The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
This is very common. Dysphoria is only mentioned by one of my doctors near the end, in part because gender dysphoria was not a diagnosis in the first half of my time as a trans individual. The rest of them said I needed the extra hormones for endometriosis (which I don't have and which he documented "there is no physical evidence" of endometriosis), dysmenorrhea ("regular light periods" documented at baseline) and headaches (obviously progestin is not indicated to treat unexplained headaches). Because the dose and combination I was on was not indicated for birth control, it was not free like birth control was, so it had to be medically necessary to be covered, which meant I needed these extra diagnoses.
Oh of course I forgot, he's trans and cut his dick off so now he can do whatever he wants anywhere he wants, sabotage any woman's efforts, threaten or actually batter any woman he pleases.
Sorry Ari has the right! An entitlement he earned. He had such a hard life! Now it's your turn.
The state of terfery in 2026 is EMBARRASSING if this is how you're really reasoning.
I don't go to sports games and don't know what's normal at these events. But if trans flags make him violent to be near then the burden was on him to leave, not start hitting women.
I just feel like there's not enough information to fully judge it and that I'm being invited to have an emotional reaction to the fact that they were escorted out and people with trans flags got to stay. But after the Seattle hoax involving the same videographer, I'm skeptical.
How do we tell the trans people killing themselves because of bullying apart from the fake trans people cross dressing before suicide due to a random mental health episode?
Have you thought about making a satire skit called Mother Ted where Father Ted transitions, in order to traumatize the pro trans Father Ted fans who don't understand what they're supporting?
So the larger running joke for my followers is that I'm a trans trans woman, the most oppressed kind. This thread is full of so much affirmation of that even though none of these people would agree that I'm a female trans woman.
Quotes a post by T22398; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Ilhan Omar's citizenship is derivative through her father, who claimed in 2000 that she was 17. You have to be a minor at the time to get citizenship this way. AJ Kern noticed that 2000-1981>18. So Ilhan's staff changed her birth year to 1982.
Trans-age is no longer satire.
Quotes a post by A0105; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I'm a detransitioner because I was trans before and now I'm not actually. I'm not sure why you're pretending to not understand how things work. @[private account] can you explain what a detransitioner is to this poor confused twitter bitterer?
I was in that 5 to 15%! That appendectomy was a few weeks after I first announced my trans identity and played a significant role in delaying top surgery for me since I was conditioned to be skeptical of the idea I needed a life saving surgery urgently by that experience.
I am so excited to read @MrAndyNgo's book about a group of homegrown transgender terrorists spawned by the SF Bay Area school of thought called Rationalism but incorporating elements of other ideologies like Veganism and Anarchism.
C2 false claimshand-codedideology cultviolence terror
An eye doctor reviewed medical charts of female to male patients, average age 26, on unspecified gender affirming hormone therapy and found the most common neurological comorbidity was increased intracranial hypertension, a known complication of all of the hormones used in gender affirming care that can lead to irreversible vision loss.
Instances of ocular findings in transgender patients undergoing hormonal therapy - PubMed https://share.google/xdQKhtETPBhRwPZE8
Let me help you off my timeline if you think I need to stop posting my entirely legal opinions about trans lunatics in public, just because they demand it.
Quotes a post by T00001; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I've made content in the past documenting the drag-trans-sex-work-medical-industrial complex before, but it is always great to have a clear demonstration of how transitioning men will use interpersonal degradation as well as financial concerns to manipulate targets into considering sex work and surgeries. For more on this I Am Jazz's Waking Nightmare: Dragnet
We have a definition but we aren't allowed to name it. Ask a TRA some time what's the label that goes with the definition adult human female. This category includes all trans/nonbinary and all non-trans/non-nonbinary adult human females, and only them. They can't do it. The category is denied a name in law.
I would call them vigilantes if the narrative is true. What it is not is an anti-trans hate crime, just because people noticed she got more violent and mentally ill after she started doing T. These people put up with her shit for 16 years knowing she'd broken their daughter's back violently pretty much on the first date it seems.
Yea I'm wearing a binder in that photo you posted due to never being trans. That's why my bachelor's is in gender studies. I was planning ahead to pretend to be detrans to become a famous terf. And my plan was, I'll take extra birth control. This theory makes so much sense.
I'm not 20 anymore but when I was, I got a lot more attention than I cared for which contributed to the great trans rite of the first haircut after discovering your gender.
"If you were thinking about becoming trans after losing your reproductive organs, you were already trans/have gender dysphoria"
This is the official definition of "being trans" going in. Only trans people think they are trans, and only trans people even wonder if they are trans. The definition coming out is entirely different, since discrediting and minimizing the number of apostates is a political project. If you stop thinking you are trans, you were never trans to begin with. Doubt is the time-traveling cure for the gender dysphoria you never had.
Quotes a post by T01073; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Wait I'm confused. So you're trans as soon as you think about being trans? I feel like you've told me I wasn't trans because I didn't undergo xyz medical regimen but here you seem to be using the standard, unmotivated definition pushed to potential newbies. Why the double standard?
Who knows, but you seem to see no issue with transitioning kids and putting them at risk of being bullied into suicide because their peers know they're trans.
There's no path to discovery that you're a trans woman that involves direct experience of femaleness. I've been told many times I'm too female to be a trans woman.
The number of times I've seen them use not being called out in every interaction or a trans ally humoring them as proof everyone is convinced is unsurprising.
I think any time a man wants to be a woman and gets so fixated on that it becomes his whole personality, that's AGP. And i think it's genetically encoded as a reproductive strategy and some men are guaranteed to manifest the trait and some will if they have brain injury or some other disorder that brings it out. But I think it's far older than our species. "Trans people have always existed" Faeder males in ruff birds, cuttlefish... sex mimicry creates reproductive opportunities as well as camouflage and safety from conflicts with males.
Does Gender Dysphoria Exist?
If you think you're trans, you're halfway there, and if you wanna go for it, you've made it. Here's your necrotic skin tube.
Link below to my latest substack essay.
He wants to be treated as another gender. He's transitioning to the gender of woman for the purposes of playing as a woman. Trans people are valid even if they don't want to medically transition according to psychiatry.
Get over it! He identifies as a trans woman so he's a trans woman. A trans woman is anyone who identifies as a trans woman because *gender is a social construct.*
Stop being a hateful bigot and make room at the table for your fellow trans woman. Trans women don't owe you femininity. You're probably just mad because he's so attractive that no one will want you anymore. It's really sad how you can't be tolerant when it literally costs nothing to be kind.
Quoting @stacycay: Enes Kanter used to be one of my favorite players, man. Now he’s the face of mocking trans women. I can’t have shit. I’m so fucking angry and I know it’s not funny to just say that but can you people give us a break for a single day? At what point will it be enough for you?
Gender dysphoria is a pattern of clinically observable preoccupation, and so it can exist even if there's no such thing as gender identity. Gender dysphoria is the label for the psychological illness characterized by a belief in gender identity conflicting with sex, and trans ideology is the reality claim the illness has caused many to make, such as their industry abusers trying to sell million dollar diseased arm skin piss funnels to teenagers.
The actual DSM-V criteria for gender dysphoria does not explicitly reference the term gender identity. It refers to experienced or expressed gender (how you say you feel and how you look to others) and assigned gender (what's socially and biologically expected of your legal sex), but also personal beliefs about whether you have gender dysphoria are literally one of the ways to have gender dysphoria. It's just gender dysphoria all the way down. If you think you're trans, you're halfway to a diagnosis. If you also want to trans, here's your nipples in a doggie bag so we don't clog the shower drain. Dysphoria cured.
