The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
This is unlikely to be true for most trans & detrans people in their 20’s and late teens. This might be true for those today in their younger teens, but I suspect it is still negligible
I don’t think autistic kids are getting lost in gender ideology.
I think autistic kids are getting lost in the wider modern society, and clinically.
Intelligent autistic girls in particular are not getting proper developmental interventions early enough and trans identity adoption around adolescence is merely a symptom of the problems this diagnostic overlooking creates.
Why do I think this?
Because kids who have developmental delays but average to above average intelligence are expected to perform at the level of kids their age. This is true especially if parents don’t want their kids diagnosed or if clinicians never bring it up as a possibility.
These kids, kids like the one I was, are expected to grow out of their “quirks” which are largely the direct result of very atypical development*.
Those “quirks” do not tend to always go away with age. They may change or they may become more obvious deficits- but rarely do most of them vanish without a lot of work or intervention.
Those who fail to keep up developmentally but are otherwise intelligent will develop a very early sense of “something is wrong with me” which due to said developmental delays and being definitionally immature, they are unlikely to have a true peer group in which to individuate.
When adolescence hits and one’s same-aged peers are rapidly developing socially, physically, emotionally and cognitively- in a roughly matched peer group- an autistic kid is unlikely to have a true peer group that is developing roughly on their own timeline. They lack the social and life skills to do adolescent identity development in a typical, embodied and social way. Thus, I propose, they are prone to try to meet those developmental needs in an intellectual, fantastical and disembodied way.
But this too goes off the rails due to any number of developmental delays and sensory processing issues. Then of course, there are any number of reasons why an autistic adolescent could experience much more severe and longstanding pubertal distress that doesn’t magically resolve with time, if sensory processing issues get worse due to pubertal hormones. I suspect this is more relevant to girls than boys due to female hormonal cycles.
(*and our society gives even typical kids far fewer developmental opportunities than it used to- so imagine the lack of any chance that a developmentally delayed but smart kid has to stay on some kind of track)
Quotes a post by A2625; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I don’t think autistic kids are getting lost in gender ideology. I think they’re getting lost in the wider modern society, they are not getting proper developmental interventions and trans identity adoption around adolescence is merely a symptom of this.
Why do I think this?
Because kids who have developmental delays but average to above average intelligence are expected to perform at the level of kids their age. They are expected to grow out of their “quirks” which are largely the direct result of very atypical development*. Those “quirks” do not tend to always go away with age. They may change or they may become more obvious deficits- but rarely do most of them vanish.
Those who fail to keep up developmentally but are otherwise intelligent will develop a very early sense of “something is wrong with me” which due to said developmental delays and being definitionally immature, they are unlikely to have a true peer group. When adolescence hits and one’s same-aged peers are rapidly developing socially, physically, emotionally and cognitively- in a roughly matched peer group- an autistic kid is unlikely to have a true peer group that is developing roughly on their own timeline. They lack the social and life skills to do adolescent identity development in a typical, embodied and social way. Thus, I propose, they are prone to try to meet those developmental needs in an intellectual, fantastical and disembodied way.
But this too goes off the rails due to any number of developmental delays and sensory processing issues. Then of course, there are any number of reasons why an autistic adolescent could experience much more severe and longstanding pubertal distress that doesn’t magically resolve with time, if sensory processing issues get worse due to pubertal hormones. I suspect this is more relevant to girls than boys due to female hormonal cycles.
(*and our society gives even typical kids far fewer developmental opportunities than it used to- so imagine the lack of any chance that a developmentally delayed but smart kid has to stay on some kind of track)
To those concerned about the 🏳️⚧️ trans-ing of autistic girls:
Yelling “THEY’RE TARGETING AUTISTIC KIDS” as a good little cultural warrior, does not actually help gender questioning autistic girls or their parents to achieve needed clarity.
The only way to help autistic girls who think they’re trans boys (as a prerequisite) is to actually understand how autistic presentations can manifest in intelligent girls, and to develop better interventions targeted at navigating their specific developmental problems.
The only way to potentially prevent such types of girls from developing such severe pubertal distress that they totally disassociate from puberty onwards, assuming their sensory processing issues haven’t caused this to happen sooner, is to identify them accurately and as early as possible.
Parents deserve to know what they’re dealing with EARLY, so they can prepare for what to expect, *before* their daughter hits puberty and shit predictably hits the fan; whether in the form of a trans identity or in the form of a body dysmorphic disorder or an eating disorder.
Treating this as solely or mostly an indoctrination issue while ignoring the obvious fact that trans identities occurring around adolescence in this population, are clear evidence of an ongoing and pre-existing developmental issue- will do nothing to meaningfully help autistic girls with their very predictable sets of developmental problems.
Signed,
A Gen Z woman who was one of those girls.
I have immense respect for every democrat, BIPOC, lesbian, gay and/or trans person who hasn’t succumbed to queer brainwashing and thus understands that Jihad poses an existential threat to the West. Where are ya’ll at?
I went from being trans and living in a man costume year round for most of my teens & 20’s to this Halloween, dressing up as my true, authentic self; if only she’d been alive in the 1980’s.
Gen X- how did I do?
My whole trans life, I hid my true self away in a full-time man costume. Every day was Halloween, but without the sweetness.
Today is my first October 31st since 6th grade where I’m not dressing up as a man. FREEDOM. At last.
How was yours?
I’m kinda joking. I’m saying that trans = autism in a large portion of cases. To specify, gender dysphoria is one idiom of autistic distress and trans is one possible attempt to mitigate various forms of autistic distress
That’s not what I’m saying. I’m saying that autism is the only genetic component to any trans identity. Everything else is a social or life history factor.
My point is that the only genetic underpinning of trans is…. garden variety autism. Theres nothing genetically distinct about any other subsection of the trans population aside from high rates of autism. The rest of it is unrelated to any provable genetic underpinning.
And furthermore, the TRAs should relax about this detrans clinic. Most people don’t get sick enough from transition by the age of 21 that it fundamentally shakes their worldview enough to snap out of their trans identity. And among those who do, they will age out by virtue of needing time to unpack all that has happened before they are likely to take another leap of faith on a new medical team who would need to experiment on them yet again. So in reality, very few people relative to the immense need will even be treated here. They should be happy about this
Wanting to be a part of something bigger than oneself is an aspect of trans communities and their appeal, but that does not lend credence to any genetic predisposition. I’m suggesting what might be a genetic predisposition. We are talking about different aspects of the same phenomenon.
I think that the only plausible genetic link to transness is the genetic link to autism. That is not to say that all trans people are autistic. It is to say that autism is the genetic condition which more frequently than others, causes people to end up trans at some point; not that one who is autistic is destined to be trans
Why?
Because trans is a lifestyle choice that many autistic people make in order to mask their social/relational deficits with a rigid systems-thinking framework that comes with prefabricated social scripts.
Trans is a framework that attracts young autists like catnip does cats, because it is an explicit formula for coming of age and going about life.
It doesn’t mean it’s good for them. It does mean that trans serves at the very least, a very compelling short term utility.
It is impossible to even go to a normal doctor who knows what to do with people with medical histories like ours. My PCP was like “I mean, it’s good that your breasts haven’t necrotized like many of my other patients who bind but whether any function or sensation can be restored…. You’ll have to go to an expert who does that” and I’m like…. “I’m not binding anymore because I’m not trans anymore. There is no expertise that I know of, which knows where to begin with me. Any ideas?” And she’s just like “no.”
It’s wild shit
I wonder why this is so hard for trans people, of all people, to understand. Perhaps it is because a significant subsection of them have deluded themselves into thinking that they’ve somehow changed sex rather than that they are now modified males and modified females with complex and unique medical needs.
When trans people tell their stories of how “gender affirmation saved my life” no one demands that they add the caveat “but it might ruin yours.”
Why should detransitioners have to add these endless disclaimers?
Trans people who are happy with the choice they have made are not threatened by the existence of detransitioners who have critical things to say about the concept of gender identity or negative experiences of transition. I know such trans people. And when I was trans, I was one such trans person.
It is not our job to placate a subset of transitioners who are so incredibly insecure in their life choices, that they need the affirmation of literally everyone else in the world, in order to continue living life as they currently are.
Quotes a post by T14956; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When trans people tell their stories of how “gender affirmation saved my life” no one demands that they add the caveat “but it might ruin yours.”
Why should detransitioners have to add endless disclaimers to placate a subset of transitioners who are so incredibly insecure in their life choices, that need the affirmation of literally everyone else in the world, in order to continue living as they are?
I wouldn’t be at all surprised if many gender dysphoric/ trans people shared certain genetic commonalities. Namely, genetic variations associated with autism.
Quotes a post by T09651; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Additionally:
The list of specialties offered is woefully incomplete, and I hope that will change.
The TCH detransition clinic also does not list neurology among its specialties, even though breast binding, cross-sex hormones, puberty blockers, and various cosmetic gender surgeries are known to cause chronic nerve pain, numbness, and other neurological complications.
Zero detransitioners and none of those harmed by gender medicine, can receive comprehensive care if their care team fails to investigate or to treat the most common types of physical injuries caused by various gender transition interventions; let alone by the most common ones.
If “detrans medicine” repeats the exact same errors as “trans medicine” has made; we are screwed.
BTW- does anyone know if the speech pathologists are enlisted only for cosmetic voice training reasons, or has any thought been given to the fact that a highly autistic population with sensory issues may need extra help in accurately communicating their pain with providers?
🚨 TCH’s decision to cap most services at its new Detransition Clinic at age 21 is a massive oversight.
Here’s my take as a detransitioner w/ a basic understanding of adolescent development:
I’ll start with my story, briefly, as a case study. Then, I’ll continue with my policy analysis:
I identified as transgender from the ages of 12–24.
Starting at 12, I bound my developing breasts after being instructed by trans activist adults online, some of them being doctors in labcoats, that it was safe and reversible. My lungs, spine, and rib cage were bound along with them.
At 19, my doctor said it was fine for me to keep binding even while I was sick with the flu, and suggested I contact a gender clinic when I recovered, in case I’d want any of their “help.” Thankfully, I did not.
(God forbid I’d miss a day of gender affirmation.)
I spent my early 20’s continuing to bind, so I could pass as a man, this time, living in the Middle East.
At 24, I had lived through 2 wars in the Middle East and realized that my whole life was a lie. I stopped binding my breasts, and began to live my life as a woman, for the first time.
At 25, I realized that what I thought was my “male brain” in my female body, was actually just MY autistic brain in MY body.
At 26, I realized that none of my transition-related injuries were resolving or reversing themselves.
Now I’m 27 and live with lasting disfigurement, nerve pain, numbness, and decreased lung capacity from injuries that I began when I was a child.
I am too old for most of the services at a clinic established to help people like me.
But this is NOT about me.
The biggest problem with this age cutoff is that the age at which someone is harmed is rarely the age at which they recognize that harm.
Between 12 and 25, the brain is rapidly developing. During this time, young people are actively developing their identities.
Youth who adopt transgender identities in adolescence may persist for 5-10 + years before realizing they were misled, and even longer before they realize they were *harmed*.
By the time they overcome the psychological difficulty of admitting they were wrong, the practical barriers of dealing with the medical system, and the reality of dealing with injuries that their doctors don’t understand, they are usually already older than 21.
Because of how narrowly the clinic has defined its scope, it risks a substantially smaller pool of eligible patients, which limits the potential data gathered on long-term transition-related injuries.
So, in a few years, despite all the money and effort thrown at this endeavor, the familiar refrains of “detransition is rare” and “we just don’t have enough data” will continue to echo. Ad nauseum. Ad infinitum.
Older detransitioners (those above 21) are not only patients who need care; we are a great source of long-term outcome data. We’ve lived a bit longer, understand our bodies a bit better, and can more perhaps more competently communicate our concerns with providers.
We are potentially a huge asset to our care providers and to researchers. Those of us who are willing to be experimented upon again by medicine, in order to heal from our first stint as guinea pigs, should not be turned away.
Most of us are above 21 anyways. Most of us were harmed before we were developmentally able to appreciate the consequences, and often as minors.
If the current age limit is temporary and the clinic intends to expand eligibility for all services for patients over 21, that would be meaningful. I would certainly celebrate it.
Otherwise, a clinic created because children and adolescents were harmed, and in the wake of a lawsuit, should not exclude most of the adults who were once those children and adolescents.
We should not be denied help for our injuries simply because we are adults now.
Quotes a post by A2967; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You will not win hearts and minds by mocking a young woman for having short hair or a visual disability.
Trans people who disagree with me vehemently about trans issues, are reaching out to me en masse to say they are disgusted by sociopathic leftist freaks like you.
Quotes a post by T25216; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Tbh I think both @BuckAngel & @[private account] should go on each other’s podcasts. Buck, Dr. Laura’s podcast is called “agree to disagree about gender” (@[private account]) and it is co-hosted by Dr. Laura who is a trans advocate & by Yvette Nary (@[private account]) who is a gender critical woman. They disagree with each other on a lot, and sometimes find common ground. But more interestingly, they host a variety of guests who comprise every flavor of both niche and mainstream pro-trans & gender critical opinions, which they explore thoroughly and in depth. I for one, think you would make a very interesting guest on their podcast. And they too, especially as a duo, would make a very interesting addition to yours.
🚨”trans people have existed since the dawn of time”
Everything about this argument is wrong.
First of all, millennium plural is, millennia* and not millenniums*
(This really irks me)
Secondly; no, we have no evidence that cross-sex identities as we conceive of them today, were cross-culturally apparent for millennia.
Cross-sexed behaviors in some males and females, have been noted and backed up by evidence, as a cross-time and cross-cultural phenomenon.
We know that there have always been a micro minority of males and females who for various reasons either cross dressed or engaged in enough sex-atypical behaviors for their time/place/culture that they stood out.
We know that there are several human cultures which castrated certain males, for religious reasons, for class reasons and for retaining a high singing voice post the age of 12 reasons. There were some males who have castrated themselves. There were other males who drank horse urine because they realized it would feminize their appearance. We don’t know whether any of these males thought of themselves as women. We do know that either they, or their society, decided that for whatever reason, these males should be castrated.
We know there are times in history in which some women presented themselves as men in order to attain the rights of men that women did not have. Sometimes this was related to employment or even military deployment. Others presented themselves as men because they wished to partner with other women, and could not do that in a socially acceptable way while presenting themselves as the women they were. Whether any of these women did this because they had a cross-sex identity, or thought of themselves as men, cannot be determined in most or all of these cases.
One could argue that “trans” as a series of actions, in its most primitive forms, has existed for a while. But then we’d need to decouple trans actions from cross-sexed identities, since we cannot deduce whether this co-occurred with the cross-sexed behaviors.
Perhaps some of those ancient people did have an identity confusion or a wish to be the other sex. Perhaps others did not, and just didn’t conform to social expectations placed upon them as sexed beings of either sex.
But we cannot assume that our modern notions of identity (which is by definition, highly socially mediated and constructed) could be applied to the motivations of those ancient people.
“Trans/-gender/-sexual” is a modern descriptive label that is at most, 100 years old. “Trans” as an identity label that someone adopts a priori and then acts upon, is a phenomenon which hasn’t been around for more than a few decades at most.
We should not assign our present-day identity labels to the behaviors of people who have been dead for more than 100 years, who lived in a different time, and who cannot tell us whether we are accurately representing their experiences with our modern words.
Quotes a post by T15317; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Gender is the social scaffolding of sex. It is not divorced from sex. A male juvenile is a boy, an adult male is a man and a female juvenile is a girl, and adult female is a woman.
People of either sex who attempt to mimic the appearance of the sex they are not, through various available means, are classified as “trans.”
A male adult who mimics a female appearance does not become woman gender, but trans-gender.
This trans-gender experience of being born and raised as a boy, growing into male adolescence and/or adulthood, and then at any stage of this process, modifying one’s body and/or life to appear more like a female, is a uniquely male experience. But because it’s not a universal male experience, it can be parsed into its own category as a trans-gender experience.
A female adult who mimics a male appearance does not become man gender, but trans-gender.
This trans-gender experience of being born and raised as a girl, growing into female adolescence and/or adulthood, and then at any stage of this process, modifying one’s body and/or life to appear more like a male, is a uniquely female experience. But because it’s not a universal female experience, it can be parsed into its own category as a trans-gender experience.
Quotes a post by T15317; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Gender is the social scaffolding of sex. It is not divorced from sex. A male adult is a man and a female adult is a woman. Adults of either sex who attempt to mimic the appearance of the sex they are not, are classified as “trans.” A male adult who mimics a female appearance does not become woman gender, but trans-gender. A female adult who mimics a male appearance does not become man gender, but trans-gender.
If your definition of “transphobia” is “an opposition to performing sex change procedures on kids” then not only are all sane adults transphobic, but many of the transphobes are themselves, trans adults.
This is an insane and unsustainable ethos for a social movement.
Quotes a post by T16564; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I never said Hunter wasn’t subjectively beautiful. I said that Hunter is objectively not a woman. Hunter is a male who attempts to mimic a female appearance (AKA trans.) Try to keep up.
Quotes a post by T04599; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The idea that I found your post by keyword searching the word “trans,” is false.
Your post came up on my feed because I started getting the eating disorder algorithm pushed on my X after I started posting about my (totally healthy) weight loss.
I guessed that you were trans, but that wasn’t confirmed by you at the time I first commented on your post.
Your potential trans status didn’t factor into my calculus of whether or not I’d compliment you on the incredible steps you ARE measurably, objectively taking to improve your health.
Here’s what factored into my decision to comment on your post:
From personal experience, fighting against disordered eating is extremely difficult. It is even more difficult when the majority of people on these interwebs are only encouraging each other to spiral into various unhealthy behaviors for their own personal amusement.
In conclusion, I think that your remarkable progress towards health deserves ample encouragement. Great job. Keep going!
I hope you will always continue to invest in your health, because you deserve to live a long, fruitful, happy and healthy life.
Quotes a post by T25961; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
That’s false. Your post came up on my feed because I started getting the eating disorder algorithm pushed on my X after I started posting about my (totally healthy) weight loss. I guessed that you were trans, but that wasn’t confirmed by you at the time I first commented on your post.
Your trans status didn’t factor into my calculus of whether or not I’d compliment you on the incredible steps you ARE measurably, objectively taking to improve your health.
Here’s what factored into my decision to comment on your post:
From personal experience, fighting against disordered eating is extremely difficult. It is even more difficult when the majority of people on these interwebs are only encouraging each other to spiral into various unhealthy behaviors for their own personal amusement.
In conclusion, I think that your remarkable progress towards health deserves ample encouragement. Great job. Keep going! I hope you will always continue to invest in your health, because you deserve to live a long, fruitful, happy and healthy life.
I’ve met quite a few trans people who are very pleasant and prosocial. But the antisocial freaks of the trans community are unfortunately not a minority of their community. Trans communities should stop normalizing antisocial behavior. It’s a bad look and a detriment.
To be fair, I don’t think trans is the mental illness that causes people to be violent freaks. I do think that trans is the catch-all category that many mentally ill freaks migrate towards these days, though. That’s not to say they comprise the entire community, but a sizeable portion for sure within Gen Z queer/trans communities are really mentally ill, and some of those in addition to being really mentally ill, are also antisocial freaks.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnessviolence terror
There are similarities between violent trans people and jihadists for sure. Both threaten and kill for an ideology. They’re extremists. It’s what they do.
The reason you keep making these nonsensical posts is because you struggle to work through the dissonance of “I like this girl because we have the skating thing, and a few other things in common” and “oh god, this skater girl is saying things I don’t like.”
I know you are telling me to change the things I post about because you think it will somehow improve my skating skills. However, this makes objectively no sense.
It is obvious to me that you are making this comment over and over again on my posts because you want to resolve this inner dissonance created by someone whose online company you enjoy, posting things that contradict your worldview.
It actually has nothing to do with the non-existent correlation between posting about trans/gender specifically and skating skills.
That is merely the pretense you are using to make it seem like you have something intelligent, insightful or worth listening to.
It is troubling that you’re rapidly nearing the age of 40, yet, no one has ever taught you how to work through these types of situations.
If you want me to change my opinions, you will have to convince me I am wrong in the old fashioned, sophisticated way.
Provide me with compelling counterarguments that are based on logos. Show me how my logic is incorrect, if you can’t come up with your own counter arguments.
Btw- I am telling you to rely on logos to convince me of your worldview because have no ethos of which to speak, and because pathos does not work on me.
Quotes a post by T00486; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The reason you keep making these nonsensical posts is because you struggle to work through the dissonance of “I like this girl because we have the skating thing, and a few other things in common” and “oh god, this skater girl is saying things I don’t like.”
I know you are telling me to change the things I post about because you think it will somehow improve my skating skills. However, this makes objectively no sense.
It is obvious to me that you are making this comment over and over again on my posts because you want to resolve this inner dissonance created by someone whose online company you enjoy, posting things that contradict your worldview. It actually has nothing to do with the non-existent correlation between posting about trans/gender specifically and skating skills. That is just the pretense you are using to make it seem like you have something intelligent, insightful or worth listening to.
It is troubling that you’re rapidly nearing the age of 40, yet, no one has ever taught you how to work through these types of situations.
If you want me to change my opinions, you will have to convince me I am wrong in the old fashioned, sophisticated way.
Provide me with compelling counterarguments that are based on logos. Show me how my logic is incorrect, if you can’t come up with your own counter arguments.
Btw- I am telling you to rely on logos to convince me of your worldview because have no ethos of which to speak, and pathos does not work on me.
I think trans people, as in people who intentionally present themselves as the other sex, do exist. I just don’t think such people have actually changed sex. Hope this helps!
Quotes a post by T17516; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think trans people, as in people who intentionally present themselves as the other sex, do exist. I just don’t think such people have actually changed sex. Hope this helps!
There’s a double entendre here: stitching as in compiling clips together in short form content (of mastectomies in this case), and stitching as in surgical stitching of incisions. I came to the comments to figure out which of these you were talking about. But re: surgical stitching, yes- it’s clear that because trans patients tend not to hold their top surgeons accountable, there is no recourse for butchery.
Someone can pass to you and not pass to me. Regardless of whether a trans woman passes in the eyes of any number of people, that individual is not female, so therefore cannot be a woman. Also, I’ve never said that Hunter is ugly. Not sure where everyone is getting that idea.
Quotes a post by T24377; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Someone can pass to you and not pass to me. Regardless of whether a trans woman passes in the eyes of any number of people, that individual is not female, so therefore cannot be a woman. Also, I’ve never said that Hunter is ugly. Not sure where everyone is getting that idea.
There are some trans women that really pass to me, like Dana International for example. I knew Dana was trans beforehand, but I still can’t see it. Other people say they can, but I have the same reaction to them saying that as you do to me saying this. Passability is to some extent, in the eye of the beholder. And it’s likely that natal males vs females pay attention to some different bodily cues to distinguish males from females.
To me, Hunter’s body proportions don’t read as female. Facial proportions read as androgynous without make up, and as feminine with make up- but bodily proportions read as distinctly male. This could change if Hunter ate a cheeseburger once in a while because the estrogen would distribute fat. That may visually offset the male skeletal proportions. Right now all I see is a skeleton with implants, because there’s not enough fat to create a feminine shape. Regardless, I do hope Hunter gets enough to eat.
Some women have one or two masculine features of their bodies that are offset by many feminine features. Beyond genetics, any person who is severely underweight (skeletal) or severely overweight can androgenize themselves more easily than people who are within a healthier weight range. But I’ll just say this- what clocks someone as trans mtf isn’t one or two masculine features. It is the combination of many of them. It is the combination of multiple masculine skeletal proportions in addition to few feminine attributes which gets someone clocked as male, because it is a combination not typically seen even on females who have a higher than average number of masculine physical traits. Hunter’s voice isn’t clockable though, but voice is not what I’m talking about here.
I can’t believe I was so terrified of being a woman that I pretended to be a man for so long and bound my breasts to the point of disfigurement. In retrospect: the whole trans arc was pretty absurd. Being a woman who isn’t pretending to be something else is f-ing liberating!
Not all transitioned people are authoritarian about the pronouns they want to be called, y’know.
Some people will just say “use whatever comes most naturally” and that’s the only approach that actually makes sense to me. Sometimes a female person really does look male and (rarely) vice versa, so it does take extra energy to use the correct sexed gender pronoun. And there are trans people who don’t pass for whom using the preferred pronoun is just as cognitively laborious and ridiculous.
I’d personally rather hang out with people who don’t require everyone in their periphery to play language games: either trans ones or gender critical ones.
Women don’t tend to see large breast implants on a male skeleton and think “yeah, that’s a woman.”
Transwomen will always ‘pass’ more in the eyes of men than they will in the eyes of women.
Why? Because women, as in people of the female sex, (regardless of how they identify) are evolutionarily programmed to pick up on sex differences for safety reasons.
Women need to know which class of people could pose a physical safety or pregnancy risk (or reward, in the case of a well-selected male mate for procreative purposes, where this is the goal). Women, for their own safety, have learned well how to distinguish males from females.
For men, sexual activity carries very little risk in comparison. They can inseminate a woman and walk away without any qualms, from their future offspring. Where they don’t, it is because they have a moral compass and a sense of duty or obligation to this female partner, regardless of whether they experience the subjective state of “love.”
Men are far more likely see large fake breasts and think “woman” even if the rest of the cues read as male or ambiguous. Because most of what registers to men as “woman” is stuff they find visually sexually attractive. They take little to no risk by being proven wrong in an evolutionary sense, because they can spread their seed elsewhere.
Women are far more likely pick up on those male and ambiguous cues fairly quickly.
In trans communities, I’ve noticed this sex difference in the ability to accurately detect sex cues are sex specific. Male trans people (transwomen) are usually really poor arbiters of knowing which of them look like women and which do not. Go to Reddit if you do not believe me. The goal seems to be “if I can get something that looks like boobs, I pass now.” We also see tons of men being tricked by Thai ladyboys.
Female trans people (transmen) are usually really good at knowing when they don’t pass as men. The ones who know on some level, that they won’t pass as male, become theyfabs or non-binaries en masse.
You just don’t see tons of transmen being delusional about their ability to pass as boys or men. You also don’t see tons of women being tricked by thai ladyboys.
I’m no longer living a transgender li(f)e, binding my breasts or carrying 70 extra pounds on my body. I no longer feel like I am trapped in my body. I am finally FREE.
I only wish every girl and woman could experience this freedom too.
I believed I was born in the wrong body for 12 years of my life, from the ages of 12-24.
I spent many years living as trans 🏳️⚧️ and pretending to be a man.
Now at 27, after years of hell, I’ve finally embraced my female body.
Life is good.
1. If you don’t like my content, unfollow me.
2. I AM POSTING ABOUT MY OWN TRANS EXPERIENCE. When trans people post about trans shit all day, there are no complaints. So, I will do whatever the hell I want on my account. You’re being detransphobic.
Retards like Saffie claim that I’m sooo obsessed with trans people (because I talk about MY OWN EXPERIENCES being trans) while stalking me and commenting on every post.
You idiot! You are obsessed with me. Get a life.
Quotes a post by T13851; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Had @xx_xyathletics never put this sweatshirt on sale in their outlet, I’m not sure I would’ve ever worn lavender.
When I first put it on, I could feel that last residual transgender brainworm leaving my skull through my right ear.
Is this my color?
When I was trans, I thought the concept of a “girl’s day out” was ludicrous and nonsensical.
I’ve come to the understanding that when the girls ( or women) you’re on a day out with are thoughtful, intelligent people like @[private account], all you’re doing, is just bonding over a shared special interest. And usually an activity. That’s what it is.
Over the course of my detransition, I’ve come to many realizations about what it means to be an adult woman. Including socially.
One of these things I’ve come to realize is that you don’t actually have to subject your senses to the onslaught of wax, nail polish or mind-numbing small talk in order to partake in this female bonding ritual known as the “girl’s day out.” You don’t even need to call it that.
All the social rituals and conventions of womanhood in any given Western society, frankly, are optional or customizable to your liking.
The only prerequisite, after all, to being a woman, is to be a female human who has reached adulthood.
What has going through life taught you about flexibility and rigidity of social norms?
The 20 year old on the left thought “he” would be transgender for life.
The 27 year old woman on the right has proven “him” wrong.
I am so grateful to be finally living in truth! What are you grateful for?
I think these kids are drawn to an escape from their current confusion. They will latch onto whichever escape the culture hands them first. Autistic people in particular tend to disassociate from their bodies, so trans is the natural progression of that unless it is *prevented* before the dissociative tendencies take on a gender identity flavor- at which point it becomes crystallized
I see trans as more likely to be eventually endemic than pandemic. Let me explain why.
I think that for as long as this idea exists in the culture, young autists will be drawn to it. The more prevalent this idea is, the more young autists and troubled youth will be caught in that net.
What will change over time is that the miscellaneously troubled and mentally ill youth without autism will be swayed into a different self-destructive behavior because they are socially motivated (rather than deficient) and socially intelligent enough to have noticed that trans allyship is increasingly not popular- so they will find their new allies.
But young autists will forever be very vulnerable to this regardless of how popular it is in the culture, because it is catnip to us. (After all, I was a little kid in 2011- this idea was not even remotely popular with my same aged peers, and yet, I still found it and stayed in it for 12 years).
Trans will probably, we can hope, return to being one of many strange, niche autistic subcultures and the personality disordered people will exit and wreak havoc elsewhere. All we can hope is that fewer autistic people see this as a panacea, while recognizing that Pandora’s box cannot be un-opened.
That’s my unpopular take.
Quotes a post by T07840; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Great question, Stephanie.
I see trans as more likely to be eventually endemic than pandemic. Let me explain why.
I think that for as long as this idea exists in the culture, young autists will be drawn to it. The more prevalent this idea is, the more young autists and troubled youth will be caught in that net.
What will change over time is that the miscellaneously troubled and mentally ill youth without autism will be swayed into a different self-destructive behavior because they are socially motivated (rather than deficient) and socially intelligent enough to have noticed that trans allyship is increasingly not popular- so they will find their new allies.
But young autists will forever be very vulnerable to this regardless of how popular it is in the culture, because it is catnip to us. (After all, I was a little kid in 2011- this idea was not even remotely popular with my same aged peers, and yet, I still found it and stayed in it for 12 years).
Trans will probably, we can hope, return to being one of many strange, niche autistic subcultures and the personality disordered people will exit and wreak havoc elsewhere. All we can hope is that fewer autistic people see this as a panacea, while recognizing that Pandora’s box cannot be un-opened.
That’s my unpopular take.
Transgender 🏳️⚧️ nonsense was pushed on me at 12. It took me until my mid-late 20’s to finally be ok with being an adult woman.
The fact that I don’t have to continue disfiguring my breasts in order to affirm a lie, is the best gift I’ve ever given myself.
Repost if you agree
After a bunch of navel gazing, I’ve realized that I am truly trans after all.
I am trans-generational.
I was born in the wrong generation.
If all trans identities are valid- will you affirm mine?
It’s also a poorly researched area with little to no follow up data being collected. My sample has always been majority Gen Z and young millennial trans people. These generations of trans people are pretty dysfunctional compared to those who are older than them. Not sure exactly why, but I have some theories.
Again- you’re arguing against a point I’m not making
Holy shit
Obviously people can skate and be trans at the same time.
I personally think everyone who is able bodied enough to skate should try it.
For me, this sport helps me to prevent myself from disassociating from my body due to my horrendous sensory processing challenges, and then trying to resolve that dissasociation by trying to modify my sex traits; because it did not work the first time. I’m finding alternative ways to manage my autistic issues which caused my protracted gender issues. My own.
This is not a hard argument to track. I don’t know why you’re not getting it, no matter how many millions of times I try to explain this basic thing to you.
Quotes a post by T00486; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Again- you’re arguing against a point I’m not making
Holy shit
Obviously people can skate and be trans at the same time. I think everyone who is able bodied enough to skate should try it.
For me, this sport helps preventing me from disassociating from my body and then pursuing that dissasociation by trying to modify my sex traits.
This is not a hard argument to track. I don’t know why you’re not getting it, no matter how many millions of times I try to explain this basic thing to you.
Alcoholism has plagued every trans Israeli I’ve met, with the exception of one person. It’s rampant in some trans communities. Also doing hard drugs. Trans people who are sober or consume these substances in moderation are probably in the minority.
Firstly, no one actually knows how many transition regretters there are. Anyone on either side of the trans debate who claims they know, is full of shit.
Do you have something specific to say about this post, or are you just going to spout the same trans talking points over and over again?
Quotes a post by T20644; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Firstly, no one actually knows how many transition regretters there are. Anyone on either side of the trans debate who claims they know, is full of shit.
Do you have something specific to say about this post, or are you just going to spout the same trans talking points over and over again?
I have muscles on the borderline between very tight and mildly spastic. I spent my childhood getting Botox injected into my legs and put in leg braces to walk properly, and then spent the rest of my time in intensive physio-therapy. None of it resolved the underlying issue. As I’ve said numerous times, I have to relax my muscles with an electric blanket for at least 10-12 hours a day just so I can skate for 1-2. I became obese because I basically could not walk. My lazy eye and my muscle problems are both due to some kind of neurological injury I received from being born weighing 1.27 kg and being premature.
