The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
"simply stating that males have XX chromosomes & females have XY will likely lead to a child being removed from the school system."
This is the necessary and unavoidable consequence of attempting to force every student to believe or defer to a falsehood. There can be no transgender inclusion without pervasive censorship and state repression of those who persist in living in reality.
Quotes a post by T08756; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Transgender pedophile served less than two years in a Swedish prison before release for kidnapping a 10 year old girl, at which point he kidnapped and murdered another woman on Christmas Day
Quoting @visegrad24: Outrage in Sweden after transgender pedophile kidnaps & murders a young woman on Christmas Day as she was returning home after meeting with childhood friends near her family home.
He had spent 18 months in jail for trying to kidnap a 10-y-o girl & having 50 000 pedophile pics.
He has recently changed name to “Vilma Andersson,” the same name as a 17-year-old girl Swedish who was the victim of a dismemberment murder in 2019. The police caught the pedophile murderer red-handed as he was trying to bury body parts in a forest of the young woman he had also dismembered.
In 2019, he tried to kidnap a 10-year-old girl. The crime was carefully planned and the preparations extended over a long period.
The girl was attacked in broad daylight, dragged into a car, and held in the back seat. Only when the driver got behind the wheel did the girl discover that the doors were unlocked and managed to escape. She ran to a passing motorist and raised the alarm, whereupon the perpetrator left the scene.
The district court established in the judgment that the abduction was only interrupted by chance circumstances and that there had been a concrete risk that the crime would be completed. He had googled the phrase “how to r*pe” before the crime.
Despite this, the pedophile murderer was only sentenced to two years and four months in prison for attempted kidnapping and gross child pornography offenses. And already at the beginning of 2021 – after one and a half years, he was released again due to the Swedish practice of releasing criminals two-thirds into their sentence if they haven’t misbehaved while behind bars.
The police investigation showed that the kidnapping attempt in 2019 had been preceded by extensive preparations.
In the days before the crime, the young man had bought zip ties, duct tape, and a mask.
IT forensics were able to recover parts of the suspect's web history. It showed recurring searches on how people can be rendered unconscious and lose control, as well as on chemicals, drugs, and autopsies.
Among the searches were phrases such as “make someone unconscious, rape drug and ‘how to rape someone’
After his release from prison in 2021, he legally changed names several times and the authorities approved his request to have protected personal data.
He recently changed named to "Vilma" to embrace his transgender character and it is believed that he has also legally changed his sex with authority registers, meaning that he would have to right to serve his time in a women’s prison after Sweden changed the law in 2024, making it easy for anyone to legally change their sex and be treated in accordance with the requested legal sex.
The pictures below show Robin “Vilma” Anderson on the left and his 25-year-old
murder victim on the right.
A woman posted a photo of a man in a bathroom and is now under criminal investigation that a state appellate court held did not violate her First Amendment rights
Criminalizing anyone who won’t falsify reality is a definitional goal of the project of trans rights. There is no supporting the project of trans rights without supporting the use of state repression to destroy the free speech rights of anyone who won’t falsify reality.
Supporting trans rights means supporting censorship and repression.
Quoting @GlobalAffairs: X is proud to support the legal case of Michelle Evans. Ms. Evans faces potential criminal charges for reposting a picture of a male transgender activist using the sink to wash his hands in the women’s restroom in the Texas State Capitol in May 2023. Ms. Evans did not even take the photo. She merely posted it on X as part of political commentary on transgender issues. Yet, shortly after, the Travis County District Attorney launched a criminal investigation into her post.
The First Amendment protects Ms. Evans' speech, yet in a 2-1 vote, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a misguided and dangerous opinion allowing the criminal investigation to go forward. X is therefore assisting Ms. Evans in pursuing an appeal before all 17 judges of the Fifth Circuit. We look forward to the full Fifth Circuit correcting this wrong and preserving free speech, which is the foundation of American democracy.
The Global Transgender Inquisition decreed that forbidding any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman was to be the civil rights movement of the 21st century and has acted tirelessly to destroy freedom of speech and conscience, to brainwash millions of confused children to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered, and to nullify the democratic will of the people throughout the entire Western world and beyond.
It can prevail only by extinguishing what remains of liberal pluralism and democracy in favor of a totalitarian compulsion of speech and thought practiced from the earliest age -- all in pursuit of self-harming delusions that can never be true.
Quoting @jk_rowling: I want my daughters to live in a country where their right to single-sex spaces isn’t under attack from their own government.
A man who had researched the addresses of three Supreme Court justices showed up outside Brett Kavanaugh's house with a gun. Years later, when the federal district court judge sentenced him for his plot to murder multiple Supreme Court justice in order to avert the overturning of Roe V Wade, she told the plotter that she was "heartened" that his murder plot had resulted in his family choosing to affirm his transgender identity right before shaving 22 years off the sentencing guideline and giving him an eight year sentence. She noted that the Trump Administration executive order requiring that all male prisoners be housed with members of their sex caused her to give him a shorter sentence than she otherwise would have given him were he to be accommodated in federal prison by being housed with female inmates.
With time already served, he is eligible for release in four years.
Quoting @nytimes: In @[private account]
The Trump administration’s political rhetoric is fueling a rise in judicial threats, Judge Esther Salas warns. For her, the issue is personal. https://nyti.ms/4aoKzwb
If this speech makes you believe that chemically castrating and dismembering confused children helps them become their true selves rather than making plain the motive of adult autogynephiles to use confused children as a tool to preserve their access to cross-sex spaces by buttressing the lie that people are born transgender, you are hopelessly credulous
Quotes a post by T00999; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The trans movement stripped out all the medical gatekeeping that once attempted to prevent perverts and psychos and schizophrenics from accessing sex change procedures. The movement successfully pushed the field to affirm and medicalize anyone who sought affirmation and medicalization.
Here is an example of what the field now does as a result:
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: Switzerland:
Woman with an IQ of 53
Intellectually disabled
Delusional disorder, mania, psychosis
Anxiety and mood instability
Self-harms
Lives in a group home because she can’t live alone
Had been committed to a psych hospital 18 times in the previous 4 years
Had just spent 272 days in a psych hospital
Starts to feel gender “incongruence”
Gets diagnosed with bipolar I disorder
Encouraged to go to trans NGO
Starts testosterone within a year
Followed by bilateral mastectomy, hysterectomy with oophorectomy, colpectomy, and proximal urethroplasty and finally phalloplasty.
The researchers conclude that transition relieved the gender problems, she’s happy three years after the phalloplasty.
https://academic.oup.com/smoa/article/13/6/qfaf098/8380239?login=false
https://x.com/Slatzism/status/2000760656413294913?s=20 As I keep pointing out, not only does the movement not try to dissociate itself from perverts and psychos who ID as trans, they literally celebrate them and demand that people defer to their self-ID
Quoting @Slatzism: so to summarize:
man rapes 2 little girls.
while in prison, tortures his mentally disabled cell mate to death.
"oh I only did those things bc I didnt realize I was 🏳️⚧️ lol”
immediately becomes a celebrated 🏳️⚧️ activist
gets profiled as a victim of the bigoted prison system
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedchild predatorfetish fraudviolence terror
Minutes after tweeting the above, I saw this claim that there is a second trans-identified member of the plot. I was right to be a bit surprised. https://x.com/MrAndyNgo/status/2000710555674325272?s=20
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: I can confirm from my investigation that the fifth far-left New Year’s Eve bombing suspect arrested in Louisiana is a former cop turned Trantifa radical. I am continuing my investigation. We have seen instances before of former conservatives becoming Antifa and far-left extremists after transitioning.
C2 false claimshand-codedcrime casemotive displacementpolitical enemyviolence terror
"Turtle Island Liberation Front" sounds like something to laugh at, but the name implies insurrectionary violence. The United States is the Great Satan in settler colonial demonology.
Yes, one of the members is trans-identified. It would be surprising if there wasn't one. It's a bit surprising there is only one.
The ideology has a large foothold throughout K-12 education. People who were adults when the End of History was announced have difficulty grasping how any of this can be real.
C2 false claimshand-codedideology cultpolitical enemyviolence terror
Withholding race is one woke policy; enforced lying about a criminal suspect's and/or missing person's sex is another. The latter may have hindered the search for a trans-identified male at Middlebury who was later found to have dead of a suicide.
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1981476189048021194?s=20
Quoting @wesyang: A trans-identified male Middlebury College student has been missing for a week and in all of the reporting, the missing person is referred to only as a woman and by she/her pronouns, with no reference to the fact that the person is a trans woman.
You would think that providing an accurate description would be important when someone goes missing, but in this case, affirming gender supercedes...helping the public to find them.
Trans issues create a zone of blatant epistemic corruption in every domain it touches -- in politics, education, media, science, medicine, and the law.
When you tell people that their moral worth hinges on affirming a falsehood and they believe it, the collapse of basic normative truth-certifying standards and practices is instantaneous and total.
Quoting @jk_rowling: Nobody's surprised when sloppy students use AI shortcuts, or when internet activists intentionally or accidentally propagate falsehoods, but we're supposed to be able to trust the judiciary. This is absolutely scandalous behaviour coming from a judge. 4/X
Newsom could not moderate on trans because no one who has staked a claim such as "brainwashing confused children to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered is medically necessary and lifesaving" can possibly back out of such a claim.
https://x.com/Variety/status/1999994035231178958?s=20
Quoting @Variety: Nicki Minaj went after California Governor Gavin Newsom in a series of X posts on Friday, targeting a quote from the presidential hopeful in which he supports trans youth:
“Imagine being the guy running on wanting to see trans kids. Haha. Not even a trans ADULT would run on that. Normal adults wake up & think they want to see HEALTHY, SAFE, HAPPY kids. Not Gav. The Gav Nots. GavOUT. Send in the next guy, I’m bored.”
https://variety.com/2025/music/news/nicki-minaj-impossible-gavin-newsom-president-2028-1236608234/
There was some mild suspense over whether Newsom would make a serious attempt to strengthen his prospects at winning a general election by sticking to his resolve to moderate on trans issues.
He began this exchange with Ezra (who believes that opponents of the trans activist agenda are "immoral") by defending his post-election about face on trans inclusion in girl's sports and wound up saying he wants to see trans kids, alluding to his trans godson, and invoking his record as governor of signing into law a sustained assault on parental right. His staff then doubled down on his wish to see trans kids along with a spiteful reference to family division incited by trans activism.
It became inevitable that we would reach this awful juncture when the trans activist movement succeeded in stripping out all the medical and psychological gatekeeping that once strove to prevent psychos and perverts from identifying into the opposite sex and conferred social deference and legal rights of entry into cross-ex spaces to any man claiming to be a woman. Now any psycho or pervert can access these privileges, which have been portrayed to them both as "rights" and as actual conditions of survival that the dominant party of institutional America promises to enforce on their behalf, through an act of self-declaration.
Any refusal of this imperious demand for special privileges becomes an "assault on rights," a framing that the dominant political party of institutional America affirms in their rhetoric and actions (which include a policy of direct defiance of federal policy intended to protect women from psychos and perverts empowered by these mandates) -- and thus provides a warrant for violence, up to and including murder, of any and all who oppose them.
The Trans Privileges Movement began by threatening the only group within left activist spaces that refused their demands ("TERFs") with rape and murder. As their movement meets resistance in the world beyond left activists spaces, the psychos, perverts, and the fragile children who have been propagandized into yearning to be chemically castrated and dismembered by the cult have been acting out the violence (against the self, in the form of suicide, against others, in the form of murderous threats and murderous acts) that were always inherent in a movement that has made the infliction of the ultimate sexual violence on children who have been brainwashed to yearn for it into its highest sacrament.
The trans activist who threatened to murder Nancy Mace cannot be released from custody because he will make good on his threat if he is free.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Update: The leftist trans activist who has been in custody in Greenville, S.C. since May for threatening to assassinate Congresswoman Nancy Mace was denied bond again on Dec. 12. Samuel "Roxie" Cain cried as the judge made his ruling. The judge said that Cain poses too great a danger to the public to be released.
The "moderate" Democratic candidate in 2020 was Joseph Biden. Once in office, Biden permitted zero daylight between himself and the most extreme trans activists and led a whole of government effort to maximize the propagandizing of children that any of them can change sex and the dismantling of any barriers to the chemical castration and dismemberment of any child of any age.
Every "moderate" Democrat has a similar record of working tirelessly to enact the most extreme trans activist demands since 2024. There has instead been a successful effort of rhetorical waffling to reduce the salience of the issue -- one that may, alas, given the other problems with GOP messaging and performance, prove sufficient for the party to regain power and resume ramming through a maximalist version of the trans agenda.
Quotes a post by T05497; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Newsom attempted to moderate on the trans issue some months ago, and now is boasting (accurately) of having signed more aggressive trans rights legislation into law than any other politician in America.
"Trans rights" are imperious demands and incursions on the rights of others, as Newsom well understands.
This part of his record deserves to be front and center as Newsom and others vie for the nomination.
The vile inhumanity of his press office's reply is par for the course for a movement making imperious demands and incursions on the rights of the others that seeks to use state power to propagandize young people into believing a falsehood and punish anyone of any age who won't falsify reality.
Quoting @GovPressOffice: Correct. We’re sorry your daughter hates you, Elon.
Obama changed administration policy to allow trans-identified people to serve in the military in June 2016.
Trump reverted to the policy that obtained from 1789-to June 2016, inclusive of 42 out of 48 months of the Obama Administration.
Of course there can be no constitutional prohibition against this act.
Quotes a post by T08250; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Chase Strangio admitted during questioning by Amy Coney Barrett for the Skrmetti case that one of the key attributes that make group eligible for designation as a protected class, immutability of the identity, does not apply to the trans-identified.
https://x.com/KDansky/status/1921245667051139359?s=20
Quoting @KDansky: In 2018, a man named Ava Pipitone got a lesbian named Julia Beck kicked off as co-chair of the Baltimore "LGBTQ" Commission's Law and Policy Committee. She had "misgendered" male convicted rapist "Karen" White. https://afterellen.com/how-i-became-the-most-hated-lesbian-in-baltimore/
Ava is now Kodah. Then and now ⬇️
Anytime a trans-identified male acquires a public profile and position of influence in policymaking, Reduxx does some research on them. The chances that they find something like this are...not low...
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨EXCLUSIVE🚨
Reduxx can reveal that a prominent British trans activist was formerly a member of a lobby group that opposed the criminalization of child pornography.
Mallory Moore has influenced policy on gender ideology and the transitioning of minors.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-influential-trans-activist-advocating-for-child-transitioning-worked-with-extreme-porn-lobby-group-which-campaigned-against-criminalizing-sexual-images-of-minors/
Here Chase Strangio is making noises about protecting "all women and girls from discrimination in sports" while seeking to head off "categorically excluding trans women and girls from all sports," while making provision for pre-pubescent kids and puberty blocked boys who never developed male strength advantages.
Let's bracket the science behind these claims (systematic advantages appear before puberty) for the moment and appreciate that this is a gesture of rhetorical moderation by Strangio on the cusp of the ACLU's defeat at SCOTUS.
Meanwhile, the ACLU continues to litigate to force prisons to allow adult male rapists and murderers into women's prisons if the male rapists and murderers say they are women.
Remember, Strangio met with trans-identified male prisoners more than a decade ago and asked them what they wanted. The prisoners told Strangio that they wanted their own separate area. Strangio refused this demand as insufficiently affirming and pursued a successful policy of litigating to force men into women's prisons solely on the basis of self-ID.
The transgender movement has always been about the imposition of dogmatic falsehoods on the world through state power.
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: All of these men are in a women's prison because of the @ACLU
Three are registered sex offenders. Three are killers.
Two are sex offenders AND murderers, and the one not on the SO registry is accused of raping a female inmate within weeks of being placed in a women's facility.
Strangio announced her goal years ago. Everything she has done since then is in the service of that goal : to stop the circulation of the true fact that there is an ongoing social contagion of trans identification among young women by any means necessary so as to shield from any scrutiny the reality that the global inquisition of which she is a leading figure seeks above all to criminalize speech that does not falsify reality.
The means will vary according to circumstance. Today's circumstance entails a pivot toward "good faith dialogue."
Glenna outlines (some of) the brazen lies that this pivot entails so as to try to salvage what she can of the prior equally brazen lies she has told.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Orwell x Kafka -- a woman was fined $95K by an Australian court for "unlawful vilification" for questioning the presence of two men on a women's sports team.
The global transgender inquisition seeks to punish people for refusing to falsify reality.
Quotes a post by A1607; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The ACLU’s lead trans rights litigator now professes to be ready to enter a good faith dialogue about the movement she steered off of a cliff, after spending years working tirelessly to force tens of thousand of K-12 girls to compete against and share intimate spaces with boys, thereby demonstrating to a critical mass of them that saying you are a girl does not turn any boy into a girl.
Quoting @BrandiKruse: WOW WOW WOW WOW. One becomes two. Two become MANY! Bravery is contagious! The girls of Washington state have had enough. Look at this showing in Wenatchee tonight. Sign the @letsgowa initiatives and show these girls that sane adults have their back. 👊🏻
The Global Transgender Inquisition seeks to criminalize references to the sex of men playing in women's sports as it seeks to criminalize all references to the sex of all men who claim to be women. This is the endgame of the movement and it is already attained in some jurisdiction.
Quotes a post by A1607; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Most days brings news of mind-bending absurdities and cruelties inflicted on ordinary people in the name of transgender inclusion.
Sporadically, but with growing frequency, there are also victories in the ongoing effort to put a stop to those absurdities and cruelties.
Quoting @America1stLegal: /1🚨MAJOR VICTORY —
AFL has obtained judgment on behalf of a female student who was told by Fairfax County Public Schools that she must share a restroom with a boy — and that SHE should leave if she felt uncomfortable.
The school board has now conceded.
Yes “trans inclusion” means more male murderers and sex offenders in women’s prisons
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨The Illinois ACLU is suing to have "at least eleven" male inmates moved to a women's prison because of their transgender status.
The ACLU had previously secured the transfer of four male inmates, including multiple sex offenders.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-aclu-files-motion-to-have-even-more-male-convicts-moved-to-womens-prison-after-securing-transfer-of-4-trans-identified-male-killers-and-sex-offenders/
This is not an outlying event in the trajectory of transgender movement. This is the core demand: to criminalize accurate references to the fact of a person’s sex whenever the person seeks to falsify it.
The most culpable of the many culpable figures in the transgender social contagion are the medical and legal professionals who embarked on conspiracies to corrupt the moral and epistemic integrity of these crucial professions by entrenching the most transparent nonsense ever to be treated with awe and reverence in both of those fields
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There can be no more reasonable opinion than that a person driven by a compulsion to mortify their bodies in order to falsify their sex are mentally ill. It was a consensus within the psychiatric profession until 15 years ago, it remains in the DSM-IV as a mental illness that serves as the basis for transgender medicalization today. Some people can disagree with it but the criminalization of it is an infringement on a right that all people hold. Your judgment is objectively unreasonable and objectively wrong.
This ambition that drives the transgender inquisition distinguishes it from mere authoritarian coercion and makes it truly totalitarian. The goal is to usher in a world where no coercion is necessary because no one thinks to question its falsehoods.
https://x.com/ahamrick/status/1995525676175134776?s=20
Quotes a post by T22091; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is no such thing as a right to tell other people "who you are" that overrides the right other people have to notice when what you are claiming on your own behalf isn't actually true. There is no right to stop other people from saying what they know to be true about you. There is a right to say what is true.
Before it is anything else, the transgender movement is an attempt to destroy actual rights by purporting to enforce fake ones.
Helen Joyce closed her book on transgenderism from 2021 with a prediction that as ordinary people find out what "trans inclusion" means in practice, it will become increasingly less popular and eventually prove untenable. (It means forbidding any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman and punishing her if she objects. It means brainwashing her daughters to welcome men in their private spaces and to hate and fear and inform on their mother to authorities who will punish her if she objects.)
The process has been slow because the trans-identified population is small and most normal people have not had experiences like these. But the number who have is growing all the time, and the polling aligns with Joyce's predictions.
Quotes a post by A1730; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Forbidding any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman is what trans inclusion is.
The reason an NYC women's shelter allowed a convicted male serial murderer of women to stay there despite the terror of the women forced to stay in an enclosed space with him (he later dismembered and beheaded a woman and is now incarcerated in a woman's prisons) is not because anarchist street militants are in power. The reason the shelter did that is because corporate-friendly Democrats funded by BlackRock and Goldman Sachs are in power.
https://x.com/ThinkItThroug17/status/1994827277562175635?s=20
Quotes a post by T08435; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I don't dispute that -- it just has no bearing on my comment, which concerned whether people had grounds to be upset that a trans-identified male won a gardening prize.
? I'm not under that impression. I do know that the DEI agenda means giving preferential treatment to trans-ID folx and naming them "woman of the year" and so forth, as happens regularly over the past decade.
The only possible objection would be if preference was given on the basis of a desire to reward special identities. There is ambient reason to suspect that these days, but in the absence of specific (even circumstantial) evidence to that effect, there's no reason to throw a fit every time a trans-identified male does something.
This person became transgender when he began claiming to be a woman. Claiming to be the sex you are not is what being transgender is.
Like all other men who claim to be women, he has always been a man and remains a man despite his claim to be a woman.
https://x.com/FredaPeaches/status/1993371538054160704?s=20
Quotes a post by T03591; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The transgender movement stripped out all gatekeeping of transgender medicalization, declared that any man who says he is a woman is a woman, and imposed a requirement of affirmation and accommodation onto every citizen and state institution, ensuring that the nexus between the psychotic, the psychopathic, the sexually depraved, the suicidal, and the murderous would be strong and grow ever stronger over time.
This was inevitable, its worsening over time is inevitable, and there is no way to stop it.
Quoting @nypost: Transgender accomplice, 43, busted with ‘Slender Man’ stabber Morgan Geyser says ‘she ran because of me’ https://trib.al/Wxqh4Ic
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcrime casemental illnessviolence terror
Haven't watched, but these are the foundational beliefs of the transgender movement that are being taught to millions of children from the earliest age and that the Reasonable Men aligned with the Democratic party have declared "immoral" to dispute
https://x.com/Tachardiella/status/1993151663691944199?s=20
Quotes a post by T00485; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The ACLU’s lead trans rights litigator wrote that “a penis isn’t a male body part. It’s just an unusual body part for a woman to have” in Slate in 2015. The belief is not an outlying part of transgender doctrine. It is a core part of the doctrine. The doctrine is not an outlying aspect of politics in the Western world. It is why male rapists and murderers are imprisoned with women in the US, Canada, and Britain. When Ezra Klein said that people who dispute transgender doctrines are immoral, this is one of the foundational doctrines to which he was referring.
Quoting @jan_murray: I hadn't heard of @robbystarbuck before ... but wow. This interview seemed to bring out new levels of crazy in Webberley.
It's calm conversation - for the most part.
But Webberley seemed rattled from from the off. I lost count of the number of times she said women can have penises in the first 15 minutes alone. 🙄
If you can stomach any more Webberley interviews, definitely worth a watch/listen.
There’s a big journo group chat where it was decided that we finally have enough proof that the decade-old mania has done the grievous harms that every sane person knew it would inflict from day one and that it is therefore OK to acknowledge it. (Too bad if your kid attended school during the last decade.)
Still must be tentative about the transgender social contagion, though.
Quotes a post by T09130; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We are providing incentives (in the form of enforced deference and accommodation) to every mentally ill, troubled, and disaffected adolescent to identify into transgenderism, an identity whose sole criterion for belonging is claiming to be transgender, with all gatekeeping stripped out on principle such that anyone making the claim is instantly affirmed socially and by the state, with no attempt to distinguish between those who are "actually trans" (a meaningless term without any articulable criteria) and the psychotic, the psychopathic, or the sexually depraved.
Small wonder that the overlap between the set of psychotic, psychopathic, and sexually depraved young people and the trans-identified is so large and always growing larger.
On top of all this, it's completely insane that a teenaged murderer was out with an ankle bracelet.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Morgan Geyser, the transgender-identifying Wisconsin woman who nearly stabbed a sixth-grade girl to death with an accomplice to appease the Slender Man fictional horror character, has cut off her monitoring ankle bracelet and disappeared in Madison.
Geyser, a biological female, pleaded guilty when she was 15 to the attempted m—rder and was sentenced to 40 years in a mental institution. Earlier this year, a judge ordered that she be released to a group home after seven years in state custody.
She is considered unstable and dangerous. http://www.ngocomment.com
One by one, the liberal media will acknowledge the gigantic fiascos that the ideological manias of 2015-2025 inflicted on American youth, while hoping to continue to evade a reckoning with the transgender social contagion
Quoting @jonathanchait: Very good @[private account] look at what's gone wrong in schools over the last decade, and why ed reformers were right all along https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/public-education-failure-american-test-scores-trump-pandemic-liberals.html
Trans activists used an all too credible threat of violence (made credible because of prior assaults) to exercise a veto on the speech of women today
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: I wanted to go to the march against violence against women in Brussels today but because of the threat of violence against us, almost all the women cancelled.
This was the banner that would have got us beaten up.
When "Trans Day of Remembrance" pretends that there is an epidemic of "anti-trans violence," 1.) they are referring to a murder rate lower than the population as a whole and 2.) they are counting in their statistics incidents such as this:
Quotes a post by T03242; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Jessica's "coming out" post is advocacy on behalf of transing children (by broadcasting the lie that he "knew he was transgender at the age of four" and by portraying GOP laws imposing age restrictions as violent attacks on "Trans Kids) and his subsequent advocacy has been in favor of compelled pronoun use. There is zero daylight between "extremist demands" and what Jessica Riedl has repeatedly sought to impose.
Similar questions for Jessica Riedl, who in his post announcing that he intended to live out his autogynephilic fetish full time said 1.) that he had known he was transgender "since the age of four" and 2.) that "my wife and kids have known this side of me from the beginning."
Since he's known that he's really a girl named Jessica since he was four, and met and married his wife and fathered his two teenager daughters after he was four, they all must have known about his [trans identity] autogynephilic fetish since before he entered the marriage and raised two daughters to the adolescence.
Right?
Quoting @preta_6: My latest Substack. Link below.
“If Knox was a baby boy since birth, as she now suggests, then was she ever a girl, a woman, a mommy blogger, a mother, a wife, a lesbian, or nonbinary? Or was she simply mistaken at all points in her life up until the latest revelation about being a man?”
"No borders, no nation, Trans liberation!" puts into the form of a slogan the Successor Ideology that is the dominant rubric that rationalizes the exercise of power in the educational and social welfare sectors of the US economy.
There is no canonical statement of this synthetic creed, but I found a vigorous expression of it in an interview with historian Robin DG Kelley from: 2020:
Quoting @bourne_beth2345: MASS PSYCHOSIS: While the rest of the world wakes up to this unfolding medical scandal, this was today’s “Trans Day of Remembrance” march at UC Davis.
“No borders, no nations, Trans liberation!”
“HRT – HRT, over the counter – and all for free”
“Affirming-care saves lives – let trans people live and thrive!”
52 percent of Virginia voters told pollsters that trans inclusion has gone too far. A quarter of those who believed this voted for Spanberger.
Her equivocations designed to keep the issue lower salience worked and they will work in Blue and Blueish purple states when other issues favor Democrats.
Although a solid majority remains aligned with reason and reality on this issue, (a majority that would be much larger if the public actually understood what the movement’s demands are), it is not a cheat code that will deliver easy victories all by itself.
Quotes a post by A0381; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Any and all claims that there is, was, or ever could be in either principle or practice a unified “community” encompassing lesbians, gays, bisexuals, trans-identified people, people with disorders of sexual development, “Queers”, “asexuals” and “plus” is an obvious liar
Quotes a post by A2032; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
They know that a penis is not a male body part. It's just an unusual body part for a woman to have. They know that children know they are trans as early as two years old. They know that people who deny these facts that science has proven are hateful bigots who must be silenced or locked up.
Quotes a post by T06081; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
But let's put aside for a moment whether marriage is fundamentally violent institution and consider whether the loss of gay marriage would make gays more magnanimous and energized to join with the transgender movement in working to prohibit women from a drawing a boundary between themselves and any man who says he is a woman, propagandizing gender nonconforming youth that they only way they can avoid suicide is by chemically castrating and dismembering themselves, and using the law to punish people who won't falsify reality by pretending people have changed sex.
I personally think it would probably make them laser focused on restoring their own lost rights.
The ACLU's lead trans right litigator said something much more radical in 2022:
"I find it disappointing how much time and resource went into fighting for inclusion in the deeply flawed and fundamentally violent institution of civil marriage. I believe in many ways, the mainstream LGBTQ legal movement caused significant harm in further entrenching the institution of marriage as an organizing structure of US civil society."
Quotes a post by T05276; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Thousands of parents have been emotionally blackmailed into giving consent to the destruction of their children’s health with this psychotic lie.
The ACLU’s lead trans rights litigator admitted in front of the Supreme Court that there was never any evidentiary basis for the claim that medical transition reduces suicide.
Quotes a post by A2621; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The transgender movement wants to force all female rape victims to refer to their male rapists by she/her pronouns whenever the male rapist decides that he is actually a woman
Quotes a post by A0971; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When confronted by Tish about a convicted male domestic abuser who identifies as a woman in the women's locker room with her, Wiener breezily declares that "Trans Women...Are Women."
Problem solved.
Quotes a post by A1730; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Don’t worry, though, despite the record breaking popularity of the event, the city council has already apologized for it and promised not to do it again, sacrificing the interests of children to the transgender Moloch
First, we establish that accurate sex based language is a fundamental right that no one may infringe through the courts.
Then we undo the social norms imposed by a small vanguard insisting that the use of accurate sex-based is a cruelty or even a faux pas.
We do the latter by being as vehement and unyielding on this reasonable and correct viewpoint as the trans activists have been in their imperious demands and sophistic attempts to turn falsifying reality into a requirement of basic decency.
People are free to choose to help others falsify their sex if they wish but others can choose otherwise without any imputation of having done anything improper.
Quoting @JonathanTurley: There is a major ruling out of the Sixth Circuit on both free speech and student rights. The court, sitting en banc, ruled 10-7 that “the mere use of biological pronouns does not entail ‘aggressive, disruptive action.'” https://jonathanturley.org/2025/11/10/sixth-circuit-issues-major-ruling-striking-down-districts-pronoun-policy/
Chase Strangio wrote that a penis isn't a male sex body part, it's just a body part that is unusual for a woman to have in 2016. None of these obviously false claims upon which all of transgender policy and lawmaking depend is new. They've been around for more than a decade and are all in various states of being embedded in language and policy and law across the Western world.
Quotes a post by A1195; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Affirmative action was opposed by a supermajority of the public from its inception until the present and survived for six decades beyond the reach of the politics based solely on an institutional consensus to which the GOP deferred. It's just not true that a wide-ranging social agenda can't be imposed against the will of the people.
The better question is whether forbidding any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who claims he is a woman, propagandizing every schoolchild that any of them can change sex and that medicalized self-harm can unlock their true selves, and forbidding the use of sex-based language are "progress" or desirable social goals we should be embracing or inherently authoritarian goals that must be refused. The real question is: Can someone's private reveries ever serve as the basis of an identity or a claim upon which rights can be conferred or duties imposed on others? The answer cannot be yes in any society that wishes to remain liberal, pluralistic, and free.
Yes, the transgender movement has relied on deeply illiberal, authoritarian means from the get-go, including violent rhetoric, imagery, and action pervasive in online messaging and conduct and messaging at street protests that has alienated the wider public from its cause. But it's ultimately the ends and not just the means trans activism that are undesirable and must be refused. The unattractive aspects of the movement's conduct reflect the intrinsically authoritarian ends it seeks.
Quotes a post by A1184; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The worst institutionalized abuses of the transgender movement continue apace entirely unaffected by Trump’s executive orders or the Supreme Court ruling
Quoting @MorrellMDmph: It’s great Skrmetti showed it’s reasonable to protect kids legally.
However, courts are still yanking kids from protective parents across the nation. Why? Because they are taking medical orgs (and fake ones like WPATH’s) word for it.
C3 dehumanizinginstitutional capturemedical harmstate takes children
The case, like the case for every other demand for trans inclusion, such as the inclusion of male rapists and murderers in women's prisons, which is required by law in California, is that "trans women are women."
This means that when a hulking male neo-Nazi says he is a woman, he is a woman, and must be incarcerated with women, or when a towering man says he is a woman, he is a woman, and therefore must be allowed to race in the NCAA championships against women, and required by law to be allowed to enter powerlifting competitions against women.
