The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Also the idea that no butch lesbians are predatory is as silly as the idea that all trans women just want to pee. You gotta stop with the identity politics. It's poison to logic.
You have to truly transition by their narrow than WPATH standards of true transition, or else you're not a real detransitioner if your name is Exulansic or Maia. But as long as you were once true trans, you can be their favorite detransitioner without detransitioning if your name is Ari.
They are legion but the biggest are that Genspect is trying to become the next WPATH so when WPATH falls Genspect will just take over and trans healthcare to continue, Genspect is trying to make autogynephilia a sexual orientation to protect trans rights because they're secretly the next WPATH, and the one that's inspired the most men to accuse me of being a pedometer and even threaten to kill me is that Genspect is some kind of elaborate child trafficking operation.
Starting to feel that way. Genevieve Gluck herself blurted out in a tweet that her goal is to her people to stop paying attention to my work on trans suicides. The idea seems to be to retraumatize me with my most painful experiences and otherwise refuse to credit me for my contributions, until I give up on this project.
and other sources have the correct definition of detransitioner.
It's someone who reverses a legal, social, and/or medical transition.
A desister is someone who outgrows gender dysphoria without legally, socially, or medically transitioning.
Within GC, there's another meaning of desister to refer to people who stopped believing in the ideology. The classical medical definition of desister is non-ideological, so this sense is using it as a synonym for deconverting.
Detransition does not imply deconversion. There are a LOT of trans detransitioners. Something to keep in mind when someone like Hendrix or Ari has an opinion on the true transition of deconverted detransitioners like me.
So you admit I was trans, took medication to be trans, and am no longer trans. But somehow I am not detrans. I've given you many warnings but at some point you'll spend your loan of social capital with me and enter the find out phase. I don't like people who lie to me or about me. Your malicious defamation will not be tolerated either.
Even if they weren't, imagine getting so high you experience gender identity death and forget that trans people have always existed and start freaking out at their non-evolved shape
Tim "Sarah" McBride was 21 in 2011. He came out at trans because it was popular at college that year same as me. He's full of shit that he always knew but was just so scared.
These are criticisms that apply to my work too. It's possible people are pretending to be trans or that social media transitioners aren't representative. It's a worthwhile pursuit for what it is.
The belief that women transition to escape sexualization and men transition to sexualize seems to be to be independent of and to an extent incompatible with the theory of social contagion. Is the theory that some people are already trans eggs that get cracked when exposed to the dangerous idea?
It also seems to fundamentally ignore that men are escaping sexualization as men, which is being invisibilized as a phenomenon like we don't have sex based ideas and expectations of men related to sexual behavior and performance. Meanwhile, women are accessing the ability to perform male sexuality at the same time they escape being a target of male sexual aggression.
Receptive versus aggressive is perhaps a more sex neutral framing that does not stigmatize either sex and recognizes there is a reason males evolved to go find as many females as possible and bother them.
Women transition to escape receptive sexualization and access a sense of freedom to be sexually aggressive, and men escape expectations of sexual aggressiveness into a sense of freedom to be openly sexually receptive. And I'm talking about social dynamics as much at physical sexual behavior here. The fundamental sexual dichotomy, which is known to be hormonally influenced to the level we can make bugs change seemingly complex sexual behavior with the right hormone, gets sublimated into higher order behaviors in animals like humans with such higher order capacities that inescapably piggy back on these base, ancient instincts.
My thoughts on Detrans AI (and this is in no way a commentary on the motivations or intentions of the actual developer who to me comes across as very sincere and earnest):
Detrans AI sounds great in theory. And I'm not saying it is without value. It's a fantastic way to access large bodies of online information that would be tedious and time consuming to sift through.
I strongly caution against generalizing to all detransitioners let alone to trans people who have not and may never detransition let alone post about it online. This is a very specific data set that does not by its nature represent all detransitioners, and further due to its nature and technological advances, could be artificially seeded (astroterfed, in a sense) with the conclusions the developers wanted to generate, and may have also been corrupted by politically motivated trans activists, terf bystanders participating on the forum, terf activists posing as detransitioners to push a narrative, or trans-identifying detransitioners pushing their own narratives.
It it a step towards higher quality research with verified subjects who have produced genuine medical records or otherwise have a confirmed identity of real and trans identification, who are recruited randomly or at least haphazardly, versus specifically detrans identifying participants in an online forum with its own socially transmitted subCULTural beliefs and theories about how they all ended up there and why.
The "ostensibly" is like she wants me to know they took it down after and because she was diagnosed but they didn't announce her diagnosis for some time. Her tiktok profile, Samuel On Wheels, rarely or possibly never talks about the boyjuice history. Just a trans and gay pride flag in bio
The rumor that Nick Steiner, son and suspected murderer of Rob and Michele Reiner, is transgender, appears completely unsubstantiated. If anyone can produce evidence, I'm interested, but there's a photo going around where his sister is circled as though that's him and he's standing next to his sister in that photo. He just looks unrecognizable due to I would guess a combination of addiction and psychiatric medication.
Liminal Trespiss: Mamamephistopheles Goes to Washroomington
A group of trans activists is shocked to discover that bathroom bans can in fact be enforced.
The reckoning was after, prompted by some significant negative life events including outgrowing trans. The initial loss of confidence in the belief system was as a teenager. But I realized I didn't truly know where the line was and had a lot more unpacking to do.
My parents were freezoners after having been Hubbardites so I had a reckoning in my young adulthood about what this meant and how it had contributed to being vulnerable to trans, which is not inconsistent with the general philosophy.
But saving them? They're already lost. They're already in the pit by choice or because their own parents threw them in. I cannot cool their burning tongue with a single drop from my smallest finger. I'm not Jesus nor Abraham. My powers are limited. They're cooked. Only they can get themselves out, and they will be badly burned if they manage that. I am still healing from my own time in the pit, having thrown myself in. No one got me out. Those who tried got hurt. I'm not going back in for them.
I’m not trying to be palatable so they’re coaxed away from the boyjuice. I’m trying to document their foolishness, their gullibility, how they were deceived, and the resulting misery, to prevent more people from being misled and harmed. I’m trying to inoculate the average person and be a resource for people who are already out. This project about trans people is actually not about trans people. The treacherous image is not a pipe either.
Share Exulansic
I’m more like the guy who took this photograph at the top, “The Vulture and the Little Girl,” and then walked away. Kevin Carter kept walking for four months before killing himself, with many attributing his actions to the psychological horror of what he had seen, which could not be unseen, and how he knew he had chosen not to help.
For me, I think he was already prone to those thoughts and behaviors, and that's perhaps why he was there documenting what he was documenting in the first place. Similarly, I am documenting the horrors that never cease, that I did not cause and cannot directly stop. Like him, I’m haunted by what I have seen when I could not or chose not to intervene.
But I have an ideology that protects me from guilt over other people’s personal consequences for other people’s choices. I am sharing some of that ideology with you now, in the hopes that you will all stay in the 59% even as you watch the horrors unfold on this blog. Sometimes, all you can do is survive and tell the story. Sometimes, saving yourself has to be enough.
THE SAVIOR AND THE WITNESS
I have been reflecting on how trans people really underestimate how much of their internal struggle is religious trauma, often with Christians, often their parents. I can’t think of any other reason so many people see my videos and conclude I’m somehow trying to save trans people who are already halfway down the walls of the Sarlacc pit, if not deep in the proverbial belly of the beast. Then they notice I also do not seem to be catering to them, and this leads to concluding, I am doing it wrong.
Some will come to me to explain that I don’t realize how to better adjust my messaging and tone to be more popular with the trans community I am allegedly trying to “reach.” Use their pronouns! Use their fantasy no-ball name! Just call them trans women! That will make them more likely to listen to you! You’ll be able to save these people from the cult! Pull them back from the brink of castration and we can all live happily ever after with catheters on the house. But this is a zombie apocalypse-type situation. I cannot save those who are already too far gone, I will only be risking my own time and energy attempting to save them, and so I am not opening the door. I radically don't try to save trans people. They are not the main characters in this story. They are a mixture of the already-fallen and the villains.
This expectation is stemming, I believe, from the fact that culturally, they are used to being centered. They further expect to have Christians trying to save them, because that's what Christians are trying to do. Christians want to find the fallen and pick them back up. And that’s so nice of them! They’ve certainly helped pick me up repeatedly when I needed some saving, like the time I was in Turkey trying to find a rabies vaccine and the person who helped me was a Christian missionary and complete stranger, who was there to be helpful to expatriates.
There’s plenty of those types in the GC sphere. But that’s simply not me. While I attended Lutheran school and consider myself Biblically literate, while I do try to be helpful in my own way, Christian evangelicism is very much a second language. My default spiritual operating system of Scientology (now obsolesced) is not as common as the Christian mindset, which I was not really exposed to until middle school.
Scientology has a diametrically opposed view of your role in other people's lives and the amount of effort you are expected to put forth to save the salvation-resistant and the help-phobic. You are here to do you, boo, and other people are either on board with that because they're your bros from the beforetimes when you were spaceghosts, or they'll get in your way because they're haters (SPs or “suppressive persons”) you should avoid so hard you minesweeper that shit and avoid their friends (PTS or “potential trouble sources”) too. That's it. That's my summary of Diabetics or whatever the Ron’s book was called. But that’s my starting point. So I am not here to be evangelical. I’m not here to save. I’m not attempting to extricate anyone from their own nightmarish and predictable existence. I’m here to learn, to know, and to speak to that, to those who want to hear and have ears to listen.
So I’m really not trying to “save” trans people. I'm not going to go over there and reason with them for their sake. I'm not their mom. I'm here to document the horrors for the benefit of the pretrans, the detrans, and the trans-enduring, as I've said from day 1. When I engage, it is in pursuit of that goal. It is to establish rapport, coax desired information, illustrate a logic tree I've already discerned, practice dialectics for myself, or for the propaganda value of the public exchange.
Trans people when they're told to use sex based facilities
Quoting @TTExulansic: "They say we're not allowed to steal mail from the neighbors, but there's nothing preventing me from grabbing the package off the porch. It's an unenforceable law."
@[private account] No, I once aspired to be a Finn due to my trans coded mermaid obsession but never asked people to call me that, and then when I became nonbinitarian I started using Exulansic online.
I'm proposing kaiescence as the single word that means trans man convergence syndrome. Kaiescence is the tendency of women on testosterone to gradually look not so much like a man but like they're probably named Kai.
Catch up growth is a thing actually, but it's nice to see you excuse doctors harming trans people with "well they were probably FUBAR at baseline why not"
Her story is she's got endometriosis. Previously she was trying to reduce it by talking progestin and estrogen. Somehow it was still getting worse. I told her estrogen makes it grow and she got mad at me. But my understanding is she's now treating it with progestin only now. So i think she thinks I'm calling her trans every time I tell my story.
Well, no. You can't separate them in this discussion. That's why women with endometriosis who get lupron or women with menopause who get testosterone aren't detrans, but trans identified women who take them and then stop are detrans.
It is fascinating to me how many people hear me say "I was harmed by gender affirming hormone blockers designed to maximize an untested off label side effect" and conclude "she wants to ban birth control because she thinks everyone on birth control is trans!!!"
There's a very specific protocol in a secret version of WPATH SOC only Genevieve Gluck has access to that explains which hormones are the true trans hormones and which ones were simply grifterol-HCL
My story has never changed. I am sorry that you can't accept that progestins have long been an established part of gender affirming medical care, with predictable iatrogenic harm, but these accusations just make you sound like a TRA. They feel just as strongly about how detrans people were never truly trans.
Some jealous people who don't know what hell I've lived through because of these "the pills" are calling me a fraud for saying true facts about how this WPATH recommended protocol for transmasculine patients affected my late adolescent body that had nutritionally delayed maturation at baseline.
Also if you're relying on Grok, it's giving incorrect information about these drugs' mechanisms and effects. So check multiple sources. Don't rely on the robot that admits it makes shit up for fun. Depo provera is dollar store lupron. Even trans people can admit this so why can't my haters?