Gender incongruence is one of SIX possible manifestations of gender dysphoria under the DSM-5. You need only TWO to qualify. You don't actually need to feel gender incongruent to have gender dysphoria. Wanting to get rid of your sex traits - what drove my use of HRT - is its own criterion.
Another criterion is wanting to be the opposite sex (trans classic). Again independent of that, is the desire to not be your sex, even if you don't want to be the other sex (nonbinitarianism). The final two are a DESIRE to be treated as a different gender and a BELIEF you're more like another gender. And yes this is an illness often borne of an incomplete theory of the world, specifically an unquestioned belief that atypical reaction patterns for an individual member of a sex category are pathological, or not mirrored in the diversity of individuals of the other sex. It can be worked through in therapy.
During my time on hormonal suppression and binding, I definitely met the official diagnostic criteria for gender dysphoria even though I had no interest, after beginning hormones and altering my appearance, to further look specifically like a man or have more of the physical traits of a man. I was happy with having fewer female traits and had a conviction my personality did not match the gender I was assigned.
This criterion based diagnosis is not ranked. You aren't more or less gender dysphoric depending on what transition interventions you wish to select. Transition is how you respond to the conclusion that you're experiencing what psychiatry has defined as gender dysphoria with reference to these 6 observable or reportable criteria.
To suggest gender dysphoria cannot describe a person's preoccupations if gender identity does not exist is not consistent with what the DSM says. Gender dysphoria, like psychiatric diagnoses generally, is not a pathogen that can be isolated. It is a pattern of psychological preoccupation some people have, for complex reasons that detrans people are pretty publicly and PAINSTAKINGLY, facing significant ostracism and denigration, picking ourselves apart to show you.
It is also akin to saying capgras delusion can't exist unless the family members are actually imposters, or cotard's syndrome can't exist since obviously the patient isn't dead, and so we shouldn't have a specific label for those specific neuropsych patterns of fixed false belief, that may be neurogenic. And that's what a sense of gender identity conflicting with sex is. A fixed false belief. No one has a gender identity.
Some people do have gender dysphoria just like some people do have OCD. But no one needs to transition to prevent suicide and no one needs to wash their hands 100 times so the planes don't fall out of the sky. The clinical label documents the reason for the clinical services. It doesn't require the patients beliefs be true, just qualitatively identifiable.
I don't know that I follow the parallel here regarding "aligning the body with the deeper identity" wrt to scientology as someone that was raised by two Hubbardians. Regarding thetans, my view is that gender is an operating thetan in trans classic. It's the same a you and you can't change your gender identity. But in nonbinitarianism, gender identity is more like body thetans. You can have more than one and they can move around and you can feel when they change because they're distinct from you.
Detransition is rare until you remember that trans people might need to go off HRT for any number of reasons besides regret and need to know how to do that safely regardless of how rare it is.
Quotes a post by T09240; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Abortion is gender-afforming care, because gender affirming care means any intervention aimed at aligning your physiology with your sense of personal identity. If you identify as a non-pregnant woman, this care affirms that category. If a man identifies as a breastfeeding mother, he can get drugs and trafficked infants to affirm that too. That's the way they make it about discrimination against trans people to not offer them the vanity phenotype they prefer, if "c!s" women can access bodily specific care.
She wants to be a victimized child so bad but she can't keep her lies straight. Half the time she's pandering to the right by calling being a lesbian a cult she got groomed into, the rest of the time she was a brave gay rights activist when the gay rights movement was noble and pure (2012?!?) who was groomed into trans by a mix of butch fetishizing girlfriends and doctors because of how much endometriosis affected her cognitive functioning. And then on top of that there's the inherent retransition pressure created by my content somehow. The world just wants her to be trans so bad.
I thought she was naturally butch and that's why she will never be feminine and why her doctors groomed her into trans. Now she was groomed into being butch? How does Tina from 4th grade factor into this?
Yes and I did something to my body I needed a major surgery to correct even though it was drug induced. But some people tell me it doesn't count because it was different than what they did to their body in the name of trans.
My take is that gender is a multiple meaning word. In gender theory, it's commonly used to refer both to sex (as in laws that mention 3 different concepts, gender identity, gender, and gender expression) and to the socially constructed categories of things that go along with sex (gender expression or apparent sex as wrt DSDs where a male sex individual looks like a woman, that's sex not equaling gender) and to your internal mental sense of sex or gender expression preferences (gender identity). And so what anyone means by gender needs to be nailed down.
So in that sense different trans identified men would be a different gender category than non trans identified men, even if they are the same biological or legal sex ("more than two genders). But when you get into "there is no sex binary" then you have categories with no anchor, the Baudrillardian "desert of the real," where anyone can be anything and there's no health consequences to messing around with your biology.
The discourse in the detrans community about who counts as a detransitioner, who "really transitioned" is not an organic or spontaneous discussion but rather something detransitioners are bringing with us from trans discourse. Because the GC side supposedly thinks no one really transitions, so that belief is imported into the GC community from people who were trans or "trans allies" and think "really transitioning" is possible.
So everyone having the discussion should be aware that the official trans ideology party line is that it is ableist and transphobic to expect trans people to take any particular medical steps, OR to deny them any medical steps they would like to take.
Quoting @OliLondonTV: Non-binary man accuses the trans community of being ‘transphobic’ towards him because he never had hormones or surgery.
“Non-binary people do not owe you visible distance from the gender we were assigned.”
Even Dr Gallagher is warning about testosterone pellets. But I think it's just becoming fashionable to be trans-critical. She's not like other mutilators. She cares.
The Zizian transgender murder cult is from my own backyard in the Berkeley, CA rationalist movement, which I was once a part of when running Cal Berkeley's Students Advocating a Nonreligious Ethos, or SANE, the secular student club. I'm really looking forward to reading this.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Trans violence is real.
Investigating this secretive trans death cult took me back to America. It put my life at risk again.
Hormones. Human experimentation. Swords. Guns. Bodies.
This is the true story of the Zizians.
ON SALE OCT. 13. PRE-ORDER NOW. https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/andy-ngo/the-zizians/9780316599030/
Her detransition was about finding a new group of surrogate parents to be disappointed by, thus acting out her childhood issues yet again. Now she's saying her detransition was some kind of performance art to attack the reputations of people who welcomed a detransitioner and also criticized a trans activist. In her mind, she's proven other people are liars with bad motives. But in reality she proved she's a liar with bad motives.
"Why would I have flown all the way to Seattle to piss off trans people?!" because Ari lives in Seattle obviously and also she bragged that this was her plan and intention.
She's so done as an attorney. She's gonna long for the day she was just getting spanked by the trans community and sat in time out while her friend Ari did nothing.
I assume she thinks I'm the mastermind of all the complaints that got submitted over her little trans genocide attempt in the park, because I commented on the news story a few times.
I think ultimately it comes down to the fact that some people are preoccupied with being the other sex, for reasons unspecified, and some aren't. The convention is to term the preoccupied as "having gender dysphoria" and the non-preoccupied as "not having gender dysphoria." The fact the gender dysphoria is socially engineered doesn't seem that relevant to the fact that some people had an experience of believing this thing and pursuing behaviors associated with it.
