The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Sam Harris recently said, "I think a doctoral dissertation, and perhaps several, could be written on how trans activism completely destroyed Democratic politics—without most Democrats knowing."
We tried to warn them. They refused to listen. They got what was coming to them.
No because it will just shift to the next intersectional box. It'll be Asian or Latina or a trans women, etc. There is no end to the moments they want to manufacture.
I witnessed these meltdowns several times. One time my (now ex) girlfriend accidentally "misgendered" a 6'2'' trans-identified male with a very deep voice and 5 o'clock shadow at a campus gathering for graduate students. They were friends, and it was done so inadvertently that she had no clue that she had apparently caused a major kerfuffle.
She was genuinely sorry, and expressed that immediately. But that didn't matter. The entire gathering got sidetracked and ended early as a result.
This 2024 peer-reviewed paper in @[private account] introduces the concept of "decolonial trans* feminism," which merges "decolonial theory with trans* of color feminism to challenge gender oppression" and "reimagines knowledge, gender, power, and resistance in educational research for queer/trans BIPOC individuals by integrating Indigenous metaphysics, diverse self-ontologies, and spiritual dimensions."
The use of the "asterisk in trans* feminism symbolizes the fluidity of gender identities, challenging rigid boundaries of thought and colonial norms."
The paper emphasized the "Androgynous Whole," and "explores how different configurations of knowledge inform gender and serve as sites of coalitional resistance."
Because most trans people are illiberal woke leftists, while you have managed to maintain your liberalism. The woke left have fully bought into the intersectional neo-Marxist framework of politics that views all interactions, including international conflicts, through the binary lens of oppressor vs oppressed.
It's the wokeness that's the problem. It's like a brain rot. I saw it destroy the atheist community in the early 2010s. It rotted the brains of many people I once viewed as extremely rational. It does this to every group it touches. It's the biggest threat to the LGBs, and even the Ts, even if most Ts are unaware.
Wokeness must be destroyed.
If this was done by anyone other than trans activists, it would be immediately labeled and investigated as an anti-gay hate crime.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Breaking: Militant trans activists have been detained by the venue security after allegedly releasing insects all over to try to sabotage the @AllianceLGB conference in London. The conference features gay and lesbian speakers critical of trans ideology. Several suspected co-conspirators are believed to have escaped but four are detained.
They still have the insects crawling on them from their bags. Police are being called. The four females are laughing and I heard them say they did it because the conference is transphobic.
#LGBAlliance2024
I think liberals care less about the source as long as they agree with it. They often use intersectional positionality as a substitute for credentials. You can have a credentialed doctor debunk "gender-affirming care" but the woke will ignore it for the subjective "lived experience" of one trans person.
It's complicated how the Left engages with credentials. However, is there a Left-wing version of Catturd? I'm not in Threads where such an account might thrive. Surely there must be some equivalent.
"The aim of this project is to expand our collective understanding of trans history, especially considering its implications for our current political and cultural climate of transantagonism."
How much retroactive transing of major historical figures do you think will result from this?
Quotes a post by T04096; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Not sure why the fact that she's a lesbian needs to be up at the top. And I believe the daughter has not yet taken any cross-sex hormones or had any surgeries, but coming out as transgender is always the necessary first step down that path. Anonymous because the mother would like to protect her and her daughter's privacy on this very sensitive and divisive issue.
This is a very thoughtful and personal essay by a mother of a trans-identified adult daughter. It argues that many parents in similar situations believe they must either affirm or reject the trans identity. But she believes there is a third option.
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/the-path-of-connection-navigating
"By foolishly betting against our innate desire for fairness, trans activism has sowed the seeds of its downfall."
A fantastic essay by @[private account]! I think she's absolutely right.
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/trans-activisms-fatal-mistake
The language around trans issues has become "so imprecise, so subjective and personalized" that "we now have very little understanding of what any of these words mean," writes @[private account].
We must return to saying what we mean and meaning what we say.https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/the-importance-of-being-honest-about
Erin Reed can't even get through 280 characters without lying. I didn't report on the ASPS statement.