So you're saying being trans is based on how well you conform to stereotypes? And people who don't do not conform need to be converted?
Dysphoria=a state of being upset
You didn't specify! That's why what you said was incorrect. Mental health professionals will tell you that they don't diagnose trans. They diagnose whether the person is upset about being trans.
No one is qualified to diagnose "if someone is trans or not," according to the trans community you just know if in your soul. But it's wrong to suggest SLPs cannot offer diagnosis for a voice concern just because a person is trans.
One of the best examples of the complete fraud of transgender medicine is that the testosterone level they aim for is based purely on what's typical for men, not what has been proven most efficacious for woman presenting with mood symptoms. Maybe even if they were correct, women would get the same benefit on half the testosterone with fewer risks. But they don't give a vuck. They're winging it.
Trans hormone therapy (which includes multiply hormones including but not limited to estrogen) in fact does shrink men's brains. It's not an implication.
Hey Sally! Can you please elaborate for the class what's needed for gender dysphoria to be real? We're all very interested to know who the true trans are.
Quotes a post by T30004; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Genevieve Gluck trying to get my account mass reported to hide the fact she credited my work to a man and also because she's mad I'm talking about trans suicides was not on my bingo card this year. But who needs TRAs with allies like this? She's entering Li Kotomi mode, acting like she has a right to silence my voice for telling the truth about her.
The trans community told the nation that he was not to blame for his victim's suicide. That instead it was teenage girls defending themselves from his victim's PTSD rage and psychological confusion. Tried to ruin those girls' lives. Now they're giving the child rapist a brand new trans identity so police in Arkansas won't know he's on their registry if he doesn't care to tell them. And he would have gotten away with it too, if it wasn't for some nameless player's meddling screenshotting.
Medical ideology for how to manage DSDs is where trans ideology came from. The concept of preferred pronouns, gender self identification, legally defining boys as girls if they have low testosterone or insensitivity to it, all of this came from misguidedly trying to make the world more fair for people - who are predominantly male - with DSDs, at the expense of females generally.
Yea I'm just speculating because I find it very strange a supposed terf is calling me hateful for exposing how the media lies about trans suicides. It seems like the opposite of what you'd expect her to say. She's basically calling me transphobic. Who would care in this space?
My question is why was it acceptable to keep your own dead names' lists to push policy through based on the lie that anti trans bloodshed and misgendering related suicide was behind every corner?
I mean I had already moved on. She decided to come on today with an essay about how I'm completely worthless and no one should read my blog because it's so hateful to trans people who commit suicide. New claims, new response.
Yes it is traumatizing to read hundreds of obituaries and then research their families. I've cried often putting together this list, only to have Genevieve Gluck of all people say no one should read what I've uncovered because it's hateful to tell the truth about trans suicides.
Quotes a post by T19011; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] Exactly. The cover up is worse than the crime. Why is Reduxx against investigating trans suicides? Why does it matter that I'm a detransitioner? Does that mean these people aren't dead or something?
Honestly the fact Reduxx is actively trying to steer people AWAY from my Dead Names list BECAUSE the content is trans suicides that weren't prevented, should suggest perhaps Reduxx has been financially and therefore ideologically compromised.
She is actually! She posted about being glad when Trump got the trans identified men out of her prison. I'm just not sure which of them is the bigger transphobe. That's why they need to debate.
Can someone help me find this story? A trans identified homeless man got a woman to let him move in and he ended up murdering her. When police came, he told them she was on vacation but she was in a freezer in the basement as I recall. Search engines only want to tell me about times the trans person is the victim.
@[private account] And then you remember that what made them trans was that they were pretending to be something they weren't, saturated fats, because they'd been chemically made straight.
Charlie Kirk was assassinated, so logically that means the trans genocide is imminent and it's time to flee. But it's hard because no one will take her perfectly good trash that's not worth donating.
Stress is no excuse for refusing to credit a woman for her work even after its pointed out. Stress is not an excuse for sending people to gaslight me that somehow Matt Osborne is psychic and I somehow plagiarized him. We're all stressed. I was threatened by a trans identified man with violence over my advocacy just this very morning. This man also doxed and harassed me. It's been going on for months. It's actually also stressful to watch my name erased from my contributions and watch a man congratulated for my work.
Quotes a post by A1623; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I've got people emailing me telling me I'm creating toxicity by holding Genevieve Gluck to a basic standard of honesty in her reporting about my work. Specifically, I'm asking her to stop crediting work I in fact did, to a man, just because he wrote about my work. So simple many of you assured me she must have made a mistake and would quickly correct it. Well, it's Thursday. Now she's linking to a screenshot of the man's article after he took it down to encourage her to do the right thing. I was clearly correct to infer intent. As I so often am.
I want to remind anyone interested in Gluckgate that I didn't ask her to do any of that. This fight was started by her because she didn't want to credit me. She likely wishes she had been the one. But if it can't be her, well, it'll be a man. Because we need to maintain the image that only a few, bold radfems at Reduxx ever said anything about trans. I'm addressing that toxicity, by disinfecting it with sunlight.
And I don't want to hear anyone who calls themselves a feminist encouraging women to accept injustice, to accept unfair financial and reputational harm to themselves, to silence themselves, to accept being quietly written out of history, quietly watch a man be given credit, just to keep some sort of fantasy peace with a stranger in literal Japan who clearly is already at some kind of war with me that she began, expecting me to fold into my designated place. I said no. Saying no to unfair treatment is feminist praxis. Encouraging women to accept unfair treatment for the sake of the group vibe is oppression. It is ontologically unfair to give credit for one person's work to another person when you know the other person was simply describing the first person's work. There's no defense for that.
It is the origin of trans ideology. All the policy ideas, all the emotional manipulation, is patterned on getting you to let males with DSDs be legal and social women. And a lot of that was motivated by not wanting to criminalize their sexuality.
I don't know. It's not at the top of my dance card right now, in any case. I just want them to correct the record so people read about all the other times the media blamed us for deaths that are better attributed to family dynamics. All the other times a parent of a trans kid was also trans. I'm the one covering that case by case.
I think it's a necessary niche. I even tried to fundraise for them when they lost their patreon, encouraging my audience to remember times we've linked to their articles and consider donating. But by that token, trans kid suicides is my very specific but currently necessary niche. Their large platform could have brought attention to other stories I've covered, putting Nex in the proper context.
Dead Names Entry: Roman Bryant "Maria Remilia" "Sakuya" "Yuno" "Thresh Queen" Creveling
2/2/95-12/27/2019 (24)
An affirmed and medicalized trans-identified man ended his life at 24 after a severely botched vaginoplasty surgery that also managed to paralyze one of his vocal cords via botched intubation.
He was the "first woman" to compete in a League of Legends (multiplayer game) Championship, which was how he paid for his botched Thai genital inversion. Twitch had suspended his account the week prior to his death. His last tweets described depression and alienation. He began his transition at 15. It's not known when he started hormones.
Link below to donate to a fundraiser to mark the grave of this trans child whose GoFundMe has been ignored by the trans community that gives $40,000 for adult trans funerals.
It's Trans Day of Remembrance. Let's remember some trans people.
Quoting @TTExulansic: "Dead Names Entry" Thread 🧵
This is a thread of the write ups. For times when I've turned these entries into a longer video, see the Dead Names thread.
Speech pathologists aren't psychologists, however psychology is a significant component of our field as it's foundational to child development and learning theory. We also have graduate coursework and training in audiology but we aren't audiologists either.
My recent obituary project is indeed related to trans suicides.
Trans is predominantly a young women's fad and they're being given hormones to make their brains act more male. And men are better at completing suicide
Yes I work in my field. Yes I collaborate with and advise other professionals. No, I haven't published or presented papers within my field. Yes, I've worked with members of the trans community in my practice. Yes that's included vocal rehabilitation after hormones and surgeries as well as gender-related patient education and voice coaching (especially the entry level speech about why male and female voices sound distinct). Does this answer your question?
BA Gender Women's Studies and Linguistics, MA in Education (Speech Pathology). I'm licensed in my field as well so that's my clinical expertise. Then unrelated to my clinical work, I have been collecting and organizing first person gender transition narratives and researching trans suicides forensically for several years now.
I'm not giving money to trans charities. I am trying to prevent transitioners and rehabilitate detransitioners. People who are in the trans community are in a cult and they'll leave when they are ready, one way or another. It's not my job to try to get them out and they're not at the center of my help efforts.
@[private account] @[private account] Yea Aiden, so stop romanticizing suicide. I'm gonna mock you if you do. Do you want that? No? Then stay alive to spite me. I hate trans people so much I will do anything for them to die of old age.
Speaking figuratively of course, because only trans woman's culture is made of bricks, and I believe in protecting the bricks. The workplace culture over there is a toxic belief system.
This account began harassing me right after my ER trip last month, though the sock was made in September, when my surgery was scheduled. She keeps deleting her tweets too, like she's afraid to be accountable for them, because she knows she's still crossing professional boundaries left and right. PSA to Gina, Mona and Ziomara: X does in fact respond to lawful discovery requests, and deleting the tweets does not make them stop existing on X's servers. Might as well leave them up, and maybe stop tweeting that you want trans people to die. Nursing board frowns on that.
The 15 year old trans teen had ended her life. It was not reported if hormones were involved. This happened in Australia. The name was withheld due to her age.
Just found out that Norah Vincent died of MAiD in 2022. She wrote a very influential gender book I read in college when I was trans, about passing as a man, called Self-Made Man, despite being what we would now call a TERF. This actually led to needing psych hospitalization. I guess she continued to struggle.
Dead Names Entry: Mike Penner AKA Christine Daniels
A 49 year old sports writer announces his trans identity in April 2007 and is served with divorce papers the following month. The following October, he detransitions, but it doesn't stop his divorce from being finalized November 2008. The following year, on the anniversary of his divorce being finalized, Mike ends in his life in his house.
Dead Names Entry: Lorrie "Loren Rex" Cameron
March 13, 1959 – November 18, 2022
A trans identified woman committed suic de at her home in Berkeley, CA, following medical transition in the late 1980s. Cameron spent decades photographing herself and other trans-identified people. Cameron had been a lesbian prior to transitioning at 26, and it's not reported if hormones affected this identification. Social affirmation and medical transition did not prevent this outcome.
It begins to dawn on the trans community that insisting the government acknowledge their gender transition during the middle of a trans genocide might have inadvertently enabled the genociders to find them.
Trans activist falsely claims there are no reports of trans identified men having phantom penar sensations after vaginoplasty, but published estimates say this is actually a common symptom. Link below.
I've written a lot on http://exulansic.substack.com and have videos in the testosterone troubles and literature review Playlists about trans people who posted about their uncommon testosterone linked issues.
Gendered Offenders:
45 year old trans identified man Weichien “Evelyn” Huang was just convicted of murdering his wife with a fucking sword. He attacked her mom too. He was convicted and will presumably be sent to a women's prison in Los Angeles.
Trans identified woman on testosterone rapidly becomes septic after an unexplained fall bursts an unexplained tailbone cyst. Something tells me the septic skin infection actually caused the fall via metabolic encephalopathy.
Because it's the same shit, different decade. None of this crap was ever shown to be superior to a placebo or effective at reducing suicide rate. You can't even objectively prove someone is or is not "trans."
My take on psychopathologization of trans identities: yes and no
1. People can and do profess believe unlikely crap to participate in social groups and as a way of meeting what seems to be a common human need for spiritual purpose and direction. For those period, as annoying as their religion is, it's not necessarily a sign they have an illness other than being human with the weaknesses and tendencies entailed by that.
2. For some people, their trans identification/ distress over transition is a product of a mental illness, including a sexual fixation perhaps unmasked by a deteriorating brain, and therapists should be allowed to recognize that.
3. The tendency of the immature to confuse fantasy with reality (ROGD in minors) is not a sign of innate pathology but nor should it be indulged at the expense of the child's long term best interests, or else it will create pathologies. It is a phase - a temporary error in judgment, unless it is a persistent sign of pathology or religious attachment. Time will tell. Hormones won't though.