Some of us have to overcome odds that you never will. That makes you lucky. It doesn’t make me a liar. Trying to negate the fact that I have to work extremely hard just to have any kind of mobility just because we disagree about trans stuff is a really, really low blow. You’ll never convince me you’re a compassionate, but misguided good faith actor in this. That’s the biggest difference between you and Brynn.
It was way more than a few crazies who supported Clancy- probably because most women can relate to wanting to kill their screaming children. The difference is that most women have the sense to remove themselves from the situation- hence why they don’t kill their kids. They underestimate that they have common sense and so they simply relate to her struggle and try to justify their own feelings by proxy of supporting her. Rather than having an honest conversation about the struggles of raising kids and the supports women need in order to not kill their kids, it’s being blamed on female hormones making women crazy. And then on SSRIs when the previous excuse gets nowhere. This discourse seems like a lame excuse for psychopathic behavior, and it has nothing to do with the misogyny boogeyman. Women will frequently intrasexually bully other women into doing things which objectively harm themselves. Trans ftm friend groups being a prime example.
Here I am, skating to one of the songs that gave me horrible gender dysphoria as a 12 year old.
Why? Because when it played, I was in a middle school dance class being told to move my hips in a seductive way, while wearing a costume that was too revealing for my comfort.
That’s what a lot of gender dysphoria- the disgust or terror surrounding being a girl who is growing into a woman- looks like in a lot of young girls.
It is never just as simple as that, of course. But it is inevitably, a large part of it.
The solution we are giving girls who feel like this right now, meaning that they don’t want to be turned into sex dolls the moment they hit puberty and find themselves exposed to the concept of “trans men”; is that we teach them to bind their breasts.
We tell them that they are very possibly boys “on the inside.”
That is a LIE.
I am only one young woman of my generation, among many, who is now dealing with the life-derailing and physically disfiguring consequences of this cultural framing of my perfectly understandable 12 year old kid feelings.
Kids like the one I was need something very different from what they are getting.
They need compassion, healthy parental boundaries, and most importantly; they need the ability to still be kids….. who aren’t expected to wear skimpy dance costumes in public middle school performances!
It’s better to embrace the weird autistic girl/woman you are, than to convince yourself that you will never be happy unless you try to mask your autistic quirks by attempting to be someone else; especially by trying to trans your gender.
I used to be transgender (12-24), but now I’m not. I’d tell my younger self this:
Being strong and logical, and therefore unable to fit in with other girls doesn’t mean you’re a man ‘on the inside.’
Maiming yourself to live a better lie is NOT worth it.
In my 27 years of life, I’ve transformed from: a very confused autistic girl child to a stealth trans 🏳️⚧️ wannabe yeshiva bochur (religious Jewish guy) only to have found my place in society as a secular Jewish rollerskating lesbian.
holy identity crisis.
Many autistic girls want to be trans boys after internalizing feminist indoctrination:
“B/c of the patriarchy, I’ll get sexually objectified, raped and killed. That’s just what happens to women.”
Whatever happened to teaching girls to be STRONG women instead of victims?
I was a confused autistic kid who got sucked into trans stuff for 12 years only to realize that I was a girl who liked girls and not a man trapped in a woman’s body.
Every day I get better at skating, is a day that I become more truly and authentically myself. No identity changes, breast binders, transgender drugs or surgeries needed!
“California Dreamin’” with the assist of an AI powered gimbal
The only reason I was ultimately able to logic myself out of a 12 year long trans identity at the age of 24 is because my thought process going into it was quite a logical one for a 12 year old. I didn’t even regret it at the time, or even realized how much I’d been harmed. I just realized that actually none of it made sense when I applied slightly more mature thinking to it. The fact that some of these women/feminists/ wherever want to use this aspect of my past as a blight on my current judgement, though I have demonstrated exceptional insight into how I got into this mess and what it took to get me out- is absurd. I’ve learned far more from the experience of having struggled against something so fundamental, in a faraway land, speaking four languages every day, and emerging victorious, than most of these people have learned in lives that are twice as long as mine has been.
Clearly there’s something else going on with them. And it’s not concern over my well being. Because I’m doing quite well. Better than I can ever remember functioning at any other point in my life
Couldn’t have said it better myself. Everyone thinks that boys or men being perverts is why so many girls/women go trans. But what if also, it’s the bitchy, mean girl behavior of other girls that makes girls go trans?
Quotes a post by T31298; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
They are self-described feminists though. What other criterion is there for entry into feminism?
I will reiterate: I bring up that they are feminists because their statements seem antithetical to ensuring or celebrating the well being of women.
Simply saying that these liars are women, I’d get yet another group of feminists accusing me of misogyny. You can never win! Someone will always be offended by a factual re-stating of the events.
Every single one of these accusers, and those who told me when I was overweight that I didn’t need to lose more weight, and in fact claimed I was spreading eating disordered behavior has abided by some kind of feminist ideology or another.
Whether they’re trans inclusive libfems or trans exclusive radfems. Every single one! It’s wild. No other members from any other ideological group have tried to spread this particular lie about me. And I think it’s curious
Today’s hot take: all trans and detrans people, especially those who are young, should pick up skating. Why? Because of the high rates of ADHD and autism in these groups.
Skating is a great way to channel the youthful drive to do stupid shit into something healthy
If I could talk to my past transgender self, I’d tell “him” that pretending to be someone you’re not is an act of fraud that takes a heavy, daily toll on the conscience. Fraud is the antithesis to “true, authentic self.”
(Btw, I’m dancing to the Beatles.)
This is my first time wearing a headband since I was a small child. I denied myself so many stupid random things that could’ve made my life easier, when I lived as trans and pretended to be a man- because it would impede my ability to pass as something I’m not.
Upon further reflection, I think that the trans life I lived was pretty insane. I was dodging military checkpoints with a female marked passport and putting myself into extremely risky situations. The dopamine of surviving my own stupidity was entertaining. Thus, I was happy. But I wasn’t fulfilled. It’s like the difference between being hungry and eating sugar for every meal and then crashing vs eating a balanced meal and having sustained life energy.
I dreamed for this level of liberation when I was trans.
But only with detransition, could I actually achieve it.
Being a quirky autistic woman is infinitely better than being a woman who is trying to convince the world that she’s a man.
As it turns out, my “true authentic self” was *for years* hiding under layers of fat and a pretend man “trans” mask.
The woman in the red is me. My true, authentic self.
You will never become more yourself by trying to be someone else.
When I was trans, I genuinely thought I was happy living as a guy.
But looking back on my old pictures, I’m barely smiling in any of them.
Pretending to be something you’re not by damaging your body- is exhausting.
Why are adults still pushing kids into this madness?
You don’t need to do anything to be trans. That’s the most inclusive definition. I did life defining and body altering things to be trans. So I did trans things. Let’s stop moving the goalposts whenever it’s convenient
I was trans for a very long time in my life. I’m new to women’s clothes.
Since these are the first skinny jeans I’ve worn in my adult life, do I:
A) tuck them into my boots
B) wear them over my boots
C) take them to alterations b/c they’re just too damn long.
I do have a substack blog and I’ve interviewed a few people on here before
https://maiapoet.substack.com/p/when-trans-masc-becomes-another-mask?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
In what way is it “not that big a deal” that my arm goes numb on a daily basis because of a damaged nerve I was not warned I could get from breast binding?
In what way is it “not that big a deal” that my breast tissue is damaged?
In what way is it “not that big a deal” that I have no sensation in my chest except for nerve pain??
In what way is it “not a big deal” that I can’t sleep without getting woken up by shooting pain in my ribs?
“Not that big a deal”
Stop comparing the adult choice you made to breastfeed your kids to 12 year old me binding her breasts after being grievously lied to by transgender activists.
I was TWELVE.
And now I’m 27. Saggy breasts are the LEAST of my concerns.
Quotes a post by T19303; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Stop comparing the adult choice you made to breastfeed your kids to 12 year old me binding her breasts after being grievously lied to by transgender activists.
In what way is it “not that big a deal” that my arm goes numb on a daily basis because of a damaged nerve I was not warned I could get from breast binding?
In what way is it “not that big a deal” that my breast tissue is damaged?
In what way is it “not that big a deal” that I have no sensation in my chest except for nerve pain??
In what way is it “not a big deal” that I can’t sleep without getting woken up by shooting pain in my ribs?
“Not that big a deal”
I was TWELVE. And now I’m 27. Saggy breasts are the LEAST of my concerns.
I’m not talking about how trans people “should” live. I’m talking about what it has taken for me to finally enjoy living in my body. If other young women follow my method, instead of relying on testosterone injections to quell their inner pain, they get to make that choice.
Quotes a post by T02111; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m not talking about how trans people “should” live. I’m talking about what it has taken for me to finally enjoy living in my body. If other young women follow my method, instead of relying on testosterone injections to quell their inner pain, they get to make that choice.
Predictable cult behavior. Some trans people aren’t hive minders. But just like with every other population on earth, most people unquestioningly believe in the ethos of their tribe. So when I find a rare trans person who has interesting and heterodox beliefs, I quite enjoy their company
A big problem is that trans communities are really bad at telling people to slow things down and to make decisions in a careful and informed way. They’re shooting themselves in the foot by encouraging people to go only by how they feel and not by anything more practical.
Hebrew is an extremely gendered language. Still, Israeli trans people who speak relatively poor or good but heavily accented English are significantly more pleasant and mentally stable than are the Israeli trans people who speak native English. It’s remarkable.
Quotes a post by T05549; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hebrew is an extremely gendered language. Still, Israeli trans people who speak relatively poor or good but heavily accented English are significantly more pleasant and mentally stable than are the Israeli trans people who speak native English. It’s remarkable.
Trans people anywhere outside of the anglophone west are baseline *significantly* more pleasant and well-adjusted than trans people in the anglophone west.
Having lived as trans in many different cultural enclaves in two different countries, I see being a native anglophone growing up with first world privileges and entitlements as the confounding variable here. Trans people are not universally delusional, insane or obnoxious. But a certain very common type of American/British/Canadian trans person will really try to make you think that every trans person is like them.
Quotes a post by T00786; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans people anywhere outside of the anglophone west are baseline more pleasant and well-adjusted than trans people in the anglophone west. Having been trans in many different cultural enclaves in two different countries, being a native anglophone is the confounding variable here.
Western trans people only take health risks when they transition in the West. Maybe they’ll get called a mean name by someone on the street.
People who transition in other parts of the world are taking life and death risks, in addition to risking their health.
“Maia was only trans for a small period of time”
Are you f—ing kidding me?
I *was* trans for longer than you’ve been “non-binary.” And I was a kid when I started. And you’re almost 40.
The weight that some girls gain because they’ve fully disassociated from their bodies mid-trans ID, and/or think being fat will make them more androgynous, and/or use both the male alter ego & overeating as a way to ‘protect’ themselves from future sexual assaults etc.,
(All things that males who identify as women will laugh off and pretend aren’t real, because they have ZERO understanding of what female puberty, socialization, and embodiment lived experiences can actually look like…outside of their own paraphilic/erotic fantasies of what it’s like to be a woman)
Quotes a post by T06033; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The weight that some girls gain because they’ve fully disassociated from their bodies mid-trans ID, and/or think being fat will make them more androgynous, and/or use both the male alter ego & overeating as a way to ‘protect’ themselves from future sexual assaults etc.,
I’m so close to losing the last of my “trans” weight; and to finally making peace with my FEMALE body.
There are aspects of ‘gender transition’ that I won’t be able to fully recover from. But I CAN heal my relationship with my body.
55 pounds down, 3 more left to go!
Maybe if you tell they/them that you are trans, they/them will take your word for it. The playing dumb is perhaps for some individuals, a symptom of actually being dumb and relying on identity politics as a mechanism by which to outsource any need for critical thinking.
I was honestly looking for an alternative from the moment I began having these feelings of “maybe I’m meant to be a transsexual too” (12) after obsessively researching transsexuality when I had finally realized I didn’t have the neurosurgical experience to figure out how to operate on INOPERABLE pituitary tumors (8-11).
I was a 12 year old who scoured medical journals for fun.
I couldn’t find one. Everything I found, said that living as a dude was the only way to navigate through life if one has these miscellaneous thoughts or developmental confusions referred to as “gender identity disorder.”
It took me a very long time to realize, ironically through these uncomplicated GC epithets, that actually I did have the option of just being a very atypical woman. I was actually initially quite angry that no one in my life had explained this to me. The only options I got from the culture was “someone like you must transition” and from those who opposed that message, the only one I got was “you just need to conform better to female grooming norms and social communication rituals.”
Both the pro-trans and trans critical arguments I had heard for the vast majority of my adolescence and early adulthood were reinforcing the notion that there’s something not adequate about being an atypical woman. And naturally, I thought that in order to move forward into life, I had to change myself one way or the other. I actually tried both, and living as a pretend man was a lot easier than pretending to be a typical (not autistic) woman. The former only required me to damage my body with a binder, slightly modifying my style and making up a new name; but my behavior didn’t need to change for me to be read that way. The latter, required putting myself through a constant sensory nightmare, continuing to fail at a social role that I did not understand and therefore failed to perform.
I took all of these things as literal mandates, as a guidebook to life. And once I started realizing there were problems and that the whole thing was kind of bullshit, I was itching to find a way out. But I actually thought I had no choice. As soon as I found out that I had a choice, it was more a matter of executive dysfunction that delayed the detransition. And the not knowing how I was supposed to just unravel the life I’d built for myself in a very sex segregated society which delayed my detransition.
Eventually being traumatized enough by non-first world problems made me stop vacillating. But I needed the framework of “detransition”- otherwise, I probably would have still stayed trans. I’ve always been the type to require some kind of framework, a manual or a formula to help me weigh my life choices.
As such, I can’t understand why someone who thinks transition is a fantastic fit for them, would be unable to contend with it being a choice they made; and a choice they can feel confident about.
Thoughts?
Quotes a post by A0882; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I was honestly looking for an alternative from the moment I began having these feelings of “maybe I’m meant to be a transsexual too” (12) after obsessively researching transsexuality when I had finally realized I didn’t have the neurosurgical experience to figure out how to operate on INOPERABLE pituitary tumors (8-11).
I was a 12 year old who scoured medical journals for fun.
I couldn’t find one. Everything I found, said that living as a dude was the only way to navigate through life if one has these miscellaneous thoughts or developmental confusions referred to as “gender identity disorder.”
It took me a very long time to realize, ironically through these uncomplicated GC epithets, that actually I did have the option of just being a very atypical woman. I was actually initially quite angry that no one in my life had explained this to me. The only options I got from the culture was “someone like you must transition” and from those who opposed that message, the only one I got was “you just need to conform better to female grooming norms and social communication rituals.”
Both the pro-trans and trans critical arguments I had heard for the vast majority of my adolescence and early adulthood were reinforcing the notion that there’s something not adequate about being an atypical woman. And naturally, I thought that in order to move forward into life, I had to change myself one way or the other. I actually tried both, and living as a pretend man was a lot easier than pretending to be a typical (not autistic) woman. The former only required me to damage my body with a binder, slightly modifying my style and making up a new name; but my behavior didn’t need to change for me to be read that way. The latter, required putting myself through a constant sensory nightmare, continuing to fail at a social role that I did not understand and therefore failed to perform.
I took all of these things as literal mandates, as a guidebook to life. And once I started realizing there were problems and that the whole thing was kind of bullshit, I was itching to find a way out. But I actually thought I had no choice. As soon as I found out that I had a choice, it was more a matter of executive dysfunction that delayed the detransition. And the not knowing how I was supposed to just unravel the life I’d built for myself in a very sex segregated society which delayed my detransition.
Eventually being traumatized enough by non-first world problems made me stop vacillating. But I needed the framework of “detransition”- otherwise, I probably would have still stayed trans. I’ve always been the type to require some kind of framework, a manual or a formula to help me weigh my life choices.
As such, I can’t understand why someone who thinks transition is a fantastic fit for them, would be unable to contend with it being a choice they made; and a choice they can feel confident about.
Thoughts?
In what way do your re-phrasings add clarity or precision that the phrase “trans is biopsychosocial sex mimicry?” (a phrase I’ve coined as far as I’m aware)
And how does one define trans as a thought, when one does not believe the concept refers to anything legitimate or existent?
To summarize: “trans” as a concept only makes sense when it is understood as a choice that someone makes to engage in biopsychosocial sex mimicry, rather than as some kind of unprovable yet immutable inner essence.
Quotes a post by T30168; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is an honest answer, and an interesting one. To summarize: trans only makes sense when it is understood as a choice that someone makes to engage in biopsychosocial sex mimicry, rather than as some kind of unprovable, immutable inner essence.
“Trans” as I see it, is a way of life characterized by various forms of biopsychosocial (cross-)sex mimicry.
You may dislike the ideological underpinnings propping up the medical, activist & legal influences which have unnecessarily popularized this phenomenon. I certainly do.
But pretending that the phenomenon doesn’t exist is not helpful. If it didn’t exist, none of us would be here talking about it.
I don’t believe in the legitimacy of Islam, or think it is compatible with Western civilization, but I’ll never say Islam (or it’s believers- Muslims) don’t exist because that would simply be untrue.
Quotes a post by A1170; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Trans” as I see it, is a way of life characterized by various forms of biopsychosocial (cross-)sex mimicry.
You may dislike the ideological underpinnings propping up the medical, activist & legal influences which have unnecessarily popularized this phenomenon. I certainly do.
But pretending that the phenomenon doesn’t exist is not helpful. If it didn’t exist, none of us would be here talking about it.
I don’t believe in the legitimacy of Islam, or think it is compatible with Western civilization, but I’ll never say Islam (or it’s believers- Muslims) don’t exist because that would simply be untrue.
Is it an emotional security barrier, or a logical reasoning barrier? Because the moment I realized that there was no objective way to determine ‘trans-ness’ my alarm bells went off, and even so, before this, I was extremely secure in my belief that I had a male brain in a female body.
Roughly 45% of the trans community says I was never trans. The other roughly 45% says I am STILL trans.
Where are the 10% of trans people who are capable of entertaining the complex thought that I was once trans, and now I’m not?
Quotes a post by T34729; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s pretty mean of you to assume that all trans people are immature self-victimizers who can’t own their own choices. I didn’t use the word “trans” in this post. I certainly wasn’t the one making that claim. This post could just as equally apply to the most annoying types of trans people as it could to the most annoying types of “antiracist” leftists. It’s about identity politics. A certain annoying type of trans person just uses them more than some other annoying types of people.
I don’t disagree with anything you’re saying here, but I also don’t think we’re talking about the same subcategories of trans identifying girls, either. There is a distinctly aspie/ ADHD subgroup and another is distinctly personality disordered. Their psychologies are profoundly different. The former thinks they will become “normal” by transitioning whereas the latter does it for oppression points.
Sometimes there’s overlap between these categories, but usually one phenotype is significantly more evident than the other, where both exist within the same patient.
Regardless, I think every little girl who was imbued with this pseudoscientific nonsense at such a tender age that it hijacks their identity development for years while damaging and stealing some body parts and functions along the way- is a victim of a wayward culture. And of poor mental health or developmental supports. Or of flawed parenting. Or of any number of factors.
We can acknowledge that there are certain girls who are too well adjusted or too developmentally typical to fall into this trans stuff no matter how much you push it on them, while also acknowledging that trans indoctrination is most successful at reeling in a particular group of girls who in previous generations, would have struggled significantly during adolescence as well.
And at the same time, we can recognize that if a confused teenager ends up harmed as a result of their confused adolescent ideations, it is not that confused young person’s fault. It is the fault of every adult around them for allowing the youth to be harmed in this way.
When trans people choose to protest by shooting up drugs in the street, does it make them look like:
A)mentally ill drug addicts
B) respectable members of society whose concerns should be taken seriously
BTW: “Optics fallacy” is not a recognized logical fallacy.
Quotes a post by T02111; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When trans people choose to protest by shooting up drugs in the street, does it make them look like:
A)mentally ill drug addicts
B) respectable members of society whose concerns should be taken seriously?
BTW: “Optics fallacy” is not a recognized logical fallacy.
Injecting drugs in public places as a protest, makes trans people look like extremely mentally unstable drug addicts.
Quoting @ScooterCasterNY: NOW: Trans activists and community members inject HRT outside NYU hospital in Defiance "We're taking our HRT here at the doors of the people who have given up to demystify, normalize, and celebrate our trans bodies in the face of NYU's cowardice."
NYU Langone Health stopped providing puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and other gender-transition treatments to patients under 19 after President Trump’s January 2025 executive order threatened federal funding for hospitals that offered the care.
For this reason and many more, trans people from non-Anglophone countries are a lot more baseline pleasant and chill than are (particularly) American ones.
“You’ll never recover from your gender dysphoria. You’ll always be trans. You’ll suffer if you detransition.”
Oh yeah?
Watch me thrive instead.
Watch me embrace my female body.
Watch me prove you liars wrong!
Being a woman who is pretending to be a man (“trans”) is so overrated. Instead, you can just be yourself. No identity change, no breast binder, no drugs and no surgeries needed.
Just four years ago I was committed to being trans for the rest of my life. Not only did I pretend to be a guy- but an orthodox jewish one at that! ‘Twas insane.
Now at 27, I’ve grown out of pretending to be someone I’m not. Being a dorky, autistic girl doesn’t make you a man!
I’d say trans is a different phenomenon in adolescents & young adults vs. in mature adults. Lots of young people’s body image issues become inextricably tied to their gender issues. The same cannot be assumed as a 1:1 ratio in more mature people.
Between creating the first protocol for trans-ing kids and now legally killing disabled toddlers, the Netherlands has truly monopolized the market for exporting pure evil to the whole world.
Quoting @LiveAction: A toddler was euthanized in the Netherlands for the first time.
For being disabled.
This child was born prematurely, developed cerebral palsy, was diagnosed with epilepsy, was visually impaired, had a developmental delay, and would be dependent the rest of his life.
He was severely disabled, but he was not dying.
This child's disabilities were not the problem.
The society that would rather put him to death than care for him is.
“I’m true trans and the rest of these people are fakers”
The only “true” thing you are, is truly committed to your beliefs. And you’re also basing your whole identity on a logical fallacy. Simmer down.
Over the course of the last almost three years, I: lived through war in the Middle East, quit binding my breasts, stopped being trans, lost more than 50 pounds, picked up rollerblading and have finally learned to love, rather than to just tolerate, being a woman.
Whiplash 😂
If any trans movement is to succeed long-term, it needs to so significantly moderate itself to the point of unrecognizability.
If any feminist movement is to succeed long-term, it needs to quit being a such a breeding ground for female social aggression.
Who’ll get there first?
That’s the meaning our society has assigned to the term “tomboy.” Whether you like it or not, the fact remains that “tomboy” doesn’t connote any breast binding, hormones or surgeries and is therefore a far more suitable term to call young girls who like atypical things- than is the term “trans boy”
I hope that soon, the word “tomboy” replaces “trans boy” in youth vernacular.
Girls who are (hyper)active, autistic, or who are confused by the illogical nature of female social communication rituals, or who are pubertally distressed, or who like other girls; are all JUST girls.
I hope that soon the word “tomboy” fully replaces “trans-boy” in youth vernacular.
Girls who are: physically active, even hyperactive, who are autistic, who see socially acceptable “girly” rituals + behaviors as being fundamentally illogical- are literally still JUST GIRLS.
I knew I wasn’t totally crazy when even before trans indoctrination, at around 10 years old, I thought that puberty was a disease. I even wrote a “research paper” about how it’s an epidemic 😂
Are your kids preemies or did they get it from elsewhere?
You are not the sex of trans person I am referencing here. I am specifically referencing a common pattern of growing up FEMALE, going through a very normal (sometimes lengthy) period of extreme insecurity and disgust at being sexualized, thinking it means you’re supposed to be a boy, and then growing out of it.
Quotes a post by T02111; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You are not the sex of trans person I am referencing here. I am specifically referencing a common pattern of growing up FEMALE, going through a very normal (sometimes lengthy) period of extreme insecurity and disgust at being sexualized, thinking it means you’re supposed to be a boy, and then growing out of it.
I’m not quite at my goal weight yet, but holy hell am I a changed woman!
After losing 53 pounds, I had to finally downsize my @xx_xyathletics clothing from a men’s size medium to a women’s extra-small.
Here are my reflections on these last nine-ish months:
The weight I’d gained from eating too much and single-handedly drinking enough alcohol to kill a small village; was killing me.
I wasn’t over-eating and drinking myself into an early grave because I “lacked willpower.”
I did it, in part, to manage my sensory needs. I’d eat only the spiciest of chips and the sourest of candies until my mouth bled. Just to feel something.
And, on some level, throughout my “gender journey” I had increasingly lost the will to live, even though I always had a smile on my face.
At first, when I was happy in my transition, I drank and ate to cope with the loud sounds, and the bright lights of sensorially overwhelming Israeli bars where I attempted to behave like a typical 20-something in order to make friends.
As I got older, I ate and drank to cope with the unsatisfying reality of living a transgender 🏳️⚧️ lie, and trying to avoid feeling “unproductive” feelings as I did not know how to get myself out of it.
And then I ate and drank to cope with the trauma of living through Oct 7 in Israel, and then I did the same to cope with the instability of initial detransition.
And because I was so autistically disassociated from my own body, I did not care that I looked unhealthy or unattractive.
But realizing that I was prediabetic at 26 ultimately forced me to find better coping mechanisms for the trauma and negative emotion which led up to my transition, and that which occurred because of it.
And now, for the first time in my 27 years of life, I can finally say that I don’t hate my body anymore. And when I’m on skates, and can perfectly control my sensory environment; I can even enjoy it!
Thank you to @xx_xyathletics for standing up for women, and being there for me at every step of my detransition & weight loss journeys.
If you’ve read this to the end; how are you going to change your life?
The people you call “transphobes” are the world’s VAST majority who: do not believe sex can be changed, do not want women & girls to be forced to share intimate spaces with males, and who don’t believe in altering children’s bodies based on feelings they’ll likely grow out of.
For the crime of holding these normal beliefs, trans activists have managed to get women fired, cancelled, sent rape and death threats- and have even at their most extreme- committed ISIS style ideologically motivated murders and threaten to commit ISIS magnitude atrocities. And very rarely does this violent tendency get called out from within the community. It usually just gets celebrated.
And then those same trans activists say “look what you made me do.”
That’s the classic language of an abuser.
If trans activists keep abusing women, children, and all of society; normal transgender & transitioned people will be unable to freely live their lives. And you will have only yourselves to blame for that.
What about this do you not understand?
Quotes a post by T25315; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedcontagionmedical harmpolitical enemyvictim dismissalviolence terror
It’s just the preemie shit getting worse because the surgery that could’ve helped me when I was a little kid, didn’t really exist back then. Preemie’s lifelong medical needs are probably as experimental if not in some cases more experimental than lifelong outcomes of trans-medicalized people.
The worst strategic move trans activists made was to try to become super visible at the same time as they campaigned to linguistically and legally contort reality, starting with impressionable kids, in order to accommodate their unconventional adult life choices.
It actually makes perfect sense why your pro-Trump aunt is more pro-trans than is your progressive aunt.
Libertarianism gives trans people far more conceptual space than does radical feminism.
The trans community fights against its own best interests by propagating trump derangement syndrome and relying on the most deranged communists to “liberate” them. That move has backfired enormously.
“Live and let live” is the only philosophy in which trans as a category of its own can meaningfully survive.
If trans activists make concessions and stop pushing for the medicalization of minors, for taxpayers to fund cosmetic surgeries and stop forcing women and girls to share intimate spaces with men and boys to affirm the ‘gender identities’ of those males— almost no one would care about a relatively small group of adults taking on the private risk of this type of body modification.
Under those circumstances, any individual adult’s transition would impact very few people. No one would care. This is how it used to be.
But, when a minority makes unreasonable demands of the majority to accommodate them, in such a way that it seriously encroaches upon the rights of that majority; that’s when the majority becomes disgruntled.
Does this make sense?
Quotes a post by T30731; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I know this may go over your head intellectually speaking: but I don’t care whether people are trans or do trans things.
What I care about is when people lie and behave badly.
The trans movement has incubated and normalized both lying and behaving badly. So I call it out.
I do the same with gender critics or conservatives when they deserve it. I’ve managed to piss off hoards of angry feminists and TERFs by calling out when they are lying too. I have an autistic aversion to lies and liars. None of ya’ll are safe in my periphery.
Have a nice day.
I know this may go over your head intellectually speaking: but I don’t care whether people are trans or do trans things.
What I care about is when people lie and behave badly.
The trans movement has incubated and normalized both lying and behaving badly. So I call it out.
I do the same with gender critics or conservatives when they deserve it. I’ve managed to piss off hoards of angry feminists and TERFs by calling out when they are lying too. I have an autistic aversion to lies and liars. None of ya’ll are safe in my periphery.
Have a nice day.
Quotes a post by T00486; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When I quit being trans, I finally began to love my body.
I never thought I’d get here. Every young girl deserves the chance to grow to love herself as she is.
“Us”- Regina Spektor.
There is no place where the differences between the sexes are clearer than they are within trans communities.
Even though both sexes are performing their version of what they think the opposite sex is, they reveal themselves to be very much an individual of their sex.
I’m a former “trans teen/young adult” who has since grown up and returned to living as a woman. I hope my take on why your step son may be doing this, is helpful.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🧵As a former trans teen/young adult, who has now returned to living as the woman I was born as, here’s my take:
When you’re a miserable young person going through an identity crisis, and become fixated on your gender as the source of your suffering, it is not hard to project your current suffering onto your past self.
If your little kid past self was happy in those pictures of themselves as a toddler whose parents put them into stereotypically gendered clothing, this creates cognitive dissonance.
The young person doesn’t have the distress tolerance or maturity yet, to integrate that little kid self (a boy, in this case) with their current self-concept as a trans person. Online trans communities frequently parrot the idea that if you’re trans now, it means you were always trans/the opposite gender, but that no one recognized it. Photos are the evidence that this is false. That you weren’t always trans.
Getting rid of the photos and the items with the birth name is one way to remove the evidence that creates that dissonance.
/1
(Pictures: me as a little girl, a minor teen, legally adult teen [trans-identifying, presenting as a guy] and now as a 27 year old woman)
Many previously compliant kids who are now teens and young adults seeking to assert their independence, have not needed to develop distress tolerance to uncomfortable situations. Why? Because their parents’ goals, and their behaviors or ability to meet those goals, were in alignment.
Teens also tend to be self-focussed, and considering the desires and feelings of others even when the teen is distressed and miserable must be scaffolded by parents explicitly.
On top of the personal dissonance, a lot of trans young people in this position are also hearing online that old photos and the birth name are inherently invalidating. That message can make the urge to erase the past feel urgent and justified.
The more autistic the kid is, the more literally they will take this, and the more black-and-white their interpretation is of why mom has old photos of you as a boy on the wall when now she’s trying to use your preferred female pronouns.
The autistic young person* may struggle to understand that his mom does not actually see him as a girl, even if she is using the feminine pronouns as a social or relational accommodation. They take things literally. If this is the case, the mom not removing those old photographs is likely to confuse the kid about which version of reality he is living in: as his mommy’s little boy, or as his mommy’s daughter who was not ‘seen’ “correctly as a girl” early on.
If this is the case, the kid may be attempting to resolve the dissonance himself by removing the pictures to see how mom will react. Testing a boundary. Testing reality.
Mom’s reaction to this drastic step then becomes evidence to the kid, of whether his mom sees him as a boy or as a girl.
He may be seeking some clarity about whether his self-concept is aligned with how his parents perceive him.
*i’m not saying this is OP’s case, but autism is just really common in trans communities, so I thought it’d be good to mention explicitly
/4
But, as the kid becomes an adolescent, they crave being able to choose things for themselves.
They experiment with weird fashion choices, bad haircuts, odd music, and sometimes even with radically different belief systems than those shared by their parents.
They do these things to establish themselves as individuals who are separate from their parents.
And an adolescent should be allowed far more choice over certain domains of their life, to prepare them for adulthood, which is right around the corner.
Not all parents find it easy to adjust to the difference between raising a sweet, compliant kid and a growling, angsty teenager who appears out of nowhere. This can sometimes cause new issues in which power dynamics become reversed (the kid is allowed too much freedom and takes advantage of it) or in which parents become more rigid about what they feel is acceptable for their kids to do and double down. But in a healthy dynamic, parents adjust their expectations to meet the new needs of this growing kid.
Regardless, teenagers tend to be angsty. Some of their angst can be directed at the parents, whether the parents have done something wrong, or whether they have not. It’s developmentally normal to somewhat reject parents and hang out with other same-aged peers at this stage.
In this case, where an adolescent identity crisis has a gendered flavor, this teenager’s current angst, they are likely projecting onto their past little kid self who lacked the choices and freedom of self-expression that they currently have.
There is more dissonance here, because freedom of self-expression is not usually the main priority of most elementary-aged children.
However, teenagers, who may have even experienced a lifelong misery of being ‘different’, or feeling autistically out of step with their peers, which they currently assimilate into and explain using a trans identity; will project all of this onto their past little kid self who may have been suffering from *something* even if that something wasn’t a gender identity or presentation matter. At this stage, they lack the maturity or emotional regulation skills to make sense of any of these confusing feelings.