The transgender issue is not solely about any of the myriad discrete issues or set of issues. It's not reducible to the endless absurdities and cruelties the movement inflicts on women and children. It is simply: can reason and reality prevail against a movement that has subverted them? Why can't we put a stop to obvious madness?
Quoting @RichardDawkins: You could make a case ( I wouldn’t) for abolishing the women’s category in a competitive sport, opening it to all humans. But there is no case for a separate women’s category if men such as Lia Thomas & Imane Khelif are allowed to gatecrash it. You cannot have it both ways.
The transgender movement brainwashed hundreds of thousands of confused young people to believe that chemically castrating and dismembering themselves was their only pathway to their true selves and that anyone that stood the way of their medicalized self-harm was a genocidal fascist against whom any reprisal was justified
Quoting @andrewdoyle_com: Violence has become normalised within trans activism.
This sounds good but when you try to imagine implementing this process, you see why the transgender movement went with self-ID -- and you also see why it simply has to remain a private eccentricity with no recognition in law.
The question of transgenderism is whether a private reverie can become the basis of an identity or a set of enforceable rights. Of course the answer cannot be yes.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Seeing this mother talk about her efforts to preserve her daughter from medicalized self-harm that trans influencers had induced her to yearn for while hundreds of raging men called her a Nazi made clear that something terribly indecent was happening
Quoting @wesyang: "We want the same thing. We both want our kids to grow up happy and healthy."
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1571525995374551040/video/1
I witnessed more than a hundred trans activists led by the hulking Alejandra Caraballo call a small group of parents protesting Boston Children’s Hospital for chemically castrating and dismembering confused children “Nazi Scum” back in 2022.
I was there with @BillboardChris, with whom I had already spent a few days in DC. He was wearing his sandwich board reading “No Child is Born in the Wrong Body and I saw first hand that the ratio of those who agreed to those who disagreed with that true statement was easily 20 to 1.
Quotes a post by A2621; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The movement is radically and profoundly zero sum. It can succeed in its objective if and only if all women and girls who haven't accepted transgender dogmas are either re-educated or permanently silenced.
This is where "inclusion" becomes a warrant for societywide repression.
The transgender movement has lost ground in public opinion as more people learn through direct experiences such as these that forbidding women from drawing a boundary between themselves and any man who claims to be a woman is the movement's primary objective
Quotes a post by T04065; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans-identified female who admitted to plotting a mass shooting at her school receives 12.5 year sentence -- more than 50 percent longer than the trans-identified male who plotted to murder three Supreme Court justices and showed up at Brett Kavanaugh's house with a gun.
And right on schedule trans activists exploit a suicide to cast blame and play the victim
Quoting @AriDrennen: They kicked Lia Smith off the Middlebury College Swimming and Diving team for being trans and now, as the 2026 season kicks off, she's dead. Rest in power, Lia. The world is so cruel sometimes.
The "reasonable moderate" trans activist who tirelessly advocates for blocking the puberty of boys as young as 12 now insists that courts require female rape victims refer to their rapists as "she" and to the sex organs their rapists used to rape them as "her penis"
https://x.com/BriannaWu/status/1982562453742600436
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is no reason that a society that embeds recognition of transgender identification into language and law should not do the same for trans-age identification, including giving access to children's sports and schools to trans-age adults. Trans ageism is not more false than transgenderism. They are equally false.
Quotes a post by A0225; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I'm sure this is ordinarily true for doctors being sued by the state but I can see a pathway to orgs being more rather than less protective of her because she was sued for trans stuff
Contrary to two viral news stories claiming that trans identification is in "free-fall" among the young, another data source shows that trans and nonbinary identities are at an all-time high
Quoting @segm_ebm: Recent claims of a “free fall” in youth trans identities may have been greatly exaggerated. A sample of 45K+ students shows trans & nonbinary identities at an all-time high. The claimed drop may stem from flawed weighting and poorly designed survey questions. SEGM's analysis⬇/1
You transitioned before there was a "trans rights" movement, right? That is to say that a total defeat of the trans rights movement a restoration of the prior status quo in which you transitioned would impose zero change on the life you were able to live prior to the emergence of trans rights -- correct?
Can anyone have a right to force others to pretend to hold a belief they regard as false? To pose the question is to become conscious of an insidious move, wherein the term "rights" has been appropriated on behalf of the annulment of the rights of others.
Trans Rights are the instrument whereby progressive illiberalism cannibalizes liberalism from within.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Morgane Oger's debate with Mia was surprisingly sedate.
One key facet of the vanishingly rare public exchanges between trans activists and unbelievers in trans dogmas (that I think accounts for why they happen so seldom) is that they make inescapably clear in a way that nothing else can that the person making a claim to be a woman is in fact a man.
There is an uncanny sense of being browbeat by the physical, material refutation of every proposition being made.
The ACLU's lead trans rights litigator wrote in Slate Magazine that "a penis is not a male body part, it's just an unusual body part for a woman to have" in 2015.
The mysticism that pervades the messaging and actual legal and political strategy of the transgender movement was present from the very outset.
Everyone that chanted "Trans Women Are Women" signed on to this and all of its implications, whether they knew it or not. They signed on to the banishment and cancellation of objective facts and the banishment and cancellation of those insisting on their existence and their relevance to an agenda fundamentally premised on riding roughshod over them at any cost.
Does a person's desire to falsify their sex confer rights onto themselves and impose duties on others? To pose the question in this way is to see it plainly and to see the absolute centrality of the suicide threat in extracting compliance from others and indeed, in establishing the predicate for gender medicine in the first place: it is the only prospect measured against which sterilizing a child could be justified and it is the most powerful means of conscripting the whole world into bearing responsibility for making the act of sex falsification work.
The promise -- the false promise -- that the transgender movement and its patrons in the Democratic party and affiliated institutions has made to an army of troubled young people is that the trans-affirming echo chamber they created for them can be expanded through state power to encompass the whole world. They told those fragile young people that their lives depended on other people affirming them (and medicalizing and sterilizing them) and we told everyone else that those fragile young people's lives depended on their affirming them.
The duty falls especially heavily on the girls, who must welcome them into their changing rooms and sporting fields -- what does their own comfort and privacy matter when weighed in the balance of the lives of these marginalized people?
These were tactics that the movement intended to deploy on a societal scale, and engineered all of its appeals to set in motion this very crisis.
A trans-identified male Middlebury College student has been missing for a week and in all of the reporting, the missing person is referred to only as a woman and by she/her pronouns, with no reference to the fact that the person is a trans woman.
You would think that providing an accurate description would be important when someone goes missing, but in this case, affirming gender supercedes...helping the public to find them.
The British are jailing people for their tweets. The Canadians are requiring academic job applicant be transgender. The woke Left emerged from US academia but seized state power in other parts of the Anglosphere, which provides a glimpse of what it intends in the US when it returns to power.
Quotes a post by T02496; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Moving to an informed consent model of gender medicine means that there is no attempt made to distinguish between those who are "really trans" (whatever that means) from perverts and psychos. Virtually anyone who shows up to the clinic seeking cross-sex hormones gets a prescription the same day, and absolutely everyone who shows up claimubg to be trans is affirmed as trans by "doctors".
For context, when Ray Blanchard was running Canada's only gender clinic, he would recommend ten patients a year for gender medicalization though they received a new patient every week.
This means that an ever growing percentage of young people insane enough to commit random crimes will be trans-identified. And not only will the trans movement and its allies not dissociate these people from the trans identity, they will actively embrace them and demand that others identify them as trans.
NPR scolded Amy Klobuchar for referring to a trans-identified male who killed two children in a church as "a man," and the federal judge sentencing the man who showed up at Bret Kavanaugh's house with a gun said she was "heartened" that his plot to assassinate three Supreme Court justices resulted in his parents affirming his trans identification en route to reducing his sentence by 3/4rd relative to the sentencing guidelines.
The reason why the transgender movement doesn’t try to dissociate itself from sadistic male rapists and murderers is that if any man’s claim to be a woman is deemed fake, there are no grounds to distinguish that claim from “real” claims by other men to be women. They are either all real or they are all fake. (They are all fake.)
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: After New Jersey approved “transgender” male inmates’ transfer into the state's only women's prison, one of the first men relocated was Perry Cerf: a sadistic rapist and killer, a transsexual, who admitted to killing a prostituted woman and drinking her blood to satisfy a “blood fetish.”
Cerf was arrested for the brutal rape and murder of 47-year-old Ecuadorian immigrant Flor Andrade in 2002. Cerf, who now goes by “Michelle Hel-loki Angelina,” was found wearing his victim’s clothes and utilizing her identification with his photo superimposed over hers.
He had been stopped for speeding while driving her car in Demearst, and further investigation by police led them to the body of Andrade, whose naked and bound body he had dumped in a nearby ravine.
While awaiting trial, Cerf penned a letter to The New York Daily News confessing to the crime and boasted about drinking the woman’s blood.
“The truth about my case?” he wrote. “Yeah, I killed her. I punched and kicked her to death, crushing her skull in the process. One of the kicks landed in such a way that it broke her neck and all of a sudden her head was on backward.”
His letter continued: “Since I have a most unusual taste for blood, I drank and licked and lapped up my fill … Let it be known: I am Lucifer’s Maiden servant, sent to earth born of sin, to bring suffering.”
The early critiques of the affirmative model of gender care and the exposure of the non-existent evidence base for pediatric medicine were important interventions at the time. But they were just the beginning of the exposure of the world historical malfeasance behind the transgender movement.
As Nancy McDermott put it in her summary of the Genspect conference: "Almost no one believes that simply providing the data or exposing the harms of the medical scandal is sufficient to stop the juggernaut of trans ideology."
No one believes it because it has been proven not to be true.
"Trans genocide" just means misgendering, keeping men out of women's intimate spaces and sports, and restrictions on chemically castrating and dismembering children https://x.com/RBs738182231461/status/1978907027305897990
Quotes a post by T12113; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Anyone familiar with cult programming tactics instantly recognizes them in the trans movement
Quoting @genspect: “My obsession with the transgender phenomenon began with a simple phrase: ‘sex assigned at birth.’
As a former cult member, I recognised the tactic — loaded language used to obscure reality and control thought.”
Bryan Wagner on how linguistic manipulation sustains gender ideology.
👇
🔗 https://genspect.org/an-ex-cult-member-on-trans/
Under what circumstances can you falsify and deny a person's claim to be the bearer of a cross-sex gender identity? The prison system, in which hulking male neo-Nazis have been reassigned to women's prisons based on their claim to be women proves conclusively that there are in fact no circumstances that permit such falsification in practice because there are no such circumstances in principle. The principles were engineered in this way deliberately to exclude any possibility of a false claim of transgender identity.
The core premise of "trans rights" is that a person's inner desire to falsify their sex can impose a duty on others to aid them in that falsification and that the state should enforce this duty.
This is of course not a right but a demand that violates the basic rights of others. It is antithetical to a liberal, pluralistic society, and the demand must be refused in total without qualification.
Quotes a post by T07273; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The dramatic rise and fall of nonbinary identification proves that faddish social contagion drove at least one of the major neo-identities.
Whether this shows that trans-ID is actually on an overall decline is less clear. This thread looks at the data:
https://x.com/VincentPsychSE/status/1978162273312022789
Quotes a post by A2987; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The police agreed that a male registered sex offender who loitered naked in a HS girl's room had a right to be there because he said he was a woman, the sole criterion for whether someone is to be treated and addressed as a woman according to transgender inclusion law.
If you support transgender inclusion, you support this.
Quoting @NickMinock: 🚨Video from my FOIA request shows 58-year-old Richard Cox, who identifies as transgender, telling Fairfax County police that he should be allowed to use a women’s locker room at a Fairfax County rec center in Oakton despite being a registered sex offender.
WJLA was the first to obtain the video and to report on Cox’s criminal history and recent reports that he allegedly exposed himself to women and girls in women’s locker rooms in Virginia ⬇️
Story: https://wjla.com/amp/news/local/virginia-video-exclusive-fairfax-county-police-body-cam-child-sex-offender-richard-cox-oakmont-rec-center-arlington-transgender-woman-lgbtqia-pool-schools-indecent-exposure
Other graphs also show a decline in trans ID, though not as pronounced as the decline in nonbinary: https://x.com/epkaufm/status/1978074217053577667
Quoting @epkaufm: 3/ Not only this, but freshmen in 2024-25 were less trans and queer than seniors whereas it was the reverse when BTQ+ identity was surging in 2022-23.
This suggests that gender/sexual non-conformity will continue to fall.
Every factual assertion made in this thread is a lie. There is no effort to determine whether anyone’s issue is “that they are transgender, or if it’s something else.” Anyone who comes to a gender clinic of any age is immediately affirmed as transgender.
Quotes a post by T04537; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Trans women" hold onto their male entitlement because they are men demanding you see them as women
"Trans men" adopt an exaggerated version of male entitlement because they are women demanding you see them as men
https://x.com/Carolinejanesvs/status/1977844953381318946
Quotes a post by T31093; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The question of trans rights is this: “Is being female a defining characteristic of being a woman?”
In any reality-based world, the answer must be yes.
Quotes a post by A3058; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The step that Wu cannot take is the step that the transgender movement cannot take but must take: It must understand that others have a right to say no, it's not true, because it isn't true, and your deep investment in it doesn't matter to anyone else and doesn't have to matter to anyone else. All attempts to compel such investment in others will be illegitimate and will fail -- or will only succeed by ending liberal, pluralistic society and replacing it with a maniacal social justice theocracy.
Quotes a post by T04070; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Trans rights" means cannibalizing the safety and comfort and privacy of people who "identify" as the sex they are in deference to the demands for inclusion of those falsifying their sex https://x.com/TheGroundOG/status/1977764919614288119
Quotes a post by T32101; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Tolerance vs radical forced acceptance" is right.
I made an analogy early on: gay rights=civil rights (a movement that builds a durable consensus), trans rights=busing (a movement that stirs up bitter political conflict and is abandoned.)
https://x.com/Sebastian_Hols/status/1977758857201140050
Quotes a post by T07552; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes, a federal court judge referred to a plot to murder three Supreme Court justices as an "infraction."
Yes, a federal court said she was "heartened" that a plot to murder three Supreme Court justices helped the family of the would-be murderer to affirm his transgender identity.
Yes, a federal court judge shaved 22 years off the sentencing guidelines and gave him 8 years in prison instead of the prescribed 30 years because she objected to the requirement that the man would be forced to be imprisoned with other men like himself despite his claim to be a woman.
Quoting @lukerosiak: The sentence also includes a lifetime of court supervision. “I am heartened that this terrible infraction has helped the Roske family… accept their daughter for who she is,” Judge Boardman said of the convict’s mom affirming his gender identity.
There are no checks and balances in transitioning. There are no criteria for being trans other than saying you are trans. There are no diagnostic criteria for receiving cross-sex medicalization other than asking for cross-sex hormones. Planned Parenthood, the largest purveyor of cross-sex hormones America advertises that it typically gives cross-sex hormone prescriptions at the first visit.
Quotes a post by T07162; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Reasonable moderates who recognize that we should be able to have a conversation about trans inclusion in sports keep assuring me that there's totally a way to honor the gender identities of "trans women" while pulling back on some of the excesses of the trans movement but there is zero evidence that it's possible for anyone to try even if anyone wanted to try.
In my interview with Andrew Sullivan, he said that Pete was the person who had to effect a break between the Democrats and the trans movement. I was skeptical but didn't say much.
It's true that Pete could fulfill that role that somebody has to fulfill if he wanted to fulfill it.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A federal judge denied a request for an injunction against Illinois for granting access to the girl's room to a boy he says he is a girl in violation of Title IX.
The judge refers to: "Plaintiff's subjective determination that a transgender female student did not meet the gender stereotypes of a girl..."
"Gender stereotypes of a girl "-- such as being female rather than male.
It should be clear from reading literally any legal filing or ruling that not one person at any level arguing for or enforcing transgender inclusion policy has elaborated a remotely consistent or coherent account of what gender identity is or on what basis it can serve to confer rights onto anyone.
No one has done it because none exists. It is a logical and semantic black hole in the midst of a process whose entire purpose is to eliminate such lacunae through clear definitions.
Quotes a post by T01758; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A decade ago, corporate America imposed a capital strike on North Carolina because its state legislature passed a law separating bathrooms by sex that cost the state $3 billion in lost business. The NBA pulled the All-Star Game from Charlotte. The NCAA pulled multiple championships from the state.
It seemed that progressives had perfected a new form of private-public governance exercising a veto on any law thwarting the consensus of corporate elites who had outsourced their moral and political judgment to an activist elite.
This consensus decreed that the law would dictate that no woman could draw a boundary between herself and any man who said that he was a woman, a cause that the Democratic Party had decided would be the Civil Rights Movement of the 21st Century.
The Biden Administration would go on to issue Title IX regulations imposing this mandate on every school in America. (The rule change was declared in violation of Title IX and the US Constitution by a federal district judge and vacated.) Every Democratic House member voted in unison twice to impose this mandate on every public accommodation in America. Leaders of the Democratic party in the Senate recently announced their intention to introduced that mandate in the fall.
Since that capital strike, hundreds of laws restricting transgender inclusion have been passed by dozens of legislatures without any protest from corporate America. The new model of tyrannical governance by corporate and activist elites has been held at bay by democracy -- at least for now.
Quotes a post by T03843; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A good ad from Sears. Messaging on the gender issue must frame transgenderism as what it is in practice: the imposition of absurdities and cruelties on people's children, turning their own public schools funded by their taxes into an obstacle course of daily humiliations. These abuses range from mandatory loyalty oaths and language rituals to indignities inflicted on girls in their intimate spaces and sporting fields -- all the way up to the male sex offender loitering naked in a HS girl's locker room with the active collusion of school staff guided by state trans-inclusionary law -- that became a flashpoint in Virginia.
Its appeal should not be to ideologically minded right-wingers (references to "the radical left") but to normal parents across the political spectrum unable to countenance further degradation of their children's well-being.
Ideally, it comes from someone who is from the robust majority of Democratic party voters who oppose trans-inclusion in their daughter's bathrooms and sporting competitions -- someone who is defecting from the party on this issue because personal experience has made it clear that this is not some made-up online culture war, but an issue more palpable and immediate in the risks and harms it inflicts on their children than any other.
Quotes a post by T09005; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think it's dismaying that children's media is full of transgender propaganda and hope that Netflix can be incentivized by consumer choice to stop producing and airing it.
Are these children "awful and dangerous" for wanting a separate bathrooms for girls from which boys are excluded, as Zohran Mamdani has claimed?
Do they hold views that are "fundamentally wrong and immoral" because they want a separate bathroom for girls from which boys are excluded, as Ezra Klein has avowed?
Is it just that they are in the majority, as Klein has conceded, or is it possible that their request is reasonable and right?
Are these girls that want their own private spaces from which boys are excluded hateful bigots engaged in the dehumanization of "trans girls," no different or better than the hateful mobs that screamed at and spat on little black children being escorted by federal troops to desegregate Arkansas schools?
Or is this an ersatz civil rights movement inflicting cruelties and absurdities on women and children to indulge a masturbatory urge of narcissistic adults to re-enact the righteous movements of the past in the present to keep the progressive gravy train running?
Quotes a post by A3058; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Here's the reality. Trans Activists have made this an all or nothing for intrinsic reasons. They are right that this is an all or nothing issue. https://x.com/wesyang/status/1930001694781308988
Quoting @wesyang: What I learned from TERF's:
The claims of transgenderism are not true
It matters that they aren't true
Trying to act as if the claims are true necessarily leads to the infliction of cruelties and absurdities onto innocent parties, most of them women and children
Telling the truth is foundational to resolving the conundrums produced by this movement -- telling the truth resolves every question while failing to tell the truth keeps every question in a state of neuralgic irresolution.
Without telling the truth the problem can never be solved, while telling the truth solves every problem. All half-measures that eschew telling the truth are the same as a forthrightly embracing the untruth.
Do they have the right of recognition as the sex they claim to be? That's not a right that all citizens have. Can men enter girl's sports and changing rooms if they say they are women? That's a right reserved for men who say they are women. And what is a trans person if not a "person who claims to be the opposite sex"? So when a male sex offender loiters naked for hours in the girls' room, by what authority do we remove him if he says he is a women?
The path back to reality
-- "Hmm, maybe women and girls actually do have interests that need protection."
-- "Gosh, it seems like those interests are in conflict with the demands of the trans activist movement, which calls to use the law to forbid any woman or girl from drawing a boundary between herself and any man or boy who claims he is a woman. All the plangent insistence by trans activists and allies that no such divergence in interests exists was never true."
-- "It looks like maybe the interests of girls and women should supercede the imperious demands of disordered men to be affirmed as something they are not."
-- "Why did we spend a decade going into paroxysms over this self-evident claim that anyone who thought about it for five minutes would realize?
-- Oh right, we exercised all the powers of the cultural institutions of the Western world to inflict paralyzing fear onto anyone on the cusp of having these thoughts. That was a mistake. Let's try not to repeat it."
Problem solved.
Does @ezraklein consider these girls to be "fundamentally wrong and immoral?"
Does he believe that these girls need to be re-educated to believe that boys who say they are girls are actually girls?
Would letting these girls have their own bathroom be "throwing trans people under the bus?"
Would it be "trans genocide?"
Was it correct never to ask these girls if they were comfortable with changing next to boys before granting any boy who said he was a girl a right to enter their intimate spaces?
Did they have no right to be consulted in advance of this choice because their elders had decided that it was a moral imperative that they accept a boy could be a girl by saying they were a girl?
Can a boy become a girl?
Quotes a post by A2659; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I recall seeing Pelosi respond to Trump's reversal of Obama's June 2016 reversal of the ban on transgender soldiers. Somehow Trump returning to the policy that applied from 1789 to June 2016, encompassing 98 percent of Obama's presidency "endangered our national security."
A year later I watched Elizabeth Warren tell a 9-year old "transgender boy" that she would give him a veto on her picked to run the Department of Education to ensure that the pick was sufficiently trans-affirming.
Joe Biden didn't attend the LGBTQIA+ forum where Warren made that promise.
He then entered office and enacted the maximal trans activist agenda, establishing by default that regardless of who was the figurehead in power, a vote for a Democrat was a vote for an agenda allowing zero daylight between itself and the most extreme trans activist.
Until a Democratic seeks national office with a record of supporting 1.) bans on child transition, 2.) bans on teaching gender ideology in school, 3.) bans on men in women's spaces and sports, the assumption that the maximal trans activist agenda will be imposed through federal fiat holds
In my interview with Andrew Sullivan, I mentioned the male serial murderer of women who was given access to a woman's shelter despite the terror of the women forced to share a women's only space with him because he said he was a woman who went on to behead and dismember another woman a few weeks later who is now imprisoned with women because he said he was a woman and the New York States corrections office is bound by policy to honor the self-identification of any man who says he is a woman in accordance with the doctrines of transgender ideology that the Democratic party has pledged to impose at every level government.
I also mentioned the black female nurse in the UK who faces the loss of her livelihood for referring to a male convicted pedophile by pronouns corresponding to his sex.
I did not mention the registered sex offender who loitered naked for hours in a girl's high school locker room in front of young girls and was later found to have
child porn and children's swim class schedules on his cell phone whom the staff refused to remove from the locker room because he said he was a woman and whom Fairfax County don't intend to charge with any crime because apparently it's legal for a man to loiter naked in a women's locker room in front of young girls and have child porn on his cell phone so long as he says he is a woman.
Quoting @NickMinock: 🚨🚨WATCH: Even after new evidence shows registered sex offender Richard Cox had child porn and children’s swim class schedules at Fairfax County rec centers on his phone, Fairfax County police told me they still don’t plan to charge Cox with any crimes.
Cox, a biological male, claimed he was a woman and was allowed to use women’s locker rooms at Fairfax County, Virginia rec centers where he allegedly exposed himself to women and girls. Fairfax County’s policy allows people to use locker rooms and bathrooms based on their chosen gender identity, not biological sex.
More details: https://wjla.com/news/local//registered-sex-offender-richard-cox-arlington-county-fairfax-county-child-pornography-childrens-swim-class-transgender-policy-womans-locker-room-virginia-attorney-general-jason-miyares
The Arc of History is going to remain tethered to reason and reality. It's not with Lia Thomas or Dylan Mulvaney or Rachel Levine or Sam Brinton or Jeffrey Marsh. It's not with the furry porn enthusiast who shot Charlie Kirk. It's not with the NYT writer who wrote that "word began to spread" in NCAA women's swimming that the 6'4" man who was dominating every race and who exposed his intact penis and testicles in the women's locker room every day may have been trans.
It's not with Chase Strangio assuring us all that "a penis isn't a male body part, it's just an unusual body part for a woman to have," or telling Jake Tapper on CNN that kids know they are trans at the age of two, before going before SCOTUS and admitting that there had never been any evidence to support the claim that blocking the puberty of children reduces suicide, en route to losing the case trying to block bans on blocking the puberty of children to "affirm their gender."
It's not with Ezra Klein and Ta-Nehisi Coates gravely, sagely nodding to one another under the studio lights as they agree that the majority of this country have beliefs that are "fundamentally and morally wrong," when they agree that women should have a right to draw a boundary between themselves and all men, including those who say they are women, in their sports and their intimate spaces.
The arc of history is with Sall Grover and JK Rowling and with robust supermajorities of the American public who know that none of the demands of this domineering, authoritarian movement that masquerades as a civil rights movement makes sense to grant because none of the claims they make about reality are true.
Quoting @salltweets: “We have never had any big backers, to this day we have no big backers I currently have half a million dollars in legal invoices sitting on my desk… I was talking to a senator & she was flabbergasted at how expensive it is. Yeah, but at least we’re doing the work. Politicians could fix it for free in a week.”
When I was at CPAC, 100% of people I spoke with assumed that I had someone wealthy behind the scenes paying all of the legal bills. They assumed this because most high profile legal cases in Australia are funded by a wealthy benefactor - the likes of Bruce Lehrman & Ben Roberts-Smith to name just two, the former who even had his living expenses covered during it all - but no, I have never had any offers of major financial support to relieve the stress of public interest litigation that actually does impact the whole country. In a way, it doesn’t bother me, because I think it is significantly more powerful to have 100,000+ people giving $10. That makes a very important point. Other times, it does bother me, because paying for this stupidity is why my hair started to fall out.
I always hate asking for money, it’s so outside my comfort zone. I remember, at one point, when there was a total media blackout in Australia, I thought I was going to have to stand on a street corner with a paper cup saying, “men aren’t women give me money!” But alas, with hard work & a slowly changing zeitgeist, that hasn’t happened… yet.
If you can, please share the giggle crowdfund so that the important point can continue to be made 🩷
Thank you everyone for the continued support. We’re in this together, and we’re about half way between the hearing (August) and the decision (late November/December). 🩷
Men are not women.
http://gigglecrowdfund.com
When he refers to "majorities" of the public, he's referring to the majorities that have said oppose trans-inclusion in women's sports and spaces. I think that's the necessary implication of his words with no realistic alternative explanations.
He has always been very into trans rights and accepts most of its terms but is also into winning elections and proceeds from the approach that you say what you must to get power and then once in power work to entrench your true aims.
The push to remove gender identity from the law is led by left-wing feminists in Britain and right-wing populists in the United States.
(The Trump Administration is in fact informed and directly guided by feminist ideas in the conduct of their campaign against gender identity while focusing their political appeals to common sense and the safety of women and children.)
Both critiques are at heart philosophically liberal responses to transgender activism, which transgresses the limits on the exercise of power that any movement that seeks to operate within a liberal, pluralistic, democratic society must observe.
There are many harms that flow from the moment, but it is the gender inquisition's ongoing assault on liberty that makes it incompatible with liberal democracy. https://x.com/JamieWhistle/status/1972352035724136696
Quoting @JamieWhistle: “Can a person’s counter factual assertion about their inner self confer a right of recognition on the person making that claim; and does it impose a duty on others to agree with it?
My answer to that question: not in any society that wishes to remain liberal, pluralistic, and free.”
@wesyang truth bomb with Andrew Sullivan.
In general, the party has to begin by acknowledging what Newsom acknowledges here.
He's speaking about sports, but it applies to every demand of the movement.
Once you understand that every "trans right" is a special privilege exacted from the rights of some other vulnerable group, you understand how this issue must eventually be resolved across the board.
The party, however, remains boxed in by the consensus of the professional-managerial class, which remains in a moral and epistemic black hole of its own making.
Senate Democrats have already announced their intention to re-introduce the Equality Act, which would forbid any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and any man who says he is a woman.
The main grievance that Chappelle had about transgenderism concerned the ability of a white man to put on a dress and win the oppression sweepstakes.
Why is a black female nurse who was subjected to racial abuse after referring to a white male convicted pedophile by pronouns corresponding to his sex in danger of losing her livelihood? Why is this happening on “TERF Island”, whose Supreme Court ruled that trans women are men and whose lower court ruled that gender critical belief is protected by law?
Was this what the drafters of civil rights legislation intended? That it would be used to strip the livelihood of black women so as to shelter the feelings of a white male convicted pedophiles?
Why is there such zeal to force people to participate in the falsification of the sex of anyone who is falsifying their sex? Why are states throughout the Western world colluding in the falsification of sex of anyone who wishes to falsify their sex? Is the category of “people who are falsifying their sex” really an oppressed class of person whose desire to falsify their sex entitles them to special treatment enforceable by the threat of punishment? Are they a class of person at all?
We are long past having glib sophistries such as these being able to disarm debate.
The reason boys are in your daughter's bathroom and sports league and male rapists and murderers are in women's shelters and prisons is because transgender dogmas were always about overwriting a biological category by a social category in law and policy. This move accounts for all of it.
The absurd and dysfunctional outcomes of these rhetorical gambits are no longer speculative, and it must all be rolled back.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There are no diagnostic criteria apart from saying you are trans. The transgender movement worked tirelessly for three decades to bring this situation about and have succeeded.
The lead trans rights litigator for the ACLU literally went on CNN the night before arguing before the Supreme Court in defense of blocking the puberty of children to say that a 2 -year old can know they are trans.
There's no way to make clearer that "diagnosis" in gender medicine consists solely of affirming a claim, and nothing else. (Which is to say that the field repudiated diagnosis as such in order to become drug dealers on behalf of a cultish ritual that mimicked the practice of medicine while abjuring its essence.)
Quotes a post by T06330; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
What has been written here should be recognized instantly by philosophical liberals (and to be an American is to be a philosophical liberal) as the liberal case against transgender rights.
It characterizes the decisive harm of the transgender rights movement as the assault it undertakes on freedom of speech and conscience. More than any other movement in the Western world today, the transgender rights movement refuses to observe the limits on the exercise of its power that any society that purports to be liberal, pluralistic, democratic, and free must impose on social movements in its midst if it wishes to remain liberal, pluralistic, democratic, and free.
Quoting @wesyang: Transgenderism must revert to being a form of private eccentricity. Recognition as one's preferred gender can be privately negotiated but with no coercion by any entity private or public. We all have an absolute right to affirm or not affirm, believe or not believe, that gender identity exists, that no one can infringe.
Sex segregated spaces and activities remain segregated by sex, not "gender identity."
Adults are free to inflict bodily self-harm on themselves in pursuit of an appearance they like but outside of any pretense of a medical protocol -- these are cosmetic procedures that come with no promises to relieve dysphoria or unlock an authentic self and the cost is borne solely by the person seeking them. Any such promises constitute consumer fraud. Children are of course unable to consent to such procedures.
The state has no role in affirming any aspect of cross-gender ideation, avoids proselytizing to children in schools or to anyone else in any interface it has with the public. The person who has inflicted bodily self-harm on his sex traits is no more a distinct class of person to whom special privileges or protections can be conferred than a person who has covered his face in tattoos. The person who believes with all his heart that he is a woman at heart and would die if others don't recognize him as such imposes no duty on any other person to share in that belief or to pretend to share in it. That person must develop resiliency about living in a pluralistic, liberal, democratic society where every person has a right to belief and a corollary right to unbelief that no one may legitimately infringe.
Any and all deviations from this resolution are morally illegitimate and practically untenable.
The attempt to turn a private eccentricity into a social cause that justified the remaking of society was a ghastly and destructive mistake. It was made inevitable by certain facets of the culture and certain aspects of our politics. We must learn the lesson that experience has now taught us.
