The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
đ¨The 1st match-up for the Worst Peer-Reviewed Paper is:
A: Queer canine becomings: Lesbian feminist cyborg
politics and interspecies intimacies in ecologies of love
and violence
B: A (m)Otherâs Work Is Becoming Undone: Liminal Belonging and Trans Potentialities
Vote below âŹď¸
My recent @WSJ essay on the new evidence backing the transgender social contagion hypothesis is now available to read for free on my website, @[private account].
Manyâincluding myselfâwere cancelled for stating this obvious truth years ago.
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/evidence-backs-the-transgender-social
The Australian Academy of the Humanities hosted a symposium on academic freedom. But instead of real debate, the event was full of virtue signalling, vague talk, and speakers who dodged the actual issues.
Philosopher Holly Lawford-Smith (@[private account]) attended the symposium, and describes how it avoided the most important topics (trans) and naming the most serious threats to academic freedom that come from inside universities themselves.
It's a revealing and darkly funny essay!
đhttps://www.realityslaststand.com/p/i-attended-an-academic-freedom-symposium
Hmm, I'm not so sure about this. I was a Democrat and the moment I started pushing back against some of their more extreme positions on trans issues I was immediately slandered and excommunicated.
They lost in 2024 because they couldn't tolerate anti-woke, left-leaning centrists.
Well, this is in a high impact journal. And we have seen so much behavior from gender activists on trans issues and "gender medicine" that mirrors what this paper outlines, though it's unlikely those involved would publicly admit any particular action they take is "data activism."
For instance, many UK gender clinics refused to share data with Hilary Cass for her review. Was this "data activism"? Johanna Olson-Kennedy revealed that she held off publishing the results of her review on puberty blockers because she feared it would be politically "weaponized." Was that data activism? Seems like it fits the description.
This paper shows that a lot of this behavior is consciously manipulative and they feel no moral duty to just get accurate data out there.
According to this paper, if you had been trans, the people who scoffed at you in disbelief would have been guilty of committing "testimonial injustice" against you.
Stop making excuses for this academic nonsense. The authors literally claimed that trans people have special insight on matters of truth and not automatically believing the things they say is "testimonial injustice."
Quotes a post by T02111; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
đ¨NEW: Be aware that when trans activists talk about "transforming" data and performing a "power analysis," they aren't talking about the standard meaning of these terms in statistics.
They're talking about committing data fraud and postmodern views on social dynamics.
The authors of this new paper on âtrans data epistemologiesâ openly advocate committing research misconduct if it advances their ideological/political goals related to transgenderism.
This is done under the banner of "data activism."
Read my latest âŹď¸
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/data-activism-and-the-death-of-truth
The authors say that not believing what a trans person says is a form of harm and "testimonial injustice."
They advocate for using data "rhetorically" rather than empirically to produce the appearance of evidence in service of pre-decided conclusions.
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/data-activism-and-the-death-of-truth
đ¨BREAKING: A new paper in a top social science journal promotes "data activism" and claims that politically "actionable and useful" data should take "utmost priority over true, accurate, or verifiable data" on trans issues.
It also asserts that trans people have a spacial "way of knowing" superior to "mainstream Western epistemological inquiries" (i.e., the scientific method), which have "historically favored the perspectives of the dominant groupâwhite, c!sgender, heterosexual men."
The authors are blatantly advocating for research misconduct by treating "data" not as a way to discover truth, but as a political weapon to manipulate public perception.
Read my detailed write-up at the link below.
đhttps://www.realityslaststand.com/p/data-activism-and-the-death-of-truth
Thrilled to see @joerogan and @elonmusk discuss my new essay on the social contagion aspect of trans identities on the podcast.
Elon's right: "If you can train kids to become suicide bombers, you can convince them of anything... The minds of the youth are easily corrupted."
Doctors and scientists need to stop lying to our children about the nature of their condition. No, you don't have a male brain in a female body (or vice versa) that needs to be "fixed" with hormones and surgeries. No, you cannot actually change your sex. And no, the choice isn't between transition or suicide.
It's been a while since we talked, Joe! A LOT has happened since. We should schedule a Round 2. đď¸
Link to WSJ essay below.