I genuinely see this debate as similar to the 4 blind men trying to describe an elephant, as well as a euphemism treadmill. If you get rid of one term, people with the preoccupation will coin another. I had been trans for 4 years when the DSM started using the term gender dysphoria. Later, that term may fall out of fashion.
Looking back, I agree my school took advantage of the other problems I had, to socially engineer a belief that the true cause was dissatisfaction with being female, so they could sell me drugs, surgeries, clothing, haircuts, a larger political ideology, a sexual fantasy, etc. But my experience was still someone who acquired this socially engineered belief, and therefore I was in the group that "had gender dysphoria."
If the solution to all the people who only think they're preoccupied with their gender is widespread political and psychological reeducation of the preoccupied, with the aim of reducing that preoccupation, that is an implicit acknowledgment of the fact that "there's a there there." Not only does gender dysphoria have to exist to be the product of social engineering, we're now discussing the best clinical approach to a patient presenting with it.
In the cruel Little Albert experiment, a baby was conditioned socially by scientists trying to engineer him to believe a rabbit was a threat. It worked. Little Albert became fearful and distressed around the rabbit. Even though his anxiety response to and beliefs about the rabbit were socially engineered, Little Albert still "had a fear of rabbits."
So this guy can't treat his medical condition without being "trans" involuntarily because the malformation caused by his medical condition is considered by some on the internet and the medical system as somehow making a him a male girl and therefore "medically female." If you don't identify with the sex you were assigned at birth, you're now trans. Pubmed has a similar case study of a man with CAIS who sought phalloplasty.
That have a hypoplastic vagina and uterus. It is possible Scalf was put on feminizing hormone therapy as an adolescent with his condition was discovered due to the ideological position that a male who has female resembling genitalia or was AFAB and who was raised a girl will identify as a woman unless they're trans. So already some people who put a lot of energy into telling the internet I'm trying to control the care of DSD patients are insisting Scalf is a trans man (FTM) and that correcting his congenital testosterone deficiency is therefore nothing to do with DSD-related medical care.
This story is sure to ruffle some feathers.
Shepard Scalf purportedly has XY chromosomes and a genitalia malformation due to a hormone deficiency caused by Swyer Syndrome. Scalfidentifies as a man and presents as a man and allegedly was fired due to appearing trans.
According to some idealogues on this app, Scalf is trans because Swyer patients are medically female and therefore this adult human male who just wants to correct his hormone deficiency to be in line with norms for his sex, transitioned.
Quotes a post by A1195; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Four-Decade Study In Denmark Shows Higher Suicide Rates Among Transgender People | American Sexual Health Association https://share.google/yZB0GGlF4mWbnNNxf
FYI I actually developed all 3 types of Eagle Syndrome. Hormones have only been hypothesized BY SOME (it is not proven) to precipitate Classic Eagle Syndrome (stylohyoid ligament ossification). I only had Classic Eagle Syndrome on one side.
My symptom onset for Vascular and Venous Eagle Syndrome was many, many years before I took hormones. The fact it was diagnosed in 2011 does not mean that's when symptoms began. It's hard to get a diagnosis for a 0.16% prevalence syndrome when everyone would rather think you have an eating disorder or don't want to go to school, and you're told over and over that every test is normal.
Suggesting it's somehow related to my interest in sex and gender because I happened to be diagnosed while trans identifying is quite a leap. Not validating the gender identity of men with DSDs who identify as women isn't targeting them. It's just declining to lie alongside them.
If you want to educate yourself about this syndrome so you stop sounding pig ignorant with these batshit theories about me, this article is good:
Carotid type of Eagle's syndrome - PMC https://share.google/f4joErR7mAifkg5PY
4 years you've been obsessively targeting me by attacking my Eagle syndrome. It's almost like you're jealous.
Which is then pathologized by sex denying psychiatrists resulting in women having more anxiety than men, resulting in unnecessary treatment for sex based differences.
I've seen at least one paper where this came full circle, and (female) trans men on testosterone's reduced neuroticism score relative to other men was used to prove "testosterone improved their mental health"
So here's the story she made up about me, but I announced my trans identity 18 months before my Eagle Syndrome diagnosis and 2 years before my surgery, and I'm pretty sure being transgender is actually not typical of Eagle Syndrome patients.
Quotes a post by T13420; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I'm joking, I'm not sure if you're familiar but Cynthia Breheny, who drew my infamous curiously complected caricature, tried to start an anonymous rumor that an ex trans man *who had stayed at her house* had emasculated her partner (Zach) in front of her during his visit. I'm genuinely not sure why she thought anonymity was an option.
This comment was in response to a video saying detransitioners were just larping when we identified as trans. But you're not allowed to take it to its logical conclusion.
I'm really confused, is this doctor uncertain about trans healthcare or is this an oblique reference to the fact she is a telehealth provider who had never sat across a desk from a trans patient?
Quotes a post by A1195; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A lot of these stunning and brave trans allies do not understand how testosterone can be healthy for a boy but not a girl. They really did accept the fantasy that we can swap kids' puberties safely because it's safe for clownfish.
I've been told a number of times that trans people know they're not changing their sex, but she's adamant that she is. We're also told that they need to transition to blend in and avoid transphobic oppression, but she's also claiming non- medically transitioning trans people are privileged.
If you measure any two groups of humans, you'll find subtle and meaningless average differences. Let me know when you do science forwards to where you can generate predictions and contradict a person who thinks they're trans but imaging proves they are not.
The fact that genetics cause brain differences in prader willi patients that make them feel like they're starving doesn't mean they're actually starving. Same for your cross sex ideation even if it could somehow be linked to these random differences that have no proven link to a delusion of cross sex identity.
You're basically finding that trans women tend to be short and saying height must determine your gender identity and then going so far as to say you've proven something.
A lesion in this area will cause a loss of gender identity?
If a man thinks he's trans but has a normal bed nucleus, he's wrong and should be denied hormones?
I've read the pamphlet and I've also read your many many tweets admitting you cannot use a brain scan to identify trans people. You are finding random differences in a group of drug users who self identify as trans, to hang your hat on, like a phrenologist. You cannot tell me which structure causes gender or what lesion location would cause a loss of gender because you are mindlessly repeating talking points aimed at convincing women you simply have to do these things you want to do.
Yea underneath that is immense pain that no one was able to really help her. She survived by selling a pound of her flesh and taking drugs that permanently changed her. The permanence combined with the euphoric feelings induced by the drugs exert significant psychosocial pressure on the person to look on the bright side of having lost body parts and to claim to be happier this way. But the grief is obvious. She would have preferred getting the help she really needed and not have to live the rest of her life with bodily modifications that people are increasingly coming to just recognize as a sign of trans. Now she has to wear her heart on her sleeve and advertise the most painful moment of her life, when she felt so abandoned or alone she chose permanent body modification over the suicide she was considering. To live with that and admit you regret it, too. You miss how you were when you didn't want to be you. That's hard.
I want a paper that scans a thousand babies, predicts which ones will be trans later, and which ones who identify as trans will be wrong, and then is proven correct. Does that study exist? Or are the scans back to being experimental and maybe someday
You can't have it both ways. It's either a coherent and complete theory that can diagnose and predict even people who don't think they are trans or who are mistaken about being trans, or it's experimental and you have no idea what brain structures are even involved here.