I see. DeBoer has made explicit reference to being close to a trans-identified person, so if that is his sister, it clarifies the connection. It's his nephew:
I think it was an awkward way of saying "its rare," + "I'm not accusing all trans folx of being predators and perverts." My QT was about how it's tragicomic that he needs to do all that (and he's probably right that he needs to be careful) when he is actually just calling for an end to self-ID and trans inclusion in bathrooms.
They also terrorize women and children with the active collusion of the staff that said he couldn’t be removed because he said he was a woman and police who said they couldn’t arrest him for the same reason.
The trans movement doesn’t disavow any bad actor. NPR scolded Amy Klobuchar for calling trans-identified male who killed two children in a church a man.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Since the recognition of trans people as their "authentic selves" is enacted solely through acts of speech that either confer or withdraw affirmation of their claim to be the bearers of a cross-sex gender identity, any refusal of a demand to be addressed by one's preferred pronouns is an act of violent erasure.
When trans activists and allies speak of a "trans genocide" they are referring to acts like the the one that the judge presiding over the case of a man seen stroking his erect penis in a women's shower room where he was granted access to loiter naked for hours because he said he was a woman made when he refused to honor the man's gender identity despite his claim to be a woman, the sole and sufficient condition for being a woman according to transgender dogmas written into law across the country.
Senate Democrats held a press conference a month ago to announce that they would be introducing legislation to impose this requirement on every public accommodation in America.
The Democratic party decreed that transgender inclusion was to be the Civil Rights Movement of the 21st century.
This means that anyone who stood in the way of the movement would be the Bull Connor of our time.
Will they send in the 101st Airborne to force the girls of California to play against the James Meredith of the 21st century?
The success of the movement depended on being able to bully and coerce the girls into playing along.
They successfully did it to the NCAA female swimmers who had to swim against and change alongside William Thomas, a 6'4" man. They told them to go into counseling to deal with their transphobia. They threatened their futures if they spoke publicly about their discomfort while changing next to a fully intact man in the changing room.
Will they succeed in bullying and coercing the female high school athletes of California back into line?
Or will these girls bring the civil rights movement of the 21st century to a halt?
Quoting @JackThompsonFOX: An eighth girls' volleyball team in California has forfeited to a team with a trans athlete. This latest forfeit comes from a school in the same district as the one with the trans player.
https://www.foxnews.com/sports/california-hs-girls-volleyball-team-trans-athlete-sees-8th-forfeit-amid-growing-controversy
So it’s not just that the trans movement ensured that there would be murderous psychos in its ranks by ending all psychological gatekeeping and telling 8th graders how to evade it , it also ensures even now that every murderous psycho that claims or claimed a trans identity is affirmed and counted in their ranks.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedinstitutional capturemental illnessviolence terror
Robin Westman, who murdered two children in a Minneapolis Catholic Church, was initially referred to as a man (because he is one), but once it became clear that he had changed his name in 2019 to affirm his cross-sex ideation, everyone shifted their pronouns and NPR even ran a note scolding Amy Klobuchar for calling him a man.
You might think Klobuchar was trying to dissociate the transgender movement from identified with a murderous pscycho — but the movement took pains to ensure that the murderous psycho (who had written in a diary posted online that he regretted trying to brainwash himself that he was female) was seen as one of them and that his preferred pronouns were honored.
Gatekeeping of cross-sex medicalization was never very rigorous but there were attempts by pioneering gender clinicians to keep gender medicalization away from people who wouldn't pass, from sexual fetishists, and from the mentally ill. Though there was never any real science to it, there was at least a functional notion that a distinction could and should be made between an "actual transsexual" and a psychotic person whose delusions included cross-sex ideation.
Now there is no such distinction, and misfit children are all being incentivized to identify into transgenderism, an identity that anyone can claim and that everyone around them is required to affirm.
Since there is no psychological assessment and thus no attempt to distinguish between perverts, psychos, and those who would be able to remain functional while investing all their energies in trying to be something they are not, the nexus between perverts, psychos, and the trans-identified will become ever more pronounced over time.
It's why whenever there is a berzerk shooting involving an ordinary middle class suburban kid, it's reasonable to ask about the pronouns of the shooter and whether they match their sex.
The NYT Magazine published a long piece in 2022 whose purpose was to assure its readers that while there were some people involved in gender medicine who were pushing the envelope, there were also reasonable and responsible actors in the field in leadership positions pushing to preserve psychological assessment as part of the process. It ends "happily" when it turns out a requirement for six months of psychological assessments does remain within the Standards of Care 8 issued by the World Professional Association of Transgender Health.
Meanwhile, the largest provider of cross-sex hormones in America requires no psychological assessment at all and has created curriculum available to 8th graders across the country telling them if a doctor doesn't affirm them in their chosen gender at the first visit or deviates from the "informed consent" (no psychological assessment) model, they should seek a provider that will act as a mere drug dealer with no attempt at psychological assessment.
Trans Activists are so paranoically fixated on "TERF's" and focus their murderous messaging at them even now as they confront a vast legion of conservatives because radical feminists were the sole threat that the transgender movement faced within the left activist spaces that the TRA's dominated before they went on to capture the rest of the institutions of bourgeois socialization. They were a group of left-aligned people who were forthright in insisting that "trans women" were not in fact the world's most marginalized people ever but a group of menacing male oppressors, the first and only women who have ever said "no, we are women and you are not."
They've never gotten over that originary trauma and are hopelessly ensnared in an endless obsessive compulsive loop where they respond to accusations of being menacing male oppressors by doing their utmost to fulfill the accusation.
C3 dehumanizingdenialinstitutional capturemental illnesspolitical enemyviolence terror
Moving to a model of care mandating immediate affirmation with no psychological gatekeeping and thus embracing a "drug dealer in controlled psychoactive substances" model of "care" means that there will be a continuous stream of psychos who are trans-identified.
That was an easy prediction of something necessarily true that we are only seeing the start of now.
Quoting @wesyang: Classic rendition of the "it's not happening" to "it's good" cycle.
To answer earnestly, what's proven here is that there is no attempt to figure out if anyone needs cross-sex medicalization, just an assumption that everyone who asks or it needs it by definition -- the opposite of medicine, which is a diagnostic practice, and its transformation into mere drug-dealing.
What's demonstrated is ample grounds to shut down this dealing of controlled substances under the guise of medicine.
It takes great sensitivity and nuance to talk about the vilification processes radicalizing young white men without either serving as an apologist for them or adding to the vilification.
This parent, whose son was sucked into the transgender social contagion as a way of managing the hair-trigger phobias and fantasies inflicted on him by woke educators, does an admirable job of striking that delicate balance.
She sees in the man who murdered Charlie Kirk a similar reaction formation to such pressures. She sees the terrible, rotten fruit of the relentless polemic being inflicted on her son, and many sons like him, causing them to find solidarity in what rapidly turn into echo chamber that normalize mania and justify violence against the self, (for that is what transgender medicalization is, the infliction of the ultimate sexual violence on people brainwashed to yearn for it) or, in rare, terrible cases, violence against others.
Tens of thousands of parents whose children are ensnared in these vectors of ideological mania that the cultural and educational and political institutions of the Western world are working relentlessly to propagate, are struggling with similar feelings.
Quotes a post by A2267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The transgender inquisition is global and unitary and seeks to deploy the coercive state power to persecute anyone who won’t agree to falsify reality
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨A Māori women’s rights advocate in NZ is facing jail time after a trans activist reported her to police for “offensive” social media posts.
Rex Landy of @[private account] was arrested and charged following a home raid where police seized her devices.
https://reduxx.info/maori-woman-facing-jail-time-after-being-reported-to-police-by-trans-activist-for-offensive-social-media-posts/
I should add the proviso -- these arguments are bulletproof if and only if we remain a liberal, pluralistic, and democratic society in which a right to belief and a right to unbelief are protected. If we transition to the totalitarian social justice theocracy that the transgender inquisition seeks to impose, all of these arguments will be overridden by default.
That is what at stake in this issue. Not just whether your 3rd grade daughter must endure being punched and spat on by a boy in the girls room at school, or whether the state will strip custody of your confused tween if you are reluctant to chemically castrate them -- but whether we enter a new dark age under the sign of progress.
The trans-identified male BDSM-sissification fetishist who plotted to kill Brett Kavanaugh in order to prevent the Dobbs decision that overturned Roe vs Wade planned to murder two other justices, searching online for the addresses of two additional justices
"NYC could provide trans-healthcare for every trans-person IN THE COUNTRY who can't afford it." https://x.com/thestustustudio/status/1952179681593032988
Quotes a post by A2848; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The trans-identified male who plotted to murder Brett Kavanaugh in order to prevent the Dobbs decision overturning Roe V Wade posted about his BDSM fetish on Reddit: "Message me if you want me as your sexual toy to frustrate, humiliate, and control.”
Since 2020, hundreds of "anti-trans" bills have been passed by state legislatures with not one punitive action taken by corporate America.
2016 was the zenith of what promised to be a new form of governance entirely insulated from the popular will, where an alliance of institutionalized NGO activists and corporations would decide what progressive movements the American public would be forced to embrace.
I know. They diagnose by asking "are you trans?" And if they person says "yes" at the first appointment, they say, cool, here's a prescription for cross-sex hormones.
Quotes a post by A0357; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
And whatever Democrats at the national level end up doing, Democrats in secure Blue states and cities are doing the maximal trans agenda with no brakes. Democrats are the national level must be held accountable for what their state and municipal officials are doing. There must be no toleration of any effort to decouple these things.
"There is no moderation of ends, only a moderation of means -- a recognition that one must obtain power first in order to impose the trans activist agenda and that strategic patience and dissimulation are necessary toward that end."
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1955496967070531804
Quoting @wesyang: McBride supports 1.) ensuring that women’s intimate spaces are accessible to any man who claims to be a woman, 2.) ensuring that children are propagandized from the earliest age that any of them can change sex, 3.) forcing schools by law to deceive parents about the mental health of their children 4.) ensuring that chemical castration is made available to children who’ve been brainwashed to yearn to be dismembered
McBride’s goals are exactly the same as the most extreme trans activists.
There is no moderation of ends, only a moderation of means -- a recognition that one must obtain power first in order to impose the trans activist agenda and that strategic patience and dissimulation are necessary toward that end.
https://x.com/TwisterFilm/status/1890230634490237079
Here's "reasonable moderate" trans-identified male Congress member Sarah McBride reading I Am Jazz to young elementary schoolchildren https://x.com/LeanneSpurs/status/1880463183124599157
Strangio told Jake Tapper that children know they are transgender as early as 2-year old and thus have been struggling for years by the time they approach the age of 9 for their puberty to be blocked days before appearing before SCOTUS https://www.cnn.com/2024/12/03/us/video/he-lead-chase-strangio-transgender-healthcare-treatments-youth-jake-tapper
My position is that a trans-identified person is no more a distinct class of person than a person consumed by a compulsion to cover his face in tattoos. The person may have what to him are strong and compelling reasons that he won't be forbidden to pursue if and only if he fully understands, and can attest in writing, that it 1.) does not change his sex, 2.) confers no right of recognition on himself or duties on others, 3.) comes with no legal recognition, 4.) is a purely cosmetic procedure that may or may not have a palliative effect on his mental issues, that 5.) is paid out of pocket, done at his own risk, and comes with no promises of any kind to do anything in particular but satisfy his desire to do it at the time he chooses to do it. If he is fully a mature adult in good enough mental health to be able to attest to all of the above, bearing all the risks and harms and prospective benefits with recourse to demands that others be coerced into participation, then I can see no reason to withhold it, though I do have questions about the ethics of any doctor willing to participate .
Rather than dissociate themselves from a mentally ill man who plotted to assassinate a Supreme Court Justice, the transgender movement moves swiftly to ensure that everyone honor his preferred pronouns
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: It's been 24 hrs since the man who tried to assassinate Brett Kavanaugh publicly identified himself as a woman and Wikipedia has already rewritten history.
Wikipedia is a deep, deep well of leftist propaganda.
The recruitment is furthest advanced at some of the most exclusive private schools in America, where trans proselytizers have ensnared the children of celebrities, politicians, and titans of industry and commerce. The parents then become invested in the cult and use their wealth influence to induct even more children into the cult. That's the usual pattern.
When they captured the son of the world's richest man, they likely thought they had scored an amazing coup and could look to him to deploy his fortune toward propagating the mania even further. It didn't work out that way.
You're so proud of the way you've slurped up and can regurgitate all the slop that trans activist organizations have been blasting out -- that the Cass Review among others has dismantled utterly. Accountability is coming for the medical organizations that colluding in propping up the desperate pseudo-science you're parroting.
NPR scolded Amy Klobuchar for calling the Annunciation Catholic killer, who murdered two children in cold blood, a man.
The NYT misgendered the Trans Woman who plotted to kill Bret Kavanaugh in a prior report -- and now refuses to correct the record.
Are they going to stop honoring the preferred pronouns of men who say they are women just because they are profoundly mentally ill and committed a serious crime?
Quoting @BrentScher: The @nytimes didn’t cover sentencing court docs that revealed that Brett Kavanaugh’s would-be assassin is transgender.
It has more than 1000 reporters. Just couldn’t allocate the resources.
Will it at least update its April article that called him a MAN *gasp* twice?
What is a woman?
Who and what is "trans"?
https://x.com/BrentScher/status/1969389107559235746
Quoting @BrentScher: The @nytimes didn’t cover sentencing court docs that revealed that Brett Kavanaugh’s would-be assassin is transgender.
It has more than 1000 reporters. Just couldn’t allocate the resources.
Will it at least update its April article that called him a MAN *gasp* twice?
Maher is thrashing around trying to distinguish those who are "really" trans and those who are just mentally disturbed youth sucked into a social contagion.
The whole point of today's "transgender" movement was to erase any possibility of setting such a line by making "says they are the opposite sex" the sole criterion for being trans.
You would think that the transgender movement would want to draw a boundary between its population and mentally disturbed murderers.
No. NPR specifically scolded Amy Klobuchar for calling the trans-identified Annunciation Catholic killer who shot two children in cold blood a man. The ACLU specifically has made cause celebre's out of male murders and rapists who demand to be housed with women and demand taxpayer funded transgender hormones and surgeries.
Maher is trying to make sense out of the nonsensical because even now he can't believe or accept that a movement that has such unwavering support from every institution in the Western world, including the Democratic party, could be as insane as it is. So he makes up stuff establishing boundaries and distinctions that the movement is working relentlessly to liquidate.
Quotes a post by A2437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
More on Strangio's admission that there has never been evidence that blocking puberty reduces suicide before the Supreme Court: https://www.city-journal.org/article/aclu-attorney-confesses-transgender-suicide-claim-is-a-myth
Those claims were totally false but live on in the memory of Trans Activists unrebutted: https://x.com/MrAndyNgo/status/1636333348715995140
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: The #Antifa violence at @[private account] was incited with the help of disinformation pusher/serial hoaxer Erin Reed, formerly known as Anthony Reed II. Reed spread the lie that @charliekirk11 called for "lynchings" to millions on Twitter. @sacbee_news published the lie (written by opinion assistant editor @[private account]) & was forced to retract it in full with an apology.
All this proved to have immense utility to the emerging leftism in a new key rising up in the 2010's, as the need for loyalty tests emerged. In the process, the movement memed into existence an army of biologically altered children hundreds of thousands in number who depend on the movement to secure the conditions of their recognition as what they claim to be.
They inscribed the dogmas of this movement in their flesh, sacrificed their long term health and fertility to it, were told that their lives depended on the obeisance of all others to their claims, seek to deploy state power to make withholding of that obeisance a crime, and have demonstrated in word and deed their willingness to kill and die for it.
These photos were taken at a Turning Point USA event at UC Davis that turned into a brawl in 2023. The violent resistance was stoked by false claims spread on social media by trans activists saying that Charlie Kirk had called the lynching on trans-identified people.
C2 false claimscontagionmedical harmviolence terror
Tennessee dismantled the suicide myth in its brief, so the justice were not going to be taken in by the lie. The question was thus whether to lie for public consumption, which Elizabeth Prelogar eagerly did. Strangio didn't lie.
With trans activists, it's not the pervasive lies that require explanation -- it's the anomalous moments of truth telling.
Tennessee dismantled the suicide myth in its brief, so the justice were not going to be taken in by the lie. The question was thus whether to lie for public consumption, which Elizabeth Prelogar eagerly did.
Strangio didn't lie. With trans activists, it's not the pervasive lies that require explanation -- it's the isolated moments of truth telling.
Thorough roundup of some of the leading Canadian trans-identified male activists who spewed hatred and vitriol on Charlie Kirk after years of calling for violence against women who don't think men can be women. https://share.evernote.com/note/e206cf4d-32a8-4f79-b884-80452e10df7a
C4 targetinghand-codeddenialpolitical enemyviolence terror
There are only a limited set of circumstances in which the FBI is investigating crimes. The piece doesn't get into the weeds but it's likely the designation concerns certain crimes where certain conditions are met where there is ideological content to the act. If a trans-identified male stabs another trans-identified male over the a vial of crack, I'm sure local police are treating it like a normal assault.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codeddenialviolence terror
Because "transgender suspects" are a tiny subset of "transgender people." It's identifying a class of offender, not apply an extremist label to the group.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedcrime caseviolence terror
Sensationalistic framing of this kind feeds the paranoia about a "trans genocide" that is inculcated into trans-identified young people as a form of the sort of "phobia indoctrination" that cults use to isolate people from outsiders and keep them under control. It stokes the very radicalization that results in violence.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedideology cultvictim dismissalviolence terror
Deliberately and dangerously misleading framing.
What this story actually says is that the FBI will classify trans-identified suspects as "a subset of the Bureau's new threat category, "Nihilistic Violent Extremists."
Framing it as a "new war on trans people" is analogous to the media reporting the FBI creating a category for "violent white supremacists" by reporting that the FBI is "labelling white people as extremists."
Quoting @kenklippenstein: 🚨 The FBI is preparing to label transgender people as “violent extremists” in the wake of Charlie Kirk’s murder:
https://www.kenklippenstein.com/p/fbi-readies-new-war-on-trans-people
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
This person is a genuine loon who needed to be committed rather than merely an otherwise functional person indoctrinated into murderous ideation by a politics of delusional apocalypticism.
But the transgender ideology makes no distinction -- if you say "I'm a woman," you are a woman.
One can already feel that youthful killers being trans-identified or motivated by trans allyship ceasing to be novel enough to be an important news peg.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
There have always been ways for children to go awry and be led astray, but never one propagated and affirmed by doctors, teachers, politicians, and the culture industries in the way that transgender social contagion has been stoked, never one in which those trying to rein it in or even just tell the truth about were smeared so relentlessly as bigots and Nazis.
The reason why this keeps happening is that there is no definition for a "trans woman" other than a man saying he is a woman, and we have been encouraging every disaffected, mentally comorbid young person in America to identify into an identity that comes with 1.) immediate affirmation, 2.) a rainbow community, 3.) a presumption that one's mental health comorbidities were all rooted in minority stress, 4.) legal access to mind-altering substances on the taxpayer dime, 5.) access to spaces normally barred to members of your sex, and 6.) the ability to extract social deference from anyone you meet.
Once people have glommed onto the identity, no one dares address the myriad mental health comorbidities that virtually always accompany and lead to trans ideation, leaving them to fester and be exacerbated by the inevitable stresses of investing all your being into trying be something you are not and will never be. The people who made false promises that can never be true to desperate and damaged children have a share of the blame for all of it.
Quoting @MaryMargOlohan: NEW: The man who attempted to kill Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh identifies as a transgender woman and was deeply mentally ill and suicidal, according to documents first obtained by @realDailyWire.
Details below: 🧵
This is why the groyper hypothesis couldn't entirely be dismissed at first. Internet neo-identities draw from the same pool of disaffected youths and it's an aleatory process which path they end up going down. Though nominally antagonistic to the death toward one another, the subcultures are profoundly the same. Both lead to the creation of maniacal paranoid echo chambers charged with the potential for murderous ideation.
The difference is that the trans subculture has teachers, guidance counselors, doctors, and the President of the United States cheerleading people on their path to self-dismemberment. The difference is that the open cheerleading for violence in the trans activist online subculture and street protest culture is never condemned by those mainstream institutions while the threat of genocidal danger that creates a sense of crisis and a need to strike back is relentlessly stoked by them.
Three days after a trans-identified female murdered six people in a religious school in Nashville, the spokeswoman for the President of the United States said of trans people protesting across the country: "this administration has their back."
As access to chemical castration drugs for minors is restricted across the United States, children who've been told that chemically castrating and dismembering themselves is their only pathway to becoming their true selves, children who've been taught to threaten suicide to coerce parents into providing consent to sterilize them, are becoming increasingly furious and desperate as the Democratic party holds itself aloof from the righteous holy war that it promised it would wage on their behalf. They are arming themselves to take up this war themselves. They fully intend to kill and die for this manufactured delusion.
The Democratic party is now at a forking path -- will they wage this holy war or not?
Quotes a post by T05857; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Eric Adams is like Donald Trump in that his extreme eccentricity is a mark of his normalcy. Either could be a colorful braggart working for the post office or electric company.
While he was doing whatever he was told by the Blob, Adams enforced trans inclusion policies that he knew were nonsense. Now that he has nothing more to gain by paying obeisance to the Blob, he is behaving like a normal person.
Quoting @ZohranKMamdani: Awful and dangerous to hear the Mayor echo the transphobic bigotry coming from the Trump administration. It's completely at odds with the values of our city and another reason why his single, disgraced term in office cannot end soon enough.
Are New Yorkers eager to turn the city into a transgender sanctuary city where their taxes will be used to fly and house people from all around the country for surgeries?
https://x.com/charliekirk11/status/1952383013503095074
Quoting @charliekirk11: A masked DSA advisor says the quiet part out loud, admits he wrote Zohran Mamdani's platform to transform NYC into a “gender affirming hub,” where people will given free flights, hotels, trans surgeries and prescriptions, all paid for by taxpayers.
The transgender inquisition is a global assault on the freedoms of speech, conscience, religion, and association that seeks to deploy state power to force people to falsify reality.
It destroys the moral and epistemic integrity of everything it touches.
Quotes a post by T05323; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I don't want to overrate the explanatory power of this observation, but I do think its interesting that Milo Yiannopoulos survived the Dangerous Faggot tour during the rise of Trump, when the atmospherics were far more fashy (Tiki Torch parade, Charlottesville, Jews Will Not Replace Us) and that Charlie Kirk, with a much more accommodating Reagan-era lacrosse player demeanor and vibe, operating openly throughout the Biden years to resucitate a normie-frat guy branded conservatism on campus, and after the popular vote victory of Donald Trump, was assassinated when the focus of wokeness had moved to trans rights
Newsom's statement is table stakes for anyone seeking the pivot on trans issues. You have to show you get this fundamental insight, and then you have to propose policies that enact this understanding.
(Ban boys from girls sports, men from women's spaces, schools from propagandizing gender ideology, governments from falsifying sex, doctors from medicalizing children, employers from infringing people's speech rights.)
Quotes a post by T07631; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's about lodging a protest, which no one actually did because everyone was an obedient little sheep despite bottled up rancor and resentment toward an absurd policy, which is what he was stoking with these comments, daring the men to act and calling them dishonorable for not acting.
This is not "insane" or excessive or pushing an envelope in any way -- it's standard issue conservative tough guy talk, and absolutely milder than the "Protect Trans Kids" shirt worn by the Lt. Governor of Minnesota with knives on it. It's calling for defensive action that never came and probably would have been counterproductive politically relative to just letting the absurd humiliation ritual happen so that all could see it and be disgusted by it. But the idea that it's some frightening neo-fascistic call to bully some fragile vulnerable widdle member of the most marginalized group ever, rather than a call for responsible to prevent their daughters and sisters from being sacrificed to an absurd ritual humiliation ritual at hands of hulking and narcissistic man empowered by an unhinged societal project that has to be stopped is ridiculous.
I grok'd whether there was any stochastic terrorism under Trump and the Walmart killer that I had forgotten seemed to qualify. I deleted because while the trans Emmett till vs trans Eric Klebold is a very clean point, the stochastic terrorism doesn't quite pass muster. (Not because of Roof.) I would say something closer to "there wasn't supposed be a white male stochastic terror victim" rather than there was only a victim and no perpetrator.
We're supposed to read this passage and start convulsing and frothing at the mouth in horror and rage at the monster who could say something so cruelly indecent. Some will.
But others will see this for what it is: a tacit admission that the age of emancipation has come to a close. The arc of history has reached its terminus and will go no further. There is no one left to emancipate but the criminal, the mentally ill, the personality disordered, and the sexually deviant. There is nothing left to emancipate anyone from but the constraints of reason and reality itself. There's no more juice left to squeeze.
They brought in their arch-conjurer to refurbish the spells. The piece amounted to a perfunctory gloss of Media Matters for America oppo research. It closed with another pro forma thunderous rhetorical salvo analogizing the present to the rise of the Ku Klux Klan -- "the terrorization of the Black population, the imposition of apartheid, and the destruction of democracy."
It doesn't hit the same way. The need to plug a 6'4" tall able-bodied Ivy League white male formerly known as William Thomas in a woman's one-piece bathing suit and cap into the slot of the world's most oppressed victim proves the utter frivolity and total inanition of their narrative. 80 percent of the public at large and 67 percent of Democrats oppose men in women's sports. The Governor of California has noted that permitting "trans women" to compete in women's sports is "deeply unfair" and that "trans rights" are about "taking away the rights of others."
Nothing will happen in the near or far future to make any of this ludicrous pandering persuasive. It has no power to persuade anyone because it isn't true, everybody knows it isn't true and everyone is tired of pretending. It's an astroturfed Potemkin Village cause, a travesty of a civil rights movement that hides absurdities, cruelties, and acts of political mendacity and medical fraud that would freeze the blood of anyone who learned about what's really going on. But Coates doesn't want to know or care to learn, and so he doesn't. He is happy to use it as a rhetorical weapon with which to flog an enemy so that the act of mourning of him will be seen as collusion with the worst abuses of American history. He glosses some oppo research about Lia Thomas with the expectation we will all rend our garments over it and calls it a day.
The spells have lost their potency.
Fixed it: The reason [trans activists] [send thousands of rape and murder threats] to Rowling is that she [denies their claims] and [funds services for women, a category that excludes men.]
https://x.com/snarky_mk/status/1968148224381948418
Quotes a post by T25707; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Will the new framing be: Tyler Robinson was moved by love and protectiveness toward his transgender lover to kill a monstrous hatemonger trying to wipe him out by denying that dosing on estrogen turns a man into a woman?
And while of course we disagree with the means he used to kill Kirk, it’s really the business of the state to remove such people from society and we should in the future rely on the law (that we must all work together to pass) to censor or imprison them while keeping the beautiful, tender, shining example of this lovely man who sacrificed his freedom so that other trans women could live?
And while of course we don’t approve of murdering other people that publicly deny that dosing on estrogen entitles a man to get naked in a changing room with your daughter, maybe they should pay attention, read the room, and consider shutting the fuck up for all time.
Quoting @CurtisHouck: DISGUSTING: ABC’s Matt Gutman says he’s not sure “if we have seen an alleged murder with such specific text messages” that were “very touching, in a way, that I think many of us didn’t expect — a very intimate portrait into this relationship between the suspect’s roommate and the suspect himself, with him repeatedly calling his roommate, who is transitioning, calling him ‘my love.’ And ‘I want to protect you, my love.’”
“So, it was this duality of someone who the attorney said not only jeopardized the life of Charlie Kirk and the crowd, but was doing it in front of children, which is one of the aggravating circumstances of this case. And then, on the other hand, he was, you know, speaking so lovingly about his partner. So a very interesting and, as Pierre said, riveting press conference.”
From the charging documents:
"Robinson's mother explained over the last year or so, Robinson had become more political and started to lean more to the left -- becoming more pro-gay and trans-right oriented."
"When asked why he did it, Robinson explained that there is too much evil and the guy [Charlie Kirk] spreads too much hate."
"I had enough of his hatred. Some hatred cannot be negotiated out." -- text message from Charlie Kirk's murderer to his trans-identifying roommate with whom he was in a romantic relationship
Quotes a post by T05445; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Karen Attiah's dismissal letter is interesting because it shows that the Post fired Attiah for repeated violations of a social media policy that prohibits denigrating people for their race and sex, citing prior tweets that denigrated white men as a class.
This policy and its enforcement represents a break with double standards both implicit and explicit within the media and tech platforms that banned such expression while excluding the white majority and the presumed more powerful sex from such protections.
It is a break with the double standard that did so much to subvert the trust in and thus the authority of the mainstream press with a growing share of the country.
It may come too late to restore that trust given the paper's record during the Russiagate years -- and its generally delusional and propagandistic reporting on race and transgender issues -- but it indicates at least some attempt to remove a cancer, albeit one that is fully metastasized.
The degree to which the paper and wider mainstream media continues to indulge fever swamp narratives about Charlie Kirk's killer being a right-wing Groyper that have already ensnared millions of left of center political hobbyists in a pseudo reality will be a good test of whether removing one of the worst actors at the paper indicates a genuine will to reform.
https://x.com/yashar/status/1967755385021808729
Quoting @yashar: Oliver Darcy has obtained the termination letter sent to Karen Attiah by the Washington Posts’s HR chief.
The letter specifically mentions her postings about “white men” violating Washington Post policy.
Oliver’s Newsletter: https://bit.ly/4me42St
Karen’s Substack Statement: https://bit.ly/3VOZTcO
The dominant response among trans activist accounts on BlueSky to the murder of Charlie Kirk was to cheer the murder of Kirk and call for the next murder. Some named Matt Walsh. Others named JK Rowling.
This post gives some background on the new culture in which this is the expected response from someone who encountered it back in 2018. It was already fully formed and in the ascendancy. It had already remade the norms of civility and collegiality dominant within the discipline of academic philosophy in the UK. It was why JK Rowling knew that saying she didn’t agree that a woman should be fired for denying that a man could be a woman was fraught with peril.
Anyone who wishes to understand what is happening today should read this post.
Quotes a post by T03032; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
It’s just extraordinary to hear someone in 2025 talk about the “cruelty” of people referring to someone by their sex after acknowledging that the dominant response on BlueSky among trans activists to the murder of Charlie Kirk was to call for the murder of JK Rowling.
Quotes a post by T03032; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
The trans activist movement is global and unitary and demands and obtains the same things everywhere it has power and all those demands must be refused. The diverging desires of trans identified individuals has no bearing on the question of what the movement seeks.
Do you agree with Governor Newsom that "trans rights" are about taking away the rights of others?
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1967261314922815796
Quoting @wesyang: True. None of that is disputed.
What the transgender movement seeks is to force people to pay obeisance to their dogmas, to propagandize children from the earliest age that any of them can change sex, to brainwash quirky kids to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered, to strip custody of children caught up in this ongoing mania from parents who don’t want to inflict medicalized self-harm on them, to prohibit any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and a man who says he is a woman in a changing room, bathroom, domestic violence shelter, or prison, and to force insurers and taxpayers to pay for elective cosmetic surgeries of those seeking to mimic the opposite sex.
None of those things are rights, all of them are imperious demands that infringe on the freedom of speech, religion, association, and conscience of others.
Or, as the Governor of California recently put it:
You know absolutely nothing about trans activists if you think anything was required for them to celebrate other than the murder of someone they wanted to see murdered
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Men aren't allowed in the women's room, no. Bostock protects trans-identified people from employment and housing discrimination but there must be no legal mandate that anyone affirms anyone's claim to be the opposite sex.
I see little evidence of anyone threatening or bullying trans-identifying people at 1/100th scale at which trans-identified people bully others. Maybe you've seen differently.
http://terfisaslur.com
The idea that Kirk used stupid college students as fodder to mine for clicks just fundamentally misunderstands what's demonstrated in these clips.
The students can't provide a coherent, non-circular answer to questions like "what is a woman" because no coherent, non-circular answers exist within transgender dogma. There is no grown up version of this ideology. You never progress beyond what's in the children's books.
When you ask anyone of any age to defend the ideology, some may be more confident in their rendition of the dogma, some may use more facile rhetorical gambits, but none will say anything fundamentally different than "a woman is anyone who says they a woman."
It's why the Brown University psychology professor ends up asking Matt Walsh "Does a chicken cry? Does a chicken commit suicide?" in What is a Woman. The Ivy League professor is not any more competent or skilled than the college sophomore. It's why No Debate has always been the rule, why censorship and shaming came before any attempt to persuade, why no attempt to persuade was ever made, and why the recourse to state coercion, threats of violence, and the commission of violence, have accompanied this movement from day one more than anything else that has ever portrayed itself as a civil rights movement ever has.