đhttps://www.wsj.com/opinion/evidence-backs-the-transgender-social-contagion-hypothesis-40937876
I mentioned it and then also cited the subsequent report by SEGM indicating that trans identities have not dipped and are at an all-time high. Read my essay. It's actually nuanced.
Was the more than 20-fold rise in trans identities since 2010 the result of people finally feeling free to express their authentic selves? Or was it a social contagion?
Five years ago, I and others were canceled for suggesting the latter. New evidence shows we were right.
Read my latest for the Wall Street Journal âŹď¸
đhttps://www.wsj.com/opinion/evidence-backs-the-transgender-social-contagion-hypothesis-40937876?mod=commentary_article_pos1
What is an example of a right trans people don't have, but want, that doesn't involve abolishing and replacing legal protections based on objective biology (sex) with a person's subjective sense of self (gender identity)?
I've never heard a coherent answer to this question.
Democrats have dug themselves in a deep hole on trans issues and are being held hostage by their woke voter base.
All this signals to most Americans is that you're either spineless or insane, and you should not be trusted holding any position of power.
âMost trans women, myself included, would rather quit their sport than to compete in [an open category that's 99% male].â
Every decision you make comes with trade-offs. If youâre male, you need to understand that transitioning means you will no longer be competitive in your sport against other males. If staying competitive is extremely important to you, you can choose not to transition.
Welcome to reality.
đ¨NEW: A peer-reviewed paper in an education journal argues that rural drag shows are powerful and important educational tools that should be implemented to destroy the traditional (i.e., "Queerphobic") norms and values of rural communities.
The authors frame their study around "the rise of Queerphobic policies and rhetoric, including drag bans and attacks on transgender youth," which they say "uniquely impacts rural communities" due to the prevalence of "conservative anti-Queer politics." They believe traditional communities are a problem to be "disrupted," and drag performances are the solution.
With "theoretical understandings from drag pedagogy" and something they call "a pedagogy of pride" underpinning the study, the researchers attended drag performances in rural southwest Virginia and took notes. This ethnographic work, they claim, reveals that drag shows have profound educational value.
The authors conclude that rural drag "serves as an educational tool; provides a source of confidence and resilience; builds community and kinship centering safety and joy; [and acts] as disruptor monoliths of rurality."
In other words, drag is presented here as a necessary form of teaching, a tool for social engineering, and a vehicle for dismantling the traditional norms of rural communities.
Nancy Armourâs USA Today column claims the IOCâs scientific panel on transgender athletes is illegitimate because it excluded authors of a 2024 IOC-funded study. But that's because the study has been widely debunked for methodological failures.
Dr. Gregory Brown (@[private account]) explains how the authors of the study used statistical sleight of hand to make it seem like trans-identified males performed the same as female athletes. But they didn't.
The paper compared 23 unfit males on testosterone suppression to 21 very fit females, then "adjusted" the results to hide obvious male advantages.
Brown: âThe female category is designed for females, not as a fallback option for mediocre males. Womenâs sport deserves truth, not ideology.â
Read the full essay below.
đhttps://www.realityslaststand.com/p/nancy-armour-ignores-the-simple-truth
Rebecca Tuvel was crucified by the left for suggesting transracialism made as much sense as transgenderism. Now woke scholars push transpeciesismâmen identifying as dogsâas a legitimate trans identity, and the same people just nod along.
Quoting @SwipeWright: đ¨You won't believe this one. A new a peer-reviewed paper in a journal from publishing giant Taylor & Francis is titled "What Puppygirls Know? The (in)Human Pedagogy of a Trans Feminine Style."
The author describes "puppygirls" as "trans lesbians that are also dogs. Not literally, of course â but also not entirely figuratively."
The paper argues that centering humans in transgender identities is "ciscentric." As the author puts it:
"I argue for the possibility of reading the puppygirl style as a critical practice: one that hints at ways of being trans that do not rely on the ciscentric understanding of 'the human' as their point of reference."
In other words, the paper suggests expanding the idea of "trans" beyond crossing sex boundaries to include crossing species boundaries. You aren't only the sex you weren't "assigned at birth"âyou might also be the species you weren't assigned.
It gets darker:
"A puppygirl may not even know she is a puppy, and needs to have this status imposed through loving, but forceful means."
"A puppygirl is a good girl. She does not necessarily have a say in whether she is good⌠the reward for this loss of self-determination is the unconditional, effusive affirmation of her desire."
