The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
đ¨Trans activists đłď¸ââ§ď¸ say breast binding is safe if you âfollow the guidelines.â
Gender critics say itâs just a gateway to âreal harmsâ like surgery.
BOTH are WRONG. Binding is a medical intervention that causes permanent damage.
REPOST to raise awareness đ§ľđâŹď¸
Thank you to @HHSGov for exposing breast binders as dangerous medical devices rather than as the harmless clothes trans activists pretend them to be
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: đ¨ Finally, @HHSGov recognizes that breast binders are not harmless clothing, but medical devices marketed illegally to girls as a treatment for gender dysphoria.
Iâm glad to have done my part in raising awareness about the dangers of breast binding.
The harms I experienced from nearly a decade of âgender affirmingâ breast binding, starting in early adolescence, are probably among the most common transition-related harms young women faceâyet they have been largely ignored in discussions around gender medicine.
Unfortunately, people on both the trans activist and gender-critical sides often dismiss the damage caused by breast binding.
Regardless of the misinformation peddled by either side, there is no healthy way to bind (especially growing) breasts for months or years, even when used as directed by healthy women and girls with no medical need, limiting use to a maximum of 8â12 hours a day in the hope of finally feeling comfortable in their bodies. Thatâs the lie sold by companies profiting from an unscientific ideology.
Breast binding is often viewed by both sides of the trans debate as a lesser or insignificant harm, when in fact the opposite is true:
- No current legislation aimed at protecting vulnerable youths from the harms of gender-affirming/sex-rejecting body modifications will actually protect them from permanent bodily harm caused by breast binding.
Thatâs because itâs an intervention that doctors do not need to prescribe to promote it shamelessly or publish guidelines on how to do it âsafelyâ without conducting a single study attesting to its safety. Neither medical professionals nor the companies selling these off-label medical devices disclose the full range of known harms resulting from their use, even when used as intended.
- Breast binding is so physically uncomfortable and damaging that most girls wonât do it as long as I did. They become even more desperate to remove their breasts because of the damage to breast tissue and the significant, function-impairing harm to surrounding tissues, organs, muscles, and skeletal structures.
- Doctors promote the lie that breast binding is a safe mental health treatment for girls and women who hate their breasts. But when a patientâs condition doesnât improve or she experiences new pain, they recommend âgender-affirmingâ top surgery.
Even girls who detransition before mastectomy (like me) suffer lasting damage and pain from years of binding. Those who proceed to mastectomies still experience previously incurred harms to their rib cage, skin, nerves, back, and muscles, even after damaged breast tissue is removed and unnecessary surgical traumas are added.
Itâs high time we all take seriously the dangers of ALL âgender-affirmingâ medical interventions rather than being misled by activist narratives claiming they arenât harmfulânot just to impressionable minds, but to the objective health and integrity of female bodies.
REPOST to raise awareness.
đ¨ Finally, @HHSGov recognizes that breast binders are not harmless clothing, but medical devices marketed illegally to girls as a treatment for gender dysphoria.
Iâm glad to have done my part in raising awareness about the dangers of breast binding.
The harms I experienced from nearly a decade of âgender affirmingâ breast binding, starting in early adolescence, are probably among the most common transition-related harms young women faceâyet they have been largely ignored in discussions around gender medicine.
Unfortunately, people on both the trans activist and gender-critical sides often dismiss the damage caused by breast binding.
Regardless of the misinformation peddled by either side, there is no healthy way to bind (especially growing) breasts for months or years, even when used as directed by healthy women and girls with no medical need, limiting use to a maximum of 8â12 hours a day in the hope of finally feeling comfortable in their bodies. Thatâs the lie sold by companies profiting from an unscientific ideology.
Breast binding is often viewed by both sides of the trans debate as a lesser or insignificant harm, when in fact the opposite is true:
- No current legislation aimed at protecting vulnerable youths from the harms of gender-affirming/sex-rejecting body modifications will actually protect them from permanent bodily harm caused by breast binding.
Thatâs because itâs an intervention that doctors do not need to prescribe to promote it shamelessly or publish guidelines on how to do it âsafelyâ without conducting a single study attesting to its safety. Neither medical professionals nor the companies selling these off-label medical devices disclose the full range of known harms resulting from their use, even when used as intended.
- Breast binding is so physically uncomfortable and damaging that most girls wonât do it as long as I did. They become even more desperate to remove their breasts because of the damage to breast tissue and the significant, function-impairing harm to surrounding tissues, organs, muscles, and skeletal structures.
- Doctors promote the lie that breast binding is a safe mental health treatment for girls and women who hate their breasts. But when a patientâs condition doesnât improve or she experiences new pain, they recommend âgender-affirmingâ top surgery.
Even girls who detransition before mastectomy (like me) suffer lasting damage and pain from years of binding. Those who proceed to mastectomies still experience previously incurred harms to their rib cage, skin, nerves, back, and muscles, even after damaged breast tissue is removed and unnecessary surgical traumas are added.
Itâs high time we all take seriously the dangers of ALL âgender-affirmingâ medical interventions rather than being misled by activist narratives claiming they arenât harmfulânot just to impressionable minds, but to the objective health and integrity of female bodies.
REPOST to raise awareness.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: They told me that breast binding was "safe."
Now, I live with permanently disfigured breasts, damaged ribs & pain while breathingâall without stepping foot in a gender clinic.
Transition damage starts long before hormones & surgery. Itâs time to talk about it
Read my story:âŹď¸
Even the women who self-identify as trans men understand the need for womenâs only spaces. The men who self-identify as trans women cannot seem to grasp whyâŚ.
What explains this?
Quotes a post by T29646; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Even in trans world, the men (AMABs) behave like men and the women (AFABs) behave like women.
Itâs almost as if you canât actually trans your gender.
Trans communities would benefit both TiFs and TiMs by discussing the necessity of disclosing trans status before sex. With a culture change, both could avoid being rapists by deception and potentially even avoid being murdered as a result of their male partners finding out
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialfetish fraudviolence terror
is also highly intelligent and makes well-reasoned arguments. Nonetheless, trans activists decide to go after her appearance (which in her case is totally unwarranted).
What youâre showing in that screenshot is unequivocally wrong, deeply unethical and should be criminalized under sex deception legal codes where they do exist. But itâs also extremely rare. In most cases these straight girls who identify as gay trans men are getting put in way more danger than they normally would be in, considering that theyâre operating on the lie that theyâre basically men now who are seen as men by their male casual sex partners, and are therefore immune to being sexually taken advantage of by men.
If theyâre on testosterone, theyâll also engage in tons of casual sex with men (sometimes unprotected) because they assume theyâre immune to pregnancy.
I know so many young women who transitioned around the same time as I did, who found themselves engaged in these endeavors.
One of them ended up pregnant in these types of interactions and due to being on testosterone, didnât realize it. She didnât know to stop the testosterone until almost four months into the pregnancy. The baby was born in early labor that couldnât be stopped, one week before the doctors would have given him life saving measures. So this 20 y/o girl had to watch her baby die even though everything about this case was totally preventable if we lived in a sane world.
As bad as the presence of confused girls in gay male dating spaces is for the internal cohesion of such gay male spaces, it ends up still being more net dangerous and devastating for the women in these interactions.
Both of these absurdities are in my opinion, good enough reasons to obliterate this ideology from western civilization.
Speaking as someone who used to be transgender:
Trans people are the biggest harassers of other trans people.
Trans people are also the biggest killers of trans people (via su*cide).
Quotes a post by T02099; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Jade is so beautiful she could be a supermodel and yet transactivists attack her looks
Jade is *really* moderate on trans issues and yet transactivists attack her looks
Why? Because deranged people with bad ideas react like lunatics when confronted with reasonable disagreement
Quotes a post by T04409; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Here I was 15. Three years into the belief that I was born in the wrong body, and already binding my breasts.
I often wonder what my life would have looked like, had I not bought into the transgenderđłď¸ââ§ď¸ lie as a 12 year old. There really is no way to know.
Speaking as someone who used to be transgender⌠thereâs a lot of toxic masculinity in trans communities.
But it does not come from the women (like this one) who think theyâre men.
It comes from the men who think theyâre women.
Is anyone else shocked that a dangerous social trend largely impacting teenaged girls has now been largely abandoned by the adult women they became?
Yeah, Iâm not either.
But, parents still contact me daily about their new crop of 13 y/o girls who now think theyâre trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸
It depends on how you use the word. If âdetransâ is used to describe a patient population of those seeking to recover from harms to their bodies and/or minds resulting from attempted cross-sex mimicry (as opposed to continuing the harm to oneself) it has a value. I think this label when used clinically should apply regardless of subjective identity claims and entirely based on objective need. Because thatâs how healthcare should work.
If you use it to describe an identity category, it becomes just as descriptive as the âtransâ identity category. It also depends on how one sees transâ whether under the old school transsexual lie or the new, queer, non-binary iteration of the trans lie. However one saw âbeingâ (more accurately, doing) trans when they abided by that self concept, is likely how they will see âdetransâ as its inverse.
I agree that âtransâ is the trajectory, the process. Not merely one specific point on the trajectory, but all points on it. Not everyone agrees. Apparently some points along the trajectory are considered as not on the trajectory when one disembarks from it, which I find weird.
I think the GC movement should include transitioners who have no intention to âdetransitionâ functionally because itâs impossible for them or undesirable, but who buy biological reality etc. the perspectives of regretful transitioners, dissilusioned transsexuals are equally important to so-called detrans or ex-trans perspectives imo
She was abused by a man who identifies as a trans woman and is still honoring his preferred pronouns.
TransGender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ ideology gets women abused and makes them bow to their abusers.
Quotes a post by T29308; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This Thanksgiving, Iâm thankful for having woken up from the transgenderđłď¸ââ§ď¸ LIE I once lived.
What are YOU thankful for?
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Itâs wild to think that just three years ago, at 23, this was my transgender life.
I was âstealthâ meaning that only a select few people knew that I was actually female.
Embracing my female reality has been liberating in ways I couldâve never imagined back then.
When I was trans, I didnât believe that everything was âtransphobic.â Thatâs probably the biggest cognitive factor that allowed me to leave the cult.
@[private account] If their identities were stable, like my trans identity was for many years, they could have (just like I did) listen to detransitioners and learn a thing or two without spiralling into violent confusion
đ¨I didnât just âidentify asâ transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸;
I passed the old school transsexual âreal lifeâ test in a country that doesnât have the practice of asking people what their pronouns are.
Where entire subsections of the society are segregated by sex in ways Western life isnât. (Your cultural competency is in the gutter if you see these pictures and think I was somehow being perceived as a woman.) I was routinely kicked out of the female spaces and embraced in the male ones.
I knew instantly how I was perceived in every interaction because of the highly gendered nature of the Arabic, Hebrew and Russian languages I spoke daily.
I lived a life wherein those around me perceived me as a male, albeit a much younger one. I did things in the Middle East that most women never get the chance to do, precisely because of how I was perceived.
I was âtrue transâ in every sense of the word until I realized itâs impractical to live in opposition to biological reality as rockets fly over your head. Life and death concerns replaced my gender concerns pretty quickly when the two conflicted. And so I made a choiceâ to stop being trans.
I was the epitome of âtrue transâ until I realized that trans is truly, all a lie.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Itâs wild to think that just three years ago, at 23, this was my transgender life.
I was âstealthâ meaning that only a select few people knew that I was actually female.
Embracing my female reality has been liberating in ways I couldâve never imagined back then.
I didnât just âidentify asâ. I passed the old school transsexual âreal lifeâ test in a country that doesnât have the practice of asking people what their pronouns are.
Where entire subsections of the society are segregated by sex in ways Western life isnât.
I knew instantly how I was perceived in every interaction because of the highly gendered nature of the Arabic, Hebrew and Russian languages I spoke daily.
I was routinely kicked out of the female spaces and embraced in the male ones.
I lived a life wherein those around me perceived me as a male, albeit a much younger one. I did things in the Middle East that most women never get the chance to do, precisely because of how I was perceived.
I was âtrue transâ in every sense of the word until I realized itâs impractical to live in opposition to biological reality as rockets fly over your head. Life and death concerns replaced my gender concerns pretty quickly when the two conflicted.
I was the epitome of âtrue transâ until I realized that trans is truly, all a lie.
Almost every trans person I knew when I was trans took anti-depressants before or during their âlife-savingâ gender transitions.
Two medical scandals found the same patients and their doctors thought nothing of it.
Quotes a post by T27256; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If transgender identities were really so healthy and stable;
The existence of detransitioners + trans regretters telling our stories wouldnât send so many of them into a violent tailspin of bullying, gaslighting, doxxing and threatening our lives.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Itâs wild to think that just three years ago, at 23, this was my transgender life.
