The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
No. Semenya and other XY DSD "women" can still compete if they lower their testosterone, and can compete in other events without doing so. If it were up to me she wouldn't be allowed to compete in any female event, and certainly no trans women would either.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] I never conflated intersex with trans. Semenya is a biological male with an intersex condition. That's a simple fact. Males that have gone through a significant degree of male puberty (as Semenya has) should not be allowed to compete against females.
@[private account] Exactly. I was more or less onboard with allowing man/woman to refer to gender identity and reserving male/female for biological sex. But now many trans activists want to claim the terms male/female for identity as well, and also have identity replace sex in law. Absolutely not.
Hi Dr. Roberts. I don't think it's useful, and may he in fact harmful, to try and use the existence of intersex people (who comprise <0.02% of the pop.) to justify trans identified people. The overwhelmingly vast majority of trans people are not intersex. These are separate...
Credit where credit's due. The Guardian highlights the serious and growing issue over trans rights lobbying groups pressuring clinicians to administer unevidenced and potentially dangerous gender-affirming treatments to children. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/jul/27/trans-lobby-pressure-pushing-young-people-to-transition?utm_term=Autofeed&CMP=twt_gu&utm_medium=&utm_source=Twitter#Echobox=1564257964
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] You realize that being trans doesn't require one to deny their biological sex, right?
"Women shouldn't be required to view male penises—outside of contexts like bio or health classes—as a condition of receiving an education."
"When the law requires an unwilling woman to see (much less handle) male genitalia, then the law has lost its mind."https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/when-trans-activism-empowers-sexual-harassment/
Thanks! It's definitely a complicated issue that a lot of people try to make black and white. I agree about Yaniv. They're definitely not doing the trans community any favors, and it angers me as well.
I don't think all trans women criminals should necessarily be placed in male prisons, but certainly all shouldn't be placed in female prisons either. I don't personally know exactly where that line should be, but it needs to be discussed.
... (i.e. trans people tend to differ from cis people in brain region X) to individuals (e.g. this person has X brain structure seen more commonly in trans people, therefore they must be trans).
That's a huge "if." I highly doubt that brain scans will be able to predict trans identity with acceptably high accuracy, since the current studies on the topic claiming to have found structural differences did not control for sexual orientation. But we'll see.
...means they might actually be the opposite sex trapped in the wrong body, which *converts* confused adolescent homosexuals into trans kids that frequently proceed on to blockers and life-long cross-sex hormones and surgery.
It IS conversion therapy! The majority of gender dysphoric adolescents desist and turn out to be homosexual adults. Homosexuals are on average more gender nonconforming than heterosexuals. Trans ideology is essentially telling people that this gender nonconforming behavior...
The majority of GD youths turn out to be homosexual adults. What blockers do is convert these gay youths into trans adults. Blockers don't treat GD, they solidify it.
And thus trans people don't merely "identify" as the opposite sex, but are literally whatever they say they are because if the boundaries of sex are arbitrary then they can be expanded infinitely to include them. And society is letting them do this because people and...
Also, intersex is not the same as trans. The overwhelmingly vast majority of trans individuals are not intersex. Stop inappropriately weaponizing intersex people to further your unrelated ideological crusade.
...ideologies of Islam? Islamophobia. Don't like people criticizing the Israeli government? Antisemitism.
It's undoubtedly true that some people hate trans people, Muslims, and Jews *as people*, but most of these accusations are false positives that fail...
"Equally, some academics—although #notallGenderStudiesProfs—are apparently happy to describe gender-critical views as attacks on vulnerable members of the trans community, not as intellectual challenges to ideas or powerful institutions."
@[private account] @[private account] @MrAndyNgo It's not rhetorical. It's being quite literal. I am not targeting trans individuals any more than a height requirement on a roller-coaster would target trans people if a trans person werem't tall enough to ride. I don't target trans, I target males trying to enter female sports.
@[private account] @[private account] @MrAndyNgo I criticize including males trying to gain access to female sporting events and leagues. Big difference. That's not targeting trans people, that's supporting female sex-based rights.
@[private account] @MrAndyNgo I don't target the trans community, I defend sex-based rights including the right for females to have their own sports leagues and events free of male athletes. And my former boss is aware and supportive of everything I've published. Nice try.
My arguments are not anti trans, they're anti having male bodies in female sports. You still failed to engage with any argument or point. Vague references to phrenology is not an argument. You're incapable of having an honest discussion and are not worth engaging further.
I had the pleasure of appearing once more on @[private account]'s "The Big Picture" along with @kdansky to discuss the issue of trans athletes in sports. I covered similar ground as my last appearance, but these facts cannot be stated frequently enough. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1rNqdGiqeY
@[private account] I think this shows the power of the human brain. It certainly doesn't show that trans people have the brains of the opposite sex. It just shows that male and female brains are remarkably variable.