Also, the claim that I "hate seeing a transgender journalist succeed" is absurd—my first-ever employee at @[private account] was @sarahigdon, a transgender reporter/journalist!
Quoting @benryanwriter: Fact check, Erin Reed @ErinInTheMorn:
Neither Colin @SwipeWright nor I reported about the ASPS statement.
To be clear, I have never stated that I want "to force all transgender people, regardless of age, to be detransitioned against [their] will."
This is just a made up lie.
Quotes a post by T05005; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I'm thrilled to share my latest article in the @WSJ dispelling widespread confusion over two male Olympic boxers with DSDs competing as women.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/does-imane-khelif-belong-in-the-womens-ring-olympics-boxing-transgender-ideology-b227f2cd?reflink=mobilewebshare_permalink
I wrote that article last year and it has nothing to do with Khelif. I shared it again because there is just a general high level of confusion going on right now about all things intersex and transgender. Everything in that article is solid, and I never linked it to Khelif.
We need to start the Multiverse Professional Association for Transgender Health (MPATH) to overtake them.
"Oh, you're just the WORLD Professional Association for Transgender Health? That's cute."
🚨ALERT: The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit has allowed an Indiana law banning cross-sex hormone treatments, puberty blockers, and sex trait modification surgeries for minors to fully come into effect.
https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/indiana-ban-on-transgender-treatments-for-minors-can-be-enforced-court-rules-5596812?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
Gender activists capturing the @[private account] would be an absolute disaster.
"Clearly, the WHO is trying to create a document to endorse 'gender-affirming care.' Then it can push such official guidelines on health systems throughout the world."
https://www.theepochtimes.com/opinion/gender-ideologues-stack-deck-on-who-panel-on-trans-health-5595317?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
🚨ALERT: "Teachers are suing California Gov. Gavin Newsom and California Attorney General Rob Bonta in federal court over policies they say force them to conceal the transgender status of young students from parents."
https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/newsom-sued-over-transgender-policy-teachers-claim-they-are-forced-to-lie-to-parents-5583394?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
Yes, I did. I explained that in certain contexts, such as speaking to a gender clinic whistleblower with a trans-identified partner and gaining their trust, it might be prudent to not offend them by maintaining a hardline stance when referring to their partner in their presence.
If we're trying to gain trust of potential whistleblowers or other medical professionals with trans-identifying partners, or who might even identify as trans themselves but still understand the reality of their sex, a hardline stance might be counterproductive. In fact, I know for a fact that it is because I have seen these conversations take place and know that a hardline stance would not have produced good outcomes.
I'll outline how I see it, and it may or may not mirror Christina's view. Basically, there are a lot of different ways that gender ideology hurts society. The two big ones are males in female spaces (bathrooms, prisons, sports, etc.) and pediatric gender-affirming care. Both issues, though stemming from the same ideology, cannot both be remedies using the same tactics.
It makes sense that those who are predominantly focussed on preserving women's spaces would opt for a hardline position on something like pronouns. Using wrong-sex pronouns is seen as partly (or largely) what got us into this mess in the first place. People's kindness was exploited, and thus the feeling of "I'm done being nice" makes some good sense.
On the other hand, we have another very serious issue of gender-affirming care (GAC). This is truly abhorrent stuff, as it involved giving children irreversible hormones and surgeries based on the lie that you can have a "gender identity" that doesn't match your bodily sex. All the medical institutions and journals are captured by this insane ideology. It's in the medical and scientific journals. Major Left-leaning outlets like the NYT have been hesitant to touch the issue, or they outright downplay it.
Things aren't going to change unless we get the Left to understand what's going on. Gender clinic whistleblowers and worried doctors are hesitant to be associated with anyone they perceive as on the Right. In order for them to feel comfortable coming forward, they need to trust us. They need to know that we have real compassion. Some of these whistleblowers are married trans-identified people. If we applied a hardline stance to never using wrong-sex pronouns in every context, then some whistleblowers might never come forward.
If we are trying to talk to the Left and gain their trust so we can enact change, we need to deploy a context-specific strategy of pronoun use so that they don't just shut down and run away.
