The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Hang on, what’s the argument here?
That trans women would have an advantage over other women in *chess* and so must be excluded?
Why is Chess gender segregated anyway?
What are they trying to say?
Graham Linehan has every right to perform a show.
Even if he is bizarrely obsessive about denigrating trans people.
Stop people you disagree with from speaking and you cease to live in a democracy.
He's right though - the SNP messed up just as Theresa May's GRA consultation acted as a lightening rod that stirred up the most organised anti-trans movement of any developed country.
This stuff can't be just about intentions - it's about how they are communicated and delivered.
For me trans women breastfeeding is simply a scientific rather than a moral question.
If they are able to produce milk (as I understand many on hormones can) why shouldn’t they? Especially if they are mothering a child?
Is your opinion dependent on or irrespective of science?
Indeed, you appear to be arguing against Stonewall's position - which is also that this should be a case by case thing and that different sports are different.
https://www.stonewall.org.uk/about-us/news/everyone-should-feel-welcome-sport-%E2%80%93-and-includes-trans-people
I agree trans women are women. I don't think there are many people who say there should be no assessment on professional sport participation - especially in the case of those who have not yet undergone medical transition. That's a very mainstream pro trans rights opinion.
what do you find objectionable to this tweet?
Do you disagree with my view that some trans women should be able to compete in women's sports if they have undergone a physical transition?
I'm going to stop engaging with you now as this does not seem particularly productive. Would also encourage you to look up my well documented views on trans rights before you lob another ad hominem.
How many people will really vote in the local elections based on transgender issues?
I've written more about the electoral risks of this move by Rishi.
"No, Culture Waring Won't Save the Tories"👇
https://tomharwood.substack.com/p/no-culture-waring-wont-save-the-tories
Rishi Sunak wading into trans debates should concern Tory MPs in marginal seats.
He risks learning all the wrong lessons from the fall of Nicola Sturgeon. In a funny way the Prime Minister's crusade is not the opposite, but rather an emulation of her. 👇
https://tomharwood.substack.com/p/no-culture-waring-wont-save-the-tories
It is worth asking the question, therefore, how far does this go?
Has he changed his previous view that it's up to individual sporting bodies to set their own rules?
Does he think a petite trans woman convicted of a white collar crime like tax fraud be sent to a men's prison?
What's more, I'm told that Starmer was meant to tweet the commitment, and yet a person in his office vetoed it last minute.
Starmer sent no tweet about Labour's trans policies on Transgender Day of Visibility last month.
A secret row is blazing within the upper echelons of the Labour Party over GRA reform.
Notice how Labour Party Chair @[private account] subtly cut out the commitment to 'modernise the outdated GRA' that the party tweeted on Transgender Day of Visibility?
Why is that? It's all to do with recent events regarding trans rights.
In 2020, Sir Keir said the Gender Recognition Act was "in desperate need of reform to introduce self-declaration for transgender people", and as recently as October said that “we will also modernise the GRA”.
The campaign group adds that “any attempt to erase the systematic murder of LGBT (including trans) people by Nazi Germany is historical revisionism of the worst kind. MPs have been suspended for less, and it is a political decision if leadership choose not to suspend the whip”
NEW: LGBT Labour has taken the rare step of encouraging its members and affiliates to report Rosie Duffield to the party “for liking a tweet from Graham Linehan which attacks Eddie Izzard and again demonises the trans community.”
What have I said that is in your view so very controversial? That we should invest in energy? Build more houses? Respect trans people? Reduce the tax burden?
If a male prisoner poses a genuine risk to other male prisoners, they are treated differently. Often solitary.
If a trans woman poses a genuine risk to female prisoners, they can be treated differently too.
There's no inconsistency there.
BREAK: Govt"will publish a draft Bill which will set out a proposed approach to ban conversion practices, this will apply to England and Wales. The Bill will protect everyone, including those targeted on the basis of their sexuality, or being transgender."
https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-statements/detail/2023-01-17/hcws500
Re: this, I explored how waging a culture war on trans issues went for conservative parties last year in two other English speaking countries: 🇦🇺 and 🇺🇸.
I've written it up, along with an exploration of attitudes, and an explanation of GRA reform here:
https://tomharwood.substack.com/p/the-most-misunderstood-debate-in
Hi Jan, as I say in the piece I think Sturgeon got the age issue wrong. But as I also write, GRA reform is a separate issue to the matter of puberty blocking drugs or surgery. As things stand trans people can receive such treatment w/ or without a Gender Recognition Certificate.
You realise that currently in order to get a GRC trans people have to prove they have been living in their new gender for two years?
That means using facilities like changing rooms for two years, without a GRC.
I’m told polling guru Frank Luntz has repeatedly told the Conservative Party to avoid waging a culture war over trans rights.
While it delights and excites some corners of Twitter, in the real world it makes the party look at best distracted and at worst cruel.
Currently trans people are required by law to live in their acquired gender for two years before they can receive a gender recognition certificate.
That should be evidence alone that having a gender recognition certificate is not about access to spaces.
Depends what you mean by self-ID. If it's about the process by which a transgender person may permanently gain a new birth certificate, then it's more evenly balanced than you imply.
@[private account] Arguabley the Middle Ages were pretty enlightened when it came to sex and gender expression.
Eleanor Rykener was likely a trans woman in the 14th century. She was certainly not burned alive.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John/Eleanor_Rykener