/3
🧵As a former trans teen/young adult, who has now returned to living as the woman I was born as, here’s my take:
When you’re a miserable young person going through an identity crisis, and become fixated on your gender as the source of your suffering, it is not hard to project your current suffering onto your past self.
If your little kid past self was happy in those pictures of themselves as a toddler whose parents put them into stereotypically gendered clothing, this creates cognitive dissonance.
The young person doesn’t have the distress tolerance or maturity yet, to integrate that little kid self (a boy, in this case) with their current self-concept as a trans person. Online trans communities frequently parrot the idea that if you’re trans now, it means you were always trans/the opposite gender, but that no one recognized it. Photos are the evidence that this is false. That you weren’t always trans.
Getting rid of the photos and the items with the birth name is one way to remove the evidence that creates that dissonance.
/1
(Pictures: me as a little girl, a minor teen, legally adult teen [trans-identifying, presenting as a guy] and now as a 27 year old woman)
Quotes a post by A0976; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
For as long as deranged leftist trans activists respond like this to being confronted with basic biological reality, ordinary trans people will keep losing the social accommodations they were granted on the basis of a compassionate exception.
Quotes a post by T24612; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Cisgender” is an absurd term.
In no other condition, is there the need to create a specialized social term to describe the non-suffering majority, to make sufferers of a condition feel more normal.
Only a fraction of the general population has schizophrenia. We don’t refer to the non-schizophrenic majority as cis-sane.
We don’t have a special name to refer to people who don’t have and have never had, cancer or diabetes in order to placate the feelings of those who do have those conditions. We just call those people “healthy.”
“Trans” describes, depending on who you ask, a small portion of people who either have gender dysphoria, or take social/legal/medical steps to be seen as the other sex, or who identify as neither sex, or all of the above.
People who don’t suffer from this condition of gender identity confusion, disorder or sex distress, do not need to label ourselves in relation to an issue that does not afflict us.
We are simply men and women who don’t have gender issues. We are simply MEN and WOMEN.
The layers of delusion here are incredible!
First of all, male fetish behavior and arousal patterns do not determine who is a woman. Only female biology does.
Secondly, i’m not a cis anything. I’m a woman who no longer believes in the delusion that she should’ve been born male.
Thirdly, I’m not trying to compete with Hunter. I have no reason to. Hunter is male and I’m female. Between us two, Hunter will always win at the competition of being male and I will always win at the competition of being female.
Fourthly, my post isn’t declaring an attractiveness contest. It is declaring that there is a fundamental biological difference between women and men who approximate a female appearance through various artificial means.
Some people, mostly men, are into males (men) with a mixture of feminized traits and male traits.
I, on the other hand, am a woman who is interested in other women who are also interested in other women.
Someone like Hunter is not competing with me for the same dating pool. Hunter is competing with other transwomen for A/GAMP men, and perhaps occasionally with other transwomen for GAMP women.
So your theory about my motivations actually does not make sense.
Lastly, femaleness is not a ‘looks thing’ men can achieve by competing against their own biology in potentially health- harming ways. It is only something they can vaguely approximate in a limited capacity, and even that is unattainable for most. Most trans women are read as either nerdy men with long hair, or as a distinct category of trans woman; and not as women. Hunter reads as trans. There’s nothing wrong with that. In my opinion, being read as trans is a morally neutral thing. If a given individual enjoys it, that’s fine and dandy- more power to them. But, even if Hunter did read as 100% female, Hunter would still not be female and therefore cannot be a woman.
It is frankly offensive to women that males feel as though they have the right to refer to themselves as one of us, sharing none of our embodied female experiences, insofar as they get silicone boob implants and mess with their endocrine systems enough.
My experience of having a female body, and living my whole life in a female body is in no way comparable to that of a male person who has a stated erotic desire to modify their body to look more feminine than it did before.
Adults of sound mind should make their own body modification choices with an understanding of the risks. But them doing so, doesn’t require everyone else to disregard the visual and auditory evidence of an mtf transitioners male biological reality by pretending that males who transition are not only somehow women, but that they are better women than actual women.
Quotes a post by T06133; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Why is it a pro-trans position to encourage trans people to take hormones that are causing them brain damage or could lead them to an early death?
It sounds like what actually want, is for gender dysphoric and trans people, to…. die???
Quotes a post by T27424; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The woketards who bungled the investigation into the murder of 19 year old trans college student Juniper Blessing are committed to woketarding their way into turning Seattle into a favela
Quoting @Polymarket: JUST IN: Seattle police are now referring to shooters as “trigger pullers” to avoid stigmatizing language, as the city responds to a recent surge in shootings.
The only happy long term trans men I’ve ever met acknowledge that they are women who want to present as men. The unhappy trans men I’ve met, try to delude themselves into thinking they’re actually men and are never able to measure up.
Do you want trans people to be miserable?
Quotes a post by T07394; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The only happy long term trans men I’ve ever met acknowledge that they are women who want to present as men. The unhappy trans men I’ve met, try to delude themselves into thinking they’re actually men and never being able to measure up.
Do you want trans people to be miserable?
Trans men are women, and therefore can and do experience misogyny.
Men who are bullied for being too girly are having a uniquely male experience of social exclusion. It’s called “effeminiphobia.”
Effeminate men aren’t women, even if they think they are.
Quotes a post by T32150; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Blaire White has no problem saying “I’m a man. Transsexual women are a subcategory of men.” The trans community is clearly divided on how to refer to themselves. That’s for your community to continue debating. It’s not my place to mediate or to adjudicate those inter-community debates.
Additionally, one can recognize and state biological reality for what it is, without having any mal intent.
I for instance, don’t call male people “men” (or female people “women”) for any reason other than that it is factual, in the same way as I don’t call people “autistic” to insult them; but rather to state a relevant fact in a relevant context.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Blaire White has no problem saying “I’m a man. Transsexual women are a subcategory of men.” The trans community is clearly divided on how to refer to themselves. That’s for your community to continue debating. It’s not my place to mediate those debates.
Additionally, one can recognize and state biological reality for what it is, without having any mal intent.
I for instance, don’t call male people “men” (or female people “women”) for any reason other than that it is factual, in the same way as I don’t call people “autistic” to insult them; but rather to state a relevant fact in a relevant context.
Ruh roh. I think I’m beginning to embark upon the first part of what you’re describing. I’ll book mark this for later. How many years into this are you, remind me? And did this cycle start initially in detransition or several years in? Cuz imo, I was stuck in some version of the trans mindset (not ideology) and associated feelings for probably the first two ish years of detransition. This is probably normal. The logical brain smells the bullshit before the emotional brain can process it outside of a thought experiment
Considering that every trans person is either male or female, of course bisexuality as a concept doesn’t exclude them. Whether people attracted to both sexes are also necessarily attracted to a mixture of male and female sex characteristics in one individual; is hotly contested.
Quotes a post by T30229; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In a culture that has until very recently fully normalized beating child as a form of discipline (“spanking”), it’s no shock that chemically castrating (“trans”-ing) little boys as a punishment for their failure to conform to macho man standards became so quickly normalized.
Embracing my inner autistic weird girl, instead of spending the rest of my life trying to turn her into a pretend (“trans”) man is the best decision I’ve ever made in my life.
Repost if you agree that autistic youth deserve protection from the harms of gender identity ideology.
Trans vs. Detrans:
How dumb it was to think that I needed to bind my breasts and damage my body in order to dress how I wanted.
Wanna know why I thought this?
Because I was a teenager.
It’s almost as if trans identities in children and adolescents are just an idiom of distress for youth growing up in the 2010’s and beyond.
There’s nothing mystical about why the types of kids who have ALWAYS struggled, in every generation, are getting sucked into this generation’s identity crisis topic.
Troubled teenagers who struggle to meet developmental milestones due to a wide array of underlying reasons will have a probably more combustible adolescent identity crisis than is typical.
This generation, they’re going trans. In the past generation, they’d go for eating disorders, heavy illegal drug use, crime, or develop any number of mental illnesses. Adolescence is a very vulnerable time.
The difference between other maladaptive teen coping mechanisms and with trans is that parents are expected by culture and most clinicians, to help the child develop deeper into their role confusion, rather than to resolve it, so as to emerge into adulthood with a stable identity.
The difference between trans and other teen identity crises, is in what the ADULTS are doing, it is not in what the kids are.
No one is entitled to have a child who does not struggle and who does not suffer. Life is struggle. Life is suffering. It just is. Americans have a Disney picture book version of reality that they become depressed about when it does not come true, even though it is a fairytale. Not everything in life has a happy ending. This doesn’t make anyone necessarily a victim. It is just reality.
Some people’s struggles are worse than others. A gender identity struggle is not for the faint of heart. That is why adults should be fostering resilience into distressed adolescents rather than confirming that their nightmares will come true.
The kids who are struggling with gender issues are not struggling *because of* their gender issues. Rather, their pre-existing, developmentally-impairing issues are what cause them to struggle so badly that they’ll latch onto whatever answer the culture gives them to explain their distress. It is a tale as old as time.
I say this as a detransitioner myself:
Can we stop acting like there’s a uniquely transgender, uniquely malicious conspiracy to incite extraordinary struggle into otherwise totally developmentally typical, mentally healthy, well-adjusted, and non-traumatized children?
Quoting @JamieWhistle: I don’t think I’ve ever mentioned this before publicly, but we should talk about it.
When we say that trans targets vulnerable populations- we rarely discuss the young people who are adoptees.
Rates of trans identification is high among teens who are adopted- especially when the adoption is international or cross cultural.
Day 2 of my re-transition update:
Some of you haterz told me that I’ll never be a real superhero because I wasn’t born a superhero. Some of you haterz are trans yourselves.
If you think a man can become a woman and vice versa, why can’t a woman become a superhero? BIGOTS
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: I’ve got an important announcement to make:
I’ll be re-transitioning.
I know this will disappoint many of you who have gotten to know me as a detransitioner.
But just know that I won’t make the same mistakes in transition this time around.
Rather than making the mistake of thinking I can to transition myself from female to male, this time, I’ll be transitioning myself from an ordinary female human to a female superhero (on wheels.)
What are you transitioning into?
Trying to become a man instead of embracing my quirks as a woman was the stupidest and most adolescent thing I’ve ever done. So glad my 12 year long trans phase is over. What a mindfuck.
For some reason, when I was coming out of my trans mindset, there was one song I listened to over and over again. It’s an Israeli song from the 70’s that is just joyful. I’m skating super fast in this video. I hope you all enjoy it.
I love having internet friends with whom I spiritedly disagree on certain issues (trans/gender for example) while we also spiritedly support each other’s skating endeavors. This is how interactions should be!
Quotes a post by T00486; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I am quite literally not trying to convince everyone who sees me that I am the opposite sex. You and other trans people do that. It’s not about some inner essence or metaphysical state. It is a choice of self-presentation.
You’re the only person who looks at me and sees a trans man. It’s comical.
People without a weird gender brain worm look at these pics (all taken within 24 hrs) and see a young, short haired woman wearing various, (weather and activity) appropriate clothing styles.
It’s always funny to me when half of the trans people who find me on here think that I was never trans, and the other half think I’m still trans. Am I a litmus test of something?
Quotes a post by T20475; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m literally just a woman. Not a trans anything. I’m done with that phase. Trans was a relic of my youthful stupidity which maturity has absolved me of. I literally just have short hair lmao.
Quotes a post by T20475; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I imagine a better world frequently: a world in which Palestinians want peace too, a world in which no child or vulnerable adult is maimed by the farce of transgender medicine, and a world in which I can go skating with my best friends @LauraBeckerReal & @TTExulansic
I worry about every other pre-teen & teen girl who is instructed, just like I was, on how to bind her developing breasts by trans influencers online.
Why? Because those girls grow into young women who, like me, have damaged upper bodies that HURT & doctors don’t know how to help us because this whole thing is an experiment they’re doing outside of a laboratory.
Does that make sense?
Quotes a post by T00486; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s such a relief to have grown out of a 12 year long trans phase. Yes, sometimes phases are *that* long.
Skating in my (female) body is so much more fun than pretending to be an orthodox-ish Jewish guy.
I’ve lived a wild 27 years so far. Can’t wait to see what’s next.
Being a weird woman is infinitely better than being a pretend man.
If you can only be a happy trans person by being a drunk trans person, you should probably quit your transition. It’s not worth it.
(Me not even 4 years ago vs. me today.)
The same delusional men who think @NancyMace looks trans now have spent the last 2 years telling me I look like a man because I have short hair.
Nancy; don’t listen to those loons. You look damn awesome.
Quoting @NancyMace: Thoughts and prayers to all those affected by my sleeves.
Made the mistake of opening my social media this afternoon. Some of yall are OUT OF CONTROL.
My biceps should NOT be a news story. We have more important things to worry about.
Goodness. And God Bless America. 🙏🇺🇸
Gender weirdos being gender weirdos doesn’t actually bother me at all. I make very few social judgements, usually to my own personal detriment. It must be an autism thing.
My genuine contention with trans on an interpersonal level is that now that I’m a woman who isn’t pretending to be a man, men who are still pretending to be women are quite a potential risk to my safety and privacy if they are in spaces where I may undress. And if they recognized their male-ness and stayed out, them being gender weirdos doesn’t matter to me and I suppose it shouldn’t matter to others. Though admittedly, most people who aren’t me, do make social judgements in an intuitive way that I know I do not.
Let’s be honest. No one cares about the men’s bathroom or about whether trans men or even sometimes just average women who can’t wait for the line in the ladies go in there. The issue is about safeguarding women and kids from male intruders.
When trans activists tell kids they can be born into the wrong bodies, we shouldn’t be surprised that disabled kids will think they’re transgender 🏳️⚧️
As someone who was born prematurely and grew up with various neurological disabilities, I bought into the trans lie as a 12 year old: because of those very disabilities.
I already felt that because my body couldn’t do everything that other kids my age could, because I had to wear leg braces and spend my free time in doctor’s offices only for no one to be able to “fix” me; something unnamed about me was fundamentally very wrong.
And so I, like any intellectual-leaning pre-teen went searching for the right way to name this condition, which developmentally speaking, I was becoming acutely aware of.
Then comes along this explanation of “if you feel like your body is wrong, it means you’re trans and you should’ve been born the opposite sex” and any suffering kid with a lifelong feeling of physical wrong-ness could buy into it.
This is especially so because they’re told there’s an easy solution to their pain.
And they could be set down a path, just like I was, which ends up making their pre-existing disabilities (be they physical, neurological or social) even worse.
There is no justifying that. That is not care. It is evil.
Repost if you agree.
They could just say that trans women are trans women, which are a subcategory of men, and no one would actually care. That’s the thing. People don’t care about alternative lifestyles when those participating are reasonable.
Quotes a post by T23466; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
They could just say that trans women are trans women, which are a subcategory of men, and no one would actually care. That’s the thing. People don’t care about alternative lifestyles when those participating are reasonable.
🚨Lying to everyone about who you are is unsustainable and it is a recipe for misery. 🧵
Unlike Jason Arday who was coddled well into his forties with every social protection in place, I learned this lesson when I lived as a largely stealth trans 🏳️⚧️ guy in the Middle East for five years.
In the highly religious/ conservative areas of Israeli and Palestinian societies in which I found myself, I had no protected status.
There was no social expectation to coddle me. I got honest feedback about which sacrifices I’d need to make EARLY.
As I dodged military checkpoints with an “F” on my passport in groups of Arab and Jewish dude-bros, I not only worried about getting caught in places I wasn’t allowed to be in, but I was constantly worrying about what would happen if a soldier checked my passport and let it slip to my male friends, that I was a woman.
The risk of deceiving the locals about my sex was mine alone to take.
As a female who did this, the risk of harm to me if the truth were revealed would be borne by me alone.
(This three-part thread will be my expansion of some of the ideas discussed by @[private account] and in the wake of Jason Arday’s suicide)
/1
Quotes a post by A0882; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
After being trans for a long time, and then being detrans for a shorter time, I’ve come to the conclusion that I was born into the right body after all, but with the caveat being my body’s annoying propensity for foot cramps
🚨Is gender euphoria real?
(This poll is for trans 🏳️⚧️& detrans 🦎 people only)
Plz answer according to trans/detrans status. You can specify more in the comments if needed.
The next/last poll is about your predictions.
🚨Is gender euphoria real?
(This poll is for trans & detrans ~ adjacent people only)
Answer based on your natal/chromosomal sex.
Next poll will be based on trans/detrans status
🚨Is gender euphoria a real thing?
First, tell me who you are. Then in the next poll, we’ll get your vote.
(Only answer this one if you’re trans 🏳️⚧️ or detrans 🦎)
I asked both trans and detrans people whether they thought that “gender euphoria” was real.
Half answered “yes” and the other half answered “no.”
I’ve decided to expand my dataset
(Comment & fill out the polls below with your opinions)⬇️
Trans-identifying doesn’t equate to transition desiring. Today’s Gen Z and Gen Alpha youth are not Gen X. We don’t live in trans 1.0 anymore. We came of age in the age of endless socially acceptable alternative gender identity schemas, which does give socially acceptable off ramps to confused teens who choose to take them.
Trans acceptance as per Jesse Singal’s AI generated image= being looked upon lovingly by a harem of theyfabs born between 1997-2005, with one trans woman thrown in for good measure.
This must be peak Millenial cringe.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
🚨 Every therapist who works with gender dysphoric youth should be somewhat of an autism expert.
You can’t do the job properly without a somewhat deep understanding of neurodevelopmentally diverse populations, how their brains process information, and on recognizing when your psychotherapeutic training alone has not equipped you with the ability to understand the full scope of this kid’s disability-related needs, which are all contributing to their high level of distress.
And no “they go trans cuz they don’t fit in with normal people” is NOT a deep enough understanding of how profoundly sensorily distressing it is to grow up with neurodevelopmental divergence and disability. I see tons of GC-aligned therapists whose understanding of the ASD/GD overlap only goes this far. That isn’t far enough.
(I personally was so autistic that fitting in with my peers was not my driving concern. My driving concern was a desire to make sense of what was wrong with me and to find a framework, a set of logics, and a system to grow into. I had almost nothing to do with kids my own age. I cared about brain tumors and memorizing the DSM 4/5 because I thought of adults as my peers. I’m n=1, but still. I’m a case study.)
This surface level understanding on the part of so many GC-aligned therapists should be corrected with deep analysis and personal curiosity. The ASD/GD overlap has so many prongs that getting tunnel visioned on trans as a social popularity strategy for autistic 12 year olds is barking up the wrong tree.
This surface level discourse will never, ever, actually help autistic/gifted/adhd/twice exceptional kids with above average IQs to cope with their human condition, with embodiment and with coming of age while being smart enough to understand that you are disabled but not being told why or what you can do to overcome very predictable difficulties.
And lastly- we should not assume that time alone plus talk therapy, in the absence of various specific developmental interventions, will do anything but ensure that this type of kid becomes even more entrenched in the adolescent self-concept they concocted to make sense of distress that no one has given them words for.
If talk therapists are not trained in autism, or have not worked with autistic people before, they should understand that this is a significant limitation in caring for gender dysphoric youth populations.
And it is a limitation which a responsible therapist should address by requiring, suggesting or referring parents of these kids to seek the care of other developmental specialists, including but not limited to: speech therapists, occupational therapists and physical therapists.
Kids like the one I was at 12, are probably too impaired by their autism or adhd to even benefit from talk therapy. They sometimes need other interventions first.
Quotes a post by T17683; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Being trans 🏳️⚧️ was a 12 yr. long excuse I’d use to justify my lifelong bad habit of autistically dissociating from my body.
Until three months ago, when I started skating. Life feels so incredibly worth living now.
Skaters & onlookers- am I out of beginner territory yet?
When I was trans and in my mid-late teens, I was of the opinion that trans visibility was one of the worst things to ever happen to trans people.
Not only did trans visibility make the prospect of quietly blending in impossible, but it attracted the most annoying allies.
When I was trans and in my mid-late teens, I was of the opinion that trans visibility was one of the worst things to ever happen to trans people.
Not only did trans visibility make the prospect of quietly blending in impossible, but it attracted the most annoying allies.
Quoting @BuckAngel: Stupid trans allies have completely made this happen
Not even the label. Autism is a disorder. Whether the label is applied to any given person who has the condition or whether the person is undiagnosed doesn’t change how autism impacts someone’s thinking. Girls on the spectrum in particular are know to be good at somewhat concealing their autistic traits, or at least disrupting others less with them. I see trans in autistic girls as another attempt for girls to mask their autism. Autistic traits in girls are seen as more masculine traits anyways so it’s just easier for such a girl who is logical and blunt and doesn’t like emotional chitchat by avoiding having to admit inadequacy and instead to transition to a role where her natural tendencies aren’t criticized as much.
So basically autumn’s school of thought is AGP=crossdresser with antisocial tendencies whereas trans= a totally separate group with different needs?
Interesting.
I found it fascinating to learn that there are AGPs who are totally asexual and sex repulsed, though that’s probably more of a potential moderate to severe autistic response to the sensory input of human intimacy rather than being anything specifically dysphoric, as most dysphoric people who are less autistic than those types do tend to desire some kind of sexual intimacy but struggle to be comfortable with the actual acts of it. I’ve only ever seen that particular asexual presentation of AGP in certain types of autists.
They don’t seek sexual relationships with others likely due to lack of social skills or desire to socially interact much, but are content to immerse themselves in special interests all day. But it’s not as if they have no attractions. It’s just that their attraction to women manifests as an attraction to self as woman. That’s how I understand it. But yeah there are both prosocial AGPs and antisocial AGPs. The more mentally ill, the more antisocial. The more mentally healthy, the more prosocial.
I’d just like a reference point for what gender euphoria actually feels like to those who report experiencing it or having experienced it.
This could apply to trans and detrans people.
This was not a huge topic of conversation in FTM spaces when I was in them, but it was somewhat discussed.
Some FTMs describe experiencing gender euphoria while binding. I can’t say I ever did. What I experienced was more of a sensory relief via compression that calmed me down so much that I failed to interpret the bodily cues that would suggest to me that my upper body was being absolutely destroyed. I was too calmed down to be euphoric. Though perhaps for others they experience a different chemical reaction in their brain, similar to that I feel on skates. Who knows.
Others, I can tell, are experiencing a level of euphoria on testosterone injections which can make them almost manic.
Any thoughts about MTF/FTM differences in relationship to the term ‘gender euphoria?’
The more I thrill seek on skates, the more convinced I become that ‘gender euphoria’ is likely the byproduct of any number of psychoactive drugs which trans people commonly take.
Do you agree, disagree or have another explanation? ⬇️
My life improved measurably when I stopped being trans and started understanding my autism.
It took me YEARS into my twenties to understand that being the weird autistic woman that I really am, is far more sustainable than is the costly pursuit of trying to mask my ‘tism with a gender transition.
I learned with time and experience that though being a pretend man in a highly sex segregated Middle Eastern society did indeed make it easier to parse less complicated social cues; just like all other autistic masking strategies embraced a bit too ardently, pretending to be someone else for the sake of social ease only brings more grief.
In addition presenting as a man didn’t solve my lifelong antipathy towards my body, which has always been sensory in nature and can only be mitigated by meeting my sensory needs. Had I known this sooner, I would have invested far fewer eggs into the trans basket.
Once I understood that the only reason I felt immediately better after a haircut is because I have sensory issues with my hair touching my neck and cheeks, and not because I had a male brain in a female body, I became truly liberated to embrace my own comfort over the pressure to conform to rigid gender stereotypes.
It is only since I began to understand my condition and to acknowledge my fraught relationship with my body and my difference from other women, for what it actually was, that I was able to start choosing my health over my desire to prove to the world that I was correct about the conclusion I came to about myself as a 12 year old.
Thank God for growing up.
Trans men in men’s sports: fine. Compete at your own risk.
Trans women in women’s sports: not fine. Your participation poses a risk to safety, fairness and dignity of those for whom the women’s category exists.
Transition involves individuals to make significant sacrifices in the hope that those sacrifices will pay off later.
It is not the job of society to soften the blow of the sacrifices made by individuals.
The sacrifices inherent to the gender transition pathway should be fully taken into account by mature adults who choose to modify their bodies and lives in this way.
Anything else is unsustainable to society, and detrimental to the individual who is tasked with making such a life-altering choice.
The new ‘moderate’ trans activist opposition to letting some men play in women’s sports comes from this wave of male WNBA prospects’ eligibility being a bad look for the trans community.
It isn’t actually based on a concern for the safety & fairness of the women for whom the category exists being threatened by these men.
It isn’t even based on an argument that the presence of a male transsexual wouldn’t significantly disrupt the environment of a women’s locker room or sports category.
Those are just givens. Acceptable collateral damage for the whims of male individuals’ cross-sex identity affirmation.
This new moderate position is not based on anything other than literally just… this is uniquely bad optics for us because these NBA guys with a clear advantage have beards whereas the other sports guys with a clear advantage who competed against women were clean shaven, had long hair and had slightly atrophied their muscles with estrogen while calling themselves by feminine names.
The new ‘moderate’ trans activist opposition to letting some men play in women’s sports comes from this wave of male WNBA prospects’ eligibility being a bad look for the trans community.
It isn’t actually based on a concern for the safety & fairness of the women for whom the category exists being threatened by these men.
It isn’t even based on an argument that the presence of a male transsexual wouldn’t significantly disrupt the environment of a women’s locker room or sports category.
Those are just givens. Acceptable collateral damage for the whims of male individuals’ cross-sex identity affirmation.
This new moderate position is not based on anything other than literally just… this is uniquely bad optics for us because these NBA guys with a clear advantage have beards whereas the other sports guys with a clear advantage who competed against women were clean shaven, had long hair and had slightly atrophied their muscles with estrogen while calling themselves by feminine names.
I still haven’t heard a good argument as to why males of any variety (whether they describe themselves as trans women or whether they were pubertally blocked, or whether they’re on estrogen), should be included in women’s sports.
Have you?
The new trans activist opposition to letting some men play in women’s sports is based on this being a bad look for the trans community.
It isn’t actually based on a concern for the safety & fairness of the women for whom the category exists, or even on an argument that the presence of a male transsexual wouldn’t significantly disrupt the environment of a women’s locker room or sports category.
It’s literally just… this is uniquely bad optics for us because these NBA guys with a clear advantage have beards whereas the other sports guys with a clear advantage who competed against women were clean shaven, had long hair and had slightly atrophied their muscles with estrogen while calling themselves by feminine names.
Quotes a post by T01740; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The research on which trans sub population?
-puberty blocked at tanner 2 males?
-post pubertal males on supradoses of estrogen & T suppression for X # of years?
Which of these populations is equivalent to the spread of natal female athletic abilities, rather than at best sitting at the upper edge of lung capacity/grip strength/muscle twitch fibers, skeletal size etc
It is not enough to hypothesize that puberty blocked males have no advantage over female athletes because the advantage must only result from the pubertal testosterone wash. Those extraordinary claims must actually be backed up. And they cannot be substantiated with the evidence we have now.
Additionally, even puberty blocked males still experience several testosterone washes in utero and pre-puberty which give them physical advantages over females of the same age. Those pre-existing advantages only grow with pubertal testosterone. But they do not appear for the first time at puberty.
Enough males have been puberty blocked to where these tests could be run if someone had a desire to. But no one does. I suspect one reason for this, is that the osteoperosis and joint issues caused by puberty blockers for years (in the cases of GAC) would contribute to why such individuals are not the trans women who find themselves competing in any professional sports. It is simply too precarious for them to continue practicing recreationally to maintain that advantage. Due to a pharmaceutically induced disability. Even so, they are male people with a disability. This does not make them female. This makes them potentially Paralympic eligible. That would be a reasonable policy proposal.
The fact remains that the burden of proof that fairness and safety can be maintained while including any male individual in any category made for female individuals, is on those who advocate for a change to a policy and norm that was instituted for very sensical reasons. But even beyond that, sports come with changing rooms. Women and girls should not have to see male genitals in their locker rooms. You may as well just disband women’s sports if you are intent on allowing even one male individual to compete in them. Male individuals will not be harmed by competing against other males, or on co-ed teams. There is just no pragmatic reason to advocate for the inclusion of any male athletes in female sports.
Quotes a post by T01739; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It is not enough to hypothesize that puberty blocked males have no advantage over female athletes because the advantage must only result from the pubertal testosterone wash. Those extraordinary claims must actually be backed up. And they cannot be substantiated with the evidence we have now.
Additionally, even puberty blocked males still experience several testosterone washes in utero and pre-puberty which give them physical advantages over females of the same age. Those pre-existing advantages only grow with pubertal testosterone. But they do not appear for the first time at puberty.
Enough males have been puberty blocked to where these tests could be run if someone had a desire to. But no one does. I suspect one reason for this, is that the osteoperosis and joint issues caused by puberty blockers for years (in the cases of GAC) would contribute to why such individuals are not the trans women who find themselves competing in any professional sports. It is simply too precarious for them to continue practicing recreationally to maintain that advantage. Due to a pharmaceutically induced disability. Even so, they are male people with a disability. This does not make them female. This makes them potentially Paralympic eligible. That would be a reasonable policy proposal.
The fact remains that the burden of proof that fairness and safety can be maintained while including any male individual in any category made for female individuals, is on those who advocate for a change to a policy and norm that was instituted for very sensical reasons. But even beyond that, sports come with changing rooms. Women and girls should not have to see male genitals in their locker rooms. You may as well just disband women’s sports if you are intent on allowing even one male individual to compete in them. Male individuals will not be harmed by competing against other males, or on co-ed teams. There is just no pragmatic reason to advocate for the inclusion of any male athletes in female sports.
I think “many” is an overstatement. Advocating for any kind of trans moderation has been extremely fringe, and even those fringe voices have largely cropped up now that there are criticisms of the mainstream trans movement. They were not a counter-force to trans extremism in its heyday.
But regardless, why should any male people be allowed to compete in a sports category that was designed to provide fair and safe competition to female people? There is already a category for male people to compete in, and there are co-ed categories which include people of both male and female sexes.
As trans supportive as Mr. Radcliffe claims to be, little Danny hasn’t released a transition celebration post for his new celebrity sister. Disappointing.
As trans supportive as Mr. Radcliffe claims to be, little Danny hasn’t released a transition celebration post for his new celebrity sister. Disappointing.
Quoting @EnesFreedom: Happy birthday to my brother Daniel Radcliffe!
Thank you for making our childhood truly magical. #HarryPotter 🔮🧹
Enes says she’s a trans woman. Therefore she’s a trans woman.
If trans women are women, then Enes is a woman.
If Enes is a woman, she should be eligible to play in the WNBA.
If you’ve advocated for trans women’s inclusion in women’s sports, you don’t get to be mad about this.
Quoting @EnesFreedom: After careful consideration and reviewing the current eligibility guidelines,
I’m officially declaring myself a @[private account] prospect.
If simply declaring who you are is all that’s required, then I meet every single requirement necessary to compete in the WNBA.
My team and I have carefully examined the WNBA’s eligibility criteria and governing framework surrounding self-identification and inclusion. Based on the current guidelines, I can and am officially declaring my eligibility for the upcoming WNBA draft in April 2027.
I know my presence on the court will stir up strong opinions.
I am definitely not here to mock, make fun of, or disrespect any community or personal choices.
I’m simply asking that the current rules be applied equally to everyone — the rules that represent the very values many WNBA players and coaches have publicly advocated for.
My team and I are prepared to ensure these guidelines are applied equally, consistently, and without exception, and I look forward to the #WNBA honoring its stated principles.
See you at training camp.
https://enesfreedom.com
In addition to Michelle’s very sensical concerns, I’ve got a few of my own.
Detransition-related medical care minus gynecology at this clinic will be capped at the age of 21. So basically, no help for most of the young people harmed, who don’t realize it until they grow up (mid 20’s).
TCH’s detrans clinic’s eligibility requirements mean that even with excellently competent clinicians, they won’t be able to help even a fraction of the kids their hospital has harmed because they will be too old to qualify for care when they realize what they’ve lost.
This begs several questions:
Will the clinic close if it doesn’t receive an influx of patients? (Most won’t be young enough to recognize they’ve been harmed to qualify for most available treatments, and youth alone masks a lot of pain…. Even really serious pain.)
How many people will it turn away who show up at 22 and have concerns which aren’t gynecological or obstetric in nature?
Does it have no duty to use available resources to help those patients too?
What will happen to 22 year old patients who come in with complex neuropathy from breast binding, genital tucking or various surgical interventions? Has this clinic truly estimated the complexity of their potential patients’ health needs?
How will this clinic ever have a big enough sample size to run studies about long-term outcomes and complex physical injuries & psycho-social traumas resulting from the very horrors their hospital has inflicted?
Both gender medicine and cleaning up the messes of gender medicine, in the hopes of restoring as much function as is possible, are totally experimental.
People who choose to detransition are only a fraction of those harmed by gender medicine. Because gender medicine as a field refuses to admit where it does harm and to use the little that it does know, to establish protocols to treat the injuries it causes, that work should fall on these emerging detrans clinics.
Otherwise, it’s all just lip service to uphold their end of a lawsuit framed as another identity-based rather than need-based form of healthcare. Providing identity based healthcare, rather than need based healthcare, by the way, was gender medicine’s original sin. Or as Michelle says, “an inversion of trans clinics”
If this proposal is a starting point with the goal of expanding to older patients, by which I mean, mostly young people who are still in their 20’s & 30’s, I’d be jumping up and down.