I was âstealthâ meaning that only a select few people knew that I was actually female.
Embracing my female reality has been liberating in ways I couldâve never imagined back then.
This was the first âtrans kidâ đłď¸ââ§ď¸ coverage I ever saw on YouTube. The year was 2011. I was 12.
The next 12 years of my life were hijacked by the transgender lie.
KEEP YOUR KIDS OFF THE INTERNET.
Women will rip each other to shreds and sabotage anotherâs reputations before theyâll allow other women to succeed.
Men form âold boys clubsâ while feminist organizations (@reduxx) will steal one womanâs work (@TTExulansic) and credit a man (@[private account]). Turns out, some feminists are doing just as much to erase women as are the transgender male fetishists they criticize.
Itâs almost as if the patriarchy, or transgender ideology, arenât to blame for women getting erased.
Rather, itâs feminist organizations like @reduxx who either through lack of diligence or through typical female relational aggression, dragging each other down meanwhile men form âold boys clubsâ and become successful.
Quoting @TTExulansic: I broke this story. Matt Osborne wrote about the story I broke, crediting me. Reduxx decided to credit HIM instead of the woman who did the work. Genevieve Gluck decided to write me out of the history of the story I broke. Shameful
Itâs wild to think that just three years ago, at 23, this was my transgender life.
I was âstealthâ meaning that only a select few people knew that I was actually female.
Embracing my female reality has been liberating in ways I couldâve never imagined back then.
Many AGPs are bisexual is the point Iâm making. Replacing âTâ with âAGPâ changes nothing functionally, except for excluding membership to the women who are heterosexual and trans identified.
âI Dodged a Nukeâ: How Autism, School Trauma, & Forced Feminization Nearly Pushed Sven Into Trans Ideology https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/i-dodged-a-nuke-how-autism-school?r=1gcde6&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
Watch this full conversation at the link and follow @[private account]
The trans activists wishing death upon are also young. But I digress.
What is the point of criticizing someone over developmental delays resulting from a premature birth they had no control over? I fail to see the logic here.
Not all kids have the same developmental trajectory. I read medical journals for fun as a late elementary schooler but only learned to tie my shoes at 14 after extensive interventions due to motor delays. Others have a totally normal developmental trajectory. No online criticism of this fact actually helps patch up the neurodevelopmental glitches which Iâve had to intentionally patch up with age.
Additionally, to say that itâs not wrong for even young adults to date minor teenagers is to take a conceptual risk of condoning a relationship between a 15 year old who may be simultaneously intellectually precocious and developmentally delayed⌠or just developmentally delayed and with the naĂŻvetĂŠ of someone much younger. Would you not agree that making these relationships culturally unacceptable is perhaps the biggest protector against an outcome of inevitable exploitation?
Finally, the exponentially rapid development which occurs yearly during adolescence makes the level of maturity between a 15 and 20 year old a significant gap primed for exploitation of the younger partyâ in a way that a 20 and 25 year old, or a 25 and 30 year old for example, would not be subject to.
Another trans person insulting a picture of me as a literal child. As a âtransâ (identifying, brainwashed) child, nonetheless.
All because Iâm not trans anymore. And because I posted that itâs a problem for grown adults to be attracted to kids of this age âŹď¸
Quotes a post by T16790; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The differences between male and female psychology are even more obvious in trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ communities than they are elsewhere.
Take this example: the men who want feminizing hormones create an elaborate grey market empire for them, whereas the women who want testosterone complain that there arenât resources available to them about how to dangerously inject themselves with a controlled substance w/o medical supervision.
Then the men who want estrogen point this out, annoyed by how these women (who want testosterone) infantilize themselves instead of picking themselves (and their illegally acquired drugs) up by their bootstraps!
TLDR: trans women are men, trans men are women. Facts donât care about your feelings.
Quotes a post by T22470; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The best arguments in favor of the double standard are that menâs sex detection capabilities are inferior to womenâs (so they probably wonât see trans men as women) and that trans men pose no threat to men. If itâs just about boundary violations then the opposition can and should apply equally across sexes, on principle. The problem is the failure to expound upon the reasons that boundaries exist in the first place đI just think itâs a third spaces issue. There should be more.
And also plenty of middle and high school boys are really uncomfortable with girls in their locker rooms. And yes I think their comfort should be prioritized
Theyâre so close to understanding why we donât want men in womenâs spaces.
Male predators will jump through hoops to access their victims. Trans ideology hands it to them on a silver platter.
Quotes a post by A2032; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
âMy mom and dad told me to take this puberty blocker to keep the moustache monster away and now Iâm happyâ â trans kid Jazz Jennings, age 11, paraphrased.
Quotes a post by T13077; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Thank you Arielle, for covering the overlap between trans and autism.
It was a pleasure to be on your show after watching your channel as an adolescent. Full circle moment :)
Quoting @ArielleScarcell: The Left Is Preying On Autistic Kids!
https://youtu.be/mls-g323TCU @thepeacepoet99
Taking showers, using the restroom and other intimate activities are a constant reminder of oneâs biological reality, including when surgical steps are taken to obfuscate it and complications are experienced. It takes a lot of effort to maintain the trans delusion.
The hardest part of being trans for me was the constant reminders of just how at odds my life of a lie during the day was, with the reality I was forced to confront at night by myself.
This was a really big aspect of my experience too, but honestly there were millions of things going on there.
The fact that these men are basically the only people who have explicit conversations about what it means to be a âwomanâ, and there explanation is not at all based in reality because they are menâ is a problem.
One of the problems is that many mothers donât explicitly discuss what it means to be a woman with their daughters in a way that is to its core correct, without both adding leniency around non-conformity and stating without question the biological definitions of womanhood. Many will just try to imbue these themes as values through rearing rather than being both explicit and reality based about what that means.
Some mothers will just parent daughters by making them/encouraging them to do certain âgirlyâ things while scolding them for âdisobedienceâ which does not allowing for enough personal choice around adolescence. Then the adolescent will be pathologized for rebelling in these more authoritarian homes.
Other mothers will take the approach of saying âyou can be whatever you want to beâ and then when the girl says âI want to be a boyâ the parents donât know how to respond because they didnât presume their daughter would take it so literally, and now they donât know how to say âwell, I meant you can professionally or stylistically be a whatever you want. You canât become a boy because it is biologically impossible.â
Put a highly literal girl in either of those extreme environments and then give her the internet right when she hits puberty and is online with men like Stacy talking about what it means to be a woman and thatâs basically one of the most robust recipes for how to create a so-called âtrans kid.â
Speaking as one of those formerly trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ ideating teens; no, recognizing transgender identities as pathological will not help these teens who have already gotten sucked in. Not on an individual level.
I believe @[private account] is correct here.
đ¨*PLEASE READ THIS POST IN FULL BEFORE COMMENTING*
There are many reasons for this, but Iâll suffice it to say that many of us got there because we already saw something natural about ourselves to be pathological.
On an individual level, I got sucked into trans before gender dysphoria was fully depathologized because I already saw something as being wrong and broken about myself and the pathologized trans identity I adopted merely echoed this fact. And gave me a roadmap to channel that spirit of self-pathologization onto my perfectly healthy body.
The argument that recognizing trans identities as pathological will help more kids is correct only insofar as it can measurably change the entire medical system and make them not do this to distressed and very young people. And frankly the distress and desire to self-destruct are arguably significantly more pathological drivers than are the subjective (and usually fluid) identity labels we as teens/young adults post hoc ascribe to justify why we must be allowed to self-destruct.
On a therapeutic level however, this stance is conceptually and clinically disconnected from the inner lives of the teenagers who need to be therapeutically reached. It is important to reach these teenagers through intentional parenting and therapy (where needed), because otherwise they head, unencumbered by any systemic protections, straight for the gender clinic the moment they turn 18.
What these teens need (among many other things) is a viable counter-narrative which they come to âthemselvesâ (ideally with the guidance of sane adults who help lead them there without demanding) in which they are not broken for having adolescent existential dread or questions about the nature of reality itself. Or for dealing with autism. Or for suffering. Or whatever it is.
Sashaâs approach is therapeutically correct and she argues it well. I urge anyone who has a problem with her stance to find a specific contention with any of her arguments themselves, and to dissect the arguments by their premises and internal logic, rather than simply restating their previously held position.
Unfortunately, because her argument is so nuanced and she indicates exactly which audience she is writing it for, many people will entirely disregard its relevance to the therapeutic context she directly addresses her analysis as being aimed at.
There are a lot more points on this matter which should be thoroughly addressed that I donât have the time to as of now, and our society will have to reckon with these questions for a while.
What Iâd encourage people to consider is that there are costs and benefits to enacting every assertion we make. And before turning our assertions into policies, we need to carefully consider these and we must weigh them alongside one another, if we are to have any hope of achieving our stated desired outcome.
Quotes a post by A3575; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Speaking as one of those formerly ideating teens; no, recognizing transgender identities as pathological will not help these teens who have already gotten sucked in. There are many reasons for this, but Iâll suffice it to say that many of us got there because we already saw something natural about ourselves to be pathological.
On an individual level, I got sucked into trans before gender dysphoria was fully depathologized because I already saw something as being wrong and broken about myself and the pathologized trans identity I adopted merely echoed this fact. And gave me a roadmap to channel that spirit of self-pathologization onto my perfectly healthy body.
The argument that recognizing trans identities as pathological will help more kids is correct only insofar as it can measurably change the entire medical system and make them not do this to distressed and very young people. And frankly the distress and desire to self-destruct are arguably significantly more pathological drivers than are the subjective (and usually fluid) identity labels we as teens/young adults post hoc ascribe to justify why we must be allowed to self-destruct.
On a therapeutic level however, this stance is conceptually and clinically disconnected from the inner lives of the teenagers who need to be therapeutically reached. It is important to reach these teenagers through intentional parenting and therapy (where needed), because otherwise they head, unencumbered by any systemic protections, straight for the gender clinic the moment they turn 18.
What these teens need (among many other things) is a viable counter-narrative which they come to âthemselvesâ (ideally with the guidance of sane adults who help lead them there without demanding) in which they are not broken for having adolescent existential dread or questions about the nature of reality itself. Or for dealing with autism. Or for suffering. Or whatever it is.
Sashaâs approach is therapeutically correct and she argues it well. I urge anyone who has a problem with her stance to find a specific contention with any of her arguments themselves, and to dissect the arguments by their premises and internal logic, rather than simply restating their previously held position.
Unfortunately, because her argument is so nuanced and she indicates exactly which audience she is writing it for, many people will entirely disregard its relevance to the therapeutic context she directly addresses her analysis as being aimed at.
There are a lot more points on this matter which should be thoroughly addressed that I donât have the time to as of now, and our society will have to reckon with these questions for a while.
What Iâd encourage people to consider is that there are costs and benefits to enacting every assertion we make. And before turning our assertions into policies, we need to carefully consider these and we must weigh them alongside one another, if we are to have any hope of achieving our stated desired outcome.
This is what happens when you embolden an obnoxious Karen with special trans privileges, unearned social status & high doses of testosterone. There is nothing good to be had from taking a socially aggressive female and giving her hormones that make her more physically aggressive.
If it were just cross dressing I wouldnât be making this post. Lots of pronoun pins, anime costumes with trans flag motifs and even some teen girls on testosterone
Itâs easy for an ivory tower academic to not notice that the trans trend is very much still alive.
But those of us who have boots on the ground & speak with impacted families daily know full well that the teenagers are still đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identifying.
Saying âwoke is deadâ doesnât make it true.
Roughly one of every five teenagers who knocked on my door tonight đđťđ either had a pronoun pin, an anime costume with a trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ color motif or was clearly a girl on testosterone.
Or all of the above. đ§ľ
Quoting @epkaufm: 1/ NEW: trans identification is in free fall among the young
Â
(h/t @[private account] data in particular)
If itâs racist to think that the original rainbow flag didnât need to start adding skin colors, symbols promoting prostitution and the trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ kiddie cutter cult colorsâŚ. then goddamn I guess I too, am a racist
Quotes a post by T06133; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Transsexualism is not an innate essence, but rather a state of disease induced by gender affirmation culture and trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸- mengele medicine.
Just because you have gender dysphoria, it doesnât mean you need to be trans.
You can choose to let your OCD-esque gender fixation rule your life. It is a bad choice. But it is a choice nonetheless. It is not a mandate.
Gender dysphoria happens for tons of different reasons.
âTransâ is probably the most maladaptive, invasive and physically/psychologically destructive path possible to treat an obsessive sex-based body dysmorphic fixation.