You defined gender as cultural expectations but are saying these expectations are somehow acquired in the womb. You say it's hard wired through developmental influences but deny it can be lost through injury or fail to develop. Now you're claiming it's somehow necessary to be alive. Sounds like you just really want to cross dress tbh. Meanwhile I outgrew it and so did this woman.
Interestingly there have been reports of dementia patients forgetting their gender identity and wanting their body parts back. That's what anyone with a functional working model of the brain would expect from a function that *develops* and involves *wiring,* but that conflicts with the "gender identity can't change" mantra. They want to have and eat the cake, but the cake is a lie.
Dementia care advice for transgender patients drawn up https://share.google/gSO0noRDtKjX9by3c
Also my background involves a lot of child development and brain injury rehab so I would say I've got practical knowledge of the general area of how brains become minds and how to put Humpty back together again. I think you're repeating a trans pamphlet and do not know what it means for something to even be hard wired into the brain. Because it means it can be damaged and the function would be lost with the loss of the wiring. Yet you insist this wiring somehow is permanent.
You are not using these scans to predict who is trans blindly. You already knew which head bumps belonged to criminals. It's the opposite of the direction science goes.
Phrenology until you can use these scans to predict not just who will be trans later but who is a future detransitioner. People self select into these groups and then you hang your hat on random differences that have no predictive value nor coherent theoretical explanatory power.
I sympathize with trans men all the time. But the fact is pretending to be a man and then starting fights with men while in character is a bad idea and she's not a victim because she found out.
You might want to sit down for this.
"More trans women have been killed by African Americans in Minneapolis than have been killed by Hamas in Palestine."
This is not satire. He's made multiple videos on this. 😭
Unreflective trans activist claims detransitioners were "just LARPing."
But no one would ever put on a dress and identify as the opposite sex as part of a live action role play.
Hmm...
It's not which is why you used that word needed. Gender affirming care treats gender dysphoria which is defined in such a way to exclude non trans people categorically. That's why we don't get free cosmetic surgery and have to establish medical necessity duh
It's been reported by multiple authors that they actually get prostatic tissue metaplasia in their vaginal walls and breasts from the testosterone. It appears to always happen.
Prostatic metaplasia of the vagina in transmasculine individuals - PubMed https://share.google/Yb1H3gJpxVC5SB4Uw
MP04-19 PROSTATIC METAPLASIA OF THE VAGINA IN TRANSGENDER MEN | Journal of Urology https://share.google/IoVKpF4n7tu1AiRKi
Prostatic metaplasia and pilar differentiation in gender-affirming mastectomy specimens - ScienceDirect https://share.google/MEeOI5WcPvC5myNQ8
Proving that these males aren't the same as those males will never persuade me that any males are female enough to shatter the protections for females against males. Trans id men play the same game about how different they are. They learned it from the CAIS men, who are overrepresented in elite female athletics for a reason.
What I would like from you is a study showing that the predicted number of actual suicides was reduced in a population of trans identifiers with and without GAC and compared to the background rate. For some reason that study never materializes even in observational form. It's always surveys of living people.
There's no evidence whatsoever that "trans kids" who receive cosmetic amputation and mind altering addictive drugs have a lower suicide rate or murder rate than "trans kids" or non-"trans kids" who do not.
There's some trans discord either impersonating loved ones or contacting them to recruit the trans statutory rapists specifically amongst them (ask me how I know lmao). I don't believe they're all just randomly googling the names of people who died years ago, only to immediately find my blog and vomit with rage.
Drug facilitated behavior modification for psychosocial and legal reasons, is simply not the same as medical treatment for a confirmed disease. The conflation is a confidence game that hurts so many. And that's what trans is. We need to transition the kids so they don't self-harm. We are said to need to give them these drugs to modify their future behavior choices.
The idea that women cannot develop abnormal testicular tissue from genetic mutations that expose them to abnormal hormones is really not that far from "trans men have prostate tissue, only men have that so they're men now"
If we legally define female as anyone who looks female, you get trans. You get men declared female if they look sufficiently female. Source: the last 20 years.
I am sorry to hear you only want trans people to get care if it involves puberty blockers. Here I thought you were an ally. But the same answer applies. Declining to disrupt your health with drugs designed to sabotage normal development is not malpractice.
Boston Children's Hospital's GeMS clinicians admitted it was due to estrogen deficiency that atrophy happens and were open spitballing ways to use the fact testosterone becomes estrogen to get women on puberty and menstrual suppression alone to take the plunge, because testosterone was somehow less likely to cause atrophy. They correctly did not think trans men would want to take estrogen cream due to ideological fear of estrogen. It is in my reaction video Boston Children's Hell.
They use women's tissue to impregnate males with a syndrome related retained womb after using drugs to make it big enough to implant an embryo into. Keep in mind embryos don't technically need to implant in a womb - they evolved to implant wherever - it's just often more compatible with life for the host. They then use more drugs to sustain this pregnancy due to the lack of gonads, at the expense of the fetus who never consented despite being the most affected by this experimental intervention. The at the end their pelvic shape typically if not always requires C section. They've run similar experiments that also involved transplanting a uterus into an actual female with a DSD. According to Talia, when these technologies converge and the first trans woman is impregnated with the help of science and a woman's body, science will have changed his sex.
He's getting a lot of angry replies from other trans people for saying the quiet part out loud, not grasping that trans people have to be tragic victims of permanent circumstance and prone to complications like self deletion for it to be a civil rights issue and a medical insurance entitlement. If you're just doing it for fun, it's a hobby, and not something that's entitled to special protections and funding.
Quotes a post by T03813; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I call them the Church of the Maculate Conception. They think their trans identity is more valid and worthy of acknowledgement even by GCs because it's rooted in an obscure medical situation involving private parts.
It'll never cease to amaze me how readily they'll admit that you can be wrong about being trans when it's time to invalidate a detransitioner, but Johnny needs the drugs at 11 because he's definitely supposed to be a girl. He said so!
You can't "make someone trans" by cutting off their body parts... people get body parts cut off because they already are trans.
Is this news to you? It's trans 101. You're not more trans than another trans person who has yet to transition, just because you were a Privileged Paulie who was able to access some lifesaving care.
When the detransition movement is infested with self-declared "detransitioners" still perfectly happy living their best trans life. "I don't need to change my documents! I don't need to go off hormone disruptors! I don't need to stop cross dressing!"
Actually detransitioning is "just more trans" but staying trans is detransitioning. Up is down, war is peace, and we've always been at war with Eastasia.
I don't share your hyperfixation on what's best for men. It's better for women and girls to have a coherent sex based legal identity. Giving men fictional legal identities based on their appearance or sense of personal identity is what led to trans. Female only spaces are only for females.
Man getting surgeries and taking hormones to look like a woman insists he's not trans.
Quoting @PinkNews: Genderfluid streamer Finnster has revealed her new look after undergoing facial feminization surgery.
Finnster has documented his transition from the very beginning. Sharing that he goes by both he/her pronouns.
And is now revealing the results of her next step.
You do believe in true trans. Your definition is people who've completed a certain selection of trans rites. This population produces the true detrans.
Many psychiatrists have a con game going. They know they can prescribe you a dangerous and potentially brain injuring drug and cover their asses if you have a reaction by changing the diagnosis. Their bullshit argument is that a bad reaction to a new medication just prescribed is somehow a symptom of the supposed illness that brought the patient to them in the first place. "If antidepressants make you manic then you're bipolar" when the reality is stimulating drugs cause overstimulation effects in healthy people based on dose and patient factors unrelated to bipolar.
