The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
⚠️CORRECTION: REPATH (re-psychopathologization) calls for transgender ideation and urge to medically transition to be recognized as a mental disorder.
Not simply "trans identification."
Thank you @stellaomalley3 for clarifying!
Is transgender identification itself a mental disorder?
At @[private account], the first installment of a point-counterpoint exchange between philosopher @[private account] and @genspect founder @stellaomalley3 over Genspect's REPATH initiative has been published.
REPATH (re-psychopathologization) calls for transgender identification to be recognized as a mental disorder.
Holly kicks off the exchange with a critique of REPATH, arguing that while gender medicine has gone seriously wrong, de-pathologizing transgender identification was not the mistake.
Next week, Stella will respond to Holly's arguments and defend REPATH.
This is exactly the kind of good-faith disagreement I love hosting at RLS. Read both sides, weigh the arguments, and decide for yourself.
And don't forget to vote in the REPATH poll (link in the article below)! We'll poll readers again after the exchange to see whether opinions have shifted.
Read Holly's critique here:
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/the-repath-debate-part-i-the-case
The leftists who don't like our HHS report on left-wing authoritarianism are really just proving our main thesis.
"How dare they call us authoritarians! We must destroy their lives for suggesting such a thing!"
The Guardian article also just straight-up lies about what our report said. They claimed it "suggests that people who receive or support gender-affirming care are more likely to support political violence."
Our report did not in any way suggest that people receiving "gender-affirming care" are more likely to support political violence. Our report wasn't about people who identify as transgender at all.
🚨ALERT: The editors of the journal Men and Masculinities will no longer allow authors to refer to individuals as being "male."
If an author uses the term, they should "specify which dimension(s) of sex are at issue, since sex itself refers to several only loosely correlated dimensions rather than a single underlying fact."
For example, trans-identifying male swimmer Lia Thomas must be referred to as a woman, and his maleness, if mentioned at all, must be attached to specific traits, like genitals, hormones, and chromosomes.
You cannot call Lia Thomas a "male" in this journal, but a woman with "male genitals" and "male sex chromosomes."
The first author of this editorial—the Managing Editor of Men and Masculinities, Tristen Kade—is a woman who identifies as a man.
The model of biological sex this editorial is pushing is what I refer to in my scholarly article "Why There Are Exactly Two Sexes" as the "multi-level" sex model. This model is not merely wrong—it is self-refuting.
From my article:
"Traits are labeled 'male-typical' or 'female-typical' only because they correlate with organisms already identified as male or female—an identification that, in anisogamous species, is made ultimately by reference to gametes."
Read my article at the link below.
🔗https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-025-03348-3
Shocking new data out of Washington state on trans-related diagnoses.
"Even measured against the DSM-5’s highest estimates, the 2022 rate among teen girls in Washington was nearly 600 times greater, and among teen boys nearly 60 times greater."
By @LeorSapir in @[private account].
Quoting @LeorSapir: NEW: At least 15,437 Washington minors had a transgender-related diagnosis on their insurance claims from 2017 to 2023.
In 2022, that included 1 in 58 teen girls.
A new @ManhattanInst analysis of insurance-claims data 🧵
🚨New genders just dropped: Sistergirl and Brotherboy
A new peer-reviewed paper claims that we must redefine sex, sexuality, and gender in order to "decolonize" health and "unsettl[e] Western biomedical norms" in service of the "LGBTQA+SB" community,
From what I can tell, a Sistergirl is just a man who takes on the role and identity of a woman, and a Brotherboy is a woman who takes on the role and identity of a man. Nothing too unique going on here.
The paper gives no specifics on how sex, sexuality, or gender should be redefined, but claims that "colonial influence manifests in data collection through adherence to a medical norm of male/female bodies."
So "male" and "female" seem to be on the chopping block.
The authors describe themselves as "a queer Yamatji person, a Wiradjuri trans fulla, a Wakka Wakka Brotherboy, a trans Ngarrindjeri man, a queer Gunditjmara woman and a trans Murri."
It's incomprehensible to me. Andrea James doesn't like the fact that an opinion piece debunking a popular trans activist narrative, so he just...makes up a bizarre lie that the Boston Globe broke some journalistic convention to attack trans people.
I legitimately can't stand the lies. Transgender activist Andrea James is upset that @[private account]'s op-ed was featured on The Boston Globe's front page.
"There is a longstanding journalistic convention that newspapers generally keep opinion columns...off the front page."
That just...isn't true.
Here are the current front pages of the New York Times, the Washington Post, and the Wall Street Journal.
Look at those opinion columns!
These people just lie with every breath. About literally everything. It drives me absolutely BONKERS. 😵💫
A nice piece in Fox News about @[private account]'s recent op-ed citing my report on the "trans genocide" myth.
I told @FoxNews: "At the @ManhattanInst, we believe that real justice requires an unwavering commitment to the truth. We have presented that truth in our report, and now the media must decide whether to acknowledge it or hide from it."
Read the Fox News piece here:
🔗https://www.foxnews.com/media/boston-globe-op-ed-concedes-violence-against-transgender-people-going-down-despite-activist-claims
A piece by @[private account] in the Boston Globe has sparked new interest in a report I coauthored earlier this year on the nonexistent "epidemic of violence" against trans people.
Our research found that the homicide rates for trans-identifying people is below that of the general population.
Furthermore, the HRC's claim that this supposed anti-trans violence is fueled by "systems of white supremacy" is refuted by the fact that over 65% of perpetrators are black, 80% is intraracial, and the main factor is interpersonal violence, not racism or transphobia.
Read the summary of our report here:
🔗https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
Or read the full, detailed report here:
🔗https://dont-shoot-the-data.github.io/TCLEAR/
Quoting @SwipeWright: 🚨REPORT: Today, on International Transgender Day of Visibility, Vincent Lundgren (@[private account]) and I debunk one of the most widely repeated activist claims: that transgender people are facing an "epidemic" of violence and murder fueled by white supremacy and transphobia.🧵
Yes, it seems that, if anything, identifying as transgender acts as a protective against murder. I think tormenting a group of people with major mental health issues is evil.
The Boston Globe has just published a shockingly sober article about the nonexistent genocide supposedly targeting the transgender community.
In it, they cite a report I coauthored showing that the murder rate is actually lower for trans-identifying people than the general population. Our report was responding to the HRC's annual reports pushing the narrative that there is an ongoing "Epidemic of Violence" against the transgender community.
The reporter says he "offered the Human Rights Campaign's key researcher, the transgender woman Charleigh Flohr, or anyone else with the organization an opportunity to rebut the Manhattan Institute finding, but they didn't reply to me."
That's unsurprising because the HRC is engaging in fundraising propaganda. They don't care about the truth, only promoting the narrative.
Our report presenting the actual data is irrefutable. That's why they have nothing to say in response.
You can read our report summary in @[private account] here:
🔗https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
Or explore our comprehensive report here:
🔗https://dont-shoot-the-data.github.io/TCLEAR/
Read the Boston Globe article here:
🔗https://archive.ph/VqhlI
Reproducibility is an important component of science, though not all journals require authors to provide their data.