My main issue in this whole recent conflict is that while I am willing to admit that a hardline stance on pronouns is probably the best strategy for protecting women's sex-based rights, many of these GC radfem activists are trying to police my language in other contexts where I believe a hardline strategy will not be optimal, and is actually likely to be detrimental to achieving my goals.
I am deeply involved in helping change policies regarding gender-affirming care. I know what's going on behind the scenes. I know what strategy regarding pronouns is best for what I do.
I have no problem with women's rights activists using the strategies they think are best for the issues and goals they're deeply involved in. But if they're going to insist I adopt their hardline approach for dealing with GAC, then the answer is no.
Anyway, those are my thoughts.
🚨ALERT: Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre accuses Justin Trudeau and the Canadian media of spreading “disinformation” about Alberta’s new policies restricting child sex change procedures, which they frame as banning “health care for transgender youth”
https://www.theepochtimes.com/world/poilievre-says-trudeau-and-media-seek-to-misrepresent-conservatives-on-albertas-child-transition-restrictions-policy-5581773?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
🚨ALERT: Hobart City Councillor Louise Elliot is appealing the decision to have her suspended for a code of conduct complaint made against her for saying "transwomen are transwomen and remain biological men," at a @StandingforXX event.
https://www.theepochtimes.com/world/senator-defends-suspended-councillor-who-spoke-out-on-transgender-issues-5581266?utm_source=partner&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
This part of the new gender medicine whistleblower's testimony both resonated with and enraged me:
When the leader of the training brought up hormone treatments, I shakily tapped the unmute button on Zoom and asked why 70 to 80 percent of female adolescents diagnosed with gender dysphoria have prior mental health diagnoses.
She flashed a look of disgust as she warned me against spreading "misinformation on trans kids." Soon the chat box started blowing up with comments directed at me. One colleague stated it was not "appropriate to bring politics into this" and another wrote that I was "demonstrating a hostility toward trans folks which is [a] direct violation of the Hippocratic Oath," and recommended I "seek additional support and information so as not to harm trans clients."
As soon as I closed my laptop, I burst into tears. I care so deeply about my clients that even thinking about this now makes me cry. I couldn’t understand how my colleagues, who are supposed to be my teammates, could be so quick to villainize me. I also wondered if maybe my colleagues were right, and if I had gone insane.
My former colleagues did this to me when I started asking very calm and clear questions about the "sex spectrum" and other concepts related to gender ideology. Before I ever wrote publicly about all of this stuff, I privately tormented on it for nearly two years very seriously questioning whether I had lost my mind.
I will never forgive this absolutely sinister and demented cult ideology for driving the most sane and principled among us to the mental brink of questioning their own sanity.
https://www.thefp.com/p/i-refused-to-approve-all-teen-gender-transitions
🚨ALERT: Maine's bill permitting children to undergo transgender procedures without parental consent was unanimously rejected by the House judiciary committee, indicating an unwillingness among Democrats for House debate on the topic.
https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/maine-child-transgender-bill-killed-in-committee-5576294?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
An extremely thorough analysis by @segm_ebm.
"To restore confidence in the trustworthiness of the planned WHO [transgender] guidelines, the current process must undergo a substantive change."
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/the-who-clarifies-its-plans-to-issue
Finally, in the @nytimes:
"As one detransitioned man, now in a gay relationship, put it, 'I was a gay man pumped up to look like a woman and dated a lesbian who was pumped up to look like a man. If that’s not conversion therapy, I don’t know what is.'" https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/02/opinion/transgender-children-gender-dysphoria.html
🚨ALERT: Lia Thomas, a male swimmer who won the NCAA Division I women's swimming title in 2022, has filed a case with the CAS seeking eligibility to compete in elite women's races. Thomas says the current regulations are discriminatory and "unlawful."
https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/transgender-swimmer-lia-thomas-lodges-case-with-cas-to-overturn-ban-5575299?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
If I could only have people read one article of mine, it would be this one: "The Transgender Umbrella Casts Its Shadow Over Gender Nonconformity."