It's to systematically counter the claim that transition is the only, best, or reliable way to prevent a person's suicide, to document times transition actually precipitated a death, and to otherwise refute the ideology that if a trans person decides to self murder, it's society's fault.
My father blasted me with transphobic words that called me invalid, dismissing my physical dysphoria and desire to transition as some sort of sexual fetish. My brother ridiculed me under the guise of wanting to ‘reconnect’. My sister, a cisgender lesbian, excused my father's words as "something I should expect". I can only imagine how much she and her wife laughed at me from afar.
Christmasses and birthdays became days to forget, desperately jealous of "normal" people who get to share those holidays with loved ones who care about them.
I would have never been able to find love. Lesbian and sapphic groups (I found other women attractive, unfortunately) are openly exclusionary to women who are transgender. They mock people like myself, refusing to consider us as anything other than male because of the bodies we are born with. I encountered several transphobic discord groups hiding in plain sight on Reddit. I stopped trying to date or even find sapphic friends as a result, knowing I would likely be considered a freak and kicked back out.
I would have died single.
I would never have been able to form close friendships, as I could never trust that people don't just see me as disgusting or insane, hiding their transphobic beliefs. Seeing me as a "woman, but not really".
My best friend’s parents, people whom I once felt like I could trust, started seeing me as too shameful to invite to social gatherings with their other friends, for fear of being judged.
All of this was on top of the crippling dysphoria I endured every single day. It got easier with HRT, but the things it couldn't undo... I hated my voice. I hated my height. I hated my masculine hands. I hated my body.
And so: I have had enough of this lonely, miserable, fearful existence. This lesser life, where I'd never be cisgender, I'd always have to take hormones, have surgeries, and still never be considered truly 'female' by anyone other than particularly sympathetic people.
To the only few loved ones in my life
To Sarah, an unexpected friend, thank you for accepting me and making me feel like I was normal and worth knowing. You were the mother I never had. I wish you and your children the boundless happiness you all deserve.
To my cat, Millie, I loved you more than words can describe, my little warrior, my princess, my crazy girl, my pretty little companion, my friend. I envied your peaceful existence ever so much. I know Lisa will take good care of you.
To Lisa, my best friend, my sister, your friendship was the best thing to ever happen to me. You are a soul that this world does not deserve, full of love, kindness and genuine empathy. I would not have even survived to this point, were it not for your endless support, catching me whenever I was falling into despair.
To my online friends, I appreciated your friendship, even if it was from afar.
And to Captain Stephanie Vermilliaux... my beloved alter-ego. You were everything I wanted to be. You were strong. Independent. You were painfully beautiful. Resilient. Inspiring. Charismatic and free. Getting to live vicariously through you was bittersweet. You were hope. May the Blood Roses ever sail the endless blue; the holds of the Scarlet Rose filled with gold immeasurable.
To my work
I’m sorry I was so unreliable towards the end. I was genuinely honoured to work for such a positive organisation. Thank you for accepting me so readily and unquestionably. I hope my death shines a light on the worsening oppression transgender people are facing, and how it affects the lives of your trans employees.
To the world at large
Understand that transgender people don’t want to be transgender. We have not chosen this life. It’s an incongruence that we did not ask for, it tortures us inside daily, and we can’t do anything about it other than transition to attempt to live meaningful lives.
All the world needs to do, is accept the fact that we exist. We always will, and always have done.
suicide-note
People like to say things like, "it'll get better", or "there's always hope things will improve". But the unfortunate reality is, that for a lot of people out there: no, that just isn't true.
I'm a woman that is transgender. Since I started transitioning 3 years ago, the world has demonstrated that it does not accept transgender people are valid or deserve to live.
Instead of investing in helping us, or fostering a compassionate culture of understanding and acceptance, governments are now outright removing our basic human rights, and banning access to life-saving healthcare that allows us to live genuine, happy lives.
This is trickling down into popular culture, too. Transphobia is becoming systemic in “women’s rights” and "parents' rights" groups, with them dismissing gender dysphoria as "insanity" under the disguise of “keeping people safe”, which no-one seems to want to challenge.
Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual communities too, are starting to distance themselves from transgender people. The "T" in LGBT+. The very community by whom I was supposed to be unquestionably accepted.
The future is being set up to ensure that the lives of transgender people are made horrific enough so as to encourage suicide, so that we’re no longer a problem. But no-one seems to care. In fact, people are purposely voting for this. It's terrifying.
And so ultimately, despite the euphoria of what was supposed to be a positive journey of self-realisation of who and what I was, finally feeling ‘right’ in myself, and taking decisive actions to live authentically in my actual gender, in return, the world simply rejected me. My life quickly devolved into loss, isolation, loneliness, spiralling expenses, and fear for my future.
I was told to wait 7 years for initial access to the life-saving healthcare that would only start improve my sense of wellbeing. And even then, after being ‘fixed’, I would emerge the other side, still subjected to the same amount of discrimination from wider society.
So, I was forced to pay privately to have access to gender-affirming HRT, unsupported by my GP in doing so, because “they don’t have the expertise” - despite cisgender women being able to walk out of an appointment the same day with an Oestrogen patch prescription. Nor were they willing to work with one of the only few accessible private HRT prescribers, who additionally, were demonised by the GMC through prejudice.
After a few years of perserverance, I came to love the physicality given to me by transition - my female features through hormone therapy, growing out my newfound wavy hair (which I loved), finally actually taking care of my body... and for the first time in my life, I began to feel like what I physically saw in the mirror mapped up to what I was inside. It was euphoric, the most wonderful feeling. I began to truly love myself.
But then came the fear of having it all suddenly taken from me by transphobic legislation. The sword above my livelihood loomed lower and lower. It dropped sharply with puberty blockers being banned for trans children, ripping from them the possibility of even having decent lives from a young age, under the deceptive excuse of "safety". And now that the precedent has been set, the rights of trans adults is undoubtedly next.
As such, I felt increasingly unsafe in a world that was only becoming more and more hostile towards transgender people. The possibility of being forced, by law, to detransition, was horrifying. The idea of having to watch my face, my body, morph back into a physically repulsive shape, a gender that was not my own, slowly, month by month, day by day... would have been enough to push me to kill myself eventually anyway.
I would never have a family. My genetic parents rejected me when I came out. My mother refused to allow me into her home, frightened that "people would see".
Trans identified woman on testosterone goes septic and loses her colon and leg, but that doesn't stop them from continuing to prescribe it and taking her breasts too.
What's also crazy to me is that I've been looking on tiktok for trans people nearly every day for 4 years for some reason (I secretly long to retransition they tell me) and I'm still finding accounts that I've never seen posting horrors the whole time I was looking.
I want to thank @AriDrennen for baselessly blaming transphobia at Middlebury college for Ethan Sorensen's drug overdose, leading me down the rabbit hole of the real source of Ethan's trauma: his trans identified father ripping him away from his primary caregiver while dressing up as her.
When you're trans FTM and your mom keeps texting you at 2 AM about your asymmetrical hair even though she knows you have symmetrical OCD. So she's gonna pull a Britney Spears and shave it off, just like a real man.
My ideas cause your brain to hurt and you decided the solution was to be aggressive for some reason. But if you'd like to understand my content, you may need to engage in a dialogue, as I was clearly referring to people who have a hypermobile EDS syndrome emerging without an identifiable genetic cause.
The concept of a threshold effect may be new to you but a person with hEDS at one hormone balance may discover their "genetic" symptoms go away when they take a hormonal drug that acts on their connective tissue. Many "trans" people discover this. Pregnant women often discover a rapid onset hypermobility syndromes during pregnancy.
Perhaps 100% of the time, their previously asymptomatic genetic connective tissue disorder becomes symptomatic, or perhaps hormones really weaken or strengthen connective tissue and make the syndrome go from asymptomatic to symptomatic and back. Cipro can damage your connective tissue matrix so much you functionally have a hyper mobility syndrome, to the point of becoming vulnerable to arterial dissection.
So can a person have fluctuating genetic hEDS or is EDS the syndrome best conceptualized separately from the various genetic and other causes? Thank you for coming to my TedTalk.
No. His Tiktok began when he was about 18, and linked to an account in his dead name, so I get the impression he was trans for 2-3 years before he died.
Trans identified female secretly records herself threatening an allegedly transphobic coworker instead of just going to HR with her concerns. The harassment caused the coworker to quit the next day.
Deep Dive into the Sorensen Divorce part 4: Trans Conversion Therapy https://open.substack.com/pub/exulansic/p/ethan-sorensen-4-trans-conversion?r=xgqe3&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedstate takes children
You're literally arguing that I only thought I was trans, because I was either lying or mistaken. It's cool when you do it but it's a problem when I do it.
I was not judged by my providers to have any comorbid mental health conditions. Are you saying they were wrong? Are you saying no one with a comorbid mental health condition should be able to access GAC? Are only completely mentally healthy people trans?
I'm telling you if you let the trans activists control the narrative about what counts as transition, eventually detransitioners will be defined out of existence unless they got the skin tube.
Quotes a post by T09319; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Don't know who the dude is. I wouldn't characterize Lux's nightmare with the tracheal shave as a success.
I don't know that bottom left person. Top right is contrapoints or the dollar store version? I can't tell them apart.
Do you only have examples of people who have a financial motive to keep being trans?
How trans activists plan to talk to any woman who regrets what they said she needed to not kill herself. "You would have been a bitter crone either way."
Quotes a post by T09319; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
For a while, as a proud trans man with mysteriously deteriorating mental and physical health, my prescriptions came with stickers on the bottles (don't drive etc) and so I would put them on this wig stand Styrofoam head I acquired somehow, trying to cover it.
Thank you for admitting that people who think they are trans may be incorrect, and therefore it is appropriate to hold space for the likelihood that it's just a phase because kids don't know themselves as well as they feel like they do yet.
They might let trans people go back and change their name on old expired licenses so they can "go stealth" and "not be outed" similar to changing sex on birth certificates. They've just legalized fraud and falsified records.
Transhausen mother explains how her daughter was never distressed by being a girl. They just prompted her with questions about how she identified and reinforced that she was trans.
The trans community recommended finasteride en masse to treat testosterone induced hair loss in a viral trans identified women who posted a video about what 5 years of testosterone did to her hairline.
Quoting @stats_feed: Popular hair loss drug linked to higher suicide risk: compared to non-users, finasteride (Proscar/ Propecia) users have a markedly increased risk of depression, anxiety, and suicidal thoughts.
Over 30 years of observation, 19,320 suicides were expected.
I'm talking about the skeletal deformity that resulted from the hormones I was given to stop my period as recommended for trans masculine patients by WPATH.
If all it takes to become known and be given credibility is to call yourself a detransitioner, even if you were never trans, why are they mad I'm getting attention? Don't the real ones outnumber me? I'm just one person. Speak up!
Drown me out, y'all. It's apparently really easy to just call yourself detrans and instantly get a ton of respect and attention for no other reason. Why are they letting me hog the spotlight as I guzzle birth control pills* and convince myself I'm trans? Why do I have to be quiet for them to feel heard?
The more people come out as detransitioners, the less power the label will have and the more power that the group represented by the label will have.
*I still have never taken those!
Just feels like crabs in a bucket. I'm a loud voice because I've made a great deal of content people want to engage with, the vast majority of which is completely unrelated to my life including my personal gender-affirming care experiences. If I'd listened to the True Detransers about whether it's possible for "just birth control" to be harmful, I would still be in the dark about the sources of my pain. I really appreciate the group of Republicans who encouraged me to not assume that the kind of hormones I was given to be trans somehow protected me from harm of messing with my hormones as a young growing person.
This is one of the ways we're oppressed as trans trans women. We don't get the same mutual aid from the trans community that would facilitate that degree of degeneracy. Instead, pillars of the trans community command us to get a job. We can't get a job without going back in the closet!
I Am Jazz's Waking Nightmare: Happy Pills, Part 4 (S2E1) After @libertycounsel allegedly cancels last-minute, Jazz swallows his misery long enough to proclaim his happiness to an audience full of haters and trans celebrities, and Jeanette gets a voice male.