The paper is by Jay Szpilka, a lesbian trans woman (i.e., a straight man) who also identifies as a puppygirl.
Read my more in-depth breakdown of the article.
đ°https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/puppygirls-and-the-collapse-of-academia
Or watch/listen to @[private account] and I discuss it on the Citation Needed podcast.
đď¸https://www.citationneededpodcast.com/p/what-puppygirls-know-and-we-wish
For the record, I don't and have never believed in "tru-trans," if by that she means that being "transgender" is an innate trait or that people can be born in the wrong body. Lots of people like to spread this lie about me for some reason.
Groups like Media Matters publish defamatory hit pieces, saturated with extreme rhetoric designed to inflame violent actors.
MM currently has 2 articles that label me "anti-trans" and suggest that I'm campaigning to deny mental-health care to suicidal children.
These are dangerous lies.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: "You've been training your whole life for this, guys."
The Antifa subreddit on @[private account] has made a post saying why Charlie Kirk and those like him deserve to be killed. To smear him, they reference a Media Matters @[private account] hit piece and tell their comrades to arm themselves with weapons.
The post echoes the Antifa belief that if you speak with a "Nazi," you are also one and should be subject to death.
Left-wing media, along with our ideologically captured medical and educational institutions, have radicalized vulnerable young people by promoting falsehoods and stoking apocalyptic fears about trans issues.
What theyâve done is absolutely vile.
Quoting @WSJ: Breaking: Ammunition engraved with transgender and antifascist ideology was found inside the rifle authorities believe was used in Kirkâs shooting, sources say https://on.wsj.com/42jMYDq
Popular transgender "journalist" @ErinInTheMorn has repeatedly spread lies about Charlie Kirk, saying that he "calls for anti-trans violence." Yet when you watch the actual interview, he says no such thing.
Spreading this kind of genocidal rhetoric is dangerous.
It's good that more prominent figures are speaking up against the trans madness. But don't mistake this for a sudden show of courage. Fear still governs their lives.
Fear of social reprisal dictated their decisions before, and it dictates them now. The line between the principled and the spineless was drawn years ago.
Quoting @DouglasKMurray: Malcolm Gladwell admits he lied about trans athletes because telling the truth destroyed careers. âŚ@nypost⊠https://nypost.com/2025/09/04/opinion/malcolm-gladwell-admits-he-lied-about-trans-athletes-because-telling-the-truth-destroyed-careers/
This is exactly what the gender activists do. We cite myriad systematic reviews demonstrating the low quality of evidence for the benefits of "gender-affirming care," and they point to some random internet survey on trans-identified Tumblr users as a counterpoint. đľâđŤ
This correction was inevitable. Reality, in the end, reasserts itself. But the mainstream press hasnât budged. Instead, they continue to misinform their readers, deploying headlines designed to obscure plain facts.
Consider a representative sample of mainstream media headlines. The New York Times claimed that Penn had agreed âto Limit Participation of Transgender Athletes.â The Washington Post reported that the school would âbar transgender athletes from womenâs sports teams.â NBC News, USA Today, and BBC all referred to âban[s]â on âtrans athletes.â
These headlines arenât just misleading; theyâre false. Lia Thomas wasnât barred from female sports for being âtransgenderâ; he was barred for being a male. Any other male, whether he identified as transgender or not, would be barred for the same reason. Trans-identifying males remain fully eligible to compete in UPenn athleticsâon the menâs team.
Read my latest on this major win for reality in @[private account].
đhttps://www.city-journal.org/article/university-of-pennsylvania-lia-thomas-swim-records-trump?utm_source=Twitter&utm_medium=Organic_Social
Obfuscatory language got us into this mess, and clarity will get us out.
Let's start with framing this issue correctly.
State laws are not "barring trans athletes in girls' and women's sports."
They're barring BOYS and MEN in girls' and women's sports.
The gay rights movement worked because it asked people to accept a simple truth: gay people were already their neighbors, coworkers, family. It relied on normalization through familiarity.
But other movements couldnât replicate this. Their populations were too small for most people to know someone personallyâso activists/advocates simply expanded definitions to make these groups or conditions appear more common.