Quoting @againstgrmrs: Charlie Kirk never mocked or dismissed young people who were lost in gender ideology. He met them with truth, conviction, and compassion — reminding them they are not broken, but loved and worth fighting for. We will carry that torch and never stop fighting. Today we remember his legacy.
The dominant response on BlueSky to the murder of Charlie Kirk among trans activist accounts was joyous celebrations and calls for the next murder target, with JK Rowling most often cited in that role. https://x.com/babybeginner/status/1966064272552906996
Quotes a post by A0267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
The norms during that period was that you spent a year trying to pass and entering women's spaces before medical transition. Nobody asked women if they were comfortable with this. Nobody gave them notice or asked their consent. If they had, would women have said yes? If some say yes would their yes override the no of other women?
There were just so few people attempting it and thus so few women experiencing it that it never rose to the level of a social or political question.
Then of course everything changed overnight and untransitioned men could be in a women's locker room if they said they were women and if women objected, as they did in the UPenn locker room when Lia Thomas was dominating the NCAA women's division, they were told to seek counseling. 90 percent of trans-identified men are untransitioned and they all must be granted this access according to the movement. The Biden passed regulation mandating that every all such men who claim to be women had a right to access the women's room.
How do we go back to the prior norms? Are there "gender doctors" remaining who will do the gatekeeping protocols that discouraged or forbade male sex fetishists or men who can never hope to pass or men who are severely mentally ill from accessing gender medicine? Of course there are none -- they were all canceled or simply driven out of business by more permissive providers. "Informed consent" is now the rule -- immediate affirmation and provision of cross-sex hormones at anyone who seeks at the first visit.
The European Human Rights Commission has deemed requiring castration of men who identify as men as a human rights violation. The idea of going back to this prior status quo is a complete nonstarter to the transgender movement. Meanwhile Colorado has passed a law requiring every public accommodation in the state grant access to the lady's room to any man who says he is a woman.
If it were not practically impossible to go back, would I prefer a restoration of the status quo of 2006, before the first pediatric gender clinic came opened? Sure. I didn't know or care about this issue at all back then. Nobody did aside from a tiny handful of grey-market niche medical specialists and a tiny subculture.
Can we go back to that? No, we cannot. And the transgender movement is moving away from totally false and corrupt charade of being medically necessary anyway -- and moving toward admitting that there is no fixed and immutable gender identity, just a right to bodily autonomy, even as they continue the contradictory claim that it's lifesaving, medically necessary (in the absence of any evidence that this has ever been true) and real medicine. It's not real medicine. It's a thing that some people have a compulsion to do. Is it ethical for a doctor to cut off a penis because a person has a compulsion for that? Is it ethical to cut of an arm? No, of course it isn't. But I'm willing to say it shouldn't be banned for adults if and only if all pretense of medicine and all entitlements to legal recognition are stripped from it and the person undergoing these procedures signs a waiver indicating that they know they haven't changed sex, they know they will not receive any legal recognition for the change, and will bear full responsibility for their choice and impose no duties on anyone else.
Do religious folk proselytize to children at school? Do they use the law to strip custody of your child if you don't convert them to their beliefs? Do they demand that you falsify reality to affirm the truth of their beliefs? Do religious men demand entry into women's sports and intimate spaces because their god tells them they have a right to be there? Do they call these entitlements they are demanding rights that others are committing genocide if they don't grant them? Are they drugging children and cutting off their breasts as part of a cult ritual that leaves them psychologically and physically harmed? No? That's what transgender ideology is doing at large scale. That "doesn't directly effect you," so you don't care? And nobody else that it directly effects should care either?
What relevance does this question have to my argument? Is murder the only form of violence? Is completed murder the only way to terrorize people into acquiesence? Is violence the only form of punishment that is routinely meted out to people who violate transgender dogmas?
Every "trans rights" is an imperious demand for special privileges, all of which are exacted from the rights of others. None are demands for equality.
All of these demands are backed by the credible threat of punishment or violence.
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1967261314922815796
Quoting @wesyang: True. None of that is disputed.
What the transgender movement seeks is to force people to pay obeisance to their dogmas, to propagandize children from the earliest age that any of them can change sex, to brainwash quirky kids to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered, to strip custody of children caught up in this ongoing mania from parents who don’t want to inflict medicalized self-harm on them, to prohibit any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and a man who says he is a woman in a changing room, bathroom, domestic violence shelter, or prison, and to force insurers and taxpayers to pay for elective cosmetic surgeries of those seeking to mimic the opposite sex.
None of those things are rights, all of them are imperious demands that infringe on the freedom of speech, religion, association, and conscience of others.
Or, as the Governor of California recently put it:
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedchild indoctrinationcontagionmedical harmstate takes children
The transgender movement identifies as a civil rights movement while actually being a global assault on the freedoms of speech, conscience, religion, and association in the service of a cult of medicalized self-harm that brainwashes children to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered
The dominant theme on BlueSky after Kirk's death was calls for the next murder.
If someone can show me a trans activist ally saying "guys, this is wrong," I'd love for you to show me. I haven't seen even one. https://x.com/babybeginner/status/1966064272552906996
Quotes a post by A0267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
It's difficult to be more specific, direct, or forthright than the transgender movement's leaders and allies have been about their open, uninhibited, unashamed advocacy for violence, celebration of it in its aftermath, or immediate recourse to self-pitying narratives of their own victimization after one of their cohort strikes at others in lieu of any repentance, remorse, or compassion for victims.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Yes. I’ve been warning about this emerging phenomenon for several years. It’s really not that puzzling when you look at the messaging from mainstream trans propaganda. They explicitly call for their trans comrades AND fellow allies to take violent direct action.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
https://nypost.com/2025/09/14/us-news/charlie-kirk-assassination-investigation-widens-to-probe-pro-trans-online-groups/
I will be very surprised if Armed Queers SLC played any role in the murder of Charlie Kirk
NYT confirms that the man who murdered Charlie Kirk lived in an apartment in St. George, Utah with a roommate after speaking to neighbors about them.
The story opens by quoting from a CNN interview in which Utah Governor Spencer Cox confirms that the shooter’s roommate, who is cooperating with police, and with whom the shooter was in a romantic relationship, is a trans-identifying male in the process of undergoing medical transition.
Viral misinformation citing prior, erroneous reports claiming that the shooter still lived with his parents is part of an intricate corpus of falsehoods that online leftists have built around the story.
The reason that "trans activist or ally" was always the most reliable first working hypothesis is that the movement has created a pseudo-reality in which perfectly mentally functional people can be easily persuaded to act https://x.com/wesyang/status/1860522561060098510
Quoting @wesyang: We are witnessing the fruits of a decade of propaganda and gaslighting, of emotionally disturbed young people being encouraged to identify into transgenderism and being told that any refusal of their demands (to be chemically castrated, to be put on cross-sex hormones, to have the ultimate sexual violence inflicted on themselves) is a form of genocidal oppression to which violent reprisal is justified.
Here, for instance, is a photo of the woman who would have taken over as governor of Minnesota if Tim Walz had won the Vice Presidency:
C4 targetinghand-codedmedical harmmental illnesspolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
True. None of that is disputed.
What the transgender movement seeks is to force people to pay obeisance to their dogmas, to propagandize children from the earliest age that any of them can change sex, to brainwash quirky kids to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered, to strip custody of children caught up in this ongoing mania from parents who don’t want to inflict medicalized self-harm on them, to prohibit any woman from drawing a boundary between herself and a man who says he is a woman in a changing room, bathroom, domestic violence shelter, or prison, and to force insurers and taxpayers to pay for elective cosmetic surgeries of those seeking to mimic the opposite sex.
None of those things are rights, all of them are imperious demands that infringe on the freedom of speech, religion, association, and conscience of others.
Or, as the Governor of California recently put it:
Quoting @BillKristol: It should be needless to say, but it is perhaps at this moment worth saying, that transgender individuals have the same right as anyone else to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
The question that will be raised by this development is the central question that can never be answered in a coherent and non-circular way: "What is a trans person?"
Quoting @FoxNews: EXCLUSIVE: Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin was in a “romantic relationship” with a transgender partner with whom he shared an apartment, senior-level FBI officials tell FOX News Digital. The partner has been “extremely cooperative” with law enforcement, sources say.
I’ve thought that it was only a matter of time until someone attempts an assassination for a while now (because hundreds of trans activists have been totally uninhibited in calling for it) but haven’t wanted to say out of the superstitious sense that it somehow makes it more likely to happen. But now it’s far too explicit and palpable to hide from — and from the horrible prospect that the Anglophone political and intellectual classes would be as equivocal and tongue tied as they were when they murdered cartoonists in Paris.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
Part of the function that Rowling has ended up having to serve in the effort to bring to heel this ongoing mania is to draw attention to the vicious sadism of trans activists by suffering their abuses herself
Quoting @jk_rowling: The rewriting of history begins.
Opponents of gender ideology haven't merely 'endured unsparing criticism'. I haven't simply been told I 'betrayed real feminism' or received a few book-burning videos.
I've been sent thousands of threats of murder, rape and violence. A trans woman posted my family's home address with a bomb-making guide. My eldest child was targeted by a prominent trans activist who attempted to doxx her and ended up doxxing the wrong young woman. I could write a twenty thousand word essay on what the consequences have been to me and my family, and what we've endured is NOTHING compared to the harm done to others.
By standing up to a movement that relies on threats of violence, ostracisation and guilt-by-association, all of us have been smeared and defamed, but many have lost their livelihoods. Some have been physically assaulted by trans activists. Female politicians have been forced to hire personal security on the advice of police. The news that one of the UK's leading endocrinologists, Dr Hillary Cass, was advised not to travel by public transport for her own safety should shame everyone who let this insanity run amok.
Lest we forget, gender apostates have been targeted for crimes such as doubting the evidential basis for transitioning children, for arguing for fair sport for women and girls, for wanting to retain single sex spaces and services, especially for the most vulnerable, and for thinking it barbaric to lock in female prisoners with convicted male sex offenders.
Now the political landscape has shifted, and some who've been riding high on their own supply are waking up with a hell of a hangover. They've started wondering whether calling left-wing feminists who wanted all-female rape centres 'Nazis' was such a smart strategy. Maybe parents arguing that boys ought not to be robbing their daughters of sporting opportunities might, sort of, have a point? Possibly letting any man who says 'I'm a woman' into the locker room with twelve-year-old girls could have a downside, after all?
Mealy-mouthed retconning of what has actually happened over the past ten years is predictable but will not stand. I don't doubt those who've turned a blind eye to the purges of non-believers, or even applauded and encouraged them, would rather minimise what the true cost of speaking out was, but 'yes, maybe trans activists went a little over the top at times' takes are frankly insulting. A full reckoning on the effects of gender ideology on individuals, society and politics is still a long way off, but I know this: the receipts will make very ugly reading when that time comes, and there are far too many of them to sweep politely under the carpet.
I said at the start of the thread that we have to be careful about this story not being who we thought it was but that "regardless of who did it," the one subculture that was most unabashedly enthusiastic about it were trans activists. And then I linked montages of dozens of accounts on Bluesky calling for the next murder. This fact is indisputable and has no bearing on who the shooter was -- as I said at the outset.
The twists and turns about the shooter's identity reflected the reporting process and I corrected as no developments. I have absolutely nothing to apologize for and did nothing wrong. You're welcome to unfollow if you're not satisfied with that complete and sufficient explanation that leaves nothing unaccounted for in any way.
Now, look, Kirk also said some much more inflammatory things about trans-identified people.
But what he says here is what all skeptics of pediatric gender medicine have always said, which is what the evidence has always supported, which is what common sense and humanity have always dictated, because it has always been true -- decent, humane, compassionate, and correct statements about what is best for a child struggling with their identity.
And the institutions that say it and don't say anything more inflammatory than just, while supplementing it with rigorous evaluation of the evidence proving the claims to be true, like SEGM, have been been branded "hate groups" for saying it by the SPLC and GLAAD.
When you hear trans activists say that Kirk spread hate and advocated violence toward trans people, remember how he actually spoke to a trans-identified female:
--Encouraged her to exercise caution before putting herself on steroids
--"I actually want to see you be comfortable in how you were born. I know you might not feel that way, but I think that is something you can achieve."
-- "You don't have to wage war on your body. You can learn to love your body."
Ask yourself: are these, in fact, messages of hate and violence?
And evaluate those telling you that they are accordingly.
Quotes a post by A2910; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Of course the primary institutions of socialization (schools, guidance counselors, librarians) now supplement the ongoing Internet social contagion among the vulnerable cohorts susceptible to trans ideation -- neuroatypical kids, gender non-conforming kids, troubled, disaffected or merely quirky, sensitive, artistic youth -- in an ongoing society-wide tragedy wherein adults who sincerely believe themselves to be heroes and saviors are inflicting terrible harms on the children they are affecting to save.
The furry reference refers to a meme that the ATF investigators may have mistaken for a trans reference. It was part of a preliminary internal report that was leaked and then walked back. https://x.com/knowyourmeme/status/1966509774452773219?s=12&t=
Quotes a post by T31923; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
He was trying to convince Kirk how rare trans and left-aligned shooters are moments before someone who had etched antifa slogans and symbols onto the casing of bullets loaded into the gun used to murder Kirk shot him dead
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: “The point I was trying to make is how peaceful the left was... right before he got shot.”
The man who posed the last question to Charlie Kirk before he was killed - asking about transgender shooters - has come forward.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
So the antifa thing held up. Among the many reasons that antifa would consider Kirk a fascist who deserves to die is that he believes that men can't be women. It would be one of the most prominent of such reasons, as anyone who has seen an antifa or seen a mugshot lineup of those arrested at protests and riots knows. Nearly everyone arrested for property destruction at Tesla dealerships has been trans-identified.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
WSJ has revised its post to reclassify the claim that the bullet casing has trans and antifa markings on them as unconfirmed. So the original claim by Crowder that there was a preliminary report within ATF making this claim was accurate -- but the claim now looks like it's not going to hold up.
This thread began by suggesting that even if the markings were there on the casings, it wouldn't necessarily mean the killer was motivated by pro-trans ideology -- it might be a false flag or mischief by a nihilistic chaos agent. It went on to document the online community most unabashed in its celebration of Kirk's death.
UFC cage fighting is a perfectly valid form of sporting competition and thus a lot more appropriate than a topless transgender influencer, but I do think the White House lawn is not the right venue for it.
I didn't say it. You said it.
"Transgender individuals with previous convictions for sexual offenses are an under-researched yet growing population in the UK."
You said it to urge me to be more inclusive of transgender sex offenders. I take note of it as a reason to be less inclusive of a growing population.
Quoting @RoisinMichaux: A “growing population”
“inclusive and flexible approaches are key to promoting engagement, well-being, and rehabilitation in this marginalized group.”
No one could say that trans women don't belong in women's sports because the reason trans women don't belong in women's sports is that they are men. We therefore let men dominate women in women's sports.
No one could say that trans women don't belong in women's prisons because the reasons trans women don't belong in women's prisons is that they are men. We therefore let male rapists, murderers, and neo-Nazis identify into women's prisons where some have raped and assaulted women.
No one could say that trans women don't belong in women's changing rooms and bathrooms because the reason they don't belong in women's changing rooms and bathrooms is that they are men. We therefore allowed a male sex offender to loiter naked in a women's changing room in front of young girls.
They just need a billionaire to endow chairs of trans-paraplegic studies and get ball rolling. They have a roadmap for how its done and proof of concept that anything can be validated
Musk disclosed not long after his purchase of Twitter that the algorithm would be deboosting the content of accounts that directly "misgender" (read: correctly sex) specific trans-identified people. One senses from Rowling's engagement stats that this hasn't happened to her. Or maybe it has and her engagement would be even larger in the absence of this policy.
Quoting @jk_rowling: Rattle India Willoughby's cage and the furious, narcissistic, abusive male reveals himself, every single time.
The trans activist movement created an identity category that anyone could identify into by saying a few words and be given leverage over others that would erase boundaries others would keep them against them.
They thus incentivized troubled, disaffected, and mentally ill youth to identify into the category, which in turn became the sole locus of concern for a cast of affirming clinicians, psychiatrists, and teachers. This would leave the myriad mental health co-morbidities that in nearly all cases accompanied or gave rise to trans ideation unaddressed while children were cheered along as they pursued a descent into unreality that the political and administrative apparatus of this country promised to make true by exerting coercive state power people over the whole country to force them to comply with falsehoods.
This structure of incentives means that over time virtually every disturbed young person from whom the ranks of the violent are drawn will be trans identified -- they will be drawn into a program of self-mortification of their bodies by the false promises of the movement and they will be further disaffected when those promises prove to be false over the medium term as the politico-therapeutic apparatus that promises to remake the world for their convenience proves incapable of delivering on that promise.
These problems are all the necessary and unavoidable entailments of a quixotic and totalitarian political project made up of equal parts scientific and medical fraud, moral and intellectual sophistry, political and legal mendacity, and they cannot be wished away. There has already been a trans Manson Family (the Zizians), a movement desperately eager to generate a trans Emmett Till has already generated a two trans Eric Klebolds. There is worse already baked in. The fault of all of it will be solely on the trans activist movement that declared itself the civil rights movement of the 21s century and no one else.
Quotes a post by T08581; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcontagioninstitutional capturemental illnessviolence terror
After the 2023 mass shooting at a Christian school by a trans-identified female in Nashville, transgender protesters rallied in the legislature and held up seven fingers to refer to seven victims -- the six gunned down by the mass shooter, and the shooter herself, killed by police at the scene of her shooting.
Three days later, the White House spokeswoman president said "LGBTQI+ kids are resilient. They are fierce. They fight back. They’re not going anywhere. And we have their back. This administration has their back."
So it's no surprise that soon after yet another mass murder of children by a trans-identified shooter, the movement are acting like they are the victims while also marking the site of a mass killing perpetrated by one of their own with their flag.
Quoting @MaryMargOlohan: Directly across the street from Annunciation Catholic Church, where a trans-identifying man slaughtered school children as they prayed, someone is flying a transgender flag next to the signs: “PROTECT KIDS NOT GUNS.”
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionvictim dismissalviolence terror
Trans-identified male WPATH president Marci Bowers, who botched a 17-year old Jazz Jennings' vaginoplasty on reality TV, said that people who do this are "kooky".
The basic asymmetry is that majority opinion is passive and thus inert while the opinion of a passionate vanguard is active and thus charged with power in a system that amplifies passionate vanguards.
The answer is to help the majority to understand that "trans inclusion" means when a male registered sex offender is loitering naked in the girls room before young children, the staff will explain that he has every right to be there because he says he is a woman -- and thus to inspire the majority to become more active in their opinion.
There also needs to be an empowered, institutionally-backed counter-vanguard just as impassioned about pushing back on the mania as is the vanguard pushing the mania.
Quotes a post by T04928; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It means something that a movement that is desperately eager for a trans Emmett Till has instead gotten two trans Eric Klebolds. It is just one of many clues that the arc of history will not bend toward taxpayer funded facial feminization surgeries in the long run.
Quotes a post by T02635; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedgov spendingshooter attributionviolence terror
It seems so surprising because it's wrong: the term was definitely in circulation prior in 2018, but not that many years before it. Another LLM fail. https://www.vox.com/identities/2017/3/15/14910900/chimamanda-ngozi-adichie-transgender-women-comments-apology
It's easy to reverse engineer the manufacture of the slogan "Trans Women are Women" from the polemical necessities generated by otherwise unanswerable questions such as these:
https://x.com/CindyHoedel/status/1963350461848731699
Quotes a post by T23588; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I'm quite sure that Rowling didn't imagine inviting the Scottish state to arrest her would or could ever be part of her life's trajectory until moments before tweeting the invitation.
I'm sure it didn't feel entirely real even after having done so.
Glinner's arrest concretizes what has remained in the domain of the speculative until yesterday -- for everyone, for us, for them, for the world.
Yes, we are in fact really doing this thing that is embedded within the very structure of the transgender movement: we are using the violence of the state to root out blasphemy.
This thread describes the hysterical fear created by narrative enforcement around the issue of "trans women" (who are men) in women's sports at the peak of the mania.
Makes it all the more bizarre that the NYTimes would choose this very moment when there is a bit of glasnost on the derangements to publish a piece in all earnestness describing the 6'4" male Lia Thomas as "indistinguishable" from the seven women he was racing against, and referring to "word spreading" over the course of months that he was transgender, as if the intact male genitals he paraded around the women's locker room left room for speculation.
It underscores that there are indeed fully brainwashed cultists still operative within media and not just otherwise rational people terrorized into compliance, though there are more of the latter than the former. A combination of active delusion and moral cowardice created and sustained the mania and continues to sustain it within the Democratic party and whole of the Blue Stack.
Quotes a post by T01704; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The trans rights movement chose the path of censorship, shaming, and state coercion because their dogmas are unpersuasive because they are false.
They chose the optimal path given what they had to work with, though it's looking, fortunately, like the path that took them further faster in obtaining disciplinary power over the public than any comparable moment in world history will not pan out in the long run.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This was the guidance that was given to women if they saw a man in the ladies room.
But after a decade or so ago, this guidance changed. The new guidance told women that if a man was dressed as a woman (or merely claimed to be one, the sufficient condition for actually being one according to transgender dogma) that he had as much right as they did themselves to be in the ladies room. Indeed, if the women felt threatened or even discomfited by the presence of a male person in an enclosed space with one exit where women get half-naked while attending to intimate bodily functions, this was a sign of their emotional or psychological issues that would have no standing before the law. Such emotions, if acted upon, could in fact serve as the basis of a harassment charge against the woman herself. Many women's bathrooms in Blue America began to feature placards with pious little homilies sternly lecturing prospective women that it was their duty to "mind their own business" when confronted by strange men who claim to be women in their bathrooms.
It quickly proceeded to the point where a male sex offender was given license to loiter naked for hours in a high schools girl's room in Virginia in front of young girls over the course of months. When women complained to the staff about a naked man in the girl's room they were told (quite correctly) that Virginia state law gave the man equal standing to be present in the girl's room because he said that he was a woman -- a requirement that Joe Biden's Department Education tried to impose on every school in America, and that every House Democrat in the country has repeatedly voted to impose as a rule on every public accommodation in America.
And now @glinner is facing a criminal charge for trying to re-establish the prior guidance about how to react to a man in a woman's room in a tweet. Glinner's advice on how a woman could defend herself against a member of the stronger sex is an "incitement to violence." His attempt to reformat public expectations in conformance with a recent UK Supreme Court holding that "woman" is a category grounded in biological sex rather than subjective feelings was framed -- by the British police -- as a crime meriting arrest at Heathrow by five armed and uniformed officers.
This is where the transgender movement was always headed -- toward arresting people for rejecting its dogmas and speaking in ways that treated men who claim to be women as a subcategory of men rather than a subcategory of woman. This is what decades of steady marching through legal and governmental institutions by transgender activists always targeted: the overt criminalization of non-affirmation of transgender dogma.
Quoting @FondOfBeetles: First, try to escape/run away.
Second, try to attract attention/scream/make noise.
But third, *if you have no choice but to defend yourself*, knee him in balls. Or kick him in the balls. Or punch him in the balls. And do it as hard as you can, make it count.
Said every parent to every daughter, forever, in what used to be an entirely uncontroversial life lesson.
#IStandWithGlinner
I guarantee that none of these girls will look back at these photos and feel ashamed. None will think they were on the wrong side of history. None will compare themselves to the white Southerners screaming at Civil Rights marchers because they demonstrated for the preservation of spaces from which men would be excluded.
All will recognize that they saw that the transgender movement was an absurd travesty of a civil rights movement that tried to use coercive state power to inflict absurdities and cruelties on them and they acted to stop it.
Perhaps they will have been crushed by the giant agglomeration of power that sought to force them to acquiesce in an assault on their privacy and dignity while masquerading as the vanguard of a beautiful future that in fact meant the chemical and surgical mortification of confused children's bodies. Perhaps they will have succeeded in beating back a global assault on their freedoms of speech, conscience, association, and religion.
In either case they will know they were morally right and righteous and they did the right thing and that the forces arrayed against them were insidious and despotic and deserved to be defeated utterly.
Quoting @bourne_beth2345: HEROINES
“No boys in girls spaces!!”
Courageous girls standing up for themselves this morning in front of Temecula Valley Unified @[private account] middle school in SoCal.
h/t: @[private account]
No one investigates it. No one condemns it. No one criticizes it.
All anyone does is indulge and ignore it.
Even in the wake of the second mass murder of children in a church by a trans-identified person, all anyone does is scold politicians for misgendering the killer.
Quoting @andrewdoyle_com: To put @Glinner’s arrest over a few harmless tweets in context, have a look at this website.
Then ask yourself: given that violent language and online threats are so normalised in trans activist circles, why do the UK police never investigate those?
https://terfisaslur.com/
C2 false claimshand-codedcoverupmedia pronoun complaintshooter attributionviolence terror
What did y’all think “trans women are women” meant? Vibes? Papers? Essays?
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: In our recent interview, Graham Linehan described the grim reality of why he moved to the US.
“At the moment we have UK police basically acting as a goon squad for a bunch of petty criminals who have have started to wear dresses and found that they they have almost magical wizardry powers over the police forces in the UK.”
This morning, @Glinner was arrested at Heathrow by that very goon squad for writing tweets that offended a man who claims to possess a magical woman soul.
The UK is fully in the throes of totalitarianism.
"Gender critical beliefs" have been designated by courts in the UK as deserving of respect and protected by antidiscrimination law. Linehan's tweets don't just state gender critical beliefs but express animus toward a group (as well as counsel violence against them.)
But whatever specific states do or don't do in conformance with the ultimate goal of the transgender movement, the will of the movement is clear and was for many years executed by social media platforms. If they have the power to make social media oligopolies censor, they will exercise that power to censor; if they obtain the power to jail people for contradicting their dogmas in speech, they will jail people for contradicting their dogmas in speech.
I think they want to sustain the illusion that they are being careful and discriminating about who they target while they establish the precedent that people can be arrested and jailed for blaspheming against the transgender theocracy https://x.com/PennyDraw/status/1962867321728536838
The transgender movement is global and unitary and seeks the same things everywhere it obtains the power to impose them. Its ultimate aim is to deploy state power to make it illegal to deny the movement’s dogmas. It is an assault on the freedoms of speech, conscience, religion, and association that will imprison people for saying that men aren’t women, that human beings cannot change sex, that there has never been an evidence base for transgender medicine, that children are never born in the wrong body, that women need their own private spaces from which men are excluded, that letting men compete against women in sports is deeply unfair because trans women are men, that sex is binary and immutable, that Rachel Levine is a deeply corrupt man who abused his power to advance the aims of a cult of medicalized self-harm that brainwashes quirky kids to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered, and that all of it is in the service of a mad imperative to make a false claim true.
Quoting @SpeechUnion: When @Glinner landed at Heathrow, he was met by five armed police officers, and immediately arrested.
His ‘crime’? Three gender-critical tweets.
As Graham says in his Substack:
“In a country where paedophiles escape sentencing, where knife crime is out of control, where women are assaulted and harassed every time they gather to speak, the state had mobilised five armed officers to arrest a comedy writer”.
Graham’s single bail condition is that he does not go on X.
We do not believe Graham’s arrest or the bail conditions imposed were lawful. We will be backing him all the way in his fight against these preposterous allegations and the disproportionate response from the police.
The idea that you can successfully market trans men to gay men seems weird and implausible to me, but this video shows that among the TQ+ youth it may be catching on to some degree: https://x.com/bourne_beth2345/status/1962341252067975451
Quoting @bourne_beth2345: “I think my trans boyfriend is living a much better life now that he’s had top surgery.”
Today in front of the Davis CA public library I beg this young man to never let his girlfriend have a gender-affirming-hysterectomy.
He says not to worry as they have no plans for kids.
Why did Riley Gaines stop using preferred pronouns?
I suspect that when she was assaulted and held hostage for three hours, with ransom demands issued for her safe departure from the building by a mob of male trans activists at SCSU, none of whom were disciplined in any way by SCSU administration, which issued a statement in solidarity with her captors, had an effect on her understanding of what she was up against.
I think during those hours, the exhibition made inescapably clear that the people she was up against were narcissistic and violent men determined to destroy her right to speak, that imposing a presumption that falsifying reality is required of everyone was how they won in the past, and that breaking that presumption was fundamental to resolving this issue.
Quotes a post by A0267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Do you want a dead son or a live daughter?" With insidious, coercive phrases like these, affirming gender clinicians emotionally blackmail parents into agreeing to medicalize their children. "Support them in becoming their authentic self or you risk being responsible for their death by suicide."
The Westmans did everything they were told to do by medical "experts" to protect their child's life. The transgender movement and affiliated institutions -- NYT, NPR -- were there to demand that everyone not misgender their son, who had written in his diary that he regretted brainwashing himself to think he was female, after he massacred two children at a Catholic Church and turned the gun on himself.
Quoting @againstgrmrs: 🚨NEW: Yearbook photo shows trans-identified Minnesota killer Robert “Robin” Westman’s first year living as a trans person.
His parents both signed off on his transition.
He was affirmed in every way, and yet his mental health only got worse, ultimately ending in fatalities.
But in the process of attempting this delusional and misbegotten project, the transgender movement wound up exposing the moral and intellectual rot of its professional middle classes.
It exposed leaders willing to call this progress: https://x.com/wesyang/status/1961987822543319120
Quoting @wesyang: Trans inclusion means letting a man who kidnapped and raped two 8 year old girls, then raped, tortured, pimped, and murdered his mentally disabled teenage cellmate move into the women's prison because he says he is a woman. It means NPR rebuking a US Senator for referring to a calling a male murderer of two children a man. It means a state affiliated professional regulatory board financially ruining a nurse for saying "human beings cannot change sex."
Trans inclusion means letting a man who kidnapped and raped two 8 year old girls, then raped, tortured, pimped, and murdered his mentally disabled teenage cellmate move into the women's prison because he says he is a woman. It means NPR rebuking a US Senator for referring to a calling a male murderer of two children a man. It means a state affiliated professional regulatory board financially ruining a nurse for saying "human beings cannot change sex."
Quoting @wesyang: "As Patrick, he'd kidnapped and raped two 9 yr old girls. Then while in prison for that, he raped, tortured, pimped out and finally murdered his mentally-disabled teenage cellmate by forcing a tea towel down his throat.
And here was Ms. Magazine, the flagship publication of American feminism, not only calling him a FEMINIST but advocating for him to be housed with women, without a hint of irony or concern for the female inmates."
A follower shared this example of Wu noting how "male-coded" the new male cohort of "trans women" who delight in threatening to rape and murder women who say no to them are. The parsimonious explanation here is that they are all men.
https://x.com/BriannaWu/status/1961781845105758280
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Beth is a sane person clinging to sanity in a world where insanity has been normalized and is enforced by governing authority. It is a world where messages such as:
Love the body you're in
Boys can't be girls
No tampons in boys bathrooms
are regarded and treated as threats to the safety of the student population.
California and Colorado and Oregon and Washington and Wisconsin and Minnesota and New York schools (among many others) are places where the trans affirming echo chamber establishes dogma and punishes those dissent from it.
Tutelary and disciplinary institutions where classes of persons whose freedoms are restricted (schools, women's prisons) are the domains where we see the social justice theocracy at work, exercising unconstrained power to enforce its dictates.
NPR is the national media voice of this emerging new ruling consensus. In this consensus, the most important thing after a trans-identified male goes on a killing spree in a Catholic church is to ensure that no one misgenders the killer.
What is being done on NPR is being presented as the only truth in tens of thousands of elementary school classrooms across America serving tens of millions of children.
Quoting @bourne_beth2345: A few favorites from today @[private account]
Love the body you’re in
Boys can’t be girls
Your body is perfect
Why are their tampons in boys bathroom?
Why is the mass shooter of children who legally changed his name to align with his female gender identity at 17 any more or less of a woman than the married conservative pundit and father of two daughters who declared himself a woman in late middle age?
Both said that they were women, which is the sole criterion for who must be referred to as a woman and who must be granted access to women's intimate spaces, according to the dogmas of the transgender movement, which Riedl zealously advocates.
NPR and other outlets are merely enforcing compliance with this rule -- the same rule, by the way, that we are all observing when we honor the preferred pronouns of Jessica Riedl. Who is Riedl to tell veterans of the movement upon which his own recognition as a woman relies what is and isn't proper?