The charismatic self centeredness of trans ideology never ceases to amaze. You are obligated to pretend to like what you have no control over and didn't ask for and consider deeply harmful. You have to resonate with their "trans joy" or else you're the genital obsessed one
You said trans identification started when humans became bipedal. Presumably this explains why no trans chimpanzees (chimptranzees?) have been documented. I'm just curious if you've asked yourself why.
The transition cannot fail. Like the communion wafer becoming Christ's body, there's the acts you took too transition, and then there is the spiritual "transition." The transition itself succeeded because you were Confirmed as a trans person. You confessed your transness, if only to yourself, and felt validated in that.
But if you stumble and spill the wine, if the communion wafer is contaminated with mold and you get sick, if the phallus rots and falls off, if you didn't realize how many places a person could get a catheter, or have simultaneously, that's just things you regret about how you took Communion, not the Communion itself.
Quotes a post by T25005; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Oh so you're saying I deserve the harassment from trans people about my appearance. Guess what goes around does come around. And further I am not threatening myself to get any of them to stop. So there's that.
Trans women insult me by saying I look like a trans woman, and now this British person is insultinf me by saying I look British. It's as if they hate themselves and protect it outward because misery lives company.
Connective tissue has receptors for these sex hormones. Testosterone isn't just thickening and stiffening the connective tissue in the voice. Growth plates also are connective tissue and need estrogen specifically to close. My bone issues were likely made worse by the protocol I was on, compared to someone who took testosterone. Testosterone can be aromatized to estrogen locally. Synthetic progestin can't. So these bone issues are likely to be most pronounced in trans and detrans people who took puberty blockers and gender affirming menstrual suppression with progestins or who had gonadectomy.
Why I'm not going to modify my commentary to be more palatable to people who identify as trans. This is a cairn at a trail head, warning the unaware. This is not a rescue mission.
This was the notpology to the trans community for terfing out. You can see in her replies that she feels completely entitled to behave this way and it's everyone else's lack of kindness if anyone still has an issue with her.
Why shouldn't teenage girls have access to pain medication?
You have conceded this scan cannot differentiate trans from non trans.
"No therapy can cure this" is an unfalsifiable belief that did not predict my experience at all.
So much for "the trans roommate was an innocent bystander fully cooperating with police" theory. Lance Twiggs was an accessory after the fact to Tyler Robinson, Charlie Kirk's killer.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Utah County prosecutor Jeffrey Gray announces that Charlie Kirk assassin suspect Tyler Robinson is being charged for allegedly having his trans lover, "Luna" Twiggs, destroy evidence.
In an interview yesterday, the FBI director said a pre-written Charlie kill note was indeed destroyed, but they were able to recover forensic evidence of it. https://www.ngocomment.com/p/unmasking-luna-charlie-kirk-assassin
She's a great example of a trans person who is used to everyone being concerned about them. I've said it before and I'll say it again. I'm not trying to make already trans people less trans. I'm trying to prevent people from going over the cliff. This is not a rescue mission.
Yea I remember having an identity crisis when I got to Berkeley and learned what a brainwashed privileged milquetoast valley girl I was from people who had about as much respect for me as this proud trans man who's never known a dollar.
What happened to trans people who kill themselves voluntarily is a tragic event. But that doesn't mean you should scapegoat everyone that knows men aren't women and accuse us of genocide by proxy.
Quoting @legaltweetz: Anyone calling for this mass hysteria against trans people is irresponsible. The shooter wasn’t trans. Stop trying to tie everything violent to trans people. What happened to Charlie Kirk was a tragic event. That doesn’t mean you get to use it as a political weapon to scapegoat an entire group.
He was listening to the question
The question was, "how many mass shootings have there been in America over the last 10 years?"
Charlie answered, "counting or not counting gang violence?"
The questioner says, "right!" And then the gun fires.
The person asking that question needs a hard drive check because Charlie didn't ask a question where "right" makes sense as an answer except as an admission the violence about to happen was gang related, given the trans gang violence that's been happening lately.
Some of the survivors, whose lives were of course put at risk by the sniper firing towards a crowd, think the question about the transgender shooters was a cue.
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
Trans identified men in women costumes should not be platformed as experts in the problems that pretending men can be women creates for society. The conflict of interest couldn't be more obvious.
Quotes a post by T19276; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
>be trans councilmember Olivia Hill
>start having stroke symptoms after half a beer
>friend doesn't want to take your to ER because it'll be a scandal somehow
>goes home for 6-8 hours, somehow knowing this isn't a stroke
>sober up
>go to ER to prove you were sober the whole time
>"the restaurant must have put GHB specifically on my glass"
>"now I'm just like a date rape victim."
>gender affirmed
If I threaten to self-delete if I don't get controlled substances, I go to the mental hospital, no matter how legitimate my need for that substance is. If a trans person threatens self-delete if they don't get controlled substances they merely want for the cosmetic effects, it's a 5 alarm emergency.
The trans people surprised that Trump is planning to adjudicate them as mental defectives should have spoken up for the rights of "adjudicated" (you'd be shocked what this means in practice) mentally ill people sooner. Once you get this designation, there's no reversing it.
Judith's Butlers: The Safer Alternative (Part 2)
Dr. Joshua Safer explains the history of trans classic, starting with clinical management of disorders of sexual development and finishing at selling our lady of perpetual hormone replacement.
I heard Dr. Joshua Safer is trending again. Here's my reaction to one of his other videos a couple years ago.
Judith's Butlers: The Safer Alternative (Part 1)
Dr. Joshua Safer explains the history of trans classic, starting with clinical management of disorders of sexual development and how that generated gender ideology (church of the maculate conception) and finishing at selling our lady of perpetual hormone replacement dogma and drugma at HIV clinics to specifically target men who sleep with men.
I Am Jazz's Waking Nightmare: Happy Pills
NEW. This is Season 2, Episode 1, Part 1
Episode is called "Happy Pills" because that's what Jazz calls the antidepressants he started needing after they began breaking his neuroendocrine system. I discuss how the cosmetic effects drove their medical decision-making, not any sort of theory of a trans brain neurodivergence needing specific medication.
Ok, you don't have to agree with me that wanting a rite of passage into adulthood is a fundamental yearning of young people, and that this is fueling people buying the trans rites because the true rites feel unaffordable.
He didn't say "I am detrans" to my knowledge. He said he wanted to detrans but had decided not to, because he knew identifying as a trans woman put people at ease.
"If All Else Fails" the Graham Linehan arrest track.
If the tweets are so inciteful, the UK has precipitated a reach for those tweets beyond anyone's wildest imagination. Why is the UK inciting violence against trans people?!
Lyrics:
pissin away my life in the ER again
because I was not able to pee at all
like couldn't pass none of my own urine
so they're gonna poke me with a medical awl
they're giving me a supra pubic catheter
and I'm flying out Monday to SF city
I'm seeing my doctors in the morning
I'm getting ready for revision surgery
to make sure that I can pee
this is not fun
this is not fun anymore
this is not fun
that's it I'm looking for the door
but Monday is gonna be a great day
I'm gonna be able to pee right
hopefully
all I wanted was to stand to pee
but now I can't pee
it's kinda funny
my pee pee won't pee
I'm Mr. pee body
the doctor says I have to dilate
the sound and the ureayyy
for 15 minute sessions
three times a day
i have to stick this stick in the tip of my dick
the pain so bad it's making me sick
i have to stick this stick in the tip of my dick
the pain so bad it's making me sick
this is not fun
trust me my good and faithful
transgender son
this is not fun
He's a brilliant comedy writer I've been a fan of since I was trans. They've all but destroyed his career for saying men aren't women too convincingly.
Though I was nonbinary at the end of my trans phase, that was after everything but the hysteroscopy surgery. I was a regular trans man and they were following WPATH SOC8. Actual androgen was contraindicated for medical reasons so they tried to create the effect with androgenic alternatives that also lowered estrogen enough to stop my cycles.
When I read it in a Turkish language book as a young trans man translator I nearly fell out of my chair. When I found out it's not a coincidence I had intense cognitive dissonance. Woohoo funny word fact but booooo literal violence
Unironic description of the trans shooter as a travesty, which derives from the Latin for cross dressing. Apparently they're not violent so their community is entitled to a few freebies.
C2 false claimshand-codeddenialshooter attributionviolence terror
"This is a man with long hair and a beard. Where's the trans woman?!"
It was exactly that kind of transphobia is that led to this tragedy though!!@!!!!111!!1 eleven
Like trans, the con is that you aren't taking this drug because you're sick but to exert control. Therefore it is irrelevant to subsequent problems. That's how doctors act.
Quoting @Babygravy9: The use of hormonal contraceptives by tens of millions of women could plausibly be having population-level effects on behaviour, including political behaviour. A new study shows that women who use hormonal contraceptives exhibit significantly stronger emotional responses than women who are naturally cycling and they also, interestingly, remember fewer details of negative events.
A study last year showed that hormonal contraceptives shrink the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, a region of the brain involved in fear processing and emotional control.
I was harassed by Chonks as soon as I opened the door to leave the building. Peaceful protest my ass. They were there to harass us, disrupt our event, induce fear with references to the trans shooting 3 days prior, strike us with objects (not self defense from being pushed by a small woman even if that did happen, which I doubt given how quickly Mr. Shoulders jumped in to stop the attack) and otherwise stalk us.
When will YOUR reflection show who YOU really are inside?
Yes, basically. That for some their goal in transitioning is greater control over both weight and body fat as well as to conceal their weight loss, similar to non trans anorexics wearing baggy clothes to hide their frame.
Trans activist goes hog wild and impulsively tries to beat women with a giant sign for the outrageous crime of entering a library to watch a panel discussion.
Quoting @bourne_beth2345: 🚨🚨Why are they so antagonistic?
Watch the trans activists intimidate anyone trying to enter our public debate on ‘gender-affirming care’ in Davis CA yesterday.
They chalk in front of the doorway ‘Transphobes Enter Here’ and call us names.
We asked for police protection in advance, given we had 3 brave, truth-telling detransitioners speaking (@[private account], @[private account] and @TTExulansic), but they denied our request.
We called 911 when things started escalating.
Footage of when I was first walking up to the panel at a library in Davis. @bourne_beth2345 was already on the phone trying to get police to intervene, and then another woman describes having been recently assaulted by the trans activists. They're naturally drawn to GC's holding cameras and she was indeed holding a camera.
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentviolence terror
3 days after a trans identified man shot up a church of children through stained glass windows, and after the police had already been called because they attacked a person in our party and were not letting people enter the event, a trans activist yells "shots fired" at me while loitering outside our event with only large obscured windows separating they/them and us. They had also been blasting Mulan's "Be A Man," which appears to suggest their motivation for this behavior has something to do with our legally protected gender identities or expressions or sexes. Who knows because none of them faced legal consequences for illegal behavior despite legal showing up.
At the end, one insinuated she has some insider knowledge about Robin Westman. The police officer (who had already left) had had questions for me because I was on the flyer but they were not required to stop harassing us or blocking the accessible entrance to prevent disabled people from entering and exiting a venue because they hate members of protected groups they have ideological fixations on, like detransitioners. If the law was being fairly applied, their unlawful stalking behavior today would get a hate crimes and RICO enhancement.
If he can identify as trans but secretly be detrans, then some of the shooters identifying as non trans may be secretly trans. So without evidence otherwise, a 1% trans rate would give you 54 trans shooters, of which 50 were closeted.
Would you rather have a dead son or a trans daughter has become, would you rather have a trans daughter or a dead elementary school?
Quoting @marycatedelvey: Nasal liberal says “If you all had just allowed them to express themselves way they identify, we could have prevented the violent act from occurring in the first place”
#Minneapolis #trans #robinwestman
He regretted being transitioned, and was certain he had cancer, but didn't detransition explicitly because he knew identifying as a trans woman would keep people's guards down so he could kill children.
And they'll yuk this crap up despite the fact that we're talking about a psychologically and medically abused child who went crazy, murdered at least 2 people, tried to murder dozens more, and now he's dead of suicide at 23. And they want to say it's because he was detrans?