Being born a man doesnât mean you have a medical condition. Not liking your maleness doesnât make your maleness a medical condition. I was sold the same lie as you but I had the sense to get myself out. You donât have to do the trans thing just because youâve experienced dysphoria. You literally can choose to not go down that route.
Thank you for listening, commenting and sharing. My focus will always be on dissecting the experience of high-functioning autism in girls and reflecting on how these adolescents, lacking reality-based frameworks to explain their social and embodied autistic distress, refract their experiences through transgender ideology. Itâs a niche within a niche within a niche. If youâd like to learn more about this niche, feel free to check out my Substack (linked in bio)
When I was 12 and falling into transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ rabbit holes online, I giggled whenever the phrase âsex changeâ was uttered.
Because I heard the word âsex.â
Because I was a child.
I didnât even realize I was permanently a girl until I hit puberty around 9.5. I also thought a growth spurt would cause me to outgrow my house because I read a shel Silverstein poem called âhungry mungryâ and didnât understand fiction from reality. That type of kid is vulnerable to transgender ideology because they do not understand they are being tricked.
Most trans widows are initially totally unaware that their husbands are fetishistic cross dressers because these men hide it well.
AGP is well known to flare up in men when their wives get pregnant or their daughters hit puberty.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: This man gets his wife pregnant and then destroys the house because she doesnât support him transitioning đłď¸ââ§ď¸ into a âwoman.â
These researchers really need to consult with those of us who are GEN Z and EX-TRANS. They have no cultural or linguistic context to interpret the data and so they come to conclusions that only make sense to ivory tower thinkers
Many people start identifying as non-binary, then escalate into trans and then go nonbinary again before desisting fully or will remain that way for a number of years. Something is going on for sure, but I donât think itâs yet time to celebrate. The on the ground reality suggests people are celebrating too quickly imo
Itâs important to understand that not every kid will be seduced by trans identities. Trans identities donât compete for the mind space of well-adjusted, popular kids.
The more this concept is pushed, the more autistic kids you will catch with it. The less it is pushed, the fewer autistic kids you will catch. But I donât think the number will ever be zero (or anywhere close) now that the option is everywhere.
Speaking as an ex-trans 26 year old Gen Z here, I donât know a single person in my former trans communities who wouldnât be immediately paranoid about answering online surveys about their gender identities.
There was an overall belief that any surveys/questionnaires could potentially being tools of future trans genocide, gathering IP information and identity information to compile a âlist.â
I for one, had never disclosed my trans identity on forms *by choice* when asked because I didnât know what would happen with my data in the future. And that was before this became a big culture war issue.
As the culture war has heated up around these issues, it makes sense that those ideologically bought in could be extremely paranoid when presented with questions about their gender identitiesâŚ..
Just something else to consider as a confounding variable which Iâm not sure has been taken into account at all.
Quotes a post by A3367; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Speaking as an ex-trans 26 year old Gen Z here, I donât know a single person in my former trans communities who werenât immediately paranoid about answering online surveys.
They believed in studies like these as potentially being tools of trans genocide, gathering IP information and identity information to compile a âlist.â
As the culture war has heated up around these issues, it makes sense that those ideologically bought in could be extremely paranoid when presented with questions about their gender identitiesâŚ..
He is a man because he is an adult human male who is choosing his transgender sissy fetish over his unborn child. This specific type of degeneracy is something only men are capable of.
âWould you rather have a DEAD kid or a TRANS đłď¸ââ§ď¸ kid?â
Most parents picked the âtrans kidâ option. Some few parents realized those werenât their only two options.
âWould you rather have a DEAD kid or a TRANS đłď¸ââ§ď¸ kid?â
Most parents picked the âtrans kidâ option. Some few parents realized those werenât their only two options.
Quotes a post by T23206; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Most trans widows are initially totally unaware that their husbands are fetishistic cross dressers because these men hide it well.
AGP is well known to flare up in men when their wives get pregnant or their daughters hit puberty.
@[private account] is a good source to correct your ignorance on these matters.
Quotes a post by T28042; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
âTransgenderâ đłď¸ââ§ď¸ is a totally incoherent concept.
Even those who identify as transgender donât agree on how to how/whether to measure it or on how to define it.
The genders are masculine and feminine (and neuter) in some languages. There are gender roles which trans activists and queer theory feminists call âgender.â And then there is sex which is male/man/boy or female/woman/girl.
And I will add that many teens start off identifying as non-binary, then after months or years move into binary trans identities, some of them will take permanent body-damaging steps through breast binding, hormones or surgeries only to regret it & ID as non-binary b/c they canât admit that it was all a big mistake.
And I will add that many teens start off identifying as non-binary, then after months or years move into binary trans identities, some of them will take permanent body-damaging steps through breast binding, hormones or surgeries only to regret it & ID as non-binary b/c they canât admit that it was all a big mistake.
Respectfully, sir-
Your beloved data set could just as easily be measuring young people moving away from non-binary towards binary trans identities.
As a Gen Z ex- trans 26 year old woman (who was trans identified from ages 12-24) who is in touch with youth culture, I have noticed that non-binary identities are less popular now but binary trans are surging in popularity.
Todayâs gender questioning teens are more likely to go for binary trans identities than teens when I was growing up a decade ago who almost all went non-binary.
Your conclusion that trans-identities are in free fall amongst youth cannot be substantiated by the data gathered based on the questions asked.
Next time when surveying a population of gen Z youth, you might consider consulting with Gen Z adults who are in close enough age proximity to your subjects to understand what in the word salad they mean when they answer your questions.
Can we please not repeat the mistakes of gender medicineâs history of shoddy studies by being very clear about which inferences we can and canât make from any given data set?
Quoting @epkaufm: Good to see that my thread, report and @unherd article on the decline of trans are sparking debate. For those claiming non-binary measures are not picking up trans trends, my challenge would be to show me a dataset where binary and non-binary trends are not correlated over time.
Respectfully, your beloved data set could just as easily be measuring young people moving away from non-binary toward binary trans identities.
As a Gen Z ex- trans 26 year old (trans identified from 12-24) who is in touch with youth culture, I have noticed that non-binary identities are less popular now but binary trans are surging in popularity.
Todayâs teens are more likely to go for binary trans than teens when I was growing up a decade ago who almost all went non-binary.
Can we please not repeat the mistakes of gender medicineâs shoddy studies by being very clear about which inferences we can and canât make from any given data set?
Yes, this graph is measuring a downward trend in *something* but from these data, we cannot say it is a downward trend in the popularity of trans identities. Everyone jumped to conclusions w/o reading the study for themselves. This is just more bad data in the field of gender medicine.
Also I donât think Kaufmann understood that trans people wonât pick âotherâ whereas non-trans people would pick âmaleâ or âfemale.â Non-binary as a concept may be our interpretation of what those results mean whereas he probably assumed that all trans people would answer âotherâ
Contrary to popular belief, the trans trend is not over
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: đ¨THE TRANS TREND đłď¸ââ§ď¸ HAS NOT ENDED.
Yesterdayâs celebrations of the âend of transgenderâ after seeing a colorful graph & a bold tag-line showcases the lack of critical thinking that got our whole society on board with castrating kids.
Read my analysis below âŹď¸ đ
Share this essay to save an autistic kid from transgender ideology
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: đ¨Why Do So Many Autistic Kids Think They're Born in the Wrong Body?
I used to be trans, and now I'm not. What I have always been, is on the autism spectrum. This is the last essay I'll write as a 25 year old, so be sure to send it to a parent of an autistic or ADHD kid ;) đđ
I donât think Kaufmann understood that trans people will identify as male or female (but as the opposite of what they are) rather than âother.â Read the analysis of the study. The data itself is shoddy.
đ¨THE TRANS TREND đłď¸ââ§ď¸ HAS NOT ENDED.
Yesterdayâs celebrations of the âend of transgenderâ after seeing a colorful graph & a bold tag-line showcases the lack of critical thinking that got our whole society on board with castrating kids.
Read my analysis below âŹď¸ đ
Quoting @epkaufm: 1/ NEW: trans identification is in free fall among the young
Â
(h/t @[private account] data in particular)
đ¨Are you a Black woman who has been harmed by đłď¸ââ§ď¸Gender Ideology?
If so, you should submit to my friendâs Substack đâŹď¸
SHARE this post if you think itâs racist for transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ activists to compare Black women to men with sissy fetishes
If youâre against đłď¸ââ§ď¸ trans-ing the kids, just wait until you hear about what happens when they wake up on their 18th birthdays and their parents canât protect them anymoreâŚâŚ
To those who believe that the oath to DO NO HARM expires on a kidâs 18th birthday, let me say one thing;
I have just as much respect for your intellectual âbraveryâ as I do for the trans activists who ruined my childhood.
Signed,
An ex-transgender 26 year old who was once 12.
Just because fewer youth are identifying as non-binary, it doesnât mean transgender identities are decreasing in popularity.
A whole generation has been swept up into a dangerous lie.
Our work is nowhere near over.
Just because fewer youth are identifying as non-binary, it doesnât mean transgender identities are decreasing in popularity.
A whole generation has been swept up into a dangerous lie.
Our work is nowhere near over.
Quoting @epkaufm: 1/ NEW: trans identification is in free fall among the young
Â
(h/t @[private account] data in particular)
According to both trans-queer activists and a large number of TERFs/ Gender Criticals, there is no such thing as âtrue transâ but there is in fact, true de-trans
Can someone explain this to me?
Fun fact about me: Iâm an ex-transgender 26 year old who writes a blog about the overlap between gender dysphoria and autism.
I write for parents & clinicians navigating gender dysphoria + transgender identification in their families/patients.
Please share to spread the info.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: đ¨Why Do So Many Autistic Kids Think They're Born in the Wrong Body?
I used to be trans, and now I'm not. What I have always been, is on the autism spectrum. This is the last essay I'll write as a 25 year old, so be sure to send it to a parent of an autistic or ADHD kid ;) đđ
If all these Gen Z trans people were so happy and secure in themselves as they claim to be, they wouldnât be sending death threats in the thousands to those with whom they disagree. Just saying.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
I would not have been able to figure out what was going on underneath without shedding the trans identity first. The fact your experience is similar points to another important pattern
And I know trans people are strong enough to hear the truth, even if they donât think they are. No one is as fragile to words as OP has made it seem. This mindset is totally incompatible with reality.
Trans identities in Gen Z youth are based in victimhood.
People who identify with their status as victims will never be able to heal from the trauma theyâre using the trans colored đłď¸ââ§ď¸ band-aid to cover up.
Iâm encouraging you to read the words I write with your higher brain rather than your lizard brain. I care about the wellbeing of trans people because I used to be one. My goal is not for OP or anyone else to detransition. My goal is for every trans person to engage in the type of self reflection that literally no one will ever require of you because our mental health institutions are filled with idiots who pander to intrusive thoughts so they can have an endless stream of miserable patients. This mindset of yours is not conducive to healing
Our society has made a grave mistake by telling kids they can be born in the wrong bodies & then telling them they havenât modified their bodies enough if theyâre still suicidal after YOU told them they were born wrong
Trans activists đłď¸ââ§ď¸, how DARE you warp young people this way.
I want only the best for trans activists and young trans identifying people. I used to be one of them.
I want them to self-accept, to live healthy lives and to have self-sustaining happiness independent of whether others âaffirmâ them.
They want me dead.
We are not the same.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Sure. All I want for you is to be honest with yourself so you can achieve a self-sustaining happiness which does not require the affirmation of anyone else; gender or otherwise. That is a recipe for misery.
If trying to pass as a woman and not succeeding 100% of the time is making you miserable, maybe the desire to pass as the opposite sex is a band-aid on a much deeper form of distress which needs to be addressed.
Youâre young. Itâs easy to mistake a mask for a cure. When I was trans and being âmisgenderedâ it didnât evoke a reaction in me that compelled me to want to harm myself. Did it sting? Sure. Because I realized that I was brushing up against a reality I was trying to run away from. That was painful. It wasnât soul crushing, though. In the end, I just realized continuing to transition wasnât worth the hassle.
Being trans can only hope to be a path conducive to happiness and functioning if you are at a minimum, extremely resilient. The words or perceptions of other people should not shake you if you wish to live a life which puts you at odds with your biology. Itâs a hard way to live and youâve got to be tough as nails to make it work.
Regardless of where your transition goes, I hope you are able to check in with yourself and to understand that holding yourself to an impossible standard in your valiant attempt to ease your distress can actually make your distress worse.
If there is even a sliver of a chance that your desire to transition is motivated by earlier pain in your life around being male, it is best to address that pain on its own merits, for your own sanity. Transition canât heal wounds. It runs the very real risk of just making them deeper, especially if you arenât careful.
You say youâre doing your best to heal, and I hope that is true. I know many people who used transition as a way to avoid confronting their pain. I hope this is not the case for you.