There is no more basis to call Jessica Riedl, a middle-aged father of two daughters who purports to have known he was "really a girl" since the age of four, and to have taken a nonexistent brain scan test that proved he had a "female brain", a woman, than there is to call a confused and disturbed teenage boy caught up in an online social contagion. If we are doing it for the one we are doing it for the other and vice versa. No male sexual fetishist left behind. That's the rule that NPR is enforcing. How dare he question it?
The transgender youth social contagion is one that Riedl helped to stoke by linking to maudlin propaganda from the Trevor Project and GLAAD falsely portraying age limits on child sex changes as warlike acts against "trans kids" that result in suicide in his "coming out" post. It is neither of those things, but middle-aged married fathers of two daughters who claim to have "always known" they were little girls since they were 4 years old (before growing up and marrying a woman and fathering two daughters with her and then assuring the world that mommy is overjoyed to be in a lesbian relationship and their daughters delighted to have to call dad "mommy" lest another crying jag ensue) rely on the sustenance of such plainly deranged, delusional, and manipulative falsehoods to blackmail and bully the world into calling them "women".
And of course they have a range of accomplices and enablers (aside from New York state government and the political, medical, legal, educational, and cultural establishments of the Western world) -- conservative white male useful idiots brimming over with pride at having a "trans friend" and loving their moment in the spotlight proving what good people they are by writing pious little homilies about being moved and inspired by their friend's courage to live authentically -- thereby locking the wife and children of this man into a cage where they are forced to affirm him or be reviled as hateful bigots. And then accusing those who are skeptical of this narrative of indecency. Who is the indecent one here? The man forcing his wife and daughters to live in a perverse pseudo-reality to affirm dad's autogynephilic sexual fetish that he wants to llive full time and all his enablers -- or those who find this problematic?
And yes, of course, it's true that the trans-identified male mass shooter who killed two children at a Catholic school harbored some regret for having "brainwashed" himself into thinking he was female that he recorded in his diary and posted online right before killing two children in cold blood. You think those private regrets make him different from anyone devoting their life's energies into falsification of their sex? You think anyone engaging in such exhibitions isn't privately riven by nagging self-doubt and concern that the charade they are indulging is in fact a charade? If so, it's you that doesn't know anything about trans people -- or about humanity or truth or reality.
Quoting @megbasham: The Dispatch’s transgender writer who we were assured was only going to offer economic commentary objects to the reporting of plain facts about the Minneapolis killer.
You can imagine a trans movement that would want to dissociate itself from child murderers. But the reality of this trans movement comes into sharper focus when you understand that for them its vitally important to advocate on their behalf.
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
You can't be more explicit than this. The Vertically Integrated Messaging Apparatus spent a decade meme-ing into existence a population of psychologically troubled youth who've been told their lives depend on access to chemical castration drugs, steroids, and surgical removal of healthy body parts, that misgendering is genocide, that exclusion from women's spaces is Apartheid, and that death is preferable to detransition.
We already know how millenarian pseudo-political cargo cults based on systematic delusions tend to go: we saw the frenzied bloodbath that the political cults of the 1960's turned into. There has already been a Trans Manson Family (look up the Zizian murder cult), there will likely be a Trans Jonestown.
The difference this time around is that the millennarian pseudo-political cargo cult is state sanctioned and backed by a gigantic machinery of public-private interest groups that encompasses the legal, medical, corporate, commercial, and educational establishments of the Western world. So the ensuing conflict will not be as small as the crackup of the radical New Left Underground; it will be something on the scale between that event and the Reformation.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: I told you that it’s a threat of violence.
The simple answer that the media outlets who correctly sexed the trans-identified mass shooter reconnected with this week is that newspapers that report on reality shouldn't engage in sex falsification through wrong pronoun usage ever.
Whether the trans-identified male chiefly regrets "brainwashing himself" into believing he was a woman or rallied in his last days and decided that he would kill and die as a woman is of no relevance to the fact that he was at every point in his gender journey a man.
Newspapers should refer to people by their sex and can refer to their trans-identification to clarify any ambiguity.
How irritating and demoralizing that everyone who made a hash of the response to Minneapolis going up in flames in 2025 is still in place today to mislead the public once again about the ongoing transgender social contagion they are stoking https://x.com/thecjpearson/status/1960763431906369725
Quoting @Cjpearson: Minneapolis Mayor: "Minneapolis will be a safe haven for the trans community."
Minnesota Governor: "We are a safe haven for transgender individuals."
Minnesota AG: "We're suing Trump for gender affirming care."
Minnesota Lt. Governor: "When our children tell us who they are, it's our jobs as grown ups to believe them."
Liberals are caught in a conundrum of their own making: "trans identity" in this particular young person is merely one episode in a young person's acting out of antisocial impulses as it is in virtually all cases.
But it has to be treated like "who he really is," in accordance with the dogmas that have been imposed on medical practice and public life, and thus the mayor has to make indignant speeches about "villainizing" trans people, thereby adding to the taboos that prevent any realistic discussion about what's going on with our young people, thereby keeping them in the trapped in the cages in which our inclusiveness placed them.
Things that were unsurprising two years ago: that a trans-identified woman still living with her parents in her late twenties went on a shooting rampage and that a few day later Joe Biden's spokeswoman said of trans-identified young people "this administration has their back."
Things that are unsurprising today: that a trans-identified man who regretted "brainwashing himself" into thinking he was a woman went on a shooting rampage and the mayor of Minneapolis. best known for breaking down in tears in front of George Floyd's casket, went on a tirade about "villainizing" trans people.
It's not about villainizing anyone but understanding the cascade of online social contagions that destroyed the psyche of the killer, of which trans identification was one particularly harmful and destabilizing one that left him susceptible to other, worse, contagions.
The trans contagion was especially important because it is a contagion that America's professional classes work tirelessly to propagate to children from the earliest age and to affirm in anyone caught up in it, thus leaving the many mental health comorbidities that give rise to trans ideation unaddressed and left to fester, while siphoning off mental energy that could be used to heal into a compulsive and futile pursuit of a delusional fantasy that can never be true.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcontagionmedical harmmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
People should not be presenting speculation as fact. And my original tweet is about how trans is just a part of the complex of mental health problems, so we agree.
All this Calvinball over whether he was or wasn't "really" trans, whether the press should hide his trans identification to dissociate an act of mass murder from a "marginalized minority" group, insist on honoring his preferred pronouns, or disclaim him as a "detransitioner" -- just underscores the point that there is no "real" trans with a stable, coherent referent to counterpose against the moral and mental chaos that has been reified in rhetoric rather than reality into "trans identity."
All it ever was in this or any other case is a maladaptive coping mechanism for the serious mental health comorbidities that virtually always accompany and/or give rise to trans ideation in teenagers who've been made impossible promises by ideologized adults, teachers, politicians, unscrupulous quack doctors, and cultists who have infiltrated the American professional class and reap a rich bounty in money and clout by brainwashing confused teenagers into yearning to be chemically castrated and dismembered.
There is of course no stable, coherent definition of "trans" other than "possessed of a false belief that can never be true that a boy is really a girl or "vice versa," and all the Chinese fire drills over how to refer to this person in the press just underscore this reality.
Trans visibility has been important in helping the public adjudicate the question of whether and to what extent to accommodate the demands of the transgender movement.
It's important to listen to trans people speaking -- and to watch what they do.
Quoting @xx_xyathletics: Can a movement built on anger achieve anything good?
Nondiscrimination against the religious means not treating someone of one religion differently than they would someone of another religion. It does not require participation in any particular religion’s rituals or affirmation of its beliefs.
Transgenderism is different in that it defines unbelief in its tenets — that having an inner subjective feeling of being a woman is what constitutes oneself (or anyone) as a woman — and withholding of participation in the accompanying rituals of belief in those tenets as a violation of a right that the bearer of a transgender identity holds.
Does my inner belief that I have a cross-sex “gender identity” confer a right of recognition onto me and a corresponding duty of recognition onto others that is enforceable by state power?
In my view, the answer cannot be yes in any society that purports to be liberal, pluralistic, democratic and free.
Blue states and cities have been repurposing civil rights law to build the outlines of a social justice theocracy with the transgender identity as a key lever, but it’s high time to subject this ghostly construct to the test of American constitutional law.
Quoting @christopherrufo: Deirdre McCloskey is a good example. Under DC law, his employer is required to affirm that he is a woman, although he is, in fact, a man. Even if McCloskey does not seem coercive in his personal behavior, the underlying concept eventually requires a public consensus—not to mention the fact that transgender identity operates on the principle of social contagion, which means that men such as McCloskey are setting an example that is not only destructive for them, but destructive for others. Even if you're a Lockean liberal, you'd have to concede that Locke and the founders believed that right existed in accordance with virtue. Only a libertarian, who has shed half of that pair, could argue that men who masquerade as woman is a "natural right."
Some outlets began the day by calling the male transgender mass shooter a man but by the end of the day pivoted back to honoring his preferred pronouns. The initial impulse seems to be to dissociate the category from child murder, but the members weren’t having it:
Quoting @marycatedelvey: On Reddit now: “Don’t misgender,” “She is a female school shooter,” “don’t deadname her”
Robert Westman is a grown man who just murdered children.
It’s no surprise that this movement whose goal is to force the whole world to affirm falsehoods generates the most brazen lie ever told nearly every day. One day it’s an overstatement of the suicide rate for trans-identified youth by four orders of magnitude by the head of the American Medical Association. The next day it’s the NYT claiming that 1.) a 6’4” man was visually indistinguishable from the women he was racing against, 2.) news spread slowly that the 6’4” man racing against women that he wasn’t actually a women, and 3.) it was the diabolical design of one conservative female swimmer to convince the world that men who claim to be women aren’t “fully truly women,” and it was her success as an influencer that persuaded 80 percent of the public that men can’t be women because they are men.
Quoting @JenniferSey: "One of Sey's biggest takedowns of the Times' story, written by Dallas-based reporter Ruth Graham, is her description of the defining competitive moment between Thomas and Gaines, with all eight swimmers taking part in the championship race looking 'indistinguishable from one another.'
No, they did not look indistinguishable. Will Thomas is 6-foot-4 with the broad shoulders and wing span of a man. None of the women look anything like him. But the writer tries to make the case from the outset that Thomas is just another woman."
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/othersports/article-15041687/New-York-Times-Riley-Gaines-profile-petty-misguided-transgender.html
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1648108470774710272
Trans activists and their allies took the occasion of one of their own massacring Christian children at a school as an opportunity to indulge in self-pity and to portray themselves as victims in 2023.
Quoting @wesyang: Trans protesters at the Tennessee capitol held up seven fingers to signify seven victims of trans-identified shooter Audrey's Hale mass murder in a school -- six victims that she killed, including three young children, and Hale herself, killed by a police officer
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyshooter attributionvictim dismissalviolence terror
Actually one of the first male convicts to be moved into a women's federal prison in the US a decade ago was a trans-identified Neo-Nazi. Just a few weeks ago it came out that a bearded neo-Nazi in Germany was transferred to a woman's prison because he said he was a woman, the sole criterion for who qualifies for recognition by the German state as transgender. The German self-ID law allows anyone to change their gender once a year and also allows them to sue people for misgendering, which the German neo-Nazi who has been moved into a woman's prison is now doing against several media outlets that referred to him as a man. If the Minnesota anti-Trump, pro-Palestine, neo-Nazi mass shooter who killed two children at a Catholic school had survived to be incarcerated, he would have been held in a woman's prison because he said he was a woman, the sole criterion for inclusion in a woman's prison. A federal court judge recently ruled that Trump was forbidden by the US Constitution from removing male rapist and murderers from the federal prisons because you see, James Madison and Thomas Jefferson intended to forbid the US President from removing male rapists and murderers from women's prisons. You'd know that if you understood Constitutional law.
Quoting @cenkuygur: The shooter in Minneapolis was a trans, neo-nazi. That's a new one. And hated Trump. This is a category I didn't realize existed. Hates Israel and Muslims - and then shoots up a church. Of all the psycopaths who become mass shooters or terrorists, this might be the strangest one.
The transgender movement is global and unitary and seeks the same demands everywhere it obtains power. It is an assault on freedom of speech, conscience, religion, and association that seeks to conscript state power to punish people who won't falsify reality.
Quotes a post by A1534; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Several TV news outlets and newspapers were referring to the trans-identified male mass shooter as "he" earlier in the day, but the NYT as pivoted back to honoring the preferred pronouns of the killer
NPR is simply applying its transgender inclusion policy to the mass shooter as it would to any other man who says he is a woman. The mass shooter is no more or less of a woman than Sarah McBride or Rachel Levine. All are men who are say they are women, which is the sole criterion for who qualifies as a woman. There are no exceptions to this rule just because the man who says he is a woman has committed a crime or is visibly mentally ill. They are either all women or none of them are.
Quotes a post by T06816; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The BBC recently declared that it was right to call a trans-identified man who killed another trans-identified that he murdered with a samurai sword "a woman". https://x.com/WomenReadWomen/status/1960635291464548653
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: Joanna Rowland-Stuart is a man. He murdered his husband, who was also living out his fetish full-time.
The two had a BDSM-themed wedding. Rather than exchanging rings, the men, who called themselves "lesbian women," locked each other in collars and chains.
It’s not about villainizing anyone, it’s about understanding a pathological social process that trans advocates and allies have set in motion. Why was a male registered sex offender allowed to loiter naked in multiple girls changing rooms for months? Why are male rapists and murderers being allowed to opt in to the women’s prisons? Why are a growing number of trans-identified youth answer the call to violence that are pervasive at trans parades and in trans online spaces?
It’s all the same process.
What happened, of course, was that multiple mental health comorbidities that give rise to trans ideation went untreated and were allowed to fester as everyone instead indulged and enabled the child to live full time in unreality
Looks like both parents were all in on their son's transgender identification, following every protocol prescribed by affirming therapists -- everything that we are told will avert the risk of suicide in trans-identified youth
https://x.com/MrAndyNgo/status/1960782789407658370
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Minneapolis trans mass sh—ter of Christian children Robert “Robin” Westman came from a very liberal family in Minnesota who fully affirmed his transition.
Westman’s 18th birthday was celebrated by his father, James, in the trans colors and the family had the court change his legal identity when he was still a minor. The reason: “identifies as a female and wants her name to reflect that identification.”
And yes -- of course, telling mentally distressed young people that pretending to be the opposite sex and inflicting medicalized self-harm on themselves will be their salvation while also telling them that the world is full of hateful bigots who will be committing genocide if they are reluctant to force women to strip naked in the locker room next to them is also a sure recipe for exacerbating the myriad mental health comorbidities that accompany and lead to trans ideation -- and that also lead to suicidal and violent ideation -- and acts. https://x.com/wesyang/status/1960783341512458440
Quoting @wesyang: Page from the video of the manifesto posted by the trans-identified mass shooter who killed two children at a church
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmedical harmmental illnessmotive displacementshooter attributionviolence terror
4 out of 15K is vanishingly rare. It's a higher rate than non-trans-identified youth, but suicide is vanishingly rare in teenagers even among kids with the multiple mental health comorbidities that accompany trans identification.
Looks like the TV networks and mainstream papers are suppressing the fact of his trans identification altogether. While it's good to call a man a man (because the trans-identified mass killer is a man), it's not good to suppress his trans identification.
And if the trans-identified mass shooter who killed two children in a church had survived to be convicted and jailed, he would have joined multiple other male rapists and murderers in federal and state prisons in a woman's prison. Indeed, a federal judge ruled that Trump had no constitutional authority to remove male rapists and murderers from women's prisons.
https://x.com/billyhu6/status/1960765960505160048
Quotes a post by T01988; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
From the name change application signed by the trans-identified mass shooter's mother: "minor child identifies as a female and wants her name to reflect that identification"
The reason that suicides and murders by trans-identified youth will become increasingly common is that anyone can identity into a trans identity and all troubled and disturbed (as well as merely quirky or benignly misfit) young people are being encouraged and incentivized to do
Quoting @reduxx: BREAKING
Reduxx can confirm the Annunciation Catholic School shooter is a trans-identified male named Robin Westman.
Prior to the shooting, Westman uploaded videos to YouTube showing weapons, including a magazine painted with the text "fuck everything that you stand for."
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcontagionmental illnessshooter attributionviolence terror
This decadelong natural experiment conducted at the UK's only pediatric gender clinic is dispositive proof that suicide is vanishingly rare in trans-identified youth. All claims to the contrary made by thousands of "mental health professionals" to tens of thousand of parents are grotesque lies. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8888486/
Spanberger cannot provide an affirmative defense for why it remains an urgently compelling imperative to Democrats to force every school in the state to allow any man who claims to be a woman (including an adult male sex offender who was allowed to loiter naked for hours in multiple girl's changing rooms) into women's intimate spaces because she doesn't believe that trans girls are "real" girls (because they aren't) and doesn't actually know why this is an urgently compelling imperative to Democrats.
All she knows is that she must hew to this imperative at any cost, no matters what, even if it costs her the election. All she knows is that nothing matters more to her party than forcing any man who says he is a woman onto the girl's sporting field and locker rooms.
Quotes a post by T09005; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Abigail Spanberger came into the VA governor’s race as a heavy favorite, borne aloft by the deep resentment toward DOGE among the federal workforce who make up such a large and active part of the state electorate.
Prior to the revelation that state mandated trans inclusion policies allowed a convicted male sex offender to loiter naked in the girl’s room, Sears was already gaining ground on Spanberger.
If Sears closes the gap entirely, we will have a clean demonstration of the potency of the gender issue. Rather than some abstract “culture war” that Democrats try to portray it as, these issues have an immediate and palpable effect on the lives of parents whose children are being propagandized to believe absurd falsehoods from the earliest age, to defer to boys who claim to be girls in their bathrooms and sporting fields, to witness pseudo-medical cult practices being inflicted on their peers, to and about whom they are forced to tell humiliating lies or risk punishment.
Trans inclusive policies are a standing invitation for the same problems recurring everywhere they exist and will over time as a matter of certainty create political problems for the party that has declared itself the enforcer of Orwellian propaganda.
Quoting @NickMinock: New: Winsome Earle-Sears is closing the gap with Abigail Spanberger, according to a Roanoke College poll, which now has Spanberger leading by 7 points. The poll in May had Spanberger leading by 17 points. The latest poll was conducted Aug. 11-15.
Quoting @wesyang: The male neo-Nazi being sent to a woman's jail because he claims to be a woman who is suing media outlets claiming he's lying will for sure win. Transgender dogma has defined the very possibility trans faker out of existence. There is no criterion for being a woman apart from saying you are one.
The male neo-Nazi sent to a woman's jail is every bit as much a woman as Rachel Levine or Dylan Mulvaney or Hunter Schaefer or Sarah McBride, and for the same reason.
All of them are men who say they are women -- the sole criterion for who is a woman.
Quoting @wesyang: Many people piled on me when I tweeted that Democrats would criminalize misgendering if they won in 2024 and I backed down because I actually did mean to say that they would designate misgendering as actionable under antidiscrimination law as the Equality Act would have done.
But Colorado Democrats have criminalized misgendering.
Quoting @wesyang: Canada's opposition leader has defended a nurse who was subjected to a yearslong inquisition for saying "men aren't women" and "human beings can't change sex" -- and a bill for $93,000 for the cost of her political persecution.
Canada's Prime Minister will now come under overwhelming pressure from within his coalition to take a stand with the state-sanctioned supervisory board that inflicted this inquisition on Amy Hamm -- to clarify that Canadian human rights law seeks to destroy the livelihood of anyone willing to say "men aren't women," "human beings can't change sex," -- or "I Love JK Rowling."
He will come under pressure from his "nonbinary" identified daughter whom he sent to the UK's only gender clinic before it was permanently shuttered by Britain after it commissioned the most exhaustive study of the evidence in support of claims of the safety and efficacy of using a repurposed cancer drug to chemically castrate confused children who've been brainwashed to yearn to be dismembered and found that there was no good evidence for any of it and banned puberty blockers outside of a clinical research trial.
He will have to say that professing one's love for the author of the world's most popular children's book series is an act of violence aimed at vulnerable members of the 2SLBTQIA+ community and that punishment is merited for that perfidious act of sedition against Canada's culture of inclusion and respect.
He will have to let it be known that dissent will not be tolerated and that punishment will be swift, sure, and ruinous for anyone who violates the sacred Canadian values of diversity, equity, and inclusion lest other Canadians get the idea that they have a right to believe or disbelieve that men can be women or that human beings can change sex.
He will have to set down clear rules and expectations that while people are permitted free speech in Canada, that does not mean one can flout rules of basic decency that command we call people what they want to be called (like the recent Quebec woman who realized she was a woman after murdering her wife and two children and was correctly called a woman across the entirety of state-funded Canadian media) and continuously affirm that some men are women and that people can change sex, as schoolchildren across Canada are taught from the earliest age.
Will he carry out the political will of what the ruling Liberal political coalition has spent a decade working tirelessly to impose on every Canadian institution of socialization?
Or will he shrink from his duty and fall silent?
Will he tacitly permit a member of the Canadian public to exercise her right to free speech and free conscience despite the terrible harm done to the 2SLBTQIA+ community by allowing people to disbelieve their dogmas?
Quoting @wesyang: A nurse working in a Washington State jail has resigned after witnessing the implementation of guidelines that allow any man to declare himself a woman and be moved into the women's section based solely on his self-declaration of gender identity.
She refers to "documented accounts of sexual intercourse, sexual harassment, voyeurism, and hypersexual behavior (including open masturbation) by male inmates in female units," and one instance in which a male charged with extreme sexual violence against female adolescents was housed with women despite protests from multiple staff members.
Professional staff in carceral and health institutions all across Blue America are dealing with these absurdities being mandated by Democratic party officials and affiliated judges at every level of government.
The transgender movement is global and unitary and seeks the same mandate everywhere it obtains the power to impose it.
Quoting @wesyang: McBride supports 1.) ensuring that women’s intimate spaces are accessible to any man who claims to be a woman, 2.) ensuring that children are propagandized from the earliest age that any of them can change sex, 3.) forcing schools by law to deceive parents about the mental health of their children 4.) ensuring that chemical castration is made available to children who’ve been brainwashed to yearn to be dismembered
McBride’s goals are exactly the same as the most extreme trans activists.
There is no moderation of ends, only a moderation of means -- a recognition that one must obtain power first in order to impose the trans activist agenda and that strategic patience and dissimulation are necessary toward that end.
https://x.com/TwisterFilm/status/1890230634490237079
If you didn’t have access to $2.6 million and weren’t willing to spend five years of your life fighting in court, you complied with the mandated lie.
If Grover loses at the Supreme Court, there is no escaping the compelled lie at any cost in Australia.
The transgender movement intends to impose this mandate on the whole world.
Opposition to transgenderism because it reifies self-hatred through mortification of the flesh and requires conscription of the whole world into the service of pathology and necessarily seeks to deploy state power to affirm a falsehood that can never be true. All in violation of basic precepts of mental and physical health that have been fatally corrupted by the transgender movement.
The picture on the left is a cardinal example of puberty blockers "working," freezing a boy in state of pre-pubertal androgyny to look like a pretty adolescent girl. To paraphrase Brianna Wu, "if you want more Seths, then you support blocking the puberty of boys as young as 12."
Wu supports using an off-label cancer drug to arrest the crucial phase of emotional, physical, social, and mental development because he fantasizes that he would not have had to spend 6 figures on four reconstructive surgeries, including sawing off a large portion of his jaw, if he had been able to arrest his puberty.
The picture on the right is someone choosing an ancient set of supernatural beliefs that form the basis of the world's largest religion that spread so rapidly and endured for so long because it answered perennial human needs for community and moral guidance through propagation of highly pro-social norms over a synthetic pseudo-religion that valorizes bodily self-rejection and self-mortification of that body as "living your authentic truth" -- an inherently quixotic and self-defeating proposition that necessarily leads to a hedonic treadmill and a drive to control and dominate others in the manner that the transgender movement attempts everywhere it obtains power.
Without being a believer myself, I judge it to be a better choice of supernatural beliefs.
The transgender movement is an assault on freedoms of speech, conscience, religion, and association that seeks to conscript state and institutional power to punish people who won’t collude in mandatory falsehoods
Quotes a post by A0267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I put this question to all trans allies and Democratic party officials at every level of government, looking forward to rational discussion...
Quoting @wesyang: If a male convicted sex offender says that he is a woman, is he woman? Is it possible to be a woman while also being a male sex offender? But what does one's criminal record have to do with one's gender identity, am I doing this right? If a man says he is a woman, he should be allowed to loiter naked in the girl's changing room, right? And if I'm against that, it means I harbor genocidal hatred for trans folx? Can you clarify whether this is right or wrong? What's your take on whether a male sex offender can be a woman?
If a male convicted sex offender says that he is a woman, is he woman? Is it possible to be a woman while also being a male sex offender? But what does one's criminal record have to do with one's gender identity, am I doing this right? If a man says he is a woman, he should be allowed to loiter naked in the girl's changing room, right? And if I'm against that, it means I harbor genocidal hatred for trans folx? Can you clarify whether this is right or wrong? What's your take on whether a male sex offender can be a woman?
The answer is that the entire superstructure of trans inclusion rests atop the most brazen falsehood ever told. There will be child rapes and murders of women by men granted access to women's spaces based on their claim to be women (there have already been rapes of incarcerated women) and the question will remain unanswerable by those who put them there.
Correction: one state medical board before Alaska banned pediatric gender medicine: Florida in 2022 https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/florida-medical-board-votes-ban-gender-affirming-care-transgender-mino-rcna54632
"We pushed too fast." You do a trans rights workshop for the staff on Tue and the adult man loitering naked in your daughter's workshop shows up on Wed.
And the staff complies with their training when they say "there's nothing we can do."
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1957937812910621021
Quoting @wesyang: Because "trans rights" are a global assault on the freedoms of conscience, speech, religion and association, there will not be Trans 201, Trans, 301, etc.
No change in cosmetics or ambience will make a movement whose goal is using state power to force people to treat a false claim as it were true, as we all now know for sure that it is and will always be, more acceptable.
I am not exaggerating in any way. I am simply stating what the Biden Administration attempted to impose on every school in America and that half of American schools have already imposed.
This is what trans rights means.
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1958897569003618530
Quoting @wesyang: Transgenderism is a global movement and seeks the same remedies everywhere it is in operation -- to criminalize misgendering, to require cosmetic surgeries be paid for by taxpayers, to teach all schoolchildren that any of them can change sex from the earliest age, to snatch confused children from parents who are reluctant to affirm their children in delusions, to brainwash as many children as they can to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered, and to destroy the ability of any woman to create a boundary between herself and any man who claims to be a woman.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedchild indoctrinationgov spendingideology cultspeech persecutionstate takes children
This is just complying with the rules of transgender inclusion. If a man say he has an inner feeling of being a woman, he is a woman and must be granted access to your daughter's locker room where he is allowed to loiter naked.
If you don't support this, you oppose transgender inclusion.
Quotes a post by T03766; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Conor is saying anti-trans bigots would oppose legislation required to give trans people the same rights as anyone else. I deny that -- they have all the same rights as anyone else.
Iran bans homosexuality and encourages sex changes, so this tracks with that. I still find this difficult to fathom -- to think of trans as an offramp from homosexuality rather than an extremity beyond homosexuality -- but I am aware that my own intuitions are more recent and less common than the contrary in the global context.
Quotes a post by T01283; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Proud attempts to analogize keeping men out of the ladies room with keeping blacks out of white bathrooms merely underscore 1.) that "trans rights" is a ludicrous travesty of a civil rights movement, and 2.) that a critical mass of Democrats truly believes its own delusions
The head of the Canadian political opposition is saying that a nurse should not be subject to a yearslong inquisition and forced to pay $94,000 for the cost of her own political persecution for saying "men are not women," "human beings cannot change sex," and "I love JK Rowling."
In reply, this member of parliament and former cabinet minister claims he is "fanning the flames of hatred against trans and nonbinary people," and that defending the right of a Canadian citizen to speak her conscience makes him "alt right."
She is leaving no ambiguity about the fact that the transgender ideology is an assault on freedom of speech, conscience, association, and religion that will seek to destroy the livelihood of anyone who won't parrot its mantras and to vilify and defame anyone who would defend those rights.
This ideology is a nakedly authoritarian force that cannot tolerate coexistence in a liberal, pluralistic, democratic society where everyone has a right of belief and a corollary right of unbelief that no one can legitimately infringe.
Quotes a post by T04039; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
White trans-allies take great relish in the license they think their allyship gives them to scold and lecture black people for traducing the spirit of the Civil Rights Movement
Quotes a post by T03829; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This won't stand up to the First Amendment, but it expresses the will of the global transgender moment -- it is what the movement will do wherever it obtains power, and it has done so in a major US state.
So you think in spite of the fact that the distribution of the 740k trans identified 13-17 is heavily clustered that the figure is higher? How high do you think it is?
The golden age of gatekept transsexualism could never have lasted given long-term secular trends in the culture, and there is no turning back the clock on this.
The infrastructure that permitted gatekeeping was all razed by trans activists and cannot be rebuilt for the simple commercial reason that anyone who attempts such a practice would be instantly put out of business by more permissive competitors. The race to the bottom resulting in the affirmative model was justified with ideological rhetoric but in the end was simply a matter of consumer capitalism at work.
Quotes a post by A0357; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think the answer is that the 740K trans-identified youth are not evenly distributed but heavily clustered (as all social contagions are) in certain classes and districts where the propaganda campaign is most intense https://x.com/fem_mb/status/1958505500859117605
Quotes a post by A0966; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
How we know gender identity is fake
1.) Germany passed a self-ID law that lets people change their gender identity every year and sue people for misgendering them. A Neo-Nazi convict who identified as a woman and is heading to a woman's prison is suing the media for doubting his self-identification.
2.) WPATH, the medical trade association that issues "standards of care" for transgender procedures that includes "eunuch identity" as a valid gender identity that creates grounds to castrate someone in order to align their bodies with their eunuch identity.
3.) Chase Strangio, ACLU's lead litigator on trans rights issue, a woman who doesn't identify as a man but merely as "trans" told the Supreme Court that trans identity is not immutable but can change.
4.) Colorado passed a law allowing people to change their gender self-ID up to three times and another law requiring insurers to pay for a range of cosmetic surgeries include nose jobs, electrolysis, and mandibular reconstruction, so long as the procedure is intended to make a man look like a woman or a woman look like a man.
This is why Amy Coney Barrett has expressed skepticism that the transgender population is 1.) a distinct class of person onto whom protected status can be conferred at all or 2.) a minority group that suffers from historical discrimination requiring redress. It is of course neither.
What is being adduced as "anti-trans discrimination" will inevitably just be some facet of a world designed to accommodate sexual difference, which sometimes requires separation of the sexes for the safety, privacy, and protection of women, which Ruth Bader Ginsberg declared a legitimate purpose of the law, and which no trans activist has ever provided a compelling reason to undo.
It only gets more ridiculous from here. But this small handful of examples should be sufficient to disabuse anyone of the notion that there was ever everything remotely real to discuss here. It's time to shut this mania down for good.
The movement seeks to destroy freedom of speech, conscience, religion, and association because the movement's falsehoods cannot survive in a society where any of those freedoms persist.
For trans rights to become real, all other rights must be subordinated to it.
If you support the continuation of the right to free conscience, speech, religion, and association, you oppose trans rights.
The years long political inquisition of a Canadian nurse by an entity deriving its authority from the state for saying "human cannot change sex" and "men aren't women" is the fulfillment of what the global transgender movement seeks to do everywhere it obtains power.
"Trans rights" means seizing the coercive power of the state to destroy the freedoms of speech, conscience, religion, and association of any who dispute the false claim that men can be women.
Quoting @preta_6: I won’t stop until all nurses & midwives in Canada are free to say that humans don’t change sex, men aren’t women, and women deserve their own spaces.
I refuse to be used as the example of why you should shut your mouth. I insist upon being the example of why you should never.
Chase Strangio acknowledged that gender identity is not immutable and can change. ACB in her decision expressed skepticism that trans identity should trigger heightened scrutiny. The court did not rule on this question but is expected to do so soonish.
The male neo-Nazi being sent to a woman's jail because he claims to be a woman who is suing media outlets claiming he's lying will for sure win. Transgender dogma has defined the very possibility trans faker out of existence. There is no criterion for being a woman apart from saying you are one.