But as it stands, there is now not enough information for us to know whether these emerging clinics will actually help people with transition-related harms to recover. For that, you NEED as many patients as you can get and you NEED to follow them long-term.
🚨The first line treatment for gender dysphoria in autistic girls should involve: roller skating, trampoline jumping & sensory integration therapy.
It is unethical to encourage girls’ autistic trans-mask-ing by socially & medically experimenting on them.
Who agrees?
can you translate the lyrics of “kalam” by Mashrou’ Leila, denoting (m) and (f) after every Arabic word which has a masculine or feminine ending and provide a rudimentary explanation of how Arabic’s gendered grammar works so the anglophones can understand what a truly subversive gender song looks like? Their pedantic, personality disordered worldview (trans)/gender-based navel gazing bores me. Is it possible to even explain to anglophones how subversive this Lebanese song is?
To every leftist who has threatened to rape (or curb stomp) me, or who has sent me death threats for openly talking about why I stopped being trans 🏳️⚧️
I pity your miserable existence. But I do not wish you harm.
Instead, I hope you all find joy.
Like I have.
When I lived as trans, I needed alcohol to have fun. I lived a life in which I was hiding my true self. I thought that being a man was the most normal path I could find for myself as an autistic girl. Until I quit transition, stopped drinking and started skating, I didn’t realize just how beautiful it is to be alive.
I know it’s normal in the trans community to use suicidal threats to get what you want. And that threatening to hurt others or wishing harm on them is also pretty normalized. That behavior is unacceptable in a civilized society. Be a role model for your community. Do better.
C2 false claimshand-codedsuicide tauntvictim dismissalviolence terror
Everyone is all “listen to trans people” until a trans person says “my trans identity is a symptom of a dissociative identity disorder, a severe mental illness that has wrecked my life.”
Why is that?
Quotes a post by T15338; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think your analysis is honest… that there are different levels to being trans. Some communities think that all levels are trans whereas others do not
FTM and MTF communities are very different. And also, most of my transition I was not in the US and not chronically online. There are cultural differences to these things. Assuming that all trans communities have the same streams of discourses would be assuming a monolith fyi
I never thought trans people were a monolith lol. I’m just trying to understand the social boundaries of the community as it has changed a lot since I’ve had proximity to it in the last almost 15 years
I’ve been hearing more discourse about trans people being transphobic to other trans people. Yall are going to have to make this make sense. What does that even look like?
Why would I want to renounce my sincerely-held beliefs in order to be accepted back into a cult that has endlessly bullied me not merely over differences of belief, but over my appearance and disabilities that I was born with and have no control over?
Nah. I’m done with you authoritarians.
I have a stable sense of self. I do not require the love-bombing of a conglomerate that will only accept me under the condition that I live a profoundly inauthentic life.
My need for in-group companionship has been satisfied by expanding my notions of ‘in group’ status to include people whose beliefs significantly diverge from my own, but who enjoy discussing and debating them with other people whose beliefs significantly diverge from their own.
Trans activists and gender critics alike are both right and wrong about different aspects of this phenomenon at the same time.
As such, there are endless ideas to discuss. I personally enjoy spirited debate far too much to find myself in yet another echo chamber.
I have perfectly satisfying friendships with my fellow non-authoritarian, pluralistic gender weirdos (both those who are trans or detrans of some flavor, or just broadly gender non-conforming).
The mainstream LGBT community of today simply cannot compete with the freedom of being friends with a pluralistic group comprised of rag tag gender weirdo autists.
You seem like someone who may actually fit into the community I’ve built here in my spaces on X. I invite you to join us.
Dysphoric people are probably more likely to be more aware of certain sex differences that the general population doesn’t perseverate over.
‘Trans’ is a term that has no singular definition and therefore can be applied to any number of people who have objectively nothing in common other than the fact that they use this word to describe themselves.
A large number of the people who describe themselves as trans will say “how dare you assume my gender by looking at me!” Or “girls can have penises and boys can have vaginas.” Such people are clearly very confused about sex differences. Whether they believe these things or are just saying them as a cope, I’m not sure.
Not everyone who describes themselves as trans buys into statements of this variety, probably because they are extremely dysphoric and are acutely aware of everything about themselves that is discernibly male or female, masculine or feminine.
So by my statement I’m not saying that I don’t value the opinions of trans people (people who self describe in this way, regardless of how similar or dissimilar they are). I’m saying that I don’t value the opinions of people (anyone who is a homo sapien) who cannot tell the difference between a boy and a girl.
The trans-medical community should decide on whether they’re treating a medical condition which they can prove exists, whether they’re modifying people’s bodies for fun, or whether they’re conspiring to make people miserable. Why can it not decide?
Quotes a post by T15026; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The reason there are trans people who are against the thousand micro genders is because they understand that it makes trans people look either insane or unserious in the eyes of society.
At the end of the day, everyone is only motivated by their self-interest. It’s evolutionary.
Quotes a post by T02540; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Even though we disagree about the trans stuff, we are both Israelis so we have each other’s backs. In today’s climate, nothing else matters.” —@[private account]
Truer words have never been said.
This non-binary Zionist Jew seems like a cool person who is on a path to a good future (student debt free) and has moral clarity on the difference between self defense and genocide.
Knowing the difference between these things is usually a good indicator of a baseline normal to high IQ and of baseline mental stability.
Even if our thoughts about gender don’t fully align, knowing that moral clarity does exist even as a minority stance in certain leftist and queer or trans communities (at least on some issues) does give me a lot of hope for our Western civilization.
May this individual be successful at changing the idiotic ideas held by the vast majority of Gen Z trans/non-binary/ leftists.
Quotes a post by T15956; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s not supportive or unsupportive of a trans identity to tell someone that it is the job of their therapist to not judge them for making such a disclosure. It is a fact. Therapists who are responsible are not supposed to affirm or reject the conclusions their patients come to about themselves. It is to guide the patient into understanding themselves and their thoughts and feelings with more clarity.
I spent my whole childhood disassociating from my body due to spastic muscles and sensory issues.
I spent my teens & early 20’s disassociating from my body by being trans.
It is genuinely odd to, at the age of 27, experience my first moments of not hating my body.
Oh trust me, I felt it. I felt a strong mind-body disconnect for as long as I can remember but I put words to it such as “I have a male brain in a female body” when I was 12.
This mind-body disconnect predated my transition, it continued throughout transition, and it has stayed with me in detransition.
What might explain this?
I was born prematurely (weighing 1.2 kg at birth) and I have a lot of random neurological issues which make me feel body feel like is a malfunctioning machine over which I have no control. I have a lazy eye I can’t control, and my muscles are kinda spastic. I have to spend almost half of the day under an electric blanket just to warm them enough to have something resembling pain-free mobility. I wore leg braces as a kid to correct my toe walking, and they gave me Botox to relax my legs.
In addition, I have sensory processing issues which confound the picture and make me feel quite at odds with my body in most situations. I’ve always struggled with understanding that it is my reflection looking back at me in the mirror. It’s almost an object permanence issue.
This disconnect, I interpreted as a gender issue for a long time because it was the only schema I was given. But now that I understand myself as someone who has an autistic brain in a female body, I have come to accept the situation for what it is. And for me, having an accurate understanding of why my experiences with embodiment are so fraught, has relinquished me from the desire to live as a male.
There are many pathways into gender dysphoria and there are many pathways out.
Many gender dysphoric people don’t have physical or mechanical problems with their bodies which precipitate their negative gender feelings, but I did.
The point is, there are tons of causes for gender dysphoria, and they vary by the individual. I personally do not believe that gender dysphoria is one condition, but rather a constellation of many. And for some people, it is clearly a symptom of a more complex neurodevelopmental condition which has plagued them from birth or from early in life, than it is a standalone event.
You are more than welcome to believe in the spiritual ‘wrong body’ explanation for gender dysphoria. Not even all trans people believe in this as the truth (especially most Gen Z-ers, I’ve noticed), and some see it as more of a metaphor or a shorthand by which to explain their condition to others.
I think of gender dysphoria as distress about one’s sex and/or associated expectations. This distress can occur at various points in life and for many different reasons. It seems reductive to presuppose that all of these various presentations of the condition in previously unheard of cohorts could be explained by the same pathology in all sufferers.
If I didn’t relax my calves with scalding hot baths in addition to 10 hours under an electric blanket, I’d probably need a walking stick at my advanced age of 27. But that’s because I got brain damage from weighing less than three pounds at birth. I know quite a few preemies who have gone trans at this point. It’s certainly not a majority, but clearly a number of us have had some kind of birth or early in life neurological trauma. I’ve known quite a few trans men with cerebral palsy as well. But most of them have connective tissue disorders like Ehlers danlos syndrome, which those who have a similar condition and have detransitioned or quit taking T say that the T accelerated their condition
Gen X trans people are built different. They have emotional resilience and a sense of humor.
Younger trans people (zoomers) are predominantly humorless, constantly offended leftists who can’t even pretend to be happy unless they’re on 20 different psych meds.
Quotes a post by T01739; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans ideations can really throw a wrench into adolescent identity development, or it can spur it on for those who explore their feelings rather than immediately following or suppressing them. It’s a learning opportunity for the adolescent, and it should not be taken at face value.
It means that your trans friendship circles are chronically Gen Z and are still going through their adolescent identity vs. role confusion stage well into their twenties
Quotes a post by T08100; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My name is Maia Poet, and I am the woman from this video (I was 25 or 26 here, and now I am 27).
I am NOT a teen.
And I went trans in 2011/2012 before TikTok even existed.
It means that your trans friendship circles are chronically Gen Z and are still going through their adolescent identity vs. role confusion stage well into their twenties
It’s funny how many TERFs and conservatives have fallen for this psyop. Have none of you watched how trans affirming parents talk about their kids? None of them refer to the kids as ‘son’ or ‘daughter’ as per the kid’s biological sex. This “dad” is a Troll https://x.com/TheWyteRabbit1/status/2079338814032736632/video/1
My disagreement with the ethos of today’s gender medicine dogma, is mostly with the one size fits all treatment for gender dysphoria.
Those suffering from other conditions (be they physical or psychiatric) are usually are presented with multiple potential treatment options and a detailed risk/benefit analysis of them all so they can make an informed decision. The same is not true for the treatment of G.D. And the social & medical transition treatment pathway presented by clinicians as the only treatment for gender dysphoria, is extremely invasive and not backed up by high quality evidence of benefit, yet gender dysphoric people are lead to believe that it is their only opinion, without any differential diagnosis or less invasive alternatives even being explored.
Everyone is just funneled down the same path regardless of their underlying physical and mental health issues.
It is no wonder that rates of dissatisfaction with the care they receive in the gender clinic is increasing both for trans people (who increasingly are going DIY even if they have the option to go the gender clinic route) who stay happily trans and for those who detransition.
I don’t hate trans people and I never have. I too am a gender weirdo. People like to spread insane propaganda about me, which is deeply unfair and untrue. Do I have disagreements with predominant clinical practice in this area, and with the philosophical constructs around it? Yes. But do I hate my fellow gender weirdos? No.
The trans person was female who clearly has not transitioned and does not appear in any way male, OP is a lesbian woman, and they were casually hooking up.
OP was not deceived about the sex of the individual. She was not informed that the other individual had a private concept of herself as being a man on the inside.
Why in that context does it matter that the other woman has a secret male identity in her head?
Yes this was two girls hooking up. One of them believed herself to be a man on the inside but didn’t disclose her trans thoughts to her hook up partner who is a woman that holds her lesbian identity in such high regard that she doesn’t want to hook up with women who say they’re men, because in her gender ideological mind, the woman who thinks she is a man might as well have been a man.
This woman feels like she was raped because her female hookup partner didn’t disclose trans thoughts that she was evidently not acting on.
I really think we’ve encouraged young women to use the word “rape” to mean “disappointment.” And that is NOT ok.
Quotes a post by T33207; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My level of optimism in these photos is a bit too 2010’s Millenial coded, but I’m used to LARPing as the gender I am not, so a trans-generational LARP would be nothing new to this Zoomer.
Trans mascs tend to have absolutely no gender nonconformity, though some of them are lesbians who are pretty GNC and basically use the label instead of “butch lesbian” or something like that. Also check out this funny street name
I think it’s unwise to pretend that transition alone will magically alleviate someone’s potentially extremely complex distress.
Transition, even in cases where it does at least in the short term alleviate suffering, should always be paired with additional strategies (which in absence of transition could suffice for some in mitigating distress).
I say this because transition is incredibly difficult and turbulent, and a large number of those who undertake it are so unsuccessful at biopsychosocial sex mimicry that their misery just continues, or it is so unnatural to them that they feel as if they are putting on a costume.
I’ve met trans people in both of these camps, who discuss how badly they wish to be feminine again but they’re still committed to their trans male identity (weird, but not uncommon).
Transition requires a certain level of resilience which my generation has been coddled from developing, and thus they fall apart over being misgendered when they very evidently still are legible as their biological sex.
This behavior is unreasonable, potentially anti-social in manifestation, and it makes the individual miserable to have this expectation and to have an inability to regulate their emotions when the expectation uncomfortably brushes against reality.
And in the absence of alternate coping strategies, dysphoric people will be more likely to be driven entirely by their distress and make irrational transition and life choices because they are grasping at straws and just, trying to feel better.
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think it’s unwise to pretend that transition alone will magically alleviate someone’s potentially extremely complex distress.
Transition, even in cases where it does at least in the short term alleviate suffering, should always be paired with additional strategies (which in absence of transition could suffice for some in mitigating distress). I say this because transition is incredibly difficult and turbulent, and a large number of those who undertake it are so unsuccessful at biopsychosocial sex mimicry that their misery just continues, or it is so unnatural to them that they feel as if they are putting on a costume. I’ve met trans people in both of these camps, who discuss how badly they wish to be feminine again but they’re still committed to their trans male identity (weird, but not uncommon).
Transition requires a certain level of resilience which my generation has been coddled from developing, and thus they fall apart over being misgendered when they very evidently still are legible as their biological sex. This behavior is unreasonable, potentially anti-social in manifestation, and it makes the individual miserable to have this expectation and to have an inability to regulate their emotions when the expectation uncomfortably brushes against reality.
And in the absence of alternate coping strategies, dysphoric people will be more likely to be driven entirely by their distress and make irrational transition and life choices because they are grasping at straws and just, desperately want to feel better.
When I was a child, I was lead to believe that my lifelong embodied discomfort & gender-atypical tendencies meant that I was transgender 🏳️⚧️.
For 12 years, I thought that the only explanation for why I was the way I was, and why I felt the way that I did, was that I had a male brain in a female body.
But that was NOT true.
In truth, I was just a girl with very normal autistic problems which impacted my ability to: relate to other girls, be normal in any way whatsoever, and to process sensory input.
Throughout my transition and detransition, I’ve changed my appearance I lot. I’ve gone from being perceived overwhelmingly as male to being overwhelmingly perceived as female.
But in both presentations, my body drives me insane to such an extent that wishing I had no body whatsoever has been a daily wish of mine from a very young age.
The ONLY time I am truly comfortable in my body is when I’m skating.
What makes me comfortable in my skin, it turns out, has nothing to do with what gender other people see when they look at me.
And it has everything to do with how my body feels in a very literal, sensory way.
And whether my clothes and hair are an assault on my senses or whether they are tolerable.
Simply wearing clothes that do not make my skin hurt has made me stop wanting to remove my sensate organs, namely my breasts (which have become almost entirely insensate because of the decade of breast binding anyways).
I guess skating gives me the type of sensory input I crave, and I would do it all day if I didn’t have other responsibilities.
How have you learned to become more comfortable in your body?
Tbh I was still an idiot at 16/17 but I did understand by then that it was fully within my control to not kill myself even if I didn’t end up on testosterone, because in those 4/5 years I had not killed myself as predicted by Johanna Olson Kennedy who I watched say this in multiple “trans kids” documentaries from the 00’s & 10’s. And with the extent of my literal thinking, it’s honestly a miracle that I made it there over those few years and had to bend my brain to realize that transition and suicide were not the only options. Of course I still had the itch to transition. But I knew that whether I killed myself was my choice, and I wasn’t actually depressive so I had no wish to do that.
16/17 year olds are still extremely immature, and their ability to conceptualize of the next year (let alone the next 5, 10, 20 or 60) is dubious at best. But they are developmentally worlds away from 12 year olds who barely understand that if they take their puppy out for a walk on roller blades, they could get badly injured if their puppy gets distracted by a plastic bag on the road and decides to chase after it (speaking from personal experience). So that’s all I’ll say on that.
It’s funny how you think I’m trans or that I try to pass as a guy in my daily life lol. Being androgynous in the dark at night is not the same as trying to pass as the opposite sex.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: From the age of 12 to my early 20’s, I thought that binding my breasts & convincing everyone I was a guy would give me the ability to exist freely in society. But now at 27, I can’t even fathom breast binding in the summer. What a prison it was. I’m so lucky to finally be FREE!
I’d like every reasonable trans person to learn the difference between a newfound hobby and whatever-the-fuck a “hate grift” is. Then, I’d like you to teach this difference to your compatriots. Though, they will probably also consider you transphobic, so maybe don’t even bother.
Quotes a post by T21999; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Some people just really love to hate me. I have a small group of my favorite weirdos on here, some trans, some detrans, some totally unrelated to the topic but are interested onlookers and we enjoy each other’s company. I don’t need to impress the personality disordered.
That was not at all a part of the trans messaging I was exposed to in 2011/2012 as a seventh grader, nor was it a part of the neurodiversity activism I sought out without a single such diagnosis in 2010/2011 as a sixth grader who read a lot of books made for adult therapists lol
Money is probably the main motivation for the expansion of gender services on the part of the providers, but there is also an ideological “gender identity” narrative created by a small group of men who want to castrate themselves for well-known reasons and this narrative requires both women and children to also be subsumed under the trans model, even though the quality of their distress is hardly analogous to what said group of male adults do.
I think teen girls are good at picking up on the zeitgeist. Teen girls are the group which creates by far the most new words (in slang) across cultures. I basically predicted the trans phenomenon of Gen Z girls by hopping onto it in 2011/2012 before everyone else did. I did the same with neurodiversity in 2010/2011 when I was in sixth grade. I never wanted ‘being trans’ to be something that got me attention. I wanted it to be something I’d do and become normal so adults would stop demanding me to change everything about myself in order to placate social norms that even kids my age weren’t brute force requiring me to do. And I liked having the ultimate autistic roadmap to follow. Transition has so many steps. I really enjoyed having steps to follow.
All 12 year olds are extremely easy to influence and trans messaging which effectively says “if you’re wondering if you’re trans, you probably are… no cis person would think about it this much” will convince just about every ASD/OCD pre-teen that they need to try to change their gender.
Quotes a post by T28997; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
All 12 year olds are extremely easy to influence and trans messaging which effectively says “if you’re wondering if you’re trans, you probably are… no cis person would think about it this much” will convince just about every ASD/OCD pre-teen that they need to try to change their gender.
“Dysphoria” just means “distress.”
I know that it’s trendy for gender critics to pretend that no people experience gender/sex distress. If that were true, nothing we call ‘trans’ would exist & none of us would be here talking about it.
Whatever happened to living in reality?
Quotes a post by A1617; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Doctors should see this as a cry for help, and not as a clinical mandate.
Phalloplasty surgeries are dangerous, barbaric and have a practically guaranteed complication rate.
The trans community should not encourage its own to risk their lives for
non-functional genitals.
Quotes a post by T24222; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Even in the most extremely progressive American environments I’ve been in where every possible transition intervention is fully covered, where pronoun sharing is the norm and where LGBTQ+ people are the literal town majority, transitioners still frequently attribute their post-transition poor mental health outcomes to ‘transphobia’ which in those environments just does not exist.
And in the inverse, the Palestinian trans people I’ve met who literally have to flee attempted honor killings from their family members frequently discuss being so grateful for their lives now, they are well-adjusted, multi-lingual and just do not seem mentally ill like their privileged, American college kid counterparts.
How do we explain this discrepancy, if not for a combination of both broader cultural differences and individual temperamental differences?
There should absolutely be separate trans prison wards. I totally agree. I’m a huge advocate of third spaces because transwomen have unique needs from other members of the male sex class and because women also deserve spaces that are able to meet their unique needs of their sex class; needs that cannot be met when there is someone that everyone can see is biologically male, walks in.
Some would go further and argue that those rights are violated even when a passing transwoman walks in but I think that if someone is a rare bird who actually passes (rather than just getting validated by their Reddit friends into thinking they do) they by definition do not disrupt the atmosphere. This type of contention to me seems totally ideological. If someone’s presence doesn’t raise red flags to everyone who sees them, and that person doesn’t use their passing appearance as a gateway to offend against women, then their mere presence doesn’t elicit a fear response or cause harm to the women in the space. That said, I still think that the policy should enforce sex segregation and those who think the can pass really well should take that risk if they want to use those spaces. Otherwise you have a situation in which any man can legally walk into a women’s space and the women can’t say anything. And I’m talking about bathrooms or changing rooms etc here. Not prisons. For prisons there just unequivocally needs to be a trans ward with some kind of requirements so the guys who prey on you don’t try to pull the same shit as they would in gen pop, and so that women have their own prison space.
My side is pretty full of libertarians lol. Trans activists are the ones who make unreasonable demands and then get shocked when there’s a backlash. As you can see through this exchange, the mainstream pro-trans position is “who cares how women feel about us in their spaces.” Whereas in the past, the pro-trans position was “go where you cause the least friction.” The trans movement has become highly anti-social because everyone went along with it when the movement was pro-social, and stuck with it even when it became anti-social. And now there’s a refusal to moderate the movement. So the backlash will continue.
Passing transwomen like yourself and like @[private account] often tell me that they are sexually harassed by the exact types of trans identifying males/transwomen that women are worried will enter our spaces while we change.
These men are motivated to violate the boundaries of anyone they perceive to be female. They will go trans to gain access to communities and spaces where they can victimize. Transmen are also quite commonly victims of the predatory behavior of these types of self-identified transwomen. One way to recognize them are: transwomen who don’t boymode (they instead crossdress) while also not caring about passing (they think it’s a bigoted concept), while also knowing they don’t pass, while also demanding to be in women’s spaces. That’s the archetype we are discussing. Everyone who has ever been in a trans community has met at least one mtf like this.
The only people who promote this narrative that it’s bigoted to keep spaces sex segregated are the ones who demonstrably don’t pass (and therefore can’t fly under the radar if such policies are enacted) and also who don’t care about the class of people (women) that they are trying to become. It’s really quite striking to notice. The fact that so many trans people have fundamentally anti-social motives is another reason as to why there’s so much backlash. It’s a profoundly bad idea for transwomen to say “we’re not predators” and then also to say “you’re bigoted for being scared when we walk in on you getting naked in a women’s only space because we do not care about how you all feel, we care only about our own whims and desires.” There is obviously a male-brained-ness to this way of thinking and like you said, it reads as being exceedingly creepy.
Quotes a post by T06478; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Passing transwomen like yourself and like @[private account] often tell me that they are sexually harassed by the exact types of trans identifying males/transwomen that women are worried will enter our spaces while we change.
They are men who are motivated to violate the boundaries of anyone they perceive to be female. They will go trans to gain access to communities and spaces where they can victimize. Transmen are also victims of the predatory behavior of these types of self-identified transwomen who don’t boymode but also don’t care about passing but who knowing they don’t pass, demand to be in women’s spaces. That’s the archetype we are discussing.
The only people who promote this narrative that it’s bigoted to keep spaces sex segregated are the ones who demonstrably don’t pass (and therefore can’t fly under the radar if such policies are enacted) and also who don’t care about the class of people (women) that they are trying to become. It’s really quite striking to notice. The fact that so many trans people have fundamentally anti-social motives is another reason as to why there’s so much backlash. It’s a profoundly bad idea for transwomen to say “we’re not predators” and then also to say “you’re bigoted for being scared when we walk in on you getting naked in a women’s only space because we do not care about how you all feel, we care only about our own whims and desires.” There is obviously a male-brained-ness to this way of thinking and like you said, it reads as being exceedingly creepy.
We all live in a society with other people. There is a benefit to recognizing this fact, especially when we make decisions which put us at odds with or separate us from most other people in our trajectories. In liberal societies, individuals have a high degree of freedom to live as they feel most comfortable, but those freedoms do not constitute a right to impinge upon the safety of others.
The fact remains that most mtf transitioners do not pass as women at all. This is especially so, to women, whose sex detection is generally far superior to that of men for evolutionary reasons (women need to know who is a potential mate/threat and who is an intrasexual competitor because of the reality of the reproductive burden of pregnancy whereas men frequently get tricked by Thai ladyboys.)
As such, someone who is clearly male, regardless of how they identify and their intentions, existing in spaces where female people are in various stages of undress, causes great psychological distress in a great number of those women, who feel their privacy is violated and will worry about their safety.
When I detransitioned and found myself in a women’s locker room for the first time in years after avoiding locker rooms like the plague, I heard an obviously male voice as I was undressing and this was terrifying. I only saw this individual after having run into a panic into a shower which could’ve been opened by anyone at any time via a curtain, and it was clear that this male person was trying to present as female.
What scared me so much about this was not that this clearly male person tried to present as female, but rather that a male person did not announce his presence before entering a place where women were naked, which gave us no chance to hide. I for one did not even feel safe enough to bend over and collect my glasses which had fallen, and I am blind without them, which only added to the feeling of defenselessness.
We as women do not know which male people are a danger to us, and we will assume that male people who go into spaces where we are undressing who don’t wear a cleaner’s uniform and who don’t announce their presence, are there to take advantage of us. There is nothing we can do about that.
This situation presents a quandary in which the interests of a minority of male people who wish to be women, most of whom are still perceptible as male, are at odds with the interests and rights to the half of the human population which is female.
The only way to honor the needs of women and girls to have spaces which are for women and girls only, while also accommodating the presence of biologically male individuals who present in a gender atypical way (whether they identify as trans or not), this population deserves the choice between male spaces and gender neutral spaces; wherever they feel most comfortable between the two.
When the requests of a micro-minority population directly conflict with the needs of half of all humans, society cannot run itself effectively by pandering to the micro-minority. The attempt to do this over the last decade and a half has wrought the very chaos which today’s trans community currently experiences.
All pro-social people make minor personal sacrifices to exist in the world with other people. That minor sacrifice in this case should be a third space or a biological sex aligned space in the case of someone who is clearly male but has an ambiguous appearance of various flavors.
Quotes a post by T04132; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We all live in a society with other people. There is a benefit to recognizing this fact, especially when we make decisions which put us at odds with or separate us from most other people in our trajectories. In liberal societies, individuals have a high degree of freedom to live as they feel most comfortable, but those freedoms do not constitute a right to impinge upon the safety of others.
The fact remains that most mtf transitioners do not pass as women at all. This is especially so, to women, whose sex detection is generally far superior to that of men for evolutionary reasons (women need to know who is a potential mate/threat and who is an intrasexual competitor because of the reality of the reproductive burden of pregnancy whereas men frequently get tricked by Thai ladyboys.)
As such, someone who is clearly male, regardless of how they identify and their intentions, existing in spaces where female people are in various stages of undress, causes great psychological distress in a great number of those women, who feel their privacy is violated and will worry about their safety.
When I detransitioned and found myself in a women’s locker room for the first time in years after avoiding locker rooms like the plague, I heard an obviously male voice as I was undressing and this was terrifying. I only saw this individual after having run into a panic into a shower which could’ve been opened by anyone at any time via a curtain, and it was clear that this male person was trying to present as female.
What scared me so much about this was not that this clearly male person tried to present as female, but rather that a male person did not announce his presence before entering a place where women were naked, which gave us no chance to hide. I for one did not even feel safe enough to bend over and collect my glasses which had fallen, and I am blind without them, which only added to the feeling of defenselessness.
We as women do not know which male people are a danger to us, and we will assume that male people who go into spaces where we are undressing who don’t wear a cleaner’s uniform and who don’t announce their presence, are there to take advantage of us. There is nothing we can do about that.
This situation presents a quandary in which the interests of a minority of male people who wish to be women, most of whom are still perceptible as male, are at odds with the interests and rights to the half of the human population which is female.
The only way to honor the needs of women and girls to have spaces which are for women and girls only, while also accommodating the presence of biologically male individuals who present in a gender atypical way (whether they identify as trans or not), this population deserves the choice between male spaces and gender neutral spaces; wherever they feel most comfortable between the two.
When the requests of a micro-minority population directly conflict with the needs of half of all humans, society cannot run itself effectively by pandering to the micro-minority. The attempt to do this over the last decade and a half has wrought the very chaos which today’s trans community currently experiences.
All pro-social people make minor personal sacrifices to exist in the world with other people. That minor sacrifice in this case should be a third space or a biological sex aligned space in the case of someone who is clearly male but has an ambiguous appearance of various flavors.
Some trans people hate the fact that there are many people who can resolve their gender dysphoria without transitioning until they die. What explains this?
Quotes a post by T26730; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When I was a 12 year old trans kid, I could have never expected that someday I’d be on the beach, on the eve of my 27th birthday, and this at peace in my female body.
There should be a Jewish conversion approach to gender transitions. Since the first points of contact these days are trans communities rather than gender clinics, communities must do the gatekeeping first
I was happy while trans and I’m happy now. But the happiness I had while trans was at some point largely mitigated by being a half functional alcoholic. I’m happy while sober now.
I have such a fraught experience with embodiment that I believe I needed to disown my body in order to appreciate actually taking care of it and living with/in it
There are no objective metrics of who is “true trans” or what that even means. Some people transition and are happy for a short while, for a medium while and for a long while. And people at each of those stages could develop regret and either stop doing it or continue doing it and being regretful. And others will continue being happy with their choice. That’s ultimately the truth. We don’t know who will persist the longest. We have ideas of that now, but no certainty
The lack of sugar coating is a must. People need to understand how miserable they will be if they aren’t certain they can pass. And perhaps if they pass but lack insight into their motivations, they will be miserable too.
Either they’ll have to live in foreign lands or in a trans-queer only bubble to make the transition possible. It is an unfulfilling life, and it is limiting.
I’m skeptical that encouraging men like this to transition, has been in the best interests of existing trans people.
But I’m open to a reasoned argument from you, Ava.
In my opinion, it is in the best interests of current trans people to discourage as many new people from transitioning as possible.
Do you agree or disagree?
In my opinion, it is in the best interests of trans people to discourage as many new people from transitioning as possible.
Trans is like an immigration issue. Rather than just integrating new people into a pre-existing society, transition as an option socially, legally and medically creates a new class of people who are entitled to access services to which most people are not entitled: including, cosmetic surgeries paid for by the state or by private insurance, access to spaces of the opposite sex and access to anti-discrimination protections on the basis of mutable rather than immutable characteristics.
And in some circumstances and in some jurisdictions, transitioners are dis-entitled from accessing certain forms of sex-based healthcare. I’ve known several transmen who get pregnant, carry the baby to term and because they look male and are legally male, the birth of that child is something they must pay for out of pocket due to insurance codes. And in other cases, because they look like men, if they do have a female reproductive system related emergency, they will not be screened for it. This risks their lives, and the lives of their children.
All of these things place burdens on society and on healthcare systems.
Trans protections are at their core very generous accommodations. They grant selective, one off exceptions to the rules we have established as a society in order to run as smoothly as possible for the greatest number of people. The more people who are allowed to access these exceptions, the more of a burden is placed on larger subpopulations within that society. Resources are limited.
Encouraging unstable people who will never be able to socially integrate, just to make a larger political contingent is both a disservice to those people, and it is not good for society.
Nobody cared that much about transsexuals back in the olden days, like 15+ years ago. If they managed to pass well enough, they would be treated like normal members of society where people could have normal interactions with them, rather than constantly worrying about offending someone who is clearly too sensitive and socially mal-adjusted to take responsibility for the consequences of their own choices.
When the vast majority is expected to treat trans people with kid gloves and to never offend them by expressing normal curiosities, they are in effect, dehumanizing trans people.
In a normal society, people get to offend each other without risking getting fired. When people feel the need to walk on eggshells around someone because of their non-conforming appearance, it actually prevents them from ever getting to know you.
Having trans people as a class be the exception to this norm, both infantalizes and dehumanizes them.
Human relationships need friction, conflict and co-resolution in order for us all to coexist on mutually agreed upon terms.
Clearly, trying to mainstream and institutionally reify the destructive, countercultural impulses of young people by squashing any debate or criticism of it, has been a disaster both for the youth in question and for the people who transitioned 15+ years ago.
Transitioners of the past had far more pro-social impulses than today’s transitioners do, on balance.
Most of today’s younger and ideologically motivated, ill raised transitioners are clearly trying to disrupt society by demanding to be pandered to. They feel entitled to get everything they want without needing to work for it and to make concessions.
I believe this difference is explained precisely because of how frowned upon it was to make such a choice and to not do it convincingly enough to blend into the mainstream. And due to the gatekeeping of the past which effectively weeded out most people who may have wanted to pursue such a thing.
Transition, even in the most tolerant societies, requires immense sacrifices, that Gen Z has been primed to think do not exist.
And they are not required to take on most of these initial risks themselves, by needing to save up for expensive surgeries which they needed to go to intense therapy before they would be allowed to access such things.