I hope you have legitimate mental health professionals at your side who will show you the respect you deserve by not pandering to your intrusive thoughts.
I hope you can heal to such an extent that other people referring to you as your birth sex does not cause you to spiral into insanity. You donât deserve that kind of misery.
I wish you the best, genuinely.
I was trans. I understand the experience. I have a different opinion about what struggling young people need than you do. That doesnât make me a liar or anti-trans. That means I have a different opinion. Stop being an intolerant bigot to people who disagree with you
đ¨Important message for young trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identifying people âŹď¸
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Sure. Last post on this matter and perhaps my most important.
All I want for you is to be honest with yourself so you can achieve a self-sustaining happiness which does not require the affirmation of anyone else; gender or otherwise. That is a recipe for misery.
If trying to pass as a woman and not succeeding 100% of the time is making you miserable, maybe the desire to pass as the opposite sex is a band-aid on a much deeper form of distress which needs to be addressed.
Youâre young. Itâs easy to mistake a mask for a cure. When I was trans and being âmisgenderedâ it didnât evoke a reaction in me that compelled me to want to harm myself. Did it sting? Sure. Because I realized that I was brushing up against a reality I was trying to run away from. That was painful. It wasnât soul crushing, though. In the end, I just realized continuing to transition wasnât worth the hassle.
Being trans can only hope to be a path conducive to happiness and functioning if you are at a minimum, extremely resilient. The words or perceptions of other people should not shake you if you wish to live a life which puts you at odds with your biology. Itâs a hard way to live and youâve got to be tough as nails to make it work.
Regardless of where your transition goes, I hope you are able to check in with yourself and to understand that holding yourself to an impossible standard in your valiant attempt to ease your distress can actually make your distress worse.
If there is even a sliver of a chance that your desire to transition is motivated by earlier pain in your life around being male, it is best to address that pain on its own merits, for your own sanity. Transition canât heal wounds. It runs the very real risk of just making them deeper, especially if you arenât careful.
You say youâre doing your best to heal, and I hope that is true. I know many people who used transition as a way to avoid confronting their pain. I hope this is not the case for you.
I hope you have legitimate mental health professionals at your side who will show you the respect you deserve by not pandering to your intrusive thoughts.
I hope you can heal to such an extent that other people referring to you as your birth sex does not cause you to spiral into insanity. You donât deserve that kind of misery.
I wish you the best, genuinely.
I hope so too. Unfortunately being trans and introspective at the same time is a good way to have your trans friends turn into your enemies so there are barriers
I donât wish pain on anyone. People being hurt by honest biological truths is totally on them. Being trans requires insane resilience. Pandering to delusion prevents young people from developing the resilience they need to survive life and to thrive. I wish you all the best.
Sure. All I want for you is to be honest with yourself so you can achieve a self-sustaining happiness which does not require the affirmation of anyone else; gender or otherwise. That is a recipe for misery.
If trying to pass as a woman and not succeeding 100% of the time is making you miserable, maybe the desire to pass as the opposite sex is a band-aid on a much deeper form of distress which needs to be addressed.
Youâre young. Itâs easy to mistake a mask for a cure. When I was trans and being âmisgenderedâ it didnât evoke a reaction in me that compelled me to want to harm myself. Did it sting? Sure. Because I realized that I was brushing up against a reality I was trying to run away from. That was painful. It wasnât soul crushing, though. In the end, I just realized continuing to transition wasnât worth the hassle.
Being trans can only hope to be a path conducive to happiness and functioning if you are at a minimum, extremely resilient. The words or perceptions of other people should not shake you if you wish to live a life which puts you at odds with your biology. Itâs a hard way to live and youâve got to be tough as nails to make it work.
Regardless of where your transition goes, I hope you are able to check in with yourself and to understand that holding yourself to an impossible standard in your valiant attempt to ease your distress can actually make your distress worse.
If there is even a sliver of a chance that your desire to transition is motivated by earlier pain in your life around being male, it is best to address that pain on its own merits, for your own sanity. Transition canât heal wounds. It runs the very real risk of just making them deeper, especially if you arenât careful.
You say youâre doing your best to heal, and I hope that is true. I know many people who used transition as a way to avoid confronting their pain. I hope this is not the case for you.
I hope you have legitimate mental health professionals at your side who will show you the respect you deserve by not pandering to your intrusive thoughts.
I hope you can heal to such an extent that other people referring to you as your birth sex does not cause you to spiral into insanity. You donât deserve that kind of misery.
I wish you the best, genuinely.
How can you prove that doing the trans thing is life saving when you admit that being misgendered is a catalyst for your ongoing harm to yourself?
I am genuinely concerned for your longevity.
You are young and you are being failed by the medical profession.
The fact that trans activists think posting a picture of them flipping me off is a good refutation to a well-reasoned question tells me everything I need to know about their mental acuity as a groupâŚ..
Quotes a post by T14253; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Some people say I need to put more âeffortâ into being a woman now that Iâve stopped living in a trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ delusion.
To those people, I say âFUCK OFFâ
REPOST if you agree that being a woman isnât a âlook.â Itâs an unchanging biological reality.
Some people say I need to put more âeffortâ into being a woman now that Iâve stopped living in a trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ delusion.
To those people, I say âFUCK OFFâ
REPOST if you agree that being a woman isnât a âlook.â Itâs an unchanging biological reality.
Quoting @jk_rowling: A woman is someone who doesn't need to put in any work to become a woman, because she's already a woman.
When I was trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸, I thought I was free. In reality, I was enslaving myself. I bound my breasts. I damaged myself. I invested thousands of hours of my precious youth into living a lie.
When I realized that I will always be a woman for as long as I live, I finally found FREEDOM
My life would have turned out differently if when I was trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ someone had said âyou donât have a male brain in a female body. Youâre just autistic.â
Bethany is just as delusional as the trans activists, even though sheâs a conservative Christian. Horseshoe theory in full effect: the dress makes the woman
Fully agree. I started out being interested in the body modification aspect. I wanted to modify the pituitary gland because I was obsessed with it in acromegaly cases and thought surely the pituitary in âtransâ patients could be modified so as to avoid a lifelong cross hormone injection regimen. I had a lot of crackpot theories as a 12 year old. Unfortunately I got more sucked in than I had ever planned on. And then a few years after I got sucked in, it seems like every single autistic or artsy girl got sucked in. Insane shit.
It just occurred to me that all the trans influencers that infected me with the brain worm are your age. Did you watch these people or was it only something teens/pre-teens would even be interested in consuming?
My stance on trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ is this:
I donât hate the victims of the social and techno-medical experiment called âtrans.â I do hate the teachers, doctors and medical bodies who engrave these đłď¸ââ§ď¸ lies onto the bodies of young people.
This woman, Chase Ross, single-handedly turned my generationâs autistic girls trans while also introducing us to sex toys as middle schoolers.
Monitor your kids online. I cannot stress this enough.
A generation of young people will live the rest of our lives with damaged, deformed and missing body parts.
Because our culture decided that peddling the transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ LIE on TV, in schools & at colleges was more important to the future than we were.
How is that not criminal?
I want Gen Z to understand that even though they told us so in school, you donât need to be trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ to be happy.
Be young. Do dumb shit. Ride a boat. Youâre perfect just as you are. Never forget that.
Looks like whether trans or ex-trans, there are a barrage of insane people sending us death threats. We are both united in our experiences of having been targeted by lunatics whose very essence is antithetical to inclusion within civilized society. We have more in common than one might think
Iâll keep sharing my experience for as long as parents tell me they know more about the trans phenomenon after hearing from me. What I need is for every adult who sees my posts, or the posts of any other ex-trans young person to make a commitment to looking out for the kids in their lives
2025 is the year where adults are finally waking up to the transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ and woke LIES that teenagers in 2015 (like me âŹď¸) were being indoctrinated into.
What are you doing to protect your kids from đłď¸ââ§ď¸gender ideology?
I refuse to believe my pituitary tumor obsession at the age of 8 was profoundly different from my trans obsession from 12+ from my toe walking, difficulty tying shoes, lazy eye and therapy Iâve had on every part of my body to treat delays etc. They were all caused by the same thing. And in light of todayâs news from RFK, Iâll add- I doubt it was from tylenol. It was caused by being born prematurely and surviving that experience. Some things are clearly ASD patterns.
But certainly, some of the self-identified autistic young women Iâve met clearly have the emotional capacity + theory of mind to emotionally manipulate people which is equal parts terrifying and impressive to me as someone who struggles with both of these. Those people seem more personality disordered than autistic in their behavioral patterns and total lack of any developmental quirks or delays.
The diagnosis is treated like a psychiatric one, based partially on culturally atypical behaviors but makes neurodevelopmental claims. Itâs very broad and almost always requires personal stories to âhumanizeâ which also leads to descriptive problems.
Lots to unpack here. I like your analysis.
Young people are very impressionable.
10+ years ago youth were bombarded with videos that told us âif you feel different it means youâre trans.â
We believed it.
Today, youth see videos that say âif youâre different, it means youâre made in Godâs image.â
And they believe it.
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/why-some-teens-go-trans-and-others?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
I have a Substack where I write about this subject specifically for parents (and clinicians) Iâm more responsive to DMs there on Substack. Hope my work is helpful
Erika Kirk is the epitome of strength.
Had I known of her as a kid, I might not have gone trans.
Charlie Kirk was a role model for young men. Erika Kirk will be a role model for young women.
Charlie Kirk helped me realize that the left was lying to me about everything I was told to believe in. Iâm not a transgender communist anymore. And I love the West. Our civilization is worth protecting. Thank you, Charlie. You will be deeply missed.
So now you need high doses of cross sex hormones to be trans? Thatâs news to me. No one told me that when I was binding my breasts, known by my peers and affirmed as a đłď¸ââ§ď¸man and found myself in trans communities. Just admit your ideology is incoherent. Moving the goalposts is a bad look. Very transphobic to deny the trans-ness of thousands of people by pretending that social transition isnât transition.
Charlie Kirk disagreed with transgenderism đłď¸ââ§ď¸ but didnât want transgender people to die.
Jimmy Kimmel disagreed with âmy body, my choiceâ regarding experimental COVID vaccines and he DID want unvaccinated people to die.
The two sides are NOT the same.
Charlie Kirk disagreed with transgenderism đłď¸ââ§ď¸ but didnât want transgender people to die.
Jimmy Kimmel disagreed with âmy body, my choiceâ regarding experimental COVID vaccines and he DID want unvaccinated people to die.
The two sides are NOT the same.
Quotes a post by T17680; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Send her over to my account. I do free speech spaces with trans activists, gender criticals, terfs, those on the left, those on the right and anyone else who wants to engage
Trans activists đłď¸ââ§ď¸often tell me that they want me to die and that they want to be the ones who will kill me.
I donât wish death on them in return.
Because I donât think human beings deserve to die even if they think I do, for my opinions.
Trans activists are just admitting that they see men in dresses and transwomen in dresses as being the sameâŚ.
Itâs a win for reality. In a weird way.
Quotes a post by T25535; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I used to be a transgender communist and now Iâm not. Hereâs what it took to get me out of the cult and back to reality âŹď¸
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: đ¨I used to be a far left transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ communist from ages 12-24.
Now Iâm 26, Iâm no longer trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ and I fight against the beliefs of the woke cult.
Hereâs every parent should know about what it really takes to de-radicalize politically extremist youthđ§ľ âŹď¸
/1
My take as an ex-transgender communist on what parents must know about how to protect their kids
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: đ¨I used to be a far left transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ communist from ages 12-24.
Now Iâm 26, Iâm no longer trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ and I fight against the beliefs of the woke cult.
Hereâs every parent should know about what it really takes to de-radicalize politically extremist youthđ§ľ âŹď¸
/1
Without these three things, I would still be a transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ communist today:
1. Critical thinking skills I learned in high school debate.
2. The experience of living through wars in the Middle East.
AND THEN,
3. Algorithms feeding me Charlie Kirkâs videos.
đĽâŹď¸
/2
đ¨I used to be a far left transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ communist from ages 12-24.
Now Iâm 26, Iâm no longer trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ and I fight against the beliefs of the woke cult.
Hereâs every parent should know about what it really takes to de-radicalize politically extremist youthđ§ľ âŹď¸
/1
A transgender, polyamorous couple is raising their kids to not know whether theyâre boys or girls.
Should parents be allowed to raise their kids in this way?
@[private account] They are threatening and killing off their ideological opponents and celebrating it instead of just engaging in a damn debate. How many death threats do you receive on a daily basis from trans activists?