The result is a form of concept creep where everything is considered âtrauma,â âautismâ is everywhere, âintersexâ is apparently as common as red hair, and kids are labeled âtransâ for not conforming to stereotypes.
In addition to inflating stats, this definitional expansion confuses the public, diverts resources, and harms the very people it was meant to help.
My new essay explains why real progress requires facing reality, not redefining it.
đhttps://www.realityslaststand.com/p/the-casualties-of-concept-creep
I mean, even if you accept that some kids are trans (which I do not), you're still faced with the impossible task of distinguishing between which kids are really trans and which kids are not. But even using the most stringent methods designed to filter out false positives, you're still going to be altering and sterilizing a lot of kids who would have grown out of it.
I don't see how it is an extreme view to say "Don't do this to kids, but adults can pursue these procedures if they desire." This is hardly a "mirror" image of trans extremism.
And which systematic reviews are you referring to regarding adults?
Even if that were true, it is impossible to distinguish between the kids who would grow up and maintain their transgender identities and those who would have naturally desisted. Right now, we know that most desist if left alone. So the question becomes how many kids is it acceptable to wrongfully and permanently transition to help the few who might benefit?
đ¨New research raises serious concerns about estrogen use in trans-identifying malesâespecially teens.
A new paper in Discover Mental Health compiles mounting evidence that long-term estrogen therapy in males is linked to infertility, cardiovascular disease, cognitive decline, early death, autoimmune disorders, brain atrophy, and elevated cancer risk.
These patterns are now visible at the population level. With thousands of teens already on cross-sex hormones, the medical communityâs failure to conduct proper safety research is indefensible.
I break down this new study and its relevance for policy and ongoing debates on "gender-affirming care" in my latest for @[private account].
Read the full piece here:https://www.city-journal.org/article/cross-sex-hormones-estrogen-transgender-affirming-care-health-risks
Claiming that "trans kids" will likely commit suicide if they're not allowed access to puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries isn't just wrongâit's dangerous.
@[private account] and I debunk the trans suicide myth on our latest podcast episode.
đhttps://www.citationneededpodcast.com/p/justice-sotomayors-emotional-dissent
The dissenting opinion was heavily influenced by the suicide myth, which is why we focused on that specific claim. We do touch on the fact that youth who identify as trans have a host of comorbid mental health issues, though these by and large precede dysphoria and trans identification. And the rare suicide that does occur is very difficult to link to non-affirmation.
Justice Sotomayor's dissenting opinion was heavily influenced by the trans "suicide myth"âthe claim that "trans kids" will kill themselves if they're not allowed to medically transition.
This simplistic narrative isn't just false, it's dangerous!
đhttps://www.citationneededpodcast.com/p/justice-sotomayors-emotional-dissent
"Trans men" don't tend to have difficulty passing as men in society even if they went through normal female puberty. So if the point of blocking puberty is to successfully pass as the opposite sex as an adult, this logic totally collapses for FtMs. Yet girls make up the large majority of minors given these treatments. Makes no sense.
It's not 2015 anymore. It's not 2020. It's 2025, yet media outlets like the USA Today are still parroting the absurd pseudoscientific claim that trans-identifying males don't have an advantage over female athletes.
Subscribe for the full episode!
đhttps://www.citationneededpodcast.com/p/a-new-paper-titled-my-pronouns-are
đ¨BREAKING: SCOTUS has issued a 6-3 ruling in United States v. Skrmetti, upholding Tennessee's Senate Bill 1, which bans "gender-affirming" medical care, such as puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries for minors.
The Court held that the law does not violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The majority concluded that SB1 does not discriminate based on sex or transgender status, thus requiring only rational basis review, the lowest level of judicial scrutiny, which the law satisfied.
Tennessee's ban is therefore allowed to remain in effect, which could impact similar laws in 25 other states.
The three leftist justices (Sotomayor, Jackson, and Kagan) dissented, arguing the law targets transgender minors and constitutes unconstitutional discrimination.
đhttps://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/24pdf/23-477_2cp3.pdf
Partly correct. But the genuine "support" eroded when people became increasingly aware that the transgender movement was denying basic biology and promoting "sex reassignment" surgery for children based on ideological pseudoscience.