We wanted to reanalyze the data of this influential "brain sex" paper with more rigorous statistical methods. The paper said to "contact the corresponding author" to obtain the transgender data.
We did. Several times over multiple months.
They never responded.
The authors were also invited to respond to our critique.
Again, silence.
Is this the behavior of scholars who care about the truth? Or is this more like the behavior you'd expect from people who are trying to hide from it?
Real scientists welcome criticism and be prepared to defend their ideas, or change their minds when presented with compelling arguments and evidence. They don't ghost their critics, especially in the academic literature.
The authors of the study we critiqued have an open invitation to respond to our paper. That invitation has no expiration date.
We hope to hear from them.
Quoting @SwipeWright: 🚨NEW: Our critique of a major "brain sex" study is now published.
@[private account], @[private account], and I evaluate a central premise of gender activism and medicine: that trans-identifying people have brains that are shifted away from their sex and toward their "gender identity."
The "brain sex" concept is so central because it purports to provide an empirical scientific basis for the notion that a child can be "born in the wrong body" and would therefore benefit from body-altering medical procedures to align their body with their mind/brain.
The problem is that this concept is pure pseudoscience and propped up by deeply flawed methods and badly misinterpreted data.
One of the most prominent studies is Kurth et al. (2022), published in the Journal of Clinical Medicine, which claimed that the brains of transgender women are shifted away from their sex and toward their "gender identity." The paper became one of the journal’s most accessed articles and has been cited in major media outlets, scientific papers, legal arguments, and policy discussions involving pediatric gender medicine and sports.
We point out that the paper's headline conclusion rests on a series of serious methodological problems.
Each group contained only 24 participants. The authors used poorly justified parametric methods, one-tailed post hoc tests, made no correction for multiple comparisons, and omitted important robustness checks. Once accounted for, the main finding is no longer statistically significant.
An even more glaring failure of the study was that it failed to account for sexual orientation, despite its known association with neuroanatomical variation and despite the authors having the relevant participant data needed to examine it!
We each repeatedly requested the anonymized participant-level data from the paper's lead author so we could independently evaluate the findings.
We received no response.
The evidence simply does not justify the sweeping "brain sex" conclusion for which this study has become famous.
Our full critique in @[private account] is open access. Read it at the link below, and please cite it and share it whenever you encounter the false claim that trans people have brains that more closely resemble the sex they identify than their own sex.
🔗https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-026-09747-2
🚨NEW: Our critique of a major "brain sex" study is now published.
@[private account], @[private account], and I evaluate a central premise of gender activism and medicine: that trans-identifying people have brains that are shifted away from their sex and toward their "gender identity."
The "brain sex" concept is so central because it purports to provide an empirical scientific basis for the notion that a child can be "born in the wrong body" and would therefore benefit from body-altering medical procedures to align their body with their mind/brain.
The problem is that this concept is pure pseudoscience and propped up by deeply flawed methods and badly misinterpreted data.
One of the most prominent studies is Kurth et al. (2022), published in the Journal of Clinical Medicine, which claimed that the brains of transgender women are shifted away from their sex and toward their "gender identity." The paper became one of the journal’s most accessed articles and has been cited in major media outlets, scientific papers, legal arguments, and policy discussions involving pediatric gender medicine and sports.
We point out that the paper's headline conclusion rests on a series of serious methodological problems.
Each group contained only 24 participants. The authors used poorly justified parametric methods, one-tailed post hoc tests, made no correction for multiple comparisons, and omitted important robustness checks. Once accounted for, the main finding is no longer statistically significant.
An even more glaring failure of the study was that it failed to account for sexual orientation, despite its known association with neuroanatomical variation and despite the authors having the relevant participant data needed to examine it!
We each repeatedly requested the anonymized participant-level data from the paper's lead author so we could independently evaluate the findings.
We received no response.
The evidence simply does not justify the sweeping "brain sex" conclusion for which this study has become famous.
Our full critique in @[private account] is open access. Read it at the link below, and please cite it and share it whenever you encounter the false claim that trans people have brains that more closely resemble the sex they identify than their own sex.
🔗https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-026-09747-2
Last week, NPR reached out to interview me about our recent HHS study on the link between Left-Wing Authoritarianism, support for clinical statements related to gender-affirmation, and support for political violence.
Normally, I would have gladly accepted. But in light of a recent interview I did for The Guardian on the study, in which reporter Melody Schreiber subsequently fabricated a fake “gotcha” moment, and which I exposed by posting the actual transcript, I decided to request that their questions and my responses be submitted in writing.
I also requested that my responses to questions be quoted in full, and if they wanted to cut them up or paraphrase my responses, then they would need my approval. The NPR website states that “For purposes of accuracy and fairness, there are times when we may want to review portions of a script with a source or read back a quotation to ensure we capture it correctly.”
My request was that, given the volatile nature of the topic, they simply extend this courtesy to me. This is especially important because my coauthors and I are forced to deal with the consequences of extreme distortions of our work. We’ve already seen ridiculous headlines saying our study claims trans people and their supporters are violent, and possibly even terrorists, and that we’re setting the stage for a “trans genocide.”
Support for political violence is rising across the political spectrum, and such extreme distortions of our work therefore put me and my coauthors at significant risk. I think my request was very reasonable. If any story requires checking in with sources to ensure “accuracy and fairness,” it’s this one.
Unfortunately, through no fault of the reporter, who ran my request by NPR’s standards department twice, my request was ultimately denied. My detailed responses will therefore not be included in the story NPR is going to run about our HHS study.
I can’t know for sure what type of article NPR is going to publish about our HHS report, but given NPR’s political skew, I predict it will not be friendly. I hope I’m wrong!
Given that likelihood, I believe it would be prudent of me to preemptively post the full, detailed answers I gave to the questions NPR sent me.
You can read those in the screenshots below, which continue in the subsequent post.
C4 targetingdenialideology cultspeech persecutionviolence terror
Quoting @benryanwriter: A central argument levied by transgender activists, Parker Molloy among them, is that overwhelming public opposition to the principal tenets of this movement is inorganic and is largely or completely the product of cynical persuasion campaigns waged by conservatives.
This new masters thesis says that "2SIQTIPeople" (2-Spirit, Indigiqueer, Queer and Trans Indigenous Peoples) experience "homophobia, transphobia, [and] racism" on "Turtle Island" (i.e., N. America) due to colonizers imposing the "gender binary and heteropatriarchy" on them.
"This research creates a relational understanding through Storytelling from a Two-Spirit perspective to examine how the Land can be healing and can teach one to be confident and proud of their 2SIQTIP identity."
Our study did not conclude that "those who support transgender people may be more likely to justify political violence."
Our scale did not measure "support for transgender people," but rather the degree to which one agrees with the "gender-affirming" norms mandated by many institutions of medical professionals.
You cannot simply equate agreement with ideological statements published by the APA, WPATH, and the AAP about how to conduct yourself in the presence of a person who identifies as transgender with "support for transgender people."