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
What to do when people want you dead. Advice to right wingers, from a trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ influencer:
1. Realize youâre delusional
2. Become obsessed with anime (porn)
3. Become polyamorous
Will you take his advice?
Wow. So sorry to hear about your son. I have a Substack where I discuss my experiences and insights from my experiences in transition & detransition, aimed at parents, clinicians and curious people.
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/trans-when-coping-mechanism-becomes
I used to be on the left. I used to be a woke, pro-Palestine transgender. I was smart enough to come up with good arguments to convince myself of these bad ideas. No one around me was smart enough to present me with good counter-arguments to make me disbelieve wokeness until I went to Israel, saw things for myself, lived through some rocket attacks, realized the left are a bunch of terrorist simps, argued with them online (which caused the algorithm to give me right wing content) where I saw people like Charlie Kirk on my timeline.
Thatâs what it took to begin questioning these beliefs because of how young I was when I was indoctrinated into them
Iâm a 26 year old ex-woke, ex-transgender Jewish lesbian.
The right has embraced me with open arms.
The left has threatened to kill me.
Yeah, of course Charlie Kirk has my sympathies. He should have the sympathies of every civilized person in the West.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Gen Zâs 9/11 came one day early.
Two small children lost their father before their very eyes. A wife lost her husband. Our country lost Charlie Kirk.
Half of us got our hero ripped from us, as the other half celebrates.
We will never be the same đ
Iâm an ex-woke, ex-transgender Gen Z Jewish lesbian.
Charlie Kirkâs respectful, open-debate approach persuaded someone like me to ditch wokeness & vote MAGA.
The woke mob couldnât tolerate that, and so they took a loving father from his two small children. Despicable.
Charlie Kirk didnât want trans people to die.
He wanted trans identifying people to be healthy, happy and wholeâideally by finding Jesus instead of forever worshipping their inner gender deity.
Charlie Kirk didnât want trans people to die.
He wanted trans identifying people to be healthy, happy and wholeâideally by finding Jesus instead of forever worshipping their inner gender deity.
Quotes a post by A2346; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Thank you, Charlie Kirk, for showing such compassion to the young trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identifying students you debated with.
Seeing your work helped me get myself out of the woke cult and to leave transgenderism behind.
You, sir, have helped to save a generation.
@charliekirk11 has changed so many lives. He will be so deeply missed.
Charlie Kirk, you gave detransitioners a national platform when no one else would.
You treated every single young trans identifying person you debated with the utmost respectâ even as wokists in the audience harassed you.
I saw those videos when I was still deeply entrenched in the cult of đłď¸ââ§ď¸ ideology & wokeness.
It was your compassionate approach that made me realize that there were good people on the other side. It was your approach that made me realize just how much the woke left had lied to me.
I ditched transgenderism and wokeness in large part due to the efforts of your movement, and your compassion alongside personal factors.
Thank you, dear Charlie, for everything youâve done for our great country, for young people and for families. You didnât deserve this.
May you rest in peace, may your memory be for blessing, and may your family receive support.
Your children will grow up with the legacy that their father was a legend. Youâve inspired a generation. I wish you were still here with us to celebrate all the good youâve done.
The world is not the same without you.
Oh my god. Poor Charlie. Sir, thank you for everything youâve done to help our country. Your debates helped me realize the insanity of transgender ideology and allowed me to get myself out of it. Youâve saved so many young people. Youâve saved a generation.
You, sir, will be so deeply missed. My thoughts are with your family. Your contributions to our country will never EVER be forgotten.
The clear problem is that people can take those drugs for non-trans reasons. Then the issues of detransitioners, some of whom will be reliant on those drugs for life, especially post-SRS males. Theyâre not even trans identifying anymore⌠should they be liable for past medical experimentation they were subjected to by a corrupt medical industry?
If this government wants to ban transgender people đłď¸ââ§ď¸from owning guns on the basis of gender dysphoria being a mental illness, theyâd first have to:
1. Define legally who is âtransâ
2. Figure out what to do with the non-dysphoric trans people
3. Figure out what to do with detransitioners who no longer âpassâ as their sex, who may or may not be dysphoric.
4. Figure out what to do with all the gender dysphoric people who donât choose transition (socially, legally, hormonally, surgically) as a treatment optionâŚ.
5. Figure out how to convince the public that theyâre the arbiters of whose subjective feelings are too mentally ill to have all of their constitutional rights
6. Figure out how to explain to the public what the rationale is for denying gun ownership on the basis ofâŚ. FeelingsâŚ. Identity claimsâŚ.. or any number of unspecified comorbid mental illnesses & neurodevelopmental conditions which manifest as gender-related distress
*and thatâs just the start of questions theyâd have to answer*
Guys, this whole thing is totally impossible to enforce. Itâs a dumb piece of legislation, clearly wonât stand up to any scrutiny and even if by some magic it passes, how can it even be enforced?
I agree fully. This stuff is totally unenforceable. In todayâs definition, not all trans people have gender dysphoria and trans is an identity anyways. So if the pathology theyâre trying to isolate is GD⌠why are they framing it in terms of trans identity? Itâs dumb. Really dumb.
If kids undergoing đłď¸ââ§ď¸ chemical castration were being closely followed by mental health professionals, as trans activists pretend they are, would this really have happened?
âI am an elementary schooler and I work to make all of my students transgenderâ
The fact that a âprankâ video hits so close to home for so many parents is objectively a problem.
When "Being Trans" is an Autistic Teen's Special Interest... https://substack.com/@thepeacepoet99/note/p-171685563?utm_source=notes-share-action&r=1gcde6
Itâs crazy to think about the few Millenial trans influencers in their early-mid 20âs back in the early 2010âs whose vlogs turned almost every autistic Gen Z kid transgender.
Mentally unstable people are allowed to have children because there are huge ethical concerns with sterilizing people on the basis of mental illnessesâŚ. except for in the case of âtransâ in which case it becomes an excuse to do just that.
If gender affirming surgery is life saving for trans people, why are you performing these radical, function destroying procedures on people for whom it isnât (by your logic) âlife-savingâ????
The TikTok trans activists are melting down over little old me đ
Imagine calling a Jewish lesbian a borderline conservative nationalist.
Losing the plot much?
Gen Z is cooked. The straight people want to be âqueerâ and the gay people want to be trans.
Everyone wants to be everything except for who they are.
I was trans identified years before this stuff popped up. I saw this whole thing play out throughout the course of my childhood and adolescence. 2016 from my recollection was the year every liberal feminist got pissed off about manspreading and simultaneously opposing âtrans bathroom bansâ that kept womenâs restrooms single sex
The reason they do this is because they see trans as some kind of metaphysical essence rather than as a set of actions one takes to approximate the appearance of the opposite sex. Theyâre trying to make sense of two competing strains of gender ideology: the lie of old school transsexuality and the new lie of gender fluidity. It causes them too much dissonance to think critically.
Liberal women believe wholeheartedly in suicidal causes including trans rights & mass Jihadi immigration b/c their empathy for the perceived downtrodden amongst men hijacks their brains and basic survival instincts.
Liberal men believe these things to sleep with liberal women.
Why Some Teens Go Trans, and Others Don't https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/why-some-teens-go-trans-and-others?r=1gcde6&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
Why do some teens think they're trans and others don't?
It's not as simple as "because they're indoctrinated" or because they really are born into the wrong bodies.
Read my latest essay to hear my take.
Not all trans women are predators, but all trans women are men.
No good man gets naked in a locker room filled with women & little girls. Or steals their trophies.
@xx_xyathletics
I have serious reservations about the ethics of gender medicine, but I certainly donât want anyone (trans or otherwise) to kill themselves. If youâre experiencing suicidal ideation, please seek help. Youâre young and have your whole life ahead of you.
The transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸â§ď¸ movement was doing just fine until it decided that anything less than promoting child castration in schools was genocidal bigotry & now the whole stack of cards is crumbling down.
Trans isnât a thing someone is, itâs a thing some people *do* and this thing that some people do to imitate the appearance of the opposite sex so as to be known in this way by others takes a tremendous toll on someone psychologically & physically and is dangerous in a way being gay in the west especially, isnât.
Being gay doesnât inherently risk a childâs bodily integrity. Being trans does.
Parents have a fundamental instinct to protect their childrenâs bodies, which is why they insist on pesky little things like wearing seatbelts and bike helmets.đŞ
Trans activists will say that gender medicine is done responsibly because âtherapy is required.â We know this isnât true everywhere. Even where it is, the therapy is affirmation only, so no underlying issues are explored. The moment someone suggests proper therapy, theyâre labeled a âtransphobe.â
Make it make sense.
đ¨Transgender ideology đłď¸ââ§ď¸has made our society dumber in so many ways.
One of which, is by capturing so many high-IQ autistic/aspie people & castrating them.
Itâs not good that our societyâs high-IQ, natural innovators are effectively prevented from reproducing.
Itâs tragic that one of the groups most vulnerable to the trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ pipelineâautistic youth with high intelligence and deep emotional sensitivityâare being fast-tracked toward castration.
Weâre only beginning to see the fallout. The worst is still ahead. Buckle up.
đłď¸ââ§ď¸Transgender medicineđłď¸ââ§ď¸:
The only medical field where âthe patient not regretting itâ (or not telling you) is the ONLY consistent metric used to determine success.
Itâs almost as if the disorder is about the feelings then, no?
My opposition to transgender medicine as a field has everything to do with its pernicious lies, false promises & pathological aversion to prove its claims with anything resembling a solid evidence base.
If gender medicine showed objective improvements to patient functioning & only used as the âgold standardâ after less invasive alternatives were thoroughly ruled out (both on the basis of methodologically sound studies)â everyone sane would support it.
The problem is, gender medicine is underpinned by assumptions which belong to three sets of claims:
1. unproven
(gender transition saves lives/itâs the only treatment for gender dysphoria)
2. unprovable
(some people have cross-sex souls that are born in the wrong bodies)
(This feature of right brain/wrong body causes incongruence)
(that liberating the gendered soul from the body is the only way to help these patients)
3. provably false (that a fully consolidated identity of any kind (gender identity included) is a thing everyone is born with/menâs thoughts about their sex are a good enough medical indication to disrupt their testosterone-feuled endocrine systems and vice versa)
(Some people innately have male/female brain inside an opposite sex body rather than a brain with atypical features for oneâs sex)
(That sex-related distress can only be mitigated by approximating the appearance of the opposite sex)
Though the claims of gender medicine (only a few are listed above) are flimsy at best and blatantly false at worst, doctors whose specialty it is to practice transgender medicine tell patients
that itâs proven to reduce distress, life-saving and totally safe.
Beyond that, the field thrives of censorship of data, studies based on exceedingly poor methodology and uses emotional blackmail to conceal its fundamentally pseudoscientific nature.
My gripe is not with the people who consider themselves to be transgender or transsexuals.
My anger is channeled specifically towards those professionals who may have started practicing gender medicine with only the best of intentions and who have decided to, despite understanding the total lack of evidence base, choose to change the goals of their practice from ârelieving gender dysphoriaâ to âhelping patients achieve their embodiment goalsâ and pretending their practice is legitimate medicine
đ¨Trans activists đłď¸ââ§ď¸ donât care that gender dysphoric individuals arenât currently getting evidence-based treatment for their condition.
Does that make trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ activists, the worldâs biggest transphobes?
đ¨Kids who think theyâre trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ DONâT have a higher rate of suicide than other kids with the same underlying mental health issues. That is a fact.
That fact should make us happy.
That fact alone should single-handedly end the practice of pediatric transition.
đ¨Getting to the root of the harm doesnât look like banning puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones & đłď¸ââ§ď¸ surgeries for minors and calling it a day.
It looks like making social transition of children by their parents or schools, totally socially unacceptable.
It looks like not concretizing a childâs cross-sex identity socially in any way.
It means that even if parents want to socially transition the kid, the school doesnât go along with it.
They should know they donât have the training or qualifications to provide such a consequential psychosocial intervention and should explain their refusal to provide social transition to students in this way to their families.
It means that pediatricians who see parents socially transitioning their small children will raise alarms and inform them of the psychosocial risks, rather than referring them to gender clinics.
It means providing adolescents with thorough assessments to diagnose any underlying physical & psychiatric comorbidities and treating those immediately.
It means starting NOW to create evidence-based psychotherapeutic interventions aimed at reducing a young personâs sex based distress without brushing off the inconvenience of proper therapy and hoping the drugs do the work for you.
Our entire culture around medical ethics & psychiatric care needs to change for any of our hard-won progress in protecting kids to be sustainable.