đ¨A peer-reviewed paper in a real journal titled âMy pronouns are fuck ICEâ argues that universities are colonial, racist, transphobic sites of oppression, and calls for their transformation through âde-stress tea,â âorganizational gossip,â and revolutionary âqueer plĂĄticas.â
One such plĂĄtica, treated as scholarly data, involves:
⢠Glo, a "trans nonbinary Afro-Caribeùx and Mexican sophomore";
⢠Toni, an "Indigenous Nahua Cipotx with Salvadoran and Nicaraguan Miskito roots"; and
⢠Mars, a "non-binary Zapotec prietx-alien-femme."
Their dialogue includes:
⢠âWhite people love killing folks.â
⢠âMy pronouns are fuck ICE, and my childhood dysphoria is crossing the damn border.â
⢠âI love my dick, and I am a woman, so what?â
⢠âCan I get my diploma and some titties?â
⢠âTitties and citizenship. Donât forget we need both.â
@[private account] and I break down this absurd paper on our latest episode of the Citation Needed podcast (link below)!
đhttps://www.citationneededpodcast.com/p/a-new-paper-titled-my-pronouns-are
Over 350 academics and clinicians signed an Open Letter titled âBiology is not binaryâ objecting to recent legal and policy developments in the U.K. that reassert the biological basis of sex in law.
The letter frames these developments as a threat to people who identify as transgender or non-binary. But in doing so, the signatories advance an anti-scientific ideology at odds with reality.
The letter was signed by some of the most influential proponents of sex denialismâthe belief that âmaleâ and âfemaleâ are socially constructed concepts rather than objective biological classifications. Among them were Sari van Anders, Canada 150 Research Chair at Queenâs University; SimĂłn(e) Sun, a postdoctoral fellow at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory; and Anne Fausto-Sterling, an emerita professor at Brown University best known for claiming that humans come in âfive sexes.â
These are not fringe figuresâthey are credentialed authorities, denying one of biologyâs most fundamental truths.
Read my full article in @[private account] below!
đhttps://www.city-journal.org/article/uk-supreme-court-biological-sex-gender-open-letter?utm_source=Twitter&utm_medium=Organic_Social
Yup. I've known the people I've been talking about for many years. They were very close friends. One lived with me as a roommate for several years. We could always have deep conversations on difficult topics, because we genuinely knew each other's motives were pure. Then I disagree about trans issues and suddenly I must have been a closeted Nazi the whole time.
Nobody is telling "trans kids" they can't play sports. They're just being required to follow the same rules as everybody else and compete in the category that aligns with their sex. This is not difficult.
Being the center of mob outrage is one of the most mentally taxing things a person can experience. It can cause deep misery. It seems like discouraging trans-identified males from competing in female sports would be the best advice to give them from a mental health standpoint.
The left canât keep citing âmental health benefitsâ to justify allowing trans-identified males to compete in female sports when they know the public overwhelmingly opposes it and will respond to these individuals with intense and often vitriolic outrage when the news breaks.
I've been pretty clear about my pronoun policy. Personally, for my trans-identified friends who reject gender ideology, I will use their preferred pronouns in private settings. But in many public contexts, especially when specifically dealing with the issue of males identifying as women and infringing on their sex-based rights and physical safety, like in this situation with Imane Khelif, using wrong sex pronouns contributes to obscuring reality.
A large swath of the public is already profoundly confused about Khelif's sex. That confusion is creating real-world harm. He's literally being allowed to punch women in the face at the Olympics. Accurate pronoun use here is more than justified to help break the spell that many are under thanks to left-wing media spreading lies and pseudoscience.
I think paying attention to context regarding pronoun use is totally reasonable.
I read a lot of woke abstracts on the intersection of queerness and essentially every aspect of society. Almost all of these papers and dissertations now cite use "recent anti-trans/queer legislation across the United States" as a justification for their projects.
"I's a trans woman / and I'm pregnant."
"To be pregnant as a trans woman is to perform these routine tasks that help her gestate the needed sperm."
đ¤Ą
Quoting @SwipeWright: As evidence, the author provides a case study of a man who identifies as a woman who had to go off estrogen to produce enough sperm to then store in a sperm bank.
Because this process involved a hormonal shift, wearing baggy clothes (underwear), and taking vitamins, and because pregnant women ALSO undergo hormonal shifts, wear baggy clothes, and take vitamins... he concludes "I'm pregnant."