That's because such guidance is not evidence-based, and new research increasingly suggests it can result in significant harm. Social transition is not a neutral act; it can solidify cross-sex identities and make people more likely to medically and surgically transition instead of learning to be comfortable in their natural bodies.
Many people don't believe encouraging or participating in a person's bodily confusion is supporting them.
The purpose of our study was to highlight the fact that these "medical guidelines" are unlike any other kind of medical guideline. They're not a product of evidence-based medicine, but ideological decrees masquerading as clinical guidelines designed to mobilize activists.
Whenever you read a headline or statement like the one below about our HHS study, be sure to compare their portrayal to the study itself.
There is a lot of sleight-of-hand taking place to make our study seem extreme, when in reality our study is very similar to studies regularly published in psychology journals that target the political right.
All we did is focus on the other side of the political spectrum for once. And the only way they can dismiss it it to misrepresent it. That's very revealing!
Despite this person's use of quotation marks, our HHS report does not, in fact, contain the text: "Supporting dignity for people who are transgender CAUSES support for political violence."
We were forthcoming and explicit about our study's inability to establish causation.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedideology cultpolitical enemyviolence terror
This is a hilariously absurd attack on our HHS report.
"It included a grant total of 13 transgender people."
Our report was NOT about trans people and their views, and it never claimed to be.
Our survey was designed to capture the views of a representative sample of Americans. Since only about ~1% of Americans identify as transgender, it shouldn't come as a surprise that 1.1% of the participants in our survey identified as transgender.
This was not a "bizarre feature" of our study. It's what you'd naturally expect of a survey designed to capture a representative sample of Americans. It would actually be very concerning if our sample ended up being, say, 10% trans, since that would indicate a very biased sampling process.
Our representative sample of Americans, after our quality checks, included 1,192 people.
Someone literally just calculated that 1.1% of 1,192 is 13.1 and ran this as a headline suggesting it somehow debunks our results.
This is the stupidest thing ever.
🚨BREAKING: Our new HHS report—"Where the Clinic Meets the Movement: Does Gender Ideology Arm Left-Wing Authoritarian Psychology?"—is out!
For decades, psychological research has looked at opposition to transgender ideology through a lens of prejudice and right-wing authoritarianism. We asked the conspicuously neglected flipside question:
What psychological traits characterize those who most strongly endorse gender-affirming norms?
In a preregistered study of 1,208 U.S. adults, we developed a Clinical Gender Affirmation Scale (CGAS) using positions drawn directly from guidance issued by the APA, American Psychiatric Association, WPATH, and American Academy of Pediatrics.
Our results shocked us.
Endorsement of mainstream principles of "gender-affirmation" was strongly associated with left-wing authoritarianism (LWA) and support of political violence.
Both LWA and endorsement of gender-affirming clinical norms were associated with greater justification for killing Charlie Kirk, Donald Trump, and Brian Thompson, as well as arson against ICE buildings, destruction of wealthy people's property, and violence against police.
These relationships remained significant even after controlling for political identity.
Acceptance gender ideology appears to augment authoritarian attitudes in support for political violence.
From our report:
"Together, these findings support the paper's core claim: gender ideology may function as an ideological accelerant, telling left-wing authoritarian psychology who the enemy is, why the situation is urgent, and—in those already disposed toward force—that violence is legitimate."
We believe institutionalized gender ideology may function as a kind of ideological "content package" for people already disposed toward left-wing authoritarianism. It assists in identifying oppressors, creates moral urgency, and provides justification for taking coercive action against opposition.
This is only the first of a series of @HHSGov reports we're working on as a collaboration of researchers at @[private account], @[private account], and @ManhattanInst.
Stay tuned for more.
Read the first HHS report at the link below.
🔗https://opa.hhs.gov/adolescent-health/gender-dysphoria/gender-ideology-and-left-wing-authoritarianism
Trans activist and Harvard Law clinical instructor Alejandra Caraballo has been collecting data all summer on the "anti-trans political movement" for a book.
He identifies @jk_rowling as the central node in the whole movement.
I have been identified as the third most influential "anti-trans" academic in the movement on social media, behind @kathleen_stock1 and @FondOfBeetles.
Amazing company!
The WNBA says only "women" are eligible to play, but it does not define it.
It's easy to dismiss demands for clarity when the threat is merely hypothetical. But now two very real, very large, and very male former NBA players have declared themselves eligible for the 2027 WNBA draft.
Their declarations have been dismissed by many as "stunts." And in one sense, of course, they are stunts. Neither Freedom nor White genuinely believes he is a woman with sudden desires to come out of retirement and play professional women's basketball. They are deliberately creating a spectacle.
But stunts can be effective in highlighting absurdity and forcing clarity—in this case, about where the WNBA truly stands on transgender inclusion. Either the league blocks these men from playing, revealing that it understands what a woman is and why excluding males is necessary, or it lets them in, likely prompting a backlash so extreme that indifference on the "What is a woman?" question won’t be sustainable.
How did we get to this bizarre point? Oddly enough, the path runs through Sophie Cunningham's (@sophaller) index finger.
Read my latest for @[private account] below.
🔗https://www.city-journal.org/article/enes-kanter-freedom-royce-white-wnba-draft
Most people don't realize "geography" isn't the field they remember studying in grade school.
Much of the field has been captured by woke activists who politicize everything, including space itself, and study how colonialism, race, gender, and other identities supposedly determine who may "occupy," "claim," or "belong" in particular spaces.
PhDs and papers are frequently about things like black or trans students forming a poetry club on a college campus as an act of resistance to the Western colonialist institutions that "weren't built for people like me," etc.
They are often totally subjective "autoethnographies" about one's experience "taking up space as a [insert oppressed identity]" in various fields and institutions.
It's all incredibly banal wokeslop, and not scholarly in any meaningful sense.
Remember the hoax paper "Human reactions to rąpe culture and queer performativity at urban dog parks in Portland, Oregon" by @ConceptualJames, @peterboghossian, and @[private account]?
That was published in a geography journal.
Quotes a post by T04373; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Now THIS is a proper headline that accurately captures the Supreme Court's decision.
None of that Orwellian "States can ban transgender women and girls from female sports" nonsense.
Thank you WSJ!
Quoting @WSJopinion: The Supreme Court struck a blow for equal rights for women, federalism and common sense by ruling 6-3 that states can ban biological males from women’s sports teams.
https://on.wsj.com/4xU4OeB
Yeah. The trans issue is where their lies are more obviously brought to the surface for all to see, but it's a mistake to think they're only obfuscating the truth on this issue. They do it on other issues as well, where the facts are a little more complex. And they get away with it more.
They know they're lying. We know they're lying. And they know that we know they're lying.
The Supreme Court did not "ban transgender athletes from sports." It allowed states to bar males from female teams.
There are many examples of "trans" and "nonbinary" female athletes competing on women's teams. You probably never heard about them, because nobody cared.
"Female plays on women's team" isn't exactly controversial. The controversy begins only when MALES enter FEMALE competition.
The reporters know this. The editors know this. Everyone involved in writing these headlines knows this.
These headlines are not "sloppy." They are carefully worded to obscure the truth.