If all we do are bans without confronting the real distress these kids are in, especially those whoâve been raised since early childhood in a cross-sex identity whoâve been conditioned to fear puberty and we yank the rug from under them without actually helping them feel comfortable in themselves;
these kids will be angry, miserable and anxious without the tools and faculties needed to develop sufficient emotional resilience. They will have to experience a healthy puberty theyâve been taught is a crisis situation and their biology will âoutâ them to their peers. This could be very traumatic to these kids who donât an identity as a member of their natal sex because they werenât allowed to develop one , whose entire social life depends on their biological sex being kept a secret. We must account for this fact.
Medical experimentation of this magnitude is extremely unethical- but also, leaving these kids out to dry isnât ethical either.
We canât just take away one coping mechanism without having a robust system in place to cushion the fallâ and pretend weâve protected these kids from harm.
Both gender dysphoria and su*cidality are known to be socially contagious. If you tell a kid itâs either transition or the end of their lives, and you do not have any systems in place to protect them from a tragic outcome, you are setting these kids up for failure.
Not only is it unethical and short-sided to pin our hopes on legislation, itâs also strategically impractical to do so.
Many of these kids will turn 18 within the next few years, just to become the next generation of trans activists because theyâre bought into a framework theyâve been taught as an unalienable truth from the most impressionable periods of their lives.
They will not have enough life experience to understand yet, what theyâve been caught up in. In the absence of real help, they will struggle to function, and their functional deficits will be blamed on lack of access to âgender affirming care.â
Then we will end up exactly where weâve started.
Sustainable progress requires addressing root problems. We havenât done that yet. We should all be concerned by this.
After the whole trans fiasco, I tried to put any perception of potential hypochondria to rest. Now Iâve learned that itâs ok to accept the obvious, even if the experts couldnât see what was right in front of their eyes
Not everyone who has experienced a so-called âgender journeyâ through transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identification, transition (socially, legally, medically, surgically), & regret or detransition wants to expose the most vulnerable aspects of their lives.
They shouldnât have to.
When they choose to, their stories should be met with care rather than with the mindset of self-righteously debating them if their political opinions donât align with yours.
/10
We also need researchers to take seriously the impacts of long-term breast binding, male genital tucking, puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones & the various surgical interventions.
By this I mean, we need researchers to investigate the impacts of these interventions when used at different ages, for different durations of time & both in isolation and in combination with one another.
Basically, whether we identify as trans or detrans or abstainâ we need good research that actually cares about developing protocols for healing to the extent it is possible, from these physically & psychologically traumatic endeavors.
These therapies obviously should be accessible based on need rather than based on an identity label or based on whether the harm was incurred in a formal gender medical system or whether it was incurred through DIYâ because for some these factors are totally inseparable and because for us all, they are both relevant for understanding the whole picture of transition-related impacts.
/7
The issues that predisposed this cohort to developing gender dysphoria in childhood, adolescence or early adulthood were never even remotely addressed in therapy *or* with gender transition interventions of various flavors.
Then came years of cross-sex identity ideation cemented by social, medical, and even surgical transition; each adding layers of psychological, developmental & physical trauma.
Some of us in this cohort, have become only more vulnerable than our same-aged peers for having embarked upon this đłď¸ââ§ď¸pathway and for having our most foundational years shaped by it.
We can only become more destined for resilience with proper support that addresses root causes of our distress & which treats the whole person.
Resilience should be encouraged in these young people even though itâs tempting for political actors to validate & encourage us to be endlessly victimized for clout.
Hereâs whatâs most important to note:
-If someone spent over a quarter to half of their young life intensely fixated on thinking of themselves as something they can never become.
-If someone spends years of their young lives trying to convince others to get on board because theyâve been convinced itâs their only chance for survival
-If someone has transitioned young enoughâthey may not have a solid sense of self to return to at all, once the trans identity begins to splinter.
Thatâs deeply destabilizing.
Young people in situations like mine need real, informed therapeutic care which is grounded in compassion, and not ideology.
/6
Too many young people of my generation have been encouraged to adopt & nurture unstable trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identities in their formative years, as a politically motivated attempt to capitalize upon our distress.
Instead of building a stable, reality-based sense of self, they/we spent their/our youth desperately trying to hold together something that is inherently fragile because it put them at odds with objective reality.
I know this because I was one.
/5
Anyone who actually cares about this cohort of currently or formerly đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identifying/ transitioning youth, should prioritize their ability to recover from traumaâwhether caused by or leading up to transitionâover milking them for a sob story, a testimony, clicks or views⌠ESPECIALLY when their ongoing vulnerabilities are still very much evident to the naked eye.
It is impossible for them to heal within trans activism.
It is also highly unlikely for young people to heal from any of this in the current gender critical political environment that becomes obsessed with conditionally uplifting them until they express narratives that are too complex.
A common experience of emerging from trans identification & grappling with what the hell happened & choosing to speak about it, is that many people with their own agendas will try to influence the way these young people see their own story and their own experience.
/4
These young people deserve to be treated as whole human beings; not as delusional freaks when they identify as trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸, and not as pitiable victims when express regret or as brave oracles of superhuman wisdom responsible for saving humanity, when they detransition.
Gender-distressed, transitioning & detransitioning youth are still young people.
We far more urgently need to develop real, alternative treatment pathways to gender transition (for gender dysphoria) with evidence-based protocolsâ than we do yet another person thinking theyâre doing something good for the world when they say âno man is a woman.â
/3
As a 26 year old woman who thought she was born in the wrong body from ages of 12-24, who tried to âcorrect natureâs mistakeâ by living as a man & then realized her youth had been hijacked by a lieâ I deeply disappointed by trans activism.
And I am also not impressed by most âgender criticalâ activism, either. Thatâs an understatement (for those who canât tell)
What is impressive to me as a jaded 20-something who spent half of her life sucker punched into the đłď¸ââ§ď¸ lie is:
when someone has enough compassion for gender-distressed people to want something better for them, than the status quo of âgender affirmationâ and transition.
And when they do something about it.
/2
I donât even see the point in pursuing an autism diagnosis other than for shits & giggles at this point.
I read medical journals at 8, fell into trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ ideology at 12 & learned to tie my shoes at 14. I know what I am đ
I donât even see the point in pursuing an autism diagnosis other than for shits & giggles at this point. I read medical journals at 8, fell into trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ ideology at 12 & learned to tie my shoes at 14. I know what I am đ
Young people who get wrapped up in thinking theyâre trans are usually very deep thinkers.
Deep thinkers get wrapped up in interesting but false beliefs all the time.
Instead of mocking these youth, the job of society should be to channel their brilliance elsewhere.
Realizing nearly every neurodivergent Gen Z-er Iâve met has grappled with gender dysphoria, AND that many will transition without ever exploring the roots of their distress because therapy is branded âtransphobicââis what radicalized me.
What opened your eyes on trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ issues?
If youâd like to hear more about my story; my experiences with transgender identification, autism, gender transition, detransition & living as a man in the Middle East while really being a woman+ advice to parentsâ
scan this QR code to read my essays:
/9
If đłď¸ââ§ď¸ gender people can falsely report their sex on documents & gain access to resources allocated for the sex they are notâ
itâs only fair that anyone can declare themselves to be âtrans-raceâ & gain access to resources allocated for the race they are not.
My Kid Came Out as Trans. Now What? https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/my-kid-came-out-as-trans-now-what?r=1gcde6&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
đ¨My Kid Came Out as Trans. Now What?
If you've found yourself in this situation, or if you've been in it for a while and are struggling, I invite you to read my latest essay âŹď¸đ§ľ
My high school queer history class trans-ed away nearly every dead, gay historical figure we studied.
Even when I identified as trans, I thought this was immoral. Now, I find it enraging.
Just because a teen boy is developing an addiction to transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ pornography, and with it, severe gender dysphoriaâ it doesnât mean we should discard him, blame him or assign perverse adult motives to him.
If you wouldnât discard, blame or assign perverse motives to a teen boy who develops a drug or alcohol addiction, why should this be treated any differently?
We are talking about kids being groomed, victimized, mind-warped & eventually potentially even castrated.
Every adult in the room should know better than to treat these boys like trash for simply adopting a maladaptive coping mechanism, which our entire society encourages.
We shouldnât blame confused teen boys for the trans affirmation culture which tells them itâs ok to violate the privacy of women and girls because theyâve adopted a trans identity after having their vulnerable minds warped when adults werenât paying attention.
Adults ten years ago didnât know any better about the dangers of the internet on the developing mind, but today I would hope they do. And I hope they would act accordingly. No one can be blamed for failing to act upon knowledge they did not have, but now that we have the knowledge, we have no excuse other than laziness not to act upon it.
These boys, just like the girls, have been wronged. Theyâve been lied to. Theyâve been exploited psychologically and sexually at vulnerable stages of their development. Do these boysâ actions impact girls? Absolutely. Is it their fault? No. Itâs NOT their fault.
Itâs the fault of the adults who perpetuate this culture instead of building one which is suitable for young people to grow into functional adults themselves. Itâs the fault of the adults who allow boys access to girlsâ sports and spaces.
The adults should know better and many have abdicated their responsibilities out of fear of being seen as a bigot, or due to groupthink and a lack of critical thinking skills. These are both cultural problems, and scapegoating confused boys will not solve them.
Both boys and girls are collateral damage in this brutal ideological agenda, in different ways and for different reasonsâ but the impact is still HARM.
These teen boys and young men deserve real helpâ not transgender affirmation and not gender critical blame.
AGP is a paraphilia with many manifestations and plenty of young men develop it now. The trans culture encourages younger and younger men to pursue transition and to nurture these paraphilias. As stated, thereâs a high degree of online grooming of very young teenagers who are already having identity issues and growing up without social skills. Itâs a perfect storm, really
đ¨Many Gen Z teen boys & young men are having their first sexual experiences with pornography.
If that porn is in the genre of forced feminization, theyâll almost inevitably find themselves in online communities groomed by older men. Theyâll receive praise for crossdressing and posting pictures in online forums.
Their parents will be unaware of this for years and suddenly their sons will come out as transgender. For mom & dad, itâll be a huge shock. Theyâll try to argue their son out of it because heâs using ideological language and they assume itâs an issue of indoctrination that can be undone with a good debate. The debate doesnât work because it isnât touching even close to a single root cause. And because the ideological framework serves an emotional need, not a logical one. The premises are wrong, the assumptions are flawed and these âdebatesâ only make both parties angry.
Iâve spent over a decade within trans communities online and in real life and this is a pattern I have seen repeating itself with increasing intensity the younger the males are.
We have to be honest here. Many if not most of todayâs trans-identifying nerdy, sensitive boys with no prior history of gender issues, have developed them as a result of a paraphilia developed (usually) VERY early in adolescence, which hijacked their sexual development at a very young and impressionable age. Paraphilias escalate into paraphilic disorders really quickly.
This particular one, autogynephilia, is socially & medically affirmed as an identity and castration becomes a treatment for the distress and shame a young man may have already felt from a young age due to his sensitivities, his ADHD or autistic traits especially⌠which the paraphilia only escalates in intensity.
Instead of either 1) pretending these boys have no paraphilia underlying their gender distress or 2) calling them pervertsâ we must understand that these boys are 1) also young victims and 2) have developed a paraphilia which (like many others) acts as a coping mechanism for trauma, confusion and/or other distress or deep feelings of inadequacy.
Without understanding both of these things *at minimum* the true needs of these boys will continue to be neglected by parents, by mental health practitioners, by doctors & by society as a whole.
These boys deserve deeper help than most people realize, or are even willing to empathize with.
Can we stop pretending there isnât a paraphilia involved for many of these boys? And, can we also stop pretending that theyâre somehow evil perverts for having their normal drives exploited into a dangerous and maladaptive trajectory at a young age by influences which are not child or teen appropriate in the slightest (and sometimes are even criminal)?
Many parents reach out saying âthere were no signs my kid was trans which is why I refuse to affirm.â
Hereâs the thing- it doesnât matter if your kid was gender non-conforming from birth or not.
Atypical preferences are just as invalid a reason as any other to castrate a kid.
If so-called gender transition werenât being suggested to children, thereâd be no trans childrenđłď¸ââ§ď¸
If so-called gender transition werenât being suggested to distressed adults, thereâd be no trans adults.
The availability of the treatment creates the disorder.
đ¨Many autistic girls, ADHD girls, anxious & sensitive girls, think theyâre trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸
They bind their breasts and the compression soothes their overstimulated nervous systems. That sense of internal calm gets interpreted as âgender euphoria.â
Unfortunately, breast binding can cause lasting, even permanent physical harm. It certainly has for me.
Iâve now found a much safer way to regulate my nervous systemâ a weighted blanket in hoodie form: the TheraHoodie.
I cannot recommend it enough.