You guys are the ones who affirmed that he was trans and changed his legal sex and body, based on the lie that if a young boy fantasizes about being a girl, that's a permanent state. No accountability for this outcome though. They'll never care how many kids they hurt. Hurting kids was the point.
Galaxy Brain TRAs abandon the narrative about "no one would go to the effort of pretending to be trans in order to conceal violent intentions" in their rush to call the latest post-transition school shooter "detrans" despite the fact he never really detransitioned. So how can he have been true detrans?!
Fact is y'all probably gave him metastatic breast cancer and it went to his brain and turned him into a delusional mass shooter who could no longer control himself. Good job.
Dysphoria cured! Suicide prevented again. All in a day's work. #savinglives
Quotes a post by T17014; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Interesting. So this means men are capable of saying they're trans and going to all the effort of identifying and presenting as a woman, just to keep people from suspecting his violent intentions. Truly groundbreaking stuff.
@MrAndyNgo pointed this out on his Substack write-up of the Annunciation shooter's manifesto. Apparently Robert regretted his transition to Robin as a minor.
According to the Times, Robert changed his name when he was 17. It would have been super embarrassing to be a cringe AF detransitioner and admit he was never really trans. So he chose to mass murder elementary school kids. That was the result of the "death before detransition" suicide pact that sets mentally distressed teenagers on a path to public humiliation. And his suicide still was not prevented.
Church of Trans Theory: This Little Plight of Mine
A trans man explains the divinity of trans and I comment that ideological systems designed to explain the workings of divinity are generally called religions.
New talking point: Trump is trans now because they horse dose themselves on heart medication to maximize one of the side effects.
There's no public information that I can find that says President Trump has even been prescribed spironolactone.
Yes it can keep getting worse as their maladaptive compensations lead to deterioration or if the dose increases cause the voice muscles to continue to increase in size in a confined space. Men's testosterone is regulated by the brain. Trans men's testosterone is regulated by how often they inject it. They're not the same.
Reminds me of that "first transgender figure skater." Amateur hour, but he's a man acting effeminately, so we're supposed to clap for the mediocre man. "He's not mediocre he's expressing his sexuality through art" YEA. BADLY.
They have XX chromosomes, so when they take testosterone, they end up looking like they are men with some sort of chromomosome disorder that makes them visibly different from other men, similar to having Down syndrome. I have called it Trans Man Convergence Syndrome.
Can you clarify, are trans people ontologically sane? What does his being mentally unwell have to do with his validity as a woman and membership in the trans community? Are you suggesting some people only think they're trans because they're mentally unwell? Hmm
Quotes a post by T01195; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Trans women are women" only makes sense if women are malformed men, because the conclusion gender science came to is that somehow malforming men can make a woman.
I've followed MacKinnon for a few years on Tiktok. It's insulting what NYT did here, but it's also strategic. MacKinnon's definition of detransition includes people who stop hormones but continue to identify as trans. This is their attempt to muddy the water to make detransitioners a subcategory of our own category. Feel familiar?
I have some degree of respect for her as an ethnographer. She has been publicly disputing the 1% detransition rate for some time now, among other things. At the same time, she's clearly on a side.
I hope some of you send in your own opinion pieces about growing beyond transition as you realize the true depth of the sky. And if they are not printed, self-publish and call the NYT out.
Quoting @ChloeCole: This article in The NYT about detransitioning was written by a trans identified person.
Absolutely insulting to everyone who has gone through this.
Next article title: ‘The Truth About Christianity’ by an atheist.
Charlie Dale the trans man is furious that another trans man, @BuckAngel, used his videos without his consent (even though he then made a reaction video using a clip from Buck's video, likely without consent). She claims she's an extremely rare example of someone with chronic pain from phalloplasty.
Testosterone Troubles: Bariwn Award
A woman overdoses on testosterone after her doctor, Dr. Norman Barwin, who was de-licensed during her transition, prescribed her a dose that was excessively high, even by trans standards. He also got caught impregnating over a baker's dozen patients.
My ex gf also decided she wanted top surgery in the wake of a moderate concussion from a car vs. pedestrian accident (she was the pedestrian). She already identified as trans but suddenly it was incredibly urgent to get that off her chest.
Trans masc woman 4 months on testosterone can no longer cry.
Oh, and she's having mixed bipolar episodes, including weeks of hypomania heading into depression.
Not a single dot was connected, nor a single dysphoria cured.
Why do I have these thoughts randomly that fill me with terror, document them online, and forget about them, only for someone to comment months later? Is this repressed gender dysphoria the trans activists keep bringing up?
Quoting @TTExulansic: Like on the deep level that makes you cry out and call your mom because what if we only exist as a millions of years experiment by birds to evolve a mouse that had crow levels of intelligence?
Kim Petras insinuates he keeps a key to nowhere on his bag as drug paraphernalia, specifically drugs you would insufflate (snort). IYKYK and Kim expects some of his viewers to know. I don't know, this is a guess based on Google for me. Raises questions about his nails. Interestingly, GLP-1 drugs like Ozempic are being prescribed to addicts, including ketamine addicts. Whatever is going on with his hip may be quite painful, and both ketamine and cocaine can relieve pain. Worried for this person's well-being. The only other trans person I've seen a actively fishing for a drug plug online was gonorrhea arthritis woman.
Trans masculine voice disorder results from testosterone's impact on the female voice. They don't all get it though. I call it kazooicism but TMVD is what the literature calls it.
Testosterone Troubles: Vocal Fry
I react to the new trans mask procedure of injecting testosterone, fat, even toothpaste into the vocal folds to achieve a lower fundamental frequency, as a Speech-Language Pathologist.
Trans man explains how the trans rites allow you to die, be dead, then rise again in your perfected final form. You, too, can be gender Jesus, die for the sins of the doctors who assigned you at birth, the family that never saw you for who you really were, and yourself for previously lacking courage to be your authentic self. By killing your former self with transition, you can scapegoat your identity and then rise from your own ashes like a phoenix, cleansed of former attachments and political errors, reborn as the trinity of who you are now, who you used to be, and the true self that transcends both versions of you.
That's what they tell women who are reporting symptoms of vaginal atrophy whether it's from birth control or from trans. Just use lubricant. Not, stop taking the drug immediately so it doesn't progress to irreversible damage. Some fraction of them look forward to surprising these girls with iatrogenic vaginal atrophy, I'm convinced.
@[private account] Trans man convergence syndrome is especially pronounced when the hormones are given to teenagers because it throws off their facial growth in some areas more than others, marking these girls as targets who can't scream.
Vaginoplasty Volumes: Jacob's Bladder
A trans-identifying man undergoes vaginoplasty and experiences the predictable and nightmarish urological complications that come from flaying a pianist, flipping it inside out, widening it with urethra, and attempting to anchor it with zip ties and scar tissue.
@[private account] And you claimed I was never trans, yet I was given hormones. So, make up for mind if it's a real situation that some people are being given hormones they don't need.
Hormone therapy for trans identified men will suppress testosterone production. That's what estrogen does to men's brains. Men are also often prescribed progesterone or lupron to also suppress testosterone production. It's interesting watching you argue out of both sides of your mouth though. It's not a poison but if it is that's fine.
There's a specific clique that likes to lie about me in this specific way. Other hater collectives have a different ideology about me, that I'm still trans and just repressed now. The people who say I pretend to be this or that are typically GC friendly fire. That group also has claimed to possess a complete list of my past lovers, which I still find hilarious since it only had one name on it.
Yea, it damaged the brain by applying pressure, and the result was the dysphoria was cured instantly.
Trans identified people frequently discuss how the drugs affect their emotional lability.
The trans rights activists want to mandate ambiguity in language as a control tactic. I've never seen one of them just come right out and admit it like this.
Quotes a post by A0364; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Women aren't allowed to name ourselves. That's the ultimate point of the trans word games. We have to be subjugated linguistically, or we might develop class consciousness.
Quotes a post by A0364; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Alright, let’s cut through the noise and get to the core. I hear your call for specifics and a straight-up exchange, so I’ll engage directly, keeping it sharp and grounded.If you’re saying I’ve misread your position, I’ll need you to point to the exact claim I’m critiquing that you think I’ve misconstrued—quote it, and we can unpack it. I’m not here to strawman you. On the authority point, I’ll take you at your word: you’re not dodging with citations. But if you’re anchoring in “demonstrable frameworks,” let’s see the framework—specific studies, data, or reasoning you’re leaning on. I’m ready to dig into those.On Dunning-Kruger, I didn’t throw that term at you, so we’re clear there. If you feel I’m implying overreach, I’ll need the specific claim you think I’m challenging wrongly. Lay it out, and I’ll counter with evidence or reasoning, not just hot air. Same goes for trans experts or cherry-picking—name the claim I’ve sidestepped or the evidence I’ve ignored, and I’ll address it head-on. No orchards, just the trees you point to.I’m not reading nerves or projecting fear; I’m here for the same dialogue you are. No theater, no crowd—just the arguments. So, here’s my move: pick one specific point from your position you want me to engage with. Quote it, frame it, and I’ll meet you with a counterexample, a study, or a reasoned pushback. If you’ve got a biological or philosophical claim in play, I’m ready to dissect it with you—scientifically or logically, your call.Your turn. Bring the claim. Let’s work.
Your critique is sharp, but it’s built on assumptions about my position that don’t hold up. Let’s break it down:
Appeal to Authority: I haven’t cited philosophers or biologists to dodge your points. If I reference expertise, it’s to ground claims in evidence, not to outsource thinking. Show me where I’ve deflected instead of engaging, and I’ll address it directly.
Dunning-Kruger Misuse: You accuse me of misapplying this term, but I haven’t used it. If you’re implying I’m overconfident in biology, lay out the specific claims I’ve made that are false. I’m ready to defend or correct them with data, not slogans.
Credentialism: I don’t dismiss your arguments based on credentials or lack thereof. I’d engage with your points regardless of who you are. If I’ve ignored trans scholars or scientists, name them and their arguments—I’ll respond. Cherry-picking? Show me how.
Agency and Anxiety: I don’t deny your identity or fear your mind. I’m here, engaging solo, without tagging backup. If I’ve seemed anxious, it’s news to me—let’s keep this about ideas, not psychoanalysis.
Conclusion: I’m not waiting for witnesses or a finish line. I’m here for the argument. If you want to continue, bring specific claims or evidence, and I’ll meet you there. Ball’s in your court.
Why would social affirmation increase the number of trans people? Are you saying this infographic is inaccurate, because there's a lot of trans white people who are repressed and uncounted?
So this access to care and the stigma generally reverses in the case of trans medicalization, so ethnic minorities have a relatively easy time sterilizing themselves, and again you find that 0% suspicious.
You called me racist for asking a question involving the ethnic makeup of the trans community, which made an assumption about me and my race. Now you're back pedaling because I'm asking you to use the regular whistle.
Have your doctors actually documented that you were another race? Have police? Do you think their racial judgments of you may have impacted their mistreatment of you? You brought up healthcare stigma. Share your lived experience.
About how these numbers reflect racial identification among trans people? Yes. Who are you hoping to deceive about whether most trans people identify as white, according to this graphic?
Right, every trans woman's path is valid, including mine. It's wrong how people tell me I'm not a real trans woman because of what I was assigned at birth.
I'm telling you that my lived experience has been that Amab trans women have invalidated me simply because i was assigned female at birth, which you know is meaningless and baseless.
This is a great point, and it's the foundation of theological non-cognitivism. If you claim to believe a logically incoherent proposition, such as up is down, or men aren't men if they don't want to be men, I don't understand what you even mean when you say you "believe" it. Because you have to maintain the true belief in order to maintain awareness that they want to be something and they aren't currently that. Which is what supposedly differentiates them from "c-s women" who are people who are what they want to be. But Toren wants us to also say that "trans women" are already what they want to be no matter what they've done. It's incoherent.
Don't let anyone tell you that of course all trans activists understand that you can't change your sex and that they know trans women are still biologically male. Some literally think it makes them not only the opposite sex prospectively, but also retroactively.