Both financial and time constraints which used to give people more time to consider the consequences of this path have all but disappeared today. The objective consequences of the transition pathway, however, have not.
The trans dogma we grew up on, told us that most gender-related interventions were reversible, that basically no one regrets it, that transition is a fine thing to do even if you don’t have gender dysphoria.
For the older half of Gen Z, gender transition as an escape for adolescent suffering was glorified on social media and in schools.
The inherent sacrifices of the physical interventions used for cross-sex appearance body modifications have been largely passed off as basically reversible, even when they are not.
The inherent sacrifices of the social interventions have been made superficially easier by progressive online and irl bubbles, and by laws that have endangered the rights of women across the anglophone west in order to accommodate men whose presence is visibly disruptive, presents a danger, and is unwelcome. Any man can say he identifies as a woman as a way to get access to women. That is a huge problem that did not exist.
The friction of changing your appearance and role in society has been artificially decreased, because any normal annoyance or uncomfortable interaction can now be framed as “transphobic” rather than as a part of the transition process which, if someone does not enjoy putting up with, will be valuable data they would have used to disembark from the real life test in the past.
The modern discourse around transition which is totally blasè about the number of sacrifices which are inherent to transition and do not disappear even in the most tolerant societies, leaves youth who are considering this option, totally unequipped to understand just how much of a toll this could take on their health and on their lives.
And unfortunately, in the attempt to be kind and compassionate, our society has done a great disservice to very vulnerable people by insulating them from the early challenges that are easier to recover from, while promising them a panacea which in the absence of any viable alternatives, they will continue to pursue long after they have doubts about its ability to measurably improve their lives.
Quotes a post by T18687; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I probably would have been less defensive if not for all the trans people who sent me death threats just for telling my story. But yeah I probably should have just ignored them rather than going back and forth on it. I’ve changed my approach to having conversations as I’ve matured, and I now have plenty of trans friends on the web with whom we both agree and disagree without losing our minds. If you’re interested in that type of interaction you are more than welcome to join my spaces. We are pluralistic.
Oh yeah telling my story of how transition didn’t solve my gender dysphoria has just done soooo much harm to people who people who have had a different experience. How tragic that we all have different experiences with how we come to terms with our bodies! I will now donate to a trans charity in shame for the fact that I didn’t need to be trans forever in order to be happy. Because that’s reasonable
Unreasonable trans people hate me.
Reasonable trans people like me.
You actually can just get to know me instead of developing some weird Maia Poet derangement syndrome….
you know, like reasonable people do when they disagree with others’ view points.
Quotes a post by T25345; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I wish more Gen Z girls understood this:
Just because you’re a girl who happens to be an autistic gender weirdo, it doesn’t mean you have to be trans or non-binary. You have the choice to just be weird.
It took me 12 years to realize this fact because I thought living as trans or passing as a man would make me “normal.” And in some ways, it did.
But that veneer of normalcy came with too many problems, none of which I willingly signed up for. Now that I’ve stopped doing that for a couple years, I’ve taken a lot of solace in embracing my identity as an odd duck.
I’ll be 27 in one week, and honestly, at my ripe old age, after having gone through the hell of living my life for the expectations of others, I’ve come to the conclusion that being normal is incredibly overrated.
When I was trans, I was *choosing* to fight against my body every single day.
Without thinking I was making a choice, I chose to live life on hard mode for no good reason.
But I’ve come to realize that being trans in my teens & early twenties was like training for a marathon with sandbags strapped to my ankles.
Now that I’ve taken those off, I’ve started cooperating with my body instead of choosing to pick fights with it every day. Now, flying into the next chapters of my life as a truly free person doesn’t seem so daunting after all.
You could narrow the scope to the Dutch protocol archetypal kid while specifying that when you interrupt the sexual development of pre-teens to preserve their neotenous appearance as early as possible, you really don’t know how their orientation would otherwise develop. In this case, the GC conversion therapy argument could apply as a potential outcome of the pathway or as an implicit motivation of any number of given doctors or parents.
But perhaps it is better understood as a poor set of priorities and assumptions based on adult transsexual cohorts and their retrospective self-analyses and the extent to which those cohorts are analogous to the younger ones. It was based on an idea that such a kid who experienced intense cross-sex ideation and cross-sex behaviors for years prior to puberty will invariably have a transsexual outcome and so it is best to ensure the ‘best’ or most passable transsexual outcome, or to exclude the possibility that the kid could grow up to be gay and happy, or to prioritize a passable transsexual outcome over a gay outcome despite the health consequences.
But we still don’t know how many of the Dutch protocol kids would have grown up to be gay vs. straight vs. bi if they hadn’t received the intervention because such a thing is unknowable. At least with the male child cohorts we have other data sets to compare them to, but those data sets span decades where absolutely no parent would have been okay with a gay or GNC outcome but social and medical transition were off the table, all the way into the decades where the burgeoning gay rights movement began.
The reason I specify that cohort is not because I think the experiment was done well or was even ethical to conduct in the first place, or because I believe in/ or that they are “true trans” (I absolutely do not), but because there were both male and female children who were transitioned under it, and for the most part, at least in the initial stages of the protocol, social transition did not occur prior to the administration of the puberty blocker.
The latter fact is important because socially transitioning a kid who is developmentally pre-sex constancy, regardless of their chronological age, totally confounds the question of whether they are experiencing gender dysphoria or whether they are experiencing developmental confusion about the permanence of one’s sex.
It would be a more honest GC argument to narrow their scope and to discuss the medical experiment’s motivations, because even in the earliest adult transition cases, these doctors thought they were converting homosexual men into women and lesbians into men.
They were so motivated to do this that they would only do it if the patient could convince the clinician that this was the case, whether it was true or not.
We can’t deny the anti-gay motivations of this experiment. We also don’t need to pretend that the landscape has not changed dramatically in ways that the original clinicians practicing in this area could have never predicted. Regardless, it’s a patently unethical thing to do to someone of any age who cannot demonstrate having achieved certain cognitive-developmental milestones in addition to the persistence of the gender dysphoria after thorough differential diagnosis and treatment of underlying conditions where relevant.
Idk. I think transition could be classified as a form of conversion therapy because you’re trying to convert someone from one thing or into something else. That thing isn’t always from gay to pseudo-straight. It could also be from straight to pseudo-gay.
One could make the argument that the generation of FTMs you’re talking about who were lesbians and then on testosterone pursued partnerships with men, were on the receiving end of conversion therapy which actually changed their sexual orientation alongside predisposing them to a myriad of health issues. If the patient’s intention is to convert themselves from gay to straight with an identity and appearance change, and an unintended consequence of the intervention causes a change in sexual preferences which would not have occurred otherwise, is that not a sort of conversion therapy?
Yes, conversion therapy has an explicitly anti-gay connotation, and yes, most of today’s transitioners who are around my age or younger are either not even slightly same sex attracted and are open about it, or they are theoretically same sex attracted but don’t ever pursue it. Being exclusively or even meaningfully same sex attracted puts you in the minority of zoomer trans & gender dysphoric populations. But the fact remains that regardless of sexual orientation or behavior, there is a conversion taking place from one category of thing into another. It’s just not a phenomenon which can be accurately painted as exclusively an anti-gay one.
I don’t really advocate for bans. I’m agnostic on them because they’re not my area of focus.
I advocate for a sober and non-ideological understanding of transition for those who desire it, for the exploration of alternate treatments which can be used in addition to or instead of transition for those who suffer from GD but have deemed transition to be incompatible with their life goals, and for an exploration of the ASD/GD overlap, particularly in girls who are the sex most likely to be diagnostically overlooked only to present with gender issues that are far from intractable but are the problem most likely to be “treated” with interventions which do not help this population to reconcile with their bodies. Look at who ends up detransitioning, and at who remains trans but suffers by far the worst physical and mental health outcomes, and my argument has merit.
But yeah I’m definitely not in favor of people who are young and particularly immature for their age due to a (neuro)developmental disability being put down a highly consequential pathway with uncertain benefits and a certainty of harms without any assessment of whether they are capable of insight around their motivations and the extent to which transition as a strategy is capable of meeting those motivations.
Three facts and three jump shots:
1. Being a quirky woman with an unconventional style does not make one a man. Or ‘non-binary.’
2. Trans people don’t own gender non-conformity.
3. Crocs are the best jumping shoes, but only if you wear them with socks.
Repost if you agree.
Why do you take seriously a random stranger who calls me they them. Like clearly this individual thought I was trans and doesn’t like my advocacy and is trying to discredit me
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27300085/
Here’s just one study sampling 1,800 trans masculine adults, many of whom began binding in adolescence, and their outcomes. 97.2% experienced at least 1 of 28 categories of harm. There are multiple different binding methods outlined in this research and none of them are safe.
There is no evidence suggesting that breast binding can be done safely, especially in growing children.
There is a lot of evidence to suggest that doing it for gender affirmation reasons causes harm in over 97% of cases.
You do not have the evidence on your side and so you resort to histrionics.
Breast binding does not reduce distress. It actually compounds it. It prevents girls from coming to peace with their bodies while actively damaging their growing bodies in ways that will cause them even worse distress than their gender dysphoria did.
Many of these girls will grow out of their gender dysphoria by their mid to late twenties, and they will be forced to contend with the consequences of their poor adolescent judgement in addition to the aftermath of being lied to by adults like yourself who should know better than to suggest that teen girls ‘affirm’ their male ‘gender identities’ by using interventions that are known to harm them and are unknown to have any measurable benefit.
I’m not the one being malicious to teenagers who identify as trans. You are.
⬇️
Quotes a post by T00819; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Like many trans people, I’m an autistic gender weirdo.
The difference is just that I’m not delusional anymore in thinking that my autistic gender weirdness means I am supposed to be a man.
I don’t want trans people dead. But for some reason, so many of them want me dead. Odd.
Quotes a post by T32558; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The quote tweets are full of trans people who are really upset that I’ve finally found peace in my skin and in my identity as a woman.
Surely, they should be the happiest to learn when someone once suffered from gender dysphoria and no longer does.
Surely that’s why they’re doing this whole transition thing, right?
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: I’ll be 27 in two weeks. Damn shame I wasted most of my youth cosplaying as a guy. Being a weird woman is so much better. If only I’d embraced it sooner.
Here’s an essay about how I used a trans identity as an attempted way to ‘mask’ my autism and related (neuro)developmental confusion.
You can read my work, exploring the overlap of autism and gender dysphoria in girls here ⬇️
Repost to share it with parents & doctors.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨could normal autistic & ADHD teen struggles (going undiagnosed) be the reason so many autistic & ADHD girls think they need to ‘mask’ by being trans boys? 🏳️⚧️🧩♾️
Read my essay to find out:
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/when-trans-masc-becomes-another-mask?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
I’m a counter-propagandist. You see, for a decade and a half, trans influencers have been spreading the lie that breast binding can be done safely.
According to them, it’s even safe for teen girls, who are still growing, to bind their breasts. They have neither evidence backing up their claims nor the credentials to give medical advice to children.
Trans activist propaganda around breast binding misleads insecure teenagers and causes them immediate harm for the price of putting them on a potentially lifelong pathway to potentially infinitely more complex and multi-system harm.
I’m here to disrupt that dangerous messaging and to replace it with facts.
Quotes a post by T00819; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m a counter-propagandist. You see, for a decade and a half, trans influencers have been spreading the lie that breast binding can be done safely. According to them, it’s even safe for teen girls, who are still growing, to bind their breasts. They have neither evidence backing up their claims nor credentials to give medical advice to children.
Trans activist propaganda around breast binding misleads insecure teenagers and causes them immediate harm for the price of putting them on a potentially lifelong pathway to potentially infinitely more complex and multi-system harm.
It’s actually insane. Binding is just objectively dangerous. There’s no evidence it can be done safely esp. while growing.
Do trans people not have the same interest in protecting young, naive, prospective trans people that everyone else does?
To those saying I’m evil:
Trans people influencing middle schoolers to dangerously bind their breasts while calling it “safe” is evil.
I’m just telling my story.
My story is one of reconciliation with my female body after waging a decade-long war against it.
That’s NOT evil
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: I’ll be 27 in two weeks. Damn shame I wasted most of my youth cosplaying as a guy. Being a weird woman is so much better. If only I’d embraced it sooner.
I have plenty of trans friends and absolutely none of them have become my friends by engaging in veiled knife threats. They engaged with me in good faith, and I returned the gesture. Now we are friends. That’s how it works.
1. Juniper wasn’t killed for being trans. Juniper was killed because a sadist wanted to kill a woman and perceived Juniper as one.
2. No evidence of foul play has been found thus far as it relates to Murry’s death.
Trans people can exist safely in the West. Why are you trying to make them think that they cannot with your disgusting manipulations?
Quotes a post by T32485; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’ve pissed EVERYONE off by saying that it’s wrong to make light of murder or to politically fetishize it.
Half of these insane people think I hate trans people. The other half think I now hate women.
Can ya’ll just stop being so insane and start being human. Or rational?
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨I was wrong.
When I entered the gender conversation publicly, I thought that “my side” (the gender critics) were motivated in our advocacy by our concern about the welfare of the young people who are being haphazardly placed onto an experimental social & medical gender transition pathway based on a shoddy evidence base underpinning.
Apparently, I was wrong.
Turns out, some of you on “my side” have neither concern nor compassion for the young people who find themselves ensnared in this, at all.
I call the trans activists out all the time when they do this, and I now feel compelled to do the same to those who share many of my beliefs:
It is unacceptable to politicize the death of a brutally murdered young person by denying them their very humanity, while also claiming to stand on the side of human rights. This is the realm of the most evil kind of hypocrisy imaginable.
Celebrating, joking or making light of the murders of innocent people, be they Charlie Kirk or Juniper Blessing cannot ever be tolerated.
We mustn’t allow disagreements over ideology or with the lifestyles of others cause us to lose our humanity.
Because politics based upon nothing more than contempt will NEVER create a more just and peaceful world.
Rest in peace, Juniper.
You deserved to live 80 more years.
You deserved to be still singing in your choir.
You deserved to be attending your college classes.
You deserved to make the stupid mistakes that all young people will make, and to grow old enough to learn from them.
You deserved the chance to become a brilliant scientist with enough hard work on your part. Or you deserved to have the chance to realize that maybe atmospheric science wasn’t your calling, and then to try on a new hat. Or to try on 500 hats until you found the one that fit.
You deserved to grow up.
You did not deserve to be murdered by a deranged lunatic, whatever his deranged motive, while you were just trying to do your laundry.
And you certainly did not deserve to have your murder paraded around as cannon fodder in one of the most caustic issues of our time, by BOTH sides of the issue.
Juniper, may your memory be for blessing. You deserved so much better.
Using sex based pronouns =\= complicity in the murder of a trans person. If you want people to like you, being an authoritarian will not accomplish that.
I don’t hate people who haven’t done things that make me hate them, or who have beliefs that I disagree with.
That is not in my nature.
If anything, I value the ability to disagree respectfully far more than I value some veneer of perfect group harmony. If I ever sense I might be in an echo chamber, I become bored and restless. If someone thinks I belong to an echo chamber which does things I find objectionable, I will call it out.
I will also add that I do not feel I have been used by anyone. I am pretty averse to being controlled by ideologues of any flavor, which is why I call out trans activists when they are being stupid, immoral pricks and why I equally call out gender critics when they are being stupid, immoral pricks. This has naturally made me unpopular with as many gender critics as it has made me unpopular with trans activists.
Good thing I don’t care about the opinions of extremists who do not value life!
I’m lucky to have cultivated a community on here with transitioners, detransitioners, democrats, republicans, normies and weirdos alike- who all value the pursuit of spirited and respectful disagreement.
Quotes a post by T17413; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I don’t hate people who haven’t done things that make me hate them, or who have beliefs that I disagree with. That is not in my nature. If anything, I value the ability to disagree respectfully far more than I value some veneer of perfect group harmony. If I ever sense I might be in an echo chamber, I become bored and restless. If someone thinks I belong to an echo chamber which does things I find objectionable, I will call it out.
I will also add that I do not feel I have been used by anyone. I am pretty averse to being controlled by ideologues of any flavor, which is why I call out trans activists when they are being stupid, immoral pricks and why I equally call out gender critics when they are being stupid, immoral pricks. This has naturally made me unpopular with as many gender critics as it has made me unpopular with trans activists.
Good thing I don’t care about the opinions of extremists who do not value life!
I’m lucky to have cultivated community on here with transitioners, detransitioners, democrats, republicans, normies and weirdos alike- who all value the pursuit of spirited and respectful disagreement.
You’re delusional.
If trans activists didn’t make such increasingly absurd demands upon all of society, a small group of transsexuals who didn’t cause problems for others in society would have been able to carry on as they wished. All others would have been relegated to the fringe. For better and for worse.
Demanding that everyone must pander to a fringe population which has made a concerted ideological effort to pander to schoolchildren and to create medical guidelines based on emotional blackmail does not in fact make people sympathetic to your cause.
And those of us who have concerns about these increasingly absurd demands have every right and obligation to argue our positions to ensure the cohesion of a pluralistic society.
Quotes a post by T03247; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You’re delusional. If trans activists didn’t make such absurd demands upon all of society, a small group of transsexuals who didn’t cause problems for others in society would have been able to carry on as they wished. All others would have been relegated to the fringe.
Demanding that everyone must pander to a fringe population which has made a concerted ideological effort to pander to schoolchildren and to create medical guidelines based on emotional blackmail does not in fact make people sympathetic to your cause.
Is police incompetence in murder investigations unique to trans victims or more prevalent in trans victims than in other victims?
It seems to me that whichever murders are solved are far more based on the geographical location of the murder than on the presence of a cross-gender identity in the victim.
The bigger the city, the more stressed homicide units are due to more murders, and the less likely they are to gather evidence in time to solve any given one.
Somehow, small town police departments that deal with almost no murders and have few resources, seem shockingly better able to solve the one occasional murder they do get. It is also not uncommon in small towns for those investigating the murder to also have a previous connection to the victim and/or their family, which gives them more impetus to not give up on solving the case. But maybe that’s just the impression I get from watching true crime.
People who aren’t trans die tens of thousands of times every day across the world.
This week, there are two trans deaths noted.
Thankfully, that’s not evidence of an anti-trans killing conspiracy.
Every unnatural death not from old age is an abject tragedy.
So, let’s be responsible with how deaths with (yet) unknown motives and causes are reported, please.
Just because the person who dies in an untimely manner was trans, this does not mean that they were killed because of their trans status.
However, this is a commonly made argument whenever a trans person dies or is murdered. That type of speculation strikes needless fear into an already mentally vulnerable population.
There’s no need to pretend there is such a conspiracy to mass murder people for ‘being’ trans or transitioning.
These deaths are tragic enough on their own, simply because those killed were human beings.
Murry, may you rest in peace.
Quotes a post by T03562; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’ve seen similar levels of evil committed by transphobe ideologues and trans activist types alike. People can become really evil when they don’t have skills or an identity outside of being a political extremist. That’s what I’ve learned. I think I didn’t understand that Westerners with Western mindsets could suck this much.
You’re acting like I don’t get those same death threats from those same trans identifying men. 19 year old Juniper was not one of them. Juniper was a teenager. An innocent teenager. Who did not deserve to die
Quoting @marycatedelvey: Honestly I ran out of compassion for these men about 700 death threats ago
You’re acting like I don’t get those same death threats from those same trans identifying men. 19 year old Juniper was not one of them. Juniper was a teenager. An innocent teenager. Who did not deserve to die
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codeddenialviolence terror
Do teen boys who have been brainwashed by trans ally (mostly) FEMALE adults to think that it’s acceptable for them to use women’s spaces, really deserve the death penalty carried out by a deranged lunatic who stabs them to death 40+ times in a college laundry room?
Are you f***ing serious right now?
Is this really the hill you want to die on?
Do teen boys who have been brainwashed by trans ally (mostly) FEMALE adults to think that it’s acceptable for them to use women’s spaces, really deserve the death penalty carried out by a deranged lunatic who stabs them to death 40+ times in a college laundry room?
Are you f***ing serious right now?
Quotes a post by T14802; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
That case is actually pretty analogous to this one, albeit that Ghey’s murder was done by two same or similarly aged peers who were friends at one point?
whereas Blessing’s murder was done by a 31 y/o w/o any relation to the victim. In both cases, TRAs automatically assumed that anti-trans animus was the cause of the murder. They ran campaigns which stirred up fear within trans communities needlessly, when in reality, both crimes were motivated by pure sadism and without a specific anti-trans animus. TRAs in both cases additionally used these tragedies as fodder to squash legitimate criticisms of the gender affirmation only care model and against women’s rights for single sex spaces, by arguing that public debates are what is killing these kids. I wasn’t around in the GC side of the discourse during Ghey’s murder, but based on what you’re saying, I imagine it is similar to the horrifying stuff we are seeing with Blessing’s murder. Why anyone would joke about something which is objectively tragic is beyond me.
My official position is that murder is bad regardless of the motive, and it is especially tragic when it takes the lives of young people. Juniper specifically seemed like a nerdy choir kid, which is an archetype of person I strongly identify with. Juniper had clear gifts, talents and aspirations. It’s clear our world was robbed of a beautiful soul.
You can be ideologically anti-trans and also anti-innocent teenagers being murdered at college by deranged lunatics. These positions are not actually incompatible.
I called out the trans activists who blamed gender critics for the murder of juniper, just as I did the gender critic-aligned contingent when they tried to spin the story that Juniper must’ve deserved this outcome because of “sex deception” when no one knew the motive.
The issue I take with your post is not that you are accurately reporting on the motive of the killer as it has been revealed by the police. The issue I take with your post is the lack of basic human decency shown to the victim. Calling Juniper “this troon” is not even remotely decent. Juniper was a teenager who did not deserve to die.
In the same way as it is wrong for TRAs to turn Juniper’s murder into political cannon fodder, it is wrong for our response to their bad actions, to be insulting the memory of a murdered teenager with immature name calling.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨Re: the tragic murder of 19 y/o Juniper.
To everyone slinging stupid comments at me and at each other, I’ll use some logic to sharpen up your dull thinking skills:
1. We still don’t know why Juniper was murdered.
All we know is that the 31 year old psychopath responsible was stalking the campus in advance, behaving oddly, & perhaps scouting for victims. Students filmed this.
We do not know whether any of them raised alarms to the campus police, or if they did, how campus police responded.
We do not know whether this attack was targeted at Juniper or whether it was a crime of opportunity. We do not know as of yet, whether the suspect was related to the victim, and if so, how.
We do know that the race of the suspect was not formally released alongside other identifying information which delayed the suspect’s timely arrest. The only reason he’s in custody is because he turned himself in.
2. Some of you speculate that Juniper’s murder was:
*a response to being sexually deceived by the killer who thought juniper was female
*evidence that juniper was a prostitute
*a racially-related killing of some kind
*an anti-trans hate crime
(motivated by advocacy for legislative restrictions of medical transition access for minors, women’s spaces/sports, questions about the legitimacy of transition interventions as the only or most effective treatment for gender dysphoria, or changing cultural attitudes about these things)
Everyone is acting like they know the reason he murdered Juniper, when as of now it is all just speculation. No motive has been released to the public.
3. Many of you in my comments act like detransitioners like myself who speak out against the harms of gender transition and the cultural and clinical lies sold to a generation of young people because it is profitable to do so, are somehow responsible for spreading hate and therefore effectively murdering this teenager. Some of you are idiots, and others of you have cluster b personality disorders. Either way, seek help.
4. Many others of you in my comments act like this teenager deserved to die because you think the murderer must’ve been on a hook up and was sexually deceived by Juniper.
Not only do you lack evidence of this theory, but you are idiots to pretend that you do and to not see this as a tragic outcome which should be prevented. And you are something of psychopaths if you are justifying what was clearly cold blooded murder rather than self defense (as evidenced by what we know about the nature of the victim’s injuries)
5. You are all going to war with other people on an ideological basis, having absolutely no understanding of what happened, before telling your ideological opponents that they are somehow responsible for this teenager’s death. What is wrong with you all?
Murder should horrify us all. It should not make us attack each other over baseless accusations of our ideological opponent’s supposed culpability in a crime with one known killer and no known motive. And yes, both pro-trans and gender critical aligned people are doing this. That behavior needs to stop. It is unacceptable and it is inhuman.
6. We are talking about a dead teenager.
The fact that this does not horrify EACH AND EVERY ONE of us, that so many would rather use this killing as a virtue signaling opportunity is disgusting. All of humanity should be ashamed of this.
Some of you commenters lack the intellectual fortitude to understand this intuitively, so I will spell it out:
The only person responsible for murdering Juniper was the 31 year old psychopath whom I will not name, who was effectively aided and abetted for DAYS by the incompetence of the Seattle PD.
Murder is different from killing in self-defense. Murder can happen for many different reasons, and every single one of them is unjustified. Juniper was killed in a MURDER. Juniper’s killing was unjustified in every way.
Can’t you show some damn respect to the memory of this soul?
🚨I was wrong.
When I entered the gender conversation publicly, I thought that “my side” (the gender critics) were motivated in our advocacy by our concern about the welfare of the young people who are being haphazardly placed onto an experimental social & medical gender transition pathway based on a shoddy evidence base underpinning.
Apparently, I was wrong.
Turns out, some of you on “my side” have neither concern nor compassion for the young people who find themselves ensnared in this, at all.
I call the trans activists out all the time when they do this, and I now feel compelled to do the same to those who share many of my beliefs:
It is unacceptable to politicize the death of a brutally murdered young person by denying them their very humanity, while also claiming to stand on the side of human rights. This is the realm of the most evil kind of hypocrisy imaginable.
Celebrating, joking or making light of the murders of innocent people, be they Charlie Kirk or Juniper Blessing cannot ever be tolerated.
We mustn’t allow disagreements over ideology or with the lifestyles of others cause us to lose our humanity.
Because politics based upon nothing more than contempt will NEVER create a more just and peaceful world.
Rest in peace, Juniper.
You deserved to live 80 more years.
You deserved to be still singing in your choir.
You deserved to be attending your college classes.
You deserved to make the stupid mistakes that all young people will make, and to grow old enough to learn from them.
You deserved the chance to become a brilliant scientist with enough hard work on your part. Or you deserved to have the chance to realize that maybe atmospheric science wasn’t your calling, and then to try on a new hat. Or to try on 500 hats until you found the one that fit.
You deserved to grow up.
You did not deserve to be murdered by a deranged lunatic, whatever his deranged motive, while you were just trying to do your laundry.
And you certainly did not deserve to have your murder paraded around as cannon fodder in one of the most caustic issues of our time, by BOTH sides of the issue.
Juniper, may your memory be for blessing. You deserved so much better.
Quoting @Slatzism: Incredible development in the case of the UW troon who was stabbed.
The killer told prosecutors that he just wanted to murder a woman. That was his motive.
So he either thought the troon was a woman, or he actively included “trans women” in his definition of “women.”
Not only was this not a transphobic hate crime, it is probably the world’s first gender affirming murder.
Transphobia would have saved this guy’s life.
https://x.com/thepeacepoet99/status/2055441778908729842?s=46
Last week I warned you all against ascribing motives to the killer of 19 y/o Juniper when one had not been released.
This motive indeed shocked everyone on both sides of trans issues.
Unfortunately, there is little in the way of genuine compassion for the young person whose life was tragically and unnecessarily ended by a deranged and evil 31 year old man.
Quoting @DailyMail: Heartbreaking video shows trans student, 19, washing her clothes in college laundry room unaware that stranger who'd just walked in had selected her to be murdered https://trib.al/cXaZDH7
What motive would a liberal state have to fudge a killer’s motive which was explicitly not an anti-trans one, but was a motive to kill anyone he perceived to be a woman? What interest would a trans interest group have in not spinning this as having a transphobic motive where one doesn’t exist?
The droves of online activists whose immediate reaction to this tragic murder of a 19 y/o was to politicize it as a transphobic hate crime or as a consequence of failure to disclose trans status before sex— are awfully silent now that the killer’s actual motive has been released.
Quoting @DailyMail: Heartbreaking video shows trans student, 19, washing her clothes in college laundry room unaware that stranger who'd just walked in had selected her to be murdered https://trib.al/cXaZDH7
The trans movement isn’t new at all. It has gained a lot more cultural salience over the last decade and a half. It has gone from being fringe to being a well-known, and in certain parts of the Anglo sphere, totally mainstream subsection of the society.
For over a decade, I thought I had a male brain in a female body. In other words, I considered myself 🏳️⚧️ transgender.
Now, I’ve quit my gender transition, and have decided to go on a health and weight loss journey. I’ve lost over 40 pounds and I’m close to my goal weight.
With every pound I’ve lost, I become even more shocked that I managed to bind my chest for as long as I did.
The measures I took as an adolescent to ‘correct’ this gender incongruence have destroyed my upper body- both in form and in function.
I have a nerve injury, horribly flared ribs, damaged breast tissue, no positive sensation in the area, weakened skin, decreased lung capacity, severe left side back and neck pain…. Just to name a few.
Shapewear can hide quite a few of these things. But there are certain things that even multiple layers of shapewear can’t hide.
None of the trans adults guiding me and other known minors online about how to bind our breasts in secret, told us that any of this could happen to us. The most they said was to not bind with an ace bandage specifically, because then you can crack a rib. Everything else, the said, was safe if you do it no more than 10-12 hours a day. Years later, that number changed to eight hours.
Why? Because they’re making it up as they go along.
What they did not warn me or my peers about was that all breast binding done for a gender affirming purpose is inherently unsafe, and even more so when it is done by someone whose upper body (breasts, lungs, heart, ribs, spine etc) are still actively growing.
Because the trans community is still overwhelmingly buying into the notion that things like breast binding can be done safely for months or years at a time, without any evidence supporting their claim, kids are still getting hurt.
If the blatant lies that were told to me as a 12 year old girl in 2011/2012 weren’t continually peddled by online & irl trans communities, I would have nothing to speak out about.
But truthfully, breast binding is one of those practices that everyone still thinks is ok to lie about the harms of.
Parents are still buying their daughters breast binders thinking that they are “safe and reversible” or that these medical devices used for post surgical recovery are somehow “just pieces of clothing.” This includes parents who are already concerned about the medical harms of gender transition, but think that breast binding is a good compromise. It is NOT. It is actively hurting your growing kids.
Gender clinics promote these practices as being safe.
Schools still give out these dangerous medical devices to children without their parents’ knowledge. These are all big problems.
Take my story as a cautionary tale. Using multiple layers of shapewear, I might look ‘normal.’
Underneath it all, my left scapula aches before sending tingling sensations and then numbness down my left arm, whenever I stand or walk too long, or whenever I use a small shoulder bag. I’m almost 27, and I need a neck brace just to sleep. I cannot take deep breaths without pain. My ribs constantly feel like they’re hooking onto things underneath me when I’m lying on my side. That is in fact a very painful experience. There is no positive sensation in my chest and the entire area is deformed.
Gender affirming breast binding is NEVER harmless, nor does it cause damage which is easily reversible, or which is reversible at all. Most of this damage is not ‘a broken rib that will heal on its own.
It is done with no end in sight, and not under the strict supervision of a doctor monitoring the patient (as they would be in the case where a maximum of six weeks of binding is the post surgical recovery protocol).
It’s time that we all take the harms of gender affirming breast binding seriously. Not one study has shown that it can be done safely.
REPOST to raise awareness
Most trans people of the younger Millenial/ Zillenial/ older Gen Z cohort I’ve met were gender abolitionists. It’s a weird brain worm they caught collectively. Those who wanted to integrate into society were in the minority of my cohort. As can be expected, the gender abolitionist types have either mostly detransitioned or they have continued to be in transition and thoroughly miserable and angry at the world people. It’s probably a generational and geographical thing.
Oh yeah I’m so bigoted. It’s not like I host spaces multiple times a week with trans cohosts and populated mostly by trans people who unlike you, are capable of engaging in unorthodox discussions and actually defending their opinions with logic. It’s almost like I see trans people as being just as capable of logic and reason as anyone else theoretically is. Clearly, most people are not capable in the realm of discourse. Congrats on being totally average in this regard. You’re not as special a snowflake as you pride yourself on being.
We live in a world where people disagree with each other.
Grow up.
It never is. They are unreasonable and that is why no one likes them. They are the biggest impediment to the rights of trans people. They are truly their own worst enemies.
Probably because the victim was trans, the killer was black and the murder took place on a college campus where the victim was clearly a defenseless teenager just trying to do some damn laundry. It’s really tragic.
Quotes a post by T03969; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Probably because the victim was trans, the killer was black and the murder took place on a college campus where the victim was clearly a defenseless teenager just trying to do some damn laundry. It’s really tragic.
This authoritarian attitude about pronouns is why trans people as a class are losing the respect of the general population. The best thing you could do for trans people’s PR is to either 1) pass or 2) be okay with people seeing you as your sex and be confident enough to move on
So now you’re offended that I called the incompetent Seattle PD who screwed up on the murder of a transgender teenager “woketarded”
It’s almost like you 🏳️⚧️-in-bio people don’t care about the trans teenager who was killed at all. You care about the chance to virtue signal.
Do you worship the police all of a sudden because someone you disagreed with called them out for screwing up?