The male neo-Nazi sent to a woman's jail is every bit as much a woman as Rachel Levine or Dylan Mulvaney or Hunter Schaefer or Sarah McBride, and for the same reason.
All of them are men who say they are women -- the sole criterion for who is a woman.
Quotes a post by A2437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Amy Coney Barrett realized this, sought confirmation of it from the ACLU's lead trans rights litigator, and received it: "sex is a concrete, biological, and observable phenomenon in nature," while "gender identity is a subjective belief" that has "no measurable or quantifiable qualities that can classify into a protected class," while "protected classes are established to defend immutable characteristics that can't be identified in and out of such as age and sex."
Quotes a post by T06634; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The founder of the evidence-based movement 1.) did a comprehensive review of the evidence on pediatric gender medicine and rated the evidence base "low quality."
So far so good.
But 2.) after years of bullying by trans activists, he issued a paper last week stating that despite the low quality of the evidence, patient autonomy should supercede the demand for evidence-based care.
That is to say, he 3.) threw out the principles that it was his life's work to promulgate in order to appease activists seeking sanction to keep doing non-evidence based procedures on children.
Quotes a post by A0873; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Because "trans rights" are a global assault on the freedoms of conscience, speech, religion and association, there will not be Trans 201, Trans, 301, etc.
No change in cosmetics or ambience will make a movement whose goal is using state power to force people to treat a false claim as it were true, as we all now know for sure that it is and will always be, more acceptable.
My initial reservations about trans rights stemmed from an intuition that it would necessarily have to become a global assault on the freedoms of conscience, speech, religion, and association.
Now that intuition is just a fact.
Why not just bend the knee, apologize, say the mantra?
Millions of others have done and will do this to avoid what befell this nurse, who was subject to a yearslong inquisition and then presented with a $94K bill for her own political persecution for having said "human beings cannot change sex."
Some people just can't bring themselves to lie, regardless of the cost. Those are the people that the transgender movement has worked tirelessly to destroy and above all -- to prevent from coming into existence in the first place. Thus, their drive to propagandize children from the earliest age that the false dogmas they seek to enshrine in law are the only truth.
An ideology that seeks to force the world to treat a falsehood as true must operate in this way. It must break people who question it.
Quoting @preta_6: Re: accusations of being a “grifter”:
You’re dumb as a bag of rocks if you think I’m better off without a highly-paid healthcare management job with pension and benefits.
Additionally, I dislike the attention my case brings. I’ve turned down many interviews/podcasts. Either because I didn’t feel mentally well enough to bring the attention to myself, or because of legal advice. I turned down one of the biggest podcasts in the world; I said “no” to an appearance there on more than one occasion.
I know I don’t need to explain myself to most. But I did want to get that off my chest.
“Grifters” have nothing to lose and evething to gain. I had evething to lose—and I did.
"Trans Rights" means
-- A regulatory body dragging a nurse through a yearslong inquisition for saying "human beings cannot change sex" and then sticking her with a $94K bill for the cost of her political persecution
-- Washington state forcing a Korean-owned woman-only spa to give body scrubs and massages to an untransitioned, fully-intact man who claims to be a woman
-- Forcing terrified women to sleep alongside a serial murderer of women in a women's shelter because he claims to be a woman in advance of him beheading and dismembering a third woman weeks later
-- Forcing women to change alongside a 6'4" male athlete who goes on to win NCAA championships in the women's division
-- Punishing boys for expressing discomfort that a female student was using the boys locker room with them
If you aren't celebrating these coercive and punitive actions against people for exercising their core freedoms of conscience, speech, religion, and association, you oppose trans rights.
Quoting @NickMinock: 🚨New: Loudoun County Public Schools will punish two boys who expressed discomfort that a female student used the boys locker room. LCPS found the boys guilty of sexual harassment and sex-based discrimination. The boys face ten days of suspension. READ ⬇️
https://wjla.com/news/local/loudoun-county-schools-suspend-boys-students-stone-bridge-high-school-sexual-harassment-female-school-locker-room-discrimination-bathroom-title-ix-investigation-gender-identity-policy-8040-education
Trans rights means state compulsion to force people to pretend that a falsehood is true.
The man is a woman because he says he is a woman.
The penis is female because the man to whom the penis is attached says he is a woman.
Believe this falsehood and act to ensure that others are forced to believe it or face punishment by the state.
If you don't support doing this, you oppose trans rights.
The other cardinal objective of the transgender movement is to make it impossible for any woman to impose a boundary between herself and any man who claims to be a woman or any institution public or private to enforce such a boundary on her behalf.
A woman-only Korean spa where women receive massages and body scrubs in the nude are was forced by Washington state antidiscrimination law to grant access to an untransitioned, fully intact man who claimed to be a woman.
"In a 2-1 opinion, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals said the Washington state Human Rights Commission’s enforcement of the state’s anti-discrimination law did not violate the spa’s rights to the freedom of religion, speech and association."
The movement is global and unitary and will pursue whatever has been pursued in one place everywhere else when the opportunity arrives.
The fundamental aim of the trans movement is the prohibition of misgendering and the compelled affirmation of its dogmas.
If you think you support trans rights but are not celebrating this decision, you don't actually understand trans rights and don't actually support them.
If you aren't celebrating this decision, you oppose trans rights.
Part of a general trend where trans affirming media continual posts things that subvert their narrative as if they buttress is (because virtually all stories do subvert their narrative.)
Seth Moulton doesn't want a goddamn hulking man to be competing against his daughter in field hockey. He resents not being able to say that. He aired his resentment in public and was immediately subject to discipline by trans activists screeching that he was cruel and indecent for not wanting what any sane person would not want and meekly voted against a bill that would have kept hulking men out of his daughter's field hockey locker room, citing completely fabricated propaganda messaging invented by the transgender lobby in justification. ("They will have to do genitals checks.") He is subject to a stifling, ridiculous taboo that prevents him from calling a man a man, from voting for a law whose goal 67 percent of Democratic voters told pollsters they support. And it's all upheld by the obligation imposed on every Democrat to collude in an absurdity that no one believes.
Yeah, that's not what Esper was talking about. He was talking about me saying that JK Rowling opposes trans women in women's sports because trans women are men. I deny that it's cruel at all or that I derived any pleasure from it or that I say for any motive other than its decisiveness to the debate.
And while I don't approve of gratuitous point and laugh sessions on social media, I do think it's vitally important to look at the media that trans-identified people post about themselves for what it reveals about the nature of the identity and movement: https://x.com/Skirt_Go_Spinny/status/1584233670629474304
Quotes a post by A2638; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I have not had many interactions with left-wing trans-identified people in their natural habitats, where I doubt I would be welcome if they knew my views. I would not hide my views but I would not impose them on the ordinary flow of conversation if the conversation did not take a turn to those issues. I would have no difficult delivering any of these long tweets as soliloquies to any of them but I don't have experience doing this.
I have had friendly interactions with trans-identified people who are willing to do things like go to Genspect or come over at a protest and have a conversation out of curiosity. I've had long and interesting and edifying conversations in which I never hid my views and learned a lot about the transgender experience and worldview without being in any way tempted to change my views.
The thread is about "transgender women" (men) in sports. People say that transgender women are men in reply to maudlin and manipulative appeals on this issue because that's the crux of the issue, not because they are getting off on cruelty.
It's not cruel to refer to someone by their sex. It's stating a fact and a relevant one. In the case of men playing women's sports, it's the decisive fact that resolves the issue: men shouldn't compete against women, and "trans women" are men.
The issue is not more complicated than that -- pretending that it is more complicated than that, ascribing ugly motives and feelings to those stating decisive facts: these are the manipulation tactics through which trans activists have successfully bullied female athletes and their sporting commissions and the entire US federal government under Biden, to impose their will in the face of overwhelming disgust with the absurd spectacles they put on in the NCAA and the Olympics.
No one has to defer to these bullying tactics. No one has to accept these moralizing, vilifying epithets. They aren't true. No one has to pretend that sex isn't what matters on this and other issues pertaining to transgender inclusion. It is literally the only thing that matters and to submit to a taboo against speaking it because someone is going to dump moralistic outrage at you is to cede the issue entirely.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I did pose the question why they did this weird artsy little mood piece instead of an investigative feature on "Donald Trump's War on Trans Kids" and don't really have a good answer.
She opposes transgender women in women's sports because transgender women are men. If they were women, her opposition wouldn't make any sense. It only makes sense because they are men.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When people say they support trans rights, they mean they want there to be tribunals that will take away a nurse's license and impose fines of $100K on them if they say that a male person is a man https://x.com/angijones/status/1956202620961599929
Quoting @angijones: Amy ordered to pay nearly $100k for tweets. Tickle wants $100k for being called a man when he is a man. Canada and Australia are the last outposts for the crazy “gender” cult and the legal process is being weaponised by ideologues to deter women from speaking the truth.
Non-discrimination in housing and employment has already been granted. Those are not "trans rights." Trans rights are the "right" to be affirmed and recognized and treated and granted access to cross sex spaces.
When people say they support "trans rights," what they actually mean is they support making it a crime to state biological reality.
Trans rights are imperious demands for state-mandated incursions on the rights of others.
Quotes a post by A1534; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
One problem with critiquing transgender ideology is that it’s scarcely possible to write a stronger refutation of the ideology than the one written by its advocates
They group by sex and than say "transgender" for each sex, but it's unclear if they are asking natal males and natal females if they identify as trans or doing something else more in keeping with transgender doctrines
Hmm why did trans go from 0.4 percent Silent Generation to 0.0 percent for Boomers?
We don't have to ask why trans is 5x between Millennial and Gen Z or 21x between Gen X and Gen Z
What was done through giant federal subsidies, incentives, and mandates can be undone through the withdrawal of federal subsidies, incentives, and mandates.
When they refer to "Donald Trump's War on Trans Kids," they just mean "declining to spend public money on propagating a cult of medicalized self-harm that recruits its victims from confused, impressionable children that the public paid to brainwash to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered."
Quotes a post by A2541; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There's a clip of a taxicab confession type reality show that went viral on here a few times (put it in replies if you have access to it) in which a black transsexual talks about why he never got the surgery -- because he's watched too many of his trans-identified friends kill themselves after the surgery. Nobody even tried to kept track of these outcomes but, even if they did, all were lost to follow up.
Most of the studies we do have have 20-50 percent loss to follow up rates.
Quotes a post by A1825; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Why do you think he's a genuine poaster? Aren't his leaked private text messages to trans-identified friend saying Trump was a fascist more indicative of his private thoughts very recently?
Yes this is a different etiology trajectory than the AGP married father. I did predict that there would be a trans Manson Family (and a trans Jonestown) a few weeks prior to the first Zizian murder being reported in Vermont.
C2 false claimshand-codedfetish fraudideology cultviolence terror
How can anyone who follows me ask such a question? When writing commentary about how a story about a girl is actually about a boy, it is important to use correct, sex-based language. And of course I do not share in the maudlin and false belief that referring to someone by correct sex-based language is "extra hurtful." It's never dehumanizing to call a man a man because a man is a type of human and all "trans women" are men.
Quotes a post by T02354; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The transgender movement is global, unitary and strives to impose its demand wherever it obtains power. Its demands are uniformly Orwellian and will extinguish basic civil liberties wherever it is not stopped.
Australian judges have a chance to stop or empower it now:
Quoting @salltweets: Finally, after 3.5 years, I feel like I can emerge from the Giggle v Tickle bubble I have been living in and it feels so good.
How am I feeling about it all?
So, so, so good. Better than I have ever felt before. Not just relieved but confident.
We took facts & the correct construction of the law into the court room. No emotion, no ideology. Just reality. This was the instruction I gave & it was achieved.
Activism is for outside a court room. Inside, it’s all about the law. My legal team consisted of some of the best legal minds in the country. Noel Hutley SC is one of the top 3 silks in Australia with over 40 years experience. He knew exactly what he was doing and his brilliant final oral submission will echo in my mind for the rest of my life.
Bridie Nolan & @[private account] have been with me on this insane rollercoaster every day for 3.5 years. We have lived & breathed this case every second of the day. We have laughed, cried, yelled, sighed, and had hours long Zoom brainstorming sessions while cooking dinner, hanging out washing & raising the 9 daughters we have between us. Everything we do is for those girls.
The Sex Discrimination Commissioners interpretation of the law is bonkers. It is gender ideology in legalese. It is an attempt to enshrine a zeitgeist into legislation, while ignoring every group the sex discrimination act exists to protect in favor of one group: men who claim to be women.
If they need to create the Men Who Claim To Be Women Act, create it. But women need laws too and the sex discrimination act has to not only include but protect women otherwise there is absolutely no point to it.
The executive branch in Australia (aka the SDC) has gone rouge. The legislature is doing nothing about it. That leaves the judiciary. They are the checks & balance. And in that sense, there is every chance right now to establish that the system is working as intended.
In the first round, the trial was a circus and the judge was aggressively hostile. An appeal court is very different, and this court room felt very different. It is the second highest court in the land and very dry. Some might say boring. Judges are supposed to ask questions and doing so is absolutely no indication of their thoughts on the issue in front of them. It is them doing their job. They need to understand every aspect of an argument to decide on it.
To win, we only need two judges to side with Giggle. While I would love all three, I don’t need to be greedy.
Will this go to the high court (the highest court in the country)? Probably. I would definitely take it if need be, and I have no doubt that the other side feels the same.
Finally, I do want say: I cannot wait to never talk about him ever again.
The fight isn’t over yet, but we’re in the strongest position we have ever been in to win it.
Thank you everyone for the overwhelming support. It means the absolute world to me. Together, we have proven that while gender ideology has institutional support, the power of the people want reality.
I couldn’t do this without you.
http://gigglecrowdfund.com 🩷
Masculinity becomes good if and only if a psychological broken women is destroying her endocrine system and mortify her body in a quixotic effort to mimic it https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14924669/Primary-school-trans-actor-Elliot-Page-lesson-masculinity.html
It also underscores the contradictory aims running through gender ideology as most women are trying to be dudes while others seek to "queer masculinity." Chase Strangio doesn't even identifying as "a man" but only as "trans," which is part of why she had to admit that trans-identity isn't immutable before SCOTUS, thereby undermining any possibility of recognizing the trans-identified as a protected class or even a coherent group.
Do trans folx want to be recognized as trans or do they want to disappear into their new identification? This is an old tension within the category that was long ago resolved in the 2000's in favor of hulking men with beards being able to use the ladies room if they say they are women.
The most cherished goal of the transgender rights movement -- forbidding women from saying "no you aren't" to any man who claims to be a woman -- is on the cusp of attaining its goal in Australia
Quotes a post by A0382; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The man on the right, Sam Brinton, was Biden's nuclear waste coordinator. A nonbinary identified male, he openly participated in spanking seminars and pup play, and was eventually twice arrested and twice convicted for stealing the luggage of women to wear their clothes.
Prior to his stint in government, Brinton played a key role in pushing legislative bans on "conversion therapy" for both homosexual and trans-identified adults in part through personal testimony about his own abusive conversion therapy. An investigative reporter at a gay magazine exposed these claims as fraudulent.
The man on the left, Rachel Levine, was assistant secretary of health and human services. In correspondence submitted to courts, Levine was 1.) found to be recipient of correspondence informing him that there was no reliable evidence in support of the safety or efficacy of pediatric gender medicalization and 2.) found to have used his position in the Biden administration to pressure WPATH, the medical trade association that creates standards of care for transgender medicalization to strip out all age limits on gender medica procedures.
The installation into positions of government power and celebration of both of these deeply unethical men by the Biden Administration partakes of the same process of culture-wide desublimation, capture of state power by a powerful social movement, and action to marginalize countervailing forces who believe heresies such as "men cannot become women," "women deserve private spaces," "standards of appropriate public conduct by elected officials should exclude open cavorting with BDSM, leather, and bestiality adjacent fetishism."
Non-DSA supporters keep saying he'll cut these people loose once he's in power and has to govern. He should be made to own this or repudiate it before he's in power. He has already proudly owned using $60 million in taxpayer dollars to trans children.
The US hasn't seen as stark a preference cascade as the UK because the media continues to obscure the basic realities of the content of the transgender movement's demands.
But when the reckoning eventually comes and Chase Strangio and the ACLU and GLAAD and HRC and the Trevor Project and the Democratic party are held to account for bringing their cause to ruin, they already have a designated scapegoat: they already released a documentary in advance of the Skrmetti decision blaming it all on the New York Times
Quotes a post by A2836; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Public acceptance of "trans rights" has cratered as the public has learned that all "trans rights" are imperious demands for state-mandated incursions on the rights of others
Quoting @jk_rowling: This shift in attitudes shown below isn't because of increased intolerance, but of an increase in understanding, and trans activists themselves bear the greatest responsibility for the change.
Five years ago, a lot of medical bodies (and trans activist organisations, lobby groups and virtue-signalling celebrities) were united in telling us that puberty blockers were completely reversible and harmless. As more and more evidence accrues showing actual and potential harm, public opinion, unlike trans activism, has shifted in line with the data.
Five years ago, the sophisticated, fashionable line was that sex difference didn't really matter in sport. Trans activists demanded that the women's category be destroyed to accommodate men who claim to be female, but the public wasn't willing to pretend they couldn't see the injustice right in front of their faces.
Five years ago, trans activists and professional lanyard- wearers were chiding us all to use preferred pronouns, because that was kind. Now the public see convicted rapists described as 'she' and 'her' by news outlets and are rightly enraged that journalists are feeding us ideological fiction instead of facts.
Five years ago, a lot of people, especially older ones, were under the impression that trans-identified men had all had full sex reassignment surgery and were sexually orientated towards other men. They didn't know that cross-dressing straight men were now asserting the right to enter all women's reserved spaces. They didn't know how few trans women have had 'bottom surgery.' They know now.
Trans activists are to blame for the hounding and persecution of non-believers, which has spilled into British courts. Women have had to fight all over again for rights they thought they'd have forever. The Cass Review brought shame on all who lobbied to continue a broadly unresearched and unevidenced medical experiment on minors. Trust in institutions, in academia, the media and the medical profession has been severely undermined. Politicians have beclowned themselves, willing to parrot self-contradictory slogans and outright absurdities rather than defend truth and freedom of speech.
The stark change in attitudes over the past five years is the direct consequence of the way trans activists set out to 'educate' us all. Giddy with the power they'd been handed by people in authority, they've tried to impose a quasi-religious, elitist, minority belief upon the whole of society. They can't complain (although, of course, they will) that the public has decided it doesn't want to buy what they're selling.
The legacy transsexual population has little relevancy to today's transgender question. They existed under certain conditions and constraints that no longer exist and that cannot be restored.
Quotes a post by A0078; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I have screenshots of a Discord server of 22 high school sophomore girls all of whom are trans-identified or nonbinary. All were groomed into the identity by an LGBTQ+ proselytizer teacher who ran a lunch club.
I don't know if this particular claim is true. I do know the Internet is a machine for making viral contagions happen at any scale. The dynamics are exactly the same in a discord with a thousand teenagers as in a Discord with 22 teenagers.
A million people protested and rioted for months in dozens of American cities because of one death in Minneapolis. It took amplification by the mainstream broadcast media to make it tip into a societywide frenzy, but the Internet is a machine for scaling up local phenomena and turning them into a global contagion. We know it has this latent power because we saw it grip our society.
In the case of the ongoing transgender social contagion, it's taken the active collusion of tens or hundreds of thousands of educators and medical personnel, armies of lawyers at NGO's and at every level of government, to take a social contagion, scale it up to a global phenomenon, and stabilize and institutionalize it.
We took an irrationa cult that mortifies the bodies of children and deployed every agency of socialization in the Western world on its behalf.
Quotes a post by T08795; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This article contains no quote from or mention of Jonah Wheeler, the 22-year old Democrat who broke with the Democratic party to vote in favor of both of these bills. It makes no mention of the Cass Review or the growing international consensus that pediatric gender medicine is a non-evidence based procedure.
But at least it doesn't repeat mindless falsehoods claiming that blocking puberty is evidence-based, life-saving, and medically necessary like most other reporting on this subject.
It's an important development that New England has joined the global consensus on this issue and important that a bright young Democratic legislator joined with the GOP to do the right thing.
The 22 year old Wheeler is young enough to have been exposed to gender propaganda in schools and to have observed firsthand the ensuing transgender social contagion among his peers, and though his party will do its utmost to punish and suppress him, the realities he is acting on will not change and thus he represents the country's reality-based future.
Quotes a post by T07127; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Puberty blockers put girls into early menopause and disrupt bone growth at the crucial phase of physical development, leaving some women in their early 20's (who claim to be boys) with the brittle bones of 70+ year old women.
Yes, some of those canes and wheelchairs you see at trans marches are affectations adopted by those who fetishize victimhood and disability.
But many have also been crippled by their "lifesaving, medically necessary gender affirming care."
Quoting @ChloeCole: The final thing that blackpilled me on transgender ideology is seeing how many transgender people, well under 30 years old, are already using canes, walkers, and wheelchairs.
Young men and women everywhere are being crippled by doctors selling snake oil.
Prison custody officer tells his bosses that he would not address men who claim to be women by their preferred pronouns because he does not believe men can become women.
"It sparked a horrified reaction from bosses at the firm, which employs thousands of justice workers across the UK, who said his views were against the law and company policy."
A few thoughts:
1.) Men can't become women
2.) No one has any duty to see anyone the way they see themselves
3.) The attempt to force people to agree with claims that they regard as false by force of law is inherently tyrannical
4.) None of the lemmings who are "horrified" by their subordinate stating his belief in a fact that will always be true believes that men can become women
5.) British law protects gender critical beliefs against retaliation
6.) Transgenderism is a doctrine that seeks to force the whole world to see people as they see themselves, an inherently tyrannical doctrine inconsistent with a pluralistic, liberal society that honors freedom of conscience and freedom of speech.
7.) The attempt to deploy state power to impose transgender beliefs on the population is inherently illegitimate
8.) It can't work without inflicting relentless absurdities and cruelties on the world, many of which we see every day.
9.) It is an inherently misguided project that must be rejected in full, along with everyone so lacking in judgment that they thought it could be made to work.
10.) It can only be made to work in a fully totalitarian world.
Why are prisons throughout the United States and Canada imprisoning male serial sex offenders with women?
For the same reason that boys are allowed to dominate girls in girls sports.
For the same reason that girls in California hold it in all day rather than use girls bathrooms where any boy who claims to be a girl has a right of use dictated by state law.
For the same reason that newspapers honor the preferred pronouns of male murderers who begin identifying as woman after their arrest for murdering women.
For the same reason that millions of schoolchildren are read propagandistic books in Kindergarten telling them that any of them can change sex.
For the same reason that Ezra Klein thinks you're an asshole if you don't use preferred pronouns.
Because state and institutional power throughout the Western world decided that people claiming to be the opposite sex were the defining civil rights cause of the 21st century, defined a "transgender person" as "anyone who claims to be the opposite sex," and acts in accordance with this principle in all cases because any attempt to carve out exceptions exposes the entire pretense as an absurdity.
There is no way out of this morass that doesn't entail saying no to all of it.
Quotes a post by T05710; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Wes Streeting is the UK Labour party minister who accepted the findings of the most exhaustive investigation into the evidence on pediatric gender medicine conducted by any entity in the world and implemented its recommendations (to restrict puberty blockers to those enrolled in a study.)
Trans activists accused him of being a murderer, vandalized his office, and threatened further violent action against him and anyone else who adheres to what the evidence demands.
Quoting @roseveniceallan: Your regular reminder that ‘trans rights’ activists are terrorists, the government must finally take the threat seriously now they’ve vandalised @wesstreeting’s constituency office. I hope he and his staff are ok.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
The transgender social contagion was a global test of moral and intellectual integrity that virtually the entirety of the world's governing classes failed.
But a handful have learned and are doing better.
It's the normal and expected pattern. Transgender ideation clusters in friend groups as socially contagious behavior among teen girls always has. I spoke to a detransitioned woman who was one of 22 female friends who all want on T at the same university.
Quoting @wil_da_beast630: The/one face of evil, below, as per my earlier post.
There is no way (.6 x .6 x .6 x .6, to start with) that this could ever be true absent abusive intervention.
Who has the inside story of how and why corporations stopped acting as a rainbow mafia cartel on behalf of the transgender lobby? I'm sure it's not for lack of the lobby's efforts.
Quoting @wesyang: The transgender mania began with major corporation joining in a capital strike on North Carolina (including the NBA moving the All-Star game in protest) because it passed a law saying that women's bathrooms should be for women only. That was the zenith of trans lobby's power, when it had lined up all of corporate America's leadership in a kind of rainbow mafia cartel.
Since 2020 more than 100 laws have been passed banning child gender medicalization and boys in girl's sports with zero protest or action from corporate America.
Prisha will now be able to sue the doctors that took a girl who had recently been involuntarily committed to a mental hospital and put her on testosterone. They are doing this to foster children and even to homeless children, autistic kids and gender nonconforming kids who left to their own devices would desist from their episode of gender dysphoria and end up gay adults in intact bodies. @[private account] has testified that the emergency psych ward where she worked would routinely be occupied by 100 percent trans identified girls.
Prisha is NOT a weird outlier. She is the modal case of adolescent girl who got caught up in the transgender social contagion.
This is not medicine. This is a cult. And it's an outrage that the Biden Administration sent the Solicitor General of the United States to the Supreme Court to claim that preventing this cult from operating would be an attack on transgender kids and a denial of their Constitutional rights.
The transgender mania began with major corporation joining in a capital strike on North Carolina (including the NBA moving the All-Star game in protest) because it passed a law saying that women's bathrooms should be for women only. That was the zenith of trans lobby's power, when it had lined up all of corporate America's leadership in a kind of rainbow mafia cartel.
Since 2020 more than 100 laws have been passed banning child gender medicalization and boys in girl's sports with zero protest or action from corporate America.
North Carolina's legislature just overrode a veto of a law that, among other worthy initiatives, extends the statue of limitation for medical malpractice claims for transgender procedures to ten years.
Extending the statute of limitations to 25 years across the whole country would be the end of the gender medicalization industry.
We know this because the law banning pediatric gender medicine in Missouri allowed the clinics to stay open for another year and continue treating children already having their puberty blocked or cross-sex hormones being administrated.
But the clinics all shut down immediately because of another provision of the bill, extending liability for those who regret their transitions for 25 years.
Though the clinicians claim they are helping people to become their authentic selves by dosing them with cross-sex hormones, they don't really believe it. If it were true, they would have no reason to fear future liability. But it's not true, they know it's not true, and they therefore shut down immediately rather than face that liability.
Quoting @PrishaMosley: I’m so grateful to the NC legislature for the override the VETO of #HB805! My medical malpractice claims can now be reinstated! This change is HUGE and means that I can seek justice for the medical harm that came to me as a teenager in NC when I believed that I was trans.
Five Democratic state senators broke with their party in PA to join with Republicans to pass a bill protecting girls sports.
They did so in spite of the rhetorical onslaught of the state's governor, Josh Shapiro, who called those supporting the bill "extremist politicians."
Polling shows that 67 percent of Democratic voters support laws keeping girls sports female.
The Democratic House Speaker has prevented the bill from coming up for a vote, "reportedly fearing that some of her own members might also break ranks with the party and support the popular legislation."
"Republicans believe McClinton is shielding Shapiro from having to either sign or veto a bill on an issue that hurt Vice President Kamala Harris during the 2024 presidential campaign. And while Shapiro has attacked the pro-girls-sports bill, he has been careful not to pledge a veto."
Shapiro posted on social media back in 2020 that "trans women are women" and has a long record of actions and statements demonstrating a deep commitment to transgender ideology.
Transgender clinicians have two completely different sets of claims that they make to different audiences.
To legislators and others scrutinizing their practicing, they claim that there is rigorous screening and testing.
To all prospective patients, they say that it would be an act of oppression to question anyone's claim to be transgender, promise to affirm and medicalize anyone who asks, and explain how they will collude with them to give them hormones at the first visit and get it paid for by insurance by giving them a fake diagnosis.
"Investigating transgender medicine" is trivially easy. You just go to the public website of the major gender clinics, where they proudly boast of 1.) doing no gatekeeping at all, 2.) dispensing with any pretense of differential diagnosis on principle, and 3.) promising to commit insurance fraud.
67 percent of Democrats told pollsters at the New York Times that they opposed transgender inclusion (boys competing against girls) in girl's sports. It's an 80-20 issue in the country as a whole. But the party staked everything on this being a civil and human rights cause and those are non-negotiable. Thus they are stuck twisting themselves into rhetorical knots.
Quoting @ClayTravis: Mayor Pete is asked if men should be able to play in women’s sports, dodges question. Can’t answer. This is what true cowardice looks like. Until Democrats all say no, no men will respect them:
Leeper and Erica Anderson said the exact same thing in the Washington Post in 2021. Trans activists all support the affirmative model and rail against any gatekeeping.
They then pretend that accurate descriptions of the very model they lobbied tirelessly to impose that all gender clinics now follow is a "lie" when cited by someone they don't like.
Quotes a post by A2836; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This mother of a trans-identified teenaged girl said the same thing back in 2022 at a small protest against Boston Children's Hospitals affirmation-only protocol for gender confused children.
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1571551652615753728
Quoting @wesyang: "We want the same thing. We both want our kids to grow up happy and healthy."
A global brainwashing campaign to manufacture more inputs into the trans medicalization apparatus from which so many doctors, politicians, consultants, educators, and NGO executives derive a rich bounty in money and clout at the low cost of the health and fertility of thousands of children
Quotes a post by A2836; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Nobody's rights were infringed during the 7 7/12th of Obama's presidency when trans identified people were banned from the military. I don't know the answer to the question of whether trans-ID folx have been more problematic than people on Prozac and the many, many other categories of people who are disqualified on the basis of their accommodations being too onerous. But I'd be pretty surprised if they turned out not to be.
The one biggest threat to "trans rights" is that every "trans right" is an imperious demand for state-mandated incursions on the fundamental rights of others
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Some people think these inducements to violence against those who don't support the transgender movement that are pervasive at pro-trans protests detract from the movement's righteous demands.
Others understand that this is just who they are and these are their demands.
Quoting @againstgrmrs: London had a pride event yesterday, ONLY for the “Trans+”
They carried & plastered signs everywhere making their “all inclusive” feelings clear with their real desires:
- sh00t people that don’t agree
- půnch “terfs”
- feminists cannot support real women
- they hate the LGB
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentlgb wedgepolitical enemyviolence terror
Virtually every problem ascribed to "minority stress" in the trans-ID context is better understood as "the problems that necessarily attend placing a narcissistic falsehood at the center of your being and demanding that everyone you encounter play along with it"
Quotes a post by A2346; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Everybody wants transgenderism to be a subject that's beneath them to discuss. they want it to be resolved with a handful of trite cliches about inclusion, a few shallow acknowledgments that parts of it went too far too fast. They want it to be a low salience issue that can be backburnered without penalty to their electoral prospects.
No one wants to accept that transgender inclusion necessarily entails the propagandizing of millions of schoolchildren and institutional enforcement across American institutions of absurdities and cruelties that have inflicted direct harms on millions of lives and fatally undermined trust in enormous party affiliated organs of power (unions, schools, professional guilds) that shape the lives of the whole population.
No one wants to accept that the project of expanding rights has fatally overreached into a Quixotic and dystopian attempt to confer a right to compel the whole world to acquiesce in counterfactual claims about the self, and that all of the institutions complicit in this overreach, the Democratic party above all, have subverted themselves beyond recourse until they explicitly abandon and disavow it.
Of course I can't prove from this data that the dark matter that keeps the party's approval rating in the toilet no matter what outrages the Trumpist GOP inflicts on the country is the misbegotten attempt to deploy state power to attack foundational rights to belief, speech, and conscience in the name of absurd and harmful falsehoods the party has decreed will be made into sacred dogma. I might be wrong in my suspicion that this is the anchor tied around the party's neck.
But I might be also be right, and in any case I am certainly provably right that an issue whose advocates try to portray as "one percent of the population existing" necessarily entail upheavals and absurdities that encompass millions in ways that the millions largely resent.
Miles Yardley was put on estrogen at his second visit to the gender clinic at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia at the age of 15. The clinicians referred to him as a "perfect example" of a transgender child.
Going trans gave him a lot of clout in New York City's fashion and art worlds but it came at a price of medical risks and harms: in April 2024, he was diagnosed with a brain tumor and hypothyroidism, both conditions with suspected links to wrong sex hormone injections.
He is now off hormones, stuck in a female-looking body, abandoned by doctors who were zealous about transitioning him but have no idea about what to do with someone detransitioning, and suing CHOP for medical malpractice.
