The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
3/ But we don't have good data on the effects of PBs when puberty is delayed during the time when children would *normally* undergo puberty. And the data we do have is raises many red flags.
PBs are used off-label in trans medicine. They are not approved for this context.
1/ This new @[private account] editorial promotes scientific falsehoods while purporting to dispel them.
Puberty blockers aren't "reversible" in the context of trans medicine. We don't know much about what happens developmentally when *normal* puberty is delayed. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-anti-trans-laws-are-anti-science/
2/ Is a rule transphobic if a trans person is told they can't ride a roller-coaster because they're not tall enough? No. Because the rule is about height, not being trans.
Similarly, the rules keeping some trans people from competing as females are about sex, not being trans.
1/ These bills don't target trans people, they target biological males who happen to be trans. Females who identify as men (trans men) are welcome to compete as females as long as they don't take testosterone.
It's not about being trans. It's about biological sex.
Quoting @POTUS46Archive: So far this year, hundreds of anti-LGBTQ bills have been introduced in state legislatures – many of them target transgender children.
Let’s be clear: This is bullying against kids disguised as legislation – and it must stop. Enough is enough.
3/ Female sports was created to control for the irreversible performance-enhancing effects of male puberty. So it's unfair for trans woman to compete against female athletes because they'd be less competitive had they not been so androgenized, even if they don't win a medal.
1/ A trans woman who competes against female athletes and doesn't win a medal still has an unfair advantage in the same way that a person taking steroids who competes in a natural power-lifting competition has an unfair advantage even if they don't win a medal.
Unfair advantages aren't measured with respect to other athletes, but measured with respect to yourself in the absence of some performance enhancing factor. In the case of trans women, it's the effects of male puberty.
3/ The activists used to say "show us the data that trans women who suppress testosterone outperform cis women!"
Well, the data now clearly demonstrate that, and—surprise!—they don't care! They never did. That was just an expedient way to temporarily shut people up.
2/ We KNOW this isn't fair.
Here are two major reviews from this year in top sports medicine journals. One is even first-authored by a trans woman—Joanna Harper. Conclusions highlighted.
2021 review #1: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3
2021 review #2: https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/
It's always similar wording: "X wants to ban transgender women and girls from competing in women's and girl's sports."
They word it this way to portray it as discrimination on the basis of being transgender per se (what!?), rather than on the basis of sex (oh that makes sense!).
Quoting @Reuters: ICYMI: Florida became the latest U.S. state to ban transgender women and girls from participating in women’s athletics at schools. ‘We're going to go based on biology not based off ideology when we're doing sports,’ Governor Ron DeSantis said https://reut.rs/3vI0u1u
The woke Left views language and other social factors as having a nearly omnipotent influence over how minds and societal norms/attitudes get shaped.
Yet somehow any consideration of social influence is completely forbidden when it comes to children claiming trans identities.
The argument to include trans women in female sports because there is some performance overlap is nonsensical.
There's a performance overlap between children and adults, and between doped and natural athletes. Yet nobody is suggesting we ignore these distinctions. Only sex.