Quotes a post by T22794; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Additionally, my official stance is this:
Gender dysphoric people deserve to not think that their only option is transition or kill yourself, because that is not the case. It is neither borne out by evidence (suicidality & attempts are different from angst and misery. The former is far more attributable to underlying mental health issues than to gender dysphoria where both are present. The latter is not a pathology)
Gender dysphoric people who do transition deserve to know that they do not have to transition forever if it stops feeling like the right choice. And if they are as autistic as I am, they deserve to be taught by those caring for them (be they family or clinicians) HOW to understand what you are feeling when you are feeling it, because they may not know and because these decisions are far too consequential to embark upon based on vibes.
Young people especially need a possibility model for someone who is gender nonconforming and who identifies as a member of their sex. Right now, today’s role models for young people are either pressured to be trans or nonbinary or they have to be a perfectly conforming embodied Barbie doll or a macho man. That is an unfair cultural expectation to place on a generation. Plenty of people will find the most peace existing in neither of those boxes, but will continue to live inauthentically because they lack the possibility model.
I also want to acknowledge that you have since changed your thinking regarding detransitioners, as you yourself noted in your follow-up post about having been unfair or harsh in the past and diminishing the plight of detransitioners and people who “made poor decisions around transitions.”
I would never insinuate that your public statements are the reason why detransitioners have shitty clinicians who don’t know how to help people recover from transition related injuries.
(This lack of clinical competence also impacts transitioners who sustain the same injuries but do not wish to detransition.)
Nor do I act like your past dismissal of detrans experiences makes you and others like you responsible for the deaths of people like Yarden Silvera.
I firmly believe, just as you do, that one can advocate for people who have been harmed by the misapplication of transition while not necessarily punishing or diminishing those who it has helped and that is exactly what my work is trying to do. I am trying to figure out *why* so many in my generation have gotten screwed over by transition or who have simply not been helped to thrive by it, whereas transitioners of older generations appear to be way more well-adjusted. Does this have something to do with the specific manifestations of the GD? The sobriety with which they embarked upon these decisions? The decision to forgo certain aspects of transition? The age they started at? Their mental health prior to transition?
I was not even aware that someone could be genuinely benefitted by this choice, because when I was trans, the trans people in my life said they were happy while actively drinking their livers into cirrhosis or cutting themselves. And when I stopped being trans and started speaking about it publicly, tons of supposedly happy and secure trans people began threatening me. As a trans person, I didn’t react that way to detransitioners.
So yes, I acknowledge I had a blind spot that people could transition + be well adjusted. Clinicians can’t identify which ones they are, which gives me a high degree of anxiety, but some of them, like yourself show up in my spaces. That’s my only reference point.
Either way this is not relevant to this criminal case because all we know here functionally is that Juniper was murdered & that Juniper was trans. We don’t know whether those facts are related or unrelated because we do not know the killers motive.
Regardless of his motive, it is a horrifying outcome. No teenager should be killed while doing laundry at school. The word has lost its mind in even debating this.
/2
Dr Laura, I wanted to address one part of your reply to my post about Juniper.
Namely, where you say that you won’t draw lines between my advocacy and Juniper’s killing because it would ‘escalate tensions.’ This comment confused me, because my advocacy is not pro-killing trans people.
As a gender weirdo myself, I do not want other people, especially my fellow gender weirdos to die. That is against my interest and against the interest of people who have a lot in common with me. Namely our shared autism, and its many different manifestations.
Therefore, not making that parallel on your part would be based on an accurate understanding of my position rather than based on an attempt to build bridges. If you truly thought my advocacy was pro killing trans people, I would hope that you wouldn’t want to have me on your podcast which is based on actually getting into the analytic meat of the issues in a non-ideological way.
I’m not trans anymore, but if I get the sense that others in my circles are pro-killing gender weirdos regardless of how they identify (including if that is trans), or even for the lesser crime of being stupid and regurgitating thought terminating cliches underpinned by no substantive insights of their own for a living— I want nothing to do with those people.
My advocacy is pro-understanding why different people develop gender dysphoria and not mindlessly suggesting to every single one of them that an invasive transition protocol will make them better. High quality evidence needs to exist to make this assertion and it does not. We know that when there are more safeguards and transition is a less culturally popular thing to do, far fewer transitioners came out and talked about regretting their sex changes. Obstacles themselves prevented lots of these outcomes. That’s a conversation worth having.
Additionally, when I began sharing my story and thoughts on the profound experience of living in the male social role in the Middle East after a protracted period of gender confusion, and discussed how further traumatic things like war caused me to change my priorities; I was met with people calling for my death, doxxing me and insulting me for disabilities I was born with. This shocked me, because trans people in their 20s did when I was a confused and impressionable kid watching them on YouTube got to tell their stories and no one came after them. And btw to this day, I do not blame those trans people for telling their stories, just because I was influenced by them. I do blame them for spreading the lie that breast binding could be done safely, changing the rules about that every few years, not disclosing that they didn’t know what they were talking about, and coaching me and other known teenagers about how to bind their breasts in secret from their parents & suggesting that parents being concerned about their teen daughters engaging in an objective form of self harm were doing so out of bigotry.
They had no right to do any of that. They knew who their target audience was, and they did not behave responsibly.
My advocacy is centered around the fact that the gender transition protocol has been ideologically framed to my generation as a panacea, and clearly, the cohort that transitioned alongside me and in my time consisting of mostly teen girls are not doing well. The only well adjusted trans people I met while I was trans were established adults when they made this choice. And both transitioned in a culture that did not promote it. You and I by our own admissions have met very different kinds of trans people, and I think there’s a reason for that. I have many Gen Z trans friends who frequently agree with my analysis because we are talking about different cohorts and different generations.
I’m grateful to know trans people like yourself who are of an older and more mature generation that doesn’t insult or threaten people like me for telling our stories. Instead, you engage. I appreciate that.
/1
🚨Re: the tragic murder of 19 y/o Juniper.
To everyone slinging stupid comments at me and at each other, I’ll use some logic to sharpen up your dull thinking skills:
1. We still don’t know why Juniper was murdered.
All we know is that the 31 year old psychopath responsible was stalking the campus in advance, behaving oddly, & perhaps scouting for victims. Students filmed this.
We do not know whether any of them raised alarms to the campus police, or if they did, how campus police responded.
We do not know whether this attack was targeted at Juniper or whether it was a crime of opportunity. We do not know as of yet, whether the suspect was related to the victim, and if so, how.
We do know that the race of the suspect was not formally released alongside other identifying information which delayed the suspect’s timely arrest. The only reason he’s in custody is because he turned himself in.
2. Some of you speculate that Juniper’s murder was:
*a response to being sexually deceived by the killer who thought juniper was female
*evidence that juniper was a prostitute
*a racially-related killing of some kind
*an anti-trans hate crime
(motivated by advocacy for legislative restrictions of medical transition access for minors, women’s spaces/sports, questions about the legitimacy of transition interventions as the only or most effective treatment for gender dysphoria, or changing cultural attitudes about these things)
Everyone is acting like they know the reason he murdered Juniper, when as of now it is all just speculation. No motive has been released to the public.
3. Many of you in my comments act like detransitioners like myself who speak out against the harms of gender transition and the cultural and clinical lies sold to a generation of young people because it is profitable to do so, are somehow responsible for spreading hate and therefore effectively murdering this teenager. Some of you are idiots, and others of you have cluster b personality disorders. Either way, seek help.
4. Many others of you in my comments act like this teenager deserved to die because you think the murderer must’ve been on a hook up and was sexually deceived by Juniper.
Not only do you lack evidence of this theory, but you are idiots to pretend that you do and to not see this as a tragic outcome which should be prevented. And you are something of psychopaths if you are justifying what was clearly cold blooded murder rather than self defense (as evidenced by what we know about the nature of the victim’s injuries)
5. You are all going to war with other people on an ideological basis, having absolutely no understanding of what happened, before telling your ideological opponents that they are somehow responsible for this teenager’s death. What is wrong with you all?
Murder should horrify us all. It should not make us attack each other over baseless accusations of our ideological opponent’s supposed culpability in a crime with one known killer and no known motive. And yes, both pro-trans and gender critical aligned people are doing this. That behavior needs to stop. It is unacceptable and it is inhuman.
6. We are talking about a dead teenager.
The fact that this does not horrify EACH AND EVERY ONE of us, that so many would rather use this killing as a virtue signaling opportunity is disgusting. All of humanity should be ashamed of this.
Some of you commenters lack the intellectual fortitude to understand this intuitively, so I will spell it out:
The only person responsible for murdering Juniper was the 31 year old psychopath whom I will not name, who was effectively aided and abetted for DAYS by the incompetence of the Seattle PD.
Murder is different from killing in self-defense. Murder can happen for many different reasons, and every single one of them is unjustified. Juniper was killed in a MURDER. Juniper’s killing was unjustified in every way.
Can’t you show some damn respect to the memory of this soul?
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: This 19 year old kid had a whole life left to live, and that life was stolen by a 31 year old psychopath, who was abetted by the incompetence of a woketarded police force.
Juniper deserved better
If I see any of my mutuals cracking jokes about this tragedy, you will be blocked.
🚨Re: the tragic murder of 19 y/o Juniper.
To everyone slinging stupid comments at me and at each other, I’ll use some logic to sharpen up your dull thinking skills:
1. We still don’t know why Juniper was murdered.
All we know is that the 31 year old psychopath responsible was stalking the campus in advance, behaving oddly, & perhaps scouting for victims. Students filmed this.
We do not know whether any of them raised alarms to the campus police, or if they did, how campus police responded.
We do not know whether this attack was targeted at Juniper or whether it was a crime of opportunity. We do not know as of yet, whether the suspect was related to the victim, and if so, how.
We do know that the race of the suspect was not formally released alongside other identifying information which delayed the suspect’s timely arrest. The only reason he’s in custody is because he turned himself in.
2. Some of you speculate that Juniper’s murder was:
*a response to being sexually deceived by the killer who thought juniper was female
*evidence that juniper was a prostitute
*a racially-related killing of some kind
*an anti-trans hate crime
(motivated by advocacy for legislative restrictions of medical transition access for minors, women’s spaces/sports, questions about the legitimacy of transition interventions as the only or most effective treatment for gender dysphoria, or changing cultural attitudes about these things)
Everyone is acting like they know the reason he murdered Juniper, when as of now it is all just speculation. No motive has been released to the public.
3. Many of you in my comments act like detransitioners like myself who speak out against the harms of gender transition and the cultural and clinical lies sold to a generation of young people because it is profitable to do so, are somehow responsible for spreading hate and therefore effectively murdering this teenager. Some of you are idiots, and others of you have cluster b personality disorders. Either way, seek help.
4. Many others of you in my comments act like this teenager deserved to die because you think the murderer must’ve been on a hook up and was sexually deceived by Juniper.
Not only do you lack evidence of this theory, but you are idiots to pretend that you do and to not see this as a tragic outcome which should be prevented. And you are something of psychopaths if you are justifying what was clearly cold blooded murder rather than self defense (as evidenced by what we know about the nature of the victim’s injuries)
5. You are all going to war with other people on an ideological basis, having absolutely no understanding of what happened, before telling your ideological opponents that they are somehow responsible for this teenager’s death. What is wrong with you all?
Murder should horrify us all. It should not make us attack each other over baseless accusations of our ideological opponent’s supposed culpability in a crime with one known killer and no known motive. And yes, both pro-trans and gender critical aligned people are doing this. That behavior needs to stop. It is unacceptable and it is inhuman.
6. We are talking about a dead teenager.
The fact that this does not horrify EACH AND EVERY ONE of us, that so many would rather use this killing as a virtue signaling opportunity is disgusting. All of humanity should be ashamed of this.
Some of you commenters lack the intellectual fortitude to understand this intuitively, so I will spell it out:
The only person responsible for murdering Juniper was the 31 year old psychopath whom I will not name, who was effectively aided and abetted for DAYS by the incompetence of the Seattle PD.
Murder is different from killing in self-defense. Murder can happen for many different reasons, and every single one of them is unjustified. Juniper was killed in a MURDER. Juniper’s killing was unjustified in every way.
Can’t you show some damn respect to the memory of this soul?
My “crowd” includes all sorts of non-terroristic types within trans and detrans or gender critical twitter circles. Finding these individuals within both of these communities are exceedingly hard to find. But it is rewarding to have cultivated such a community. You are welcome to join my spaces anytime. I’m sure you’ll like my crowd.
So you’re of the opinion that it’s fine for some unrelated teenager to be killed (or for others to joke abt it) in a murder with a yet unknown motive, based on a combo of the teen’s trans status & the fact that Charlie Kirk’s murderer was dating a trans partner?? Are you serious?
The phrase “two Jews, three opinions” is well-known for a reason. It’s because it’s true.
Jews are over-represented in political activism on both sides of any given issue, including both in trans and gender critical activism b/c we have a strong sense of justice.
We know that generations of genetic insularity, including intracommunity marriage and genocides have created genetic bottlenecks. As a result, Ashkenazi Jewish populations are more prone both to genetic disorders and seemingly to baseline higher IQ.
I wonder if this is why there’s a genetic-cultural feedback loop of high achieving, a value on education, a certain type of religious rigidity, high IQ and baseline higher levels of culturally normalized autistic traits seen way more in Ashkenazi Jewish communities than in other Jewish communities, for example.
Thoughts?
Quotes a post by T18379; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
1. That by mistakes I meant “desire to transition” rather than the literal word I used…
2. That skepticism around transition as being some kind of panacea (which is how it is portrayed today) is causing trans people to be killed. That is absurd. You can’t just say shit like that without attempting to prove it with logic.
I’m always sad about teenagers getting killed. And we still do not know why this murder happened. Suspect seems to have been a stalker of some kind who was scoping out this school for a while. The murder may have had nothing to do with Juniper’s trans status, or it may have had something to do with it. Either way, it is a tragedy. No kid deserves to be murdered. Ever. It sounds like with Juniper, the world lost an incredible person. It’s just sad.
Trans is a ‘solution’ to whichever number of things an adolescent naively thinks it will solve, and these days with all the helicopter parenting, it’s a good way of getting parents to back off and let their kids individuate because it’s not like we were even allowed to walk to the corner store for some candy without someone getting worried about lone “neglected” children wandering about. Trans & non-binary has become the adolescent rebellion of a generation that has not been allowed to assert itself and do normal, embodied psychosocial development in their adolescence and young adulthood years due to being raised by the internet and then coming of age during a pandemic. That’s my assessment on a cultural level. On an individual level or cohort level, there are too many possible permutations of sexual preference, trauma history, mental health history, environmental or developmental histories to reduce it to “transition is the solution to homophobia.” This may have been very true in the past, and somewhat true in the cases of early onset GD… though even early onset GD could be attributable to a developmental delay associated with autism which may or may not manifest as later in life homosexual attraction. I’ve noticed on trans kid parenting forums that tons of autistic diagnosed four to six year olds today are being transitioned by their parents, whereas the elementary-aged ‘trans kids’ I saw on tv growing up did not seem very autistic.
In my experience, in the West, most teen girls and young women who identify as trans these days are straight. Most female detransitioners are also straight. These results do not appear to reflect reality, or there is something off about the sample or methodology, because in 14 years in trans and detrans communities online and IRL in two different countries, I have not seen this to be the case. Most of my cohort just identified as gay trans men, or they are nonbinary and into men, or nonbinary and asexual. It is rare for a Gen Z female transitioner to be a lesbian or even meaningfully into women or bisexual. There is less of a pattern of FTMs identifying as lesbians, transitioning, and then switching to exclusively male partners in my generation compared to past generations. My generation of female transitioners overwhelmingly dated men before transition, continued dating men while transitioning, and did the same after detransition, as far as I have noticed. Very few are lesbians among Gen Z.
There are also fewer women who identify as women and as lesbians in Gen Z, in my opinion, so it is hard to tell because they call themselves “sapphic” or “queer,” which can mean straight. Functionally, though they say they are queer, they only date males but will play with your feelings by pretending they might seriously consider dating you if you are female (both feminine and masculine/male-presenting women fit this pattern).
I can count on both hands the number of “straight trans men” I have met in trans communities, and this continues among detransitioners. Gay women who transition in the Middle East seem far more likely to persist rather than desist or go back and forth between trans male and nonbinary identities. Most are Israeli, Russian, or Arab in origin. Most culturally Western ones, including Tel Avivis, partner with men and lack a history of dating women or significant attraction to them. I do not have enough fingers and toes to count the gay trans men and nonbinary females I have met who have only and always dated men, both in the West and among properly anglophone Israelis from non-religious or semi-religious North American or British families.
My similarly aged cohort of female transitioners in the West are predominantly heterosexual in their attractions. They call themselves gay when trans but are pretty open about that.
It seems there is a generational difference here. Curious to hear your thoughts.
The libbed out woketards in Washington state’s police dept who are responsible for solving the brutal murder of a transgender teenaged college student, sat on this murderer’s race for *days* before providing it in a description of the suspect, or releasing his image to the public.
They’ve functionally delayed justice and endangered the public by failing to disclose this important identifying information as soon as they knew it.
Clearly they care more about protecting murderers who happen to be black than about safeguarding both trans communities (of which there are many in the state) and the rest of the general public, from grown psychopaths who murder teenaged college kids before being allowed to run loose in search of their next victim.
Woke progressivism and identity politics will always be a beautiful-looking veneer used to avoid correcting the ever-rotting institutional incompetencies in governing of blue cities and states. And it will always eat itself before it succeeds in protecting a single population which we know to be vulnerable to violence.
Quoting @SeattlePD: Detectives seek suspect in homicide of University of Washington Student. https://spdblotter.seattle.gov/2026/05/11/detectives-investigating-homicide-at-university-of-washington-housing/
In my experience, in the West, most teen girls/ young women who ID as trans these days are straight. And most of the female detransitioners are straight. I’m not sure what you mean by them using lesbianism as a relief for their GD. I haven’t seen this to be the case. Most of my cohort just IDs/IDed as gay trans men or they’re nonbinary and into men or nonbinary and asexual. It’s rare to be a Gen Z female transitioner and to be a lesbian or even to be meaningfully into women and bisexual. There’s less of a singularity of FTMs IDing as lesbians and then transitioning and switching to exclusively male partners in my generation. They sort of just date men and continue to date men as far as I’ve noticed.
There are also less women who identify as women who also are identifying as lesbians in Gen Z imo, so it’s hard to tell because they call themselves “sapphic” or “queer” which can mean straight. But functionally, though they say they’re queer, they only date males but will play with your feelings by pretending they might seriously consider dating you if you’re a female (both female presenting and masculine/male presenting women apply to this pattern).
I can count on both hands the number of ‘straight trans men’ I’ve met over my time in trans communities, and this continues amongst detransitioners. Though gay women who transition in the Middle East seem way more likely to persist in their transitions rather than to desist or to go back and forth between trans male ID and non-binary ID. And most of them are Israeli, Russian or Arab in origin. Most of the culturally western ones including Tel Avivis partner with men and don’t have a history of dating women or experiencing significant attraction to women such that they would settle down with a woman. I don’t have enough toes and fingers to count the number of gay trans men and nonbinary females I’ve met who have only and always dated men, both in the West and amongst properly anglophone Israelis who come from non-religious or semi-religious North American or British families.
My similarly aged cohort of female transitioners in the West are predominantly heterosexual in their attractions, and they call themselves gay when they’re trans, but they are pretty open about that.
It seems there’s a generational difference here. Curious to hear your thoughts.
This is what it looks like to live in my body after spending over a decade in a trans identity, waging a war against it.
Sometimes it’s the simple things, like roller skates, that are enough to connect to our bodies. No invasive life changes needed.
Who agrees?
This is very, very, very true. Too bad I was in kindergarten back in ‘05. Having the mindset of an ‘05 female transitioner as a Gen Z adolescent/young adult and being in trans communities with one’s fellow ‘trans’ peers is actually an alienating and disillusioning experience.
Maybe we disagree about trans issues.
Maybe we disagree about which country in the Middle East is most moral.
Can we at least agree that roller skating is the most fun way to get exercise?
They’re not just individuals. We are talking about standards of care and healthcare guidelines which are based on numerous fallacies and which promote dangerous practices. Surely, you wouldn’t want to be the reason that trans people are getting injured by dangerous community practices, right?
If the trans adults and the gender doctors did their jobs, so many young people in their twenties wouldn’t be injured. Those who made their beds should in fact, lie in it.
I’m not going to stop talking about what happened to me as a little kid, because little kids today are still getting injured by breast binding practices that are still being promoted as safe and reversible.
If trans adults took some responsibility for giving dangerous medical advice to little children on Internet forums, perhaps we wouldn’t all be making it into our twenties with injuries that said trans adults and gender doctors certainly did not tell us could even happen.
If you want to compellingly argue that gender affirming care saved your life, be my guest. I’m not telling you to stop telling your story even though I believe your story is injuring the next generation of kids. We should both tell our stories and let the public, and clinicians, make up their minds for themselves, rather than based on the type of censorship you advocate for out of cowardice and a contempt for the truth.
Quotes a post by T13213; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m not going to stop talking about what happened to me as a little kid, because little kids today are still getting injured by breast binding practices that are still being promoted as safe and reversible.
If trans adults took some responsibility for giving dangerous medical advice to little children on Internet forums, perhaps we wouldn’t all be making it into our twenties with injuries that said trans adults and gender doctors certainly did not tell us could even happen.
If you want to compellingly argue that gender affirming care saved your life, be my guest. I’m not telling you to stop telling your story even though I believe your story is injuring the next generation of kids. We should both tell our stories and let the public, and clinicians, make up their minds for themselves, rather than based on the type of censorship you advocate for out of cowardice and a contempt for the truth.
Today’s 12 year olds don’t deserve to get injured in order to protect from scrutiny, adults’ transgender identities and their associated actions.
Me talking about how dangerous breast binding is, does not take rights away from anyone.
Your argument is incoherent.
Quotes a post by T13213; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Today’s 12 year olds don’t deserve to get injured in order to protect from scrutiny, adults’ transgender identities and their associated actions.
Your argument is incoherent. Me talking about how dangerous breast binding is, does not take rights away from anyone.
To everyone accusing me of ‘grifting’ or making up how dangerous breast binding is (particularly when started in adolescence and done for many years) I’d like you to read my friend Aaron’s post.
These are side effects that trans communities didn’t talk about back in 2011/2012 when I got into them as a little kid. All they said back then was that you could break a rib by binding with an ace bandage but that everything else was safe. Ofc they made no mention that it’s uniquely dangerous to bind while still developing, because they themselves were not binding in development. Yet, they thought it was fine to tell 12-15 year old girls how they can make breast binders out of household items and by layering multiple sports bras and wearing them constantly to prevent further development…. And that this was a totally fine thing to do to yourself because otherwise you’d off yourself.
You can’t hold people liable for not knowing how dangerous various transition interventions are, when trans communities back in the day didn’t know what they were talking about either….. and when the people in question were little kids in communities with adults in their mid-late 20’s who knew full well they were talking to middle schoolers and should have known better than to give them medical advice.
Quotes a post by A0882; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
🚨When I thought for 12 years (12-24) that I had a boy brain in a girl body and needed to ‘pass’ as a man to be happy, I was not capable of understanding how badly I would get injured by being 🏳️⚧️trans.
Binding large breasts during a decade of one’s development is a really bad idea. And like most bad ideas, if you’re a teenager, you’ll probably think it’s “no big deal.”
This is especially so when everyone on the internet tells you that breast binding is totally safe and reversible. Those people are LIARS.
Not even losing 40 + pounds has taken that lasting pain away. It’s bittersweet to see the fat I was hiding under melt away. Sweet, because I look objectively better now. Bitter, because it makes the damage I’ve done to myself more evident.
Many layers of shapewear can hide the aesthetic damage, which is.. whatever. It’s a lost cause at this point.
But the pain in my back and the tingly, hot/cold sensations that become numbness in my left arm have only gotten progressively worse since I’ve stopped binding. While binding, my left arm would only go numb occasionally. Now, even with dramatic weight loss and the passage of time, the (presumably) nerve pain is more persistent. It has become a daily occurrence. It is inconvenient to have your arm go numb this often and I wish it would stop.
I’d like to regain the ability to stand up straight and to lie down on my side without my ribs hurting or feeling that my rib bones are hooking onto whatever is underneath me or to the side of me. I would like my old lung capacity back. I don’t have sensation in my chest except for pain and irritation. I do hope that goes away. I’m not sure what my next steps are. Anyone have any ideas?
There is nothing safe or reversible about binding your breasts in the long term, especially starting as a teenager.
REPOST to raise awareness.
Feels good to be 40 pounds lighter on my feet! Only ~7 away from my goal.
The 12 y/o trans🏳️⚧️ -ideating kid version of me who bound her breasts until 24 could’ve never imagined achieving this level of comfort in her own skin.
Growing up is really something!
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/how-both-sides-of-the-trans-culture?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
I run a blog for parents and clinicians about exploring neurodivergence-informed ways to parent kids through their gender crises while also giving them skills they’ll need to experience peace in their bodies & minds throughout life.
If I weren’t Maia Poet, but instead identified as having a they/them multiple personality disorder, the pronoun people would be cheering me on for this look.
Why is gender non-conformity only ok if you say you’re trans and are committed to destroying your health to prove it?
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: The coolest thing about not being obese anymore is that I can finally wear fun clothes.
Would anyone else wear this tracksuit?
I’m a bigot because I think that changing your appearance doesn’t metaphysically change your sex.
I’m an even bigger bigot for treating all people who are worthy of respect, with respect, regardless of their chosen or immutable appearance.
Trans people are always welcome in my spaces here on X.
As a gender weirdo myself, who has accepted her sex, I don’t hold animosity towards gender weirdos who continue to feel ambivalence about theirs.
I feel a ton of animosity for people who behave like deranged lunatics, however, regardless of their personal appearance.
We can hold different beliefs about what our ‘gender weirdness’ means about who we metaphysically are, or about how we ought to live our lives, or about what this means for policy, and still be fast friends.
This is not actually complicated.
I’m a bigot because I think that changing your appearance doesn’t metaphysically change your sex.
I’m an even bigger bigot for treating all people who are worthy of respect, with respect, regardless of their chosen or immutable appearance.
Trans people are always welcome in my spaces here on X.
As a gender weirdo myself, who has accepted her sex, I don’t hold animosity towards gender weirdos who continue to feel ambivalence about theirs.
I feel a ton of animosity for people who behave like deranged lunatics, however, regardless of their personal appearance.
We can hold different beliefs about what our ‘gender weirdness’ means about who we metaphysically are, or about how we ought to live our lives, or about what this means for policy, and still be fast friends.
This is not actually complicated.
Quotes a post by T19103; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
How did I miss your response until just now! I’m not sure who you are, but we appear to have many mutuals. I hope trans communities have their own me too movement. Incubating abusers helps neither the community’s safety nor is it good for PR. Gatekeeping is a good thing because it prevents needless harm. I hope the sentiment changes quickly.
I’m a reasonable person who respects those who show up to my spaces with respect. I do not demand agreement with my opinions. I actually quite enjoy disagreement and fruitful discourse.
I enjoy the company of trans people, detransitioners, Israelis, Palestinians, gender critics, pro-trans activists, democrats, republicans, people born in all parts of the world etc., in my spaces.
Within any of those groups, there are plenty of people who disagree with one another about everything we discuss! And I welcome all of them, for as long as everyone remains respectful and contributes meaningfully to the discourse.
Is that really the archetype of an evil person?
It’s pretty easy for parents who don’t want their kids diagnosed with ASD to not have their kids diagnosed with ASD in the US. If your kid ends up in an alternative school or a private school, like I did because of my developmental delays and my parents desire to properly educate their kids, those teachers will never even suggest that the kid has a problem as long as they’re not being disruptive.
It wouldn’t have occurred to mine that such a diagnosis would be necessary, considering that I come from a long line of mathematicians and engineers, until of course it did when my gender issues were not going away and I was still despite their efforts, not picking up on social cues. They were also already taking me to so many specialists to solve my many issues. My whole childhood was basically just seeing doctors after doctor. But by then, when even they had agreed that it might be autism when I was 19. And I was not about to try and figure out how to get that done. I was more concerned with thinking trans was my only possible future and then acting upon it.
My goal is to process my own experiences in the hopes that other people find them relatable, as a start.
Then with enough feedback I’d like to collaborate on a working model which could assist with non-invasive treatments for gender dysphoria which are attuned to the specific manifestations of the comorbidities of each subsection of those for whom gender dysphoria comes with a discernible comorbidity.
Today’s teenagers aren’t old enough to have insight into any of this. Neither are most of Gen Z. Their broad dependence upon gender ideological language makes it hard to analyze their experiences for qualitative data. On the detrans GC side, there’s plenty of ideological language which I believe also potentially stunts self-awareness.
The only nuance I’m looking to provide is that there is something about autism itself which predisposes both males and females to developing gender dysphoria. I have theories about what some of those predisposing factors are on the female side of things, based on my lived experiences and based on being in and outside of trans communities with other autistic females over 14 years and being thoroughly fixated on the subject and trying to research it. In males, there seem to be similar predisposing factors but somewhat different mechanisms. If trans activists get to tell everyone else their stories of what makes them trans, I think it is the duty of people whose experiences are different to tell our stories too.
The woke mob will “trust the experts” all the way to their graves when the experts agree with their pre-existing, emotionally-driven lay conclusions.
As soon as the medical opinions begin to shift it’s all the crying about ableism and transphobia.
You guys have got to pick a side. Do both parents and clinicians not make the choice to not evaluate a kid with lots of clear autistic traits for a diagnosis they think will be too stigmatizing, or to evaluate on another basis? Does autism only exist the moment a clinician notices it, either correctly or incorrectly? Does “trans” exist only when a clinician diagnoses it, or are people born that way? Does this analysis change based on whether the person making the point agrees or disagrees with you?
The entire internet and everyone who meets me including therapists without the power to diagnose gets to call me autistic, gets to refer to my neurodevelopmental trajectory in that way. But when I finally accept that which has been true about my entire life, because a series of incompetent clinicians who; didn’t care why I toe walked (diagnosis: IDIOPATHIC toe walking) and waited three years before treating me with Botox injections and leg braces; who didn’t tell my parents that I needed to patch my lazy eye as a toddler; who attributed my lack of eye contact to my “active mind,” who saw the evidence of obvious impairment and thought it was no big deal because I was also gifted: BECAUSE these incompetent idiots who were responsible for doing their jobs, failed to properly assess me at every possible chance, somehow it means I’m lying about having a very autistic neurodevelopmental trajectory?
Quotes a post by T32916; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Though it may seem like the next anti-woke thing to be anti- autism diagnosis for kids who are any more functional than literally banging their heads against a wall in frustration, it is actually setting kids up for failure in their young adult lives.
Kids and teens on the autism spectrum who decide they are trans may have long before that point really struggled to play a constant game of developmental catch up.
/4
The transgender identity framework I had found as a 12 year old, already embarked upon a years-long quest to understand what was wrong with me, was the wrong conceptual framework to understand myself through.
As an extreme systematizer, I can only understand my experiences by finding the right framework(s), by mastering them and then by understanding their explanatory limitations.
/2
🚨I thought I was Trans for 12 years: I Was Wrong.
I would not have ever been able to cure my gender dysphoria without understanding that the boy brain I thought I had inside my girl body was actually an AUTISTIC FEMALE BRAIN all along. 🧵/1
I think it’s a huge problem that conditions like autism and adhd are routinely missed in young girls.
It causes them needless suffering to have no understanding of the pattern of their developmental problems. At adolescence, everything gets harder and they stumble across trans as their first explanation these days. This will only further impair their development.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨When kids come out as trans, their parents are bombarded by conflicting advice. The pro-trans side tells them to just affirm, and the gender critical side tells them to just say no.
So where does this advice leave smart kids with special needs?
Read my essay to find out.
The problem with considering any and all gatekeeping oppressive is what causes the more naive members among the group to be manipulated by the more nefarious and socially intelligent ones. I’m sorry for the situation you’ve been through. SA is so common in trans community spaces and it isn’t talked about enough. I agree that a whole me too movement is well overdue. And I hope that you are able to find peace.
🚨The first line of treatment for gender dysphoria, particularly in today’s female adolescent population, should be some kind of sensory integration therapy. Why?
Because girls on the spectrum tend to have worse sensory issues than boys do, while being better at redirecting them into non-socially disruptive ways, so they are left to flounder. Sensory processing disorders are a very common sense reason that someone would feel really, really uncomfortable in their body. Lots of ASD & ADHD people have them.
Girls’ sensory issues tend to get worse with the hormonal fluctuations of puberty. Mine got way worse than they were before, and I was already a toe walker from toddlerhood (treated w/botox injections and leg braces in kindergarten with no determined cause) who also pulled out my eyelashes starting in first grade, (a habit I’d developed around the time I could no longer toe walk due to Botox and leg braces. But it persisted until I was medicated for ADHD at 14 and I redirected the impulse towards compulsive hair twirling) which was misdiagnosed as OCD despite my not having other traits of that condition.
Girls with no intellectual impairments are the least likely to have been screened for autism or to received any kind of sensory integration therapies earlier in life.