Kind of like when a trans person ends their life after bottom surgery while on hormones, we can't blame the boy juice. It must have been that time he/him was she/her'ed. The dysphoria won in the end. Once you are in their office, you become the invalid and they are your god. Any worsening symptoms are your fault but any improvement is thanks their expertise.
Quotes a post by T16342; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I'm so sorry to hear about his neurological injuries. I appreciated how he's boosted my writing about trans genital surgeries and the late detransitioner Yarden Silveira in the past.
I hope you've consulted with speech pathologists experienced with brain injury rehabilitation. I've seen a lot of near miracles in my line of work, in people with permanent injuries. A lot of people with brain injuries considered permanent, still regain some measure of their former coherence and tranquility because of the right approach from a person with true insight.
Sometimes more or less or different drugs are not the answer. Sometimes you need the targeted mirror neuron piggybacking from a skilled clinician to reconnect those areas impacted by chemicals and sepsis. I am certain you will both keep fighting for the best care for him. Akathisia proper is outside of the SLP wheelhouse, but perhaps with foundational attention or executive function retraining, he could relearn how to grab and hold those reigns of impulses to move, by himself again.
I'm sending my sincerest regards for his improved quality of life.
Their collage of who counts as female and who counts as male is very apparently a product of an extended committee of people with their own motivations for getting their gender identity validated. They don't have a coherent theory. Like other trans activists, their strategy is to destabilize YOUR understanding so you adopt theirs in your confusion.
The protocol I was on is never used for birth control. Progestins are definitely in the standards of care. But you're not trans, supposedly, so no wonder you're ignorant.
It's used in GAC for both men and women for the same reason (lower natural sex hormone production). Since you say you're not trans or a clinician, why are you pretending to know what happens in a gender appointment?
Whining about how people are objecting to your "mere existence" is the trans emdash. The reality is I haven't done that at any point. You are reaching for that victimhood because you are motivated to generate justification to harass me for not believing you have testicular anything.
This therapist explains that gender dysphoria is always a reaction to a lack of environmental affirmation. Yet on this app, anyone reporting resolution of gender dysphoria and resulting detransition is informed that we were never really trans but merely thought we were due to mental illness.
Yea. Somehow I'm bad for pointing out that they actually argue that trans is some kind of DSD half the time, where you have a girl brain in a boy body. But I'm supposed to ignore that.
Right. Because the drug itself is not what makes you trans or not trans. What makes you trans is that you think you're trans and do things in the name of acting out that thought.
Otherwise, medically you transitioned and you're ftm now. You're biotrans. But we both know that's not how transition works. Though I'm still baffled why you feel so confident in your knowledge here when your source is gossip because you're definitely not trans. No it's all natural, that's why it's more noticeable recently.
Right so progestin and progestogen and medroxyprogesterone acetate are spelled differently from progesterone for a reason.
If you didn't do the thing to be trans, then no it didn't magically make you trans to do the thing.
I was not discriminated against for not being trans. I was discriminated against because my spiritual beliefs conflict with the theory some souls are in the wrong bodies.
Church of the Maculate Conception: The Great Ball Heist
A woman takes testosterone as part of trans nonbinary hormone therapy. She develops mental illness symptoms that lead to more meds, psychosis and homelessness. Suddenly the furry hackers contact her with a revelation.
Whoever it is, they're pushing the implied premise that to be trans is to do trans. And that conflicts with the idea that some people just are trans and that's why they NEED to do trans.
They were never against conversion therapy. My individual online therapy has to be "trans inclusive" and I need to believe souls have a gender and can be in the wrong body, or else.
Quotes a post by T15313; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Interrogating a patient about their spiritual beliefs and then abandoning the patient based on their spiritual beliefs is actually not ok! You would have a cow if you heard a trans person was abandoned as a patient as soon as the therapist found out he identifies as a woman.
No, there's no copay. I really expected a therapist to not cross examine me about whether I internally misgender her trans clients I've never met and then tell me that's why she was dropping me.
I was discriminated against for being a detransitioned gender atheist today.
To celebrate Trans Day of Visibility, my therapist ended our therapeutic relationship because I said I don't believe in the gender souls of her other clients.
In response to her probing and off-topic questions, I disclosed that I do not believe her other clients - whom she volunteered were satisfied with their transition - were born in the wrong body. I explained that I think this is because no one is "in" a body. We are our bodies.
I also said that the only way a person can be trans is to believe they are trans, just like the only way I think people are Christian is if they believe they are Christian, due to not sharing their belief in Communion with a deity. I said I view this as a difference in spiritual/religious belief. She then told me that due to her work with the trans community, she is not the right therapist for me. She then ended the session early.
I've never had my atheist-materialist beliefs or detrans history be a barrier to accessing care before. I went to therapy in good faith. I was referred to her randomly by my insurance. I was not there to talk about her other clients' gender, obviously. I doubt trans clients get asked about or dropped for their thoughts about gender atheists, terfs or detransitioners.
Since I won't say trans women are women, I have to to go the back of the line again, wait several more weeks, spend several more weeks explaining my life story to someone new, only to wonder what in my history, what religious or political belief of mine that the therapist might ask about several sessions in, will cause the therapeutic relationship to end without warning.
I had brought up my detransition prior to being referred and in the initial session. But this was the first session she directly asked if I think her clients actually have cross sex souls, and she ended the therapeutic relationship as soon as I explained that I do not. I'm in the process of requesting records to file a complaint which is why I am leaving out MR's identity yet. If you're detrans seeking therapy in the SF bay area and need to know who to avoid, DM me.
This is how that same profession that was happy to affirm you, inject you or even cut you to pieces will treat you when you realize it was a phase.
Ultimately it comes down to people walking into my past and saying the way I was trans was not the way they were trans and so I need to stop telling the truth about my life to please them. Obviously the answer is no.
You've manifested a lack of coping skills over this topic for 4 years. I don't know why, just that.
Reclassifyng males as female is an unreasonable accommodation that infringes on the rights of females and gave birth to trans, which infuriates The Lawful Evil to have pointed out.
Was your mom trans at some point? I didn't ask what was common but fwiw, WPATH recommended progestin therapy is common gender affirming care for both females and males
Detransition includes stopping social and legal transitions as well. In pubmed literature, desister means someone who outgrew gender dysphoria, and detransitioner means someone who socially, legally and medically transitioned and then stopped/ reversed it - who may still say they experience gender dysphoria. The only thing detransitioners have in common is that whatever we did, we did to be trans.
Have you watched Maia's talk?
Binder ad says lesbians cannot look dapper with "sandbags." All the transmasc products seem to be marketed more and more to lesbians who aren't trans lately. They're calling it "tomboy binding."
For example
Defining Desistance: Exploring Desistance in Transgender and Gender Expansive Youth Through Systematic Literature Review - PubMed https://share.google/rsC2Wdz9ZIA34HWiH
See my project The Dead Names for even more examples of transition failing to cure dysphoria despite activist assurances that no one but trans people ever wonder if they're trans, let alone actually transition, and the only reason someone might gently challenge this belief is a desire for the trans person to stop existing.
Suddenly it happens all the time. Suddenly the people who fail the test of faith are revealed to be spiritually deficient. Oh well. It's a religion, and religions hate apostates.