2. My weighted blanket.
It kept my nervous system in check as I encountered worldview-threatening ideas đĄ and allowed my brain to function in a more calm and rational way as I questioned my entire worldview surrounding my 12 year long transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identity
1. WAR.
Living through war(s) in the Middle East shifted my priorities from indulging my transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identity OCD into focusing on survival.
Gender dysphoria became a first world problem I didnât have time for as rockets flew over my head.
đ¨Two (quirky) things that made me realize I wasnât actually âborn in the wrong bodyâ after spending 12 years being trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ âŹď¸ đ§ľ
đ¨The philosophy of transgender medicine is this:
âIf youâve got psychological trauma, youâll never be complete without added physical, medical & surgical trauma too!â
What I Wish My Parents Had Understood About My Trans Identity https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/what-i-wish-my-parents-had-understood?r=1gcde6&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
đ¨Teens who identify as transgender are often attempting to make sense of overwhelming distress they don't understand.
Parents panic. Kids shut down. Everyone loses each other.
Hereâs what Iâve learnedâas a former trans kid, and now as a parent coach working with families âŹď¸
Trans identities are one giant obfuscation which often give parents a way to think theyâre meeting their kidsâ needs while also not even remotely meeting their kidsâ needs.
Many such cases of parents misattributing the underlying reasons for their kidâs trans identity and the needs it is trying to meet because the truth unsettles them more than leaving their kidâs issues unresolvedâŚ.
đ¨Why canât trans activists đłď¸ââ§ď¸ admit that itâs not the fault of @genspect or of anyone else, that estrogen is harmful to men?
It is simply reality.
Quoting @genspect: đ¨ MAJOR NEW STUDY raises the alarm on estrogen use in trans-identified males: blood clots, brain changes, cancer, infertility, and more.
Great to see real cross-org collaboration, with contributors from Genspect's Killarney Group (M. Lal) and @donoharm (Lauren Schwartz).
đ§ľ
The reason why trans people đłď¸ââ§ď¸ so often demand to be âaffirmedâ by everyone, is because their identities are so untethered from reality and so destabilizing, that they will cease to exist without life support.
đ¨The trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ movement is failing because it based its success on maiming the healthy bodies of as many children as possible, to justify the unhealthy identities of a small group of adult men who felt they couldnât survive without living their sissy fetish full-time.
đ¨To those who compare transphobia now to homophobia in the 70âs:
The idea of transsexualism has been around for about 100 years. Gay people who transitioned got marriage rights before gays who didnât. Gays donât hold society at gunpoint to be recognized as something theyâre not, nor do they use healthy kids to post hoc rationalize their unhealthy adult identities.
Across the West, people who transition have no fewer rights than anyone else. Gays donât seem personally offended by those who disagree with homosexuality as a natural, healthy variation of human sexuality. Transitioning people far more often feel personally slighted when anyone expresses reservations with their life choices and see bigotry within the inherent human ability to differentiate males from females.
Thereâs a good reason our society got behind gays in a few decades, whereas with trans, there was a hay day decade where the public could be threatened into entertaining this fiction until they realized they were being dangerously defrauded, so now thereâs a backlash.
Quotes a post by T14053; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
To those who compare transphobia now to homophobia in the 70âs:
The idea of transsexualism has been around for about 100 years. Gay people who transitioned got marriage rights before gays who didnât. Gays donât hold society at gunpoint to be recognized as something theyâre not, nor do they use healthy kids to post hoc rationalize their unhealthy adult identities.
Across the West, people who transition have no fewer rights than anyone else. Gays donât seem personally offended by those who disagree with homosexuality as a natural, healthy variation of human sexuality. Transitioning people far more often feel personally slighted when anyone expresses reservations with their life choices and see bigotry within the inherent human ability to differentiate males from females.
Thereâs a good reason our society got behind gays in a few decades, whereas with trans, there was a hay day decade where the public could be threatened into entertaining this fiction until they realized they were being dangerously defrauded, so now thereâs a backlash.
Genuinely funny how much of trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ activism is based on invalidating the lived experiences of people who overcame gender dysphoria WITHOUT pretending to be the opposite sex
Quotes a post by T00309; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
đ¨Man who claims to be a woman also thinks itâs fine to castrate boys into a permanent child-like state to affirm his fetish.
Why do we call these men âtransâ instead of naming the type of threat they actually are?
Being trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ felt like one big, long, 12 year hallucination that upended my identity development during critical years of development.
Living in reality is far more conducive to human flourishing, than sacrificing your life to endlessly fight it.
My transgender identity đłď¸ââ§ď¸of 12 years vanished after I understood I could be a woman with short hair and an extensive bow tie collection.
Hi Hendrix,
Regardless of any choices you make, donât feel pressured to stick to them for anyone but yourself.
Your return to honesty and critical thought on trans issues has been amazing to witness, and however you choose to grapple with it personally in regards to your own identity makes no difference to me. Many of us (myself included) respect you deeply for that alone.
I know this advice regarding peer pressure isnât as relevant to you because youâre older than I am and are therefore probably more immune to peer pressure than my cohort/younger people are. But I thought Iâd state it anyways.
All the best,
Maia
đ¨Being a man is a necessary condition (a requirement) for being a âtranswoman.â
How do I know that all transwomen are men, even if they look âlikeâ women? âŹď¸
Transwomensâ XY chromosomes make them men. And we know which chromosomes they have because of the expression of their SRY gene which caused them to develop as unambiguous males with penises and testicles, evident at birth.
When weâre talking about transwomen, we arenât even talking about some group of people comprised mostly or entirely of edge cases of XY males like Imane Khelif, whose maleness became evident at the onset of puberty due to being undiagnosed with a DSD at birth in a poor, under-resourced country. Khelif doesnât identify as trans. Many people with DSDs donât.
It is both inaccurate and disrespectful to make this conflation. DSDs that almost zero transwomen have isnât even relevant to the conversation, nor does it validate the false idea that sex is somehow a spectrum. It isnât.
The vast majority of men, transwomen included, are thoroughly, unambiguously male in every cell of their bodies. They can alter their external appearance to varying degrees of success, to obfuscate some male characteristics (though often to a low degree of success when compared to many of their FTM counterparts)â but thereâs no degree to which successful obfuscation of oneâs maleness actually makes that individual any less male, or any less of a man.
Quotes a post by T16992; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans activists have a problem where they hate people with disabilities despite advocating for people to disable themselves with gender mutilation treatments
Trans is a coping mechanism, in many cases for kids who have traits of autism or adhd. Iâd rather they get diagnosed with the thing they have rather than diagnosed with distress resulting from those things being untreated, especially when that option carries a lifelong medical burden
đ¨Why Do So Many Autistic Kids Think They're Born in the Wrong Body?
I used to be trans, and now I'm not. What I have always been, is on the autism spectrum. This is the last essay I'll write as a 25 year old, so be sure to send it to a parent of an autistic or ADHD kid ;) đđ
The only difference between a âcis manâ and a âtrans womanâ is an identity claim.
Men in womenâs intimate spaces & sports represent a threat to women regardless of how they subjectively identify.
Personal gender identity is totally irrelevant.
Trans women just like ALL men, must make the choice to be good men.
Trans women just like ALL men, must choose to not do the things that only BAD MEN do.
Not all trans women are predators, but all trans women are men.
No good man gets naked in a locker room filled with women & little girls. đ§ľ
@Simone_Biles
Inclusion of âtrans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ womenâ in womenâs sports is a potential Larry Nasser situation in every locker room.
Certainly, @Simone_Biles wouldnât want what happened to her to happen to other girls, right?
đ¨Autistic youth are uniquely vulnerable to đłď¸ââ§ď¸gender ideologyâpartly because they grow up being fundamentally misunderstood by nearly every important person in their lives.
If you donât want the đłď¸ââ§ď¸techno-medical industry to be the one that âgetsâ your child, itâs time to deeply understand how autism is impacting your childâs experience of reality & embodiment.
If you want to truly protect your autistic or neurodivergent child from the clutches of nefarious gender doctors, understanding the way your childâs brain processes information is the first step in finding the best strategies to help them.
Iâve helped many families navigate these turbulent times with their neurodivergent kids in one on one coaching sessions. I use my insights from my personal experiences of neurodivergence & trans identification to help families put the puzzle pieces together.
If this is of interest, please read my essays linked below, or DM me.
If you think itâs only unethical because theyâre doing it to kids, just wait until YOUR 18 year old comes home from college saying sheâs trans & demanding you pay for her âtop surgeryâ
If you donât accept it for your young adult child, you shouldnât accept it for anyone elseâs.
đ¨Share this post to spread life-saving knowledge for parents of autistic kids.
The transgender mutilation industry is coming for them. Parents deserve the tools to understand & protect their kids.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: The Misunderstood Autistic Girl to Trans Boy Pipeline https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/the-misunderstood-autistic-girl-to?r=1gcde6&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
đ¨Most âexpertsâ donât understand why so many autistic girls adopt trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identities.
I doâbecause I lived it. Now Iâm obsessed with writing about it
Subscribe to my Subst4ck if you want to understand the gender debate 3 levels deeper than the rest of the internet.đâŹď¸
đŚžSHARE: to spread knowledge that will save autistic kids from gender mutilation.
đ¨HOW DO WE END THE TRANS CRAZE?
Step One: Diagnose Girls With Autism
Step Two: Understand Them.
Is it really that simple? Read my essay to find out âŹď¸
How Do We End the Trans Craze? Step One: Diagnose Girls With Autism. https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/how-do-we-end-the-trans-craze-step?r=1gcde6&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
If by âtrans rightsâ đłď¸ââ§ď¸you mean:
sterilizing vulnerable children & adults, letting grown men with âgender identitiesâ get naked in front of little girls before crushing them in contact sports, and grooming gender non-conforming/autistic/unhappy kids into thinking they were born so wrong that only taking a scalpel to their breasts & genitals can âfix themââ
Then no, trans rights shouldnât be up for debate. They shouldnât be entertained, let alone granted, in civil society. They should be treated as a criminal advocacy & prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.
Quotes a post by T14253; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Even without hormones or surgery, early trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ identification robs young people of something priceless:
The chance to grow into a grounded & stable sense of who they truly are, as a boy or a girl.
How can someone easily return to the Self they were never allowed to become?
Sometimes this whole âparenting trans kidsâ thing seems like some mom or dad choosing to castrate their princess-loving sons so they donât âhave toâ beat the gay out of him instead.
Somehow this is considered progressive by many even current gay marriage supporters
The reason why being trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ is so hard, from my experience as someone who isnât trans anymore: Itâs not because of âtransphobia.â
Being trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ is hard because sustaining an identity which is objectively based on a lie is an inherently unstable & precarious way to live.
đ¨ When Gender Dysphoria is Autism in Disguise:
At 12, I thought I was trans.
At 25, I understand I'm autistic.
My new essay unpacks how giftedness, ADHD, & undiagnosed autism fueled my gender confusionâand how I help parents see whatâs really going on beneath itâŹď¸
More trans activist fear mongering about stuff that isnât happening, as an obfuscation of the barbarity theyâre trying to hide in plain sight âŹď¸
đłď¸ââ§ď¸Trans healthcare đĽź= a doctor justifies making you physically sick because youâre already mentally sick.
But when you want to stop being sick, youâre on your own.
If this is compassion, I certainly want no part of it. Do you?
Call me crazy, but I donât think that damage to healthy body parts & endocrine systems counts as healthcare.
The concept of âtrans healthcareâ doesnât even make sense.
I didnât grow up religious, but I did think I was transgender for 12 years, joined a cult & pretended to be a man in the Middle East. Was my trans experience a type of religious trauma?
People are allowed to change their opinions. I used to be transgender, a communist & pro-Palestine. Now Iâm none of those things. That doesnât make me an evil grifterâ it makes me SANE & open-minded.
How have your beliefs changed?
I feel so bad for the parents who shelled out $100K per year to send their kid to an Ivy League only for the kid to come home wearing a Middle Eastern terrorist tablecloth kerchief, demanding her parents fund a transgender breast removal operation. Horrendous.
The trans community has become the de-facto autism support group for the undiagnosed.
Imagine how much benefit could be done just by diagnosing autism in people who have it, so they know *why* theyâre different & the explanation is based in REALITY.
Trans Identity: When Parents Try to Win the Debate, Their Kids Alienate. https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/trans-identity-when-parents-try-to?r=1gcde6&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
đ¨Trans Identity: When Parents Try to Win the Debate, Their Kids Alienate.
Why does every conversation about gender identity turn into a family flame-war? What can parents do to maintain relationships with their kids during these trying times.