Everyone needs to understand how common non-conformity to sex-based stereotypes is being medicalized.
EXCERPT:
Planned Parenthood (@[private account]) is a US-based nonprofit that provides services to transgender patients at all their locations, and in 2020 were “second largest provider of gender affirming hormone care” nationally. On their website, “gender” is defined as “a social and legal status, and set of expectations from society, about behaviors, characteristics, and thoughts,” and that “it’s more about how you’re expected to act, because of your sex.” The “gender binary” is defined as “the idea that gender is strictly an either/or option of male/men/masculine or female/woman/feminine based on sex assigned at birth,” and they define “nonbinary,” which is a type of transgender identity, as referring to a “rejection of the gender binary’s assumption that gender is strictly an either/or option of male/man/masculine or female/ woman/feminine based on sex assigned at birth.”
The literal and straightforward reading of this is that people who are gender nonconforming—i.e. people who do not behave according to traditional notions of masculinity or femininity that society expects of them because of their sex—are transgender.
The Human Rights Campaign (@[private account]), in their Glossary of Terms, defines “transgender” as “an umbrella term for people whose gender identity and/or expression is different from cultural expectations based on the sex they were assigned at birth.” The “gender binary” is the system in which one’s “gender identity is expected to align with the sex assigned at birth and gender expressions and roles fit traditional expectations.”
Again, the most straightforward reading of this is that a transgender person is someone who simply does not conform to traditional stereotypes of masculinity or femininity associated with being male or female.
But what about scientific institutions?
The American Psychological Association (@[private account]), which is in charge of establishing the norms for clinical practice in the United States, defines “transgender” as “an umbrella term for persons whose gender identity, gender expression or behavior does not conform to that typically associated with the sex to which they were assigned at birth.”
The Endocrine Society (@[private account]), which is the world’s oldest and largest organization dedicated to research on hormones and the practice of endocrinology, defines “transgender” in their Clinical Practice Guideline as “an umbrella term for people whose gender identity and/or gender expression differs from what is typically associated with their sex designated at birth.” This is also the same definition used by the Pediatric Endocrine Society.
The American Psychiatric Association (@[private account]), which is the main professional psychiatric in the United States and the largest psychiatric organization in the world, defines “transgender” as “an umbrella term describing individuals whose gender identity (inner sense of gender) or gender expression (outward performance of gender) differs from the sex or gender to which they were assigned at birth.” And their definition of “gender expression” is “the outward manifestation of a person’s gender, which may or may not reflect their inner gender identity based on traditional expectations.”
Lastly, the United States’ Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (@CDCgov), which purports to be “the nation’s leading science-based, data-driven, service organization that protects the public’s health,” defines “transgender” on the LGBT health section of their website as “an umbrella term for persons whose gender identity or expression (masculine, feminine, other) is different from their sex (male, female) at birth.”
All these institutions are saying the same thing: if your expression or behavior is different from what is “typically associated” with your sex based on “traditional expectations,” you are transgender. This is literally equating common gender nonconformity (i.e. masculine females, feminine males, and androgynous people of either sex) with transgenderism.
I could go on endlessly citing more examples, but for the sake of brevity I will leave it there.
READ THE FULL ARTICLE ON @[private account]
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/the-transgender-umbrella-casts-its
"A British psychiatrist...has actually referred to Trans as 'Goth 2.0.'... However: teens and young adults immersed in Goth might have pierced or tattooed their limbs, but they didn’t have healthy body parts removed by surgeons." – @[private account]
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/the-revolt-against-authority
🚨ALERT (GOOD NEWS!): Ohio Senate overrides Gov. DeWine's veto on a bill banning sex trait modification procedures (puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries) for minors and banning males from competing in female school sports.
https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/ohio-legislature-overrides-governors-veto-bans-trans-procedures-for-minors-5573374?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
A very good article on the need for a protected female sports category.