“If you’re a gender-nonconforming kid, you should be allowed to be yourself. I think that was the biggest problem. I didn’t feel like I could be confident in who I was. And if that person happens to like singing and dancing and cooking and Barbie dolls, who really cares? You can be a boy who likes that,” Yardley says.
“At the time, nobody in my life told me that was possible.”
That you should take such kids and subject them to the ultimate sexual violence, leaving them sterile, anorgamsic, and kept on a medical leash for life, is the foundational premise of the transgender movement.
You could just leave them alone and let them grow into healthy, intact bodies instead of profiting off of brainwashing them to yearn to be chemically castrated and dismembered.
Whenever good liberals talk about "protecting trans kids" or "saving the dolls," they mean using the force of law to ensure that only the first of these options happen and never the second. They truly believe they are being heroes and saviors while they do this, as they work to inflict the ultimate sexual violence on confused children who simply needed a more tolerant and accepting world.
As @[private account] put it to me, nobody who wears sneakers to work (nurses, orderlies, etc.) and thus deals everyday with actual patients believes any of the transgender dogmas and mandates imposed on them by those wearing leather pumps and dress shoes (administrators, insurers.)
Quoting @Jebadoo2: 1/ The Peggie tribunal is an important moment in isolating the bourgeoise character of gender madness. This came from the ivory towers of Berkeley via well fed otherwise unemployable DEI drones and cheered on by the equally unemployable gendocrats of Stonewall.
JK Rowling indicated her willingness to go to prison for stating an empirical fact. She faced down the Scottish state, which declined her invitation to arrest her for calling a male murderer a man.
Which state will become the first to jail someone for calling a man a man?
The transgender movement has sought this power from the outset and is on the cusp of exercising it.
Quotes a post by A1855; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Who disputes this claim? Who is outraged by it? Who believes the contrary? https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5412545-rahm-emanuel-transgender-controversy/amp/
It is never dehumanization to call a man a man because a man is a type of human.
It is, however, a crime in Brazil, punishable by decades of prison time.
Brazil is one place where the global trans activist goal of conscripting state power to punish people for acknowledging reality has been attained.
This goal is being pursued everywhere and will be enacted in every place it is not stopped.
Quotes a post by A1855; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Even if WikiPedia wasn't dominated by some of the most extreme Trans Activists (as it is), simple garbage in, garbage out dynamics would dictate this outcome. WikiPedia relies on citations from news outlets, all of which present poorly grounded opinion as fact.
Quoting @LeorSapir: What's the technical explanation for why Wikipedia pages dealing in one way or another with gender medicine seem to be written by gender medicine activists?
Claims that are opinion--and not well-grounded opinion--are regularly presented as indisputable fact. Why?
These arguments are unanswerable except through repetition of transgender dogmas. If you accept the dogmas, everything follows. If you reject the dogmas, because they are both internally self-contradictory and absolutely disjunct from any observable reality, the entire edifice crumbles.
There can be no serious dispute that anime message boards are a key vector of the online social contagion. This of course does not mean that most people exposed to anime go trans.
In Time to Think, the account of the closure of the UK's only pediatric gender clinic, @[private account] describes how many of the children appearing at the Tavistock seeking to have their puberty blocked identified as both transgender and East Asian because anime message boards were a key vector of the ongoing transgender social contagion. Despite this unmistakable evidence that these kids were caught up in an online fad, the clinicians happily acceded to the request to block the puberty of those children.
Quoting @BillboardChris: .@elonmusk, the anime community is one of the premier sources where kids are indoctrinated to believe they are trans.
Please send Ani to the trash bin.
It’s never dehumanizing to call a man a man because a man is a type of human. Refusing to parrot someone’s counterfactual claim about themselves is not hateful or demonizing. “Your inner wish to have changed sex does not make it so,” asserts the priority of material reality over subjective fancy as a measure of truth, nothing less or more.
The transgender movement seized the instruments of social conformity and coercion by relentlessly asserting, on the basis of sheer repetition and zero evidence, that it is dehumanizing and hateful to prioritize reality over fantasy. They deployed hysterical, hyperbolic claims of genocide on day one, which in turn served as the warrant for campaigns of repression and intimidation of the whole public enacted by means of the destruction of the livelihoods of people who told the truth. That is all the movement has ever been or can ever be.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"The president has your back" was the talking point.
Three days after a mass murder of six, including three 9-year olds by a trans-identified female, this is what the spokeswoman for the President said: "LGBTQI+ kids are resilient. They are fierce. They fight back. They’re not going anywhere. And we have their back. This administration has their back."
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Not one of the Reasonable Pundits who opine about the need to slow the pace of progress on transgender issues so as to allow the public to catch up with elite consensus has acknowledged that male rapists and murderers who claim to be women are incarcerated with women and are the subject of relentless ACLU litigation to ensure that their cosmetic surgeries are paid by taxpayers
Quotes a post by A2443; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
So for example, the main reason PMC's reflexively trans their kids is because they trust medical authority. Whereas the populist/Trumpist/anti-covidian right wing culture has a longstanding hostility to experts. This does mean that rebellious hicklibs in their midst will go trans and (and will collect at the state U) and you'll see it keep growing for that reason -- but it might not be the same for the population as a whole. Even the lower tier colleges are producing "educated" people who function as local elites. (Teachers, etc.)
For the most part they aren't acting on the race stuff. They remain in their non-diverse enclaves etc.
But on trans, they are walking the walk on trans and actually chemically castrating their own progeny.
https://x.com/DeusMozzarella/status/1944813164056732018
Quotes a post by T30277; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
One parent sending her kid to a highly competitive school for the gifted in NYC said her trans-identified son's class is more than half trans-identified.
No the woke people actually are the ones putting the kids on hormones. There are multiple trans and nonbinary playgroups for preteens in Park Slope, Brooklyn.
Now we do have some anecdotal evidence that trans is making major inroads into Appalachian and downscale America. So it's possible we will see a sad and terrible replay of what happened after the 1970's, when wealthy elites were the first adopters of divorce and later re-moralized their class societies -- while marriage as an institution crumbled amidst the working classes and never recovered.
This sounds superficially appealing but it's educated and wealthy elites who are being consumed by it more than anyone else.
The schools where 30-50 percent of the kids are trans-identified are all elite private schools and competitive public schools in SuperZIPS full of children of academics and other knowledge workers.
Quotes a post by T04742; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Perhaps someday WPATH president Marci Bowers, the gender surgeon who castrated Jazz Jennings at 17 on a popular reality TV show and told Matt Walsh that apotemnophiles, who seek to amputate healthy body parts to affirm their identification as amputees, are "nuts", will someday be canceled for denying that trans-paraplegics should have their arms cut off.
Quotes a post by A0961; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We know that gender surgeons have cut off the breasts of preteen girls as young as 12.
We know that at least a thousand teenage girls had their breasts removed in order to affirm them in the delusion that they are boys in every year between 2017-2023.
We know that the Biden Administration's Assistant Secretary of Health, Rachel Levine, intervened in the formation of the WPATH Standard of Care 8 to pressure the organization to remove any age guidelines on any gender procedure, including surgeries.
We know that every girl to whom this was done was grievously and irreversibly harmed -- the ones still in the clutches of the bizarre cult belief that cutting off their breasts turned them into boys even more so than the ones who eventually realized it had all been a monstrous scam in which they were used as pawns of a power-seeking social movement.
We know that the Biden Administration issued a weak disavowal of its tireless efforts to propagate any gender procedure on anyone of any age as widely as possible toward the end of his term with a terse statement claiming they didn't support gender surgeries on minors.
We know that the transgender movement is propagandizing millions of children from the earliest age to believe that any of them can change sex, thus setting up a vulnerable fraction of them for the eventual infliction of the ultimate sexual violence on themselves.
We know that the propagation of this cycle is a key priority for public funding and public mandates at every level of government for Democratic party elected officials, and that they loudly broadcast their will to defy federal mandates seeking to end this mania.
We know that this happened because of institutional capture more complete than has ever been enacted by a social movement across America's educational, medical, cultural, legal, and social welfare agencies.
We know it happened because of the moral and intellectual mediocrity of its bourgeoisie -- its incuriosity and indifference to truth, its unwillingness to listen or learn or care about the actual consequences of its actions, its willingness to amputate its humanity in the service of personal comfort, its willingness to collude in absurdities and cruelties inflicted on the most vulnerable among us so as long as they were marketed as inclusive.
Quotes a post by A0447; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Friedrich Nietzsche said that the most dangerous person to any movement is the person whose defection would cause it the most harm -- that is to say, the most capable, dedicated, and energetic member.
Jamie Reed, who worked for four years managing intake and tracking the progress of hundreds of trans-identified minors at a gender clinic in St. Louis is that person to the pediatric gender cult.
Quoting @JamieWhistle: Just landed in California. Flew coast to coast today- DC to CA for a huge action planned this weekend. The airport here smells like tacos :)
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] The segregation in an enclosed space is supposed to provide even greater protection from a dick than the street afford but under the transgender inclusive regime, it produces not just less but makes it impossible to avoid
All the desperate rationalizations for the obvious wrongs and harms that the transgender movement is seeking to inflict on the world are as exacerbated, tortured, hysterical, hyperbolic, buttonholing, and bullying as this one because there are no sound rational arguments for any of it.
There is simply no way to persuade anyone into it -- all they can do is deploy thermonuclear rhetoric to coerce you into acquiescence.
Quoting @LeorSapir: The belief that only females should compete in women’s sports is a “perfect on-ramp for a long list of sexist, racist, and ultimately eugenic beliefs,” says the Communications Strategist at the @ACLU Women’s Rights Project and LGBTQ & HIV Project.
Revealing exchange with Ben.
Riedl did not "defend her integrity with science." Riedl wrote a coming out post in February that portrayed GOP laws protecting children from gender experimentation as part of a malicious assault on "trans kids", claimed that he had taken a brain scan that proved he had a female brain (no such scans exist), claimed to have known he was a girl since age of four, (classic AGP etiology of married middle-aged father who abruptly announces he's going to live his paraphilia full time makes this claim highly dubious,) and linked garbage propaganda studies claiming that kids who aren't affirmed and medicalized will commit suicide.
He posted all of this trash as his first act of public declaration, thus linking his own personal transition to a public controversy in a manner that subverts the position taken by his employer, which has published researching contesting all of these claims, and which operates in a state whose civil rights laws makes contesting transgender dogmas in the workplace a form of illegal discrimination.
He was therefore not just "existing as trans" but engaging in a polemic and is therefore 100 percent open to being factchecked.
In these replies, Ryan makes clear he knows that the studies are trash, the "science" is bunk, but asserts that all that matters is that some people said mean things to Riedl on the Internet. None of that of course has any bearing at all on whether Riedl's polemic is true.
In a prior tweet, I explained why this matters:
"Marginalized identities" function as warrants to abandon any epistemic standards in progressive spaces. It's how we saw medicine corrupted to the point where major medical associations all colluded in the lie that chemically castrating and dismembering confused teenagers was "medically necessary" and "lifesaving care."
Manhattan Institute has played a key role in exposing this epistemic corruption and in contesting it successfully in federal courts across the country.
Does the Manhattan Institute agree that because Jessica Riedl claims to be a woman, he is also released from any duty to apply normal standards of rigor in his public statements about human biology?"
Ben makes clear in this exchange that his answer to this question is that so long as a marginalized person (middle aged white male who suddenly claims to be woman) is being treated rudely online, all that matters is scolding those treating them rudely and not whether what that person is saying that are true or not true, our first goal is to defend the marginalized while whether the agenda they are pushing is "besides the point."
In other words, exactly the dynamic through which TRA's managed to corrupt the science of pediatric gender and inflict harm on thousands of children.
https://x.com/wesyang/status/1939709206841438542
Quoting @wesyang: "Marginalized identities" function as warrants to abandon any epistemic standards in progressive spaces. It's how we saw medicine corrupted to the point where major medical associations all colluded in the lie that chemically castrating and dismembering confused teenagers was "medically necessary" and "lifesaving care." Manhattan Institute has played a key role in exposing this epistemic corruption and in contesting it successfully in federal courts across the country.
Does the Manhattan Institute agree that because Jessica Riedl claims to be a woman, he is also released from any duty to apply normal standards of rigor in his public statements about human biology?
The small minority of trans-identified men who relentlessly harassed her on Twitter before being convicted for rape? https://x.com/spursjord/status/1939950348061352409
Quotes a post by T07894; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedactivist harassmentdenialviolence terror
The claim is not that there are "zero studies" into brain difference. It's that the studies are "fatally flawed" and do not provide evidence that anyone is born trans.
Time for Manhattan Institute management to instruct their employee to cease blasting out misinformation that directly contradicts their own research on this subject.
https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
Oh you're saying AGP's were transitioned before the turn of the century. Yes, of course, people had to lie, people lied all the time , gatekeeping wasn't exact, and the standards were arbitrary and made up then as they are now because because dosing people with hormones and cutting off their genitals isn't medicine and isn't evidence based. It never was.
But there was some gatekeeping and there goal was to get rid of it for everyone, including minors, and that happened through vicious cancellation campaigns against Bailey and Blanchard up until the point that Rachel Levine leaned on WPATH to remove any age limit on any procedure at a time when affirmation was automatic and hormones were routinely prescribed at the first visit.
Part of McCloskey's attacks on Bailey were precisely to sustain this lie that AGP didn't exist and was an ugly slur on "trans women" when in fact his own writings reveal that he was AGP. McCloskey's story confirms the thumbnail history I referred to and does not disrupt it in any way.
Knowing what an "autogynephile" was was a bit of esoteric knowledge for those read into the internal debates of sexology.
Then that knowledge was suppressed for a decade by trans activists seeking to end gatekeeping of trans medicine that eventually culminated, by a strange confluence of events, in a social contagion of teen girls dosing themselves with anabolic steroids and cutting off their breasts.
But AGP's love to talk about themselves and parade themselves around and have been doing so on Reddit and TikTok for a decade and the Internet is a machine for observing and naming things, so as the phenomenon went ever more viral, a continual rediscovery of it happened.
Now everybody knows.
Why is it “good” to comply with trans activist campaign to end all gatekeeping in trans medicine such that male paraphilics should be medicalized and have their preferred pronouns honored? What’s good about that?
The first screenshot is Manhattan Institute federal budget expert "Jessica" Riedl, a middle-aged man who knew he was a girl on the inside at the age of four and went on to marry a woman and father two children, citing "brain studies" as evidence that he was actually "born trans."
The second screenshot is three researchers employed by the Manhattan Institute nothing that these studies are fatally flawed and do nothing to support the claim that anybody is "born trans."
Married middle aged heterosexual fathers of two daughters are classic autogynephiles whose condition of transvestic fetishism would have been disqualifying from trans medicalization until the turn of the 21st century.
The reclassification of these men as "trans women" who must be referred to as "she/her" was accomplished through campaigns of cancellation of the doctors attempting to gatekeep trans medicine. What followed is the collapse of all gatekeeping and the spread of it to minors that we see ongoing.
All of it is inextricably linked, all of it is linked to the same corruption you cover everyday but somehow I'm a jerk for knowing that. OK.
There's nothing subtle about the citations. I told you what he meant by the links because he told us what he thinks in the sentence linking them. He thinks the attempt to protect children from gender medicalization is part of an indecent ongoing assault on "trans kids" that he feels impelled to characterize in the manner he does. That's advocacy.
Did you follow the links? He referred to GOP bans on child transition and men in women's sports as attempts to "legislate, beat, mock, and boycott" trans people out of existence. He linked scaremongering suicide statistics that are a key element of the emotional blackmail used to pressure parents to affirm and medicalize. He's more than implying that people who knew they were trans at 4 years old (like him) should be free to transition. He's claiming that efforts to stop child transition as malevolent and pointless and that kids will kill themselves if they aren't allowed to transition. That's classic child trans advocacy, can't be more unambiguous.
I disagree that it's any kind of kindness and I have a right to make that judgment call that no one can infringe. There are of course situations in which I'll defer to preferred pronouns by default but my view is that we have a category error where we are trying to scale up interpersonal kindnesses (or just deference to the path of least resistance) that is not scalable to any kind of general rule without trampling on a core right of free conscience.
Social transition is the clear instance where the slippery slope argument is shown to be the right because of the overwhelming supermajority of those who are affirmed that go on to medicalize. I'm of the view that none of the excesses I've catalogued on my feed are avoidable in any society that makes trans affirmation a rule.
The successful attempt to create a social obligation to affirm other people's counterfactual assertions about the self is how we get Trans Kids. There is no such obligation. No one who uses accurate language to refer to a person's sex has done anything wrong.
He needs access to sources on the trans side and is of course on thin ice with them because he reveals truths. Getting piled on by TERF's is probably a successful strategy for preserving the appearance of moderation, but I think it would be better for him to just keep reporting and stay out of all polemics.
Hundreds of trans-activists shut down Wintemute's speech at McGill University in 2023.
Wintemute was one of the legal architects of gay marriage in Europe; his defection from the cause of "trans rights" is especially difficult for trans activists to take, leaving them feeling entitled to use coercive force to prevent him from speaking.
At a certain point he realized the movement's demands were not in fact rights.
Quoting @clairlemon: "There is no human right to government documents that are biologically false. An individual’s birth sex never changes, regardless of any medical treatment she or he receives."
- Robert Wintemute, Professor of Human Rights Law at King’s College London
I didn't claim an increase in autistic male cases. I simply said the widely anecdotally observed increase in male computer nerds who go trans is curious.
There are of course well documented overlaps between trans and autism and trans and computer nerds and computer nerds and autism and there's a lot of fuzziness around the meaning of all these terms, but I'm tweeting and not writing a scientific paper ATM.
No, it's a characterization of what the site does -- a direct assertion rather than an insinuation. I've interviewed multiple detransitioners who witnessed or participated in the adult-minor contacts that happen on it. "Cracking an egg" means manifesting someone's trans-ID. Or just spend 15 minutes of the site and confirm its overt and unhidden purpose: https://www.reddit.com/r/egg_irl/comments/1lgb9bo/egg_irl/
One of the theses about autism is that it is a form of hyper-masculinization of the brain. How this has culminated in a social contagion of MTF trans-identification among computer nerds is something I'd like to understand better.
Quotes a post by T03218; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
What are the best written accounts of trans-identified men imposing themselves on lesbian and woman's separatist spaces such as Michfest and rape crisis centers and shelters in the 1990's and 2000's?
Yes, "gender clinicians" are slicing off the breasts of middle school girls after assuring them that doing so will help them be the boy they always really were on the inside.
Yes, they are all brimming with pride and believe themselves to be heroes and saviors as they inflict macabre medicalized self-harm on children.
Yes, the whole Democratic party at every level is unified in ensuring this practice spreads as widely possible and in calling anyone who tries to stop it a cruel bigot "attacking" the "Trans Kids" denied gender-affirming double mastectomies.
Yes, it is exactly as insane as it sounds, it has happened thousands of times to girls as young as 12, and smooth-voiced men with reasonable demeanors like Ezra Klein now want to heed Sarah McBride's call for a tactical reset to ensure that the public is properly persuaded that doing this is necessary and good through incremental change.
Quotes a post by A0447; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's entirely a private matter, confers no rights on the sufferer, and imposes no duty on any other person. "Eccentricity" encompasses the full spectrum from mental illnesses to mere whims that constitute the category of the trans-identified.
McBride is not seeking a foothold among my cohort but to rally liberals who have misgivings about this issue. He has a path with them for sure but faces more determined resistance within the trans movement itself.
I don't tell the transgender movement to compromise. I tell it to respect the same limits on its ambitions that every other movement in a pluralistic, democratic, liberal society must respect. What remains of the trans activist agenda if it obeys such a stricture?
Quotes a post by T03663; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The piece is a good quick round up of the insanity of the movement's intellectuals that can held normies get up to speed on what those of use paying attention to this issue have known for years.
But remember: none of these contentions held up as indicative of the "radicalization" of the transgender movement is more radical or more insane than the one that the Solicitor General of the United States argued for and that "every major medical organization" claims in unison, without evidence, is medically necessary and life-saving: that we should use an off-label cancer drug to stunt the crucial stage of physical, emotional, and cognitive maturation in young children so taht they become more convincing non-functional, sterilized, anorgasmic simulacra of the opposite sex on a medical leash for life.
https://x.com/jonkay/status/1935945480485089439
Quoting @jonkay: The New York Times has done a deep dive into the radicalization of trans activism, and the collateral damage it’s inflicted on the wider progressive movement… by way of case study, it highlights the insane scholarship of @[private account] law prof Florence Ashley, who sees the physical mutilation of teens as “gendered art”
For the past several years, the NYT reader picks of comments on the transgender stories have consistently shown that the paper's readership of urban, educated, highly partisan Democrats have mostly not joined the gender cult
It's hard to conceive of anyone being made less rather than more skeptical of trans activism by Masha's writing, so I think it's a good thing that she is occupying that slot at the NYT
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's for sure a striking development, but an inevitable one with regard to trans rights, which fundamentally requires restrictions on free conscience to disbelieve transgender dogmas and cannot survive in the absence of coercion https://x.com/SanchoPanzy/status/1935708625483255815
Quotes a post by T07433; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The key point is that the crusade was launched without deliberation or debate. It took the form of cancellations within left activist spaces, the vilification of elements within the left activist coalition that saw the fundamental debility of the movement's claims and the inexorable problems of its implementation.
This pathological process of consensus building was then exported to the wider world, where it eventually summoned up wider opposition. And just as the transgender movement claims it is only beginning its fight, so the much belated opposition is only beginning as well.
Also did not intend to capitalize "Democratic," as it was meant in the small d way.
The trans movement was the apotheosis of the undemocratic alliance of "professional activists and activist professionals" that drove the Great Awokening -- a self-conscious vanguard occupying the chokepoints of cultural transmission who became drunk on their power to impose new visions of social transformation on the wider public.
It operated with disdain for common opinions and sensibilities and made instant recourse to the instruments of social coercion while seeking the instruments of legal coercion to impose their unconstrained vision of the future.
That the vision is at once incoherent, harmful, and entails the cannibalization of the rights of prior progressive movements (women and gays) only underscores the fundamental debility at the heart of this project: that its foundational premise isn't true and that no amount coercion and repression can ever make it true.
The NYT Magazine has written a thorough account of the fiasco of pediatric gender medicine. The author frames Skrmetti as having set back the cause of trans rights by a generation.
It frames Skrmetti as a strategic error by the ACLU driven by the impetuousness of its lead trans rights litigator, Chase Strangio, and its Executive Director, Anthony Romero, who backed him fully as the organization drifted toward the iceberg.
The criticism is well-deserved as far as it goes. The tactical and strategic errors the story documents are indeed enormous.
But the fiasco of the trans rights movement cannot be cured by better messaging, strategy, or tactics.
In fact, the trans rights movement in itself illustrates that we have reached the end of the age of emancipation.
The giant apparatus we constructed to launch new civil crusades had no one left to liberate and thus set about manufacturing a new subpopulation of the marginalized by chemically castrating children at the crucial stage of physical, emotional, and cognitive development.
This was an experiment in the overt, self-conscious, institutionally-directed reconstruction of social reality. And in the process, we reached the limit of how far-reaching such projects can go in a society that remains pluralistic, liberal, Democratic, and free.
The Canadian media rigorously observed the preferred pronouns (she/her) of a man who began identifying as a woman immediately after his arrest for the murder of his wife and children.
They did so because the transgender movement has defined the possibility of a trans faker out of existence. The term "transgender" was coined for the very purpose of defining the possibility of a trans faker out of existence.
It did so deliberately in order to make "self-ID" the sole criterion for who counts as transgender.
Self-ID is the standard that the Biden Administration applied when it ruled that every school in America is mandated to grant bathroom access on the basis of gender identity rather than sex -- that is to say, to give access to the girls' changing rooms to any boy who says he is a girl.
It did so because there are no coherent criteria that can distinguish "real" from "fake" trans people apart from tran-medicalist ones like castration.
The "transsexual" movement used to submit to requirements for state recognition of legal sex change of surgical transition. It now declares such requirements to be a human rights violation.
The definition of a transgender person really is "anyone who claims a cross-gender identity."
Now anyone that wants their identity marker on a passport to reflect their cross sex self-identification has a judge mandated right to get one from Donald Trump's State Department. The sole criterion for eligibility for such recognition is self-identification.
Quoting @bendreyfuss: I mean, look, there are actual trans people out there and they deserve all the support and dignity of everyone else. But there are a great many more people pretending to be trans. This second group is so large it set off a predictable backlash.
Framing the GOP's efforts to protect children from the onslaught of maniacs brainwashing quirky kids to yearn to be sterilized and dismembered as a "cruel crusade against trans kids" is an act of monstrous indecency.
But framing it as "a distraction" and making no specific promises to continue the movement's onslaught also shows the cheap and perfunctory character of this vile smear. Schumer himself does not really want to continue this mania, which he knows to be an absurdity, as does any sane person over the age of 40.
Nonetheless, the party will continue on with undimmed fervor.
Quoting @SenSchumer: Republicans’ cruel crusade against trans kids is all an attempt to divert attention from ripping healthcare away from millions of Americans.
We'll keep fighting and we'll keep marching on.
Chemically castrating and chopping off healthy body parts of confused children, leaving them in irreparably damaged bodies for life before most have ever had a first kiss is "care" in much the same way that "trans women are women"
Quotes a post by T08599; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
As a mother of seven enveloped in Christian piety and the kindness valorized by that piety , she had every reason to defect to a maudlin view of the marginalized trans person -- but she also has a lawyer's insistence on defining terms
That is to say that Trans Activists are already apoplectic about the podcast in advance of listening to it because they know that any investigations of the origins of the movement is inherently discrediting to the mystifications upon which they rely to prop up the most blatant absurdities ever foisted on the public at this scale.
The transgender movement is about establishing as fact and enshrining in law that wishes and desires are sufficient to alter reality, indeed that some desires only emerge by virtue of the desired thing already being true, and that the person subject to these desires has a right enforceable by state power to have that wish and desire to be affirmed by all others.
It is the place where rights held against the state become duties enforceable through the state, and the moment where all become subject to the whims of each.
Quotes a post by A1628; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A picture perfect illustration of what happens when you say even one thing that obliquely indicates some hesitation or reservation about any aspect of transgender dogma: the dogmas are so fragile that the discipline has to be utterly ruthless.
No amount of prior service to the cause protects you. The one statement annuls the decades of prior service in an instant.
Quoting @legaltweetz: I’m not crashing out. I’m just getting started. First of all, I have no master. I will not be told what to do, how to think, or how to speak. Second, I will be friends with whoever the fuck that I want to be friends with. Third, I’m about to be 43 this month. I ran out of fucks to give a long time ago.
People within the trans community massively unfollowing me, trying to cancel me, contacting my work to get me fired, and calling for my disbarment is surely the way to get me to comply 🫠
If one post, versus 29 years of dedicating my life to this cause, can create that for me? We have much bigger problems in the community than I originally thought.
50 percent of gays and lesbians say they have a lot in common with straight people while only 28 percent say they have a lot in common with trans people
Sullivan asks: "So why are we in alliance with trans people and not straights?"
No "pivot to moderation on trans issues" that doesn't begin with this recognition as the foundation is a pivot to moderation at all
Quoting @wesyang: We did some basic due diligence before getting onboard with an ersatz civil rights movement that wielded greater disciplinary power than any before it and learned it was grounded entirely in the most extreme and self-evident medical malfeasance any of us has ever witnessed
In one's dealings with Trans activists and allies, it's often helpful to proceed from the assumption that these are people clinging to false promises made to them by others and false affirmations they've made for themselves -- and that the violence and rancor which they react to any suggestion that these promises are false manifests an inner recognition that they are fighting to stave off. This framework can be applied to the Democratic Party as a whole.
The wound requires daily dilation to prevent closure and frequent courses of antibiotics to fight infection, but no vaginal care is needed.
It's "trans men" -- women who are dosing themselves with wrong sex male hormones -- that have a high risk of vaginal atrophy
The comically brain poisoned rhetorical gambits of the trans activist movement all moved seamlessly into the mouths of normal Democrats because the goals of the fringe of trans activists have been adopted wholesale by every Democratic party official at every level of government
Quotes a post by A2156; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The trans community knows that anyone who hesitates even .01 percent in defending every last dogma to the death will soon unravel totally because the dogmas are inherently fragile because they are false
Quoting @legaltweetz: I’ve gotten a lot of blowback from the trans community for this post. Which very clearly states that I’m overwhelmed, burnt out, and tired of inter community fighting. Nowhere did I say “hey I’m a bigot now.” I got unfollowed by the likes of India Willougby and others. That’s really supportive of someone who fights for trans people day in and day out 👏 Goddamn. Ya’ll have the memory of a goldfish.
I’ve been fighting bigots for 29 years. Ever since I was 14. I’m allowed to be tired. It’s been a long long haul of hatred. Spare me the faux outrage.
Things that have been called genocide in recent years:
-- An elevated rate of death by disease and accidents at Canadian schools for native children where some of the children were converted to Catholicism
-- Higher murder rates for native women in Canada
-- Efforts to prevent the chemical castration and sterilization of confused children caught up in the transgender social contagion
-- Keeping women's sports and changing rooms for women
-- Misgendering
Anyone who pursues a stable, coherent, consistent definition of "actually trans" comes up empty because the movement simply defines it for the purposes of language and law as "says they are the opposite sex."
Thus, a man who murdered his wife and child and identifies as a woman after his arrest has his preferred pronouns respected by the newspaper, consistent with the only definition of "trans" in operation.
That man who murdered his wife and child is every bit as much a woman as Dylan Mulvaney and Rachel Levine, two men that it was for a long time grounds for banning from social media to call men, and for the same reason: all say they are women, and all are therefore women, and all are entitled access to women's spaces.
Quoting @marycatedelvey: Luke is so close to getting it
The most harrowing and discrediting things that can possibly said in opposition to genderism are all said by trans activists attempting to advocate for it
Quotes a post by A2836; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Sure gender nonconforming people have always existed. What's new is calling gender nonconforming children "Trans Kids," and using an off-label cancer drug once used to chemically castrate adult sex offenders before that was judged to be a form of cruel and unusual punishment on children as young as nine and cutting off the breasts of thousands of teen girls as young 12 after propagandizing them to believe that gender nonconformity means they were "born in the wrong body" and need to be rendered sterile, anorgasmic, and tied to a medical leash for life before most have had their first kiss.
Quotes a post by T06181; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Five Democrats crossed party lines to join the with GOP majority in PA to protect girls sports.
While the Democratic-controlled House is not expected to pass the bill, the partisan firewall is finally beginning to subside as a small but growing number of D officials muster courage to...represent a supermajority of the party's own voters who know that "trans inclusion" in girls' sports is deeply unfair because "trans girls" are boys.
Quotes a post by T02731; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When I explained the ongoing transgender social contagion to my daughter, I referenced footbinding as a precedential instance of a society mortifying the bodies of girl children in pursuit of some irrational group belief
Did the administration have to add language to its EO impugning the honor and mental soundness of trans-identified people? It did not. Those lines were gratuitous and were the basis of a lower court judge ruling that the administration was driven by animus in reaching this decision. They placed at risk a decision that was clearly within the administration's discretion to decide.
Nonetheless, the Supreme Court saw it differently and overruled the lower court judge (who also create a ridiculous circus by lecturing about intersex people and demanding briefs on the biology of sex difference.)
You can't be diabetic and in the military because the medical regimen and accommodations are too onerous for a fighting force to have to worry about. Any solider that requires nightly "dilation time" for his neo-vagina is NGMI.
How do we go from the corporate freakout of 2016 to like 300 "anti-trans" laws being passed from 2022-2025 with zero corporate pushback of any kind?
Did everyone just realize all once what pernicious nonsense this was?
Trans-identified soldiers were barred from serving in the US military for 89 out of the 96 months of Obama’s presidency. He ended the ban in July 2016.
When Trump reverted to the Obama policy that applied for the first 89 months of Obama’s presidency one year later, Nancy Pelosi announced that the ban “threatened our national security.”
This bizarre lie, so brazen that it cannot have been meant to be believed, made me aware of the unlimited extent and reach of the mendacity that would soon swallow up the Western world.
Up until then, I had seen the issue as a bizarre and comic iteration of “the Left eating itself.” Trans activists shut down Germaine Greer when she tried to speak on a college campus like she was a war criminal, and then Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie was piled on for refusing to say the mantra — for refusing to say that “Trans Women Are Women.” This was a new level of insufferable left wing nonsense, but confined to left activist spaces.