Read my essay đ
Iâve been told by some that Iâm an âold soulâ
Iâm 25, but I prefer Shakespeare to TikTok. I know how to sing every word of a 1,000 year old secular Arabic love poem. I know zero words of âWAP.â
Does that make me TRANS-generational?
Having a transgender identity doesnât make someone vulnerable.
What makes someone vulnerable is the multitude of psychiatric issues that get totally ignored from the moment a highly distressed person says âIâm transâ
Iâm so glad my parents didnât affirm my transgender identity đłď¸ââ§ď¸
Did it stop me from embarking upon a dangerous path of self-destruction? No.
But, their non-affirmation prevented my teenage woes from controlling the rest of my life.
For that, I am grateful â¤ď¸
Imagine being some 20-something who has been trans for two years in an affirming Western bubble, telling @BuckAngel who has been transitioned longer than you have been alive, to âstop being anti-transâ
More trans people/transitioners should be actively demanding better healthcare, instead of threatening detransitioners for speaking out against the medical industries & practices that harmed them when they were trans.
If you say âI donât hate trans peopleâ a million times, while also saying that people canât change their sex, you will still be accused of hating trans people.
Clearly, we are dealing with unreasonable people.
This didnât come out of nowhere. It was filmed over nearly two decades:
The creation of the âtransgender childâ was televised âŹď¸
What did you think when it was going on?
If youâre so mad that the kids you influenced into thinking theyâre trans, end up regretting it & speaking outâ perhaps you could stop meddling with the minds of vulnerable kids.
Ever thought of that?
Just your daily reminder that TRANS đłď¸ââ§ď¸ is a CULT which has captured all of our institutions- not some vulnerable, oppressed minority constantly being hunted down.
Have a good day â¤ď¸
Quoting @reddit_lies: Not only are Redditors targeting detransitioner @thepeacepoet99, the mods of r/UofO are actively encouraging targeted harassment.
âIn the past, trans men had to settle for being butch lesbians. But now we have the technology to live as our true selves- as straight men.â
Hearing this phrase repeatedly as a kid was powerful enough to alter my life trajectory.
âŹď¸
https://open.substack.com/pub/maiapoet/p/how-a-normal-adolescent-experience?r=1gcde6&utm_medium=ios
How does a normal first crush turn into a 12 year long trans identity crisis? I lived it. And I wrote about it.
My essay is linked in my bio.
Post your favorite excerpts, questions & personal experiences below âŹď¸
If you say youâre not ok with trans kids, but youâre ok with trans adults-
that means youâre ok with replacing sex in law with âgender identity,â youâre ok with doctors manipulating young adults, youâre ok with men playing in womensâ sports & watching little girls undress in changing rooms
Wanna re-evaluate that statement?
Scratch a trans woman, and youâll find a perverted, vile man underneathâŚ.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Iâm doing my first college speaking event with @TPUSA at the University of Oregon tomorrow. Itâs by far one of the wokest campuses there is.
How do you think itâll go for me?
No one is âtrulyâ transgender.
The whole thing is a scam, based on a psychopathic lie that gay, autistic & unhappy kids are âborn into the wrong bodiesâ
I wonder if she legitimately thought I was making a trans activist argument.
Apparently someone needs to read until the end of a short post before commentingâŚ. Again.
@[private account] @[private account] I was trans for half of my life despite my parentsâ parenting. I just realized that living a lie of cross-sex impersonation is more trouble than itâs worth
Not affirming my trans identity was certainly difficult for both me and my parents, but it ultimately spared me from even more significant bodily harm than I have already faced from breast binding.
Iâm inclined to agree with your opinions on these matters.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: The best thing my parents ever did for me was NOT affirming my transgender identity đłď¸ââ§ď¸
From ages 12-24 I hated them for it. I thought they stood in the way of me becoming my âtrue, authentic selfâ
In reality I was a brainwashed kid & they were my protectors. I â¤ď¸ you, mom & dad
YES! We need to stop telling parents that non- đłď¸ââ§ď¸affirmation = childâs self-deletion.
It is an evil lie which actively prevents a childâs flourishing.
My story is a perfect example that even if a kid sticks with their trans identity into adulthood, DO NOT AFFIRM!
Parents lose custody of their kids for doing exactly what my parents did to protect me from the trans cult.
Our âexpertsâ are LIARS
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: The best thing my parents ever did for me was NOT affirming my transgender identity đłď¸ââ§ď¸
From ages 12-24 I hated them for it. I thought they stood in the way of me becoming my âtrue, authentic selfâ
In reality I was a brainwashed kid & they were my protectors. I â¤ď¸ you, mom & dad
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedcontagionideology cultinstitutional capturestate takes children
If youâd like to support my projects, find me on other platforms & read my long form writing about all things âtransâ đłď¸ââ§ď¸ you can find that info in my bio.
Your support allows my advocacy to reach more people. Thank you to you all for joining me in this fight for sanity!
The best thing my parents ever did for me was NOT affirming my transgender identity đłď¸ââ§ď¸
From ages 12-24 I hated them for it. I thought they stood in the way of me becoming my âtrue, authentic selfâ
In reality I was a brainwashed kid & they were my protectors. I â¤ď¸ you, mom & dad
I wish that all the gay adults in my life did not affirm my transgender identity.
I needed role models. I needed older lesbians to tell me that thereâs a place for women like me in society.
Instead, I got affirmed in an identity which ultimately disfigured my breasts, rib cage & stole half of my life.
Thank you, Julie, for being one of the realest advocates for these kids. Youâve been speaking far before it was popular to do so.
I only wish Iâd encountered you at age 12 when I most needed a gay adult role model, and not at age 24 after having spent half of my life in pursuit of a dangerous lie.
How it DEHUMANIZING to refer to transgender ideology đłď¸ââ§ď¸ as a cancer?
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Itâs actually GOOD to remove CANCER from the body. It makes the body function more easily & can prevent premature death.
Samâs analysis is once again, wrong.
The political goals of gays & lesbians do not overlap with the goals of Big Pharma.
đââď¸ THOUGHT EXPERIMENT (related to Marcusâs shirt)đ¨
DOES HAVING GENDER DYSPHORIA MAKE SOMEONE TRANS đłď¸ââ§ď¸?
If having gender dysphoria makes someone trans & then transition cures their gender dysphoria~ does that mean theyâre no longer trans?
Iâm not sure.
What I am sure about is that plenty of people experience gender dysphoria.
Currently, all of them are told that transition will solve it.
Those who detransition or regret transition are often told they were ânever transâ or ânever dysphoric.â
This statement makes no sense, whether you define âtransâ as a set of actions or as of having experienced gender dysphoria.
The idea that detransitioners & regretters were ânever truly dysphoricâ makes no sense:
No one would attempt to live as the opposite sex, much less to bind their breasts/genitals or to medicalize unless they were truly distressed.
In reality, many regretters & detransitioners still experience dysphoria. Many current trans people do too.
People may quit their gender transition when they realize it isnât solving their sex distress, that the feeding the obsession makes it worse, that there are health consequences & that less invasive methods are better treatments.
Itâs almost as if making oneâs distress a part of their identity by attaching a trans đłď¸ââ§ď¸ label to it, often makes the dysphoria worse because itâs harder to heal from distress which one has turned into their sense of self.
In summary, transition should stop being peddled as THE treatment for gender dysphoria when evidence cannot even bear this out.
Distress can be mitigated by less invasive methods, so peddling the most invasive ones as the only option is beyond misguided. It is insane. It is medically fraudulent.
Letâs normalize the idea that someone can experience sex distress/gender dysphoria and can choose to handle it without undergoing a gender transition.
You expect binding to suck. You donât expect quitting binding to suck worse. Plus, I was trans. I enjoyed living as a man.
Why havenât you stopped your transition?
Important trans info for parents of teen girls âŹď¸
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: đ¨You do NOT have to see a doctor to be medically damaged by a gender transition.
I bound my breasts for 10 years from adolescence to early adulthood.
Now, I cannot breathe without pain. My breasts are deformed. My ribs hurt. I canât stand up straight.
NONE of it is reversible
https://x.com/thepeacepoet99/status/1878688043986764132?s=4
đ¨transgender breast binding is DANGEROUS
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: đ¨You do NOT have to see a doctor to be medically damaged by a gender transition.
I bound my breasts for 10 years from adolescence to early adulthood.
Now, I cannot breathe without pain. My breasts are deformed. My ribs hurt. I canât stand up straight.
NONE of it is reversible
Neither the Womenâs News Network nor trans activist đłď¸ââ§ď¸ accounts like âcringeyâ are chill with three friends hanging out.
Who wants to play a game of horseshoe 𧲠theory with me?
I met Laura in Spring of 2023 when I was still trans. She showed me unconditional understanding, kindness & compassion as I came to terms with the termination of my gender transition.
This woman has SAVED me on so many occasions. Letâs show her some love â¤ď¸
Trans rights are NOT human rights.
No one has the human right to sterilize a child in order to affirm an adultâs identity claims.
No one has the human right to control how others see them, speak about them or think about them.
Trans rights are religious rites, NOT human rights.
It truly is. We have people who donât agree with gay marriage & flaming homosexuals fighting together to protect kids from getting transgender mutilation procedures. Itâs a massive victory
Whatâs insane to me is how many middle aged adults expect me to join their ideological thought cults & virtue signalling purity echo chambers~ just because Iâve left the trans cult đłď¸ââ§ď¸
I spent half of my life in one dumb cult. I will not be joining yours.
Hot take from the gay dude pioneer who thinks that anti-trans bigotry đłď¸ââ§ď¸ is the only reason someone would oppose castrating little boys because god forbid they *might* grow up to be happy, gay đłď¸âđ adults like HIM.
Buck was the only catalyst which allowed me to question transition & transgender ideology.
People like @BuckAngel are the most likely people to make these trans identified youngsters to question this path because they wonât listen to anyone else.
Iâm not saying theyâre the same level of insane intervention, but both are unethical.
Performing medically unnecessary interventions onto people who cannot possibly consent, on the basis of a lie is profoundly unethical.
A healthcare system that normalizes systematically removing healthy body parts from children is inherently vulnerable to adopting the Mr. Potato Head model of gender medicine.
This should come as no surprise.
Trans isnât as unique of a phenomenon as many of us make it out to be. This is the direct byproduct of prioritizing intervention over prevention & invasive interventions over least invasive interventions.
Itâs no wonder that this niche medical child transition experiment in the Netherlands was catapulted to the rest of the world by specifically the American healthcare system.
The American healthcare system sees the body as a bunch of extractable & rearrangeable body parts, with aesthetics as a concern outweighing function. This is obviously the wrong way to think about the body
Circumcising healthy children is deeply unethical.
Cutting into a healthy child for any reason is deeply unethical.
Why do some adults believe that performing transgender đłď¸ââ§ď¸ operations on children is unethical, but that somehow routine male circumcision isnât?
If you tell your kid that their transgender identity đłď¸ââ§ď¸ is âjust a phaseâ~
Rest assured that they will do EVERYTHING in their power to make sure that it ISNâT âjustâ a phase.
Dealing with these kids is a game of strategy. Do we want to be right, or do we want to win?
My TRANS phase đłď¸ââ§ď¸ was 12 YEARS LONG, just saying.
Is the length of someoneâs gender transition retrospectively indicative of how âgoodâ of a candidate they are, for undergoing breast/genital compression damage, endocrine disruption & healthy body part removal?
The saddest part of the advocacy Iâm doing is hearing 18 year old trans activists coming into my spaces.
One young person had his puberty blocked at 11. He casually says âIâve never had a sexual feeling in my life.âHe discusses osteoporosis as if itâs no big deal.
Beyond tragic
If you hate being trans so much, just stop being trans.
I didnât even hate being trans, but I stopped it because I realized it was an impractical & miserable way to live.
Why wonât she stop being trans if itâs making her miserable?
This LESBIAN mom is BASED for NOT ACCEPTING her DAUGHTERâS gender TRANSITION đłď¸ââ§ď¸
Every gay adult in my life affirmed my transgender identity đłď¸ââ§ď¸ because it was the âkindâ thing to do.
The trans critical gay awakening đłď¸âđis beautiful to witness. Nature is healing.
This gay man is slowly waking up to trans insanity đłď¸ââ§ď¸ after being called transphobic for referring to two transgender customers as âyou guysâ
When did âyou guysâ become a âtransphobicâ dog whistle?
The harm of transgenderđłď¸ââ§ď¸ ideology does NOT begin in the doctorâs office.
It begins from the moment that a child believes they were born in the âwrongâ body.
Is there any idea which is more harmful for an adult to tell a child, than this one? âŹď¸
The kids seem to be well adjusted in this family. Iâve been following their story since they became ex-Mormons.
Still, itâs pretty clear that liberal womenâs toxic empathy is a large contributor to the trans crisis