Quotes a post by T00873; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If she doesn't get a gender affirming intervention she decided she doesn't want, it's fine because she's not the only trans person to not do that. But when it's not about her, the rules are completely different.
Who told people they had to take ivermectin? What are you talking about? If I'm only feeding into a market that already exists, and reaching no one who doesn't always agree, why are you so panini pressed that I am somehow louder than trans people? Please reconcile your delusions
APSA changed their mind! What right wing money? Sounds like you have difficulty coping with the fact people want to hear what I have to say. I'm not trying to change the minds of trans people, also. You're not my target audience Kai
Taking drugs your don't need is not a medical intervention. It's recreation and body modification. So, no trans person is receiving medical interventions to treat disease.
Some "trans women" like David Arthur Kendall have a sexual interest in spreading HIV. For some reason certain GCs like @[private account] and @[private account] promote him anyway despite the fact he's confessed to spreading HIV through condom sabotage. He was convicted of child molestation. He's still actively trying to gain access to kids.
Transitioner explains a variety of ancillary medications that are neither puberty blockers nor cross sex hormones, but which are used in gender affirming care to tailor the specific physical changes of the gender journey directed by the trans client.
Happy international women's day from a sapphic afab nonbinary woman who doesn't think this is her day, too. Trans ideology is an attack on women's class consciousness and therefore our solidarity.
It's gender affirming care - nonbinary hormones I received because I was nonbinary (much like cats receive food for cats which we call "cat food" even though it's not what makes the cat a cat and it's not what cats produce naturally). There's no true transition. Just whatever trans rites you take while trans.
By your logic women who stop at top surgery aren't trans since they didn't take testosterone. Do you harass them that they just wanted to prevent cancer and call them grifters? The nipnopers especially don't even have a masculine chest since men have nipples
The change was plenty meaningful without the testosterone. Your fixation on testosterone is sectarian. Using this sectarian dispute between classic and nonbinary trans to justify lying about whether I received and was harmed by a gender affirming intervention I took to treat gender dysphoria is actually despicable. Glad it's all out in the open what you're real motivation is here for libeling me. You just don't think nonbinary transitions count.
Repeating it doesn't make it true.
If ovulation suppression was the goal I wouldn't have been on multiple ones since one would have been adequate. I was trying to maximize side effects that I found gender affirming, such as menstrual suppression.
If I was on anything to treat gender dysphoria, you're admitting I medically transitioned and received gender affirming care.
If taking estrogen makes you more feminine, what does reducing estrogen do?
The hormones I took can activate androgen receptors too, despite being classed as progestin, inducing masculinizing effects in conjunction with the defeminizing effects of estrogen suppression. Known side effect even if you're only on one, and only taking it for birth control.
Some trans people have medical contraindications for testosterone.
Some nonbinaries want to be nonbinary, not male passing.
The protocol I was on is never used for birth control, but even normal birth control used continuously is WPATH recommended for menstrual suppression for transmascs. So why are you being transphobic by invalidating an entire class of trans people just to spite me? You're gonna cause so many suicides.
How well did that reasoning work out for her? Toxic cult nonsense meant to progressively isolate people and reinforce the idea that everyone who isn't trans will abandon them.
Please provide me one verified example of a non trans person receiving covered cosmetic procedures to better conform to their assigned "gender" using the diagnosis of gender dysphoria, which is for people who don't want to align with their assigned "gender." I'll wait.
This article says the daughter is 18
College administrator threatens to kill activist protesting transgender mutilation - IFN https://share.google/YzmKnsITsvYwNtqm2
Wu, did you mean to say the quiet part out loud here? Were trans kids actually less rejected in the 90s? Did trans visibility cause more harm than good
Medical Mercenaries: Trans Drugs are Drugs https://open.substack.com/pub/exulansic/p/medical-mercenaries-trans-drugs-are?r=xgqe3&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
When I was at Cal (class of 2011), nonbinary was not in common use even in the gender studies program. If you were a masculine of center afab, but less than a trans man (not yet on testosterone), you were transmasculine genderqueer. The earliest I can find mention of nonbinary in my writings was after I left Cal.
One of the clearest examples of Church of the Maculate conception I've found - trans people who claim one or more DSDs to justify their sense of gender discontent and desire for experimental hormones.
Brad the trans man describes how metoidioplasty aftermath feels: "like you have a razor blade in your urethra." Thank God we are paying hundreds of thousands of dollars for young women with mental illness to get this for pennies on the dollar, instead of going to school or starting a family.
Yes I think he absolutely set her up and tried to get her incarcerated for fighting back. Somehow this just keeps happening! He thinks women who identify as trans should be force-masculinized because he says they're the ones hiding behind a facade of fragility and oppression (what he's in fact doing)
Then you gave it to a woman you thought was bipolar who could not even keep her own appointments, knowing it might set off mania, knowing the drug was a controlled substance, knowing she had not been medically cleared, telling her she needed up be on testosterone to function correctly because she was trans and maybe it was the cure for bipolar even. You are an abusive POS with a forced masc fetish and you know it. You've admitted it.
Yea appearance really does affect how people interact with you and perceive you. That doesn't mean some males are women if they look enough like women. That logic gets you trans ideology.
I'm not part of trans ideology. I'm not talking about a perceptual social house of mirrors. They're males and as a direct result of being males they have a male experience that only males have.
A woman with CAIS would have distinct anatomy and a different life experience
Non-trans people crashing out about trans people having their false info driver's licenses invalidated thread 🧵
1. Oregonian has an idea: fuč̣k some shiŧ up
More and more transitioners are realizing that the psychiatric claim that gender dysphoria and trans identity is a permanent state was never based in evidence, as they outgrow their transition phase and long to reidentify with their true sex.
The dysregulation of her immune system and incompetence of the gender affirming clinician. Hysterectomy isn't a treatment for PCOS and all the trans pages say it was gender affirming. Testosterone induced uterine fibroids may have been a factor but my impression was this was phase 1 bottom surgery.
This one goes out to all the haters. I'm one of you again. You've called me ugly enough times that I'm retransitioning.
"Retrans Envy (No Way Out of the Nonbinary)"
another Tuesday night
I'm feeling light
but something is nagging me in the back of my mind
what will I find if I look a little deeper
it's the other versions of me
those little sneakers
I'm starting to worry
that I'm not a terf after all
I'm starting to worry
that my detrans grift is about to fall
I'm reee reee reee transitioning
I've finally gotten bored of such a hateful existence
blaming trans people for all my problems
I'm reee reee reee transitioning
they were right
i should have known how toxic the drugs were now that I was trusted to drink
22 year olds are famously good at judging the risks of long term toxic effects of medicaments presented to prevent the torment of my mental tenement
I've realized it's only a disguise, another set of lies I use to hide my snide remarks behind
you've caught us
I'm the accountant
not the host
and all the alters issue from her
including the ghosts
of the copies of those we loved the most
we might have lost them
but they will never leave their post
we fight and we make up but we never break up
of course we will wake up tomorrow
with all the same sorrow
so to borrow a phrase that's quite hollow in many other ways
united we stand
divided we follow
we can't be a man
but we still can.
demand to retrans
I'm reee reee reee transitioning
I've finally gotten bored of such a hateful existence
blaming trans people for all my problems
retransitioning
it's left the he/hims even more stunned
retransitioning
the bravery of alienating everyone
You take the drugs because you're already trans. You're being such a transphobe right now. Not sure how you live with yourself.