Pelosi’s bizarre lie made me aware that the mania was about to swallow up everything.
Anarchist street militants who want to destroy capitalism and feel entitled to throw bags of feces at people for thinking that...women's sports should be reserved for women...are in lockstep alignment with the HR directors of BlackRock and Goldman Sachs, and every Democratic party official in America.
All work together toward the same goal; the street militants using violent terror, the citadels of global finance directing capital flows toward other trans-affirming corporations, and the Democratic party bringing state power to bear on the 15-year old girls that beg their school boards and state legislature to allow fair competition and must be shut down and punished.
All that stands against them is 80 percent of the American public and 67 percent of all Democrats who know that trans inclusion in women's sports is "deeply unfair," as Gavin Newsom put it, (because trans girls are boys) weeks before Democrats in the California voted legislature unanimously to ensure that boys continue to dominates girls in girls' sports.
Does the will of the people matter, or do powerful, well-funded lobbies working in concert with violent street enforcers ride roughshod over the will of the people into perpetuity?
Quoting @KatieDaviscourt: Breaking: A trans Antifa militant assaulted a volunteer at the TPUSA @Riley_Gaines_ event.
The militant suspect threw a bag of feces at the victim.
Tension has drastically increased. Antifa is now posted up in front of the event venue.
There is no reductio ad absurdum of the transgender privilege movement that can cause any Democrat to say "this has gone too far"
Quoting @MorrellMDmph: This bill—unlimited cosmetics if you say you are trans—will pass Colorado’s Senate today and go to the governor’s desk.
Its sister bill, 1312 is heard again today, it makes calling a man “he” a crime of discrimination, “misgender” and “deadname” enter our legal code.
The Colorado legislature is creating a taxpayer funded privileged caste the cost of whose elective cosmetic procedures will be borne by everyone.
The redefinition of these cosmetic procedures as medically necessary by law is a reductio absurdum of the transgender movement -- as if any further reductio is required. And yet it marches through the legislatures that Democrats control.
"• Men who believe they are women will have their breast implants guaranteed — but women going through breast cancer WILL NOT.
Men who want elective skin tightening procedures will have them covered. But REAL mothers will not.
• Men who want facelifts & eye-lid lifts & nose jobs will have them covered by insurance. But real women will not.
• Men who want hormone therapy to play pretend will have it covered. Women who NEED hormone therapy will not.
• We the people will be paying for CHILDREN’s wrong-sex hormones — oh, and this bill eliminates all data tracking for Testosterone Rxs, so you’ll be paying for SECRET wrong-sex hormones for little girls.
• These reps refuse to acknowledge the care and coverage desperately needed for DEtransitioners. They *only* care about wrong-sex coverage.
Quoting @Erin4Parents: 🚨 While the entire WORLD is watching HB 1312 (aka trans your kid or the state will take them law) — We cannot take our eye off of its sister bill 1309…
This law forces private insurance and Medicaid to cover all elective “trans” procedures.
• Men who believe they are women will have their breast implants guaranteed — but women going through breast cancer WILL NOT.
• Men who want elective skin tightening procedures will have them covered. But REAL mothers will not.
• Men who want facelifts & eye-lid lifts & nose jobs will have them covered by insurance. But real women will not.
• Men who want hormone therapy to play pretend will have it covered. Women who NEED hormone therapy will not.
• We the people will be paying for CHILDREN’s wrong-sex hormones — oh, and this bill eliminates all data tracking for Testosterone Rxs, so you’ll be paying for SECRET wrong-sex hormones for little girls.
• These reps refuse to acknowledge the care and coverage desperately needed for DEtransitioners. They *only* care about wrong-sex coverage.
Here is my testimony against 1309 in house committee. This was rammed through with no debate along with 1312.
Colorado: make your voice heard, or this will be forced on you. Email senators. Testify against it. Tell others. Vote these psychos out.
C3 dehumanizingdenialgov spendingmedical harmstate takes children
"But you used the term 'transgender women.'" Yes, the language should be understood to mean what it is: "a man who presents as a woman and/or claims to be a woman while remaining a man."
I tweeted before the election that I couldn't support Donald Trump because of his history of bringing the causes and people who associate with him to ruin. Obviously if he crashes the economy, which seems likely, then he will lose, the Democrats will have paid no price for their commitment to gender derangement and can return to power in four years and restore the prior status quo of giving unlimited license to the most extreme trans activists to do whatever they want to women and children in the name of inclusion. That's all par for the course.
He's nonetheless done some good things in restoring and enforcing Title IX, issuing EO's that define sex that will at minimum force his Democratic successors to be explicit and on the record about the desperate sophistries they rely on to circumvent these meanings when they try to override them and may do produce even better outcomes than that before courts and other agencies. And this HHS might produce a rigorous study with sound methodology that can withstand all the other associations. (They also might not.) Of course the gender doctors and their enablers in the party will dismiss it regardless of who did it.
The kooks on this issue are all on the pro-trans side: https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/23/23-477/328275/20241015131826340_2024.10.15%20-%20Ala.%20Amicus%20Br.%20iso%20TN%20FINAL.pdf
It showed that social influence was a key factor in the rapid scaling up of transgender ideation in the same mentally comorbid adolescent cohort from which prior social contagions tore through. This has been exhaustively documented by Abigail Shrier and Hannah Barnes, who spoke to dozens of people through the system who witnessed this social phenomenon that anyone can document by talking to one of the thousands of parents who have witnessed it up close, dozens of whom I have interviewed myself. There's no doubt or ambiguity on this matter. It's in the open, there's no basis for a serious or honest person to doubt it. You've shown yourself to be neither.
No it has been copiously documented by the most exhaustive study ever done on the subject, by Hillary Cass, but also by the application of the most basic reason and knowing the history of the derivation of the bullshit claims made by trans-activists. It's all made up bullshit by naked fraudsters and has been repeatedly exposed as such with zero room for ambiguity.
There is no way to justify a 4,000 percent increase in trans-identifying young people, 80 percent of whom are teenage girls, in a half-decade without reference to the waves of social contagion that have repeatedly rippled through the adolescent female population.
All alternative explanations rely on active cult belief or willful credulity of the deepest and most irresponsible kind. The Cass Review and several other reviews by the European social democratic national health services leave zero doubt about what's been happening here.
The (relatively small) role that the very real and totally insane agenda that trans-activists and their enablers in the Democratic party played in the party's loss is entirely the fault of the party, no one else's.
Their choice to ignore criticisms like mine and double down even in defeat on inflicting absurdity and cruelty on the nation's women and children is entirely their own choice, no one else's.
The consequent harms that result from their neglect of reason and reality on this and other issues and the ensuing loss is entirely on them, no one else.
As the consequences of transgender dogmas proliferate along with inclusion policies that impose them, ever greater repression of those resistant to them will be required
Quotes a post by A2156; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
1.) is relevant to transgender inclusion if and only if 2.) is true. No one would bother try to disprove 1.) if 2.) wasn't true. So attempts to disprove 1.) prove 2.).
Those people are the Virgin Data Manipulators; Strangio is the Chad Big Lie Enforcer.
Back in 2017, Ngozi Chimamanda Adichie was asked whether she agreed with the sectarian Left dogma that Trans Women Are Women.
She demurred, saying that "Trans Women are Trans Women."
This demand was then perceived as being on the fringe of progressivism.
Within eighteen months, it was at the center of democratic party policymaking, exerting greater disciplinary power than any other stricture over every elected official within the party at every level of government.
If Trans Women Are Women, then Strangio is right.
There are no men in women's sports and male physical advantage has no bearing on whether women trans women should be allowed to compete against other women.
Strangio played a trick on you by manipulating the meaning of the word "woman" to make it inclusive of people of both sexes. And there's no way to escape the trap he set without acknowledging that Trans Women are Men, the one thing you aren't allowed to do.
If Trans Women are Women, girls who don't want boys in their bathroom are Nazis.
Those girls aren't Nazis if and only if Trans Women are Men.
Either we have an outbreak of Nazism that must be brutally suppressed among 12-15 year old girls
Or
Trans Women Are Men
https://x.com/EndWokeness/status/1906767745682698517
Quoting @EndWokeness: ACLU lawyer: "There are no cases of men in women's sports"
The reason transgender inclusion in women's sports is "deeply unfair" is that:
1.) Men have a physical advantage over women
2.) Trans women are men
In lieu of acknowledging these two facts, the Democratic party calls women and girls begging them to put an end to deep unfairness Nazis.
Gosh, I wish these stunning and brave transgender women didn't keep scoring "own goals" against themselves with "bad optics" by threatening those who resist their demands with murder, particularly recalcitrant women who persist in claiming they have a right to draw boundaries that exclude them to protect their safety and privacy -- it's such a distraction from all their other legitimate and justified demands such as propagandizing children from the earliest age that any of them can change sex, and medicalizing quirky kids of any age who've been convinced by relentless culture wide propaganda that they are trans.
Quotes a post by A0267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentchild indoctrinationcontagionviolence terror
Formal recognition of those harmed by medical transition creates a structure for this burgeoning population to emerge out of the obscurity to which the vindictiveness of trans activists and the indifference of the clinicians who harmed them has kept them confined
Quotes a post by A2621; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I look back at my essay that says "Blacks Trans Lives Matter" repeated 100 times that got me into all the Ivies plus Stanford and CalTech and beam with pride
Quotes a post by T05010; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
None of the convoluted pseudo-scientific or social constructivist sophistries used to rationalize transgenderism offers a more truthful or nuanced description of biological reality than the recognition that sex is binary and immutable, nor do any of them offer a more sophisticated or capacious understanding of human variability across gendered conduct than the blanket stipulation that the physical and mental health of tomboys and girly men is best served by a culture tolerant of atypical self-expression without seeking to reify it into cross-sex identities or through grisly medical experiments.
That you are healthier in an intact body with a functioning reproductive system than one that has been pumped full of exogenous steroids and dismembered for the purpose of purely cosmetic mimicry of the ones belonging to the sex to which you do not belong is a self-evident fact that can only be obscured by deliberate corruption of the normative standards that separate modern medicine from witch-doctoring.
The twin recognitions (of the immutability of sex and the variability of personality) should be recognizable as what liberal humanists interested in reforms aimed at tolerance and inclusion would counsel, while the latter is what postmodern antifoundationalist techno-radicals would seek to impose.
What's of interest is the way postmodern antifoundationalist techno-radicals were able to repackage their wares in liberal humanist garb and make successful appeals to kindness, tolerance, inclusion and reform -- and place these values in the service of an agenda that will subvert and destroy those very values.
Anyone paying attention to the language and conduct of the transgender ideologues sees the inhumanity of this agenda: https://x.com/babybeginner/status/1907355886701756868
Quotes a post by A0267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Bills like this force Democrats go from "it's not happening," to "it's good," parrot desperate canned sophistries bristling with deranged hyperbole and hysteria (likening the protection of women's sports to Jim Crow and Nazism) that trans activists feed them, and publicly announce their will to defy the supermajority of their own voters rather than acknowledge the reality that letting "trans girls" compete against girls in sports is, as Governor Gavin Newsom put it, "deeply unfair" -- because trans girls are boys.
Rather than make this admission about reality and fairness, the Democrats have once again made a party-line vote to ensure that teenage girls are denied fairness.
Quotes a post by T04954; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It was a real missed opportunity that @charliekirk11 did not say "Hold on a second there, Gavin. Explain to me why it's unfair to let a trans girl compete against girls. What's unfair about it?"
The ACLU’s lead trans rights lawyer proceeds from the assumption that Trans Women are Women to assert that “there are no men in women’s sports.”
The assertion was not just a form viral marketing, it is the whole of the claim upon which the entire legal and medicine edifice is construed.
When they got the whole of the Democratic party to chant the mantra, they extracted their agreement to everything that followed.
Here in this tweet, Strangio dares and taunts those who have signed on to the full agenda to concede the existence of a countervailing right to fair competition — the right that Gavin Newson conceded when he noted that trans inclusion in girl’s sports is “deeply unfair .”
Newson did not say why it is unfair because he could not say what Strangio dared him to say in his tweet - the thing that no one can say because it is true and everyone knows it is true and the world of make-believe depends on its suppression.
Quoting @EndWokeness: ACLU lawyer: "There are no cases of men in women's sports"
I have no way of judging whether this figure is true or plausible. SImon based the estimate on the rapid growth of r/detrans subreddit (57K members) and the activity at on the detrans discord where he talks to hundreds of others detransitioners who are in hiding.
He went on to assert that in 5-10 years, this ever burgeoning population will be protesting in the street demanding redress and retribution against those who brainwashed them into medicalized self-harm when they were screwed up children with no capacity to consent.
I don't know if that's true either. But it does pose an intriguing prospect. I have long noted that the reason a tiny vanguard of fanatics has managed to dominate the public on issues where a robust supermajority rejects the claims of that vanguard is precisely that the preferences of large majorities are often by virtue of being so self-evidently correct, passively rather than actively held, and thus subject to being overridden by a vanguard pledged to a passionately-held error.
What is required to overcome such passion it a group that becomes equally impassioned on behalf of what are the passively held preferences of the vast majority.
Those who were directly harmed by the ideology are of course the primary candidates for this. At the moment, we have mostly a self-selected group of unusually honest, unusually courageous, and well-spoken members of this cohort willing to speak up.
But as the numbers of those who have been harmed swell, we will need -- and are likely to see the emergence -- of an army of those willing to march and get passionate and get loud, bringing numbers to bear against the vanguard. And they could be an important force against the trans activist mobs that use violence, threats, and intimidation to ensure that only the most disagreeable and most courageous speak.
Quoting @wesyang: I recently asked Simon to estimate the ratio of detransitioned youth who are in hiding from vindictive trans activists to those who are willing to be public about it like himself.
"500 to 1," he replied. "There are thousands of us."
This is the transgender advocacy organization where Chase Strangio got a start pushing to force US prisons to house male rapists and murderers with women
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: A prominent trans activist organization in New York actively recruited a convicted pedophile to be a spokesperson for their organization.
Despite having raped a toddler, sex offender Xena Grandichelli (Jeffrey Willsea) has been performing "community outreach" for the Sylvia Rivera Law Project, which assists male convicts in legally changing their identities.
#TransDayOfVisibility
This is a pithy condensation of my speech delivered at Genspect referring to just a few of bizarre entailments of the transgender ideology and movement: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pisxTjRvJ_o&t=152s
The teen girls speaking at meetings in defense of girls sports are the germ of this emerging trend. They just need a handful of enterprising ones to create appealing messaging on TikTok for this spread as rapidly as the trans contagion spread.
Why do the vast majority not seek a transfer?
I’ll tell you what, convince the ACLU to seek a separate ward for Trans identified males with no contact with the female population, and I’m sure most will not object.
I wouldn’t mind a separate prison or a separate ward. if safety is the issue (but then why do the vast majority of trans id males not seek a transfer? Because homosexual transsexuals prefer to be around men) then of course they can have a separate ward within the men’s prison.
You are trying to distinguish your relative from men who simply claim to be women with reference to the yearslong persistence of his cross sex identification, the earliness of his medicalization, and the consequent convincing character of his appearance.
In practical terms, these aspects mean a lot to the character of his experience and of the ease with which he is accommodated socially. They do distinguish him from the hulking AGP’s who get euphoria boners while taking selfies in the girls room.
If he really is part of the 1-2 percent who passes seamlessly, then he gets to live the way many trans identified people wish to be able to live, having his preferred pronouns deployed by default , without any request, and his ability to access women’s private spaces unchallenged.
But there is no ambiguity about his sex, which was not changed by the cascade of early interventions that refashioned him to resemble the opposite sex, and which must remain the basis of separated sports and spaces. He cannot compete against women in sports or enter their spaces as a matter of right, even if he cannot compete against pass undetected. He must register with Selective Service at the age of 18 like all other American males. There is no cruelty or unfairness in any of this, and there is no denial of any right that he holds.
There are no trans wards separated from the general population — and when transgender prisoner sought the arrangement, the ACLU advocating on their ostensible behalf rejected it as stigmatizing and pursued a litigation course seeking full recognition of trans identified males as women and their inclusion into the general female population.
No, the biggest sin of the trans movement is brainwashing thousands of teenagers to yearn to dismember themselves and threaten suicide if their parents don’t consent to medicalized self-harm with the active collusion of teachers who violate constitutional rights to lie to their parents about name and pronoun changes
Quoting @RichardHanania: The biggest sin of the trans movement is that it created a generation of rightists who believe they can stop trying to learn anything and always reply “what is a woman?” as the answer to all social and political questions.
If you agree with that statement, you support the transgender movement.
If you disagree with that statement, you oppose the transgender movement -- and the transgender opposes you.
Ordinary people actually have to witness cruelties and absurdities being inflicted on their daughters before they care enough about this issue to get activated and match the passion of the trans-affirming side. Maine is one place that has crossed this threshold.
Quotes a post by A2704; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Tonight, Democratic party senators will demonstrate their obeisance to transgender ideologues when the vast majority of them, perhaps with one or two holdouts, defy the will of 67 percent of their own voters to vote against the Protection of Women and Girls in Sports Act
Anyone familiar with the violent meltdown of the black radical successor movements to the civil right movement of the 1970’s — from the Weather Underground and Symbionese Liberation Army to Jonestown — can see the same dynamics at work in the transgender movement, scaled up by several orders of magnitude by social media.
Four decades after the American electorate decisively rejected dead end racial radicalism, the entire stock of slogans came to be taught to millions of schoolchildren after a long march through the institutions.
The transgender movement differs from black radicalism in that it began life propagated by the institutions that had already been captured. The doctrines were scarcely invented before they were being taught to the youngest schoolchildren.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Zizian-like Trantifa extremists have been promoting a slogan about killing people if their trans identity is not affirmed and their demands are not met.
They’ve been boasting about stockpiling firearms and recruiting veterans for paramilitary insurrection groups.
C2 false claimshand-codedchild indoctrinationideology cultinstitutional capturepolitical enemyviolence terror
Anyone paying attention to the relentless phobia indoctrination, violent imagery, and rhetoric about "trans genocide" constantly in circulation within the transgender movement throughout the Biden Administration, which worked tirelessly to satisfy every possible trans activist demand, will not be at all surprised if this direct call for violent resistance by a 500K Facebook group yields actual violence in the real world
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: A Zizian-like trans terror group on Facebook called "Trans Army" has over half a million followers and is urging its comrades to recruit ex-military members, stockpile weapons and train to kill for a paramilitary insurrection against the U.S. government. https://ngo.locals.com/post/6717869/trans-extremists-recruiting-armed-militants-for-paramilitary-death-cult
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Seth Moulton made some waves by saying that he didn't want his daughters competing against boys in sports and resents not being able to say that, was instantly met by huge protests and a promise by party leaders to primary him, and justified his vote against the Protection of Women in Sports Act by repeating absurd fabricated trans activist propaganda claim that it would require "genital checks" to be enforced.
https://x.com/BuckDharma2/status/1896246320001867950
Quotes a post by T31236; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Nothing will disabuse you of the notion that there is any coherent grounding for the claims of transgender identity more completely than reading the legal filings and academic output of proponents of the claims of transgender identity
"We can easily strike a moderate, reasonable balance where we remove trans women from sports, keep male rapists and murderers out of women's prisons, and exercise reasonable safeguards about transitioning children while continuing to shame and stigmatize anyone who refers to the inescapability of biological reality."
Actually no -- no you can't.
There is no way off of this precipice that doesn't involve a party leader saying some version of "trans women are men." You can't overcome falsehood without reference to truth.
Quotes a post by T03966; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A moderate Democratic party think tank had a meeting and agreed that the party going forward should "ban far-left candidate questionnaires and refuse to participate in forums that create ideological purity test."
This of course is a reference to the ACLU's questionnaire in which Kamala Harris endorsed giving gender surgeries to trans-identified illegal aliens in US custody that became a flashpoint in the election when an ABC News moderator falsely "factchecked" Trump's accurate claim that Harris had endorsed the practice.
The five page document of takeaways is nonetheless unable to name the 80/20 issue with which the party must break decisively if it seeks to cease being associated with the infliction of cruelties and absurdities on ordinary people: a search for the term "gender" generates zero results.
Like all cluster B manipulation, the trans movement began with weepy appeals for empathy and compassion and when those ceased to be effective as people came to understand the necessary entailments of the movement's demands, they moved to violent mob intimidation.
The Iowa legislature and governor stood firm in doing the right thing -- others must show the same fortitude.
https://x.com/WomenReadWomen/status/1895414821711204474
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: Just hours ago, "gender identity" was successfully removed as a protected characteristic from the Iowa Civil Rights Act.
Leading up to the decision, hundreds of trans activists filled the State Capitol building in protest, and shouted "F*ck you, fascists."
Senate File 418 passed in a 33-15 vote.
Less than an hour later, the Iowa House passed its version, House File 583, with a vote of 60-35.
All one has to do to unravel the mystifications of transgender ideology is describe its practices in plain language rather then the contorted jargon that has the intended effect of begging every question in order to manipulate you into consent
Quotes a post by A0873; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Voters believe Democrats are too obsessed with trans rights because parents 1.) have seen their K-3 children propagandized by schools that any of them can change sex, 2.) have seen teachers lie to parents about name and pronoun changes of their children enacted at school without parental notice or consent, 3.) have heard their daughters don't use the bathroom all day because any boy who claims to be a girl can use the girls room, 4.) have seen clusters of girls identify as boys in schools where teachers proselytize trans identities to any quirky kid, and 5.) seen girls who don't want to compete against boys in sports punished for it by their schools, 6.) have watched Joe Biden mandate that every school in America give any boy who says he is girl access to the intimate spaces of women, 7.) watched a man who began claiming to be a woman after marrying and raising a family in his 50's pressure WPATH from his perch in the Department of Health and Human Services to strip out all age limits on all transgender procedures, including surgeries, 8.) watched the Solicitor General of the United States claim without evidence that child sex changes are lifesaving, saw 9.) Vice President Kamala Harris write a letter to Dylan Mulvaney, an untransitioned male who became a TikTok sensation while claiming to be a woman but insisting on "normalizing the bulge", commemorating "365 Days of Girlhood," and witnessed 10.) Democratic legislatures in California and Minnesota mandate that any man who claims to be a woman has the right to be imprisoned with women.
Quotes a post by T00072; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Nothing will happen to make any of these numbers move in the other direction than the one they have been rapidly trending toward as people learn what these demands of the transgender movement yield in practice
Quoting @buttonslives: New @pewresearch: A majority of U.S. adults (56%) now favor laws banning medical interventions for gender transitions in minors.
And this number will only keep growing!
The judge’s aberrant behavior should not surprise any observer of the conduct of transgender advocates in every domain.
Sustaining belief in falsehoods and absurdities necessarily leads to moral and intellectual contortions and drastic departures from professional norms.
Quotes a post by A1663; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Title IX created a separate but equal legal regime based on the premise that female equality required protected domains (sports, changing rooms, shelters, prisons) from which men would be excluded.
Overwriting sex as the relevant class with "gender identity" means that any man who claims to be a woman becomes a part of the class of person entitled to access to those protected domains.
Insofar as the ability to identify into one of those protected domains has been framed as constitutive of "trans rights" by the transgender movement, there is an irreconcilable clash of interests between the rights protected by Title IX and "trans rights."
You can protect the class of person defined by sex or the class of person defined by gender identity at the expense of the class of person defined by sex. Those are your choices.
All of Blue America has chosen to annul the rights of the class of person protected by Title IX, an approach that the federal judge who vacated the Biden Administration's attempt to overwrite sex by gender identity in Department of Education regulations ruled to be illegitimate.
Iowa is attempting to reaffirm that Title IX protects women, not any person who claims to be a woman -- and are being met by the physical commandeering of their legislature by a mob.
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: JUST IN: Trans rights activists storm the Iowa State Capitol as lawmakers consider a bill to remove gender identity as a protected class
You CANNOT protect both sex and gender identity in law as they directly contradict each other. Stay strong, @[private account] !!!
After a decade of pretending to be a boy starting at the age of 12, no trans activist is going to say anything to Maia that she hasn't encountered before or said herself and exposed as desperate sophistry on her path to growing up and getting over the LARP that consumed her youth
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: I’m doing my first college speaking event with @TPUSA at the University of Oregon tomorrow. It’s by far one of the wokest campuses there is.
How do you think it’ll go for me?
If you've paid attention over the last decade, you should realize that the thing that sounds too ludicrously on-the-nose not to be a made up smear often ends up being fully documented.
Thus: "Transgender Vegan AI Murder Cult," and "Transgender Marxist Cult in the NSA"
Quoting @christopherrufo: The NSA whistleblower tells me there is a clique of male-to-female transgender Marxists who have established a "cult" inside the agency. "They hate capitalism. They hate Christians. They're always espousing Marxist beliefs."
"It infected everything."
https://www.city-journal.org/article/nsa-whistleblower-trans-gender-ideology-dei
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedideology cultinstitutional capturemental illnesspolitical enemyviolence terror
NSA whistleblower tells Rufo that trans-identified NSA staff wouldn't report on adversaries under surveillance if it required using someone's "deadname."
"You had analysts that didn’t want to do the reporting they were supposed to be doing because they were going to have to report on somebody’s “dead name.” They were having this crisis of conscience about reporting the adversary’s actual name because they thought it was their “dead name,” and they didn’t want to disrespect the person. It was like a cult that was hellbent on pushing gender ideology."
Quoting @christopherrufo: EXCLUSIVE: A longtime NSA insider explains how trans activists infiltrated the agency, pushed Marxist politics, and jeopardized national security. "It was like a cult that was hellbent on pushing gender ideology."
"It's going to get people killed in the field."
Why are Democratic politicians at every level doubling down on deranged laws that do things like ban the misgendering of the dead?
Because they are fully bought into deranged misinformation and pseudo-science in constant circulation in the trans activist echo chamber.
Quoting @Erin4Parents: Colorado Rep Karen McCormick @[private account] just said (while explaining her bill to make it criminal to misgender dead people) that a baby’s sex is determined in the 1st trimester — but their GENDER IDENTITY is formed in the 2nd trimester. 👀
@[private account] @JamieWhistle @MorrellMDmph @SwipeWright @[private account]
None of the other demands of the trans movement that Democrats at every level government are working tirelessly to impose — imprisoning male rapists and murderers with women and paying for their sex change operations with taxpayer funds; forcing every school and public accommodation in America to allow access to women’s intimate spaces to grant access to any man who claims to be a woman; teaching every kindergartener that any of them who fails to conform to sex stereotypes that they were born wrong and can be fixed by chemical castration and surgery; using Child Protective Services to snatch away children from parents who don’t want to place their children who have been caught up in the ongoing transgender social contagion on a conveyor belt to a lifetime on a medical leash; banning mental health providers from exploring the underlying comorbidities that manifest as trans ideation; refusing to enforce custody orders for non-affirming parents; allowing adolescent minors to consent to transgender medicalization in defiance of parental will; facilitating the social transition of trans-identified children while actively conspiring to deceive parents that this is ongoing — is any more popular. But the issue is the heart and soul of the party and giving an inch on any them is what is meant by those darkly warning that the party must not “throw trans people under the bus.” Ceasing to do any of the above is what is meant by that term.
Is gender fluid or immutable? It needs to be immutable to become a protected class, so lawyers tell judges that it is immutable. But Germany has already passed legislation allowing anyone to change their official gender designation every year. The law includes a provision for imposing fines on those who refer to prior gender designations in the present with derisive intent.
Is gender dysphoria a mental illness or is it a slur to call it a mental illness? There needs to be a medical condition to treat when insurance companies and Medicare pay for castration and facial feminization surgery, so gender dysphoria remains in the DSM as a mental illness.
But Twitter used to ban people for referring to this fact. And transgender academics have written that concern that trans masculine women who continue taking testosterone during pregnancy should not be pressured to expose their fetuses to the risk of birth defects since that concern represents the desire for normative bodies that is mere prejudice. This is to say that there is no stable definition of health or illness apart from what a person desires to do to themselves.
This sociopathic unconcern for intellectual and moral consistency is characteristic of a movement based on attempting to turn a counterfactual assertion about the self into an identity claim — my true self is what I am not and can never be; you must agree or be branded a bigot and silenced by state power. They are making it all up as they go along. They are saying whatever they must to get what they want depending on the situation. The incoherence is a feature not a bug of their approach to seizing coercive power for themselves. The symmetry is perfect along every dimension: the movement masquerades as medicine and as civil rights but it is neither, all in the service of people masquerading as what they are not.
The most revealing disclosures about what drives transgender ideation are always posted by the trans-identified themselves
Quoting @WomenReadWomen: Hunter Schafer's deleted Instagram post from 2018 is so disturbing that The Daily Mail once mistook it for a school shooter's manifesto.
"My gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."
"My sexual orientation was not gay, it was not straight, is an attraction, always to misogyny."
"Not feeling femme enough w/o being a victim of r*pe... The idea of being eaten used to arouse me."
It's an 80/20 issue, with a solid majority of Democrats opposed to letting boys compete against girls in girls' sport.
Even the Biden Administration's trans-affirming Title IX overhaul avoided mandating allowing boys to compete against girls nationally. The rest of it was enjoined nationally by a federal judge and the Biden administration itself rescinded the regulations in its waning days.
Quotes a post by A1095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Brianna may be one of the only trans-identified persons acknowledging publicly that 1.) pediatric gender medicine has never been evidence-based, 2.) the cohort of teenage girls who are chiefly responsible for the 4000 percent surge of trans-identification in today's young people are socially influenced, 3.) 80+ percent of gender dysphoric youths would desist if not affirmed, 4.) gender clinics have stripped out all gatekeeping for those claiming a trans-identity and will give anyone seeking cross-sex hormones a prescription at their first appointment -- all of which Brianna eagerly (and correctly) affirms as true during the course of Sapir's presentation.
So far so good.
However, 1/x
Quotes a post by T04133; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Our professional classes parroting gaslighting lies fabricated by transgender activists while looking and sounding sober and authoritative. A grotesque travesty.
Quotes a post by A2621; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes, the transgender movement requires the cannibalization of the privacy and safety of women and girls and a prohibition on the exercise of everyone's rights to free conscience and free speech when it conflicts with the imperative to affirm a counterfactual assertion about the self made by a class of person that anyone can identify into.
An assault on the rights of all is a necessary condition for the protection of the right of a tiny minority to be recognized as something they are not.
Quotes a post by T05705; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is no transgender inclusive policy that bars this male sex offender who claims to be a woman from the girl's locker room while allowing other males who claim to be women into the girl's locker room. Either you believe that claiming to be a woman is what makes someone a woman or you don't.
The Biden Administration issued regulations mandating that every school in America give access to the girl's room to any boy claims to be a girl. Every House Democrat voted in support of the Equality Act, which would have extended this mandate to every public accommodation in America.
Schools throughout Blue America are defying Trump administration executive orders mandating that private spaces be separated by sex. They claim to be on the right side of history. They claim that ensuring that any man who claims to be a woman gets to use a changing room with girls is "the civil rights movement of the 21st century."
I think this is an absurd and malign travesty of a civil rights movement and that anyone who says otherwise is a liar or a maniac.
Quotes a post by T00652; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The movement that institutional America has declared to be the civil rights movement of the 21st and rallied all of its powers in messaging and coercion to impose on every American proceeds from this premise: that acknowledging that trans-identified males are males and that their maleness disqualifies them from certain domains restricted to girls and women in the interests of their safety, privacy, and the fairness of competition is a form of violent erasure of "trans people" (boys and men who claim to be women or girls based on unverifiable and unfalsifiable claim of a non-observable subjective entity called a "gender identity" knowable solely through the testimonial of the bearer of that identity, which is not immutable and can change over time, but that must be honored in whatever state the bearer claims it to be at a given moment) that can rightly be prohibited and punished by the state.
The corruption of Scientific American and the actual peer reviewed journals by mindless copypasta on gender and race bears its poisoned fruit when we learn that federal judges have imbibed the desperate sophistry trans activists have successfully embedded into them as fact
Quotes a post by A3114; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Brinton’s assault on the social fabric upon which we all rely was truly depraved. He also fabricated a story of his own conversion therapy that helped push through laws banning the practice that has had a chilling effect on the treatment of young people caught up in a social contagion of transgender ideation.
But the greater moral outlaw is the man to his left, who used his perch in the Biden Administration to push WPATH to strip out ALL age limits on transgender procedures