s=20
Quoting @reddit_lies: 3 years ago, Redditors on r/VaushV lost their minds over Matt Walsh quoting Males of Reddit's screenshot of jesseboy347.
u/jesseboy347 just shot up a school in Tumbler Ridge, Canada yesterday.
It is not at all incidental that every screwed up young person is sucked into trans-identification
https://x.com/DavidPasko_/status/2021605136376676829?s=20
Quotes a post by T02886; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Reduxx thread on the trans-identified male murderer of ten in British Columbia: https://x.com/reduxx/status/2021485274375635244?s=20
Quoting @reduxx: (Continued)
In 2021, Strang launched a YouTube channel that was promoted by his mother on her Facebook. The channel was dedicated to "hunting, self-reliance, guns" and his other interests.
At some point, Strang deleted the content on the channel and changed his handle from "Jesse Boy" to "JessJessUwU."
The only remaining post on the channel was made 6 months ago and reads "I've been pretty, um, aimless."
Whenever a trans-identified murderer emerges, as they do with metronomic regularity, the dilemma that the media and police face is this: 1.) should we try to protect the interests of the transgender movement by hiding that the murder was trans, so as not to associate transgenderism with psycho murderers? or 2.) should we try advance the agenda of the transgender movement by honoring the preferred pronouns of this psycho murderer, as we would for any other man who claims to be a woman or woman who claims to be a man?
This dilemma always works itself out with 1.) some early coyness about the identity and the sex of the murderer, followed by 2.) lockstep coalescence around honoring the psycho murderer's preferred pronouns, because using a mass murder to teach the public that any man who claims he is a woman is a woman overrides any interest in denying that transgenderism is associated with psycho murderers.
NPR literally scolded Amy Klochubar for referring to the man who murdered multiple children in a Minneapolis church as "a man."
The reason it is reasonable to ask "what are this person's preferred pronouns?" whenever a white person under 40 goes on a killing spree is that 1.) the transgender movement explicitly defined "transgender identity" as anyone who claims a cross-sex identity, thereby defining any possibility of a trans faker, or person who can otherwise be gatekept out of the identity, out of existence, both as a matter of social affirmation and access to transgender medicalization, both of which have been defined by the movement and recognized as the state as sufficient grounds for legal recognition, and 2.) made impossible promises of magical self-transformation to every disaffected and self-hating person in the Western world, thus incentivizing the entire class of person of which the suicidally and homicidally inclined are a subset to identify into the category.
Not only does the movement not try to gatekeep the mass murderers in their midst, it attacks anyone who would try to keep them out.
So far, the roll out of the news of yet another psycho trans-identified male who went on a killing spree, this time in British Columbia, is holding true to form, with police referring at the first press conference to the killer of ten people as "a female in a dress," thus leading me to go to bed without commenting on this story.
I awoke to Juno News reporting that the shooter's uncle had confirmed that the shooter is a trans-identified male whose YouTube handle includes the term "UwU," a reference to a furry meme that was also engraved into one of the bullets found in the rifle of the man who murdered Charlie Kirk.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcoverupmedia pronoun complaintmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
The fraudulent framing of transgender activism as a civil rights movement has immunized its claims from any scrutiny and given it a license to tell the most brazen lies ever told with impunity
Quoting @LeorSapir: I’ve seen commentators dig in over highly partisan issues, but never in my life have I seen a debate in which prominent voices lie so brazenly and so constantly, and without ever being fact checked by mainstream media, as pediatric gender medicine.
It’s just astonishing.
No. This is just like people in 2018 laughing at people reporting that trans activists think "men can get pregnant" in advance of millions of schoolchildren being brainwashed into the belief within a few years.