Read my latest for @[private account] below:
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/they-know-theyre-lying
The state laws the media like to spin as "banning transgender athletes from women's sports" also ban "c!sgender" athletes from competing in women's sports, provided they're male.
You can tell they know they're full of 💩 by the way their headlines are perfectly crafted to hide the relevant truth.
Yes, states can technically "ban transgender girls and women from school athletic teams."
But they can only be banned from female teams, because they're males.
Imagine if I, a 40-year-old man, tried to play in a children's (ages 4-7) Tee Ball league and the state passed a law banning me from competing in the wrong age category, which the Supreme Court then upheld.
Would the Globe and Mail write a headline saying "Supreme Court allows states to ban men from sports teams"?
While it would be technically true that states are allowed to ban adult men from sports teams, leaving out which sports teams we're allowed to be banned from—teams designated for young children—is a pretty major omission!
Leaving out that centrally important detail can't be explained by accident or ignorance. Especially when the same detail is omitted from headlines across left-wing media outlets.
It's fully intentional. It's designed to obscure reality and mislead the public.
Yeah, they somehow feel more free than ever to express themselves due to social acceptance, but did you also know there's an active transgender genocide going on and states are introducing bill after bill to take away their life-saving healthcare? Weird.
Even the BBC can't bring themselves to state basic facts that would totally demistify what this ruling is actually about.
They want to convey to readers that these people are facing discrimination for being "transgender" instead of simply being required to be appropriately placed in jails that match their sex.
The Mayor of Chicago has declared a ludicrous "Transfemicide State of Emergency," because it seems every progressive city needs to manufacture its own moral panic.
But the data don't support the narrative.
Trans-identifying people are murdered at lower rates than the general population, and my review with @[private account] of 304 cases from 2015–2024 found that only 3.3% resulted in confirmed hate-crime determinations.
The leading identified circumstance was intimate partner violence.
If Chicago officials actually want to save lives, they should stop laundering make-believe activist talking points through city government and start describing the problem honestly.
Read our report below:
🔗https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
She's referring to the fact that I, in private settings, don't have an issue using wrong sex pronouns for some of my personal friends who identify as trans, even though I've never dictated what others should do.
It doesn't matter to people like Danni that I never and would never do so publicly. She and others want to police my speech in private settings. That drives them nuts.
I don't know what she's referring to re "insulting women who have been in this fight longer than he has."
Lots of feminists want to deflect blame for the modern transgender movement on grounds that it did not *originate* within feminism. Genevieve has pointed to psychiatry, sexology, and now, apparently, porn as the root source.
But my claim was never that gender ideology *originated* within feminism, but that it was readily adopted by and mainstreamed through it. Gender ideology wouldn't be the behemoth it is today without Third-Wave Feminism's embrace of intersectionality, inclusivity, and postmodernism. That is just an undeniable fact.
The movement was fertile ground for gender ideology given its acceptance of social constructivism and extreme rejection of the biological basis for many sex differences.
But ultimately I care much less about pointing fingers about who started it than addressing the problem as it exists here and now.
ANNOUNCEMENT: WE’RE SAVING SCIENCE!
We’re often told that science is “self-correcting.”
But that’s not really true.
Science doesn’t correct itself like a thermostat adjusting the temperature in your house. Science is a human institution run by human beings. And human beings are vulnerable to career incentives, groupthink, moral fads, political pressure, and fear.
And when those forces capture academic journals, peer review stops being a filter for bad ideas and starts becoming more of a credentialing system for fashionable nonsense.
This isn’t exactly new.
In 1996, the physicist Alan Sokal managed to publish a totally gibberish article in the journal Social Text full of trendy postmodern jargon. His point was simple: if you flatter the ideological commitments of certain academic editors, nonsense can pass as real scholarship.
Two decades later, @ConceptualJames, @[private account] , and @peterboghossian pulled off the “grievance studies” hoax, placing over a half dozen absurd papers in peer-reviewed journals. One paper used dog parks to analyze rape culture and queer performativity. Another rewrote parts of Mein Kampf in the language of feminist theory.
The problem wasn’t just that fake papers got published. It was that they were completely indistinguishable from the real thing.
And today, the problem is even worse.
We now have serious SCIENCE journals publishing papers about feminist lesbians marrying brine shrimp. We have disturbing papers that aim to “queer” and sexualize infants. We have scholarship on “lesbian-queer-trans-canine relationalities” and “trans-dog intimacies.”
But while Clown World papers are concerning because it makes a complete mockery of academia, the same broken, ideologically captured system is also publishing research in legitimate science and medical journals that pushes sex and gender pseudoscience, relies on deeply flawed data, and influences policies on the medical transition of children and young adults.
That’s not funny. That affects real people. It affects medicine. It affects law. It affects children.
And when critics try to respond, they often discover there’s no serious mechanism for correction. Submitted Letters to the Editor often go completely ignored. Contrary evidence is rejected without comment. As a result, the best critiques are often relegated to personal blog posts, social media threads, or newspaper op-eds, while the original paper remains in the literature wearing the armor of “peer review.”
That is untenable.
So Kevin McCaffree, editor-in-chief of Theory and Society (@[private account]), and I decided to do something about it.
Today, in the Wall Street Journal, we announced a first-of-its-kind article type called “Peer Review.”
The idea is simple: publication should be the beginning of academic scrutiny, not the end of it.
A Peer Review article can critique a paper from any scholarly journal. It can address problems with methods, evidence, logic, definitions, theory, or interpretation. But it has to focus on the claims and arguments, not personal attacks.
Submissions are capped at 2,500 words and go through a straightforward merit review instead of endless gatekeeping and ideological screening. We ask just one basic question: Is this critique coherent, serious, reasonable, or even popular enough to deserve scholarly attention?
If yes, it gets published.
And the authors of the original paper get a built-in right of reply, so readers can see the critique and the response in a legitimate academic venue.
That’s how science is supposed to work.
Science becomes self-correcting only when real people build the mechanisms that allow correction to happen.
That’s what we’ve done.
Now it’s time for academics to use it.
Read our announcement on the @WSJ below.
🔗https://www.wsj.com/opinion/a-way-to-challenge-the-groupthink-of-scholarly-journals-8e59b215
Hasan Piker's subreddit moderators are removing posts that link to my scholarly article "Why There Are Exactly Two Sexes" in threads discussing whether trans people can actually change their sex.
I know the deleted post contained a link to my article because Altmetric had already catalogued it, and the link takes me to the deleted comment.
When you control for same-sex attraction, this observed cross-sex shift in "transgender women" disappears. This sexuality-related shift has been known for decades, but trans activists like to use it to push their "born in the wrong body" agenda.
It's nothing but propaganda.
Quotes a post by T06558; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This new thesis titled "Attitudes Toward Menstruation in Transgender/Nonbinary Menstruators" doesn't know the difference between a hypothesis and a prediction.
Hypotheses are testable and falsifiable explanations for why or how a phenomenon occurs.
Predictions are about the observable and measurable outcome you expect that follows logically from your hypothesis.