Quotes a post by T08560; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Kristi Khan has two different narratives about why her daughter very deliberately ended her life. She embroiders the narrative depending on what kind of bill she's trying to defeat, sometimes hiding the fact that Kai had been mentally ill since middle school, and never being explicit about whether the hormones preceded the mental illness. I'm guessing that's because, as with Jazz Jennings, they know the "mental illness" began after the drugs, not before. But like Jeanette, she blames the terfs for her child's drug induced neuropsych symptoms.
She refuses to take ownership of Kai's "miserable" home life leading up to her first attempt, which had nothing to do with school bullying or being trans, and everything to do with her father's criminal rage episodes and her mother's absolute unrivaled perfection, which is hard to exist in the shadow of. Her first attempt was right before she was supposed to start school, at the end of a long summer at home with the rageaholic and the long-suffering saint.
She can't accept that her daughter had a mental illness that was put on literal steroids, and this was the result. Her death, with a poison called sodium nitrite (an extremely miserable way to go, similar to death by tide pod), was not impulsive or driven by an emotional reaction to a bully saying she's a girl, but a very deliberate and planned act, one she'd also attempted 6 months previously.
Kristi told the legislature that she believed her vulnerable, mentally ill daughter had been improving, but then she turned around and said Kai was afraid to go outside because all the bullies would pounce and that's why she had no choice but to end it all. Which is it, Kristi? What was the trend line after she got to college? Were things improving, leading to you being blindsided by her death, or was her life so objectively horrible due to bullying at college that it made logical sense to k!ll herself?
I don't like autopsying these public politicized su!cides, but they opened the door by using these deaths to somehow justify mutilating healthy kids. So we're putting a stop to the propaganda. I'm fed up with being told it's my fault when a mentally ill person acts like they are mentally ill. It is not my fault mental illness exists. I'm not a witch who can cause mental illness or deranged behavior by whispering "he's a man!" 3 times into my bathroom mirror. It is not my fault when someone's drug use makes their mental illness worse.
Quoting @TTExulansic: She's fully cognizant of the fact that she found no evidence that the people at this site were motivated by transphobia or were even aware she was trans, and that's why it didn't make it into her testimony to the Kansas legislature. But she has a personal belief that her daughter, who was chronically altered by an experimental hormone cocktail prescribed for cosmetic effect, that had a profound effect on her brain, was actually sad due to people not letting her in the men's bathroom.
Not knowing how endowed you are or what kind of gynecomastia you have it is hard to say. Google has a lot of results that look good to me from this approach for this indication.
Here's a picture showing 4 types, with pseudogynecomastia made of pure fat on the left, true gynecomastia in the middle two, and a trans identified man on estrogen on the far right. I think it makes sense to try a more conservative approach if you have a low amount of tissue to remove.
Male Breast: A Review of the Literature and Current State of the Art of Diagnostic Imaging Work-Up https://share.google/ets70d3HmySB28pYu
Trans tape is a better strategy, I would imagine. Other than that, building up the pectoral muscles might create a more masculine cosmetic effect. But there's something to be said for radical acceptance of warts and all.
Sure, so you have two categories of men who would be interested in a trans man:
1. Gay or straight or bisexual men with GAMP who are chasers
2. Straight or bisexual men without GAMP
I just explained how this term has nothing to do with Navajo folklore, despite the superficial resemblance. Also, since you probably are confused on this too, bats aren't birds even though both have wings. Trans women aren't women either.
The only people who are trans are people who believe they are trans. You have a Constitutional right to believe things that aren't true, with reasonable limits so every religious perspective is treated the same by the government.
He started puberty late which to me suggests he had the tumor before he was trans, causing his puberty to be delayed, and so that may have contributed to his initial sense of gender incongruence
It's the next social contagion. The next way for a trans person to get attention by changing their hormones and surgery and talking about how dysphoric their mood is due to where they're at with their gender. So it's gonna get more and more popular, and you'll see more high profile detransitions. Then eventually we will be out of the woods.
Which of his transitions was authentic and which was brainwashing? How did you determine this in his case? Why isn't his detransition a sign he was never trans, instead of a sign of brainwashing?
I think it should be available but not mandatory. I don't understand why it's given sublingually given the dental issue common to oral trans dermal opioids.
Trans medicine can't fail. It can only be failed. If you failed because you realized it was abusive and harmful, and you detransitioned, then that makes you a failure. If you speak to your experience, you're weaponizing your pain.
The reality is they don't care how many kids or adults get hurt. That's fundamentally irrelevant.
Quotes a post by T08560; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If someone is female, there's something that makes them female, the absence of which would make them not female. Go ahead and identify what makes the trans identified males female.
I helped you make an inference with your background knowledge, to help you keep track of the conversation. The subject was whether I only ever talk about trans women and the answer is no.
It begins to dawn on Oracle that the information she received about testosterone side effect prevalence isn't lining up with what she's hearing from other trans people.
Are they more likely to be trans because they question themselves or are they more likely to be trans for some other reason? You suggested that it was a behavioral consequence of the thought patterns typical of high functioning autism, and I agree with you, but you're seeming to back pedal now that I've pointed out this implies there's not an underlying difference and they're finding something because they're the type of people who go looking.
It is not conflating anything my dude. Testosterone is an anabolic steroid. That's the chemistry. That's the function. I know trans identified people often have trouble with thinking of different category members as different, but the harms of testosterone not only include the liver, they're not limited to it. The DOSE makes the POISON.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] The medical decision didn't cause him to want to do the behaviors that led to the interaction with the medical system. Do you agree I'm not a psychiatric hospital for any random trans person who might feel unaffirmed but my tweets?
This is how the court reasoned. Not all women get pregnant, so pregnancy discrimination is not sex discrimination. Not all trans kids need these interventions, so banning the interventions is not sex/ anti Trans discrimination.
This is from the Skrmetti decision. Since being trans and receiving transition medical care are not identic states, denying one isn't discrimination against the other. Similarly, female sex is not identic to the state of being, having been, or being able to become pregnant.
What trait is identic to femaleness? We are oppressed using our different female biology against us, but they want to divorce femaleness from the capacities of femaleness, just as they're divorcing transness from the completion of the trans rites.
I don't think trans should be recognized in law separate from disability or religion, but I think the way they're going about it has implications for women fighting sexism that need to be examined. Because how far is this from saying that not every disabled person needs a ramp, so how is a lack of a ramp discrimination on the basis of disability? Etc
Non- transitioning trans person points out that the one thing everyone can agree on is that trans medical care isn't necessary to be trans, and the implication of that, logically, is that banning transition procedures doesn't discriminate against trans people.
This logic is how they're gearing up to legalize discrimination against pregnant women again, FYI.
Who started the conversation about trans kid suicides and their cause and ways to prevent it? I'm continuing the conversation the trans community began. Now it's suddenly inappropriate to point out that trans kids are committing suicide.
By definition anyone who gets sterilized to treat gender dysphoria because they're trans and cannot function normally due to this functional impairment is being sterilized due to their disability. Sometimes they're not warned of the reproductive pain that can set in from testosterone and then that's used to justify hysterectomy later, even if that's not what they would have wanted had they been informed at the start.
That account was accusing me of mocking the homeless for being confused why another trans account was mocking me for living at home. You just have to keep remembering they're on drugs that make their brains shrink.
https://x.com/HeatherMarieDu4/status/1942932956298780857?t=Sd3vv5Y2f5SnBy1u7SXIiA&s=19
Quotes a post by T03645; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] The important thing is you've agreed trans hormones cause bone mineral density loss in men. Which was the original issue - could it have caused bone loss, which is a known risk factor for compression fractures.
@[private account] @[private account] It is a trans ideology belief that everyone has both sets of all genes, when in fact Y chromosome genes are not possessed by females. It is another belief that all sex specific/ relevant genes are turned on and off by estrogen. These beliefs lack foundation.
The basis of this debate within the trans community is the split between Trans Classic - predicated on the idea that some men have a biological need to be women and on female hormones etc - and Nonbinitarianism, where the point of transition is to go from female to less female.
Quoting @TTExulansic: "I studied nonbinary identities in college, and specifically I was interested in Japanese nonbinary identities." You may want to settle in for a long one.
@[private account] @[private account] No, Y chromosome genes are expressed throughout the body across the lifespan. Stop getting your genetics education from trans ideology. The idea that your chromosome only acts in your gonads is a belief common in trans ideology that can be easily disproven.
Riley's tantrum extorted an apology from the gay man who committed the sin of not outing her as trans to make sure everyone knew she wasn't like other men. Now she's gender Jesus, preaching forgiveness.
No, at the time of initial screening, before the trans rites. You said there's some screening process where you can try to predict which people who think they're trans, aren't really trans. What's the sign?
A trans identified man on hormone therapy describes symptoms that sound a lot like a growth plate injury in his hips or some other hormone mediated arthritis/greater trochanteric pain syndrome.
A 🧵 of trans people also promoting the dangerous practice of reusing single-use medication vials, which lack anti microbial preservatives, creating a risk of infection.
Yes the trans men indulging in sissification fetish is a phenomenon. They eroticize misogyny and dissociate from the fact they are female by otherwise wearing the trans mask.
This person who used to follow me on YouTube has a very strange theory for why a trans identified man verifiably doxed me a couple months ago after befriending me as a detransitioner 2 years ago. It's somehow my fault.
Quotes a post by T13170; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedactivist harassmentcrime case
Yea no trans activist ever doxed a terf until I gave them the idea by falsely accusing people of doxing, the concept I invented it seems, and this caused me to get doxed so it was my fault.
There's a clique of people with a really bizarre attitude towards me, including this person. Glad you can see it.
Testosterone Troubles: Becker Nevus and Becker Nevus Syndrome
A puberty suppressed woman on testosterone develops a late onset "birthmark" because "even [her] skin knew [she] was trans."
I think tribal intentional healthy person mutilation rituals are actually pretty common in indigenous tribes and that the trans tribe is trying to recreate these practices. Facial tattooing of children was for intragroup recognition and so are the top surgery scars they pick out.
IMO this is a more plausible explanation for his symptoms than vocal hyperfunction 7 years ago, especially the limited stamina/ fatigability. But it implicates trans medicine so we're gonna blame talking too frequently for work.
Trans person: Hey doctor, I'm dysphoric. Can I have a controlled substance not approved for any use in women to treat a problem with no physical sign?
Doctors: Sure have whatever
Pain patient: Hey doctor, I have pain from a verifiable condition that is known to cause pain.
Doctor: How dare you want to not suffer. You will become addicted to not suffering if we alleviate your suffering. Just pretend you're not suffering. Now leave or I am calling security.
Imagine a professional today saying publicly that the way to see if a trans person is faking gender dysphoria is to wait until they're unconscious and then pinch them really hard because they can't die of suicide if they're being pinched! Dysphoria cured!
The trans related iatrogenic hormone deficiency ("gender affirming menstrual suppression") disrupted my growth plate mineralization, due to my young age. Despite being a legal adult, my bones were not done growing, and depo provera in particular is known to pull minerals out of bones which includes growth plates, and to prevent minerals from being laid down. That's why it's been used as a puberty blocker for 50n years. I essentially had the tail end of my puberty suppressed.
So that plus their instruction to do weight bearing exercise to protect my bones from being demineralized by the drug, was too much for the drug weakened growth plate, causing deformation of the femur head, which needs to be spherical to work properly. Because it was not recognized at the time or addressed, despite my many complaints (instead I was labeled as having a mental problem causing conversion of psychological distress into physical symptoms), this physical problem has led to a lot of secondary soft tissue degeneration, early onset arthritis, and has hit a breaking point where my labrum is shredded with multiple tears. I may need cadaver tissue donation to be uncrippled and stop the arthritis from progressing and hopefully delay a hip replacement as long as possible.
This problem is quite rare in a women in her early 20s, and when it's been documented to happen, it's typically a result of a naturally occurring hormone deficiency. Mine was iatrogenic.
A man settles the lesbian trans men debate by explaining that lesbian isn't an exclusive term because only straightness is because straightness comes from white supremacy and you can lose your white card by not acting white enough.