Activist idiot ideas are all going to be imposed everywhere, including the most prestigious journals and medical schools with zero pushback, as already happened with fat acceptance, and they are going to put boys in your girl's dressing rooms, and a registered sex offender will loiter naked for hours in a girl's room in Fairfax County and the local police will say he didn't violate any law, and a male serial murderer of women will be granted access to a women's shelter over the terrified protests of women forced to share space with him and he will return to a women's prison after beheading and dismembering yet another women a month later, and all of this insanity will go forward totally unconstrained by reason and reality and "the vast majority of doctors who know that men can't have babies."
Quotes a post by T05409; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is no legal right to be something you are not or to compel others to endorse falsehoods. But thank you for confirming that recognizing "trans people" necessarily entails criminalizing statements of fact.
https://x.com/MtnLover35433/status/2021083546924773663?s=20
Quotes a post by T32204; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Summer, in the letter she posted, said that she hoped her death would bring people together, would bring awareness to the suicide epidemic (especially the trans suicide epidemic), and would raise $1 million for the Trevor Project."
The project is happy to quote from the letter.
A 34-year old veterinary student goes on trial tomorrow in Brazil for having posted the following true statement on social media: "“A person who identifies as transgender retains their birth DNA. No surgery, synthetic hormones, or change of clothes will alter this fact.”"
She faces up to five years in prison.
The Transgender Inquisition is global and unitary and seeks the same goals wherever it acquires the power to impose them: it seeks to deploy state power to punish people for dissenting from its false dogmas and to compel them to parrot those false dogmas.
The medical lobbies that masquerade as purveyors of "standards of care" for transgender "medicine" tell the most brazen lies ever told in the history of medicine
Quotes a post by A1525; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Both of them outsourced their thinking to their trans activist staffers and lobotomized themselves in the way anyone must in order to insure that they don't have their own thoughts.
They are sadly representative of the entire American professional managerial class.
Quoting @DIAGdemocrats: “There are people in elitist professions like … celebrities with young fan bases, who did all they could to champion the idea of gender identity… They're just as culpable as the clinicians.”
Hi @[private account] @[private account]!
And hi @TheDailyShow @jonstewart!
People who think I am "obsessed with trans" simply aren't competent readers. "Trans" is barely my subject at all. "Trans" is rather the ultimate paradigm case of my actual subject, which you've nicely summarized. https://x.com/mralpacalips/status/2019676836633145823?s=20
Quotes a post by T01405; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Regular reminder that this ideological zombie speech that now pollutes all institutional messaging is made in deference to *women pretending to be men* ("trans men") who need to erase women in language and law so that they can be affirmed as members of the sex they are not
Quotes a post by A2445; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The former assistant New York state attorney general
Glenna Goldis, who was fired last month for publicly contradicting false claims made by the office of Laetitia James concerning pediatric gender medicine, will be moving to the Federal Trade Commission to investigate transgender medical providers as perpetrators of consumer fraud.
A "trans man" is competing in the Olympics against women because trans men are women. If she was taking testosterone, she would be ineligible to compete in competitive sports because testosterone is a performance enhancing drug and performance enhancing drugs are banned . But she isn't, so she's competing against her sex.
The same rule will apply to "trans women" -- they must compete against men because trans women are men.
Problem solved.
Quoting @JamieWhistle: The Winter Olympics begins Friday. There is a trans identified athlete from Sweden competing in moguls.
She identifies as male, completes in the female category, and has not started any medical transition.
Her name is Elis Lundholm.
These anon anime trans accounts have the same views as the actual federal Bureau of Prisons
https://x.com/carleobealeo67/status/2019158453680591009?s=20
The transgender movement's goal is to deploy state and non-state power to force everyone to affirm a falsehood. It cannot coexist with freedom of speech and conscience. It must either relinquish its foundational goal or achieve it by snuffing out freedom of speech and conscience.
The ACLU's lead trans rights litigator understood this and declared it.
Quotes a post by T04835; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"No sane person would put 'male rapists' in women's prisons" -- therefore multiple US states and the federal Bureau of Prisons is not putting male rapists in women's prisons.
Except they are.