Also, given how this "study" was designed, it's impossible to tell whether some males were included in the data on the experiences of menstruation in people who identify as transgender/nonbinary.
Mia Bailey, a schizophrenic trans-identified male, was just sentenced to 50 years in prison for m*rdering his parents because they interfered with his scheduled genital surgery.
We've moved from "Let me transition or I'll kiII myself" to "Let me transition or I'll kiII YOU."
C3 dehumanizingcrime casedenialsuicide tauntviolence terror
A recent “systematic review” claiming transgender women show no meaningful strength differences from women after hormones went viral in progressive circles, but it should never have been published.
It included studies that didn’t even meet its own criteria, and excluded relevant studies that did but contradicted its preferred conclusion. It made sweeping claims based on limited (and flawed) data, and one outlier study drove the headline result.
This did not pass even basic expectations for scientific rigor, and yet it passed peer review in a top journal.
Exercise scientist @[private account] does the rigorous, line-by-line review this paper should have received before publication, breaking down exactly where it went wrong and why the conclusions don’t hold up.
Read the full article below.
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/how-a-flawed-meta-analysis-misled
Harvard Law School instructor and trans activist Alejandra Caraballo is upset that the bogus diagnosis of being "born in the wrong body" has led people to reconsider psychiatric diagnoses more broadly and conclude that lots of it is total BS.
Everybody should read @buttonslives' excellent essay!
🔗https://www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-autistic-i-was-wrong
This new academic paper claims that @jk_rowling has essentially become Voldemort via her “celebrified transphobia,” which is apparently the authors’ term for Rowling publicly acknowledging basic biology.
It argues that the “Wizarding World should be considered a cultural field” whose defining principle is “trans/queer inclusivity,” and says Rowling’s views have “significantly depleted her once-elite status.”
It says Harry Potter has been read as “resisting binary gendering” and presenting gender as “varied, easily shifting, exploratory, and ‘slippery,’” with the Wizarding World offering trans and queer fans “identification and community” and “a ‘place of belonging.’”
So Rowling became the moral equivalent of her own villain because some readers projected gender ideology onto the books, then felt shocked when the author turned out to believe sex is real.
And in case the paper was not absurd enough already, its conclusion declares: “You’re a muggle, Joanne.”
"The Pokémon Company says it will fix a bug in Pokémon Champions that briefly showed Gallade as female — a glitch many fans immediately celebrated as an unexpectedly trans-affirming moment."
This is a forced detransition. A genocide against trans Pokémon.
@[private account] @[private account] I wouldn't back any policies he tried to implement affirming that "trans women are women," but I would back other policies I agreed with him on.
This new academic paper claims that “plática” (an informal chat) is a legitimate “methodology and method” for researching “AfroLatine and Queer Latine college experiences,” contributing to “growing empirical research” and helping build “equitable educational and research systems.”
They use “a critical lens” (not to be confused with critical thinking) on “AfroLatine/a/o activists and queer and trans-Latine students” to show how plática can “center and research Latine experiences” in “transformative ways.”
Translated into plain English: this paper is arguing that listening to activist identity groups describe their experiences through an explicitly ideological framework counts as a research method. It's not exactly what most people mean by “empirical.”
Since I started writing about sex pseudoscience, critics dismiss my arguments because I mainly published in popular news outlets instead of academic journals.
Well, my scholarly article "Why There Are Exactly Two Sexes" published last year is now the most-read academic article on the subject.
Only one scholar has written a formal critique of it, but from a "feminist epistemology" perspective. It was laughably nonsensical. I responded (link below).
I am still waiting for a biologist who thinks I'm wrong to expose and embarrass me with formal, detailed take-down of my arguments.
If I'm nothing more than an anti-trans bigot promoting "junk science," as the SPLC has claimed, publicly demolishing my supposedly crank views should be seen as a public service. And it should also be an easy way to add to your academic résumé.
LINKS (all open access):
-My paper "Why There Are Exactly Two Sexes":https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-025-03348-3
-A critic's "feminist epistemology" response:https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-026-03418-0
-My response to the critique:https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-026-03452-y
🚨NEW: A recent paper claims that an "accurate approach to teaching about the diversity of biological sex" makes "LGBTQIA+" students feel more included and enjoy their course more.
The only problem is that their supposedly "accurate approach" is actually sex pseudoscience.
The author information section also contains a positionality statement stating: "The authors possess c!sgender and transgender identities, include members of the LGBTQIA+ community, and include biology education and disciplinary biology scientists."
All this paper shows is that certain students prefer to be fed pseudoscientific political propaganda they are ideologically aligned with.
This will likely be used to claim that teaching the true, binary understanding of sex rooted in gametes harms LGBTQIA+ students, and should therefore be banned.
The HRC has lied for over a decade about a supposed "epidemic of violence" against the trans community fueled by "white supremacy."
@benshapiro breaks down the findings in @[private account]'s and my latest article in City Journal exposing that lie.
Our investigation found:
- Trans homicide rates are below the that of the general population (debunking the "epidemic" narrative)
- The large majority of suspects are black, not white (debunking the "white supremacy" cause)
- The HRC wrongfully compares homicide rates of black men who identify as women to black women to make homicide rates seem inflated, when in reality black men to identify as women have homicide rates substantially below black men generally.
- And much more (see full report below)!
The HRC publishes their blatant lies in annual "Epdemic of Violence" reports to whip up a moral panic and secure donation money, even though their lies actively harm people who identify as transgender by supporting policies disconnected from reality.
It's not compassionate to lie about the nature of transgender homicides; it's exploitative.
Read our City Journal article here:https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
Read our full report here:https://dont-shoot-the-data.github.io/TCLEAR/
Is “White Supremacy” Causing an “Epidemic” of Transgender Murders?
https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
One way the HRC manufactured the appearance of an "epidemic of v!0lence" against "Black transgender women" was by comparing these MALE victims with black non-transgender women (FEMALES), which makes their h0m!cide rate look unusually high for "women."
With the appropriate biological comparison, the HRC's narrative falls apart.
Using the best available data, the h0m!cide rate per 100,000 per year is about 24 for black males who identify as women, aged 15–34. By comparison, the rate is approximately 8 for black, non-transgender women aged 15–34 and about 73 for young, black, non-transgender men, aged 15–34.
In other words, black "transgender women" are about a third as likely as their non-transgender, same-sex peers to be k!IIed.
@[private account] and I expose all the HRC's lies in our latest @[private account] piece below.
For over a decade, the HRC has published annual reports whipping up a moral panic about an "epidemic of v!0lence" against the trans community fueled by "white supremacy."
This narrative could not be more disconnected from reality.
Using court records, police statements, local news reports, and other public documentation, @[private account] and I independently verified every case from 2015 through 2024.
We found that transgender h0m!cide rates are well below the general population rate (debunking the "epidemic" claim), and that most perpetrators were black, not white (debunking the "white supremacy" claim).
Check out our write-up of our comprehensive new report below.