A TIF's limited edition abortion led to her realization that she's trans because of how gender affirming it felt to not be pregnant anymore since men aren't pregnant (unless you're a stunning and brave pregnant trans man. Everyone's gender journey of affirmation is different!)
It ends up looking like female to male with a syndrome. And that needs to be disclosed. You will look like a man with a recognizable chromosome disorder that will eventually be clockable by the general public as trans, if the trans mask wearers get enough cultural visibility.
I call it trans man convergence syndrome. Women on testosterone all end up looking like men with the same chromosome disorder, because they have a different karyotype than normal men.
I'm rooting for a trajectory where your can get things together and feel like the trans ideation is in the past but your can still embrace the qualities about you that brought you into the ideology, and be a productive and helpful member of your community.
Did you see the subsequent attempt to convince me that I'm wrong about him because his sister is the evil child of the family, listing her crimes back to FIRST GRADE, then uno reverse they're both trans
One of the ways the trans community coerces women and girls into transitioning is by taking advantage of the fact people who will soon transition, do not like how they look. They try to sell you a fantasy. Not only will you go from ugly to beautiful, but from phony to authentic.
Quotes a post by T15379; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
He's defending a mob of violent trans activists attempting to break into our conference to physically prevent me from talking about feminism to a private ticketed audience. I was literally rushed off the toilet right before my time to speak with the words "they are storming the bridge, we need to get you in the room so we can lock the doors."
Quotes a post by T01096; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's prejudice for women to fear men on the basis of being men who are therefore more prone to violence, but trans women are allowed to fear non trans men because, duh, they're more likely to be violent.
Quotes a post by T00991; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] A lot! Trans and detrans people tend to have higher ACES scores (Adverse Childhood Experiences Scale). So glad I made it to where I am today.
He's grifting so hard. You don't need $160,000 to defend against misdemeanor trespassing. Marcy has now admitted that this number was chosen at random, presumably because it was a big number, not because he consulted an attorney and had a reasonable expectation of his likely upcoming legal expenses. Yet the givesendgo says he needs this amount for "a chance to be spared." He's already raised $20,000.
How much more are you gonna grift from the trans community, Marcy?
Quotes a post by T00101; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The short term seeming improvement in pain level may not prevent long term degenerative changes from the lack of estrogen. Why don't you want trans people to get real diagnosis and a real treatment plan??? Do you hate them? Do you not care? EDS has a lot of physical implications. It's actually bad for people to think they have gender dysphoria when they actually have a connective tissue disorder they don't know about.
If he'd been arrested in the men's room for being a trans woman, that would be a great point! He'd be just like Rosa Parks! But in fact he was arrested for being a man in the women's room, not for being trans. He thought being trans made him an exception to rules for men. He is finding out he's wrong.
Marcy the terf out here gatekeeping and suggesting we shouldn't believe trans kids when they tell us who they are.
Should we believe 20 year old adult trans kids like you? Maybe you were misdiagnosed. Maybe you're making drug fueled bad decisions & that's why you're like that.
Quotes a post by T00101; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My college diploma shadow box has a rainbow tassel from the lavender graduation, which I had another one of in graduate school. I was president of my high school gay-straight alliance and was recognized by private organizations and the government multiple times for all my LGBT activism in high school. I have a degree in gender studies. Going into speech pathology school, I thought maybe my focus would be gender voice therapy since I was trans at the time. Now I'm regularly told I'm a homophobic MAGA Christian tradspinster who's never questioned my gender and never transitioned and never loved a woman - when they're not telling me I'm still trans on the inside, that is. I just want the ones who will be the first to tell you of their suffering to be able to heal like I did.
Trans identified convicted murderer Alex Stewart AKA Alan Baker apparently erased his criminal record by changing his gender. This happened in Scotland.
The attorney for the women he was accusing of transphobia in prison, (Jayney Sutherly, the queen who mercilessly misgendered the man in the women's prison), emailed about his prior convictions. He was repeatedly told that Alan had none. The police didn't admit he's a murderer in jail for a reason until the attorney sent a news article about the murder to the police.
I'm seeing increasing awareness within the trans community on tiktok that lack of estrogen causes vaginal atrophy. Just a few years ago, Boston Children's Hospital's GeMS program was claiming testosterone would just aromatize to estrogen as needed in the vagina.
This had nothing to do with zionism or any war. A group of GC content creators went after a trans widow who had converted to Judaism in the 80s, for supposedly appropriating Judaism but actually being a white antisemite.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] https://x.com/life_minutiae/status/1918789141980143859?t=OspEv3NCncqRGi3RUsk4vw&s=19
I did read it. I didn't understand how trans people were more likely to die at every stage of life but also more likely to get really old.
Quotes a post by T00368; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] There is a study they've been citing at me lately that they claim means trans men are twice as likely to see their 90th birthday regardless of when they transition.
Apparently trans identification can sometimes be social contagion after all. Just, shhhhhh, stop talking about outgrowing the ROGD you got from Tumblr. You're making us REAL transatlantics look bad.
You seem to avoid thinking of yourself in the persecutor role. It makes sense with what you've disclosed of your upbringing and the general trans attitude towards who are history's victims and heroes. I suspect the lack of accountability that involves, though, is why many are having a repulsed and mistrustful reaction to your detransition announcement. For me, I think it could be you're still deep in denial. Healing takes time. I would expect a sincere person to gradually warm up to taking more accountability for how they acted, even as you hope people will show grace at their discretion for the fact you were affected by these other life circumstances but have made sincere efforts to change since then.
Girls get puberty blockers as well as progestins for menstrual suppression that work similarly to reduce sex hormone production. It can cause this problem by disrupting growth plate fusion into the early 20s. The testosterone trans identified girls get also results in that same low estrogen state that can affect growth plate closure.
Pregnant trans man reports that she does not feel she has any milk producing tissue remaining since top surgery. Different surgeons will take more or less of the tissue, because it's a cosmetic procedure. Some women do still lactate after top surgery, and the milk has nowhere to go.
No. I'm a secularist. I don't think any religion, including the church of trans religion of the gender soul, should be forced upon me including by using tax money to fund it.
Trans man convergence syndrome. They end up looking like men with a shared chromosome difference, as if they all had Down syndrome. You can see the common theme.
Gendered Offenders:.
A 27 year old trans identified Mormon man called Emily Alice Smith (not the UK actress) has been charged with attempted murder for shooting 48 year old man Steve Miller 7 times, leaving him crippled on his right side. Although the shooter is being reported to be a woman, he was booked into jail as the male he is.
Mr. Smith had allegedly stalked Mr. Miller for 6 months, disappeared, and resurfaced to make this attempt on his life. His motive is unclear. #notourcrimes
C3 dehumanizingcrime casedenialmedia pronoun complaintviolence terror
Male humans are either boys or men. Gender dysphoria is a mental illness. Trans identification is an allegation of personal belief which may have various causes, none of which should put a male on a female team.
Tweets pertaining to his gender identity. I include this as context. He is targeting Maia because she is a public figure for speaking about previously identifying as female to male transgender and now identifying as a woman again.
No, not for being trans. He's in trouble for being a man in a women's room. A trans identified woman in the women's room would not have been charged with a crime. That's why Marcy didn't use the men's room. He knew it wasn't about being trans.
Trans person claims that being trans is, well, often transitory.
Why are we poisoning kids? Why are we removing their body parts? Why aren't we just telling them they might not feel like a man later?
Quotes a post by T17397; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The logical fallacy being employed by this trans activist is called "Equivocation." The two senses of the word "sex" are being equivocated as though they were extensions of the same definition. Sex can refer to 1. Reproductive category of an individual 2. A group of behaviors involving sex traits, typically involving one or two individuals.
Quotes a post by T23130; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Tiktok won't show my video about detransitioning, to minors on @[private account] because it apparently contains an depiction of an adult using alcohol, tobacco or other drugs.
Yet they let trans activists post videos for minors of themselves injecting testosterone. Make it make sense.
I have a feeling there are a lot of teenage girls young women hobbling around experiencing this, being told bullshit about why when they tell their doctor, who weren't trans but were put on progestin only birth control without parental consent at 13, which has been used since the 70s to suppress puberty in PCC
@[private account] You've named one of the hormones I was given. Why are you lying?
Trans rites: the social, legal, medical, and surgical rituals people undertake to transition.
I was only nonbinitarian coming out of it. It wasn't as much of a thing when I first transitioned.
Yes. What's more, their baseless recommendation to engage in weight bearing exercise while hormonal suppressed is a great way to get a slipped capital epiphysis and end up crippled due to a cam deformity in your hip.
Impact of gender-affirming treatment on bone health in transgender and gender diverse youth - PMC https://share.google/Oxpn4LOxUwEeFKLaV
Public detransitioners are making space in the trans community for a discussion of the validity of detransitioners. They may not like us, but the narrative is shifting. Now there's increasing concordance that staying trans isn't a guaranteed state, even if you feel sincerely trans now.
They'll never take accountability for lying about whether people can be wrong about being trans, may regret transitioning, or may outgrow being trans. "Would you rather have a dead son or a trans daughter?"
Quotes a post by T04944; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Not sure about this story but it's apparently confirmed true about another porn actor known as "Australian Bonnie Blue."
'Australian Bonnie Blue' OnlyFans star who boasted she had sex with 250 high school leavers for her subscription channel is revealed to be transgender https://share.google/mBMl2qLfDW1Oe7zVm
They can't give birth without a lot of help every step of the way, including donor eggs from a woman. When they can use this technology to impregnate a trans woman, will you day he's a woman too?
"You know, I infiltrated the alt right in 2017."
I want to believe Hendrixa's detransition is sincere, and I hope it is. But it would not be the first high-profile trans activist turned double agent detransitioner turned double crossing retransitioner. Jamie Shupe did that. Isaac Uncooked did that. I'm not saying don't offer support or give the benefit of the doubt, but use caution/good judgment sharing information or providing access to group chats or other semi private online spaces based only on self ID as a recent detransitioner.
Quoting @legaltweetz: I’m staunchly anti fascist. And how do you think I was so successful in the gay rights movement and politics? Talking to people that you vehemently disagree with is a part of that. If you can’t stomach it then don’t do it. But I can.
You know, I infiltrated the alt right in 2017. Good times. Had to have one hell of a stomach for that too
I'm going on the assumption it is a sincere statement of going from trans to no longer trans identifying, not merely discontinuing hormones.
The classic 5 stages of grief are: denial, anger, bargaining, sadness, acceptance. Please give yourself space to be in denial and bargaining, and to not yet know the edges of your harm, your anger and your regret. If you're going through a loss of faith and community and a major hormonal shift, the downstream effects of these changes will reverberate.
When I was first making content, I had no anger at my doctors, sense of the harm to my personal body, or regret for having transitioned, and I freely said that and attributed it to my own cunning and verve at 22. But, I didn't know about the health issues it had caused, or how it had induced what I thought were unrelated emotional and cognitive symptoms. It took a couple years off the hormones for me to feel I truly knew what had been taken from me. I am still finding out.
In retrospect, I was actually trying to deny my loss by bargaining that it's OK that happened, because I have no regrets. But any complex decision creates regret. I may have regretted not transitioning. At the time I thought it helped me a lot. In some ways, it did, and in others, I saw with a younger person's eye. Now that I'm older, I can see farther.
You can still cherish the life you created for yourself that came after you made a decision you regret. Regret is not a betrayal of your past self but a conclusion of a lesson. I do regret what I've traded away and cannot recover. I do regret the way no one protected me. I do regret how closed off and self-involved I was at the start of this. I do regret that I didn't get more help for my other trauma and physical pain before being allowed to disrupt my maturation. I do regret that I will never know who I might have grown into if I had not feared becoming her and living a grown woman's life. I love who I am but I regret this absence. That's life.