The unexamined premise here is:
-- No sane person put male rapists in women's prisons ✅
-- The political leadership of the United States, operating in accordance with the demands of the transgender movement is sane ❌
ergo
-- There are no 'male rapists' in women's prison ❌
An army of online trans activists are spreading the fabricated smear that is decisively debunked in this article.
It should not surprise anyone that a movement whose ultimate goal is deploying the coercive power of the state to force the whole world to affirm a falsehood makes ready recourse to lies and smears against those who reject its demand to affirm a falsehood
Lawyers (as opposed to therapists and teachers and journalists and doctors and politicians) are clear-eyed about what transgender inclusion actually means. The other group that is clear-eyed about what transgender inclusion means is transgender activists.
Transgender activists well understand that they are seeking to do exactly what lawyers who are critical of transgender activists know them to be doing.
Quotes a post by T02322; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Epstein was situated at the nexus of several key categories of person that make his interest in and financial support of the castration of minors unsurprising: transhumanist researchers, Democratic party elites, and perverted men in possession of vast inherited fortunes.
These were the forces that worked together to astroturf the trans movement into power.
A "trans woman" is a man who claims to be a woman but remains a man because sex change isn't possible and gender is an irrational pseudo-religious belief system with no grounding in reality that some people are free to indulge but that no one may coerce anyone else into participating in.
All "trans rights" are imperious demands for others to be coerced into regarding, treating, and referring to people as something they are not, overriding the right that every person has to say what they know to be true and not be coerced into saying what they know to be false.
Quotes a post by T01911; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I don't think the Australian government should be funding a trans youth charity co-founded by a pedophile
Quoting @angijones: Here in Australia we have porn industry lobbyists with close ties to child sex offenders telling @[private account] and local governments to remove safeguarding for women and children and they complied.
A pedophile co-founded Gov funded trans youth “charity” @[private account] and it barely made the news.
The global transgender inquisition's goal is to forbid any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who claims to be a woman. This mandate recognizes no limit on who may avail themselves of this privilege based solely on self-identification.
Quoting @reduxx: NORWAY: A man on trial for trafficking and exploiting multiple mentally disabled women has declared a transgender identity in court.
Harald Tancred Paulsrud Bye has changed his legal sex marker to "female" and is being referred to as a "woman" by media.
https://reduxx.info/norway-psychopath-charged-with-sex-trafficking-mentally-disabled-women-changes-legal-sex-to-female-during-trial/
Something that came across clearly during the demonstrations and social events in DC surrounding the SCOTUS case on men in women's sports is that this issue is going to be won not just because it is the one where the bizarre derangement of transgender dogmas are most palpable and self-evident to the wider public, but also because the women who have rallied to this cause have a lifetime of training in persevering through adversity, summoning reserves of courage and energy in the face of resistance, bouncing back from injuries and losses, and risking everything in pursuit of victory.
They will win because they are winners and winners win.
Quoting @JenniferSey: This is my story.
This is why I fight for women and girls.
This is why I started @xx_xyathletics.
Persecuting people for accurate references to a person’s sex, even inadvertent ones, is an essential component of the global transgender inquisition that has its tentacles in millions of schools across the Western world
Quoting @JamieWhistle: Holy shit, in Maine tonight. A Mom is speaking- her son received an in school suspension for an accidental misgendering.
It took 28 minutes for the board to determine first that no one outside the district can speak- then the board finally voted to allow @[private account] and I to present as outside experts.
That only happened because we partnered with board members.
This is a fully packed school board meeting with police present.
This is the work.
In addition to being a conflict over law and policy, transgenderism is a conflict over social norms. Is an accurate reference to a person's sex rude, disrespectful, deserving of censure? The answer cannot be yes in any society that respects everyone's rights to free speech and free conscience that entails the ability to believe or disbelieve moral diktats that others regard as compulsory.
The transgender movement has had rapid success in imposing this mandate on wide swathes of bourgeois America through a relentless campaign of maudlin appeals and bullying.