🔗https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
You can find the full dataset, methodology, and case-level documentation in our T-CLEAR (Transgender Comprehensive Lethal Evidence Analysis Report) report below.
https://dont-shoot-the-data.github.io/TCLEAR/
That narrative has been pushed for over a decade by the Human Rights Campaign (@[private account]) in their annual "Epidemic of Violence" reports, and has been referenced by presidents, medical organizations, journalists, activists, and even used to justify legislation and government programs.
But when we independently verified all 304 transgender homicide cases in HRC’s own comprehensive victim lists from 2015–2024, their narrative completely collapsed.
What we found:
- And among identified suspects, most perpetrators were black, not white.
- Transgender homicide rates are below the general population rate.
- Only 3.3% of cases resulted in confirmed hate-crime determinations.
- The leading identified circumstance was intimate partner violence, not anti-trans bias.
In 2020, when the “white-supremacy-fueled epidemic of violence” narrative was being pushed especially hard, there were ZERO identified white suspects.
We also show how the HRC manufactures their false narrative. In a 2021 report, HRC pointed to the deaths “four Black transgender women” that HRC cited in a report titled “Black LGBTQ People and Compounding Discrimination” as proof that “white supremacy” was driving an “epidemic of violence.”
But the actual facts did not match their narrative.
One case remained unsolved, with no public evidence of anti-trans bias or anything tied to white supremacy.
In the other three cases, every identified suspect was a black man.
By the time HRC published its report, arrests had already been made and these basic facts were public.
In other words, HRC took four cases and spun them into evidence for a political narrative that the known facts did not support.
The truth matters, not just for its own sake, but because false narratives will inevitably produce ineffective solutions. If the deaths of transgender people are the result of a hate-crime epidemic driven by white supremacy and transphobia, then a reasonable response might be more anti-bias campaigns.
But if the main problem is intimate partner violence, then the most-effective interventions would likely include domestic-violence services tailored to trans-identified victims, emergency housing for people trying to flee abusive relationships, and other violence reduction efforts in the places where these killings occur.
Federal government and state governments have already spent hundreds of millions of dollars implementing ineffective policies based on the HRC's lies.
Now that the facts are finally public, ignorance is no longer an excuse. The HRC has a choice: keep repeating a false story that serves progressive ideology, or finally face facts and respond to the problem as it actually exists.
Read about our detailed findings in our new @[private account] article below.
🔗https://www.city-journal.org/article/human-rights-campaign-transgender-murders-white-supremacy
🚨REPORT: Today, on International Transgender Day of Visibility, Vincent Lundgren (@[private account]) and I debunk one of the most widely repeated activist claims: that transgender people are facing an "epidemic" of violence and murder fueled by white supremacy and transphobia.🧵
🚨NEW: This guy got a PhD studying "The Positive Effects of Catholic Exorcism on People Affected by Satanic Influences."
Woke people need to realize that the way they view this "research" is exactly how non-woke people view the "gender-affirming care" literature.
THIS PAPER: "Satan and all the demons exist, and it is urgent to know who they are and what strategies they use to separate humans from God."
WOKE: "Trans kids exist, and it is urgent to know who they are so we can make sure their correct gender identity is affirmed."
THIS PAPER: "How do exorcists perceive the importance of training to distinguish between psychological disorders and legitimate cases of satanic possession that require major exorcisms?"
WOKE: "How do gender clinicians perceive the importance of training to distinguish between psychological disorders and legitimate cases of transgenderism that require gender-affirming hormones and surgeries?"
THIS PAPER: "The findings suggest that exorcist training must encompass broad, in-depth knowledge of demonology and fundamental aspects of psychology. Major and minor exorcisms, along with other spiritual means such as prayer and sacramental life, play a vital role in the deliverance of individuals."
WOKE: "The findings suggest that gender clinician training must encompass broad, in-depth knowledge of gender identity and the fundamental aspects of psychology. Social transition, puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, surgeries, and other affirming interventions play a vital role in the well-being and actualization of gender-diverse individuals."
The bargaining chip idea is the most compelling so far.
"Hey look, we'll remove all the trans stuff. That's like half the bill! Look how reasonable we're being."
Why did Republicans add transgender issues to the SAVE America Act? This seems counterproductive and gives Democrats an easy excuse to not vote for it. Should be a clean bill.
🚨NEW: What happens when a psychotherapist can no longer speak plainly because ideology has stripped him of the authority to do so?
In this powerful essay, @[private account] explains why working with trans-identified teens has become so difficult: schools indoctrinate, the internet reinforces, and any attempt at honest exploration can be branded “transphobic” on the spot.
This is a revealing look at how gender ideology has made honest therapy nearly impossible.
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/why-traditional-psychotherapy-is
Yeah, I've had my opinions on whether humans can change sex dismissed because I am not transgender. Somehow that apparently gives a person special insight to biology.
When I started criticizing sex pseudoscience, the line of attack was:
"Are you a biologist?"
"Yes."
"Do you have a PhD?"
"Yes."
"In what?"
"Evolutionary biology."
"Where did you get your PhD?"
"At UCSB, a top-ranked university for my field."
"Oh, but are you a Christian?"
"No. I'm an atheist."
"But you're MAGA."
"No, I don't support Trump." (true at the time)
"You support JK Rowling so you're a transphobe."
"I'm... not a transph–"
"BIGOT!!"
Essentially, they only bring up your lack of a PhD because it's the quickest thing they can use to disregard your opinion. But if you had a PhD, they'd just move down the list to the next thing they can use to disregard your view. And the next...
When you get to the bottom of their list unscathed, they'll just assume you're a bigot or a grifter. You just hate trans people. Oh you just wanted to sell your book.
There's nothing you can be, do, or say to make them consider you might have a valid opinion.
HARRIS: "[Trans issues are] such a superstimulus for at least half the country that...they will never vote for somebody who is not making sense on that topic."
MAHER: "I don't blame them."
People who claim to believe in sex and gender pseudoscience are either stupid, insane, or lying about their belief to gain power.
No matter which of the 3 it is, the person can't be trusted.
🚨NEW: A paper in a @[private account] journal proposes a new name for the current geological epoch—the "transthropocene"—that combines "environmental pollution and social transphobia...through a concept of phobic discourse."
It continues: "In the transthropocene, transgender people are imagined as a form of pollution at once ontological, theological, and material; as foreign, human-made objects that contaminate natural categories of gender and sexuality, at once caused by and causing toxic pollution in our ecosystems, contagious materially and socially, that need to be hygienically removed from social life and perhaps existence as such."
This headline in the Washington Post makes it seem like trans-identified Kansans aren't allowed to drive, when in reality the law simply requires their sex marker on their ID to be accurate.
The law also requires that people use the bathroom that matches their sex. That's all.
🧵A new woke paper introduces the concept of "temporal dysphoria" and "trans time," which is a distinct relationship to time experienced by transgender people.
Yes, really.
It supposedly manifests in three forms:
• "Missing time"
• "The time loop"
• "Disjuncture of time, place, and progress"
🚨WPATH's "Standards of Care" just got graded, and it failed.
A new peer-reviewed paper by @[private account] et al. used a standard tool for evaluating medical guidelines to appraise key chapters of WPATH’s SOC8 (the world’s most-cited transgender care guideline).