In my case, I had weird combination of developmental delays with motor skills (starting from how I never crawled and needed occupational therapy to teach me how to pull myself up when I fell down ~ age of 1) and was simultaneously verbally precocious, so I got treatments for those things individually but because no one knew what autism looked like in girls in the 2000’s so there was nothing to predict the suffering I would later experience at puberty as the sensory issues got exponentially worse. At the onset of puberty, I went from having perfect vision to needing glasses. A year later, I needed bifocals. A year after that, I needed cylinders to correct an increasingly prominent lazy eye that no one thought to patch when it was milder as a kid. I lost any chance at depth perception. I became way more clumsy. Even the sunlight began to hurt my eyes. My body was a miserable place to be. It felt like I was losing new function every day while everyone else’s skills were improving. Simply moving around became difficult as my center of gravity shifted and my brain struggled to adjust.
The disconnect I experienced from my body had nothing to do with a peer to peer social contagion (I really didn’t care about the interests of my same aged peers. I cared about studying rare brain tumors and whatnot. Also it was 2011/2012) and it had everything to do with a process of development which should have been easy to reliably predict with a few of my earlier in life data points.
I fear so many other girls in my position are experiencing needless suffering from these issues and the only time their cries for help get noticed is when they develop eating disorders or when they’re diagnosed as gender dysphoric which ultimately is the natural extension of having social deficits while being an autistic pre-teen GIRL and having severe sensory processing issues that make your environment and body feel totally unreliable as is, and then with puberty, everything is worse and you don’t know why.
If indeed the social deficits experienced by autistic people are downstream impacts of delays with the development of sensory processing, and both cause autistic girls so much distress at the onset of puberty that they either go trans or develop eating disorders, that is a catastrophe.
It would make sense that the absolute first line of defense in treating (at least) teen girls even if they don’t have an autism/ adhd/ SPD diagnosis at the time the present with GD— should be a sensory-based therapy rather than one of identity affirmation, injections and scalpels. None of those things address the reason for the girl’s distress.
Treating autism with gender transition is unconscionable.
Quotes a post by T13437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The first line of gender dysphoria treatment in today’s female population needs to be some kind of sensory integration therapy, because girls tend to have worse sensory issues than boys while being better at redirecting them into non-socially disruptive ways, their sensory issues tend to get worse with the hormonal fluctuations of puberty and they’re the least likely to have been screened for autism or received any kind of sensory integration therapies.
If indeed the social deficits are downstream impacts of sensory processing issues, and both cause autistic girls so much distress at the onset of puberty that they either go trans or develop eating disorders, that is a catastrophe. It would make sense that the absolute first line of defense even if the girl doesn’t have an autism/ adhd/ SPD diagnosis yet should be a sensory-based therapy rather than one of identity affirmation, injections and scalpels. None of those things address the reason for the girl’s distress.
The reason is because dysphoric =\= trans. Trans can be used to describe those who make subjective identity claims and/or who do things to alter their appearance to not appear as their sex. Dysphoria is one potential driver for trans, and even that does not exist for the same reasons for all people. Plenty of people who transition have no gender dysphoria. They just feel very euphoric when they alter their bodies. There are lots of sources of gender dysphoria for whom the pathway of social and medical transition really does not mitigate the feelings and less invasive interventions to get to the root of the distress are in order.
https://maiapoet.substack.com/p/how-both-sides-of-the-trans-culture
To read my essay about how both sides of the culture war on trans issues keep failing autistic and adhd kids, follow the link.
🚨When kids come out as trans, their parents are bombarded by conflicting advice. The pro-trans side tells them to just affirm, and the gender critical side tells them to just say no.
So where does this advice leave smart kids with special needs?
Read my essay to find out.
Trans activists get so triggered when I talk about how they duped 12 year old me into believing I was born in the wrong body. They rage “B-Buttt that’s a MeTaPhOr y-you weren’t supposed to take that LiTerALLy.”
Wanna know which kids take metaphors literally? The AUTISTIC ones.
Trans activists hate us *because* we are effective.
Autistic children and adolescents deserve better than to be told they will only be whole when parts of themselves are gone.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨After 12 years of thinking I was born with a male brain in a female body, I now understand that I was born with an AUTISTIC brain in a female body.
I then began to understand that I could cure my own crippling gender dysphoria by better understanding my autism.
Instead of binding my breasts & pretending to be a man, I now meet my sensory needs with mild compression undershirts that don’t actively destroy my lungs, back, ribs, spine, nerves and breasts.
I now intentionally choose to wear bras with a maximum of two textures, and thick straps that don’t twist as I move, in addition to the mild (full upper body) compression shirts because I know this is what I can tolerate.
By managing the sensory needs of my whole body in all sorts of new ways, I no longer focus on the discomfort my breasts and 99.99% of bras cause me.
As a result, my body is now a much more tolerable place for my brain to live.
The only qualms I have now have with that part of my body I used to hate so much, was the destruction I’ve caused myself in the misguided attempt to fix an unacknowledged severe sensory issue (that as a kid caused me to toe walk and to compulsively pull out my eyelashes before it became fixated on gender) with an attempted gender transition.
Happy autism awareness month!
I’ve written a whole essay about trans identities in girls as a form of autistic masking. You may find it interesting.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨could normal autistic & ADHD teen struggles (going undiagnosed) be the reason so many autistic & ADHD girls think they need to ‘mask’ by being trans boys? 🏳️⚧️🧩♾️
Read my essay to find out:
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/when-trans-masc-becomes-another-mask?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
Repost to raise awareness about how girls with autistic traits may be using their transgender identities to mask those traits, and to raise awareness for the fact that therapists should know better than to socially, chemically & surgically encourage this transmasc-ing
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨could normal autistic & ADHD teen struggles (going undiagnosed) be the reason so many autistic & ADHD girls think they need to ‘mask’ by being trans boys? 🏳️⚧️🧩♾️
Read my essay to find out:
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/when-trans-masc-becomes-another-mask?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
Not everything is a conspiracy to turn your kids trans.
Some parents do sexually abuse their kids.
Those abused kids have no safe adults protecting them, except for the doctor or teacher who is mandated to.
If all parents were trustworthy, we wouldn’t need these systems.
Quotes a post by T15174; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A small number of them are gay, it’s not that this doesn’t exist. They’re just a minority of the under 18s telling their parents to trans them (perhaps they’re a larger majority in the under 11s but it feels morally wrong and factually inaccurate to attribute sexual orientation to prepubertal or even early pubertal kids for whom neither identity nor orientation are even remotely fixed) and gays are an even smaller minority in the 18-25s trying to trans themselves. Again, not to say they don’t exist because, well, hello. But I was a minority among my cohort.
There are plenty of insecure gay and straight teenagers who feel weird about their burgeoning sexual feelings for a million normal and healthy adolescent reasons, and regardless, some influence will tell them they’re either wrong for being same sex attracted or opposite sex attracted and give them a complex over it.
But my theory as to why the LGBT lobby is pushing the trans kid narrative is to trans straight teenagers into being pseudo-gay to bulk up their numbers since millennial gays grew up and became normies who got gay married, and lost any impetus for whatever communist postmodern radicalization they otherwise may have had, and the rainbow orgs need those numbers up.
When the gays became normies and you couldn’t give every one of them an identity crisis, problematize heterosexuality, promote biopsychosocial cross sex mimicry and just have at it!
I know women who were denied make up tutorial appointments after their GC opinions were deemed offensive to the largely trans clientele seeking gender affirming make up so I can see why a clinician would treat weird sex stuff as a form of gender affirmation
Somehow I managed to be trans for a very long time and only figured out what yaoi was from MTFs I met in twitter spaces after I’d already quit being trans. Then again, I didn’t use the internet to socialize with people as a kid. I used it as a research tool to find med journals
I wish more people did too. Everyone is brainwashed into thinking it’s safe and reversible, both many trans and many detrans people believe this propaganda despite there being evidence in one’s own body of the harm. Thank you for raising awareness.
🚨Clearly there’s a misunderstanding that I will clear up in depth about whether I’m advocating for eating disorders.
The 😂 emoji indicates a joke.
Neither of us are experiencing a starvation in the way that those in famine are.
We are both intentionally eating fewer calories than our bodies need to maintain their current weight, which allows us to subsist largely on the energy we’ve already converted to excess fat.
We are both starving ourselves relative to what we were eating before, because those previous caloric intakes are needed to maintain a higher body weight- which both of us are trying to avoid staying in.
I thought that much was clear. It is normal to experience intense hunger when you eat significantly fewer calories than you’re used to. So, the colloquial “omg I’m STARVING” would be an appropriate use of non-literal communication, especially paired with an added emoji for context to communicate the intended use of a colloquialism rather than literalism.
It is also normal to feel like you’re starving when eating fewer calories, and that does not mean that you need to eat more because logically we both know that we have excess fat that will sustain us for quite a while even without any access to additional food.
Eventually the stomach and body adjust to functioning at a lower caloric intake, because human beings are highly adaptable to various environments in a way that other mammals are not. We also have higher emotional capacities and therefore can use food and other substances beyond subsistence purposes.
People who accumulate excess fat are usually unaware of how and why they use food beyond subsistence, and/or have interoceptive issues which impair their ability to properly gauge bodily signals including hunger and satiety.
Why you immediately assumed that by making a joke, I was advocating for people to develop eating disorders is frankly puzzling and thoroughly illogical. I don’t see our approaches to weight loss as being materially different. We just use different words. Hope this helps.
I do wonder whether our previous ideological disagreements about trans issues has caused you to immediately choose the least logical and least charitable interpretation of my light hearted posts. Might this be the case?
Quotes a post by T01073; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I need to run a poll about this sometime, because the trans community cannot agree on how to answer this question anymore. Whereas when I was trans, they seemed to very much agree on the label applied to how I was living my life 😂
The scandal is precisely that patients who say they’re trans can get instantly prescribed radical, life-altering and health destroying interventions for conditions they don’t have on the basis of a lie they tell to their psychiatrist.
That is in fact a problem.
Quotes a post by T33125; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You just said that transitioning makes people look stupid as fuck. You’re the transphobe, I’m afraid. You also just invalidated the transitions of so many trans people. It makes you look unwell.
Since when does transition require surgeries? I thought that not all trans people do those things and that it is super valid. I don’t say I detransitioned because I stopped binding. I say I detransitioned because I stopped trying to pass as the sex I am not. Transition is entirely about trying not to be perceived as your biological sex. You’re also not answering my question, which is telling.
I’m obviously talking about those who realize that it is not making their lives better. It’s hard to say who is the majority now, and whether that will differ from who will be the majority in five years.
This entire topic is deeply polarized and there are lots of ideological reasons on both pro-trans and trans-critical sides for people to construct narratives that do not jive with reality, because the genuine pursuit of truth is absent. The research into both transition and detransition is in an abysmal state.
Both transition and detransition were historically rare phenomena. Now neither are. In my opinion, both populations are being seriously failed by mental health and medical practitioners who claim to know more than they do about objectively invasive medical & life choices, which they recommend far too carelessly.
The only people who don’t think breast binding is a harmful gender affirming intervention with the capacity to cause permanent damage are definitionally trans activists of the most dishonest variety.
Even trans activists who are honest know that breast binding is an inherently harmful medical practice, which is why they advocate for mastectomies instead.
Autism and ADHD are real, observable conditions that are highly heritable neurodevelopmental conditions which cause observable impairment.
Trans is not a heritable condition. It is a condition created by the attempt to either treat gender dysphoria, or to meet gendered embodiment goals via biopsychosocial sex mimicry.
In other words, trans is a choice someone makes because they conjecture it’ll make their lives better. It is a choice they can choose to stop making when they realize that it does not. ADHD and autism are not identity and embodiment choices that people make to treat their neurodevelopmental issues, they are in and of themselves, conditions.
The truth is, that finding solutions for this vast and diverse cohort of gender dysphoric young people is a monumental task, because the kids themselves are too young to understand their own motivations. They aren’t developmentally there yet. They are largely incapable of insight at those young adolescent ages.
Then you add in something like ASD or severe ADHD and there are basic problems of functioning that *many* these kids have, and as is, there are very few institutions even capable of seeing through the gender veneer to give these kids the help they need.
Honestly I think parenting interventions are the most useful approach in a landscape that is still predominantly ideologically captured.
I say this as someone who was the kid who was constantly in doctor’s offices, going to speech therapy, physical therapy, vision therapy, occupational therapy, social skills support groups, and psychotherapy in addition to a lot of tutoring and many extracurricular activities.
Most of these things at best only treated symptoms. The cost was that they took me out of my home environment, away from building relationships with kids my own age and with my parents. Instead, I just saw a list of incompetent “experts” who couldn’t even figure out that I was autistic and that all of my odd developmental issues followed an autistic neurodevelopmental trajectory perfectly. I got a 7 hour long psychoeducational eval/ IQ test meant to test me for learning disabilities and giftedness. The test showed both but the evaluator was just like “wow you’re so quirky” and sent me and my parents home with nothing else despite very clear evidence of severe, function impairing ADHD. They thought my toe walking was a mechanical error so they gave me Botox in addition to the leg braces, rather than understanding it as a sensory processing issue which is known to get way worse with puberty in girls particularly due to the hormonal fluctuations of the menstrual cycle.
So instead of understanding all of my issues as being part of the same neurodevelopmental etiology (call it severe adhd or ASD or whatever you want), I thought that *everything* was wrong with me because even with all of these interventions, I was totally lost.
At 11, I was already desperate to try and solve my own problems by researching and analyzing them to death. I was far more interested in understanding how to help myself than were almost any adults in my life responsible for facilitating or providing that kind of care.
I think parents who have kids like mine are best equipped to help them, but only with the right skills and tools. Parents have a vested interest in wanting their kids to learn life skills, to thrive and to gain independence (where possible. It is not in all of these cases) whereas most therapists of different kinds have no curiosity about root causes because it jeapordizes an endless income stream.
The fact that so many people treat trans as a cult rather than as a subculture comprised of different communities with varying degrees of authoritarianism basically obfuscates the role of dysfunction in family dynamics which leads to kids seeking these environments to the exclusion of interaction with their parents…. And also the degree to which sensory processing issues are 100% at the root of the struggles that particularly many of these gender dysphoric girls face.
Everything is downstream of that. If your body gives you an overwhelming sensory experience of reality from your earliest moments, of course you will try to ignore what it tells you and become disconnected from it. Of course you will fail to engage in social development healthily or properly.
But everyone just seems to be stuck to these culture war narratives that these kids are only having these ideations because of some cult, rather than that they are earnestly trying to solve their very real problems in the only way that society is giving them. That’s where I see everyone dropping the ball.
Quotes a post by A0882; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The truth is, that finding solutions for this vast and diverse cohort of gender dysphoric young people is a monumental task, because the kids themselves are too young to understand their own motivations. They aren’t developmentally there yet. Then you add in something like ASD or severe ADHD and there are basic problems of functioning that these kids have, and as is, there are very few institutions even capable of seeing through the gender veneer to give these kids the help they need.
Honestly I think parenting interventions are the most useful because having been the kid who was constantly in doctor’s offices, going to speech therapy, physical therapy, vision therapy, occupational therapy, social skills support groups, psychotherapy in addition to a lot of tutoring and many extracurricular activities- I will say that most of these things that took me out of my home environment, building relationships with kids my own age and with my parents, I just saw a list of incompetent “experts” who couldn’t even figure out that I was autistic. They thought my toe walking was a mechanical error so they gave me Botox in addition to the leg braces, rather than understanding it as a sensory processing issue which is known to get way worse with puberty in girls particularly due to the hormonal fluctuations of the menstrual cycle.
So instead of understanding all of my issues as being part of the same neurodevelopmental etiology (call it severe adhd or ASD or whatever you want), I thought that *everything* was wrong with me because even with all of these interventions, I was totally lost. I was already desperate to try and solve my own problems by researching and analyzing them to death. I was far more interested in understanding how to help myself than were almost any adults in my life responsible for facilitating or providing that kind of care.
I think parents who have kids like mine are best equipped to help them, but they need the right skills and tools. Parents have a vested interest in wanting their kids to learn life skills, to thrive and to gain independence (where possible. It is not in all of these cases) whereas most therapists of different kinds have no curiosity about root causes because it jeapordizes an endless income stream.
The fact that so many people treat trans as a cult rather than as a subculture comprised of different communities with varying degrees of authoritarianism basically obfuscates the role of dysfunction in family dynamics which leads to kids seeking these environments to the exclusion of interaction with their parents…. And also the degree to which sensory processing issues are 100% at the root of the struggles that particularly many of these gender dysphoric girls face.
Everything is downstream of that. If your body gives you an overwhelming sensory experience of reality from your earliest moments, of course you will try to ignore what it tells you and become disconnected from it. Of course you will fail to engage in social development healthily or properly.
But everyone just seems to be stuck to these culture war narratives that these kids are only having these ideations because of some cult, rather than that they are earnestly trying to solve their very real problems in the only way that society is giving them. That’s where I see everyone dropping the ball.
I wonder why that is. I thought trans people’s transitions were life saving or life improving, yet so many of them look and behave like depressed people whose underlying mental health issues have gone totally untreated by a corrupt psychiatric institution. It’s almost as if…
They think trans people are born rather than made because they lack zero insight into the fact that gender dysphoria is caused by something, and their whole worldview shatters when someone lives a trans lifestyle and then stops doing it. We prove that trans (biopsychosocial sex mimicry) is a choice. Nothing more and nothing less
Trans people on this app HATE me, even though just like most of them, I’m also an autistic gender weirdo. Why?
Because I’m just like them. But I’m NOT trans anymore.
I’m happy to be a woman who embraces her quirks instead of squashing them down under a miserable man mask.
Gen Z trans people 🏳️⚧️ think they own the rights to a very specific, autistic-coded type of gender non-conformity in women.
My existence disproves their worldview and causes them immense cognitive dissonance.
You can be an autistic gender weirdo and choose NOT to be trans!
Trans people 🏳️⚧️ still can’t decide whether I was NEVER trans, or whether I’m STILL trans.
Why’s that? 🧵⬇️
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Not trying to pass as a man is actually liberating because now I get to wear whichever quirky cat themed clothes my autistic heart desires 🐱
I’ve written an entire essay (spent 100 hours researching and writing) on the topic of autism in girls and how they use trans to mask their autistic traits. Give it a read!
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨could normal autistic & ADHD teen struggles (going undiagnosed) be the reason so many autistic & ADHD girls think they need to ‘mask’ by being trans boys? 🏳️⚧️🧩♾️
Read my essay to find out:
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/when-trans-masc-becomes-another-mask?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
🚨 How to 🏳️⚧️ trans(mask) an autistic girl in 10 simple steps:
1. Don’t diagnose her early in life.
2. Encourage her to mask her autistic traits so she doesn’t inconvenience others.
(Pay no attention to the impact this has on her. She’s not being a problem yet.)
3. Diagnose her with tons of mental illnesses she doesn’t have instead of treating her for the difficulties caused by autism she actually does.
4. Wait for puberty to hit. Wait for her to develop whatever mental illness she was misdiagnosed with because she’s floundering without help or support for her pervasive neurodevelopmental issues.
(This is a fantastic baseline to enter the inherent instability of adolescence with)
5. When at puberty she’s even more confused by how impossible it is to logic her way through profoundly illogical adolescent female social rules, tell her she’s struggling because she’s got a boy brain inside her girl body.
(Or let her figure it out online)
6. Never ever help her with the social communication delays or the sensory processing issues that make her feel overwhelmed in her own body and in the world.
7. Encourage her to socially & medically mask her autism under a ‘Transmasc’ identity.
8. Tell her it’s a legitimate treatment pathway for her legitimate condition.
9. Celebrate her for trans- masking so well!
10. Watch her mental health decline because for her whole life she’s been encouraged to think that wearing literally any mask is a better fit for her than it would ever be for her to just be her true, authentic self.
REPOST if you’ve made it to the end and think it’s evil to treat autism in girls with gender transition.
I think trans also functions as a possibility model. No one has a fully crystallized trans identity per se without hearing that ability to biopsychosocially sex mimic exists. At that point it’s just a desire or a cross-sex ideation which is either intermittent or persistent. The existence of the treatment creates desire for the treatment and I believe that is where the cross sex ideations become a trans identity
Clearly, there are people who transition (engage in biopsychosocial sex mimicry). Those people are referred to as ‘trans.’ In that sense, trans people exist. I think people transition for many different reasons, and not all of them are gender dysphoria. Many trans people have no gender dysphoria and there are many dysphorics who don’t transition, so I think it’s better to look at it as a process an individual embarks upon rather than as a metaphysical essence.
🚨Today is World Autism Awareness Day 2026.
I spent 100 hours researching one overlooked reason that so many autistic teen girls develop gender dysphoria.
Autistic girls real support grounded in evidence, not to be maimed by the trans 🏳️⚧️ trend.
Please REPOST if you agree 🧵⬇️
🚨Today is World Autism Awareness Day 2026.
I spent 100 hours researching one overlooked reason that so many autistic teen girls develop gender dysphoria.
Autistic girls DESERVE evidence-based support; NOT to be maimed by the trans 🏳️⚧️ trend.
Please REPOST if you agree 🧵⬇️
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨Today is World Autism Awareness Day 2026.
I spent 100 hours researching one overlooked reason that so many autistic teen girls develop gender dysphoria.
Autistic girls real support grounded in evidence, not to be maimed by the trans 🏳️⚧️ trend.
Please REPOST if you agree 🧵⬇️
🚨Today is World Autism Awareness Day 2026.
I spent 100 hours researching one overlooked reason that so many autistic teen girls develop gender dysphoria.
Autistic girls DESERVE evidence-based support; NOT to be maimed by the trans 🏳️⚧️ trend.
Please REPOST if you agree 🧵⬇️
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨Today is World Autism Awareness Day 2026.
I spent 100 hours researching one overlooked reason that so many autistic teen girls develop gender dysphoria.
Autistic girls real support grounded in evidence, not to be maimed by the trans 🏳️⚧️ trend.
Please REPOST if you agree 🧵⬇️
🚨could normal autistic & ADHD teen struggles (going undiagnosed) be the reason so many autistic & ADHD girls think they need to ‘mask’ by being trans boys? 🏳️⚧️🧩♾️
Read my essay to find out:
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/when-trans-masc-becomes-another-mask?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
🚨Today is World Autism Awareness Day 2026.
I spent 100 hours researching one overlooked reason that so many autistic teen girls develop gender dysphoria.
Autistic girls real support grounded in evidence, not to be maimed by the trans 🏳️⚧️ trend.
Please REPOST if you agree 🧵⬇️
🚨 I’ve decided to be trans 🏳️⚧️ again.
For real this time. 🧵
After marinating in all the loving, tolerant messages from trans & detrans activists; especially the ones calling me a faker, a traitor, non-binary, or casually threatening to unalive me…. I’ve finally seen the light.
Quitting my imaginary transition was obviously a massive betrayal…. to everyone. The death threats, threats to beat me up and the rape threats were exactly the tough love I needed to reflect and realize: I just wasn’t committed enough.
To prove my devotion and silence the doubters, I’m going all-in. Since I can’t actually change my XX chromosomes or grow a male body no matter what I do, I’ve decided to pursue every single trans surgery I wisely skipped the first time.
And because half-measures are for cowards, I’m also amputating one leg. That way I can finally live as my true authentic self: a heroic amputee veteran from WW2.
No one will call me “fake trans” after that level of commitment. This is peak gender-affirming care. It’s also era-affirming care. Trans activists and war reenactment activists alike will surely celebrate my 5-7 years of glowing gender (and era) transition satisfaction before the predictable deeper regret inevitably sets in.
And when I experience even worse regret and permanent disabling impairment this time around, no one will get to call me “fake detrans” either. After all, certain detrans voices have made it crystal clear they won’t respect my lived experience or contributions to the discourse about autism, gender dysphoria and the harms of breast binding (the most common FTM gender affirming intervention) until I reach this exact threshold of self-harm. It’s a totally coherent, reasonable stance for anti-transmedicalization advocates to take!
And I’m doing it all for the approval of online strangers who care so deeply about which words I’m allowed to use to describe my own journey in my mind, in my body and in my life. Because they care profoundly about my health and well-being, obviously.
I’ve already permanently damaged my developing chest by binding starting as a minor and continuing into early adulthood to affirm my gender and to pass as a man in the non-gender affirming Middle East. Clearly that wasn’t legitimate or risky enough. I was not devoted enough. Now I must remove the damaged breasts entirely. Otherwise, I have no right to speak about what happened to me and to warn other autistic girls (and their parents) away from the same path.
Their behavior has made that crystal clear.
Their validation is everything.
Thank you to my glitter family for the endless support and kindness throughout this difficult journey. Your threats, insults, and purity tests have truly healed and radicalized me.
Understanding (and medical referrals) appreciated. 🏳️⚧️➡️🦿
For FTMs, the “T” voice is well-known, as are the top surgery and phalloplasty scars, as are the body proportions. And now growing a beard if one is able, does not offset these things for normies. It used to be that only trans women had a hard time passing. Now even trans men who may have passed as short men with an interesting or unusual vocal quality, or who could play off chest scars as some other kind of operation, are now immediately clocked as women who did stuff to look like men. They pass as trans now, whereas in the past, the vast majority seemed to be able to convincingly be read by others as just short men.
“Why are so many trans men gay?”
Because most people on planet Earth are straight. And gender ideology once adopted as a trans self-concept, queers them into being “gay” via its upside down world framework.
Quotes a post by A0882; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Why are so many trans men gay?”
Because most people on planet Earth are straight. And gender ideology once adopted as a trans self-concept, queers them into being “gay” via its upside down world framework.
After having spent hundreds of hours in the literature to understand where everyone is getting their definitions of desistance from, I respectfully disagree with this take.
Either you believe that transition is something akin to a change of sex, which can be achieved fully with enough procedures (a “full” transition), or you don’t hold that belief.
This is the difference between holding a belief in the legitimacy of old school transsexualism over the trans-queer zeitgeist of today, or in the gender-critical belief that the entire enterprise underpinning legally reified, biopsychosocial sex mimicry is conceptually illegitimate based on its own premises.
This thing we call “gender transition” is a trajectory of biopsychosocial sex mimicry. We don’t live in the old school trans era. People who aim to achieve the goal of biopsychosocial sex mimicry do so in a variety of different ways which are sex-variable, and therefore these patients have a variety of clinical needs. As a clinician yourself, it is of the utmost importance for those needs to be understood rather than to be dismissed simply because the patient’s bad outcome isn’t the worst possible imaginable outcome.
Btw, the worst possible imaginable outcome of transition is premature death by suicide (from an inability to cope with regret or from untreated underlying mental health issues) or from transition related injuries. By that standard, all of the patients you are seeing have lucked out… because they are alive and talking to you.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: On the absurd dichotomy of who desisters and detransitioners are/ which experiences define them (as someone who has spent hundreds of hours immersed in the literature on this subtopic)
Desistance in the clinical literature on gender dysphoria has always described the natural cessation of cross-sex ideation and dissatisfaction with one’s sex, measured by the fading desire to pursue any form of transition (role and body/ appearance modification).
It referred specifically to the cross-sex desire fading over time in cohorts of young boys who presented with distress about their sex prior to puberty.
With the natural changes of puberty and often psychological/ play-based interventions which encouraged natal sex identification, many simply grew out of it. Their cross sex desires desisted. They were the “desisters.” Their counterparts with enduring cross sex ideation were the “persisters.” The dichotomy was always “desisters v. persisters” rather than “desisters v. detransitioners.”
That was the context. Early onset gender distress in boys who without any transition intervention, but with other psychological interventions, mostly grew out of those desires.
There were no puberty blockers offered to most of these boys (until the later Dutch studies which still measured desistance as cessation of transition desire as a variable independent of medical or social intervention precisely to test the impact of said intervention on cementing cross sex identities) ***because**** the interventions at the time were psychological and aimed at reconciling the boy with his sexed body and role.
As such, social transitions were neither recommended nor possible in the stage of life through which desistance occurred. This changed with the Dutch protocol, but even they recommended against social transition prior to puberty for fear of needlessly cementing cross sex identities.
Even then, there were no whole cohorts of teenaged girls declaring specifically “I’m trans/non-binary, give me hormones” for the first time in early adolescence. The reason desistance was used purely to describe a psychological state of cessation of cross-sex desire fading with time was because the clinicians were trying to determine which underlying factors might cause a young boy’s dissatisfaction with growing into a man to either necessitate intervention as an adult or not, and the scope of analysis was focused on sexual orientation in later stages of adolescence and early adulthood. Studies from that era, like those by Zucker and others, documented desistance rates often exceeding 80% in these unmedicated boy cohorts once puberty took its natural course.
And btw in those days, even social transitions (the real life test) for adults were interventions recommended by clinicians in a rigorous gatekeeping process before hormonal interventions were prescribed, to act as a measure by which to assess transition fitness.
2
The clearest, most coherent definition remains straightforward: to detransition means to have pursued any attempt of biopsychosocial sex mimicry, and then to have stopped. (Basically what @TTExulansic is arguing but with more precise jargon.)
Yet some prominent detrans voices, those who underwent extensive medical interventions themselves and now advocate fiercely against them, push for a stricter true-detrans gatekeeping that requires specific surgeries or hormones. This stance carries significant hypocrisy.
Creating a category of true-detrans and fake-detrans implicitly accepts that true-trans people exist as a more legitimate category, with an innate essence that justifies the necessity of their path towards objectively extreme body modifications…. Because if there weren’t something fundamentally different about them, why would they go down this extreme path?
If some trans identities are true and immutable, then early medical experiments on distressed youth become harder to criticize. After all, the reasoning goes, the real ones won't regret it as adults.
Many of us who have stepped away from transition know these choices often arise from genuine distress which we’ve misattributed to an innate cross-sex essence.
Defining detransition to include anyone who pursued social, legal, or medical steps and then desisted from their cross-sex embodiment desires doesn't erase the most severe medical regret stories.
It actually reflects reality more honestly and improves research and support for everyone navigating this.
A reasonable person, trans or not, detrans or not, should see the value in consistent terminology. It leads to better data on outcomes, clearer conversations about what actually resolves distress, and fewer irreversible steps taken lightly under the pretense of a panacea.
OP’s narrow attempt at gatekeeping who and what counts as detransition is borrowing the same flawed logic it claims to oppose, by treating some cross-sex identifications and some cross-sex mimicry as more real than others, rather than actually advocating for the full range of psychosocial, medical and legal support detransitioners as a patient population need in order to recover from the harms we’ve experienced from gender transition.
5
This new, narrower definition of desistance, to encompass what is actually a cohort of detransitioners who in addition to experiencing a cessation of cross sex ideation also often experience transition regret and transition-related health consequences is pushed by some (like OP) who seem to have only skimmed the literature at best. Or at worst, are just playing a pseudo-intellectual game of identity politics and oppression Olympics.
And their definition is actually a massive impediment to proper research and understanding.
This re-definition of desistance as a separate category of those who have transitioned (but not in ways they personally see as valid) creates real inconsistency with decades of prior research.
It feels like a clumsy retrofit that ignores how dramatically the gender medicine landscape has shifted.
In today’s DIY reality, where both social and medical transitions can easily bypass any semblance of gatekeeping entirely, clinicians have been reduced to rubber stamps that individuals can easily ignore. Most of these interventions have left the clinical landscape as a necessary condition for access with all the DIY.
Gender clinicians today don’t care about the persistence or desistance of transition desire anymore because they don’t have a role beyond rubber stamping, and even their rubber stamp means nothing because you can go on the internet and get as many breast binders and cross-sex hormones as you could want.
Tracking persistence or desistance of transition desire has largely lost its old clinical meaning. So why are these true trans/true detrans people trying to re-define it with zero understanding of the term, what it actually tried to measure and how its context and goals differ from those of today?
The core experience of transition isn't a checklist of procedures. Those are tools aimed at achieving a goal of biopsychosocial sex mimicry. Some use them to attain the goal because they feel they need them, and others don’t feel they need them to attain the goal.
Transition is the intentional pursuit of cross-sex mimicry, driven by the belief that one must live as the opposite sex to be whole/ sane/ or authentically themselves.
Insisting that only certain medical steps count as real transition draws an arbitrary line that ignores this fundamental reality. It's an absurd hierarchy that treats transition like a menu rather than as a defining life trajectory built on cementing cross sex ideation into an embodied state.
4
Nowadays, social transition is not an intervention doctors need to prescribe. Though in the past, it was.
Both the parents of young children who see something about trans kids on the internet, and teenagers and adults of any age don’t need a medical permission slip to cross-dress in public, to socially or legally change their name, or to change their sex marker. They just go ahead and do it.
In the same way, breast binders, though they don’t need to be prescribed to access them, still are recommended by pediatric gender doctors who publish entire guidelines endorsing these medical interventions as treatments for gender dysphoria.
Also btw, breast binding used to be an entirely DIY practice that doctors didn’t endorse, prescribe or recommend when it was done with duct tape. But now, with commercial grade breast binders available on the market, these practices are granted clinical legitimacy in the halls of gender medicine. They have become totally legitimized medical treatments with a false veneer of safety simply because they’re now clinically endorsed despite zero studies showing anything but long-term harm in 97.2% of cases as per a 2016 study.
Hell, even cross-sex hormones can be accessed these days without a prescription, often through unregulated online pharmacies and homebrew networks that have few if any safeguards against minors or adults ordering them.