It will take time and patience and a relentlessness that is the equal of those seeking to impose this illegitimate mandate to undo it. It begins with people asserting their indefeasible right to say no.
Quotes a post by T02322; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Glenna is one of the best legal analysts, and the best writers of any kind, on the transgender issue. Today she paid a price for standing up for reality and truth -- a price that a politicized state agency indifferent to the truth or falsity of the claims it makes in the service of political priorities dictated from above have shown they are eager to exact from anyone who would correct the falsehoods they have been placing on the legal record. It is an act that shames the agency and reflects on Glenna's integrity and courage in equal measure.
If you don't already, follow her on X and on S*bstack, subscribe to her, support her, and above all, read her, knowing that you will thereby derive a superior understanding of the unbelievable legal morass unfolding in American courts in the name of gender affirmation than you can get from any other source.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Thanks to action by Trump's EEOC, women no longer have to shower with men as a condition of their employment
Yes, Biden's EEOC mandated that women had to shower with men as a condition of employment.
Didn't you know that forbidding women from drawing a boundary between themselves and any man who says he is a woman was declared to be "the civil rights movement of the 21st century" and that the Democratic party is pledged to reimpose this prohibition on every school, workplace, public office, and public accommodation in America the instant it reclaim power?
When Democrats say "we can't throw trans people under the bus!" this is what they are referring to.
Quotes a post by A1280; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No, you did NOT say you prioritize housing over trans issues. You said you prioritize housing over "the details of his sex life."
You're confirming my critique of your bad faith by repeating the very thing I criticized!
And now you're saying it's "sign of mental instability" that I called you dishonest -- in the very course of re-enacting the very dishonesty I was criticizing!
It's too perfect.
Quoting @RichardHanania: Go back to the original post and see what triggered this. I said I prioritize housing over trans issues, he responded with a rant about how I am dishonest and want to exterminate parts of humanity.
Obsession with trans I’ve found to be a sign of real mental instability.
The enforcers of transgender dogmas persecute people for referring to male pedophiles, rapists, and murderers by their sex because the movement correctly judges that the acceptance of anyone's claim to possess a cross-sex identity that confers a right of recognition onto them depends on the acceptance of everyone's claim to possess a cross-sex identity.
Whether or not Melle is fired for referring to a male pedophile by his sex, she is already the victim of state persecution that has already sent out a signal across the NHS and society as a whole that non-compliance with the imperious demand of any man who says he is a woman that others must pretend that his false claim is true will be enforced by state power.
Quoting @ClaireCoutinho: Today is the day Jennifer Melle will find out whether she is sacked by the NHS after ‘misgendering’ a paedophile.
She did nothing wrong, but she might lose the job she loves because of radical gender ideology.
Join 18,000+ people supporting Jennifer at http://www.SaveJennifer.com
Because I am a man who doesn’t claim to be a woman, I’m not allowed to go into a woman’s changing room.
If I claimed to be a woman tomorrow, I would be considered “a transgender woman” by virtue of that claim , (the sole criterion for who is and who is not a transgender woman being whether a man claims to be a woman) and allowed into a woman’s changing room.
All “trans rights” are imperious demands for special privileges that are available to no other category of person — chiefly enforcement by coercive state power of the demand of a special caste, consisting of anyone who claims a cross-sex identity, seeking recognition as something they are not.
Quoting @NewYorker: Jennifer Welch, the co-host of the “I’ve Had It” podcast, talks to David Remnick about why Democrats need to be “the party of equality” and fight for trans rights. Listen to their full conversation: https://newyorkermag.visitlink.me/Cd1-rC
Because I am a man who doesn’t claim to be a woman, I’m not allowed to go into a woman’s changing room.
If I claimed to be a woman tomorrow, I would be considered “a transgender woman” by virtue of that claim , (the sole criterion for who is and who is not a transgender woman being whether a man claims to be a woman) and allowed into a woman’s changing room.