SOC8 is treated like a global standard of care, but this paper shows that the process used to produce it doesn't justify viewing it as authoritative.
I break down this paper in a new article below.
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/wpaths-standards-of-care-dont-meet
Did you know that Gavin Newsom was "dyslexic" before he brought it up last week?
It's obvious what he's doing. He knows that the woke left is going to heavily penalize him for being a straight, white guy. He desperately needed to surface some "oppressed" intersectional identity.
He's going with "disabled" and will start "calling out" his opponents for "abelism" now.
The only other option he had was some "trans" identity like "nonbinary." But he knows he couldn't pull that off, and gender ideology is increasingly cringe and politically unpopular. Although I wouldn't totally write off the possibility of him flirting with this.
His best bet was "disabled." You could tell he was itching to bring it up, as his recent call-out was a serious stretch. The last time he mentioned it on X was 10 years ago.
Expect to see him bring it up more and more during his presidential campaign.
Alejandra Caraballo, a Harvard Law School clinical instructor and trans activist, is unable to make sense of my position regarding Algerian boxer Imane Khelif. So let me clarify.
I don't care how Khelif thinks about himself. I don't care if he maintains or abandons his female identity after taking a chromosome test.
All I care about is that he not compete in the female category, because he is not female. He is male.
That's my entire position, and I've articulated it many times. It really shouldn't be difficult for a Harvard Law School instructor to understand.
🚨NEWS: 38 biologists, doctors, and other experts have penned a letter titled "Biology is not binary" to Bridget Phillipson, the UK's Minister for Women and Equalities, urging her to "take action to restore the rights of trans & non-binary individuals to access public spaces."
This is in response to a UK Supreme Court ruling that the term "woman" refers to a human of the female sex, and that access to single-sex spaces must be based on "biological sex" instead of a person's subjective "gender identity."
The letter (LEFT) claims that "biological sex" is not a scientific term but a political one. It also peddles sex pseudoscience, falsely stating that an individual's "sex" is "made up of a collection of characteristics, including external genitalia, secondary sex characteristics, gonads, chromosomes, and hormones," and should be considered "bimodal" instead of binary.
This claim is not only incorrect but incoherent, as I explain in detail in a recent Commentary for the Archives of Sexual Behavior (RIGHT).
Of the letter's 38 signatories, 23 (~60%) included their pronouns, and 5 (~13%) used "nonbinary" pronouns.
Links to sources below.
🚨TRANS SPORTS: A new poll reveals that 25% of American voters oppose/somewhat oppose "a national law that would require transgender athletes in K-12 to compete" according to their biological sex.
In 2018, half (50%) of Americans supported boys competing in girls' sports.
The Pawtucket sh—ter, Robert (aka "Roberta") Dorgan, is not a left-wing gender ideologue.
He:
- Claimed to be "far Right"
- Opposed men in women's sports
- Opposed transitioning children
- Believed a "sex change" surgery should grant him access to women's private spaces
- Warned that criticizing trans people would cause some (him?) to go "BERZERK"
This is a truly bizarre and disturbed individual who, despite being politically on the right, seemingly felt that not accepting him and other trans-identified men as women justified a murd*rous rampage.
There may be another motive that will emerge, but his X posts yesterday suggest that he may have been motivated by what he perceived as anti-trans sentiment.
Robert (aka "Roberta") Dorgan, the Pawtucket "transgender" sh—ter, believed that having sex reassignment surgery entitled him to use women's private spaces.
The Pawtucket "trans" sh**ter, Robert (aka "Roberta") Dorgan posted on X less than a month ago:
"violence is not the answer... It's the solution come up"
This is absolutely wild. The hockey game mass sh**ter in Pawtucket, RI, who sh*t 5 people, kiIIing 2, is a "trans woman" named Robert (aka "Roberta") Dorgan.
Just yesterday he posted twice on X hinting that he might "go fkn BERSERK."
🚨NEW: A new study found that only 2.5% of adolescents and young adults who identify as transgender completed fertility preservation before medical transition.
Out of 311 patients, just 8 preserved fertility—all of them male.
This is despite the fact that many reported wanting children in the future and that having biological children is important to them.
Many also said they'd "reassess" their desire to preserve their fertility later into their transition, even though that option may not exist later due to the nature of the treatments.
I break down what the study believes to be the reason for the low rates and sex disparity in fertility preservation, how it fits with previous research, and what it reveals about the state of pediatric "gender-affirming care."
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/when-affirmation-means-sterilization
"The other side does the mean, angry, exclusive, us/them, divisive politics. That's their home court. Our court is coming together."
All right, try publicly uttering the simple truth that "trans women" are men and see if you're whistling the same tune.
https://x.com/TheChiefNerd/status/2022787149465088267/video/1
Why Recreational Fitness Data on Trans Athletes Can’t Set Elite Sports Policy | @[private account]
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/why-recreational-fitness-data-on
Major scientific and media outlets have been using a recent BJSM paper to falsely assert that “transgender women” have no advantage over biological women in sports.
But what does the study ACTUALLY say? A new article in @[private account] by @[private account] breaks it down.
If it's discovered that the transgender Tumbler Ridge sh—ter left a manifesto, can we please just make it public immediately instead of covering it up for a year until it's ultimately leaked?
The public deserves to understand the ideology motivating these attacks.
C2 false claimshand-codedcoverupshooter attributionviolence terror
The rise in violent extremists who identify as transgender is not a figment of your imagination or a result of confirmation bias. It's a real problem that must be addressed.
The left has fed vulnerable and mentally unwell youth a constant stream of su*cide narratives as well as apocalyptic and even genocidal rhetoric for years. It's no surprise some take these narratives seriously and resort to violence.
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/gender-nihilism-and-the-revolutionary
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnesspolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
Yesterday’s horrific school sh*oting in Tumbler Ridge is a grim reminder of something we’re not allowed to talk about honestly: the rise in transgender-linked extremist violence and the conditions that can fuel it.
In this must-read essay for @[private account], psychologist @[private account] examines the pattern and offers a framework: identity instability + nihilism + apocalyptic “victimhood” narratives + revolutionary moral certainty can, in a small subset of alienated young people, erode restraints and make violence feel justified.
This piece was published a day before the Tumbler Ridge attack. This is a problem we can't shy away from.
Gender Nihilism and the Revolutionary Impulse:
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/gender-nihilism-and-the-revolutionary
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionspeech persecutionviolence terror
🚨NEW: A new paper by exercise scientist @[private account] demonstrates a male advantage in running performance among under-8, under-9, and under-10 athletes in 70 m, 100 m, 200 m, and 400 m races.
"Between-sex performance differences were more than twice as large as the variability within sex among comparably placed finishers."
It simply isn't true that all sex differences in athletic performance arise during puberty. Trans-identified males who blocked their puberty still have a biological advantage over females, and should not be permitted to compete in the female category.
🔗https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2772696726000025
🚨NEW: Major scientific and media outlets have been using a recent @[private account] analysis to assert that “transgender women” have no advantage over biological women in sports.
This is HIGHLY misleading, and it’s being used to justify elite sports policy the data cannot support.