The author says: "To be pregnant as a trans woman is to perform these routine tasks that help her gestate the needed sperm."
The paper concludes that the case studies presented demonstrate that "trans reproduction involves an inclusive and existential experience of giving life that goes beyond biological reductionism."
According to the author, "This will benefit all pregnant people, those who can become pregnant, those who desire and dream about pregnancy, and those who care about pregnancy."
Do you agree?
The next case study presented to argue that men can get pregnant is a trans-identified male in 1969 who paid a woman to have his child and then claimed to have "gestated and birthed" the child himself.
The authors description of events flips between affirming his pregnancy and admitting that "While Hall did not actually gestate a child herself, she rehearsed the motions of pregnancy."
The author ultimately concluded that "Hall used genre norms to achieve her reproductive desires and gain legitimacy as a woman capable of gestating, despite the challenges."
Okay, now onto the arguments.
The first argument supporting the view that males can get pregnant is that there are some similarities between pregnancy and transitioning.
You see, because "pregnancy and transition both involve a subversion of hormones, radical changes to the body, and a new self" and "are both processes of becoming," then it follows that trans women can therefore get pregnant.
What the f*ck?
Recent @triggerpod guest Deborah Frances-White downplayed the widespread irresponsibility of people on the left calling people "Nazis" for opposing trans extremism as just "some young people" on the internet.
But last month, CA Rep. Rick Chavez Zbur, compared people defending women's sports to Nazis.
This isn't coming from random internet trolls. It's their standard tactic.
Watch the full segment on @[private account] below.
https://www.ntd.com/tracking-moves-on-dei-transgender-issues-in-trumps-first-100-days-in-office_1063641.html
I try to only post the truly insane woke papers I come across. I skip over a many papers because, even though theyâre examples of abhorrent scholarship, theyâre just SO boring.
Hereâs a typical one: "This qualitative study investigated the impact of participation in drag on shaping resilience, gender identity, and advocacy among cisgender and transgender performers."
Tons of woke slop like this gets published every week. It all fades into background noise for me until something eye-popping like the "Loving the Brine Shrimp" or "Queering Babies" papers breaks through.
A very important new essay by @buttonslives.
"Ultimately, transgender identification is an individual choice made in response to gender-related distressânot the result of a hardwired biological condition."
https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
We have a piece about these studies. Larger project is in the works exposing the flawed research.
https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
Parents of kids with ROGD are attacked by trans activists. Parents of kids with severe autism are spoken over by neurodiversity activists. Now parents seeking residential care for their kids with major emotional & behavioral needs are being condemned by anti-treatment activists.
Quoting @buttonslives: Over the past five years, sensational stories about the âtroubled teen industryâ have taken holdâdriven by the accounts of anti-treatment activists led by @[private account].
Aside from rare cases of actual abuse, most stories from self-described âsurvivorsâ are filtered through a trauma lensârecasting standard or necessary interventions as abuse.
Mainstream media has fueled public fear with exposĂŠs, documentaries, and soon a dramatized @netflix series starring Toni Collette that âexplores the insidious underbelly of the 'troubled teen industry.'â
Left out are the realities faced by families with children who have severe emotional and behavioral needs. Activist-driven messaging is deterring parents from seeking residential care and shaping policies that restrict accessâleaving fewer options for those with nowhere else to turn.
I wrote my first report for @ManhattanInst addressing the five most common allegations against residential treatmentâand five solutions for improving the sector.
Just to make sure I understand what you're somewhat peeved at, you want everyone to publicly mention your name every time the name "Rothblatt" is brought up in the context of trans madness?
I don't believe that we were "act[ing] like he was just discovered." We simply mentioned him because I gave a talk about why sex is binary 2 days ago and afterwards Mia brought up the fact that Rothblatt wrote a book chapter titled "Five Billion Sexes."
A great piece by @[private account] about the @[private account]'s commitment to gender pseudoscience that sparked an exodus of high-profile advisors.
"Given the organizationâs embrace of quasireligious and unscientific dogma, Iâm proud to proclaim myself a heretic."
https://www.wsj.com/opinion/losing-my-nonreligion-transgender-ideology-essay-resign-b7e6d745
đ¨DATA: A huge problem with the rapid rise of gender ideology and its assault on language is that many people have no clue what any of the terms mean.