Also lol good luck with the belief that all drugs that act on the same receptor are the same.
They're correct? Hmm, we may have found a relevant difference there. Transmedicalism was not correct about whether I would try to end my life if I couldn't meet my gender goals. Nor were they correct that trans was some permanent state.
Whoa, didn't expect this to blow up! Let's address some FAQs:
1. What's a trans nonbinary hormone? Is it a hormone that makes to nonbinary?
>no, it's a hormone you take when you already see yourself as nonbinary, in pursuit of nonbinary gender goals, which typically implies a higher dose or off label use but sometimes involves lower doses compared to binary gender affirming care.
2. What hormones did you specifically take?
>etonorgestrel, medroxyprogesterone acetate, and levonorgestrel
3. Isn't that just birth control?
>not in that combination, because you get no additional benefit and more side effects, so there's no point in using multiple birth controls at the same time for birth control.
4. So why were you taking that dose and combination?
>I was maximizing side effects to achieve my trans nonbinary gender goals, including management of dysphoria and modification of my primary and secondary sex traits, and otherwise alleviate mental health symptoms.
5. Why did you think you were nonbinary?
>I didn't feel I confirmed to sex stereotypes and had a lot of trauma my reflection reminded me of, and my school also taught me this was a thing that existed
6. Which school was that?
>the hellmouth of nonbinitarianism, They/Themicca, where Judith Butler themself teaches (UC Berkeley)
7. Did you have dysphoria? Were you a transmedicalist?
>yes, I believed I had a permanent medical condition that required these hormones to prevent suicide and otherwise ensure mental stability.
8. Why do you hate trans people?
I don't.
9. Are you trying to ban hormones?
No, I'm trying to punish malpractice and get religion out of publicly funded schools.
10. Were the effects entirely reversible just because your skin improved?
>no, I have permanent scars and have needed major surgery to correct skeletal injuries from estrogen deficiency during a critical period of development combined with neglect due to incompetent providers.
@[private account] They had such strong opinions about trans women versus transwoman but suddenly on my page they forget how adjectives work. I bet they think hot dogs are inherently hot.
They got her addicted to testosterone as a 15 year old, in the name of trans, and now she can't stop even though she now recognizes that she is a woman.
Two risk factors include drug use in early pregnancy, which she denies but which I am skeptical about, and a history of UTI, which testosterone causes women to have. Lifestyle factors like smoking are elevated in the trans community as are factors like maternal malnutrition, such as due to gender related anorexia and reliance on testosterone injections for energy in lieu of food.
Oh they're absolutely keeping track of the unpublished trial. They pretend they're not because it's a "medical treatment" but if you recall they were taking extensive notes in the Tuskeegee experiment too. We just haven't seen them yet. Someone has binders full of trans women.
Some of my published writing from 2012 Exutransic era. I really put a lot of work into pretending to be trans so I could become a detrans grifter on social media in a decade. /s
Hey remember when this guy wanted to trans kids? You know, the medical, legal and social strategies sex traffickers would use if they wanted to conceal a trafficked child's identity.
Quotes a post by T29304; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I was identifying as trans masculine and then nonbinary from 2009-2019. I discovered Magdalen Berns in October 2019 and Kellie-Jay Keen shortly after and began deprogramming myself.
https://x.com/i/status/1863452258366804264
Here's an essay I wrote about it at the time. It was published in a feminist 'zine in 2010. It is super short, I just wrote "I took depo provera so I'm trans now like all women who get depo, the end."
Quoting @TTExulansic: Exutransic versus Exulansic
I read an essay I wrote when I was drunk on gender ideology wine in 2010, as a Gender & Women's Studies Bachelor of Arts student, about the partner who sprung his autogynephilic proclivities on me after we moved in together.
He was informed by a doctor that he's male and after being notified by a doctor that he's male he elected to identify as a woman and take hormones to make his body more feminine. Trans
He's a man who identifies as a woman. He's trans. The fact a doctor was allegedly wrong doesn't make him any different from any other man pretending to be a woman intentionally to deceive women.
"Trans Friends Aren't Friends"
Latest AI slop gen
Back in June
sad and alone
i started injecting
testosterone
So did my friend
we did it together
we both became Kai
she started as Heather
everything seemed
to be going as planned
and as a transitioned
she became a man
but suddenly she, well
everything changed
suddenly she became
utterly deranged
you've changed
no the drugs could not have changed you
actually you stayed the same
and the drugs have just revealed you
we always knew
you were like this
deep inside your wicked mind
you've changed
Heather and yes I will dead name
transition cannot fail
it is a holy test of faith
you weigh your heart
against a feather
and put your trust
in Anubis' scale
he tells the tale of your true title
good or evil
Angel or devil
and you thought your gender was so simple
and you thought the pain would now be over
now you've lost your only friends
and its your fault
the trans community turned its back
and blocked your main
and all your alts
now you've lost your only friends
and its your fault
the trans community turned its back
and blocked your main
and all your alts
now no one talks to you anymore
of course no one talks to you anymore
dysphoria cured
by ostracizing you
because it couldn't have been the boy juice
you put the noob in Anubis
and now you've burned in the crucible
of your sin
goodbye my friend
goodbye my friend
it's all your fault
it's all your fault
make sure no one blames the boy juice
it's all your fault
it's all your fault
make sure no one blames the boy juice
it's all your fault
it's all your fault
make sure no one blames the boy juice
it's all your fault
it's all your fault
make sure no one blames the boy juice
Transitioning is when you do behaviors consequent to transgender ideation. Good luck recovering from the false belief that you can *actually* transition beyond that. It can take awhile to stop believing transition is medically possible.
Kid killed himself with drug addiction. He died after a multi day drug binge, alone in his dorm that dad got him back into after he called dear old dad to help get him out of the homeless shelter where he was fenty folding with vagrants. Kid was trans too by that point. Dad made him tell mom about the cross dressing when he was a kid, then took his mother from him.
Trans Tiktok creators are attempting to wrap they/them/their head around the idea that transtrenders were an Epstein plot to sleep with men without being gay all along. Let's see how they're coping.
Trans nonbinary woman who's undergone top surgery discusses how she obtained gender affirming menstrual suppression from planned parenthood using progestins because she did not want testosterone.
A gender-affirming menstrual suppressor discusses the non-testosterone drugs used to stop periods in trans identifying women who have period dysphoria, including combined oral contraceptives, progestin-only, aromatase inhibitors, and estrogen-mimickers.
Some GCs and terfs talk about hormones marketed as birth control like trans activists talk about puberty blockers. The fact is no hormones are harmless. No hormones are reversible
Trans identified man explains that taking progestins too early in MTF transition has been linked to tubular breast growth, which is perhaps the mistake they made with Jazz Jennings that led him to feel "deformed" and seek "top surgery."
Making fun of trans ideology has a political purpose. What's the political purpose of saying some trans are more real, more deserving of medicalization, than other trans?
@[private account] Ok so why are you gaslighting me about what she's claiming if you agree with her that some trans ideation is more realistic/rational?
Denial ("that's not a risk!!!") is a stage of grief at the traumatic news that the drug you're taking to change cellular genetic expression can in fact alter cells. So is bargaining ("well everything has risks!!! Medicine is imperfect!") And anger ("you chose this risk!!!")