The BJSM study measures recreational fitness in amateur populations, not elite athletic performance under extreme training.
Overlap in average fitness does not predict outcomes at the performance ceiling, where outcomes in elite sport is actually decided.
For @[private account], ports scientist @[private account] breaks down why using this paper to justify competitive sports policy is scientifically unjustified.
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/why-recreational-fitness-data-on
The only difference between Imane Khelif and a "trans woman" is that doctors made a clerical error when Khelif was born by recording his sex as "female." He therefore he never made a conscious decision to identify as trans.
But he is still, like a "trans woman," a man who claims or believes himself to be a woman.
The media is using gender ideology to obscure that fact, referring to him as "c*sgender woman" because he identifies as the sex he was "assigned at birth."
This post really demonstrates how woke language is designed to obscure reality, because it's actually "true" within the ideological framework of gender ideology.
This is because "c*sgender" is defined as a person who identifies with the sex they were "assigned at birth," and Khelif was "assigned" female at birth and identifies with that label. Therefore, Khelif is a "c*sgender woman."
This language obscures reality because it fails to account for the fact that a person's sex can be recorded INCORRECTLY at birth due to the presence of a DSD.
So the only reason Khelif is not considered a trans woman—despite being a male who identifies as a woman—is because of a clerical error.
And every major left-wing news outlet is using that clerical error to hide biological reality from their readers.
Quoting @NYMag: Boxer Imane Khelif is a cisgender woman. So why are famed transphobes like J.K. Rowling, J.D. Vance, and Donald Trump attacking her for competing at the Olympics? https://trib.al/tOtOe67
There's a trick activist researchers do when comparing physical differences between women and "trans women" (i.e., men who identify as women) for the sake of sports where they try to hide important physical sex differences by using relative measurements.
For instance, this new BMJ meta analysis acknowledges that transgender women have "higher absolute lean mass compared with c!sgender women," but concludes this isn't really an advantage because they found no significant differences in "relative" lean mass.
In other words, when they control for the fact that the "transgender women" were all much taller and heavier than the female athletes, the sex difference disappears! But, uhh, being a lot taller and heavier is itself a major advantage in many sports!
There are many other things wrong with this study, but I just wanted to highlight this common sleight of hand.
If they start arguing that everyone should get all their desired cosmetic surgeries, procedures, and HRT covered by health insurance, that will be the end.
Insurance companies are not going to foot the bill for every woman who wants lip filler, breast augmentation, or a BBL. And they're not going to cover men getting hair plugs or wanting steroids to get jacked. At least, not without health insurance costs skyrocketing.
This attempt to call every cosmetic procedure "gender-affirming care" is an attempt to normalize transgender procedures as common and equivalent procedures we all accept as normal. But they're not.
Activists always insisted that trans-identified male athletes could be ignored due to their rarity, but it seems the best time to actually implement policies to preserve fairness is BEFORE the problem becomes widespread. If something isn't fair, it should be banned, regardless of its prevalence.
It is true that trans-identified male athletes are a small minority of those competing in girls’ and women’s sports. But their numbers have risen dramatically, and when men or boys do compete in events against women or girls, they finish 🥇, 🥈, or 🥉 HALF the time.
Men who “identify” as women remain eligible for the male category, and women who “identify” as men may compete in women’s sports, subject to antidoping rules. Eligibility is based on sex, not subjective beliefs about identity.
https://www.wsj.com/opinion/the-transgender-sports-deception-33b7547f
🚨In my new essay for the @WSJ, I call out the media’s distortion of the Supreme Court’s women’s sports cases. Despite their efforts to mislead, Americans have never been more clear-eyed on the topic.
This isn’t about “banning trans athletes.” It’s about sex-based categories.
The woke Left falsely claims that "trans" youth are so suicidal that they present parents with the a false binary of having a living "trans" child or a dead non-trans child.
Yet they also somehow hold that parents should not be informed when their kid identifies as trans.
The Left cannot appeal to common sense on trans issues, so they instead rely on keeping their voters in a perpetual state of terror, warning of an imminent "genocide" fueled by Nazi ideology.
These people are sick.
This trial cannot be allowed to proceed. The medical justification for administering puberty blockers to trans-identified youth rests on the pseudoscientific premise that some people are born with a "brain sex" that does not match their physical sex.
🔗https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/751839
🚨A new peer-reviewed paper in the @[private account]'s American Journal of Orthopsychiatry refuses to acknowledge sex differences in athletic performance.
It claims that "sex and gender" are "social constructs," and rejects "testosterone's role in superior male performance."
It further claims that "laws and policies preventing transgender athletes from competing in sports in the gender category matching their gender identity contribute to significant physical and mental health disparities in this highly marginalized population."
It doesn't seem to care about or even consider the physical safety or mental health of the women and girls who are forced to compete against male athletes.
It's amazing how papers so detached from reality manage to still get published in ostensibly scientific journals.
🚨A new paper in a top feminist journal purports to debunk the right-wing “litterbox lie”—a false rumor claiming that schools were placing litter boxes in schools for kids who identify as cats.
Yet even when responding to a genuinely false right-wing narrative, the author cannot manage even a semblance of academic seriousness.
The paper is riddled with “cheeky” cat puns such as “CATegories,” “clawback,” and “catty,” and declares that it will respond through “radical ridicule of the queered cat creative kind,” engaging in “semiotic guerrilla warfare” to “enabl[e] trans-cat alternatives” to “online anti-trans disinformation and hate.”
While debunking one right-wing moral panic, the author fully demonstrates why the right-wing assault on academia is fully justified.
The New York Review of Books (@[private account]) recently published an article by trans-identified female and Gender Studies professor Paisley Currah criticizing @HHSGov's definitions of "sex," "male," and "female."
She claims that "Biomedical researchers have come to recognize that sex is not a single thing but an umbrella term for a number of things, including sex chromosomes, internal reproductive structures (prostate, uterus), gonads (testes, ovaries), and external genitalia."
She also implies that a person's sex literally changes over time because "elements of sex" like "facial hair and breasts" and "hormone levels" can "vary over the course of a life."
Currah's description of sex falls into the 4th pseudoscientific model of sex—the "Polythetic Model"—I described in my latest article in @[private account].
As I point out in my article, the polythetic model is logically self-refuting:
"Traits are labeled 'male-typical' or 'female-typical' because they correlate with males and females already identified independently—ultimately by reference to gametes. In other words, the model presupposes the binary categories rooted in gametes it seeks to replace and then infers those categories back from their correlates."
We see Currah doing this exact thing in her essay when she says, "For most people, these characteristics generally align in a single direction, male or female."
But how do we assign individual traits a male or female "direction" unless we have some universal trait they are correlated with independent of the trait in question? For instance, how do we know that having a Y chromosome or a prostate gland are in the male "direction" unless we already know what males are independent of Y chromosomes and prostate glands?
Her argument against the binary nature of sex rooted in the type of gamete an organism has the biological function to produce actually presupposes the reality of the sex binary. It's unavoidable.
Read my full article below:
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/why-there-are-exactly-two-sexes