And if you have enough money, you don’t need to get a diagnosis for insurance to cover a gender procedure. You can pay out of pocket.
Every step of transition intervention from social, to legal, to medical, to surgical, has a non-clinical or non-formal diagnostic route these days.
Gender transitions are increasingly becoming an almost fully DIY enterprise, and they have been trending in this direction for a while for those who have fallen asleep at the wheel.
3
On the absurd dichotomy of who desisters and detransitioners are/ which experiences define them (as someone who has spent hundreds of hours immersed in the literature on this subtopic)
Desistance in the clinical literature on gender dysphoria has always described the natural cessation of cross-sex ideation and dissatisfaction with one’s sex, measured by the fading desire to pursue any form of transition (role and body/ appearance modification).
It referred specifically to the cross-sex desire fading over time in cohorts of young boys who presented with distress about their sex prior to puberty.
With the natural changes of puberty and often psychological/ play-based interventions which encouraged natal sex identification, many simply grew out of it. Their cross sex desires desisted. They were the “desisters.” Their counterparts with enduring cross sex ideation were the “persisters.” The dichotomy was always “desisters v. persisters” rather than “desisters v. detransitioners.”
That was the context. Early onset gender distress in boys who without any transition intervention, but with other psychological interventions, mostly grew out of those desires.
There were no puberty blockers offered to most of these boys (until the later Dutch studies which still measured desistance as cessation of transition desire as a variable independent of medical or social intervention precisely to test the impact of said intervention on cementing cross sex identities) ***because**** the interventions at the time were psychological and aimed at reconciling the boy with his sexed body and role.
As such, social transitions were neither recommended nor possible in the stage of life through which desistance occurred. This changed with the Dutch protocol, but even they recommended against social transition prior to puberty for fear of needlessly cementing cross sex identities.
Even then, there were no whole cohorts of teenaged girls declaring specifically “I’m trans/non-binary, give me hormones” for the first time in early adolescence. The reason desistance was used purely to describe a psychological state of cessation of cross-sex desire fading with time was because the clinicians were trying to determine which underlying factors might cause a young boy’s dissatisfaction with growing into a man to either necessitate intervention as an adult or not, and the scope of analysis was focused on sexual orientation in later stages of adolescence and early adulthood. Studies from that era, like those by Zucker and others, documented desistance rates often exceeding 80% in these unmedicated boy cohorts once puberty took its natural course.
And btw in those days, even social transitions (the real life test) for adults were interventions recommended by clinicians in a rigorous gatekeeping process before hormonal interventions were prescribed, to act as a measure by which to assess transition fitness.
2
🧵 🚨Breast binding is a medical intervention.
Breast, chest & abdominal binders are commonly used outside of gender medicine for short periods of time (maximum 6 weeks) under clinical supervision to aid in post surgical recovery.
Like with other trans-medical interventions, this one is used off label for treating gender dysphoria. There is no limit on how many days, months, years or decades these medical devices are reccomended to be used for, because it is a physical/medical treatment for feelings about your gender that could last or could decipate.
Breast binders are used & recommended by gender clinicians and by WPATH as treatments for gender dysphoria.
They permanently alter the body through long-term physical compression of the breasts, ribs and lungs, complete with documented risks like tissue damage, restricted breathing, rib damage, permanent changes to the form and function of the breasts, skin issues, musculoskeletal damage and others.
To deny this fact is to be deliberately obtuse.
Even some trans activists are beginning to move in the direction of admitting that gender-affirming breast binding cannot be done safely (though their pivot is to encourage the validity of gender-affirming mastectomies moreso than to discourage binding, which OPs framing despite coming from a place of alleged detrans advocacy, endorses somehow)
All trans medical interventions that categorically alter the body, binders very much included, exist primarily to extend the shelf life of a social transition, making the cross-sex presentation more believable and sustainable over time.
Even a purely social transition, with no permanent physical changes, is still called social transition, not social persistence, for a reason. It is an active intervention: a deliberate choice to live and present as the opposite sex, rooted in the conviction that one's sense of self requires crossing sex categories to feel authentic or sane. (The former wording is Gen Z coded and the latter is everyone else coded)
1
Quoting @TTExulansic: Here let me help clear it up
To be detrans, you have to have been trans and then stopped.
It sounds like you’re frustrated by the comments made by an individual who is not me, and comments he made in my spaces.
As you know from your own participation in my spaces when you were an out and proud trans activist, I invite people into my spaces to share their opinions even when I disagree with what they say. What was said about you which you interpret as abuse and lies, is inappropriate for you to project onto me for simply hosting a space where others are free to speak.
I’m not exactly sure what “abuse and lies” you are referring to which were said about you in my space (not by me… there is a difference) which you evidently disagree with, because I have not seen you articulate them clearly.
If what was said about you in my spaces is in fact untrue, and you wish to correct the record about what is true about you, you have every right to dispute it with that individual who made claims about you which you believe to be or know to be false.
Furthermore, being lied about, while unpleasant, distressing and potentially reputation damaging, is still in no way comparable to becoming aware of someone in your inner circle making detailed threats of violence, expressing disturbing violent fantasies about women, and their attempt to find themselves in proximity to the individual they are threatening so as to presumably carry them out or to continue the intimidation or harassment.
Please be intellectually honest with yourself.
Quotes a post by T13360; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It sounds like you’re frustrated by the comments made by an individual who is not me, and comments he made in my spaces.
As you know from your own participation in my spaces when you were an out and proud trans activist, I invite people into my spaces to share their opinions even when I disagree with what they say. What was said about you which you interpret as abuse and lies, is inappropriate for you to project onto me for simply hosting a space where others are free to speak.
I’m not exactly sure what “abuse and lies” you are referring to which were said about you in my space (not by me… there is a difference) which you evidently disagree with, because I have not seen you articulate them clearly.
If what was said about you in my spaces is in fact untrue, and you wish to correct the record about what is true about you, you have every right to dispute it with that individual who made claims about you which you believe to be or know to be false.
Furthermore, being lied about, while unpleasant, distressing and potentially reputation damaging, is still in no way comparable to becoming aware of someone in your inner circle making detailed threats of violence, expressing disturbing violent fantasies about women, and their attempt to find themselves in proximity to the individual they are threatening so as to presumably carry them out or to continue the intimidation or harassment.
Please be intellectually honest with yourself.
I get flack from trans activists for “claiming to be a woman” while wearing occasional bow ties (which should make me non-binary).
I also get flack from certain TERFs for having good faith conversations with trans people & their supporters.
Being a heretic is so fun 😂
# Not all TERFs/ Not all Trans, BUT:
TERF accounts are the only ones that give me shit for having conversations with trans people and trans supporters in good faith.
Trans accounts are the only ones who give me shit for my gender non-conforming ways of dressing.
Heresy is fun
When I was trans, I thought I had found true freedom.
Only when I stopped pretending to be a man did I feel free to leap in this spring garden, arms open, embracing the home that is my body.
No one *needs* to rewrite their whole identity to become their most authentic self.
Me in 2022 could never have imagined my life in 2026.
I went from being undercover trans 🏳️⚧️ and an Israeli-Palestinian peace activist to being a detrans activist who raises awareness about the harms of gender-affirming breast binding at @genspect
Being in your 20’s is wild.
🚨The whole point of every trans🏳️⚧️ -medical intervention is to make passing as the opposite sex more likely (not to guarantee it).
But if one can pass as the opposite sex in society without needing to do all of these myriad of medical interventions, that doesn’t mean they haven’t meaningfully transitioned.
Here’s why:
The whole purpose of the 🏳️⚧️medical interventions is to aid in the social transition under the presumption that this protocol will mitigate or cure the feelings of gender distress.
I now have big disagreements with these premises as you know, but I digress, as that is not the point of this post. To continue:
The breast binding I did to pass as a man, made it possible for me to pass as a guy (a teenage boy, usually) in the society I lived in.
Here I am on the men’s side of the western wall at 19, where the local Orthodox Jews presumed I was a young boy who had not gotten his bar mitzvah yet. When I informed them I was 19 and indeed had not had a bar mitzvah, they without my knowledge did one for me there 😂.
This pattern would continue in many aspects of my life both in israel and in the palestinian territories over the course of the next half decade.
I established friendships and worked under a male identity. I was a peace activist under a male identity. I went out in the town, to bars, went on hikes, to raves in the desert, I crossed military checkpoints known in a male identity. And I was always relieved when soldiers and bartenders alike didn’t speak enough English to notice the “F” on my documents, and to question me about it in front of a group of people who all knew me under a male identity.
People’s only question was why I looked so young, and not whether I was really a woman. I was ok looking increasingly young for my age, and I had to be because I could not yet access the bureaucracy needed to get my hands on high doses of injectable testosterone to grow a beard. So I spent years living undocumented in a country, paying half a year’s rent up front in cash and working shit jobs for cash while I fought the bureaucracy for over three years to become a citizen so I could access those things by the time I would no longer be believably seen as a male of my age. That constitutes a meaningful transition, socially. Does it not?
Additionally, the medical intervention I used to facilitate the social transition was a breast binder. I began to intervene in my body in this way **years** before I transitioned socially in order to ensure (what I was convinced at age 12) better ‘top surgery’ outcomes due to smaller breasts and potential eligibility for a keyhole procedure without scars rather than a double incision mastectomy with nipple and areola grafts which if I were to take my shirt off, would potentially impede my passability in adulthood. That was my logic. At 12, I thought of binding pre-social transition as something akin to a puberty blocker at the time.
The result of my attempts to modify the appearance of my body so as to pass as a man in society have left me with damage, disfigurement and pain which I was not even remotely warned could happen when I was a 12 year old kid back in 2011/2012 and got binding advice from online forums. The only things discussed in those days were that ace bandages and duct tape could make you crack a rib, not that if you start intervening in your body in this way as a little kid and even with ‘less invasive’ methods, that by adulthood, it will disfigure you and leave you in pain.
But, it achieved its intended goal, which was to spoof people about the fact that I have a female body. In what way is that not a ‘meaningful’ medical transition?
I now live with the effects of long-term breast binding I did precisely to pass as the opposite sex, and because I was not warned of anything remotely similar to what I now experience in my body every day, I am warning others about it so that at least they understand what they could be signing up for if they attempt the same.
Quotes a post by T00863; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The whole point of all of these trans-medical interventions is not to guarantee, but to make passing as the opposite sex more likely.
But if one can pass as the opposite sex in society without needing to do all of these myriad of medical interventions, that doesn’t mean they haven’t meaningfully transitioned. Here’s why:
The whole purpose of the medical interventions is to aid in the social transition under the presumption that this protocol will mitigate or cure the feelings of gender distress. I have disagreements with these premises as you are well aware, but I digress, as that is not the point of this post. To continue:
The breast binding I did to pass as a man, made it possible for me to pass as a guy (a teenage boy, usually) in the society I lived in. Here I am on the men’s side of the western wall at 19, where the local Orthodox Jews presumed I was a young boy who had not gotten his bar mitzvah yet. When I informed them I was 19 and indeed had not had a bar mitzvah, they without my knowledge did one for me there 😂.
This pattern would continue in many aspects of my life both in israel and in the palestinian territories over the course of the next half decade. I established friendships and worked under a male identity. I was a peace activist under a male identity. I went out in the town, to bars, went on hikes, to raves in the desert, I crossed military checkpoints known in a male identity. And I was always relieved when soldiers and bartenders alike didn’t speak enough English to notice the “F” on my documents, and to question me about it in front of a group of people who all knew me under a male identity.
People’s only question was why I looked so young, and not whether I was really a woman. I was ok looking increasingly young for my age, and I had to be because I could not yet access the bureaucracy needed to get my hands on high doses of injectable testosterone to grow a beard. So I spent years living undocumented in a country, paying half a year’s rent up front in cash and working shit jobs for cash while I fought the bureaucracy for over three years to become a citizen so I could access those things by the time I would no longer be believably seen as a man of my age. That constitutes a meaningful transition, socially. Does it not?
Additionally, the medical intervention I used to facilitate the social transition was a breast binder. I began to intervene in my body in this way **years** before I transitioned socially in order to ensure, what I was convinced at age 12, better ‘top surgery’ outcomes due to smaller breasts and potential eligibility for a keyhole procedure without scars rather than a double incision mastectomy with nipple and areola grafts which if I were to take my shirt off, would potentially impede my passability in adulthood. That was my logic. At 12, I thought of binding pre-social transition as something akin to a puberty blocker at the time.
The result of my attempts to modify the appearance of my body so as to pass as a man in society have left me with damage, disfigurement and pain which I was not even remotely warned could happen when I was a 12 year old kid back in 2011/2012 and got binding advice from online forums. The only things discussed in those days were that ace bandages and duct tape could make you crack a rib, not that if you start intervening in your body in this way as a little kid and even with less invasive methods, that by adulthood, it will disfigure you and leave you in pain.
But, it achieved its intended goal, which was to spoof people about the fact that I have a female body. In what way is that not a ‘meaningful’ medical transition?
I now live with the effects of long-term breast binding I did precisely to pass as the opposite sex, and because I was not warned of anything remotely similar to what I now experience in my body every day, I am warning others about it so that at least they understand what they could be signing up for if they attempt the same.
You’re a 21 year old adult and you decided to beef with me on the internet. And I responded. Take accountability for your actions.
It is telling that your best attempt at a counter-argument is to insult me for physical disabilities I was born with, over my gender non-conforming style and that you felt the need to invalidate my experiences of gender transition. How very progressive of a trans person to do!
I merely responded in kind.
Am YISRAEL 🇮🇱 chai. May the beautiful people of Iran be freed from Islamic terrorist rule.
Be well,
Maia.
Quotes a post by T28089; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If gender affirming breast binders are just compression clothing, there should be no problems for trans people if I manage to get these things banned. There’s all sorts of ‘compression clothing’ out there.
I’m all for banning public funding of transgender body modifications and all for diverting those funds for these people who think I’m a man to get their eyes repaired if they so wish
Drag queens aren’t really trying to deceive anyone about their sex (their whole thing is looking like the most outlandish possible mix of man & woman traits for a performance where everyone paying them is paying to see a man in a dress) and neither are prepubescent children whose parents pick out their clothes.
Trans wasn’t a thing I identified as. ‘Identifying as trans’ as a concept makes no sense. I took actions to deceive others about my sex and those actions are ‘trans.’
You still haven’t shown me how your definition has any utility either conceptually or clinically, for the purposes of investigating and treating transition-related injuries.
So I guess you’d be happy if gender affirming breast binding were outlawed considering you’re saying it’s not gender affirming/trans healthcare?
Cool. I’ll talk to my government contacts about drafting that up right now!
Breast binding is a medical intervention with medical consequences used in other areas of medicine (just like puberty blockers are) with a harm/benefit analysis. In gender medicine it is used off label (not for its intended use) even where no pathology or post-surgical necessity warrants such an intervention. Seems like your understanding of trans is based on a desire to uphold a notion of true transsexualism that even most old school FTMs would disagree with.
All of these trans-medical interventions into the function of the body are meant to be aids in one’s ability to pass/sex mimic. But the ultimate truth is that there are people who live their lives being known as not their sex who have used few if any of them.
Show me how your argument of drawing the line of “trans identifying” to “trans” at some modifications to the body while excluding others which are used for the same exact purpose is in any way coherent.
Sooo lemme get this straight. My years-long LARP as a male Orthodox Jew was just me ‘identifying as’ trans, rather than me *living as* trans?
Put your word salad back in the fridge, Karen.
Quotes a post by T00132; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Do you think “trans” is a medical condition that needs to be treated?
If so, tell me where this medical condition exists in the body, what the treatments are how these treatments you mention aim to theoretically fix it, and how one knows when their ‘trans’ condition is fixed…
Funny how you see legitimacy in the trans concept such that you want to mince words about it, even though you claim to advocate for the sanctity of women’s sports lolz
For those who would like to understand my thoughts on why so many autistic girls think they’re trans boys, you can read my essays on Substack: linked below and in my bio.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨Why Do So Many Autistic Kids Think They're Born in the Wrong Body?
I used to be trans, and now I'm not. What I have always been, is on the autism spectrum. This is the last essay I'll write as a 25 year old, so be sure to send it to a parent of an autistic or ADHD kid ;) 🔗👇
These people still can’t decide whether I was never trans or whether I’m still trans. Here’s the simple truth:
I used to be trans, but I’m not anymore.
My whole “gender journey” was a catastrophic judgement error belonging to an autistic 12 year old, and it managed to impair my health & functioning for over a decade.
My advocacy is a form of taking accountability. Rather than complaining about how I’m some kind of pitiable victim (I do not see myself like this) or that current trans people are inherently villains for simply making a choice (which, yes, I see as being risky, not a panacea and net detrimental to health and functioning, to be avoided at all costs) I investigate the phenomenon of ‘trans’ in depth; clinically, historically, politically and about how the trans self-concept has been understood throughout time by those who hold it.
As a part of this investigation, I have written numerous essays analyzing my thought processes throughout those years of my life including;
What caused me as a 12 year old to think that such a catastrophic idea could be such a good one that I continued it until 24 despite the numerous sacrifices it required of me along the way.
The underlying issues (autism namely) which precipitated and interacted with my desire to transition.
The misconceptions I encountered about transition as a 12 year old and how they impacted my life and my health: psychologically, psychosocially and physically.
The harms of “gender affirming” breast binding.
If you would like to engage in a good faith discussion about my arguments rather than to engage in irrelevant comments about my appearance, feel free to read any of my essays on Substack, linked below and in my bio.
Quotes a post by T32732; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans people get a whole month in June and some days in November. Why can’t detransitioners have one single day to raise awareness about the fact that we too exist?
Quotes a post by T28307; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Teen girls (like the one I was) who think they’re transgender 🏳️⚧️, are being told it’s safe and reversible to bind their breasts.
But here’s what girls like me were NEVER told:
That not only will long-term binding destroy our healthy breasts, but potentially our skin, lungs, nerves, necks, and spines as well. That this damage only gets more painful with time, not less.
That we will live with lasting pain and disfigurement to our chests sustained because of breast binding, whether we continue onto mastectomy or whether we do not. That mastectomy will not ‘erase’ or undo the harms of binding.
Those who argue that “gender affirming” breast binding is “just social transition” akin to a change of clothes are either simply ignorant or they are simply LIARS. I am done mincing words here.
I no longer care whether the people who peddle these dangerous ideas via bad arguments call themselves trans activists, gender critical activists or detransition activists.
An identity label or activist label of any kind does not entitle one to blatantly mislead the public about the most common source of transition-related injuries that young women experience.
Breast/chest binders are medical devices with approved clinical uses in post-surgical recovery for very short periods of time under strict medical supervision to monitor harms.
There is no legitimate medical reason for a healthy girl or woman to be compressing her entire upper body (especially during development) for 8-12 hour days, stretching into months and then into years at a time. It will neither make her happier, nor healthier, nor more functional. It will only damage her body, cause her a potential lifetime of devastating pain and make her desperately want her now irreparably damaged breasts, removed.
How do I know?
Because I was one of those young women who was lied to.
Because my whole generation was lied to.
And because so many people, both trans activists and gender critical activists continue to equivocate about “safe” ways to bind your breasts without so much as study showing it can be done safely.
Thank you to the team at @genspect including the spirited, determined and energetic @stellaomalley3 for giving me a platform to raise awareness about the cause of (by far) the most common but least discussed sources of transition injuries faced by young women, and of course, for allowing me to share my thoughts on gender identity ideation, desistance, detransition and to say a few words on how these themes overlap with autism.
There’s nothing “medically proven” about how screwing up the endocrine system & damaging/removing healthy body parts is supposed to reduce mental suffering.
Nearly trans person I talked to about this when I was trans, discussed being still very dysphoric *years into* transition.
There’s nothing “medically proven” about how screwing up the endocrine system & damaging/removing healthy body parts is supposed to reduce mental suffering.
Nearly trans person I talked to about this when I was trans, discussed being still very dysphoric *years into* transition.
Quotes a post by T23774; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans activists either think I’m still trans or that I was never trans. Some of these trans activists (not OP) LARP as detrans activists… which makes it all the funnier.
Quotes a post by T28828; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@ADM_Christine of @HHSGov is a truly exceptional man, who unlike his predecessor Rachel/Richard Levine, 1) knows he is a man and 2) wants to protect youth from harmful, experimental transgender 🏳️⚧️ procedures.
Naturally, he now owns one of my handmade totes!
Thanks @genspect for such an incredible event.
Trans activists have this habit of making unreasonable + insane demands, threatening those who don’t comply & then narc spiralling when their unhinged behavior gets socially punished.
They really do bring this backlash onto themselves instead of moderating any of their stances.
Quoting @BuckAngel: Since when does your SEX marker prevent you from driving or getting a job?
I did it for years and never had an issue!
All you idiot trans activists brought this on yourselves and you will never admit it.
Trans activists have this habit of making unreasonable and insane demands, threatening those who don’t comply and then narc spiralling when their unhinged behavior gets socially punished. They really do bring this backlash onto themselves instead of moderating their stances.
WPATH already is an organization of activists who take their recommendations directly from other activists. If the activists say that misgendering is violence and that trans people have such bad outcomes because of minority stress, it’s not a stretch that the organizations overseeing their care would affirm murder as a valid form of gender affirming care. It just takes one worse activist to find themselves in that group to make it possible
Not all trans people are murderers.
But why do so many of their communities think it’s ok to murder someone for ‘misgendering’ you?
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨 16-year-old girl Julia Egler murders her mom for not affirming her as transgender. 🏳️⚧️
What could possibly go wrong when society empowers delusional people to become paranoid about a trans genocide whenever someone accurately notices their sex?
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedcrime casemental illnessvictim dismissalviolence terror
Hmmm I wonder why ideologically captured mainstream media institutions wouldn’t include the non-affirmed for being trans motive for murdering her mother into their report back in 2024 😂
Watch the video linked in the thread.
Simply the fact that someone can avoid getting treated for the real issues they are suffering from by virtue of declaring a transgender identity, because clinicians abdicate their responsibilities and lose their minds over this, is harmful to suffering individuals and to society
I fear that the certain sections of the gender critical movement are not protecting themselves from the potential of unhinged violence from anyone who espouses a trans-critical belief. Critical thinking and pattern recognition are virtues. Sometimes there just are red flags.
Quotes a post by A2190; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I mean, sure. But not all of those disorders involve violent tendencies. When transgender identity enters the picture, suddenly clinicians feel it’s okay to stop doing their jobs; assessing and treating the real issues their patients have, whatever myriad of things those may be.
Not all people who transition have to suppress violent urges when someone accurately detects their sex. That said, some are delusional, feel so entitled to affirmation from everyone else, and trans activist narratives of a “genocide” make them feel that murder is self-defense.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnessvictim dismissalviolence terror
When you claim to be a TERF or gender-critical activist yet make trans activist arguments less intelligently than they could be made, you are merely a less intelligent trans activist operative.
🚨When you claim to be a TERF or gender-critical activist yet make trans activist arguments less intelligently than they could be made, you are merely a less intelligent trans activist operative.
Quotes a post by T01053; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans activists didn’t freak out at gender docs who chemically castrated kids without long-term follow-up data.
It’s almost like they never cared about proving their radical experiment was a good idea. Their plan was just to experiment on kids & brow beat us into letting them.
But she was nonbinary. What gives you the right to say that her nonbinary identity wasn’t valid? I thought all trans and nonbinary identities are valid
🚨Both trans people 🏳️⚧️ and detrans people 🦎 who are honest, decent individuals admit that breast binding is inherently dangerous, damaging, and harmful.
Anyone, trans or detrans, who downplays this obvious damage is either an idiot or genuinely evil. I’m convinced.
Both Trans & Detrans have an ideological victimhood component for many of my fellow zoomers. It seems dumb that millennials or gen X with similar experiences would fall for this type of framing because it is the thinking style of an immature individual
That is precisely what both trans and detrans are. Actions underpinned by thought processes. Identifying as either is simply a statement of “I have these thoughts and engage in these processes upon that basis” or “I no longer have those thoughts and therefore choose not to continue processes pursuant to those thoughts.”
Or am I missing something?
26.5 isn’t young, but it’s not fully old either. By this age, I’ve lived multiple separate character arcs and through tons of terror attacks. I think that makes me experientially old. I went from being trans-gender to being trans-age.
Quotes a post by T01053; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
All I do is analyze how I got into trans, through trans, and out of trans. I analyze my thought processes throughout the whole process. I talk about the benefits and the drawbacks of the decisions and discuss their utility in my life at the time. That’s literally what I do 😂. I didn’t transition because I hated myself. I also don’t want kids to die. You’re making all of these assumptions about me based on something you’ve made up in your head.
Because I analyze a phenomenon of why so many autistic people have fraught relationships with gender & embodiment, suddenly I want all trans people dead?????
What in the hyperbole is this 😂
Quotes a post by T26466; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s so weird that we got into this trans stuff during the same years, but I still thought it was a great idea to take my puppy for a ‘walk’ while wearing roller blades and that nothing could go wrong and you were the age I am now, and now we talk to each other on the internet
Hopefully plastic surgeons will orient themselves to fixing the injuries caused by the transgender techno-medical enterprise sold to children and young people upon the basis of a lie
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨At 12, I was told that 🏳️⚧️ “Gender Affirming” BREAST BINDING was safe and reversible.
They LIED.
Now at 26, I live in pain. My upper body is permanently disfigured.
Schools still secretly give these dangerous medical devices to little girls.
REPOST to raise awareness ⬇️
Thank you to @[private account] for giving my testimony a platform, and for fighting for America’s kids.
And by the way, whether the
medical interventions that harmed you were breast binders purchased from a medically recommended and endorsed list of commercial breast binder companies, that your doctor irl or the one giving you advice online, assured you was safe…
Or whether you are harmed by the myriad of hormonal suppression and pubertal blockade drugs available on the market
Or whether you were harmed by the experimental hormonal cocktails your doctors advised you to take, or prescribed to you for a gender/mental health reason rather than for an actual medical health reason
Or whether you were harmed by any number of facial/vocal/chest/genital surgeries done by a surgeon who prioritized getting you into and out of the O.R. more than they cared about your mental or physical ability to recover, or to withstand a range of complications which were not properly explained, who cut into you without understanding whether the disease they were attempting to excise could even be found there….
Or whether you were harmed by all of the above
If what was done to you has left your body in pain they didn’t tell you would feel like this, or that could even last this long,
It doesn’t matter whether you identify as trans or detrans. It doesn’t matter whether you regret it or choose to think of it as “well, it is what it is. I can’t undo what was done, so no use in regretting it.”
Every trans person who was harmed in these ways has the same grounds to sue their negligent doctors that any detransitioner with the same complaints does.
So yeah, I do hope that all individuals whether they are trans or detrans in their life trajectories, sue the living shit out of the medical practitioners who neglected them.
🚨Detransitioners aren’t the only group harmed by their gender doctors.
Trans people have just as valid of a reason as Fox Varian did, to sue their doctors for botching surgeries, downplaying the injuries they caused & failing to properly assess mental health comorbidities.
🧵
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: 1st Detransitioner to Take a Medical-Malpractice Lawsuit to Trial Wins $2 Million Judgement
Fox Varian sued her Westchester, NY, area psychologist and plastic surgeon for the gender-transition mastectomy she got at 16.
I was the only reporter to attend the entire 3-week, historic trial. Subscribe to my Substack to receive an alert about the feature article I have coming out next week in a major publication out about the trial: https://benryan.substack.com. I cover pediatric gender medicine as a specialty on my Substack.
Sorry to just give just a teaser for now about the case! But I wanted to get the word out about the verdict promptly, the slower pace of feature-article publishing notwithstanding.
The entire case file was put under seal when the trial started (although I obtained all those documents before they was sealed), and all the transcripts from the trial are also under seal. The riveting trial was sparsely attended and there was only one other reporter at the trial; and he only attended for part of it and, as I observed, took few notes. So my own hundreds of pages of notes from the trial will likely remain the only way for the public to learn about the all finer details of what transpired, possibly ever (or until an appeal, should that happen).
In addition to my article coming out in the media outlet soon, I intend to write a lot about what I observed and learned on my Substack over the coming weeks. Stay tuned…
Having an analyzing/systematizing inclination is one reason I suspect so many autistic girls, myself included, immediately bought the “you have a male brain in a female body” explanation as soon as we turned 12 and heard it from some 20-something on the internet.
Being a teenage girl with near-zero social intuition, sensory issues exacerbated by pubertal changes, and non-conforming thinking are all bigger predisposing factors than simply “they’re all doing it for popularity or special status.” (As cultural warriors with zero working model of autism claim is the motivation for this cohort)
Let’s be honest: how many autistic kids even intuit that social hierarchy exists, let alone calculate how to climb it? I certainly wasn’t able to think that way. In seventh grade in 2011/2012, when I adopted a transgender self-concept, I was far too busy wondering whether trans patients’ pituitary glands could be modified to avoid lifelong exogenous hormone supplementation— to even consider gender transition as a social status move 😂
Quoting @JDHaltigan: Yes. Heather Mac Donald has always spoken the truth about this. This is also why autism is male-coded. That is because autists are adept at finding lawful patterns in data. Truth is male-coded, thus civilization is male-coded.
Having an analyzing/systematizing inclination is one reason I suspect so many autistic girls, myself included, immediately bought the “you have a male brain in a female body” explanation as soon as we turned 12 and heard it from some 20-something on the internet.
Being a teenage girl with near-zero social intuition, sensory issues exacerbated by pubertal changes, and non-conforming thinking are all bigger predisposing factors than simply “they’re all doing it for popularity or special status.” (As cultural warriors with zero working model of autism claim is the motivation for this cohort)
Let’s be honest: how many autistic kids even intuit that social hierarchy exists, let alone calculate how to climb it? I certainly wasn’t able to think that way. In seventh grade in 2011/2012, when I adopted a transgender self-concept, I was far too busy wondering whether trans patients’ pituitary glands could be modified to avoid lifelong exogenous hormone supplementation— to even consider gender transition as a social status move 😂
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: 🚨Why Do So Many Autistic Kids Think They're Born in the Wrong Body?
I used to be trans, and now I'm not. What I have always been, is on the autism spectrum. This is the last essay I'll write as a 25 year old, so be sure to send it to a parent of an autistic or ADHD kid ;) 🔗👇
🚨American Society of Plastic Surgeons confirms that teens who hate their bodies (for transgender 🏳️⚧️ reasons), will survive until at least their 19th birthdays without state-funded boob jobs, nose jobs or the amputations of their healthy body parts.
Is anyone surprised?
Trans activists have long tried to squash criticism of obviously experimental gender medical protocols by saying that they’re supported by every major medical association which they, through lobbying, systematically captured.
That is no longer the case.
This is HUGE.
Quoting @LeorSapir: BREAKING: American Society of Plastic Surgeons issues new position statement opposing "gender-affirming" surgeries in adolescents under the age of 19.
ASPS also acknowledges risks of endocrine interventions, poor guidelines, and inappropriate use of "autonomy" principle.
A lot of young women who experience gender distressed are (undiagnosed) autistic who get diagnosed as trans.
Autistic girls seem to be way more likely to experience severe pubertal distress, as both social communication issues and sensory issues become more complicated.
Unfortunately it’s FAFO. The earlier the rock bottom moment, the better the outcome imo. You can’t logic someone out of something that meets an emotional need. I’ve done a whole thing about it, linked below.
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/how-do-i-know-if-my-trans-identifying?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios&shareImageVariant=overlay
🚨Detransition & desistance are severely understudied in the already under-researched field of gender dysphoria & trans identities.
REPOST to help desisters & detransitioners take the survey & improve understanding of these issues.
Trans identified/ gender questioning and where relevant, gender dysphoric/ distressed are probably good terms to describe the entire population. It’s also important to note that some youth might have gender confusion (but not necessarily distress) as kids and develop distress around adolescence as a part of this trajectory. To their parents it might seem “rapid onset” but to the kid it might have been a lesser, but still present concern they were too young to articulate. That could apply to some of these girls, seeing as being a tomboy pre-puberty isn’t an issue, but during puberty they’re expected to just become a totally different person and that causes distress.
Trans women ≠ women, but edible fan mail is the best fan mail.
Thanks to @[private account] for sending the most glorious cookies I've ever seen (and tasted) in my 26 years on Earth!
After 12 years of being transgender 🏳️⚧️ and spending my youth permanently damaging my body with breast binding while pretending to be a man, I realized that I was born in the RIGHT body, after all.
Repost if you think that NO ONE is born in the wrong body.
I always find it funny when the trans rights people openly hate the one country in the Middle East where they’d have trans rights.
It’s even funnier when they want random Jews on the internet deported to Israel over… gender critical beliefs? A concern for the Palestinians? Make your mind up, Charlie 😂
Quotes a post by T12995; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Why do both trans people and detrans people act like they’re the world’s biggest victims?
If you’re not getting murdered by the state at 26 for publicly desiring freedom, you are LUCKY and BLESSED.
Be grateful.
Quoting @NoaMagid: THEY WILL EXECUTE HIM TOMORROW
ERFAN SOLTANI
Apparently, child killing for convenience purposes “affirms” the genders of women, trans men and nonbinary women.
So, which gender is being affirmed here? Murderergender?
Quotes a post by A1052; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.