"Let there be no doubt: this is not about preventing transgender individuals from partaking in sports; it is about ensuring fair play and safety for all, especially women."
https://www.theepochtimes.com/opinion/olympics-including-transgender-athletes-in-female-competitions-5571149?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
🚨 The Supreme Court declines to review an Indiana school's transgender bathroom case, letting stand the 7th Circuit's ruling that supports transgender students' rights under Title IX. The decision leaves varying judgments in pending cases across the U.S.
https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/supreme-court-declines-to-take-up-transgender-bathroom-case-5566960?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
What's great about @elonmusk buying Twitter is that I can post this cartoon @buttonslives and I made without getting suspended like before.
🔗https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/trans-activism-and-the-road-not-taken
Resisting the Transgender ‘Assembly Line’
Dr. @[private account] on how to protect children from gender ideology.
"What these kids need is psychotherapy. They need to look at their lives deeply with somebody who has experience, compassion, & understanding."https://www.theepochtimes.com/bright/resisting-the-transgender-assembly-line-5536224?utm_source=partner&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
🚨Federal Judge Sides With Teachers Who Object to Secretive Gender Transition Policies
"Ms. Mirabelli and Ms. West...objected to the K–8 school district’s policies [that] compelled teachers to assist in a student’s transgender 'social transition.'"
https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/federal-judge-sides-with-teachers-who-object-to-secretive-gender-transition-policies-5563857?utm_source=prtnrhard&utm_campaign=SwipeWright&src_src=partner&src_cmp=SwipeWright
The new @[private account] textbook "Gender-Affirming Psychiatric Care" is out and, as expected, it's pushing sex pseudoscience.
On page 32, the authors give their definition of the term "sex." They claim that the terms male and female "are used to describe characteristics of an individual—not individuals themselves" (my emphasis).
In other words, they claim that we cannot refer to people as belonging to a sex category, but can only describe their various traits as being sexed. For example, instead of statements like "Joey is a male" or "Jennifer is a female," we should break them down trait-by-trait and say "Joey has male chromosomes, male genitals, a male hormone profile, and a male gender identity, etc."
This is scientifically inaccurate and actually self-refuting when you prod it even a little. It is self-refuting because the only way we can code various traits like chromosomes, genitals, and hormones as male or female is by understanding that males and females exist independently of these individual traits. How do we come to associate an XY karyotype with males and an XX karyotype with females without knowing what males and females were beforehand? How do we associate testosterone with males and estradiol with females if males and females don't exist independently of hormone levels?
You see, we are only able to code these various traits as male or female because being male or female is totally independent of these traits, and is based on the type of gamete (sperm or ova) an individual has the function to produce.
So why do gender activists and doctors insist on viewing sex as applying to individual traits and not entire individuals? Because it is a necessary premise for the justification of "gender-affirming care." The entire practice requires sex to exist along various axes or "levels," such as chromosomal sex, hormonal sex, genital sex, behavioral sex, and even "brain sex" (which they call "gender identity"). That's because if sex exists along multiple independent axes or levels, then it's possible for some of these axes or levels to be incongruent and then made congruent through some medical intervention.
According to their ideology, a person is considered transgender if they have a "mismatch" between their brain sex (gender identity) and the sex they were "assigned at birth" based on their genitals. The goal of "gender-affirming care" is to use hormones and surgeries to alter a person's hormonal sex and other physical traits so that they "match" a person's brain sex.
The mutability of one's physical sex through the use of hormones and surgery is foundational to gender-affirming care. This is why gender activists insist that sex and the terms male and female apply only to characteristics of an individual and not individuals themselves. If sex were instead viewed correctly as applying to individuals independent of their secondary sex characteristics, then the entire premise of gender-affirming care crumbles because there would be no such thing as a mismatch between different levels of a person's sex and altering a person's sex by hormonally and/or surgically altering their secondary sex characteristics would be impossible.
Pointing out that the evidence for the efficacy of gender-affirming care is extremely poor is important, but it is perhaps even more important to expose the fact that the entire premise of gender-affirming care is unsound and pseudoscientific. We need to attack the premise.
This is what I have been trying to highlight for a long time, and I am happy to finally be working as an expert witness in court cases to drive this point home. This is also great optics, because lawyers look like fools sparring with biologists about basic biology.
This is how we are going to win.