In the UK, ~40% of people don't know that "trans" or "transgender" women are biologically male. In London, it's as high as 57%.
@[private account] @SarahTheHaider @[private account] @buttonslives The paper literally found the transgender groups were sex-typical. They did NOT find a cross-sex shift in brain structures after controlling for sexual orientation. Read the paper again.
STATEMENT 4: "Physiologically, neuroimaging research has suggested that cortical brain volume in transgender individuals appear to be more like their preferred gender (see Mueller et al., 2021; Nguyen et al., 2019)."
This is simply false. In fact, @buttonslives, @[private account], and I co-authored an article today explaining why these brain studies do not support the claim that people who identify as transgender have brains that exhibit a cross-sex shift.
In short, the studies claiming to find such a shift fail to control for sexuality, which is known to be associated with a cross-sex shift in certain brain structures. When studies do control for sexuality, the cross-sex shift vanishes.
So, what about the two studies the APA cited above to support the notion of a cross-sex shift in trans people's brains?
The first (Mueller et al., 2021) did not account for sexuality when reporting their main results about cross-sex shifts. However, they did include sexuality in the analysis in their Supplementary Materials, which found that the brains of people who identify as trans did not differ from "cisgender" controls of the same sex. So this study does not support the APA's claim that trans people have brains that "appear to be more like their preferred gender."
The second study (Nguyen et al., 2019) also does not control for sexuality, rendering it completely useless and incapable of supporting the existence of a cross-sex shift in the brain structures of people who identify as transgender.
To the extent any cross-sex shift in brain structures are observed in people who identify as transgender, that is due to a high prevalence of same-sex attraction in that population. It has nothing to do with "gender identity."
Please actually read the papers you cite. The paper you linked totally agreed with our analysis: "After controlling for sexual orientation, the transgender groups showed SEX-TYPICAL FA-values."
The only difference they found in the "trans" groups were in "brain areas that mediate own body perception."
So we are 100% correct. The brains of people who identify as transgender don't have brains that exhibit a cross-sex shift.
Public-health policies must be grounded in comprehensive and unbiased research. Otherwise, vulnerable young people will continue to face irrevocable and potentially devastating treatments.
Read our more detailed article below.
https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
This review should include scrutinizing studies that promote the âtransgender brainâ hypothesis, and incorporate evidence from desistance and detransition research, which highlight how transgender identities are often transient.
The "transgender brain" hypothesis is pure pseudoscience, and it needs to be ejected from our culture, courtrooms, and clinics.
Policymakers should mandate rigorous, independent reviews of the scientific claims surrounding transgender identityâs supposedly biological basis.
When sexual orientation is controlled for, the reported neuroanatomical shifts in brain-scan studies diminish greatly or vanish entirely.
But what if the âtrans brainâ hypothesis were true?
The central flaw in these studies is this: most donât control for sexual orientation. Whyâs that a big deal? Because most trans people arenât exclusively straight, and same-sex attraction is tied to brain shiftsâcross-sex or androgynous structures.
These "brain sex" studies are fatally flawed, yet few people possess the expertise and background knowledge required to understand why. And the volatile atmosphere surrounding trans issues means that facts often take a backseat to politicallyâand legallyâexpedient narratives.
In Talbott v. Trump, challenging a trans military ban, activist Nicolas Talbott and others claimed âstrong researchâ shows gender identity is biologicalâtrans womenâs brain structures match non-trans womenâs.
This has become a courtroom staple.
đ¨NEW: Proponents of "gender-affirming care" assert that "trans" people have an opposite-sex brain, a belief shaped by a pervasive pseudoscientific narrative flooding culture, courts, and clinics.
Here, @[private account], @buttonslives, and I address this fatally flawed "research." đ§ľ
The belief that people who identify as trans have opposite-sex brains is extremely pervasive and influential among progressives. Unfortunately for them, it's pure pseudoscience.
Debunking this narrative with @buttonslives and @[private account] will be a special focus this year.
Quotes a post by T00652; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The London Fire Dept. is accepting applications for Camp FFIT, a program open only to "young women, gender diverse and transgender youth" to "encourage more gender diversity" in fire service.
Regular boys cannot apply, only boys who claim to be girls or some other "gender."