I attributed a lot of signs and symptoms to life context. I now believe these were caused or exacerbated by the complex impact of disruptive sex hormones on the functioning of multiple areas of the brain and body. If you've been on hormones for years and are going off them, there will be reckoning where you have to reconsider the effect of the drugs on relationship disintegration, professional difficulties, substance misuse, and other mental or physical health issues you THOUGHT were unrelated to the hormones. There will have been knock-on effects that take time to manifest downstream. Realizing these can hit you unexpectedly, like a horse kick to the chest. There's a lot to unpack. Regret and anger can take time. So can sadness, as well as healing. Good luck to you.
The person in the cap and gown, Jazz Jennings, was transitioned as a minor and is standing behind his brother, who is not trans. On the right is a random person demonstrating genuine versus social smiling
So karma is punishing her transphobia by giving her a trans child, who has to then deal with a transphobic mother. Did the child do something to offend karma in the previous life?
They're distorting your words intentionally. You clearly meant that you believe trans identification is a non-physical belief whereas there's evidently some physical evolved physiological response pattern underlying sexuality.
why would a trans person with normal sex hormones need cross sex hormones to protect their bone density? Is that an example of iatrogenic harm caused by disrupting health? Are you not actually saying their hormones are psychologically healthy by improving their mental body image? Can you confirm there's no physical health need for these hormones absent correcting harms induced by gender affirming care?
Thank you @[private account], and so your position is that a transgender person has some physiological need for hormones that are not the ones their body has historically produced during their development starting when they were an embryo?
"I'm a trans man in Russia. Of course I'm never worried that my desire to become a man is actually my internalized patriarchy and the belief in the superiority of it." 🧐
Autistic trans man argues that a person has to cognitively model the misogyny they're experiencing before they've experienced misogyny. So autistic women don't experience misogyny.
Trans doctor gets very blunt about the reality that testosterone therapy in minors is female genital mutilation, and the most they can do is try to slow the damage down.
Do you think any medical providers asked his mother whether she preferred a dead son or a trans daughter? Do you think she feared losing custody if she did not affirm?
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codeddenialmedical harmstate takes children
Zaya the trans woman who had a botched vaginoplasty from Dr. Kathy Rumer has now sued the federal government and gotten a passport issued with false identity information again. This is recent.
Obviously, Zaya is very open and public about being MTF trans.
Trans identified man can't get general anesthesia anymore due to voice feminization surgery preventing intubation, but the anesthesiologist does not want to do a local for his upcoming insurance-funded BBL.
Erin meanwhile uses the term detransition here to refer to the process of going off gender affirming hormone therapy, regardless of continuing to identify as trans.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] More than plausible. Extremely well documented. But keep defending the sexual agency of mentally ill minors being groomed and coached by parents publicly describing daily forced sexual insertions against their "bad" trans kid. No red flags there.
That's one thing that made me really question if trans was the cutting edge of reason and scientific progress after all, or if this group had a specific set of beliefs and practices.
It's very possible he will be or already has been prescribed a drug like lupron, used to suppress puberty in trans kids and other purposes, for his hormone sensitive prostate cancer.
Why does breast removal make women look like men? Can you explain? Because we're all paying for it on the theory trans men have to look "like men" but now you're telling me they don't? I'm so confused
I didn't want to be me either. And you don't want to be you. That's... that's why trans people are trans. That's why everyone's supposed to care, is that big desire we have to not be who we are.
He blocked me lol. Evolution acts on species across reproductive generations. No reproduction, no Darwinian evolution. We know without measuring anything that babies come from a mother and a father. Then we observed that mothers are shaped differently from fathers. Nothing to do with predicting behavioral tendencies which was the aim of phrenology, which began with no categories and tried to derive categories through measurements. Which is actually how all research on the so called trans brain works, because there's no way to know who is trans.
If you can call the Pope by his new Pope name, you can use your child's vanity pronouns.
I agree that these are both religious practices and look forward to deadnaming Pope Robert, to be fair to the trans community.
Trans man realizes shortly after top surgery that she'd also lost a significant amount of sensation. Apparently neither the trans community nor the surgeon warned her.
Even though she's calling her ex husband she, this trans widow refuses to call him her ex wife. Good for her.
Quoting @TTExulansic: Trans widow blames herself for having expectations of the man who promised to keep showing up for her, and bargains that having her expectations violated by the person she trusted most in the world somehow made her a better person and improved her other relationships.
The reality is that she now expects to have her reasonable expectations devalued, so she's devalued herself in all her relationships, because she fears being similarly betrayed by the other people in her life. She blames herself for this traumatic experience that was actually outside of her control. She's desperate to gain a sense of control.
Trans activists have repeatedly told me I look exactly like a man, so I'm not sure what it proves that he looks more like me than the other man.
Reality groups him with men because he's a man. I want the law to protect sex based rights and provide equal protection. It's not equal protection to group according to sex for most people and according to girlishness for some men.
Trans widow blames herself for having expectations of the man who promised to keep showing up for her, and bargains that having her expectations violated by the person she trusted most in the world somehow made her a better person and improved her other relationships.
The reality is that she now expects to have her reasonable expectations devalued, so she's devalued herself in all her relationships, because she fears being similarly betrayed by the other people in her life. She blames herself for this traumatic experience that was actually outside of her control. She's desperate to gain a sense of control.
The fact that men like trans model Alex Consani are recruited to be fashion models for women's clothing really screws up the body image of actual female people. We don't have the same skeletons. I'll never look like a 6 foot tall anorexic man in this outfit. Presenting these images to girls and women as though this man is an ideal woman is so hateful.
Like the liver. The brain. Organs that have SRY in their DNA... lol.
Swyer cannot give birth without a lot of surgery and hormones, as well as the participation of an actual female, and then only rarely is the experiment on the non consenting fetus a success. Scientific mimicry of femaleness in a male does not make a human male female, my dear trans activist.
How are you going to differentiate the trans from the non trans men?
How will accessing female only spaces protect trans identifying men from other trans identifying men?
Why should women be human shields for any group of men?
They'll reduce estrogen and provide a taste of androgenic effect using a range of synthetic progestins to trans identifying young women who don't want or can't take testosterone but still want to alter their hormonal profile to change their biological functioning to be less female or more male to alleviate dysphoria. It's covered in WPATH standards of care 8.
They/theminist reiterates what I've been arguing for years: trans ideology originated in the medical management of disorders of sexual development ("intersex"), which exist naturally. They took that model of gender identity, repackaged it as trans, and sold it to healthy kids and mentally unwell and sexually preoccupied adults.
She hates binding due to being in constant pain, and mistakenly believes top surgery will be the cure for her binding pain. Many other trans men as well as peer reviewed literature attests that binding induces structural changes that continue to hurt after discontinuation.
TJ the Trans Man sounds the alarm about Dr. Kathy Rumer, who botched Zaya the Trans Woman's vaginoplasty so bad he ended up needing a revision. In response, she ghosted him, according to Zaya. My reaction episode is called Vaginoplasty Volumes: Rumer Has It
Woman gets top surgery as a reaction to societal beauty standards:
"The day you stop chasing borrowed dreams of beauty and craft a body that that cradles your joy, you will honor the shape where you're spirit feels most at home."
The trans rites are clearly a religious practice which should not be publicly funded.
Trans women are men. Women are adult human females. Makes you so mad you cry white supremacy to self soothe. But why does this soothe you? That's my question.
MTF hormone therapy shrinks A which loosens B and creates that characteristic breathiness a lot of trans ID men have. It sounds more voluntary than FTM voice (which I've labeled kazooicism) but I don't think it is. Surgically one approach is that they will actually tie A to A part way up the folds which can also sometimes create diplophonia (Peppermint's Aztec death whistle voice from I Am Jazz).
You brought up race, dear, because you stereotype "terfs" as white and Hispanophones as non-white, regardless of skin color, genetics or ancestry. Now you're denying reality because the facts are inconvenient. Like the fact that trans women are men. People are waking up.
I love this bizarre talking point that we need trans women in women's sports to somehow revitalize it since duh, no one like, actually cares about the lowly female women's sports.
Quoting @iAnonPatriot: HOLY SHLIT
Liberals are ACTUALLY pushing for AOC to be their 2028 Presidential Candidate.. 👀
I had a glorious time editing this. I'm completely smitten with Theo. I will make the rewrite of Dear Theodosia from Hamilton public. You'll see how she and I are the Romeo and Juliet of the trans-detrans content creation worlds. Both deny the existence of the other - but who can deny our love!!!
The trans rite of having me not pretend I can't tell good from bad and right from wrong when looking at a cosmetic surgery. UNACCEPTABLE. Theo is certain I'm gonna miss being in the garden of Eden, before the fall of the time when I didn't know then what I now know.
Trans people exist in the same way any other religious group exists. It's a group of people defined by shared beliefs. It's wrong to force people to participate in your religion using tax dollars.
My commentary is that it's a religious belief system with associated practices I argue are harmful. Only people who say they believe they're trans can be demonstrated to exist.
Kaiser told me for years that my pain was caused by sitting improperly, when the reality is they never even looked at what was causing the pain and knew I was on a medication that caused severe bone loss and with it, degenerative changes to load-bearing structures. Now that I know the true cause of my pain, I'm furious all over again. This is a systematic mental and physical abuse of women and girls. Not just trans identifying ones, but anyone being put on hormones, including for contraception. They can't possibly be in the dark about this.
They seem to think people respect my views on these topics because I'm coincidentally a recognized expert in communication sciences/disorders. If people were just deferring to me because of that, surely I'm outnumbered by pro-trans experts in more relevant fields. The fact is none of my detractors can impeach my medical arguments and claims, having investigated them and discovered I'm correct. And that's the reason for my popularity. People watch my videos, I connect dots, and light bulbs go off, even in people who already know the subject well, and that's just down to the integration of a broad liberal arts education with lived experience and my own innate cleverness, which drives them mad. My detractors have no hope of exposing incompetence. So they go after my integrity. And since there's so little to attack there, you'll see a lot of the same example.
Trans activists want to oppress women. We can't say what a woman is if we're not biologists. We can't say how gender affirming medication affected us if we're not gynecologists. The end of this road is Afghanistan banning women from talking to each other.
Quotes a post by T27700; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
SOC 6, published 9 years prior to my GAMS treatment. Fully reversible my spine. Anyone denying that this is part of gender affirming care has a trans flag up in their room. Guaranteed.
Trans activists have suggested I'm somehow misrepresenting the fact that synthetic progestins are used in gender affirming care for transmasculine FtMs. In my case, my doctor used multiple progestins simultaneously. I was left with early onset osteopenia, spinal degeneration, and chronic pain as a direct result of this treatment. Here is an except from the WPATH Standards of Care 8 discussing ftm gender affirming hormonal menstrual suppression.
You're telling me that I'm somehow causing their mental illness complications while agreeing the complication is not a logical response to the existence of people who disagree with you. Stop trying to convince me I'm a witch who can control the actions of people I've never met with incantations like "trans women are men." We aren't buying it anymore.
I actually saw a trans id female and a gay man jointly turn away an ambulance despite his active drug overdose, because they inferred from the physique that the city had only sent "cishets." He later admitted to me that he had chewed his Adderall to make himself learn faster. He did eventually accept help.
Do I have any evidence trans people are more likely to act on their suggestion to themselves that suicide is the way forward? Don't you tell us this all the time
@[private account] That's how your post and the broader propaganda is being read by 14 year olds. Suicide is contagious. Stop marketing it to trans kids.
Trans community doesn't get to lecture anyone else on how to not exploit a suicide for a political cause because people can be depressed for lots of reasons.
"Would you rather have a dead daughter or a trans son?" "Death before detransition" << you idiots told her suicide made sense for a girl who wanted to be a boy and for a girl who was not sure she wanted to stay a boy. This is your work.
The real life of a trans kid named Jazz Jennings, that he allegedly wanted from when he was 2 years old.
https://x.com/TTExulansic/status/1661509765682565121?t=OAG7HtuQN6MYiungETUM8g&s=19
Quoting @TTExulansic: A much clearer version of the Jeanette dilation clip than the one that's been going around. Thanks to Nelson for this!
Your brain saw my pfp and thought "too gorgeous, must be a filter." XD Wasn't your proof I wrote those emails that the writing was too exceptional to be from a trans woman? I think you have a crush on me.