@[private account] can you discuss prostatic metaplasia prevalence in so called trans men (females on high doses of testosterone) in breast and vaginal tissue?
And so your claim is that testosterone can never cause abnormal cells?
The 100% of women on trans doses of testosterone with prostatic breasts want a word with you.
Nonbinitarian argues that c!s women sometimes use chest binders to be more effective and comfortable at work. Nursing mothers are another major consumer of trans masculine chest binders. This video really opened my eyes.
"For some trans people, wearing a chest binder is all they need," explains trans identified woman. Not every trans person has a problem with their physical body. It depends on what sect they are in. Nonbinitarians, especially the dissociative types, just don't want to feel limited. Body modification therefore might feel more limiting than interventions that disrupt an awareness of sex without affecting the ability to present as your default on days you feel a female alter is "fronting" (in conscious control of the body).
Where in god's name are you getting the idea that I have complete faith in people who say trans women are women? LOL. I have faith in my own goddamn eyes my dear.
No this is an actual trans medical intervention being sold. You can get injections of testosterone or a bulk agent like filler directly into the cords, reducing systemic effects.
Uh no, that's not at all an example of begging the question. And you were just trying to argue some trans men want hip deformities the way they want no breasts and facial hair. Not sure you're ready for formal logic.
One of the many ways depo provera is not progesterone is that progesterone converts to a psychoactive metabolite called allopregnanolone, which has profound and complex effects on mood and is one of the neurohormones that SSRIs naturally elevate apart from serotonin. Depo provera does not metabolize into that metabolite, and simultaneously suppresses production of natural progesterone, resulting in mood symptoms for many patients, sometimes severe. If you're trans nonbinary, they often simply blame the dysphoria for your hormone induced symptoms, which you accept because of the ideology, or they give you new labels. And then the real nightmare begins.
The time I experienced reverse trans broken arm syndrome from a gaslighting doctor as a stunning and brave young trans man.
I came in with a possible fracture from a specific incident. Instead of ordering imaging, despite the hormone suppression I was on, known to reduce bone density and increase injury risk from minor trauma, my doctor simply called me a drunk, out of nowhere, said I was just like my dad, and sent me home without even a muscle relaxer let alone pain management recommendations. Didn't even tell me to take ibuprofen. Just made me promise to drink less - obviously a dangerous way to manage suspected alcohol withdrawal. But, she didn't actually suspect that.
My shoulder still hurts, but now I have a caring orthopedist who looked disgusted when he said he didn't understand her medical reasoning in that visit. Now I'm waiting on a scan. I'm optimistic I'll finally have an answer. My clavicle feels like it's been the wrong shape since that incident. Clavicle growth plates are normally still open at 25, even without hormone blockers keeping them open by causing estrogen deficiency. Estrogen closes growth plates.
They tell you that if you think you are trans, you will develop mental health problems if you do not transition.
They give you drugs that disrupt your mental health.
The new mental health problems caused by the hormones are naturalized because obviously you just haven't gone far enough and should have started sooner.
Your mental health continues to deteriorate. Friends and family don't recognize you anymore. But this is also naturalized. They must have been transphobic all along.
Soon you don't even know what normal feels like.
Better stay on the hormones. Who knows what could happen if you detransition now.
You already lost everyone else. You can't lose them too. You can't risk what's left of your sanity admitting it was all one big con.
They're telling you "death before detransition." I'm telling you that's true. Because life comes after detransition.
I'm just confused by the fact that Hendrix is still siding with transmedicalists while claiming to believe transmedicalism is incorrect. But to be clear, being nonbinary doesn't automatically make you less of a trans medicalist or mean you don't think you physically somehow need the treatments you're getting on the basis of your gender identity. I just an baffled to see the sectarian squabbling I've documented at length reiterated in a detrans context where we supposedly don't believe it anymore.
What gets me is the insanity that if she thinks you shouldn't have been medicalized, it's OK to call you a fake when you say the truth about your medicalization, which is WPATH recommended and used for nonbinaries, transfemmes and transmascs. When she attacks former nonbinaries as liars and fakes, she's promoting her interpretation of trans ideology via these intentionally deceptive statements she knows to be false.
Apparently she's so well funded any reasonable woman would be jealous. She's got expensive new cars even. Trawling her through Lake TERF seems to have been a political decision to give her a back story as a brave women's rights activist, and pretending to be super unfamiliar with trans even though she's not a trans sibling was part of that. But the reality is she feels no solidarity with our movement, and it's easy to be right that men aren't women.
female to less female nonbinary types use the term to mean we identify as more masculine but don't want to identify as a binary man. Or it can just mean the adjective form of trans man. So all trans men are trans masculine but not all trans masculine people are trans men. Butch women would be considered transmasculine under this framework.
That's just more of your abusive lies, Ariwen. No one is buying it. It's just excuses trans activists are using to attack actual detransitioners while running interference for WPATH to minimize public perception of the harms done to patients.
No one did that lol. The histrionics from trans accounts like yours are so predictable. It won't blow up anyone's life to be accurately recorded as your biological sex in the eyes of the law. Don't pretend to be detrans or a terf when you're not.
Another email from 2011 where I identified as trans. If you have been told I never came out at trans, that it wasn't a core part of my identity for several years, I'm sorry that you were lied to, and I encourage you to ask yourself why that person lied to you.
Excerpt from a long letter I wrote to a queer blog apologizing for comparing the infamous Laurelai Bailey (who was in the group XD) of ALL people to Loretta/Stan from Monty Python's Life of Brian.
This email was sent to a group back channel of the LGBT+ offshoot of the blog Skepchick, called Queereka, in September 2013. I blamed transphobia. I still identified as trans nonbinary.
I gave reasons for my social detransition and described my transition as occurring prior to graduate school. I also identified as transmasculine in my bio on this blog. I was not a significant contributor. I don't think I posted more than 5 times.
Some people are so focused on their obsession with "winning" against me they think proving my doctor neglected a preexisting condition of my hip while exacerbating it with experimental hormones billed fraudulently would exonerate him from the charge of iatrogenic harm.
They seem to think it's only harm to cause a problem to a healthy person. Worsening the health actively or passively of an already sickly person with the trans rites apparently doesn't count to some.
Gender medicine is directly targeting (see CHOP shop) people with eating disorders and other chronic health issues like EDS and autism, and it is for multiple reasons. One is that these groups are more vulnerable and suggestible. The other is that they they want to be able to blame us for the health problems they induce and exacerbate.
It's harmful to females and males to have your hormones blocked, resulting in hormone deficiency, period, end of sentence.
I represent a class of women and girls being offered these common hormone blocker treatments (some published research suggests 25% of AFABs who do not immediately start testosterone are prescribed hormone blockers instead). Most of the women and girls affected are nothing like me in terms of their personality. They're women and girls you've never met and never will meet.
You don't have to like me. You really don't. But you do need to care about women and girls as a class, if you call yourself a women's activist. Otherwise what even are you purporting to stand for? The reputation of the illustrious true transition? Don't make me your olive whale, Ahab. I'm not the target unless you're on the other side.
You left the trans rights movement due to infighting and drama? I thought you had a revelation that trans was a big lie and you wanted to detransition??
1. From Google you can see it on a scan just fine.
2. So these studies cherry pick people who identified as trans when they were alive and took hormones? How many people have trans bed nuclei but never identitified as trans when alive?
3. @[private account] what is the Texas Sharpshooter logical fallacy