It's by reading the legal filings and arguments of the dominant civil libertarian organization in America that you really out any possibility that there is any cogent case for transgender legal recognition that anyone can make
It took time and study and observation and the overcoming of a lot of prejudice to see what the Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminists understood from day one: https://x.com/wesyang/status/1930001694781308988?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: What I learned from TERF's:
The claims of transgenderism are not true
It matters that they aren't true
Trying to act as if the claims are true necessarily leads to the infliction of cruelties and absurdities onto innocent parties, most of them women and children
Telling the truth is foundational to resolving the conundrums produced by this movement -- telling the truth resolves every question while failing to tell the truth keeps every question in a state of neuralgic irresolution.
Without telling the truth the problem can never be solved, while telling the truth solves every problem. All half-measures that eschew telling the truth are the same as a forthrightly embracing the untruth.
It tells you that "gender" is a private reverie that leads some people to pretend to be something other than the sex they are and the "identity" of a "trans man" is "woman pretending to be a man" https://x.com/Yuplifeishell/status/2012874605543772528?s=20
Quotes a post by T26219; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Transgender inclusion means: letting a man who raped and killed a 13-year old girl move into a woman's prison if he says he is a woman.
If you are against letting a man who raped and murdered a 13-year old girl move into a woman's prison because he said he was a woman, you oppose transgender inclusion.
Quotes a post by T07466; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I've heard that the trans flags that used to be pervasive in Congressional offices are mostly down. This is solely about optics and not any actual change of position.
Trans-affirming centrists: “I don’t see what the problem is. There’s absolutely no problem clarifying that men who are actually women can get pregnant while men who are actually men can’t, and both subgroups of men are men. Just say that instead of looking weird on camera!”
Trans activists and allies:
Quotes a post by A2032; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Quoting @esjesjesj: Right wingers love to say liberals pretend to not understand things but this “can men get pregnant” shit is 100% that. No one thinks cis men can get pregnant. Trans men can. You fucking morons
The trans activist movement constantly whiplashes between one position and its opposite because it is entirely untethered from the constraints of reality or logic. All that holds it together is the dogmatic pursuit of a goal by any means that might work.
Quotes a post by A0386; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Democrats have responded to the challenge of electoral pushback on gender ideology by inscribing the most extreme trans activist demands into law wherever they control state and municipal power and making clear they intend to resume doing so the instant they return to federal power
Quoting @libsoftiktok: HOLY SHIT. Four Colorado Democrats have introduced a bill that would allow children to change their name, suppress records documenting a name change, and allow the court to strip away parents’ rights if they do not “affirm” their child's name change.
Democrats want to tear children away from parents who don't conform to radical gender ideology.
This is deranged
C2 false claimshand-codedchild indoctrinationideology cultpolitical enemystate takes children
There are no moderates in the Democratic Party on gender. Every leading contender for the nomination did their utmost to advance the most extreme trans activist goals. There is no other issue that has the same degree of unanimity.
Quotes a post by T05497; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A boss can make sexual advances on his subordinate and HR will fire the subordinate for objecting rather than the boss for making sexual advances -- if and only if the boss is a man pretending to be a woman.
Making it a hate crime to reject a sexual advance from one category of person is a not incidental part of the transgender project. (See: "cotton ceiling.")
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: I recently found out a not-close acquaintance is a TERF (I never brought it up with him because, well, you know) but one day I just blurted out to him: I write about trans ideology; and I'm against it. And he was like, yup me too.
Turns out he was fired from a long-term project because his boss trooned out and made multiple sexual advances at him. Also acted sexually/inappropriately in meetings and around others. But he was untouchable because "trans" and "diversity" (it was during the Floydian epoch)
So the guy, this acquaintance of mine, complained to HR and they got rid of him and kept the leery transvestite.
The lawyers for the trans-identified male athlete asking the Supreme Court of the United States to find that girls sports is unconstitutional floated the "counter-intuitive" suggestion that men who are dosing themselves with estrogen are actually at a competitive disadvantage to a women because the muscles they've weakened through the injection of wrong sex hormones cannot bear the weight of their big male bones.
This is to say that the lawyers engaging in desperate sophistry and telling brazen lies to the court were aided in their mendacity by a body of corrupt research published by trans activists and allies who have infiltrated science and medicine to launder activist claims as "science." And they were aided by the justices themselves, who amplified the desperate sophistry and brazen lies coming from the plaintiff's lawyers and eagerly added their own.
There is simply no way to make a case this facially absurd without recourse to brazen lies. Decades worth of antecedent lying in the pages of scholarly and medical journals laid the foundation for the lies told to the highest court in the land.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Trans woman” must revert to being a cute term of endearment to be used within the small private subcultures where it’s understood that playing make-believe with cross-dressers is the done thing. It cannot be scaled up as an identity with any legal standing without destroying the freedoms of speech and conscience that every person holds to choose to play along with someone else’s game of sex falsification or to choose not to play along.
Anything more than this is totalitarian.
In a replay of the dynamic that played out at the Skrmetti demonstrations, supporters of the gender skeptical side vastly outnumber pro-trans protestors at 9:10 am because trans activists do not wake up early enough to show up in the morning. (ACLU charter busses made the pro-trans crowd much larger at 11 am at Skrmetti and will do so today.)
My appeal to the court: don’t make the country wait for years of further litigation to resolve such an obvious legal question as the one implicit in this case. Don’t just find that it doesn’t violate equal protection to keep boys out of girl’s sports but that allowing boys into girls sports does. Find that it’s not just permissible that some schools remove trans-identified males from girl’s sports but that all schools must.
The Post has had some of the most deranged reporting on trans published anywhere in the world, but its editorial board and opinion section have been better than most for a while now
Quotes a post by T29878; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Good quote by Newsom.
He later said the following, also on the subject of sports, but equally applicable to all of the other imperious demands of the trans movement.
Quoting @DIAGdemocrats: 1-13-26.
Look! Gavin said something true! Good job. Have a cookie 🍪
Interesting that as Wiener seeks to move from the California state senate to the US House of Representatives, the controversial prior stance he must jettison is not ripping families of trans-identified children apart, allowing male rapists and murderers to be locked up with women in prison, decriminalizing the transmission of HIV, allowing a 24-year old to have gay oral and anal sex with a 14-year old without compulsory inclusion on the sex offender's list, and decriminalizing loitering in a manner that made it impossible for police to act against the sex trade which now thrives in the open, but rather withholding himself from accusing Israel of genocide
Quoting @helenlewis: Wiener told me (in my story published today) that he wouldn't call it a genocide, and objected to the purity tests of those who insisted on it: "If you’re not willing to use the exact language that we want you to use, then you’re a bad Jew".
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/01/scott-wiener-yimby-shouted-at/685566/?gift=SKtFP-7gCBnFn1bNJdqPMpemnci-YLSRYwnd_ULtdno&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share
The goal of the global gender inquisition is to use repressive state power to destroy the freedom of speech and conscience anyone who questions the dogmas of the transgender movement.
Making an example out of Rowling by jailing her for an accurate reference to a person's sex would make clear to the world that no amount of fame or money can shield someone from the Inquisition.
The inquisition, which has the EU and the entire apparatus of transnational governance at its disposal, as well as control of most of the states of the Western world and Anglosphere, is biding its time for this fateful act.
Quoting @jk_rowling: Fabulous! I've been trying to get arrested for knowing what a woman is for a couple of years now and no luck at all, yet they persecute and harass working class women who need to crowdfund for their defence. I've been discriminated against far too long. Fingers crossed for 2026!
It will be a stopgap. The real decision is that letting boys compete in girl’s sports (a “trans girl is a boy — didn’t you know?) violates the US Constitution.
Not that some schools can ban boys from girl’s sports but that all schools must.